Panoro Energy ASA (PEN) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
May 28, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
John Hamilton
executiveGood morning, everyone, and welcome to today's Panoro Energy Q1 2020 Results Presentation or Webinar. This is John Hamilton, Chief Executive Officer of Panoro Energy ASA. We're all getting quite used to webinars now, so today we're trying something new. I hope it works. With our previous provider, there was a 30-second delay. So we're trying this GoToWebinar product and hopefully it works for everybody. If anybody thinks otherwise, please drop us an email, and if I could have the next slide, please. Before we get started, I'd like to quickly go over a few items we anticipate in today's call. Your screen should look a little bit like this when you're looking at your computer desktop. In your upper right hand corner you can see circled in red the interface that you can use. So you're listening in using your computer speaker system by default. If you prefer to join over the phone, just select phone call and the audio pane, the dial-in information will be displayed. If you are tuning in by telephone, you'll be only in listen-only mode. Next slide please. You'll have the opportunity to submit questions to myself and to the presenters by typing in questions into the question pane there on the left in the slide illustrated.
John Hamilton
executiveQuestions can be submitted whenever you like — we’ll gather them and handle them at the end during the Q&A session. Also, if you look on the right-hand side, you can raise your hand for a verbal question by pressing that button, and then we can unmute you and bring you into the call. I’ll remind you about all of this near the conclusion of the presentation. May I have the next slide, please. As a reminder, this conference call today includes certain statements that are, or may be considered, forward-looking statements, which cover all statements apart from statements of historical fact. Forward-looking statements involve making certain assumptions grounded in the company’s experience and perception of historical trends, current conditions, expected future developments and other factors that we believe are appropriate under the circumstances. Although we believe the expectations reflected in these forward-looking statements are reasonable, actual events or results may differ materially from those projected or implied in such forward-looking statements because of known or unknown risks, uncertainties and other factors. For your reference, our results announcement was released this morning. A copy of the press release and our first quarter 2020 report are available on our website as well.
John Hamilton
executiveMoving to the next slide, please. As is customary on these calls, I have with me these gentlemen: Qazi Qadeer, our CFO; Richard Morton, our Technical Director; and Nigel McKim, Project Director. All of them will take part in the webinar and will be on hand for questions too. Next slide, please. So this quarter has been rather interesting, I believe, for everyone, and the same holds true for Panoro. Perhaps I can briefly mention a handful of highlights, if that's the right word for them. On the operational front, the key thing is that our people are in good health and have adjusted to the new circumstances — both the office-based employees, who have for the most part been working from home across all our locations, and the operational personnel, who have truly stepped up to the challenge and performed well. As far as we know, we have no unpleasant incidents when it comes to the virus's effects within our community, and for that we are extremely thankful. The HSE culture we maintain, along with the systems we have in place, have so far demonstrated resilience, which is something we take great pride in as well. I believe that is the absolutely crucial and foremost point we can share today: that our operations have run safely and our staff remain healthy up to now.
John Hamilton
executiveAnd even with all of that, output has mostly stayed on track. In fact, during the quarter we're generating more than 2,000 barrels per day, an increase over Q4. So production kept going through this stretch. We've faced difficulties — there have been nights with little sleep, crew rotations, and a bit of drama surrounding lifting operations and similar matters that kept us busy — yet up to now things have turned out alright, though not without a fair amount of pressure and strain in the process. As we said before, certain development work in Gabon has been pushed back. Turning to oil sales, essentially all of our liftings took place according to plan, which is worth noting because sadly not everyone in this market is able to say the same. So we lifted at the times we chose. Our oil sales during quarter one were rather light, and I believe that was clearly signalled. We had just a single Gabonese cargo plus certain domestic sales in Tunisia, and those will ramp up as we move through the coming quarters. So it was a light quarter. We also completed an international lifting in Tunisia early in April. Our crude is priced against Dated Brent, which I'll return to. And another point we'd like to emphasise here is that analysts and shareholders ask us a great deal about our offtake and marketing contracts, and about where those are listed.
