Mutares SE & Co. KGaA (MUX) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
April 11, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorGood afternoon, everyone, and thanks for joining us for the Mutares call covering Full Year 2023. Presenting today are Robin Laik, our CEO, and Mark Friedrich, our CFO; they will walk you through the results and the most important developments from the full year 2023. Once the presentation wraps up, both will be on hand to take your questions. The deck you see is going to be posted on the Mutares website following this call. Before we begin, please be aware that forward-looking statements appear in this presentation, including projections that might not turn out the way we currently expect. So I kindly ask everyone to review the precautionary warning regarding forward-looking statements, which you will find in the materials posted on the website. With that, I will now hand things over to Robin Laik.
Robin Laik
executiveYes. Good afternoon, dear shareholder, dear bondholder. I'm Robin Laik, and I serve as Founder, CEO and main shareholder of Mutares Group. And today we're very happy to be able to present a very successful 2023 to you. And before we begin our presentation, I'd like to explain once more what Mutares actually does. So when we launched this business 15 years ago, we wanted to approach big corporates, and these big corporates still hold assets that are underperforming. While the key strength of Mutares, what we do, is that we go in with our own team into these companies. And this is our DNA. Our DNA is that we want to enter companies of big corporates, carve-outs from big corporates, which are not performing. And then into these companies, we come with an own team. And the team takes over a key management position, it can be a CEO position, it can be a production manager, it can be a sales manager, it can be a controller, and that's what we do. So here you see the landscape where we stand today. So we have 11 European offices, but we also now have an office that we are planning in Chicago and <<inaudible>>.
Robin Laik
executiveAnd we talked about India as well. We'd like to be recognized as the people who understand how to get it done. So we're fond of the phrase, first in mind, first in choice. Whenever a large corporation makes the decision to leave the company or shut down a production site, we believe we should approach them and say it's always preferable, before you decide to close a plant, to sell the plant to Mutares, to sell the company to Mutares. First in mind, first in choice, that ought to be Mutares. So what kinds of companies do we put money into? The first segment we invest in is automotive. Automotive is our suppliers for BMW, for Mercedes, for Stellantis, to worldwide OEMs that we supply from our automotive subsidiaries. The next company, and that's based here in Germany at the start, so it's a very engineering-driven company. So we have many engineers on board. And this is our sector, Engineering & Technology, machine tooling, where we have a lot of machine tooling guys in our team. The third sector is a service business, where we do service business. And lastly, we just opened up a new sector, which is Retail & Food.
Robin Laik
executiveThe target company we're looking to acquire should have sales of roughly EUR 100 million to EUR 750 million. And we want to be known as the people who can pull off the turnaround. So how is our group structured? Today, we're talking about 250 people. Of those 250 people, more than 150 are operational consultants. And when we buy these companies, we put our own consultants into them. And through this, we already generate consulting income of EUR 10 million today. And this matters to us, because it's a resilient business model. This is a consulting business. And if we want to grow our business, that number of consultants will grow as well. The second source of profit is that when a company's turnaround is complete, they can pay us dividends. So we have this consulting income. Then we have dividends, and the third column we have is exit proceeds. And when we're sitting together in 2008 -- '18. So 10 years after we began the Mutares adventure, and at that point, here you see the figures for 2020. But in 2018, we had 3 years in a row with EUR 1 billion turnover and EUR 20 million net income.
Robin Laik
executiveSo then we asked ourselves, how do we expand this business? And back in 2018, we set a goal: by 2028, this company ought to reach EUR 10 billion in turnover along with a EUR 200 million net profit. And we're truly happy and thankful to be able to report that already at this point, we're discussing a company with EUR 5 billion in turnover and EUR 100 million in net profit. And that net profit we referred to is made up of these 3 pillars: consulting income, dividends and exit proceeds. And as you can see here, we now want to set new targets, and you'll notice we also have new targets when it comes to you, the shareholders, regarding the dividend as well. So previously -- we had a minimum dividend of EUR 1 plus a base dividend. And now we're talking about a EUR 2 dividend that we intend to pay our shareholders every year. And this year, since it was such a successful year, we chose to go with a EUR 2.25 dividend. So we want every participant -- all the stakeholders involved in this Mutares story -- to share in it. So how do we generate our profit again?
