Siemens Energy AG (ENR) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

November 15, 2023

Deutsche Boerse Xetra DE Industrials Electrical Equipment earnings 110 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Robin Zimmermann

executive
#1

Good morning, everyone, and welcome to the Siemens Energy Annual press conference, coming to you from the <<inaudible>> here in Munich. It's wonderful to have you all with us this morning, and a warm welcome as well to everyone watching our live stream. Ladies and gentlemen, at 7:00 this morning we released our figures for fiscal 2023, and we'll be examining those in greater detail in just a moment. This financial press conference marks the first time that Siemens Gamesa is included, and that's why we'd also like to extend a welcome to the representatives of the Spanish media joining us through the webcast and on the telephone line. And naturally, we are providing interpretation into Spanish too. Here on stage beside me are our CEO, Christian Bruch, and our CFO, Maria Ferraro. As usual, the two of them will begin by giving us an overview, and they'll discuss the strategic matters of fiscal '23, after which they will take your questions. Christian Bruch will speak in German, while Maria Ferraro will speak in English. As always, the presentations will be available for download from our website following today's conference. And just for your information, this conference is being recorded, as usual, and it will be broadcast live on the Internet.

Robin Zimmermann

executive
#2

You can also follow this conference in the original audio, in German and in English. An English-language channel is available too, along with a Spanish channel, and you're free to switch between the 2 whenever you like. Before we begin, please note our safe harbor statement, which appears in the quarterly presentation. It's visible here on the screen as well. Following the presentation, we'll move to the Q&A. <<operator_script>>. At this point I'll turn things over to our CEO, Christian. Please go ahead.

Christian Bruch

executive
#3

Thank you, Rob. I wasn't aware you were adding Spanish. Well, I've been doing so since year 6. Welcome, everyone, to what is now the fourth annual press conference. I'm delighted that so many of you have made your way here and that so many are also joining online to discuss our results. I'd especially like to welcome the press representatives from Spain. I'll give you a brief overview of how we developed over the past financial year, and then I'll address the quality problems in the onshore wind business, and we'll discuss the ramp-up, which is something we've looked at a great deal. After that, I will of course talk about guarantees and agreements with the German federal government and banks. There has been much discussion of that in the press before Maria then gives you the forecast and numbers for 2022. So perhaps we can sum it up as follows: the difficulties we've experienced in our wind business have unfortunately completely overshadowed what was otherwise excellent business in other areas. The market in which we were operating was extremely strong in 2023; incoming orders at Siemens Energy exceeded the already high level of the previous year by more than 33% — in total 33.8% — and rose to EUR 50.4 billion, with both wind and grid technology contributing significantly to this growth.

Christian Bruch

executive
#4

Still, I have to say that we're very pleased with the incoming orders we booked in 2023. Our backlog stood at EUR 112 billion when the 2023 financial year closed, which means we hit a new record figure. What that implies for guarantees is a topic I'll get to shortly. Revenue rose roughly 10%, reaching EUR 31.1 billion. Every division except wind contributed to that growth once again. Gas Services, Grid Technologies and Transformation of industry all beat their revenue targets for the financial year, and so they were decisive in the group meeting its forecast on that front. Siemens Energy's profitability took a hit from the huge loss at Siemens Gamesa, which presented substantial difficulties and produced a problem of income before special items of minus EUR 2.776 billion. The margin before special items came in at minus 8.9%. Free cash flow pretax fell to EUR 784 million, largely because of Siemens Gamesa. Mind you, the cash inflow a year earlier was especially strong at EUR 1.5 million. Put differently, that's more or less half. It was, even so, well above what we had expected, so cash inflow in the final quarter of 2023 actually came in higher than our expectations.

Christian Bruch

executive
#5

Siemens Energy's net loss came to EUR 4.588 billion as of 30 September, and that puts us inside the range we had expected following the announcement we made in the third quarter. What that tells us is that Siemens Gamesa did not incur any further quality costs, though naturally this result is a huge disappointment. On the brighter side, Gas Services, Grid Technologies and Transformation of Industry are all moving along the right track toward their mid-term target for 2025. If you recall, at the IPO we projected that Siemens Energy, across all 3 of its divisions, would post an adjusted EBITA margin before special items of between 6% and 8% in 2023. Such was the forecast. Yet we began at 1.4%, and today we stand at 7.1%. That means we hit our very own target in spite of COVID, in spite of supply chain chaos, shortages of raw materials and the war in Ukraine. We take great pride in this, and all of our employees deserve our thanks. We are deeply grateful. This success story demonstrates that within Siemens Energy we can push toward profitability and transform our divisions. With that same focus and discipline, we must also devote effort to making our wind business more profitable and to restructuring it.

Christian Bruch

executive
#6

Because of quality problems at Siemens Gamesa, the offshore segment is going to need additional time before it reaches breakeven. As you may recall, our initial target for the wind business was 2024. Our current assumption is that breakeven will now come in 2026. Quality-related costs and the difficulties in the 4x and 5x areas are what lie behind this. And naturally, the new plants in offshore, which we already discussed during the third quarter. Most of our technical analysis is now complete. That means every one of the critical areas has been examined. A team of experts from Gamesa Energy, TUV Nord and other individual partners, Alix Partners, is now going through this with us. So at this point we are planning the implementation and the measures that are needed. As you know, these measures are going to take many years. It's comparable to a recall in automotive, for the automotive vendors — certain things can be handled right away, while other things will take longer. We are in the middle of planning this right now. And naturally, we are doing so keeping in mind that these turbines have to be resold. During the final quarter, we found no errors, and the provisions we set up for the quality problems remain unchanged since the third quarter.

Christian Bruch

executive
#7

First, we’ve halted sales of the 5x turbine while we work out what our fixes will be. At the moment we’re looking into when and how those corrective steps can be carried out. As I mentioned, planning is underway right now, and we’ll set it out going forward. On the offshore side, our emphasis is on raising productivity to support ramping up 4 factories. That relates to longer wind blades, and during fiscal year 2022 output had already gone up considerably. So the question is how many blades each plant can turn out and which nacelle types we could <<inaudible>> manufacture and raise volumes of, especially at Cuxhaven, Hull and Aalborg, where we managed to recruit and train staff to reach that productivity level. In this area we are a major employer in Europe, and we intend to grow it further. Naturally, this process took a lot of time and proved more complicated than we had hoped and than we had planned. Offshore carries a record backlog of EUR 17 billion. And when it comes to new orders, we have grown very selective. So we verify that the risk return ratio is positive on any new contracts we sign.

Christian Bruch

executive
#8

But we’re also seeing delays to individual project assignments in the offshore segment. As you’ve seen in the press and in customer commentary, we have no actions without bids for tenders, so those have to go out for retendering. As a result, we expect incoming orders in the offshore area to be very low in financial year 2024. That isn’t such a problem, since we have plenty of orders on the books, but going forward we’ll be very selective. In onshore, we expect lower incoming order volume due to the interruptions in operating phases. That will definitely affect our order books in 2024. Still, I think it’s certainly sensible in light of our restructuring. Even with the progress we’ve made in wind, this time around it will cost us time, and so we assume we’ll reach breakeven in the wind area in 2026. That’s 2 years later than originally planned. It’s very painful. For us, it means we need to review our strategy in the wind areas — which products are we using and selling in which areas, and what are long-term profitable markets?

Christian Bruch

executive
#9

Also, in what ways could we optimize further and bring costs down? Those are questions such as make versus buy, where we're in an excellent position. That work is under way. It will take some time, though. It won't happen overnight. But like any other area, it comes down to focusing on the most important items and then addressing them with discipline. The industry is right now at a watershed moment. Many things have been paused; many wind projects have been paused. Adjustments in tender conditions and requirements are needed if we want to grow wind energy generation quickly. The EU Commission recently launched this wind power package, which is very encouraging. It's encouraging to see how we can make the wind energy industry successful and achieve huge growth across the entire value creation chain. Siemens Energy's other businesses ensure the survival of the Siemens Wind business area. And we need to reach a positive result as fast as possible. We took over Siemens Gamesa 100% because we're convinced it's a company that will have an impact on the transformation to green energy, and we'll address this in the renewable energies area. We must confront criticism regarding the strategic decision and knowing better after the fact, we solve our problems today.

Christian Bruch

executive
#10

We’re addressing individual topics one at a time. And naturally, that’s something we’ll discuss during our Capital Markets Day next week. An energy market that lacks wind cannot work. So maybe I can turn now to the subject we’ve concentrated on, especially over recent weeks: guarantees. As you’re aware, together with the federal government, our bank partners in Siemens AG have reached an agreement for reinsurance. During the recent weeks and days, it matters to me now to make clear how this guarantee instrument really functions, since it is fairly complex, and I believe it is frequently misunderstood. Demand for our technologies and products is enormous. Our backlog, as I’ve already mentioned, stands at EUR 112 billion. Industry practice involves ensuring — offering guarantees to ensure potential customer requirements are met. These protect down payments, performance or warranty claims. That is an industry standard. Normally, banks supply this security as a guarantee, which is also called an aval. Banks provide these avals for a fee that we pay. This is a well-established industry instrument, yet its practical relevance is actually quite minor.