John Hamilton
executiveSo are we concerned about them? And do folks need to come purchase our crude — and we're extremely, extremely lucky. In Gabon we operated at the International; that went off without a hitch, and in Tunisia we're working with material at a first-class counterparty too. So we haven't encountered any problems around people being unwilling to lift crude, people failing to pay for crude, things of that nature — that hasn't been a problem for us. On the finance side, we've kept a strong balance sheet and a net cash position. Our hedging strategies have proven effective, we believe, in this downturn. We'll return to that topic. And as flagged earlier, we've cut CapEx and we've been reducing costs too. So on the outlook side, we've really been concentrating on financial discipline and on maintaining our existing production, which matters very, very much to us. Our production guidance for the year is 2,300 to 2,600 barrels a day. That's a slight trim from the prior one, based on the recent announcements together with BW Energy regarding the production range, decreasing a little in Gabon because we weren't able to tie in well six and seven. But the upside to our asset base remains.
John Hamilton
executiveWe just ran into some timing delays. So we believe the future looks bright for us. Next slide, please. Now all of us have been through the coronavirus and the fall in the oil price, but I thought I would just mention a couple of these things. How has this affected the oil sector in general? Certain supplies to Panoro, certain ones don't, and again we have been fairly lucky we have been in a position to lift, we have been in a position to sell, we have been in a position to produce, so but here are the matters that kind of kept us awake at night and to some degree still do. I think things have eased a little now, but logistics have simply been the thing to worry about. We have a global business. Our business depends on international people, international suppliers, ships coming and going, selling crude internationally on the high seas. And the logistics of that have simply been severely compromised by the travel restriction, the border is closing, the need for quarantines, isolation. This has all really affected the business and has resulted in HSE protocols really having to be stepped up and adapted where possible. So we have been extremely busy trying to make it all work and again in Panoro's case, and the operations we have, it has worked.
John Hamilton
executiveBut once more, tremendous effort has gone into this, with many sacrifices — personal ones — made by the people in the business. Still, we managed it successfully, and I think maybe we're somewhat luckier than others. We've also witnessed the effect on oil prices along with the price war. Global demand has fallen, storage capacity has turned into a massive topic. We've seen oil prices swing wildly. I mean, setting aside whatever happened with WTI Dated Brent — it's a seaborne crude, and negative prices, I don't believe, will show up in Brent, but even so, it has come under tremendous strain. And we've seen, in numerous instances, stranded oil cargoes, or cargoes sold at single-digit dollars per barrel, elsewhere in the world. So it's been an extremely, extremely tough period for the industry, and I'm not certain we're out of it yet, though things appear somewhat brighter at present. Next slide, please. Nigel, I just want to show what happens here. We do receive plenty of questions about how you sell your crude, what crude gets — how crude is priced. Brent is priced off what we call Dated Brent, which is the physical market — that's what actually happens at the coalface, so to speak, when we sell the crude.
John Hamilton
executiveAnd that's frequently a different price from what shows up on your screen when you check Bloomberg or similar, which tends to be a futures price, a near-term futures price. And what we've done here is simply plot the Delta, meaning the gap between the dated physical — the physical on that day — and the futures price visible on your screen. Across the last five years, and if you go back even further, you'll notice comparable patterns. More or less, it typically sits at a modest discount to the futures price. At times you'll see it trade at a premium, depending on supply/demand conditions, storage and so on. But what you witnessed during the crisis was unprecedented — a truly unprecedented fall in the physical price of Brent. And that, again, is the price at which you sell your crude, not the one shown on the screen, the futures price — this price at which you sell your crude dropped to a $10, $12 discount versus what the screen showed. And naturally, depending on your location, you had people seeking discounts beyond even that. That's the point where you see cargoes sold for single-digit numbers.
John Hamilton
executiveFortunately, that's been fixed now. At present we'll return to a more conventional discount relative to the futures price, thankfully. Yet this is genuinely what everyone was going through and the point at which panic took hold. Next slide, please. So how has oil been positioned for all of this, and what has our response been? I'd like to believe we took numerous steps ahead of the crisis. Naturally we couldn't predict the crisis, but I think we've consistently kept a reasonably prudent approach to running our business. For 2020 and 2021 we secured oil hedges with floors at $55 a barrel. In October of last year we completed an equity placing with very strong backing from some of our largest shareholders and others. That was really meant to get us into a decent balance sheet position as we entered the next phase of our company's expansion. We had the option, perhaps, of time to arrange a debt facility. We concluded that was probably the wrong move at that moment. Looking back, that was clearly a very good thing. We streamlined our organization. As you guys know, we inherited an organization from DNO.
