New Fortress Energy Inc. (NFE) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
November 8, 2022
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Patrick Hughes
executiveThanks, Jake, and hello to all of you on this morning's call. It's a pleasure to welcome you to New Fortress Energy's Third Quarter 2022 Earnings Conference Call. This session, as Jake mentioned, is being recorded, and a replay will be accessible in the Investors portion of our website, listed under the subheading Events and Presentations. In that same spot, you'll find our Q3 2022 investor presentation, which we'll be referencing throughout today's discussion. That presentation includes a number of important disclosures regarding forward-looking statements and non-GAAP financial measures. We urge participants to examine those important disclosures along with the description of risk factors found in our SEC filings. Now, let's get into today's call. This is Patrick Hughes. I handle Investor Relations at New Fortress Energy. With me today are Wes Edens, our Chairman and Chief Executive Officer; Chris Guinta, our Chief Financial Officer; Andrew Dete, Managing Director in charge of commercial activities, plus several other members of our team. With that, I'll hand the call over to Wes.
Wesley Edens
executiveAlright, thank you, Patrick, and I appreciate all of you joining us this morning. As always, I'll be walking through the investor deck we posted earlier today, so if you wouldn't mind pulling that up and following along, that would be helpful. Let's begin on Page #4. Q3 proved to be yet another strong quarter for the company. Financially, it was a very, very solid quarter: $291 million in EBITDA, which keeps us squarely on track toward our $1.1 billion target for the year. That's a substantial increase over Q3 of last year, when we posted $170 million. Broadly speaking, on the financial front it was — it was actually a fairly productive quarter; beyond that, we achieved meaningful progress on the 2 major aspects of our business, those being the supply side and the demand side. On supply, naturally, I'm referring to the FLNG business. Chris will get into that with some detail. Last week, down in Corpus Christi, we hosted a big group of investors, equity analysts, and other participants, sharing with them not just the specifics of what we're actually doing down there, but also giving them an introduction to the highly talented team of people we have executing for us, and we feel terrific about that; on the demand side, there's plenty to discuss. Andrew will devote a lot of time to that; and really it comes down to the 2 aspects of demand; near term, the dislocation around the world is significant, and we're all aware of that, but we'll address that specifically. Over the long term, our mission of delivering power to the places around the globe that need it most is very much the company's mission, and the problems and dislocations worldwide that we've witnessed in Europe, in particular, have only worsened the needs that people have. So we'll cover a lot on that as well; so both sides, that's great. Another notable financial element of the quarter is that we've raised our guidance on our illustrative goals for next year, going from $1.5 billion next year to $2.5 billion. So that's a meaningful upward adjustment reflecting what we're seeing in the world right now, and Andrew will address that shortly. Now turn to Page number 5. This is a new page, a new format for us in terms of presenting the supply and demand side, and I find it especially useful. At the top, you can see the supply side summary. So the volumes, TBtus, 74 TBtus, in 2021, 88 in 2022, 161 as FLNG volumes kick in, particularly in the second half of 2023. There are lots and lots of different adjustments in this business. 50 TBtus equals about 1 million tons of gas. Alright, roughly 1.5 million tons in the prior year, approaching 2 million tons in the current one; then 161 — so next year we're in fact applying a substantial upward revision, but if you continue toward the right, our expectations for the remaining FLNG volumes across 2024 and 2025 become visible, and a rather dramatic rightward shift in volume is apparent. Now take those volumes and look at the row directly beneath, which shows the margin realized on our positions. Put simply, volumes multiplied by margins gives you adjusted EBITDA. There is no clearer or more transparent method of examining this business. In 2021, margins realized came to $8.14 per TBtu; in 2022, $12.50. Our projected $2.5 billion of EBITDA translates into $15.53. Margin gains appear in every one of those years, which ought to align with your instinct about events in the world, correct? As the world has become dislocated, chances to capture better margins exist; yet what clearly holds our attention is not near-term results but the longer horizon. Consequently, if you check the right-hand portion, we have normalized those margins to what we consider attainable mostly via selling power and gas to customers globally. Once more, Andrew will devote considerable time to this topic, but at $10, $12.50 and $15, the resulting illustrative EBITDAs for those years run from $3.3 billion at the very low end in 2024 up to $6.96 billion at the top end on the opposite side; this entire calculation presumes the supply held in our inventory matches what we have already effectively committed. Naturally, we believe considerable growth possibilities exist worldwide and throughout our portfolio; still, this represents a highly discrete way to examine matters, and I hope you find it useful. With that, let's turn to Page #6; given the favorable operational developments, we generate substantial free cash flow. Cash on hand as of today stands at $1.4 billion, with targeted operating cash flows across the coming 3 years of roughly $10 billion. So once we subtract the CapEx needed to complete our FLNG and other initiatives throughout the company, we anticipate producing more than $5 billion in liquidity during the next 3 years; that's a considerable quantity of liquidity. Which raises the question of how to deploy it. Down in the box, 3 evident options appear. First, additional investments are plainly possible. Second, capital can go back to shareholders, whether through deleveraging the company followed by issuing dividends, deleveraging the company and repurchasing stock, or some blend of all those approaches. We have not yet settled on precisely which path we will pursue. So at this point we're sitting on quite a bit of liquidity. What we discussed with the Board yesterday is that we'll be running extensive analysis across roughly the next 30 days. Our aim is to step forward on or around December 15 and give shareholders a clear message regarding our intentions — near term as well as longer term — especially when it comes to dividend policy, and regarding what we plan to do with that capital. So this is a serious undertaking. As we like to say, when you examine the balance sheet and the capital structure, it's that classic case of measure twice, cut once, given that we're dealing with substantial sums of capital — but it leaves us well positioned to potentially give capital back to shareholders, to pursue things that expand the business, and all of those considerations will factor in. So expect further updates in about a month. Before I hand things over to the rest of the team, Page 7 is the final one from me. If a picture is worth 1,000 words, this one could be worth 10,000 words. In fact, this is a chart you might want to print out and keep with you, since I believe it says a great deal about the current situation worldwide. Looking beyond the yellow box on the left side, you'll see, for the most part, natural gas's 3 major indices.
