Pennon Group Plc (PNN) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
May 21, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Susan Davy
executiveI'm speaking to you from Devon. Right now, everyone at this company is 100% dedicated to getting a safe water supply back to the residents and businesses in and around Brixham. The health and safety of our customers and our operational teams remains our top priority, and those teams are putting in round-the-clock effort without letup. We're making sure customers can get bottled water, and for a number of the customers who were affected at the outset, we have already brought normal supply back. Working alongside the relevant authorities, we're continuing at pace to restore supply in full to every customer and business, and we will not stop until that is done. We recognize that this has brought significant disruption and distress to our customers. I am truly sorry. Customers have every right to be angry, and they will have questions for us. I am fully committed to making sure our customers get all the answers to every question. But at this moment, my focus is 100% on restoring the full water supply in Brixham. As soon as water has been safely restored, we will conduct a full investigation into what happened. Make no mistake, as we work to fully understand what has happened, I am clear that whatever we conclude, delivering safe, reliable, and clean drinking water to all our customers is our responsibility.
Susan Davy
executivePast Brixham, delivering safe and dependable drinking water remains our top priority, consistent with what our 4 million customers expect. This event, occurring after year-end, shows just how significant our role is. So today, I'd like to walk you through the results and highlights from the past year, emphasizing the continued investment in our services and infrastructure. Our fundamentals remain solid, shown by record investment levels, record customer support, and record job creation both directly and within the supply chain, which supports the region's economic health. We're growing sustainably, whether by acquisition or through investment, backed by an efficiently funded and robust balance sheet, growing shareholder value. The building blocks are in place, focused not just on what we do but on how we conduct business, and that, in turn, ensures we're making solid operational progress, delivering on our four priorities and on what matters most to customers. With a strong balance sheet comes a sustainable future. We have a clear twin-track growth strategy, both organic and acquisitive. Let's begin with organic. Peak capital investment rose nearly two-thirds year-on-year, reaching GBP 583 million for 2023/2024. That marks our largest-ever investment program in water. It translates into cumulative RCV growth of 65%, and we're on track to deliver 70% to 2025.
Susan Davy
executiveFor investors, this investment provides asset-backed inflationary returns. Within the group, our operations need a reliable and efficient power supply, and through Pennon Power we are putting money into expanding our renewable energy provision, with the first EBITDA contribution expected at the end of 2024, backing our net zero ambitions and covering 40% of the group's energy requirements. We are also making progress on our acquisition strategy, which is moving along well in two key areas. First, we are realizing the benefits we set out as part of the Bristol Water acquisition, with roughly GBP 17 million of annualized operating synergies, and we are on track for the targeted GBP 20 million run rate for 2024/2025, in addition to the GBP 18 million of financing benefits already realized. Second, having acquired Sutton and East Surrey Water in January, we safeguarded their financial resilience through a successful equity raise. We are now fast-tracking through the CMA process ahead of plan. Across four priorities on what matters most to customers, we continue to deliver. We're listening, whether from Bristol to Bournemouth and across Devon, Cornwall, and the Isles of Scilly, and soon to be Sutton and East Surrey. A personal highlight has been our customer and community roadshows, as we have been able to reconfirm our four priorities.
Susan Davy
executiveWhen it comes to investing in protecting water quality and boosting resilience, we've broken the drought cycle for Devon and Cornwall well ahead of plan. On tackling storm overflows at our beaches and eradicating pollutions, we expect to hold onto the gains made in previous years, with a revised trajectory toward four-star performance for 2025. We're working to shield the environment from climate change, and our catchment management schemes are progressing well. Meanwhile, we keep successfully managing customer bills so they are lower than 10 years ago, as we pledged to eradicate water poverty. Bills in the region are no longer the outliers in the sector that they once were in the aftermath of post-privatization and the GBP 13 billion legacy costs of putting wastewater treatment into the region for the first time. For our PR19 commitments, we are ahead or on track in delivering 70% of our outcome delivery targets. This is also a year in which the weather has been both friend and foe. Fundamentally, we have broken the cycle of drought, achieving 100% strategic reservoir capacity for Devon and Cornwall ahead of target, with a third of the improvement directly because of our interventions, supported by the weather.
Susan Davy
executiveTeams throughout South West Water and our supply chain have put enormous effort into this. Quickly, we brought 2 reservoirs online at Blackpool Pit and Hawks Tor, plus several pump recharge schemes, and we raised treatment capacity at Rialton. A 2-phase desalination scheme for Cornwall is likewise on schedule. Thanks to this, we could hit our 2025 target for Devon 1 year ahead of time, adding 30% resource availability. In Cornwall we are tracking toward a 45% gain in resource availability, and 30% has been delivered so far. Fixing the present hasn't been the whole story, since we are putting in enough investment now to safeguard resources across the coming 25 years. Every coin has two sides. Sure, it means diversifying the mix of resources we rely on and putting money into them, yet it also means cutting demand. We are meeting our leakage goals. Our demand reduction programmes, which lead the sector, aim to help customers consume less water and spend less money, and more than 500 water-saving devices go out each day. We are trialling tariff pilots too, to spread charges more fairly and promote efficient water use. And although we have safeguarded water resources, water quality remains good.
Susan Davy
executiveDuring 2023, we achieved a genuine step change across the Isles of Scilly: treatment processes had zero failures for Devon, Cornwall, and Bournemouth, and a robust action plan is now in place for Bristol. Let me say a brief word about the weather. Raising it isn't meant as an excuse; rather, it provides important context for the plans we've concentrated on and, crucially, for how we're evolving where we direct our attention next. Because of that weather, wastewater flows have risen sharply, and this has affected our headline results on wastewater pollutions and storm overflow usage. September brought 10 named storms and 12 yellow weather warnings, and average rainfall climbed 50% against long-term averages, giving Devon and Cornwall their 5th wettest year on record. In 2024, rainfall so far remains above the long-term average — up 40% — and elevated groundwater levels are producing a 1-year impact on flows equal to the prior 20 years' rate of increase. Now let's turn to pollutions. To grasp how our plans have been bettering outcomes, we must look beneath the headlines. In the past, 70% of pollutions arose within our networks, and the work carried out there is paying off, with performance stabilizing.
