Ninety One Group (N91) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
June 4, 2025
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Hendrik du Toit
executiveGood morning, everyone, and welcome to the presentation of our results. For the active asset management sector, the last 12 months proved difficult once again, and tougher still for firms offering active emerging market and international strategies, Ninety One among them. Still, I'm very pleased to say that our performance matched the expectations we laid out at the half year stage. Our second half was notably stronger, with positive net flows recorded and a boost from higher average assets under management. Investment performance was credible as well, and the overall picture now looks better than it did 12 months ago. Competition for new business stays fierce. Over the year, we've honed our focus and kept pursuing strategic clarity. That approach is beginning to pay off for Ninety One. Amid widespread industry uncertainty and negative sentiment, our business stayed calm and stable. In November last year we announced our transaction with Sanlam, and it has advanced well since then. Our people stay committed and motivated, and they are significant shareholders. We're working hard to develop our business into the active investment manager of the future. Assets under management rose 4% during the reporting period, reaching GBP 130.8 billion.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveEven with that rise, the last 12 months proved challenging. Net outflows totaled GBP 4.9 billion — far better than the GBP 9.4 billion recorded in the previous year — and following that, we reversed the flow trend across the latter six months of this reporting period. Basic earnings per share fell 7%, reaching 17.2p per share. Adjusted earnings per share dropped 3%, to 15.5p. That metric is the one we prefer for earnings. The full-year dividend is 1% lower, at 12.2p. Our adjusted operating profit margin landed at 31.2%. In spite of all the gloom out there, I want to remind shareholders that few businesses — very few indeed — match a well-run investment management firm when it comes to capital efficiency, margin richness and cash flow generation. Following the business review, Kim McFarland, our Finance Director, will walk through the financial results in greater detail. Allow me to summarise the key events and developments from the last 12 months. Stakeholders have given strong backing to the Sanlam transaction. Our clients grasp the rationale, and our shareholders have backed the share issuance, subject to regulatory approval. Across Ninety One, we have enabled and promoted AI adoption. You'll hear more about that near the close of the current financial year.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveWe’ve launched 2 offices in the Middle East and stepped up our activity across that region. That flow turnaround is now taking place within the areas where we focus. And just to remind everyone, those areas are global, international and emerging market equities, emerging market fixed income, including specialist credit and sustainability and impact strategies. As ever, we keep putting money into talent. We’ve elevated new leaders in 2 of our client groups, and we’ve brought in a few key investment professionals who could make a substantial difference in the years ahead. Ninety One is built to grow through the cycle, and difficult markets don’t pull us away from the long-term work of investing in our business. In November last year, as I mentioned, we announced the transaction with Sanlam, Africa’s largest nonbank financial services group. That raises assets under management by roughly GBP 17 billion. It also gives us preferred access to their distribution network. This doesn’t just add scale — it also makes Ninety One stronger in parts of the South African market where we are relatively underrepresented. Sanlam will additionally serve as an anchor investor in our international credit strategies. Needless to say, this arrangement explicitly — it will explicitly respect Sanlam’s fiduciary duty to its clients.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveThis makes our business stronger and helps our growth prospects. Whenever we report results, I like to remind everyone about our long-term track record. As you can see, this business was built carefully, patiently and organically over many years. We've formed deep and lasting relationships with our clients. Right now we're in the maelstrom of a fast-changing world. Back in 2019, we began using the tagline, Investing For a World of Change. We had little idea how much the world would truly change over the following 5 years. My sense is this will only speed up in the years ahead. While we pursue sustainable organic growth over the long term, the past shows we've often had periods of either asset stability or asset drawdown. We've always emerged stronger, and we intend to do exactly the same now. We're working hard to make Ninety One future fit. Our near-term objective is to define and build the active investment manager of the future. At its core, our business model hasn't changed and won't change; however, the tools, the efficiency and the effectiveness required will have to change. Our clients, the most sophisticated asset owners and intermediaries in the world, will demand nothing less.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveOur business model puts clients first, requires little capital, and centers on people. And at this point it isn't just technology-enabled — it increasingly has to be AI-enabled too. We're urging everyone across the firm to make use of the AI tools that are available so they can work with greater efficiency and effectiveness. Looking forward, we expect the pace of change to pick up even more. Put differently, we have to adjust to the new realities of a marketplace that is ever more competitive, along with the enormous strides in technology and, especially, AI. Our view is that the AI revolution's impact is going to be profound. If you'd like a sense of the opportunity and of what we're doing, please take a look at a recent presentation by Khadeeja Bassier, our Chief Operating Officer, titled Gutenberg to GPT, AI as the next frontier in Asset Management, which you can find on our website. AI represents a huge opportunity, yet it also carries significant risks. We are a differentiated global specialist, and we want to stay that way. We commit the firm to best-in-class active investing and client engagement. Our aim is to build Ninety One into a better and stronger company. To succeed in this business, being simply good enough won't cut it — you have to be better than that. Rather than chase fads to satisfy short-term growth demands from transient stakeholders, we build for the long term.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveAchieving better results demands relentless effort throughout our whole organization. That's the commitment we've made, and it's what will set us apart in the years ahead. Even though equity markets have climbed modestly, geopolitical tensions have stirred up volatility that has affected markets and how investors behave. Such shifts carry major consequences for the investment management industry and for society, and they introduce extra risks into financial markets. How regions perform has shifted substantially over the last year. The market has also widened out from the highly concentrated, U.S. tech-heavy conditions we saw in 2023. And as I noted before, the contest for client assets has grown extraordinarily fierce, while pressure on pricing persists. Even so, conditions like these ought to create opportunities for active investment management. As evidence, allow me to cite a remark from one of the world's foremost asset owners, the Managing Director of the KIA, his excellency, Shaikh Saoud Salem Abdulaziz AlSabah, who said not long ago that active investing is back. Growth in our assets under management recently came mostly from investment returns, since we kept seeing net outflows amounting to GBP 5.3 billion during the first half of the year. Over the second half, we reversed the trend and generated net inflows of slightly less than GBP 0.5 billion — GBP 0.4 billion.