Metropolitan Bank Holding Corp. (MCB) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

January 21, 2026

New York Stock Exchange US Financials Banks earnings 25 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Mark R. DeFazio

executive
#1

Thanks, and good morning everyone. We appreciate you being here for our quarterly earnings call. Our performance in Q4 and for the full year 2025 is something we feel good about. With net interest margin, net interest income, deposits, and loans all growing steadily, plus ongoing gains in our efficiency ratio, we're set up to finish the year strongly. The momentum built during Q4 gives us a solid base for meaningful progress in 2026 and beyond. Our careful underwriting and the risk management culture that runs across our entire franchise keep anchoring how we approach safety and soundness. Over the year, our loan portfolio grew by about $775 million, which works out to almost 13% growth. We originated roughly $1.9 billion in total loans. Deposit growth funded that loan growth — deposits rose by around $1.4 billion, roughly 23%, with support from our strategic funding initiatives. Those initiatives involved going deeper in existing deposit verticals and finding new ways to diversify and strengthen our funding base. During Q4, we opened a full-service branch in Lakewood, New Jersey, converting what had been an administrative office. Beyond that, we anticipate opening two additional branches in Florida during the first half of 2026 — one in Miami and one in West Palm Beach — and together these will strengthen our footprint in these important growth markets. Asset quality is still solid, with no broad-based negative trends showing up across loan segments, geographies, or sectors; we stay closely engaged with our clients to evaluate shifting market conditions, and so far the feedback has not pointed to any trouble spots. That reflects our careful underwriting and proactive portfolio management. Going forward, our focus stays on managing asset quality, optimizing profitability, and growing our presence in New York and other complementary markets. Our strategy for 2026 and beyond is centered on capturing more market share through traditional channels while positioning the franchise to take advantage of opportunities that boost long-term shareholder value. A number of new initiatives will launch in 2026, and we anticipate early returns in the form of low-cost deposits and growth in increased fee income. These efforts show our commitment to building an institution that is more diversified, efficient, and resilient. I want to sincerely thank our employees and directors for their dedication and contribution throughout the year. Their commitment to excellence has been instrumental in MCB's sustained performance and will keep driving our success in the years ahead. I'll now hand the call over to Dan Dougherty, our CFO.

