Terna S.p.A. (TRN) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

May 8, 2024

Borsa Italiana IT Utilities Electric Utilities earnings 30 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Good afternoon, everyone, and thank you for joining us for Terna's presentation of consolidated results for the first quarter of 2024. Right now, everyone is connected in listen-only mode. I want to let you know that this conference is being recorded today. Now I'll turn things over to today's host, Mr. Omar Al Bayati, who leads Investor Relations, Corporate Development, and Sustainability. The floor is yours, sir.

Omar Al Bayati

executive
#2

Good afternoon, all, and welcome to the presentation of Terna's results for the first quarter of 2024. Our CFO, Francesco Beccali, is hosting this call. After the presentation, a Q&A session will follow. We kindly ask you to send any questions to investor.relations@terna.it. Francesco, please go ahead.

Francesco Beccali

executive
#3

Thanks, Omar, and good afternoon, everyone. Before I get into the numbers, I want to walk you through our most recent key accomplishments. First, let me recall that on March 29th, we unveiled the Group's 2024 to 2028 Industrial Plan, whose goal is to solidify the company's strategic role in running the Italian electricity system and, more broadly, to reinforce the commitment to enabling the country's energy transition. To achieve this, Terna intends to raise its investments substantially across the plan's duration, to EUR 16.5 billion — the highest figure ever in the group's history, 65% higher than the prior industrial plan. At this point, our focus is on executing the new plan. On that note, let me emphasize that we are well on track when it comes to authorization processes and the procurement of the main projects contained in our 2024 to 2028 plan. In fact, in January, the Ministry of Environment and Energy Security granted authorization for the realization of the Adriatic Link, the submarine power line set to connect the regions of Marche and Abruzzo. This development project is viewed by the regulatory authorities as strategic for the country, and it will reinforce energy exchange in central Italy, addressing the security and flexibility needs of the national electrical system as well as the targets for further growth of renewables.

Francesco Beccali

executive
#4

Carrying out the plan isn't just about making investments — it also means making sure the plan can be financed. On that front, on January 10th the company brought a fixed-rate single-tranche bond issue to market successfully, with a total amount of EUR 550 million. Those proceeds are going to be used to cover ordinary financial requirements and to fund what the group's industrial plan needs. Then, in February, Terna signed a financing contract with the European Investment Bank covering the last tranche of the EUR 1.9 billion loan for the Tyrrhenian Link project — the submarine electricity cable that connects the Italian mainland with Sicily and Sardinia. Also, on April 4th, within the financial strategy set out in the new industrial plan, Terna successfully issued a hybrid green perpetual bond with a total nominal amount of EUR 850 million. All of these operations, which will be described in more detail in the next sections of the presentation, strengthen the solidity of our financial structure and further diversify the investor base. Terna's leadership in the field of sustainability is once again demonstrated. Indeed, the sustainability plan has been embedded in the industrial plan. The activities envisaged by the Sustainability Plan include projects and actions confirming Terna's commitment to delivering a Just Transition — a fair, inclusive process that takes into account the potential impacts on all stakeholders, including workers, local communities, and suppliers.

Francesco Beccali

executive
#5

In addition, Terna appears on the roster of global frontrunners in combating climate change, as reported by CDP's Climate Change Survey. Terna also made the list of top international firms for engaging their suppliers in the battle against climate change. Following that short preamble, I'll walk you through the customary snapshot of the Italian electricity market. Please go to the next slide. This chart shows that during the initial three months of 2024, national demand came to roughly 78 TWh, up nearly 1% compared with a year earlier, when national demand stood at approximately 77 TWh. Across the first quarter of 2024, renewables met around 36% of national demand, which is 7 percentage points above the prior year. As for national net total production, it amounted to 61 TWh, down 4% from the same period of 2023. I should add that during this first quarter, renewable sources supplied about 46% of national net total production. The year-over-year rise also reflects contributions from wind and solar output, which increased by 13% and 6%, respectively, compared with the first quarter of 2023. Let's now turn to the period's key figures. During the first three months of 2024, we saw robust growth across every P&L line and in CapEx.

