Terna S.p.A. (TRN) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
March 22, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Stefano Antonio Donnarumma
executiveGood afternoon, everyone, and welcome to Terna's Full Year 2022 Results Presentation. As always, before we begin examining the features, I'd like to share the latest key achievements with you. On regulated activities in 2022, Terna secured approval from the Italian Ministry of Environment and Energy Security and the Regional Councils for 29 projects, with investments totaling more than €2.5 billion. All of that goes toward developing the Italian electricity grid, confirming our key role as an enabler of the energy transition. With this, Terna records—after surpassing €1 billion in approved investments in 2021 for the first time in history. On this point, let me remind you that the company's sustainable investments create value for the country, with positive effects on gross domestic product, and they also create jobs. So they help make Italy become even more crucial within the European system and the Mediterranean hub for electricity. In this regard, at the beginning of 2023, the Ministry of Environment and Energy Security also launched the authorization procedure for Adriatic Link, in which Terna will invest over €1 billion. The project will connect the Italian regions of <<inaudible>> market and will directly or indirectly involve about 120 external partners.
Stefano Antonio Donnarumma
executiveOn the sustainability front, Terna has once more been affirmed at the very top globally. The companies ranked within the top 1% for sustainability here, book 2023, the leading industry publication from Standard & Poor global that assesses ESG performance. The score given places Terna as the highest scoring company among the 250 electric utilities examined worldwide. This international recognition strengthens Terna's role as a direct player and an enabler of the energy transition toward an increasingly sustainable, safe and resilient electricity grid. Terna's leadership in sustainability is also highlighted by the company's inclusion in several major ESG indexes such as the Bloomberg Gender Equality Index, Euronext <<inaudible>> is efficacy for good Stoxx global ESG leaders. On shareholder remuneration, today's Board of Directors approved and will propose to the general meeting the 2022 final dividend of €20.83 per share, payable in June, up by 80% versus the prior year, consistent with the communicated dividend policy. The 2022 interim dividend of €10.61 per share was already paid last November. Thus the total dividend for 2022 amounts to €31.44 per share. Lastly, on international activities. The LATAM consolidation process is going — gone as planned. Confirming the company's broader strategy to refocus its international activities, as already announced in the updated industrial plan.
Stefano Antonio Donnarumma
executiveFollowing that quick intro, I'll walk you through the standard snapshot of the Italian electricity market, so let's turn to slide five. This chart shows that in 2022, national demand came to roughly 317 terawatt hours, which works out to a 1% decline compared with the prior year, when national demand stood at approximately 320 terawatt hours. That modest rise in electricity demand was largely a consequence of the mild weather seen in <<inaudible>> and the winter months, along with steps taken to curb power usage by households and companies. Renewable sources supplied around one-third of national demand in 2022. In other words, 31.1%. As for national net total production, it came in at 276 terawatt hours, 1.3% below 2021. Even so, I want to point out the notable gain in <<inaudible>> production, which rose 11.8% compared with the previous year. I should also note that renewable sources accounted for roughly 56% of national net total production in 2022. Let's now turn to the key highlights of the period on page six. Group revenues and EBITDA in 2022 increased 14% and 11%, respectively, versus the year before, meaning €360 million and €204 million above the same period of 2021.
Stefano Antonio Donnarumma
executiveGroup net income came in at €857 million, marking a relevant increase of 9% compared with last year. Group CapEx was roughly €1.8 billion, up 16% versus the prior year, which confirms once more the strong CapEx acceleration consistent with Terna's institutional role for the country. Even with this CapEx acceleration, net debt at the end of December, 2022, was €8.6 billion, compared with about €10 billion at 2021 year-end. As the chart shows, every main feature of the period meets and exceeds the updated guidance provided for the year. Let me also remind you that thanks to initiatives aimed at further increasing benefits for the system and efficiency. 2022 EBITDA and EPS guidance had already been raised back in November, during the presentation of the 2022 nine months results. Now let me pause briefly on the main results recorded over this last three years, going back to the next slide, number seven, the growth path. The growth path you can observe over recent years is briefly presented in this chart. Specifically, 2022 revenues, EBITDA and EPS grew by 19%, 14% and 9%, respectively. Despite a reduction in regulatory work, group CapEx registered an increase of about 30%, all compared with the 2020 year-end level.
Stefano Antonio Donnarumma
executiveAs you can see, even with the difficult situation we faced, we managed to substantially raise the investments aimed at meeting system requirements and enabling energy transmission, while creating value for all our stakeholders. At this point, I'll hand things over to the CFO, Agostino Scornajenchi, who will give a more detailed look at the 2022 figures. Moving on — to slide number eight.
