Tata Steel Limited (500470) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

February 7, 2020

BSE Limited IN Materials Metals and Mining earnings 63 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Samita Shah

executive
#1

Good evening. And on behalf of Tata Steel, a very warm welcome to all of you who dialed in to listen to our call to discuss our results for the third quarter of FY '20. The management team is led by our CEO and MD, Mr. T.V. Narendran; and our ED and CFO, Mr. Koushik Chatterjee, and we are joined by several members of the team. Before I hand it over to them, I'd just like to make a couple of announcements. Firstly, like before, we will be taking call -- questions, not just on Tata Steel, but also on Tata Steel BSL and Tata Steel LP or Long Products. Secondly, we also have a link for retail investors who can key in their questions. And if they are not answered during the course of the call, we will also take those questions. Lastly, the entire discussion today will be governed by the safe harbor clause on the presentation, which will cover the entire discussion today. So with that, thank you, and I will hand it over to you, Naren.

Thachat Narendran

executive
#2

Thanks, Samita. Good evening, everyone. I'll start with the macroeconomic situation and a bit of a commentary on the industry. As you all know, the global economic growth slowed down further amidst the rise in the U.S.-China trade war tensions at that point in time. However, Chinese apparent steel consumption remains steady and despite higher production, the steel export stabilized below 5 million tonnes a month. In fact, this quarter, it was not China, but exporters from India, Russia and Turkey who set the prices and as some of these markets stabilized, we saw Asian steel spot prices improve from mid-November. In Europe, the overall slowdown was more pronounced due to seasonal weaknesses. Gross spot price for Hot Rolled Coil dropped sharply from quarter 2 peak as benefits of softness in raw material prices were offset by the steep decline in steel prices. And Hot Rolled Coil prices went below $470 as unfairly priced imports remained at an elevated level in Europe. During the quarter, Indian economy remained weak and domestic steel prices reached its lowest level in a long time in October 2019. However, steel prices have since started moving up from the middle of November and with inventory rationalization and increase in government spending and -- I think we look forward to some positive months ahead. Moving on to our performance. During the quarter, India, which is Tata Steel Standalone, Tata Steel BSL, Tata Steel Long Products put together, delivery showed a strong volume growth of 17% quarter-on-quarter to 4.85 million tonnes, and this was in a market which shrunk by 3%, which shows the strength of our business model. And to counter the market slowdown, we successfully ramped up our sales growth. Sales in Branded Products & Retail segment by 22% quarter-on-quarter and Industrial Products & Projects segment by a healthy 12% quarter-on-quarter. Also, despite the continued weakness in the automotive industry, we maintained our sales volume in Automotive and Special Products segment. Tata Steel Europe's profitability remained weak, mainly due to the weak market conditions, coupled with -- by the seasonal -- coupled with the seasonal slowdown. We have initiated a transformation plan, which we aim to make the business stronger and more sustainable with a focus on boosting productivity, reducing the bureaucracy and increasing the sales of higher-value steel products. Some comments on our key subsidiaries and large projects. Tata Steel BSL achieved its highest quarterly sales at 1.26 million tonnes and continues to improve its operating KPIs. We are now operating at a level of 5 million tonnes, which is what we have promised to within 24 months of acquisition. We've done it in time, if not slightly earlier. Tata Steel Long Products continues to focus on stabilizing of the newly acquired facilities and improving parameters. This quarter, we ramped up production at its captive iron ore mine, which has helped in improving the cost structure and turn EBITDA positive. It has also started commercial production at the pellet plant. Moving on to our Kalinganagar Phase 2 expansion. In light of the slowdown in the market, we -- and our intent to deleverage, we have prioritized the pellet plant and the cold rolling mill because the pellet plant helps us take -- bring down cost efficiencies -- further cost efficiencies in Kalinganagar and the cold rolling mill helps us add value to the product mix that -- and we maintain our target to commission the same in about a year from now. As involved earlier, we are working towards ensuring the continuity of our ferroalloys business. We have successfully won the Saruabil and Kamarda cold rolled mines, which will enable us to service our ferro chrome customers over the medium term. I will now hand over to Koushik to comment on our financial performance.