Wesley Edens
executiveFor a long time, the three benchmarks—Henry Hub here at home, TTF over in Europe, and JKM in Asia—moved in a fairly coordinated way. The interesting part is that the point when things began to come apart is July '21. That means a full 9 months before the Russian invasion got underway, the world's balance, or rather imbalance, started shifting in a major way, and that sent prices sharply upward. Of course, looking at this chart, the question I ask myself is: what should we expect as you keep extending it further right and conditions return to normal? What does the new normal look like, and at what level would we anticipate gas finally settling once this crisis resolves itself in 1 form or another? In my view, that new normal could sit at a somewhat higher level, or possibly a considerably higher one. It may also be that the age of inexpensive energy—especially in Europe—belongs to yesterday, and that once things stabilize, assuming they truly do, we land at a higher point on the whole. Clearly, though, that carries a substantial effect on margins within the business. Our margins are something worth watching closely. Still, several elements aren't captured in this chart that I believe might matter a great deal. Chief among them: in Asia, there's been a clear step-down in LNG imports into China—specifically, the 0 COVID policy there has clearly hurt them economically. They've actually pulled back sharply on that. We monitor it closely, and we believe it could shift considerably; yet the other point I'd raise about this chart is that it largely concerns the developed world. It covers the United States, Europe, and Asia; and naturally, there are many, many billions of people beyond the developed world who badly need energy. Andrew will address that in just a second; but I think that no matter what happens in Europe, you've got enormous demand and a need for power across these various markets. So that's something to keep your eye on. An interesting chart there on the left. I'll hand it over to Chris. Chris?
Chris Guinta
executiveAbsolutely. Morning, everyone, and thank you, Wes. If you’ll turn with me to Slide #9, I’ll bring you up to date on the LNG supply portfolio we hold and the steps we’re taking right now to expand it, particularly through our fast LNG projects. What this slide shows is major expansion across the portfolio between 2021 and 2025. The supply contracts we have today moved from 74 TBtu in the prior year to 88 TBtu now, and they’ll reach 114 TBtu across 2023 through 2025. Once FLNG volumes are added in, that brings another 350 TBtu, roughly 7 metric tons per annum, starting up in the near term. Unit number one is set to start operations in May or June 2023, with the other 5 switching on by the end of September 2024, which is under 2 years away. That gets us to 161 TBtu of volumes in the coming year, rising to 464 TBtu in 2025. Let’s move to Slide #10 now and discuss how FLNG is progressing. As you’re aware, and many of you were there, we held an investor and analyst event last week at the Kiewit shipyard in Corpus Christi, and it gave us a wonderful chance to show investors how far we’ve come. Like we said on site, none of what we’re doing is too complex or hard, though it does demand that the team stay organized, efficient, and accountable to each other. The 2 main takeaways from last week’s event and the quarter’s highlights are these: first, FLNG #1 is moving along very well, and we expect mechanical completion on March 17, followed by the asset being deployed and operating in May and COD in June 2023. Second, we achieved enormous progress on deployment options, including permits at our different locations, which we’ll go through over the next couple of slides. As I said, FLNG 1 is closing in fast on completion. Looking at the modules in the upper left of this page, there’s a photo showing where we put together the modules that will be lifted beneath the jack up rigs. Module 1, for gas treatment, sits on the first rig; module 2, the liquefaction unit, goes on the second rig; and then a 1 smaller module for utilities and accommodations is placed on the third rig. Every one of these large modules will stand 4 to 7 levels tall and weigh more than 5,000 tons once finished. Underneath is a photo of the jack up rigs where those modules will go in. Demolition is done, and we’re close to finishing the whole strengthening and enhancements to the foundation, along with a complete overall and upgrade of the marine systems. Beyond that, we’re currently getting ready for deployment and operations after FLNG construction wraps up. Our commissioning team has been hired and is working to commission as much of the asset in the yard as they can. When the system is finished, we can move straight into activating and testing it. On the installation side, we're taking steps so that every subsea tie-in, pipelay job, mooring and riser task is finished, which guarantees that the moment the FLNG arrives on site, operations can start right away. On the operations side, our personnel have already started training and running simulations so they're prepared to run the asset as soon as it's in place. Please turn to Slide 11. We've discussed these sites previously, but we've broadened the deployment choices for our FLNG to 3 separate locations, and those could handle as many as 6 FLNG units. Like Wes said, we were in Mexico City for yet another meeting with President López Obrador and the CFE Director, and there we signed binding documents to deploy as many as 3 units at Altamira. That project would use U.S. feed gas molecules moved into Mexican waters through the Sur de pass pipeline. Every permit application has been filed, and those are now in final review. All the relevant permitting agencies involved have given us active, vocal public support. We anticipate wrapping up the permit process early next year. The second box covers the West Delta 38 site, where our MARAD application was filed to install 2 FLNG assets. Here too we'd rely on existing pipeline infrastructure along with reverse flow of gas from onshore out to our unit offshore. Many of you are aware that our stock clock order was lifted on October 28, and we anticipate EPA issuing our draft environmental impact study very soon. That keeps us on track for final permits in the first half of 2023. The third site is an innovative partnership with Pemex to complete the Lakach field. NFE will finish 7 wells and then start producing in summer 2024; roughly 1/3 of the gas will go to shore for Pemex to use, while the remaining 2/3 will serve as speed gas for our FLNG 4, which will use the Sevan semi-submersible drillship. We really like this model, since it captures proven but undeveloped and stranded gas reserves, sending a portion to shore and the rest to NFE as feed gas to convert into LNG. Please turn to Slide #12. Wes covered this page last week in Corpus, but it lays out a road map of which units we're building, where construction is happening and when each should be finished. The page lists the mechanical completion dates for every unit, and after that it takes between 2 to 3 months to mobilize, install and commission before reaching COD. These schedules come from simplifying the design with an emphasis on repeatability. We have the module fabrication time line and the marine infrastructure make-ready down to about 12 to 14 months, while to mobilize hookup and install takes about a 2- to 3-month process. Commissioning runs 1 to 2 months. And in total, future units can be done in 18 to 20 months from FID to COD. Also, for every one of the FLNG units 1 through 4, we have placed orders for all the essential or long lead components already; and clearly, the same suppliers are being used across each unit. Because the module engineering follows one uniform design, most of what we procure is shared among the units. So there are larger hues for compression, Chart supplies the cold box, Siemens provides gas turbines, shell bore handles marine equipment, and so on. So to wrap up, you can see that our LNG supply is expanding quickly across the coming 2 years. That will not just feed a downstream portfolio that is growing but also puts us in an ideal spot to take advantage of present market dynamics and the rising worldwide demand for dependable LNG to strengthen energy security. With that, I'll hand things over to Andrew.
