Siemens Energy AG (ENR) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

August 7, 2023

Deutsche Boerse Xetra DE Industrials Electrical Equipment earnings 90 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Morning, everyone, and thanks for joining Siemens Energy's conference call for the third quarter of 2023. Just a note that this call is being recorded. Before we get started, please take a look at the safe harbor statement found on page 2 of the Siemens Energy presentation. During this call, we may make forward-looking statements. Such statements rest on the company's present expectations and specific assumptions, which means they carry certain risks and uncertainties. A question-and-answer session will follow the presentation. To ask a question, press star then 1 on your phone's keypad. Should you want to leave the question queue, press star then 2. I'd now like to hand things over to today's host, Michael, sorry, the Head of Investor Relations. Please go ahead.

Michael Hagmann

executive
#2

Thanks so much, Natalie. Good morning, and a warm welcome to our Q3 conference call. As usual, every document went out at 7:00 A.M. on our website. Our President and CEO, Christian Bruch, our CFO, Maria Ferraro, and the CEO of Siemens Gamesa, Jochen Eickholt, are all here alongside me. Christian, Jochen, and Maria will walk you through the key developments from the past quarter. That should take roughly 45 minutes, and after that, as Natalie mentioned, we'll move to a Q&A session. We've set aside one and a half hours for the whole conference call so we can get to as many questions as possible. I can already see plenty of questions coming in, so later on, please keep to one question if you can. With that, I'll pass things to Christian. Christian, the floor is yours.

Christian Bruch

executive
#3

Good morning, everyone, on my side as well — many thanks for being with Maria, Jochen, and me on our Quarter Three conference call. I trust that you and your families are healthy and safe. This has been an exceptionally tough quarter for Siemens Energy. The former gas and power businesses turned in an outstanding performance, but at Siemens Gamesa we took a severe setback. As we stressed in our ad hoc communication on June 22nd, two factors in particular drove the unexpected charges at Siemens Gamesa. First, we found higher failure rates after a certain runtime for specific components in the onshore products 4.X and 5.X. Second, the productivity gains that were targeted for Quarter Three did not materialize, especially with regard to the ramp-up of the offshore business. We have launched a series of remediation actions and had to book substantial charges this quarter. Jochen will walk you through more detail on this call about the problems and challenges at Siemens Gamesa, and about the actions we are taking. That said, I am very impressed with the entire, entire Siemens Energy team and with how they are supporting their Siemens Gamesa colleagues, finding solutions, addressing the challenges, and really implementing the measures now.

Christian Bruch

executive
#4

I want to say this to everyone at Siemens Gamesa as well: this is a very tough situation, and I'm confident that by working together, we'll get past the challenges we're facing right now. The market environment for the former gas and power businesses keeps improving, and we're also seeing robust demand in the wind business, with customers increasingly aware that the economics have to work across the value chain. Maria will, as she always does, walk you through the financials. I'll go directly to what we expect the impact to be for the full fiscal year 2023. The issues I mentioned at Siemens Gamesa weigh heavily on our guidance, especially on profit before special items and net income, as a result of the charges taken in Q3. We still anticipate strong growth for Siemens Energy Group, though slightly lower than previously. Due to the charges at Siemens Gamesa, we anticipate a negative profit margin before special items of -8% to -10%. Since we also have changes to valuation allowances tied to deferred tax asset, we anticipate a net loss of roughly EUR 4.5 billion for fiscal year 2023. Owing to Siemens Gamesa, we now anticipate a cash outflow of up to a low triple-digit million EUR amount.

Christian Bruch

executive
#5

Before I turn things over to Jochen for more detail on the Siemens Gamesa developments, I'd like to talk about how the former Gas and Power businesses have performed so far this year. As you're aware, that's 2/3 of our revenue, and what we're seeing right now is a great illustration of how to fix businesses that have been struggling. In the third quarter, the pattern looked just like it did in Q1 and Q2. Orders grew strongly, which mirrors the robust demand out there in the market; revenue also grew strongly as we work through the backlog; margins improved strongly as well, helped by the selectivity we've shown over the past 2 to 3 years when it comes to projects, by our cost measures, and by lower non-conformity costs; and cash flow was strong thanks to the high order level. What that adds up to is excellent performance at the former gas and power businesses across the first nine months of the year. The most striking part is that those businesses brought in EUR 1.4 billion in EBIT, with cash conversion above one thus far this year. Building on how good our products are, our worldwide footprint, and the openings the energy transition creates, we took orders worth EUR 27.3 billion. That works out to a run rate of EUR 9.1 billion each quarter, which is nearly twice the quarterly run rates we saw in 2020.

Christian Bruch

executive
#6

For the first nine months, revenue in the former gas and power business increased 22% on a comparable basis, reaching EUR 16.1 billion. That EUR 1.4 billion in profit before special items that I referred to earlier corresponds to an 8.7% margin. That represents a gain of over seven percentage points from our starting point in 2020. As a result, Gas Services, Grid Technologies, and Transformation of Industry are each on track to meet every assumption we set out at the start of the year, and they are well positioned to hit the midterm targets established at the Capital Markets Day in May last year. Because we concentrate on selective bidding, cost out, and operational excellence, we are confident these businesses will keep developing even more favorably amid the positive market development. As usual, allow me to share a few examples of our highlight projects from the last quarter. The first project illustrates well how we help customers facilitate the energy transition through improving security of supply, since the plant will serve as a backup when renewable generation is lower. Castlelost, the project, a company in Ireland, awarded us a contract for 275 open cycle gas turbines.

Christian Bruch

executive
#7

We're supplying five SGT-800 turbines plus the control system for that plant. Their reason for picking us comes down to the flexibility, reliability, and redundancy our solution delivers. On top of that, the technology is future-proof, since the plant could potentially be converted to operate on hydrogen with zero carbon emissions. Our leadership position in offshore wind is what the second project underscores. An agreement was signed by RWE with Siemens Gamesa to construct their 1 GW Thor offshore wind project in Denmark. That offshore wind park, featuring 72 14-megawatt turbines — 40 of them fitted with recyclable blades — will supply green energy to over 1 million Danish households. Offshore installation is expected in 2026, and it will be fully operational no later than 2027. How we can stabilize grids is shown once more by the project with Conrad Energy. An order was awarded to us by Conrad Energy for three synchronous condensers across two projects in the UK. In cases of volatility and electricity generation, these synchronous condensers will help stabilize the grid. Our ability to reduce carbon emissions in the process industry is demonstrated by the last project. A contract has been awarded by the Ksi Lisims LNG project in Canada to Siemens Energy to assist with the project's design: liquification, compression, and associated electrical systems.

Christian Bruch

executive
#8

Built to tie into British Columbia’s renewable hydroelectric power supply, Ksi Lisims’ LNG emissions are going to be more than 90% lower than what a conventional LNG facility powered by gas turbines would produce, giving it one of the lowest carbon intensities among LNG export terminals anywhere in the world. That obviously makes us very proud. With that said, let me hand things over now to Jochen, who will give you more detail on the current Siemens Gamesa situation?

Jochen Eickholt

executive
#9

Okay, thank you, Christian. And good morning, everyone joining us. Let me get into a few specifics regarding the quality issues we've seen in Siemens Gamesa's onshore business. So, in the course of monitoring work that we routinely carry out, we picked up on signs of reduced availability affecting portions of the 4.X and 5.X onshore fleet. The cause is failure rates of certain components running above what we had anticipated, showing up once those turbines had logged a particular amount of running time. Most of the time, these problems relate to main bearings and blades, along with a few other parts. Because the components come from various suppliers, meaning they aren't identical even within the same 4.X or the same 5.X turbine, our estimate is that a differing count of our wind turbines are impacted. On the 4.X side, roughly 2,100 turbines are out in the field. As for the 5.X, we're currently talking about a volume of around 800 turbines. One thing that matters here: the bulk of our overall onshore fleet is running in line with contractual obligations. That said, we do observe certain variations in availability depending on region — though this isn't really a regional effect as such; it ties more to the patterns of failure.

