Terna S.p.A. (TRN) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

May 13, 2020

Borsa Italiana IT Utilities Electric Utilities earnings 42 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Good afternoon, everyone, and thank you for joining us for Terna's first-quarter 2020 consolidated results. Right now, everyone is in listen-only mode. Following the speakers' presentation, we will open the floor for questions and answers. If you would like to ask something during that session, please press Star and One on your phone's keypad. I should let you know that this call is being recorded today, Wednesday, 13 May 2020, and at this point I'll turn things over to one of our speakers, Agostino Scornajenchi, our CFO. Sir, the floor is yours.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#2

Good afternoon, everyone, and welcome to the presentation of our first quarter 2020 results. Before we get into an analysis of the figures, I'd like to share with you the most recent trend in electricity demand in Italy. During the first three months of the year, because of the lockdown measures put in place by the COVID-19 health emergency, national demand came in at 77 terawatt-hour, which is a 4.5% decrease compared with the same period of 2019, when national demand was about 81 terawatt-hour. Let me point out that about 33% of it was covered by renewable sources, versus 31% in the first quarter of 2019. National net total production stood at 66 terawatt-hour, with a strong increase recorded in hydro production, which grew by 19% compared with the same period of last year, confirming the strong growth trend for renewable that we already highlighted in past months. Before going deep into the results for the period, let me underline that in this COVID-19 emergency, employees' health and safety have been and will continue to be the top priority for Terna. In line with the guidelines and restrictions established by the government and the regional authorities, Terna introduced a series of measures to guarantee continuity of the electricity service in full safety. Terna set up a crisis committee in constant contact with the Civil Protection Department, authorities, trade unions, and major Italian companies.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#3

For 100% of our non-authoritative employees, we rolled out smart working, and we suspended every non-essential trip. Offices and construction sites also received periodic sanitization, and we added temperature checks for 100% of our staff using thermal scanners set up across all our facilities. Moving on to the key figures for the period, found on page five. Even with the COVID-19 emergency lockdown, in the year's first three months, group revenues and EBITDA rose 6% and 3%, respectively — that is EUR 31 million and EUR 14 million above last year. We also posted net income of EUR 187 million, EUR 1 million above last year, while group CapEx came in at EUR 218 million, 32% higher than the first quarter of 2019, which confirms the strong CapEx acceleration established in the 2020 to 2024 strategic plan we presented last March, even amid such a complex national emergency framework. To back this CapEx acceleration, our net debt was EUR 8.4 billion against roughly EUR 8.3 billion at year-end 2019, entirely in line with what we expected. As for the effect of the restrictions imposed by the COVID-19 emergency, we anticipate no significant direct effects, since our business is largely regulated in nature.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#4

Let's move on to a more in-depth look at the numbers now. As we typically do, we'll begin with the revenue review found on page 7. During the first quarter of 2020, our total revenues rose 5.7% to EUR 567 million, which represents an increase of EUR 31 million compared with the corresponding period a year earlier. This growth came primarily from regulated activities, which added roughly EUR 17 million. On the non-regulated and international side, the gains over the same quarter of 2019 were EUR 11 million and EUR 3 million, respectively, driven largely by Tamini, the Italy-Montenegro private interconnection, and our Latin American projects, which we'll examine in greater depth later in this presentation. Now let's turn to the specifics of how regulated and non-regulated revenues developed, as we move to the following slide. Regulated revenues came in at EUR 517 million, which is EUR 17 million above last year's figure. That improvement stemmed mainly from tariff evolution, while other regulated revenues were up EUR 5 million, chiefly because of higher revenues tied to improved service quality during the period. Keep in mind that the volume impact stemming from the COVID-19 emergency was limited, in the region of a low single digit.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#5

