Phinia Holdings Jersey Ltd (BWA) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
January 28, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorGood morning. My name is Joelle, and I will be your conference facilitator. At this time, I would like to welcome everyone to the BorgWarner to acquire Delphi Technologies investor conference call. [Operator Instructions] I would now like to turn the call over to Patrick Nolan, Vice President of Investor Relations. Mr. Nolan, you may begin your conference.
Patrick Nolan
executiveThanks, Joelle. Good morning, everyone, and thank you for joining us on our call today to discuss BorgWarner's acquisition of Delphi Technologies, which we announced earlier this morning. Joining me today are Fred Lissalde, BorgWarner President and Chief Executive Officer; Kevin Nowlan, BorgWarner Chief Financial Officer; as well as Richard Dauch, Chief Executive Officer of Delphi Technologies. We're also joined by Delphi Technologies Chief Financial Officer, Vivid Sehgal, for the Q&A portion. Before we begin, I need to inform you that during this call, we may make forward-looking statements, which involves risks and uncertainties as detailed on our 10-K. With that, I'm happy to turn the call over to our CEO, Fred?
Frederic Lissalde
executiveThanks, Pat, and welcome, everyone, and thank you for joining us on short notice this morning. This is an important day for BorgWarner. With our acquisition of Delphi Technologies, we expect to strengthen our electronics and power electronics capabilities with product, scale and respected engineering competencies, while, at the same time, advancing our balanced propulsion strategy across combustion, hybrid and electric vehicles. To summarize the key point of this transaction, let's turn to Slide 3. First and foremost, it reinforces our leadership position in electrified propulsion system as we gain scale, expertise and capabilities in electronics at a time when the industry is moving towards electrification. At the same time, it enhances our combustion, commercial vehicle and aftermarket businesses, driving an even better market balance for us. The combined company will offer a comprehensive portfolio of industry-leading products and systems across propulsion types. As we bring our offering together, I know we will be better positioned than ever before to meet our customers' evolving needs. But it's just not the strategic fit we're excited about. We believe the financial benefits are also compelling. Kevin will share the details later, but I would like to highlight that we expect this transaction to have significant synergies and to be meaningfully accretive. We also announced that our Board of Directors has authorized a share repurchase program of up to $1 billion to be executed over the next 3 years, which reflects our belief in the strong free cash flow profile of the combined company. We're confident that this transaction will deliver enhanced returns for shareholders, both in the near term and long into the future, while also advancing our vision of cleaner, more energy-efficient world. Before I discuss the strategic benefits in more detail, let me turn it over to Rick for his perspective.
Richard Dauch
executiveThank you, Fred. Good morning, and good afternoon to all of you on the call today. As Fred mentioned, this is a very significant day for both of our companies. The combination of BorgWarner and Delphi Technologies is expected to create a pioneering propulsion technologies leader with unique capabilities, a competitive global footprint and enhanced opportunities to create value for our combined stakeholders. Before I share some thoughts as to why this is a compelling transaction, I wanted to provide a quick overview of Delphi Technologies, particularly for those of you who are not familiar with our business and the journey we have been on over the last couple of years. Following the separation from our former parent, Delphi Automotive, at the end of 2017, we have focused our investments and efforts on technologies and programs that have the potential to provide the most attractive, profitable growth and support our mission to make vehicles that drive cleaner, better and further. We have more than 25 years of experience in the power electronics and related software -- system software for electrified vehicles. We recently completed the construction and launch of 3 new facilities in China, Poland and Mexico, which demonstrates our industry leadership and confidence in the future of electrification. We have developed a unique portfolio of advanced automotive-grade technologies that include inverters in our patented Viper power switch, DC/DC converters, onboard charging and battery management solutions as well as propulsion control and diagnostic software for both onboard and cloud-based systems and networks. Given the powertrain technology transition from diesel to gasoline for light vehicles, we are also launching new gasoline direct injection technology in Europe, Asia and North America. In addition, we've invested in higher-pressure diesel systems for commercial vehicles and continue to position our aftermarket business for accelerated global growth and profitability. We are also in the midst of reshaping our organization and cost structure, moving away from a historical OEM legacy type overhead structure to a leaner, Tier 1 supplier model like BorgWarner. There is tremendous opportunity across the combined companies to become a more cost-efficient business. Since announcing our 3-year $200 million restructuring plan at the end of October, we have made great progress and have already started to see benefits in the fourth quarter, as you see in our results. We are ahead of our plan in terms of our headcount and cost savings targets. I won't go through all of the details on the slide, but you can see that we have a balanced book of business. We've also enjoyed decades-long strategic supplier relationships with the leading automotive and commercial vehicle OEMs. From a product perspective, we also have a nice balance between longer-term growth technologies and more mature offerings that deliver excellent profitability and cash flow. Electronics, including power electronics, engine controllers and other gas electronics, make up approximately 18% of our 2019 sales mix. Turning to the next slide. As I just mentioned, this is a compelling transaction for our stakeholders. From a strategic perspective, this is expected to create a propulsion technology leader, made up of 2 highly complementary portfolios, with greater scale to better serve our customers, both OEMs and in the aftermarket. In my opinion, we expect our combined product portfolio in the area of electrified propulsion systems to be unmatched in the industry. For our stockholders, we expect they will benefit from the future upside and value creation opportunities from the combined company. For our employees, the combination creates exciting opportunities as they become part of a company with enhanced scale and reach based on shared values and cultures. Before turning the call back to Fred, I would just like to add that my confidence and passion about the upside potential for Delphi Technologies has not changed one bit. The combination of Delphi Technologies and BorgWarner only increases my confidence in the enhanced opportunities this will create for our stockholders, our customers and our employees. Back to you, Fred.
