Pennon Group Plc (PNN) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

November 24, 2020

London Stock Exchange GB Utilities Water Utilities earnings 47 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Morning, everyone, and thanks for joining us for today's Pennon Half Year Results call. I'm Adam, and I'll be operating the call for you. <<operator_script>> At this point I'll pass things over to our CEO, Susan Davy, to get us started. Susan, over to you.

Susan Davy

executive
#2

Thank you very much, Adam, and good morning to everyone. Paul Boote, our Group Finance Director, is with me today, and I trust all of you have had a chance to look at the slide presentation from earlier this morning. Before we move into the Q&A, I thought we might give a brief overview of those results and then open up the lines for your questions. Clearly, the pandemic has posed an unprecedented challenge to our sustainability and resilience. So I'm very pleased that, for Pennon, we are reporting robust first half results for 2020. Plainly, this has only been achievable thanks to our impressively dedicated colleagues, whose hard work has allowed us to operate as normally as possible. We are therefore very much focused on delivering for all our stakeholders and making that positive contribution. Having taken on the CEO role in August this year, I'm delighted to be leading the business at this important moment. So, first of all, you've seen the results, and speaking of the reshaping of the Pennon Group through the sale of Viridor, which completed in July, this half year, as expected, has seen significant shareholder value realized. We received GBP 3.7 billion of net cash proceeds, and you've seen the results, the GBP 1.7 billion profit on disposal.

Susan Davy

executive
#3

So what have we done with the proceeds? Well, we've been responsible. As most people would expect, we're paying down debt at the Pennon level. To date, we've repaid roughly GBP 750 million, and we've put about GBP 6 million into the Pennon pension scheme. So now we'll focus on U.K. Water — we have South West Water and Pennon Water Services, our business-to-business retailer. And we've just begun our new regulatory delivery period for South West Water, which runs out to 2025. So what matters about this 5-year period? Well, we're looking at a new deal that changes the nature of our relationship with customers, communities and people. And one part of that has been our groundbreaking, innovative WaterShare+ scheme, which has given customers a stake and a stay in the business. So we've returned GBP 20 million to customers. That comes as a result of our financial outperformance in the last regulatory period. Customers had the option of either taking a GBP 20 credit on their bill or taking a stake in Pennon with their share. Really pleased to say one in 16 household customers have opted to take the share, more than tripling the number of Pennon shareholders and demonstrating significant customer ownership for us as a listed company.

Susan Davy

executive
#4

There's a really shifting dynamic there in how we relate to customers. It isn't solely about shares, and it isn't solely about putting money back on the bill — it's also about getting the basics right. And in the presentation you'll see that during the first half of this year we've been driving operational excellence for customers. Of course, with our 5-year delivery plan now in place, we've been delivering against our commitment of 80% of our ODIs already on target or in reward across some key areas where we're delivering. So on customers and communities, and when it comes to our employees, we're very much nurturing talent, with 500 apprenticeship scheme planned over the next 5 years. And we were an early adopter of the government's Kickstart scheme, where we're bringing in individuals who are on universal credits, 16 to 24-year olds. We bring them into the business. We've already got offers out. And those individuals come into our business and then, hopefully, through that process move on to our pension scheme. With our nearly diverse share register, that means both customers and shareholders can benefit from our sector-leading dividend policy — meaning they benefit from the announcements today, where we're raising the dividend by 2% ahead of CPIH inflation, which for this half year is 2.7% overall, at 6.77p per share.

Susan Davy

executive
#5

And with that, I'll pass things along to Paul, who's going to walk us through the key points from the financials.

