Spruce Power Holding Corporation (SPRU) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
May 15, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Bronson Fleig
executiveThanks, and good afternoon. I appreciate everyone joining Spruce Power's call today to go over what we achieved in Q1 2023. Joining me are our Chief Executive Officer Christian Fong, Donald Klein, who is stepping down as our Chief Financial Officer, and Sarah Wells, who is taking over as our Chief Financial Officer. During this afternoon's call, we'll make remarks about what the company anticipates, how it expects things to look, or what it predicts for the future, and those count as forward-looking statements under federal securities laws. Such forward-looking statements carry risks and uncertainties, and a great many of them lie outside our ability to control, and they could lead to actual outcomes differing substantially from what those statements express and/or imply. In the same way, we can't control when certain processes we'll be talking about today happen, and that could affect the expectation-related remarks you're about to hear; we have no duty to revise or update any forward-looking statements unless the law demands it. For information on risk factors and forward-looking statements, please see the disclosures in today's earnings release, our annual report on Form 10-K, and other filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission. Our press release is available on the investor relations section of our website if you'd like to consult it. The non-GAAP financial measures we mention on this call are reconciled against the U.S. GAAP equivalent and appear in the press release we put out this afternoon. With that said, I'll hand things over to Christian Fong, our CEO. Christian, the floor is yours.
Christian Fong
executiveThanks, Bronson, and I appreciate all of you being with us on today's call. Spruce has never been in a better spot, and our attention is fixed on keeping customer service at a high level, holding a sizable portfolio of rooftop power systems that produce zero carbon clean electricity, and running the long-dated contracts with attractive margins that deliver consistent cash flow. Through this quarter, we basically wrapped up Spruce Power's shift into a pure play residential rooftop solar business, with only a handful of remaining items. Among them is a management change that has been planned for a long time, with Sarah Wells stepping in as our new CFO. I'll say more about that shortly. Another item is the runoff of costs related to winding down XL Fleet, and part of that weighed on the Q1 bottom line. Most of those costs have already been recorded, so going forward our figures will truly highlight how appealing our business model is. Looking forward, we hold a sizable cash balance that can fuel additional growth and create value for shareholders, and we're able to deploy that cash toward growth by making acquisitions, which we showed at the close of March when we purchased the portfolio now called Spruce Power 4. That transaction grew our total portfolio by 44%, which equals a full year's target for customer growth achieved in a single move. Today, I'll walk through our operating results for the quarter and discuss some recent developments through the lens of our strategy's three core pillars. Pillar one is creating the industry's best customer experience. Our customer satisfaction score for the first quarter came in at 71%, above our 70% goal and sharply higher versus a year earlier, when it was 54% in Q1 of 2022. We're also on schedule with this year's technology roadmap, which is meant to guarantee reliability and system visibility month after month for a customer base that has now grown beyond 72,000; on the IT side, we completed the launch of new billing software tailored to the Zuora ecosystem and introduced a customer portal with a single login. Building a strong customer experience doesn't just help individual customers, it also opens the door to creating added value for Spruce as customers move up to full home power systems featuring battery storage and, in time, newer technologies like EV charging. We haven't yet reported our battery leasing figures separately, since retrofit batteries remain a niche market that varies a lot by region, and more than 80% of our leasing activity sits in California. Pillar two is achieving operational excellence, both in our main business of generating carbon-free electricity and in turning our portfolio into cash. At Spruce, our Q1 Performance Ratio, meaning output relative to the theoretical maximum for the installed solar panels, reached 92%. That compares with 95% in Q4, mostly due to the record rainy January along the West Coast; clearly, winter storms aren't something we can control, and that's well beyond my pay grade. We also track the weather-adjusted Performance Ratio, and there Spruce recorded a robust 102%, which shows how efficient and reliable our portfolio is. When it comes to finances, what measures our operations is how well we produce cash. The strong results from our portfolio make up most of Spruce's present run rate, which sits at $110 million to $130 million in yearly cash inflows—something we'll get into later. Next, we combined growth with capital as pillar number three, since growth mostly comes via M&A, and we remain disciplined about how we use capital. In the past, the price of growing has been low enough that investment returns stayed consistently strong. That pattern held in Q1, when we knocked it out of the park by buying the Spruce Power 4 portfolio. Through this deal, which transformed the company, our portfolio jumped 44% in a single night, bringing in contracted cash flows from more than 22,500 customers. Throughout Q2, we've been working to integrate what we acquired; it lifted our run rate