John Hamilton
executiveWhen it comes to Tunisia, we reduced our debt expense by 40% in the last year, and corporately we've sort of consistently maintained a fairly low footprint. As was well pointed out, during the crisis we trimmed CapEx in Gabon by 40%. We pushed back Ruche Phase 1 — that had more to do with oil pricing than with the virus. And in Tunisia, we postponed higher-CapEx activities such as the Guebiba 10 sidetrack and Salloum West until the macro picture becomes a bit clearer. We've also made significant strides in lowering overheads. We've even gotten a little clever with some hedging around currencies — the dollar, <<inaudible>> sterling, and the kroner cost base that we carry. So I believe we responded effectively to this both before and after. Next slide, please. This slide speaks a bit about — actually, we had this discussion with the Board yesterday; we held a Board meeting yesterday. It's about stepping back and examining the corporate strategy across the last few years. We wanted to place ourselves in a position to weather the cycle. Ours is a cyclical business, without a doubt — the cycle that — I'm not even certain what we've just been through qualifies as a cycle. But the shock we've just come through isn't something any of us truly prepared for, yet we were prepared for the industry's cyclicality.
John Hamilton
executiveIf you take a step back and look at the big picture, we've positioned ourselves so that we're now producing considerably more oil. That means real cash flow is coming through the business. Over the years we've strengthened both our balance sheet and our cash position. A few years back we had only a couple of wells; that count has risen to 18 — or 20 counting Aje — and those wells give us diversification. We're in different countries too. In Gabon we've had to defer some activity, since there's still no flag, but in Tunisia we've been able to step things up. That diversification across countries and well count, I think, is proving to work, and we've made new discoveries too — a couple of discoveries in 2018, and best case in 2019 — and we still hold a huge exploration portfolio. So through the exploration drill bit we're able to replace the reserves we produce. So I think, as we've discussed at the Board, we're happy with where things stand currently, but even so I think we're glad we've placed ourselves in a stronger position than would have been the case a few years back had we weathered the shock we've just been through.
John Hamilton
executiveMoving to the next slide, please. At this point, I’d like to hand things over to Qazi Qadeer, our CFO, who will give you a brief walkthrough of our financial highlights and say a little about our debt and our hedging as well. Qazi?
Qazi Qadeer
executiveThanks, John, and good morning, everyone. Turning to Slide 11, we've got a summary of our headline results for the first quarter. As usual, I should note that the results we're presenting and discussing here are unaudited. Our reported result is split between continuing and discontinued business activities. The discontinued portion covers Aje operations, while the continuing activities take in our businesses in Tunisia and Gabon. I'll begin with revenue for the first quarter, which came in at $3.4 million, a notable decline versus the fourth quarter of 2019. That was mainly due to a lower number of liftings and partly due to a decline in oil prices. Sales volume in the current quarter was 71,000 barrels, compared with 210,000 barrels in 4Q 2019. Realized prices <<inaudible>> per barrel in Q1, and $65 a barrel in Q4 2019. Including the commodity hedges, the realized price was $55 a barrel for the first quarter of 2020. Moving to EBITDA from continuing activities, for Q1 it was $310,000, compared with $5.5 million in the previous quarter. Once again, the lower EBITDA reflects low volumes and lower oil prices in the current quarter. Despite the adverse macro environment, we achieved a positive EBITDA for the current quarter.
Qazi Qadeer
executiveAfter the EBITDA line, we recorded after-tax profit of $8 million in the first quarter, and that figure included a $10 million gain from marking commodity hedges to market. I'll go into more detail on those hedges on upcoming slides. Lastly, we ended the quarter holding $24 million in cash alongside $23 million of debt. Moving to the next slide, please. On this slide we cover the loan instruments Panoro currently has in place. There are two external instruments: a senior secured loan facility with Mercuria totaling US$16 million, and a $7 million non-recourse loan owed to BW Energy. Both of these are stated as of the end of March 2020. The Mercuria loan carries quarterly repayments of roughly $0.7 million for 2020. Because LIBOR rates have fallen recently, we anticipate effective interest cost will decrease by at least 1% for 2020. Throughout this downturn and the impact of COVID-19, Mercuria has proven a very supportive lender. In Gabon, we hold a non-recourse loan with no fixed repayment schedule; following each lifting, excess cash flows from cost oil, after operating costs are deducted, go toward repayments. The profit oil portion of revenue is always kept by Panoro.