Paul Boote

executive
#6

Thanks, Susan, and morning to you all. Let me speak briefly about the financials. Obviously, COVID-19 has made things hard for every business during this half year. Still, I'm glad to report that Pennon has experienced only a modest net financial effect from COVID. Demand from business customers has fallen, yet that was largely balanced out by stronger demand from our household residential customers over the period. Another aspect of COVID is how it affects cash collections, and once more, I'm happy to say these stayed strong and robust throughout. Turning to Pennon Water services, our business-to-business retailer, it's good to see new revenue arriving as it secures large national contracts with sustainable businesses. All of this produces a continuing group profit to underlying profit before tax of GBP 86.7 million, and that supports our underlying earnings per share of 17.9p, which, as Susan mentioned, backs the 6.77p interim dividend for this period. It's also worth flagging that this is clearly a landmark year for the group, with the sale of Viridor recording profits after tax at GBP 1.7 billion, which, along with the continuing group profit, brings statutory profit after tax to nearly GBP 1.8 billion for this half year period.

Paul Boote

executive
#7

To sum things up, the group has delivered a robust and resilient performance. Our attention is on the water and wastewater operations that lead the sector, and we feel we are financially well placed to handle both the challenges and the opportunities as they come along. With that said, I'll hand things back to Adam, who will begin the Q&A.

Operator

operator
#8

<<operator_script>> Today's first question will be from Mark Freshney at Crédit Suisse.

Mark Freshney

analyst
#9

Mark, two questions if I may. First, regarding the possible proceeds you’ve stated at GBP 2.7 billion. Based on my figures, that would likely push you to the high 60s for RAV gearing at South West Water, assuming you returned or deployed all of it, depending on the leverage and what you acquired. My question is: given what the sector has experienced and the criticism about high leverage in recent years, wouldn’t you consider it sensible to stay definitely below 65? And my second question concerns the GBP 2.7 billion. I believe, Susan, in your prior role, you suggested there might be a capital return and a possible purchase of a water company. Today I get the sense it would be either an acquisition or a full return. Has your thinking changed on how those proceeds would be divided?

Susan Davy

executive
#10

Susan here. I'll likely take the second question first — hope you're doing well. So on your question about whether our messaging is shifting a bit regarding what we're doing with the proceeds once we've paid down the debt and then put money into the pension scheme: I think the answer is no. The message isn't really changing regarding what we said we've been doing. We've been working extensively to look at opportunities across the water sector and assets that are executable — obviously, with the water sector, that's the reason the companies are in it — and we're looking to see if we can deliver something that gives attractive financial returns or benefits to customers. I think we've always said it's compelling value, and opportunities of favorable capital will be returned to shareholders; obviously, we haven't defined what that mix of balance may be. And obviously, that will depend on where we get to with that review. So the metric hasn't changed. And certainly, no nuancing should be taken from any of the work we've put out today. So very much as we were working through the potential for opportunities, obviously balancing that and benchmarking it against a return of capital to shareholders, but obviously, we will update in due course when we finish that review.

Susan Davy

executive
#11

Paul, would you like to handle the question about gearing and the RAV?

Paul Boote

executive
#12

Yes, absolutely. Let me begin with this. In the slide deck, there was that slide you mentioned showing the GBP 2.7 billion figure. Essentially, that chart lays out the announced uses of proceeds we have identified so far. As you know, we have consistently spoken about reducing a certain level of debt and about making pension contributions. It also illustrates how you bridge from the GBP 4.2 billion enterprise value, so to speak, for Viridor down to the GBP 3.7 billion in cash proceeds. And then the announced uses of proceeds. Obviously, that reflects the position as announced, and as Susan mentioned, the reshaping of the group is plainly still in progress, and we are in that transitional phase at present. So as we proceed through that and work through opportunities and consider shareholder returns, at that stage you would clearly expect a further announcement at some point concerning those uses of proceeds, which would then be reflected in that GBP 2.7 billion. So I would not interpret it quite the way you have, as though there is a definitive plan to do something with GBP 2.7 billion, and that gearing would therefore rise significantly from where we stand today.

Operator

operator
#13

The next person to ask a question is Jenny Ping from Citi.