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveThe demand recovery picked up speed as we moved through the fourth quarter, which is encouraging, and that momentum has carried over into the new financial year. Net flows by asset class — here's how the flows break down by class. You can see things look somewhat better in the second half. Multi-asset saw outflows, driven by a structural shift toward specialist allocations in the South African market along with peer relative investment performance that wasn't compelling. We're working hard on addressing competitiveness in this area. Equity-only portfolios accounted for most of the net outflows, mainly from global and sustainable equities. Fixed income — largely emerging markets in the case of Ninety One — had outflows exceeding GBP 1.7 billion across the full year, despite good relative performance against peers and, importantly, against developed market fixed income benchmarks. Positive net flow in the South African fund platform and in alternatives accelerated during the second half. That reinforces our belief that we're on track when it comes to building new revenue streams with high growth potential. Now here's the flow picture by client group. Regardless of flow momentum, our priority is always meeting what our existing client base expects.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveA big chunk of the net outflow came from rebalancing away from equities and trimming emerging market exposure, not from clients ending their entire relationships. That point matters. For us, net outflows didn't mean we lost clients. Most of our client groups — though not every one — turned around the outflow momentum from the first half. The Asia Pacific, Europe and Africa client groups were positive in the second half. The United Kingdom has lately been a very tough market for active investment managers and hasn't yet turned the corner. Going forward, we have confidence in the rejuvenated leadership team and focus of our U.K. business. In the Americas, we've seen modest outflows throughout the year, but we're excited by a range of very real substantial opportunities in the pipeline. We have a strong team in the Americas and remain confident that this could become a much larger part of our business. Our core task is to meet the performance expectations of our clients in the medium to long term. Ninety One is proud of its long-term and recent track records. Firm-wide performance has improved over all periods when compared with the previous full financial year.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveCompared with twelve months ago, we are now better placed to expand the business. I'd like to commend the investment teams for how they steered through such treacherous markets. What this tells us is that Ninety One has investment offerings capable of competing effectively for client capital in the new financial year and beyond. Ours remains a people-centric, capital-light business. People and culture truly matter. We are building an intergenerational business, and we keep replenishing and strengthening our human capital. In our business, it goes without saying that pay has to be aligned with outcomes if we are to achieve business success. You've seen this year that we have shown discipline on that front and that our compensation is results related. Staff now hold just under 33% of Ninety One. That demonstrates commitment and alignment. I put the resilience of the past year down to our healthy and vibrant culture. I will now hand over to Kim McFarland, who will take you through the full year results. Kim?
Kim McFarland
executiveThanks, Hendrik. I'm pleased to walk you through yet another strong set of financial results covering the year that closed on 31 March 2025. I want to point out that our core operating business delivered solid results given how tough the environment has been. Worth noting: management fees and adjusted operating expenses each rose by 2%, which meant recurring results for the core business stayed flat versus the prior period at GBP 152.4 million. Management fees came in at GBP 567.1 million. That reflects average AUM rising from GBP 123.9 billion to GBP 129 billion, together with the average fee rate falling to 44 bps. Adjusted operating expenses of GBP 414.7 million take in the interest expense on lease liabilities for our office premises and the full bonus payments, while leaving out corporate-related professional fees. Adjusted operating profit of GBP 187.9 million sits just 1% below the prior year. Two items, each moving by 10%, explain that decline: lower performance fees of GBP 27.5 million and higher other income of GBP 8 million. Other income mostly combines operating interest with several fair value adjustments on seed investments, partly offset by FX losses caused by sterling strengthening against the U.S.
Kim McFarland
executiveThe adjusted operating profit margin fell to 31.2% from 32%. That compares favorably with the interims, when the adjusted operating profit margin we reported was 30.5%. Profit before tax at Ninety One — after taking into account adjusted net interest income, the small share scheme net credit and corporate-related professional fees — was down 6% to GBP 204.3 million. Bonus payments were fully expensed within adjusted operating expenses, no matter how they are settled. IFRS calls for amortization of the bonus-related share awards across 4 years, and that is what produced the share scheme net credit. The effective tax rate came in at 26.5% for the year, versus 24.4% a year earlier. That rise stemmed largely from nondeductible expenses and from the global minimum tax rules coming into force. Taken together, these factors give a profit after tax of GBP 150.1 million, 8% lower than last year. Adjusted EPS is down 3% at 15.5p, a bigger drop than the 1p decrease in adjusted operating profit, mainly because the effective tax rate on adjusted operating profit was higher. Turning to the analysis of the movement in adjusted operating expenses: they rose 2% to GBP 414.7 million.
Kim McFarland
executiveStaff costs make up 63% of the overall expense base. A year earlier the figure stood at 64%, and it rose slightly, by GBP 1.2 million, to GBP 261.3 million. The driver was growth in fixed pay, in line with more people on the payroll plus inflationary uplifts. More than 50% of staff costs stay variable, and the compensation ratio that came out of this was 43.4%, compared with 43.7% a year earlier. Business expenses were up 6%, reaching GBP 153.4 million. We've started examining where the cost changes came from, and at a broad level we've split the movements out like this: inflation-driven rises of GBP 2.2 million on those costs exposed to inflation. The FX-related effect was negligible. Technology spending has picked up by GBP 2.3 million, and that will carry on as we put money into our front office systems. Other cost increases came to GBP 3.5 million, mostly tied to higher business activity, specifically third-party administration costs. I'd point out that almost every cost category went up slightly during the year. Going forward, we expect inflation and the planned extra technology spend to affect business expenses. That remark leaves out the Sanlam cost effect, which will be mainly headcount driven, staff costs, and the general office cost increases that follow from them.