Qazi Qadeer
executiveIn January of this year, we made a $1.4 million repayment to BW Energy. When oil prices are low, we anticipate that repayments will be extremely, extremely small. Let's move to the next slide, please. As John mentioned earlier regarding the dynamics of Dated Brent and physical crude pricing, our hedge positions are likewise priced off Dated Brent, and therefore they have a linear relationship with our cargo pricing, which is also based on Dated Brent. Our hedge positions are executed with Mercuria, which is again a first-class and robust counterparty. Each month, almost 20,000 barrels are hedged and settled, equivalent to roughly 25% of our production, mostly with floors of approximately $55 a barrel, and these have been delivering the necessary cash flow support during recent months of a low oil price environment. As of 31st of March, we have a $9 million mark-to-market valuation on our commodity hedges contracts, maturing during 2020 and 2021. That concludes my review of results. I'll now hand over to John, who will take us through the guidance on Slide 14.
John Hamilton
executiveAppreciate that, Qazi. We've already gone over part of this. Guidance for production right now sits at 2,300 to 2,600 barrels per day. Clearly that's a big step up versus 2019, and it comes in slightly below the guidance we issued most recently, which reflects the announcement made lately involving BW as well, regarding permits for certain output at Salloum because of COVID-19, and naturally Aje is not included in that figure. As for our international liftings, guidance at present is roughly eight liftings during this year. One was announced in the first quarter. We likely have four additional ones left across the remaining three quarters in Gabon, plus three in Tunisia. That's always open to some variation, but it reflects how we see things at the moment. Turning to CapEx, everything there was announced before; we had full-year CapEx of $31 million, which came out earlier this year. That figure has since been reduced to approximately $22 million, and at the close of the first quarter we have roughly $15 million of that left. About five of it is in Gabon, with the remainder being the Salloum commitment well over in Tunisia, and that one would be a sidetrack. Both of those are delayed at present. We are keeping them within our CapEx guidance.
John Hamilton
executiveAs for timing, there's some uncertainty there — likely toward the end of the year. And obviously, in light of the situation, we're looking for CapEx cuts across the board and throughout every one of our operations. So those CapEx figures and assumptions are historical ones. With luck, we can manage slightly better than that. Next slide, please. At this point I'd like to hand things over to Richard Morton, who can walk you through some of what's taken place in Gabon. Much of this has already been highlighted, but I'd like Rich to take you through it, please.
Richard Morton
executiveThanks, John, and good morning, everybody. So in Gabon, of course, output keeps coming from the Tortue field. The quarter's key points are that DTM-4H and DTM-5H, the first 2 of the planned Phase 2 production wells, started up in March. Gross output for the quarter therefore averaged 11,485 barrels of oil per day. That comes to 861 barrels of oil per day net to Panoro. Right now we're producing roughly 17,000 barrels a day from the Tortue field, from 4 wells. Completing Phase 2 at Tortue is being affected a little by the COVID pandemic. The 2 remaining wells will start up later than first planned — more on that shortly. And so we have now reforecast an average rate of 15 to 16.5 thousand barrels of oil per day for the year, with an OpEx of $15 to $17 per barrel. On sales in the quarter, we had 1 lifting in Q1, with a net parcel size of 44,000 barrels of oil net to Panoro at a price of 32.90. BP will carry out the next lifting in Tortue in June. And we have another 3 liftings scheduled for the second half of the year.
Richard Morton
executiveCrude gets priced off a Dated Brent average for the month of lifting, plus a premium. Looking ahead at Tortue, as I said, COVID has pushed things back, and the last few wells in the Phase 2 program have also been affected. The 6H well was in fact drilled, but it hasn't been hooked up yet, and as for the 7H well, drilling got postponed and the Rick was demobilized in March. On top of that, the firm exploration well that was planned for the end of the 2020 drilling campaign has been postponed, together with the optional exploration well slots we were considering at that time. Naturally, we still gain from a sizable exploration inventory in the license — the prospect map of the area on the right shows discoveries in green, and prospects in yellow, orange and brown — and we intend to target some of these once the oil price situation gets better. Soon, we're eager to hook up the DTM 6H well as soon as operations allow. After that comes the drilling, completion and hook-up of the last Phase 2 well, which is DTM 7H. Our expectation is that these activities will happen either at the end of this year or early in 2021.
