Terna S.p.A. (TRN) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
November 8, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorGood afternoon, everyone, and welcome to the presentation of Terna's consolidated results for 9 Months 2023. <<operator_script>> I'd like to let you know that this conference is being recorded today. Now I'll turn the conference over to today's host speaker, Mr. Omar Al Bayaty, who leads Investor Relations and Sustainability. Please go ahead, sir.
Omar Al-Bayaty
executiveGood afternoon, everyone, and welcome to the Terna 9 month '23 Results Presentation. Our CFO, Francesco Beccali, is hosting today's call. After the presentation, there will be a Q&A session. We kindly ask that you send any questions to investor.relations@terna.it. Francesco, please, the floor is yours.
Francesco Beccali
executiveThank you, Omar, and good afternoon, everyone. Before I begin, I want to say that taking on this new challenge makes me genuinely proud, and I'd like to express my gratitude to the company for this opportunity, which I'm embracing with plenty of energy, interaction and commitment, fully aware from my experience of Terna's <<inaudible>>. Now let me walk you through the period's main achievements. On regulated activities, I can say we are tracking really well when it comes to authorization processes and the procurement of the key projects in our strategic plan. Indeed, in September, the Ministry of Environment and Energy Securities authorized the Western range of the Turanian link and the final project of the SEC oil 3. As you know, the Turanian link is a direct current submarine power line that will connect Sardinia, CCD and <<inaudible>>. It is a strategic project for the Italian Peninsula system within the framework of the energy transition targets set by the national integrated plan for energy and climate, the so-called MIX. It will contribute to achieve the phase-out of coal by increasing the transport capacity, enhancing the security, adequacy and flexibility of the National Electricity Transmission WiT as well as promoting the integration of the domestic market and renewable sources.
Francesco Beccali
executiveOn the <<inaudible>> front, the project's goal is linking Sardinia, Corsica and Pascal, with capacity reaching as much as 400 megawatts in total. After it enters service, <<inaudible>> is going to help reinforce the European electricity market, encourage growth of renewable services, and boost transport capacity linking Central and Northern Italy, CCD and Sardinia. That delivers substantial reliability plus security for the national transmission WiT, along with lower costs in the dispatching service market. Also, on procurement, early in September Terna handed out premium in the contract covering supply and lane of the submarine and underground power cables for the Adriatic Link — the 1,000-megawatt HBVC interconnection between the <<inaudible>> regions. That cable supply marks one more milestone in how quickly the project is being implemented. Turning to our sustainability results: Terna has once again confirmed its place as a worldwide sustainability leader. In fact, this marks the 13th year in a row that the company has appeared in the stock of global ESG leaders index, which picks out the strongest firms around the world according to ESG best practices. Last, on shareholder remuneration, today the Board of Directors gave approval to a 2023 interim dividend of EUR 0.1146 per share, payable at the end of this month, which is 8% higher than last year and consistent with our dividend policy.
Francesco Beccali
executiveFollowing this quick opening, let's turn to the next slide and examine the most recent electricity demand trends in Italy. This chart shows that national demand came in at roughly 233 terawatt hours during the first 9 months of 2023, which represents a 4% decline versus last year, when national demand stood at 242 terawatt hours. The drop in electricity demand over the first 9 months of the year stems chiefly from lower industrial consumption and higher average temperatures. Renewable sources met approximately 37% of national demand in the first 9 months of 2023, 5 percentage points above last year. National's net total production reached 197 terawatt hours, roughly 7% below the equivalent period in 2022. Even so, I want to point out the striking growth in hydro production, which rose 29% relative to the first 9 months of last year. In addition, renewable sources supplied around 44% of national net total production during the period under review. Let's now turn to the period's key figures. Group revenues and EBITDA each increased in the first 9 months of 2023, by 13% and 10% respectively versus last year, meaning EUR 265 million and EUR 144 million more than in the first 9 months of 2022.