Jochen Eickholt

executive
#10

Unpleasant though it is, we're in the early stage of the product life cycle, with only a limited count of units out in the field. Experiences like these aren't uncommon once wind turbines have been running for a given stretch of time. Now, while these problems leave me quite disappointed, I take some comfort in the fact that in most instances we spot them long before our customers learn of them. I'd also like to point out that the 4X and 5X wind turbine variants we're selling to customers today are either already modified or are slated for modification. Put differently, the issues we've identified are being addressed, and what remains is fixing them in the respective turbines currently in the field. Going forward, let me say that we'll be highly selective about which projects we decide to take on. That's our general policy in any case. Now let me attempt to walk through some of the mitigation measures. The moment we became aware of possible quality problems on the 4X and 5X platforms, we set up an expert task force at Siemens Gamesa and moved up the annual quality baseline validation, which under normal circumstances would not have taken place until Q1 of the fiscal year 2024.

Jochen Eickholt

executive
#11

We've pinpointed and put numbers on the corrective steps, and we're still working to validate and fine-tune those steps with a larger task force. That task force is now made up mostly of specialists from Siemens Gamesa, though it also brings in senior experts from Siemens Energy. They may not always have wind turbine experience, but they definitely know rotating equipment. We've also got outside consultants from AlixPartners involved. As you may know, AlixPartners is a highly regarded global consultancy that handles matters like this... The task force reports straight to the board of directors at Siemens Gamesa, and it will also look at how we can do better on mitigating the measures going forward, or maybe find other alternatives for the repairs we intend to carry out. Following a thorough analysis, we took a EUR 1.6 billion charge tied to the product quality issues on the 4.X and the 5.X. That charge covers the cost of the mitigation measures plus wind turbine repairs and knock-on effects. And of course it also covers things like what it costs us to meet contractual obligations. Beyond that, because of cost increases tied to rectification measures themselves — for instance, minor modifications — we'll also see a lower profit contribution going forward from some of these projects.

Jochen Eickholt

executive
#12

Allow me to point to specific steps we've already taken to tackle these issues. Number one, to guarantee component quality, we're running separate, tougher procedures for qualifying suppliers and for the manufacturing carried out at those suppliers. It's probably also fair to mention that supply from certain suppliers was halted. In that sense, a few suppliers were nearly disqualified. We're also in discussions with particular suppliers regarding compensation. Keep in mind that components can sometimes lie at the root of many of the problems. We keep refining processes in our plants so that products leaving the factory display the quality we want. Going forward, the heart of stabilization will be simplifying what we offer — meaning fewer product variants. In other words, less variation in our regional offering and across the portfolio, even at the cost of slower growth. This has already been kicked off under the Mistral strategy program. That's why, in the past, we also cut down on the number of variants on offer, and we'll keep sharpening this approach. Offshore is a different part of our business. Availability across our fleet matches expectations and our contractual obligations, and here we gain from extensive experience throughout the fleet, essentially.

Jochen Eickholt

executive
#13

But the situation offshore is a bit difficult, because in a sense we fell victim to how well we did in prior years. There was a great deal of interest in our products, and that led to more orders during 2021 and 2022. That has now required us to ramp up manufacturing capacity and production across nearly every one of our production facilities, and in particular where we build the 11 and the 14-megawatt platforms. So all of the offshore manufacturing sites are in ramp-up mode right now. The goal is to raise capacities, though you could also say the offshore sites are, to a substantial degree, construction sites as well. That means it is a combination of difficulties that we encounter there. We must move to blades and nacelles for the larger platforms, while at the same time new people need to be onboarded. In Hull, in the UK, for example, we are approximately doubling our blade capacity. In Le Havre, in France, we are ramping up the new facilities for producing nacelles and blades. We are ramping up capacities in Aalborg and Cuxhaven. We anticipated that these ramp-ups, all of these ramp-ups, would be challenging. But, for example, labor markets meant the pace of all these things was slower than expected, particularly after COVID-19.

Jochen Eickholt

executive
#14

Issues with finishing the factory infrastructure and slower hiring were hurting productivity gains. Our teams are now addressing these problems, but honestly no single factor is behind the full set of delays — as you can imagine, it's more a mix of them. We're working hard on this, though it does mean reaching targeted production levels will sometimes take longer. On top of that, we saw cost inflation on our side staying higher than expected, so extra productivity has to offset that on the cost side for us to hit target profitabilities. That now means the mix of higher costs and weaker productivity is hitting not just current operations and expected growth margins — in our backlog we could also see an effect on future contracts where we're bound by preferred supply agreements signed in the past. Because of these effects, Siemens Energy had to book a charge of EUR 600 million in the quarter. Most of that really ties to those preferred supply agreements from the past.

Jochen Eickholt

executive
#15

It's an effect that's genuinely tough. You might also recall, from earlier sessions, that we were constantly attempting to enhance supply agreements inherited from the past. On the cost side, we weren't successful in every case. To a certain degree, we now have to recognize that going forward, there will be an impact in dimension size. As we laid out in the course earlier, for more recent contracts, we've been negotiating different terms and conditions, particularly regarding inflation compensation, yet that doesn't assist us with legacy contracts and legacy preferred supply agreements. Let me now walk through the remedial actions for offshore. We've been increasing prices. I mentioned that even sometimes past the level that's publicly known. We also made improvements to contracts that are existing, and we have negotiated far more favorable terms and conditions so that we're covered in the event of cost inflation and risks beyond our control. We have, for instance, shifted from a steel tower indexation to a much broader cost coverage mechanism on our material cost side, including tower and non-tower steel, and so on. We're working on productivity improvements going forward by incorporating the lessons learned in the areas of planning and routing hours for the ramp up in order to optimize the overall situation.

Jochen Eickholt

executive
#16

We’re pursuing cost-reduction steps jointly with our suppliers. That point is probably also worth noting. Because of that, we’re likewise taking another look at our CapEx plans tied to launching new platforms, so that ultimately we can improve the return on the investment. With that said, perhaps I’ll hand it back to Christian.

Christian Bruch

executive
#17

Yeah. Thanks, Jochen. Let me recap the main points I'd like you to remember about Siemens Gamesa. Remedial steps have been taken, and we've installed a very capable task force to fix the quality problems on the 4.X and 5.X onshore platforms. Availability across our offshore fleet has been high and remains high, and a number of the industry's best-known experts have validated and certified the 4.X and 5.X platforms. That also holds for the processes we've introduced along the way to resolve those quality issues, and we're executing new projects on the updated versions of the 4.X and the 5.X, and of course carrying on with our successful offshore platform. With the Mistral organization now implemented, clear accountabilities exist across Siemens Gamesa, and that will help us overcome the challenges we're facing now. As Jochen described, we're reviewing and strengthening processes within the organization. On administrative processes, Siemens Gamesa in selected areas is already tapping into the systems and processes used at Siemens Energy. That's a big help, and the challenges at Siemens Gamesa make it very clear, obviously, that there's a setback.

Christian Bruch

executive
#18

Since the cost is higher, growth will be slower and the route to reaching our target profitability will take longer, as our focus is on stability and profitability ahead of growth. We already used this guiding principle successfully in the former gas and power businesses, and we'll now use that same principle at Siemens Gamesa. I'll now turn things over to Maria for the financials.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#19

Thanks so much, Christian. Morning, everyone. Let's dive straight in, beginning with the group as a whole — the Siemens Energy figures. On orders for Siemens Energy, we booked EUR 14.9 billion in this quarter, which works out to a bit more than 54% growth on a comparable basis. Large orders at Siemens Gamesa and Grid Technology drove that. The book-to-bill ratio landed at a very robust 1.98, and the order book climbed to a fresh record of EUR 109 billion. Order intake for the quarter is also a record, at slightly under EUR 15 billion. Turning to revenue, it rose 8% on a comparable basis, reaching EUR 7.5 billion in the third quarter, with double-digit growth across all the former gas and power businesses. Service growth of 8% outpaced new units, giving us a favorable business mix. As you'll remember, that's typical for Q3; naturally, the mix looks different in Q4, when it shifts proportionally toward a larger new unit share rather than service. Profit before special items stood at EUR -2 billion, driven by the charges at Siemens Gamesa. Every other business area — GS, GT, and TI — as you'll see shortly, sharply exceeded the prior year quarter's level, both in profit and in the corresponding margin.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#20

