Pennon Group Plc (PNN) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

June 3, 2021

London Stock Exchange GB Utilities Water Utilities earnings 51 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Good day, everyone, and welcome to the Q&A portion of Pennon Group plc's Full Year Results 2021 call — apologies for that. I'm Emily, and I'll be coordinating today's call, where Paul Boote and Susan Davy from Pennon Group are with us. <<operator_script>> At this point, I'm glad to hand things over to your host, Susan Davy, to get us started. Susan, over to you.

Susan Davy

executive
#2

Thanks, Emily, and good morning, everyone. I appreciate you all taking the time to join us this morning. I figured it would be helpful to briefly walk through the results we released today. It's a pleasure to report on what has been a truly transformative year for Pennon, and we have been reshaping the group. Maybe I'll begin with last year's sale of Viridor, which brought in net cash proceeds of GBP 3.7 billion. On the use of those proceeds, we concentrated on three areas. The first area is that we've been putting the group on a sustainable footing. So, as any responsible employer would, we've been reducing leverage on the balance sheet by GBP 1.2 billion. We've also made extra contributions into the pension fund amounting to GBP 0.1 billion. That covers the first set of actions. The second is reinvesting in U.K. water. So today, we're announcing that we are acquiring Bristol Water for GBP 0.4 billion — a logical, accretive deal for a great water company based in the South West. And on top of that, we're putting in a further GBP 0.1 billion to support South West, to build back better through some of the investments we have planned in the South West Water region.

Susan Davy

executive
#3

That covers pillar number two. Pillar number three, then, is about rewarding our loyal shareholders — two-thirds of whom are U.K.-based pension funds, charities, employees, and quite possibly customers. And we intend to return GBP 1.5 billion of special dividends, plus a further GBP 0.4 billion to fund the share buyback program, which will depend on additional growth opportunities that we might look at in the stretch out to September next year. So that's the first piece of this morning's presentation. The second piece concerns the continuing group's results for 2021. So we've made a robust start against what is ascribed to the 2025 regulatory delivery period, operationally as well as financially. 80% of our business plan commitments are on track or ahead of target. And we're delivering a return on regulated equity performance of 7.8%. On the Pennon Water Services side, we're growing in the business customer market. And we've had GBP 20 million of annualized contract wins over this last year. So that performance underpins our sector-leading dividend policy of CPIH plus 2%, as well as resetting that going forward. Given all the changes I've just described today, we'll be rebasing that dividend by 2p or 9% going forward.

Susan Davy

executive
#4

With that said, I’ll turn things back to Emily for the Q&A.

Operator

operator
#5

<<operator_script>> Our first question comes from Martin Young from Investec.

Martin Young

analyst
#6

So I have a couple of questions. First, regarding Bristol Water, on the earlier call there was a mention of totex synergies and benefits for the broader stakeholder group across the greater South West. Could you expand on both of those points, and maybe attach some financial quantum to the totex synergies? Then my second question is really a general one for the water industry. Clearly, the small map you showed of the greater South West area indicates your ownership of South West Water, your ownership of Bournemouth Water, and your new ownership of Bristol Water as of today. There is a piece in the middle, Wessex Water. Should we be taking a longer-term view and considering whether the best structure for the water industry in England and Wales is one of integrated greater regional companies? This is not me asking whether you would acquire Wessex Water at some point. It is just about the longer-term challenges for water in this country and whether those challenges would be better addressed by greater regional companies covering both the clean water side and the waste water side?

Susan Davy

executive
#7

Alright, and many thanks for those questions. Maybe I'll begin with the first one, which concerned the advantages we anticipate from Bristol Water joining the Pennon Group and how those will play out over the months and years ahead. Honestly speaking, we regard the acquisition of Bristol Water as a terrific opportunity. Back in 2015, when we went through the experience of buying Bournemouth Water, we submitted our proposals to Ofwat and the CMA to show how customers of both companies stood to gain from that kind of acquisition and merger. That was set to bring improvements to services as well as advantages on the cost base, through operating in a manner capable of delivering that. Once again, we will be putting those proposals before both Ofwat and the CMA to lay out precisely how we believe that will function going forward. And we firmly believe that is a strong position to be in. We also find it genuinely exciting that we are bringing another company into the listed market, which we see as a great thing to do, and our customers and employees will gain from that taking place.