Christian Bruch

executive
#11

Those almost never come to pass — roughly 0.2% throughout the industry globally — so if the highly unlikely were to occur, it would be covered. If we have an interest in this, or we want to be certain that we can draw on it when truly needed. When a guarantee is in place, no money actually moves or changes hands. This isn't a loan — it's a guarantee, and that is extremely valuable. We pay for it, but under EU law it is not a loan, and I wanted to emphasize that point. It's an instrument that matters so we can cover our enormous incoming orders, especially in the wind area. As I said, it's a complex instrument. But I want to ensure we all grasp why it is needed. Why does the federal — why do we require the federal government? Well, our backlog is so large — the Minister of Justice actually called it a comp risk, since we hold the biggest backlog in energy technology in Europe. This guarantee volume is a challenge for our corporate bank; this EUR 7.5 billion is a significant sum. We had EUR 20 billion of guarantees.

Christian Bruch

executive
#12

Naturally, this comes down to whether we can keep up with a business that keeps growing steadily. The federal government has now given us a tool, along with our banks, that lets us hold a safety net for the coming 2 years. That ties into growth during a challenging stretch. Our wind energy segment is obviously a difficult one, yet this gives us coverage and a safety net. You might not have come across it, but a comparable debate has been going on at EU level for the last 2 years. So in what way can guarantees be provided in the wind energy segment? You've likely heard Commission President Ursula von der Leyen speak about the wind power package. She mentioned guarantees, and that is precisely what she was referring to. Industries exist, but instruments exist for the entire industry to provide counter guarantees. Those structures are in the process of being built right now, since we observe that, given these substantial investments in the shift to green energy, structural issues exist that need to be settled and fixed. So regarding the volume being issued, we managed to reach an agreement with the federal government, the banking consortium and Siemens AG amounting to roughly EUR 12 billion.

Christian Bruch

executive
#13

The federal government has now provided the banking group with a counter guarantee worth EUR 7.5 billion, which means we pay a fee to both the banks and the federal government. No burden falls on the taxpayer. This also means the federal government gets income as usual — even if the wind energy area had been successful, we wouldn't be discussing this. We want to resolve the issues we face as fast as we can. Our aim is to make a wind energy area as successful as possible. We don't want to push this instrument too far, but right now it helps a great deal. I'm also very grateful to all parties for the constructive talks we've held on this matter. Beyond that, we settled our product structure with Siemens AG, which provides something called a share pledge. So this represents a pause of payments, plus a security of EUR 1 billion, and in this particular case it is what's known as an insurance — it offers that insurance as a structure, since the default risk is low. The result is a total structure with all parties involved, and we consider it a very good agreement for securing Siemens Energy's growth over the long term.

Christian Bruch

executive
#14

When the federal government steps in with guarantees, that's really standard practice. Everyone here surely knows this from the export sector — what people call Hermes guarantees. For decades, these have been supporting foreign trade, and I want to give special thanks to the federal government for everything they've done and for the constructive dialogue during the last few weeks. My particular thanks also go to our colleagues at the banks, who've been working around the clock. I'd like to thank Siemens AG as well — Roland Busch, who took part in our talks in a very constructive manner. Sadly, the press often portrays this in varying ways. Still, I've consistently found our discussions to be highly constructive and expedient, even if they weren't always simple. What I want to address now is how we contribute to the shift toward green energy, and I'll give you a few examples showing how Siemens Energy matters for the transition to Green Energy. The first project you see connects fossil fuel wells with new wells — a project in France, and it's a gas turbine. That's the HYFLEXPOWER project, which can run on hydrogen and natural gas. This has already been demonstrated.

Christian Bruch

executive
#15

There's an electrolyzer — a facility for making hydrogen — and that's the facility demonstrating how the hydrogen molecule can serve as stored energy through a gas turbine. Operations have now successfully kicked off the second project: 1.5 gigawatts, the biggest European offshore wind project, with 139 of our 11-megawatt turbines installed in Holland. Hollandse Kust Zuid was inaugurated not long ago. That's enough to supply 1.5 million households with renewable power. The second image from the right is Shannonbridge in Ireland. It's a product through which we're establishing a strong link to enhance grid stabilization and also to deploy large-scale battery storage. Here's the question: how can accessible renewable energy be captured, transported, and stored? On the other side, there's the matter of stabilizing the grid — it can power roughly 9,500 homes for a day, which is what the shift to green energy requires. I take real pride in the progress we're making with hydrogen. A lot of you were in Berlin last week when we opened our factory together with our partner Air Liquide, so we have 200 megawatts of capacity, which is being delivered to Normand'Hy, where starting in 2026, Air Liquide will be capable of producing 28,000 tonnes of green hydrogen per year for the mobility sector.

Christian Bruch

executive
#16

So at this point you can see the direction we're taking with renewable energy. That energy needs to be moved around. The grid, as a result, needs stabilization. For industry, we must produce green hydrogen, and transitional technologies are going to be necessary to keep the grid supported. Existing gas turbines are usable for that if they get converted. So this proves that structurally, it can work. Alongside securing guarantees and growth, we've been chasing other objectives too. For instance, making our balance sheet stronger. For us that's an absolute priority. Initial transactions involving parts of the companies have already begun. Those that aren't part of the core company, such as divesting our high-voltage branch to the investor Triton. Additional divestments of that kind are planned as well, so we can concentrate even more on our core business. In addition, we've agreed with Siemens AG to sell 18% of its interest to Siemens India Limited. This -- since Siemens India is a listed company, the aim is to separate the 2 companies. That's a process we intend to speed up. Right now we hold 24% of this company. And step by step, we will separate the 2.

Christian Bruch

executive
#17

This marks the initial phase of that process. How we run things in India isn’t what’s at issue here. For us, India is a key market, and that will stay the case. It’s also a key market for workforce, and we intend to expand there intensively. Still, this lets us separate the companies as fast as possible. It also means we get a cash inflow of EUR 2.1 billion. Altogether, we expect cash inflows of between EUR 2.5 billion and EUR 3 billion in 2024. So at this point I’d like to hand things over to Maria.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#18

Thanks. Hello, everyone. Hello to those of you here with us in the room. A warm welcome from me, and hello to everyone joining us online today. It's a pleasure to walk you through our fourth quarter results and, naturally, our annual results too, and I'll be guiding you through them. And naturally, I'm happy to take your questions afterward. If we could please begin, yes, on the next page, with an overview of the Siemens Energy Group's performance for fiscal year 2023. As Christian said, the Gas and Power businesses delivered an excellent performance in fiscal year '23. Looking at Gas Services, Grid Technologies and Transformation of industry. This was marked by strong orders, so a very strong top line, rigorous project execution and operational improvements. These improvements we've been working on for many years to make sure we raise our profitability accordingly. This was overshadowed by the challenges that persist at Siemens Gamesa, where we continue to deal with, as Christian mentioned, the onshore issues, looking at increased product costs and the offshore ramp-up challenges. However, our market overall remains strong. As a group, we managed to increase orders by 34% comparable to just over EUR 50 billion, with a very strong quarter 4 of last year.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#19

We’re seeing large orders throughout every business, especially in our Grid Technologies unit, where big HVDC orders plus a sizable offshore order at Siemens Gamesa contributed to that rise. Our order backlog reached a fresh peak of EUR 112 billion. Revenue increased in every segment except Siemens Gamesa. On a comparable basis, it rose by just under 10%, putting us comparably and comfortably at the midpoint of our revenue growth guidance range of 9% to 11%. Profit before special items came in negative at minus EUR 2.8 billion because of the loss at Siemens Gamesa. As a result, our corresponding profit margin stood at minus 8.9%. Free cash flow pretax fell year-over-year to EUR 784 million following an exceptionally strong quarter a year earlier. Even so, it came in much better than expected across all businesses here, Siemens Gamesa included. That was a very strong close to the year when it comes to free cash flow. Turning to the next slide — I think this is a very important one, always making sure we understand what sits in our backlog. And I believe that transparency you see before us is super important, since it underpins our business plans going forward.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#20