Revenues from non-regulated and international operations came in at EUR 51 million, roughly 37% above the prior year. Several factors drove that increase: higher turnover at Tamini's transformer business, the Italy-Montenegro interconnection coming online, and the contribution from the Brazilian projects, which started operating between the end of 2018 and the first half of 2019. Let's now move to the operating cost analysis on page nine. The chart shows total operating costs of EUR 133 million, up 14% versus last year. That rise came mainly from Terna, reflecting greater volumes of activity, and was partly offset by lower costs tied to quality of service. To look more closely at the group's OpEx components, let's go to the next slide. Starting with regulated OpEx, we maintained full control over our costs, reporting EUR 98 million, essentially flat compared with last year and that is despite the significant growth in our asset base. Non-regulated and international operating expenses totaled EUR 35 million, which is EUR 13 million above last year, primarily because of how Tamini's orders evolved. Let me now walk through EBITDA. On to the next slide. Taking into account the effects just mentioned, group EBITDA came to EUR 434 million, EUR 14 million better than last year.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#6

We saw a positive EBITDA contribution from both regulated and international activities, with those growing by EUR 13 million and EUR three million, respectively, compared with last year. That rise came mainly from higher regulated revenues and from the contribution of the new lines in Brazil running at full operation. Now let's take a look at the lower part of the P&L, moving to page 12. Depreciation and amortization came in at EUR 152 million. The year-over-year increase was primarily driven by the impact of new assets that became operational during the period. As a result, EBIT came to EUR 282 million, which is EUR 2.2 million above the first quarter of 2019. Net financial expenses were reported at EUR 19 million, EUR 3.4 million above the same period last year, mainly because of inflation and capitalized financial shares dynamics during the first three months. Taxes were EUR 76 million, with an average tax rate of 29.1%, roughly in line with the same period last year. Therefore, group net income came to EUR 187 million, essentially stable against the same period last year, even with a higher depreciation and amortization level tied to the acceleration of investments already mentioned.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#7

Now let's look at capital expenditure. Across the first three months of 2020, total expenses came to EUR 218 million, which is 32% above the equivalent period a year earlier — well on track toward the full-year target established in the strategic plan, even with the main construction site halted from 13th to the 20th of March owing to restrictive measures tied to the COVID-19 emergency. During phase one, only activities deemed essential were guaranteed. Under phase two, every activity is progressively returning to normal. Roughly EUR 206 million went into regulated activities. Key projects in the period include the rationalization of the Naples metropolitan area, installation of synchronous compensators, and asset renewal. Within the CapEx categories, development CapEx came in at EUR 74 million, equal to 36% of total regulated CapEx. Asset renewal and efficiency reached EUR 93, or 45%, whereas standard CapEx was EUR 39 million, or 19%. Non-regulated and other CapEx totaled EUR 11 million, encompassing capitalized financial charges and other investments. Turning to net debt and cash flow analysis, please go to page 14. Net debt as of the close of the first quarter 2020 stood at EUR 8,409 million, EUR 150 million above the 2019 year-end level, driven mainly by the strong CapEx acceleration seen in the period.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#8

I want to emphasize that regarding working capital, we saw no meaningful lag in cash settlements, so we don't anticipate any bad debt problems over the next few months. Against that backdrop, operating cash flow came in at EUR 306 million, which allowed us to more than cover the CapEx spending for the period. Now let's take a closer look at our debt profile. We reaffirm a solid financial structure, with a duration of 4.8 years and fixed debt at roughly 80% of total gross debt. Beyond that, we foresee no significant financing needs before 2021. As a result of the debt management actions carried out, the cost of net debt at period end stayed broadly aligned with year-end 2019 levels. I'd like to point out that after the 2020 to 2024 strategic plan was presented, every major rating agency reaffirmed the rating assigned to Terna. On that note, allow me to also mention the fourth recent rating confirmation, this one from Fitch, even after the downgrade of Italian government bonds' rating that was decided only a couple of weeks ago. Many thanks for your attention; we are now ready to begin the Q&A session.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#9

Please.