Daniel F. Dougherty

executive
#2

Thank you, Mark. Good morning to all of you, and once more, we appreciate you being on this call. Today we'll walk through the solid results for the fourth quarter and wrap up with our 2026 guidance, which centers on continuing — and, just as importantly, capitalizing on — the foundational financial strengths that our Q4 results demonstrated. Let's start with a handful of remarks regarding the balance sheet. Our loan book came in basically unchanged during Q4. Even so, we did hit our growth target for the year. During 2025, loans on the books rose $776 million, which works out to roughly 13%. What held loan growth back in Q4 was roughly $317 million of prepayments, a figure about $150 million higher than the trailing three-quarter run rate. Q4 originations and draws combined came to approximately $599 million, booked at a weighted average coupon, or WAC, net of fees, of 7.28%. The mix of newly originated volume matched our historical pattern, at roughly 70% fixed and 30% float. Across the coming six months, roughly $1.1 billion of maturities come due, carrying a WAC of 6.94%. Our assumption is that we keep somewhere around 75%-80% of those cash flows. Within our forecast model, we assume renewals will reprice at roughly 25 to 50 basis points under the rates on our new volume originations. Since the Treasury curve, three years in, out, has barely shifted since the Fed kicked off its latest easing campaign, our loan spread guidance, our price guidance, keeps driving coupons comfortably above 7%. Our loan pipelines remain robust. I'll give 2026 guidance covering loan growth along with other related metrics near the close of this narrative. During Q4, deposits rose by $304 million, or approximately 4.3%. As the press release noted for the full year, deposits were up $1.4 billion, or about 23%. Measured on a spot basis, quarter over quarter, the cost of interest-bearing deposits fell 43 basis points. Because our balance sheet stays modestly liability-sensitive, and more than $2 billion of our indexed deposits reprice on the first business day of the month after a rate change, the advantage from mid-December's reduction in the Fed Funds Target Rate won't show up until Q1. We hold $1 billion of hedged indexed deposits, which carry positive carry all the way down to a Fed Funds effective rate of approximately 3.50%. In our forecast model, we apply a generic cost of funds equal to the Fed Funds Target Rate minus 50 basis points. Now some comments on the net interest margin. The margin came in at 4.1% for Q4, which is 22 basis points above the previous quarter. As you're aware, the Fed launched the recent easing campaign in mid-September of last year. Throughout the 75 basis point easing cycle so far, our deposit beta on unhedged interest-bearing deposits has run at about 75%. We anticipate being able to match that performance for at least the next 50 basis points of rate cuts. Thanks to the deposits we brought in, we managed to retire every bit of wholesale funding — $450 million in total across 2025. Now I'd like to shift to a few big-picture points regarding our income statement. Our steady balance sheet expansion along with NIM growth keeps producing strong top-line numbers. In Q4, net interest income came in at $85.3 million, which is an increase of over 10% from the prior quarter and nearly 20% higher for the full year. Let's spend a moment on the diluted EPS figure of $2.77. As I noted earlier, Q4 brought unusually high loan prepayments. Because of that, prepay penalty plus deferred fee income ran roughly $1.7 million above what we'd typically see. On top of that, during Q4 we sold bonds and booked a gain of approximately $675,000. Also in the quarter, we recorded an insurance claim recovery tied to a discontinued business line plus a compensation accrual adjustment, which together came to roughly $2 million. Taking everything into account, my estimate is that non-core credits added up to approximately $4.6 million, which works out to around $0.30 per share. Our Q4 NIM, once adjusted for the above-normal prepayment penalty and fee income, stood at roughly 4.02%. Our Q4 ROTCE, adjusted for each of the income items I just walked through, came in just above 14%. Non-interest income during Q4 totaled $3.1 million. I already mentioned the securities gain; we don't anticipate recognizing additional gains down the road; that said, we keep pursuing new business initiatives, as Mark noted, to fuel growth in non-interest income. Non-interest expense for the quarter reached $44.4 million, which is $1.4 million lower than the prior quarter. Here's how operating expenses shifted on a quarter-over-quarter basis. Comp and benefits fell by $1.3 million, mostly because of a lower bonus accrual and reduced restricted stock expense. Professional fees dropped by $649,000, largely from a decrease in legal and other fees. As I said, part of that legal fee decline stemmed from receiving an insurance claim. And lastly, technology costs rose by $668,000. The main reason for that increase ties back to the digital transformation project. Altogether in Q4, digital project costs came to approximately $3.1 million. The effective tax rate for the quarter was roughly 30%. Now let's turn to what has our full attention right now, the 2026 outlook. First, a few thoughts about our interest rate assumptions and the balance sheet. We've assumed two 25 basis point rate cuts, one in June and another in September. Obviously, when those rate cuts land affects how much they move our forecast financially. As in 2025, we anticipate loan growth of around $800 million, or roughly 12%. We expect the mix of new loan volume to match what we've seen recently. We expect deposits to fund all of the loan growth we've planned. The securities portfolio will stay at roughly 10%-12% of balance sheet footings. Alright, let me share a few perspectives on earnings along with other financial measures. For 2026, we anticipate that the NIM will modestly widen as the year progresses. How many additional rate cuts occur, and when they happen, stands as the main factor shaping new performance. Beyond that, the yield curve's slope matters as a significant variable; within our forecast model, we do incorporate a bit of modest loan spread tightening across the year, which mirrors the demand behind our loan growth. According to our present forecast, we anticipate reporting an annual NIM of roughly 4.10% for the year. Crucially, we anticipate that our business model — we hold the view that our business model is well positioned to protect or perhaps even grow the NIM whether or not further rate cuts materialize. Turning to the provision, my sense is that current consensus broadly matches our own view. I should point out that we are moving through the workout process on a number of the credits for which we recorded specific reserves during 2025. How these credits are ultimately resolved might lead to allowance adjustments falling outside our business-as-usual planning; regarding non-interest income, a 5%-10% growth assumption strikes me as reasonable. As I noted, we do aim to rebuild the fee income line over time, using our 2024 results as a general benchmark. Now, a few perspectives on what we expect for operating expenses. We anticipate the annual operating expense line will come to roughly $189 million-$191 million. A number of unique items are baked into the OpEx forecast. The first concerns the Modern Banking in Motion project. Within our annual expense guidance, there is $3 million of first-quarter spend, mostly tied to extending the conversion timeline. The second concerns the premises expense line item; during 2026, we will grow our real estate footprint at both our New York City headquarters and in West Palm Beach, Florida. The related new expense run rate comes to roughly $2.2 million annually. Because of timing, the 2026 increase will come to roughly $1 million. Last, our plan incorporates growth in deposit verticals that get expensed below the line. These fees are expected to see their annual run rate rise by roughly $6 million in 2026. Tallying all of this up, our forecasted ROTCE gets close to 16% by Q4 of 2026. Lastly, before we open the floor for questions, I want to note that MCB is hosting an Investor Day at our headquarters in New York on Tuesday, March 3rd. Along with Mark and myself, several of our other senior leaders will present. Additional information is available on the events page of our Investor Relations website. A limited number of seats remain for those attending in person. Should you have questions or wish to attend in person, please reach out to our Investor Relations team at ir@mcbankny.com. I will now hand the call back to our operator for questions.

