Panoro Energy ASA (PEN) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

November 29, 2023

Oslo Bors NO Energy Oil, Gas and Consumable Fuels earnings 59 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

John Hamilton

executive
#1

Good morning, everyone, and thanks for joining us for our Third Quarter Results Presentation. Joining me on the call today are Qazi Qadeer, our Chief Financial Officer, Nigel McKim, our Technical Director, and Andy Diamond, our Head of Corporate Development. Richard Morton, our Technical Director, is actually in Bata in Equatorial Guinea today, so he isn't with us. He's down there working on getting the drilling program started in Equatorial Guinea, and we'll come to that in a moment. Next slide, please. As a reminder, today's conference call contains certain statements that are or may be deemed to be forward-looking statements, which include all statements other than statements of historical fact. Forward-looking statements involve making certain assumptions, based on the company's experience and perception of historical trends, current conditions, expected future developments, and other factors that we believe are appropriate under the circumstances. Although we believe the expectations reflected in these forward-looking statements are reasonable, actual events, or results may differ materially from those projected, or implied in such forward-looking statements due to known, or unknown risks, uncertainties, and other factors. And for your reference, our results announcement and this presentation that we're going through the release this morning, which can be found on our website.

John Hamilton

executive
#2

Moving to the following slide, please. Now regarding the question period, you have the option to enter a question by typing. Over on the left-hand panel, as you'll notice, you key it in, and we'll do our best to respond to it, provided that a prior question hasn't already covered it. Alternatively, you may raise your hand — you'll see that small hand icon at the upper left — and we'll attempt to unmute you so you can pose a spoken question over audio. I'll also repeat these directions for you at the close. On to the next slide, please. It proved to be a really robust quarter for us. In fact, it stands as our fresh all-time high quarter, with revenues comfortably above $100 million, exceptionally solid EBITDA of nearly $65 million, and net profit of close to $28 million. Following that, we have the year-to-date highlights, illustrating how the business has progressed across three quarters, with, clearly, one quarter still remaining. And then a balance sheet that remains, on a net debt basis, in our view rather robust, at $35 million net debt. When performing those calculations, we offset against the cash drawn down under the short-term advance payment facilities, which assist us in managing working capital.

John Hamilton

executive
#3

Still, those figures do a good job of showing where the company stands on its balance sheet, and that position is solid. Today we also put out a separate press release announcing a cash distribution of NOK40 million, and the details of that distribution are available there. One thing worth flagging: this will be paid as a return of paid-in capital, so it isn't a dividend as such, though in the end it amounts to the same thing — cash. Returning it in the form of paid-in capital may give certain shareholders a tax advantage, and for us it's an efficient way of getting cash back to shareholders. That works out to NOK0.342 per share. The final cash dividend for 2023 will be declared when we report fourth quarter results, which happens in February. Next slide, please. We figured it might be helpful to take a step back and consider the context around what we're doing, where we sit on our growth trajectory as a company, and what that implies for distributions to shareholders. We don't need to look very far back to see that Panora was a very small company, producing roughly 1,300 barrels a day back in 2018. We began coming online during that period, and by 2020 we had reached 2,200.

John Hamilton

executive
#4

And we're moving up that ladder gradually, producing roughly 9,000 barrels per day in this year. As everyone is aware, our aim is to generate more than 13,000 barrels per day over the course of 2024. And we've genuinely begun through our pledge to give cash back to shareholders. That pledge started six months sooner than the guidance we originally issued. It began in February 2023, when we made the very first payment of NOK30 million. And as you can see, we have been increasing that amount. We've now progressed to NOK40 million, and I'll discuss it soon, but we have also announced the 2024 framework, the policy covering shareholder returns. So I believe what we're attempting to show here is that the company and its Board are extremely dedicated and committed to being a very strong company focused on shareholder returns, while at the same time trying to operate a business and manage our capital expenditure, along with our other financial stakeholders simultaneously, running a very prudent operation. Another point worth making here really concerns where we expect the free cash flow inflection point to be. We remain in a busy stretch. We're only roughly halfway through our enormous drilling program. And we expect free cash flow — the true inflection point for the business — to arrive around mid-year, which is when most of the CapEx will be behind us.

John Hamilton

executive
#5

And hopefully we'll be putting out a lot of barrels per day. That's really the direction we're heading. And that really gives us room to keep looking at extending our shareholder return story from where we stand today, which we believe is already in very good shape. Next slide, please. So what we've announced today is the framework for our shareholder return policy for 2024. We're targeting somewhere between NOK400 million and NOK500 million. The precise timing depends on de-risking our production operations. We'll talk about that. We're roughly halfway through our extensive drilling program. This is probably the busiest stretch in Panoro's history. We're about halfway through it now, as we de-risk those production operations in Gabon and Equatorial Guinea in particular. And as we do that, the waiting will shift toward the second half, as production milestones are hit. On the core cash distribution, we see it paid quarterly, beginning with our first quarter results, which we'll discuss in May. And those will be — paid as a return or paid-in capital again, which may carry certain tax benefits for certain shareholders, an efficient way for us to do that.

John Hamilton

executive
#6

However, we also aim to retain a very sizable chunk of that $400 million to $500 million via special distributions and share buybacks. We realize that at times — in fact, most times, all times — we trade at a discount to our net asset value. And we believe that depending on the circumstances within periods and the share price in the prevailing market, opportunities will arise for us to conduct meaningful share buybacks over the course of next year. The key factors and assumptions behind these: what we tried to do is take an oil price that represented where we felt the equity analysts on average had built their 2024 models on. By our calculations, that's around $85 a barrel. Current change rates around 10 to 1 on the Kroner. And the Board will obviously continue to assess this upwards or potentially downwards, should oil prices be higher or lower, or if production de-risking occurs. So clearly, there's some upside, particularly as we get into the second half of next year to consider further revisions. This is approximately a doubling of last year's, the 2023 return policy. So, we really do feel we're continuing on, to be on the ladder here of increasing shareholder returns.