Pre-tax free cash flow came in at EUR 27 million, an improvement from EUR -25 million in the same quarter a year earlier. We saw robust cash flow at GS and TI, which was partly offset by the cash outflow at Siemens Gamesa and the anticipated one in Grid Technologies. Turning to how the order backlog developed, I think it's worth stressing, as in the other quarters, that the order backlog matters a great deal to us, since it provides substantial visibility as we move forward. During the third quarter, the order backlog increased in every business, despite a modest decline at GS. That decline is purely a matter of timing, so it represents a shift. With that said, of the EUR 109 billion Siemens Energy order backlog, roughly EUR 40 billion relates to Siemens Gamesa, and as a result the charges taken in the quarter along with continuing problems have made the quality of the order book at Siemens Gamesa weaker. Even so, the margin profile of the order backlog at GS, GT and TI — which accounts for about EUR 70 billion, or 2/3 of our backlog — keeps getting better and backs our short and midterm targets. Let's now go to the next slide, please, on our strong liquidity position. I do want to point out that we have a strong balance sheet, we have a track record, and we have kept a strong balance sheet ever since the spin, including now after the buyout of the Siemens Gamesa minorities.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#21

We remain committed to keeping an investment-grade rating, and that commitment is absolute. As this bridge shows, our liquidity stayed solid in Q3, with cash and cash equivalents totaling EUR 4.4 billion overall and financial debt of EUR 4.7 billion, EUR 3.2 billion of which is long-term in nature. That leaves us with a slight net debt position of EUR 336 million, and when pensions are factored in, our adjusted net debt position comes to just over EUR 900 million. Turning to liquidity, Siemens Energy had EUR 9.4 billion of total available liquidity as of the end of Q3. That consists of, as I just said, roughly EUR 4.4 billion in cash and cash equivalents plus EUR 5 billion of undrawn credit lines maturing in 2026. It's probably important to give you some orientation on where we'll land relative to year-end. At the group level, in Q1 through Q3 — year to date — we generated negative free cash flow pre-tax of negative EUR 324 million. Under the revised guidance, negative free cash flow pre-tax is expected to reach up to a low triple-digit million amount.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#22

Looking at the fourth quarter, we anticipate free cash flow before tax to land somewhere between neutral and break-even, consistent with the updated guidance we provided. Regarding cash outflows during Q4 that fall outside how we define free cash flow, our assumptions are as follows: roughly EUR 100 million for cash tax payments, approximately EUR 100 million for interest payments, cash related to the Siemens Gamesa buyout, EUR 270 million for minorities, and EUR 300 million to EUR 400 million for non-carve-out items. As a result, our net debt position, as expected or approximated at year-end, will come in somewhat above where it stood at the close of Q3. Let's now turn to our business areas, beginning with Gas Services. Once more, Gas Services delivered a very strong quarter on both revenue and profit. Order intake in the third quarter totaled EUR 2.2 billion. That reflects a decline on a comparable basis, driven by robust orders in the service business alongside weak new unit orders. Again, this comes down purely to timing and shifts in timing. During the third quarter, we booked 9 gas turbines above 10 MW, and every one of them was an industrial gas turbine in the 10 to 100 MW range.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#23

We did not record any large gas turbines above 100 MW. Once again, this stems from shifts in timing regarding bookings for projects that were already secured. As noted, those projects are already signed and are in their final stages, so they will be booked in Q4 accordingly. To be clear, we anticipate robust large gas turbine orders in Q4. On the revenue side, in GS we achieved strong growth of more than 21%, reaching EUR 2.7 billion. That was driven by both the new unit business and the service business, with each growing by roughly 15%. In particular, the outstanding performance of our short-cycle service business helped produce a positive business mix this quarter. Turning to profit, it nearly doubled compared with a year earlier, coming in at EUR 296 million. That represents a margin of 10.9%, an increase of 440 bips versus Q3 of last year. This strong gain reflects a combination of higher revenue and an improved cost structure, along with, as I mentioned, a favorable mix. Consistent with our known seasonality and prior year results, we do expect the business mix in Q4 to include a smaller portion of services, and therefore a correspondingly lower margin. Moving on to Grid Technologies, on orders, this was truly an outstanding order development, supported by strong demand across the business.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#24

During the third quarter, orders booked came to EUR 4.3 billion. That represents an extraordinary rise of a touch under 64% on a comparable basis. Large orders in the solution business helped drive this growth, among them an order for offshore Grid Tech connections in the North Sea. Every region posted growth, and the strongest gain came in Europe, where book-to-bill overall stood at 2.35. Revenue climbed significantly, up 18.7% on a comparable basis, once again helped by very strong order intake in the prior fiscal year. Profit was strong at EUR 159 million, with a margin of 8.7%. That is an improvement of 710 basis points compared with Q3 of last year. I'd just like to offer a friendly reminder that the prior-year quarter was, of course, burdened by strong headwinds from supply chain constraints. What we are seeing now is strong development driven by margin-accretive volume and underlying operational improvements. Well done to the GT team. On the next slide, we see — or rather, let's take a closer look at our Transformation of Industry business area. Here, the main message is that the turnaround plan put in place a few years ago, and the transformation, are working. The focus on profitability is paying off across all businesses, where we are well on track to achieve our targets.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#25

On orders, we booked EUR 1.3 billion worth of orders. That reflects a 13.9% increase on a comparable basis. The biggest contributors to this development were our Electrification, Automation, and Digitalization, along with the industrial steam turbines and generation businesses. Revenue was up 10.5% on a comparable basis, with support from all 4 IMBs, or independently managed businesses, driven mainly, of course, by the underlying service business. Profit before special items, where TI carried on the positive trend from the prior fiscal year and the first 6 months of the current fiscal year, once again confirming the turnaround. Profit came in at EUR 70 million. That reflects a margin of 6.5% and compares with a profit of EUR 17 million in Q3 of the prior fiscal year. This marks an improvement of 490 basis points versus last year. Also important, again, is that the increase rested on progress across all of the independently managed businesses, and I think that is very noteworthy and well done to the team. Next slide is Siemens Gamesa. I think the colleagues have already explained the situation at our wind subsidiary, Siemens Gamesa, and the comprehensive plan to mitigate the issues. However, the third quarter financials clearly reflect how severe the impact is.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#26

Turning to orders, in Q3 they grew by more than 2x, reaching EUR 7.4 billion, with EUR 5.3 billion of that total coming from our offshore business. That was, naturally, fueled by a larger volume of big-ticket orders, among them one offshore contract valued at EUR 2.3 billion. Siemens Gamesa's order backlog stood at EUR 39.9 billion at the close of the third quarter — just under EUR 40 billion. Revenue fell 12.2% versus the prior year on a comparable basis, landing at EUR 2 billion. The drop in onshore and service stemmed from the quality issues and the related percentage of completion accounting method, under which we are recording cumulative catch-up effects for those charges. In offshore, revenue climbed 19% despite the ramp-up challenges we have already flagged. On profit, we posted a negative figure of EUR 2.55 billion. That number includes the EUR 2.2 billion in charges mentioned earlier, which get more detail on the next slide in just a moment. Free cash flow at Siemens Gamesa was negative EUR 393 million, driven mainly by operating performance and the execution of owners' projects. It is also worth noting that the cash impact from the EUR 2.2 billion in charges this quarter was fairly limited.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#27

And as I mentioned, this will be distributed across the coming several years, with only a limited effect in fiscal year 2023. Moving to the next slide, you'll see how the Q3 charge for Siemens Gamesa breaks down. As has already been noted, we recorded the EUR 1.6 billion charge tied to quality, connected to the 4.X and 5.X onshore platforms. The rest — EUR 0.6 billion — splits into two categories, with EUR 0.4 billion tied to onerous loss provisions on certain offshore contracts stemming from higher product costs. Then there's the EUR 0.2 billion. Among other things, this reflects the offshore ramp-up challenges that Jochen described, which are causing project delays and underutilization, et cetera, at our factories. To go a bit deeper on the higher product costs, they stem from revised cost assumptions for materials, labor, and other production costs, and also from the fact that productivity gains are not coming through as previously expected. A root cause here links to the ramp-up challenges, since we're not hitting the load plan and therefore the productivity levels in our factories that were previously assumed. Beyond that, these issues at Siemens Gamesa and the charges also produce negative tax effects in Q3, totaling EUR 0.7 billion.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#28

