Terna S.p.A. (TRN) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

May 5, 2023

Borsa Italiana IT Utilities Electric Utilities earnings 39 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Hello, everyone, and welcome to the call covering Terna's consolidated results for the first quarter of 2023. I'm George, and I'll be coordinating today's event. Please be aware that this conference is being recorded, and throughout the call your lines will remain in listen-only mode. That said, you'll have a chance to ask questions once the presentation is finished. <<operator_script>> At this point I'd like to pass the call to your host for today, Mr. Agostino Scornajenchi, so that today's conference can get underway. Please go ahead, sir.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#2

Good afternoon, everyone, and welcome to the Terna First Quarter 2023 results presentation. This was the final set of results published before next week's AGM. As we remind you, its agenda includes, among our items, the renewal of the Board of Directors. As usual, before starting to analyze the figures, I would like to share with you the latest main achievements of the company. Without being regulated activities, let me remind you that on the 16th of March, we published the new 10-year National Development Plan, which foresees more than 21 billion of investment confirming our key role as energy transition enabler, the investments foreseen in this new National Development Plan, aimed at continuing the integration of renewable sources in the progressive phase out of coal fired power plants, in line with the targets set at national and international level. Our over March thermosyphon agreements with the European Investment Bank for the second and third tranches of the 1.9 billion loan for the uranium in the submarine cable connecting the Italian peninsula, with CCD and then to Sardinia. The contract signed established a fourth or two tranches totaling €900 million for the construction and the commissioning of the east and west sections of the perennially.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#3

When it comes to DC infrastructure, we'll be fully up and running in its entirety by 2028, and Terna plants is planning an overall investment of roughly 3.7 billion. Last, on Terna's financial structure: on the 14th of February, the company successfully launched a fixed rate single trench bond issue totaling €750 million. That issuance got a great response from the market, with demand outstripping supply by nearly four times the offer, and the amount represents part of the €19 medium-term notes program. The bond carries a duration of 60-years and will pay a component of 3.625%, well below the market standard for this period. The proceeds will be allocated to meet the ordinary financial requirement and to fund the needs of the groups in that plan. After this basic introduction, let me give you the usual overview of the dynamic electricity market. Turning to the next slide. And now at Page 5. As you can see from this chart, in the first three months of 2023 national demand was about 77 terawatt hours, a decrease of 4% versus last year when national demand was about 81 terawatt hours. The reduction in electricity demand observed in the first three-months of the year shows a decrease in trend compared to the same period of last year.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#4

The rise in average temperatures and the drop in industrial consumption are the main reasons for this. And in the first quarter of 2023, renewable sources met roughly 20% of national demand, a slight increase compared with last year. As for national net total production, it came in at 64 terawatt hours, 10% below the same period of 2022. Even so, let me point to the growth in solar generation, which was up 4% versus 2022, and let me also note that during this first quarter, renewable sources met about 36% of national net total generation. Now let's turn to the period's main features. The first three months of the year remain marked by a complex scenario. Despite the difficult and highly volatile environment, Terna posted a significant improvement in both economic and financial indicators. Indeed, group revenues and EBITDA rose by 11% and 8%, respectively, versus last year, which is 68 million and 3 9 million above the first quarter 2022, while group net income was €200 million, an increase of 4% versus last year. Group CapEx came to 350 million, 7% more than the first quarter 2022, once again confirming Terna's CapEx acceleration, driven by growing system needs to ensure efficiency, resiliency and security of supply, in line with Terna's institutional role for the country.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#5

By the close of March 2023, net debt stood at 8.8 billion, compared with roughly 8.6 billion at the end of 2022, and it was completely in line with what we had expected internally. Now, if we turn to the next slide, Page 8, I'll go into a more detailed review of the first quarter 2023 numbers. Total revenues for the first quarter of 2023 rose 10.6%, coming in at 730 million, which is 68 million above last year, and as you can see, we posted positive results from both regulated and non-regulated activities, contributing 52 million and 60 million, respectively. To walk through the renewals evolution in detail, let's go to Slide 9. Regulated revenues came to 614 million, 52 million better than last year, which works out to roughly 9.2% more than the same period of 2022. That increase was mainly driven by a higher output-based incentives effect tied to the greater benefits generated for the system. Non-regulated revenue was 99 million, 19.7% higher versus last year. The non-regulated result was mainly attributable to the larger contribution from Brooke and Kamini, the growing revenues of the energy solution business directed to the LC group, and the start of operations of the private section of the Italy-France interconnector. International revenues were at about zero, in accordance with IFRS 5 accounting standards referring to assets held for sale.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#6