Kim McFarland
executiveEven so, we continue to expect that the Sanlam transaction will boost our operating profit margin. What you're seeing here is business expenses and total expenses expressed as a percentage of average AUM, in basis points, across a 6-year period. The adjusted operating profit margin for that period also appears at the top of this slide. Regardless of how AUM has moved, business expenses have risen slightly over the period, mainly because of the investments we've made in our core IT systems. Total expenses have actually come down, since we've stayed disciplined on employee remuneration. The adjusted operating profit margin has held within a 31% to 35% range, which reflects sensible cost management against fluctuating revenues. This next slide analyses the absolute movement in adjusted operating profit from FY '24 to FY '25. It makes clear that management fees went up, but that rise was largely offset by higher business expenses — principally technology — and, to a lesser extent, by higher employee remuneration. And here is the capital position as at 31 March 2025. Ninety One's qualifying capital stood at GBP 327.3 million at the end of March 2025. Consistent with our dividend policy, the Board has recommended a final dividend of 6.8p, bringing the full year dividend to 12.2p per share — a decline of 1%, matching the fall in adjusted operating profit.
Kim McFarland
executiveOnce this dividend is paid, we estimate a capital surplus of GBP 160.9 million, which gives us capital coverage of 253%. We kept running our buyback programs during the period. That gave back GBP 17.1 million of capital and cut 10.6 million shares. At last night's close, we had returned an additional GBP 19.1 million of capital, bringing the closing share count to 883.3 million. Since we listed 5 years ago, in keeping with our capital-light model, over 50% of our initial market capitalization has gone back to shareholders. A few points on the Sanlam transaction. The parties signed the related operative agreements on the 6th of March. Then on the 9th of April, shareholders approved the share issue for the consideration almost unanimously. The Sanlam transaction is set to complete in 2 tranches. We expect the U.K. transaction to close mid-June, and the South African transaction by the end of the calendar year, once all required regulatory approvals are in hand. Accordingly, Ninety One is expected to issue roughly 13.7 million shares in June for the U.K. transaction, with the remaining 112 million shares issued later in the year for the SA transaction.
Kim McFarland
executiveSo, because of the large quantity of shares we issued to Sanlam, when it comes to next year's results, we're expecting to adjust the share count used for calculating adjusted EPS by weighting the shares issued to Sanlam. That's a one-time calculation adjustment relating solely to the Sanlam transaction. Thanks. I'll hand you back to Hendrik now.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveThanks, Kim. To wrap up, we put in a lot of effort to get our momentum back during the second half. From the start of 2025, we've seen improved business conditions, better investment performance and a stronger pipeline. Our footprint will be reinforced by the Sanlam transaction, and it will support growth over the long term. We'll keep doubling down on the areas where we specialize. In a competitive world like this one, focus is absolutely essential. We're relentlessly working to build a better business, modernizing and innovating it. That motivates good people, and good people are key to success in the future. Looking ahead, we're planning for more macroeconomic uncertainty against -- and rapid technological change. The good news is that demand appears to be shifting toward what we offer, and we are indeed seeing a growing set of business opportunities. Our focus is on clients and investment performance. Technology and AI will help drive efficiency and effectiveness while we keep investing for growth. Where few do, we see an opportunity for active investment management in the years ahead, and we'll pursue that with vigor. Thank you very much. We can turn now to Q&A, and let's start with those in the room before those online. And Hubert Lam's hand is up before he even got the mic.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveThis is from Bank of America.
Hubert Lam
analystHubert Lam here from Bank of America, with 3 questions. First one, on flows: it's encouraging to see the second half come in slightly positive. Would you say we've now turned the corner? And how much of that betterment comes from — I suppose it may still be early days — a rotation, possibly out of the U.S., into more international EM products? Perhaps you could discuss the trends on that front.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveI think, Hubert, we're seeing 2 trends here. First, existing clients are showing interest as they consider reweighting their portfolios, so using active long-only equities as the banker for private commitments appears to be slowing, and that means the rebalance isn't being driven by performance the way it was in the past — instead, it's someone saying, look, I actually appreciate some liquidity, so I go back to my trusted suppliers and I weight up. That's part of it. The other part is there's definite interest in the emerging market complex. It's still difficult, because it depends on what day of the week it is and which White House press conference came last before you're talking, but the structural research work and investigation and the busyness — I mean, today, even in the office there, if you're allowed upstairs, you'll see some clients you probably recognize. But they're not bringing money; they're coming to look, and that has definitely lifted the engagement and the interest. Long-only investment management was a very lonely place 18 months ago, I can tell you. It feels less lonely, but it's not clear what part of that is simply a rebalancing and what is a structural growth.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveHere's what I'd point you back to: just run the basic arithmetic. Roughly 70% of the world's mobilized money sits in the U.S. Should asset owners outside the U.S. trim their weighting even a little, the effect on that smaller slice is twice what it is on the bigger one. So the impact could be quite meaningful. Second, there's the dollar's opening up — something I mentioned last year and that now looks like White House policy; regardless of the rhetoric, it does appear to be policy. And the rest of the world seems to welcome it. What that implies is a shift in weight toward revenue streams. True, U.S. public equities also draw close to half their revenue from non-dollar sources, but the reweighting is toward something different, and the euro has benefited. Last, what could happen at the margin — and this has been very, very much working against us — is that fixed income diversification may start to look more attractive. You've seen local currencies perform well. You've seen emerging market debt hold up quite solidly despite tariff worries. At some point that becomes compelling, though not yet. So those are roughly the 3 waves. I'm hoping at the half-year mark to come back with something more concrete.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveWhat we're really saying is that interest has picked up and some reweighting is underway. Some flows are in the pipeline, and our performance happens to be reasonably competitive, but we're not at boom time yet. So let's not go out and celebrate. That time hasn't arrived.
Hubert Lam
analystThe next question concerns operating margin. I understand it landed at 31.2%, while the range is 31% to 35%. Is 31% the floor? I realize this is prior to the...
Hendrik du Toit
executiveWe aren't aiming for a specific operating margin. What we do understand is that you — because of volatility in the markets and in the revenue stream — have to maintain some cushion, though you can't operate as leanly as a business whose revenues are contractual. But I'm not sure — Kim, would you like to add anything?
