Mutares SE & Co. KGaA (MUX) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

April 18, 2023

Deutsche Boerse Xetra DE Financials Capital Markets earnings 56 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Good afternoon, everyone, and welcome to the Mutares earnings call covering the full year 2022. Joining us today are the CIO, Johannes Laumann, and the CFO, Mark Friedrich, who will walk through the results and the most relevant events of the full year 2022. Once the presentation is done, they will be available to take your questions. The presentation being shown is available on the Mutares website after the call. Before we begin, I would like to remind you that this presentation contains forward-looking statements, including projections which may not develop as currently expected. I therefore kindly ask you to take note of the precautionary warning about forward-looking statements that is included in the materials on the website. Now let me hand over to Johannes Laumann.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#2

Good afternoon, good morning, good evening, everyone. A very warm welcome to our conference call covering financial year 2022. I'm delighted to open the presentation by introducing a new record year in Mutares' history for 2022, and then later on, looking ahead to '23, which appears very promising in terms of continuing to deliver what we promise. So I'll guide you through the company and remind you again about our business model. Then my colleague, Mark Friedrich, will take the financials before I close the sessions with the outlook. So, a small introduction. The phases should look familiar, or unchanged — unchanged is also the shareholding. We currently have — has a Management and Supervisory Board. And we're very happy with that. And we have no plans to change that. We have no plans to divest this. We have no plans to deal with this — on the contrary. I think we believe in the company, and you will see, when it's possible, that this share potentially also might increase in the weeks and months to come. Let me take you to the key highlights of 2022.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#3

And I think, again, we delivered what we promised, we delivered what we said, and we also delivered what you out there expected. So on the buy-side of transactions, we carried out 13 buy-side deals, which works out to roughly one per month as we did, across all our segments, across all sizes, across all our countries. We'll get to that later on as well. On the sell-side, we carried out 6 sell-side transactions. The biggest one was the Nordic sell-side transaction, and we wrapped up the year with the Royal de Boer sell-side transaction, which we sold to Turntide, a strategic player from America. When we look at how the portfolio developed — and Mark will take a deep dive into that in the financial segment — we faced 3 challenges in 2022, which are very obvious, but I'd like to remind you of them. So the first one was the start of the war at the beginning of 2022 in Ukraine, which also consequently had an impact on certain other things, like energy prices, which went up significantly. Just to give you a flavor, we — in part of our companies, energy heavy companies, we saw energy cost increases of 300% to 400% compared to the previous year.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#4

And finally, the entire supply chain issue — the global supply chain as a whole, materials shortages, and particularly in the auto segment too — the OEMs constantly changing their production planning, and changing their call-offs, of course, that creates some difficulties in the market as well. No significant capital market transaction took place in 2022. But we had already completed the groundwork for refinancing the bond, the Nordic bond facility, and that was struck a couple of weeks ago, refinancing the existing facility plus a slight upgrade to EUR 100 million. In total, Mutares Holding now has 200 people, has grown to 200 people, which is a further increase of 40 to 50 people, while Mutares Group is close to 20,000. And that is our key asset. That's the reason I want to bring it up here. And I believe it's also a good moment to thank these guys and girls for their contribution and for what's happening on the growth side. So without our people, without our employees, without the team spirit that we have, it would never be possible to achieve this steep and truly unique growth path we have been on since 2019, and we are following through on what we said, and we delivered what we said.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#5

So I want to thank the guy, thank these more than 190 people, and thank this 19,000. Without them, I couldn't present the results I'm presenting to you. For this call, I'd like to shine a little flashlight on the Nordics. The Nordic office in Stockholm was created in late 2020. And I think the path we've set here proves our concept that we want to be local in order to grow the business. We want to be local in order to make transactions. And what you've seen, what Carl Kistenmacher, who is leading this Nordic enterprise — and what Carl has done with his team — have 8 transactions signed. We've built up a team of 12 professionals, M&A and operational. We've opened up the Helsinki office again and have our main one in Stockholm. And we have a business in operation, which is above EUR 1 billion of turnover. And with Nordic, we have already conducted and proved the concept. We've already conducted our first exit in Nordic. So a very, very strong development, and Nordic stands for 20% of our total business at Mutares Group. So I'd like to give you this flashlight because also with Frigoscandia, with Terranor, with Palmia, with Arriva, which is a business predominantly in Denmark acquired from Deutsche Bahn, transaction will be closed in mid of May.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#6