Agostino Scornajenchi
executiveThank you, Stefano. We'll begin by looking at the revenue figures. In 2022, total revenues rose 13.8%, hitting €2,964 million — that's €360 million more than the prior year. As you can see, we posted positive results from both regulated and non-regulated activities, which contributed €289 million and €71 million, respectively. To walk through the revenue breakdown in detail, let's turn to slide number 10. Regulated revenues came to €2,542 million, €289 million above last year, meaning roughly 13% more than 2021. That growth stemmed chiefly from a larger output-based incentives effect tied to the greater benefits generated for the system. Non-regulated and international revenues totaled €422 million, 20.2% higher than last year. Growth in non-regulated was mostly due to higher revenues from the energy solution, largely connected to LT Group, acquired in October 2021, and to a bigger contribution from Tamini and Brugg. International revenues were set at about zero in accordance with IFRS 5 accounting standard for assets held for sale. Now let's move through the operating cost analysis, and we're now on page 11. Total operating cost came in at €905 million, 20.7% higher than last year. On the regulated side, the increase was mainly due to insourcing of new competencies and a higher level of activity.
Agostino Scornajenchi
executiveNon-regulated operations were affected primarily by increased raw material purchases tied to Brugg and Tamini, along with the LT Group contribution. Now let's break down EBITDA. Turning to slide 12. Taking into account those previously noted effects, 2022 Group EBITDA came in at €259 million, up 11% from the prior year. Regulated activities drove most of that gain, adding roughly €206 million and posting an EBITDA of €2007 million for 2022. Next, let's examine the bottom section of the profit and loss statement. Moving on to slide 13. Depreciation and amortization totaled €726 million. The year-over-year rise stemmed largely from new assets entering service during the period. Consequently, EBIT came to €1,334 million, an 11.1% increase over 2021. Net financial expenses were reported at €100 million. That increase relative to last year resulted mainly from inflation climbing during the period. Taxes came in at €355 million, which is €37 million above last year, essentially reflecting higher profits. The tax rate was 28.8%. Accordingly, Group net income hit €857 million, roughly 9% above the same period a year earlier. Now for CapEx. In 2022, total CapEx reached €1,757 million, approximately 16% more than last year.
Agostino Scornajenchi
executiveAnd just to confirm that double-digit acceleration we pointed to at the start of the presentation. We put roughly €1,668 million into regulated activities. Among the key projects for the period, I should mention the Tyrrhenian Link, the Paternò-Pantano-Priolo line in eastern Sicily, and spending on <<inaudible>> devices like STATCOM — synchronous compensators that keep the grid secure — for the CapEx categories under development. CapEx accounts for 41% of total regulated CapEx. Defense CapEx came in at 16%, while asset renewal and efficiency was 43%. Non-regulated and other CapEx was €89 million. That figure includes capitalized financial charges and other investments. On net debt and the cash flow analysis, let's go to page 15. Net debt at the end of December 2022 was €8,576 million, roughly €1.4 billion below the level at year end 2021, mainly because of the hybrid bond issued in February and booked as equity, plus the effect of commercial items on working capital dynamics compared with 2021. Over the year, we generated operating cash flow of €1,596 million, which let us cover nearly all of the CapEx spending for the period. Now let's look more closely at our debt profile. Moving to page 16. Thanks to the efficient, proactive approach to debt management we've taken over the last few years, at the end of December 2022 the fixed over floating ratio on gross debt was about 87%, while average duration was around five years. Thanks to the strong credit profile, Terna can access the financial market on extremely favorable terms, as shown by the Green Bond Hybrid launched in February 2022 with a nominal amount of €1 billion, which the market welcomed successfully.
Agostino Scornajenchi
executiveI'd also like to point out that in September, Terna issued a fixed-rate single tranche bond via a private placement process, for a total of €100 million. Those notes, with a five-year duration, carry a coupon of 3.44%. During the year, Terna additionally signed ESG-linked credit facility agreements totaling €600 million. Those credit lines come with a three-year term, and the interest rate is tied as well to how Terna performs against specific ESG indicators. Lastly, on November 8th, Terna signed a €500 million contract with the European Investment Bank to finance the East branch of the Tyrrhenian Link. This loan represents the first branch of €1.9 billion in total approved by the European Investment Bank for that project. The 22-year loan offers a longer maturity and a more competitive cost than what is generally available in the market. Alliance with Terna policy to optimize its financial structure. Thank you very much for your attention. And now, before we enter the Q&A session, let me hand the floor to Stefano for his closing remarks. Please, Stefano.