This comes from valuation allowances on deferred tax assets in Germany, the U.S., Spain, and Mexico—though those have neither a profit nor a cash flow impact. Beyond that, the legal existence of these loss carryforwards is unaffected, meaning they remain usable to offset profits in future periods. Another point worth stressing: the problems we found at Siemens Gamesa during the third quarter will carry certain operational consequences into the quarters ahead. Take the margin potential of our legacy backlog—it has weakened even further. The drivers are the quality issues already mentioned in onshore, plus higher product costs in offshore. In particular, those higher product costs will weigh on offshore profitability until the legacy backlog has been worked through. The ongoing delay—including in the offshore ramp-up—will produce shifts and, as a result, revenue below what we had assumed, which translates into missed project profit and greater underutilization at our factories. These challenges, described above, will make the margin recovery curve flatter across the Siemens Gamesa businesses. Reaching target profitability will take longer. So what does that mean for the fourth quarter of this fiscal year, 23? It means the amended profit guidance for Siemens Gamesa, following a year-to-date loss of roughly EUR 3.7 billion, points to an expected loss of around or approximately EUR 0.6 billion in Q4.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#29

So again, this should be split into two parts. In the first, we’re looking at roughly EUR 300 million to EUR 400 million, which reflects continued execution of our legacy backlog. Then, on top of that, because of the charges in Q3, we see around EUR 200 million to EUR 300 million in additional consequential operational effects, and those weigh on Q4 especially. These include the continued delays in the offshore ramp-up as described; of course, those delays are also further limiting the improvement measures we intended. With that — I know it was quite detailed — let’s sum up for the first nine months of the fiscal year. I think Christian already mentioned it. We had excellent performance across all of the former GP businesses since Siemens Energy’s inception. In the first three quarters of 2023, with orders of roughly just over EUR 27 billion, that’s a 54% increase, 22% comparable revenue growth, and a profit margin before special items of more than 8%. Again, driven by the strong underlying operational improvements we’ve undertaken in the last years across all 3 business areas. However, the financial performance of Siemens Gamesa does mark a setback. Since the capital reduction was approved in June, we now own 100% of Siemens Gamesa, and this allows us to rigorously tackle the issues necessary, necessary to ensure the turnaround, as Christian explained, and Jochen and his team.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#30

The former GP's robust cash flow performance shows we can turn those businesses around and keep producing free cash flow—not just in earlier years, as Christian noted, but in the future as well. Our balance sheet remains strong, and we hold a confirmed investment-grade rating with a stable outlook. One more thing to mention: we've changed the CFO at Siemens Gamesa. I'm delighted to announce that Stefan Huppertz—previously head of Finance Grid Solution Technologies in our Grid Technologies business area within Siemens Energy—has been appointed the new CFO of Siemens Gamesa. Stefan comes with a proven track record, considering the progress achieved in the GT solution space at Siemens Energy, and he understands how to handle complex, finance-driven project structures. I'm very pleased that he has taken on this important position. He'll start at the beginning of September. Turning to our guidance, our amended guidance. Let me say broadly that all assumptions, all overall assumptions for the segments—Gas Services, Grid Technologies, and Transformation of Industries—for fiscal year 2023 remain unchanged. As a result, GS intends to deliver comparable revenue growth of 10%-12% and a profit margin before special items of 9%-11%.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#31

For GT, we're aiming for comparable revenue growth of 12%-14% and a profit margin before special items of 6% to 8%. At TI, the goal is comparable revenue growth of 8%-10%, with profit margin before special items between 3% and 5%. As the Q3 results show, we're on a strong trajectory toward hitting these targets. Siemens Gamesa has revised its revenue and profit assumptions for fiscal year 2023: it now assumes comparable revenue growth of -3%-0%, versus +6%-+10% previously, and a negative profit before special items of around or approximately EUR 4.3 billion. So, as a result, consequently, we had to adjust our outlook for Siemens Energy Group for fiscal year 2023, and we now expect comparable revenue growth in the range of 9%-11% — a slight notch down — previously 10%-12%, and a profit margin before special items between -10% and -8%. This was previously around the low end of our guidance range of +1%-+3%. The net loss of Siemens Energy Group is now expected to be around or approximately EUR 4.5 billion. Previously, this was expected to exceed prior year's fiscal year's level of EUR 712 million by up to a EUR low triple-digit million amount.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#32

Also, keep in mind that for fiscal year 2023 we now anticipate free cash flow before tax reaching as much as a negative low triple-digit figure in euros, whereas earlier we had projected it to be positive up to a low triple-digit euro amount. That said, Christian, I'll now turn things back over to you, and thank you all for listening.

Christian Bruch

executive
#33

Thank you, Maria. Before I wrap up with my main priorities, I want to make the following point: what has happened at Siemens Gamesa represents a significant blow for us at Siemens Energy. That said, our former gas and power businesses are producing excellent results, and that stands as a reassuring sign that we possess the know-how to restructure struggling businesses successfully. Think back to everything we discussed 3 years ago when we examined the prior gas and power businesses. That expertise, together with our emphasis on selective bidding, cost out, and operational excellence, gives us confidence that the organization has what it takes to help Siemens Gamesa genuinely complete a successful turnaround of a business that is operationally challenged yet otherwise strategically attractive in terms of growth. At this moment, I also want to sincerely thank every employee at Siemens Energy and Siemens Gamesa, especially for the last couple of weeks, which for everyone has been a very work-intensive period, and truly the dedication and the knowledge our people show is a great thing to witness, even under such circumstances. I am convinced that wind is an indispensable part of a successful energy transition. Clearly, this has to be achievable in a predictable and reliable manner going forward. Over the coming weeks, we will revisit our original plans at Siemens Gamesa to make sure the challenges of growth are handled diligently and with a profitable outcome.

Christian Bruch

executive
#34

On November 21st and 22nd, at our Capital Market Day in Hamburg, we'll give you a thorough update on the various businesses. I hope you're able to be there with us. Now, moving to what I'm focused on. Along with Jochen and the entire Siemens Gamesa team, my goal is to turn Siemens Gamesa around — by resolving product quality issues and cutting costs in onshore, handling the offshore ramp-up, and improving the cost structure, tightening up processes, and sharpening our focus, as Jochen mentioned earlier, on core regions and products. At Siemens Energy, we keep leveraging our new operating model to seize market opportunities and to drive performance at Gas Services, Grid Technologies, and Transformation of Industry. With that, I'll hand things back to Michael to moderate the Q&A session, and Maria, Jochen, and I look forward to your questions.

Michael Hagmann

executive
#35

Thanks, Christian. Thanks, Maria. Thanks, Jochen. We've got roughly 45 minutes now for the Q&A. Just a reminder: press star 1 to join the queue, star 2 to drop off it. Q, looking at the list — the first three questions are from Vivek Midha at Citi, Ajay Patel at Goldman Sachs, and Gaël de-Bray at Deutsche Bank. Vivek, go right ahead.

Vivek Midha

analyst
#36

Thank you so much, Michael. Morning, everybody. I'd like to ask about the offshore business. Could you quantify what share of the offshore backlog and pipeline is onerous at this point? And do you have a refreshed view on when the offshore business should return to profitability, or would that be something for the CMD? Thanks.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#37

Yes. Thanks, Vivek. Good morning, and I appreciate the question. As we've said previously, the onerous backlog was primarily tied to the onshore business in earlier periods. Naturally, with the additional charges in Q3, we are seeing the onerous backlog grow in onshore. During earlier sessions, management pointed to roughly EUR 2.5 billion. We also stated that figure would decline to EUR 2 billion. Now, because of the charges, it sits just a bit above EUR 3 billion. Turning to offshore, we likewise have a handful of contracts that have become onerous. Naturally, those contracts will be executed somewhat further out. As you know, the length of our contracts onshore runs about 2 years-3 years, while offshore runs 4 years-5 years. This mainly concerns the product cost problems we flagged in Q3.