Susan Davy

executive
#8

That likely addresses the first question. Now, turning to your second one, Martin: do we believe contiguous geography is required for these arrangements to succeed? It doesn't have to be contiguous, necessarily. As you noted, Bristol sits inside the greater South West, and there's another company in the South West too. And of course, we've carefully worked through what we see as a strong opportunity for us. Still, contiguous advantages aren't strictly required for these things to work. That said, it's an interesting point you raise there, Martin.

Operator

operator
#9

James Brand of Deutsche Bank has our next question.

James Brand

analyst
#10

Congrats on the deal. I've got two questions, really, and the first one has a few parts to it. First question is about dates — and sorry if you've already laid this out somewhere and I just missed it. On the capital return, is there a fixed date for that, or at least some indication? Then on the buyback, does it start right away and run over a 12-month period, or does it begin at a later date and then run for 12 months? And the third part on dates is whether you have an expectation for how long Ofwat's — I suppose it's more of a CMA review — how long that will take? That's the first one, on dates. And then second, Bristol was obviously one of the companies that went through the CMA. And setting aside the fact that there should be room for significant totex synergies as part of the integration, I think one of the reasons Bristol went to the CMA is that it disagreed with Ofwat on costs. And although some of the companies did get uplifts to their totex allowances, those weren't huge.

James Brand

analyst
#11

I guess I was hoping you might share a few reflections on how Bristol felt, as a standalone company, coming out of that CMA process—or how you think it came out of it—and on whether the totex allowances, looked at on a standalone basis, seem more reasonable following that appeal?

Susan Davy

executive
#12

Alright, thanks, James. So, Paul, would you like to take on the question about the dates?

Paul Boote

executive
#13

Yes. Regarding the timing for the special dividend — I believe that's what you meant — we have a few dates laid out. First, it's worth noting that we're proposing that special dividend alongside a consolidation exercise. That consolidation will go before the general meeting, scheduled for the 28th of June. Then, provided shareholders give their approval, the dividend gets paid in July — on the 16th of July. I think that likely covers your question there. As for the buyback, to keep it orderly, we'll clearly wait until the consolidation process wraps up, assuming shareholders do approve it. Once that share consolidation finishes in July, we'll then be in a position to start the buyback program. We expect the GBP 400 million buyback program to wrap up by the 30th of September 2022. So I think that hopefully addresses your questions about the dividend dates. On the Ofwat/CMA process — obviously, these things take however long they take, to some degree. As you know, we do have past experience with this kind of activity.

Paul Boote

executive
#14

We're clearly thinking in terms of weeks and months here. Maybe roughly 6 months is a reasonable point to focus on, though it could obviously be plus or minus from that.

Susan Davy

executive
#15

Alright, thanks, Paul. Then regarding your question, James, about the totex for Bristol Water — clearly, Bristol Water went through the CMA process, and that ended up where it ended up. I think they essentially got back to almost where the original business plan stood. So I won't really be commenting on that process or its outcome. What matters most, I think, is that we concentrate on what we're doing going forward to ensure Bristol Water can, clearly, deliver on its plan. And when we look at the RORE potential for Bristol Water, you can see there that they have the potential to reach, to some degree, a return on regulated equity that falls within the plan as determined. So opportunities exist for customers and for the business to deliver on that plan. And that's something we will be supporting them to achieve.

Operator

operator
#16

Mark Freshney of Crédit Suisse has our next question.

Mark Freshney

analyst
#17

I've got four questions in total, but I'll hold back and only put two. On the filings you submit to the CMA, there's clearly a chance for you to offer what could be described as remedies, which would help offset any concerns raised elsewhere by Ofwat. I believe you touched on some of the issues around those arguments. But will you be putting remedies forward as part of the process to secure merger clearance? And second, building on that, on the subject of synergies, I know the presentation highlights what the synergies could be. But obviously there are gains from removing costs, sharing best practice and buying power, and so on. So could you address both of those points, please?

