Monte Carlo Fashions Limited (MONTECARLO) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

August 6, 2026

National Stock Exchange of India IN Consumer Discretionary Textiles, Apparel and Luxury Goods earnings 55 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Ladies and gentlemen, hello and welcome to the Q1 FY ’27 earnings conference call of Monte Carlo Fashions Limited, brought to you by Emkay Global Financial Services Limited. <<operator_script>> At this point I hand the call over to Mr. Sunny Bhadra of Emkay Global Financial Services Limited. Thanks. The floor is now yours.

Sunny Bhadra

analyst
#2

Thank you, Anushka. Good morning, everyone. I'd like to extend a welcome to the management team and express our appreciation for this opportunity. Joining us on the call today are Mr. Rishabh Oswal, Executive Director; Mr. Sandeep Jain, Executive Director; Mr. R.K. Sharma, Chief Financial Officer; and Mr. Ankur Gauba, Company Secretary. At this point I'll turn things over to the management for their opening remarks. Gentlemen, over to you.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#3

Good morning, everyone, and thanks so much for being here on today’s earnings call as we go over how we performed in the quarter that closed on 30 June 2026. I’ll begin with the financial highlights, followed by the operational highlights. In the first quarter under review, revenue from operations came in at INR149 crores, which works out to 8% growth year on year. The first quarter stayed a lean period, and that led to an EBITDA loss of INR13 crores along with a net loss of INR23 crores. Quarterly performance was mainly hit by a rise in product returns during this period, and the effect of that will be offset in the quarters that follow. Turning to operational performance, we saw broad-based growth across our key product categories. Cotton volumes were up 23% year on year. Home textile rose 42% year on year. Kids wear increased 5% year on year, reflecting strong product acceptance. Our Rock.It brand carried on along its growth trajectory, while the Home Textile segment kept up healthy momentum. <<inaudible>> sale also climbed 38% YoY, and we stay optimistic about continued growth in these emerging categories. Our retail expansion strategy remains on track, with a target of opening 40 to 45 exclusive brand outlets during the year, with a strategic focus on the western and southern regions.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#4

Online sales rose 15% year over year, so our digital channel keeps building momentum. We also deepened our online footprint by teaming up with major quick commerce players such as Blinkit, Swiggy, and Zepto, which makes 30-minute deliveries possible. On top of that, working with Salesforce is helping us run things more smoothly, improve how customers experience us, and build stronger long-term loyalty through digital transformation efforts. In February and March 2026 we also held our pre-winter and winter trade show successfully; it drew encouraging participation and helped with order booking for the coming season. With solid momentum across every one of our product portfolios, growing retail and digital reach, and encouraging customer response to our upcoming seasonal collection, we stay confident in our long-term growth strategy. We believe we are well positioned to strengthen our market presence and deliver sustainable value for our stakeholders. With that, we now open the session for question and answer. Thank you very much.

Operator

operator
#5

Thanks a lot. At this point we’ll open it up for questions and answers. <<operator_script>> Our first question comes from Sucrit D. Patil at Eyesight Fintrade Private Limited. Go ahead.

Sucrit Patil

analyst
#6

Morning, everyone. I’ve got two questions. First, for Mr. Rishabh — this goes beyond the usual outlook. I’d just like to get a sense of the top two to three execution priorities you’re concentrating on over the coming quarters, and along with that, what do you view as the biggest risk when it comes to shifts in consumer demand, fashion cycles, or competitive pressures, and how are you getting ready to handle those while also strengthening Monte Carlo’s position in the branded space? That’s my first question. I’ll follow with my second one after this. Thank you.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#7

Okay, good morning. Sandeep Jain here, and I'd like Rishabh to back me up on the answers as well. On the first question, since I clearly grasped what our plan is for the next two quarters — if you look at this quarter, the returns came in higher largely because we arranged our returns to be dispatched on time with better planning. That's the reason we pulled them into the June quarter, since last year they were split between the first quarter and the second quarter. So, to plan sales better in the year ahead at our factory outlets too, and to manage return inventory better, returns were higher this quarter, and we think we're well placed for a strong year, this year as well, and we expect growth in double digits going forward. Yes, there has been some tension from geopolitical issues. There have been inflation issues, there have been issues around freight, and input costs are rising. But in spite of all of that, we're well positioned to hit our growth. I'd also ask Mr. Rishabh to lend his support on this.

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#8

As Mr. Sandeep ji correctly pointed out, the higher returns we're seeing in our numbers for the first quarter come from better operational performance on our side, and this time we recalled and processed the returns on schedule, so the overall returns count should average out during the second quarter. Second, we're placing a great deal of emphasis on our digital channels too—mainly our own website, along with quick commerce. Our approach has always centered on outright sales, which makes sure we end up with the smallest possible level of returns. Beyond that, significant effort is going into stock planning for what we send to our stores. Previously we relied entirely on the orders coming in from our retailers. Now, though, a back end team we've set up using multiple software tools scrutinizes every retailer's order, which helps us improve our sale through and discounting.

Sucrit Patil

analyst
#9

Thanks. My second question is for Mr. Sharma. Looking at it from a financial standpoint, I just want to get a sense of whether you foresee any major risks or challenges over the next few quarters, and what particular steps are being taken to keep margins in check, keep cash flow stable, and preserve the strength of the balance sheet — particularly in areas such as raw material cost, volatility, receivables and compliances. Thank you.