Michael Hagmann

executive
#38

Thanks, Maria. We'll take the next question from Akash Gupta at J.P. Morgan.

Akash Gupta

analyst
#39

Thank you for your time. To start, I appreciate how much detail you gave in the presentation. It's really helpful for understanding the moving parts. My question was more about the orders outlook. I mean, looking at your Q3 orders, you had EUR 15 billion, almost 2 times book-to-bill. Year to date, we have 1.8 times book-to-bill. What does your pipeline look like over the next 3 months-6 months? Any comment on that would be helpful. Thank you.

Christian Bruch

executive
#40

Yes, thanks a lot, Akash. Good morning to you. So, since you're linking this to the EUR 15 billion, the business overall — all things considered, we continue to see a solid project pipeline. But keep in mind too, as we've said previously, we'll be quite selective when it comes to orders. On that point, we clearly expect a continued positive outlook, though we certainly won't take things on board unreasonably — that's very clear. On wind, this quarter was very clearly dominated by offshore, as he laid out in his numbers. Particularly in onshore, we'll be extremely careful and highly selective about taking on new projects. As he indicated during the call, we will of course review how things go going forward, and stability and profitability would always come first for us, ahead of growth. That's a balance we intend to keep so that we can execute through the backlog. Book-to-bill in quarter four, roughly speaking, if you look at current businesses in quarter four, would be around 1, roughly.

Michael Hagmann

executive
#41

Okay, I realize I may have gotten that list a little off, but the following questions come from Gaël de-Brayl at Deutsche, then Nick Green at Bernstein, and after that Alex Virgo at Bank of America. Gaël de-Bray, please go ahead.

Gaël de-Bray

analyst
#42

Yes, thank you so much. Good morning, everybody. I have two questions, if I may. The first, naturally, concerns Gamesa, and the fresh guidance for Gamesa points to an operating loss of EUR 600 million in Q4. You just mentioned that this figure would take in EUR 200 million-EUR 300 million of knock-on effects tied to the matters you have just laid out. So my question is this: could you maybe help us grasp how large those knock-on effects will be as we head into next year? Should we treat that EUR 200 million-EUR 300 million as a quarterly run rate? My second question concerns the balance sheet. It looks as though your net debt might rise by roughly EUR 800 million in fiscal Q4. First, can you confirm the math? Or... Second, do you feel comfortable with your BBB minus credit rating?

Maria Ferraro

executive
#43

Thanks, Gaël de-Bray. I'll go through each question individually, perhaps. Regarding Q4 profitability, you're correct. Just to run the numbers again, we show EUR 3.7 billion for the year to date. Then we have roughly EUR 600 million in Q4, which we split into two portions, correct? The first is that onerous backlog we keep working through. As you're aware, with onerous backlog, even when charges are taken as we did in Q2 — in Q3, sorry — that only covers the direct costs on those projects, correct? Other costs, naturally, keep coming in, which explains the underlying negative movement across the quarters, and that holds in Q4 as well. That's the roughly EUR 300 million to EUR 400 million figure we're discussing. The second category is this EUR 200 million to EUR 300 million. These are what you call the knock-on effect, or the resulting operational problems, and a portion of them apply only to this Q4, owing to certain issues Jochen described earlier. For instance, a few of the productivity measures simply can't be delivered within this window, so those are truly Q4 specific.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#44

Factors such as under absorption in the plants—as you know, when ramp-up tends to, let's say, get better moving forward, then naturally that's also a Q4 subject. I think that's how to think about it. Can that be carried into next year as a rule of thumb? I'd say, Gaël de-Bray, as always, give us a bit of time. We're working through that precisely to see exactly what the go-forward impacts will be. Q4 in particular does have an elevated level of these consequential dam—not damages, please don't quote that. Consequential operational effects, owing to the Q3 charge.

Michael Hagmann

executive
#45

Thanks, Maria. We'll take the next question from Nick Green at Bernstein. Nick, go ahead whenever you're ready.

Nick Green

analyst
#46

Good morning, everyone. Thanks for taking my question. This one is technical. Based on what Jochen said during the earlier press call, you've indicated a few things: first, that the root cause can't be determined yet; that one turbine may have multiple issues while another turbine of the same model has none at all; that you're not willing to confirm how many turbines are at fault; that you've found wrinkles on blades, but this is regardless of the root cause, or may be regardless of what's causing the problem; that you've discovered particles in the raceway of the main bearings, but right now you can't confirm where those particles originated, or whether the blade issue is connected in any way to finding those particles. I have three specific questions, please. First, is it therefore fair to say that you cannot confirm with any confidence that you can bookend what is actually going wrong here? Second, is it fair to say that at this stage you cannot offer comfort that remaining turbines within the same models won't later develop abnormal vibrations? Third, accordingly, with what confidence can investors take that this EUR 1.6 billion charge won't be higher in the future?

Nick Green

analyst
#47

Thanks.

Jochen Eickholt

executive
#48

Right, maybe a few questions. Thanks a lot. And many thanks as well for tuning into the earlier session. I'd say the conclusions I'd reach are, well, not quite the same ones that may have been alluded to. First off, the point is that, at the end of the day, we're still talking about 4.X, and about 5.X too, especially right at the start of the operating duration, which means we have relatively few physical findings, so our assumptions have to rest heavily on probabilistic calculations. Those probabilistic calculations are ones we typically apply, sure, but we've also had our methods as such validated through an external third-party assessment. That's TUV Nord in this case, and they determined that the approach for handling these matters is, in their own words, kind of best in class. The probabilistic model as such is fine. Still, it keeps struggling with too few data points. Data points as such can't just come from anywhere, and we'll be constantly reviewing them and trying to optimize them as time goes on. Over time, that will give the numbers more stability. Second, we tackle the issues we know about in a highly systematic way and try to ensure that going forward, symptoms of that, or failure modes of the components, don't recur — perhaps even without a full grasp of the root causes.

Jochen Eickholt

executive
#49

That's the work the task force—the quality task force, as it's sometimes called—is doing, and doing at this very moment. Looking ahead, our sense is that a meaningful share of the underlying causes can certainly be addressed in such a way that what we deliver to customers no longer exhibits these phenomena. Keep in mind that what we owe the customer is often tied to the availability of the turbine itself. Failure rates of an individual component are not the point. That's a separate, that's a separate matter. Looking forward, my assumption is that the changes we make, that we, we put in place, will bring us to turbines that fully qualify under our commitment to the customer. Now, of course, the overall picture is such that one could say, well, there are a couple of big hits here. I have to say I entirely agree with that. The trouble is that we've now seen this magnitude of hits. We've also seen this magnitude of hits in this constellation, and we hadn't seen that previously, so it's a somewhat unique situation we find ourselves in. We're trying to work our way through this situation as, as, as diligently as we can.

Jochen Eickholt

executive
#50

The mix of onshore operations plus the offshore circumstances just mentioned is, for us as an organization, a one-of-a-kind situation. All told, this means our accounting principles are established, sound, and stable, and after that we've attempted to place everything we're aware of into our figures in the best way we can, in line with our accounting standards. It's also reasonable to say that, seen from this angle, the accruals sit at the right level. We keep moving ahead on the issues that are known. As I noted, the Q3 situation was, to me, unique in that we hadn't seen it before. It's a blend of things that struck us, and they arrived at, at, at — I mean, we didn't anticipate that happening, since otherwise the order of events would certainly have been different. I hope this goes some way toward answering those questions.

Nick Green

analyst
#51

Thank you. Michael, if you would just allow me. Let's approach it from the opposite direction, then. Where did the $1.6 billion figure come from? What we're hoping to gain reassurance on is that no further turbines will emerge down the road with an issue. From how you've described it, since the problem isn't fully understood, we equally can't state with confidence that a turbine passing inspection today won't have difficulties 12 months from now. Walk us through the $1.6 billion. Is this a probability-weighted estimate? Or do you have a specific count of turbines you're comfortable standing behind, yet the actual cost is an average per turbine, which is a variable element? Help us see how to bracket these issues. Thank you.