Jenny Ping

analyst
#14

Three questions from me, please. So looking at one of your presentation slides, Slide 24, which covers the 8% RORE in the first half. And if I focus specifically on the financing, the 2.1% with the effective interest rate of 2.5% versus the GBP 4.2 million of Ofwat, how much of that would -- the differential will you be able to keep for Pennon shareholders, i.e., what is the portion that's ultimately going to be clawed back through the netting process at the end of the regulatory review? And if you can give us an update on whether Ofwat has given any more visibility on how to deal with that, that would be great. And then the second question is just on the M&A point following Mark's questions. I just wondered whether you can give us a sense of how you're approaching it, whether you have got specific targets inside, which you are effectively negotiating or then starting conversations with the management? Or are you sort of doing the sum, so to speak? And then -- or approaching whichever companies that actually are willing to talk and then bring the sum. So which way around is, if you can give us an idea of how you're going about this.

Jenny Ping

analyst
#15

And now for the final question — regarding ODI versus totex, you clearly mentioned totex outperformance during the first half and a negative ODI-on-totex position. One of your peers has argued that it's preferable to deliver on ODIs even at a potential cost on the totex side, since ODI benefits repeat over the 5 years rather than being a one-off 1 year impact. How do you view that in the context of South West Water?

Susan Davy

executive
#16

Thanks for those questions. On the first one, about the financial outperformance — or financing outperformance, sorry — regarding the gap between Ofwat's allowed returns and the effective rate, and where we stand: obviously, we're financing, and there is a sharing rate as such when it comes to financing. So it's unlike totex and the work we're doing on sharing for that, and how the consumer methodology on financing differs. And yes, it was attracting — I mean, I got to that — but there is a sharing rate as such. One thing we have done, though, and some of you may be aware of this from the last regulatory period, is that we have a sharing mechanism called WaterShare+, where — as is being done this time around — when we have an overall net benefit in terms of financial outperformance for the regulatory period, we will share benefits back with customers. And a lot of times, we did put customer fee and financing outperformance into that mechanism to share with customers, which we will do again this time to have a net overall outperformance for the business, which obviously, we're targeting to do.

Susan Davy

executive
#17

To begin with, there’s no regulatory mechanism for sharing around finance. So I’d say, clearly, based on our business plan and what we’ve done this time around, we’re very eager to share that outperformance with our customers. And then maybe I’ll take question 3 before question 2, since in a way it’s kind of tied to these ODIs, and whether it’s better too that we’re delivering on your ODIs rather than on totex. So yes, we very much plan to deliver on our ODIs. We’ve made a good start in this first half period, where we’re delivering 80% of our commitment either on track or on target. There are a couple where we obviously need to focus, and the specific one around pollution, so we’re very much focused on delivering those ODIs. And it’s not all about investment. It’s also about our processes and our systems and how we organize ourselves. So we’re very much focused on improving ODIs, but we also think it’s really important to be as efficient as we can be, and that’s why we always focus on our cost base and make sure that we’re driving ourselves to be more innovative.

Susan Davy

executive
#18

And you can find plenty of instances across our business where innovation is stepping up. Take our treatment logos, for example, and the network centers we're installing too, which are genuinely helping us push some of that totex efficiency forward. So delivering on that totex efficiency really matters, since it brings customers' bills down and, over the long run, gives investors a return as well. So it's a matter of concentrating on both, and we are 100% focused on those, and we are 100% delivering on both too. So that covers 2 answers for 2 questions, 1 and 3. Then when it comes to M&A, obviously there are lots of questions about that, I'm sure, regarding what we're doing and how we're going about it. We are being extremely disciplined in how we approach this. We're examining our opportunities, and we've narrowed down what we're assessing, but there's nothing else we can report or announce today on that front. Still, as we go through that review, we are evaluating opportunities to make sure they are only treated, that value creation is present, and that covers the effect on shareholder returns, income and growth, along with the impact on customers and stakeholders too.

Susan Davy

executive
#19

And we’re measuring that against what we return to shareholders. We know who — when it comes to our track record on acquisitions, with the Bournemouth Water deal and the fact that it clearly turned out very well for us and worked very well for customers too. So our attention is on examining those opportunities. We’re narrowing things down. We’ve been working very diligently on that across the last few months, but there’s nothing else to announce on that today, Jenny.