Francesco Beccali

executive
#6

In fact, group revenues and EBITDA rose 20% and 26%, respectively, compared with a year earlier — that works out to EUR 146 million and EUR 128 million more than in the first three months of 2023. Group net income came in at EUR 268 million as well, up 34% against the same period a year ago. Group capital was EUR 483 million, a double-digit rise of 53% compared with the first quarter of last year. I want to emphasize that this is a record level of capital for the opening three months of the year. Once again, it confirms the strong acceleration of our capital to meet the system's needs and enable the green transition, consistent with the industrial plan we presented recently. To underpin that acceleration, net debt at the end of March 2024 was EUR 10.6 billion, against roughly EUR 10.5 billion at year-end 2023. Now I'd like to take you through a deeper look at the period's figures. Turning to slide 8. We'll begin with the revenue analysis. Total revenues for the first three months of the year climbed 20.4% to EUR 858 million, an increase of EUR 146 million versus last year. Growth came from both regulated and non-regulated activities, which contributed EUR 116 million and EUR 29 million, respectively.

Francesco Beccali

executive
#7

Now let's dig into how revenues actually moved. On the next slide. Regulated revenues came in at EUR 730 million — that's EUR 116 million above the prior year, roughly 19% higher than the same period a year earlier. The growth came mostly from a larger RAB, from the revised WACC remuneration figure, and from a bigger output-based incentives effect tied to the greater benefits delivered to the system. Non-regulated and international revenues hit EUR 180 million and EUR 28 million, up 29.8% versus last year. On the non-regulated side, the gain was mostly down to higher revenues from Tamini and a larger contribution from LT Group's energy services. International revenues were set to zero. Since the IFRS 5 requirements have been satisfied, the full 2023 and 2022 results attributable to the South American subsidiaries covered by the planned asset sale have been placed in the line for profit or loss for the period from assets held for sale within the group's reclassified income statement. Now let's walk through the operating cost analysis. As this chart shows, total operating cost was EUR 230 million, 8.3% above last year. For regulated activities, the decline mostly reflected greater capitalization of labor costs after factoring in a rise in average headcount versus the first quarter of 2023, while non-regulated activities were mainly hit by higher costs for purchasing raw materials and services tied to Tamini and LT Group.

Francesco Beccali

executive
#8

Now let's look at EBITDA. On the next slide. Because of the effect I mentioned earlier, group EBITDA for the first quarter of 2024 came in at EUR 628 million, up 25.6% compared with the same period a year ago. Growth was driven primarily by regulated activities, which added roughly EUR 124 million versus the first three months of last year, posting an EBITDA of EUR 610 million in the first quarter of 2024. I want to highlight that this EBITDA growth from regulated activities stems not only from higher regulated revenues but also from a notable decrease in operating expenses, which shows our capacity to keep the cost structure under control. Now let's look at the lower part of the P&L. On slide 12. D&A came to EUR 209 million. The year-over-year increase was driven mainly by full recognition of depreciation tied to new assets entering operation. As a result, EBIT was EUR 419 million, 33.6% higher than in the first quarter of 2023. Net financial expenses were reported at EUR 37 million. The rise versus last year is mainly due to new financings being subscribed and to higher interest rates, partly offset by lower inflation on the inflation-linked bond that expired in September 2023 and by greater financial income on available liquidity.

