Terna S.p.A. (TRN) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

November 6, 2024

Borsa Italiana IT Utilities Electric Utilities earnings 38 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Good afternoon, everyone, and welcome to the presentation of Terna's consolidated results for the 9 months of 2024. <<operator_script>> I'd like to let you know that this conference is being recorded today. At this point, I'll turn the call over to today's host, Mr. Stefano Gamberini, our Head of Investor Relations. Sir, the floor is yours.

Stefano Gamberini

executive
#2

Good afternoon, and welcome to Terna's presentation of results for 9 months 2024. I'm Stefano Gamberini, and it's a privilege to be here today in my new role as Head of Investor Relations at Terna. Having spent 30 years working as a financial analyst, this new challenge is something I'm very excited about. Alongside the IR team, my aim is to carry on and strengthen the excellent relationship that has been established with the financial community in support of our company's growth. Our CFO, Francesco Beccali, will be hosting this call. After the presentation, there will be a Q&A session. So we kindly ask that you send any questions you may have to our e-mail address, investors.relations@terna.it. Francesco, please, the floor is yours.

Francesco Beccali

executive
#3

Thank you, Stefano, and welcome aboard. Good afternoon, everyone. Before we begin examining the numbers, I want to walk you through the key highlights from this period. First, let me remind everyone that at the close of July, the authority released 3 documents concerning the renewal of output-based incentive schemes. We output-based — the update of the allowed WACC and deflator assessment. To go into more detail, resolution 326 of 2024 establishes, from the launch of the new ancillary services market incentive scheme, 2 periods of 3 years each: 2025 to 2027 and 2028 to 2030. Under that resolution, for every year of the 2025-2030 period, Terna will receive 12% of the overall MSD cost reduction. For every year in the 2025 to 2027 period, the baseline will be 2023 actual MSD cost, increased by an extra component to factor in the expected changes arising from evolution of the energy scenario. Then, as part of defining the WACC for 2025-2027, beyond updating market parameters according to predefined rules, consultation document 342 of 2024 tackles various themes, among them the update of the beta parameter and the recognized corporate tax rate. The regulator is also assessing whether to confirm the trigger mechanism for adjusting the WACC to material shifts in market conditions, as was done during 2022-'24.

Francesco Beccali

executive
#4

And lastly, under consultation document 340 of 2024, the authority has begun the process of assessing potential changes to the capital cost revaluation criteria that apply to electricity and gas infrastructure services, specifically regarding how the deflator is used. The consultation covers two options: keeping the deflator alongside corrective measures, or swapping it out for alternative inflation indicators. Also, on the subject of the Italian transmission grid, I want to announce that Terna has signed a term sheet with Acea covering the purchase of part of the high-voltage grid across Rome and its suburban area. We'll go into that in greater detail on the following slide. Financially speaking, we have devoted considerable effort to maintaining a financial structure that is both balanced and solid. On that point, allow me to remind you of the agreement inked on October 24 with the European Investment Bank — a EUR 400 million loan aimed at renewing the Italian transmission network. Now let's move on to our sustainability commitment. As we have said before, for us sustainability lives not just in what we do but equally in how we operate. That commitment shows up in our financial structure as well. In fact, on top of the ESG credit facilities already published and disclosed to stakeholders alongside the second quarter results and financial statements in July and October, Terna has signed 2 ESG-linked credit facilities totaling EUR 800 million.

Francesco Beccali

executive
#5

This credit facility matures in 5 years, and its financial charges are tied to how Terna performs against particular environmental, social, and governance indicators. Lastly, on shareholder remuneration, the Board of Directors today approved a 2024 interim dividend of EUR 11.92 per share, which is 4% higher than the prior year, consistent with the baseline dividend policy we communicated to the market. I'll take a moment now to discuss the new deal. Let's go to the next slide. As I noted earlier, Terna has signed a term sheet with Acea for the purchase of a portion of the high-voltage grid in Rome and its suburban areas. Several key factors drive this transaction, and they align with our long-term objectives. Consolidating our high-voltage operations lets us substantially cut operational complexity, including congestion resolution and service quality improvement. That simplification enables us to react faster to challenges and strengthens our overall service delivery. A further crucial element of this acquisition is centralizing high-voltage management activities under the transmission system operator's control. It's worth emphasizing that this process aligns with ARERA resolution 616 of 2023, which established an incentive mechanism designed to encourage the transfer of high-voltage grid assets from distributors to Terna.