R.K. Sharma

executive
#10

When it comes to our company, the primary difficulty boils down to just two things: discounts and returns. Provided we can hold returns at the level we've planned, roughly 12% to 13%, our margins will certainly get better. Regarding the rise in metal costs, we actually secure everything ahead of time when we do the pre-book — all raw materials plus all other accessories. So the impact on that front is hardly anything. And on the working capital side, we are certainly keeping a very tight watch on all our debtor outstanding collections, and we expect that will get better going forward as well.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#11

I’d like to add one point: since input packing costs have gone up a little, there could be a 100 basis point gap in margins for this financial year compared with last year’s.

Sucrit Patil

analyst
#12

Thanks, and all the best to you.

Operator

operator
#13

Thanks. Our next question comes from Gunit Singh at Countercyclical PMS. Go ahead, please.

Gunit Singh Narang

analyst
#14

Thanks for the chance to ask this. What I'd like to get clear on is that our cotton sales volumes rose 24% and home textiles rose 40%, yet our revenues didn't rise even 10% during this quarter. So could you walk me through in detail exactly what took place, and when you mention sales returns, which are higher this quarter — so what was the figure for sales returns in Q1 FY ’26, and will there be no sales returns at all next quarter, or could you elaborate on that?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#15

That is a fair question, certainly. If you've noticed, Cotton segment volume has increased by nearly 20%, just as you correctly mentioned. Home textile is growing as well. Therefore, the sole cause of lower sales is that we received a greater number of returns. Usually the split occurs between the first quarter and the second quarter. However, during this quarter we had roughly INR50 CR more in returns versus the prior financial year. That is essentially what damaged the revenues portion. So in the second quarter and in the third quarter, you would see us offset this return, since returns should be lower than last year. And we will achieve revenue growth in the second quarter and the third quarter.

Gunit Singh Narang

analyst
#16

What caused those returns to be elevated? Did they involve winter items, and when a return comes in, how is it handled—does it get deducted from revenues?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#17

No, no. Here's what happens: the winter returns come in, with a portion arriving in March and the remainder in the first quarter and second quarter. So whenever we manufacture the material, we make it at WSP. But when we bring it back, we bring it back at a cost. That's why we also have to take a loss. So now — this inventory is now carried at a cost on our balance sheet. So when we bill it again, the profit will be booked once more.

Gunit Singh Narang

analyst
#18

Understood. What caused the returns to come in higher this quarter? And does that mean we won’t see returns in the next quarter? What makes you confident about that?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#19

Right, no, you'll see returns come through in the second quarter as well. But if you take the first-quarter returns together with the second-quarter returns, the percentage return relative to total revenue will level out. So this quarter, you'll see INR50 crores of additional return has been processed — previously our capacity for inverting returns was limited. We've raised that capacity. That's why we've managed to pull more returns into the first quarter. This has already been refinished and already been sent to new distribution channels, such as our online channel, brand factories and factory outlets. This will help us in achieving better realization of these products. The overall return is more or less the same as last year in percentage terms. Just to add to what Rishabh has said. See, the main reason is that we wanted to refinish it as soon as we could so that we can dispatch it in time. Because normally what happens is there's a lot of pressure when the returns come in late. Because the season starts in September, October. So we wanted to refinish it in time so that we can dispatch it on time.

Gunit Singh Narang

analyst
#20

You brought up that processing capacity for returns has gone up. So what exactly did you do, and when did that increase happen?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#21

You've just brought on additional warehouse space and more staff. During definition, the process involved is quite manual. So that's everything we've done. Earlier there was a constraint on space, which is why that occurred. Now that we have this space, refinishing capacity has gone up as well.

Gunit Singh Narang

analyst
#22

Understood. So by processing it, you basically mean whatever comes back can be handled fast and then returned to the store. That's the idea, correct?

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#23

Yeah, so just to give you an example: if before we were doing 5,000 pieces per day and today we can do 10,000 pieces per day, then the refinishing capacity has doubled. That is helping us even to take returns earlier, so we can finish them well on time and dispatch them on time.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#24

To give you a rough sense of the total returns we were expecting across the first and second quarters: last year, we had processed roughly 50% of total returns in Q1 and 50% in Q2. This year, we've processed nearly 65% of the total returns we're due to receive. That means next quarter we'll get only 35% of the total returns. Hopefully that adds a bit more clarity.

Gunit Singh Narang

analyst
#25

But on returns — when you talk about returns, if a customer comes in and wants to bring their products back, I mean, you can't turn them away, right. So it isn't about our ability to handle it. It's really just customers coming in and making returns. Right.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#26

These aren’t returns from customers. What you’re talking about is only the returns from online sales that take place. What comes back to us from our retailers is institutional returns. So this is B2B returns. And we can definitely prevent our retailers from sending goods back to us if it’s more than what we’ve agreed. This isn’t B2C returns, this is B2B returns. Yeah. And we have complete control over how much we want to pick up from our retailers.

Gunit Singh Narang

analyst
#27

Understood. And regarding sales returns, could you also break that down — say, of that INR50 Cr, what portion consists of B2C returns within the customer?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#28

B2B returns account for 100% of this. Every bit of it is B2B. This is entirely B2B returns.

