Natural Grocers by Vitamin Cottage, Inc. (NGVC) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

November 17, 2022

New York Stock Exchange US Consumer Staples Consumer Staples Distribution and Retail earnings 29 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Jessica Thiessen

executive
#1

Good afternoon, and thanks for being with us on the Natural Grocers by Vitamin Cottage call covering results for the fourth quarter and fiscal year 2022. Joining me are Co-President Kemper Isely and Chief Financial Officer Todd Dissinger. Just a reminder that some of what we discuss today consists of forward-looking statements that rest on present expectations and assumptions and carry risks and uncertainties. A range of factors — among them the risks and uncertainties laid out in the company's latest Forms 10-Q and 10-K — could cause actual results to differ materially from what those forward-looking statements describe. No obligation is taken on by the company to update forward-looking statements. You can find today's press release on the company's website, and a recording of this call will be posted there at investors.naturalgrocers.com. With that, I'll hand things over to Kemper.

Kemper Isely

executive
#2

Thanks, Jessica, and good afternoon, everybody. We're thrilled to share that fiscal year 2022 brought us record earnings, as we hit our guidance for both daily average comparable store sales growth and diluted earnings per share; net sales came to $1.1 billion, with diluted earnings per share of $0.94. Fiscal year 2022 represents our 19th straight year of positive daily average comparable store sales growth. We're extremely proud of everything the company achieved this year; over the last several years, we've seen sustained growth. Compared with fiscal 2019, or pre-pandemic levels, daily average comparable store sales are up 15.7%. The basket has risen more than 20%, and diluted earnings per share are up 124%, which shows how relevant and enduring our business model is. Three years ago, we started paying a cash dividend, and it has returned $2.96 per common share cumulatively to our stockholders. That dividend speaks to our strong operating performance and financial position, our confidence in the business model, and our dedication to giving value back to stockholders. Fourth quarter results matched what we expected, since we were cycling strong performance from the fourth quarter a year earlier. Todd will go through the results in greater detail once I touch on a few key company initiatives. Our {N}power loyalty program keeps proving to be an effective way to optimize promotional activity and boost customer engagement. We closed the quarter with 1.8 million loyalty members, which is an 18% increase year-over-year. For the fourth quarter, net sales penetration for {N}power reached 76%, compared with 72% a year ago, which shows customers appreciate what this program offers. Our Natural Grocers Brand Products stay a key point of differentiation and a sales driver, since today's consumers increasingly prioritize value. In the fourth quarter, private label brands made up 7.6% of total sales, versus 7.1% in last year's fourth quarter. During the quarter, we introduced 12 new branded products, among them four varieties of wild-caught seafood that come pre-seasoned and ready to cook, and they taste quite good. In fiscal year 2022, we expanded our private brand offerings by 41 SKUs. For the year, sales growth for our Natural Grocers Brand Products outpaced the company's growth rate. We credit that higher growth to customers recognizing the strong value proposition of our premium-quality offerings at compelling prices. Now for new store development. In the fourth quarter, we opened our first South Dakota store, located in Sioux Falls, opened a new store in Brighton, Colorado, and relocated our Cheyenne, Wyoming store. Across fiscal year 2022, we opened three stores in total and relocated two. We're very pleased with how these new stores and relocations are performing. Delays in construction, permitting, and the availability of materials and equipment held back our new store development in fiscal year 2021 and 2022. Looking ahead across the coming years, our expectation is that we will get back to launching 6 to 8 additional locations annually, assuming that construction and supply chain situations keep getting better. Natural Grocers has a history of operating as a values-driven business. Our dedication to creating a healthy, sustainable future for our shoppers, our Good For You Crew, and the communities we serve goes back a long way and is genuine; we put in serious effort to make sure our product assortment, locations, operations, corporate policies, and supply chain all mirror those values; during fiscal year 2022, combining what the company gave with what customers raised came to over $1 million in cash contributions along with greater than $4 million worth of donated food and products given in-kind to local food banks. We stand alone among national grocery chains in providing the resources of a full-time nutritional health coach at every store, and that person's main job is to deliver free, science-based nutrition education to our shoppers and the community around them. During fiscal year 2022, what we spent on offering free nutrition education came to over $4 million. Earlier this month, we put in place yet another wage rate bump of $1 per hour for hourly store crew. This raise marks our third $1 per hour increase from when the pandemic started. The average hourly wage rate across our whole company for full-time store crew is now above $20 per hour, which includes $1 per hour in Vitamin Bucks; that stacks up against the November 2019 average wage rate of roughly $15.50 per hour and shows how we have stuck with our commitment to putting money into our crew; to wrap up, I want to give a shout-out to each and every member of our Good For You Crew for their ongoing hard work and dedication to the principles we were founded on, which includes bringing the best quality products at prices that are always affordable to the communities we serve. Having said that, I will hand the call over to Todd so he can go through our financial results and guidance.