Francesco Beccali

executive
#9

Taxes came in at EUR 112 million, which is EUR 30 million more than a year ago, mainly because profit went up. Our tax rate was 29.2%. Consequently, group net income hit EUR 268 million, up 34% compared with the same period a year earlier. Now on to capital analysis. During the first three months of 2024, total capital came to EUR 483 million, 53% above last year, which confirms the strong acceleration consistent with our institutional role for the country. I want to stress that this marks a record level of capital for the first three months of the year. In fact, we put roughly EUR 462 million into regulated activities. Key projects in this period include the Tyrrhenian Link, the Adriatic Link, the Colunga-Calenzano connection, upgrading of the high-voltage grid at the sites tied to the 2026 Winter Olympics, and spending on stabilization devices for grid security, synchronous compensators among them. Within the capital categories, development capital accounted for 64% of total regulated capital. Defense capital was 10%, whereas asset renewal and efficiency made up 26%. Non-regulated and other capitals, by contrast, totaled EUR 21 million. That figure covers capitalized financial charge and other investments. Turning to net debt and cash flow analysis, net debt at the end of March 2024 was approximately EUR 10.6 billion, roughly EUR 93 million above the 2023 year-end level, chiefly as a result of the capital acceleration carried out on the national grid.

Francesco Beccali

executive
#10

Over the period, operating cash flow came to EUR 461 million, which allowed us to fund the bulk of capital expenditure for the period. Now let's take a closer look at our debt profile. Turning to page 15. Consistent with our prudent, proactive approach to managing debt and with keeping a solid financial structure, at the close of this first three months of 2024 we recorded a fixed-to-floating ratio on gross debt of roughly 89% and an average duration of roughly six years. As noted earlier, since the start of the year Terna has brought two bond issues to market successfully. In January, the company placed a fixed rate, single tranche bond for a total of EUR 850 million. That deal, part of the EUR 9 billion Euro Medium Term Note Programme, drew a very favorable reaction from the market, with demand exceeding supply by nearly three times the amount offered. The bond, priced at a spread of 100 basis points over mid-swaps, carries a duration of 7 years and will pay a coupon of 3.5%. In April, Terna successfully placed a perpetual green hybrid bond issue with a total nominal amount of EUR 850 million.

Francesco Beccali

executive
#11

Also, this issue got a really strong reception in the market, with maximum demand exceeding EUR 3 billion — roughly four times the amount offered, so demand outstripped supply. The bond cannot be called for 6 years, and it was issued at a spread of 214 basis points over the mid-swap, with a subordination premium of 130 basis points — among the tightest seen for this kind of instrument since the end of 2021. The issue will pay an annual coupon of 4.75% up to the first reset date, scheduled for April 11th, 2030, and its effective rate will be equal to 4.8%. Turning to bank debt, in February the European Investment Bank and Terna signed the contract for the final tranche of the EUR 1.9 billion financing for the Tyrrhenian Link. Under this contract there is a final tranche of EUR 500 million, on top of the earlier finance contract signed on November 8th, 2022, and March 30th, 2023, for building and commissioning the east and west sections of the project. Let me remind you that, with terms of around 22 years from each drawdown, these loans have long maturity and a more competitive cost than what is generally available in the market. That makes them consistent with Terna's policy of optimizing its financial structure.

Francesco Beccali

executive
#12

Also, Terna raised the overall size of its ESG-linked Revolving Credit Facility — originally signed on May 12, 2023 — to EUR 2.255 billion in April, by entering into an amendment and restatement agreement. Every other term and condition of that credit line stays as it was. Before we open the Q&A, I want to stress that given the robust results we just walked through for the first quarter, we can confirm our 2024 guidance in full. Thanks for listening. We are now ready to take your questions.

Omar Al Bayati

executive
#13

Thanks, Francesco. A number of questions came in. We’ll begin with the first one. Go ahead, Cristiano.

Cristiano Bertoldi

executive
#14

All right, thanks, Omar. We'll begin with the first one. A number of questions came in about how much in output-based incentives was booked during the first quarter of 2024. Francesco, would you like to address that?

Francesco Beccali

executive
#15

Sure. Regarding the output-based incentives that were recognized during the first quarter of 2024, that number comes to roughly EUR 60 million, tied to efficiency incentives in the dispatching services market linked to the cost savings from the decrease in volumes traded on the market.

Cristiano Bertoldi

executive
#16

Thanks. And once more, regarding incentives tied to output, what assumptions apply for 2024 and across the plan period?