Frederic Lissalde
executiveThanks, Rick. At BorgWarner, we have an immense respect for Delphi Technologies employees and the portfolio of world-class products that they have developed over time. Our strategy is designed to foster growth, regardless of how the market evolves. To do that, we have been executing a balanced propulsion strategy. This transaction is consistent with that strategy and positions us even better to capitalize on future propulsion migration. On Slide 6, we show how Delphi Technologies will further strengthen our electrification portfolio. BorgWarner, as you know, has tremendous expertise in mechanical, clutching and hydraulic controls, and we have a world winning electric motor technology. Delphi Technologies [indiscernible] in electronics, software and control. What you have on this slide is an example based on the battery electric vehicle Integrated Drive Module, also called iDM, bringing together and at scale the mechanical, motor, electronics and software expertise. We will optimize all aspects of an iDM, including interfaces, software, noise, vibration harshness, systems efficiency, thermal management and control as well as costs. As a result, we will deliver a truly differentiated iDM for our customers. This equation of mechanical, plus rotating electrics plus electronics, software and controls, is applicable to many other combinations. Like all hybrid modules, P2s, P3s and hybrid transmission, it also applies to eTurbo, eBoosters and many other electrified products in our propulsion space. This is expected to unlock new opportunities for the combined company, as we will be able to offer customers a suite of both integrated and standalone offerings of mechanical, motor and power electronics products and capabilities. We didn't get to where we are today overnight. Rather, over the last several years, BorgWarner has been on a journey to transition to advanced propulsion and electrification. As you see on Slide 7, we have successfully navigated this transition by complementing organic growth with acquisition. To the extent we look outside our company for value creation opportunities, our focus is centered on technology. We believe our recent acquisition, beginning with Remy in '15, Sevcon in '17, Rinehart Motion Systems and AM Racing in '19 as well as our joint venture with Romeo Power Technologies have positioned the company for success in both the near and long term. As the industry advances towards more and more electrification, we knew we needed to -- we needed increased electronics capabilities and scale, and today, we're doing just that. Of course, the success of this evolution would not have been possible without the hard work of the BorgWarner employees around the world. I want to thank them. I have no doubt that this team will continue to flourish alongside our new teammates from Delphi Technologies. Let's now look at our revenue mix versus the industry mix on Slide 8. We have been positioning BorgWarner to be slightly overweight in hybrid and electric by 2023, while maintaining a relatively balanced exposure to the overall industry. Delphi Technology adds towards this goal and better positions us as the industry moves towards electrification, while enabling us to maintain flexibility across all propulsion architectures. By 2023, we estimate the breakdown of pro forma BorgWarner will be 63% in combustion, 29% in hybrid and 8% in electric. This 8% in electric would represent a 30% increase in BorgWarner's standalone exposure to the electric market. The combined company will be a leader across all propulsion types, serving customers around the globe, whether in combustion, hybrid or electric propulsion, while it is easy to see the benefits we're getting with Delphi Technologies' electronics and power electronics capabilities, also gaining complementary products on the combustion side. Let's turn to Slide 9. Today, BorgWarner is outgrowing the combustion market because our product has penetration rates that have continued to grow. This is driven by the increasing regulation for CO2 fuel economy and emission. Delphi Technologies expects similar outgrowth for some of their core products. A good example is their GDI business that goes hand-in-hand with our turbocharger business. Both continue to enjoy increased penetration rates in combustion vehicle, and we should not forget that both of these mainstream products are also experiencing even stronger growth and higher penetration rates on hybrid vehicles. Everything I've said so far is consistent with our stated balanced propulsion strategy. As we continue to adapt to the changing market landscape, we've made it a point to maintain a level of market balance, as you see on Slide 10. With Delphi Technologies, we're also enhancing our end-market exposure to commercial vehicles and the aftermarket business, which we find attractive. And as you look at the chart on the right side of the slide, you'll see that our geographic mix remains diversified, which is important for us. Before I hand it over to Kevin to discuss the financials in more detail, I thought it would be useful to show you on Slide 11 what our combined portfolio would look like. First and foremost, we are enhancing our position in electrified propulsion as we're gaining scale, technology and talent in electronics, adding to our existing electrification capabilities. Second, we're gaining complementary offering across combustion, hybrid commercial vehicle and the aftermarket. As a combined company, we look forward to delivering superior solutions to our customers, while delivering increased value for our shareholders. And now I'll turn the call over to Kevin to discuss the terms of the transaction as well as the compelling financial benefits.