Todd Dissinger

executive
#3

Thanks, Kemper, and good afternoon to all of you. For Q4, the outcome matched what we had anticipated, since we were up against a tough comparison from the same quarter a year ago, saw a change in how shoppers behaved, and dealt with cost pressures affecting our operations. Net sales came to $274.2 million, which was up 0.6% versus the equivalent period last year. On a daily average basis, comparable store sales were basically level, with a decline of 0.2%. Our three-year comp for Q4 rose sequentially, reaching 15.8%, up from 14.1% during Q3 and 13.5% in Q2. That 0.2% comp drop consisted of a 2.6% fall in transaction count, which was offset by a 2.5% rise in transaction size. The 2.6% transaction count decrease showed the fading of pandemic-era patterns, such as more typical amounts of summer travel and eating food away from home. Also, during Q4, roughly 20% of the transaction decline came from reduced SNAP EBT purchases. SNAP EBT accounts for a low single-digit percentage of overall sales. The 2.5% gain in transaction size came mostly from retail price inflation, partly offset by fewer items in each basket. We calculate product cost inflation at about 7% in Q4 and 5% for the fiscal year. Our inflation rate has traditionally been steadier than that of conventional grocers, thanks to our specialized supply chain. Over the past year, our inflation rate stayed below that of our peers and did not boost our comparable store sales to the degree it did for them. During Q4, we conveyed the effect of product cost inflation via pricing and anticipate continuing that practice for the foreseeable future. Item count per basket in Q4 fell by fewer than one item versus the prior year. Though it's hard to measure, numerous simultaneous factors might be driving the drop in item count. These factors probably include how consumers react to price inflation in their food and non-food buying, their move toward food away from home, and their reaction to macroeconomic worries. Remember that the number of items in each basket increased more than 10% compared with three years ago. Just as we anticipated, supplements sales in Q4 lagged the overall company sales comparison, because the prior-year supplements figure was a tough one to beat. Generally, supplements have experienced less inflation than food has; looking at a two-year timeframe, the supplements comparison was up by a high single-digit percentage. Dairy, meat, and grocery turned in the strongest department results during Q4. We saw only minor evidence of trade-down in Q4. Quite a few shoppers switched from branded items to private-label options. With our Natural Grocers Brand, customers get premium quality at a price that's appealing. Looking at the fourth quarter, bread, bulk grains, and supplements were among our private-label items that grew units faster than the equivalent branded products. We ought to note that certain premium goods, such as pasture-raised eggs and grass-fed milk, continue to expand more quickly — a sign to us that many buyers still care more about what a product delivers than its price tag. In-stock availability during Q4 returned to pre-pandemic levels. Let's now turn to the other sections of the P&L. Gross margin for the fourth quarter dropped 20 basis points, landing at 27.6%, driven by softer product margin stemming from higher freight, distribution, and shrink costs. During Q4, store expenses as a share of sales increased by 150 basis points, driven by greater labor costs resulting from higher wage rates. In the fourth quarter of fiscal 2022, store expenses included $2.8 million in impairment charges on long-lived assets related to two stores, compared with $1.1 million in the fourth quarter of fiscal 2021. For the fourth quarter, net income was $2.2 million, and diluted earnings per share were $0.09. Last year's fourth quarter, by contrast, had net income of $7.2 million, or $0.32 in diluted earnings per share. Adjusted EBITDA for the fourth quarter totaled $13.6 million. Now, a quick look at how we did across the entire year. Revenue for fiscal 2022 came in at $1.1 billion, up 3.2%. Comparable store sales on a daily average basis grew 2.6%, and measured over three years that works out to a 15.7% gain. Gross margin for fiscal 2022 finished 30 basis points higher than the year before, driven by improved product margin as well as leverage on the cost of occupying our stores. Store expenses measured as a share of sales held steady versus last year, because the leverage gained from stronger sales cancelled out the rise in labor expense tied to higher wage rates. Within store expenses, fiscal 2022 included $2.9 million in long-lived asset impairment charges, while fiscal 2021 included $1.5 million in long-lived asset impairment charges plus store closing costs. When we look at fiscal 2022, net income came to $21.4 million, and diluted earnings per share were $0.94. In fiscal 2021, those figures stood at $20.6 million and $0.91 of diluted earnings per share. Adjusted EBITDA for fiscal 2022 reached $62.2 million. Now let's move on to the balance sheet and cash flows. We closed out the year in a strong liquidity position: $12 million in cash and cash equivalents, nothing drawn on our $50 million revolving credit facility, and a $15.7 million balance remaining on our term loan. Looking back at the fiscal year, we saw a 13% increase in total inventory. A few things drove that: product in-stock levels came back to where they were before the pandemic, product cost inflation, and inventory we added for new stores and relocated stores. We feel the inventory level we have right now is appropriate. During fiscal year 2022, cash from operations came to $39.7 million, and we put $31.1 million into net capital expenditures. Those capital expenditures covered opening three new stores, two relocated stores, and buying a property we had previously been leasing. Free cash flow came in at $8.6 million. Today, the company announced that it has declared a quarterly cash dividend of $0.10 per common share. The dividend is scheduled for distribution on December 14th, 2022, going to shareholders who are on the books as of the end of business on November 28th, 2022. At this point, I'd like to present our outlook for fiscal year 2023. This guidance was put together after taking into account where operating trends currently stand, what consumers are doing, and how uncertain the economic picture is, factoring in inflationary pressure and the possibility of a recession. Within our outlook we've incorporated gains from opening new locations, marketing that emphasizes the value we offer, and efforts to boost store productivity. As we see it right now, same-store sales comparisons are going to be tougher during the first half of the year, since we're going up against strong comps that Delta and Omicron drove. Finally, our outlook assumes gross margin will stay level compared with the prior year, while store expenses measured as a share of sales will climb because of increased labor rates. Looking at fiscal year 2023, our plans call for opening four to six new stores, relocating one to two stores, posting daily average comparable store sales growth somewhere between -2% and +1%, delivering diluted earnings per share in the range of $0.70 to $0.90, and directing $28 million-$35 million toward capital expenditures in support of our growth initiatives. To wrap up, we enjoyed yet another strong, record-setting year, which we credit to numerous factors, though above all it's our customers' appreciation for how dedicated we are to our principles and values, our reliability, and the hard work of our Crew. We keep working toward being the preferred grocer for top-quality natural and organic products at prices that remain affordable. In our view, Natural Grocers remains highly differentiated within the marketplace and uniquely relevant to shoppers; we're excited about the many opportunities that fiscal year 2023 will bring. Having said that, I'd like to turn the lines over for questions. Thank you.