Francesco Beccali
executiveGroup net income also came in at EUR 642 million, which is 9% higher than a year ago. We set group CapEx at EUR 1,434 million, a double-digit rise of 39% compared with the same period last year, confirming again the strong acceleration of our capital spending to meet system needs and enable the energy transition. To back this acceleration, at the end of September 2023 net debt was EUR 9.5 billion, versus roughly EUR 8.6 billion at 2022 year-end. Now I'll walk you through the period's figures in more depth. Turning to Slide #8. We begin with the revenue analysis. Total revenues for the first 9 months of 2023 rose 12.2%, to EUR 2,247 million, an increase of EUR 255 million year over year. Growth came from both regulated and nonrelated activities, which contributed EUR 184 million and EUR 71 million, respectively. Let's now look at the revenue evolution in detail on the next slide. Regulated revenues amounted to EUR 1,904 million, EUR 184 million above last year. That increase was driven primarily by the investment acceleration on the national win and by a higher output-based incentive effect tied to the greater benefits generated for the system.
Francesco Beccali
executiveRevenues from nonregulated and international operations came in at EUR 343 million, up 25.9% compared with a year earlier. Growth in nonrelated revenue was driven chiefly by larger contributions from Brook and Tamini, along with a bigger contribution from energy solutions, largely tied to the <<inaudible>>. Under the IFRS 5 accounting standard covering assets held for sale, international revenues were set to 0. Let's now walk through the operating cost analysis. This chart shows total operating costs of EUR 691 million, which is 19.1% above the prior year. On originated activities, the rise came mostly from insourcing new competencies and a higher level of activity, whereas nonregulated activities were affected chiefly by greater costs for purchasing raw materials and for services tied to group and LPG. Let me turn to EBITDA now. Moving to the next slide. Reflecting those effects I mentioned, <<inaudible>> group EBITDA came to EUR 1.556 billion, which is EUR 144 million better than a year ago. Regulated activities drove most of that increase, adding roughly EUR 132 million more than the same period last year and posting EBITDA of EUR 1.508 billion for the first 9 months of 2023. Let's now look at the lower part of the P&L, moving to Slide #12.
Francesco Beccali
executiveDepreciation and amortization came in at EUR 577 million. The rise compared with the prior year was driven chiefly by new assets that went into service during the period. Consequently, EBIT came to EUR 990 million, which is 9.3% above the figure posted for the 9 months of 2022. Net financial expenses were reported at EUR UR 81 million. That increase over last year stemmed mainly from the cost of the new financings and from higher interest rates, partly offset by lower inflation during the period, growth in capitalized financial expenses, and greater financial income on admirable liquidity. Taxes amounted to EUR 263 million, which is EUR 25 million more than last year, owing to higher profit as well as positive one-off items booked in the 9 months of 2022. Accordingly, our trust rate came in at 29.1%. As a result, group net income hit EUR 642 million, up 9.3% from the same period a year earlier. Turning now to the CapEx analysis. During the first 9 months of 2023, total CapEx reached EUR 1,434 million, 39% above last year, which confirms the solid acceleration consistent with our institutional role in the country. I would highlight that this represents a record-breaking CapEx level for the first 9 months of the year.
Francesco Beccali
executiveFor this, we put roughly EUR 1.36 billion into regulated activities. Among the key projects during the period, worth noting are the Iranian link, the Adriatic link, the Albanian connection, and the investments in stabilization devices such as synchro compensators. Within the CapEx categories, development CapEx accounted for 56% of total regulated cars. Fee CapEx came in at 12%, whereas asset renewal and efficiency made up 32% of the total. Nonregulated and order CapEx amounted to EUR 74 million. That figure includes capitalized financial charges as well as other investments. Turning to net debt and cash flow analysis: net debt at the close of September 2022 was approximately EUR 9.5 billion, roughly EUR 900 million above the 2022 year-end level, chiefly because of the investment made during the period and the 2022 final dividend payment in June. Over the period, we produced operating cash flow of EUR 1.168 billion, which allowed us to cover the bulk of that period's CapEx spending. Let me continue with an analysis of our debt profile, moving to Page 15. This aligns with our cautious and proactive approach to debt management, which is aimed at keeping a solid financial structure. At the end of this first 9 months, we recorded a fixed floating ratio on gross debt of approximately 87% and an average ratio of about 6 years.