Kim McFarland
executiveYeah, I believe that’s accurate. And it seems like every single year we get the same question at this point about whether we sort of set a floor or a target. No, but we have enough levers in the business to try to keep it within that kind of range, which is what you’ve seen in the past. So it’s a comfortable position for us to be sitting in.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveAnd we're getting to a stage where tech used to be just costly. It's now benefiting you on certain fronts, and you have to be able to halt structural cost inflation, but we don't aim for a particular margin. And a few of our competitors are quite at ease in the late 20s and appear to be pretty content there. We just -- that's where we are.
Hubert Lam
analystAnd our last question concerns the Sanlam deal. Could you perhaps tell us a bit about how clients have reacted to it, on both the Sanlam side and the Ninety One side?
Hendrik du Toit
executiveI mean, once again, the realities of competition and of the Competition Commission prevent us from addressing the third-party client base directly. So we haven't had any interaction there. But what we're picking up in the market is that our client base, at least, has grasped the rationale and recognizes this wasn't a crowding out of what they were receiving. As a matter of fact, it's complementary, and so they now have a stronger provider that is more resilient and more robust. And as for the relationship with the Sanlam people — ultimately, whatever the bosses commit to us, the people on the ground are the ones who have to deliver. That relationship we've been building is in a very good space, and the contractual negotiator is Jonathan Shaw, who did most of — a great deal of the work. That's finished and settled. So you don't have this notion of, okay, I'm still negotiating things and there's bitterness and all of that. We're very clear. There's a joint project to serve a new set of savers, which Ninety One can serve really well on behalf of an organization that accumulates those savers, Sanlam. So that is working well. We'll have to see where we get to, but our indications are — and again, many of those clients have other touch points with us — that it is perceived to be positive.
Hendrik du Toit
executivePlus, the truth is we’ll be adding some more investment talent to our operation as well — and you know how it goes when you’ve got a good football? Which football team do you support? Do you have one, or are you...
Hubert Lam
analystNope.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveOh, no. Now it's common. Sorry — I owe the rest of the audience an apology. But you know how it works on a football team: bring in players from other clubs who might not cost as much or carry as much prestige, and once they're playing for the new side, they turn into the star. So we believe we'll be able to tap some outstanding talent, and in this new setup that talent will be unleashed and perform really well. That leaves us quite optimistic over the longer term. And I want to be very clear when you build your models: don't get too carried away over the first 1 or 2 years. This is a relationship of 15 years plus. The payoff will grow larger and larger further out if we execute well — exactly as happens with all our other major distribution partnerships, which we have across the world and in South Africa. Another question? You usually ask 3.
Kim McFarland
executiveHis question was the third one.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveOh, it's 3, isn't it? My apologies. David? David, you nailed the earnings.
David McCann
analystDavid McCann with Deutsche Bank here. I have three questions, if that works too. Let's pick up on flows. You mentioned a few of the product shifts that occurred, but judging by geographic location, Asia Pacific seems to have been the major swing factor in the second half compared with the first. Is there anything more you could share on that — what's behind the greater flow coming from that region? That's question one.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveI mean, first of all, regardless of what they're saying at the White House, the world's economic center of gravity is gradually moving East, and that's been happening year after year. So institutional weight is increasing over there, since savings pools are expanding. And we have an installed base of clients, and some of them began upweighting earlier. That's really what it was. It's an upweighting. It's not a change in the business or anything very different. These are very large clients who were probably early-ish in the up-weighting process. And based on good past performance and service delivery, I think that's what we got. The excitement I relayed about our 2 new offices in the Middle East and what we want to do there that's slightly innovative and different, that hasn't shown up in the top line yet. That's actually been a cost up to now. And Neil is looking at me here from the finance side. That's been a cost, not a cheap place to operate. But we are excited about that, which is later. This was sort of existing client base upweighting on the basis of their views on investment markets.
David McCann
analystMoving on to the fee rate. Clearly, it came down roughly 1 basis point across the year. The exit rate appeared to be closer to 43 bps during the second half. So a decline exists there relative to the first. So perhaps you could discuss what is behind that? Is it mix? Is it another factor? Is it — does it relate to the flows somehow?
Hendrik du Toit
executiveNo — it’s not about upweighting jumbo clients. Put differently, small accounts — if you bring in retail business and the fee is identical, that’s one thing, but when very large clients with strong relationships — clients that genuinely carry very high margins, high profit margins — return at lower fees, you do get some pressure. So take the Americas, a jurisdiction with higher fees; I’m not sure how they manage it. They hold the largest assets and charge the largest fees. Yet if the Americas begin to accelerate, you’ll build up business at higher fees. Then, if you capture business in Europe, where nobody is willing to pay much of a fee, that contributes less — it places pressure on your fee margin. So that’s approximately — and Kim, tell me if I’ve got this wrong. No clearly identifiable asset class effect has shown up in this kind of margin.
Kim McFarland
executiveNo, I think there are two other factors at play. One is large clients coming on board. We've observed quite a bit of activity on the South African platform business in particular. And that ties directly into why several of our business expenses went up — which I noted earlier relates to extra third-party administration, since a great deal of that cost is activity based. We've...
Hendrik du Toit
executiveHowever, that pertains to expenses as well, and that also...