Koushik Chatterjee

executive
#3

Thanks, Naren, and good evening to all of you. I would like to share some highlights of our financial performance. Our consolidated revenue for the quarter were around INR 35,520 crores, and our consolidated reported EBITDA was INR 3,659 crores. These numbers do not include our Southeast Asian operations as they continue to be classified as assets held for sale. Tata Steel India, which includes Tata Steel Standalone, Tata Steel BSL and Tata Steel LP, recorded revenues of INR 21,299 crores, and the reported EBITDA for the quarter was INR 4,111 crores. Tata Steel Standalone revenue were INR 15,262 crores. While the operating revenue per tonne appears to have dropped by INR 5,486 per tonne over the second quarter of the financial year, the -- actually, the drop in steel revenue per tonne is about INR 3,500 per tonne. The rest of the drop is on account of lower nonsteel revenues, which is lower revenues from the ferroalloys business as the prices in ferroalloys have come down, tubes, power sales, et cetera, which has depressed the numerator when the denominator has expanded due to higher steel deliveries. Tata Steel Standalone EBITDA was INR 3,791 crores, which is an EBITDA margin of 24.8%. However, if you strip the FX impact on our intergroup preference shareholdings, the adjusted EBITDA was down to about INR 3,471 crores. This translates into an adjusted EBITDA per tonne of INR 10,124, a drop of about INR 1,077 crores (sic) [ INR 1,077 ] over the second quarter. Tata Steel BSL and Tata Steel LP continues to focus on operational improvements and better working capital management. Both have generated positive cash flow this quarter, which has been used to repay some part of their debt by an amount of around INR 800 crores. Significant cost improvement initiatives are underway in both facilities. And we continue to see better operating performance from both. Moving to Europe. The revenue stood at about GBP 1.49 billion in the third quarter of this financial year as compared to GBP 1.62 billion in the second quarter. The revenue declined due to a sharp drop in the European steel prices by almost about GBP 75 per tonne and average sales mix resulted in -- and a lower adverse sales mix resulted in a loss of about GBP 108 million at the EBITDA level. Year-to-date, the impact on the market on 9 months has been almost about GBP 500 million. As mentioned earlier, we are carrying out the transformation program to make our European operations more profitable and self-sufficient as far as cash flows are concerned. Tata Steel's employee costs have come down in Europe by around GBP 32 million on a quarter-on-quarter basis, with reduction in both payroll and temporary labor. This quarter, we have spent about INR 2,777 crores on capital expenditure, which takes the year-to-date number to INR 7,762 crores for the 9-month period. During the quarter, we have spent around INR 1,367 crores in India, which includes about INR 935 crores expenditure in Kalinganagar. As you will remember, in April 2009, we had guided towards an FX -- towards a CapEx of about INR 8,000 crores for the financial year FY '20 and an additional spend of around GBP 300 million in Tata Steel Europe. During the second quarter results call, we have revised our CapEx guidance to around INR 8,300 crores across all entities. And some of the CapEx is really committed in TSE. The actual spend has been a bit higher, and we're looking at the year-end to be more around INR 9,000 crores. But we are also looking at the capital allocation very sharply for next year. I want to spend some time walking you through our cash flows. We generated about INR 3,659 crores from the operations in EBITDA and INR 6,355 crores from release of working capital. This has been very significant during this quarter. Tata Steel India has reduced by about INR 2,100 crores. TSE and others have reduced their working capital and released cash by about INR 4,900 crores. So the key outflow in the quarter was about INR 2,777 crores on CapEx, INR 1,356 crores on interest. Charge to P&L was about INR 1,931 crores. Cash outflow was more around INR 1,356 crores and INR 500 crores on taxes. The net cash generated during the quarter was around INR 4,261 crores after adjusting for INR 1,142 crores on FX impacting -- FX impact, it's a swing on fair valuation in Tata Steel Holding and Tata Steel Global Holdings. We have also reduced our borrowing by about INR 3,368 crores. However, the leases increased the overall leverage by about INR 312 crores and an adverse FX-translated impact of INR 1,373 crores. As a result, our net debt reduced by about INR 2,324 crores to INR 104,628 crores. I would like to mention here that post December, we have further repaid about $500 million of the 2020 bonds, which will further reduce our gross debt by approximately about INR 3,500 crores. Our liquidity remains robust at INR 14,027 crores, comprising of cash and cash equivalents of INR 5,239 crores and undrawn bank lines of INR 8,788 crores. Earlier this month, we also refinanced the external debt of Tata Steel Europe by raising about EUR 1.75 billion. This has been done at more favorable terms and prices, and it also extends our overall maturity profile. Deleveraging the consolidated balance sheet remains an enterprise strategy and priority, and we will continue to plan and act in that direction, even in these challenging times. With this, I will end my comments. And open the floor for questions.

Operator

operator
#4

[Operator Instructions] The first question is from the line of Amit Dixit from Edelweiss.

Amit Dixit

analyst
#5

My first question is on domestic demand. So while like Q3, you have shared that various demand segments moved down. So is it possible to share the corresponding numbers that you are seeing in Q4? And also whether the demand is more due to restocking? Or do you see some real demand also inching up?

Thachat Narendran

executive
#6

Sorry, I think I was giving you a story when I was on mute. Anyway, let me start again. So basically, if you look at Q4 and starting from Q3, we've seen some positive movement in some segments. So let me break it up for you. So one is, if I look at construction, and if I split construction into infrastructure, commercial, residential and industrial, we are seeing positive activity in industrial, which basically is for warehousing, supply chain investments. We're seeing positive activity in commercial because there's a lot of private equity investment coming in there. Residential is not so great, but affordable housing is picking up. And infrastructure, again, we haven't seen much money coming in. But given the government's focus on it, we expect things to pick up. If I look at automotive, things are still quite weak. Hopefully, things will get better quarter-on-quarter, but still not enough to offset the reduction that we've seen in the past. Some other areas where we're seeing positive activity are railways, where the government is spending. Oil and gas pipelines, where again, the government is -- I mean, there are projects. Also, water conveyance is still -- so there are subsegments where there is positive activity. Appliances has been reasonably strong as well. So basically there is restocking, which had happened in November and December when the steel prices went up, but there are also areas where we're seeing demand growth.

Amit Dixit

analyst
#7

Okay. Great. The second question is on KPO expansion. So while pellet and CRC are coming up, is there any thought to maybe delay the Phase 2 expansion because the leverage still remains quite high?

Thachat Narendran

executive
#8

Yes. So like we said, we are prioritizing these 2. And the other work, we will phase it out depending on how the market conditions are. If the market improves rapidly next year, then we will be in a more comfortable position. So for now, the focus for next year is on the pellet plant and the cold rolling mill. Work is going on at a slower pace in all the other areas, but it's not that work has completely stopped. But we will take that call depending on how the market plays out over the next few months.

Operator

operator
#9

The next question is from the line of Indrajit Agarwal from Goldman Sachs.