Francesco Beccali
executiveOn top of that, Terna wants to position itself among the leading players in the sustainable finance markets. That approach was also confirmed over the first 9 months of this year, and while we were updating our green bond framework, Terna received from Moody's in late October the highest score available in the second-party opinion — a sustainability policy score of 1. As a reminder, in July Terna issued a 10-year fixed rate bond for a total of EUR 650 million. Demand in the market was strong, with the order book peaking at roughly 4x the offered amount, and the final spread came in at 90 basis points over mid-swap. This green bond carries a duration of 10 years and pays a coupon of 3.875%. In addition, let me mention that last May Terna signed an easing revolving credit facility totaling EUR 1.8 billion. These transactions allow Terna to rely on liquidity suited to its current rating, giving the company's financial structure a further boost. Turning to bank debt, 2 EIB loans amounting to EUR 900 million in total, intended for building and commissioning the East and West sections of the Turanian link project and signed in March, were increased in June and October, respectively.
Francesco Beccali
executiveSo to wrap up, on the back of those strong results for the period, we've reconfirmed all of the guidance for 2023, while we await the new business plan, which we expect to present by Q1 2024. Thanks for listening. We're now ready to take your questions.
Omar Al-Bayaty
executiveThanks, Francesco. Now we'll begin the Q&A. A solid batch of questions came in. Some have been grouped together. The initial group concerns the 9-month figures. The first item has to do with output base incentives, and on that topic we got 3 main questions. How many outbase incentives were recorded in 9 month '23? Is the roughly EUR 300 million expectation for the full year confirmed? And what is anticipated for the years ahead?
Francesco Beccali
executiveSo, the auto-based incentives we recognized this year come to roughly EUR 200 million. Those relate to restructuring services market efficiencies, and they're tied to cost savings from the reduction in volumes traded on the market, as well as to internal incentives linked to creating additional transport capacity among Italian pricing zones, as regulated by resolution EUR 567 million of 2019. For 2023, we're assuming outdoor based incentives of around EUR 300 million, mainly tied to dispatching service market efficiency incentives. And for the remaining years of the business plan, we expect the AutoBased incentives contribution to keep tracking consistently with the performance we'll register on the relevant KPIs.
Omar Al-Bayaty
executiveLet's turn now to the cost of debt and financial charges. First question: could you provide additional detail on the actual cost of debt and what we expect for full year '23?
Francesco Beccali
executiveOkay. At the close of the initial 9 months of 2023, our cost of debt stood at 1.7%. Regarding what we anticipate for the entire year of 2023, we project it will come in a bit under 2%, which mirrors the steep rise in interest rates seen during the most recent month tied to the company's ambitious CapEx plan.
Omar Al-Bayaty
executiveCould you provide additional detail on the financial charges for the 9 months in '23?
Francesco Beccali
executiveDuring the year's first 9 months, net financial charges came to EUR 81.2 million — an increase of roughly EUR 25 million compared with the 9 months of 2022. That rise in net financial charges stems chiefly from higher interest rates, something we also flagged during the presentation; this affects what the new debt costs as well as the floating portion of debt already outstanding, so — and it is partly offset by inflation running lower than in 2022. Beyond that, I would also point to the increase in capitalized financial expenses and to higher financial income on available liquidity, both of which help reduce the cost of debt for the period.
Omar Al-Bayaty
executiveNow let's turn to guidance and outlook. Are there any upside risks for guidance '23?
Francesco Beccali
executiveAs we mentioned in the presentation, we're reaffirming all of the 2023 guidance once again.
Omar Al-Bayaty
executiveAnd what can you tell us regarding the outlook for '24?
Francesco Beccali
executiveRegrettably, where 2024 guidance is concerned—just as was the case a year earlier—we're going to hold off until the talks now under way are finished, talks about the fresh business plan we expect to have in place, with the event, as already mentioned, by Q1 of next year.