Kevin Nowlan
executiveThanks, Fred. Before I dive in, I would first like to echo some of Fred's comments. It is because of our proven track record of delivering strong financial results that we are in a position today to announce an exciting transaction like this. At BorgWarner, we manage our portfolio actively and take a thoughtful and deliberate approach to capital deployment, which ensures we can capitalize on value-creating opportunities when they arrive. And at the same time, because of our strong cash flow generating ability, we are able to maintain strong liquidity and a very prudent leverage profile, which allows us to effectively manage our business through the demand cycle, while continuing to invest for the future. As Fred discussed, this transaction is consistent with our balanced propulsion strategy, and it also fits within our stated M&A criteria and our capital allocation priorities. Let's turn to Slide 12. As you undoubtedly saw in our press release this morning, under the terms of the agreement, Delphi Technologies stockholders will receive a fixed exchange ratio of 0.4534 shares of BorgWarner common stock for each share of Delphi Technologies they own. That equates to an implied equity purchase price of roughly $17.39 per share. We view this as a very attractive acquisition multiple of 6.4x on 2019's EBITDA. But after you consider run rate synergies, the multiple is closer to 5.2x. One of our priorities in this transaction is to maintain our strong balance sheet, which we think is a competitive advantage for BorgWarner. As we head toward closing, we anticipate that we will upsize our revolving credit facility to provide more liquidity in support of a larger pro forma company. And then because we are executing a stock-for-stock transaction, we expect to maintain a healthy leverage profile, with pro forma gross debt to adjusted EBITDA of approximately 1.6x at closing. We expect that this will continue to support our strong investment-grade credit rating. And finally, we anticipate that the transaction will close in the second half of 2020 following the satisfaction of customary closing conditions. Now let's turn to Slide 13, where you can see the pro forma financial profile of the combined company, starting with revenue growth. As we've discussed in the past, we expect BorgWarner standalone market outgrowth to be approximately 500 basis points for the 2021 through 2023 time frame. Nothing has changed in that regard. On a combined basis, we expect the pro forma company to continue to deliver strong outgrowth of approximately 450 basis points. And keep in mind, that's on a larger base business. But what's really exciting for us regarding the revenue growth is the potential as we look beyond 2023. We believe we will see significant revenue synergy potential from an increased win rate and accelerated time to market, particularly for the integrated electrified product offerings Fred highlighted, which we expect will deliver further value creation to the company's stockholders long into the future. Turning to margins. In 2019, BorgWarner's adjusted operating margin was approximately 12.1%, while Delphi Technologies operating margin was approximately 7.2%. Factoring in the impact of purchase price amortization associated with this transaction, the company's combined margin would be approximately 10%. However, as I'll detail on the next slide, we expect $125 million of cost synergies in 2023. After you account for these synergies, the company's pro forma margin would be around 11%, which would still be among the strongest in our industry. So from a financial perspective, this transaction delivers continued market outgrowth and sustains our strong margin profile, both of which we're really excited about. Now let's discuss a couple of the key attributes more specifically associated with this transaction on Slide 14. Starting on the left side of the slide, a critical part of our due diligence efforts is centered on synergies associated with the transaction. Based on a thorough analysis, we expect to generate at least $125 million of cost synergies in 2023. The bulk of these savings are driven by SG&A and procurement synergy opportunities. And as you can see, we believe that nearly all of these savings will already be in the P&L in 2022. Also it's worth noting that these cost synergies are entirely incremental to the existing cost savings plans that both companies are already working on. As it relates to those other cost savings initiatives, we've done a lot of work around Delphi Technologies' previously announced restructuring plan and feel really good about where they're tracking. And while we aren't going to break down those numbers in any further detail, I will say that we are confident in our ability to effectively execute on the balance of their plan following the closing, in addition to delivering on the cost synergies inherent in this transaction. Shifting to the right side of the slide, you can see how the cost synergies are expected to drive meaningful earnings accretion by the time we get to 2022. Specifically, on an adjusted GAAP basis, we expect EPS accretion of $0.31 in 2022, and that's even with an estimated $65 million to $70 million of incremental purchase price amortization flowing through the P&L, or roughly $0.19 per share. If you exclude that noncash amortization, the transaction is accretive from day 1, and the EPS