That's visible in the order backlog we hold. Each of our businesses recorded a book-to-bill ratio above one across the last 12 months. And naturally, as I noted earlier, that backlog gives us visibility into revenue stretching well past a 12-month horizon. For fiscal year 2024, a large majority of revenue is already secured within our backlog. And when you look at the size of that backlog, it covers nearly 3x our annual revenue. The mix, as you can see, is quite favorable too. Take Gas Services: its backlog is very resilient, thanks to the long-term service business. And importantly, every one of our former Gas & Power businesses has an order to book profile that supports the midterm targets, which is more than 2/3 of our backlog. Now let's move to liquidity, on the next slide. Thank you. This is where I do want to perhaps clear up any misunderstanding. Much has been said about our financial situation over the past week. So I really want to make sure this is clear. First and foremost, Siemens Energy is committed to maintaining a strong balance sheet, consistent with a conservative financial risk profile and also a profile of an investment-grade rating.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#21

So this gives us a really solid base for ongoing growth as we work through that EUR 112 billion order backlog. On this slide you can see that, even with headwinds, our liquidity position remains very strong. If we look at cash and cash equivalents, we hold EUR 4.6 billion, and within financial debt, EUR 3.2 billion of that is long term. Taking our financial debt into account, that result is a slight net debt position of EUR 193 million. That's below where we were in the prior quarter. It's also materially better than we had expected. The reason is the stronger-than-expected free cash flow in Q4, which I mentioned earlier. Now turning to liquidity. At the close of Q4, Siemens Energy's total available liquidity stood at EUR 9.6 billion, and of that, as I just said, EUR 4.6 billion is cash and cash equivalents while EUR 5 billion comes from undrawn credit lines. As I noted, our balance sheet is very strong, and we'll keep working to make sure it stays that way in the years ahead. And as you can see, we're also taking proactive steps, doing everything we can, to keep strengthening that balance sheet.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#22

As you know, we're in the final stages as well, with a few other noncore disposals that Christian mentioned, and we'll keep finalizing those soon. On the next slides, I'll walk quickly through the quarterly figures by business area and also point out some of the annual achievements. Turning to gas services, another very solid quarter for gas services against a fairly strong prior-year quarter, with comparable increases across all areas. All told, Gas Services delivered an exceptionally strong fiscal year 2023. Revenue growth of over 18% year-over-year. Now the fourth quarter of GS always carries a different revenue mix. As you know, that's been the case in all of the prior Q4s, when we have a smaller portion of the service business. So this creates a mix issue, and therefore a correspondingly lower margin. For the full year, though, the profit margin landed on guidance at 9.3%, well within the guidance. Please look at Grid Technologies on the next slide. Overall, as mentioned, we had a successful year, with tremendous order growth year-over-year of just over 50% on a comparable basis, revenue at plus 17%, and a profit margin of 7.5%, close to the upper range of the guidance for our Grid Technologies business.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#23

Honestly, that was a truly outstanding performance — great job to the GT team on an exceptional fiscal year 2023. Turning to the quarter, profitability improved sharply, driven by higher volume as well as better project costs. And as you'll remember, the same quarter a year earlier was weighed down by significant headwinds tied to supply chain constraints. Orders fell versus the prior year purely because the comparison base was high. In last year's final quarter we booked 3 major orders. So there's no cause for worry there. Once again, the year as a whole was a great success for GT. Turning to Transformation of Industry, that segment is likewise posting very encouraging orders and revenue growth plus a solid book-to-bill of 1.37%, which really sets this business up for the future. As with GS, seasonality plays a role here too — for TI, the fourth quarter is the weakest one of the year seasonally. Still, for the full year the profit margin before special items landed at just over 5%, above the 3% to 5% margin guidance we had given. That shows the hard work many people put into building the turnaround plan we're still seeing today — that focus is paying off, and we're reaping the benefits across every business within TI. Well done.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#24

Moving to the next slide, Siemens Gamesa. I believe Christian gave you a fairly thorough update on where things stand in our wind business and the progress we're making. In Q4, we're seeing moderate comparable order growth. That's coming from the offshore and service business. It was helped by a large order in Taiwan worth more than EUR 2 billion in total. Onshore orders went down, which, as was mentioned, reflects the fact that we're pausing commercial activities for now until we feel comfortable with the quality issues. Revenue fell significantly, by just shy of 20%, because of the known quality issues in the onshore business. And of course, we still have our factory load plan changes in the offshore business. As a reminder, though, we do face a tough basis of comparison in Q4 of last year. We had the sale of the wind farm development portfolio, which gave a positive boost to both revenue and profit. And just as a reminder, that was EUR 0.6 billion from the sale. Profit came in negative at the EUR 664 million mark, in line with the indication we gave at the Q3 results presentation. So overall, to summarize, truly excellent performance from our Gas Services, Grid Technologies and Transformation of Industry businesses, and well on track to meet the midterm targets.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#25

Naturally, Siemens Gamesa's financial results fell short of what we hoped for and represent a step backward, yet as Christian noted, we are implementing wide-ranging actions to bring stability to those operations. Let me turn now to our financial outlook and guidance. We have our outlook for fiscal year '24, and we have also given you targets for fiscal year '26 — a small preview of what we'll cover in greater depth at next week's Capital Market Day. For fiscal year 2024, we anticipate comparable revenue growth for Siemens Energy within a range of 3% to 7%, along with a profit margin before special items of between negative 2% and positive 1%. Net income is expected to reach up to EUR 1 billion. That figure reflects impacts from disposals and from speeding up our portfolio transformation. We assume negative free cash flow pretax of roughly EUR 1 billion. Furthermore, as noted, we anticipate proceeds ranging from positive EUR 2.5 billion to EUR 3 billion stemming from disposals and the accelerated portfolio transformation. As shown on the right-hand side, you can see the fiscal year '26 targets, which we'll lay out in far more detail at the CMD next week.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#26

On the revenue side, our growth outlook has become considerably more favorable—for Grid Technology and Transformation of Industries, for instance—and that, of course, also shows up in the higher margin targets set for those 2 businesses for fiscal year '26. At our Capital Markets Day next week, you'll get further detail on these midterm targets across all our businesses. So with that, thanks for listening, and I'll hand things back to Christian.

Christian Bruch

executive
#27

Thank you so much, Maria. Now I’d like to turn to summarizing what we’re prioritizing for this financial year. Siemens Gamesa in particular has to be stabilized, and the quality issues in the onshore business need to be fixed. Offshore must complete its ramp-up, and we’ll keep working at improving the cost structure. Even with that focus, we have to seize where needed the market opportunities that other divisions offer us — that 70% of the 3 business areas. We also have to convert this backlog into results and secure new business, so that our mid-term targets can be met and surpassed. Last, as Maria already mentioned, we’ll concentrate further on strengthening our balance sheets and, in doing so, separate ourselves from business that isn’t part of the core. In just a week, our Capital Market Day takes place, and that’s where we’ll discuss this. We’ll also go into our midterm targets in greater detail there. We have everything required to make our future a success. Market prospects are excellent. Our customers have confidence in us, and 96,000 employees are passionate about the company and give their best day in, day out. The past weeks in particular have shown one thing: the success of the transformation to green energy needs Siemens Energy, and we are ready to take on this responsibility.

Christian Bruch

executive
#28

That's going to make us even more successful. We'll keep working on this at full seam. And now I'd like to hand the floor back to you, Robin.

Robin Zimmermann

executive
#29

Thanks a lot, Maria and Christian. At this point, you're able to ask your questions. As I mentioned earlier, there are 2 ways for you to do that. Let me walk through the instructions. Again, it isn't so simple when 3 languages are involved. So let me take a minute to conference with you. <<operator_script>>. I want to start with the Q&A portion, and let's start with Mr. Hubner. Please go ahead.

Alexander Hübner

unknown
#30

Is my audio coming through clearly? Excellent. There are 3 questions I want to start with. The first is quite straightforward. Was my math right? If you strip out the divestments, or the portions of the business that have already been sold off, then for the current fiscal year you would still be looking at a net loss. Is that accurate? You also mentioned that so far, no additional provisions have been established for the issues at Siemens Gamesa. Am I reading too much into that? When you phrase it that way, does it suggest more could be on the way? Or would you exclude that? And speaking of excluding things, without getting ahead of next week, it didn't sound like any significant measures are being planned. So is it possible to exclude divesting a business area, for instance onshore?

Christian Bruch

executive
#31

Let me get right to that question. As for the current fiscal year, I think I can hand that one over to Maria, but — regarding the other 2 questions, if that works for you. And then, Maria, you can handle the remaining one. On the matter of quality issues, what I stated was that during the last quarter, we found no additional root causes — that we have looked into everything. I'm comfortable with these investigations on the 4x and the 5x. I think the question is, well, could something else occur? That's somewhat difficult. The reasoning behind all of this is that you have maintenance and repairs, and something like a problem might arise here or there — it's like with your car, that's entirely normal. But in Q3, we said it was too much when it came to probability and the costs tied to that. So that's why we carried out this analysis in more detail than ever before. So I think we have a solid basis here. And at this point in time, I see no other issues. And we're working on this throughout. But of course, looking into the future, I do feel that we have a good base line here when it comes to implementation.