Gunit Singh Narang

analyst
#29

Understood. My next question concerns inflation in yarn and cotton prices. Have we implemented any price increases? You said our margin would take a 100 basis points hit. I didn't quite follow what you meant there. So we — our margin will be 100 basis points lower this year.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#30

I'll split this into two parts. First, the winter trade show, which took place four months ago. As Rishabh correctly noted, the trade show went well at that point, and we raised prices by roughly 6% to 7%, depending on increases in raw material costs. Now, turning to the summer season, we have another trade show coming next year. So we're implementing a further increase of approximately 8% to 10%, depending on how much cotton prices have risen. That's the first area. The second area is input cost. Other cost pressures from inflation and freight have also risen. And it's not as though we've fully passed on every single increase, since some materials are procured a bit later as well. So my assumption is that most of these things will be covered. That said, there could be a small gap of about 100 basis points versus last year's margins as we move through this financial year.

Gunit Singh Narang

analyst
#31

We observed that impact during Q1 too.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#32

Could you say that again?

Gunit Singh Narang

analyst
#33

We also experienced that 100 basis point impact during Q1.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#34

When I discuss this, I mean the entire financial year—not any single quarter. So any time we provide guidance, it covers the whole financial year. Offering guidance at the company level is very difficult.

Gunit Singh Narang

analyst
#35

Understood. What was the same-store sales growth for Q1?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#36

It came in at approximately 7%.

Gunit Singh Narang

analyst
#37

7%. And regarding FY ’27, could you break that down — I mean, what kind of SSG <<inaudible>> should we expect? We’re also adding 40 new stores. So would you be willing to provide some guidance for FY ’27 on growth and EBITDA margins?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#38

We've already said we'd be growing at a double-digit rate. At that double-digit rate — I can't put an exact number on it — it will be in the low double digits. Yes, there will be a slight margin reduction, 100 basis points, we assume, and as for SSG, when it comes to our in-house targets, we're aiming for 10% SSG in this financial year as well. We grew 11% last year too. So beyond that, we'll grow SSG by 10% in this financial year as well, and 40 to 45 stores, which we mentioned earlier in our presentation, we'll keep opening those stores in this financial year too.

Gunit Singh Narang

analyst
#39

Understood. On EBITDA margins — last year, unless I'm mistaken, we posted roughly 18%. So should we expect something like 17%, or would it be beneath that, in the 12% to 15% range?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#40

To start with, I’m not able to provide precise figures, but when we look at inflation and the rising input costs, we feel confident in saying it could be under 100 basis points moving ahead, since we don’t want to promise something beyond our reach. That said, if the next quarter turns out really strong — and we’ve observed that geopolitical tensions have cooled off, oil prices have fallen, and input costs are easing — then there’s a possibility we could hold the same margin or even see an upward revision. Beyond that, everything hinges on how the next three to four months play out. We’ll be able to share guidance during the second-quarter con call.

Gunit Singh Narang

analyst
#41

Understood. Thanks a lot. Best of luck, and I’ll rejoin the queue.

Operator

operator
#42

Thanks. Our next question comes from Amit Kumar at Determined Investments. Go ahead.

Amit Kumar

analyst
#43

Thanks a lot. So I actually pulled the figures from your presentation on sales returns. I was just hoping to understand something: you already had an opening provision for sales returns of roughly INR180 crores, and the actual came in at around INR130 crores. So why does that whole amount end up going through your P&L? Shouldn't it be set off against the provisions you're already carrying on the balance sheet?

R.K. Sharma

executive
#44

This is R.K. Sharma. In fact, what you're describing is correct — it is adjusted against the opening provision itself. But what happens is that our returns come in. We get returns across two financial years. So part of it arrives this year, and part arrives next year. Therefore, the remaining portion will come in during the second and third quarters. So the returns relate to last year. And accordingly, that INR180 crores of opening provision will be adjusted within that same thing. So this is just the first quarter. That INR180 crores opening provision covers the full year.

Amit Kumar

analyst
#45

All right, I understand. Got it. Thanks. Many thanks.

Operator

operator
#46

Thanks. Our next question comes from Mahindra Jain at Way2Wealth. Go ahead, please.

Mahindra Jain

analyst
#47

Appreciate the chance to speak. Let me just check — you can hear me now.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#48

Yeah, yep. We can hear you.

Mahindra Jain

analyst
#49

Yes, thanks. What I want to get clear on is the roadmap over the coming three years. In the quarter, we're growing. So where does margin in cotton improve down the road, given how large the unorganized sector is and how tough competition is? And since we're offsetting this winter with cotton and home textiles, where do you see us in three years on margin in cotton plus contribution in cotton — what will the split between home textile and cotton contribution be in the next three years?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#50

Looking at the trend over the past 2, 3 years, it's pretty clear that cotton sales as a share of total sales have been climbing. So we've gotten to roughly 45% cotton and 55% winter wear sales. We've also mentioned that within the next 2 to 3 years, summer and winter sales will even out, and eventually cotton will overtake winter sales. That's the ultimate goal, and we're essentially positioned for that kind of target. And as for — what was the second question again?

Mahindra Jain

analyst
#51

On margin — what would the margin scenario look like in three years for cotton? Considering demand from competitors or the unorganized sector, how do we see our margin, given that our brand is reputed? So where do we see the margin improving?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#52

I’m glad to say that, right now, we’re seeing stronger margins on cotton winter products. Compared with winter wear items in the Cotton segment, it’s up by nearly 100 basis points. So there’s no concern about margins in the Cotton segment. Margins there are already equal or better, and we expect to keep them at that level in Cotton because we have some advantages. We’re number one in T-shirts in India. We sell almost two million pieces in India, and that is growing at a very good rate. At the same time, if you’ve looked at volume growth in the other categories—shirts, trouser, denims—all of them are growing. That gives us confidence that we’ll be able to maintain margins going forward as well, and overall for the next three to four years. We said earlier that we’re looking for double-digit growth going forward, even in this financial year. Earlier we indicated that we may grow at around 20%, but given the geopolitical conditions and also to protect ourselves, we planned for less inventory, so that if something goes wrong, we are not trapped at the retail end or at the consumer end.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#53

That's the reason a portion of the inventory has been reduced. Even so, we remain highly confident about achieving double-digit growth in this financial year.