Richard Morton
executiveAnd lastly, regarding Ruche Phase 1 — that’s the development of the Ruche Hibiscus fields tied back to the Adolo FPSO. That too has been pushed out, and CapEx has been deferred. We felt it was prudent to put this project on hold for the time being until the macro situation improves. So with that, I’ll pass things over to my colleague Nigel McKim, who will walk you through activities in Tunisia. Nigel?
Nigel McKim
executiveThanks, Rich, and good morning, everyone. Turning to Slide 16, we're giving you an update on where things stand with the Tunisian assets. The map on the left hand side shows how the two assets Panoro acquired sit contiguously — the TPS production assets, which are onshore in the area around the city of Sfax, plus another field offshore to the north of the Cercina Islands. Possibly its flat offshore exploration permit, located next to these concessions, offers exploration upside. We have an active operational program on the TPS assets, which had been temporarily delayed because of the COVID-19 pandemic and is about to restart with a number of well workover operations. On the Sfax offshore exploration permit, we are in the final stages of detailed planning and approval for drilling the Salloum West well. Average gross daily production for Q1, 2020 came in at 4,000 barrels of oil per day, which is an increase of 15% compared to gross production of 3,473 barrels of oil per day during Q4, 2019. At present we're producing roughly 4,000 barrels a day, and our near term objective is to lift output to our target of 5,000 barrels of oil per day. Production was only slightly affected by the pandemic — the focus during the Tunisian lockdown was on keeping existing production levels up, whilst new well work activity was deferred.
Nigel McKim
executiveOperating expenses for the operation come in below US$15 per barrel, which makes it very robust in the current environment. During Q1, two domestic liftings took place, totaling roughly 27,000 barrels net to Panoro, at a sales price of $54 per barrel. In April, after the quarter ended, a lifting of about 90,000 barrels occurred at a sales price of $19 per barrel. The following lifting is then anticipated for late July or early August. Luckily, our hedging strategy has delivered extremely strong results and is helping us keep revenue steady through this unprecedented period. Looking ahead, we're set to begin a very active stretch featuring multiple well work and drilling activities, which I'll cover on the next slide. Beyond that, we are carrying out additional optimization at the production facilities. We also have subsurface modeling work underway on two of the TPS fields, which we hope will result in further development activity in due course. Next slide, please. This slide presents the TPS well activities — the specific recent, ongoing and planned activities for the months ahead. The Rhemoura 1 workover involved stimulation and ESP replacement. The stimulation worked very well, producing a fourfold productivity increase in this well.
Nigel McKim
executiveThat has prompted us to pinpoint more candidates for stimulation in the remaining fields, and it is also revealing extra upside within Rhemoura itself. A number of the most impactful near-term chances involve restarting output at the EL AIN field. At the EL AIN-01 well, we will perform acid stimulation and afterward complete the well using an ESP, which is a first for us. We will additionally return the EL AIN-03 well to production following simulation. Then there is Guebiba-5, where we have lately perforated the Douleb reservoir along with the fields, and in the days ahead we will carry out an acid stimulation. These steps on their own are expected to let us hit our target output of 5,000 barrels of oil per day. Going forward, we intend a sequence of further well work operations. At Guebiba-4, we are hoping to retrieve the failed downhole completion and to complete this well on the Douleb reservoir as well. We are in the last phases of planning to drill a sidetrack on the Guebiba-10 A well. And with the delay in final approvals for the super Salloum West well, we have used that opening to schedule this activity using a CTF rig six ahead of the Salloum West well.
Nigel McKim
executiveI'm going to pass it over to John now so he can take us through the following slide, which is Slide 18.
John Hamilton
executiveOkay, thanks Nigel, and thank you Richard. A few more updates on other things we have in progress. In South Africa, we formed in February a very exciting exploration venture alongside Africa Energy. An application has been sent to the ministry — the application for Panoro to enter into the license. As with many ministries and government offices around the world, those ministries have been shut. So it isn't clear precisely when the approval timetable will play out, though our best estimate is Q3, perhaps Q4 of this year. Completion of this transaction depends on that consent being granted by the government, and also on the concurrence given by Azinam for 50% of this block. Meanwhile, we're busy doing what we can, which is assessing cost savings related to the drilling operations, and carrying out quite a bit of subsurface work still on this very exciting area. At Aje, production has carried on, with some limited shut-in periods. Cost savings have been put in place by the operator there. We have, as previously announced, a transaction with PetroNor for the sale of this business, which is subject to ministerial consent for this transaction plus another transaction that PetroNor is doing together with the operator.