Jenny Ping

analyst
#20

Sorry, perhaps a quick follow-up on that first question. What really caught my attention was the indexation piece. Could you say more about it? Of that gap between the 4.2% million and 2.5%, how much will effectively be handed back through the indexation mechanism?

Susan Davy

executive
#21

We do have the iBoxx trading, which relates to what new debt costs, and clearly we'll be doing that trued up at PR24. But as for the figures we've reported today, I'd say the effect is small, though obviously we can come back to that one.

Paul Boote

executive
#22

Yes. And obviously the iBoxx trading does go up across that period. So, as we set things at the beginning, that would mean less of an impact during this initial stretch.

Operator

operator
#23

Dominic Nash from Barclays has our next question.

Dominic Nash

analyst
#24

I have just a couple of questions, if I may. First, on ODIs: you mentioned that you're performing well on 80%, but clearly pollution incidents are pulling that down somewhat. There have been quite a few recent press reports about the environment agency and raw sewage being discharged into rivers. What Star ratings does your EPA currently have? And do you believe you're on track to hit your 4 Star target, I think, by 2024? My second question is about totex. It appears that your run rate in the first half matches AMP6, and what we're asking is whether you think you can gain momentum in outperforming totex from this point, so that we can actually see the proportion of totex outperformance rise from here? Or do you think the efficiency targets will keep you constrained as we move through this current review?

Susan Davy

executive
#25

All right, thank you for those questions, Dominic. So to begin with, regarding the ODIs and efficiency — yes, definitely, we performed strongly in the first half period, with 80% either on track or beating target. Yes, pollution is an area of focus for us. And when you look at our ODIs, which are divided among bespoke, common, and common comparative — it's within common comparative that we have the 3: internal sewage flooding, leakage, and supply interruptions — so bespoke is performing really well. And then there's pollutions, which is generating a GBP 4.9 million negative impact for this half year. So we're putting a lot more effort into pollutions. Obviously, that comes from bespoke. In August, we changed the management team in wastewater, we've restructured our approach with supply chain, and we are pinpointing a number of hotspots across our region that we're concentrating on and assigning for improvement, and that work is underway. And in fact, it's early days, yes, but certainly, month by month, since August, we've observed a solid decrease in the count of pollution incidents that we're seeing. So I'm happy with the progress we're making, but there remains much more to do. So onto your question about the EPA.

Susan Davy

executive
#26

Right now, we're a 2 Star company. And yes, our goal is to reach 4 Star, and without question our plan along with our pollution incident reduction plan is going to take us to that 4 Star position, which we aim to achieve by the close of this regulatory peak period, and we're putting every kind of change and plan in place so that we deliver that surveillance plan alongside it. And then the totex run rate? As for the run rate, yes, it's a very similar run rate to what we had in AMP6. I believe we mentioned in the presentation that we saw good delivery in this first half year, and based on the work we're doing internally and the efficiencies we can see locked in, we can see that run rate carrying on through K7.

Operator

operator
#27

<<operator_script>> James Brand from Deutsche Bank has our next question.

James Brand

analyst
#28

I’ve got 3 questions. There’s a fair amount happening in these results. My first one concerns ODIs, I suppose, and the overall scale of outperformance—and you’ve just addressed Dom’s question about totex. So if we’re looking at incentive outperformance, excluding financing, for the remainder of the period, it ultimately sounds as though it may hinge on ODIs and on whether you can lift your performance in that area. So I wanted to ask whether you could give some expectations on whether you anticipate that modest outperformance to strengthen as we move through the period? And whether that might ultimately prove material. Certainly, one of the hopes has been that opportunities on ODIs for companies to do that would net in during the last period. My second question is about acquisitions. You mentioned Bournemouth, though obviously I won’t ask you to comment on any specific potential targets, but there have been press reports that you are examining large targets. I wondered whether you could just share how you see your ability to secure synergies from a large target versus a small one? With Bournemouth, it was very easy—maybe not easy, but you stripped out a lot of their costs, which is perhaps harder to do with a large water company?