Christian Bruch

executive
#32

So I think we can implement those corrective steps starting next week. I believe you heard that correctly. When we describe the business that's losing money, say in offshore, well, fixing it has to fall on us. That's really the only way I can express it. I won't add anything further, and I think, as I mentioned, we've identified the right measures. Going forward in Wind, we'll need to ask which products I'll have in which market. How broad do I want the base to be. And I think I said this last quarter too, we'll need greater focus, both regarding regions and regarding products. But I think yes, we have faith in wind, and we believe a turnaround is possible, and we simply must work through these issues -- resolve these issues. Naturally, these are also existing contractual obligations in onshore and offshore. And our name is on all of it. And as Siemens Energy, we certainly won't walk away from these things. It's painful, yes. But I think expecting something very spectacular next year would really be wrong.

Christian Bruch

executive
#33

Maria, do you want to go ahead and ask — take the next question?

Maria Ferraro

executive
#34

Yes, absolutely. On the net income for the year — as we said, we've got EUR 2.5 billion to EUR 3 billion in disposal proceeds coming in as cash during the year. That certainly affects net income. So at this point we see as much as EUR 1 billion of positive net income, and that includes the gains from those disposals.

Christian Bruch

executive
#35

So operationally, yes — the wind business would keep posting losses, and that holds true. Said differently, that's the loss we still expect from wind in 2024, since our assumption is that breakeven in Wind won't arrive until '26.

Robin Zimmermann

executive
#36

Mr. Frühauf, I believe there's another question you wanted to ask.

Markus Frühauf

unknown
#37

From EUR 2.5 billion up to EUR 3 billion — that's what applies to the share package, right? Is that accurate?

Christian Bruch

executive
#38

Yeah, that’s right.

Robin Zimmermann

executive
#39

Ms. Maier, you have the next question — please go ahead.

Angela Maier

unknown
#40

Yes, thank you. I have to say this comes as a bit of a surprise. There's been a lot of discussion about the balance sheet and your desire to reinforce it, given the substantial liquidity you hold. So my question is: what about equity? Looking at the balance sheet, equity was halved last year by EUR 5 billion. In the prior year you had EUR 17 million. That means it now sits below the EUR 10 billion of goodwill. So, examining the balance sheet, I would simply like to know — perhaps the CFO could address this for us — what does your equity position look like? What plans do you have on that front? Then, a second question: I would also welcome more detail on the divestment in India. What is the fair value of the India stake — the 24%, or perhaps 18%? How is that carried on the balance sheet? And what profit do you anticipate from this transaction, with Siemens? I would also like to raise the 15% discount at which you will be selling that stake. Could that stake perhaps have been placed on the market instead? A discount on large packages is fairly normal, I think, but 15% strikes me as a substantial amount.

Angela Maier

unknown
#41

What's behind a discount that steep? It seems to me we could have brought it to market. And naturally, if you look at 5%, that would be worth something to a big shareholder too. So perhaps other Siemens Energy shareholders — and you have assets going to the large shareholder, and then there's the discount. That strikes me as somewhat strange. Perhaps you could walk us through that.

Christian Bruch

executive
#42

I'll walk through how the structure works, and then when it comes to equity, you can handle the other one. Let me comment on this structure. What's the reason behind granting this discount? If you look at the Indian share market, the multiples there are very high. I believe it's 57, if my memory is right. You'd find that on a western stock exchange. So in that sense, when we speak about the Indian share market, they're not really liquid. And there was no way for us to accomplish this differently. That's precisely why this is a very positive aspect. The fact that Siemens AG was ready to turn this into cash — it was a cash issue, and not so much a matter of profit. Cash is what we're talking about, and that is the structure. The 5% you referred to — that's a different matter. It isn't going to Siemens AG. It's going to a security pool, so to speak. And this would amount to EUR 1 billion. To begin with, from this — the shares going from Siemens Energy to Siemens India — this is a separate company set up for this purpose. And after that, we will have payments claims business agreements between Siemens Energy and Siemens AG.

Christian Bruch

executive
#43

These will be entered into this as well. So we’ll then arrive at EUR 1 billion. This pool is a form of reinsurance with the banks, first of all, and the federal government would have access if the guarantee is strong. This is the very improbable 0.2% that I mentioned in my presentation. And if no agreement exists between the customer and Siemens Energy has to deliver at that point, then, of course, we could access this pool. But that is the logic behind this, yet it will not go to Siemens AG but rather to this company, which is basically a fund for banks and insurance companies too. That’s how it should be understood. I hope I explained that a bit better this time. Thank you.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#44

All right, that leads perfectly into what you asked about SIL and the profit tied to SIL, since naturally there's a book value involved, Angela. And the figure we've cited as proceeds reflects market value as of yesterday, I believe, simply so we have a placeholder in place. Naturally, though, the deal closes in December. So it would be market value at that point, naturally, and market value minus our book value will generate that again. Now, just to work the math backward a bit, Angela, I've said we expect net income of as much as EUR 1 billion, including gains from disposals. And as we said earlier, a portion of the business keeps generating losses, so this disposal profit offsets that, which explains why we can guide toward positive net income of as much as EUR 1 billion. On equity, Angela, you're right, your math checks out. Yes. I mean, if we have losses, naturally that hits equity. And what we're focused on doing at present is making sure we have a solid balance sheet, as you observed with a net debt of 0.2 or 0.8 at the close of fiscal year, depending on how you look at it — very slight either way — and we keep reinforcing our balance sheet as we work through the slump, because then, as we said, in fiscal year '26, we see SAG reaching breakeven.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#45

The remaining segments kept adding value, and we can report net income in the range of EUR 1 billion to EUR 1.5 billion, so they keep contributing to equity. That, then, is precisely the response I'm able to give. I hope that is helpful.

Robin Zimmermann

executive
#46

After that, we’ll go to the chat questions <<inaudible>>. I’ll read it aloud in English — the 5x platform’s commercialization has been paralyzed. How long do you think it will take before the correct equipment is available and you’re back in sales?

Christian Bruch

executive
#47

I'll respond in German. Many thanks for that question. That is exactly what we are looking into right now. At the moment we are working out the first solutions based on 5x. We feel confident that, with the right packages, 5x can serve as a solid platform for us. Still, it's going to take some time yet. My sense is that in the coming weeks and months we'll be in a position to share more details on the launch timing — on when exactly this will happen, since it comes down to planning. The moment we enter the market, we have to provide delivery times. That is something still under discussion. We need to talk with our suppliers. And as you know, component issues remain a challenge. Naturally, in such situations we will also work alongside other suppliers. This point still has to be clarified. Right now we have a task force in place that is preparing exactly this. And as I said, we are working on it, and I'm optimistic that within the next weeks and months we'll have a solid foundation for it.

Robin Zimmermann

executive
#48

That wraps up the questions from the chat. A number of colleagues from Spain have raised this, and Ms <<inaudible>> as well: with the guarantees in place, how can we be sure about the <<inaudible>> within the EUR 12 billion or EUR 15 billion? How was that figure arrived at?

Christian Bruch

executive
#49

Okay, so the whole guarantee volume question is in fact much bigger than the EUR 7.5 billion to EUR 12 billion range. I believe we've got a handle on this — this isn't a new field for us. We're definitely actively engaged on these guarantees. We're in talks about it with the different countries. At the end of the day, this is a very standard instrument within reinsurance systems across various countries. We'll be discussing this with the countries where we have work places. We've had those discussions in Germany since, naturally, we have 26,000 employees there, and we keep growing in that country, and we'll carry on doing the same elsewhere. The second item is the European Union and its wind energy power package, which is meant to establish guarantees for large-scale wind energy projects, since that didn't only affect us but our suppliers and competitors as well. This is currently under development. Where is it coming from? How is it structured? How can it be paid for? What is the repayment guarantee? But I think that at the beginning of next year, we'll have the corresponding instruments for it. We'll work through this and work through the individual questions.

Robin Zimmermann

executive
#50

Appreciate it. Present in the room is Mr. Hapnov, who has a question.

Speaker

unknown
#51

Only 2 follow-up questions, if I may. On the guarantees issue — does a political solution need to be found, or starting in 2026 could you handle that on your own, provided there's profit in Wind? And second, as far as Wind energy goes, you're not at present looking at additional possible areas on the offshore side. Is that correct?