Susan Davy

executive
#18

Yes, absolutely. So again, those are two more excellent questions. Regarding the process we'll be going through with Ofwat and the CMA, from where I sit, everyone involved is after the same things here. We're all seeking the same result. And we want services delivered to customers. The efficiency benefit — we've revised that once more — can ultimately mean lower bills for customers down the road. Now, when you actually work through the process with Ofwat and the CMA, what's being asked is whether there's a detriment that needs remedying through that process. Now, first of all, you have to establish whether a detriment exists or not. Now, setting all of that aside, we believe the right course of action is to do what we did when we acquired Bournemouth Water and what we've shown with South West Water — that we can provide outstanding service to our customers and achieve efficiency that ultimately ends up with the villages benefiting customers going forward. And that's something we'll be concentrating on. So we will be submitting our proposal to Ofwat and the CMA that lays out why we believe this will be a great deal for customers and for the Bristol business.

Susan Davy

executive
#19

That covers that piece. Whether you choose to label them remedies or not, as I mentioned, strictly speaking, that would assume some detriment existed that needed remedying. Beyond that, though, we believe it's the correct course of action. Clearly, we'll be examining what can be shared with customers. Clearly, we'll be examining how we ensure Bristol Water's balance sheet sits in a solid position as we move forward, including where we concentrate regarding things like our gearing levels. And we'll ensure it's an excellent package for everyone. So that's likely the main point to make there. Then the second question concerned synergies. I believe you nailed it there, Mark, regarding which synergies there will be. Well, operationally, for instance, we know that at South West Water — as you'll see in the presentation released today — our performance on supply interruptions has been very strong this year. We've achieved one of those supply interruption metrics, our 2025 target, during this year. So that's been outstanding. And we know it's an area where Bristol has not yet hit the target in its business plan.

Susan Davy

executive
#20

So once more, there will be lessons that are going to be excellent to pass along. And on the flip side, when it comes to CMF performance, Bristol Water sits above the average. Meanwhile, South West Water's CMF performance is a bit below average. And once more, I believe there will be things South West Water is able to pick up from Bristol Water. And it truly is going to be the best of the best. So we are really enthusiastic about these opportunities and really enthusiastic about what this is able to achieve, not only for customers but for the wider sector as well. Bringing another company back onto the listed market is a wonderful thing to witness.

Operator

operator
#21

<<operator_script>> The next person to ask a question is Chris Laybutt with Morgan Stanley.

Chris Laybutt

analyst
#22

The first question is about the GBP 400 million buyback — I suppose, does that proceed as currently planned if you do land any other opportunities on the M&A front in there becoming 18 months? And then secondly, regarding Bristol's performance in fiscal '21, you've provided some pro forma unaudited information. Could you give us a sense of their RORE?

Susan Davy

executive
#23

Alright. Paul, how about you handle the question about the buyback?

Paul Boote

executive
#24

Yes. On the buybacks, we laid out the figure of GBP 400 million, and we've described that as a program running through 30th of September 2022. And you're correct — should attractive growth opportunities emerge during that window, we might consider deploying that financial flexibility if a compelling opportunity does appear. So that's certainly a possibility. As you know from Pennon's history, we have obviously made acquisitions before, with Bournemouth Water, which clearly had an equity placing alongside it at the time, and then obviously today, with Bristol Water. So by nature, Pennon is an acquisitive company. And we're always keen on attractive opportunities that may or may not come along. And this simply gives a bit more flexibility for a stretch of time while giving shareholders clarity over that stretch and over what happens should nothing come to fruition.

Susan Davy

executive
#25

Alright, thanks, Paul. And I believe your second question concerned the pro forma results included there, specifically where Bristol Water stood on its return on regulated equity. Regarding those pro forma figures, I'd say there is a slight negative when it comes to the bid for ODI position. But obviously, there are some favorable elements to Bristol Water's performance. And as I mentioned at the start, Bristol Water has laid out plenty of opportunities in its plan to truly deliver for customers. And they will be absolutely targeting that. And after speaking with the team today — we're here at the Bristol offices this morning — they're a great team, and they're really focused on doing well for customers and employees.