John Hamilton

executive
#7

Moving to the next slide, please. What we've aimed to do here is sum up the busy program we discussed. This company is genuinely in the most active drilling phase it has ever seen. Truly. It's remarkable. And thanks to the backing of our shareholders and the backing of the financial community that's on this call and our lenders, we've truly put the company in a good position to be able to really take on material capital programs. And as you can see in 2023, we drilled 4 Hibiscus wells. We drilled at least halfway through the Ruche well that will only be completed in 2024. And we've made a Hibiscus South discovery. And what we have going on now is a series of workovers in Hibiscus, which we'll return to, tied to the ESP issues that have been well flagged. And we're — in Equatorial Guinea, we're also warming up the rig right now with a couple of workovers before we spud the first well, probably around Christmastime. Then we still have next year, 3 more production wells in Gabon, 3 production wells in Equatorial Guinea, and 2 exploration wells. So, I can't really think of a time in my time at Panoro when the company's been busier.

John Hamilton

executive
#8

Toward the bottom of this slide, we attempt to walk through a bit of the positives, a few of the highlights and the low points of where we stand today. Safety performance on the campaign so far has been excellent, which matters a great deal. Output rates from the 4 Hibiscus wells came in above what we expected, with production hitting nearly 40,000 barrels a day while 4 of those wells were onstream before certain of the problems we encountered with ESPs. So we know the reservoir is currently performing at or beyond what we anticipated. That shows you part of the upside. On the downside, the ESP problems have brought variability in production. Those, along with some of the earlier slippage on the project, have likely left us, in our estimation, 3, perhaps even 4 months behind the original schedule we had been following. So that is clearly a negative, and I think the market has reflected it quite loudly. Then on the right-hand side, let's spend a little time on the electrical problems, which we believe can be and will be fixed. The reserves are not affected, so this is deferred production — preferred, in other words — rather than production that is lost. We have now brought in an extra seventh production well for the Gabonese campaign, which ought to let us reach higher rates, handle the reservoirs more effectively, stretch the plateau further out, and achieve greater diversification of the well stock.

John Hamilton

executive
#9

It's genuinely a good extra piece of value for us. These infill wells over in Equatorial Guinea are capable of adding further volumes beyond what we've observed up to now. On top of that, we've got 2 exploration catalysts with very high impact: Bourdon — which longtime Panoro followers will know as the old prospect B — and the Akeng Deep well, the Cosmos-operated well in Equatorial Guinea. It's a very busy stretch. Next slide, please. I won't spend too long on this one. It's basically a tally — production across recent quarters, where our guidance sat, and restating the point that we'll reach 13,000 barrels a day once 6 of those Gabonese wells are producing simultaneously. We also have the Equatorial Guinea campaign coming through, which ought to give us some additional upside there. As a group, we've exceeded 12,000 barrels a day back when the ESPs were functioning properly. So we do know the potential exists to get there. It comes down to resolving the electrical problems we've encountered in Gabon. And then bearing in mind that we altered the sequence of the drilling program in Gabon, our guidance for the year stands at roughly 9,000 barrels a day, as announced previously.

John Hamilton

executive
#10

Moving to the next slide, please. Here's our lifting update. As we've consistently presented it, this is the last lifting we have for the year; we've already lifted in Gabon and Tunisia during Q4. So far, we've lifted roughly 0.5 million barrels — a little over 0.5 million barrels — in Gabon and Tunisia. One final lifting remains in Gabon, and it falls right at the edge of the New Year, so to speak, which means it could slip just into early January. We'll see. But this is largely in line with what was already guided. Next slide, please. Each time we provide a small update here on where our debt stands along with some CapEx guidance, there are no changes on the left side of this slide. On the right side of the slide, we've got it at around $75 million. That's unchanged for this year. We are raising slightly our CapEx assumptions for next year, in 2024, to a range of $70 million to $75 million. We have never really given firm guidance on that. But I think, indicatively, most people assume we're at $60 million or $65 million. So, we're upping that slightly. The reason for that, I think, is evident.

John Hamilton

executive
#11

We moved the Hibiscus South discovery forward quickly. So there's an additional development well going in there — and two exploration wells are being drilled. One, Hibiscus South, is already drilled, and the other is Bourdon. So those elements combined, along with some rig time spent on ESP remedial work, mean CapEx has come in somewhat above what some may have anticipated for next year. But that's understandable, I think, given the bigger work program. Next slide, please. I won't spend much time here, but once again we do try to offer this slide each time, purely to illustrate how cash builds within the business and where the different pieces sit. I won't devote any time to this, but should questions come up on it, I'll handle them during the Q&A. Next slide, please. Right, Gabon. We've already covered it a bit, but the four Hibiscus wells are there. Those have shown excellent reservoir performance, with good flow rates on them. We have some electrical integrity problems with the ESPs, and right now we're in a phase of diagnosis, repair and replacement. That program has begun. I'll mention it a little later in the presentation, but it is currently underway.