Christian Bruch

executive
#52

First off, if wind energy had worked out as well as we intended and we were already turning a profit, there would be no reason for us to be discussing federal government guarantees. Our rating would already be sufficiently high. And our goal must always stay this: to rely on that instrument for the briefest period we can. That is also part of why we will be reinforcing our balance sheets, since they don't require those back guarantees — counter guarantees. We are positioned very well. We have 17% — 70% successful business, and then we come to renewable energies, and the best-placed companies weren't earning a profit, which will be an issue 2 years ago. I began holding this discussion with the European Union. That is essentially how we contributed our input to the wind energy package. Naturally, suppliers sit behind all of these stories. These are businesses with thin margins, and they need to expand. Within the renewables sector, this is a significant matter, which is why we have talked it over with the European Union. But for us, certainly, given our other strong areas, this has to be resolved through ordinary commercial banking models.

Christian Bruch

executive
#53

Wind energy overall isn't something we're debating. Onshore is a topic you'll also hear discussed next week, though I wouldn't add anything beyond that. What you will hear from us, though, is that we'll concentrate on the key regions and products and on fixing structures. That has to happen before we consider anything else. We must keep evaluating whether the business will hit its midterm profitability targets. Offshore wind is the biggest piece. It has a profitable service business. Yet in the end, we have to reach a profits corridor consistent with our midterm targets. If not, this will remain something we constantly have to review. But right now, next week we'll be focused on fixing the problematic structures so we can stop the leak that's occurring.

Robin Zimmermann

executive
#54

And with that, let's turn things over to another colleague.

Thomas Magenheim-Hörmann

unknown
#55

Regarding the 96,000 employees, how many are actually working in Wind, and where are the largest sites? Mr. Magenheim-Hörmann is the one asking these questions. If you're considering recalling products, 5x your newest products in order to ramp up other business areas, won't this create capacity problems in your factories? What would that mean for your employees in the factories? Would it mean a decrease in the number of jobs?

Christian Bruch

executive
#56

Thanks a lot for those excellent questions. Of course, I need to run the numbers on this first. In this area we essentially have 2 topics at all times: new business and service business. Service business starts at roughly 10,000 employees, and my sense is that this sits about 70% onshore. So that works out to somewhere around 3,000 onshore employees plus a handful of factories -- meaning half of the business with Siemens Companies is onshore. But this is a long-term service business. So it's the people who actually climb up onto the turbines, for instance; you could say that's a base of 50,000 turbines. That implies our business model is largely profitable even when some losses show up here and there. This is a system that exists around the globe, since these are distributed well.

Thomas Magenheim-Hörmann

unknown
#57

How about production?

Christian Bruch

executive
#58

Not today—I’ll get to that. Please just let me finish what I’m saying. The key offshore locations, from an engineering standpoint, are Spain, Denmark, and Germany. Spain matters especially because of the legacy Gamesa business. Our production sites are China, India, Spain, and North America—those are the main manufacturing locations, naturally. If order volumes are lower—substantially fewer orders across 2023 and 2024—we had anticipated more incoming orders, and those were before completion. The effect will be lower capacity utilization at certain individual factories and sites. Naturally, though, we have a backlog that has to be worked through. So we need to weigh when we will begin, and we also need to weigh make versus buy. On the onshore side, there are specific questions about Horizon blades, and some blades we purchased came in broken. We don’t make all of these blades ourselves. Some we do, others we don’t. So we have to strike a balance between what we buy and what gets made in our own plants to keep capacity utilized—though offshore capacity utilization, of course, is lower than expected earlier, and that produced a dissatisfactory result in 2023 and 2024.

Thomas Magenheim-Hörmann

unknown
#59

I’m still not clear on this. Is there any risk here?

Christian Bruch

executive
#60

Right now, that question remains unresolved. We have not discussed shutting down sites, though naturally those conversations come up from time to time—specifically regarding which countries need measures in South America given 2023, we talked about certain things that would not be continued. And when the industry felt—sites in several areas and regions where projects are happening—as to whether that is the right way forward, that is a question for another time. But as far as capacity utilization goes, we have not yet talked about absolute closures. I cannot confirm what is being printed in the press. And of course, we will offer you these numbers in more detail.

Analyst

analyst
#61

I've got a couple of follow-ups for you, Mr. Bruch. First, when it comes to the Siemens Energy structure, is that something that works going forward? You've mentioned several times today that the legacy area — that's the business that survives — is what keeps the company alive. So my question is: does a structure as big as the one you have actually make sense? That's my first one. Second, there's a dividend ban in place — how long does it last? Could you give us a time line for it? And maybe a related question on the offshore issues: with everything that's happened in the U.S., have you seen any significant cancellations from customers for offshore wind turbines? Then one more: are you considering a capital increase?

Christian Bruch

executive
#62

Alright. I'll start with the first question. Does the structure make sense at this point? If there are areas where we're losing money, then of course you have to question the strategy. There's no question about that. We're taking a very careful look at this. In other words, what are we going to focus on, and how quick will the transformation be? When we first began, we had a very big continuous issue not only when it comes to the business areas, but also the whole setup. I think you're familiar with this: 23 SAP systems, also different IT systems, a lot had to be harmonized over the last 3 years. There are many areas where we have different issues. But they also have synergies, data, technology, execution. And maybe we take a look at when we can see from -- we can say everything went very well. But we have to ask these questions: what will our strategy be going forward? You've always said we will also have to have transformation in all technologies to new technologies with a certain growth rate, but also with certain requirements with regard to profitability. Some of them meet these requirements, but not all business areas do so.

Christian Bruch

executive
#63

And that’s why we’d take a close look at the portfolio to determine which structure gets us where we need to go. My perspective now is different from what it was 2 years ago. We didn’t gauge the grid as much as it actually was, but far earlier than gas turbines. We believed that was the situation. Circumstances are shifting. The underlying conditions are shifting. We likewise view this as an opportunity. We’ll have to keep working on our portfolio. The basic structure isn’t really the main point. In certain areas, I have to be candid and say that when we examine onshore quality, we can see the situation we had in '17 through 2020. Those are the things we find very painful, the errors that must be corrected. It isn’t just the structure as such within the business areas that deserves criticism. The basic structure isn’t the problem. But naturally, we must be open enough to say, and to ask ourselves, is what I believed 2 years ago correct? Or must we say, "No, we’re going to have to change things." And in the final analysis, we will have to hit the profitability and growth targets.

Christian Bruch

executive
#64

Offshore wind turbines came up in your questions as well.

Analyst

analyst
#65

Are there any cancellations related to the United States? I believe that’s the area you’re concentrating on there.

Christian Bruch

executive
#66

Individual projects have kind of vanished, so to speak, and as a result of what we're seeing here, things have been scaled back. Nothing got canceled out of the backlog, if that's what you're driving at. And that's the reason I said I'm viewing 2024 this way. We were at a stage where reflection is needed. You have to see what the projects need to look like. There's one major customer of ours, and they've made some announcements recently. Of course, this affects how many projects are awarded and the interest costs — all of this has an impact. So I assume that in 2024, incoming orders will be low. I think we have to sort things out in this industry.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#67

Now I'll turn to the capital raise. Thanks for the question, of course. Maybe I should just reflect on what we mentioned regarding the measures we're already proactively taking. The EUR 2.5 billion to EUR 3 billion — these are measures, as you can see, that will have a cash impact this year, yes. So if you look at our balance sheet, this actually gives us the ability to be net cash this year once those proceeds are in. And all of the proceeds will come in during this fiscal year. That's what's planned. And of course, this is very important to us. What I always say is we need a balance sheet that has an investment-grade profile. But as you see, there's more and quite some optionality that we have as a company in order to continue to strengthen the balance sheet if need be. But it's not just about strengthening the balance sheet. It's also about, as Christian mentioned, how do we continue to optimize or capitalize on opportunities within our business? You see the massive order growth. There are opportunities that we would look to see and how we accelerate, for example, our divestment program already to make sure that we are able to capitalize on those opportunities.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#68

So every option is on the table for us. That's certain. And once again, we're committed to keeping a solid balance sheet.

Robin Zimmermann

executive
#69

Mr. Fleming. After that, we’ll go back to the chat. Mr. Fleming?

Analyst

analyst
#70

I’ve got 3 questions, I believe — one for Mr. Bruch and two for Ms. Ferraro. Mr. Bruch, you mentioned that in wind, it comes down to focus and deciding which products get offered in which places. Now, when you discuss wind, this is a sector that’s running at a deficit. What factors are you weighing here? In other words, how are you sorting through all of it? And perhaps you could address the revenue volume — what does your analysis show on that? You said it’s better than expected, and that cash flow in the fourth quarter has also come in better than expected. Could you walk us through the relevant factors behind that development? And the second one: Siemens Energy posts a huge loss. Even so, you pay taxes of EUR 1.2 billion. Why is that the case?