Stefano Antonio Donnarumma
executiveThank you, Agostino. Following those strong 2022 results, I'd like to share our 2023 guidance with you. For 2023, our expectation is revenues of €3.11 billion, along with EBITDA of €2.12 billion. Earnings per share will come to €0.43 per share. As for CapEx, we're expecting a figure of roughly €2.2 billion next year. This acceleration in CapEx for 2023 forms part of a broader growth process, driven by rising system needs aimed at ensuring efficiency, resiliency, and security of the supply. Indeed, let me highlight that on the 15th of March, we published the new 10-year national development plan, as shown on the next slide, number 19. This new national development plan arrives at an historic moment in which energy is even more central. In a phase of rapid and deep geopolitical change, the energy system must contend with a series of unprecedented and ambitious challenges. The targets set as part of the ongoing energy transition will be fully achievable only by developing infrastructures. In this regard, Terna is increasing the investments for resin in the New Year development plan, which for resist more than €21 billion of investments, the highest ever, with an increase of about 17% compared to the previous plan.
Stefano Antonio Donnarumma
executiveUnder the national development plan, money will go toward resin investments so that we keep integrating renewable sources and keep moving forward with retiring coal-fired power plants, consistent with the goals established domestically and internationally. Also, given that the full lifespan of the projects in this development plan goes beyond the 10-year starting point, the overall investment figure will be greater than €50 billion. To wrap up, Terna keeps generating value for shareholders and for communities through the resin investments in the updated industrial plan and through its robust dividend policy. Even with the very difficult situation we face, where investments accelerate during the quarter to satisfy system requirements, Terna will stay dedicated to maintaining a solid and sustainable capital structure. As we have shown during this presentation, Terna managed to deliver a very good set of results, even surpassing the guidance given for 2022, along with a strong expectation for 2023, which shows the commitment to executing the plan. Thank you for your attention. We are now ready for the Q&A session.
Operator
operatorThanks, Mr. Speaker. <<operator_script>> Our first question comes from Stefano Gamberini at Equita. Your line is open — please go ahead.
Stefano Gamberini
executiveGood afternoon, everyone, and thank you for the presentation. My first question is about the 2023 guidance: can you help us understand what contribution you expect from output-based incentives in 2023? And also, could you give an idea of what the level of this output-based incentive was in 2022, considering your guidance through 2026 to receive €600 million of output-based incentives and the better 2022 results, the better guidelines in 2023 — could we expect an increase of this total amount of €600 million? The second question is regarding the opportunity of investment, considering also the trend in renewables, this amount and the new project that you presented of US$11 billion including the 10-year development plan, clearly are linked to the development of renewables. Could you give us a picture of the situation for the renewables growth during 2022? What was the level that was reached and what you expect in 2023? Because my concern is if we don't have a huge acceleration in renewable installment capacity, you can also have some slippages in the investment in your — of your CapEx. These are my main — sorry — the third one is regarding the working capital.
Stefano Gamberini
executiveOn the cash flow slide in the presentation — slide 15, if I'm not mistaken — you highlighted a positive cash flow, a working capital effect above €900 million. Should we anticipate that this working capital gets absorbed during 2023? And what's the net debt guidance for next year? Or might we view this positive effect as a kind of structural improvement that ought to persist — hold up as well in the years ahead — and could clearly assist the company in its financial structure when it comes to handling all the investments in your business plan? Many thanks.
Stefano Antonio Donnarumma
executiveThanks for the question. Let me begin with the first one, about the 2023 guidance, and talk about the contribution, if I've understood it correctly. On these results that come basically from incentives. For this year, this contribution — for the prior year, 2022 — is roughly €400 million on the results. And for 2023 it's roughly €300 million. And within the 2022 results, our portion of that €400 million relates to the new MCD incentives. Speaking about — so you can see that in our guidance for 2023, we keep our increase on a structural basis, our results, and it comes from the incentive rules that we apply. On the second question, Agostino may add something, but I'd like to complete it — the second question about investments in renewables. Okay. You ask how this increase behaved over the last year. Probably we mentioned this a while ago, during 2022 there was an acceleration, certainly because the normal pace of investment over the last 10-year period was about 1 gigawatt per year. Last year it was about 3 gigawatts in a single year. And now the pace may be more than that.
Stefano Antonio Donnarumma
executiveWe estimate roughly 4 to 5 gigawatts for this year. The key point is that connection requests have gone up very substantially. That means the foundation for arriving at the next specific figure is entirely unlike what it was just a few years back. Think about it: 3 years ago, when we launched Terna, when this mandate began, we were looking at approximately 50 gigawatts of overall demand, mainly for solar plants. Today we're talking about over 300 and upward of that for wind generation. So we expect that, even with certain streamlining of the current authorization process, the return could rise. In any event, regarding our investment and how this evolution affects it, allow me to reassure everyone on this matter. We are tasked with restoring the system. And the infrastructure must be built over multiple years. As you're aware, once we plan an investment, carry it out, and construct the new line, that takes somewhere between 7, 8, and 10 years, so the network's full evolution requires multiple years to complete, and we can't adjust the pace of our infrastructure to match how quickly rest — and renewable installation — grows.