John Hamilton

executive
#12

Sure, that’s definitely been a speed bump for us. It hasn’t been pleasant, since we know how well these wells flow. But everyone is focused on this issue. We have Baker Hughes, the pump specialist and supplier, involved, along with the MaBoMo, right now, together with BW Energy crews and other third-party experts. So we are really pushing hard on it. But — it has caused a small delay to business. Hibiscus South will be fast tracked into production. You can see Hibiscus South there on the map. It was a really beautiful little 20 meter oil pay, 6 million to 7 million barrels. It may not sound big, but these are extremely valuable barrels. We calculate something like NPV 10, at least $40 a barrel in these. So basically, the OpEx is almost free on them, because you’re already paying for everything through the MaBoMo, through the existing production. So, it’s been a fantastic discovery for us. And we’re finally going to get after Bourdon as well as part of this program. This is a rather large structure that could be extremely large. We have it currently at about 29 million barrels. It’s got targets in both the Gamba and the Dentale, and it will probably be the last thing that we do as part of this drilling campaign.

John Hamilton

executive
#13

All right, so we have exercised those options. Over at Tortue, the gas lift compressor was put in place and started up during July, and it has run without issue from then on. Tortue is still producing as expected, with all six wells online. Let's go to the next slide, please. We all tend to get a bit wrapped up in electrical problems and the various ups and downs that come with this industry, but we wanted to pull back a little here and remind ourselves — and anyone willing to listen to us — just what Dussafu really is. If we begin where we began at Panoro, we bought the seismic and drilled those very first wells, discovering Ruche and Tortue back in 2013. By the time 2017 arrived, we figured roughly 24 million barrels were sitting on that block. Since then, discoveries and revisions have added 91 million barrels. We have taken the field to nearly 120 million barrels. And once the Hibiscus South discovery is included, we have already produced 24 million barrels. So, as you can see, since 2018 this thing is going to keep producing for many, many years ahead.

John Hamilton

executive
#14

Beyond that, we also have the 2C — those discovered resources that haven’t been commercialized as of yet. There’s Bourdon, and then there’s the rest of the exploration portfolio as we see it today, which we estimate could hold as much as another 142 million barrels. So we’re on a license that will produce oil and, hopefully, keep finding more oil over a long stretch of time. The ESP problems are extremely frustrating, but we believe this really is a very accurate description and depiction of Dussafu within this wonderful block that we hold. And we try not to lose sight of that as we move forward. Next slide, please. Well, this is just about to become the next exciting development. Equatorial Guinea has been producing fine, but it’s about to get exciting. We have a very, very active program here over the coming six months. The Island Innovator, which you can see in the picture, is in country. It has already begun the planned workovers. The thinking is to sort of get the rig warmed up with a couple of easier workovers before it comes in and drills three new infill production wells. The first should be on stream probably toward the end of Q1, and the next two somewhere in the second quarter.

John Hamilton

executive
#15

Beyond that, a great deal else is happening — flow line replacements, gas compression units, and gas injection. There are many, many projects underway here. And in addition to all of that, we're drilling the Akeng Deep prospect, a Cosmos-operated well that comes at the tail end of the campaign, so likely late in Q2. We will drill it. This one tests a deeper Albian play. We've mentioned it previously. Should it be a discovery, you can tie it back. Its infrastructure leads back to the FPSO. The gross un-risked mean resource estimate comes in at roughly 180 million barrels. So it's potentially a transformational exploration well, with about a 25% chance of success. So we need to bear that in mind. But what this portfolio shows us, together with the Gabonese exploration wells I mentioned earlier, is that plenty of strong exploration catalysts lie ahead over the next six months as well. On a positive note, there's also been — people always talk a lot about tax and tax risk in the North Sea and the U.K. and other jurisdictions. Well, in EG, they've moved in the opposite direction.

John Hamilton

executive
#16

They've actually cut the profit tax rate to 25% from 35%. That takes effect starting in 2025. But this is a very, very progressive government we have here when it comes to encouraging you in the gas sector. So that was very, very pleasing. We have a standard yearly tax payment. It's a lump sum tax payment that's due in Equatorial Guinea each year, so to speak. That's the tax regime. It's built into the production sharing contract. This year it comes to roughly $20 million paid as a lump sum, and that will be paid in the fourth quarter of this year and every year going forward. That's simply the timing of that tax payment. Next slide, please. Tunisia is performing very, very well. I think we're in a transitional period there. We've been heavily focused on the onshore blocks here. The ones shown in orange there in Guebiba, El Hajeb, El Ain. These fields have been producing very, very well. But we're about to begin a period of focusing now on the offshore, on the Cercina field, where we're carrying out a series of workovers in 2024, which will really help us build up the field's potential there, as we move into a renewal period on that license.

John Hamilton

executive
#17

I think you'll hopefully be hearing more about Tunisia in 2024, then. It wasn't a particularly active year in terms of news flow in Tunisia, although production held up very well. But 2024 could see a lot more activity as we get into some workover campaigns in Cercina. Next slide, please. So our typical summary slide — we really find ourselves in probably the busiest period of our history. At Dussafu, we still very much stand by the delivering 40,000 barrels a day gross. There's been some noise around that kind of thing. But we very much stand by that. And we also very much stand by our production targets, 13,000 barrels a day. It's a group. These are unchanged targets. The results of the new wells in Gabon have exceeded expectations. And the reservoir deliverability has been very, very good. The ESP issues have obviously constrained production, but we're getting after it as we speak. There's a three well drilling campaign coming from Equatorial Guinea. And we have the two infrastructure led exploration assets in Equatorial Guinea and Gabon combined with a cash distribution framework, which we think is very shareholder forward. If I could go to the next slide now, as a reminder how to ask questions here.