Chris Laybutt

analyst
#26

Yeah, the performance improvement is definitely something we're excited about. Would it be okay if I ask Paul a follow-up right now? So, on potential targets, are you still considering the same kind of remix, meaning U.K. water? And I suppose if you could share some commentary around that. Also, will the strategy stay consistent with what it's been in the past?

Paul Boote

executive
#27

Yeah. Well, I think it’s fair to say that the strategy, as you know, has been centered on the U.K. water industry, and that’s going to stay the case. When it comes to this GBP 400 million buyback and possible other uses, we’ve talked about growth opportunities. That could be organic — it might not only be M&A, as we’ve demonstrated today. The package we’ve announced here today includes a Green Recovery, and it also includes the acquisition of Bristol Water. So there are other routes beyond just acquisitions. But you can rest assured that we’ll apply our usual highly disciplined approach when evaluating all those opportunities and benchmark them against continuing the share buyback in terms of returns to shareholders.

Operator

operator
#28

Dominic Nash of Barclays has our next question.

Dominic Nash

analyst
#29

I have two questions, if I may. First, regarding AMP8 — clearly, Ofwat is starting up that process. If you look at the documentation surrounding it, there seems to be a possibility of a fairly significant increase in the promised totex and CapEx figures over the medium term, as it were. And one of the major projects that I think has been discussed for some time is a water link connecting the Bristol region with the South West, along with the potential for new reservoirs of that kind or other means of moving water through. What is your view on the medium- and long-term growth prospects for AMP8 and beyond, and particularly also on integrating Bristol and the synergies you'll gain from higher totex? My second question concerns your Ofwat RORE. ODI is clearly minus 0.7%. But you also have a tax of minus 0.6% this year. Your ambition, I believe, is to get ODIs to positive 0.5% — remind me on that one. Do you think ODIs will move into positive territory this year? And second, is that tax — the negative tax — a one-off? Or will it persist through this AMP8?

Susan Davy

executive
#30

Yes. Thanks for that, Dominic. So maybe I'll start with the first question about AMP8 and what we see ahead regarding potential investment and the outlook for water resources. Certainly, whenever we've examined the longer-term plans in the region, we've found that there's probably as much investment coming in the next 25 years as we've had over the past 25 years. Whether that concerns South West Water, whether it concerns some of the work we're doing on the environment, whether it's something we need to do on resources, we definitely can see investment coming. Now we're all part of the regional resource group in the South West, so Bristol is part of that, as are South West and Bournemouth Water. And we obviously know there are potential schemes and projects that could help with the resource situation in the south and east of the country. And that's something we're very interested in examining. And I think that's something that has been great. And regulators have really encouraged all of us to work together as a U.K. sector to really focus on it.

Susan Davy

executive
#31

And I think that's something we'll be examining as we move forward. Doing so makes a great deal of sense. And that's something we're going to be really focused on. So yes, it's great that you raised it as a question, and it's something that's on most of our minds as we go forward. But when it comes to the return on regulated equity and the ODI performance for Southwest that you can see in today's results, yes, there is a negative in terms of the impact for this last year, which we have principally as a result of our performance not being where it needs to be around pollution. We are addressing that. And you will see in today's presentation that our performance around pollution, since we kicked in a new plan and delivery last September, has been halving the number of pollution incidents compared to the previous year month-on-month. And we're in a much better place than we were for that delivery. And we do say in the presentation that we are targeting getting back to a net positive in ODI for this year, '21/'22. And then I think the other question was around tax on the return on regulated equity.

Susan Davy

executive
#32

So I believe that's roughly the way it gets captured within the RORE calculation at this point. With Ofwat, clearly note there is some shield regarding tax. And so that will clearly have an effect year by year. And we'll provide updates on that as the increase continues. On the whole, where our return on regulated equity performance stands is a very good place relative to where it needs to be.

Operator

operator
#33

Moving on, we have a follow-up question coming from Mark Freshney at Crédit Suisse.

Mark Freshney

analyst
#34

Regarding the B2B water suppliers — Pennon Water Services and the one that comes with Bristol — would you think about combining those two, or would you keep them running as separate suppliers? And are there any things to weigh there, for instance around minority interests in your own business?