Christian Bruch

executive
#71

I'll start by talking about rationality. Ultimately, the question we're asking is whether, over the medium term, I can get into that target margin corridor we described as above 8%. For us, and for competitors as well, we've seen figures of up to 10% in some cases. In this area, that ought to be achievable. So these are medium- to long-term charges. But when it comes to rationality, I need to examine how much volume one product can cover, since a great deal will hinge on repeating the same operation many times over — the same turbine. And productivity will rise. At Siemens Gamesa, we have all kinds of different turbine versions aimed at sort of different markets — not only the 5x with 1, 2 or 3 as business. All of that isn't necessary for me. If I have 1 model, how many markets can I address with it? That's one notion underlying all of this. And this could mean that in certain markets, I can't even offer my product. So we'd need to ask: what can I do to keep my manufacturing and productivity as simple as possible? So that I'm able to use the same thing repeatedly?

Christian Bruch

executive
#72

There's also the option of examining the competition in the market. Chinese rivals in particular markets are a prime example, above all where they've got capital construction, financing, and so on. Naturally, I'm under no obligation to join that fight — I can concentrate on the places where the big markets sit and where I, as a supplier from the West, am able to operate. We won't be doing so. On a global basis, we have no desire to operate in every region. So in principle, we draw a line between onshore and offshore. Offshore is a far more worldwide market. It exists in just 8 to 10 countries, and that's a major focus. Which is why the question here becomes when the next largest turbine will arrive, what the service life of this product is — and it's less about countries and regions. It's about simplification and focus, and the question is whether I'll be in the providence, in the card, and how much money I need to put in up front. The wind industry must invest in plans for product development. I need to strike a balance with my investments. I need to be able to generate as much revenue as possible.

Christian Bruch

executive
#73

So there are regions where I might hold some market share, yet even so, I just wouldn't have a large enough slice of that market to recover the capital I'd put in. That's why profitability expectations are what guide all of this. You could put it this way: it spares us from complications with our competitors. The industry's view is that over the medium term, our profits can fully show that we trail the field. Quality problems are the reason we sit behind the competition. And that's exactly why I'm certain that in chosen markets, a solid profit pool is available to us. If it weren't, we wouldn't be operating there.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#74

On net debt and cash flow — yes, those came in stronger than we had anticipated, as I said earlier. And in fact, that holds true across every business area. I dug into the details pretty thoroughly. A great deal of it stemmed, naturally, from how our top line developed with regard to advance payments and similar items. You may also have picked up on a positive movement on our balance sheet in contract liabilities, which contributed as well. And one thing the team has done a really strong job on this year is focusing on receivables that are past due. I've brought this up in prior quarters. In Q4, for instance, we managed to collect a single overdue account — a fairly large one, in a particular country, that had been stuck for a while. So those elements together drove what I'd call this exceptional free cash flow, and as a result, lower net debt for the quarter. On your second question — yes, you're completely right. We are posting losses. And regrettably, we keep paying tax. That stems from the unfortunate business situation, of course, with the downturn at Siemens Gamesa. Sadly, we aren't in a position to use deferred tax or recognized deferred tax assets as an offset, let's say, in the places where we are currently profitable while carrying losses.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#75

You're correct that we're unfortunately getting hit from two directions at once. We are monitoring that very closely and doing everything within our power, but this is the situation we currently face.

Robin Zimmermann

executive
#76

Does that address your question, Mr. Fleming? Great. Now let's turn to the chat. Here's one for an engineer. Mr. Bruch, would you go over again precisely which corrective steps have been taken on the 4x and 5x platforms and how that works in actual operation — but explain it so a lay person can follow? Well, I'm pleased that manager magazin is putting the question to an engineer.

Christian Bruch

executive
#77

There are a lot of topics here. What matters for running without errors is making particular problems easier to use. The less critical components are ones I already mentioned: blades, storage, and bearings. With the blades, the repairs had to be done on the turbines themselves. So maybe you sand down a specific spot and then fill it back in, in a very straightforward way. And then you climb back down — in other cases, it may have been necessary to take the blade off completely. With the bearings, the question is more about which point is where, so high up on the bearing that it has to be swapped out. If a replacement is needed, that has to be done with a crane, so it calls for more planning. This happens with coordination that requires setting priorities. For 5x, some of these turbines are still in the plants or on the construction side. So if we see that certain things need fixing, we can push this forward so it gets delivered to customers faster. No matter what the wind regime is, we can see how the wear and tear looks and when things will need to be done. Planning is possible.

Christian Bruch

executive
#78

There are also some smaller items on the periphery. And if we're already installing something, then we can go ahead with ABCDE, which is why, much like automotive recall campaigns, we can take a comparable approach to guarantee operation free of errors across 20 to 30 years. So the trouble spots are those blades and bearings. Multiple remedies exist. This is complicated. We lack a single universal fix for all of it. When we brought this in, we stated that we have several suppliers for, say, a bearing. That doesn't necessarily imply we can apply the identical repair approach going forward. So naturally, we'll need to coordinate tightly with our customers.

Robin Zimmermann

executive
#79

Here's a question, for example, from Javier Radio of Cinco Y Diez. When we speak about additional cost cuts and making processes more efficient, does that mean there will be layoffs and factory shutdowns at Siemens Gamesa, and particularly in Spain?

Christian Bruch

executive
#80

Right now, there aren't any concrete plans for that. You have to keep in mind that we have — we've been buying companies and bringing people on the entire time, more than any layoffs or anything like that. So the real question becomes: how do we actually redeploy people? If we move parts of the business around to take account of this, well, we have no plans for layoffs. But naturally, we have plenty available to us, and that's the key point. As I mentioned, Spain is a really important location for us. You're aware that the wind headquarters sit in Spain. And as far as I'm concerned at this moment, that isn't something to be debated.

Analyst

analyst
#81

I'd like to know how worried you are about the pace of your investment. If you were to drop a level, would that affect the guarantees? I have a question regarding the guarantees — what fees do you have to pay? And then the key point, the really critical question, Gamesa. During 2017, '18, '19, you shifted Gamesa over to Siemens AG. What debt existed at that time?

Christian Bruch

executive
#82

Interpreted Or maybe I could. So the first question was about guarantees and fees. Maria will handle the question on the investment rate. On the guarantees and profits currently under negotiation — just to make this point clear — we have a structure that has been defined regarding which fees get paid and at what point. Negotiations on this are ongoing, and it will be finalized over the coming weeks and months. What matters is that these fees are normal and common to the market. This is assistance. Of course, it has to be a commercial model, but it is not assistance. Is it common for the market? Once again, this is a press conference. And I take it you are relying on what you have just said — and what impact does that have on the investment grade? What are the rest — what exposure is created in the bank? We were talking about the banking consortium earlier, and Maria will discuss this as well. There is no single true number. What matters is that there are conditions regulatory authorities would agree to and that this is done in a commercial way, as in private pass. Siemens Gamesa — I don't necessarily want to talk about whose fault it is.

Christian Bruch

executive
#83

These issues go beyond that level of complexity. Certain matters are visible within the Supervisory Board, while others are not if they extend further down. A few of these things are just inherent to the industry. Race came about as we will be in a position to build the next turbine, yet we must ask ourselves why this occurred so that we can learn from it. Still, assigning who is to blame makes no sense. From where the Board sits, we naturally have a more limited view of what takes place deeper down in the engineering area. So my view is that discussing responsibility and fault is the wrong conversation to be having right now.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#84

As I mentioned before about the investment-grade rating, we remain firmly committed to the view that an investment-grade rating matters enormously to us. Naturally, that rating is essential to how our business model works. I believe we've been saying this from the very start, since the company was founded. And we are taking every possible step to make sure our balance sheet and the overall profile of the company are worthy of an investment-grade rating. That is precisely why, knowing in advance that we would face a cash gap this year, we acted proactively and put measures in place to reinforce that balance sheet right away, using the EUR 2.5 billion to EUR 3 billion in proceeds coming from speeding up our divestment program. I think this is truly essential, and we are always engaged in very good, constructive discussions with S&P, our credit rating agency. And this is something we, of course, handle with a very, very serious approach.

Robin Zimmermann

executive
#85

All right. Let's go on with Mr. Hess.

Analyst

analyst
#86

I've got 2 questions. The first one is about India. That business is expected to expand, so how do you plan to run it? From what I gathered, your intention is to exit that region entirely. My second question concerns China. We've just heard quotes saying it would be a mistake to shut Chinese competitors out of the European market, to deny them access to tenders, since they're superior when it comes to technology. Wind power ramp-up could in fact be accomplished with their help. I'd like to hear your perspective on these points.

Christian Bruch

executive
#87

When it comes to India, we’re going to stay within Siemens India and keep our seats on both the Supervisory Board and the Executive Board. The structure itself is going to shift. But this divestiture creates 2 companies. You could say we’ll have Siemens AG, or Siemens Energy AG India. Through this divestiture, we end up with one Siemens AG covering this business field and the other covering the Siemens Energy business field. If you recall, a report came out. There was always a share swap involved. This time it will be set up differently. It’s really a matter of separating the companies in their current form. Operations for us will carry on as usual. We’ll keep growing in India and keep expanding production in the areas where we work. None of that changes. This simply takes the divestiture structure a step further.