Kim McFarland
executiveNo, no—it ties back to the fee as well. There are 2 points I'm connecting here. First, we have observed a decline. Part of that effect relates to greater activity in that area and the business that has arrived there. The second thing, which Hendrik brought up, involves sizable new inflows coming through. And then there are the places where we incurred losses. A number of those carried higher fees too. So it's essentially the outflow on certain—on the out book too. You could nearly assign almost 1/3, 1/3, 1/3 to every one of those kinds of categories, from our perspective.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveBut that's quite hard to model and to know, because unlike another option, where book churn isn't so significant in a traditional long firm, a very large share of the churn in the book comes sort of from client demand rather than from factors within our control or that we drive. So I'd say we remain at roughly the same level. But looking forward, what's going on in the market is a narrowing — 10 years ago, clients wanted to purchase the best, fees were the fees, and they were negotiated slightly. Now you're shifting into a market driven by relationships, where large distributors or large asset owners say, okay, I want to work with you, 4 or 5 asset managers, but I'll be loyal, I need a package. And it turns — it could lead to better business for us, that is, business that's more stable with a higher operating margin, though not necessarily business with higher fees, because for that loyalty, for that long-termism, there's a quid pro quo. And I think that's becoming fairly prevalent in certain — particularly in the U.K. If we begin winning in the U.K. as we believe we will, you'll see us building a book of higher quality that's more focused, but that carries a certain commercial sting in the tail.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveThis isn't about slashing fees just to win a mandate. It's a structure. And I think over the past 10 years that has definitely shifted in our industry, which really ought to raise the quality of your business. So don't just stare at the headline fee — examine the quality of the book and who the people actually deal with. That's how we approach the calculation. So at Ninety One, any pricing decision that falls outside the advertised pricing range has to be signed off by a pricing committee. It isn't made by client-facing people who simply want to generate volume. And that's the reason we've defended our fee better than others have. We're very deliberate about it, but we're also realistic about where the market is heading.
David McCann
analystOkay, and then the third item is just regarding that other income line. Clearly, that item is volatile at all times. You mentioned in the latter half that there were some FX gains and a few seed benefits. There have obviously been plenty of shifts in those lines since March ended, I'd guess. So as things stand right now, how would that figure appear for the 2 months so far?
Hendrik du Toit
executiveWe can let him know — but smile, always keep smiling.
Kim McFarland
executiveYeah, we can share that with you — precisely. Honestly, putting a forecast on that figure is tough for me, since, like you mentioned, it combines valuations at different points in time. If I were to build a model for it, it would likely come out at a lower number.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveEven so, she tends toward pessimism.
David McCann
analystIs that a smaller positive figure?
Hendrik du Toit
executiveYes, though she is a pessimist.
Kim McFarland
executiveA somewhat lower positive figure.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveDavid, she's a pessimist. All right. So — the answer is that there's no major impact.
Kim McFarland
executiveYes.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveThere wasn't any significant impact.
Kim McFarland
executiveIt's not a big impact, but I've always found it's the toughest piece to model — that one, plus the share scheme credit, which is the other item that's hard to model, though that sits as a below-the-line adjustment.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveRahim, since you're sitting in the first row, you'll be the first one to receive an answer.
Rahim Karim
analystRahim Karim from Investec here. I have 3 questions too, if I may. Hendrik, if I caught what you said correctly, you mentioned a robust pipeline in the Americas, or one that was building. So perhaps I could ask you to elaborate on that a little. Are we seeing that investment you've put in over a number of years start to pay off?
Hendrik du Toit
executiveThe investment generates cash, correct? So in contrast to any tech company, where you can lose money for 10 years and still get a sky-high multiple from you folks — in this business, we aim to turn cash generative as quickly as we can, and from there grow modestly within our means instead of pouring tons of money into it. What has happened in that business is this: a year ago we placed one of our best leaders there, someone with a proven business track record. And what I'm very confident about is that the business is well focused on the right client base, and that client base is asking questions about our areas of expertise, which is international and emerging markets. I've been preaching about it for roughly 3 years, saying we're not going to change. We're going to stick to it. And I mean, an example: our international — our quality investment capability is one of our strong capabilities. We seeded and built an international franchise strategy from nothing. I think we started 7 years ago, the PM joined us. It's now got 5-year track record. It's well through the GBP 1 billion. Now suddenly, it can compete.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveA small strategy in the U.S. really couldn’t compete—people just don’t look at it. They want—so that homework has been done. If that starts happening and we know where to go, you still have to win the finals. I mean, in the last quarter, 6 months, we’ve lost a few where we got right to the final and then you get punched on the nose by a giant like PIMCO or someone, and you just have to take it and play again, but you don’t win them all. But if your win rate starts increasing and you can get to the opportunity—all I’ve told you is we have—we can see opportunity and we are going for it, we now have to convert. There is a gap between the 2, and you can play really well and still not convert enough. But what I see—and our market is—our client base is very, very focused. So we know exactly who they are. We spent the time, you know them better, which means your chance—my experience is in the second or third finals you typically win.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveThe way it works is you show up one time, they size you up, you perform well, and then they stick you in the cooler box and ask, how are they going to perform, how are they doing? And when somebody who won the first time falters, that's when you get in. And I think we're getting closer to that point. So -- and half year would probably be a better stage, the evidence would be there or not. The team tells me they're excited. They had an offsite, but whether that's just because the offsite was good, I don't know.
Rahim Karim
analystWhich offsite is bad, I mean...
Hendrik du Toit
executiveThe Americans.
Rahim Karim
analystThe second question was simply about capital surplus, which clearly rose compared with a year earlier even though part of the buyback has sort of been executed. Could you maybe take us through how you're thinking about that level near term while the Sanlam transaction wraps up and closes, and whether you're comfortable with it staying at 200% over the medium term, and whether we ought to anticipate further buybacks during the coming year?
Hendrik du Toit
executiveBefore Kim responds, I just want to mention one point that I find quite exciting: the Sanlam U.K. leg is completing in June. We've already repurchased more than those shares, all right? So the SA one is clearly larger now. But when you work this out factoring in the dilution of the shares — though the dilution has disappeared at a certain point — the accretion, of course, goes up. That said, that's a conceptual way of looking at it. Kim will give you...
Kim McFarland
executiveI believe Hendrik has likely covered half of that question already. You gave a pretty extensive answer, so — no, it really is a key point. So yes, our position is that we'll keep — as I mentioned at the start — well, actually during my remarks, we intend to stay capital light. So what does that mean in practice? We have a dividend policy that's clear. I think we've been transparent about how we return money. We distribute dividends to the market. That's generally at roughly the 80% level against our post-tax adjusted operating profit. Whatever remains, we review continuously with the Board, and that gets used for buybacks. I think some attractive market opportunities are emerging — looking at results over the past couple of months, when the price was clearly low, so we — I think we performed quite well with the buyback programs we've been running. And we'll keep going — so the thinking is to maintain it at approximately the 200%. We have a few — out of that, I need to set funds aside for some capital investments across a number of areas, which we will target as well. Beyond that, we'll keep it at roughly the 200% and aim to carry on doing buybacks in the market.