Mahindra Jain

analyst
#54

So where do we stand in home textile across general market scenarios—are our products very well accepted, yeah?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#55

Yes, happy to report that in the prior year we achieved growth of about 12%, and for this year we expect roughly 20% to 25% growth in the home textile segment. Revenue-wise, I believe it came in around 170 last year. This year we should close at approximately 215. That works out to a 20% to 25% increase. So we're in a strong position, and the brand enjoys very good recall. In addition, our summer wear line, a collection within home furnishing, is expanding at 60% to 70% versus the prior financial year. So I think we'll deliver roughly 20% to 25% growth in home textile sales during this financial year, as far as growth goes.

Mahindra Jain

analyst
#56

So what does our CapEx plan look like? As you said, we’re modernizing our country. Is this just, I mean, working CapEx or something you’re adding, or what cash do we have on the books now after solar and all of this?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#57

No, our business is very asset-light. Capital expenditure goes only into warehousing, which we are already building during this financial year, plus some machine modernization that does not exceed INR10 Cr to INR15 Cr. So this is a very CapEx-light business, and we will keep that CapEx guidance of INR30 Cr as well for the next financial year.

Mahindra Jain

analyst
#58

So, what's the cash on the books at the moment, and what are we planning to do with it going forward, given that our market cap is pretty much, I mean, equal to the company's net worth? So are you planning anything like planned visits or an analyst meet or something along those lines? Are you planning to just make people aware of the valuations?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#59

We have INR305 crores of cash on the books, and we always welcome all our analysts and stakeholders to come visit us and see how — how we've been doing here, and everyone is welcome to visit us, and even after this con call, if any questions remain unanswered, you can always send a query to our <<inaudible>> advisors and we'll be glad to answer it.

Mahindra Jain

analyst
#60

Would that be INR305 crores?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#61

Yes.

Mahindra Jain

analyst
#62

All right. And how are those solar initiatives performing? I mean, when do we expect a return on that investment?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#63

The solar projects haven't begun yet. We're currently in the land aggregation phase, so my expectation is that within the coming nine to 12 months the plants should come online, and billing ought to get underway starting in the next financial year.

Mahindra Jain

analyst
#64

Are you planning to increase CapEx in solar going forward? I mean, more investment in solar.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#65

Our priority is getting these projects implemented and commissioned first, so we can build high confidence. But yes, we're putting in roughly 50 megawatts in D.C., which is an investment of around INR150 crores. So we'd want to finish that investment first, get it commissioned, begin billing for the project, and only then move on to new tenders. Still, we're quite optimistic about this segment. That said, if something interesting comes along, we'd be more than happy to pursue it as well, yes.

Mahindra Jain

analyst
#66

Regarding any other vertical—I mean, do you have something in mind, like, say, we're in footwear—so is there any other vertical you're planning to move into down the road, or is that our own business?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#67

Footwear falls under the lifestyle segment as well, and as a brand, when we move into lifestyle, we have to serve all categories. So we'll keep adding categories. Solar, though, is a separate vertical that we've taken on. At the moment, our focus is solely on retail and solar. We aren't looking at any other segment.

Mahindra Jain

analyst
#68

All right, all right, thanks. I'd like to go see the plant. I'll ask <<inaudible>>.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#69

Absolutely. We’ll have our Company Secretary, Ankur Gauba, coordinate with you on that, and then we’ll follow up with you.

Mahindra Jain

analyst
#70

Thanks.

Operator

operator
#71

Thanks. We’ll take the next question from Neeraj <<inaudible>>, an individual investor. Go ahead.

Neeraj

analyst
#72

My question was about overall sales—how much of that comes from a B2B sales perspective and how much is sold directly by the company. So if I look at last year's sales, it was INR1,300 crores here. So roughly what percentage is that?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#73

B2B sales alone account for more than 90%. The only direct-to-consumer online sales come straight from our website. So that, I believe, makes up 3% to 4%.

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#74

Yeah, even for online sales, only 20% of the total comes from our own website and roughly 45 company-owned EBOs — that's the direct sales piece.

Neeraj

analyst
#75

So essentially, based on the company's own EBO, what portion of the sale is actually coming through? Is it just 10%, with the rest coming from the B2B vendor?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#76

We’re able to look into that and get back to you in writing. At the moment I don’t have a specific number, but roughly speaking, it ought to be about 20% of total EBOs’ sales — that’s company owned, I believe. So the sales would be along those lines. As for the precise sales figure, you can reach out to us separately, and we’ll provide an answer.

Neeraj

analyst
#77

And moving to the sales return piece — that's relatively high. When I look at total sales against sales returns, it comes out at roughly 25 to 30 percentage of the sales we do. How does this essentially — it essentially puts extra burden on the P&L too. What's our plan for bringing down this level of sales return?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#78

We rank among the top companies in the entire sector, delivering a return of roughly 11% at the overall company level. If you put us up against any listed or unlisted firm, theirs tends to sit around 15% to 16%, or perhaps even above 20%. That makes us one of just a handful of Indian companies generating a return of 11% on total sales, if you look at it that way. The catch is that the third quarter carries a very heavy load, so it begins showing up right in the first quarter. Yet once you look at our second quarter, third quarter, and fourth quarter results, you'll notice this doesn't surface. The return issue doesn't surface. It's confined to the first quarter. We do run into some difficulties there, given how heavy the third and fourth quarters are. Still, on the whole, please evaluate us on full financial year performance set against the prior financial year. That way you'll find our returns, our profitability, and our revenues lining up with what we are committing.