Andrew Dete
executiveThank you, Chris. Hi, everybody. It was wonderful to be with all of you in Corpus Christi last week. What Chris, Alap, and the team have accomplished is remarkable. Standing on those rigs and gazing out at all the components waiting to be hoisted onto them was really enjoyable. Given my position on the commercial side, that was a hugely significant moment for us. So, as Chris just walked everyone through, NFE is bringing 7 Mtpa of new volumes online in the near term. That lifts our overall portfolio from roughly 2 to 2.5 Mtpa up to 9.5 Mtpa, which, as Chris demonstrated, equals 464 TBtus by 2024 on a run rate basis. I'm now on Page 14. What we'd like to do at this point is take a minute to lay out our long-term commercial approach for selling these volumes in a manner that generates long-duration sustainable returns. You'll notice that this strategy broadly aligns with the same core mission NFE has pursued since day one of expanding access to affordable power around the globe, which we view as both a sound business and an excellent mission. So on Page 14, on the left-hand side, what we're really presenting is an energy density chart of the world. The tagline reads: 70% of the world's electricity is consumed by just 10 countries. And so what we witness daily in these markets, and what we firmly believe, is that these other nations that are less energy dense are headed in only 1 direction, and that's toward greater energy consumption, greater electricity consumption. I think I almost owe Wes a royalty for saying this; but as long-time followers know, Jamaica consumes about 1/10 of what we consume in the U.S., and Kenyans consume about a tenth of what Jamaicans consume. And so what we see is an enormous opportunity and a massive market, which is to deliver affordable power in places that lack it today. The more time we spend in these markets, the more we observe that demand is truly constrained only by supply, and in that instance, by affordable supply. And so when we look at the right side of this page, which contains new data from EIA, what they're showing is that for the first time in 20 years of collecting data on access to electricity, they're actually seeing the number of people lacking access to electricity rising for the first time in 2022; that's somewhat of a canary in the coal mine pointing to a broader story about energy flows being redirected toward Europe and generally the developed world, and about the world being short on energy on a global basis. What this does is lay out the framework for the opportunity as we see it and explain why it matters so much to us; and over the long term, our continued conviction is that combining our LNG supply with power generation lets us earn differentiated, sustainable margins across that horizon. Today I'd like to share some insight into how we intend to accomplish that. Turning to Page 15. NFE today genuinely operates as an integrated power company. To date we've supplied, converted, acquired, and built more than 3,000 megawatts of power across 8 separate power assets; what we're trying to give you here is context on our track record as we size and evaluate what lies ahead. Selling Power is genuinely a downstream activity. We're integrated the whole way to the consumer, and now we're layering in supply to essentially close that loop, and we plan to do more power. Power delivers an essential necessity and service to consumers and industrial businesses, it's usually obtained under long-term contracts, and from a credit standpoint it's highly resilient; replacing an operating one is very hard. Shutting it off costs more, and our credit track record in these countries has been exceptionally strong even during a worldwide economic downturn, we've been paid promptly in every one of these jurisdictions. So today 90% of operational volumes at NFE relate to power, and the more than 3,000 megawatts where we've served as either supplier or owner really speaks to our path forward. Moving on to Page 16. The left side shows the dimensions of the supply Chris discussed. So in 2024, on a run rate basis, we'll be at 464 TBtus. Current contracts will account for 130 TBtus of that, while 334 TBtus will be new supply. Broadly speaking, our rule of thumb is that each 10 TBtu works out to roughly 100 megawatts, so that 334 TBtus equates to approximately 3,300 megawatts of fresh power demand that we'll serve with our LNG supply; on the right side, 1,700 of those megawatts are already under development. The power plant in Barcarena, our 600-megawatt facility in Ireland, 300 megawatts in South Africa, and 200 megawatts of new power in Jamaica. Beyond that, we have a development pipeline exceeding 5 gigawatts in growth markets; what we're illustrating here is that as our supply scales toward this total portfolio of 9.5 Mtpa, the chance to integrate it with downstream power demand is roughly comparable in size to what we've already accomplished, and more than half of that volume is already in development. On Page 17, my aim is to take that opportunity before us and try to size it in terms of margin. When we consider power, what we're really talking about is selling electricity over the long haul through PPAs at rates that compete well. That brings me to the left-hand portion of this page, where you see $12.5 for power. We believe that's a cost that can compete globally in these expanding markets. Usually, you'd also have either a capacity payment or a return on CapEx — the gap between the expense of building and what the plant is worth — and that comes to approximately $0.025. So over the long term, for 100 megawatts of simple cycle power, we can offer electricity at an all-in price of roughly $0.15 per kilowatt hour. If we assume a 9,000 heat rate, that works out to around a $17 per MBtu sale of gas. On FLNG plus transport, our production cost sits at roughly $7 MMBtu, which produces a total gas margin of approximately $10 for MMBtu. That matches the historical figures Wes presented earlier — $8 moving to $12 moving to $15 — and it's also what we anticipate over the long term. So at the bottom of this page, we're referring back to the margin page shown earlier to illustrate that as we reach our targets of 464 TBtus run rate for '24 and '25 at $10 in margin, that equals $4.6 billion of margin. And this genuinely aligns with our past performance and our intentions moving forward. Let me now turn to Page 18 and discuss how we arrive there.