Francesco Beccali

executive
#6

The purchase price of EUR 224 million equates to a 10% premium on the estimated 2024 calendar, and it's subject to certain adjustments, among them the 2025 CapEx spending. In addition, this deal encompasses buying an optical fiber network, a portion of which—the part beyond what the national transmission grid requires—is sold to third parties. This acquisition, with a simplified investment decision process, expands the pipeline of potential projects on the high-voltage grid in the Rome area and Central Italy. It should also be noted that acquiring existing assets, rather than developing a greenfield project, permits immediate recognition of the full time, which, combined with the anticipated contribution from commercializing the optical fiber network, makes the deal EPS accretive starting in year one. To wrap up, allow me to emphasize that the transaction aligns completely with the goals set out in our 2024-2028 strategic plan, with a neutral effect where our credit revenue is concerned, and it's intended to strengthen our dedication to growth. Now I'll provide the customary overview of the Italian electricity market. Moving to the next slide. As this chart shows, during the first 9 months of 2024, national demand came to roughly 236 terawatt, up 2.1% compared with last year, when national demand stood at approximately 231 terawatt hour.

Francesco Beccali

executive
#7

That rise is mostly tied to the year's third quarter. In fact, as you can see from the graph, helped also by the high temperatures we saw over the summer, national demand during Q3 came in at roughly 84 terawatt hours, up nearly 4% against the same stretch a year earlier, when demand stood at around 81 terawatt hours. Across the first 9 months of 2024, renewable sources met approximately 43% of national demand, which is 6 percentage points above last year. As for national net total production, it reached 199 terawatt hours, 2% above the same period of 2023, with a striking rise in hydro output, up 45% versus the equivalent period a year ago. I'd also point out that during this period, renewable sources supplied over half of national net total production. The gain over last year also reflects the contribution from solar output, which rose 17% relative to the first 9 months of 2023. Finally, let me tell you that in 2024, operating renewable capacity grew by 5.3 gigawatts. That figure is 33% above the same period of the prior year. Now let's turn to the period's main figures.

Francesco Beccali

executive
#8

During the first 9 months of 2024, we recorded double-digit growth across every P&L line and in CapEx. Group revenues and EBITDA, in fact, rose 18% and 22%, respectively, compared with last year — that's EUR 400 million and EUR 336 million above the first 9 months of 2023. Group net income came in at EUR 813 million, 27% higher than the same period a year earlier. Group CapEx totaled roughly EUR 1.7 billion during the first 9 months, a 19% increase versus the first 9 months of 2023. That once more confirms how we are stepping up investments to meet the requirements of the Italian energy systems and to make the green transition possible. To back this acceleration, at the end of September net debt was approximately EUR 10 billion, compared with about EUR 10.5 billion at year-end 2023, as the slides coming up describe. Now let's dig deeper into the results as we move to the next slide. We'll begin with the revenue analysis. Total revenues for the first 9 months of 2024 amounted to EUR 2.,647 billion, an 18% increase, EUR 400 million above last year. That growth came from both regulated and nonregulated activities, which contributed EUR 317 million and EUR 83 million, respectively.

Francesco Beccali

executive
#9

Now let's dig into the revenue trends as we move to the following slide. During the first 9 months, regulated revenues came in at EUR 2.222 billion — that's EUR 317 million more than a year earlier, representing roughly a 17% rise versus the same stretch of 2023. This gain was primarily fueled by the higher WACC as well as the revised regulatory WACC value. Nonregulated and international revenues totaled EUR 426 million, up 24% from last year. The nonregulated improvement stemmed chiefly from greater revenues out of the equipment business tied to Tamini, adding EUR 32 million, along with a larger contribution from LFT Group's Energy Services, which added EUR 37 million. International revenues were set to zero. Since the IFRS 5 requirements have been satisfied, all results for the first 9 months of 2024 and 2023 attributable to the South American subsidiaries covered by the asset sales plan launched at the end of 2021 have been placed in the profit and loss line for the period from assets held for sale within the group's reclassified income statement. Let's turn now to the operating cost analysis. The chart shows total operating costs at EUR 755 million, which is 9.3% above last year.

Francesco Beccali

executive
#10

On the regulated side, the year-on-year change is essentially flat. The hit to personnel expenses from rising labor costs tied to carrying out the group's investment plan was offset by a matching rise in capitalized costs. Nonregulated activities took the main hit from higher spending on raw materials and services linked to the LC Group and Tamini. Those increases came from a larger volume of activity, which also showed up in revenue growth. Now let me break down EBITDA. On to the next slide. Because of the effect I mentioned earlier, group EBITDA for the first 9 months of '24 came in at EUR 1.892 billion, 22% above the same period a year ago. Regulated activities drove most of that gain, adding roughly EUR 316 million more than the prior-year period and posting EBITDA of EUR 1.824 billion in the first 9 months of 2024. Nonregulated activities also lifted EBITDA, growing 42% versus the first 9 months of last year and posting EBITDA of EUR 68 million. Let's turn to the lower part of the P&L. On the next slide. D&A came to EUR 635 million. The year-over-year rise was mostly driven by new assets coming into operation.