Susan Davy
executiveThere are three areas I want to highlight: we're delivering internal sewer flooding performance that leads the sector, we're beating the regulatory targets for sewer collapses and blockages, and we're holding onto the improvements we've already achieved in cutting network pollutions. That's come from putting money into 12,000 sewer deck monitors, which support predictive and proactive interventions, plus ongoing investment in rising main replacements and sewer upgrades, together with ramping up maintenance and targeting cleansing activities. Returning to that 20% increase in flows entering our system, we have to remove or divert those flows, so our focus is on infiltration, reduction, and sewer separation to get there. We've needed to rebalance our efforts at both treatment works and pumping stations, since those high flow levels have caused spikes in performance. By reinvigorating action plans, treatment works performance has come back from the degradation we saw in 2023, stabilizing through 2024, using a combination of inlet and storm tank cleansing, risk-based generator servicing, site-based compliance, re-bed surveys, and refurbishments. Attention has now shifted to our pumping stations, with better site MOTs and enhanced cleansing, as well as addressing power resilience. Cutting pollutions stays a top priority for the board and for all my colleagues. We're clear and transparent about where we stand, and over time we've improved how we self-report pollution incidents, and we're now among the best in the sector.
Susan Davy
executiveI take some reassurance from the fact that in 2023 we kept serious pollution incidents at their lowest levels, though I should note our target remains zero. Across all incidents, we now have a revised path toward four-star performance for the 2025 calendar year. Demonstrable improvements from our interventions to lessen storm overflow impact have been masked by higher flows in our networks. Looked at on a like-for-like basis, the investments we are making today are delivering underlying performance improvements that we will see in future years. There are 280 schemes completed or underway. To give you an example, our work at Hatherleigh Sewage Treatment Works has cut spills by 90%, and the tank we have installed at Chittlehamholt has cut spills by 70%. With our focus by 2025 on improving 49 of the 151 beaches through our WaterFit program, WaterFit Live is giving communities and visitors to the region near real-time information about their favorite beach, alongside community roadshows, as we place communities at the heart of our plans. While beaches are a priority, we are equally focused on improving river water quality, with reasons for not achieving good ecological status reduced from 19 to 12.4%. We have a nature-first approach to investment.
Susan Davy
executiveOur award-winning catchment management program is setting the pace when it comes to biodiversity gains, and it also keeps helping others with how they look after their land — boosting water quality, biodiversity and climate resilience. The work spans constructing ponds, upgrading farm tracks and slurry storage, plus planting trees and buffer strips that catch and filter water. Cumulatively, we've restored 127,000 hectares, and we've gone past our tree planting goal of over 250,000. After 15 years of work across our catchments, we now have the science that backs up these improvements, and I was delighted that in March this year we officially opened our partnership with the University of Exeter, which delivers research through a state-of-the-art laboratory into the key challenges and issues the water and wastewater sector faces. When it comes to affordability, there are two elements: first, keeping bills as low as they can be for every customer, and second, supporting those who are struggling. We have always concentrated on being as efficient as possible in delivering services and in holding bill increases through 2025 well below inflation. That is why we keep supporting customers and communities, having provided over GBP 100 million of customer support, with 132,000 customers benefiting from one of our social tariffs, while also building awareness of our customer outreach engagement programs.
Susan Davy
executiveSo because of that, more than 98% of customers in every region we serve consider their bills affordable. And when it comes to our customer commitment, 70% of our outcome delivery incentive schemes are either ahead of schedule or on track. Since you can't pick your water provider, we think you deserve a voice — that's why we intend to expand our distinctive WaterShare+ scheme and, for the first time, offer it to certain East Surrey customers. The foundations for a sustainable future are now set. We're restructuring the group so it stays efficient while we grow, and to make sure we're performance-led, with planned upgrades to processes and operational effectiveness — which delivered synergies of GBP 26 million in 2023, 2024, with a targeted GBP 86 million annualized run rate into K8. We're strengthening delivery across the wider supply chain, known collectively as Amplify, with a two-tier supply model that's already in place and already mobilized, delivering 1,000 projects in support of our GBP 2.8 billion investment in the region. And to be a sustainable business — I've always been clear on this — our investments can't be only in assets; they have to be in people, too. We're the only water company to have been recognized as a top 100 employer for apprenticeships.
Susan Davy
executiveWe've had more than 470 apprenticeships so far, and we're accredited as a gold employer for our earn and learn approach — 1 in 10 colleagues have either done an apprenticeship or a graduate program. We've promoted social mobility, giving young people the chance to dive into their local water company. For the 3rd year running, we've had our best health and safety performance as we deliver on our Home Safe strategy to ensure everyone who works for us and with us goes home safe every single day. Finally, we're leveraging technology, trialing AI in customer services, and using predictive modeling to support wastewater operations. Overall, we have a robust financial position with solid financial performance, and we are well positioned for the next regulatory period. Our efficiency programs are focused on keeping costs below inflationary levels, despite the impacts of the unprecedented wet weather. Furthermore, with a robust balance sheet, we are also efficiently funded and growing shareholder value. Our strategy for financing will continue to seek to ensure we remain one of the most efficient in the sector. We have raised around GBP 1.2 billion of new and renewed facilities since March 2023, and with a successful equity raise of GBP 180 million for the Sutton and East Surrey acquisition, we're well on track for our funding.
Susan Davy
executiveAt 63.5%, our water group gearing aligns with K7 policy, and that reflects both the higher investment spend on assets and the timing of the RCV build. Through delivering excellent customer service, our business-to-business retailers — Pennon Water Services and Water to Business — are achieving an EBITDA increase of over 50% along with greater market share. On the 5th of April, 2024, we paid an interim dividend of 14.04 pence per share. We have carefully assessed the recommended final dividend position, taking into account the group's performance in the round, growth at our business-to-business retailers, development of the Pennon Power business, and our water businesses, and we have taken Ofwat's recent guidance in this area into consideration. The final dividend recommended for Pennon has therefore been adjusted to reflect a GBP 2.4 million fine connected to a South West Water prosecution we had in May 2023, and in that case we believe the group's ultimate shareholders, rather than customers, should bear the impact. Accordingly, the revised final dividend recommended is 30.33 pence per share. With that, I am pleased to hand over to Steve, who will deliver his first year-end results for the group.