Feddie Strickland

analyst
#3

Morning, everyone. I'd like to begin with the composition of our loans. I appreciate the remarks you made at the start, and it's encouraging to see some momentum in owner-occupied CRE across the past 2 quarters. That said, I'm wondering whether C&I might return to growth once again following 2 quarters of decreases.

Mark R. DeFazio

executive
#4

I doubt it, Feddie. Where core C&I is concerned, I don't expect meaningful expansion. You will see C&I with a medical connection. We keep growing our healthcare practices and the way we push further into healthcare. As for core C&I, my view is that we'll keep handling that risk at the pace we have now, or a bit above, or perhaps a bit below.

Feddie Strickland

analyst
#5

Got it, that's useful. And kind of following up on that same point — clearly, CRE concentrations have ticked up somewhat, since you've been doing some buybacks and similar things across the past few quarters, even while owner-occupied has risen. Going forward, as you keep growing owner-occupied CRE, do you figure it'll stay roughly steady from here?

Mark R. DeFazio

executive
#6

Yeah, I'd say so. For sure, I expect our concentration increase to risk-based capital will be pretty stable moving ahead.

Feddie Strickland

analyst
#7

And before I go back into the queue, one final item from me. I understand that you've launched a few new branches across New Jersey and South Florida, and it sounds like additional ones are in the pipeline there; I was just wondering how significant a role those played in the municipal deposit growth that we've witnessed over the past couple of quarters?

Mark R. DeFazio

executive
#8

On the New Jersey side, yes, since they got somewhat of a head start with the branch, with the administrative office being converted. Florida really hasn't contributed yet. We only just converted the Miami office, and in West Palm Beach we're under construction; so my expectation is significant contributions down the road from Florida and even greater ones from New Jersey as we move forward.

Feddie Strickland

analyst
#9

Okay, sounds good. Much appreciated, Mark. I'll go back into the queue.

Mark R. DeFazio

executive
#10

Thanks, Feddie.

David Konrad

analyst
#11

Morning, everyone. I'd like to spend a moment on asset quality. I realize nonperforming assets rose by roughly $5 million, and they've been fairly steady during this quarter, but could you discuss those two credits, and perhaps give us an update versus last quarter regarding the larger relationship — has anything shifted, and what has occurred with that relationship in terms of NPAs?

Mark R. DeFazio

executive
#12

So those two loans were multifamily assets already on the market in their respective areas, and once they sell, we anticipate minimal or no losses tied to them. When it comes to the specific reserves for the prior quarter, the workout process is still ongoing. My optimism remains guarded. During the last quarter's call, I mentioned that these loans should reach resolution before this quarter wraps up, and we're in active discussions with the property owners. Workouts don't happen overnight. Patience and maturity are required. My expectation is that we land in a favorable position, and I hope to share that news in Q1.

David Konrad

analyst
#13

Thanks. I appreciate it. Now, as a quick additional question regarding capital — from what I understand, your CET1 ratio currently sits at roughly 10.7%. Could you take us through what you're aiming for there, the range you'd like that ratio to fall within as the balance sheet expands — something in the double digits, perhaps?

Mark R. DeFazio

executive
#14

Sure, David — when I think about that, my main focus is really on TCE. We're expecting that trend to move from where we are now, in the high 8s, around 8.8%, up to roughly the low 9s. That's the level where we feel at ease operating the institution.