Francesco Beccali

executive
#11

So because of that, EBIT came in at EUR 1.257 billion, which is 28% higher compared with the first 3 quarters of 2023. Net financial expenses were reported at EUR 105 million. The rise compared with last year was mostly due to subscribing to new financing and to the increase in interest rates, partly offset by greater financial income on available liquidity and by higher capitalized financial expenses. Taxes were EUR 339 million, and our tax rate was 29.4%. Consequently, group net income came to EUR 813 million, 26.6% higher compared with the same period a year earlier. Turning to the CapEx analysis. Over the first 9 months, total CapEx was EUR 1.699 billion, 19% above the same period last year, confirming the strong acceleration consistent with our institutional <<inaudible>>. That means roughly EUR 1.625 billion went into regulated activities. Among the key projects in this period, worth noting are the Tyrrhenian link, the Adriatic Link, the SACOI 3, the modernization of the high-voltage grid in the locations due towards the Winter Olympics in 2026, and the investment in stabilization devices for grid security, including synchronous compensators. Within the CapEx categories, development CapEx showed a larger contribution to total CapEx, accounting for 61% of the total against 56% in the first 9 months of 2023.

Francesco Beccali

executive
#12

When it comes to the rest of the categories, 29% came from asset renewal and efficiencies, and defense CapEx was 10%. Nonregulated and other CapEx came to EUR 75 million. That figure includes EUR 52 million of capitalized financial charges plus other investments. Now for the debt and cash flow analysis. At the close of September 2024, net debt was roughly EUR 10 billion — close to EUR 500 million below the level at the end of 2023. The main driver was the favorable effect of the hybrid green bond issuance, which is recognized as an equity instrument, partly offset by the June dividend payment. Over the period, operating cash flow came in at EUR 1.388 billion, which allowed us to cover over 80% of that period's CapEx spending. Let's turn now to a detailed look at our debt profile. Page 16, please. Consistent with our cautious and proactive approach to debt management — designed to keep a low risk profile and a solid financial structure — at the close of these first 9 months of 2024, the fixed-to-floating ratio on gross debt stood at roughly 86%, with an average duration of about 6 years. Consistent with our strategy of pairing sustainability with growth to advance the energy transition, as I mentioned at the start of the presentation, in October Terna signed an agreement with the European Investment Bank for a EUR 400 million loan on very competitive terms.

Francesco Beccali

executive
#13

This is a 22-year loan aimed at backing investments to renew Italy's electricity transmission grid and to boost its resiliency and reliability. In addition, beyond the ESG-linked credit facilities <<inaudible>> shared with stakeholders alongside the second-quarter results and financial statements in July and October, Terna signed 2 ESG-linked credit facilities totaling EUR 500 million. Those lines will carry a total term of 5 years and will be tied to how Terna performs against specific environmental, social and government indicators. Thank you for your attention. Now, before we move to the Q&A session, let me offer some closing remarks. First of all, I want to emphasize that we are well on track with executing our CapEx plan and are accelerating toward the 2028 plan targets thanks to the term sheet signed for acquiring the portion of Rome's high voltage grid. That gives us a solid foundation for the future, particularly when it comes to integrating renewable energy sources into our grid. By strengthening our infrastructure, we are not only raising efficiency but also paving the way toward a more sustainable energy future. Furthermore, as you appreciated from the presentation, we delivered a very strong set of results for the first 9 months of the year, with a double-digit increase across all P&L lines.

Francesco Beccali

executive
#14

So in closing, because of the bigger boost from output-based incentives tied to the existing MSD scheme — that scheme wraps up at year-end — along with low internal dispatching costs and related charges that cut end-customer bills, we can now raise our 2024 guidance. We're looking at revenues of EUR 3.610 billion, which is almost 2% above the earlier guidance, while regulated revenues from the tariffs stay in line with estimates. We'll also lift the 2024 EBITDA guidance, now at EUR 2.5 billion, and the EPS guidance, which goes up to EUR 0.52 per share, 6% above the prior figure. Thanks for listening. We're ready now for the Q&A session.

Stefano Gamberini

executive
#15

Thanks, Francesco. Let's begin with the questions on the 9-month results. We got a lot of them regarding output-based incentives. Can you share more detail on how many output-based incentives were booked in the 9 months of '24?

Francesco Beccali

executive
#16

Sure, Stefano. The output-based incentives that were recognized during the 9 months of '24 come to roughly EUR 200 million, which is largely in line with the prior year. These are mainly tied to dispatching service market efficiency incentives linked to cost savings from the reduction in volumes traded on the market, and to a lesser extent they relate to the interzonal incentive schemes associated with creating additional transport capacity around the Italian pricing zones.