Jochen Eickholt

executive
#52

So, how do I approach this? I mean, one way to put it is that we have observed a small number of failures. Based on our experience, when a turbine is early in its service life, a handful of failures like these tell us we are somewhere along a failure rate curve. That curve gets modeled statistically, using probabilistic methods, and it gives us a broader picture. That broader picture, as I was attempting to explain, received confirmation first from Siemens Gamesa's experts, then from a joint task force of Siemens Energy and Siemens Gamesa, and afterward from an independent external review. That picture is then reflected, so to speak, in what we know about particular corrective actions. Keep in mind that in these situations, the majority of corrective actions are not treated as standalone, separate tasks; instead, the plan is to carry them out alongside standard or scheduled maintenance work, so to speak. All of that together brings us to EUR 1.6 billion. At this moment, we have no better information than that. Naturally, as we move forward, we will try to refine those figures to the greatest extent possible, but as of today, regrettably, that figure is the figure.

Nick Green

analyst
#53

Alright, thanks. I’ll hand it over now. Thank you, Michael.

Michael Hagmann

executive
#54

Thanks. Appreciate it, Jochen. We’ll take the next question from Alex Virgo at Bank of America. Alex, the floor is yours.

Alexander Virgo

analyst
#55

Thanks, Michael. Good morning, everyone. I was hoping I could build a bit on the reply Maria gave to Gael's question, since I don't believe you quite wrapped it up, Maria. I was wondering whether I could fold that into a wider question about cash flow. Just thinking, could you provide some guidance on the cadence of the cash going out? I mean the EUR 1.6 billion mainly, but clearly all of it. I believe Gael's question concerned the triple B minus rating. If you could just make the figures you provided for Q4 clear so that we have them recorded, pat, that would be helpful. Thank you.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#56

Thanks, Alex. And yes, you're absolutely right. My apologies, Gail. There were two other parts to your question I intended to address, if Alex hadn't already covered them, so I appreciate that. Perhaps I'll begin with cash, since that seems like the logical first area. As we've already said, the cash impact from the charges will be distributed across multiple years. We're still working this through. We don't yet have it fully pinned down, so to speak, in terms of the numbers and so forth. That work is ongoing right now. What we can say is that we expect the bulk to fall between fiscal year 2024 and 2026, and it may even peak in fiscal year 2025, again based on high-level estimates. What we also know is that this fiscal year sees only a limited impact. And another thing we know, beyond the five-year horizon I just mentioned, is that a lot of this — or rather some of it — relates to long-term service contracts. So it will be distributed across an even longer period, since our long-term service program in some cases extends past 10 years. At the same time — and this is why we'll provide further insight in our Q4 and certainly at the Capital Markets Day — we're also putting the contingency measures in place, as Jochen and Christian have indicated, and naturally, we're reviewing our strategic and business plan assumptions.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#57

So because of that, we'll provide clearer detail on the financial expectations, as I said, at the Capital Markets Day and Q4. Regarding where net debt and cash stand at year-end — I believe Gaël de-Bray also raised this question. At the close of Q3, the net debt position came in at roughly EUR -336 million. Our guidance has been for negative free cash flow pre-tax of up to a low triple-digit million amount. Year to date, across Q1 to Q3, we produced negative free cash flow pre-tax of EUR -324 million, and as a result we anticipate neutral to break even free cash flow, again, estimated for the fourth quarter. And so, to move to the next stage regarding cash outflows, which as such aren't included in the free cash flow definition, we're assuming a cash tax payment of around EUR 100 million, plus interest payments of approximately EUR 100 million. There's cash for the buyout of the SGRE minorities of EUR 270 million, and non-carve-out topics of between EUR 300 million-EUR 400 million. So on the basis of those estimates, we expect the net debt position at year-end to be slightly higher than in Q3.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#58

To repeat, those figures are only rough approximations, meant to give you some sense of direction. Regarding the BBB- rating with a stable outlook—do I feel at ease with it? We have stated repeatedly, and I will say it once more here, that our balance sheet is solid, correct? With the investment grade rating we have secured, and we are pursuing that comprehensive turnaround plan for Siemens Gamesa through all the different measures. It also matters to point out, as I said before, that the cash impact of the Siemens Gamesa charges will be distributed across the coming years. It is essential that we remember the robust performance and cash flow from our former gas and power businesses. Over the past 2.5+ years, those businesses generated more than EUR 4 billion in cash, I believe. That point is truly significant for completing the picture, so to speak, as to why I feel—as you know—that we possess a solid balance sheet underpinning the investment grade rating of BBB-, which now carries a stable outlook. Our balance sheet as it currently stands leaves me very comfortable, yet let me also reassure you: we are not standing still.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#59

We'll keep focusing on how we manage the balance sheet and making sure that — you know, inventories and accounts receivable — those are items we review each month, and more often when needed.

Alexander Virgo

analyst
#60

Thanks a lot. Appreciate it.

Michael Hagmann

executive
#61

Thanks, Maria. The next question is from Ajay Patel at Goldman Sachs, then after that we'll go to Govinda Rajpal at AlphaValue, and Sean McLaughlin at HSBC. First up is AJ.

Ajay Patel

analyst
#62

Good morning, and thanks for the presentation. Perhaps I could just add to the previous question. One thing I often discuss with clients is how much Siemens Gamesa's turnaround story will affect the balance sheet and how that develops. Some of the components you've shared today clearly help with that, particularly the last point where I believe you mentioned the EUR 1.6 billion of provisions and how that would crystallize in cash terms over the coming five years. What I'd like to build on, or ask about, is the second point in that part of the presentation slide, which refers to lower profit contribution from future execution of Siemens Gamesa's order backlog. What — could you give any details? I know that getting it to the nth degree will take some time, but just in terms of orders of magnitude, are we looking at Siemens Gamesa being negative cash flow for the next three, four, five years? Is that sizable negative cash flow, or is it minimal? Just to try to understand here that you've still got cash to come out of these charges you've put through, and profits are going to be impacted, but just to try to get an understanding of what the balance of that looks like, against a gas and power business, which clearly is doing well and is throwing off a lot of cash.

Ajay Patel

analyst
#63

Assuming all those pieces come together, can you say outright — based on the EUR 1.6 billion figure you announced today — that no equity issuance will be needed, and that the business as it stands and as you see it now more than covers you? Hello?

Maria Ferraro

executive
#64

We try to handle these costs, or these fixes, during the normal maintenance intervals, so that work will take over — as I said, mostly 5 years, and even longer, depending on how long the contract runs. So I think it's really important to grasp that. Then the second piece is what you're asking about regarding the onerous backlog, and that's what I brought up earlier. We did have onerous backlogs, but mainly in our onshore business, which has been hit by the quality issues — that, as you correctly noted, the $1.6 billion charged this quarter. Because of that, we do have an uplift in the onerous backlog within onshore that we now need to take the time to execute on. How long that takes and exactly how it will play out over the coming quarters is something we'll only be able to give at the Capital Market Day, plus some insight in Q4. Just thank you for your patience on that 1. I think that's really important. Last but not least, again, to restate my view and our view on our balance sheet: we continue to have a solid balance sheet. It's absolutely in line and commensurate with our investment grade rating.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#65

I believe this matters, and once more, as we look ahead, we will keep generating robust cash from our gas and power operations—our prior cash, gas, and power operations. As things stand right now, based on what we know today, a capital raise is not something we see as necessary.

Ajay Patel

analyst
#66

Thanks so much.

Michael Hagmann

executive
#67

Thanks, Maria. The next question comes from Kulvinder Rajpal at AlphaValue. Please go ahead.

Kulvinder Rajpal

analyst
#68

Morning, everyone. I'd like to go a bit further into what you're doing on the supply chain remediation front in the onshore business. On this claims process you've started, could you shed a little more light on how it will play out? Will there be any financial — let's say a positive financial impact that comes back to you, perhaps at some point, or is that too unclear to size right now? Second, cash flows will probably take a hit over the next few years, so how should we view the dividend being restored over the medium to long term? Thank you.