cash flow right away, and beginning in Q2, we anticipate a clear picture of how its cash flow affects the company's financials. As a refresher on how much more efficient our M&A approach is compared with peers: starting in 2019, we've bought roughly 55,000 residential solar systems and contracts across a dozen distinct transactions. Per customer, our average acquisition cost comes to roughly $375. That stacks up well against last September, when the average cost we reported was $421 per customer. We anticipate stair-step growth as we target 90,000 customers and contracts by the close of 2024. Keep in mind, we never reveal or talk about how many deals are in negotiation right now, or what they involve, so no timing guidance is possible. Ahead of covering the capital strategy, I'd like to stress one financial headline. Aside from the legacy XL items still being finalized, Spruce Power generates positive cash flow; indeed, Spruce closed the most recent quarter again holding more than $200 million in cash, which includes $173 million that is completely unrestricted. And again, there's no debt at the corporate level; with cash that size, we ought to talk about how much should stay in reserve and how we plan to put any surplus to work. To start, cash liquidity serves as an excellent safety net, so through 2024 we intend to hold no less than $75 million in cash. Let me be clear: we aren't saying that from our quarter-end balance of $205 million, the plan is really to spend our way down to $75 million. Instead, we're pointing to a sensible threshold that still sets aside enough investment cash to hit our 90,000 customer goal. Later, in the financial section, we'll go through our cash run rate. I'd simply note that with the cash our core business produces, plus what we already hold, our capital allocation can follow an all-of-the-above strategy. That covers purchasing additional assets, reducing debt, finishing CapEx projects, putting money into our team, and giving some cash back to shareholders. Let me say more about that final point. Several days ago, our board gave the green light to a two-year common stock repurchase program worth up to $50 million of our common shares. For one, we think buying back shares is an effective method of returning cash to shareholders. This buyback doesn't obligate us to acquire a set quantity of stock, though returning capital to investors is what we prefer to use it for. Reason number two is nearer term; when we look at where our shares trade right now, we see an opportunity to create per-share value. At a steep discount to what we consider intrinsic worth, the market is willing to sell shares to us — or honestly to anyone. Given a sizable cash position, positive cash generation from our core operations, an excellent management team, and a distinctive business model within a fast-expanding sector, our desire is for this repurchase effort to signal clearly that, at today's share price, deploying capital this way ranks as a top priority. Now I'd like to offer a few remarks on the macro picture for residential solar and where we stand. Over the long haul, demand for home solar ought to remain robust, yet installers upstream and buyers confront difficulties. Among these, notably, is a pricier cost of capital. By contrast, Spruce remains mostly shielded from short-term swings in debt capital markets. Our non-recourse project loans carry appealing rates and the closest maturity is still several years away, plus we carry zero corporate debt.
Christian Fong
executiveEven when borrowing costs move, we have the ability to stay disciplined about how we price upcoming acquisitions so that we still hit our goal for return on equity investment, which is an IRR in the mid-teens. On top of that, we are noticing a meaningful change in how consumers make their financing choice when they decide on rooftop solar — they are gravitating toward lease and PPA products rather than loans. Our connections with installers throughout the United States give us this insight. Of course, that works in our favor, since systems owned by third parties make up our addressable market for acquisitions; we anticipate tailwinds for even more lease and PPA market penetration once there is clarity regarding the TPO market's capacity to capture additional ITC adders, as outlined in last year's IRA legislation. In the end, that ought to enhance how competitive leases and PPAs are. To put it plainly, we think Spruce Power compares favorably in today's capital and tax environments. We're enthusiastic about what we've accomplished as a public, pure-play investment in residential solar, and we're particularly happy with the significant growth from the Spruce Power 4 portfolio we acquired last quarter. Before I pass the call to Don for the financial discussion, I want to recognize that this will be his last earnings call with us as we move forward with the next phase of our post-merger management transition. Last week we announced that Sarah Wells will step into the CFO role on May 19th. With Deloitte having just come on as our independent auditor, now is the appropriate moment for this long-planned transition. Since 2018, Sarah has served as Spruce's Head of Sustainability and has worked by my side leading finance and accounting for Spruce Power and its affiliates. She is a smart, experienced, and driven member of the Spruce team who has been a leading force in Spruce's strong growth over the past years. Don, I want to recognize you for your vision and dedication over the past year as Spruce's CFO. You played an essential part in the business combination last fall and in helping Spruce Power transition to a position of greater strength as a public company. On behalf of the entire company, we thank you. I'll now turn the call over to you and Sarah to go through the financials for the first quarter.