Kim McFarland
executiveWill buybacks keep happening in the market? Yes, assuming everything else stays the same.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveYes. And I think, looking at it from both a capital standpoint and a cost line standpoint, we believe that if the market begins to adjust away from the very negative regime we've experienced over the past few years, there's a kind of once-off opportunity. If you fail to get into the action, you're going to be frozen out until the next cycle. So our posture has shifted from — and that's probably — if you're a near-term earnings forecast, so you might be getting very worried and sell a share today, but it depends. Our posture has shifted from being quite defensive, making sure we survive to now going after the opportunities, which means if the decision is, do we make the investment, in other words, do we hire the person or do we invest behind an initiative, we will rather than not because the cost of not capturing the shift that we think is in the offering could be massive if you're too conservative. So again, that will be a half year conversation. We'll have a feel whether it's a real shift or whether we've just been fatigued by 3.5 hard years and I see a little bit of growth, which overexcites us.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveWe can't say for sure, but we would—and that's the reason Kim responds to it rather cautiously, since if a gap appears, we'll likely pursue it. Business has been scarce. Should it arrive, and should new relationships exist and they request commitments, we'll likely make those commitments. But we won't move, and that point really matters. We won't move away from our focus areas. Within our focus areas, we will innovate very aggressively, and in adjacent spaces too, but we won't move away from our core skilled areas, where we're building long-term—call them 100-year—franchises that will grow stronger and stronger and stronger over time, far beyond the horizons of the people sitting in this room. I think that's the part where you have to balance that focus. But the level of what I'd call entrepreneurial vigor is going to rise, because if we simply sit and defend for the next year, we'll likely miss an opportunity of a lifetime.
Rahim Karim
analystAnd last thing, regarding Sanlam, is there any chance for you to speed up distribution or the private credit ventures before the SA deal closes? Or are those sort of...
Hendrik du Toit
executiveWe need to be — I mean, Sanlam has been our client for quite a while. So there's a solid commercial channel where we generated more than $1 billion for them prior to them approaching us about this deal. That's still going, and it remains open. But what we can't do is put the transaction at risk through any sort of pre-implementation, because competition authorities get quite upset about pre-implementing, and we recognize that we're able to prepare. Still, I think we've got some solid things to offer — not just to them but to our other clients as well, which we'll be rolling out. And — but there are others too. I mean, they aren't the sole partner we work with. They aren't the only one. So if your question is whether we're pushing hard on our emerging market and sustainable private credit platforms and our smaller yet very exciting European specialist credit — yes, we are. Angeliki?
Angeliki Bairaktari
analystAngeliki Bairaktari here, from JPMorgan. I have three questions too. First, returning to flows for the quarter to date: looking at industry data, April was clearly a highly turbulent month, with outflows across most active strategies. May has been somewhat more encouraging — in EM especially, we saw inflows for the first time in quite a while. So I wanted to ask whether you could take us through it, since I'm finding it a bit hard to square the improved business momentum with what April showed us.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveSo Angeliki, first off, our — we don't — I realize that you, David, and others build your models on data that's publicly available. Since we're not a South African retail operation outside of that market, what we do is at times shaped by conversations and timing with individual clients, and a few of those take a great deal of time. We ought to have closed that business last year, and it's still in progress, but they have their own processes. As a result, sometimes we don't appear exactly like a business that's mainly funds-driven. We've had — actually, the seasonality you mention isn't something we've had. What we've observed is steady interest, probably from the fourth quarter of the financial year onward — say, right after the half year results presentation, the discussions began, and the direction has been positive. There's invariably a summer slowdown with our large clients. So by June and July we might be feeling rather pleased with ourselves, and then August arrives and it goes quiet. So we aren't 100% certain, but the Southern Hemisphere usually counterbalances that — places such as Australia, South Africa, and Latin America. So interest has risen consistently, but that's mostly tied to the asset pools we run or put money into, not to the market overall.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveThe other thing I was hearing about — and again, if you're one of those large U.S. fixed income giants, every one of them has been losing money on bonds and simply pulling in more capital because yields are higher now. That's just been the game. At some point that game is — we aren't taking part in that game. We haven't yet witnessed the upside of that game ending. So there are enormous pools of liquidity parked somewhere else right now that will begin flowing in the opposite direction, and that definitely has not happened. That's when you'll see consistency in your retail funds, et cetera, whether ETFs or equities, with these risk assets getting snapped up. We aren't there yet. And I think the uncertainty created by Liberation Day, et cetera, has definitely pushed that back. If you spoke to us in — if we'd done this presentation in March, I'd probably have been structurally more optimistic. I'm not less optimistic now because I think ultimately, what's happening is undermining U.S. dominance. But over the short term, it creates uncertainty, which then sends people back to kind of a nice, safe — what they believe is a safe bond fund.
Angeliki Bairaktari
analystAnd one more thing on the adviser side — we saw larger outflows there this year compared with institutional. So...
Hendrik du Toit
executiveI'd actually like to drop that classification, because in our adviser segment we have some really big financial platforms, simply due to the fact that they're served by what we used to call our adviser team. Outside of South Africa, we don't really have that split in any meaningful way. In South Africa, you've got a deeper adviser business that's driven off a funds platform, and that runs on somewhat different logic — more distribution logic than alpha logic, since it's built on deep relationships with people who treat you as an admin back office and, because of that, also use your funds when they're not necessarily choosing the best. They do pick us for the best too, but — so it's a different kind of setup. What we've seen here is a handful of large financial institutions or fund platforms that have changed strategy or downweighted something. Take a U.S. warehouse, for instance. It gets a new CIO, and that changes what it does. It doesn't actually fire you, but it downweights product Y, and you benefit a lot from that product because you're a component in selling product X now, which you're not necessarily part of. They're busy. What are they doing in the U.S.?