Robin Laik
executiveSo we grouped our entire portfolio into 4 distinct sectors. Sector one is what we call the acquisition phase. At that point the business is burning cash, and what we typically do is approach the seller — which ought to be a large corporation — and we request that the seller provide us with a strong balance sheet. That's where the Mutares journey begins. We ask them: can you supply us with funds so we can carry out the turnaround, since for you, a big corporate, that is cheaper than shutting it down and cheaper than handling it on your own. In many cases these large corporates have already made attempts. They brought in external consultants and tried everything, but it didn't work out. And then our secret kicks in — what is our USP? It's an intervenership. We enter them with our own teams into the acquisition phase. So we have a cash out for a purchase price, but then we have cash in from day 1, as we send our consultants in. The second time is then the realignment phase. So the team is already in and we bring the company back to breakeven. In general, we buy companies, let's assume EUR 100 million in sales, but EUR 10 million of losses.
Robin Laik
executiveAnd in many cases we acquire them from the seller with a balance sheet that gives us, say, 12 or 18 months until the company turns cash flow positive again. That period is what we refer to as realignment. After that, we move into an optimization stage. During optimization, we consider how sales can be grown. Could we perhaps acquire another company to enter a new market? Do we have the product we need? What steps can we take to grow the business? Then, in many cases, at the optimization stage, we pull our consultants out and bring them into a new — challenge them with a new company — and after that comes harvesting. Harvesting is the time when we can take dividends, when we receive exit proceeds. So that is Mutares' life cycle. And across all of these life cycles, we stated at holding level that we wanted to reach EUR 100 million. That is what we promised you, the shareholders, and that is what we delivered. In recent years, we exceeded our own targets. And here you have an overview of our portfolio. You can see Automotive, Engineering & Technology, Goods & Services and Retail & Food.
Robin Laik
executiveI also want to mention a few of the businesses so you get a sense of what we're up to. Let's take Steyr Motors. We brought our team in, and the people there build engines for special-purpose vehicles. Quality was poor. Pricing wasn't acceptable. We went through difficult periods — before that came COVID, and then raw material prices rose. When we came in, the company had chosen to move into various products that the market didn't require. So we narrowed the product portfolio. Early on, in many instances, we had to lower costs. We also had to speak with our employees quite candidly and say, in this situation it's too expensive, and we need to cut staff. Nobody enjoys doing that — trimming overhead costs. But here it was unavoidable. After that we approached our customer, and the customer didn't even want to meet with us. So we arranged a dinner before requesting the operational meeting in the morning, and the customer refused to turn up.
Robin Laik
executiveTheir dissatisfaction with both the quality and the delivery of our product was very clear. Later that evening, we listened and worked to grasp what their real problem was. We then gave them our assurance that we could turn out the quality they require and that we would put money into the R&D facilities. And we managed to take a company that was losing cash and turn it into one with 20% EBITDA that runs at a solid profit. Another business I'd like to mention is Conexus. Conexus operates in high voltage, and we acquired it in Italy from Safety Group; with Marco and other people brought in, we are now turning that business around, which sits in this energy market. Just yesterday, we announced the purchase from Alta of a company in Poland — our first Polish transaction. I'm very happy for Dominic and the team there. Now we can grow this business, which runs at a healthy profit with a 10% EBITDA margin. Then you look at Retail & Food, the most recent sector we opened, where we bought several companies during last year and which are also developing quite well.
Robin Laik
executiveWhen we acquire these businesses, it matters to us that we aren’t purchasing solely within Germany. That’s the reason we’re genuinely a global participant now, yet we don’t wish to be exposed to risks that sit in just a single market or at just a single stage. So we acquire early-cycle businesses, late-cycle businesses, and noncyclical businesses. That balances things for us regarding the operational risk of the market. A few key figures. Perhaps the companies — we are quite active on this front. Last year we acquired 16 companies across all sectors. For instance, we acquired Glaserne Molkerei in the dairy industry, where we make milk, butter, and cheese and sell it mainly in Germany today. Then we acquired many other companies, as you can see here, some truly substantial brands. For example, we are now the owners of Peugeot Motorcycles. It’s a 2-wheeler business. And we also increased our bond, but you can see that the bond now totals EUR 250 million. And all of this with the new dividend strategy, with the achievement of the promises — we truly delivered on our promises. We were able to be included in the SDAX now, which for the team is, of course, a very nice appreciation, and we were also able to sell 7 companies last year.
Robin Laik
executiveWhat shaped last year's results, naturally, was Special Melted Products. That U.K. business we acquired — we brought in our people, and we put someone in charge of running it alongside plenty of others: Thomas in finance, Dario in safety. A really solid sales force was in place there. Even so, we managed to get quality back where it needed to be. That's the work we're doing now. We turn out their specialty steels, which go into aviation and are also used at nuclear power stations. At the time of purchase, this was a EUR 20 million company carrying over EUR 10 million in losses and EUR 20 million of pension obligations on the balance sheet. When we came in, everybody — my Supervisory Board in particular — said to me, Mr. Laik, stay away from this company. But we then examined the markets and understood that aviation is a sector with room to grow. We were fairly far along in upgrading the quality for the turbine. Rolls-Royce ranked among our largest customers. And in the end we sold that company to an Italian strategic buyer for EUR 160 million — over EUR 160 million, and we were able to keep less in exit proceeds.