John Hamilton

executive
#18

You can either type in a question or raise your hand. My hunch is that many of the questions will focus on the ESP issues, and we think this has introduced some uncertainty—we have some uncertainty ourselves—and we recognize that it's frustrating. It's frustrating for us too. It's frustrating for BW as well. But instead of, sort of, filling up the Q&A with questions about the ESPs, you'll understand that we're in the middle of this diagnosis program. So there are only a limited number of things we can say. What I'm going to do, though, is actually do a Q&A myself. So I'll anticipate the questions that I think you guys are going to answer—that I would like to answer. And then I'd ask that, you know, you try not to repeat those same kinds of questions when you come online. I just have a feeling that a lot of questions may be coming from the same angle. So let me try to head them off. Hopefully, I'll do a good enough job, and you'll appreciate that. Obviously, we're in the middle of a program where we're getting information and details every single day.

John Hamilton

executive
#19

Okay, this is clearly an evolving situation, so there's not a great deal more I can add beyond what I'll say now. After that, I'll throw things open for questions. With any luck there won't be too many about the ESPs—hopefully I'll have already covered them. So the first thing I want to ask myself is: what's going on right now? To begin with, it's worth noting something. The thing driving adoption of these ESP technologies—these so-called access ESPs—is that this technology offers an edge over conventional ESPs, in that you can swap out failed pumps by way of a production platform, along with wireless systems. That means you don't actually need a drilling rig. So this genuinely generates a lot of operational efficiencies. ESPs do fail at some point. They don't last forever. And if you can come in with a wireline, pull them out and reinstall them, you avoid having to bring in a drilling rig—an expensive drilling rig—to replace them. So that's the main driver. Longer term, we expect these ESPs to deliver meaningful uptime cost benefits as a result. Right now, BW is in the middle of a diagnostic exercise; enormous resources are being mobilized—and I genuinely mean enormous.

John Hamilton

executive
#20

For BW, this ranks as the number one, number one, number one priority. And it isn't just BW—the ESP supplier, Baker Hughes, is on site in force alongside third-party exports on the MaBoMo. So the work now in progress, which will probably run over the coming weeks through to the end of the year, let's say, involves pulling those ESPs out and likely at minimum one of the lower completions beneath the ESP, purely to establish where the root cause lies for the problems we've been having. So it's genuinely a root-and-branch exercise. Pull it all out and take a look at what we've got. We don't yet have a coordinated time with BW for updating the market, but we'd expect that probably in the New Year. Still, for everyone involved right now, this is the number one priority. The next thing I ask myself is: what might the issues be? Well, our theories are numerous, and more work is needed on them. These ESPs see wide use across the industry, and nearby as well by Chevron in Congo. So our feeling is that a solution will be found. As we've said, the reservoir performance of the wells has been fantastic.

John Hamilton

executive
#21

Getting this situation corrected is absolutely the top thing for us. The next thing I ask myself is: how long is the fix going to take? Once again, it's premature to say with certainty. And honestly, any answer we give right now might be somewhat misleading. But if you look across the range of outcomes, we could see it taking up to three months, depending on what the issue turns out to be — and it may be possible to resolve it sooner. Still, that's likely the best estimate I can offer at this point. How the remediation work will overlap and be combined with the drilling program is still unclear. And naturally, there's the Bourdon well coming in as well. So we're juggling supplies, logistics and which new wells get drilled first — everything overlaps, and we're still assembling the puzzle. The group's priority, however, is to maximize production. So we won't sacrifice production. What we truly want is to try to ensure everything is done as correctly as we can when it comes to repairing these ESPs, while at the same time keeping production rates as high as we can.

John Hamilton

executive
#22

The next thing I want to ask myself is whether you agree with the BW guidance they gave last week, which obviously stirred things up quite a bit for those who track the two companies. That guidance caught us off guard, especially the low end of it. Part of what they put out may have stemmed from a wish to set a low target, or one they'd be able to beat. In our view, what could have been spelled out more clearly was how timing affects the annual averages they presented. Under the original Dussafu schedule, all six of those wells were to be finished by the end of this year — around Christmastime, in December, early January. So by January, you'd have been at something like full tilt, sitting on a nice plateau, so to speak. But because of all the well-publicized delays we had, and now with these ESP issues stepping in, plus bringing in the Hibiscus South well and shuffling the program somewhat between exploration and development wells, everything has slipped, as I mentioned, by a stretch of, let's say, three months. So when you look at an average production rate for a calendar year, if you begin on January 1 at the top.

John Hamilton

executive
#23

Clearly, that figure differs from what you'd get if you began at the top, say, during the second quarter at some point. So I believe that point could have been explained a bit more clearly. And I think it does account for at least part of the reduction in the production target for next year. So essentially, that just moves the calendar to the right by, let's say, three months. So I think that's the point that probably could have been, and should have been, better explained. What really matters for us is reaching the 40,000 barrel a day level at Dussafu on a sustained basis and capturing that deferred production that we've been losing just recently. And obviously, from a Panoro perspective, what we really like is that we have the EG wells coming online during this period as well. So the benefits of a diversified portfolio are really beginning to come through. Despite the adversity of these electrical issues, we still have EG, which is now stepping up to come onto the field and contribute new volumes for us. So, again, we'd like to now open it up for questions. And with respect, we will answer questions around or try to answer questions around the ESPs to the extent I haven't dealt with them.

John Hamilton

executive
#24

I'd just ask folks, if possible, to steer clear of questions I likely won't be able to address, or ones I've already covered in what I said before. So, Andy, shall we open the lines and take whatever questions we have?

