Spruce Power Holding Corporation (SPRU) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

March 14, 2024

New York Stock Exchange US Utilities Independent Power and Renewable Electricity Producers earnings 29 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Bronson Fleig

executive
#1

Thanks, everyone. Hello, and welcome to the conference call for Spruce Power, where we'll go over the fourth quarter and full year 2023 results. Joining me are Christian Fong, who serves as our Chief Executive Officer, and Sarah Wells, our Chief Financial Officer. During this afternoon's call, we'll make statements regarding the company's expectations, outlook, and predictions of the future, which count as forward-looking statements. Such forward-looking statements carry risk and uncertainties, a great many of which lie outside our control, and these could lead our actual results to differ materially from those expressed in, or implied by, these statements. We have no obligation to revise or update any forward-looking statements, except as may be required by law. Please see our disclosures about risk factors and forward-looking statements in today's earnings release, and other SEC filings. Our press release has been posted to the Investor Relations page of our website for reference. The non-GAAP financial measures discussed in this call are reconciled to the U.S. GAAP equivalent, and can be found in the press release that we issued this afternoon; with that, I'll turn the call over to our CEO. Christian, go ahead.

Christian Fong

executive
#2

Thank you, Bronson, and I'm glad everyone could join us today. Spruce's mission centers on being the foremost long-term proprietor and operator of distributed energy assets. Clean energy reaches around 80,000 homes through our work, which translates into real savings for those we serve and robust operating margins for our investors. Alongside our renewable power technology sits our servicing technology platform, which sustains lasting relationships with customers, and we've honed it so that satisfaction ratings from our customers regularly exceed 80%. That exceptional customer experience creates a gateway to promising organic growth prospects. In 2023, we grew our portfolio by nearly 50%, acquiring the cash flows associated with roughly 25,000 rooftop solar assets and contracts. We added these streams of recurring cash flow in a careful manner, closing 2 acquisitions that offered attractive equity returns above 20%. Just as importantly, we did this while still leaving plenty of cash on hand for growth down the road. If you exclude the cash we set aside for a handful of legal matters that Sarah will discuss, Spruce ended the year with $156 million in net cash. Turning to 2024, our plan is to stay very disciplined about acquisitions, taking on only portfolios that come with strong investment returns and produce an immediate lift to our free cash flow; our fixed cost platform ranks among the lowest in the industry, which provides flexibility and ought to let us generate considerable value over the coming year. How? To start, Spruce is broadening its programmatic alliances to reach the most capable installers nationwide. In situations where installers have to fix cash-flow problems by offloading assets — or exit the business altogether — Spruce is positioned to step in as the sector's most seasoned buyer of portfolios. Next, we now offer a servicing technology platform that stands alone in the marketplace. To the best of our knowledge, no competitor is even nearing our 80% customer satisfaction mark. Spruce Pro was introduced last November, and this January we rolled it out so that other owners of distributed solar portfolios could access that platform. We can't really discuss outcomes yet, though the initial response has been encouraging — both from the residential side we already serve and from pushing our servicing tech into solar for commercial and industrial customers. Next, starting in 2024, we're rolling out a campaign for early renewals aimed at boosting long-term hypothetical customer value and converting it into locked-in contract value. Before I get into the Q4 numbers, I'd like to say that I believe Spruce has never been in a better spot than it is now as we move forward into 2024; looking at 2024, our ability to project long-term cash flow is extraordinarily precise. We keep our cost structure in check so volatility stays low and operating free cash flow stays positive. And in 2024, our cash reserves are substantial. If any companies in our sector are facing challenges with liquidity, my message is simple: reach out to us. We will never chase expansion just for the sake of expanding—that discipline won't change—but we've got a strong track record when it comes to buying businesses, and our leadership is prepared to act decisively on something significant. Looking ahead to 2024, we'll keep advancing a product pipeline that has grown organically from what we already do and who we already serve. Whether that means taking Spruce Pro further into the B2B space or rolling out longer-term contracts for B2C customers, we're expecting substantial organic growth with attractive margins. Now, looking at Q4 and the full year 2023, my remarks will sit inside the framework of our three core pillars: an industry-leading customer experience, operational excellence, and growth achieved through disciplined capital allocation. Starting with customer experience. Roughly 80,000 households rely on Spruce to consume clean energy. Each day, we aim for an exceptional customer experience. That approach is sound business practice, and it opens new chances to unlock value throughout our platform. Our Q4 customer satisfaction score came in at 75%, while the full-year average was 74%, comfortably ahead of our 2023 target. Because these scores come from fresh customer interactions, our servicing teams cannot coast on prior results when pushing for higher marks. Looking at 2024, our goal for CSAT is 80%, and we've hit that mark already during this year. A major element of keeping customers happy is the field services initiative. When I spoke about this in the fall, I noted that New Jersey would be home to our inaugural in-market crew. Good news on that front: an operations team is now in place, and the local build-out has just gotten underway. We're eager to provide more updates as 2024 progresses, including whether we expand into other markets that have enough customer concentration to make a team profitable. Let me now discuss operational excellence as it relates to generating cash flow. In the fourth quarter, our performance ratio — that's the actual electricity generated compared with what the installed solar panels could theoretically produce at maximum — came in at 94%. For all of 2023, once adjusted for weather, the figure reached a robust 102%. Spruce generated $30.1 million in total cash inflows during Q4, which are sometimes called top of the funnel cash flows; PPA and lease payments, environmental commodity sales, and interest on invested cash make up the bulk of these inflows. One thing to keep in mind: proceeds from issuing debt are not counted by us as part of our ability to generate cash. Such an assumption would depend on periodic access to capital markets rather than on actual operations. Looking at 2024, we are reaffirming the cash flow projections we previously provided. Sarah is going to walk everyone through the fairly encouraging cash flow figures we expect for this year. And finally, turning to expansion and purchases: in 2023, we kept building on our solid track record, picking up the cash flows connected to about 25,000 rooftops. That worked out to growth of almost 50%, with an average underwritten IRR of 21%. The assets we brought in through the SEMTH and Tredegar transactions have now been folded into our current portfolio, and they're beating what we had underwritten. Even though Spruce didn't close any deal in Q4, our M&A group is busy evaluating opportunities. Concerns about liquidity across the residential solar industry are very much real. Given our strong balance sheet and our reputation as a repeat buyer, we have secured a first look at multiple opportunities in the secondary market. Beyond established assets, during the previous autumn we observed an actual-time migration of newly added systems toward solar leases and PPAs. From where we sit, the strongest installers are backed by sponsors possessing the working capital needed to continue construction, even though a number of them have contacted us regarding Spruce acting as a programmatic buyer of completed systems for its portfolio; therefore, I want to stress that our expansion isn't constrained by whether rooftop systems are available to purchase, since supply there stays abundant. Even so, the gap between bids and asks has grown wider. Those selling are unwilling to transact at broader levels, betting that private capital will approach them. By contrast, since we buy with leverage, we hold an unambiguous view of today's worth at returns that are more disciplined. We remain firm about what we require in returns, and that's precisely what we intend by remaining disciplined in the current market. Thus, for 2024, we are not staking a claim to any official growth objective measured by how many new customers or rooftop systems we add. Our attention is on free cash flow along with organic growth; and should portfolio pricing shift in our direction, we stand ready to purchase. I want to go deeper into one of our organic growth efforts.