Neeraj

analyst
#79

And as far as that sales return goes, is it mainly tied to the woolen piece, or does it span the quarter and the other items as well?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#80

Returns happen in every category, though woolen carries a higher ASP. So that shows up more on the balance sheet in the first quarter. Still, each of the categories does see some returns. The overall percentages, however, remain unchanged — roughly 11% at the company level, as I mentioned before.

Neeraj

analyst
#81

So when I looked at these figures, INR180 crores represents the total sales return for this quarter. From what I understand, that accounts for 65% of all returns, and the remaining 35% is what we're essentially expecting in quarter two. So if I take that into account, overall sales return would come to roughly INR250 crores, INR260 crores.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#82

Apologies. So 65% of the winter returns — right now we’re handling the winter return, and summer returns are going to come on top of that, arriving in the third and fourth quarters.

Neeraj

analyst
#83

On the quantum side, what sort of estimate are we looking at? I'm not after precise numbers—just a rough ballpark, something along the lines of what we have now, like this <<inaudible>>.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#84

Let me just put it this way. During the first quarter, we took back close to 1 lakh additional pieces as returns, and in the quarter after that, we'll bring back roughly 70,000 fewer in volume versus the same period a year ago. So when you look at the two quarters together, total returns will be up by 35,000 to 45,000, which matches how dispatches have grown.

Neeraj

analyst
#85

All right. And from what I gather, you're saying there's no way to bring down that specific level of returns. It's standard practice in the industry, and it's simply something you expect — as our sales go up, sales returns are going to rise as well, on that percentage basis.

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#86

Returns are the top KPI we monitor across the whole company. That's because this is the one thing that can affect both our margins and our profitability. So, as Mr. Sandeep ji mentioned, thanks to all of these efforts, we have one of the lowest return rates in the industry compared with any other company. These things are part and parcel. They can never be eliminated. Our best effort is to bring them down as low as we possibly can.

Neeraj

analyst
#87

All right. Nothing more to add. Thank you.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#88

I appreciate that.

Operator

operator
#89

Thanks. Our next question comes from Amit Sanghvi <<inaudible>>, an individual investor. Go ahead.

Amit Sanghvi

analyst
#90

Hello there. Can you hear me okay?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#91

Yes, we can hear you now.

Amit Sanghvi

analyst
#92

Looking at this P&L, advertisement and business promotion costs are down by INR362 crores. Yet despite that, losses have gone up by INR10 crores. So how should we interpret this? Regarding the sales we're anticipating going forward — will they be comparatively lower than last year, than last Q2 and Q3, or how should we read this given that advertisement and business promotion expenses are lower?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#93

I’d ask that you not look at advertising expense quarter by quarter. For the full year, our guidance is roughly 3% of sales, and that level will stay in place. So there have been shifts, with variations from one quarter to another at times. In some cases, the first quarter carries a lower advertising expense. In the second quarter, the expense is higher. So sometimes the results are good in the second quarter. Overall, at the financial year level, it will stay the same.

Amit Sanghvi

analyst
#94

All right, so you're confident top line revenue will grow by double digits, and that EBITDA growth will be about the same, or off by 1% either way?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#95

Yes, that's accurate. That's exactly what we've been saying.

Amit Sanghvi

analyst
#96

Alright. Alright. So how much has been spent in total on this energy project up to now?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#97

Up to now, no investment has actually been made. The amount will be around INR147 crores to INR150 crores. However, in the next quarter, none of this money has been invested so far.

Amit Sanghvi

analyst
#98

But I believe we announced this 12 months ago. So even after lakhs of that, we still haven’t incurred any expenses?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#99

No — because after we announced that the LOA had been obtained, it was then converted. After that, a PPA process had to be carried out, and signing it took an additional three months. Right now, since it's the rainy season, we're in the middle of aggregating land. In the coming quarter you'll see — because this project is very short-term — that disbursement will take place within two quarters. So you'll see the full amount going out over the next two quarters. The time being taken is for compliance, for getting the agreement signed.

Amit Sanghvi

analyst
#100

Alright, that covers all the points I had to share. All right, thanks so much.

Operator

operator
#101

Thanks. Our next question comes from Diwakar at Fusion Equity <<inaudible>>. Go ahead, please.

Diwakar

analyst
#102

Good morning. Given how healthy the company's cash position is, is management looking into the possibility of a share buyback?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#103

Yes, absolutely. The board is always discussing that. So if any plan comes up, we will certainly make sure all our stakeholders are informed about it.

Diwakar

analyst
#104

All right, so regarding that double-digit growth you mentioned you're aiming for — are you thinking more along the lines of 10% to 12%, or something higher, like 18% to 20% growth?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#105

As you can see, we pointed to growth in the low double digits.

Diwakar

analyst
#106

All right, thanks.

Operator

operator
#107

Thank you. We’ll take the next question from the line of Sheetal Shah <<inaudible>>, an Individual Investor. Please go ahead.

Sheetal Shah

analyst
#108

Hi there. Can you hear me okay?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#109

Yeah, we can hear you.