Robin Laik
executiveThat's also why we got those strong exit results last year. It was one of the 3 pillars that came together really well last year. Together with Ivo and the British team, we managed to produce those high exit proceeds. And I'm very pleased that in our market segment, particularly in the U.K., we were recognized for having the best turnaround in the U.K. Another company where I sat in the 100 days meeting this week. We flew in Tuesday morning. This company is called Efacec. Efacec is a business we acquired in Portugal. They make transformers, but their main responsibility is electric diversification and the distribution of electronics in Portugal. This used to be a state-owned company, yet as you can see here, enormous losses because of inefficient projects they had taken on. Our team there now focuses on projects for the future — for instance, we produce the electronic charging systems for the highways. And here we also make transformers for the nuclear power plants, and what we did at the start here. We focused on the main issues, on what is the core of our business. And building on that foundation, we now have a very strong pipeline in place.
Robin Laik
executiveOrder intake has been substantial, and we're highly confident this will be what is <<inaudible>> Mutares in the years ahead, because we're seeing very good order intake, a very good backlog, and the turnaround plan we carried out there is quite substantial. So what's key? What's the key factor across all of these cases I'm presenting to you? It's that we go in with our own team. Only the team can deliver the turnaround. And these aren't external consultants — this is us. It's a very direct approach. So we take — as we take over in many cases, the key management positions. It is not an external passive fund. We are the active investors. We are the ones who enter the companies and we do the turnaround ourselves. And with that, I'd like to hand over to Mark. Thank you.
Mark Friedrich
executiveThanks, Robin. So beginning with the financials, here again is the overview of the financials and how they developed over the last 3 years. What you see here is essentially that we kept growing the Mutares group at a very solid pace of roughly 25% to 30% per year in revenues, reaching EUR 4.7 billion in 2023. And more important for us, we also see how adjusted EBITDA has developed. It has improved year by year. Even though we added plenty of loss-making — by nature loss-making — entities and portfolio companies to the group, we were still able to bring adjusted EBITDA up to a positive level of EUR 3.5 million for the full year, which shows the development — the underlying development in the portfolio toward a positive contribution here, and we will look at it in more detail in the segments, where we performed really well and where we have added plenty of loss-making entities and can work on that over the next couple of months. The financials of Mutares holding here also pretty much always track the group financials, with revenues, consigning revenues, reaching more than EUR 100 million. And the run rate stands at approximately EUR 120 million based on how the full group has developed here.
Mark Friedrich
executiveThe net result—Robin has already walked through it—was heavily shaped by the largest exit in Mutares history, S&P, which also brought in over EUR 100 million. For fiscal year 2024, we have already provided guidance of roughly EUR 6 billion in group revenues. And again, net income at 1.8% to 2.2%, which works out to EUR 108 million to EUR 132 million in net income at the holding level. Looking at how things developed quarter by quarter shows that it swings around more than we would prefer. You can see that the trend, particularly in Goods & Services, is the most steady in terms of delivering a positive contribution. And versus last year, it is still essentially twice as high. On the other hand, the largest turnaround shows up here in Automotive & Mobility. We will go into greater detail on the following page, where we did this—it is a substantial turnaround, though there is still a way to go. Let me turn to the segment details, beginning with our biggest segment by revenue, at close to EUR 2 billion. And you can see that we were in fact quite busy in this segment yet still have only 5 groups. Over on the right, you can see that we added over EUR 700 million in revenues through acquisitions, mainly as a result of the other acquisitions we made for FerrAl United and HILO Group at the end of the year, since we firmly believe that size matters in this segment.
Mark Friedrich
executiveSo that's the reason we've put such a large amount into building up FerrAl United, which brings together over EUR 1 billion in revenue run rate. And we're firmly convinced this is the correct path ahead. In addition, HILO Group grew quite substantially toward the end of 2023, thanks to the 2 add-ons we completed there. Conversely, we saw genuinely strong progress in the transformation and restructuring at SFC and LMS, both of which sit within the Amaneos Group. As a result, we finished with adjusted EBITDA of EUR 3.3 million, versus minus EUR 49 million in 2022. Turning to the Engineering & Technology segment, we've both added and sold a great deal over the past 18 months. You can see it in the first bullet on the right-hand side: we acquired many entities — NEM, Guascor, SMP and others — and divested plenty as well. So there's quite a mix here, credit movement within the segment, and it's quite an interesting segment. That's because several entities in this segment are performing really well — namely the NEM Group here, and Guascor too, which has improved considerably now at the start of 2024 — and Robin also already covered Efacec and Steyr; Efacec in particular had a very heavy impact on adjusted EBITDA in Q4, so quiet — 1st of November, because we had to restart and production was pretty much empty, and the amounts involved here are quite substantial.