Jonathan Baldwin

analyst
#4

Hello, Jonny Baldwin here, filling in for Greg. I appreciate you taking my question. Regarding the 2023 comp guide ranging from -2% to 1%, could you elaborate a bit on the assumptions behind that, particularly around cost inflation? Do you anticipate mid-single digits as we head into 2023? And what kind of promotional activity do you expect to see? Thank you.

Kemper Isely

executive
#5

I appreciate the question. Several things to note; we expect inflation to remain, well, roughly stable, certainly during the first six months. Beyond the inflation benefit, certain sales drivers would include our marketing push around the value proposition as well as new store productivity. Among the risks and uncertainties incorporated into our forecast are certain consumer trends we're observing, such as continuing food away from home and travel. There's economic uncertainty regarding inflation and, likely in the latter half, the danger of recession. Considering the first half against the second half, during the first half we're comparing against strong comps from last year in Q1 and Q2, which had certain tailwinds from the pandemic that, as you know, we aren't experiencing right now.

Jonathan Baldwin

analyst
#6

Understood. That logic tracks, and I appreciate the additional detail. Turning to the 6 to 8 stores we're targeting for long-term expansion, how should we frame the comps benefit once we reach those later years and those locations are folded into the current base? What's the right way to think about the comp lift from that? Thanks.

Kemper Isely

executive
#7

For starters, our new locations post stronger comps across their initial five years compared with our established ones. That becomes a solid tailwind as soon as our pipeline of new stores is built out and operating. For this year, visibility looks fairly solid — likely around six new stores plus two relocations. With any luck, we'll avoid the kind of bureaucratic headaches and so forth that cropped up late last year when we were trying to get stores opened.

Jonathan Baldwin

analyst
#8

Okay, understood. Thanks very much. That's everything from me. I'll rejoin the queue.

Kemper Isely

executive
#9

Thanks.

Scott Mushkin

analyst
#10

Hey, guys. Nice to be talking to you again.

Kemper Isely

executive
#11

Good to be talking to you, Scott.

Scott Mushkin

analyst
#12

It's been some time. I believe you brought up how consumers are behaving differently. You know, other retailers have told us that as we moved through October and then into November, you know, the consumer genuinely appears to be altering its behavior, or their behavior. I was curious whether you might have any, you know, perspective on that, and any further specifics you could provide regarding what you mentioned.