Sheetal Shah

analyst
#110

Good morning. Apologies — I dialed in late. So if I’m asking something that’s already been asked, forgive me. Q3 is always the joyful quarter for us as shareholders. But that joy fades as we move into Q4 and Q1, and it becomes sorrow once we get to Q1 of the following year. Management has taken a step to offset this impact by diversifying into cotton and leather products. But somehow the impact isn’t showing. My question is: what is management considering, in terms of how to reduce this impact or offset it, so that it doesn’t distort the full-year figure?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#111

To start, let me wish everyone pleasant quarters. As we said on our call earlier in the year, we give guidance for annual performance rather than for individual quarters. We stated correctly that there would be some pain in the third quarter and the fourth quarter, with pain in the fourth quarter and the first quarter. Yet looking at this fourth quarter, we took adequate measures, and this fourth quarter was positive; the second quarter was positive; the third quarter was positive. A loss occurred only in the first quarter. The same practice will be followed this year as well. The first quarter is again having a — the first quarter is again having a loss because of returns. And the second, third, and fourth quarters definitely will be followed as we followed them in the last financial year. But the good thing is that we have been known as a winter wear player. If you look at it, there has been volume growth of 27% in the first quarter in summer season sales. So that shows — that shows that summer wear categories have been accepted and are being established in the market as far as the Monte Carlo brand is concerned.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#112

That's a really positive indicator for us moving ahead as well, since otherwise we had been intending to achieve greater double-digit expansion, yet we reduced our output given the geopolitical strains and inflation. So there could be some possibility of somewhat better returns, and monsoon-related problems have also appeared. If not for those, we would have guided toward growth above 20%. Still, we aim to stay quite cautious and to safeguard our margins too. That's the reason we have trimmed the growth somewhat. Even so, we aren't giving up much on margins or much in other respects.

Sheetal Shah

analyst
#113

I'd just like to add one thing — is there any step we could take to bring these sales returns down? Because that's really the one terrible item on the financial side; if it comes down, our profit numbers for the whole year look decent. So is there anything we can do, or does management have some kind of game plan for lowering this hidden sales figure?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#114

This question has come up multiple times during this call. We've made it clear that returns are an inherent part of the business. The only thing we can do is keep them to a minimum. And we're already at a very low level — 11% to 12%. When you look at industry-related figures, they exceed 15% to 20%. Still, we keep pushing for more efforts to bring returns down. But in percentage terms, it can't be very high. If I'm at 12%, I can go to 11.5%. But bringing it to 9% or 8% is not possible at all. What we do try is to always have a lower return than the previous financial year — maybe 30 basis points, 40 basis points, 50 basis points. That's what we're always aiming for.

Sheetal Shah

analyst
#115

Alright. Alright. The rationale was that our stock trades at just 10x, whereas other retailers trade at 30x or more. That was the primary basis for this request. And the second question is that in the last two con calls, you had said that while we hold this kind of margin, we can only grow by this amount. So my question is that earlier you had said we can easily grow by 15%, 20%. So because of geopolitical tension you are saying our sales revenue guidance is cut to low double-digit. So if geopolitical tension eases, do you see any other headwind for us not growing by 15%, 20%?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#116

Yeah. Yeah. Could you say that again? I couldn’t hear it.

Sheetal Shah

analyst
#117

Apologies, apologies, sir. During the two con calls, you had mentioned that if we hold revenue at this level — I had asked you why we wouldn't push our revenue higher. At that point you said that to preserve this kind of margin, we can only grow by this amount. So 15%, 20% — we can easily grow while keeping this type of margin. That is why we aren't raising our revenue, to keep our margin safe. Now, because of geopolitical tension, sir, you are saying we can grow at low double-digit. So is geopolitical tension the only headwind preventing us from growing 15%, 20%, 20%, or do you foresee any other headwinds?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#118

You've partly answered your own question, so let me address the balance of it. First, yes, we did clearly state that our aim was 15% to 20% growth. In the fourth quarter, during a con call, we had clear visibility into that 15% to 20% growth, since our order book stood at that level. But now we have deliberately reduced production. It isn't that the order book has disappeared. It's just that certain issues have emerged from geopolitical tensions. Inflation has risen, which the RBI has already flagged. There has also been news of a monsoon deficit, and I think everyone knows India is a heavily agricultural economy that also relies on the monsoon. So we don't want to take undue risk with our margins. That is why we've trimmed production somewhat, so we can grow at roughly double-digit levels without being aggressive, in case this work drags on or further problems arise with the monsoon or inflation. If that happened, it could hurt sales, and then there could be more discounts, and it could also drive more returns.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#119

So, just to protect ourselves, we've said we'll grow at a low double-digit rate. Otherwise, the original plan—based on order bookings and what came from the trade show—was only 15% to 20%. But again, this is purely to protect our production and protect our margins. That's the decision we've made.

Sheetal Shah

analyst
#120

Got it, sir — thank you, sir. Finally, our stock is trading at a very low P. Sir, going forward, please think about the buyback proposal. Sir, that is everything from my end. Thank you, sir, and best wishes.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#121

Thanks.

Operator

operator
#122

Thanks. Our following question comes from Ritika Pahwa at Pahwa Securities Private Limited. Go ahead, please.