Christian Fong

executive
#3

Throughout 2024, we have been building out an early renewal initiative that lets customers choose to lengthen their lease or PPA term ahead of the maturity date originally set out in the contract. This program benefits both sides. Customers gain the certainty of ongoing cost reductions relative to retail electricity prices, and those retail rates have climbed far more quickly than overall inflation across a number of our key markets — most notably California. For Spruce's shareholders, added net asset value comes as these contract extensions flow into our portfolio. Our actuarial expertise allows us to set the right price for this product. Starting in 2021, we worked through a substantial renewal cycle involving a group of early solar adopters whose contract terms ran just 10 or 15 years. That effort produced robust information about how consumers actually behave, which now informs how we build suitable incentive structures. Out of a group of roughly 500 customers whose contracts were expiring, slightly more than 50% selected a renewal after contract end or a system purchase plan, amounting to an average 35% reduction from the contract rate in effect at that time. Extensions averaged 7 years; this reflects hard data drawn from a statistically significant sample and time series. The investor presentation posted today on Spruce's Investor Relations website incorporates that real-world experience when determining our net portfolio value. Finally, I'd like to discuss how the capital markets are enabling our growth. For Spruce, both demand for and access to non-recourse project debt remain quite strong; as a result, we expect to move portfolio acquisitions toward greater use of non-recourse portfolio debt and reduced reliance on equity capital; this simple capital-light approach helps us maintain a high cash balance. How is this accomplished? Because our asset management and customer servicing teams have performed so well, our portfolios have beaten the underwriting assumptions made when they were acquired; that added value expands our borrowing capacity. One illustration of this outperformance is our Spruce Power 4 Portfolio, featured on Slide 18 of our investor presentation, where the current loan-to-value is 70%. Within this portfolio, more than 90% of contracts are tied to utility rates, most of them in California, where those rates have been climbing quickly. Rising cash flow within the portfolio lowers the risk of any upcoming refinancing of the non-recourse portfolio debt and also creates the chance to pull out the equity cash required for the following portfolio acquisition. This is Project Finance 101, in which asset and liability cash flows are closely aligned. Future interest rate swings are hedged on the debt, and every bit of that debt is non-recourse. A few closing thoughts before I turn things over to Sarah. Although plenty of broad worries exist around residential solar markets, we want to be completely unambiguous. To begin, Spruce has 0 liquidity concerns. Next, the move toward more leases and PPAs in originations generates enormous tailwinds for our business, since Spruce is the finest long-term servicer and owner of such assets. And third, ahead of us lie both organic growth and disciplined growth through acquisitions and partnerships. Our goal is to lead when it comes to the energy transition over the long haul. Having said that, let's turn to the figures alongside our CFO, Sarah Wells.

Sarah Wells

executive
#4

Thanks, Christian. To start, I want to cover a few administrative matters affecting how we report our finances — in particular, an update on the conclusion of legal matters tied to the legacy XL Fleet Corp. and what it did. As of the close of 2023, we recorded a net expected legal settlement accrual of roughly $17 million. The bulk of that accrual at year-end related to the securities class action in the Southern District of New York concerning XL Fleet's 2020 merger. Within that class action, Spruce paid out $15 million. Final approval is still required for that payment, and the court has scheduled a hearing on the matter in April. Now, turning to our fourth quarter results. Revenue for the fourth quarter came in at $15.7 million, a decline from $18.1 million during the same period a year earlier. That year-over-year drop stems from shifts in the weather. Core OpEx in the fourth quarter — which we define as SG&A plus portfolio O&M — totaled $17.9 million, versus $31.3 million a year earlier. If we break that apart, portfolio O&M expense for the fourth quarter rose to $5.5 million, up from $2.7 million