James Brand

analyst
#29

And then third, a quick one. You mentioned a limited COVID impact that was in line — I think you said you expected a GBP 10 million impact at the beginning of the year for the full year. Is it in line? When you say you're in line, are you kind of half that at GBP 10 million, is it GBP 5 million in H1?

Susan Davy

executive
#30

Yes, James. To begin with your first question about ODIs — if you look at our half-year results and strip out the effect of the pollution's ODI, we'd be at roughly a GBP 4 million reward position for this half year. So can we see rewards? Yes, we can, and we're delivering on them, and it's a key focus area for these solutions, but of course, regarding Dominic's questions, I'll discuss the work we're doing there, and it's significant in terms of that work. And as I said, we've changed our processes, we've changed our management team. We're focused on hotspot interventions, and we're on that 7 to 8 weeks. And I'm leaving boards on that 7 days a week to make sure we can turn that performance around. So very much focused on delivering on the ODIs. On acquisitions, yes, we saw synergies from Bournemouth Water. But as you'd imagine, for any water company coming together, whether it's large or small, there will be some synergies to make both operationally and financially as a result of that. Obviously, from Bournemouth Water, there were learnings that we took into Bournemouth Water and vice versa.

Susan Davy

executive
#31

You can picture that happening with whatever mix you end up with. Those are exactly the kinds of analysis we do as we examine opportunities throughout the sector. Paul, would you like to take the COVID question?

Paul Boote

executive
#32

Yes, absolutely. So in these results, we have laid out a COVID impact—a total revenue hit of GBP 10 million—along with an impact on profit before tax of GBP 5 million. The slight gap between those 2 figures comes about because a portion of that GBP 10 million is tied to Pennon Water Services, outside the South West Water region's revenue. So when that amount falls for Pennon Water Services as well, the group's costs come down too. As a result, on that piece of the COVID revenue reduction there is minimal PBT effect, since you are only considering the margin—specifically the non-household retail margin. So those are the figures that have in effect flowed through into the results. They match what we anticipated, as we laid out back in June. And the guidance we have in effect reaffirmed on a net basis is very much the same for this—for the full year, as we see it now. So at this stage we are not anticipating any further material impact. Though obviously, we do need to keep watching that, because it does hinge to some degree on how the pandemic develops and on continued government support measures.

Paul Boote

executive
#33

That being said, I believe the biggest effect was clearly during April and May, and since then things appear to have steadied to some degree.

Operator

operator
#34

The next person to ask a question is Fraser McLaren from Bank of America.

Fraser McLaren

analyst
#35

I have a few questions, please. First, about that press speculation that you might consider acquisition targets significantly bigger than South West Water. I'm wondering: in a scenario where you wanted to do more than existing resources would allow, would you be open to including new equity as part of any deal so that you can still return some cash to your shareholders? Second, on the time line, will you set an actual deadline for making a decision on user cash either way, and thereby provide clarity? And finally, just seeking clarity on the dividend, 6.77p for the first half, perhaps somewhat lower than a simple 1/3 split of the previously indicated 22p. May I just check whether 22p remains the plan for the full year, all else being equal?

Susan Davy

executive
#36

Fraser, I hope you're doing well too. I'll begin with the first question, which is about acquisitions and larger opportunities. What I mean is, as I mentioned earlier, Fraser, we're now working extensively on the potential opportunities out there, and we haven't really ruled anything in with respect to the speculation surrounding that. So we're working diligently on it. And regarding your question about new efficacy and so on, around returns — again, we've simply been very disciplined in how we approach assessing those opportunities. We're looking at whether they're earnings accretive, we'll examine value creation, and we'll consider what serves the best interests of both shareholders and customers in doing so. And everything we do will be benchmarked against returning capital to shareholders. So I'm afraid, Fraser, that's pretty much all there is. As for the time line or timetable around it, as I said, we've been working extensively. We'll keep doing the same through to the end of that review, and obviously we'll update everyone on the outcome, and we have been narrowing down what we've been looking at, but we aren't in a position to make an investment at that step.