We truly have a very solid presence in that region, and when it comes to turnaround, we are among the leading players—or the leading player—in the Nordic market. So that's a tremendous accomplishment by our Nordic team in a very brief span of time. I'm very pleased to see it. Let me walk quickly through our business model, and I'd like to frame it somewhat differently than we have previously so as not to bore you. On the figures, we continue to hold the 2025 target, under which we aim to reach EUR 7 billion, along with EUR 125 million to EUR 150 million of profitability at the holding net income level. That guidance stands confirmed. I have great confidence that we'll get there, that we will once more deliver on what we pledged. Mark will cover things in somewhat more detail. And afterward, we'll also look more closely at the 2023 guidance. But allow me to concentrate on the slide at left—what we do, why we're so successful, and what underpins all of these figures. So we have now opened Warsaw, our 10th office in Europe. We're present throughout the continent, and in the European market we aim to be #1 for turnaround special situations.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#7

And through this approach, we aim to be in a position where we can decide whether we want to carry out the transaction or not. And maybe a fairly interesting story here. Right now we're working on a deal in France where, before we were granted exclusivity on the buy side, we learned from the advisers that one of our competitors had asked whether we were in the deal or not. And with a positive signal coming from the adviser that we were in the deal, our competitors pulled out, since they believe that if we are in the deal, they won't win it. So that's a great sign. This is the first in mind, first in choice, DNA, that I would like to have in the team, and that I would like to have as a perception. Then the 3 diversified segments, the auto segment, the engineering technology and the goods and service. This is a really great driver also from a risk mitigation point of view, not only from a growth standpoint where we see different segments, early cycle, late cycle, but also from a risk mitigation standpoint. And when you see, and Mark will come to that later as well, the auto segment was under heavy pressure in 2022.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#8

So it posted a loss of nearly EUR 50 million in operating results. But what we're seeing is that this is bouncing back. In Q1, we saw fairly strong income on the auto business, and we expect that to carry on through the rest of the year as well. So the diversification across our segments benefits the buy side. It benefits the sell side, but it's also genuinely beneficial for spreading risk inside the portfolio after acquisition. On the company side, I believe we've shifted our sweet spot. So a company with turnover of EUR 100 million up to EUR 750 million is, as we put it, the area we're in. And if you look at the buy sides of 2023, if you look at MoldTecs, if you look at Cimos, and also if you look at Arriva, which is going to be closed now in May, all of these businesses sit in the EUR 200 million, EUR 300 million, EUR 400 million, EUR 500 million turnover size. So that's our new sweet spot, where we believe we operate quite successfully in all the countries. And for me, this is the Mutares DNA: corporate carve-out, European and quarter-based, 3 segments, company sizes in this range. And that DNA is something we will always respect and we will not let go of, because it's what made us strong and what, in my view, will also make us even stronger.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#9

Moving to the next slide, I'd like to explain a bit about how we view things day to day and how decisions get made day to day. Our DNA, then, is a European focus and the turnaround. And ultimately, it comes down to the 3 segments and the scale of the company. Whatever we put in, whichever company we buy, we ask ourselves: can this fit our DNA? Can it serve our targets? Can it serve our guidance? And what we use as a sort of gatekeeper is this: whatever we invest, can we generate 7 to 10x the return across the life cycle? Roughly 10% of the time, the investment is a purchase price. In 90% of our investment cases, we're talking about commitments, we're talking about equity injections at the closing date into the company. We're talking about supplying financing lines over a certain period for restructuring efforts. So that's the kind of investment we make. And the decision resting on that investment is whether we get 7 to 10x our money back. Then we begin the first phase, which we refer to as the realignment phase.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#10

The realignment phase is really the heavy restructuring stage, where we bring our forces together. As of today, we have more than 140 people on our consulting team who fly out on a Monday and come back on Thursday, so Fridays they're back with their families, trying to face the company. So I believe the first 6 months after acquisition are the crucial months for separating the company, carving it out, and taking the important steps to turn it around. And then the second one is what we call the optimization phase. This is when the company has been turned around and we're able to provide dividends to us. So -- and in 2022, we had some very strong dividend payers, which are at the end of the optimization phase or even in the beginning of the harvesting, which also contributes positively to the return of the 7 to 10x. And then last but not least, the exit proceeds. The exit proceeds are coming over our average holding period, which is 3 to 5 years. And you will see later on the outlook that 2023 is the year where the, let's say, the adopted Mutares way of working, which happened in the mid of 2019, that this pays off now.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#11