David Konrad

analyst
#15

Alright, that sounds good. Appreciate it.

Mark R. DeFazio

executive
#16

From that point, you're able to return to CET1.

David Konrad

analyst
#17

Yeah. Yep. Perfect. Thank you.

Mark Fitzgibbon

analyst
#18

Hey, guys. Nice quarter. First question I had, Dan, wondering if you could share with us when you expect the digital transformation cost to be fully done and that transformation to be completed. Is that in the Q1?

Daniel F. Dougherty

executive
#19

The conversion is anticipated still in the Q1. In fact, President's Day weekend. That's the big day.

Mark Fitzgibbon

analyst
#20

Alright.

Daniel F. Dougherty

executive
#21

Once we get through that, for the majority of those, that's the point where the clearly identified cost comes to an end, and after that the ongoing run rate begins to take form—there's invariably some residual items—but that marks the moment when the $3 million of spending wraps up.

Mark Fitzgibbon

analyst
#22

All right, that's helpful. And one more thing I wanted to ask about — did any interest recovery come through? I recall you brought up income from prepayment penalties during Q4, but was there any interest recovery within NII for this quarter?

Daniel F. Dougherty

executive
#23

None.

Mark Fitzgibbon

analyst
#24

All right, and next I was hoping you might tell us which verticals were mainly behind the increase in demand deposits during this period. The tables didn't make that completely clear to me.

Daniel F. Dougherty

executive
#25

For the quarter, overall growth. Munis came in as the top source. It was genuinely broad-based, with a really good spread, though munis and property managers stood out. After that, customers — those borrowing from us as well as new deposits — contributed the most; and naturally, EB-5 added a little too; so it truly was broad-based. The standout piece within all of this was munis.

Mark Fitzgibbon

analyst
#26

All right, and finally, perhaps a question for Mark. Mark, the value of your currency has strengthened a bit. I realize you continue to view it as cheap, but with the conditions in the broader environment, do you think M&A has become more feasible and probable at this point?

Mark R. DeFazio

executive
#27

Right now, we aren't seeing much worth pursuing among the franchises present across every market. As a result, we intend to remain extremely cautious. There are some quite promising new initiatives coming that you should be reading about, ideally before Q1 wraps up. So we'll simply continue handling the fundamentals and beating our competitors by a wide margin, while those other M&A deals remain out there and resolve on their own. For the time being, though, we're keeping our heads down and concentrating on organic growth.

Mark Fitzgibbon

analyst
#28

Great. Thank you.

Feddie Strickland

analyst
#29

Hi, I have a brief additional question that follows up on the same topic. Regarding the broader approach to expansion, I was wondering whether recruiting an entire team in a market where you don't currently operate could happen without doing any acquisition. If a strong group became available in a brand-new region or one nearby, would you be more inclined to pursue that?

Mark R. DeFazio

executive
#30

Probably not; that simply isn't how we operate as a company. We have brought on strong people in the regions where we do business, and we've done that without exposing ourselves to financial danger or dealing with the difficulties of merging teams and blending cultures. That's why taking over entire groups of employees from another firm isn't something we generally favor. That said, if a one-of-a-kind opportunity came along that seemed like a good match, we'd be open to looking at it. Still, there's plenty of standalone talent available in the areas we serve. This approach has served us well across 27 years. Our plan is to continue with the same growth strategy we've been using.

Feddie Strickland

analyst
#31

Great. Thanks.

Mark R. DeFazio

executive
#32

Thank you. I'd like to wrap up by pointing out that what we've reported once again demonstrates how solid and stable the foundation of our business model is. The strategy MCB follows rests on disciplined underwriting, a cautious approach to risk management, and making the most of where we stand in the market — and that leaves us well placed to keep producing sensible growth along with excellent financial results. Our commitment to backing our clients and the communities we serve stays firm, even as we generate suitable returns for shareholders. Thanks once more for joining the call, and we hope to see you and talk with you at our Investor Day.

Daniel F. Dougherty

executive
#33

Thank you very much.

Operator

operator
#34

That wraps up today's conference call and webcast. A recording of this call is available on our webcast archive at.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Metropolitan Bank Holding Corp. transcript — plus 131,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Metropolitan Bank Holding Corp. earnings transcripts and 131,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Metropolitan Bank Holding Corp. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.