John Hamilton
executiveThose processes are underway—they've clearly been affected by COVID-19 as well—and we expect them to take another several months, but they are underway. Next slide, please. This is a summary slide. Despite some of the timing delays we've encountered, we believe we still have a very strong outlook. On the corporate side, we believe we have a solid balance sheet with low cost production. Our shareholder base and our lenders have been amazing partners to have through thick and thin. We look forward to dividending the PetroNor shares subject to the completion of that transaction towards the end of the year, hopefully. Our reserves, our resources remain there highly valuable, they're still in the ground, nothing's changed that. And we're taking a look at some market opportunities out there. We have nothing immediate, but clearly this market does throw up quite a bit of opportunity. And of course we need to be alive to that. On the production side, we look forward eventually to the hook up with DTM-6H the well, it was drilled in Gabon and drilling the DTM-7H when conditions allow. We look forward obviously the Ruche Phase 1 and 50 million barrels that we have lined up to start producing there.
John Hamilton
executiveAs Nigel mentioned, in Tunisia we aim to bring the production wells online through workovers in the very near term. After that, we're still examining Guebiba and other efforts to increase output there. Regarding exploration, Salloum West remains in the works as we continue planning around it. Exploration at Dussafu, as Richard mentioned, has been pushed back, though it remains firmly on our radar. And naturally, we have Block 2B in South Africa, which is likely a 2021 event. That wraps up the presentation. As a quick reminder, if you want to submit a question, you can type a written one via the question panel. If you'd prefer to ask verbally, those of you online can raise your hand by clicking the raise hand button, and we should be able to see it. So now I'd like to open things up for any questions.
John Hamilton
executiveI notice a question coming in right around here — it's a new technology from Teodor. Teodor, I'm going to try to unmute you now. And Teodor, did that work? No, okay.
Teodor Nilsen
analystMorning — can you hear me okay?
John Hamilton
executiveGood morning. Hi, Teodor. Hi there?
Teodor Nilsen
analystMorning, and thanks for the update. I have two quick questions. You talked about realized oil prices for Q1 — can you say anything about realized oil prices so far in Q2 versus the reference price shown on the screen? My second question concerns the dividend, specifically the dividend on the PetroNor shares this year following closing of the deal. You said previously that you're aiming for a cash dividend from 2022 onward, so I'm wondering what sort of oil price environment we would need to see for you to actually pay a cash dividend from 2022.
John Hamilton
executiveAlright, regarding the oil price — the sole cargo we’ve sold thus far in Q2 is the one we already mentioned in Tunisia, which came down in early April, unfortunately right in the middle of the crisis. So we got roughly $19 a barrel for it, and that is a terrible price. That said, I believe other cargoes are being sold in Africa at the same time for single digits. So I suppose we should count our blessings there. That has been the only lifting so far, and the only other one we have planned for this quarter is in Gabon during June. How Gabonese cargoes are priced is we take the average of Dated Brent for the month of lifting — so in this case June. We’ll take the 30 days in June, work out what the average Dated Brent is, and then we’ll be paid a $1 premium on top of whatever that number is. Currently Dated Brent is trading a couple $1, $1.5, $2 below what you probably see on your futures screen, so right now probably around $33, $34 a barrel, something like that. But we’ll have to wait and price until June.
John Hamilton
executiveMeanwhile, of course, we do hold a hedge—although we didn't add one in May—so there is hedging income for May, since those hedges settle each month, and June will see comparable hedges too. As for the cash dividend, what we've consistently indicated is that our preference would be to distribute a cash dividend at the point when some Ruche Phase 1 output is flowing, meaning that third production phase. That is, once roughly 40,000 barrels a day gross of production is online at Dussafu. That intention hasn't changed—Ruche Phase 1 still requires resanctioning. In our view, we need to work alongside the operator, with Telo, and with the State of Gabon to get that resanctioned, and I think we would prefer to see somewhat firmer oil prices prior to doing so. Clearly, should we resanction it, we'd be bullish on the oil price. So our plan would remain to endeavor to pay the dividend—a cash dividend—once that production level has been reached.
Teodor Nilsen
analystAll right, thanks.