Hendrik du Toit
executiveNow? Democratizing private markets — that's wonderful. It's about finding liquidity for assets you otherwise couldn't sell. But regardless, that process now demands a lot of attention. It doesn't require the attention of the main one. So I'm just giving an example here. This isn't what happened. But at some big financial institutions, there were fairly large shifts. So I would almost view it as institutional. If you're modeling us, you should actually look at us as an 80%-plus insti business, or 85%. So don't spend time on the adviser-institutional split, because, by the way, the fees are roughly the same, again, except where we are properly represented in a middle market adviser business, which is different.
Angeliki Bairaktari
analystOn my final question about partnerships, more generally following the Sanlam partnership, would you be open to doing more of that kind of thing? Across the asset management industry, we're observing a consolidation trend. You clearly have scale, though you aren't the biggest player in the market. And in active, more and more partners are appearing. So...
Hendrik du Toit
executiveHere's where we won't play: it isn't that we doubt the success of that approach — it's hugely successful — but we won't adopt an Amundi-style model in which you essentially purchase your flows for the coming years via a tightly structured transaction, since that's a different business. Ours is built on relationships with chosen distributors where we believe we can bring something to the table and they, in turn, can speed up our growth or lend the book more stability. Take the Sanlam case: the upside sat in South Africa, and we had hit the ceiling of the channels we — well, not the ceiling, but we were filling up the channels where we excel. This one was a retail channel. We work with a number of distribution partners — others are present there too, in fact — but this was a specific one, and access to the insurance book in particular was appealing to us. On top of that, this client approached us, and it was a client with whom we shared a strong cultural fit. I believe we'll see, in our credit business in other parts of the world, potentially more asset owners who are genuinely aligned with what we do and would be ready to move faster because they have a need to expose.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveBut would we go out and do a whole lot of deals like that? No, because we are still — we're an alpha house. We compete on Alpha. That's where our main focus is. But stability of book and acceleration of growth opportunities are the 2 things we search for. And we have many partners around the world. And in fact, we have many conversations with partners. But what we won't want to do, and again, where you sit as an analyst is a buyer, in other words, an issuer of shares at the top to acquire growth. We want to earn growth, which means we'll partner with someone, build something up from the bottom up rather than buy an existing book of someone who is exiting a business. The Sanlam is different because it was in a market where we could very easily absorb that and where true scale benefits would accrue to us, which in the rest of the world is probably not the case. But I don't know, Kim, would you like to add to that?
Kim McFarland
executiveYes, I would 100% back the point you just made.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveBut we're quite willing to enter partnership arrangements with firms that would rather not hire directly the types of skilled professionals we do in order to meet their investment goals or serve their clients — we're very open to that. And in fact, that's becoming a growing piece of — I mean, take a look at the KKR-Capital transaction that happened recently. KKR lacked the advisers in the U.S.; Capital had them. Capital had no interest in building private markets on its own. They're a fantastic, excellent public markets business with 3 trillion under management, and they struck a deal. I believe you'll be seeing a great deal more of that kind of thinking across our industry. Sorry, I didn't catch your name...
Jonas Døhlen
analystJonas.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveJonas, when you first came up and introduced yourself to me, I...
Jonas Døhlen
analystJonas Døhlen at Deutsche Bank here. I've got two quick questions. First, a follow-up about the regulatory capital requirement. Could you explain the reason it has dropped by GBP 7 million — that regulatory capital requirement?
Kim McFarland
executiveOn the regulatory side, those requirements have mostly come from taking an internal look at the business — that was from an analysis we ran ourselves. It isn't tied to any one particular item; it was really about reviewing our risk position and our risk appetite internally. Then, on the effective tax rate, that has risen a bit. Could you walk through what's driving that, and whether that's a good rate to use as a base going forward? Two factors are behind it. One relates to the fact that we had certain expenses that aren't deductible for tax purposes, and those are the ones reflected below the line, as you can see. The second is the minimum tax rules that came in. So what you're seeing come through is more of a permanent adjustment. Basically, you can see what was nondeductible from what's below the line — that will be your corporate expenses — and the minimum tax rule is now going to be baked in.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveYou all ought to go lobby to make investment bankers tax deductible once more. But I believe there's a key point here: the tax one — government has returned to our world. And government has returned to every business. And if you happen to be an OMS manufacturer, you'd say wonderful, since governments are your clients. I believe our industry genuinely must accept the fact that government is now a key player in markets. And not just from a regulatory standpoint — they're beginning to act as venture capitalists, they're beginning to act as capitalists. And it's so ironic that you hear folks pointing fingers at China, saying government is involved. Well, the U.S. government is involved in nearly everything today. The U.K. government — Boris Johnson launched the entire venture capital business, which now owns steel. Government has returned, everywhere. And that renders our business more complicated, because rules are regionalizing rather than globalizing. So the simple notion of scale, which brings me back to the Middle East business we want to do, is that we would like to find another place where we can intermediate a domestic flow of capital or a regional flow of capital, right? Because then, you know, you operate within certainty, you operate in a context which works.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveSo, if you could, like, you guys — why are you doing well? Because you're in Europe, Deutsche, because you're in an environment that's okay. But as soon as you cross those big boundaries, you begin dealing with very divergent issues and challenges. And I think for our industry, it's not a net positive for us going forward, because we have to be attuned to that. And so government is back, taxes are going to be higher in time. They're not going to be lower. Yes, get used to that. Varuni. Online?
Varuni Dharma
executiveWe've got a few questions coming in online. The first comes from James Slabbert at SBG Securities. On the Sanlam transaction, you said there are South African markets where you were underrepresented. Could you give us a bit more detail on what those markets would look like once the transaction is done?