Omar Al-Bayaty
executiveLet's turn now to execution. Can you give us any updates or specifics regarding how projects are progressing?
Francesco Beccali
executiveYes, I’d say we’re on the right track with how we’re handling utilization across structural activities and procurement, consistent with the milestones in the updated industrial plan. On authorization specifically, nearly all of the budgeted CapEx has now been authorized. As for forward contract procurement, a possible materials shortage isn’t a reentry concern for Terna, since we’ve already secured almost all the procurement requirements through the end of 2023, also thanks to <<inaudible>>.
Omar Al-Bayaty
executiveLet's turn now to a more technical question about Sedo and CPI. Any comments you'd like to offer on that flat trend when you compare it with how CPI has evolved?
Francesco Beccali
executiveThe one thing I’d say here is that, looking back, the flat trend has shown less volatility than CPI. That holds whether things are moving up or moving down.
Omar Al-Bayaty
executiveAnd let's turn to dividend policy. Any updates you can share on that front?
Francesco Beccali
executiveTo start with, I want to state that the dividend policy we have now is entirely sustainable, and it rests on keeping the proper balance between rewarding shareholders and keeping the investment plan sustainable. In my view, this required guaranteed and predictable growth, along with complete visibility over the plant. Any further points regarding dividend policy will be addressed when we discuss the new business plan, which, as we have said, we expect to present in the quarter of 2024.
Omar Al-Bayaty
executiveLet's turn now to regulation, since there have been a number of questions about the authority's recent resolution on the ROS. Can you offer any comments on that resolution, specifically regarding how the criteria of the ROS regulation are to be implemented?
Francesco Beccali
executiveAbsolutely. Under resolution 497, which came out at the start of this month, ARERA sets out how the ROS bad regulation will be applied, and it brings in the following regulatory measures, which mark an improvement over the measures currently in place. First, beginning in 2024, investments — and, taking effect from 2025, depreciation on assets — will be recognized in the year after the ending 2 operations. As a reminder, under the regulatory framework now in force, as we said, in the tariff BRP the depreciation is recognized for assets that entered service through 2022. In addition, let me note the revaluation based on the playoff for the first 4 years of assets under construction, which today are not revalued, along with applying the remuneration rate of the first 2 years also to years 3 and 4. What's more, for a specific subset of capital incentive assets — typically above INR 1 billion — this rate is extended across the first 6 years. Lastly, the results of the <<inaudible>> on requesting activation of the corrective data factor, the account to account for operational cost increases tied to new activities and to changes in the scope of managed assets. Regarding the capitalization rate, let me add as well that the latest resolution provides for determining it for the years 2024 and '25 on the basis of the average rate of PS2021, '22, '23, and those are historical efforts.
Francesco Beccali
executiveAnd so, for years '24 and '25, which I’ve laid out as prospective. The further capitalization rate for '26 and '27 is proposed by taking the average rate spanning 2023 through 2027, with update or reopening pose. Assessing what this new growth deferment will mean is going to form part of the conversation around the new business plan, clearly. More detail on that will come your way in due course.
Omar Al-Bayaty
executiveLet's turn now to the international strategy. Could you share your thoughts on what comes next for that strategy — specifically, the U.S. commission markets?
Francesco Beccali
executiveOkay, first I’ll give you an update on how the consolidation of LATAM activities is going — the process that will let them get the most value out of the international portfolio while improving the group’s risk-return profile. At the same time, we’ll keep looking for other opportunities. Those could also involve partnerships, and they’ll be chosen with a low-risk profile and limited capital absorption, drawing on what’s newly developed, like <<inaudible>>. Our attention will go to markets that have either that profile or a low country risk, such as the United States, which you mentioned; we’ll take a gradual approach to offering and to drawing on our new outlook in infrastructure design and operation.
Omar Al-Bayaty
executiveThere was a question about whether the CapEx plan can be financed given today's rate environment and the headroom on the balance sheet. Could you confirm that in this context — are you planning to issue another hybrid?