Our sales pipeline is the strongest it has ever been, since we began expanding aggressively in 2019, 2020, and 2021 in the areas where we generate — from that point on, we have averaged 1 transaction per month. And that single buy-side deal each month, once you factor in the holding period, is exactly what is beginning to show results in 2022. So down the road, you will see that 2023 will be an extremely strong year on the exit side, and we have already completed 4 during the first 4 months. So I will get to that later. But it matters to understand that when we acquire, it is a day-to-day call made by Robin, Mark, and myself — do we get the money back at 7 to 10x. First, we recover it via our consulting management fees, which are predictable. We know precisely what we are after. And here, in 2023 we will be on a run rate above EUR 100 million. Optimization means the dividends pulled out of outperforming portfolios. And finally, exit proceeds when we deliver an exit and when we carry out an exit after our holding period has been finalized. Turning to our portfolio, and I will only deep dive into a few. You see fairly good leverage on automotive, engineering technology, and goods and service.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#12

On the turnover side, you look at the balance—what I mentioned earlier regarding early cycle, late cycle, and non-cycle. That essentially reflects how our portfolio is shaped at present. Let me highlight one example from each category that I'd like to bring up. The first, in automotive—I believe this was also public, it was announced, launched with the M&A group, a group where our focus is particularly on e-mobility for plastic injection molding parts. We had a new kid in this segment. We had a new kid on the block, with more than EUR 1.2 billion of turnover, and that EUR 1.2 billion spans the globe. So we're on every continent—India, Asia, U.S., South America, Africa, and especially Europe as well. And every OEM sits in our customer bank. So that's the new kid on the block, and I think the lounge, capturing the synergies, and bringing this to customers—I think Mathieu Purrey, who runs it as CEO, has done a tremendous job on that front. Second, the engineering technology segment. Here I'd like to spotlight that in 2022, we acquired 2 businesses from Siemens Energy.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#13

Siemens Energy was itself going through a transformation — a typical seller, repositioning around a new strategy, with half its businesses not fitting that strategy. Carving out a complex piece of a large corporation — not necessarily the most agile company in the world — but we got it done jointly with them to separate out the business. And I think particularly NEM, which is a business located in the Netherlands, and we acquired it and combined it with the Balcke-Durr Group recently. I think this took a really, really big effort to carve out and make it happen, and it's already showing positive results in 2023 at the holding level. And I think Fatmir Veselaj from the operations team there did a fantastic job getting all of this out on the street and putting the horsepower behind it. And then last but not least, goods and service. And obviously I'll take Lapeyre here, because a lot of shareholder questions run through that, so I used the opportunity. So Lapeyre is performing to budget. In 2022, we hit exactly the budget we had set for ourselves there in 2021. And as the numbers show, we see a very nice development in Lapeyre's main segments. So we have stabilized the operations, the plans we have, we have sold the plant.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#14

We've consolidated somewhat, so operations have stabilized. The customer experience, the stores, and the way we sell products have improved dramatically—that's been handled very well. And then, of course, last but not least, we've genuinely caught up on the CapEx backlog by bringing new products to market. So I'm quite optimistic that in 2023, Lapeyre will, for the first time in over 10 years, achieve a positive operational result for the business in 2023. Turning to our ESG approach, which of course applies not only to the holding but also to all our portfolios, where we aim to align our targets and our highlights. I'd like to emphasize maybe 3 points here, if you'll permit. So first, regarding CO2 emissions, with LMS, one of our automotive businesses, one part of the Amaneos group. It's a large plant near Frankfurt, roughly EUR 350 million in turnover, with main customers such as Mercedes and Audi. We've implemented a strategy so that this plant—which is a plastic injection molding operation, including a full-fledged paint line—we've set ourselves a goal of making it CO2 neutral within the next 5 to 6 years.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#15

So that's what's going on. We focus on CO2 neutrality. That's our primary environmental priority here. Then in the middle segment, I want to emphasize community engagement. And it isn't just the donation to the children's hospice that's mentioned here, which we do. I think whatever the business does for us and whatever results we've delivered — and I know we delivered the best results in history, and I'm also sure that will continue. We live on the bright side of life, and we shouldn't forget about people who aren't there. And our main engagement here in 2022 really, really was our plant in the Ukraine and our employees in the Ukraine, which we supported heavily. And before I come back with the outlook, which will be quite intense and more detailed than in the past, I'd like to give you a deep dive and Mark can facilitate that much better than I.