Steve Buck
executiveThank you, Susan, and good morning, everyone. All things considered, the financial results we delivered for 2023 to 2024 came in as we had anticipated. The main points are these: a stronger income statement, with underlying profits rising to GBP 334.7 million of EBITDA. Capital investment stepped up to GBP 642.4 million, and that is fueling substantial growth. Cumulative outperformance of K7 regulated returns came to 7.3%. We hold more than GBP 1 billion in equity liquidity, giving us flexibility and resilience. And gearing stands at 63.5%, inside our target range. Our headline results include Sutton and East Surrey Water, SES. From the time of acquisition, and to aid comparison with the prior year, in some places we have shown figures that exclude SES, and we flag where that applies. As we had expected, the income statement for the year was weighted toward the second half. The second half also swung from a loss in H2 2022/23 to a profit. I will take you through the headline year-on-year movements on the next slide. Non-underlying costs totaling GBP 25.9 million relate to the SES acquisition and to putting in place a comprehensive cost transformation program and readiness for K8. I will come back to this program. Earnings per share, excluding the expected SES loss, came to 7.2 pence and are broadly flat year-on-year.
Steve Buck
executiveIf we leave SES out, organic revenue growth came in at roughly 6%, driven by inflationary tariff increases and partly offset by last year's ODI penalties plus an adjustment for over-recovery in earlier years. After the large inflationary increases of the prior year, the cost base is now stabilizing, helped by softer inflation and self-help measures to cut costs. Consequently, the South West Water cost base is broadly flat, even with the weather impacts. As you'd expect, growing the RCV has pushed up the depreciation charge. The same applies to financing costs, which rose because of more debt and higher interest rates. I'm pleased that Pennon Water Services kept growing and remained profitable, with its profit before tax more than doubling during the year. SES is consolidated from the acquisition date of 10th January and, as expected, posted a loss of GBP 2.5 million. You'll be aware of the post-acquisition integration program for Bristol Water. That program is nearly finished, having delivered GBP 17 million of annualized synergies, and it should hit the targeted GBP 20 million of savings... Our ambitious PR24 plan submission carried a commitment to cut costs, which will bring customer bills down. To underpin that ambition, we've started a program to reshape the business.
Steve Buck
executiveThis program has delivered GBP 9 million in Totex benefits in 2023 and 2024, and it's targeted to achieve roughly GBP 55 million in annualized savings in K8. The program is going to optimize asset maintenance activity, improve the chemical and power consumption of operational sites, reduce our overheads, and strengthen procurement. We've targeted GBP 11 million of integration benefits from the SES acquisition. That program will begin once we have CMA clearance for the acquisition. As you're aware from the business plan, years four and five are the peak years for the K7 investment program. This has been our largest year of capital expenditure, with investment up 80% year-on-year, at GBP 642 million, excluding SES. The regulated water business lifted investment by 63% year-on-year to GBP 583 million, with the remainder being the start of our GBP 59 million investment into renewable energy, Pennon Power. The K7 investment has enabled significant growth in the RCV, which now stands 66% higher than at the start of K7. Around GBP 820 million of shareholder value has been created in the water business during K7 from base returns, RCV inflation, and RoRE outperformance. A prudent approach to dividends in the water business has meant that only GBP 250 million of this value has been distributed by South West Water to Pennon for K7 to date, leaving over GBP 500 million of retained shareholder value.
Steve Buck
executiveThe K7 investment program and reinvesting RoRE outperformance were skewed toward years 4 and 5. We've successfully pulled forward GBP 80 million of investment from year 5 in the water business to boost resilience to drought and improve water quality. This is purely a matter of timing. That said, an additional GBP 80 million has gone toward base maintenance to lessen the effect of severe weather on pollution and leakage, while we also expand our Quality First program. We expect to recover 50% of that expenditure in K8. Consequently, we anticipate capital expenditure will come in at around GBP 930 million cumulatively across years 4 and 5, as the timing unwinds and base maintenance goes back to levels consistent with the PR24 plan. I'm especially happy with our strong liquidity and the debt-raising we completed successfully over the past year. To fund the business's growth, we've raised approximately GBP 850 million of debt through our diversified debt portfolio. Our latest private placement drew 4.5 times oversubscription. We've lifted our liquidity above GBP 1 billion, giving us both flexibility and resilience. We're going to set up an EMTN program, which will broaden our debt portfolio to include U.K.
Steve Buck
executiveAnd European debt markets. We've made substantial progress toward securing two public credit ratings, and we anticipate those will land at a strong investment grade level. We keep turning in robust RoRE results — 7.3% cumulative — which works out to roughly GBP 160 million of outperformance. That has allowed us to fund further capital investment initiatives, as covered earlier. Thanks to how the debt book is structured, we've achieved financing outperformance of GBP 255 million so far in K7. Year 4 saw that outperformance carry on, though it has come down versus the prior year because of falling inflation. ODI penalties have been triggered by the extreme weather events, among them heavy rainfall that ran through to March 2024. In line with the plan we submitted, several ODIs are calculated at the close of that K7, and we expect those to deliver a reward on the order of GBP 20 million. Peak levels of capital expenditure mean Totex has cut outperformance by GBP 60 million on a cumulative basis. South West Water gearing stands at 63.5%, excluding SES. Once the de-gearing is finished following CMA clearance, the SES business will be brought in going forward. South West Water gearing runs roughly 2% above plan, reflecting the larger capital spend and lower operating cash flows stemming from the income statement.
Steve Buck
executiveOur position remains inside the 55%-65% policy range, and we expect that to hold true when K7 concludes. As we move into K8, the group is going to have room to react to how the PR24 draft and final determinations turn out. That covers making sure South West Water keeps a strong investment-grade credit rating, looking at debt leverage opportunities for Pennon Power, and weighing the retained value of more than GBP 500 million in South West Water. From there we'll develop K8 balance sheet and capital allocation policies aimed at delivering the best value for shareholders. I'll now hand things back to Susan.