Paul Boote

executive
#37

Alright. And regarding that dividend question you just raised, let me just clarify how that figure was calculated. So you'll recall that back in June, we announced a new dividend policy that talked about moving from a base of 21.11p. That's very much still the case in arriving at the 6.77p — the calculation involved taking last year's interim and final and expressing them as a proportion of the 21.11p. So it might not be a straightforward simple term, but that's how the calculation was done to keep it moving in line with historic trends.

Operator

operator
#38

The following question is from Verity Mitchell at HSBC.

Verity Mitchell

analyst
#39

I have a couple of quick technical questions, if I may. First, regarding Isles of Scilly, how should we view that in relation to the FD, considering you spent roughly GBP 36 million? I mean, how does that fit alongside South West Water? Then, on your technical guidance for tax, you have GBP 15.6 million. Should we treat that as the figure for the remainder of the AMP, or is a steadily rising profile what we should expect? And lastly, I was curious about your common ODIs. You mentioned pollution incidence. One of them concerns reducing per capita consumption — how are you going about achieving that, which is clearly something Ofwat takes an interest in when it comes to water conservation?

Susan Davy

executive
#40

Okay, Verity, I trust you're doing well. Thank you for those questions. Let me begin with the Isles of Scilly. Yes, we began operating the Isles of Scilly starting in April of this year. And even with COVID, we've clearly managed to get our operational teams and our supply chain established and to begin making the investments that are required on those islands. That GBP 36 million referenced in the slides is the investment that has been permitted — it's a determination covering the 5-year period. So that's what that figure represents. It applies to the entire 5-year period, not what we've reported for this first half year. And of course, that has been included in the determination and formed part and parcel of it. So Paul, would you like to take up the tax-related ones?

Paul Boote

executive
#41

Yes, absolutely. So in the guidance, we laid out what the continuing group's prior current tax rate was for '19/'20. You will have noticed that for this half year, we're arriving at approximately 14%, which is a bit lower. Regarding movements from here, yes, I'd likely expect that it would edge upward in the direction of a U.K. effective rate, without quite reaching it, though I do anticipate a rising trajectory given that we have capital allowances and depreciation movements that will unwind over time, and so you'd expect a natural move back up. For this year, though, we clearly got off to a good start and currently sit at 14% for the current year's current tax rate.

Susan Davy

executive
#42

Alright. Thanks, Paul. Now regarding consumption per person, Verity — I mean, that has been one of the things we've concentrated on, and it's likely no shock to those listening today, but with the stay-at-home rules and the reality that those have applied from the start of this financial year. Still, we have observed a rise in — we've spoken about the growth we've seen from households when it comes to what they use. So consumption per person has gone up during this year. So it's something we are actively addressing and examining. We've carried out considerable outreach with customers to figure out how we can assist with messaging about using water efficiently. And certainly, we've put in a great deal of effort. It's less about seeing how we can discuss with our customers becoming more efficient with water. And one item we're concentrating on across this 5-year period, and we're discussing in terms of the build-up, improving the green recovery, is our Smarter Healthier Homes program. So that involves exploring how we could pilot smart metering inside customers' homes, while at the same time examining leakage from their connection pipes, since we know leakage results — in fact roughly 1/3 of leakage originates from leaks on the customer side of their property.

Susan Davy

executive
#43

We’re therefore examining ways we could collaborate with customers so they use water more efficiently — installing those smart metering systems, potentially repairing the pipe and addressing the leakage occurring on that side, while also considering how that approach could be extended across the region. There is clearly far more activity on the PVC side there, but it may not surprise people that PVC has risen for us during this first half year.

Operator

operator
#44

<<operator_script>> We'll take our next question from Martin Young at Investec.

Martin Young

analyst
#45

I trust everyone is doing well. I have just a few questions once more regarding the M&A side. So I noticed there was a bit of back-and-forth surrounding Fraser's equity question. That said, if I examine how the water companies out there are owned, a lot of them have several owners. Would you be open to a scenario in which you acquire a majority stake, though not 100% ownership, of any business you might look to buy? And my second question concerns the CMA, which in its provisional findings for the appellant has essentially set aside the gearing outperformance sharing mechanism. Does that create the possibility that you could operate an acquired business at a greater level of gearing than the notional, provided you aren't undermining financial resilience, whether of what that business does or of what the group does overall? Since clearly, that represents a different way of looking at what you may or may not be able to consider?