John Hamilton
executiveThere are a few more questions coming in, so just give me a moment. We've got one from Jorgen at Fearnley Securities. Jorgen, good morning. You might have to unmute your line, Jorgen. Jorgen, are you with us? Hello, Jorgen, are you there?
Jorgen Torstensen
analystYes, I’m on the call.
John Hamilton
executiveAlright, that sounds fine.
Jorgen Torstensen
analystAll right, good morning. My question follows a similar thread to Teodor’s regarding pricing. During the presentation, if I heard you correctly, you mentioned that the security delay stems more from oil prices than from the COVID-19 situation. So what I’d like to ask is: what level of oil prices would you need in order to, let’s say, resume normal activity and proceed with the next phase at Dussafu?
John Hamilton
executiveThanks, Jorgen — that's a really good question. Let me try to be a bit more precise here. What took place at Dussafu was partly tied to COVID and partly to the oil price. We had a rig out in the field, as you know, drilling those four wells. Three of them got drilled. On the fourth, we ended up having to demobilize the rig, and that came down to COVID. We simply couldn't bring in the crews, the suppliers, or the contractors — that was purely a COVID issue. The plan had been to drill both that third and the fourth well. We got the third done but not the fourth, and then bring in an installation vessel in June to hook the two of them up. That was the intent, but because of COVID that installation vessel can't carry out the work right now. That's really where the uncertainty comes from. So both of those pieces of activity have been affected by COVID. As for the Ruche development, which we're about to kick off — and had already started on a little — it's been pushed back because of the oil price. And in Gabon we benefit from very low operating costs and a favorable tax regime. For that development, CapEx per barrel is modest — roughly $10 a barrel.
John Hamilton
executiveTechnically, $30 oil would still be okay. I think, along with the rest of the JV, we probably need to see a bit more strength in the oil price. I'd say something with a four at the front of it is probably where we need to be psychologically, even though technically I believe we could sanction and still make money at these current oil prices. I think it's about confidence — having a little more of a buffer ahead of us. We've got meetings coming up soon. So I'm sure this will be debated quite actively; I think everybody has been focused a bit more on making sure we maintain what we have. Looking forward, I suspect it will be something like that. But we'll update the market as soon as we have a common view on that.
Jorgen Torstensen
analystAll right, thank you.
John Hamilton
executiveOkay, Vernard has a question — Vernard, I'm going to bring you in, and you'll have to unmute yourself. Are you with us? Vernard — all right, I'll circle back to Vernard. Maybe Stephen from Auctus Advisors. Stephen, are you able to hear me? Hello Stephen.
Stephen Foucaud
analystYes, hello John. A few questions from my side, and good morning. So, a couple of things from me. First, on Tunisia: you mentioned the 5,000 barrels per day that could be reached by carrying out work within the subsets of the work program, and I'm not referring to Salloum. So what upside case do you see if sidetracking and everything else are included in the 2020 well programming channels production? Second, in your talks with PetroNor in Nigeria, how do you view this — PetroNor is clearly responsive and clearly engaged, and last week we got the divestment of the New Gen asset. And finally, leaving aside 6H and 7H in Gabon, what is your latest view on the 2021 development CapEx program? Thank you.
John Hamilton
executiveNigel, would you like to handle the first question regarding what the potential upside scenario in Tunisia might be?
Nigel McKim
executiveSure, John. So the near-term well work we discussed is beginning today — in fact, it's underway on two of the wells, and through that work we hope to raise output toward the 5,000 barrels of oil per day goal we set. That activity will move forward and unfold across roughly the coming month. As for the additional work you pointed to — the Guebiba 10 sidetrack and, of course, operations at Guebiba 4 — here's where things stand for later in the year: at present we expect drilling to begin in August, though that obviously depends on global conditions improving as international borders open up once the pandemic subsides. So the exact timing remains uncertain. For that operation, we anticipate a well rate of 500 barrels of oil per day, give or take. But we must keep in mind that these assets are declining continuously at the same time. We can also lose ESP pumps now and then, and those typically last two, maybe five years. So some drop in base production is normal while we bring on added output from new activities. So we're aiming at 5,000 barrels of oil per day in the near term, and we hope to exceed that.
Nigel McKim
executiveThat said, the exact goal isn’t clear yet at this point later in the year.