Donald Klein
executiveAppreciate that, Christian. Ahead of getting into our first quarter results, I want to go over several items that had an effect on our financial reporting. During our prior quarterly update, we noted that the former Drivetrain and XL Grid businesses had been placed in discontinued operations. We disposed of the last legacy businesses during the first quarter, and while some cleanup items will show up in quarters ahead, we don't anticipate material expenses moving forward tied to discontinued operations. Certain expenses related to XL Fleet will appear in our continuing operating results — specifically legal expenses connected to the previously disclosed SEC inquiry and related shareholder lawsuits. We can't comment on when this matter will conclude or how it will turn out, but we do expect to incur additional moderate legal expenses. Regarding our Form 10-Q, we filed an extension while we complete the technical accounting for the March purchase of Spruce Power 4, though we don't expect any impact on what we're discussing today. With that said, let's turn to results. First quarter revenue, made up entirely of Spruce-related revenue, came in at $18.1 million, versus $18.1 million in the fourth quarter of 2022. As Christian noted, weather had an outsized effect on our West Coast assets and moderately impacted revenue in the quarter; higher than expected proceeds from renewable energy credit sales partially offset that. Keep in mind that the fourth and first quarters typically produce lower revenue because weather affects electrical production. First quarter OpEx, covering both SG&A and portfolio O&M, was $17.6 million, compared to $30.6 million last quarter. That sequential decline mostly reflects much lower integration costs tied to our acquisition by XL Fleet. Notably, SG&A expense during the quarter includes approximately $8 million of expenses attributable to the legacy XL Fleet business, specifically legal expenses associated with the previously disclosed SEC inquiry and shareholder lawsuits, plus compensation expenses for exiting XL Fleet personnel. If you exclude these expenses, core OpEx comes closer to $9.6 million, which gives a clear view of OpEx for a standalone Spruce Power. On a GAAP basis, net loss from continuing operations was $15 million, versus $27.7 million in the fourth quarter of 2022. Adjusted for certain items, including legal charges and the change in fair value of interest rate swaps, adjusted net loss was $7.7 million. Adjusted EBITDA totaled $4.7 million, compared to $3.5 million in the fourth quarter of 2022. As of March 31, 2023, we had cash equivalents and restricted cash of approximately $205 million; that compares to $240 million at the end of the fourth quarter of 2022. The sequential change in cash includes approximately $10 million for principal and interest payments and approximately $23 million of net cash paid for the acquisition of Spruce Power 4. The total principal balance of long term debt as of March 31 was $652 million. As a reminder, all of our debt is non-recourse and backed by our long term contracts with customers. In today’s market, the cost of our debt is quite favorable, with a weighted average of about 5.6%, and that figure takes in the credit facility we picked up when we bought the Spruce Power 4 portfolio. One point we think deserves emphasis: interest rate swaps cover 97% of all our variable rate debt. In fact, a large share of those swaps extend far into the future, largely through the 2030s, so that our portfolio’s interest hedges stretch considerably past the senior loan. Last, when it comes to valuing our long term solar contracts with customers, we have supplied metrics for both gross and net portfolio values, reflecting the present value of remaining net cash flows from our rooftop systems and contracts, discounted at 6%. The gross portfolio balance stood at $938 million as of March 31st. Once total loan balances are accounted for, net portfolio value came to $286 million, or $313 million when the swaps’ value is added in. Combined with cash on hand, that comes to $518 million in net value. I will now hand the call to Sarah Wells, who will cover the acquisition of the Spruce Power 4 portfolio.