Indrajit Agarwal

analyst
#10

Two questions from my side. First on Europe. Can you shed some more light what exactly is the trajectory that you're looking at in terms of profitability because when you look at your closest peer in that region, they have reported kind of stable profitability quarter-over-quarter. So what exactly can we do better? And what kind of trajectory you are looking at going forward?

Thachat Narendran

executive
#11

Sure. So Indrajit, we've had, obviously, a very challenging quarter. I think the spreads and the market conditions continue to be weak. And we have launched a transformation program a few months back, which has got us some benefits, but not enough to offset the deterioration in market conditions. So while we do expect Q4 to be better than Q3, I must also guide you that in this year, we will -- just like in India, the auto contracts and long-term contracts are renegotiated and takes effect from October, in Europe, it takes effect from January. So to that extent, we will see a bit of squeezing further of our spreads, but we expect to more than make up for it by cost takeout and slightly better volumes in Q4 because Q4 seasonally is a better quarter than Q3. The transformation program is pretty deep program, which we are driving. I know we've done many of these in the past. But this is another one which is focused both on Netherlands as well as U.K. I think in the past, we've been more focused on U.K. This time, we are focused on the U.K. certainly, but also on Netherlands, where the operating performance has slipped a bit over the last couple of years. So I think the focus of the management team there, Henrik and Sandip, is to again drive the transformation program. Our stated ambition is to be cash positive in Europe, and that's what we are focusing on. And I hope that in the next 6 to 12 months, we will start seeing some of the results. We've also released a fair amount of working capital there. We are operating at a much more efficient level now. So there's a lot of work to do. Some of it has been done. Some of it is visible, may not be visible in the numbers, but it's kind of starting to get visible to us at an operating level. There is also operational stability far more in the last 2, 3 months than we had before. So that's as far as the guidance on Europe is concerned.

Indrajit Agarwal

analyst
#12

Is there an adverse carbon credit impact in the European numbers? Or that is...

Thachat Narendran

executive
#13

Compared to the previous year, yes. Because last year, which is the last financial year, we had a positive impact. This year and next year, we will have a negative impact.

Indrajit Agarwal

analyst
#14

My second question is on the India business. Can you highlight what kind of price increases we have taken so far? So NSR at the spot, how much is it higher than the average of December quarter?

Thachat Narendran

executive
#15

Average of?

Indrajit Agarwal

analyst
#16

December quarter, third quarter.

Thachat Narendran

executive
#17

Yes. So we expect this quarter on an average to be about INR 3,000 higher than last quarter average.

Operator

operator
#18

[Operator Instructions] The next question is from the line of Pinakin Parekh from JPMorgan.

Pinakin Parekh

analyst
#19

My first question, again, is on Europe. I mean, this is one of the largest ever EBITDA losses reported in recent history. When the thyssen JV was called off, there was a commitment by the company in terms of ability to deliver a positive free cash flow. Now that obviously does not look like happening anytime soon. In terms of the transformation program, can we get more granular clarity and guidance as to, over the next 2 to 3 quarters on an absolute basis, what kind of savings or a positive uplift to EBITDA can we see?

Thachat Narendran

executive
#20

Yes. So Pinakin, I think one point we must keep in mind is the average spread in the last financial year was EUR 270, EUR 280. And this year so far is this EUR 185. If you just do the math on that, that EUR 100 into 10 million tonnes or itself will give you what we've lost out purely in terms of externalities, in terms of the spread squeeze. So anything that we've done is obviously not visible because whatever has happened is offset that. And when we say, we are chasing cash positive, I don't think we realize that there would be such a big drop in spreads. Because normally, long-term spreads are in the EUR 220 to EUR 240. So this is pretty much one of the lowest spreads that we have ourselves seen. Obviously, we expect next year the spreads to be slightly better, and that will help us. But we are not hoping or expecting it will go anywhere near the EUR 270, EUR 280 that we've seen in the year before. It will be somewhere in between EUR 180 and EUR 270, right? So that is one, maybe in the early 200s rather than anywhere else. The second part is the transformation plan has multiple streams, including workforce reduction, which has been talked about in -- it's there in the public space. Then there is the work that we're doing on the procurement side, there is work that we're doing on the operations side. And I would say there are 5 work streams, each of them are in the EUR 100 million to EUR 150 million range that we are working on. I must tell you that we have, since the beginning of the year, reduced our workforce by 800 already. So some of it is happening. There are obviously some difficult discussions going on as well because it's never easy to reduce the workforce, and we've done a lot of that in the past as well. So I think the -- and we've also pruned on the CapEx at least in the last 6 months. Most of the CapEx that you see in Europe was what was done in the early part of the year. So when we look at driving the business as cash positive, it is obviously also about optimizing between CapEx, working capital and Europe and seeing that the EBITDA can cover that. So obviously, we have not been able to deliver on that this year. But if the transformation plan, the way we see it, if it progresses as it has progressed so far and continues to progress this year for the next 12 months and the spreads come to around EUR 220-odd levels next year, then I think we will be cash positive for next year.

Pinakin Parekh

analyst
#21

Sure. My second question is on Tata Bhushan Steel. The performance -- operating performance has steadily deteriorated over the last 4 to 5 quarters. Now we understand that there is a steel pricing environment which is at play. But the difference between the company's profitability and other nonintegrated steel companies' profitability has widened. So are there any issues in terms of operating performance which has led to such a sharp drop in terms of profitability?