Mark Friedrich
executiveWhat you're seeing here is basically on the left, since adjusted EBITDA for the full year is almost entirely Efacec. Then Goods & Services, our best-performing segment, with quite a broad range of different portfolio companies. You can see adjusted EBITDA nearly doubled there. And here, in 2023, we saw some decent development at Terranor and Frigoscandia, already sold by now, but also Ganter, and quite positive results when it comes to how a handful of other companies we added to the segment developed, namely GoCollective, but also REDO, Conexus and again the Terranor Group. The last segment, the one we newly formed out of Goods & Services, Retail & Food, where we had Lapeyre, Keeeper and Fasana, 3 companies already in the Goods & Services segment, and you can see the 3 acquisitions we made here contributed only a bit to overall revenue in the segment, because those acquisitions closed mostly in the second half of the year. And here we still saw some headwinds in the market for Lapeyre. On the other hand, good development at Keeeper and Fasana, and promising development, especially at Glaserne Molkerei and Prenatal.
Mark Friedrich
executiveNow on the final page, looking at the current life cycle: honestly, it’s much as usual — it appears fairly healthy, and you can basically see that we completed plenty of acquisitions here. That’s what shows up in realignment — many businesses coming together with EUR 2.2 billion of revenues and substantially negative in 2023 — and here we’ll pull out a few entities and shift them into optimization in the Q1 presentation. Because optimization here also includes a lot of fairly well developing entities, EUR 1.7 billion of revenues here. You can already see the newly formed HILO Group in there. and their combination <<inaudible>>, profitability got to a positive level. And then, at the end, we have only a handful of assets in harvesting, most likely also for Q1; here we’ll see a bit of change, adding a few companies and having less revenue here than last year, since we sold part of the Donges Group. But again, a quite positive adjusted EBITDA thanks to the performance of the companies that you see here. And with that, I’ll hand it back to Robin already.
Robin Laik
executiveYes. Thank you, Mark. For me too, this is a moment to express a big thank you to Mark. I mean, Mark has been with the company for 12 years already, and CFO for 9 years. And when you have a company that is only EUR 1 billion, and today we talk about a EUR 5 billion company, it's a lot of work when it comes to year-end accounts. And Mark, what you did here together with your team, Simon, and many more is really incredibly strong. And thanks a lot for all of this work. What we are doing — and that's maybe for you as shareholders — we are really the guys who are on the ground. We fly into these companies. We take over responsibility, and what we have shown — and this is for U.S. shareholders or at bondholders — is a very attractive access to the private equity market. What we are doing is private equity. But based on a family business, based on a business which is still in the hands of entrepreneurs. And our dividend strategy speaks for itself. We are always increasing our dividend. We had several years now, EUR 1, then EUR 1.50, then EUR 1.75. And this year, it tops with EUR 2.25.
Robin Laik
executiveThe way the share has performed, I believe, makes the case on its own. We aim to be extremely transparent—that matters a great deal to us too. That's why we purchase plenty of businesses, some of them from the state as well. Take Efacec, as I mentioned earlier, acquired from the Portuguese state, where the Finance Minister of Portugal said to me before the deal closed, "Mr. Laik, you're now responsible for a great many employees. I'll support you, I'll provide a solid balance sheet, I'll even throw in a cash dowry. What matters to me, though, is that you're now in charge and you move faster, you act more like an entrepreneur, you'll get it done." And naturally, we take a substantially long-term orientation. That, in my view, is essential for us—and for you as investors and bondholders. Still, we're convinced our business model is resilient and expanding. As I said, we intend to be a genuinely global player. In the past I would always say I wanted us to be—or we wanted to be—the #1 private equity firm in Germany, and Focus Money honored us 3 times in a row as the best private equity company in Germany. Our goal, though, is obviously to be the worldwide player when it comes to development and growth, in both sales and the number of companies we acquire, and in profitability at the holding level.