John Hamilton
executiveYes, Stephen, so I would back up what he said. I believe he is attempting to reach our first target. Obviously, there is more upside past that, and I think we have to prove to ourselves — and to accomplish all of that — that we are capable of reaching the five. After that, we will begin examining the next level. But what is really encouraging on our side is that we have been able to restart operations. Tunisia has more or less emerged from a lockdown; they have observed Ramadan, and Eid has finished. So right now, everything there is genuinely coming back together, and we are in a position to pursue that work, which is very encouraging. On your question about PetroNor and Aje: PetroNor has been a fantastic partner. They stay deeply involved in everything happening in Nigeria. We work together extremely well. And they have plenty to contribute to the Aje story. They have a longer-term plan for Aje that they are busy preparing; clearly they are not licensed yet. So, so to speak, they must do it on paper, but they have been very involved and a very constructive counterparty to deal with. On CapEx 2021, DTM-6 and DTM-7, we have already spent a fair amount of money on those wells, because on DTM-6 only the installation remains, and for DTM-7 we obviously purchased most of the items for us; it was only tied to drilling activity and, obviously, the eventual hookup that is still to come.
John Hamilton
executiveThere's likely some CapEx tied to those two items, though it's fairly modest. As for Ruche Phase 1, my hope is that we'll resanction it at some point. We have to coordinate with our partners on that, and the real CapEx for it probably wouldn't actually land until 2022; 2021 would see some CapEx, but it was always somewhat back-ended. You had certain long lead items, and we'll have platform-type things. There is some significant cost earlier in the cycle, but much of it arrives closer to the end, with the drilling activity. So given all the uncertainties, it's really too early to say, but on paper, 2021 — setting aside Ruche Phase 1 — is a very modest CapEx year for us.
Stephen Foucaud
analystThanks.
John Hamilton
executiveAlright, I believe there's one more. Yes, Hugo. Hugo, I'm trying to reach you now. Can you hear us? I think you're on mute — you need to unmute. Hello, Hugo. It seems like you're unmuted, but we still can't hear you. Okay, well, meanwhile, it appears we have a question — actually a few questions — that have come in. Okay, there's a question on M&A regarding whether startup additional opportunities? Yes, I think that the shock — as this question essentially puts it, would you say that the shock we've been through has created more M&A opportunities in Africa, is it possible to agree on price, or is the bid ask spread at the asset level typically very wide, or is M&A not the top of your agenda these days with the oil price uncertainty and reluctance to add debt to your balance sheet? Yes, I think everybody is looking to do deals in this market. Obviously, there's been a huge dislocation. And as you say, the bid ask spread, I think is still an issue. So obviously, companies would love to buy assets at a cheap level if they can, but sellers are reluctant to try and pick this price out in the market and say that that's the new reality.
John Hamilton
executiveI believe there’s still opportunity out there. If you’ve got seasoned people who can examine perhaps contingent structures—arrangements that could pay off later should oil prices climb or production end up being generated—then that’s a possibility. So we have plenty of investment bankers who’ve likewise been sitting at home working remotely, dreaming up all sorts of things. So I’d say there’s lots of chatter with very little activity, and we’ve seen Total come in and pick up (inaudible). We’ve also seen deals fall apart, again with Total on the Anadarko deal. So, I think there’s a lot of chatter, but not so much activity yet. I think we may see some, but I think the world needs to stabilize a little bit first, because for most companies, you’re going to be relying on external capital to do transactions of your shares and share prices are low, external capital is probably scarce. So I think it’s been a little while before we see a boom, but certainly I think that there will eventually be quite a bit of opportunity available. Right, I think that is it. I see Hugo still got his hand raised.
John Hamilton
executiveAlright, let me give it another shot with Hugo and see whether this works. Yes, Hugo, I can tell you're no longer muted, but I still can't see or hear you. Fine — Qazi, are there any other questions you've noticed that I skipped?
Qazi Qadeer
executiveJohn, I don't see any further questions or any hands going up.
John Hamilton
executiveThanks a lot, and thanks to everyone for being here. Once again, we're hoping our tech trial went off without a hitch. Should you have any comments about it, just send us an email. Also, after you exit today's webinar, a follow-up email will arrive in your inbox containing a link to view the recording of today as well as a recording of today's webinar. So thank you so very much for being with us, and enjoy the remainder of your day. Many thanks.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Panoro Energy ASA transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Panoro Energy ASA earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Panoro Energy ASA or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.