Stefano Antonio Donnarumma
executiveBasically, we now have to continue for the next 10 years under the national plan — the new one we've presented. That said, this plan gives us some room to be flexible, since we reached an agreement with the authority on something like an entirely new approach: the ability to design projects and plan investments that, at this level, are anyway covered by the authority. In other words, the authority funds our design work, our project, our planning. On top of that, we won't build these systems if something changes down the road. Let me give you an example. Say the government at some point decides to provide incentives in the north of Italy — for photovoltaic, for instance. Right now, most requests come from the south of Italy, but things may shift. So our network design could change as well: if we're moving ahead with the project, we can also switch direction. This ties specifically to the fact that every two years we must redo and refresh the plan covering the next 10 years. So the network design should be seen as dynamic, and we hold all the leverage needed to manage it.
Stefano Antonio Donnarumma
executiveOn the third point, I believe Agostino might respond to that, but Agostino, could you add something to my first …
Agostino Scornajenchi
executiveNo, there isn’t much more to add. The only point is that MSD’s output-based contribution for 2022 comes in a little under €200 million, while for 2023 it is a little over €200 million. Output-based totals €400 million in 2022 and €300 million in 2023. On your third question, about working capital dynamics, as you know there is now a structural issue there, driven by several so-called pass-through energy items. As you’ll recall from the past, we built up some working capital because of the uplift mechanism, particularly around the middle of the pandemic in spring 2020. That amount was reabsorbed over a couple of years, so it was fully absorbed in 2022. And during 2022, there was a decrease in the credit tied to the uplift, plus a rise in payables linked to the essential plans for the security of the electricity system, which will be reabsorbed in the coming months. So there is some fluctuation, which is typical for our business, and we do expect that amount to disappear next month.
Stefano Gamberini
executiveCould I ask a question, since I’m not clear on where both of those first output-based incentives stand? What I understand is that the goal was €600 million by 2026. Now you mentioned €400 million in 2022 and €300 million in 2023. That comes to €7 million across two years. So the 2026 target — the US$6 million increase — goes to, I don’t know, where. And second, I didn’t catch the answer about working capital. You had an improvement of US$900 million in 2022, partly also against the earlier worsening. So roughly what amount do you expect to be recovered during 2023? Many thanks.
Agostino Scornajenchi
executiveYes. I’ll begin with the second question. The sum you should expect to see taken back over the next few months comes to roughly €901 billion. That gives you a sense of the scale: it is a buildup of payables tied to pass-through items that ought to have been settled by the end of 2022. To make such a payment, we need to wait for a specific resolution from the authority. That resolution was not issued by the authority in time at year-end 2022. As a result, we are holding this extra cash. The authority will handle and resolve this matter during 2023. Turning back to output-based incentives, yes, naturally, your calculation is correct. Such contribution has gone up. We have seen a rising amount of output-based contribution, particularly on MSD. The initial target stood at €500 million. We raised that target to €600 million, and at this point we have some further contribution from output-based. That is the reason we have €400 million in 2022 and €300 million in 2023. And you should expect something comparable for 2024 as well.
Stefano Gamberini
executiveAll right, that’s clear. Thank you very much — and thank you again, many times over.
Agostino Scornajenchi
executiveHappy to help.
Operator
operatorJavier Suarez from Mediobanca, your next question — you're live, go right ahead.
Javier Suárez
analystHello, everyone, and thanks for the presentation. Along with the earlier question from Stefano, I have three questions. So the first is a high-profile one about the 10-year development plan that you recently presented. There is — and you mentioned this in the presentation — a significant increase in CapEx of 17%, and that is the largest 10-year development plan ever in Italy. So could you help us understand what that business plan brings to Terna, to the country, and to the European Union? And what has changed because of the crisis, and because of the lesson learned through the crisis, that makes this CapEx plan even more important for Italy and then for Europe? That high-profile question would be extremely interesting for seeing the company's strategic path over the next 10 years. Then, on the company's reporting and its numbers, two follow-ups. The first concerns the output-based incentives. You gave the figure for 2022 and the expectation for 2023. For 2024 and 2025, could you share your latest expectation on these output-based incentives?
Javier Suárez
analystYou've just been referenced, I believe — a figure for 2024 that's comparable to the 2023 one. So roughly €300 million, and then for 2025 as well, that would be useful. Then regarding working capital, could you tell us what you expect net debt to be at the close of 2023? That would also help. And on the new 2023 guidance, there's a component of higher output-based incentives compared with what might have been expected previously, plus a higher deflator too. Could you expand on that a bit and help us grasp these raised guidance consensus expectations — the various building blocks behind that argument. And the last question is about how Tamini and Brugg are performing operationally. Can you indicate whether this subsidiary contributes anything to EBITDA and what you expect in the years ahead? Thank you.