Robin Zimmermann

executive
#88

This comes from Martin, and I consider him a highly capable colleague.

Christian Bruch

executive
#89

I don't recall exactly what was written down or precisely how it was phrased, but I have a few remarks. Protecting the market from Chinese competitors in a wind area isn't the issue here. A level playing field is what we need. That's the reason guarantees have to be used. We must look at what Chinese competitors are doing. It has to be fair. We need to think about how investments, new products, new platforms, new factory structures are being carried out. I respect our Chinese investors. They excel at building production plants, for instance — I've got 30 years of experience in this area. But I've also come to understand that we can keep pace with the Chinese and even beat them on an international level if the right solutions are available to us. Our Chinese passages -- well, first of all, I should say, we need to solve our own problems first. In order to confront and beat Chinese competitors. The problem I see is that we have countries and regions where I would question whether this is indeed a level playing field. It's necessary to talk about this, but separating the market is not what we're talking about. What we're talking about is creating criteria that matter to us as regions and countries in order to have a sustainable industry where production is carried out, where research is carried out — it's not so much the question who is doing it, but where it is done.

Christian Bruch

executive
#90

How are things going on the sustainability front and with the CO2 footprint? In what way do tenders capture these concerns? And when it comes to wind tenders, the issue arises whether price alone decides or whether additional criteria also matter. That is a topic Wind Europe and we have discussed. Our request to them was to examine it and widen the scope so that the individual elements contained in it are reflected. Yet this is not about shutting anyone out of the market, as I mentioned — the Chinese wind energy market accounts for half of the global market, and we cannot get access to it. Still, we have to view this in a balanced way. What is at stake is a level playing field, not exclusion.

Robin Zimmermann

executive
#91

Thanks. We have another 2 questions from the room before we get to the final comments, and then we’ll return to the chat. Mr. Hermann. An onshore region, so that isn’t the factories and it isn’t service. That’s 2049 colleagues. If you look at the figures from the factories, we’ll provide those figures later on, and we’ll move to the chat to reach a minute on the financial time. Could you please elaborate on your review into the scope of Siemens Gamesa’s activities? Are there some products you might stop in the future?

Christian Bruch

executive
#92

Yes. In certain areas, it may be too soon to give an answer on that. But what we're doing at present is asking ourselves how we need to be positioned so that we can potentially execute things, and how I can best manage my plan. That matters most to me. The first thing in particular was that we took all of the different varieties, 4x and 5x, the large versions we had with special equipment or whatever. We said we're not going to do that anymore. After that, we want standardization of the basic product. We're not doing any of these other special things. And the second point is that we have to think about when we will be launching the products offshore. That's the big question. How fast do we want to move on to the next platform? Here, right now, which I'd like to state clearly, we want to operate the platforms for a longer period of time. We want to sell them for a longer period of time and launch the new ones later on. We have to do the same thing over and over again. Those are 2 things that are driving us. We're also taking a look at products where we can say it's just one market, which depends on one product because of the wind conditions.

Christian Bruch

executive
#93

So we ask ourselves whether we're the right people to be doing this. Should we pursue partnerships, or should we divest it? We aren't at that point in our discussions right now, but that's a question I can't answer today. What we're asking is: how do I achieve a very large volume with one product?

Robin Zimmermann

executive
#94

Now let's move over to the phone lines. <<operator_script>>. We have Mr. Pleasure with Energy.

Analyst

analyst
#95

I have a couple of questions regarding offshore wind. In the financial results, it says that ramp-up challenges persist in offshore activities. You brought those up in Q3 too — have they shifted at all, and if they have, in what way? Then, to build on what you said about streamlining the turbine portfolio, where it notes offshore is concentrating on the SG-14, the new turbine: does that imply older turbine types will be discontinued? If so, what happens with products and projects that already placed orders for those turbines?

Christian Bruch

executive
#96

I'll do my best to answer that. The real question is how many blades and how many cells I can turn out at each plant. In offshore plans, that has gotten much better at reaching earlier milestones. Even so, productivity is still short of where it needs to be when you look at the former business plan. That is the reason offshore won't be in the profitability range we had planned for next year. So more measures are needed, yet we can see clear improvement, and every control mechanism is now in place so we can genuinely see which blades are being made. And naturally, as I already said in my presentation, this remains a matter of process, one that involves a great many employees who must be hired and trained and who have to repeat the same task over and over. That way we can raise productivity over the long play, the offshore blades. Here we have to check whether quality is good enough and whether the processes are correct. Those are things that require training. That is why the product life of a product matters.

Christian Bruch

executive
#97

We're seeing improvement. Yes. But not everything we set out to accomplish has been reached yet. It's going to keep us busy throughout all of 2024, so we can get to where we want to be. On the new product side, yes, we have 15, 16 megawatt turbines in the market. And we're still building the 11 more, and we're looking at various markets and the contracts we hold. So for existing turbines, the contracts already signed will be carried out. Nothing changes there. This is a gradual launch of a new product, and then we'll have ramp-up on one hand and phasing out on the other. And the products work such that you start with a nacelle category and a blade leg, and the following development would keep the nacelle the same while the blade gets longer. So these are step-by-step improvements that are coming, but it's a process that is planned. It's running to plan. And it changes nothing when it comes to the backlog or project execution.

Robin Zimmermann

executive
#98

There are 6 more questions in the queue. We've run a little past the time we set aside. Still, please keep things brief so Chris and Maria have room for fast replies. We'll start with the phone line from Mr. Baer, then move to the chair. After that, we can wrap up. Please go ahead, Mr. Baer.

Analyst

analyst
#99

I just wanted to ask about the plans for U.S. markets now that the Virginia blade manufacturing facility has closed.

Christian Bruch

executive
#100

I'm not sure I got that right. You mean the U.S. market?

Analyst

analyst
#101

My apologies. I simply wanted to gather a bit more detail regarding the halt of the Virginia blade manufacturing policy facility and what the plans are for the U.S. market after that.

Christian Bruch

executive
#102

So first, there’s a site that already exists, and it’s still in place. An option to expand it was available, and we chose not to pursue it — that has been made public. Why? Because, as we explained, we couldn’t see the projects supporting it. Should projects become appealing later on, we could revisit that decision. Right now, though, the expansion is not moving forward. Yet, as I mentioned on the Q3 call, our attention will go to the plants we already have — optimizing them and lifting their capacity utilization — rather than pursuing expansions and new sites. We’ll proceed one step at a time.

Robin Zimmermann

executive
#103

Javier from Cinco y Diez here. Any updates at all on how the sale of the factories in Spain is going?

Christian Bruch

executive
#104

No, that still falls under our make-versus-buy talks. Those talks are still going on. They aren't finished yet. And the moment we reach a conclusion there, we'll let you know. But really, it comes down more to the question of who is the best owner of what.

Robin Zimmermann

executive
#105

I see Mr. Richard from Dow Jones is in the chat now. These guarantees — how long do they last, until when do they run out?

Christian Bruch

executive
#106

We'll need to clear up these details. Our aim is to keep them as brief as we can. We're going to have to put real effort into our balance sheet. How long these guarantees will remain in place, I can't tell you at this moment. But as I mentioned, having them as short as possible serves our interest and that of our shareholders. And my assumption is it will be under 2 years. Still, that's something we must wait and see about. We have a structure in place. We have certain planning for the next 2 years, but it falls on us to no longer need these guarantees.

Robin Zimmermann

executive
#107

There's also a follow-up question that came in through the chat. It's in the government's press release as well — they mentioned a ban on dividends. What's your take on that?

Christian Bruch

executive
#108

That's another point we'll need to go through carefully. It's one of the requirements, and honestly it isn't typical around here. I believe we should discuss it, though it does appear in the paper. We'll also need to make this clear with the federal government. Still, it's fairly evident: while our company is loss-making and the government provides a guarantee, I can see why such a condition exists. That's precisely why avoiding this matters so much. We want to steer clear of needing those guarantees. While that remains true, we'll be in a position of having no net income, and net income is the precondition for distributing a dividend. That's why this makes a lot of sense as well. So the primary goal has to be generating net income, which would put us in a position to pay a dividend. Thank you very much.

Analyst

analyst
#109

I've just got 2 really quick questions, Ms. Ferraro. When do you actually hope or expect the credit rating, or the investment grade rating that got downgraded, to be upgraded again — something along those lines? And which regions or markets are you especially focused on when it comes to your assessments of where you'd like to work going forward?