Susan Davy

executive
#46

Alright. Martin, I hope you're doing well too. So regarding your question — first of all, on M&A, when it comes to ownership, in situations where there are multiple owners, would we be comfortable holding a majority rather than 100%, if we decided to pursue something along those lines? So in terms of what we've said before, I can probably point back to the earlier question about efficiencies and synergies and how those would work. Our view is that we could only achieve that by taking a majority stake in the business, so that you have operational control. Otherwise, unlocking that would be quite difficult. So as for us simply investing in a minority stake in another water business, we haven't given that. And as a result, you wouldn't necessarily capture all the logistics benefits that could flow from it. I think that probably covers that question. On the CMA provisional findings — and they are provisional — I think we shouldn't try to guess their final results from those until February now, so we'll wait and see where that lands. But on your point about gearing, I mean, we obviously want to make sure we're being very responsible and very sustainable with our balance sheet going forward.

Susan Davy

executive
#47

When it comes to the ideal gearing level, that is clearly a matter we would look at. But speaking technically, as Pennon Group, you will have observed the historical position we have always maintained both at South West Water and subsequently at Pennon Group regarding our gearing levels. And the fact that the water business has always sat within that notional Ofwat range. And historically, that has always been between 55% and 65%. For Pennon Group, we had gearing around 70% in terms of our gearing levels. So we have always ensured that we maintain a sustainable balance sheet, and that is something we will be focusing on going forward as well.

Martin Young

analyst
#48

Let me just quickly follow up on the response to the first question — if someone wants to come in as your financial partner, should I take from what you said that you'd be comfortable with something like 80% of your share and 20% going to that financial partner?

Susan Davy

executive
#49

I think, Martin, it really boils down to what that structure was — it would still come down to ensuring we could unlock those operational and synergistic benefits. So provided we can unlock that, then the structure is probably a secondary consideration in that sense. But yes, we can make sure that — I think with Bournemouth Water that we can allot those initiatives, benefits, then whatever structure works.

Operator

operator
#50

Chris Laybutt from Morgan Stanley has our next question.

Chris Laybutt

analyst
#51

I really only had a single question. Just to pick up where we left off regarding the bigger targets, since we're moving away from that topic. Have you discussed with Ofwat the way you'd report 2 large entities within your group? And would you combine them and report them as one? Or would you keep them apart? Do you have a preference, I suppose, over the sort of medium to longer term — I realize there will be some near-term requirement to report them separately. But how do you see that reporting structure over the longer term?

Susan Davy

executive
#52

Yes. That's a good question, Chris. So I mean, I think one aspect is reporting. And another aspect, I think, is delivery. So whatever we did as a combination, as it is with Bournemouth, we acquired Bournemouth Water, and we focused on delivering the synergistic benefits from that combination. For that 5-year period, we did report separately for Bournemouth Water. But we did obviously make sure we delivered all the efficiencies that we have to deliver through that. So I think reporting is one aspect, but the delivery is really the key focus to that value being unlocked and being created.

Operator

operator
#53

We’re going to take a follow-up question from Mark Freshney at Crédit Suisse.

Mark Freshney

analyst
#54

Let me ask a follow-up on the turnaround and integration plans. Thinking back to what you and your predecessors went through, Pennon was a mid-length company back in 2006, and it took a 10-year process to make it the Frontier company. Looking at some of the other businesses in the water sector, many have gone through multiple management teams and multiple failings, and they've let consumers down. So my guess is that turning a company around, gathering synergies, and getting it where it needs to be would be a 10 or 15-year project, at minimum. At what point, when you're looking at some of these companies, would you say, look, this is simply too difficult? It isn't worth it. The reputational risk is too great. We don't want to put South West Water in danger — let's just pass on this and return the cash to shareholders. Presumably there is a point, and there is a threshold, when you weigh up the risks.