Stefano Antonio Donnarumma
executiveThanks for that question. I'd like to begin with the second one—the contribution from incentives and the MSD methods. Let me make that clearer. The contribution for last year and for this year, as provided for this year, is entirely clear and has been calculated. So we're giving it to you in numbers, as you can see. Then we intend to pursue a similar impact in the following year. But we must—first of all, we have to consolidate the results during this period. After that, we can provide a number. You should keep in mind, though, that this isn't a one-off result of this year versus last year; it's more of a structural behavior. What really matters is that at the close of this year there's an important appointment with regulation, as you know, for next year. We also expect a modification and perhaps an increase in the WACC value coming out of the observation period. I don't need to explain that to you. So the mix of possible effects that will hit the next two, three years must be carefully calculated over the coming month. I think that by the end of this year it may be possible for us to update the plan, and the closer we get to the final definition of the rules, the more precise we will be on this.
Stefano Antonio Donnarumma
executiveOkay, so let's make sure we get the timing right on this one. Now, going back to your first point — that's a really good question, because our development plan covering the coming 10 years is, I'd say, fantastic news for Italy, for the European electricity system, and for the Mediterranean region, since, as you can see, we've got planned investments of €21 billion. That works out, as you mentioned, to roughly 70% more than the plan we put out just two years back, which came to about €18 billion. With that spending, we make it possible for our grid to carry close to twice as much power from southern Italy up to the north. That matters a great deal for a number of reasons. First of all, consider that the benefit-to-cost ratio of this particular plan versus the earlier one has gone up substantially, because we get four to five times the effectiveness in transferring energy for the same amount of money. So the €11 billion that we allocated with what we called the hyper grid involves an application of completely new technology. Our idea is to move energy along the same corridors we have on the continent, but using a different type of power — and also voltage, I should say — and we step up the voltage through the HVDC application that we typically deploy for undersea connections.
Stefano Antonio Donnarumma
executiveAnd this matters a great deal, since the environmental effect and the <<inaudible>> effect are cut substantially. The time needed to construct this type of network also drops considerably — by several years, in fact. Along with certain other initiatives involving subsea links around our nation, we'll help remove every bottleneck and raise that power transmission capacity. That's significant because over the coming years we'll also hook up the north of Africa, Tunisia and Sicily. We'll finish the link joining Campania, Sicily and Sardinia. We're also considering building the second connection with Greece as well as the second one with Montenegro. And at the table there are merely talks now under way, though a possible revision of the next plan could come in two, three years. We expect to connect Algeria too and perhaps Egypt as well with Italy, since across the whole community — and I mean the entire TSOs community in North Africa, southern Europe and the Balkans — there is discussion about the possibility of handling a different energy flow from the south toward the north. Bearing in mind that, when you talk about Photovoltaic in southern Italy, you're talking about 2000 hours of productivity.
Stefano Antonio Donnarumma
executiveIf you head to northern Africa, you can get 3000 hours there as well. That means productivity is entirely different, with lower energy costs in that region. So when it comes to how renewables are evolving, the energy transition, Italy's central role, and this network within this whole system, I'd say it truly is a revolution. Our company, More Grow Company, is one that delivers results as well as satisfaction and dividends for shareholders, but it is also a company that must handle a target that right now is, you could say, geopolitical, or energy independence and security. I think that's enough information on this. Then may I ask Agostino whether you'd like to move on to the third question, about working capital?
Agostino Scornajenchi
executiveYes. Once more, regarding how working capital moves, I can only say again what I just mentioned: it is basically a buildup of payables tied to pass-through items that ought to be settled by year-end. However, to clear those items, we have to await a specific resolution from the energy authority. That resolution did not arrive in time. So we do anticipate getting that resolution at some point in 2023. That is the reason we expect to take this amount back in over the months ahead. As for your final question, if I may, Stefano, on Tamini and Brugg, the contribution from Tamini Brugg was genuinely favorable when it comes to generating revenue. Naturally, we have also looked at a huge rise in costs, particularly those linked to metal, copper and aluminum, which are the raw materials mainly used by those companies, and they went up a great deal. So, net-net, the contribution came out neutral, but we have a substantially larger pipeline for 2023 and we hold genuinely favorable expectations for the 2023 result.
Operator
operatorOur following question comes from Jose Ruiz at Barclays. Your line is open, so please proceed.