Mark Friedrich

executive
#16

Thanks, Johannes. Now turning to the financials, beginning with how things developed overall. As a group, we're fairly happy with what we saw in 2022. We managed to grow the number of portfolio companies, and through that also lifted group revenue to nearly EUR 3.8 billion. EBITDA fell to EUR 180 million versus 2021, and the main reason is the largest acquisition we made in 2021, Lapeyre, where we booked the biggest bargain purchase income of over EUR 400 million, which sits in 2021. What matters more to us is how adjusted EBITDA moved. That underlying performance indicator for the existing portfolio improved considerably, even though we brought more portfolio companies into the group, and normally we buy loss-making companies. This demonstrates rather clearly that we could carry out the restructuring programs we launched across the various portfolio companies and could deliver that kind of restructuring program. On the slides that follow, I'll get into more detail on how the segments developed differently. And there you'll see the various movements in adjusted EBITDA. The holding's key KPIs, namely revenue, portfolio income and net income, largely tracked the group's development.

Mark Friedrich

executive
#17

And so we managed once more to grow the revenue we bring in from management fee and consulting, reaching EUR 71 million — that's slightly above 40%. But what matters more to us is that the run rate we were already seeing in Q4 of 2022 points to a portfolio income for 2023 that we now expect to exceed EUR 100 million, and in all likelihood we will receive EUR 110 million in 2023 as the holding's revenue. Portfolio income rose fairly significantly. Across the portfolio, we produced considerably more dividends than anticipated. As Johannes already noted, those dividends come from a handful of companies spanning the life cycle — from harvesting, where we get dividends from Terranor, Clecim, La Rochette, as well as from businesses in the other stages, here in optimization and also in the realignment phase. Net income ultimately came in at EUR 72.9 million, within the range we have consistently communicated. If you look at how the different segments developed quarter by quarter, you can see once more that the automotive and mobility segment faced a fairly challenging environment, particularly in the first quarter, and then improved gradually over the following quarters until it was almost 0 in Q4.

Mark Friedrich

executive
#18

And that's carrying over into 2023. So we're fairly hopeful about the volume ramp-up we expect to see, and also about the fact that our restructuring work is now helping drive better profitability. When we refer to restructuring, what we usually mean is that we bring in fresh management, we streamline the organization, we renegotiate contracts with suppliers, and we reorganize the shop floor. But in 2022, another key element mattered a great deal in our development: we managed to renegotiate prices with customers. In the automotive segment, there's a longer time lag between cost increases and passing them on to customers, and that's precisely what you're seeing here, while in the goods and services segment we could roll over the price increases much more quickly. As a result, we're able to protect profitability there in a considerably better way than in the automotive and mobility segment. Engineering & Technology was fairly stable all year. We'll see that some companies perform better than others. So the segment has its bright spots and its shadows, but on the whole it came in close to 0. Starting with automotive and mobility.

Mark Friedrich

executive
#19

We raised revenue once more by over EUR 400 million — EUR 300 million — largely through the acquisitions, though we also recorded organic growth, driven by higher volume as well as higher prices with customers, particularly in Q4. And once again you can see that we managed to bring adjusted EBITDA down close to 0 by year-end. The substantial cost increases we faced, above all in the first half of 2022, were weighing on profitability, and we then succeeded in passing them through to customers with the countermeasures we launched to streamline the cost base, which then helped us get nearly back in EBITDA. The Engineering & Technologies segment stayed quite stable across the year, hovering around 0 the whole time, with some companies operating in project-driven businesses — Donges, Balcke-Durr, NEM, and also ADComms and Gemini. Then there are companies that did quite well, such as La Rochette, Clecim, and the newly acquired entity, Steyr Motors. The profitability shown here was roughly EUR 4 million negative, hit quite hard by the recent acquisitions of S&P, VALTI and Guascor, which together posted a negative adjusted EBITDA of minus EUR 14 million.

Mark Friedrich

executive
#20

Conversely, La Rochette performed quite well for us, and that business is the biggest driver behind the organic growth visible here. Clecim as well, and also S&P, which we bought in May 2022 and which weighed quite negatively during 2022 — yet the run rate, particularly in Q4, was already recovering substantially, turning to a positive figure. In Q1 it now sits fully on track against the budget numbers we agreed with the company. So we are quite happy with how things have developed. Here too we have the segment where we divested Royal de Boer along with Japy in January, and also the Nordic Group. The last segment, goods and services, is the one that managed to roll over prices — price increases came much faster there than in the other segments. As a result, you can see profitability in Q4 improved quite substantially to 4%, above 4% in these segments, which include Lapeyre, the largest company in the group. Lapeyre in particular was one business that contributed quite positively, adding roughly EUR 8 million of adjusted EBITDA to the Q4 figure here. Conversely, we also saw positive contributions at Frigoscandia, and especially at Terranor, while Keeeper and Ganter were likewise companies contributing quite positively — showing that we could carry out the restructuring programs and the optimization programs here, and then also reap the benefits of the work done here previously.