Andrew Dete
executiveWhat makes this chance so remarkable for us right now, and what sets this business apart from how it used to be, is that this is a fantastic moment to be adding supply and holding a long position, since there's basically a short-term LNG market opening unlike anything we've seen before. Over on the left-hand side of the page, we've been running extensive, granular modeling on European gas balances for 2023. For anyone tracking this, the problem is extremely variable. Still, we prefer to return to something like 1 straightforward metric: Russian pipeline gas supply came to 122 MTPA during 2021; during 2022, that figure was 67 MTPA. For 2023, our expectation is 0. That amounts to swapping out 1,500 LNG cargoes, and doing so requires 20-plus new LNG terminals. So plenty can be said regarding what 2023 holds, but our effective view is that this market will stay short. And that price graph on the right — the same one we presented before, the one all of us now carry around in our pocket — really represents the near-term opportunity. So we're assembling a long position ahead of this opportunity, which we'll term out gradually through integrated LNG to power. Page 19 goes somewhat further regarding European infrastructure, since we want to walk you through some of these specifics so you understand exactly how attractive this opportunity is and how we intend to go after it in the immediate future. Today Europe possesses considerable regas infrastructure along with a highly interconnected LNG market. That means roughly 30 terminals, around 3,000 LNG cargo slots per year, with the market trading at an index price. The primary index goes by the name TTF. It's the gas network of the Netherlands, while the other gas networks across various European countries essentially trade at some basis relative to the TTF price. Now, the wonderful part for us, and something quite unlike most of NFE's history, is that we hold 2 things. We hold existing infrastructure, and we hold a centralized market price. That means we don't need to hunt down individual buyers. Instead, we can sell essentially through a centrally cleared exchange at an index price. And so this infrastructure has choke points when it comes to entering Europe; and clearly, those are now filling up further. We're building new capacity, which we've highlighted here — namely the Eemshaven terminal in the Netherlands, which we partnered with Gasunie on and which is the first new terminal to come online since the Russian invasion. Additional new terminals will follow, particularly in Germany, with some in Italy and elsewhere too, and those will grow that infrastructure — though probably not enough to keep this market from being anything other than very tight over the next few years. Even so, there will be infrastructure available for suppliers such as us to get gas into Europe. Once more, if you're talking about substituting 100 MTPA of Russian supply, you'd likely need somewhere between 15 and 20 additional regasification terminals just to get a sense of the scale of that chance. So as our supply portfolio grows, we'll be in a position to sell into Europe through infrastructure that already exists, at whatever the market price happens to be, and that's delivering strong returns for us in the near term. Over the longer haul, our genuine conviction is that LNG to power represents the distinctive route to creating a competitive edge. It delivers an actual service downstream. It delivers attractive margins, and it's something NFE possesses the know-how and the track record to execute. So that gives you a bit more detail on how we view the long-term opportunity and how we intend to put all those FLNG volumes to work, and I look forward to discussing it further with you. Over to Patrick.
Patrick Hughes
executiveAppreciate it, Andrew. I'll be referring to Slide 21. We're going to take just a handful of minutes to discuss hydrogen; so we — I suppose the place to begin is by noting that our hydrogen business, the one we refer to as 0, kept achieving meaningful advances during Q3; and like Wes has repeatedly mentioned, our belief is extremely firm that hydrogen is going to serve as a foundational element of a future built on clean energy. Specifically, our view is that it has a major part to play in the hard-to-decarbonize portions of the industrial economy, such as refining, petrochemicals, steel and cement manufacturing, where meaningful decarbonization gains are achievable, yet we're also noticing, in fact, particularly over the last few months, that numerous adjacent chances exist in what you might call secondary and tertiary segments, for instance transportation, hydrogen storage and renewable power, and from a strategic standpoint we keep evaluating quite a few possibilities in those segments. Having said all that, a clean hydrogen economy is genuinely still in its infancy as it starts to take shape. So let's begin with Beaumont and that asset we've described to you in earlier quarters, and after that we'll walk through several other points before handing the call back to Chris; so we take pride in having — a genuine early-mover edge in this space via our inaugural industrial-scale green hydrogen plant located in Beaumont, Texas. What we're constructing is a 120-megawatt green hydrogen facility that will be able to generate 50 tons per day of green hydrogen, equivalent to roughly 18,000 tons per year. Once it starts operating, which we anticipate happening in 2024, it will rank as the largest such facility in the U.S. Beaumont is itself a major industrial hub in Southeast Texas that a lot of us know well from prior transactions and activities, with plenty of refineries nearby and plenty of other operations that consume hydrogen currently; and thus our obvious customers sit right there, either within or immediately beyond our property line. For some perspective, a mere 3 or 4 refineries in the close surrounding area need more than 1,000 tons a day of hydrogen; and again, at our initial scale we're making 50 tons. So 1,000 tons per day represents more than 20x the amount our plant by itself could turn out during that initial phase. So there's ample demand and ample room to grow within the nearby region. As a lot of you are aware, we locked in our long-lead equipment for this facility during the quarter, among it our electrolyzers through the deal we struck with Plug Power. Essentially, they build the machines responsible for producing the hydrogen. The initial one of these units is going to arrive at our site during 2023, and assembly will be finished and operations will begin, as I mentioned, in 2024. Additionally, in the course of the quarter, we reached an agreement with Entergy to supply renewable power to our site. That agreement actually has several dimensions, and thus far they've proven to be an excellent partner. Entergy is obviously involved with the power hookups — the high side and the transformers at the site that appear on Slide 21 — but beyond that, we are exploring additional ways we might work together with them. Moving along to Slide 22 now. It turns out that when it comes to where clean hydrogen projects can best be built, the U.S. is likely the top location anywhere on the planet. As lots of you are aware, earlier in this year Congress channeled a huge investment into clean energy infrastructure — in fact, the biggest climate investment in American history. This legislation, commonly called the Inflation Reduction Act, is anticipated to drive over $4 trillion in infrastructure investment across the coming 10 years. Within that, annual hydrogen spending will triple, alongside other significant commitments to areas such as carbon capture and storage, solar, electric transmission — essentially the grid that enables everything here. Naturally, we are highly focused on the $3 per kilogram clean hydrogen production credit, since it moves our hydrogen business from barely profitable to extremely profitable and genuinely enables our sector to make green hydrogen in a way that is both economic and scalable. Now please turn to the final slide of the hydrogen section — Page 23. During our previous call, we told you we have projects underway along the Gulf Coast and at additional sites across the U.S. On that same call, we specifically brought up the Marcellus project. What we are assembling here amounts to a pure-play, multi-asset clean hydrogen infrastructure company, and we intend to capitalize it separately before long. Throughout recent months, we have kept fitting together every component for Beaumont, and we have gained considerable knowledge. Those lessons are being applied so we can truly refine how we tackle upcoming projects — this includes carefully considering who our customers are and where hydrogen demand truly exists, establishing these clean hydrogen markets precisely in the places they are required; in essence, we take everything that works well from the Beaumont project and replicate that template in other regions of the country. To frame this in familiar terms, we are creating the foremost industrial-scale clean hydrogen business, and at the outset our platform should equal 5 Beaumonts; thus the figure of 90,000 tons per year shown on your screen matches roughly 600 megawatts, or approximately 520-megawatt Beaumont facilities. As is clear, a great deal more lies ahead on this front. We will reach out again shortly regarding important commercial milestones at Beaumont as well as specifics on our expansion and separate capitalization strategy. Chris, the floor is yours.