Moving on to the analysis of operating costs. Our total operating costs came in at 113 million, which is 16.1% above the figure for the same period a year earlier. When it comes to regulated activities, the rise was primarily driven by bringing in new competencies and a higher level of activity, whereas non-regulated activities were affected chiefly by greater costs for raw material purchases tied to group and meaning, as well as by the LT group contribution. Let me turn now to EBITDA, on Slide 11. Taking into account the facts I just mentioned, group EBITDA for the first quarter of 2023 came to €500 million, up 8.4% compared with the same period of last year. Nearly all of that increase came from related activities, which added roughly 38 million versus the first three months of last year, delivering EBITDA of 486 million in the first quarter of 2023. Now let's look at the lower section of the profit and loss statement. Moving to the next slide. Procession and amortization totaled 187 million. The rise relative to the same period of last year stemmed mainly from the effect of new assets coming into operation during the period. As a result, EBIT came in at 313 million, 6.7% above the first quarter of 2022. We recorded net financial expenses of 32 million.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#7

The year-over-year increase was driven primarily by inflation that occurred during the period, which affected our inflation-linked exposure, along with higher interest rates seen in the capital market. Access came to that 81 million, five million above the equivalent period a year earlier, essentially as a result of higher profit. The tax rate was 28.9%. Consequently, group net income came in at €200 million, 4.4% above the same period a year earlier. Turning to the CapEx analysis on Page 13. During the first quarter of 2023, total CapEx was 350 million, roughly 7% above last year, confirming the strong acceleration in CapEx that is fully in line with the target set in the NASA plan. In fact, we put about 288 million into regulated activities. Among those, one project worth noting is the Turanian link, the LBMA, literally the paternal Pantanal, which we have in eastern Sicily, plus investments in stabilization devices like synchronous compensators for grid security. As for the CapEx categories, development CapEx accounts for that 43% of total regulated CapEx. The same CapEx was at 13%, whereas asset renewal and efficiency made up 44%. New regulated and other CapEx amounted to 27 million.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#8

That covers capitalized financial charges and other investments. Now on net debt and cash flow analysis, let's turn to the following slide. At the close of March 2023, net debt came in at 8,847 million, which is 271 million above the 2022 year-end level, mainly tied to the gradual settlement of metric tables relating to 2022. Over the period, operating cash flow generated reached 368 million, and thanks to that we were in a position to cover all CapEx spending for the period. Let's now take a deeper look at our debt profile. Going to Page 16. This reflects our efficient and productive approach to debt management over the last few years. At the end of March 2023, the six over floating ratio and gross debt came in at roughly 87%, while average duration was around five-years. As already noted in March, Terna signed contracts with the European Investment Bank covering the second and third tranches of the 1.9 billion loan for the perennially. Following the first tranche of €500 million assigned at the beginning of November, the loan representative covers two tranches totaling €900 million for the construction and commissioning of the East Branch and the West Branch of the submarine cable.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#9

These loans run for roughly 22 years starting from the initial disbursement date. That feature means a longer tenor, and they are more competitive on both counts than the currencies you can find in the market. So they form part of a fairness policy aimed at optimizing its financial structure. Lastly, on February 14, Terna successfully resolved a major single transport issue. The bond, totaling €750 million, was issued at 99.281% with a spread of 70 basis points over the network, carries a maturity of six years, and pays an annual coupon of 3.625%. Now, before we move to the Q&A session, let me also stress this after band of this first quarter. In fact, we are well on track with executing our plan, and we are confident about maintaining our strategic path toward the energy transition going forward as well. Thank you very much for your attention. I'm now ready for the Q&A session. Thank you.

Operator

operator
#10

Thanks, operator. <<operator_script>> The first question we have today comes from Mr. Javier Suarez at Mediobanca. Sir, the floor is yours.