Susan Davy

executive
#35

Alright, and yes, thank you for raising that, Mark. Paul?

Paul Boote

executive
#36

Right. So, just so everyone listening in can follow the ownership picture — for Pennon Water Services, our stake is 80%. And water2business, which came in via the Bristol Water acquisition, represents a 30% interest in that entity. At the moment, then, these are clearly distinct entities. When it comes to Pennon Group, obviously this enlarges Pennon's share if you look at it on a pro rata basis. I think that until we've spoken with Ofwat/CMA about how we take this transaction forward, these are matters that will get considered at that stage. After that, we'll examine what the best route ahead looks like. That said, when it comes to sharing best practice and getting the best out of the best, the approach we'd want to take would be a similar one. But we'll need to wait and work through that due process.

Mark Freshney

analyst
#37

On the valuation side for that B2B water supplier — I mean, you've got the premium to RCV, and there are the considerations we can work out. I think it's roughly GBP 25 million that you're attributing to businesses other than the wholesale Bristol business. Is that the value you're putting on that water supplier? Or are there any other nonregulated businesses that now carry a valuation?

Paul Boote

executive
#38

Right. So from the announcement, you'll have gathered that our focus on the RCV premium is very much on the regulated business, Bristol Water plc. When it comes to other operations, obviously water2business is the main piece there. But there are other elements we would also have taken into account in that formation. That GBP 25 million figure you mention strikes me as a touch on the high side. Still, I'm sure you worked that out somehow.

Operator

operator
#39

Martin Young from Investec has a follow-up question, and that's the next one we'll take.

Martin Young

analyst
#40

This is kind of along the same lines as what Mark asked. But when you look at the wholesale side, South West Water and Bournemouth Water are obviously now handled as a single entity for regulatory purposes. Do you see Bristol Water being merged with those other two for AMP8 and beyond, so that all three businesses get one combined settlement?

Susan Davy

executive
#41

Thanks for that, Martin. As we mentioned at the start of the call, there's a process we need to work through with Ofwat and the CMA regarding precisely how this will operate going forward. When we bought Bournemouth Water, we reported on that company's performance separately for the K6 regulatory period. That was clearly useful for the regime, and it helped them understand at the time how Bournemouth Water was doing. So we'll want to understand how Bristol Water is performing. How that carries forward into the next regulatory period is something we'll examine. But let me repeat the purpose behind this acquisition and what we're doing with our strategy: we believe there are benefits to be unlocked by doing this. Both we and the regulator want the same outcome — we all want customers to benefit, and we want those benefits to flow back to customers. That's what we'll really be focused on.

Operator

operator
#42

The following question is from Verity Mitchell at HSBC.

Verity Mitchell

analyst
#43

Nice work on the deal. I have a couple of questions. The first concerns tax opportunities. Does this transaction give you a chance to try to alter tax by accelerating or making some new investments? And secondly, the CMA mentioned the possibility of adding leverage without returning the benefit to customers. Could you remind us — I believe you stated what your target debt to RCV was at the close of the AMP. Is that simply a natural consequence of the merger rather than any other structural shift in your capital?

Susan Davy

executive
#44

Yeah. Thanks, Verity. Paul, would you like to handle that one?

Paul Boote

executive
#45

On tax, obviously everybody knows about what the government has announced on allowances that will shift over the coming 2 years. And then the rate of tax, the later changes, how the businesses combine — the businesses will keep going very much with the plans we have laid out. We have of course put forward a Green Recovery proposal, and that speeds up investment. So some elements clearly will land in that tax bracket in the years of that additional investment. As for the Bristol Water acquisition, there is nothing specific there. On your second question...

Susan Davy

executive
#46

Regarding your second question, it concerned the gearing level and the effort to reach...

Paul Boote

executive
#47

Yes. So the gearing level we discussed during the presentation — Pennon Group at 65% as a target by the end of the AMP — that really comes as a result of all the announcements made today. So, as you will have seen, we are talking about de-gearing the Pennon Group balance sheet. We are talking about reinvesting in the water industry. And that is not only Bristol Water; it means investing in South West Water, which then also affects South West Water's gearing. So we intend to bring down gearing across the aggregated water businesses. And we have set a target there of 60% again by 2025. So we are very much looking to make sure the group is positioned sustainably going forward.