accretion would be closer to $0.50 in 2022. Importantly, these accretion figures don't contemplate the upside we'll generate from the new share buyback program we're announcing today, which I'll cover on the next slide. The bottom line is this. We believe this transaction is good for both companies' stockholders, all of whom will have the potential to share in the meaningful financial benefits we expect to deliver. Another exciting announcement that we've made today is summarized on Slide 15. As Fred mentioned, our Board of Directors has authorized a new share repurchase program of up to $1 billion to be executed over the next 3 years. This authorization is a testament to our strong belief in the value creation potential of this transaction and the strong free cash flow profile of the combined company. Over time, we expect these share repurchases to largely offset the dilutive effects of the share issuance at closing. Over the years, we have maintained a disciplined approach to deploying capital in support of stockholder value-creating opportunities. And as we told you on previous meetings, that is our capital allocation strategy going forward. This new authorization is entirely consistent with our capital allocation framework: generate strong cash flow; reinvest for growth in the business, both organically and inorganically; and return capital to stockholders. So to sum up, from a purely financial perspective, we think we're executing this transaction at an attractive valuation multiple. We expect to maintain a strong balance sheet even after closing. We're going to continue to drive long-term revenue outgrowth, while sustaining a top-tier margin profile. We'll deliver a meaningfully accretive deal driven by the significant cost synergies we expect to generate. And we remain bullish on the long-term cash flow generating ability of the company as evidenced by our new $1 billion buyback program. With that, I'll now turn the call back over to Fred.
Frederic Lissalde
executiveThanks, Kevin. We will open up the call for Q&A in a few moments. Before doing so, let me reiterate that this transaction represents the next step in accelerating our product and system offering in electrified propulsion as well as executing our balanced propulsion strategy, as you can see outlined on Slide 16. Technology has been a driving factor in our M&A pipeline. And with Delphi Technologies, we are capitalizing on an opportunity that adds electronic products, capabilities and scale, while strengthening our combustion, commercial vehicle and aftermarket business. As the industry moves towards electrification, I am confident that, together with the great team at Delphi Technologies, we will be able to leverage these trends, meet the demands of our customers around the globe and deliver significant value to our shareholders. Thank you all for joining us today. Now I will turn it back over to Pat.
Patrick Nolan
executiveThank you, Fred. Joelle, we're ready to open it up for questions.
Operator
operator[Operator Instructions] Our first question comes from Rod Lache with Wolfe Research.
Rod Lache
analystI wanted to ask 2 questions. First, longer term, it does look like there should be some technical synergies in electrification as well as combining your combustion technologies, Delphi on the fuel management and BorgWarner on the air management with turbos and variable valve timing, and that could differentiate you. Was hoping you can maybe give a couple of examples of how that actually practically will come together from your customers' perspective. What's the potential efficiency gain from combining products? And actually, are customers really awarding business in a way that, that would allow you to take advantage of that?
Frederic Lissalde
executiveYes, the technical synergies are extremely important. Technology was the drive for this transaction. Who else in the world is going to have engineering production at scale and purchasing at scale of mechanical products, rotating electrics -- electronics and software and system capabilities? That is going to differentiate the offering of BorgWarner around the globe not only for battery electric vehicle, so-called iDM, still going to be key, but also on hybrid powertrain P2s, P3s. And we feel that we can really generate customer value in bringing together those knowhow and designing the best system and the best product we can not only being -- having to sell a system, but also being able to sell inverters on its own, motor on its own or mechanical products on its own. This is going to be a key differentiating factors for us. And you're right, from a GDI standpoint and air management standpoint, turbo, EGR, all those products are key products to make engines cleaner, more efficient. And those state-of-the-art engines are growing in the hybrid world, so this is exactly why we think that this transaction makes a lot of sense.
Rod Lache
analystOkay. But your customers are awarding business in a way that allows you to take advantage of that. Or do they sort of do all that in house.
Frederic Lissalde
executiveYou don't have -- if you see the product, we don't have overlap of products, and our customers are looking for people they can talk system with. And the match of those 2 companies is like hand in glove from an electrified propulsion standpoint as well from -- as well as from a combustion standpoint and commercial vehicle standpoint.