Thachat Narendran

executive
#22

So if you look at it from an operating performance point of view, the production volumes are now, as you can see from the numbers, are at 5 million levels, pretty much at 5 million level. In fact, December, I think we produced 410,00 or 420,000 right? So what -- so one of the targets was to take it from 3 million to 5 million in 24 months. I think that has happened. The second is to see the iron ore supply for Bhushan that has, now for the last 2 months or so, we have not had to buy any iron ore from the market. Of course, the benefits is not -- are not visible in Bhushan because that benefit accrues to Tata Steel. Third is, from a cost point of view, even during the year, we've taken out about INR 6,000 per tonne of cost. Again, the net realization drop has been to the tune of about INR 10,000. So again, the cost takeout is not so visible. Fourth is, Bhushan, TSBSL has also had to bear the brunt of exports because the export percentage has gone up significantly over the last few months as the market slowed down. And the impact was felt a bit more there. So -- but your point about the difference between the other nonintegrated players and Bhushan, I think it is true of last quarter. But if you look at the earlier quarters, I think we are about INR 1,000 behind the peers who are not integrated as far as the EBITDA per tonne is concerned. And that's, I think -- the aim is obviously to make that up, and I think we are confident we can make that up.

Pinakin Parekh

analyst
#23

And just to follow-up, sir, that recently Orissa iron ore auctions have taken place at a very high premium. Now are there any implications for the Tata Bhushan and the Tata Usha Martin assets that do -- will they need to buy iron ore, will that cost lower? Or that is -- this is not an issue for the group at an India level?

Thachat Narendran

executive
#24

At the India level, it's not an issue because between the Usha Martin iron ore mine which we've got when we acquired the company, and the Tata Steel assets, we have enough to cover our needs for Kalinganagar Phase 1, Phase 2 as well as Bhushan and TSL -- the Usha Martin assets as well as Jamshedpur. So we should not get affected by that.

Operator

operator
#25

The next question is from the line of Rahul Jain from Systematix. There seems to be no response from the line of Mr. Rahul Jain. We'll move to the next question. The next question is from the line of Ritesh Shah from Investec Capital.

Ritesh Shah

analyst
#26

I wanted to understand on the balance sheet deleveraging target that what we have laid at the start of the year, where we are and specifically on Southeast Asia sales, which is expected by March, where we are?

Koushik Chatterjee

executive
#27

So Ritesh, when we started the year, we said that on the back of last year's second half, we had repaid about INR 18,000 crore, and we said we will continue to repay about $1 billion per annum. And that continues to be the target from, as I mentioned, in my enterprise level. Obviously, this year, we've been deeply impacted by the market movements on internal cash flows and internal generations. We started back from a peak of INR 1,11,000 crores in September post the acquisition of Usha Martin and the changes in the lease accounting, which is the 2 big impacts that moved from the March to September. And since then, we've started looking at tightening up the cash flows through working capital release, through reduction in CapEx to the extent possible and trying to repay as much debt as we can. In this quarter, we've repaid gross debt of about INR 3,500 crores. The impact that you see in balance sheet will be because it is after the translation in changes of about INR 1,300 crores. So what you see is about INR 2,300-odd crores number. We continue to look at what opportunities we can develop to repay further. It may not hit the full $1 billion number. But in January end, we have also repaid another $500 million of our ABJA bonds 2020. And we are seeing what else we can do till March of 2020. As I said, that given the underlying generation issues, it is the -- these surpluses are not coming up from the operating cash flows, but through working capital and reduction of spend. We are looking at alternate options. And as in the end of March, you will see some more movements hopefully. But continuing on a multiyear theme, I think I can say that as an organization, we will be focused on $1 billion of repayment every year. We need Europe to be self-sufficient in cash and cash flows, and that's the effort that is being pursued there through the transformation program. All efforts are on cash related savings or cost takeouts. And it will have an impact, we believe, in subsequent quarters. And also in India, as Naren highlighted in his commentary that our focus on CapEx is on the Kalinganagar, very specific facilities and not the entire volume expansion at this point of time. We would certainly go back and calibrate that once we are in -- the market conditions are more stable. And at this point, there is a very sharp look at the capital allocation for CapEx along with working capital. And the efforts that I think Pinakin asked the question about the cost -- about the performance of Bhushan. I think Bhushan and Tata Steel Long Products, given the focus on cost reduction, will have the effect on internal cash flow generation going forward once the market recovers a little bit. At mid-cycle level, I think we would be better placed. But we will continue to look at deleveraging at all entities, so that the gross deleveraging is about $1 billion. That goal, we are not changing. We might as well -- we might be lower than that this year, but that stands. In the second part, on the Southeast Asia, we are talking to multiple parties. That's why we continue to classify it as assets held for sale. As and when we get to a more final position, we will be making appropriate disclosures.

Ritesh Shah

analyst
#28

Sir, looking into the deleveraging targets into next fiscal, how should one look at the potential tax gains on back of Bhushan merger? I'm not sure of the timing over here. And secondly, how should one look at the rights issue. I think the second tranche is still pending. If you could some -- provide some color over there?

Koushik Chatterjee

executive
#29

So I think when I say deleveraging of $1 billion, I'm not taking either into account at this point of time. We're only focusing on operating level cash flows to be used for delevering. The whole merger process is regulatory driven. And I can't comment on that at this point. I can only say that it is certainly not in March 2020. As far as the rights issue is concerned, it has a certain trigger, in the sense that it is based on a certain market price of Tata Steel. Since we are away from it at this point of time, we've not -- the Board of the company has not considered to exercise its option to call for those rights. So I would say, more operationally, we are focused on the deleveraging, not taking these 2 into account. If these happen, it will have a different implication.