in the comparable prior-year period. That rise is mostly attributable to the timing of routine O&M spending, since supply chain conditions and labor availability permitted us to complete the planned 2023 O&M. SG&A expenses fell sharply, landing at $12.5 million in the fourth quarter, compared with $28.6 million in the fourth quarter of 2022. The earlier period took an outsized hit from restructuring costs and legal fees connected to the legacy XL Fleet lawsuits. Finally, Spruce posted a GAAP net loss attributable to stockholders of $30.4 million in the fourth quarter. That said, management treats operating EBITDA as a key metric when assessing Spruce's operating performance. Our definition of operating EBITDA is adjusted EBITDA plus net proceeds from the SEMTH master lease investment, interest earned on cash investments, and proceeds from buyouts and prepayments. Let me walk through why we evaluate our business this way. First, GAAP earnings leave out cash flows we get from our Spruce Power 4 Portfolio. That portfolio is treated as an investment in a master lease, and the proceeds from it appear in the cash flow from investing activities section of our consolidated cash flow statement. To show how much this Spruce Power 4 Portfolio matters — we acquired it in March 2023 — partial year proceeds from that investment came to roughly $20 million in 2023. Next, the interest we earn on our cash investments is substantial; we regard the yield on our sizable invested cash balance as a meaningful source of cash flows, since we keep a disciplined approach to near-term M&A, which Christian described earlier, as satisfying our equity requirement is largely pre-funded through available debt capacity. To highlight the relevance once more, we earned $8 million of interest on investment-grade securities in 2023. Last, the cash inflows we get from buyout or prepayment of customer contracts represent a meaningful source of cash flows. For 2023, that figure came to about $7 million. With all of that in mind, I'll now bridge fourth quarter operating EBITDA. For the fourth quarter, adjusted EBITDA came in at $390,000. If we include the $6.4 million in net proceeds from the Spruce Power 4 Portfolio, that takes us to $6.8 million in total. Then, when we add $1.9 million of interest earned on cash investments plus $1.3 million of proceeds from buyouts and prepayments, operating EBITDA reached $9.9 million for Q4. Now let me briefly turn to where we stand on capital and liquidity. At December 2023, our cash and cash equivalents stood at $173 million. That's compared with $240 million in cash and cash equivalents as of December 31, 2022. The primary driver of the net change in cash is XL wind-down activities, which include the settlement payment to the SEC in October that we previously disclosed and cash usage for discontinued operations, along with our 2 acquisitions and share repurchase activity. Long-term debt had a total principal balance of $647 million as of December 31, 2023, carrying a blended interest rate of 5.7%, inclusive of the impact from hedge arrangements. As a reminder, there is no corporate-level debt at Spruce. Our debt is entirely project level debt, backed by our solar loan portfolios, and it is non-recourse to the company. At year-end, 97% of our debt profile was hedged, with mark-to-market on our swaps at positive $27 million. And lastly, Spruce's gross portfolio value — the present value of remaining net cash flows from customers at a 6% discount rate — stood at $784 million at year-end. As Christian mentioned, this reflects an update to our renewal assumptions. Then, after deducting non-recourse debt and adding back cash balances, our net portfolio value came to $311 million. If you exclude the $17 million of net cash settlements expected or reserved as of year-end, that gives us net portfolio value per share of over $16. Finally, let me cover Spruce's financial outlook for 2024. Spruce expects operating EBITDA — which, as I defined earlier, is adjusted EBITDA plus net cash flows from the Spruce Power 4 Portfolio, interest on cash invested, and proceeds from customer buyouts and prepayments — to range between $68 million and $86 million for 2024. Once we deduct project finance debt service and make some other adjustments for non-cash items, we expect adjusted free cash flow to range between $0 million and $5 million for 2024. You can find the reconciliation of these non-GAAP measures in our updated Investor Relations' presentation posted on our Investor Relations' website. That wraps up our prepared remarks. Operator, please open up the line for questions.