Maria Ferraro

executive
#110

Yes. Thank you for asking about the credit rating. So at present — you may have seen that S&P issued a notice placing us on credit watch. In that watch notice, they actually offered considerable praise for the steps we are taking that I mentioned earlier, the product measures relating to the balance sheet. They likewise acknowledged the work done across the remaining parts of the business. But naturally, they also took into account how SGRE affects us as a group. In their report they further stated that there are specific items they need to observe, and one of those is today's development. Naturally, seeing our publications and similar materials, including to some degree the Capital Market Day, and at that stage they will decide whether the credit watch gets removed. So that is our current position. So there has been no credit action as such. Our investment grade rating remains in place. So nothing has changed in the business today.

Christian Bruch

executive
#111

When we look at the markets — we're a European company. Europe is a key market. It's going to stay that way in the offshore area. It's growing significantly for onshore. So Europe will be an important market for us. That is clear. The U.S.A. also offers attractive conditions for offshore. Onshore, we'll have to see what happens given these shifted options and the reaction of the U.S. government. But of course, or anything else, we'll have to see what happens. Those are 2 such central markets that offer a significant volume. And then we need to ask the question in how many markets do we need to be present. Of course, my focus is Europe and the U.S.A. There are always opportunistic markets, where the same products are always thinking about products work due to the wind conditions. But of course, that would have to be looked at later on.

Robin Zimmermann

executive
#112

Much appreciated, Mr. Stahl, for a second time — is there anything else you'd like to ask?

Analyst

analyst
#113

Mr. Bruch, here's a question that matters. Everyone here wants wind energy, and everyone here needs it. But making a profit from it appears impossible. Could you list 5 reasons why that happens to be so?

Christian Bruch

executive
#114

Siemens Gamesa provided a booklet listing those 5 reasons. In the end, this sector expanded extremely quickly. And I believe we underestimated the difficulties that come with such growth. That sort of thing is fairly common in other plant construction industries. Yet we've lost sight of how that felt, since it happened base 30 years ago. A major issue is that products came to market much too fast. The second is supply chains, which did not stabilize quickly enough. And then, naturally, the war, corona, rising costs that ordinary inflation increases could not offset. And thirdly, we must not overlook that the price of wind energy fell, dropped dramatically. We had seen steady growth, but then all at once prices went into a downward spiral. And this came down to the economics of simply the cheapest way of producing energy. The industry did not confront this promptly, particularly when it came to launching new products. What matters is plan-ability. That is an issue where, following a substantial surge of projects, we experienced an abrupt collapse and our factories are not all running at full capacity. And as a result, we had to decline in terms of productivity. So we require plan-ability. We require stability for the production of the product.

Christian Bruch

executive
#115

We also require a risk profile for projects involving both our customers and suppliers, one that's balanced when it comes to equipment. It bears remembering that a lot of companies had substantial sums invested in operating wind farms. The opportunity out there is enormous, and balance is needed. As I mentioned, these are growing pains of a very young industry, and they're extremely unfortunate.

Robin Zimmermann

executive
#116

Interpreted Ms. Mayer, we’ve got one last question from the room, and after that we’ll return to the chat.

Analyst

analyst
#117

Two quick questions. To recap, you set up 2 committees and one Supervisory Board task force where all of this is meant to be talked through and clarified. How was this able to occur? What do you expect from those committees? My second question means stepping back a bit. The market got a genuine shock late in October when it emerged that you had to go to the federal government asking for aid. My question: how did things reach that point? We are all aware that wind energy turbines are complex. That has been known for a few years now. In the end it looks like a bottomless pit of complexity. The rating was downgraded in July. Cash outflow wasn't especially large from the new quality problems. So that cash was still led because of high down payments. How can a cash gap of that size arise, such that you need so much cash, Ms. Ferraro? Could you have raised the alarm sooner? Maybe 6 months ago, could a capital increase have been carried out? Why did you let it get this far?

Christian Bruch

executive
#118

Maybe I can address the income and quality task force question. For every one of the big issues, we did root-cause analysis, for instance. There are a handful of completion reports, but engineer teams examined those. They evaluated the underlying causes. Corrective actions—some quicker, some longer-term—are now being defined so we can determine what is fixable or improvable. On the quality task force, I mentioned this back then: I'm confident it will stay in place for 1 to 2 years so we can build up experience and figure out which projects should be tackled first and which later. There's a great deal to get through. The special committee is evaluating what you might call the next line of defense. They examine provisions that have been set up and how we proceed from here. That's the role of the cyber committee. It performs similar evaluations and weighs what could be done better going forward. But as I said, right now it has grasped the issues and is moving into implementation. Before you respond, Maria. I deliberately noted that quality and guarantees—this subject was launched roughly 2 years ago, and that is when we began conversations with the federal government.

Christian Bruch

executive
#119

Our order books are actually expanding at a faster pace than revenue. For a company operating in a low-margin business area, that is a significant challenge. In any case, this would always have been a matter of concern for us. And I was rather surprised that you wrote a very good article Ms. Mayer. I have to mention that. Congratulations, but many people misunderstood this. It comes down to state aid and cash inflow. As a business, we started examining the complexity of guarantees very early on. We did not do this at the high-quality problem costs that Siemens Gamesa had at its heart in the third quarter. The quality limitations we had continue to constrain us in our planning for 2024. So if we have productivity, the quality issues now, they will not vanish by tomorrow. Thus business planning at Siemens Gamesa has in fact deteriorated significantly, and given that we had EUR 15 billion each year, so EUR 7.5 billion in guarantees have to be issued or drawn upon each time. So it is these 2 effects, especially for Siemens Gamesa, that came together. But we did say early on that the topic of guarantees was very important, and this has not been announced just today with the wind energy market.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#120

I don't want to mix up the guarantee issue with the cash issue you're rightly raising. If you recall, back in Q3, we stated then that our estimate for the quality matter for fiscal year '23 would be a modest figure. That's precisely because the effort Christian referred to had to be carried out to pin down exactly when the repairs will need to happen and what the corrective actions are. And also when — since the charge was booked, but when will the cash actually need to be, so to speak, outlaid going forward? And Angola, that's precisely what we've now completed. And we've said, alright, '24 we have an impact, '25, we have an impact. And we've consistently signaled that the curve roughly looks like this. What we now know is that 50% of the cash between now and 2030 will be spent. And then the remainder gets spent far out into the future, since it depends on our contractual commitments, correct? And we also stated that wherever possible we aim to fold those repairs into the regular maintenance intervals. So that only became clear as we carried out our work. And naturally, the second item, Angola, which we brought up in Q3 and which likewise carries an impact in 2024, is that we signaled there would be a consequential profit impact, because the onerous backlog has now grown as a result of the quality issues.

Maria Ferraro

executive
#121

And naturally, even for the ones that aren't burdensome — contracts in the onshore business, say — because of quality costs, if their profit stood at a given level, it then got trimmed correspondingly going into the following year, for instance. So those are the effects that showed up in fiscal year '24 after the Q3 quality issues. I hope that makes it clearer.

Robin Zimmermann

executive
#122

And the well-known final question today goes to Spain, to Ed Daez. I'd imagine we've already covered it. But Christian, perhaps a very quick response. Last night the Spanish government said it is working on a possible line of bank guarantees for new Siemens Gamesa contracts abroad. How does that fit with the overall guarantee scheme we just announced?

Christian Bruch

executive
#123

Like I mentioned, there are all kinds of conversations of this kind that we'd had before this one as well, including with the government — the German government. With the German government we had a dedicated package in Spain. I believe this was public, as noted in the German government's publication, concerning the EUR 3 billion — 12 plus 3 gives you 15 — and that EUR 3 billion is going to be in countries where we're active too. So they'd have guarantees and structures and so on as well. And as I said, naturally, countries such as Spain — which is a very important country for us when it comes to the wind business, and also for the European Union — together with the European Investment Bank. And here, what we see is that this forms part of an industrial measure that we intend to carry out.

Robin Zimmermann

executive
#124

I really appreciate it, Christian. And thank you, Maria. That wraps up our conference. We ran over the time we had planned. It looks like you all had plenty of questions. Getting into greater detail mattered to you. My hope is that Christian and Maria have addressed every question. Should anything have gone unanswered, our press team will of course be on hand afterward to respond to what you ask. That's the close of our webcast. Keep in mind that an analyst call is scheduled for 11:00. It will also be streamed live online. At this point we want to express our thanks to everyone who joined us by phone, through the webcast, or in the chat. We now have just enough time for a quick coffee with Christian and Maria. I should mention that we're now off to the side, in a manner of speaking. So today's press conference ends here. Many thanks to all of you for attending and for your interest.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Siemens Energy AG transcript — plus 131,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Siemens Energy AG earnings transcripts and 131,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Siemens Energy AG or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.