Chris Guinta
executiveOkay, thank you, Patrick. Let's move to Slide 25. I'll take us through the Q3 financial results fairly quickly; during the 3 months that closed on September 30, adjusted EBITDA came in at $291 million, and that works out to roughly $1.2 billion on a trailing 12-month basis. Operating margin for the Terminal segment reached $251 million, with an additional $88 million contributed by the ship segment, and additional detail is available in the appendix. Net income for the quarter was $86 million, equal to about $0.41 per share once onetime items are excluded. Total volumes sold this quarter came to 24 TBtus, translating into an average operating margin of approximately $15 per MMBtu, which clearly exceeds what Andrew tells us is achievable over the long term. Henry Hub came in at an average of $8.30, which clearly flows through, though it did affect both revenue and costs during the period. Let's go to Slide 26. We're presenting a side-by-side comparison of the balance sheet as of June 30, 2022 against its current position. And as you can see, the picture looks completely different. Thanks to the tremendous efforts of our M&A teams, we've delivered on our commitment to monetize more than $2 billion in assets, which provides full funding for our growth initiatives. We've streamlined the corporate debt down to just 2 tranches of bonds, at 6.75% and 6.5%, respectively; in addition, we hold a $440 million revolver and a $250 million letter of credit facility, giving us access to low-cost, flexible capital whenever required, and it remains undrawn at present thanks to our cash position; and finally, there are the Jamalco bonds, which represent asset-level debt, nonrecoursed NFE, yet they are consolidated on our balance sheet and therefore appear here. As you can see, our liquidity profile is robust, with more than $1.4 billion in available capital. Turning to Slide 27, we've achieved meaningful progress against our financial objectives, and we'll use this slide in discussions with the rating agencies over the coming weeks; we believe we're well positioned for an upgrade and look forward to those conversations. Today, as I noted, our trailing 12-month EBITDA stands at approximately $1.2 billion, and with 7 terminals either operating or close to completion, our debt-to-EBITDA ratio sits below 3x. As the graph at the bottom left shows, deleveraging happens quickly as each FLNG unit comes online. There will be — we will sit under 2x leverage once our first FLNG asset is up, and below 1x after the second one comes online later next year. Lastly, at the bottom right of the page, we show that cash on hand plus availability under the working capital facility totals $1.4 billion, which together with our operating cash flow provides full funding for the FLNG initiatives. Finally, Slide 28 reflects our ongoing commitment to operating as a world-class company. During the third quarter, we handed over 24 TBtus to our customers, and the reliability of our assets is still over 98%. It's worth highlighting that our outstanding crews in South Florida and the Caribbean managed to safely and efficiently halt operations as hurricanes neared our facilities this autumn, and then got everything running again inside 24 hours after the Coast Guard gave the all clear. Finally, and just as importantly, we recorded zero safety incidents in Q3 and continue to hold our total recordable incident rate at 0.0. Having said that, I'll now hand the call back to Patrick.
Patrick Hughes
executiveAppreciate that, Chris. Alright Jake, I believe we're set to open it up for a few questions. If you wouldn't mind walking the callers through how to do that, that'd be wonderful.
Ben Nolan
analystThanks for fitting me in. To kick things off, I'd like to get a clearer picture on the FLNG front regarding which location gets which equipment — it seems as though Altamira sits at the front of the queue for the jack ups. If that's the case, I take it that means the floaters would be headed to Louisiana. First off, have I got that right? And assuming I do, does that alter the MARAD process in any way when it comes to approvals, time lines, or anything along those lines?
Wesley Edens
executiveBen, this is Wes. It was nice catching up with you last week. Like Chris mentioned, on Friday — immediately following our tour in Corpus — we put our signatures on agreements with the Mexican government. So we now hold definitive agreements permitting us to position units at Altamira, which is excellent news. That provides us with a great deal of certainty, because in the FLNG business, what can I say, 2 factors are what count. The first is constructing the unit, and the second is securing a location to site it. So our position in Mexico has us feeling very good, and we believe this represents the initial one among numerous opportunities available to us in that region. Next, regarding MARAD, our engagement with them is quite active. At this stage, our permitting team communicates with them every single day. As you're aware, the statute gives them a 364-day window within which they must issue you a permit. Should questions arise during that stretch, they're essentially able to halt the clock while they request that you supply more thorough answers, then resume it once they're content that you've complied. We just recently went through precisely that sequence; they halted the clock on our project in the middle of August. At the end of October, they got the clock going again, which has us feeling great. And so we consider both of those sites to be strong contenders for the first of these units. At this stage, I'd note that Altamira holds a slight edge, given that it's a bit further ahead in the process. Still, our aim for next year would truly be to place assets on both sides, which would deliver the greatest diversification for the company and open the door to additional units beyond those. So that's the current state of things. As it stands right now, we'd be the first 1 in Altamira around the middle of the year, and the second 1 in Louisiana later on in the year.
Ben Nolan
analystAll right. And in Louisiana, if we're talking about a floater, does that alter how things work at all?
Wesley Edens
executiveIn Louisiana, we're actually permitting the floating rate option together with the fixed platform. Our plan is to pursue both there. So it's one or the other, correct? So, as Chris described, we aim to be extremely precise about this, and we hold a fairly granular understanding of the schedule involved. The initial unit is set to leave the yard in March, the next one in November, and then roughly every couple of months after that. That gives us considerable latitude regarding what kind of infrastructure is used. Naturally, as we mentioned earlier, the liquefiers themselves remain identical no matter which marine infrastructure they're placed on. So.
Ben Nolan
analystAll right. That's great. And I believe I have one more question. But quickly, is there anything new regarding Ireland? It has been somewhat inconsistent, but what is the situation right now?