Ritesh Shah

analyst
#30

Sir, possible for you to classify the cash flow impact, the benefit which will be there on back of the accumulated losses or the Bhushan merger? I'm just trying to understand the cash flow. If at all this event had to materialize, what will be the cash flow benefit that will come to us?

Koushik Chatterjee

executive
#31

No, I wouldn't like to do that because it's based on how much of underlying profits would be there on the combined entity and that's how we'll have to calculate that. So I would suggest that you don't model that at this point of time and take it when it actually happens.

Operator

operator
#32

The next question is from the line of Sumangal Nevatia from Kotak Securities.

Sumangal Nevatia

analyst
#33

Sir, first question is, your strategy over the next 2 to 3 years. I mean, Kalinganagar Phase 2 looks to be coming only end of FY '23 or even FY '24 now. So next 3 years, assuming market still continues to grow at 5%, 6%, clearly we'll be losing market share as we won't have steel volumes to sell. So one is, if you can share your strategy to offset this?

Thachat Narendran

executive
#34

Yes. So the full benefit of Bhushan running at full capacity will be felt next year because it was only towards the end of this year that we started operating at close to 5 million run rate. So you'll get additional volume from there. You will get additional volume from Tata Steel Long Products, which is the Usha Martin steel business. We also have the option to reduce our exports because we've done significant exports this year. And so we don't need to do that. We can always bring that down. And if the markets are strong next year and prices are good, we can always pull back on Kalinganagar because it's not that the work had not started. I think a lot of the work has been done. We have just rolled it down, so we can always accelerate that. So these are the levers in our hand. And we'll take a call depending on how things play out over the next few months.

Sumangal Nevatia

analyst
#35

Understand. So by the end of this year, how much CapEx we would have spent on KPO 2.

Koushik Chatterjee

executive
#36

Total spend on KPO is about -- roughly about INR 1,500 crores...

Thachat Narendran

executive
#37

For this year.

Koushik Chatterjee

executive
#38

For this year.

Sumangal Nevatia

analyst
#39

So CWIP of KPO 2 will be...

Koushik Chatterjee

executive
#40

No, it will be a little higher because if you include last year's spend also, last year, we had spent roughly about -- total will be about INR 3,500 crores on KPO Phase 2.

Sumangal Nevatia

analyst
#41

Understand. Okay. Sir, second question, with respect to Europe, now assuming for next 1, 2 years, the spreads remain around EUR 200, EUR 225, what sort of cash burn should we model in FY '21, '22?

Koushik Chatterjee

executive
#42

So as Naren mentioned earlier, that at about EUR 220 spread plus, the target impact on the transformation, we should move towards a cash-neutral position by the end of 2021. That's our target for which a couple of things have to happen. One is, the CapEx will have to get recalibrated down from the current year. Second, the working capital release have to sustain irrespective of increase in spread or increase in prices. And third is the operating part of the transformation program has to deliver. This year, to be fair to Tata Steel Europe, we did have transformation benefits of almost 300 to 400 -- GBP 380 million, of which there are repetitive ones, which is almost about 200 -- GBP 170 million, GBP 180 million, which will continue in subsequent years, and there were some tactical positioning, which will not continue in next year. Next year, what we will have is replacement of these tactical by more structural benefits. And if we do have that delivered, which is -- and the team and us are very bullish about that we will be able to get through there, then along with CapEx and working capital, we should be able to reach the cash neutrality from a free cash flow perspective.

Sumangal Nevatia

analyst
#43

Understand. So if I understand correctly, FY '22 should be -- I mean, we should benefit from all these and FY '21 could most likely be a transitional year unless and until the spreads expand dramatically?

Koushik Chatterjee

executive
#44

No, we are saying FY '21 to be that period. So the all of -- these are actions which have already started and will continue over the next, if I take today as February, then over the next 13 months, and we should get to that position. Our assumption on the spreading expansion is therefore very modest, if you compare to EUR 270, et cetera, which existed 12 months back. So on those assumptions, we feel that TSE can be cash neutral for themselves.

Sumangal Nevatia

analyst
#45

Understand. Sir, last question is with respect to the ongoing auctions. I mean, in terms of reserves, major -- largely the operating mines are -- the auctions have kind of completed, and we've not had any success yet. So if you could just share, I mean, what is our thought process? And do we think that the current clearing price is quite irrational?

Thachat Narendran

executive
#46

Obviously, whoever bids those prices have some logic for it. But we certainly did not want to bid at those levels. I think that's very clear. We -- where we sense there is value, we bid aggressively, which is the chrome ore auctions. I think iron ore -- we obviously participated, but did not want to go to the levels at which it has gone. So we'll wait and see, and this is not the end of the iron ore auctions. There will be many more, and we will wait and see. We will be picky on what we want to chase and what we want, we've been certainly been aggressive before.

Sumangal Nevatia

analyst
#47

Understand. Just to confirm, Bhushan -- for Bhushan, we do not require any external purchase from next year onwards?

Thachat Narendran

executive
#48

Hopefully not, we will minimize it. Obviously, like for the last few months, we've not had to buy anything, at least since September -- I mean, since October, I think we haven't had to buy anything. We will maybe buy some small volumes here and there, but nothing very material. It will also depend -- see, oftentimes, the problem is not the iron ore. The problem is the logistics. So getting the material on time because Eastern region is a bit challenged as far as movement of material is concerned. And so sometimes those are the bottlenecks. So the intent is not to buy anything, but I would budget 0.5 million tonnes to 1 million tonnes between the multiple units. Because sometimes even in Kalinganagar, we buy small volumes locally because it's better when the market prices are low and -- because there are iron ore mines very close to Kalinganagar as well. So we'll take that call. But we obviously will minimize as much as possible.