Mark Friedrich

executive
#21

Now on to the final perspective — the life cycle view of the group, where we’ve once again sorted the companies into the familiar 4 phases. The acquisition phase is one we typically haven’t shown up to now. As of today, we have just one company in that bucket, and that’s Arriva, the acquisition from Deutsche Bahn that’s set to close in mid-May, as Johannes mentioned. Then there’s the realignment phase, which is negative by nature, since we acquire loss-making companies, and it’s quite full. That’s a good thing, because it means the team has plenty of work ahead and plenty of opportunities looking forward when it moves into the development stage within the group and on to the final harvesting stage. The optimization phase here is meant to sit closer to 0. We can see here that we’ve already managed to bring profitability down to minus 1.8. We have a number of companies in that bucket doing well, but also here with SFC Group and KICO, ISH Group, 2 companies from the automotive segment that were heavily affected by the trends I explained earlier.

Mark Friedrich

executive
#22

At the harvesting stage, the final one, profitability rose to nearly EUR 50 million in adjusted EBITDA for 2022 with only 5 companies in that stage. Through this last stage, we typically send a signal to the market that we intend to divest over the coming 12 months. And today we also have this slide in the deck showing how things developed across the different quarters. Here you can see that the optimization phase managed to turn positive in Q4, which is also something we want to see from the group. So this was driven by what we observed, particularly from the automotive companies, which then contributed again in a way that was not as negative as in Q1. On the other side, we also saw that we managed to narrow the negative impact in the realignment phase, which is attributable especially, once more, to Lapeyre. But most importantly, it demonstrates that the business model works. We can acquire loss-making companies. We can then bring them to 0 profitability in the optimization phase. And then finally, bring them to a positive operating indicator, adjusted EBITDA, in the final phase, after which we want to divest. So overall, we are quite pleased with the development and the restructuring efforts we were able to carry out and with what we have seen in the financials, particularly in Q4.

Mark Friedrich

executive
#23

That brings us to the outlook.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#24

Thank you so much, Mark. I'd like to walk you through the 2023 outlook fairly quickly, and I want to give you a bit more insight into what we expect — or what I expect — will happen over the remaining 8 months. In short, I'm quite confident — and the next slide will lay this out in more detail as well — I'm quite confident that in 2023 we will once again deliver what we promised, and that 2023 will be another record year for the company since it was founded in 2008. So why do I believe this? Fundamentally, we're seeing portfolio development that Mark has already touched on somewhat. We went into Q1 in pretty good shape. We don't have the final figure yet, but what we've seen so far for Q1 is very promising and, I think, carries on the strong operation in the portfolios that had already begun in Q4 of last year. So we're quite happy with how the portfolios have performed at the start of the year. That's the first point. Second, when I look at the buy side — what we're currently seeing there is 93 projects with total turnover of EUR 13.3 billion. I've tracked this, and it's the largest buy-side pipeline since I took charge in mid-2019.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#25

I'm therefore quite confident that the goal we've set for expansion — our objective of completing one transaction each month, the narrative we've been running with — will carry on through 2023 as well, because put simply, a very large pipeline lies in front of us. Deals are beginning to come through now in quarter 2 and particularly in quarter 3, ramping up, with the pipeline expanding continuously rather than shrinking. So the buy side is genuinely ticking along. And what's behind that? In our view, the complete effect of inflation won't show up until this year. That's what has been accumulating. Interest rates are climbing, and the real impact arrives in 2023. And then, in the pricing environment — like the one we had in '22 as we came out of COVID — now the war has occurred. Companies typically return to their core business, and they attempt to divest the things sitting to the left and right of that core. So they concentrate and focus on a business's main asset. And that, obviously, is fantastic news for a turnaround investor who specializes in carve-out situations involving loss-making businesses. So that's one of the triggers. And beyond that, we're seeing more and more privatizations happening in Europe.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#26

Take one example: what we picked up from Deutsche Bahn, Arriva — that's one of the prioritizations — but we're also seeing more and more of this now in countries where privatization wasn't so active, for instance what we're looking at right now in one in France. So that's the buy side, where — alongside the portfolio, which is going quite well in Q1 and started in the year, the buy side looks really, really promising for 2023. And then, as I mentioned before, taking the life cycle, taking the holding period, when you look at the sell side, I think this will be a super intense year on the sell side. We've already done 3 sell-side transactions to strategic. So FDT, Dante France. FDT, we — for example, we divested to Holcim. And then Japy Tech, #4 of the sell-side transaction already in the first 4 months. And what we see on the sell side, and this is why it keeps me so confident that it will run also much, much larger than in the years before is we have now more and more of the companies which we started to buy starting from 2019, 2020 onwards.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#27