José Ruiz
analystYes, good afternoon, and thank you for taking my questions. I have three questions, and all of them relate to the 10-year development plan. The first one: in the next update of your CapEx plan, can we translate that 17% increase directly into a 17% increase in CapEx? My second question is, of that 17% increase from 23 to 2032, how much reflects cost inflation? I mean, we have seen cost inflation heating other interconnection projects, for example, Spain and Italy, with cost increases of around 37%. And my third question is just the time allocation, so the €11 billion hyperlink project, how much is included up until 2032, and how much falls beyond 2032? Thank you very much.
Stefano Antonio Donnarumma
executiveAll right, that's all clear. So in our actual industrial plan — the 21 to 25 one — you'll only see a small amount of this increase, because, as I said earlier, planning and construction of our network takes 8, 9, 10 years. So the majority of this increase will fall in the second portion of the plan. So, in the second five years, so to speak. That is, between 26, 27 through 31. And to address the last question: when you mention hyper grades, the extra €11 billion, that forms part of the €21 billion. You need to bear in mind that the whole project is worth roughly €50 billion. And in the first 10 years — since we are required to plan for just 10 years, because it's an Italian rule we must comply with, together with ARERA and the ministry — we show only the initial 10 years, with the €21 billion. A significant share of that €21 billion also involves hyper grid connections, because we changed the priority. And as I explained earlier regarding hyper grid, some of these investments are simpler than others, let's say, when it comes to construction, authorization and timing. But regardless, over a total period of 15 years, we will have spending of approximately €50 billion.
Stefano Antonio Donnarumma
executiveNow, on that cost inflection point—in our planning we use roughly 4% for the calculation—but please keep in mind that when we talk about realization and the return on these investments, our regulatory rules also take the inflection into account. So for us, up to certain values, the inflection really isn't an issue—in fact, it may even be an opportunity. Agostino?
Agostino Scornajenchi
executiveYes. And once Stefano is included, naturally, a few particular points come up regarding cable substation transformers. Market pressure is significant for that type of infrastructure. And naturally, over there you can also see that you wind up paying even more. All right. Since competition is intense, particularly around the critical components needed for the high voltage grid, above all in submarine and underground cables.
José Ruiz
analystThat's very clear.
Agostino Scornajenchi
executiveThanks.
Operator
operatorMarcin Wojtal from Bank of America is up next for a question. Your line is open, so please go ahead.
Marcin Wojtal
analystYes. Good afternoon, and thanks for taking my questions. So, first off — first question: once you're permitted returns, would you be able to say where you expect your allowed return to be set in 2024, taking into account the effect of what's called the trigger mechanism? Yeah, based on the current mark-to-market. Next question — that's a small detail, but it concerns your discontinued operations, which produced a loss of 20 million in 2022. Is it right to expect those discontinued operations to be essentially at zero in 2023, given that you've already divested all of your Latin American assets? And I think lastly, if I may ask, do you have plans to organize a capital market today this year where you could perhaps offer more comprehensive earnings guidance for the next five years? Thank you.
Stefano Antonio Donnarumma
executiveOn the WACC figure, based on what we've seen in the numbers so far, it could land at roughly 5.5 or around 5.6 — close to the level we had before the reduction a couple of years back. But we'll see. In any event, our current simulation sits near that level. As for the third question — the plan, the new plan, the updated plan — I believe it might be feasible before the end of this year. It could be worth mentioning during this period, since we need a clearer picture of the discussions with the authority over the second half of the year. So, to give you a sense: we're operating in very solid continuity, with our results improving, and the outlook for 2023 looks really good, and in a certain way we also see continuity and growth with 2024, even though we haven't calculated it yet — we're in a comfortable position. Right now, we'd rather get clarity on what the discussion with the authority will be through year-end.
Stefano Antonio Donnarumma
executiveAnd we can provide an update on the plan, along with the specific figure for WACC and for the incentive that was calculated during this year. So I think that comes in this period. As for the second question, if you would like to, Agostino…
Agostino Scornajenchi
executiveThat's right. We aren't anticipating any meaningful positive or negative effect from the discontinued operation—particularly Latin America—in 2023.
Marcin Wojtal
analystAlright, thanks so much.
Operator
operatorOur next question comes from Davide Candela at Intesa Sanpaolo. Your line is open, so please go ahead.
Davide Candela
analystHello, and good afternoon, gentlemen. Thank you for taking my question. I have three. The first is a follow-up on the National Development Plan. I was wondering whether the investment included in the plan also covers some offshore wind capacity that should be connected to the Italian grid, if this capacity comes onstream in the next years. And also on this aspect, whether Terna is the company that will be in charge of the connection for this kind of plan. Just a more general question on this aspect. And the second one relates to the European Commission proposal on the new electricity market design. And I was wondering if you can share with us a general view of your thoughts about the proposal and what the role of the TSOs could be with regard to the new proposal, if this is approved by the European Commission. And the third one, I was wondering if you can share with us some thoughts about your refinancing needs. And considering that, if I'm not wrong, you have about €1 billion maturing this year and a further €800 million in 2024. Thank you.