Operator

operator
#10

Thanks very much, ladies and gentlemen. We're moving into the question-and-answer portion now. Just a quick reminder: to pose a question, hit star one on your phone and hold until your name is called. Should you need to withdraw your request, press the hash key. So again, that's star and one for any questions. Our first caller is Harry Wyburd from Bank of America. Please go ahead.

Harry Wyburd

analyst
#11

Hello there, and good afternoon to everyone. I appreciate you taking my questions. I have three, if I may. To start with, there has been a bit of press coverage regarding the notion of a combination involving Snam and Terna. I was just curious about your perspective on how plausible it is that such a thing could ever come about. The second one concerns demand. You provided us with some solid specifics about what took place during the first quarter. It would be quite interesting to hear your take on the data regarding what you have observed over the past few days as the lockdown has begun to ease. In your capacity as the system operator, have you noticed any trends regarding a pickup in business demand that matter, that could help us grasp what the effect on demand will be, not only for you but for the broader sector? Just the demand trends from the last few days. And then the last one is about the regulatory review. It is still a while away, but I would be interested in your thinking on whether the crisis could affect the review. Obviously, I assume the government will be eager to sustain investment, since it carries a very high GDP multiplier.

Harry Wyburd

analyst
#12

So do you think the regulator might therefore end up being perhaps somewhat more lenient, whether directly or indirectly, regarding the returns allowances it grants when the next WACC review comes around? Thank you.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#13

To begin with the final point: honestly, I don’t perceive any implication from the crisis when it comes to possible shifts in how the Italian Energy Authority regulates, or more broadly in how the government approaches making investment happen. On the other hand, I do see certain opportunities here. I’ll reaffirm that speeding up infrastructure investment is among the primary instruments for helping the economy recover quickly. That is what we’re doing on the operational front. As I mentioned earlier in my remarks, we had to make some choices to halt certain work in some locations—not because we lacked permission, since electricity transmission is a sector holding a special authorization allowing it to keep working. The difficulty was logistical, because the country was essentially shut until two weeks ago. Moving goods and people around the company was not feasible. What we’re doing at present—and we began two weeks ago—is reopening our sites gradually, and we’re also rescheduling every activity planned for the second half of the year, while attempting as well to pull forward some activities that were originally expected in the first half of 2021.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#14

We're also seeking help from the government on the authorization side so that the authorization process itself can be sped up, which would let us recover. What I can say is that at this point we're near 80% of activity restored, as usual. More than 100 sites — construction sites — have reopened over the most recent weeks. Let me begin there to address the second question regarding demand. Naturally, throughout the lockdown, particularly from the second half of March through the end of April, we observed a significant drop in total energy demand. In certain weeks, we saw an enormous reduction compared with the same weeks a year earlier. During some weeks, the decline reached almost 20%. At year-end, we currently anticipate an average reduction of between 8% and 10%. That's our present view. This won't carry meaningful consequences for our margin, since, as you're aware, just a very small share of our revenues ties directly to the volumes transported on the grid. Keep in mind that of EUR 2.2 billion in regulated revenues, under EUR 200 million is linked to volume.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#15

For every percentage point of reduction, you can figure on a bit under two million. As we mentioned earlier, we're looking at reductions in the millions that we can handle without difficulty by year-end. That's the reason I don't expect any effect on marginality for 2020. As for your first question, naturally, the Terna and Snam merger is a subject that has come up on several occasions already. What can I say at this point? We have stayed within a technical collaboration framework, cooperating to construct the joint energy scenario for the future. That's something of interest to both of us. Thank you.

Harry Wyburd

analyst
#16

All right, thanks.

Operator

operator
#17

Thanks, operator. Our next question is coming from Enrico Bartoli at MainFirst, who's joining us live. Enrico, please go ahead with your question.