That's the first point. And second, on the sell side we're seeing two things. On the quantitative side of the bidder pool, it has shrunk, particularly among financial sponsors. The era when you'd simply send out information memorandums late in the evening and then collect bids by a set deadline — that's not happening anymore. It's finished. What we do see is strength on the qualitative side among strategic bidders, and right now we have 4 live processes in the market at an advanced stage. And we're seeing competition among strategic bidders. Strategic bidders have become much, much more serious about transactions and much, much more active on transactions than they were during the COVID period. So the quantitative bidder pool declined, while the qualitative side, especially strategic bidders, rose significantly over the last 6 months. That's what we're seeing in the 4 live processes we're running at an advanced stage right now, where the strategics are genuinely interested in the targets we have in the market. That also gives me confidence that 2023 is a year of significant and successful exits, and it makes me more or less confident that we can already have part of this executed before our annual meeting in July.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#28

Basically, then, on the portfolio side, the year got off to a promising start and carried on from a really, really strong fourth quarter last year. Next, on the buy side, we have the biggest pipeline in the 3.5 years I've been tracking it. And it looks very, very encouraging on the exit side, or even for 4 life processes that are at an advanced stage, and I'm very pleased and very optimistic that this keeps going with our harvesting portfolios. As for how things are developing geographically — the last point on the outlook — we can confirm, and it's unchanged versus the '25 target, that we'll be at EUR 7 billion and EUR 125 million to EUR 150 million of net holding income. We're confident this remains the correct guidance, and it's guidance we can deliver on. And second, we've now executed Warsaw to move into Poland and Eastern Europe. And we've always said that in the second half of 2023, we'll go to the United States of America — not necessarily to pursue local deals in the U.S. and transplant our business model there, but more for American corporate divestitures or carving out global operations. Those deals aren't made — even though it's a global operation, those deals are make in America.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#29

Second, European companies divesting their U.S. operations. Those transactions, despite the seller being a European corporate, get executed in America rather than Europe. And second, big industrial M&A deals — the large-cap segment in Europe is currently somewhat weak, while in the Americas it's still alive. On large-cap transactions, poison pills are invariably part of the picture, and we ought to be the party with a solution, removing those poison pills from the scope of the final cut transaction. So those 3 are the primary drivers and core ideas as we head into the U.S. during the second half of 2023. So many thanks for your attention. And before I hand back to the moderator, once more, the slogan on the earlier slide was: we deliver what we promised. And I'm quite certain that in '23 as well, we will deliver what we've put here on paper and what we promised. And why do I feel confident about that? It comes down to one simple sentence: because I have the best team in the world. Thank you very much for listening, and back to the moderator for questions.

Operator

operator
#30

<<operator_script>> Our initial question is from Zafer Ruzgar at Pareto.

Zafer Rüzgar

analyst
#31

Can you hear me okay?

Mark Friedrich

executive
#32

Yes.

Zafer Rüzgar

analyst
#33

Great. My first question concerns your net income target and what feeds into it. To make sure I understand and to get a sense of what the exits this year can deliver. And if my math is right, and I assume holding revenues of EUR 100 million and, let's say, OpEx of EUR 65 million plus dividend proceeds of, yes, let's say, EUR 25 million. Then I think you'd need exit proceeds of roughly EUR 60 million to land at a net income of EUR 100 million. And considering what Mr. Laumann said about 2023 being a strong year with exits. Doesn't that seem a bit conservative for this year, given the EUR 60 million of potential exit proceeds?

Mark Friedrich

executive
#34

Perhaps I'll begin with the first question. You observed that the components behind the holding's net result in 2022 and '21 came largely from the dividend side. We've also mentioned here during the quarter and on the prior call that we believe we're now positioned to complete far more exits in 2023 and in the years ahead, and we're truly concentrating on that. So consequently, in 2023 and looking beyond, we anticipate a considerably larger contribution from exits, typically now estimated at EUR 60 million. As you noted, perhaps what we did was somewhat conservative, but we've learned that exit processes aren't entirely within our control. That's the reason we currently have a few additional processes in the market. And then we may need to revise our guidance for the net results as the year progresses, possibly following Q2, once we've completed a few exits. But at this point, we're holding to the communication we gave previously: that we sit between 1.8% and 2.2% of the expected group revenues. That's what we expect regarding the holding's net income.