Henry Roberts

analyst
#5

This is Henry, sitting in for Jordan. First off, congratulations on getting Spruce Pro out the door. Taking a closer look at that offering, I realize it's still very new, but could you share how you expect that ramp to unfold as the year begins, plus any early reactions you've gotten to it?

Christian Fong

executive
#6

Spruce Pro arrived on the scene with considerably more traction than we had expected. That's the simplest way to describe it. As we examined this opportunity, we considered the complete expansion of our servicing technology platform. That happened — this was prior to our IPO. Over the past 4 or 5 years, we focused intensely on perfecting it, lifting those customer satisfaction figures to 80%. Then we told ourselves, if we're achieving that level in creating something best-in-class, why not simply provide it as a first offering. Another company could lease the platform, in a manner of speaking; and that accounts for one portion. The remaining portion involves SREC trading, which we refer to as the environmental commodities markets. Regarding both, we simply observed that there are parties beyond Spruce, beyond our own portfolio, who could essentially, quote, "lease the platform." The ECM or the SREC desk is a pretty familiar market, and other participants operate there too. So I'll simply say we're collaborating with significant asset owners, spanning C&I and residential, located within several key SREC markets, yet lacking the kind of trading desk that we possess. There are a handful of them. They tend to be institutional. We've already secured our first C&I contract, and asset registration is underway; so that unfolded according to plan. That's how I'd describe it. What caught us off guard was the distress occurring in residential solar, and how that would push outside parties toward attempting to lease a servicing platform. Our head of corporate development occasionally remarks that servicing is the thing keeping the riffraff out of this industry; it's genuinely difficult, and requires many years to establish. So on the inbound side, we maintain a reasonably deep pipeline of clients in discussions with us regarding contract signings. As I mentioned earlier, it's somewhat early. We only rolled this out in January, 8 weeks ago. We needed to take the action of reassigning staff internally to that initiative, since inbound interest proved so robust. So I'll leave it at that. It's somewhat premature, given there's no revenue, so discussing it isn't particularly enjoyable until cash flow begins flowing.