Speaker

unknown
#25

Thanks, John. Our first question comes from Steffen Evjen at DNB Markets. Good morning, Steffen.

Steffen Evjen

analyst
#26

Good morning. Good morning, Lars. I trust you can hear me. Thanks for clearing up the ESP details — that was quite useful. Two questions from me, both about your balance sheet and your distributions. First, I understand that if oil goes above $85, you'd likely raise both dividends and also speed up debt amortization. Given that, I'm curious what you view as the ideal net debt level going forward. My second one looks a bit further out, but it appears 2024 will be more of a transitional year, and '25 may be when all the work you're doing next year reaches its full effect. So what sort of long-term capacity do you see for dividends and buybacks, given that this growth will probably show up more in 2025 on production rather than in 2024? That's all from me.

John Hamilton

executive
#27

Yes, regarding the balance sheet and what an optimal debt level looks like. To be clear, there isn't a net debt target that we've set. If we examine our borrowings — and I'm not certain whether any of our bankers are joining the call today — what those bankers do is calculate the theoretical borrowing capacity of the assets, and from there they work out how much you could technically borrow. Without revealing all the figures, what I'd say is that this company is very under-geared. With the debt we currently carry, we feel quite comfortable. Clearly, with interest rates at high levels, that represents a burden in terms of interest cost. So we aren't sanguine about it, yet at the present debt levels we don't feel uncomfortable. As we begin to generate free cash flow, I think we would like to see those levels come down. Having a little bit of debt in the company is something we do like. For an E&P company, we view it as good discipline. I've spent a long time around this sector, and I believe that an RBL is a really important tool for a company to have.

John Hamilton

executive
#28

It brings in outside oversight, with independent reservoir engineers who come in, poke around, and pose hard questions. That kind of scrutiny is really beneficial for the company. It also gives you a ready-made arrangement that you could draw on at short notice—say you needed a new development and required drilling plus a bit of extra funding over the near term. The facility is already there, so you don't have to build it from nothing. So philosophically, I think we'd want to carry some debt on the balance sheet, though we'd keep it modest. On your point about '24: yes, I'd say we're arguably a few months behind where we'd hoped to be. Had you asked us a year ago where we expected to be with Dussafu, it has slipped—as I mentioned—to the right by 3 or 4 months, roughly, and that pushes into 2024. From what we can see in the Board's decisions regarding doubling the target for 2024, I think it reflects a genuine intent to be a highly progressive, shareholder-friendly company when it comes to returning cash.

John Hamilton

executive
#29

And like you said, once we're well into the back half of 2024 — that's basically when we move past the $70 million to $75 million of CapEx I mentioned — most of that spending really falls in the first six months of this year. But we begin to emerge from it during the latter part of the year. And clearly, '25, '26, '27 — those are years when, assuming everything stays the same, CapEx will be significantly lower. Of course, if we hit a major discovery at Bourdon, or a major discovery at Akeng Deep, then all at once we've got a nice problem to have: some extra CapEx timing plus extra reserves. But these should be years in which free cash flow, at a normalized oil price, is substantial relative to our market cap. So I think you'll keep seeing the Board take a progressive stance on distributions to shareholders. I hope that goes some way to answering your question.

Steffen Evjen

analyst
#30

Yes, that’s quite clear, John. Thanks for taking that over for me.

Speaker

unknown
#31

Thanks. Moving on, our following question comes from Stephen Foucaud at Auctus Advisors. Stephen, your line is open — please go ahead.

Stephen Foucaud

analyst
#32

Good morning, guys, and thanks for taking my questions. I have a few. So starting with the dividend for 2024. If we look at the core dividend you mention, how should we think about it relative to 2023 — is the core dividend of a similar magnitude? At least that, or what's the thought process? Trying to think — the floor cash payment at $85 a barrel. Then on Bourdon, I think the well is targeting both the Gamba and the Dentale. Could you give us an idea of how those 20 plus million barrel resources split between these two horizons? And perhaps lastly, Tunisia is becoming more important next year, so to get a sense of the materiality, what sort of percentage of CapEx do you see going to Tunisia in 2024? Thank you.

John Hamilton

executive
#33

Thank you, Stephen. Those are excellent questions regarding the core dividend. We didn't provide a specific figure. The reason we held back — and I realize many of you would very much like to hear that figure — is that we're still several months out. This program is currently underway. We want to let things develop a bit further over the coming couple of months. Then we'll return and discuss it, early in the New Year. What I can say, and should say, is that we anticipate a level above what we've been paying during the '23 cycle — we expect that core dividend to be substantial. However, we want to retain a good deal of firepower for the share buyback and/or the special dividend, depending on the share price and market circumstances. So we will come back to you. But I think you can imagine it will be considerably higher than what we've paid to date. On your second question about the Gamba and Dentale split on board — Nigel, I don't have that in front of me — I believe the bulk of the volume sits in the Gamba. There's a very large Dentale structure beneath it. Nigel, do you have that available, or is that something we may need to follow up on with Stephen, I believe.

Nigel McKim

executive
#34

Right, John, I was actually just looking into that. The figures aren’t right in front of me. I believe we’ll need to come back to it later.

John Hamilton

executive
#35

Stephen, we’ll return to that. Still, it’s a really, really attractive Gamba four-way, and that would be the primary target. The Dentale beneath it is, you know, where people historically have seen, you know, the chance that Prospect B could hold more than 100 million barrels. Much of that comes from the Dentale—the scale of the Dentale under the Gamba. My understanding is that most of the 29 sits in the Gamba, with some contribution from the Dentale. But we’ll do our best to get back to you on that. And Tunisia—Tunisia, Capex. Yes, Tunisia, Capex isn’t especially high. I don’t have the precise figures in front of me, but I would have thought about $70 million. $75 million—perhaps 10% or 15% of that will be in Tunisia; it’s not a large number. And really, it isn’t focused on major drilling campaigns; it’s on smaller-scale workovers. Depending on how you classify them, they can be classified, for tax reasons, as OpEx or Capex. But it’s not a huge number, Stephen.