Rod Lache
analystOkay. And for both Rick and Fred, I understand that there's a fantastic power electronics business inside of Delphi and it's growing 50% per year, but that's around 60% of the company. And from the Street's perspective, there's been a lot of focus on the risks. Organic growth was a bit negative in 2019. There's still significant commercial vehicle, China, light-duty diesel exposure, which seems like that could continue to be a headwind. Could you just talk a little bit about how you're thinking that plays out in the near term? And then longer term, are there significant restructurings needed in both companies' combustion businesses as some of those businesses transform?
Frederic Lissalde
executiveSo we're confident in Delphi Technologies' growth potential. We think that this is really compelling. We are doing our own restructuring program, and we'll talk more about that in a couple of weeks. And during due diligence, we were impressed with project pioneer, how Rick and his team are managing it. And I want to turn it over to Rick to give you a little bit more color on that.
Richard Dauch
executiveYes, thanks for the question, Rod. So as you know, I've been pretty open about some of the things we're doing at Delphi Technologies. We've got some major launches that we have focused on our GDI business and we have 5 plants in GDI. We have a sixth coming on now. Those launches are going quite well. We're working through our supply base to make sure they're ready to go at the higher levels in 2020. So I feel very confident about that. Two, we have some major commercial vehicle launches to meet the emission requirements for 2021, and we're on track for those as well. And most importantly, as we announced in October a $200 million restructuring, we are executing that very aggressively. We're quite -- we're ahead of schedule. We've already completed 1 of our works council negotiations with 2 underway as we speak. And we think we'll be able to beat some of those numbers.
Operator
operatorYour next question comes from John Murphy with Bank of America.
John Murphy
analystAnd congratulations on this. Just a first question, given the industrial logic that you guys laid out, it's pretty obvious and it makes sense all day long. I'm just curious what the impetus for executing on something like this, right now, at this time. Was it just opportunistic just given what's happened with Delphi's share price? Or is there something else you're seeing out there? Just trying to understand why now.
Frederic Lissalde
executiveWe are -- we think that it's the right timing from a technology perspective to capitalize on the growth of electrified powertrain. And we've structured the deal in a way that protects our strong balance sheet. And we're very, very confident in the strong free cash flow generation of the combined company.
John Murphy
analystOkay. But there's nothing as -- I mean, is this more opportunistic just given what's happened with the share price, Fred, you'd say? I mean, because the industrial logic makes sense. I mean, I totally agree with you. But was this just opportunistic? Or is there something else that you're seeing? I understand the tech.
Kevin Nowlan
executiveYes. And I think -- this is Kevin. I mean, we take a thoughtful approach, as you know, to capital deployment at this company, which maintain -- where we maintain a prudent leverage profile and generate strong free cash flow, which simply means we can capitalize on opportunities when they arise. And that's what we did in this particular situation. And so important for us was that as we look at the strategic rationale of this transaction, both companies were interested in ensuring that both sets of shareholders would fully participate in the upside potential of this company going forward, while protecting the balance sheet and delivering an accretive transaction to shareholders by the second full year of the deal.
John Murphy
analystYes. Okay, that makes sense. And then just a follow-up on management. There was no mention, Rick, of you staying on board. I mean, given that Delphi is going through a pretty heavy sort of launch and rationalization process in the business, what's your commitment to the combined entity? Are you going to be staying on for a number of years? How have you guys worked that out?
Frederic Lissalde
executiveI -- Rick is a terrific leader, and I am impressed by his career and the way he's run the company. We're going to work very, very close to -- with each other to make sure that we ensure a seamless transition and a very, very successful integration. And we've both been very, very pleased to have been -- to strike this deal.
John Murphy
analystSo there's no term that's settled right now as this deal is closing. So this is still a TBD, Fred.
Frederic Lissalde
executiveYes. I think, for now, we're taking each step after the other. We're focusing on integration. And Rick and I are going to stay very, very close to each other, and we'll keep you posted.
Richard Dauch
executiveYes, let me make a comment, John, in terms of -- my job right now is to run the day-to-day business of Delphi Technologies, make sure we get the shareholder approval across the board in April and make sure I work with Fred and his team to establish a detailed plan to execute a successful integration of our 2 companies in the near future. That's our focus. And Fred and I will take it from there.
Operator
operatorYour next question comes from Emmanuel Rosner with Deutsche Bank.
Emmanuel Rosner
analystSo the -- there definitely are some attractive technologies that BorgWarner would acquire as part of Delphi -- as part of this Delphi acquisition. It also seems though that, at least in the near term, you sort of like dilute a little bit your growth profile, a little bit your sort of like margin outlook. And so I wanted to see, Fred, you could comment on what you felt was sort of like the absolute needed technology, the absolute needed parts of Delphi that would sort of make sense to sort of take this risk in the near term, both on how much execution needs to happen for the combination as well as potentially diluting some of your near-term metrics and it makes it all worth it.