Susan Davy
executiveSo when we look forward to PR24, all of this gives us a solid foundation to build on. The plan we have is an ambitious one, and it rests on the four priorities that matter most to customers. We're going to invest, and we'll do so efficiently. The plan's total expenditure comes to GBP 4.5 billion, with 12% efficiency, which keeps bill increases as low as possible, and customer support is good at 74%. For investors, there's growth: 38% in nominal terms and 25% in real terms. We've set out an ambitious group of outcomes that offer the chance to benefit from strong performance, with the ability to share that between investors and customers, at a maximum return on regulated equity of 8.6%. With a draft determination scheduled for the twelfth of June, we're ready to deliver, and we have an investor update planned for that day along with a capital markets day in late September. To sum up, our fundamentals are strong, which shows in record investment levels, record customer support, and record numbers of jobs created both directly and in the supply chain, which supports the region's economic health. We're growing sustainably, whether by acquisition or organic investment, with a robust balance sheet that's efficiently funded, and shareholder value is growing.
Susan Davy
executiveThe foundations are set, and our attention is on both the work itself and the way we operate as a business. That, in turn, means we're achieving solid operational momentum, fulfilling our 4 priorities and addressing what customers in U.K. Water care about most, and we're well placed going forward thanks to strong financials. Thank you.
Operator
operatorThanks for waiting. We’re moving into the question-and-answer portion now. Just a quick note: to ask a question, press star and then one on your phone’s keypad. Our first question today is from Sarah Lester at Morgan Stanley. Your line is open—go ahead.
Sarah Lester
analystThanks. Thanks a lot. My apologies, Susan.
Susan Davy
executiveMorning, Sarah. Morning, Sarah. I figured we'd start with a short introduction, if that works, since I have a couple of folks waiting on me this morning.
Sarah Lester
analystNo worries at all.
Susan Davy
executiveIs that alright? Thanks, Sarah. Sorry about that. We’ll get underway shortly. So, good morning and welcome, everyone. With me are my Chair, Gill Rider, and my CFO, Steve Buck. As you saw in this morning’s results presentation, we’re speaking to you from Devon. Although today we’ll clearly be discussing Pennon Group’s 2023 to 2024 results, my colleagues and I are right now concentrated on our top priority: the health and safety of our customers and our operational teams, who are working tirelessly around the clock to restore a safe water supply to the people and businesses in and around Brixham in Devon. For now, though, let’s move to the 2023 to 2024 results. A few brief comments from me on them. I know you’ve seen the presentation, but as a summary, this has been a year of securing the building blocks for the long-term business we are and securing shareholder value over the long term. It has been a transformative year for us as a business, and in fact, it’s been a year in which we have done what we said we were going to do.
Susan Davy
executiveInvestment has hit record levels—three times the scale we saw at the beginning of this regulatory period—and that puts us in a genuinely strong position as we head into the next regulatory period, with a run rate that matches. The drought cycle has been broken. Our drought came in 2022, and we've invested heavily. Yes, rainfall has helped us, but we have invested heavily, and a third of the gain in our resource level comes from the fact that we've invested, and the investments we've made will keep us in good shape on water resources for 25 years. The gains we achieved on environmental performance have been retained, and we've been reshaping the business. We've delivered synergistic benefits with a solid run rate, again, into the next regulatory period. We've delivered on growth, both organic and acquisitive, and the acquisitions are on track. For those acquisitions, we're delivering what we said we would do. We've righted the balance sheet for those acquisitions that we've invested in, and we are delivering efficiency, which will help with customer bills going forward. Certainly—sorry—our latest acquisition is fast-tracking through the CMA process, which is great news. So, we know that to attract investment, we need investor support.
Susan Davy
executiveWe do have solid, robust liquidity, and Steve, I'm certain, can discuss that this morning. Yet we understand how important dividend payments are as a central part of shareholder return. So we've looked carefully at the recommended final dividend position for Pennon. We've taken into account that the group delivered strong performance in the round, but we've also taken note of the recent March guidance regarding dividends for the wholesale water business. We have adhered to Pennon's policy, the K7 policy, of raising the dividend by CPIH + 2%, but we've adjusted the final dividend content by GBP 2.4 million, which equals the Sutton and East Surrey Water fine we received in 2023 to 2024, signaling that we are listening and that we're clearing the path for long-term shareholder value. So I just wanted to make sure those points were really clear before we open up the Q&A. With that, I'll hand back to you, Sarah, and apologies for making you wait.
Sarah Lester
analystNo, that's fine. I figured you might have something to say first. Good morning — take two. I have two questions, if I may. First, regarding the additional spending in FY 2024: I'd like you to walk us through the thinking a bit more, and especially the net benefit to longer-term shareholder value that you expect from the investment and initiatives undertaken during the year. Second, on talent and people resources in the sector — I'm curious whether you're seeing people leave the sector, or any recruitment difficulties, given the media attention on the broader space. Thank you.
Susan Davy
executiveAlright, thank you so much, Sarah. So maybe I'll begin with the first item, Steve, and then pass it over to you to cover CapEx as well. If you look at how CapEx breaks down, on the water side of the business, we've actually spent more on the water resources side. I've just briefly mentioned the drought and the spending we've incurred there. So, you'll notice a peak in investment that we've had for drought purposes, which came through as a result of that. But Steve, I'm not sure whether you'd like to elaborate a bit further on CapEx?
Steve Buck
executiveOkay, absolutely. So, as you saw in the presentation, CapEx has two themes. Year 4 is our peak year, and I believe everyone was aware that Year 4 and 5 would be our peak years based on the Final Determination. GBP 80 million of that peak has been pulled forward from Year 5 into Year 4. The net benefit of this is that Devon and Cornwall have become resilient to drought effects sooner. That's the timing aspect—it's purely a timing matter between Year 4 and Year 5. We've incurred another GBP 80 million, and it's a different GBP 80 million. It's always somewhat annoying when you have two 80s, but it's a different GBP 80 million regarding our base maintenance costs. We've incurred more base maintenance costs in Year 4. That's to address pollution and water quality priorities, as well as to deal with the effects of the unprecedented weather we experienced throughout the winter. That GBP 80 million isn't a timing issue. It will flow through and add to our overspend, so our CapEx spend position. Previously, we guided Year 4 and Year 5 at GBP 850 million.