Stephen Foucaud

analyst
#36

Thanks a lot — that's great.

Speaker

unknown
#37

Thank you. Our next question comes from Teodor Sveen Nilsen at SB1 Markets. Teodor, your line is unmuted — please go ahead.

Teodor Sveen-Nilsen

analyst
#38

Morning, and thank you for taking my questions. To start, I have one about exploration. From what I understand, you're planning to drill 2 exploration wells during 2024. On slide 13, regarding the resources shown for the Dussafu license, I'm curious: when should we expect you and BW Energy to go after those resources? Should any new wells be anticipated in 2024? Is this more of a 2025-or-later scenario? My second question — I won't ask about the ESPs — but I wonder whether you could comment on what production from the Dussafu license is right now, today. And a final question, which I think we've discussed before, but I want to raise it again: the general M&A market in North Africa and West Africa. Where do you see opportunities, and which ones are less likely to be looked into? Should we expect you to do anything on the M&A front over the next few years? Thanks.

John Hamilton

executive
#39

Sure. Excuse me. Regarding exploration, what we've accomplished with BW is that whenever we bring a rig out to drill additional development wells, we're both mainly focused on production rather than exploration-driven strategies. I believe we all understand that you need exploration within the E&P portfolio. It's best to pursue it while you're producing oil and have the cash flow to support it. Consequently, on this particular occasion, we've effectively been drilling two exploration wells, so Hibiscus South, which has been a discovery in Bourdon. And clearly, the Akeng Deep that you mentioned as well. And I think you'll see that trend persist. So everyone is aware that there'll be the next phase of Dussafu, the Hibiscus Ruche Phase 2, which is not a 2024 event. That's more a 2025 event. The drilling rig will return and probably the same thing will happen again, which is we will look to drill additional near field infrastructure led type of exploration prospects on that block. So I wouldn't anticipate any further exploration activity from Panoro beyond the two wells that we've mentioned. Regarding your question on Dussafu production, I mean, it was one of the reasons I wanted to try and preempt some of those questions is that production at Dussafu is extremely variable right now.

John Hamilton

executive
#40

We're closing things down and bringing things back up, so it shifts from one day to the next. Therefore, responding to that question, I believe, would be rather misleading — possibly misleading. And what I'd say is that we'll attempt to come back with an update alongside BW. And once more, we have no scheduled timing for that. My guess is it would be early in the New Year, in terms of what it is. We've made the decision — the matter concerned where production stands and which forward-looking plans exist, and how far those require discussion. Pardon me. The M&A market, I believe, I believe it keeps being dominated by big majors offloading assets, as those reach a point of immateriality for them or maybe in an effort to remove some carbon from their balance sheet, so to speak; that trend will keep showing up, and it has been running for decades now. Big firms selling small firms. That trend carries on strongly and it is intensified. It's encouraged by a few of the larger mergers that have taken place — the Anadarko, and with Chevron, Noble, the series of mergers that have occurred — and what that does is generate ongoing churn within these portfolios of these bigger companies.

John Hamilton

executive
#41

Panoro's part in that matters, I believe. I think we've presented ourselves as a highly responsible partner inside the JVs. We appear to be held in good standing in the nations where we work. So being well accepted by regulators in those nations is really important. So over the years we've put in hard effort to ensure we're viewed in our industry—so not necessarily in the stock market, but in our industry too—as a dependable party that delivers on its word. We aren't the largest company globally. So it's difficult to consider the truly large players. But opportunities will come for Panoro. I think the largest part, the largest problem for us really, and that likely applies to plenty of other companies or sectors, is that we trade at a discounted NAV. So if you're seeking to take part in the M&A market and seeking to generate money for your shareholders while you trade at a significant discount to NAV, that raises the hurdle. So we are, as you've probably heard from us previously, extremely selective. We were very, very lucky to be able to acquire the Telo assets, as we did a couple of years ago, you know, at a very, very attractive price.

John Hamilton

executive
#42

And those have proven to be great acquisitions. We are seeking that kind of opportunity where, due to some particular circumstance — maybe a corporate situation, maybe a temporary market dip, maybe something unusual — an opening arises for Panoro to genuinely attempt something smart. At the same time, we are not overly greedy. We truly have our hands full internally right now. You know, this is the busiest stretch in the company's entire history when it comes to drilling and production growth. So we really need to be somewhat careful regarding these sorts of opportunities. But the M&A landscape exists, and it exists for companies such as Panoro to take part in. Yet the deal must be the right one. I hope that answers the question in some respects.

Teodor Sveen-Nilsen

analyst
#43

Sure, that helps a lot. Appreciate it.

Andy Diamond

unknown
#44

Thanks. The following question comes from Alex Smith at Investec Securities. Alex, your line is muted — could you unmute it, please?

Alex Smith

analyst
#45

Hi there. Is my voice coming through at this point?

John Hamilton

executive
#46

Thanks, Alex.

Alex Smith

analyst
#47

Great, that covers nearly everything I asked about. If I could, a quick question about Equatorial Guinea. With that profits tax update, Akeng Deep becomes even more appealing, I'd say. And is anything else in the pipeline? I'm aware there's a fairly sizable 2C resource sitting there. But does this start to get you thinking about perhaps accelerating some of those infrastructure-led developments you have waiting in the queue, pulling them forward a bit? Or are those conversations still underway with the partners?