Francesco Beccali

executive
#17

Our strategic plan is built on roughly EUR 400 million cumulated across the plan's time horizon, with that distribution weighted toward the front end.

Cristiano Bertoldi

executive
#18

Alright, thank you. Perhaps one final question about incentives tied to output. Could you say anything about when we might get greater visibility regarding the possible renewal of the ancillary service market incentive scheme?

Francesco Beccali

executive
#19

So with the significant drop in ancillary services market costs across the first 2 years of the incentive schemes, the Italian Regulatory Authority is now evaluating whether the scheme might be extended into the years ahead. In any case, a decision on whether the scheme will be renewed is anticipated before the year is out.

Cristiano Bertoldi

executive
#20

Thanks a lot. Since we're always operating within the regulatory framework, we're moving on to a different topic, because a handful of questions came in regarding a possible reassessment of the deflator for the 2024 tariff. Could you shed some light on that for us?

Francesco Beccali

executive
#21

Okay. Under resolution 615 of 2023, the deflator that gets applied to the 2024 tariff comes out to 5.9%. That figure is the cumulative result of two components: the deflator for the final three quarters of 2022, which was not included in the 2023 tariff, at 4.2%, plus the change in the 2023 fixed income investment deflator, with an expected estimate of 1.6%. And let me stress this — that value is going to be reassessed by the regulator in 2025 using ex post data. The reason is that the historical deflator series published by ISTAT will undergo further quarterly revisions until ARERA adopts the final value in the first month of 2025. So making projections right now about the 2024 deflator reassessment is premature.

Cristiano Bertoldi

executive
#22

Thanks. On regulation again — could you maybe say something about the WACC assumption starting in 2025 and after?

Francesco Beccali

executive
#23

Sure. Our current WACC estimate for 2025 onward remains at 5.5%, the same figure we presented to the market in our business plan. This reflects a move from 6%-33% in the weight of the cost of debt from the prior regulatory period, which is set at 2.4%. The most recent data available — the mark-to-market of values recorded from February 2024 — covers all parameters requiring updates for calculating the cost of equity. Note that our regulatory WACC assumptions align with those on the cost of debt, giving the company a sort of partial natural edge. On fiscal parameters, the values for the second period, running from 2025 to 2027, will be set through an analysis of applicable tax legislation and the actual tax incidence level seen in 2022 to 2023. Lastly, regarding Beta Assets, a revision of the methodological calculation criteria is scheduled for 2024 across all regulated electricity and gas infrastructure services.

Cristiano Bertoldi

executive
#24

Thanks a lot, Francesco. We also got a few questions regarding the ROSS framework. Would you mind giving us an update on the regulatory side of the ROSS system?

Francesco Beccali

executive
#25

So with the ROSS approach, we see a chance to generate additional value both for the electricity system and for shareholders. It aligns with the direction we've already been moving in toward an output-based approach. Near the end of last year, the regulator signed off on the integrated ROSS regulation text, which contains the general ROSS principles and the criteria for determining the allowed cost value for the 2024 to 2031 period. ARERA confirmed a gradual path for putting ROSS regulation into effect, anticipating the first phase — the so-called ROSS base — beginning in 2024. The key change ARERA brought in under the ROSS base framework has to do with applying the capitalization rate to divide total expenditures between slow and fast money components, as a way to support the financeability of investment. As for developing the ROSS integrale model itself, which will be applied in 2026, ARERA has set out a two-step approach: a framework resolution on the general criteria, and a second resolution on specific sectoral measures meant to define methods and possible experimental applications of the ROSS integrale model. The resolution of the ROSS integrale will come about through a dialogue process between ARERA and operators. Throughout that process, ARERA will publish consultation documents so that objectives and tools behind the new framework can be shared and discussed with the regulated entities.

Cristiano Bertoldi

executive
#26

All right, thanks, Francesco. Let’s turn now to the debt profile. There are a few questions about hybrids. More specifically, some folks are asking whether you intend to issue any additional hybrid, and what is the maximum potential capacity that Terna has for issuing this?