Mark Friedrich

executive
#35

And when it comes to the exit proceeds, Johannes, perhaps you could say a few words there.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#36

I tend to be quite a conservative person. So no, I believe I can back up what Mark is saying. Clearly, we have them out in the market now. And right now, the figure looks conservative relative to what we expect, but we haven't delivered yet. We have not -- the ink hasn't dried. So we chose to stay on the conservative side for now and then potentially have a positive deviation later rather than the other way around.

Zafer Rüzgar

analyst
#37

All right, good. And then the second thing — a quick question, since we haven’t yet seen the balance sheet figures at the holding level. How much would you need in order to pay out a dividend of EUR 2 per share?

Mark Friedrich

executive
#38

We stated our intention to carry out a meaningful exit before then. And adding EUR 1 would bring it to EUR 20 million. So as for the exits we hold or the processes we're running right now, our expectation for all of these processes is a figure well above EUR 20 million. So in technical terms, we require EUR 20 million, perhaps EUR 25 million, though our preference is to concentrate on getting the exits done and then see which of them closes by the end of Q2.

Operator

operator
#39

And our following question is from Marie-Therese Gruebner at HAIB.

Marie-Therese Gruebner

analyst
#40

Is my voice coming through clearly?

Johannes Laumann

executive
#41

Absolutely, Marie-Therese.

Marie-Therese Gruebner

analyst
#42

About the companies in the harvesting phase, there are 5 of them, and this year they'll deliver roughly EUR 50 million in EBITDA. Can you at least give us some sense of the range of multiples you're seeing for that bracket of companies, and on the process side, the sell — the exit processes you currently have running, especially since you mention strategic buyers are taking a bigger role this year? I'd assume those guys are probably ready to pay higher prices. Could you expand on that a bit?

Johannes Laumann

executive
#43

Clearly, a broad answer isn’t possible here, since every process is, in a manner of speaking, its own individual work of art. Still, my view is that in the end — and I’m familiar with all those various industry multiple tables — what drives the multiple, ultimately, is competition. A high multiple can exist within an industry. With just one bidder involved, that multiple will come in lower than — likely lower, since competition is absent. That’s precisely why answering is so difficult. From the point at which a process starts to when bids come in, we haven’t observed much deviation in expectations, all right? So when you refer to logistics or service, you’re still within a multiple range of somewhere between 6 and 9; on the production side, in more CapEx-intensive businesses, it’s more — it hinges on the USP you hold. It can actually fall between 5 and 10. So the spread is wider. Auto, I think, right now — leaving divestment aside, and there’s no need to discuss that at present. But it remains a highly individual process.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#44

Naturally, the greater the competition, the simpler it becomes to push up a multiple. Still, in the end, we must acknowledge that qualitative interest from strategic buyers has risen during the last — during the processes we're currently running, that's point one. Point 2, that clearly depends very much on a case-by-case basis regarding multiples, and on how — how well a process is facilitated. Ultimately, I believe that whenever we divest, it is always a blend of price, a clean exit for us, and a strong new owner for the business, one where we also have something of a complete life cycle story. That is what we aim to accomplish through the processes currently out there in the market.

Marie-Therese Gruebner

analyst
#45

Alright, perhaps one more question along those lines. What would you say the typical leverage level is within the harvesting bracket? If I consider — once I arrive at a market value or after deducting net debt, what leverage on average would be applied to these businesses, or that you are divesting, in those terms.

Mark Friedrich

executive
#46

If you look at those 5 businesses — Clecim, Keeeper, Terranor, Donges and SABO — their net debt comes to under EUR 50 million.

Marie-Therese Gruebner

analyst
#47

Under EUR 50 million for each of the 5?

Mark Friedrich

executive
#48

Yes.

Marie-Therese Gruebner

analyst
#49

Alright, great. And then finally, on the net income guidance you've provided for next year — EUR 92 million to EUR 112 million — does that imply you're meaningfully raising the dividend payout ratio? Or what should people anticipate regarding the basis dividend? I realize it's very, very early in the year to comment on that. Still, considering the sort of lead we'll see in net income, what do you plan to do with that cash?

Johannes Laumann

executive
#50

I believe you mean this year, Marie-Therese, correct? You mentioned next year, but the EUR 92 million applies to this year. So the payout will be communicated. There are 2 things here. Let me say — first, let us do our job. After that, I think we've demonstrated previously, and we've demonstrated this year as well, that when we succeed and when we deliver the potential or the growth that's expected, our shareholders get to participate in an equivalent way. So — and that's also our intention as we raise things now: our shareholders will take part. So we have no plans to deploy this money into other business models, other capital market setups, a fund, or god knows what. So we run our business, we run our core business. We expand internationally. We grow the segments, and we deliver what we promised. So obviously, with more income and the same number of shares, the likelihood is very high that shareholder participation will rise as well.