Michael Hagmann

executive
#69

Jochen, why don't you kick things off, and then Maria will go after you.

Jochen Eickholt

executive
#70

Let me begin with the supply chain, if I may. What we found is that at times the components going into our turbines had not been qualified adequately or to a sufficient degree. In other cases they were qualified, yet when it came to the actual serial deliveries, so to speak, those shipments failed to meet the quality standards expected. There are a few reasons behind this. Ultimately, we attempted to remove the failures originating from the components. And beyond that, where a legal basis exists — meaning a liability that a supplier owes us — allowing us to step up or step in to obtain relief for the quality problems, we will pursue that. We now have a few suppliers with whom we are in serious negotiations, so to speak, regarding their contribution, their share. We have also halted a few components, and there are a number of suppliers, particular suppliers, with whom the business relationship — at least for those components — has come to an end. As for the liability that suppliers carry, that liability usually extends to 100% of their delivery volume. That means the effect is limited relative to the damage we are seeing on our side from those components, but even so, the contribution can be significant, which is why we are pursuing those.

Jochen Eickholt

executive
#71

Maybe moving on to the next one.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#72

Yeah. No, thanks. On the dividend question, as I just said, our top priority is keeping the balance sheet strong, consistent with an investment-grade rating, which, again, has just been confirmed. Potential dividends would then hinge on what we expect for positive net income. Also, just as a friendly reminder, we have a dividend policy in place of 40 to 60% of net income attributable to Siemens Energy shareholders, and of course this will be discussed further in conjunction with the Capital Market Day in November.

Michael Hagmann

executive
#73

Thanks to you both. Sean McLoughlin from HSBC gets our next question. Sean, go ahead, please.

Sean McLoughlin

analyst
#74

Good morning, and thanks for taking my questions. There are two of them. First, just so I understand why profitability on your now onerous contracts came in lower than expected, why weren't these booked as part of the Q3 charges? How should we think about the size of the cost to execute on these contracts? Do they now represent, you know, 100% of what sits in your backlog? The second question is about onshore — just looking at the ASP and the volumes, I mean, can we infer any loss of price discipline from these numbers? Could you just talk us through where things currently stand with your customers in the onshore space? Thank you.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#75

Hi, Sean. I'll handle the first question about the backlog. I think, once again, what we were able to identify within the Q3 charges, and for those projects that became onerous — again, where the project margin turns negative — all of that has been fully provisioned for. What it doesn't account for is the gross profit lost on projects that were profitable. So it's actually a reduction in profit going forward. That's something I tried to explain regarding the consequential operational effects. You know, looking ahead, the backlog is somewhat more onerous, as I mentioned, for onshore, and so even for those projects that were profitable, we have lower profitability for those affected by the Q3 charges. I couldn't and shouldn't provision for those as a charge in Q3, because again, they're still generating profit, just at a smaller amount.

Sean McLoughlin

analyst
#76

Could you maybe pin down what share that represents? So, you know, I follow you. So, contracts that have moved into—

Maria Ferraro

executive
#77

Yeah.

Sean McLoughlin

analyst
#78

The negative figures are provisioned.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#79

Yeah.

Sean McLoughlin

analyst
#80

Contracts that are, yeah, displaying a reduced level of positive profit are basically—

Maria Ferraro

executive
#81

Okay.

Sean McLoughlin

analyst
#82

That remains a question about operations.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#83

Okay.

Sean McLoughlin

analyst
#84

Do you have any clarity on the relative size of these two?

Maria Ferraro

executive
#85

Absolutely. No, glad to help. Perhaps just to frame this once more, to set a bit of a boundary around it. Again, when it comes to onshore, most of the upcoming cost sits in onshore, since the bulk of it was already onerous. That's why I mentioned earlier—in prior periods, management pointed to a EUR 2.5 billion onerous backlog for onshore. Well, that figure has now pushed past the EUR 3 billion level. That gap will require some additional time from us and is in fact captured in the onerous charge for Q3. What's left are those projects—and we have plenty of them—that continue to generate profit going forward. For the ones hit by higher charges, we anticipate reduced profitability, which is exactly why we need to grasp precisely how that will play out over the coming quarters, and that's the kind of insight we'll provide in Q4 and at the Capital Market Day—to be precise, in a progressive, sort of post-2023 mode. Right?

Sean McLoughlin

analyst
#86

Yeah.

Jochen Eickholt

executive
#87

Moving to the onshore question — yes, the onshore question. We remain, I mean, as was indicated, we're still selective when it comes to onshore. There are a couple of components there. The first is simply price. At times, you know, there's talk about what's called the ASP. As we also tried to point out earlier, that ASP is somewhat indicative of an overall price level, though not necessarily of a single project's profitability, given scope items and other things, plus regional aspects and variant aspects, and so on. In our view, the ASP is kind of developing as expected. A second component of our selectivity concerns what we call the terms and conditions. Those mostly relate to the overall volume of liabilities, but then also, for instance, to the scope offered on the service side. That very much applies to projects requiring project financing. Sometimes, there, we see the requirements as rather extensive, and so we find it difficult to comply with them. As I said, we stay selective on things we can stand up for. If you compare the habits in our industry space here with the habits in other industry spaces, then the liabilities the supplier is to take over are substantially different, substantially more risky for us, and that, going forward, is something we jointly need to work on with our customers.

Michael Hagmann

executive
#88

Thanks a lot, everybody. We've got the next three questions lined up for Sebastian Growe from BNP, Alex Hauenstein at DZ Bank, and Will Mackie of Kepler Cheuvreux. Sebastian, please go right ahead.

Sebastian Growe

analyst
#89

Okay, good morning everyone, and thank you for taking my questions—and also for the greater transparency. My first one concerns the growth trajectory at Siemens Gamesa from here. Chris and Jochen, both of you mentioned the solar growth that's needed. Given the $21 billion backlog in the turbine part, what growth rate would you really regard as healthy going forward? My second question is more for Maria. Since you mentioned the duration of the onerous contracts and the backlog, it sounds to me like breakeven will be several years away. Given that you've made changes to our portfolio before, if and when an asset failed to meet the 8% group target margin, how should we really think about any potential strategic review of the wind business, given a multi-year restructuring and cash burn line ahead?

Christian Bruch

executive
#90

Yeah, you start off by keeping one eye on the strategic review and one eye on the other thing.

Jochen Eickholt

executive
#91

Good. Growth, if I may start with that. We see. Well, obviously, you see some, some ambitious growth figures on our side. That, in my view, means two things. First of all, the growth in itself, which may be a challenge as such. Secondly, we oftentimes have to refer to the change in the portfolio, in the sense of growing also towards turbine types, towards products, which may be seen as more modern, certainly as bigger, and certainly as, how shall I say, as less proven technology. These two combinations, in our view, form the challenge, or these two elements, in combination, form the challenge. Going forward, our hope would be that we can certainly prolong the life cycles of the products. If we then would have to focus on, if you say, just the extension of capacity, that would certainly be easier. In terms of quantification of that, that's not so easy, but it would probably be less than what we see today.

Christian Bruch

executive
#92

Sure, perhaps regarding the portfolio more broadly. Like I mentioned, there's quite a bit—let's say we'll lay it out at the Capital Market Day, and that includes the growth path for wind power as well, correct? Since right now it's really about settling at the proper altitude so we can expand profitably. Yes, we always keep examining the various businesses. The criteria that you established, we keep adhering to those too. Certain things are in motion. You may even have come across some divestments on the wind side, and naturally we're also continuing to watch the other areas to ensure that, moving ahead, we can adjust the portfolio appropriately. One aspect is profitability, and another is ensuring it aligns with the company's future structure and remains manageable when it comes to organizational simplicity. We'll keep at that. And also—please understand—we're going to cover the majority of this at the Capital Market Day.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#93

Let me perhaps expand again on how long that onerous backlog will last. As we said, yes, it's going to come out later. For instance, in the past, or before, what we assumed for the onerous onshore backlog was that most of it would land in the following year, with the tail end, if you will, falling in 2025. Naturally, with, let's say, a few of the setbacks, our expectation then moves that to the start of 2025. On timing, that's a modest shift, so you're absolutely right. Once more, this is precisely the thing we're attempting to work through and get our heads around, and we'll provide more transparency and timing, again, on the Capital Market Day.