Frederic Lissalde
executiveWe like the whole portfolio at Delphi Technologies. And you've seen in Kevin's remark that our outgrowth of the combined company is still going to be in the top quartile with 450 basis point outgrowth. But more importantly, I think that the combination, back to Rod's first question is really -- the purpose is really to work for sustaining a clear outgrowth above market and capitalizing on the acceleration of electrified powertrain. I will let Kevin give more color on margin. But from a top line perspective, this is really a key differentiating factor where we bring world-class electronics with mechanical rotating electric. We've been incredibly impressed by the talent and the capability at Delphi Technologies.
Kevin Nowlan
executiveAnd with respect, Emmanuel, to the margin profile, as I mentioned, as we bring these 2 companies together and then execute on our $125 million of run rate synergies, we expect this company to be operating around 11% operating margin, which we believe puts us in the top quartile of companies in this space. So we will continue to sustain our strong margin profile. And when you couple that with the revenue outgrowth we'll continue to generate on this larger revenue base, it's going to support long-term free cash flow generation, which is why we announced the $1 billion buyback program today. So we feel really good about the operating profile of this business going forward.
Emmanuel Rosner
analystGreat. And then as a follow-up, still speaking about the outgrowth in your some -- I guess, some of the near-term challenges. I couldn't help but notice that -- so on Slide 13, your outgrowth slide speaks about the period between 2021 and 2023. At the same time, this morning, you obviously provided an initial 2020 outlook as well, which sort of suggests revenue down organically and then only 1.5 points of growth sort of above market. Can you maybe comment about some of the dynamics in the nearer term? What's happening in 2020 with both pieces? Why is sort of like the outgrowth versus market much lower, maybe where the backlog is? And then similar on Delphi, if that's something that you care to comment on.
Kevin Nowlan
executiveYes, let me -- I'll take that, Emmanuel. And starting with the 2020 outlook. I think to understand that even, you have to start with 2019 and how we wrapped up the year. And you probably saw on our pre-announcement of our results this morning, we actually had much higher revenue than we have been guiding to before. And our outgrowth was very significant in the fourth quarter. And when you look on a full year basis, our outgrowth came in at about 530 basis points, which was above our previous guidance. And actually, that's even with about 100 basis point headwind from CV. So we had significant outgrowth, particularly in the fourth quarter of 2019. Now some of that could have been a pull ahead, particularly in China, where we saw really strong outgrowth, and that might have been a pull ahead of some volumes from early part of 2020. And we also saw diesel production up for our business in Q4 beyond what we expected as well. So some of those things have the potential to create a headwind as we head into 2020, depending on how those markets play out. I think you need to think about that as you factor in the guidance that we have. Then just generally on 2020, we're expecting markets to be under pressure, as we've talked about previously, down about 2% to 4% in aggregate, and that's impacting our overall guide.
Operator
operator[Operator Instructions] Your next question comes from Joseph Spak with RBC Capital Markets.
Joseph Spak
analystI wanted to focus in on the synergy target for a second because on the scope of the combined company, it actually looks a little bit small. And I know there's a lot going on at both companies. Each company has its own restructuring. You've got some integration risk. So I guess, I'm wondering whether you factored in some of the complexity and being able to achieve some of the synergies for that target.
Kevin Nowlan
executiveThanks, Joe. I'll take that one. I mean, when we look at the synergies, we performed a thorough analysis on the business and what we thought we could actually execute on a risk-adjusted basis and truly deliver in 2022, 2023 time frame. But I think it's actually a pretty healthy synergy level, about 2.8%, 2.9% of the revenue of the Delphi Technologies company. That's pretty consistent with the types of synergies, I think, we've seen in precedent deals. But more importantly, it's what -- we're confident we're going to be able to [indiscernible] as we build up our detailed plans going into the post signing period here and in the pre-merger integration. So we feel really confident about that.
Joseph Spak
analystOkay. And then just a second one on -- and it's back to, I think, Rod's first question. Like the industrial logic between putting turbos and injectors together, I think, makes a lot of sense. I guess you guys are implying you could package that as a system. Does that -- do you think that helps you either protect margins on the ICE portion of the portfolio or potentially even enhance the margins there?
Frederic Lissalde
executiveJoe, I think the combination of the 2 companies from a technology standpoint, from a differentiation standpoint is much more important and acute in the electrified propulsion area with iDM, P4, P3, P2. From an engine standpoint, it's true that you've got a few key sub-elements of an engine. Air path is 1, and fuel is 2. Electronics is extremely important. We see some potential from an engineering standpoint. I would -- but I would say that from a technology standpoint, the technical synergies are more important in the electrified propulsion architectures than in the combustion side.