Javier Suárez

analyst
#11

Hello everyone, and thanks for the presentation. My first question follows up on the CFO's last statement. Hopefully this is still a valid question, given the recent management changes following the Annual General Meeting. What I'd like to ask is whether there have been any notable shifts in the company's statistical path, and any color you can offer on that would be very welcome. That's my first question. My second question concerns the positive deviation versus what I take to be expectations for this quarter. I believe that stems from a higher collection of out-of-date incentives, so could you please quantify how much of those out-of-date incentives was collected during the quarter, and give an update on your expectation for the full year? My third question concerns the recent documentaries director with the definition of the general guidelines for implementing the tax system in Italy from 2024. Could you share the brilliance of this document and your latest view on how these might affect their business plans going forward? Thank you.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#12

Thank you so much, Javier. I'll begin with your second question and then return to the first one. We'll see — correctly speaking, the results for the first quarter of 2023 are affected by greater output-based incentives. Relative to what had originally been anticipated, this is something we already examined at the close of 2022. What I can confirm is that across 2023, we do expect roughly €300 million in output-based incentives, of which two thirds — so you can figure about €200 million — is tied to MSD incentives. On the subject of the gradual regulatory shift and, as they put it, the loss implementation: first of all, let me remind everyone that we firmly believe bringing in loss would align with the direction we are already pursuing. This output-based approach is something we have discussed before. The greater the benefits we deliver for the system, the greater the rewards we could secure. As a result of that invoice approach, we see a chance to generate filter value for the system and for shareholders, since this could encourage, let me say, overall efficiency via new output-based regulatory measures. We are entirely committed to doing so, and we are pleased about the steps the authority has taken with the resolution of and out of the base incentives.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#13

To give a bit more detail, at the end of April — if I recall correctly, it was 20 April 2023 — ARERA issued a specific resolution approving the 24 Tier 2/1 Ross regulated integrative text, which at this point contains the general principles and the criteria for setting the allowed cost for that period. With this resolution — what we'd call the initial one on the general principles — but it matters, because through it ARERA confirms the gradual approach to integrating the auto regulation, looking at the first phase, the so-called SPC Ross base framework. We are — at the start, the standard is what we're allowed in substantial continuity with the current rules, and overall expenditure will be split between slow money components and fast money components according to their capitalization rate. I think that's what we have in front of us up to today. We do expect clarification of porta de from the authority, and we'll come back to you as soon as possible on this. As for your first question about the potential impact coming from the change in the management — well, as I said, it's pretty simple. You can assume that at Terna we will continue to pursue the goal of driving the energy transition process, supporting the country and this, let me say, difficult task.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#14

We consistently deliver top-tier, cutting-edge services while guaranteeing supply security and efficiency for end users. Being on the management team, I know firsthand how much responsibility this position carries. With the upcoming appointment of <<inaudible>>, who offers broad technical expertise in building and rolling out critical networks, along with managerial capabilities and business foresight, I have no doubt whatsoever that Terna will keep growing and reinforcing its part in supporting the country's development of the future electricity system.

Operator

operator
#15

Thanks, sir. The next question we have today comes from Stefano Gamberini of Equita. Sir, please go ahead.

Stefano Gamberini

executive
#16

Good afternoon, everyone. I’d like to follow up on the question about the simplified topics. Specifically, the fact that the regulator will monitor the return, or introduce the return on regulatory equity. So what’s your comment on this measure—could the regulator then share the excess return with clients, would you expect that? Second, regarding the government’s aim to require public companies to use the NIP funds: which projects in your business plan could be financed through these measures, and could you receive some form of remuneration if you use this money—otherwise, we know that this should be deducted by the ramp? Last question regarding the net working capital, where you experienced a positive impact of around one billion at the end of the years—you underline €300 million more or less—we already restored in the first quarter; was it the surpass of the full suite invest trend for this US$1 billion, when will this be fully restored? And very finally, sorry, as we got the storage: your 10-year development plan includes 70 gigawatts of new installed capacity, renewable installed capacity, but also 11 gigabytes of utility scale storages.

Stefano Gamberini

executive
#17

Can you tell us whether anything is shifting—what incentives is the government developing to speed up investment in our store? In particular, might that end up being directly tied to storages at some point, sooner or later? Thanks a lot.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#18

Stefano, please keep all of those questions in mind as well — I’ll give them a try. Starting with the first one.