Sarah Wells
executiveThanks, Don. I'm also very glad to be starting my next phase here at Spruce in the CFO role. Before we take questions, I want to talk more about how much of a difference the Spruce Power 4 acquisition makes. Right away, it strengthens the cash we generate. Those acquired assets are held outside our mezzanine facility, which was established several years back and today takes any excess cash remaining once senior debt service on our legacy portfolios is paid. Spruce Power 4 produces cash and was underwritten assuming standalone portfolio customer billings of $21 million along with portfolio EBITDA of $18 million. Since the deal closed late in March, our second quarter results will show the first complete quarter of contribution from Spruce Power 4. I want to flag a few accounting details related to this transaction. What makes up the portfolio is the pass through leasehold interests of roughly 22,500 residential solar contracts. Put differently, although we hold the right to 100% of customer payment streams across their contractual period, the underlying rooftop solar systems are not owned by Spruce. Under GAAP, accounting for these leasehold interests will route most customer payment streams into the cash flows from investing section of our consolidated statement of cash flows. No matter where accounting rules place the cash within the financial statements, we think the key point is the robust cash coming in that Spruce Power 4 adds to our core residential solar business. Along those lines, this is the way the Spruce team assesses our business internally, concentrating on cash coming in from our long term customer contracts, or what we call business cash inflows. Given how nuanced the accounting is for Spruce Power 4, we believe giving investors this framework is helpful so Spruce can make clear how it affects the underlying business performance of our core business, both the residential solar systems and the contracts connected to them. As we consider business cash inflows for Spruce across the coming 12 months, we target a range of between $110 million-$130 million. In the middle of the funnel sit cash flows that remain once OpEx and debt interest are covered, and there we expect an annual range of $35 million-$45 million. Once scheduled principal payments are made, we target a range of between $5 million-$15 million. Then, with modest amounts of discretionary CapEx related to enhancing customer experience and putting money into employee tools and trainings, we still end up with cash remaining; consistent with Christian's earlier remarks on capital allocation, we have three solid options for allocating this excess cash flow. One, it can return to our general cash position to support our M&A growth strategy. Two, we can put it toward the newly authorized share buyback. Three, we can reduce our debt. To wrap up, generating positive cash flow in the core business, even after CapEx, is a moment any growth company would be proud of; we look forward to carrying out our growth strategy and strengthening how much cash our portfolio can generate. Having said that, I'd now like to hand things back over to the operator so we can move into the Q&A portion. Operator, the floor is yours.
Tristan Richardson
executiveHello there, good afternoon. Given all the expansion we're observing in third-party owned, plus what installers have been saying, I'm just wondering about additional paths for growth at Spruce. In other words, could one possible route involve teaming up with an installer later on and serving as the originator of a flow-forward setup? Perhaps I'm just interested in, you know, the patterns you're noticing when it comes to third-party owned growth and, you know, the way that might open up further growth opportunities for Spruce?
Christian Fong
executiveAlright, this is Christian Fong, and Tristan Richardson is on the line. So here's the thing — the share of installations that flow into PPA leases keeps climbing, and you can see that reflected in what a number of our competitors already disclosed during this quarter. Over the long run, roughly 28% is the figure a few independent research firms have put out, and it's moving into the 30s, possibly even as high as 40%. A great deal is in the pipeline. That's a legitimate question you're raising. Keep in mind that Spruce Power began its life as a channel partner — that's the term for this model — where you simply team up with installers, hand them a PPA and lease agreement, and supply the capital behind it. Honestly, it's a pretty solid business; obviously Sunnova operates that way, Sunrun operates that way, and we operated that way too. Roughly 22,000 out of our 72,000 customers came in through that kind of flow partnership arrangement. Could we pull that off once more? Without a doubt. It's the sort of thing people sometimes refer to as real options, correct? It's essentially a real option just sitting there in the background. We know how to execute it; the documents are already in place. The only reason is that M&A let us expand so quickly. Could we ever reactivate it? Yes. Should we reactivate it? That brings us to what an acquired customer costs. Back in September we told you it ran about $421 per customer; now it's somewhere near $375 per customer. During the period when we ran that channel partnership, the expense was in fact significantly greater. You needed sales teams on payroll, plus relationship management and coordination with all those various installers. I won't claim we'd never pursue it. Obviously, the fact that something carries a very high margin doesn't mean you ignore other channels; as things stand, we're hitting our growth targets at a cost of acquisition that, judged by industry standards, is extremely competitive, and we'll continue on that path for now. So the answer is yes. To put it plainly, yes — we could.
Tristan Richardson
executiveAppreciate it. So, in what you wrote, you mention keeping a floor on cash. I mean, could you walk through a situation that could set off or bring about a case where you draw it all the way down to that floor? Would that only happen with some big opportunity? And, you know, what's your thinking on where cash stands right now compared with drawing it down to that minimum?