Marie-Therese Gruebner

analyst
#51

Right. But is there intent — I mean, since you're going after bigger companies on average, which come with less bargain purchase income, is it fair to think that at least a portion of this cash will just get reinvested in the next transaction and won't be distributed on a linear path, say, to shareholders?

Johannes Laumann

executive
#52

I'd say the amount we've been investing over the last 3 years has been pretty steady, with a slight increase last year. And, I mean, it's always a dynamic market, right? So it depends on the opportunities that come your way. I think right now we're looking at a business where I have the chance at a purchase price that seems significant, but it's a onetime EBITDA. So I think — and I have synergies within my portfolio, it's an add-on. So if I get the chance to buy at a onetime EBITDA, as an add-on, even if the purchase price is, say, EUR 8 million, EUR 9 million, EUR 10 million, I think that's a good deal. And so it really comes down to the dynamics of the market and the opportunities you have. And you can't apply the linear math that says the bigger the deals you do, the more cash you need to make this transaction up. So actually, that's not a link you can make.

Operator

operator
#53

Stefan Augustin from Warburg Research has the next question.

Stefan Augustin

analyst
#54

Two brief questions, if I may. First, regarding your consultants and employees: do you feel you're well positioned to attract the specialists you currently require in the market? Or are there, say, bigger constraints or hurdles when it comes to bringing people onto the team? That's question one. Question two is also fairly brief and concerns Lapeyre. Looking at your budget through the end of 2024, could you comment on the free cash flow you expect between now and then — is there, say, meaningful cash outflow still anticipated? Or are we roughly at breakeven, in a phase where free cash flow is positive?

Mark Friedrich

executive
#55

Alright, to begin with the first question about how we can grow the team. We keep adding people. This year, we aim to bring in between 20 and 30 professionals across the various countries and across the various practices. And at this point we have — we've assembled a team of over 125 professionals within our operations, and now we're trying to bring on new team members and close those gaps when it comes to the different practices, but also in the countries that were — or where we identify gaps. Johannes told us today that the Nordics has turned into an important market for us. And there, we see that in Sweden and also in Finland, we could bring in some professionals, and we will find them. We'll find them via the network of the current team and with headhunters operating in the various countries. And here, over the last couple of years, we've developed a solid network of headhunters who understand our culture very well, our way of thinking, our way of working, and what kind of characters we're looking for. And so, I'm fairly confident that we will be — that we'll manage to bring in these 20 to 30 professionals over the course of 2023.

Mark Friedrich

executive
#56

And we identify those individuals who are ready to depart alongside us.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#57

All right, that's fine. The second question was a bit tricky to follow, but our understanding is that it concerned cash flow — specifically Lapeyre's free cash flow. Is that right? Yes. So, as I mentioned earlier, we're pretty pleased with how Lapeyre is developing, and Marc Tenart and the team, I believe, are taking the right steps and countermeasures to get us to the plan we've set out. At the close of March, Lapeyre's cash position stands at EUR 192 million. And of course, more CapEx and investments are planned there, but we don't expect that cash position to shrink meaningfully before the end of 2024. That's also because Lapeyre should be operationally positive. So in fact, the only cash flow or cash burn comes from investments rather than from day-to-day operations. So that's where things stood at the end of March, and we don't anticipate much of a decline before the end of '24, since operations are positive.

Operator

operator
#58

Right now, we don't have any more questions. <<operator_script>> That means there are no additional questions. I'll turn things back to the speakers so they can offer a few closing remarks.

Johannes Laumann

executive
#59

We're running 3 minutes early, so the timing works out really well. Many thanks for joining us. As I mentioned, we're extremely pleased with 2022. We're delighted to have this team with us that we do. And we're highly confident that 2023 is going to be another record year, and the portfolio is off to a very nice start indeed this year. Again, at the risk of repeating myself, the buy side appears extremely promising. And on the sell side, I believe it will be the strongest year ever on that side. So I have great confidence that we'll deliver what we promised and possibly even exceed your expectations in a positive way. Thank you so much. Enjoy the remainder of the week. And we'll see each other for Q1 in May. Thank you. Bye-bye.

Operator

operator
#60

We appreciate all of you joining us on this call today. We hope the remainder of your day goes well. Until we speak again, goodbye.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Mutares SE & Co. KGaA transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Mutares SE & Co. KGaA earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Mutares SE & Co. KGaA or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.