Ritika Pahwa

analyst
#123

Yeah. Hello sir, I’ve got a couple of questions. The first concerns your expansion of stores. In the presentation, I noticed that you plan to add roughly 40 to 45 stores this year. I’d just like to get a sense of the overall investment required for each store. What’s the payback period? If you could say a little more about how you approach that. And my second question is on exports. Is the company putting any focus on exports?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#124

Let me address the first question. So what does the CapEx cover? The CapEx relates solely to the franchise. We only make CapEx investments in stores the company owns. So that accounts for, I believe, just 10% to 15% of the outlets opened during a financial year. That is the only CapEx we undertake. The remaining CapEx is handled by the franchisees, and you should expect an ROI of three to four years.

Ritika Pahwa

analyst
#125

Understood — usually it’s 3 to 4 years.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#126

On exports, right now we don’t have any exports, but we’ve been doing some online exports, so to speak. Mr. Rishabh will explain the reasons. Yeah.

Rishabh Oswal

executive
#127

As a company, we aren’t an exporter — we’re a retailer brand. So exports aren’t where our focus lies. When it comes to selling overseas, our focus is only on sales that happen under our own brand. For that, we’ve partnered with a few portals in the Middle East and Europe where there is some sale, but it isn’t at a level that’s worth discussing. But as a company, our focus is on the domestic market, not exports.

Ritika Pahwa

analyst
#128

All right, got it. So none of the FTAs India is signing — whether with the UK or Europe — gives you any advantage? Within this entity, you don’t see any upside from the FTA, correct?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#129

No. The reason is that our company doesn’t possess many manufacturing units. Most of our production is outsourced, and the only manufacturing we do exists to serve our own demand. So, as we’ve said, we’re an asset light company. That means exporting would require having those manufacturing capabilities in house. If we didn’t, we couldn’t operate it under a trading model.

Ritika Pahwa

analyst
#130

Okay, and one more thing — what's your capacity utilization at the moment, and what do you see as the maximum turnover? Could you grow with the capacity you have now, or would more capital be required?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#131

On the Woolen side, we've brought in roughly 15 to 17 additional machines, and our cotton plants are operating at full capacity. We have no spare capacity on hand. Any other demand that comes in, we outsource to third-party vendors, and that's how we'll approach it going forward.

Ritika Pahwa

analyst
#132

There's no additional CapEx on the table. As for any incremental demand you're referring to, such as double-digit growth <<inaudible>>?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#133

Yes, so annually we allocate somewhere between INR10 crores and INR15 crores toward our in-house facilities — upgrading them and bringing in a couple of new machines — and that's really all. There's no significant CapEx on the production side.

Ritika Pahwa

analyst
#134

I really appreciate it. Thanks.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#135

Thanks.

Operator

operator
#136

Thanks. Our next question comes from Gunit Singh at Countercyclical PMS. Go ahead.

Gunit Singh Narang

analyst
#137

Thanks for the follow-up. Sir, back in 2015 our stock traded at INR567, and now, 11 years later, it is at that same price or even below it. Even though we are among the oldest brands in India, the share is valued only around its book value. By comparison, other branded companies command multiples like 2x or 4x of book value. So my request to you is this: instead of deploying funds into commodity businesses such as solar, where the returns are tiny, why not look at putting money into our own company through a share buyback and raising the promoter shareholding to 75%? I believe at these levels there is no better investment than repurchasing our own shares, especially since we hold cash as well, and it would deliver a long-term benefit to enduring shareholders by lifting EPS on a permanent basis. So I would like to know whether the board has any such plan under consideration, whether anything like this is on the books, and if it is not, I would respectfully ask you to think about it.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#138

Thanks, Gunit ji. I can certainly appreciate the pain on that front. We feel that same pain too, since the share price hasn't performed even though the company has nearly multiplied its turnover from 2015 through this financial year. And yes, we have definitely taken note of your suggestions.

Gunit Singh Narang

analyst
#139

Thanks so much, sir — that's great. A share buyback would also demonstrate how confident we are in our own business, and it would send a solid signal to the market too. So I really appreciate you taking it into consideration, and I hope something happens along those lines. Thank you.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#140

Thanks.

Operator

operator
#141

Thanks. Our next question comes from Jigar <<inaudible>>, an Individual Investor — please go ahead. Mr. Jigar, I'd ask you to unmute first and then speak. Since there's no response from Jigar's side, we'll just proceed to the following question. We now take the next question from Amit Sanghvi, an Individual Investor — please proceed.

Amit Sanghvi

analyst
#142

Yes sir. As you mentioned, the sales return for this Monte Carlo is industry-based at around 12%, versus 15% to 20% per industry standard. So I don’t think there’s any further possibility to reduce this 12% percentage. As you say, it could be 11.5% or at most 11%, but not beyond that. So what I feel, and what I suggest, is that if you can make a higher provision in Q3 — based on the average sales return of the last two years — where our sales are on a very high side, then this EBITDA margin or EBITDA level will even out, and this type of distorted Q1 or Q4 will not be there. So I just wanted to have a suggestion on it.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#143

That's a helpful point. Still, we've set aside solid provisioning this year. As a result, our fourth quarter came in positive, whereas it was negative in the last financial year. But rest assured, we have made note of your point.

Amit Sanghvi

analyst
#144

All right, thank you, sir. And thanks from me as well.

Operator

operator
#145

Thanks. <<operator_script>> Our following question comes from Jigar <<inaudible>>, who is an individual investor. Please go ahead.