John Hamilton

executive
#48

Yes, absolutely. So first, on the tax. Yes, I mean, it does make everything we do — not only Akeng Deep, but it makes it much more attractive. It extends the economic life of the field out. It's then encouraging, obviously, us to drill for more wells. The government's been very, very good about that. We don't necessarily put it in the press, but, you know, they've also encouraged us to drill Akeng Deep. So, they're allowing us to cost recover some of the costs of that well from Block S into Block G. So it's effectively a way of the government trying to encourage exploration and sharing the risk with the operators for that risk. So, we're very, very pleased with the progressive nature of that opportunity. There's so much to go for in Block G. We have a lot of contingent resource. We have a huge stow-up there. There's, you know, so much oil has been generated, has already produced 500 million barrels that field. And there's just so much more to give. So, I think that this is the real first campaign that we've had with these three new wells and the exploration well. There are a couple of additional slots on that rig as well.

John Hamilton

executive
#49

Whether or not it ends up being exercised, we definitely foresee a sustained effort across the years ahead aimed at pursuing part of that 2C resource and likely uncovering additional volumes as well. Frankly, we gain a great deal from the 40 seismic surveys conducted there. So through the years, with several seismic acquisitions, it becomes possible to examine things in a way where, with the passage of time, you can observe how the oil has migrated, you can identify the areas that remain un-swept, and every subsurface indication at that location points to this field holding substantially more resource than what is booked at present. So I trust that addresses your question.

Alex Smith

analyst
#50

Yeah, no, that's very clear. Thanks.

Speaker

unknown
#51

Thanks. Our next question comes from Christopher Buck at Clarkson's. Christopher, you're muted as well. If you wouldn't mind unmuting and asking your questions. Thank you.

Christoffer Bachke

analyst
#52

Perfect. Hi, John, and hello to everyone else on the team. Thank you for taking my questions. To start with, I'd like to ask about the well campaign currently underway in Gabon, which has now been reordered to seven production wells plus one exploration well. On the timeline, do you feel confident that every one of these wells will be drilled and completed by early first half 2024? My next question concerns dividends. If production next year came in above expectations, might that result in a higher dividend payment for 2024, or would you remain within the guided NOK400 million to NOK500 million? Also, could you say a bit more about how you plan to strike a balance between dividends and the share buybacks, given that you are on such a discounted now — you may have touched upon this earlier, but please just to clarify.

John Hamilton

executive
#53

Thanks. Absolutely, glad to assist. The three wells still to be drilled at Dussafu — again, the sole remaining question at this point is precisely when we get those started. That hinges somewhat on how we proceed with the ESP campaign. But yes, our expectation would be that all 3 get drilled and completed. What was it you mentioned about the first half of this year? Likely, you know, likely perhaps all 3 wrapped up by, let's say, some point in Q2 or thereabouts. My expectation is that early in the New Year we'll be picking drilling back up — almost exactly when, I can't tell you right now. But yes, we'd anticipate all 3 wells being drilled during that window you referred to. So on exceeding — if production exceeds, would we raise the dividend? Our intention in January, as is our usual practice in January, is to try to come forward and state what the CapEx is and what we foresee our production ranges being for the year. And what underpins those production ranges is that we sit down and coordinate with the operators across each of the assets.

John Hamilton

executive
#54

We're clearly an operator in Tunisia, though we operate inside the operators' budgets, and we aim to set an expectation for what we believe production will be. That output is grounded, naturally, in timing and reservoir performance. It also reflects things like FPSO uptime — those vessels aren't available 100% of the time; it might be 95%. So perhaps, as we move into the New Year, we'll try to establish what we consider a sensible production range. And once more, we're attempting to stay consistent with where the operating budgets sit. Obviously, with our two biggest assets, I believe there's upside that could show up in the first half of the year, as we get into those wells and begin producing from them. So I think the straightforward answer is yes — of course, if production comes in line with current expectations, there's room to revisit the shareholder distribution plan, for sure. And clearly, oil prices matter given the CapEx we have, especially in the first half of the year. Even $5 swings. Christopher, your recent research report, I think, even made this point — particularly right now, at this moment in time, oil price matters, as we get over the hump.

John Hamilton

executive
#55

Naturally, that gives us far greater flexibility when it comes to the oil price. Still, I would definitely anticipate that, with all else held equal, if output comes in higher, we can speed matters up. Once more, I believe the feeling among the Board — and hopefully this comes across in these communications — is that our Board takes shareholder distributions very seriously; it isn't being cautious merely for caution's sake, nor overly bullish just to appear overly bullish. It's simply a commitment. Our Chairman is a major shareholder too. So we consider ourselves quite well aligned with what shareholders expect on that front. We will, of course, do everything we can. And should we outperform, I think that will be welcome news for everyone.

Christoffer Bachke

analyst
#56

Thanks, John. And on how dividends and share buybacks are balanced, any thoughts you could share there?

John Hamilton

executive
#57

I'll go back to what Stefan asked earlier, just a bit. Where will the core dividend land? Clearly, it will be above what we've been doing recently through share buybacks. There's a genuine sense inside the company that the stock is undervalued, and that repurchasing shares is a very effective way to deploy shareholder money — if I can phrase it that way — to buy back our shares. We're trading at a big discount to NAV, what that mix looks like right now. I'd rather not be drawn on that quite yet. Again, we still believe we're a little bit early in that cycle. We just want to enter the New Year, get our bearings, and work out exactly where we stand. But I think you'll find that share buybacks will be something we'd really like to use. We've done it before in the past, and very small ones. But you will see that it's very much in focus for the Board at the moment.