Chris Guinta
executiveSure. We are currently in the final stages of review. Clearly, certain dates were put out earlier by Ireland's permitting agencies, and those have slipped somewhat. Our feeling is that our position there is quite strong. There are now public remarks concerning the government's backing of LNG, and the review of supply security that the government has undertaken certainly favors LNG; therefore, on a daily basis we are collaborating to respond to inquiries and handle other matters so that we can help ensure our permit is completed before this year ends, yet we have confidence it will occur. That covers the terminal as well as the 600 megawatts of power, which we also want to be certain we address.
Sam Margolin
analystDuring your prepared comments, you mentioned that this year the conversion of operating margin into cash is happening far more efficiently, which is excellent. When FLNG production starts up, certain factors shift, such as working capital requirements and the way the financials flow in and out. Could you elaborate a bit on how — is there anything that must be addressed regarding the balance sheet or liquidity to handle working capital positions as you transition into being a major LNG producer?
Chris Guinta
executiveSam, this is Chris. The brief response is that we do not anticipate any significant working capital outflow whatsoever. In fact, at this very moment, we purchase LNG cargoes from current suppliers, and that prepayment is purely a result of lacking investment grade status and is typical for the industry at present. Once we begin accepting feed gas supply, what we have arranged is that the feed gas supply contracts we will hold, sourced off the Sur de pass line from the CFE or located in Louisiana, will all be settled in arrears. And regarding Lakach, we are in fact the party making payments to Pemex. Therefore, I anticipate that you will reach a working capital positive position quite quickly. The physical activation of the equipment, clearly, does not involve large expenditure. What I mean is that it consists of labor and power, which essentially equates to the cost of the feed gas entering the unit. So we are not expecting any major drags whatsoever. It is important to mention that we keep increasing the size of the revolver and the LC facility, giving us considerable flexibility as well. That represents inexpensive capital.
Sam Margolin
analystThat sounds great. Now, one more quick question. The slides show that TTF's forward curve completely backs up this margin outlook beyond 2025. Looking at LNG capacity, a lot of it can work with a margin around $15, while much less can work at, let's say, a margin of $3 to $4, but I believe yours can. So my question is: as you build out this term business, how hard do you actually want to fight against that rival capacity while you push this strategy forward to bring energy to places that lack it?
Wesley Edens
executiveRight. One reason we brought Andrew in — he can walk you through the specifics of power-side economics and the scale of the global power shortfall — is to demonstrate what the company's long-term trajectory looked like. We began developing our own supply well before any crisis emerged, and we did that to meet what we see as an almost limitless pool of demand on the receiving end. The margins you earn in that business are substantial. When you set our margins of $8, $12, $15 next to the margins that big gas producers report — $1 or $3, $4, $5 — clearly ours are considerably larger. They're considerably larger because this is tougher work. You've got to construct terminals. You've got to construct infrastructure. You've got to construct power plants, and you've got to run operations for them. If high margins came easily, everyone would enjoy them. So we've put in a serious effort on the downstream side to fix people's problems, and knock has pulled that off quite well. Another point that I believe gets underestimated: one way to gauge how well that's gone is that the credit quality of that downstream operation is outstanding. We just came through a worldwide pandemic and are still dealing with its aftermath in many regions; the places where we operate rank among those hit hardest economically, yet we haven't seen even a single dollar of overdue payments from any of them. The service we deliver is essential, and they must have power. They must have energy. We're the cheapest choice available to them. So even though it demands far more in resources, capital, time, and staff, when you add it all up, you get a downstream portfolio that pairs with your upstream portfolio, you produce bigger margins, and you're fixing genuine problems instead of simply acting as a wholesaler. Essentially, at each level we operate as a retailer rather than a wholesaler, and that represents a significant commitment — you're able to see quite clearly right now what the advantages are, not only when it comes to the economics that flow down to the bottom line, but likewise the present characteristics of it, and further, simply the mission we're aiming to fulfill.
Sean Morgan
analystRegarding Altamira's DOE filing, I find it quite compelling. It appears you might be able to obtain gas out of Agua Dulce, something of a cherished objective for American exports, since many consider that supply typically costs less than certain Henry Hub volumes, where substantially greater export capability draws from. So as you consider needing to move that gas somewhat farther—a few pipelines are involved, as I understand, to bring it from the wellhead down to Jetty—where do you expect your export expenses would land compared with some current rivals within the U.S.?
Wesley Edens
executiveOur view is that ultimately the numbers come out quite comparable, whether we genuinely generate LNG and Agua Dulce gas down at Altamira or near the Louisiana coast. Clearly there's basin differential, transport costs, personnel costs and similar items—a whole range of distinct factors. Yet when all is said and done, it's genuinely very competitive in one location against the other. On a broad scale, 97% of global LNG today comes from onshore, with 3% offshore. Naturally, given these 5 projects we're currently constructing, we instantly rise to the top as the global leader in actually producing them. Just 6 units are in existence worldwide at present, and we're building 5 more. That establishes us as the global leader; that IP, in my view, is extraordinarily valuable; so clearly, what we're doing across the initial couple of installations involves utilizing pipeline gas that already exists from America, which is a prepared supply, offers favorable pricing, is dependable, and represents a fantastic market for conducting business. The project we're pursuing alongside Pemex marks our first instance of purchasing gas straight from an active well offshore. We believe the long-term consequences of that are remarkable. And we believe the IP needed to construct equipment that genuinely functions under those circumstances enables us to reach truly stranded gas, and that's the subsequent layer of added advantage available to us. So it's a gradual, phase-by-phase review, yet the straightforward response to what you asked is that we see the numbers as approximately equal. A plus or minus could exist on either side, yet they aren't especially different once you factor in both basin differential and transport. However, we believe the following stage would involve sourcing genuinely true standard stranded gas, and that might deliver an incrementally vastly different outcome.
Sean Morgan
analystOkay, got it. That helps, Wes. One more quick question about Altamira — my understanding is the application seeks 2.1. And last week, as I recall, we discussed total export capacity of 1.4. So is that 2.1 simply spare room in case you decide to grow the Altamira project? And beyond that, on an MTPA basis, what's the most the current pipeline infrastructure could handle?