Enrico Bartoli

analyst
#18

Good afternoon, and thanks. I have three questions as well. To start, a broad one: what effect do you anticipate the COVID emergency will have on how the energy transition is approached or backed at the political level? If you could expand a little, some indications of possible discussions or signals coming from the political level, on both the EU and Italian sides. Related to that, the press mentioned some talks with the government about possibly speeding up authorization processes to increase, accelerate CapEx execution on your side too — if you could comment on that as well. Do you expect any impact on your operating costs from the lockdown or the emergency at the 2020 level? The third one, you are quite clear, but if you could elaborate a bit more on any possible impact on working capital because of the economic situation — maybe there could be some delays or bad debt in the electricity system — if you could also provide more details on that point. Thank you.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#19

Alright, there are 4 of those. I'll address questions 1 and 2, and handle them together. Regarding investment, and regarding the government's approach on authorization — from a technical standpoint, the investment required in the energy system prior to the COVID emergency remains necessary following it as well. Let me take a minute on that. In my view, the emergency served as an outstanding instrument for helping us grasp the physical and practical consequences of a system increasingly grounded in renewable sources. As you can picture, during the latter half of March and the opening half of April, the country was essentially shut down, industrial consumption sat at very low levels. Weather conditions were outstanding, so the contribution from renewables proved impressive. Naturally, the technical consequences of handling that growth were impressive too. That is why we gained a practical demonstration that investment in the grid is required so that, from a technical standpoint, a massive acceleration in distributed renewable generation becomes possible. We were convinced of this already, but now we hold the practical demonstration as well. This is something fully understood at the Terna level, and it is something the government level understands too.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#20

As I’ve told your colleagues previously, we’re coordinating closely with the government, since it’s evident that infrastructure investment ranks among the most effective tools for stimulating the country’s economic recovery. On top of that, there’s a multiplier effect. Together with policy makers, we’re examining ways the authorization process might be made shorter so the investment process can be sped up for the years ahead as well. On operational cost, naturally, certain specific categories of costs have risen, but savings elsewhere are essentially outweighing those increases by more than enough. As you can imagine, nobody at the company is traveling these days. In addition, the variable portion of FTE compensation has fallen sharply owing to the adoption of smart working. Also on the operational cost side, we completely reaffirm the guidance we communicated. On working capital, naturally, in a crisis setting, you can imagine the end customer might choose to postpone payments to the sale companies. The sale companies might choose to postpone payments to the distribution companies. Ultimately, the distribution company might choose to pass that effect through to a transmission company such as Terna.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#21

I'll make two separate points here. First, on the formal side, the authority has stated plainly that this isn't permitted, through a specific resolution adopted in April. The transmission tariff is owed as a matter of law. Practically speaking, we haven't observed any delays at all. Each month we collect roughly EUR 160 million on average for the transmission portion of our tariff, and we don't expect to encounter any delay whatsoever.

Enrico Bartoli

analyst
#22

Appreciate it.

Operator

operator
#23

Appreciate it. Our next question will come from Stefano Gamberini at Equita SIM. Go ahead with your question.

Stefano Gamberini

executive
#24

Good afternoon, everyone. I have three quick questions, if I may. First, could you repeat your estimate for power generation consumption at year-end? The decline was 10% in March. What kind of recovery do you expect for the full year, or what is the target on that? In particular, what kind of summer can we expect in terms of electricity consumption, considering that smart working increased a lot and probably the situation will remain this way during the summer? Second, regarding renewables. During 2019, if I'm not wrong, one gigawatt was installed and on stream. What happened in these two months? In particular, if you have some feedback from all the investors on the other side that are asking for new capacity and new interconnection for renewables, are they postponing their investment? If you have any visibility. The last is just on the guidance, if it is possible, of net debt at year-end. Thanks.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#25

Okay, I'll begin with the final item. As you're aware, we won't be giving any guidance on net debt. On volumes, let me restate the figure we're seeing at year-end: cumulative through year-end, total consumption is down between 8% and 10%. That wasn't tied to March — it was tied to all of 2020. Thank you. Turning to renewables, we keep witnessing a steady step-up in pace. We were already beginning to see that step-up in 2019, with an extra one gigawatt installed. We're still engaged with plenty of private operators. As you know, we get direct information from the demand we receive for new interconnection, for new technical connection on the high-voltage network. Naturally, there are likely some delays tied to the lockdown, but I'm not seeing any meaningful shifts there.