Francesco Beccali

executive
#27

Okay, so in light of the recent problems we just went over when we presented the first quarter results, our approach to funding going forward is still centered on optimizing the hybrid capital portion of our capital structure as opportunities arise from time to time. The group is going to keep watching the market for potential opportunities and will come back to those markets down the road as needed, so that we protect our credit profile and take advantage of any suitable opportunities that come up. Following the EUR 850 million we issued recently, we still have room for roughly EUR 2 billion in additional hybrid issuances within the Industrial Plan horizon, to be used if needed and if suitable opportunities arise.

Cristiano Bertoldi

executive
#28

Thanks a lot, Francesco. One more question came in about how you expect net debt to develop after those hybrid issuances you just referred to. Could you say a bit about that?

Francesco Beccali

executive
#29

As you're well aware, we don't give any guidance on net debt. Net debt is going to reflect the guidance we've provided on CapEx and EPS, along with where working capital stands at the close of 2024. That said, let me point out that under IFRS, hybrid bonds get treated as equity, since these securities are perpetual in nature and because coupons can be deferred at Terna's discretion. As a result, our hybrid issuances won't show up in net debt, and the coupon payments won't be booked as financial charges in the payment statement.

Cristiano Bertoldi

executive
#30

Thanks a lot. Now let's move on to the procurement authorization. We've gotten a handful of questions regarding where the procurement authorization stands, so could you bring us up to date on that?

Francesco Beccali

executive
#31

Okay, on the authorization front, I’d say we’re heading in the right direction, and the CapEx plan is robust, solid, and secure. The key HVDC projects have been authorized, and the Italy–Tunisia link is close to receiving authorization. When it comes to procurement, we’re obviously mindful of possible shortages and bottlenecks across the relevant supply chains as we invest in the industry. Even so, we handle that risk by putting in place a set of actions so that any issues can be addressed promptly and efficiently. So on the procurement side as well, we’re very much on track, since we’ve already secured nearly all procurement requirements through the end of 2024, also with help from the group. In fact, as far as the strategic plan goes, roughly 80% has already been procured, and approximately 70% is covered by procurement contracts that are already in place.

Cristiano Bertoldi

executive
#32

Thanks. Now here's a question that comes up a lot: does 2024 guidance leave enough time?

Francesco Beccali

executive
#33

The sole response I can give you is this: as we said in the presentation, because of the robust results for the first quarter that were just presented, we can confirm our guidance for 2024 in full.

Cristiano Bertoldi

executive
#34

Thanks again so much. Lastly, a few questions came in about electricity trends, covering both the supply side and the demand side. We've summed that question up like this. If renewables development slows down, or if electricity demand shifts in new ways — data centers, for instance — how would that affect our CapEx plan?

Francesco Beccali

executive
#35

Okay, regarding this topic, let me restate the main goals that Terna must pursue and keep enhancing in order to carry out its TSO role. Above all, energy continuity across the country has to be assured, safeguarding service quality and supply continuity within the energy system amid a rapidly evolving landscape. We are shifting quickly from a conventional setup built on centralized generation facilities and one-way flows toward a complex, integrated system that is far less predictable, marked by flows moving in multiple directions among a great many participants. Next, strengthening the grid's resilience so it can withstand possible stresses is essential, and that matters greatly for keeping energy supply continuous. Moreover, lastly, securing the electricity grid is necessary so we can tackle fresh challenges arising from the shift to a more intricate energy system. All of these growing system requirements shape our CapEx plan, which seeks to handle and get ahead of any foreseeable trend capable of affecting the electricity system.

Omar Al Bayati

executive
#36

Thanks, Francesco. That's all the questions. Yeah, we did get quite a few questions. So thank you, everyone, for being on the call, and please know that the IR department is available to you for anything you need to follow up on.

Francesco Beccali

executive
#37

I appreciate that.

Omar Al Bayati

executive
#38

Thank you. Bye.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Terna S.p.A. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Terna S.p.A. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Terna S.p.A. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.