Jigar

analyst
#146

Morning, sir. Thanks for letting me ask. Sir, my first question is about the economics of the stores. You're planning 40 to 45 store openings this year. So what's the typical payback period, and what EBITDA margin do mature stores run at? And over the next five years, how many stores can India ultimately absorb?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#147

To start, I already mentioned that foreign franchisees see ROI in three to four years from opening their store. So second, how many stores India can accommodate — that I might not be able to answer. But for sure, we have a plan for roughly 45 to 50 during this financial year. And we may raise that once all this situation gets back to normal. When it comes to inflation and geopolitical tensions, we might open additional stores in the next financial year. It's a massive market, a country of countries. Our population is 140 crore to sport. Middle class income there rises each year, the lower middle class is moving into the middle class, and the poor are moving into the lower middle class. So there's definitely plenty of room for organized players such as Monte Carlo to grow their sales. Even now, we are — we're adding only 20% of organized sales, so if INR100 of sales is happening, just INR20 is organized sales. So there's a lot of potential to go from 20 to 50, as we've seen in other developed markets like America, Europe and China.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#148

Their organized sale accounts for nearly 35% to 40% or 50%. So there's a lot of room for a brand like Monte Carlo to grow in this space.

Jigar

analyst
#149

Thanks. My next question is about the revenue guidance. You've already guided to low double-digit revenue growth, so could you help us understand the expected contributions from store additions, from same-store sales growth, and from price increases?

Sandeep Jain

executive
#150

I don’t have that data ready at hand. We can follow up with you in writing. Please share your email with our Valorem Advisor, and they’ll get back to you.

Jigar

analyst
#151

Appreciate it, sir.

Operator

operator
#152

Thanks. We’ll take the next question from Mahindra Jain, who’s on the line from Way2Wealth. Please go ahead.

Mahindra Jain

analyst
#153

Yes sir. I'd like to repeat my question, as I did, about the solar contract. Could you expand on that a bit? Are we putting money into land, or what does the exit clause look like? Say in the future we decide we don't like this business, since we're only doing investment, as you mentioned on the last call as well. So what does that contract clause look like? Are we purchasing land ourselves, or something along those lines? Could we please examine this, given that the margin — EBITDA — is 15%, as you said on the last call. So are these liquid investments, or what type of investment is it, please.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#154

So the land for every one of these projects is leased, not purchased. These leases run long term, anywhere from 25 to 30 years. The PPA we signed with the Madhya Pradesh government covers 25 years. That means we're on the hook to sell them these units for the following 25 years. We can't exit this investment during the one year after investment, after commissioning. Once that's past, though, we're fine if you want to monetize this asset. We want out of this business. There are plenty of buyers in the market, plenty of funds that purchase these recurring revenue assets, and they get sold at a basic discount rate of cash flow. That's the entire reason this is being set up in an SPV rather than in the mother company itself. The reason is that it will be an easy transfer if you want to exit this business down the road.

Mahindra Jain

analyst
#155

So I’ll purchase even the solar panel, and all of this installation will be handled either by us or by an EPC contractor, and it seems like…

Sandeep Jain

executive
#156

An EPC will receive it, and they'll handle the installation and all of that.

Mahindra Jain

analyst
#157

But investment is going to be our, like, okay.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#158

Right. That's the way every solar installation operates. There are professional EPC companies that do the installing — we have roughly, even our own in-house solar capacity is contracted out to EPC companies. We don't keep an in-house engineering team that can handle installation.

Mahindra Jain

analyst
#159

Right, right. So basically, whenever possible, we can exit, provided we don't have to enter that business down the road.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#160

Yes, it’s been one year since commissioning, in line with what the agreement specifies.

Mahindra Jain

analyst
#161

Alright. So the SPB is going to provide the precise return that you will receive. It will be merged into the parent company only now at the end of the year.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#162

Yes. That subsidiary is fully owned by the parent company.

Mahindra Jain

analyst
#163

Alright.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#164

Just like you mentioned for the coming 25 years, if your plan is to leave this business, transferring an SPB over to a new investor is a far simpler process than going through an asset sale.

Mahindra Jain

analyst
#165

Yeah. Because everyone is attempting to figure out why our valuations are low. I’m not referring to the stock price. I’m — it doesn’t exactly reflect the valuation of the business, the brand. Right now we are seeing new IPOs. Any company that they’re cooking their books, whatever they are doing. But we are a very reputed company. So it should be, it should be, I mean, noticed by investors and all this. So we have to exercise. Not exactly. I’m not advising any buyback, nothing like that. But we should put our investment into high growth areas and which especially in our overall strength like in textile or in woolen or whatever. So the expansion you are doing in the right path. So we hope to increase and anything regarding to restore confidence of the investors we have to do service.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#166

From a promoter standpoint, we stand to benefit the most when the multiplier goes up. Doing that is squarely in our own interest, but we've received quite a few questions on this front, and we commit to being more forthcoming about it, and we will take action, and by next quarter you ought to see results.

Mahindra Jain

analyst
#167

Yes, sir. Thank you. Thanks.

Operator

operator
#168

Thank you. Since participants have no more questions, I'd like to turn the conference back to management for closing remarks. Over to you, sir.

Sandeep Jain

executive
#169

Yes, thank you very much. I believe we’ve managed to address every question in a satisfactory way. Should you have any additional questions or anything else you’d like to learn about the company, please contact our higher advisors, Valorem Advisors. Thank you very much.

Operator

operator
#170

Thank you. That brings this conference to a close on behalf of Emkay Global Financial Services Limited.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Monte Carlo Fashions Limited transcript — plus 130,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Monte Carlo Fashions Limited earnings transcripts and 130,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Monte Carlo Fashions Limited or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.