Stefano Gamberini

executive
#19

I could say that again.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#20

I understand. I'm confident on that point. So regarding the implementation — and remuneration on equity — I think it's a bit too early to offer comments. We don't have that information yet. As I mentioned earlier, the resolution adopted by the authority at the end of April, and the initial joint general principles, are more or less aligned and confirm what we expected beforehand. But let me address these points. Again, we have no concern whatsoever about how this new mechanism will be implemented. Ultimately, we do anticipate benefits. Naturally, there will be managerial efforts, given that our capacity to control the business in real time and to supply the data — let me see — to remain up to date on efficiency in our projects, particularly regarding the match and the timings, will be more critical going forward. But I believe we are very well prepared for that. And as we said last week, in the second part of the year at the moment, we will receive more detailed information from our ARERA, and we will be more than happy to share it with you.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#21

On your second question about BM and what the error implies for us: as we mentioned earlier when discussing residual implication, our business case is a remunerated business case within our regulated space. Whenever public incentives come in, we deduct them from the RAP. So under the current regulation, I don't see much interest on our side in pursuing this. Naturally, if we can contribute to realizing national critical infrastructure, we would be more than happy to do so. Certain projects have already been identified under that agreement. For us, I view this as a residual option. On your third question, networking capital: we hired in Q1 2023. Typically in the first quarter your working capital deteriorates, since there are out-of-payments tied to investments — meaning accounted invoices received late in the prior year. So that is the standard, the duration of that. On top of it, we have the progressive selection of the advantage obtained for it in 2022. At present, from that we move to regulatory items we could not liquidate with our market counterparts, due to a lack of resolution that the authority was unable to take in time by year-end.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#22

So they've begun, and we do anticipate a gradual reabsorption of the amount you saw at the close of 2022, happening over the second half of 2023. On storage: it's a critical item, especially as we raise our expectations for renewables—the more we do that, the more we'll require regulation, storage, and stabilization of the system, and storage is going to play a crucial role in this. As things stand today, from a formal and political standpoint, nothing changes; we aren't permitted to play any role in storage. We would be more than happy to have a discussion on that and to offer our ideas and contribution. I do expect we could facilitate and make a good contribution toward countering—that's also on this front.

Stefano Gamberini

executive
#23

That's very clear. Thank you very much.

Operator

operator
#24

Thanks. We move on to our following question, which comes from Mr. James Brand at Deutsche Bank. Sir, the floor is yours.

James Brand

analyst
#25

Hey there — another solid quarter. I was hoping you could expand a little on the incentives side, since you've set that 300 million target. Could you walk us through what you're actually doing to make those incentives happen? And specifically, you've performed really strongly against the targets tied to lowering system costs — you've brought system cost down fairly dramatically. I'd genuinely like to hear what you're doing on that front and how you've gone about achieving that reduction.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#26

We're right in line with what we announced two years ago. Across the different years, the average weight of the output-based incentive will rise all along the way. As a reminder, today the business plan carries a general target of €500 million, and we're extremely well on track to hit it. That wasn't the situation just a few years back — it was 250, the prior business plan 200, and before that. So as we move further toward the future, these aspects will play an ever-greater role. Going into the details here, we're discussing incentives aimed at creating efficiency when it comes to reducing the price difference internally across the different electricity zone energy areas, and also between the different zones. Stabilization of prices across the different geographical areas — it's an ambitious target. And I believe we're well on track to reach it, and this is something we also began in the past. As a reminder, back in 2017 we already started doing something similar by introducing the interconnection. The agenda, the sequence through which we managed to cut the price difference among the different zones in some parts of the country, expressing a big value.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#27

We're doing the same thing today, and since last year we've also been putting a lot of work into lowering MSD costs. As you know, MSD makes up a significant portion of overall energy costs. We fully adopted our inspection strategy. Trying to bring that cost down for the end user isn't an easy job. I believe the team has done an outstanding job. Since we made that decision, we've moved into something entirely new — let me put it as deploying many IT tools. Plus plenty of technical tools, such as stabilization devices and synchronous compensators, so we can cut as far as possible the need to call on — forgive the non-technical wording — emergency services, which are truly, truly costly for the system. In 2022 we achieved the first major result, the one we've already talked about, the one we'll return to by date. We covered it in March when we presented the direct financial statement, and we're continuing along that same path for 2023 as well. As I said earlier, we anticipate at least €300 million by year-end from our current incentive, with MSD incentives making up the main portion of that.

James Brand

analyst
#28

Thanks a lot. That’s everything from me once more.

Operator

operator
#29

Thanks, sir. Next up is Sarah Lester from Morgan Stanley. The floor is yours.