Stefano Antonio Donnarumma
executiveOn the — thanks for the question. On the first one, when we talk about the plan, when we put the plan together — the 10-year plan — our starting point is what the system needs, and what the system needs right now is to enable roughly 70 gigawatts of renewables to be added, mostly located in southern Italy and central Italy, since that reflects how things are actually distributed today. When I say 70 gigawatts, I mean not just solar but wind as well. We can't say where it will actually get built, but we do know that, beyond the existing requests or connection applications for offshore and onshore wind installations, some of this falls into that category. So it matters to understand that we're building a grid capable of moving that energy from the south to the north, and that includes the islands and international connections. We don't include in the plant the direct final connection to the — say, to the wind plant, the offshore wind plant. Keep in mind that to hook up one or two gigawatts of plant — an offshore plant — you need to build a connection that could cost on the order of 1 billion.
Stefano Antonio Donnarumma
executiveAt our plant, that last mile of connection isn’t defined, let me put it that way, or it will be realized, because that actually sits at the end of the proposal from the company or operator putting forward this installation. At a later stage, perhaps we’ll be involved as something like a service company—an engineering service company, let me say—or it may be possible that, in talks with the authority, we’ll determine that this will form part of the national grid. This isn’t an issue only in Italy; it’s a discussion actually also under way in other countries, in the north, in the North Sea. They have a choice, a certain model in the United States. They are talking about another model. So this model isn’t ready at the moment. Thus, in our plan, you don’t see the money needed to connect the final mile of this plant. But you do see the networks required to bring all this energy from us in the south to the north. Then on the second—on the second point, if you want Agostino to say something about the process in Europe for the market.
Agostino Scornajenchi
executiveYes, absolutely. There's plenty of debate going on right now at the European level about reforming the market. Things are also shifting around a fair bit. Different stances have emerged on whether nuclear generation should be part of the framework or not. That conversation keeps moving forward and then stalling again. In my view, the biggest chunk of the discussion will centre on market design — in particular, whether to keep or, let me put it this way, modify the rules governing how prices are formed. As things stand today, the system remains one built on the system marginal price. We're all aware that the system marginal price is heavily influenced by the price of gas. And you know better than we do that this is the elephant in the room. Because the more you push on renewable and that the more you keep this renewable connected with the price of gas, you more will be complicated to reduce the total cost of energy, given that it will remain connected with a specific commodity that you cannot control, at least that we cannot control as fair, but also as nation, given that we don't have relevant sources of natural gas that we can control.
Agostino Scornajenchi
executiveWe’re required to purchase. We bought a large amount of gas from Russia. Now we’ve altered those flows. We purchased substantial gas volumes from other nations, but regardless, our own gas isn’t what we’re discussing. So it would be worthwhile to examine whether gas pricing could be separated from the overall price of electricity. There’s a constructive conversation about the relevance, the increasing relevance of long-term contracts, and that’s something we do value. I believe both conversations should be tracked, and we’ll continue tracking those conversations over the coming months. On your third question, regarding our refinancing needs, assume we anticipate roughly a couple of million euros in 2023, including €1 billion of standard bonds to be refinanced, €700 million of inflation-linked bonds that ultimately mature in 2023. Plus a normalized €300 million of bank loans requiring refinancing, and assume an additional €1.2 billion in 2024. Let me say that, as usual, we face no kind of pressure doing this. We keep viewing the market not as an obligation but more as an opportunity.
Agostino Scornajenchi
executiveAs I've mentioned previously, our debt structure is extremely solid, with an appropriate level of debt indexed at a fixed rate. The average cost of our debt remains quite low — we're around 1.3. New debt will, naturally, carry a higher cost, but we're genuinely resilient, and going forward we anticipate only a marginal adjustment to our cost of debt.
Davide Candela
analystAppreciate it.
Operator
operatorOur following question comes from Emanuele Oggioni at Kepler Cheuvreux. Your line is open, so please go ahead.
Emanuele Oggioni
analystGood evening, everyone, and thanks for the presentation. There's one question I still have regarding the totex mechanism. I was wondering whether you might explain, or perhaps give us additional detail on — taking the United States <<inaudible>> as the basis. Now, I realize the discussion around data is rather extensive, so everything is still in progress. But how would the totex mechanism, once the current period ends, affect the incentive scheme that is output-based at present? And, still on the totex mechanism, my understanding is that — each individual project of — essentially, CapEx on every individual project is going to be reviewed and approved by the authority. So, going forward, should we see an inflationary environment, perhaps a cap would be placed on the — on the projects, on the CapEx for every project. Is that correct? Thank you.