Chris Guinta
executiveChris here. Correct — extra headroom is what we're after, you've got it right. The pipeline can move 2.6 B per day. We're aware of ongoing talks aimed at raising that capacity to slightly more than 3. According to public filings, the pipeline's historical utilization sits near 20%. So essentially, what we're doing is fixing an issue for CFE — assisting them in offsetting a portion of their firm transportation expenses, and simultaneously partnering with them as we take the LNG to market worldwide.
George Burwell
analystI'd like to focus on terminal sales and the room you have to keep selling to third parties in the coming year, and I suppose in 2024 too, since some terminals are scheduled to come online. Related to that, on Slide 27, you said there are 7 terminals now and 9 in 2024; could you walk us through which 7 those are, and then which would be the 8th and 9th?
Chris Guinta
executiveGlad to discuss the terminals, and if you'd like, we can also get into the downstream opportunities. The 7 terminals we're referring to are Old Harbour, Mo Bay, San Juan, La Paz, Puerto Sandino Nicaragua, Barcarena, Santa Catarina. We anticipate wrapping up developments we're currently in talks about in Ireland and South Africa, which brings us from 7 to 9.
Andrew Dete
executiveYeah. Regarding that first one, there are a few agreements that I believe are going to kick in during 2023, with Norsk Hydro and Barcarena being the major one. I'm not certain I fully grasped what was being asked, but we're going to keep activating those agreements. I believe we're indicating 130 TBtus as a sort of run rate for 2023 volumes. So there's somewhat of a gap between where we stand at present and where we'll finish 2023, and Norsk Hydro makes up a large portion of that.
George Burwell
analystAll right. That basically covers it — I suppose my follow-up would concern the MARAD process. You've already addressed it during the prepared remarks and in the Q&A, I realize, but based on what you've experienced so far — how things have unfolded and what you've taken away — how would you describe whether this process can be repeated? And do you believe it might move faster in the future? Because it seems to me the U.S. Gulf of Mexico is likely an excellent spot for you folks to rapidly expand fast LNG past those initial 5 units. So I'm curious what you think about that.
Wesley Edens
executiveSo, multiple agencies are involved in the MARAD review, right? And each time we've dealt with them, they've been very professional and quick to respond. From our perspective, they've finished everything they're supposed to do — both the letter and the intent of it — and we're feeling really good about that. When you look at their track record over the years, they've issued permits — they're responsible for approving every fixed platform in the Gulf, and I don't know the exact count, but it's likely in the tens of thousands — so this team has a tremendous amount of experience. So what we're working on isn't really all that new compared to what they've already handled. Clearly, the thing that sets this apart is the addition of a liquefier. Since you need compression to convert that gas into LNG, a liquefier comes with a power plant. That air permit, then, is the single incremental item that's different — though it's not a big one. In our view, their reaction has been entirely fitting, involved, and highly professional. So taking everything into account, we certainly see this as something that can be replicated many times over. We've examined numerous possible sites, in Texas and Louisiana alike, that would make sense for subsequent projects should this one pan out — and we're confident it will — but overall, it's been excellent. The modular method for constructing liquefaction facilities and situating them atop already-present marine infrastructure strikes me as both far less costly and much quicker. So, when I mentioned that 97:3 figure — the ratio as it stands now — my view is that it's very, very probable, essentially a certainty at 100%, that those proportions will change as time goes on, since this strategy makes tremendous sense. That holds not only for projects situated off the U.S. coastline, where gas is inexpensive and plentiful, but gas is also cheap and abundant in many regions worldwide. It lets us move from one location to another, and lower cost plus greater speed is plainly superior; so that's excellent.
Martin Malloy
analystI've got a question regarding 0. And I'm curious to hear your perspective on the offtake arrangement from that hydrogen facility, plus how you view the optionality around it. Clearly, that region has a substantial amount of industrial load; however, my understanding is that Entergy is also pursuing a fairly sizable proposed power plant. They're able to accept hydrogen, and additionally they possess pipeline infrastructure along with underground storage assets. And, I suppose, tied to that as well, what's your thinking on the milestones for scaling it up?
Patrick Hughes
executiveYeah. Appreciate it, Marty. You're completely correct. There's a great deal of diversity when it comes to the offtake pool located right nearby. I mean literally inside hundreds of feet, and then inside a couple of miles. So you're bringing up the — the refining type of community represents the figure I provided earlier, meaning 1,000 tons per day of hydrogen demand among just the 3 or 4 situated right there. And once more, since we're generating 50 tons, it follows that we're quite sought after, with plenty of parties examining that 50 tons per day of green hydrogen, which is a rather distinctive offering. We're likewise, in fact, collaborating with Entergy regarding their requirements in the area on the power side; the facility you're referring to goes by the name Orange County Advanced Power Station, and over time they'll have a considerable need too; and then I brought up storage along with transportation. So you've got items such as Spindletop plus several other current pipeline networks for moving the hydrogen essentially throughout the region; so plenty of choices for us. And essentially what we're attempting to do is examine how to optimize that initial phase. And after that it's — the favorable aspect regarding electrolyzers is that scaling is pretty simple, because it's just — it's mostly a matter of simply adding units. So the initial 120 will be 2024. And afterward we can add units as demand rises and the region requires more green hydrogen.
Wesley Edens
executiveRight. The key point, though, is that when you factor in the production credit, you're making hydrogen at roughly zero. And clearly, that creates extremely strong economics, and buyers are prepared to pay what the market charges. Like Patrick mentioned, the scale of what's required dwarfs everything that's been made so far. So I'd say the opportunity in hydrogen output — green hydrogen, blue hydrogen — is enormous, not only within the U.S. but globally. The reality is that right now, it amounts to a hobby. It's a fairly minor slice of the total energy picture. What I believe is that the Inflation Reduction Act genuinely supplies funding for many different pieces of this, such as making it, plus batteries, plus carbon capture and storage. Many elements of this are in fact quite potent. And in my view, appetite for green hydrogen simply cannot be exhausted, full stop, and we're able to deliver it at prices that work economically. So this has shifted from a venture that was barely turning a profit, yet still intriguing, into one that is thoroughly profitable and could then scale up enormously. That said, you cannot construct a second one before the first exists, and that's precisely where our attention sits today. After that, I think you're looking for gains in efficiency throughout the whole system — not merely in hydrogen generation, but in moving it, in using it, in every piece that will ultimately turn this into something beyond a hobby and give it a real part to play in decarbonization.