Kemper Isely

executive
#13

Okay, so something we've really been seeing is that people are taking vacations again in a way they hadn't been. Back before the pandemic, there was always a slowdown for us in October. These days schools generally let out for roughly 2 weeks of fall break toward the end of October, and we saw that slowdown show up, and then once those October school breaks wrapped up, things picked back up. Over the summer, we've clearly seen that vacation patterns have had a real effect on the number of customers coming into the stores whenever vacations are at their peak. Another thing we've observed versus a year ago is, like Todd said, we benefited last year from the pandemic winding down. Our supplement sales went up enormously. This year, compared to that, they've come down a lot. That's something we've seen. And also, with people dining out at restaurants, it looks like that's pulled some business away from our in-store food sales.

Scott Mushkin

analyst
#14

When you're considering the consumer, you know, over the past, let's say, month or so, has there been some softening, or really not? Since I believe you folks mentioned that they still appear fairly robust, but I was curious whether there's any indication as we, you know, move through the quarter.

Kemper Isely

executive
#15

Okay, so what we've genuinely been seeing is softness among those at the bottom — the lower-income shoppers, the ones receiving SNAP benefits. At our locations, SNAP transactions have dropped by 20%. I mean, they don't make up a big portion of what we sell, but buying among that lower tier has clearly slowed quite a bit.

Scott Mushkin

analyst
#16

Scott Mushkin, go ahead.

Kemper Isely

executive
#17

Kemper Isely here — as I mentioned, the folks who make up the bulk of our business continue buying at a fairly steady pace, with the exception of that vacation situation.

Scott Mushkin

analyst
#18

Okay, so just to jog everyone's memory a bit — clearly your items are far healthier, yet that also means they cost somewhat more. How are you folks approaching that? I'm on board with the point that was made: we're likely entering a recession around the close of 2023. So walk us through how this business holds up once the unemployment rate rises and conditions tighten somewhat. I realize that probably makes things tougher, but take us through the performance again. And what steps can you take to offset part of that?

Kemper Isely

executive
#19

You know, one thing you do is really put your promotional emphasis on the basics, so customers get that you carry affordable products. Take, for example, our free-range eggs at $1.99 — that price is basically beating everyone else's in the market. Then there are organic avocados priced at $0.99 daily, which again undercuts everybody on that item. A major marketing focus for us at the moment is meal deals, bundling multiple products into something like a deal to feed a family of four for under $15, or feed a family of four for under $16, something along those lines. Our marketing really centers on those budget-friendly options. When it comes to a recession, it can actually benefit our business somewhat, since folks dine out less and take fewer vacations, meaning they eat at home more, which boosts our food sales. They may cut back somewhat on supplements and somewhat on body care. The other two categories, though, can be quite beneficial. It all hinges on whether we can get the right promotions out there and have them connect with shoppers, something I believe our marketing team excels at. Plus, with roughly 80% of our sales now coming from our {N}power customers, we can reach our core shoppers three or four times weekly through our {N}power email.

Scott Mushkin

analyst
#20

Yes, that's quite impressive. A substantial rise. For my final question, I'd like to ask about how newly opened locations are doing. What's your take on that? I'll hand it over.

Kemper Isely

executive
#21

My outlook on how our new locations are doing is quite optimistic. I believe we've chosen several excellent and compelling spots that will open during the coming twelve months, and I expect those to deliver solid outcomes.

Scott Mushkin

analyst
#22

Okay, everyone. Much appreciated. Once more, it feels good to be speaking with all of you again.

Kemper Isely

executive
#23

Thanks. I appreciate that.

Kemper Isely

executive
#24

In 2022, we celebrated 10 years since our initial public offering. Over that decade, our store count has almost tripled, while sales and earnings grew at a pace that was even quicker. On top of that, we've added more than 2,500 jobs. What matters more is that we've given over 100 additional communities nearby access to top-quality, healthy nutritional products at prices people can afford, along with free nutrition education grounded in science. We take real pride in what we've accomplished across this past decade, and we're just as enthusiastic about what's still to come; we can't wait to talk with you on our next call, when we'll go over our first quarter of 2023 results. Thanks, and have a great day. Bye.

Operator

operator
#25

That brings this call to a close. We appreciate your joining us for today's presentation. You're free to disconnect at this point.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Natural Grocers by Vitamin Cottage, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Natural Grocers by Vitamin Cottage, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Natural Grocers by Vitamin Cottage, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.