Analyst

analyst
#58

Thanks a lot.

Andy Diamond

unknown
#59

Thanks. Our following question comes from Tom Erik Kristiansen. Tom Erik, your line is now open — go right ahead.

Tom Kristiansen

analyst
#60

Thanks for taking my question. It seems to me that the dividend guidance came in pretty much as expected and was a solid one. But of the remaining capital you expect to generate, how much do you think you can put toward organic opportunities versus growing the company's underlying M&A capacity? And where does that stand right now, in your view, in terms of being able to further accelerate growth through more acquisitions?

John Hamilton

executive
#61

That's a strong strategic question. I believe what the company is doing at present is clearly delivering on what we promised. We have substantial production growth coming our way. We're fully occupied. Yet obviously, an organization such as Panoro must always weigh possibilities, be they corporate ones or asset-based ones that could need some capital allocated toward opportunistic moves. So again, this really returns to what we discussed earlier: we're identifying appealing, inventive chances in the M&A market. We will definitely be putting free cash — some free cash flow — toward those chances. But we must evaluate them against, obviously, our share price and the alternative of repurchasing our shares instead. So it's an iterative process we have to keep working through. But it's in our blood, it's in our nature as a midcap oil company to keep trying to grow. However, we don't set out production targets. We want to be a fifty thousand barrel a day producer. We don't do that, because that's essentially brainless.

John Hamilton

executive
#62

Honestly, anyone is able to purchase production. Our job is to acquire reserves and production effectively and at a low cost, with upside potential too. Technical upside. We need to complete all the proper due diligence there. So if we can locate the right opportunities that are competitive with shareholder returns when it comes to their attractiveness, then we will definitely allocate a portion of the free cash flow toward that growth.

Tom Kristiansen

analyst
#63

I've got a quick follow-up for you, John. In the market as it stands now, how easy or difficult would you say it is to locate those opportunities, relative to, say, last year, when you had oil at nearly $100 and things remained quite strong this year, though lower — call it an $80 Brent average across the year? Have seller expectations, call it, moved down toward a more realistic level, or does it remain a bit too sweet for the industry to harvest cash at these oil prices?

John Hamilton

executive
#64

I'd say it's still a touch too sweet. People are still, you know, putting in — the seller is clearly going to be looking at the forward curve or something similar, while a buyer won't be looking at that forward curve. The buyer will be assuming that oil prices fall considerably from here once you get a year or two out. And so once you begin plugging those sorts of oil prices into financial models, you still wind up with that gap between what the buyer expects and what the seller expects, which often gets bridged in transactions that we see and ones that we've even completed before, where you give the seller contingent consideration. You say, well, right, if you're correct, if oil prices are $100, you can receive some contingent consideration. 2027, if oil prices are $100, we're glad to hand some of that upside back to you. So you're finding those sorts of creative structures through deferred or contingent consideration — those are the tools required to close that gap and — maybe that's become a bit more realistic. But again, we're finding that your standard M&A opportunity where 20 oil companies are invited to bid for something, this is not — this isn't a good environment for Panoro to wade into and try to be the highest bidder on situations.

John Hamilton

executive
#65

We actually like a somewhat atypical setup — an atypical corporate setup in which Panoro holds a strong position. That could come from the fact that we're listed publicly, or from the fact that we're Norwegian, or from the fact that we're accepted in the country — where we're able to set ourselves apart from the masses, and honestly, the masses aren't all that large. In this market, for these sorts of things, there are just a handful of credible counterparties. But where we can set ourselves apart as a buyer, and where we can land on a price that works well for the company.

Tom Kristiansen

analyst
#66

All right, that's clear. Thanks.

John Hamilton

executive
#67

Thanks, Tom Erik. Andy, I figure we're at roughly an hour now. I'm not sure whether anyone still has a pressing question, but we ought to, you know, honor the hour at this point.

Andy Diamond

unknown
#68

Yeah, John, one question coming in online: could you give us some context or insight regarding the group's operating cost per barrel metrics at the company level?

John Hamilton

executive
#69

I’ll take that question, and then perhaps we can wrap things up there. If anyone still has a pressing question, you can of course get in touch with us via other channels. The three assets differ quite a bit when it comes to operating cost per barrel. We have Equatorial Guinea and Tunisia, which are, so to speak, steady-state assets, and their operating costs are kept comfortably low—it depends precisely on how you calculate operating cost per barrel. You could see something in the $18, $19 a barrel, $20 a barrel kind of territory. Dussafu has been more—well, this has been flagged. The operator comes out each quarter and provides an exact calculation of that. And that is obviously higher, closer to $30 at the moment, because we are dealing with an FPSO, which is a fixed cost. That accounts for the lion’s share, together with the O&M contract on the FPSO—it is the lion’s share of the operating cost. So the variable cost per barrel is very low. So the intention here is that as Dussafu gets up toward that kind of plateau rate, those operating costs per barrel also come down into that kind of territory. Let’s call it high teens.

John Hamilton

executive
#70

We're not at that point yet, but assuming everything unfolds as intended, we will reach it. I hope that addresses your question. As for everything else, I want to thank all of you for being with us. This has been a lengthy call, yet I'm grateful for everyone's focus and for your interest in the company, and I look forward to bringing you updates on everything happening at Panoro before long. Thank you so much.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Panoro Energy ASA transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Panoro Energy ASA earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Panoro Energy ASA or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.