Steve Buck
executiveThat second GBP 80 million brings us to GBP 930 million cumulative across the two years. From that GBP 80 million, we expect 50% to come back to us via the regulatory mechanism.
Susan Davy
executiveAll right, thanks a lot, Steve. Maybe I’ll start with what you asked about—how we bring talent in and keep it. My new CFO, Steve Buck, is here with me today. So we’re definitely putting money into the community. We’ve got colleagues coming on board alongside the investment plans we have in place. Clearly, the headcount within the organization has risen, and in fact employee turnover has fallen compared with a year earlier. What we’re focused on is ensuring that we provide really strong training for the people who join us. 1 in 10 of our colleagues has gone through either our apprenticeship or our graduate scheme. And as always in a sector like this, yes, we are in the spotlight, but there are great roles for individuals, with great training opportunities for them. And obviously we are hiring and bringing people into the business. As always—and I say this every time—we are a sector that is in the spotlight, but nothing matters more than delivering safe, clean drinking water. And the sector is full of people who want to make sure we can deliver that for our customers.
Susan Davy
executiveSo yes, we are putting money into our people, and yes, we have folks coming on board. Great. Thanks.
Operator
operatorThanks. We'll take the next question from John Campbell at Bank of America. Your line is open now. Go ahead.
John Campbell
analystThank you, and good morning to everyone. I have three questions, if that's alright. One concerns your dividend, another is about price review 2024, and the third relates to the current situation involving South West Water. So, beginning with the dividend: I noticed you cut it by GBP 2.4 million in connection with a fine that came your way in 2023, back in May 2023. Separately, I saw that on the seventeenth of April the Environment Agency put out a press release indicating that you were before the court alongside South West Water over what may be a different matter. Is there anything you're able to tell us regarding that case? And might it be that, should things not turn out in your favour, we could end up seeing consequences for the group dividend, whether this year or possibly in later years too, as we look ahead? The second item I'd like to raise with you is price review. You've had people floating the notion of Totex reopeners — Chris Walters discussed it in a piece for Utility Week. What, in essence, has Pennon picked up on this subject? Do you hold a view on the proposal? And the final question concerns the South West Water issue as things stand right now.
John Campbell
analystIs there an estimate of what it might potentially cost to compensate customers for the disruption, and any infrastructure-related expenses as well? Thank you.
Susan Davy
executiveAlright, John, good morning, and thanks for your questions. Maybe I’ll begin with the dividend one and then hand things over to you, Steve, for PR24. So on the dividend question—look, let’s be clear, we have a policy in K7, and we’re adhering to it. That said, we’re conscious of the very recent guidance Ofwat issued regarding dividend considerations for water businesses, and we are listening. Yes, we made an adjustment to reflect the fact that we had a court fine for South West Water last year, but really what we were doing was simply ensuring we signaled that we were listening and clearing the path for long-term shareholder value with the dividend policies we have now, and I’m sure we’ll reset for K8. So all we’re doing is saying we’re cognizant of the spotlight we’re under. We believe it’s right that we adjusted the dividends this time around for what we had come through last year, and that followed what happened with the court fine for South West Water. But that doesn’t set a precedent—it’s simply something we took into account.
Susan Davy
executiveThat likely covers everything I had on the dividend topic. And with that, I'll hand things over to you, Steve, to discuss PR24 and the Totex reopener.
Steve Buck
executiveRight, of course. Hello there, John. What we have here, essentially, is uncertainty—and this concerns a mechanism for handling that uncertainty. From where we sit, the first thing to say is that we're glad to see mechanisms for coping with uncertainty. Consider the position we're in at the moment, PR24, with investment at levels never seen before. There's still some shifting about among the different regulators and the government regarding what the obligations are for PR24. And the fact is, the world doesn't run in five-year cycles, which is what a regulatory price review imposes. So if mechanisms are going to exist that address change or provide clarity beyond those five-year boundaries, we very much welcome that. We actually believe it's good for customers too, because the worst outcome would be—and I completely understand the regulatory view here—customers paying for things that aren't clear. Equally, we don't want to end up in a situation where things become clear and there's no mechanism available, or you must wait years for it to true back up again. So we absolutely welcome it.
Steve Buck
executiveI think this is a genuinely solid proposal for addressing what is, in my view, a fair amount of uncertainty surrounding PR24 and what's behind those obligations.
Susan Davy
executiveThanks, Steve. And John, I believe you raised the question about the incident. So to be clear, right now we're just concentrating on making sure service is restored for customers in Brixham. In terms of being able to lift the boil water notice we have in place, 85% of customers are back on. And the remaining 15% of customers are what we need to focus on and get sorted. Along the way, we have given compensation to household customers. The cost of that will be single-digit millions in terms of what we've announced. But to be clear, what we're focused on at the moment is making sure supply is where it should be for those customers in Brixham, and that is my absolute focus at this point in time.
John Campbell
analystAppreciate you taking my questions.
Operator
operatorThanks. We’ll take the next question from Jenny Ping at Citi. Your line is open now. Please go ahead.
Jenny Ping
analystHi, thank you very much. Good morning, everyone. So just to follow up on John's question about the dividend. Am I right in understanding that you will in effect consider any future fines, whether from the EA or Ofwat or any other parties, on a case-by-case basis, or is this now part of the broader policy? And also, I suppose, where do you draw the line? So some of the compensation issues that you've just set out for your water challenges, drinking water business challenges, does that also flow through the dividends? Or how do you draw that line, in effect? Second one, just regarding the CapEx increase, obviously the additional GBP 80 million this year. I wondered whether you could comment on the risk of that rising further. We've obviously seen a number of increases in terms of the Totex, the last two years of the AMP. So I just wondered how confident you are, net, whether you effectively, you know, have that under control in terms of resolving some of the issues, or could we see prices and costs escalate further? And then just thirdly, just on the balance sheet, noting your net debt, are you still in the camp of being comfortable going into AMP eight without equity?