Michael Hagmann

executive
#94

Thanks, everyone. Alex Hauenstein from DZ Bank has the next question. Alex, go right ahead, please.

Alexander Hauenstein

analyst
#95

Yes, thank you. This is Alex Hauenstein from DZ, and I have three questions. First, I'd like to return to breakeven, specifically the potential adjusted-profit breakeven level for SGRE as a whole. I'm not certain I fully understood it, so perhaps you can help me out a little and explain your current thinking—at today's portfolio setup, as we speak. I'm unsure whether we're discussing a further 2-year delay when everything is factored in, or something more. Is it still uncertain? Maybe some clarification there would help. Then, moving to my other questions, which are more qualitative. I'm curious what reputational damage you foresee from this entire story, what impact it could have, and how you plan to prevent any such reputational harm. Finally, when we last spoke, you mentioned a culture of keeping negative news buried for too long, as you put it. So how do you plan to change the corporate culture overall on that front?

Alexander Hauenstein

analyst
#96

Much appreciated.

Christian Bruch

executive
#97

Yes, thanks a lot for that question. Obviously, when it comes to all the forward-looking elements, please keep in mind that it's really meant for the Capital Markets Day. What I just want to emphasize is that, obviously, with the other businesses, we expect to be on—or really better than—on that trajectory. Obviously, if you're talking about the company as a whole, this feeds into the equation, and the remainder will also hinge on how we decide at the end to shape the wind business, and how that then balances out. On reputation damage in terms of where the market stands at the moment, I mean, the organization around Johan is doing extensive work right now with the customers. Actually, I'd say it's somewhat the opposite, right? Because we are addressing these things very early, we are proactively reaching out to customers and saying, "Hey, look, there could be something if you don't do anything." That is, I think, also a bit of what I always appreciated when I was a customer at my company before. Address the issues early. There are issues, but we do it while the turbines are operating. That is also seen by the customers as not entirely negative, and this is where I think we can definitely manage the current situation in close collaboration with our customers.

Christian Bruch

executive
#98

Regarding that remark you mentioned, thank you for raising it, and I want to give it some context. I believe you mean the ad hoc call where I made a statement. And just so we're clear, I haven't seen anyone deliberately withholding information in any of these discussions. When a hit like that lands on the company, it's also worth asking how we can spot challenges sooner and more proactively, and truly ensure everyone has every sensor up and watching so we detect these things and mitigate them as quickly as we can to steer clear of such hits. This will always be a risk-based business that we have to manage, and the better our management of it, the better we get back to profitability. That's where I believe — that's my view — this is a muscle the organization needs to strengthen. Quite plainly, I don't think this is a case of people, shall we say, hiding something; it's really about making sure we act on these elements faster so we can execute projects successfully, as other parts of the business have shown.

Alexander Hauenstein

analyst
#99

All right, thanks — and best of luck with that.

Michael Hagmann

executive
#100

Thanks. Our next question comes from Will Mackie. Will, please go ahead.

William Mackie

analyst
#101

Okay, hi there, and good morning. Appreciate you making the time. So my first question is about how the 4.X and 5.X are designed. How much would you say the design is now locked in and settled, with no further changes needed, and the issues you're dealing with are really about rectification and getting the supply chain and manufacturing processes stable? My second one relates to slide 8. You laid out the EUR 1.6 billion charge and helpfully gave us a bit more broad-brush color, but you flag just over EUR 1 billion of provisions for wind turbine repairs, with the remainder split between roughly EUR 400 million for service and the rest from knock-on impacts. Is there any further detail you'd be willing to share on how those figures were calculated? More specifically, the duration of the utilization of that backlog and the knock-on effects on commissioning timetables across your onshore portfolio. My last question is about how we should, you know, conceptually think about service within Siemens Gamesa. You've had roughly EUR 2.2 billion of annualized revenue, growing mid-single digit, give or take, and historically targeted margins of around 20%. Is that sustainable, or should we now throw that assumption out the window?

William Mackie

analyst
#102

Much appreciated.

Jochen Eickholt

executive
#103

Let me begin with the design question. Where design is concerned, I think we need to assume that some degree of optimization is always intended, for a range of reasons. As I see it, design isn't really a fixed thing. It's closer to a roadmap that follows a variety of criteria. Often, for example, a cost-out exercise itself does call for a design change. In that sense, what we're discussing here isn't so much a design matter, in my view, as the overall system, with its contributions relating to our own processes and to the supplier components. In certain cases, design modifications are also part of the picture. On the EUR 1.6 billion, perhaps you'll let me try to illustrate once more how that figure is arrived at correctly. We have a number of components, and those then have different failure modes, as we call them. Yeah, a single component can have several root causes for something to occur. Here the likelihood of something has to be taken into account, and that is a consideration across the lifetime. For the lifetime, we usually calculate roughly 25 years. That brings us to a few numbers which, as such, are independent of one another.

Jochen Eickholt

executive
#104

When a turbine has an issue with a blade, it might or might not also have a bearing issue somewhere else. That's why calculating how many turbines are affected isn't so straightforward, if you like, since for most of these matters we now have probabilistic figures. Using those probabilistic figures, we go into our cost modeling. Then, through the cost modeling, we state what we expect to be using across that period, depending somewhat on when it arrives and when it happens and when it doesn't. That then gets translated into those figures in the specified breakdown. At the end of the day, that's the best knowledge available to us at present. Right? On the third item, service — would you like to comment, or should I?

Christian Bruch

executive
#105

I can also address the service side of things. Obviously, this is also where we'll provide an outlook, so to speak, moving forward at the Capital Market Day at this point, clearly, and this is what you've seen, well, regarding the allocation. A portion of the accruals goes to the service business. That will lower the profitability of the service business over the midterm. We'll provide an outlook then, truly going forward, at the Capital Market Day.

Michael Hagmann

executive
#106

Thanks to all of you.

Jochen Eickholt

executive
#107

Alright.

Michael Hagmann

executive
#108

Just one more follow-up. Yeah, you've already asked three questions.

William Mackie

analyst
#109

On that EUR 6 billion provision figure—could you give us some sense of how quickly you expect that provision to be consumed across the coming one to two years?

Jochen Eickholt

executive
#110

No, it’s still too early to have that worked out, unfortunately. Keep in mind that in certain cases, we don’t really have a complete picture of the underlying causes yet. We’ve now set up the task force, and that task force has one main objective, which is to firm up the numbers. Over the coming months, we’ll try to get as clear and as solid as we can, but as of today, that really isn’t possible.

William Mackie

analyst
#111

Appreciate it.

Michael Hagmann

executive
#112

Yeah, right. Unfortunately, we truly are out of time, since a few folks asked more than one question. I'd like to pass it back to Christian so he can offer a few closing remarks.

Christian Bruch

executive
#113

Thanks a lot for making time to spend a bit more with us. Given where things stand right now, I'd say it's definitely worthwhile, and I really appreciate the conversations. Naturally, I expect quite a few of you will also be in touch on, shall we say, follow-up calls across the coming couple of weeks. So please put the Capital Market Day on your calendar — the 21st and 22nd. That's also a chance to see the Wind Factory, which is clearly a big help too. In the meantime, stay tuned, and I look forward to seeing you. Thanks for your time.

Michael Hagmann

executive
#114

I appreciate it, everybody.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#115

Thanks.

Michael Hagmann

executive
#116

Take care. Goodbye.

Operator

operator
#117

Ladies and gentlemen, that brings us to the end of today's conference call. Thank you so much for joining us. A replay of this call can be found in the Investor Relations area of the Siemens Energy website. The address is www.siemens-energy.com/investorrelations.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Siemens Energy AG transcript — plus 131,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Siemens Energy AG earnings transcripts and 131,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Siemens Energy AG or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.