Hendrik du Toit
executiveYes, James, that's a good question. You'd have noticed that the figure we provided for additional assets under management was roughly the same as before, and markets have moved around a lot since the announcement. And we're feeling quite confident. We haven't disclosed the exact figure since we're not yet at the transaction completion date. But the key point is that those portfolios contain a large fixed income component. We've been a decent fixed income player, but there were segments of the fixed income market — and for those of you unfamiliar with South Africa, it's a highly sophisticated institutional market. In terms of financial sophistication, it's almost like a small Australia. And there's a very strong fixed income component. In many of those niches, we haven't been playing — or we haven't been leading the frame. We have a good fixed income business, but in somewhat adjacent spaces. So that's what I mean by that. It's not directly on top, but it gives us access to new opportunities in a market where we've been playing, just not in exactly the same way. And the people who possess the skills are coming along with us. So that's an example that covers probably, I don't know, John — Chris, 2/3 of the book, a big part of the book.
Varuni Dharma
executiveNext up, we have questions from Jaimé Gomes at Laurium Capital. You've already addressed a few of these, but I'll go ahead and read them out regardless, in case there's anything more you'd like to add. First, how big would you estimate the market that the Sanlam retail distribution network serves to be? And second, please, could you give us some detail on how much the Sanlam deal will shift your asset mix?
Hendrik du Toit
executiveI'd lean toward the second one. We've kind of already addressed that it's becoming a bit less equity heavy. On the first point, though, for us it genuinely isn't only about the book. The thing is, South Africa isn't getting wealthier per capita. The economy has been flat for quite a while, yet this is a very well intermediated business, and people are putting money aside for themselves through saving. It's an economy with a high degree of financialization. What that means is the markets Sanlam mostly serves, along with some of our other large insurance and other clients — and we have quite a few of those — those markets are expanding because people are actually on the move. Corporate provision has shrunk. Formal employment has shrunk, but people are saving, whether through policies or other vehicles, and there are some meaningful cash flows in there, though those clients are of a size and of a nature that we don't typically reach. Via the insurance products and the savings products and, in this instance, what Africa's largest nonfinancial or nonbank financial institution is offering, flows will arrive that will need to be deployed per specification. So we end up with access to a pool of flows that is in fact growing. If you look at their results, or at any of the financial firms such as Capitec and the big banks, you'll notice a great deal of money in motion.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveAnd that’s the thing—it’s what will let us reach that, which normally, as a firm that’s mainly institutional or an upper-end wealth manager and IFA-facing firm, we wouldn’t have been able to reach. And a big share of that is fixed income. A big share is—or some share is equities, but it isn’t in—it doesn’t come to them the same way it would to, say, a sophisticated wealth manager. It comes to them in a different way.
Varuni Dharma
executiveJan Meintjes from Denker Capital has the next 2 questions. First, when employees are purchasing additional shares and the company is also doing buybacks, how do you handle the conflict between those two?
Hendrik du Toit
executiveJan, there's no conflict, in the sense that we — corporate simply does what it needs to do. A market exists. Our rules are very clear, our processes are very segregated, our decision-making is very segregated, and it's carried out on a decentralized basis. Is that correct, Kim?
Kim McFarland
executiveYeah. I'd say you're right about that. It is completely kept apart. It's handled via separate channels. Right, so there are quite explicit guidelines in place to address exactly that issue, since that issue matters.
Varuni Dharma
executiveAnd Jan's second question is this: with the share price where it is, is there pressure on the funding vehicle for the staff shareholding? And does that pose any risk to the business?
Hendrik du Toit
executiveTake a look at your screen.
Kim McFarland
executiveIn brief, the answer is no.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveNo, no — we're quite conservative folks. So we kind of budgeted as if preparing for the second world war, and that hasn't come about so far. The third one hasn't come about either. But no, the funding is done in a pretty conservative way.
Varuni Dharma
executiveWe have one more question that just came in from James Slabbert at SBG Securities. His question is whether you can offer any commentary on what you see over the medium term for savings and investments in South Africa. Some of your competitors have said this does not look terribly hopeful and so should keep contributing to outflows for them. Do you agree with this?
Hendrik du Toit
executiveJames, I think you're right about certain segments of the market, and the competitors are right too. That said, we see enormous opportunities there to serve it in a different and more suitable way. So I've raised the point about flows shifting into discretionary savings or the insurance space, away from pensions. On top of that, there's a tremendous amount of liquidity sitting in fixed interest and money deposits, and in my view those pools aren't taking enough risk to meet the long-term liabilities of those wealth owners, whoever they may be. If we can evolve how we deliver this so that — and I'm not fond of the term financial inclusion, because it often means lending to the poor at a high rate — but if you can financially include the poor in effective savings, there's a vast amount of liquidity in that market that our industry hasn't yet tapped. We're thinking about this very clearly and asking how we can serve those investors better. And it has been a very stable pool. Even though it hasn't been a growing pool, it's been a pretty stable pool. And in a world — and James, you haven't operated in the rest of the world trying to offer people things like emerging markets — it's been a port in a storm for us.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveFrom our perspective, South Africa isn’t a high-growth bet — it’s a stable one. And if we innovate quickly enough, we’ll be able to reach enough, relative to our size, to give our business a modest but genuine growth path going forward. That’s why it matters. And on top of that, we can then take some of those ideas into other markets. So once you — once you grasp how to serve particular channels and particular institutions, that skill can be carried over. So for Ninety One, which is mainly a non-African business, this is genuinely interesting. If you were 100% stuck there, I think we’d also have a fairly negative story on a results statement, because we wouldn’t know where to go. We actually did that groundwork 20 years ago, and we positioned ourselves. But it is a very interesting market. And I think the way we’re set up today is a positive rather than a negative. And in a market like that, when you — if you can properly capture the advantages of leadership, you also capture the advantages of attracting talent, et cetera, and then you build and — and in this industry, there are very few moats and they’re very shallow, but you can build something resembling a trench.
Hendrik du Toit
executiveThat, in turn, will create value for the business. Yet the key factor is the South African economy, and the situation is identical in Europe, but in any place where the economy must expand, wealth pools will subsequently grow and the range of opportunities will widen. And should that fail to occur, it is a hard blow. Thank you. Many thanks, ladies and gentlemen. We hope that a few of these developments come about. We appreciate the time you have given us, and we will see you in November. Thank you.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Ninety One Group transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Ninety One Group earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Ninety One Group or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.