Jenny Ping
analystThanks.
Susan Davy
executiveThanks a lot, and good morning, Jenny. I'll begin with the first one, on dividends. Look, what you said is absolutely right. We've considered this in the round. It doesn't set a precedent, and it isn't policy, but we are listening, and we felt it was right to signal, you know, that it was very clearly shareholders who bear the risk of the issue that we saw for South West Water with its environmental fine last time. But we will look at this on a case-by-case basis going forward, and it's right and proper that we do that, but we are signaling that we are listening. Then, Steve, do you want to talk about the CapEx increase?
Steve Buck
executiveRight. So, Jenny, let's just confirm we mean the same GBP 80 million. There's this annoyance about having two separate GBP 80 million figures, but the one I believe you have in mind is base expenditure.
Jenny Ping
analystYeah, the base one, not… yeah.
Steve Buck
executiveYes. Yeah, yeah. So on that point — I mean, first off, I just want to be clear, because you said "about getting it under control." It is under control. So I wouldn't want to leave you with the impression that it isn't. It has — you know, what we've done is we've intentionally raised the investment because of everything I've described regarding pollutions, leaking, the quality program, and the weather. What we'll see in Year 5 is a return to the levels we've seen before, either in the prior year or the levels we've set out in our PR24 plan. So it's very much about our return to normal in terms of getting that back to what we're saying, in terms of the GBP 90 million-GBP 130 million. Do you want to answer the third one, or do you want to?
Susan Davy
executiveYes, I think so. Thanks for that, Steve. The third item concerns net debt and where we expect to end up at the close of K7 and as we move into K8. Obviously, gearing at this year-end is a bit higher than what we submitted in our business plan. But, as we've mentioned previously, we sat comfortably inside the 55 to 65 range throughout K8. Under our business plan, we obviously have to get the Draft Determination on the twelfth of June, just like everyone else, and, you know, we'll work through that process alongside Ofwat until we reach FC and see where things stand. But we're comfortable that we'll land at the end of K7, certainly well within our policy. We obviously need to hear from Ofwat what the transfer scheme will deliver.
Sarah Lester
analystThat’s great. Thanks so much.
Operator
operatorThanks. Dominic Nash from Barclays has the next question. Your line is open now, so please go ahead.
Dominic Nash
analystMorning. I have a couple of questions, if I may. First, returning to the dividend policy: could you shed some light on what was actually in the letter that Ofwat, I believe, sent around the water industry — in culture, I think — and what the guidance for dividend policy across the sector actually says? My second question is: could you update us on where you think the timeline stands for the Ofwat investigations into both your leakage figures and CSOs? Thank you.
Susan Davy
executiveSure, I'm glad to address those, John, and good morning. Regarding the detail surrounding the particular dividends and the guidance that Ofwat recently issued, we did include some notes in the SEA and the presentation we released this morning. I doubt anyone on the call will find it surprising, but as you know, Ofwat wants companies to confirm they have taken the dividend position into account in the round, examining how the business has performed and factoring in what has been delivered to customers. As you can see, our position today reflects heavy investment. Our ODIs are running at approximately 70%, which makes us one of the strongest performers in the sector on that measure. We have clearly sped up our investments and broken the back of the drought for 2022. So we have weighed all sorts of things, but the information and guidance from Ofwat plainly seeks to ensure that every aspect is being taken into consideration. With that in mind, we judged it appropriate to signal that we were listening regarding this final dividend recommended from today. And by doing so, I believe we are clearing the path for long-term shareholder value. That, John, is where we stand on that point.
Susan Davy
executiveOn the second item, regarding the question about the investigation: yes, there are 2 Ofwat investigations still outstanding — 1 concerning leakage and 1 concerning full flow to treatment. We keep providing information to Ofwat. On timing, no definitive timescale for conclusion has been given to us. But if you want my expectations, I'm hopeful it will be around Q2 of this financial year. That said, it really hinges on where those interactions take us. As I said, we haven't received any feedback as such from them, though we are continuing to share information with them.
Dominic Nash
analystThanks. Can I just ask a quick follow-up on your first response to the broader question about how performance ties to the dividend? Does that imply you believe ODI performance will grow more and more important as time goes on, and that pressure will build on you and on other companies — if the ODI figures aren't met, would the dividend perhaps have to reflect that too?
Susan Davy
executiveOkay, so John, I think — if we're focusing specifically on ODIs, when I discuss performance, meaning how we've performed overall for customers, I mentioned that we've come in 7% above our ODIs, right, as one indicator of performance, but that isn't the sole thing to consider. We're aware there are mechanisms in the regulatory regime that account for areas where we do well or, on the other hand, where we've already fallen short, and those bring financial penalties for ODIs. So I'm not claiming there's some mechanical pass-through for performers. I think it's a step back, and the fact that we're delivering at 7% levels — which places us among the stronger performers in the sector on ODIs — simply offers a sense of the broader discussion we've had on this. Now, regarding ODIs, yes, we haven't found ourselves in net rewards for ODIs during this regulatory period. Those were challenging targets that got set. You know, we've submitted a position for K8 concerning those incentives. We'll see where the DD comes out on that. But as I've said previously, and I'll repeat it, you know, a number of ODIs are entering the framework next time that aren't part of the common framework this time, and those are ones where we do well.
Susan Davy
executiveBathing waters is one of those areas, and catchment work is another, where we've seen a net ODI reward of roughly GBP 20 million for this period up to now. So I'm eager to see how the new incentive regime plays out. The issues being raised and the stance we've adopted—we believe it's the correct one, showing that we're paying attention and ensuring investors receive the dividends that form part of the policy we've established.
Dominic Nash
analystRegarding the original filings for South West Water, Bristol Water, and Sutton and East Surrey Water, what's different now about how much you think could be spent overall? The thing is, we can't really boil this down to a single figure, as the 80 showed us. It shifts constantly. Over those last nine months, how has your thinking on CapEx evolved?