Susan Davy

executive
#48

And maybe I'll just piggyback on that first question, Paul, regarding the tax positioning. And I suspect what you're driving at with that question relates to true-up. I mean, we were the company that proposed tax true-ups in the last regulatory period before anyone else adopted that methodology. We believe we understand where companies do gain from those elements. And that ought to be shared somewhat and returned to customers, lowering their bills in the future as a result. So then whatever we do when it comes to performance, we've committed again through our water mechanism. If any benefits happen to accrue outside the regulatory mechanism, we'll share those suitably with customers going forward.

Operator

operator
#49

The next question comes from Jenny Ping at Citi.

Jenny Ping

analyst
#50

I have a couple of questions, if I may. First, on strategy, Susan, you mentioned previously — obviously in the context of working out what to do with the Viridor proceeds — that holding on to the cash effectively lets you avoid some of the cost of returning it right away and then raising it again if and when you find a deal to do. I suppose my question is really this: now that you've decided to give the money back, and done Bristol Water, is that it as far as further M&A goes? Or are you still looking to grow the business beyond where it is now, and if you do find such an opportunity, would you come back to the market and ask shareholders for equity? So that's the first question. Second question, just on the size of Pennon Group. Obviously, after the returns and the share consolidation, the market cap would be significantly smaller than it is today. And I presume you may not be in the FTSE 100 longer term, purely by sort of mechanics. Are there any other issues you face as a smaller company going forward, whether it's the ability to sign contracts or raise debts?

Jenny Ping

analyst
#51

I'm just attempting to think creatively here. Is there any justification for you to stay a publicly listed company? Then third and finally, regarding the buyback, just to verify, are you considering a linear kind of possibility to repurchase the debt — sorry, to repurchase the shares, meaning does this begin in September this year and then buy back? Or are you actually backloading it and waiting for other opportunities to emerge? And if that doesn't emerge, then you'll spend the money, let's say, Q2 next year?

Susan Davy

executive
#52

All right, several questions came up there, so let's work through them for you. Maybe we begin with the first, which was about the money from selling Viridor, and the point that we were retaining those funds while we considered where to put them to work for growth, whether built internally or bought. Have we wrapped that up now? To put it plainly, at the time Viridor was sold, we stated that the proceeds would be kept within a certain window. Keeping hold of them wasn't a strategy as such; it was simply being economically sensible — if an opportunity arrived, better to examine the process we had taken them through and then return to the market. As we laid out in this morning's presentation, we have clearly been through a process, and we have the Bristol Water investment plus the buyback you mentioned to me a moment ago. We said that process runs until September next year. And naturally, should opportunities arise during that window, whether built internally or acquired, we will of course weigh them against that buyback.

Susan Davy

executive
#53

And when it comes to shareholder value, we'll certainly consider that. I think that's about all I can say regarding the proceeds. Moving to the next item, which concerns Pennon Group's size and our thinking on it — I'll let Paul address that — but one of the things you brought up was being a listed company. And then, do you believe we wouldn't be able to view being listed favorably, and what would we do in that case? I think it's quite clear to us that there are genuine advantages to being a listed company. Customers and employees both benefit from it, and I think it's a great place to be. So, Paul, would you like to discuss Pennon Group's size going forward?

Paul Boote

executive
#54

Yes, absolutely. So to some degree you're correct, Jenny, that it's clear returning capital to shareholders is going to lower market capitalization and, obviously, keep Pennon where it is in the FTSE 250. As for other effects, I mean, I really can't come up with any additional effects that would be material in any way. And probably you mentioned raising finance — worth pointing out that, over the years, South Water has always been viewed as a regulatory ring-fence. And we've raised finance for South West Water within South West Water. We've secured a low cost of financing for many years now in South West Water, and all of that has come on the back of South West Water's size and scale. So we don't anticipate any changes to that approach. That approach has always been separate and will stay that way now going forward. So no particular issues when it comes to any operational impacts or financing impacts from that return of value, and therefore the reduction in market cap.