Stefano Antonio Donnarumma
executiveThanks for that question. I’ll begin at the start, though I want to address the final part first: it isn’t fully accurate, and we’ll explain the reason now. In any event, beginning at the start, please keep in mind that the totex methods are only now being tested in a particular manner by has — together with Terna, using the MSD methodology. It was designed precisely to deliver an output-based impact that is clearly defined — an example, let me say — beforehand with the authority and to produce a measurable effect on the system. Keep in mind that over the last year we generated an impact for the end customer of roughly €2 billion in reduced dispatching costs. That is truly an enormous amount, an incredible amount when you consider that we went from something like €18 of cost of — period cost to 0.8, 0.9 during the most recent period. So it’s genuinely interesting. And also <<inaudible>> a great deal because this is the first experiment, a concrete experiment in Italy for a first approach to how to put be and totex. On the second point you raise, I’ll ask Agostino, if you would, to explain more clearly the totex approach for the future that we are providing.
Agostino Scornajenchi
executiveYes, Stefano. Thank you. I've mentioned this a number of times — it's a gradual shift away from a fully input-based principle, where basically you get paid according to what you spend, toward an output-based approach, as Stefano said, where you'll receive a growing contribution in proportion to the benefits you create for the system. So that's the authorization principle, and the totex mechanism will be applied in this area. You've already seen this happening in our business plan and in our figures. You'll recall that we began with an output-based contribution of €200 in the previous business plan, rising to €244, then to €500, then up to €600. And today we've just made clear that you can expect something more for the future as well. What will the authority do to measure? The question is whether the authorities will start measuring 100% of individual projects. We don't expect that. We rather expect a sort of mixed regime, where we'll have a sort of base remuneration still managed through an input-based approach to an average work on invested capital. And on top of that, some output-based contribution starting from the biggest project. Why the biggest project?
Agostino Scornajenchi
executiveSince the largest initiative—the MSD experiment—is the big project, it will be the simplest to measure: it's easy to evaluate, it demonstrates a positive contribution, and the authority allowed us to keep part of that extra marginality, plus there's the enormous community benefit Stefano described. That's how we look at it. That said, a discussion is still open. The authority is going to issue some resolution in the second part of the year. And naturally, we'll keep you updated on how this process unfolds.
Emanuele Oggioni
analystThat’s very clear. Thank you.
Operator
operatorOur following question comes from Bartek Kubicki.
Bartek Kubicki
analystThanks a lot, and good evening. I have just 2 remaining questions, if I may. First, regarding your regulated OpEx, excluding IFRIC: OpEx rose 15% year-on-year in 2022. I'm curious what the dynamics for OpEx might look like in 2023, given that your headcount continues to grow. And as a result, whether the regulator will factor in the entire OpEx increase in the next regulatory period. That's the first one. Second, on the plan — again, in my view, the plan relies heavily on large projects. So I'm wondering whether you're considering bringing in partners on some of those projects, or whether there's a risk the regulator could introduce some form of competition into the model, so that others — other players — would also be permitted to build such massive projects. Thank you very much.
Stefano Antonio Donnarumma
executiveAgostino, would you mind kicking things off with the first question, and I …
Agostino Scornajenchi
executiveRight, of course. So OpEx is climbing in 2022. A portion of that comes from certain extraordinary items tied to letting staff go, and we've already recognized some severance costs in 2022. Beyond that, there are also particular external communication expenses — covering webcast advertising as well as TV advertising — that fall under a specific arrangement with the energy authority. Every bit of that cost gets recovered through the tariff in the usual manner.
Stefano Antonio Donnarumma
executiveThank you, Agostino. On that second point — no, your hypothesis is interesting, but we don't believe we should move in that direction. As of now, our intention remains to stay the sole company, the monopolist of the network in Italy. And we are 100% certain that over the next 10 years we will be able to sustain this kind of plan. From the financial standpoint as well, we have solutions and we have room for this. Perhaps the only interesting angle is having technological partners down the road. That's a separate topic, a separate point, given the major difficulties worldwide stemming from the growth in the overall volume of investment in networks — in transport and network in Europe in particular, but not only there. So it matters to establish a sound approach on the, let me say, technology side — so cables or transformers. And certain components and accessories — it matters to establish what the right path forward is for finding possible cooperation. But when it comes to managing — management of the network and ownership of the network, no, I see no chance.
Bartek Kubicki
analystI really appreciate it.
Operator
operatorLooks like we don’t have any more questions right now. I’ll hand things back to the CEO and the CFO so they can close out.
Stefano Antonio Donnarumma
executiveThanks to all of you, and thank you.
Operator
operatorThat brings us to the end of today's event. Thanks for joining us. You can go ahead and disconnect now.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Terna S.p.A. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Terna S.p.A. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Terna S.p.A. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.