Christian Fong
executiveAbsolutely. Right now, we're describing it as all of the above. If we break down how the $75 million figure came about, it's because we were able to fully fund the maximum size of the share repurchase program we recently announced. We could also cover roughly $5 million in yearly discretionary CapEx, which is primarily tied to customer experience. Then, when you consider how much growth capital remains — going from 155 down to about two years' worth of discretionary CapEx — the drop from 155 to 75 comes out to $80 million. Alright. Let's look at that alongside what we just pulled off with the Spruce Power 4 acquisition, where we deployed net cash of $23 million and brought in 22,500 customers, with those contracts generating cash inflows. When we frame it that way, it's about $1,000, and that was an extremely efficient acquisition. I don't expect we'll replicate that every quarter; it leaves substantial dry powder to expand through customer acquisition, well past the 90,000 customer target we've set for 2024. This is one of those situations where we felt confident calling $75 million a minimum liquidity threshold, given where the economy stands, while still preserving plenty of dry powder for something transformative, should it come along.
Jordan Levy
analystGood afternoon, everyone. Sarah, congratulations on becoming CFO. You may have said before that you expect positive cash flow somewhat later in this year, or in quarters still to come. The Spruce Power 4 acquisition appears to be a major factor in that. Could you perhaps explain what it is regarding that deal that makes the positive free cash flow projection more attainable?
Sarah Wells
executiveHello, Jordan. Thanks very much. Spruce Power 4 generates quite robust cash flows for us, and it stands apart since, in contrast to our legacy assets, it falls outside our net facility. Those cash flows carry no encumbrance, so following our OpEx and debt interest, whatever remains goes to Spruce.
Jordan Levy
analystI really appreciate that. As a brief follow-up — and I believe I raised this on the previous earnings call — I'm simply wondering, Chris, about the landscape you're observing when it comes to transactions, plus whatever rivalry might be emerging now that leasing has grown more dominant?
Christian Fong
executiveRight. The bulk of what we close originates from three — I'd describe them as three categories of sources. First, there are utilities that are engaged, occasionally beyond their own service areas. That's a separate industry segment, yet their needed returns on capital, along with the cost pressures they face, are quite familiar within it. Second, you have financial investors who build up these assets. Third, you have the installers themselves — whether they're big and recognizable, or part of what remains, you know, an extremely fragmented sector. People everywhere across the country, possibly operating within their own nearby markets. Once more, we won't get into details about the quantity of bids we've submitted or the number of one-on-one talks we're conducting. All I'll say is that the response to each is affirmative, right now. Still, since these negotiations are happening live, I'd rather not jeopardize what could be in play; we remain committed to our mid-teens IRR objective. In our view, that's quite attainable. Since we're able to adjust how we price the equity we deploy, we worry far less about whatever the debt markets might be doing. You know, should debt decline by 50 basis points, sellers will likely just factor that in and still expect the same, you know. You have to divide the pie, as they say, whenever you're negotiating with independent buyers and sellers. Yes, we're observing things. We anticipate seeing them somewhat further ahead. Let me use this question as a chance to point out that a great many of the transactions we review involve seasoned deals. Instead of — somewhat similar to what Tristan just inquired about — could we team up with an installer? Sure, we could, and then we'd be able to get them lined up as they exit those installers' construction pipelines. Through buying portfolios that are seasoned, let's just say a portion of the early difficulties has passed. These portfolios are delivering very robust results; that's the reason our weather-adjusted portfolio ratio is capable of surpassing 100% by a sizable margin; it comes down to that seasoning and purchasing truly excellent assets. What that means is the present shift toward PPA leases, which is taking place owing to climbing interest rates, with solar loans being, well, just slightly less appealing, will supply a pipeline over the coming four-five years, as those various kinds of owners select when to exit.
Jordan Levy
analystThat's really helpful context. Thanks a lot.
Bronson Fleig
executiveThank you, operator, and thanks once more for being with us today, and for sticking with us. Should anything come up, feel free to reach out to me or to the members of our investor relations team. That wraps up today's call. Everyone is free to disconnect now.
Operator
operatorThis concludes today's conference. You may now disconnect.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Spruce Power Holding Corporation transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Spruce Power Holding Corporation earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Spruce Power Holding Corporation or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.