Operator

operator
#55

Bartek Kubicki from Societe Generale has our next question.

Bartlomiej Kubicki

analyst
#56

Bartek Kubicki here. There are three things I'd like to address regarding this transaction. First, on integration and how you'd bring your corporate culture into Bristol and actually turn the business around from being a totex underperformer and ODI underperformer, at least in AMP6 — how long do you expect that to take? And do you think extra investment will be needed on your side to get the company running as efficiently as yours? Second, on the cost of financing at Bristol Water — could you compare Bristol's cost of debt with yours and say whether it's higher, which I assume it is? What will you do with the outstanding debt: restructure it, or simply leave it in place until it expires and then refinance at the lower rate? And third, I'd like to ask how you would explain the valuation discrepancy. You're paying a 44% premium over RCV on Bristol, which is an underperforming company at least at present, while you, as an outperforming company, trade at roughly, let's say, a 30% premium to RCV. So I wonder how you would explain that discrepancy and what value you could create going forward to account for it?

Susan Davy

executive
#57

All right, and thanks so much for those questions, Bartek. On your first one, about how the integration will go — I believe an earlier question also touched on integration. The first point I'd make is that proposals have to go to Ofwat and the CMA, simply to show how customers of both companies can gain from this acquisition and how that would operate. One thing worth noting regarding Bristol Water, and it's the reason we were so keen on the company: they enjoy an excellent relationship in that region and an excellent relationship with their customers. This year marks their 175th anniversary. They take real pride in their heritage. And there are some excellent ideas within this business. So yes, when it comes to the financials and some of the areas we'd target, there are things each of us can learn from the other. But they're in a great place. Let me return once more to the situation when we acquired Bournemouth Water and the sort of capabilities involved there, where both businesses gained from the process and we managed to secure the highest level of return through that regulatory review and through coming together.

Susan Davy

executive
#58

That likely addresses the first portion of what you asked. The second piece concerned the cost of debt along with premiums. Paul, would you like to take those?

Paul Boote

executive
#59

Yes. Thank you, Susan. So regarding the cost of debt, I believe it's reasonable to state that Bristol Water's cost of debt is clearly greater than what we'd observe at Pennon and South West Water. The instruments they currently have in place there are fixed as far as their maturity dates go. Now, from a shareholder value standpoint, it's clear that taking action with those instruments can erode shareholder value, since you'd then simply need to put other arrangements in place. So the starting point on return would be to leave them as they are and then seek to refinance more in keeping with the South West Water strategy, in order to lock in lower rates. That's probably the approach we'd take there. But obviously, we'll be examining every one of those instruments. On the value points, well, I think it's reasonable to say that when we examine value — and I believe we've discussed this, likely during the last year, as we've been discussing how we view opportunities — we consider fundamental value, and we consider discounted cash flows to be the true driver in terms of how we assess business value and what it can deliver for shareholders.

Paul Boote

executive
#60

We view the RCV premium, if you will, more as an output rather than a value driver in its own right. And it really comes down to the long-term value we can see here with Bristol Water too. So if you look at — well, I think Susan has probably already brought up the sort of blueprint, if you like, of Bournemouth Water and what we've managed to achieve there, which obviously was outperformance through the AMP in which the acquisition took place. But also in the following AMP, we've also been able to make significant investments that go well above the scale of their RCV that would have been sort of permissible if the acquisition hadn't have happened. So very much it's about long-term value here and that's how we see the value, that's how we look at it. And the premium that is paid on any given day is more of an output of that.

Operator

operator
#61

Moving on, we have Dominic Nash of Barclays with a follow-up question.

Dominic Nash

analyst
#62

Apologies — just two quick items. First, picking up a bit on what Bartek asked: Bristol Water clearly carries a credit rating. Will you keep a rating in place, or actually bring one in at the Pennon Group level as you go forward? Second, on the share consolidation and the payback: how many shareholders do you now have who are stakeholders — shareholders — given the 2 shares? And what happens there? Do they drop to 1 share as a result of this consolidation? And in what way will you pay them? Any thoughts on that particular point?