Susan Davy
executiveAlright, good morning, Mark, and thank you for those questions. I understand your point regarding the dividend element, but let me be clear — and I'll repeat this — this is not a matter of precedent or of setting any precedent. It isn't about altering a policy either. It's simply that we are listening, and we are listening to the very recent guidance issued by Ofwat. So that is really all I will say on that point, Mark. On your second question, yes, over the last nine months since we submitted the business plan, we said at the time of submission that we were very confident in what we put forward, and we were very clear about the work we had done and about understanding the environmental obligations and what investment was needed to improve those areas. Our WINEP has been agreed. Yes, there are items on the call that may arise as reopeners, but I would welcome that as a process to work through. So I think we sit here confident in the plan we submitted, confident that we are progressing with it. Our supply chain is in place.
Susan Davy
executiveThat’s been in place since last autumn, and already they are working on 1,000 projects. So, you know, we are doing this, we are delivering it, and, you know, once we reach the Draft Determination we will be confident that, whatever appears in it, we have the right plan. So, I don’t believe anything has changed our view, Mark. Of course, we have had wet weather, but you will see in the presentation, you know, things where, if I take solutions on the investment side, we have been investing heavily in networks, where we have seen 70% of our solutions occurring in networks. And actually, through the wet weather, the networks have held up pretty well after all that investment. Yes, it has been good because it has given us the opportunity to see, you know, where our other assets, like compensation, are and how they are operating. But we are confident we have the right plan. And indeed, going back to the CapEx question that you had earlier, our run rate for base expenditure is our run rate going into K8. So yes, it is slightly elevated above K7 allowances, but it is the run rate going into K8, so we are confident of the plan we have put in, Mark.
Operator
operatorThanks. We move now to Ajay Patel at Goldman Sachs, whose line is open. Please proceed.
Ajay Patel
analystThanks. I suppose this may sound like I'm belaboring the issue, but I'm not certain I've fully grasped some of the responses yet. So if you take the dividend and the adjustment for the small fine we had today, and then you turn to page 24, which shows the contingencies and possible scopes for fines, I don't follow that. It's like today we're announcing an adjustment of GBP a few million to the dividend, and yet you're listening. But if any of these contingent outcomes actually leads to a fine, that you don't go in the same direction, what differs between the two that would lead to a different approach? Because right now, I'm not really getting either one, and why case by case is the right approach here. It seems that if you were to get a fine on this side of the equation, it would lead to the same result. It'd be very hard to justify otherwise, wouldn't it? Any further commentary to help me think through the logic behind that would be really helpful.
Susan Davy
executiveAlright. Thank you, Ajay, and good morning. I mean, I suspect I'll keep returning to this point — you know, you really need to examine how the business has performed across the board, but then also keep in mind the criteria Ofwat has built into licences for the water businesses, and that all water businesses — and let me be clear, this criteria has been handed to every water company to assess and to understand. We've considered our performance as a whole, and we felt it was appropriate on this occasion to make an adjustment. Now, depending on where we end up with some of those investigations, obviously, as we go forward, we want to ensure we are once again reflecting our performance in the round. Now, we fully expect to deliver — to deliver for customers, to deliver for the environment. So no, in my view this isn't a precedent being set; it simply reflects where we are and signals that we're listening.
Ajay Patel
analystI appreciate that.
Operator
operatorThank you. The last question we'll take today is from Pavan Mahbubani at JPMorgan. Your line is open now. Please go ahead.
Pavan Mahbubani
analystMorning, everyone, and thanks for taking my questions. I have a few, please. First, regarding the GBP 930 million of CapEx in the water business over the years ahead, could you clarify how much of that is base spend versus overspend? As I understand it, the incremental new base GBP 80 million you mentioned, Steve, will be treated as overspend as it flows through the Totex mechanism. Second, on the dividend, when we think about next year's payout, I understand the in the round discussions, but on what basis should we be judging the CPIH + 2 — would it be the GBP 44.37 dividend you talked about today? Or will growth be calculated on a, quote-unquote, ex fine number, around GBP 0.452 per share? And my last question is about gearing. You mention 63.5% for the... am I correct in understanding that applies only to the water business? And does that assume some leverage at group level for Pennon Power, and has that figure already stripped out the fair value adjustments? Those are my questions. Thank you.
Susan Davy
executiveSteve, would you like to address the CapEx?
Steve Buck
executiveOn CapEx — regarding what's paying for the 930, it's probably worth keeping in mind that this is obviously a five-year picture, as you know. So the price reviews, the green recovery agreement, the accelerated infrastructure, plus the reinvestment of our performance that was signaled previously — those are what fund all of it. So all of that is funded roughly by the reinvestment of our performance, which will qualify for customer sharing at K8, at the start of K8. Then if you look at this 18, to be clear, it's the 80 on base, since the enhancement one is timing only. That 80 will be classed as an overspend, and so also subject to customer sharing, and so will get 50%. Through the true-up mechanism at the beginning of K8, we expect to get 50% back.
Susan Davy
executiveRight. Then on dividends — I believe the next item, AJ, came from you, about dividends and how we should think about the coming year's. The change we made in the current year was a one-time shift in the policy stance, so it will be rising off that policy position. And the final item concerned gearing?
Steve Buck
executiveYes, that's doable. On gearing — 63.5% relates to South West Water Group. And just as a reminder, that currently leaves out Sutton and East Surrey, sorry. Well, when we report next time, assuming we've gotten a successful clearance from the CMA, it will be part of our gearing. So 63.5% is water only. We do have a few more percent of gearing. There's roughly 4% gearing up at the group level, which relates to Pennon Power, as you rightly point out, the PWS business, and also timing between South West and Pennon.
Operator
operatorThanks. We’ve got another question, this one from Bart Kubicki at Bernstein. Your line is open now — please go ahead.