Operator

operator
#49

[Operator Instructions] The next question is from the line of Ashwani Kumar from Nippon Indian Mutual Fund.

Ashwani Kumar

analyst
#50

My question was that, is there a delay in, let's say, likely commissioning of the expansion in Kalinganagar by any chance? This is reflected?

Thachat Narendran

executive
#51

Yes, Ashwani, basically, what we said is we will focus on the cold rolling mill and pellet plant, both of which we are targeting to commission in the next financial year. All the other facilities for now will be looked at the year after, but we will take that call. If markets suddenly improve and cash flows improve very significantly, we can always try to accelerate that.

Ashwani Kumar

analyst
#52

Because sir, this slowdown in India is pretty old. Basically, this started somewhere in '18 and -- middle of '18, that's your August, September '18. And now if the initiatives of the government are to improve infrastructure or put more money in manufacturing in due course of time, I was thinking that you should have -- you should actually advance the whole thing because the kind of steel intensive demand opportunities which could come the way of Tata Steel and with its distributions, you have any thoughts on this, sir? At least on the volume side? We are not talking price?

Thachat Narendran

executive
#53

Sure. No, I think we -- we are trying to drive a balance between our objective to deleverage and growth. So we just want to get the timing right. That's all. But directionally, what you're saying is right. If even a fraction of the $1 trillion that is supposed to be spent on infrastructure gets spent, I think it's good for the steel industry because it is -- infrastructure is steel intensive. We are already seeing the benefits in many of our businesses. If you look at airports, for instance, we are a big supplier. Tata Structura is a big supplier of structural tubes for the airports. We benefit from that. We benefit again from the gas network, which is being built, pipeline network for gas. Between Tata Steel, Tata Steel BSL, et cetera, we are one of the biggest manufacturers of pipes in the country. So we are certainly well positioned. What else, we are also very big in the wires business, stranded DC wires and so on and so forth. So we have multiple products for the infrastructure space. And hence, we think we are well positioned. So we will ramp up in tune with the needs of the market. And like I said, we have the lever -- actually, we also have the lever of reducing exports. And that's a couple of million tonnes in hand. So if the domestic market really picks up, we can -- and that itself is -- the overall volume may be the same, but the -- from a bottom line point of view, it gives us a big impact.

Operator

operator
#54

The next question is from the line of Raashi Chopra from Citigroup.

Raashi Chopra

analyst
#55

I wanted to check on Europe. Just doing a simple math, if I take the revenues and divide it by the volumes, it appears that some of the EBITDA decline -- or EBITDA per tonne decline has come through from the revenues, but there's something in the costs as well. So how do we look at that at the moment or on a spot basis? That's one. Second is on the working capital release, is the bulk of it coming from inventory unwind. Another question is, you mentioned that the realizations for India should be higher on an average by INR 3,000. Does that -- do you anticipate any sort of price correction in the upcoming months because of the whole Wuhan situation?

Thachat Narendran

executive
#56

Yes. So first, are you talking of cost of Q3 versus Q2 in Europe?

Raashi Chopra

analyst
#57

Yes.

Thachat Narendran

executive
#58

Okay. So what has happened there is in sterling -- in pound sterling terms, it has come down. But because of the appreciation of the pound against the rupee, in rupee terms, it is not visible. So because Europe -- this was one of the things that we had looked at in detail earlier because the costs have been taken out and where did it go. So it's more kind of, I mean, exchange issue. But otherwise, at the actual level, the costs have come down. The revenues, as you rightly said, have certainly come down. Working capital release is largely from inventory, where we have brought down -- typically, Tata Steel Europe inventories used to be about 2 million tonnes and now we are well below 2 million tonnes. So that is where the working capital release will largely come from. And the realizations, yes, INR 3,000 is what I guided. As of now, the coronavirus impact is being seen in Southeast Asia. I think, it works both ways. While everyone is a bit concerned because economic activity in China may slow down a bit, but the flip side is also that material is not moving so easily. So even -- so what is happening is steel plants who have produce material are also not able to ship it out to wherever they want to. So it's not that we've seen a flood of exports into the world markets. So -- and in India, I don't think we've seen any impact as yet, though India has been driven more by the local positive sentiment which is emerging. So I -- that's why I said INR 3,000 and not more. Because originally we thought there's an opportunity for further increases, but we have now said INR 3,000 just to factor some of this.

Operator

operator
#59

The next question is from the line of Rajesh Lachhani from HSBC.

Rajesh Lachhani

analyst
#60

Sir, 2 questions from my side. The number one is, on working capital release, so clearly, we have been able to deleverage this quarter due to the working capital release. I wanted to understand the scope of -- quantum of release in the next quarter. So that would be my question number one. My question number two is, with regards to auto renegotiations in Europe and India. So in India, we are understanding that the renegotiated price are at INR 6,000 lower than the prices prevailing previously. Is that correct? That is number one. And in Europe, what is the quantum of reduction in renegotiated prices for auto? And I assume we are selling 30% of our output in Europe to auto sector.

Thachat Narendran

executive
#61

Yes. So I'll answer the second one, and Koushik will answer the first one on working capital. On the auto renegotiation India has done at INR 6,000, as you rightly said. And Europe also, we expect it to be something in the similar line, yes. And -- but Europe contracts are from 1st of January. So that's where the impact will be seen. That's why we have said that the spreads this quarter may be lower than what it was last quarter, the spreads which are relevant to us. But we are expecting to more than offset that by the cost takeouts. But Europe, I think it's -- 30% is -- 30%, 35% is what the percentage of contracts we won, auto and packaging also, which are the 2 long-term contracts.