Henry Roberts

analyst
#7

Then here's another question for you, Christian. I realize you touched on programmatic partnerships not long ago. I'd like to explore that subject a bit further. What I'm wondering is whether the installers who've previously handled PPA and lease origination are newcomers to this market. And regarding certain channel PPA participants, are they expanding into new areas because of the liquidity pressures happening right now?

Christian Fong

executive
#8

Yes, during the most recent quarter, we actually referred to this as programmatic offtaker, and we've taken things one step further. Once more, by way of Spruce Pro — these being 2 key products we can roll out right away from our platform, thanks to what we do best. Let me explain that there are 2 methods by which we screen out whom we choose to work with. Actually, let me mention a third. At present, the question is which installers — from the broadest national tier down through the regional or local tier — which of them will even remain viable and keep operating; so I'll simply state that our partners are those possessing adequate liquidity and sponsorships to remain strong a year from now, 2 years from now, 3 years from now; we also seek sustainability in how they run their businesses. Beyond that, the candidates we consider are those capable of completing 1,000 systems or more annually. This isn't the outdated style of channel partnership, in which you simply announce to everybody that they may use your product and regardless of whether they handle 20, or 50, or 100, or 10,000, we accept all comers. What we want is volume — the super regionals, so to speak. The second point, and the other respect in which this differs somewhat from a conventional channel partnership, is that working capital is not something we provide. That serves as another filter, since the market's strongest participants not only can handle well beyond 1,000 annually — perhaps 5,000, 10,000 — but additionally have financing of their own arranged. Consequently, we don't have to move into supplying working capital; and to our thinking and based on what we've lived through, since we did channel partnerships in the past, prior to going public, that's the burden, that's the vulnerable spot in that kind of business model. We simply won't go there. So, addressing your second question about their origins — since, once more, they're handling 1,000 plus annually and are highly seasoned at doing PPAs and leases, varying by market — they're arriving from existing — I want to phrase this cautiously. Naming names isn't something I wish to do, but they are certainly arriving from other platforms that in the past supplied PPA and lease working capital style financing. And they're departing those platforms because they worry about whether those platforms will survive, and they're heading toward a position of strength. We have ample cash. Our cash flow is positive. We'll be around for the long haul. Essentially, there's a reshuffling happening, so to speak, at the level above us in the chain. And when those calls come in, we're glad to be on the receiving end of quite a few of them.

Joseph Osha

analyst
#9

Could you share a bit about how well you've been doing at selling more to the customers you already have, especially when it comes to storage? And I'm also curious whether, since we're seeing some momentum behind certain products that come with inverters built in, that might be something you'd consider offering too?

Christian Fong

executive
#10

Sure, I'll address the first question, and I'll hand off the second one. When it comes to components, we don't play favorites. That's the simplest way to say it. So honestly, I don't devote much time to examining which types of components are being installed. On the battery side, our strategy in the market is retrofit batteries, which sets it apart from a solar plus storage approach. Our installer peers have been reporting those attachment rates quite well. Regarding retrofit batteries, I've mentioned before a run rate of roughly $200,000 annually in sales, revenues, leases — I'll just lump them together. $200,000, as I've consistently said, simply isn't sufficient to build a model around; it's hardly enough to sustain a small team and keep serving our customers; and that figure stayed flat right up until California shifted to NEM 3.0, after which it dropped even lower. So although we've always maintained this isn't a bad business, we'll provide it whenever customers request it. As for NEM 3.0, I'll just come out and say it wiped out the economics and the incentives that supported a retrofit battery system. And even though we always aim to be there for our customers when they ask for a product they have a specific need for, I genuinely cannot fathom how it makes financial sense for them or for anyone.

Joseph Osha

analyst
#11

All right. And regarding what you told the person who asked before me, without identifying anyone, it sounds like you're starting to observe some bigger regional and super-regional players peeling away from a few of the very large partners because of certain widely reported liquidity worries. Is that what you're saying?

Christian Fong

executive
#12

Yes, that's right.

Bronson Fleig

executive
#13

Appreciate it, operator, and I want to thank all of you for being with us on today's call; we're at the point of wrapping things up. Should anything come to mind, feel free to contact me or members of our team, and we will follow up with you. Thanks so much.

Operator

operator
#14

This concludes today's call. You may now disconnect.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Spruce Power Holding Corporation transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Spruce Power Holding Corporation earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Spruce Power Holding Corporation or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.