Francesco Beccali
executiveOkay, so to start, let me just confirm what we already told the market last year: we're committed to keeping our screen risk profile where it is, and we feel good about the current solid investment-grade rating area. The <<inaudible>> from February 2022 is the first proof of that approach. Even though our financial ratios so far really are comfortably in line with our rating, we made the decision to give the market enough—to take advantage of opportunity market conditions and thereby mitigate a problem that will only show up years down the road and that we'll keep monitoring and keeping under control. Our funding strategy from here on is to spread out the hybrid issuances over time so we can optimize the portion of that capital within our capital structure at any given moment. So we'll return to those markets in the months ahead next year, as soon as it's necessary and with whatever amount is needed to protect our credit profile, potentially looking at our 4-5 weeks capacity. Last, let me point out that we're also open to using other tools to keep our financial standards in place. The agreement to dispose of our international activities that we talked about earlier, and that we then signed at the end of May 2022, is proof of our willingness to concentrate on our connectivities and to keep the leverage fully under control.
Francesco Beccali
executiveLet me close by saying that there are a number of levers we can pull, and from time to time we'll pick whichever ones work best.
Omar Al-Bayaty
executiveWe also got a few questions about whether Terna might get involved in both offshore wind and storage. Could you say more about that?
Francesco Beccali
executiveNaturally. No offshore wind or storage investments are part of the CapEx plan we have right now. I want to be clear about that. Requests for grid collections coming from large-scale offshore wind power plants have gone up significantly as of late. We'll keep watching how this technology evolves, and anything further on that subject will be taken up when we discuss the new business plan. As for workforce storage, it ought to be developed via market options, and Terna cannot be directly involved. We strongly <<inaudible>> how important storage development is for the LCC system, and we will actively more into its evolution.
Omar Al-Bayaty
executiveWe got a couple of follow-up questions. One is about regulation, and the other is about working capital. Starting with the first one, what do you expect the WACC value to be for the '24 tariff?
Francesco Beccali
executiveIt's pretty clear, I know, when I talk about the final WACC value for 2024, that we need to factor in the resolution from the authority that will come out by year-end. That said, as things stand right now, what we're seeing is an estimated work variation of roughly...
Omar Al-Bayaty
executiveCould you give us some specifics about how working capital behaved during the first 9 months of '23? And how do you expect that to play out for the whole of '23?
Francesco Beccali
executiveDuring the first 9 months of 2023, working capital shows a reduction of roughly EUR 204 million versus the end of last year. Those results, which weighed negatively on net financial debt, stem mainly from, on the one hand, a drop of approximately EUR 96 million in net trade payables. This concerns net pass-through energy payables, reflecting lower debt from the essential plants for the security of the electricity system, partly offset by lower credits from the cost of procuring resources on the dispatch and service model. Beyond that, we also saw a rise of around EUR 214 million in net receivables stemming from regulated activities, chiefly owing to space market in sensing mechanism revenues and to test internal incentive levels, which will be collected according to timing defined in the resolution itself. Most various items are partly offset by an increase in net tax liabilities of about EUR 128 million, driven by the growth of income tax expenses for the period and of the net VAT payer. Please keep in mind that in 2022, Terna benefited, as we already discussed, from a positive cash flow effect deriving from net working capital decrease.
Francesco Beccali
executiveFor the whole of 2023, what we expect is that we will take back at least part of the gains that came from the energy pass-through items we recorded at the close of 2022.
Omar Al-Bayaty
executiveThanks, Francesco. That wraps up everything we needed to address.
Francesco Beccali
executiveThanks, Omar. And thanks to all of you for joining this call — we'll see you at the next business presentation.
Omar Al-Bayaty
executiveThank you.
Francesco Beccali
executiveThat wraps us up for the first quarter of 2024. Goodbye, everyone.
Omar Al-Bayaty
executiveThank you, and goodbye.
Operator
operatorThanks. That brings us to the end of today's conference call. We appreciate everyone for joining us, ladies and gentlemen. You can go ahead and disconnect now.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Terna S.p.A. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Terna S.p.A. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Terna S.p.A. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.