Paul Boote

executive
#63

Yes, absolutely, Dominic. So on the rating side, you're correct that Bristol Water carries a rating that supports some of the financing currently in place. Obviously, that will need to be kept up. As that financing is kept up, you may recall that at the time of the Bournemouth Water acquisition, that was also the situation. But I suppose, looking at where things stand now, that rating is no longer there. So we'll clearly be examining that. And through the process we go through with Ofwat and CMA, we'll be looking to see what the best options are on that front. On shareholders and customer shareholders, we mentioned 52,000 customer shareholders. As you rightly noted, they hold 2 shares of each at the time they took that option to become shareholders, although many have actually now added to their shareholding. And for those customers, they'll be just like all shareholders, offered the dividend reinvestment plan. So they'll be able to maintain it as well, should they wish to make that election and be able to take that dividend and the fractional entitlement and stay at 2.

Susan Davy

executive
#64

Yes. And another point worth mentioning on that, Dominic, is that we noted in today's results presentation that we had always planned to carry out one more of those issuances and the scheme, likely later during the K7 period. However, we are speeding that up. Customers have responded well to it. We believe it is an excellent move and one we intend to bring forward into next year.

Dominic Nash

analyst
#65

That sounds good. And I assume Bristol customers are going to receive that offer too, correct?

Susan Davy

executive
#66

So that process we need to work through — honestly, I believe it's a terrific thing to be in a position to provide to customers, and to the customers in South West and Bournemouth. And Bournemouth customers clearly gained from it, had the chance to either take up shares or receive GBP 20 off their bill. And a number of Bournemouth customers, clearly, enrolled in the share scheme. So it's a great option for customers and one more route by which value can be returned to them from being part of a listed company.

Operator

operator
#67

And Jenny Ping from Citi has one more follow-up question for us.

Jenny Ping

analyst
#68

To follow up on the third question I asked earlier, regarding how the share buyback will be phased, is it reasonable for us to expect that to be linear?

Paul Boote

executive
#69

Yes. So regarding the buyback program, as Susan mentioned, we'll launch it after the consolidation exercise is complete. And the precise details of it haven't been laid out or specified. But we will wrap it up by 30 September 2022.

Operator

operator
#70

And last up, we've got a question coming from Nitant Gupta at Rothschild & Co.

Nitant Gupta

analyst
#71

Well done on completing that acquisition. I've got a couple of additional questions building on what's already been asked. First, you mentioned something about operational improvements in certain areas where Bristol Water performs better. Could you tell us what revenue you're assigning to synergies and operational improvements when you value Bristol Water? Then my second question is really just a point of clarification: the multiple you show in your announcement — 1.44, or 44% — does that apply only to the regulatory business, or does it also take in the non-regulatory side?

Susan Davy

executive
#72

Well, thanks a lot for those questions. So regarding the possible operational improvements, along with the benefits and values on those, obviously that's something we'll work through with Ofwat and the CMA. When we put those proposals together, that will be part of it. And then as for the premium to RCV, yes, so 44% is the regulated business.

Nitant Gupta

analyst
#73

All right. Could you put a number on the synergies — like what value you've assigned to them, or...

Susan Davy

executive
#74

Regarding our approach to valuing what we purchased, it’s an excellent business. We’ve clearly discussed how we’ll perform as a group moving forward. And clearly, that has factored into some analysis we’ve carried out to judge whether this is a good price at which to do the deal.

Operator

operator
#75

Ladies and gentlemen, that brings us to the end of the time we have for questions today. So at this point I'll turn things back over to Paul, Susan and Jen to wrap up today's session.

Susan Davy

executive
#76

Alright, Emily, thanks a lot for that. And thanks to everyone who's on the call this morning. So, to wrap things up today, I'd say this is a major milestone for the Pennon Group, and one that I believe will bring genuinely strong benefits to all of our stakeholders. We've clearly unlocked meaningful value for shareholders, and going forward for customers, and for everyone across the Pennon Group, while also making sure we keep our focus on operations and on what we're doing to serve the communities in the companies within the group. So, many thanks for today, and I'm sure we'll speak again soon.

Paul Boote

executive
#77

I appreciate everyone joining.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Pennon Group Plc transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Pennon Group Plc earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Pennon Group Plc or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.