Susan Davy

executive
#55

Yes. Well, that's a good question, Martin. Naturally, we've been examining every possibility regarding their financial and operational standing, and how a merger involving the 2 companies could work to unlock benefits for both customers and shareholders. So we would certainly be considering that, just as we did with Bournemouth, to ensure we could achieve a fit there. On your point about how those benefits and synergies could be unlocked — for Bournemouth, we essentially unlocked phase I. And within the past 12 months, we had captured that substantial amount in terms of operational know-how, efficiencies, and learnings, both from Bournemouth to South West and from South West back to Bournemouth. So as far as a combination goes, that can be unlocked pretty quickly. Regarding your point about companies that may be in differing positions operationally and performance-wise, and how we would unlock that — well, I think we've always demonstrated that we're a very agile management team. We've acted very swiftly to make changes within the group whenever required, both on the Viridor side and on the water side.

Susan Davy

executive
#56

And we’re in a very strong position to do that moving forward too, as well as as needed.

Operator

operator
#57

Dominic Nash from Barclays has our next question.

Dominic Nash

analyst
#58

Apologies — just a quick follow-up from me. On that GBP 34 million totex outperformance, could you break down where within the price control you managed to achieve it, please?

Susan Davy

executive
#59

On the totex platform, we divide that between 2/3 and 1/3 — what we call the capital program versus our day-to-day operating costs — so that's 2/3, 1/3. And given the plans we have in place through the remainder of the K period, that split is pretty much what we'll see, though we might see a bit more OpEx come out as our efficiency plans take hold this year and in future years. But roughly 2/3, 1/3.

Dominic Nash

analyst
#60

Okay. And regardless of whether we’re talking about retail, bioresources, or waste treatment as well. Do we have a breakdown showing where you’re performing above average?

Susan Davy

executive
#61

Yes. That's a good question. I mean, we're delivering efficiencies pretty much in every area. I'd say on the waste side we're probably delivering slightly more efficiencies, but that's mainly because it's a bigger chunk of the business — yet across all areas of the business, we are delivering efficiencies.

Operator

operator
#62

The last question we have now comes as a follow-up from Fraser McLaren at Bank of America.

Fraser McLaren

analyst
#63

I have a couple of quick follow-ups, if that's alright. I presume you've been in discussions with Ofwat regarding your plans in principle. I'm just curious what your thinking is on whether, to secure regulatory approval, you'd have to pass on merger savings on top of the mechanisms already in place? And then last, a quick question about interest costs. Of that interest rate beat in the first half, how much is attributable to lower RPI, please?

Susan Davy

executive
#64

All right. Thank you, Fraser, for those follow-up questions. I mean, I mentioned that we are examining opportunities. I mentioned that we have been through <<inaudible>> where we stand. We have not reached the point where we are disclosing any specifics on that, and that applies to all stakeholders. We are not there yet. So I don't think we probably need to discuss the upside of it at this point. And then regarding interest rates...

Paul Boote

executive
#65

Yeah, let me just briefly address that, Fraser. So we mentioned the 2.5% effective interest rate for the period. That's 90 basis points better than the same period a year ago. And I believe we've said that more than half of that benefit came through active management and how we've deployed our hedging strategy through it. As for the remainder, the biggest pieces of that remainder tie back to inflation movements.

Operator

operator
#66

That brings us to the last question for today. I'll now turn things back over to the management team for their closing remarks.

Susan Davy

executive
#67

All right. Thanks a lot, and thanks to all of you for being with us this morning. I realize everyone is extremely busy right now. So thank you so much, and I'm sure we'll all reconnect before long. Thank you.

Paul Boote

executive
#68

I appreciate that.

Operator

operator
#69

That brings us to the end of today’s call, everyone. We really appreciate you being with us. You’re welcome to disconnect your lines now.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Pennon Group Plc transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Pennon Group Plc earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Pennon Group Plc or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.