Sarah Lester

analyst
#30

Thank you very much for the chance to ask. I actually have two. Apologies — I want to press a bit further regarding output-based incentives, and I realize the regulation on this has now been finalized. Still, I’m curious how confident you are that the regulator will permit the levels of output-based incentives you’re delivering to keep going on a continuous and lasting basis. So past, let’s say, 1 or 2 years, do you believe the regulator is fine with those levels becoming normalized should they continue? And second, regarding grid connection requests and wait times, any fresh commentary on what you’re observing there would be excellent, plus any commentary on renewables permitting and the bottleneck that exists?

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#31

To put it briefly, what should be expected is that the long-term will be represented by wash. Right now, the regulator is in the process of writing the rules. As we see an interim period tested several times, we will add — and personally, I do expect — a sort of mixed regime that will have a joint component of a basal regulation and investment capital and additional regulatory regulation nowadays, with the Ross mechanism. Today, we already have some clear signs of the ultra bass principle represented by this specific project I mentioned before: reduction of price difference among different zones, internally the different zones, reduction in MSP costs. So today, we have specific big projects that have set the stage to be easy to be measured. In the future, we will have a more complicated system. Now they will change. Meaning that I do expect, as we demonstrated last year and that we are going to fit in this year with the results representing today. This will require additional managerial effort, but this will put us in the position also to obtain additional results.

Sarah Lester

analyst
#32

Thanks.

Operator

operator
#33

The following question comes from Marcin Wojtal at Bank of America. Go ahead.

Marcin Wojtal

analyst
#34

Good afternoon. If I may, just one question. I'd like to ask about how your operating expenses have evolved within your regulated perimeter. I believe they rose roughly 13% in QR, which is, let's say, in line with — or perhaps above — the rate of inflation in Italy. For the remainder of the year, would you expect your operating expenses to keep climbing at a comparable rate, or, given that inflation is beginning to normalize, would you also expect last compensation? Thank you.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#35

Okay, so overall in sales, there are two separate reasons behind the increase in operating expenses. When you look back at the stand, you'll notice they've gone up within the regulator business, and that stems from the effort we're making to expand or tighten up our internal organization so it can keep pace with growing activity. Let me remind you that the 2023 CapEx target stands at 2.2 billion. That's not far off three times the goal we set just two years back, with the 2018 facility sitting well under one billion. We're permitted to do that without tripling staff or operating expenses, but naturally we have to keep reinforcing — that's the reason we've stepped up our hiring process, and we'll exceed 5,000 FTE by the end of 2022, and we do expect further growth in 2023 as well. So we're strengthening our staff and bringing in different competencies. And naturally, we're definitely feeling the impact of external costs. This is also referred to as current and entirely consistent with the targets we've communicated — no surprises there. Naturally, part of that increase — sorry, this applies to the related business.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#36

The second commenter is here on behalf of the business. We're expanding <<inaudible>>, we're growing, and orders have absolutely exploded in the backdrops. And of course, we're more than happy to have that, but we also have to bear an increase in raw material prices. So that's the explanation for the €15 million increase you see on page 10 for the -. Both elements: operating costs are regulated, and operating costs on non-regulated sites are of course affected by inflation, that kind of impact, but you know that this inflection is in any case fully covered by our regulatory system on the regulated part. Maybe with a bit of timeline, maybe we'll have a short-term impact on our cash or something negligible if you keep comparing it with the sides of the credit lines that we do have. So an increase of OpEx due to acceleration of inflation dynamics will be offset by higher allowed CapEx that will be recognized in the time. Finally, regarding my expectation, on inflation that is pretty seems complicated to take a position on that. What we do expect and we will continue to see some increase until the second part of the year and we do expect the starting from October before we should see some sign of stabilization in inflation rates.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#37

That is the picture as things stand right now. Naturally, this is a volatile item, and we'll need to keep watching it, and naturally, we'll keep you updated.

Marcin Wojtal

analyst
#38

I appreciate that.

Operator

operator
#39

Thanks a lot, sir. Since it looks like there are no more questions right now, I'll hand the call back to Scornajenchi for any extra or closing comments. Thank you.

Agostino Scornajenchi

executive
#40

Ladies and gentlemen, I really appreciate the time, the attention, and the patience you devote to answering. Let me note that we'll be waiting for you with a new CEO at the end of July, when the first-half 2023 financial statements are presented. Many thanks.

Operator

operator
#41

Thank you, sir. Ladies and gentlemen, that brings today's presentation to a close. We appreciate your participation. You may disconnect at this time.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Terna S.p.A. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Terna S.p.A. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Terna S.p.A. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.