Koushik Chatterjee

executive
#62

So on the working capital, I think, for the fourth quarter, we are looking at somewhere around INR 1,500 crores additional. And depending on actually the prices. But I think we are well on our way across to look at about another INR 1,500-odd crores, it could be plus-minus a few hundred crores.

Rajesh Lachhani

analyst
#63

Understood. And sir, just on auto renegotiate, the contracts are for 1 year or 6 months?

Thachat Narendran

executive
#64

In India, it's 6 months. In Europe, it's 1 year.

Operator

operator
#65

The next question is from the line of Abhijit Mitra from ICICI Securities.

Abhijit Mitra

analyst
#66

Before I ask the question, it's really commendable to see INR 2,300 crores of deleveraging in what has been a tough quarter and it's equally refreshing to see management stance of taking a step back on expansion and focusing on deleveraging. So if you can just lay out the volume road map over the next 2 years as well as -- as far as the Standalone entity is concerned or as the India entity is concerned. And also, the CapEx road map that you would ideally like to have in the Indian entity over the next 2 years?

Thachat Narendran

executive
#67

Yes. So as far as the volume is concerned, for next year, again -- this year, we had guided 1 million. I think we are slightly more than that compared to the previous year. And next year will be anything from 0.5 million to 1 million, in that range. We'll come back with a more precise guidance in April. This was in terms of absolute volume growth. And then we have, like I said, if the domestic market really picks up, we have the option to divert exports to domestic. So these are the levers in our hand. In terms of -- in an ideal world, the India CapEx would have been about INR 8,000 crores a year.

Koushik Chatterjee

executive
#68

At the time of the -- at the peak level of the expansion.

Thachat Narendran

executive
#69

Growth, correct.

Koushik Chatterjee

executive
#70

But we have -- see, just now, we are working up for the next year and 1.5 years. But at this point of time, we had targeted about INR 4,500 crores, INR 5,000 crores all taken together for India business. We are looking at prioritizing on the pellet plant and the cold rolling mill in Kalinganagar. So that will take up a bulk of the capital allocation. And then it will be more down to the critical sustenance category one to CapEx, which is essentially environment, safety, critical sustenance improvement because we also have small, but multiple projects on -- which has faster paybacks and small allocations. So we create corpuses around those. So it is clearly a very sharp look at the capital allocation on what is essential and not at least for 2021. And based on how the market performs and we achieve our targets on the balance sheet side, we will be looking at pacing the Kalinganagar expansion accordingly.

Abhijit Mitra

analyst
#71

Great, great. And the other question I had is on Europe. Have you written down any inventories? Is there any other provision of cost which is sitting there because certainly we could sort of see a very sharp reduction in the inventories which were reported in the P&L also.

Koushik Chatterjee

executive
#72

No, no, we have not reduced any -- written down any inventories. All that has happened, the inventories have walked out of our doors. And that's the basis on which we have reduced the inventory. As Naren a little while back mentioned that typically our inventory levels used to be more than 2 million tonnes in finished stocks, is now well under 2 million tonnes. And that is the release that we have seen. The team is working on finding the new baseline which can be sustained and that is part of that whole transformation project because it is not only just the inventory management, but also how the entire hubs between Netherlands and U.K. work. So it is clearly focused on releasing capital on -- from working capital and sustaining that because if spreads increase, then we have to ensure that the working capital doesn't get rebuild.

Operator

operator
#73

The next question is from the line of Bharat Shettigar from Standard Chartered Bank.

Bharat Shettigar

analyst
#74

First question is on the debt in the Europe business. From what I understand, the tranche B1 and B2 is going to start amortizing from April 2020. Just trying to understand how do you plan to meet those amortization payments? Is some new debt being raised? If so, at what level?

Koushik Chatterjee

executive
#75

No, I think the -- we have refinanced that entire SFA now. And therefore the first repayments are a couple of years from today. So therefore, we do not have any material repayment out of Europe in -- not only material, no repayment out of Europe in 2021. The repayment in the group is more at India level, but Europe repayments actually are pushed beyond 2024.

Bharat Shettigar

analyst
#76

Okay. That's good to know. One other question on Bhushan Steel. Now if I see last 12-month EBITDA is only around INR 2,400 crores. So now with all the improvements that we are talking about, from a mid-cycle point of view, what kind of annual EBITDA numbers should we assume for the Bhushan Steel entity?

Thachat Narendran

executive
#77

Yes, I think, immediately, what we're looking at is at least INR 8,000 per tonne. But in the long term, obviously, we want to see the INR 10,000 range, and that's what we have said in the past. And as somebody asked earlier, obviously, we will always benchmark Bhushan with other companies who don't have the iron ore linkage.

Bharat Shettigar

analyst
#78

I mean, given that this quarter, it's only about INR 2,260, I mean, how realistic is it to reach about INR 8,000? And in what kind of time frame are we talking about?

Thachat Narendran

executive
#79

I think if the prices stay where they are, quite soon. And if you recall, it was not very -- it was in the -- if I remember right, it was INR 6,000 in the quarter before that and INR 10,000 two quarters before that. So if you really look at it, it's just 1 quarter where we are way off from that. Otherwise, on most quarters, we have been in that space, in the INR 6,000 to INR 10,000 range.