Stefano Gamberini

executive
#26

Just to get a sense of it, for the coming quarters or over the summer, do you still see demand staying soft ahead?

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#27

I'm seeing demand recovering progressively relative to the volumes we'd expected before. That will hinge on how long the measures last and on the degree to which the actual restrictions we encounter in normal life are, let me see, released. Naturally, it won't be up to us. What it will hinge on is how the crisis evolves from a health and safety standpoint.

Stefano Gamberini

executive
#28

Appreciate it.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#29

Glad to help.

Operator

operator
#30

Thanks. Our next question is from James Brand at Deutsche Bank. Go ahead with your question.

James Brand

analyst
#31

Good afternoon. It's good to see fairly uneventful results at this point in time. I've got two questions covering different areas. First, regarding the LatAm operations you have: I understand they're clearly a fairly small portion of the group overall, and the group as a whole is very stable in the current environment. I was just wondering whether you could provide a little detail on what the COVID impact was on the operations and in LatAm — that is, which of those projects are dollarized and which are in local currency? Obviously, there have been pretty large depreciations, and whether there are any volume impacts we should be thinking about there. The second question concerns your 10-year plan, which you published after the business plan, where obviously you set out the targets over the medium term. The 10-year plan was a pretty punchy overall number in terms of CapEx and seemed to suggest annual CapEx rising quite substantially further than the kind of numbers you'd outlined over the medium term, possibly up to over EUR 2 billion per annum, if my calculations are reasonable. I was just wondering whether you could talk a bit about that and what's driving the higher CapEx in the second half of the decade and where the opportunities are for greater investment.

James Brand

analyst
#32

Appreciate it.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#33

Alright. When it comes to LatAm, as we all know — thank you — we do have certain operations in Latin America, Brazil in particular. There are assets under construction in Peru and Uruguay, of limited size. On Peru and Uruguay, naturally, we're seeing a bit of slippage in the completion, but we're absolutely not worried, and we expect to be able to make up for the time lost. On Brazil, the assets in operation are doing rather well, with no adverse effects stemming from the COVID emergency. Let me add that, as you noted, only a small share of our capital sits in Latin America, denominated in local currency, which in the long term we regard as hedged. The second question concerned the trajectory, let me say, of our investment spending. Let me confirm that we are gradually shifting from the past situation, in which we averaged EUR 700 million-EUR 800 million annually, toward an average of EUR 1.2 billion, EUR 1.3 billion, or even EUR 1.4 billion, depending on how precisely the various projects are scheduled. That is confirmed by the 10-year development plan we published just a few weeks ago.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#34

We look at EUR 1.3 billion, EUR 1.4 billion as being the standard path, and if you examine what we actually delivered to the market over the recent two, three years, we've moved progressively from EUR 700 million-EUR 800 million to EUR 900 million, EUR 1 billion, EUR 1.1 billion in 2020. We are getting to that path, and in the years ahead we will get to that path. We will stay there.

James Brand

analyst
#35

Alright.

Operator

operator
#36

Thanks. Our next question is from Javier Suárez at Mediobanca. Go ahead with your question.

Javier Suárez

analyst
#37

Hello, and good afternoon, everyone.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#38

Hello there.