Martin Malloy
analystGreat. For my second question, I was hoping to hear your perspective regarding how things are going on the path toward an investment-grade rating. Also, do you believe that several of these fast LNG projects need to be operational first before that becomes achievable?
Wesley Edens
executiveWell, assuming the folks at the rating agencies happen to be tuned in—and I certainly hope they are—our view is that we ought to be investment grade at this moment. What I mean is that, speaking quite seriously, the amount of cash flow we produce and how we turn EBITDA into free cash flow is substantial. Beyond that, the agencies have been excellent partners throughout this journey. Our dialogue with them has been strong, especially following these earnings, and our plan is to return and revisit things with them. There's one item where we're seeking recognition from the rating agencies, and we also want recognition from the equity analysts as well as the broader investment community: the scale of the cash flow generation we're on the verge of delivering is enormous. I'm not exaggerating when I say that if you examine the 500 businesses comprising the S&P 500, only a small number—possibly not even one—managed to produce $5 billion in EBITDA within their first 10 years of operating; therefore, as a company we have a remarkable chance to generate a substantial quantity of cash flow, and we've achieved that mostly without bringing in outside capital, since it came from within. So when the rating agencies, the equity analysts, and investors evaluate our business, generating cash flow isn't the only consideration. What matters is whether you can accomplish it without seeking funds from others. That's a question we're able to answer with an emphatic yes. As I mentioned, we hold a considerable amount of cash on our balance sheet—which is true—and we anticipate producing considerably more. Naturally, the repeatability and the sustainability of that is what all 3 of those counterparties care about very deeply. That's the reason Andrew and others have devoted substantial time to examining the long-term characteristics, rather than only the near-term disruption, the market opportunities present there, and the surplus cash flow that will result—which we're confident will occur—but also the long term, carrying out what we initially intended: essentially delivering power and gas for power in a significant manner to communities globally that require it, which is simultaneously doing well by doing good. So clearly it's a very solid business for us over the long term. We're genuinely creating a meaningful impact in the communities we serve; so all of those factors go into it. Based on what I've seen with the agencies, this isn't a single event but rather a process; and it involves consistently delivering what you promised you would do. And when I think about how we've done since the day of our IPO through today, I'd say the record is pretty spotless—financially, we've usually hit what we told everyone we would, or come in well ahead of it; and I believe that gets factored in. Also, on the ratings side, these folks are typically followers rather than trendsetters—that's just how that business works—but over the long haul, we're quite hopeful about where we stand.
Greg Lewis
analystYes. Since we've hit the top of the hour, I'll keep it to 1 question. Wes, when we consider the rhythm around fast LNG — and I believe at this moment there are 7 MTPA on the board — obviously you folks see opportunity in the market, yet I keep returning to the larger picture. When we consider what gates how large your FLNG solution can become, should we think of it as eventually reaching a stage where we're serving our Caribbean projects, our Brazil projects and others — that is, are these units being built with an eye toward satisfying our demand for those projects as we foresee them later? Or are we going to be stuck in a situation where, for the long haul, you're basically always in some steady-state mode, selling gas on the open market outside of your own company's end markets?
Wesley Edens
executiveYeah, that's a really great question. And here's how I see it — although forecasting what happens down the road isn't something anyone can really do. When we first set the scale of our FLNG output, we did it to match the demand that was clearly visible to us in the markets we serve. That said, what we're supplying is just a slice of the genuine needs that exist in places like Mexico, Brazil, South Africa, or even Ireland. The potential gain from just putting up the infrastructure and keeping up organic expansion in those areas is enormous. The bigger-picture issue I mentioned before is figuring out what the post-transition landscape will be once everything wraps up; that's clearly something people will argue about rather than something with a settled conclusion, and lots of factors play into it. One point I'd make: when it comes to the downstream portfolio, it's clear this fits well alongside what we already do since it delivers duration. So whenever returns come up in conversation, duration deserves a mention too. Like many of you, I've been on the other side of the desk when someone tells me they can earn 15%, 20%, or some other return on an investment — I've heard that from a million people in my lifetime. The truth is that those who can achieve 20% returns over 25 years are Warren Buffett and only a handful of others, which shows how much duration matters. And the duration we gain from these long-term portfolios is worth a great deal. In fact, I believe it's significantly undervalued at present, both in terms of how large our earnings are and how completely durable they are. Another factor I believe people don't give enough credit to is how much latitude these multiyear agreements give you. What I'm getting at is that everyone, again and again, asks for less gas and electricity than they actually end up needing. Honestly, I'd call that just part of human nature. That pattern isn't limited to emerging markets at all. As I see it, the identical situation unfolded across Europe, once those countries came to realize they'd need very large supply quantities to meet their own demands. They came in with nominations that were too low, and their assumption was consistently that additional barrels could be purchased at the margin through spot transactions whenever the need arose. That incremental demand is precisely the kind that, under ordinary market conditions, simply turns into additional demand at an unchanged price. During an exceptional stretch, what it effectively does is let you hold surplus supply so you can subsequently capitalize on it in the marketplace. So that's a subtle distinction, yet an extremely, extremely important one. Still, we hold a deep conviction that pairing the upstream with the downstream supply — which represents the demand — those 2 elements combined are not merely solid business partners; they are in fact essential if you genuinely intend to run the business correctly. And the margins you produce under those circumstances look noticeably different. If you revisit and examine any of the remaining gas producers throughout the whole spectrum, they run excellent businesses, but there's one thing they typically do. They generate gas, then either transport it or, in the case of some, actually employ it across various installations. Nobody operates the way we operate. And I believe the economics behind it, along with the margins we produce, serve as proof of why that's such a worthwhile thing to weigh. So that's a lengthy response to your brief question, but I'm grateful for it. That was a really excellent one.
Patrick Hughes
executiveJake, since we've hit the top of the hour — this is Patrick speaking — we'd like to go ahead and wrap things up. I imagine there could still be additional questions out there. So please, anyone who hasn't had a chance to get their questions addressed, don't hesitate to contact me directly; and Jake, if you wouldn't mind bringing the call to a close, that would be wonderful.
Operator
operatorCertainly, everyone, that brings today's conference to a close. We appreciate your joining us, and you're welcome to disconnect at this point.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete New Fortress Energy Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to New Fortress Energy Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in New Fortress Energy Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.