Operator
operatorYour next question comes from Chris McNally with Evercore ISI. Our next question comes from Brian Johnson with Barclays.
Brian Johnson
analystReally a question for BorgWarner because I think I know that Delphi answered this. But Delphi Tech has struggled with the transition from diesel to gas GDI, ramping the gas GDI factories with enough scale to be profitable as well as potentially just with a lot of capacity competitors in the GDI relative to diesel, perhaps margins there. So what did you find in your due diligence that got you comfortable with the P&L implications of this transition? And is there anything you're bringing to this that will make the transition from diesel to GDI less painful?
Kevin Nowlan
executiveYes, Brian, it's Kevin. I'll talk to that. That was an area of focus for us, was really understanding the margin implications on the business as we've seen some of the shift from diesel to gas to GDI. And that Rick and Vivid have been very open about in terms of how that's impacted the business. I think the key for us, as we look ahead, was then getting comfortable with how that trajectory plays out combined with the restructuring initiative that Fred and his team have laid out and are executing on it. So we were comfortable after diligencing that plan that, that's exactly what the business needs to be able to mitigate the impact of that transition from a margin perspective.
Brian Johnson
analystOkay. And just more of a housekeeping question. Can you comment on what you're going to do with the Delphi balance sheet and some of the debt they have outstanding?
Kevin Nowlan
executiveYes. I mean, it's -- when we get to closing, we'll talk a little bit further about that. But I think with the term loan that's outstanding, our anticipation -- our expectation is that we'll pay that off with -- at closing with some combination of cash and probably a new issuance on BorgWarner's part. And with respect to the notes that are currently outstanding, we will assume those obligations at the BorgWarner level, the details of how that transaction to work be -- to be discussed as we get closer to closing.
Operator
operatorYour next question comes from Noah Kaye with Oppenheimer.
Noah Kaye
analystFred, you said that the technology logic here is really more on the hybrid and electric side. So getting back to the power electronics portfolio that you're acquiring, I guess, what did you see in the technology suite that really stood out to you, impressed you? The company, Delphi, has obviously had a lot of bookings with the business on the technology side. Sometimes they've highlighted design as well as introduction of new materials. But as you look at what they are bringing to the table relative to kind of your own history, including what you acquired with Sevcon, what from a technology standpoint stood out to you? And what are customers asking for that they bring?
Frederic Lissalde
executiveNoah, first, we were impressed by the electronics knowhow overall and the scale that -- and the talent and the capabilities on the electronics. First, power electronics, this is world-class. Delphi Technologies is really ahead of the curve. I think they're a year advanced than others. The power modules, the Viper, the 800-volt inverters, all this was looked at in great detail from a software standpoint, from a system management standpoint. This was clearly, as we start talking, really became obvious that this was just a world-class technology that they're running.
Noah Kaye
analystYes. And you've said in the past, and we've asked this question when it comes to motors and other components about preference for a system sale versus a component sale. Here you have power electronics, really, which has been kind of a standalone component play for Delphi. Are you anticipating -- and this is really just a question about what your customers are indicating that more of your sales, integrating this portfolio are going to be in that standalone variety over the next several years. Or do you think that you're going to have more traction getting wins for the iDM kind of on a shifting basis relative to the standalone strategy that Delphi has pursued?
Frederic Lissalde
executiveI think you will see both. You will see customers that we won by subcomponents. But when you march towards what I call iDM generation 2, it is absolutely obvious that some customers will want a system. And with Delphi Technologies and BorgWarner with inverters, motors and transmission under one roof, we'll create differentiation.
Operator
operatorYour next question comes from Dan Levy with Crédit Suisse.
Dan Levy
analystFirst, just looking at Slide '18, and I know, generally in combustion, not as much an overlap, but could you just talk to where there may be areas of product overlap in combustion? I believe that you both do valvetrain. And similarly, are there any product areas that you may look at and view to be noncore? I mean I know for the Delphi team in the past, the areas like powertrain, like canisters, that doesn't get as much airtime. So what are the areas of overlap? And what might be viewed as noncore in the combined entity?
Frederic Lissalde
executiveThere is -- and that's what we love. There is not much overlap. You have a little bit of valvetrain that I think we're going to strengthen even more. We're confident in Delphi growth potential. We like everything we've seen. And your question around potential divestiture, we're not here yet. We had to announce the deal today. And the portfolio management is something that we do continuously. The Delphi Technologies did continuously that we would carry on doing continuously.