Bartłomiej Kubicki
analystThank you very much, and good morning. There are just three matters I'd like to raise. First, regarding the investigations currently underway and the possible penalties, I believe this is the first time the press release has made clear that the revenues relevant to the sewage treatment works investigation are the regulated wastewater revenues, whereas for the leakage data it is the drinking water revenues. Are you confident those are indeed the relevant revenues to consider when calculating the potential fine, and therefore what the maximum fine might be across those two investigations? Second, looking at how you've incorporated Bristol Water, you mention synergies. I'm wondering whether those synergies show up somewhere in your RORE outperformance. And relatedly, looking at AMP8, have you factored those synergies into your business plan, so that as a result there would be no outperformance in AMP8 because of the consolidation, or does room for outperformance in AMP8 still exist? And my final point concerns inflation: when you provide your RORE guidance, you state that inflation will of course have a negative effect on your financial outperformance. That much is certainly clear. But would it have any effect on your Totex underperformance? In other words, will lower inflation reduce the scope for Totex underperformance, excluding the additional CapEx spend you have in 2024?
Bartłomiej Kubicki
analystI appreciate that.
Susan Davy
executiveAll right, thanks so much for the questions this morning. On the first one, I believe it concerns the revenue base that applies to the fines. Clearly, we have examined the precedent for each of those and the way they are positioned. So yes, what appears in the stock exchange announcement on that reflects how we understand it. For the leakage investigation, that would cover the sea water and drinking water revenue, while for the wastewater investigation, it would cover the wastewater revenue, as a fine imposed should findings lead to that. The second question concerns the Ofwat performance?
Steve Buck
executiveRight, so those were the synergies relating to Bristol. Where exactly do you locate them? They sit within our Totex. When you examine Southwest Group's cost base, it's essentially flat, even once you factor in how weather has affected the business. So it shows up in the Totex you're seeing today, and as a result, it feeds through into the RORE. On PR24, yes, everything is reset at PR24, and then we have to go at it again. That's precisely why you hear us highlighting the efficiency programme for K8. Regarding inflation, I believe your question is whether, as we move toward an environment of lower inflation, that alters our CapEx forecast for Years 4 and 5. That figure of 930 rests on our present assessment of how inflation is impacting our cost base.
Gill Rider
executiveIf I could jump in here, what I was really asking about is the Totex underperformance — does shifting from a high-inflation setting to a low-inflation one have any effect on that Totex outperformance or underperformance?
Steve Buck
executiveI— I— I—
Gill Rider
executiveSo I mean, is part of the reason you've underperformed on Totex that inflation has been high?
Steve Buck
executiveYes, yes. The figures we’ve been discussing already take that into account.
Susan Davy
executiveAnd you'll see in the presentation — I mean, on the cost side we've been holding our own, and in fact, as you mentioned, there are the synergies we've been delivering, so that keeps the cost base as efficient as it possibly can be, and there are further efficiencies still to come.
Gill Rider
executiveAll right, thanks.
Operator
operatorThanks. We’ve got a question coming in from Dominic Nash at Barclays. Your line is open—please go ahead.
Dominic Nash
analystHello there. Yes, sorry for wrapping up with another question as well. I'm actually just a bit curious. This is probably one of the rare occasions, I suppose, where you'll speak before we head into the draft. But during AMP7, you and the whole sector have essentially fallen short on Totex and on ODIs, and financing has more or less bailed everyone out. Yet given that financing should mean revert and inflation is coming down, et cetera, et cetera, that's plainly not something you should count on going forward. What... at what point will you be able to know how you're going to perform against ODIs and Totex after, let's say, the DD or into the FD? Do you think that if you find yourself in a position where you believe you can't deliver on those two, that would be something you'd then consider taking to the CMA? Or do you think you could put up with another AMP with negative Totex and ODI numbers?
Susan Davy
executiveThanks, Dom. Those are all excellent questions, but as you can probably guess, my answer has to be that we need to wait and see what comes out of the Draft Determination and then work our way through to the Final Determination. A few months separate the two, and we haven't laid eyes on our draft yet. So, all good questions. The point I'll keep returning to is that we submitted a genuinely strong plan. It was ambitious, yet we worked extremely hard to ensure we're already positioned to begin delivering on it. So we have a great plan. We've submitted it, and we've set out investment figures we regard as sensible, along with a sensible ODI framework, and we'll find out where Ofwat comes out on the twelfth, after which there's a process for us to go through. Obviously, you know, we'll examine what's published on the twelfth and, I'm certain, with the team I have around me, we will be holding some discussion on the twelfth with everyone, simply to bring them up to date on where we stand and how that looks for us. But there's plenty to work through between the drafts and the final.
Susan Davy
executiveThose are great questions, Dom. I appreciate them.
Dominic Nash
analystI appreciate that.
Operator
operatorThank you. Right now, there aren't any more questions in the queue, so I'll return the floor to the management team in case they'd like to make any closing comments.
Susan Davy
executiveAlright, thanks a lot, Alex. So with that, I'll pass things over to Gill.
Gill Rider
executiveWell, first off, I want to thank Susan and Steve for walking you all through it. And thanks for all your questions—they were, as always, very thoughtful. I'd just like to go back to where we began today and take you back to—if we ever needed a reminder of how important what we in the water sector do every day is, it's what people and businesses in and around Brixham are experiencing right now that reminds us of that importance. And also, you know, we've taken a lot of questions here, but our responsibilities really do stretch far and wide, and they go beyond the pipes, the treatment works, and the reservoirs, because we're investing in climate change and protecting the environment and making sure water resources are there now and for generations to come. And Pennon is really well positioned to do this, and clearly, the headlines of the day always affect how we think about the business. But we are ready to make record levels of investment, and we are transforming what we do and how we do it. Our commitment to the water sector in the UK is very clear, but we couldn't do any of this without you, our shareholders and investors.
Gill Rider
executiveAnd so, to wrap up, I want to say thanks for sticking with us, for your backing, and for the questions you raise, which always get us thinking. So many thanks to all of you.
Operator
operatorI appreciate everyone being on today's call. At this point, you're welcome to hang up your lines.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Pennon Group Plc transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Pennon Group Plc earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Pennon Group Plc or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.