Javier Suárez

analyst
#39

There are two questions left. The first follows up on the earlier one about the 10-year development plan. What the company has done — and I agree with the different administration regarding the 10-year CapEx plan, meaning it's an increase compared with the prior plan — I'm just wondering whether you could help us understand the thinking behind this 10-year investment plan. What has been approved relative to the earlier version? I'm aware there's an annual recovery within this 10-year plan, but I wanted to see what's different in the latest version compared with the previous one. The second remaining question concerns the acceleration of CapEx. Several questions have come up about the capacity the company has to contribute to the economic recovery by accelerating CapEx. The question for you would be: to what level do you believe the company can raise its yearly CapEx given its current structure? You just mentioned that CapEx has been raised to EUR 1.3 billion or EUR 1.4 billion per annum. To what level of CapEx could the company move in order to help with the economic recovery? Many thanks.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#40

Well, I think there's always room for improvement. EUR 1.3 billion, EUR 1.4 billion — that's already pretty ambitious, in my view. Don't forget the company stood at just EUR 700 million a few years back. If I recall correctly, the 2017–2021 business plan set EUR 3.7 billion as the total CapEx expectation across that five-year horizon. Today we're at EUR 7.4 billion — double. Essentially, with the same organizational structure, we're basically asking our engineers to deliver somewhere between 50% and 100% more. That's an incredible effort we're requesting from our people. Naturally, when it comes to our 10-year development plan, several relevant projects are part of it. Let me bring up the Tyrrhenian Link. This is a project connecting the southern part of the peninsula with northern Sicily and southern Sardinia. It will have a significantly dramatic impact on how the electricity system in Sardinia functions. Beyond that, we'll be closing a kind of ring so electricity can move around the country not via the peninsula but via the island. You can picture the level of benefits this will bring to the stability of the system as a whole.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#41

Naturally, that single investment will land somewhere between EUR 3.5 billion and EUR 4 billion. EUR 900 million of that is already baked into the five-year business plan, and the rest gets completed after 2025. A further EUR 1 billion will be tied to the Adriatic Link, which is another submarine interconnection — this one sits in the long-term development plan rather than the business plan, since it starts after 2025. Setting aside particular spikes like these kinds of projects, I'd say once more that 1.3, 1.4 is an ambitious trajectory for the future. From a debt profile standpoint as well, I view it as fully sustainable.

Javier Suárez

analyst
#42

Thanks.

Operator

operator
#43

Thanks. Our next question is from Olivier van Doosselaere at Exane. Go ahead, please.

Olivier Van Doosselaere

analyst
#44

Yes, good afternoon, and thanks so much for making time to answer our questions today. I had just one question left. It's actually, once again, about volume effects. I understand you're saying that you don't foresee implications or a risk that people won't pay their bills, but I'm curious what the implications would be if overall volumes simply come down, as you mentioned, by between 8%-10% this year. Obviously, you get paid your transmission share, but if volumes are lower, does that mean the regulated costs also face a shortfall of that order of magnitude, which would then be recovered through a tariff increase? Are you paid in a different way that might not be volumetric? If a tariff increase is needed to recover that, could you please indicate over what time periods that normally gets spread? Thank you.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#45

I think, first of all, the effect that comes from changes in volumes is minor, since — let me say it again — 90% of the tariff fee we charge has nothing to do with how much traffic we carry on our lines. Naturally, this is an unusual situation, and what happens on the other side will hinge mainly on events over the next two months. Right now we are seeing demand come back quickly and steadily, which follows from the country reopening step by step, along with industrial and commercial activity, both of which we observe growing day after day. Naturally, that will need confirmation from a medical standpoint. I am not a physician. I am not standing here to persuade anybody that we are past this or not. Naturally, should further decisions be taken to bring lockdown measures back, then naturally the situation would get worse. My hope is that in the end we can keep such a decline as limited as we can. Either way, the effects on our numbers will be negligible.

Olivier Van Doosselaere

analyst
#46

Thanks so much.

Operator

operator
#47

Thanks. That brings us to the end of the question-and-answer session.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#48

All right, thanks a lot for the time you gave us, and enjoy the rest of your day. We hope to see you over the next few months. Thank you.

Operator

operator
#49

Thanks. That brings today's conference to a close. We appreciate everyone joining us. You're welcome to disconnect at this time.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Terna S.p.A. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Terna S.p.A. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Terna S.p.A. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.