Robin Laik
executiveSo here's what we intend to report going forward — and this is the approach we've taken over recent years — we want to show our net results at the holding level. And this result of EUR 100 million that we've now achieved, many years ago that was a dream, and now we have new dreams. And of course I'd like you to follow us along in this development, as I can show you here, we've already set a target for this year. With the 3 acquisitions at the start of the year, we believe we'll be able to grow our sales number. but we also want to raise our result level, net result on holding level, which rests on the 3 pillars, which rests on consulting, on dividend and exit proceeds. And our long-term target when it comes to the dividend, we've already mentioned that we want to pay out a minimum of EUR 2 in the future, and we are quite positive that this is achievable. Thanks a lot for your attendance. And with that, I would like to hand over to the operator.
Operator
operator<<operator_script>> Our first question is from Marie-Therese Gruebner at Hauck Aufhäuser Investment Banking.
Marie-Therese Gruebner
analystCongratulations on such a fantastic year, first of all. If you — if I could, I have several questions I'd like to pose one after another, since otherwise all of us get lost. So — first of all, can you hear me?
Robin Laik
executiveYeah. No, I'm really struggling to hear you.
Marie-Therese Gruebner
analystAll right, apologies for that. Is the audio coming through more clearly now?
Robin Laik
executiveConsiderably interrupted.
Marie-Therese Gruebner
analystAlright, hopefully that comes through more clearly now.
Robin Laik
executiveThat's an improvement.
Marie-Therese Gruebner
analystAlright. Yes — my first question is about the guidance <<inaudible>>. Could you give us at least some indication of how that figure breaks down between dividends and consulting <<inaudible>> proceeds that you're budgeting in on the holding guidance, at the net income level for the guidance, please?
Mark Friedrich
executiveYes. Marie-Therese, it was still cutting out. So let me say again what I heard. You wanted a little more detail on the input factors behind the guidance for the holding, is that right?
Marie-Therese Gruebner
analystRight, exactly. And on the breakdown, if you could give us some indication there, that would be great.
Mark Friedrich
executiveOkay, so the revenue we expect for the holding is roughly EUR 120 million. And from that, we arrived at the net result, and the underlying assumption there is net proceeds exceeding EUR 100 million coming from exits. So the start of the year with Frigoscandia, where we already have over EUR 50 million, was pretty good. We're very active there and have kicked off a handful of other exit processes, which is why we feel quite confident in communicating this guidance that we've laid out here in the presentation.
Marie-Therese Gruebner
analystThat's clear. Could you maybe clarify — you mentioned consulting revenues stood at EUR 100 million in <<inaudible>> at the close of last year. Should we take that figure as the one to use for '24? Or would it be somewhat higher?
Mark Friedrich
executiveWhen it comes to '24, you should figure on EUR 120 million.
Marie-Therese Gruebner
analystAll right, all right. Now, regarding possible upcoming exits, or businesses you've been attempting to sell for a while — La Rochette, for instance — is there anything new there? And beyond that, could you say anything about exits still pending, perhaps in Q1 or Q2? In Q1, Frigoscandia was already done, but what about Q2?
Robin Laik
executiveWe really don't want to get into specifics on that. That's confidential information. But you can assume that for the companies that are harvesting, we check on a regular basis whether we're able to secure a good buyer. And we're not in a position where we're like a typical front facing exit pressure. We try to sell the companies — since we're a stock listed company — when we believe this is a right price.
Marie-Therese Gruebner
analystAll right, got that. My final question, then: could you say something about any deal activity coming up in China and the U.S., where you set up a presence not long ago? That's all I have on my side.
Robin Laik
executiveYeah. So in the U.S., we’re looking at various companies. There’s 1 automotive supplier with turnover of about EUR 200 million in cash losses, which fits the typical Mutares business model, and we’re also looking at an automotive supplier in China. So in both countries, I think that we — that we’ll have at least 1 deal announced this year.
Operator
operatorWith no more questions coming in, I'll hand things back to Robin Laik and Mark Friedrich. The floor is yours.
Robin Laik
executiveYes. That's where we stand today. Naturally, this is the moment to express gratitude to our employees across the globe. We've now delivered a fantastic result. We're growing, and that's only achievable because of you, because of the enormous commitment you bring to the companies. Many thanks. Thank you as well to you, our shareholders and bondholders, for the confidence you place in us. We made a promise and we delivered on it. That is what we aim for. Our targets are ambitious, and we intend to grow this business. And I hope you'll remain with us and assist us in reaching our targets. Many thanks, and we'll be speaking again soon. Thank you. Bye-bye.
Operator
operatorWe appreciate your joining us on this call today. We hope the remainder of your day goes well. See you on the next one — goodbye.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Mutares SE & Co. KGaA transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Mutares SE & Co. KGaA earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Mutares SE & Co. KGaA or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.