Dan Levy
analystGreat. And then as a follow-up, wanted to ask on the engineering side because for the Delphi team, this has obviously been very central to the restructuring. Obviously, as you're combining, there's probably going to be incremental engineering rationalization that's going to need to occur. Could you just talk to some of the challenges that may occur around further rationalizing the combined engineering resources of the company? And specifically, what type of cash restructuring expense might we expect to see? And if I'm also doing the math of pro forma R&D as a percent of revenue gets to roughly 6%, is that a fair run rate for what the combined company should be? Or should it be lower?
Kevin Nowlan
executiveWell, I'll take that. And when we think of the synergies that we're talking about from the combined company, there's still a lot of work to do between now and closing before we can provide significant details. Obviously, in any transaction like this, it's not uncommon for there to be headcount reductions across the combined organization, but it's premature to get into that at this point. We've got a lot of work to do to get to closing. But what I would say is we have a great deal of respect for the Delphi Technologies team around the world, and we look forward to benefiting from their expertise as part of the combined company.
Operator
operatorYour next question comes from Armintas Sinkevicius with Morgan Stanley.
Armintas Sinkevicius
analystJust thinking back to the time where Delphi spun from Aptiv, and I think we were having a conversation around potential consolidation then, not that I would expect you to talk up potential deals or whether you were even looking at it then. But just curious, you had all the pieces in place with the Remy acquisition and the Sevcon acquisition. And really, it was all about growing scale, and you have the capabilities there. So maybe you could talk to -- was it the scale that gravitated you towards Delphi, were there some capabilities that are particularly interesting that you didn't -- you had not yet developed? Just thinking through that process.
Frederic Lissalde
executiveWe are executing our strategy. And from an M&A perspective, I always said that technology was going to be the main driver in getting scale in power electronics and system expertise. This is exactly what we're doing today. We've been very impressed with what we saw from a technology standpoint. Delphi Technologies has scale in areas that -- where we don't have scale. We have scale in areas they don't have scale. And the people and the engagement of their people has been just extraordinary from what we've seen. Looking forward to combine those 2 teams and create a lot of value.
Armintas Sinkevicius
analystOkay. And then perhaps, Delphi, since the spin of Aptiv, has had a series of negative estimate revisions here. New management team placed to have a transformation strategy in place. And it seems like we're dropping earnings. But what gave you confidence that the trajectory is about to change for Delphi?
Kevin Nowlan
executiveYes. I think we -- I mean, we had a large team of our experts go in and perform due diligence on the company and really build up from the ground up, our assessment of the valuation of the business and the financial prospects of the business. So we have a lot of confidence in what we think this combined company will look like. And what we think it looks like is, as you get out a couple of years, a fully accretive transaction and a company that's delivering 11% operating margin.
Operator
operatorWe have time for one final question and that question comes from James Picariello with KeyBanc Capital.
James Picariello
analystJust thinking about the pro forma leverage of 1.6x on a gross basis, what could that look like on a net leverage basis? And then given your internal free cash flow expectations, the $1 billion share buyback effort you announced, what's your targeted net leverage over the next 3 years or so? And just how should we be thinking about this trajectory?
Kevin Nowlan
executiveYes. So at closing, you're right, we expect 1.6x on a gross basis. I think that's going to translate to about 1.2x on a net basis at closing. As we look ahead, the capital -- how we deploy future capital going forward, remember, our approach hasn't changed. We have a strong balance sheet, and we don't think there's anything else we need to do to reduce the leverage profile of this business. We'll increase our liquidity associated with -- by increasing the size of our revolving credit facility, but we have exactly what we need from a balance sheet perspective as we look ahead. I think your expectation should be that, that leverage ratio probably trends down a little bit over time simply because of the growth in earnings, not because we need to take out more leverage from the business. So what does that mean with incremental cash generation? It means that it's consistent with the historic track record we have of deploying that capital in smart ways to invest in growth, whether it's organic or inorganic, or return value to shareholders. And that's how you should think about our cash flow generation as we move ahead.
James Picariello
analystGot it. That's helpful. And then just 2 housecleaning items. The $0.30 accretion in 2022, that reflects no buyback deployment within the $1 billion authorization. And then was this an auction deal or privately negotiated?
Kevin Nowlan
executiveI'll answer the first question. I'll turn it over to Fred for the second. But the $0.31 in 2022 has no buybacks in it, that's correct.
Frederic Lissalde
executiveYes, we started talking -- we know the industry, we know the players and we've started talking to each other early '19. And the discussion accelerated at the end of last year. And as we carried on talking, it became obvious that the combination of the 2 assets were going to generate a lot of value and make a lot of sense.
Patrick Nolan
executiveSo with that, I'd like to thank you all for your great questions today. Joelle, you can wrap up the call.
Operator
operatorThat does conclude the BorgWarner to acquire Delphi Technologies conference call. You may now disconnect.
This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Phinia Holdings Jersey Ltd earnings transcripts and 32,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $24.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.