Operator

operator
#80

The next question is from the line of Vishal Chandak from Emkay Global.

Vishal Chandak

analyst
#81

Just wanted to understand what would be the actual impact of the carbon credits in Europe in this quarter and next year?

Koushik Chatterjee

executive
#82

There was no carbon credits in this quarter. Actually, the credits were only in FY '19. This year, I think, the total impact is more -- 50 million more as an outgo, so there is -- for the full year -- for the year-to-date at this point of time.

Vishal Chandak

analyst
#83

And next year, how much of outgo can we build into this?

Koushik Chatterjee

executive
#84

Next year is difficult to say at this point of time. Once we get to the plan level and get a better understanding of the -- get a better level of the volumes, then -- and a sense of the carbon rates that are prevailing, we will -- I think it's more a April conversation at this point of time.

Vishal Chandak

analyst
#85

Okay. Got it, sir. Second is, sir, we have been talking about prioritizing pellet as well as CRM. So what kind of savings is likely? Let's say, assuming a INR 6,000 purchase price on the pellet, what could be the likely savings for the next year would be, that this is likely?

Thachat Narendran

executive
#86

Well, the advantage of pellets is, we can use our own iron ore to make pellets rather than buy pellets from the market, which is based on market price of iron ore. So that to me is the biggest advantage of pellets. And as far as the cold rolling mill is concerned, as you know, it's more the value addition to sell as HR and more value-added products.

Koushik Chatterjee

executive
#87

And we are buying pellets at this point of time, which will get reduced. And the pellet premium, as you can see, is pretty elevated over the last few years.

Operator

operator
#88

We'll take the next question from the line of [ Prashant Kumar ] from CGS-CIMB.

Unknown Analyst

analyst
#89

My question is related to the European emissions. Sir, what proportion of our European carbon emissions are we allowed to emit? And what is the proportion that is for which we are required to buy credits? Broadly, if you could break it down between U.K. and Netherlands.

Koushik Chatterjee

executive
#90

Well, I think I don't have the numbers for U.K. and Netherlands. But broadly, you can -- there is a certain -- based on certain volumes, you get the credits and capacity. And then you have to use those credits for the actual production that one does. Therefore, it's -- I can -- we can give you a separate, outside -- maybe Samita you can send them the details. I don't have the exact numbers as far as the U.K. and Netherlands. So overall, I think at the current level of steady state production, the deficit is about 2 million -- 1 million to 2 million. And if you look at the current rate of carbon -- CO2 that is trading under EPS, it's about EUR 23, EUR 24 per tonne. So you can do your math.

Unknown Analyst

analyst
#91

Sure, sir. And sir, if you could also break down for us, if possible, EBITDA per tonne at U.K. and Netherlands, if at all possible.

Koushik Chatterjee

executive
#92

Yes, so you have to talk to Samita after this. I don't have the numbers.

Operator

operator
#93

We take the last question from the line of Rahul Jain from Systematix.

Rahul Jain

analyst
#94

I was looking at the way the world has changed in the sense that iron ore assets are changing hands. So do we think we have -- what strategy do we have post 2030 when our iron ore deals would expire? And in the sense, I want to know how much of the EBITDA is coming from iron ore?

Thachat Narendran

executive
#95

I didn't hear the first part of your question. Are you saying what happens after 2030?

Rahul Jain

analyst
#96

Yes, because like your leases would expire in 2030, right? And so what -- and you're continuing with your CapEx in Kalinganagar. So just wanted to know on that.

Thachat Narendran

executive
#97

So obviously, we will obviously try to monetize as much as possible till 2030. And post 2030, we will do what everybody has done, buy iron ore in the market or participate in auctions and get the iron ore. See, if you really look at it, so most of the last 100 years that we had, iron ore -- for 80 years, iron ore was $25. It's only in the last 15, 20 years, it has become such a big issue. So 2030 is a long way off, so let us see what happens in 2030. And we will take -- we have some plans. We will -- and we are participating in the auctions. There will be many more auctions which come. So obviously, the cost of iron ore for us will go up. But that's okay. I think, by then, we would have also driven a lot of efficiencies beyond what we already have. If you look at coal, Tata Steel at one time used to have a lot of the coal, but today 75%, 80% of our coal is bought out. So there are some advantages of being able to buy iron ore and coal because we can choose what you buy. And that gives you also some benefits in operations. So we are not -- we are working towards it, but I don't think that's a game changer for us as much as some people think.

Rahul Jain

analyst
#98

Do we have the option to sell iron ore if need be? If tomorrow we are -- the steel market is more stressed, you need cash, something like that. Is it possible?

Thachat Narendran

executive
#99

Not for -- we -- all our mines today are captive mines. So we are not allowed to sell any iron ore.

Rahul Jain

analyst
#100

Right. And sir, just on your stand-alone number, how much is the EBITDA from iron ore sales to Tata -- TSL?

Thachat Narendran

executive
#101

We don't calculate that because these are internal cost transfers.

Operator

operator
#102

We'll take that as the last question. I would now like to hand the conference back to Ms. Samita Shah for closing comments.

Samita Shah

executive
#103

Thank you very much, everybody, for dialing in and for the questions. In case there are any more queries, we will be available to take them. Thank you, and good night.

Operator

operator
#104

Thank you very much. On behalf of Tata Steel Limited, that concludes this conference. Thank you for joining us, ladies and gentleman. You may now disconnect your lines.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Tata Steel Limited transcript — plus 248,000+ transcripts from 12,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Tata Steel Limited earnings transcripts and 248,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $24.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.