Stefano Gamberini

executive
#17

Returning to the topic of incentives — what are your updated expectations for the total 2024 contribution coming from output-based incentives?

Francesco Beccali

executive
#18

Okay, I want to emphasize again that the output-based incentives for 2024 are tied primarily to the dispatching-activity incentive mechanism that wraps up this year. That scheme was designed to reward how efficiently dispatching activities are carried out and, as a result, to bring down the cost of the dispatching service market. Our expectations incorporate the revised performance estimates for 2024, which will permit us to book incentives at slightly over EUR 300 million, consistent with the MSD incentives recorded in 2023. Beyond that, regarding incentives for additional interzonal transmission capacity, the figure anticipated for 2024 comes to roughly EUR 15 million, which has already been accounted for in September.

Stefano Gamberini

executive
#19

This is the final question on this subject. Could you give some guidance on how much the new output-based incentive framework that was recently approved is expected to contribute to dispatching next year?

Francesco Beccali

executive
#20

So, as we mentioned over the past month, in the 2024–2028 strategic plan, we're assuming roughly EUR 400 million in cumulative output-based incentives across the business plan period, with that distribution front-end loaded. At the current pace, we won't be giving precise guidance on what additional contribution we might get from new frameworks approved during 2024.

Stefano Gamberini

executive
#21

Turning to operating expenses, what can you tell us about how regulated labor costs have been trending across the 9 months of '24?

Francesco Beccali

executive
#22

Yes. In Q1, labor cost went down compared with the same period in 2023. Even though gross personnel expenses rose because we have more employees — roughly 330 full-time equivalents above the prior year — labor cost still declined. The reason is that capitalized personnel costs were higher than a year earlier, supporting the acceleration in CapEx.

Stefano Gamberini

executive
#23

On the financial structure side, can you bring us up to date on how you intend to fund the CapEx plan you have in place right now? Also, what hybrid capacity stands at presently, and which further levers exist for keeping the finances sustainable?

Francesco Beccali

executive
#24

We said this at Capital Market Day, and the rating agencies have since confirmed it: from a financial point of view, the 2024-2028 CapEx plan is fully sustainable. On the levers for managing the company's credit worthiness, we confirm that, if needed, we could use all of the full hybrid capacity of the company, which we estimate at up to EUR 4 billion by 2028, and that includes the EUR 1.85 billion already outstanding. Beyond that, we could gain further flexibility through additional grants that we could use if necessary.

Stefano Gamberini

executive
#25

Turning now to what's happened recently on the regulatory front. Would you be able to shed some light on the possible move from deflator to CPI when it comes to RAB indexation?

Francesco Beccali

executive
#26

Sure, Stefano. As was noted in the presentation, on July 31 the Authority began a consultation to assess whether to keep using the deflator alongside corrective measures, or to swap the deflator for alternative inflation indicators so as to address the problem of capital revaluation levels coming in lower than inflationary trends, along with the deflator's limited stability and predictability. That consultation is set to wrap up at the end of April 2025. As for the deflator applied to the 2024 tariff, which the regulator fixed at 5.9% as of October 4, it published the fixed investment deflator figure, factoring in the second quarter of 2024 as well. In those publications <<inaudible>> it revised the old historical series, which moved the 2023 variation to a positive figure, from minus 0.8% to 1.2%. On that point, we do expect the 2024 deflator for the tariff <<inaudible>> will not differ substantially from the present 5.9% that was set <<inaudible>>.

Stefano Gamberini

executive
#27

Could you share what your expectations are for 2025 and beyond, please?

Francesco Beccali

executive
#28

Regarding the WACC figure covering 2025 through 2027, ARERA is going to refresh it before the year is out. The window for observing and updating the key macroeconomic parameter wrapped up in September. Based on where the market stands right now — factoring in how the graduality rule applies when working out the permitted cost of debt, and presuming some adjustment to the fiscal and beta parameters — we'd land at a WACC of 5.4%. ARERA will publish the resolution containing the definitive number before this year closes, and that will also settle the choice on meta and the tax rate.

Stefano Gamberini

executive
#29

All right. Next up, we have a question regarding the storage system. Could you give us an update on the Italian Max — the so-called Max framework — please.

Francesco Beccali

executive
#30

Sure. As you know, Terna has been working on the design of Max — the long-term procurement mechanism dedicated to storage technology — to ensure the development of the required storage capacity. Max, which was drafted in compliance with legislative decree 210 of 2021, was approved at the beginning of October by the Ministry of Environment and Energy Security. This will ensure that new storage capacity is procured progressively over time, and the first option is expected to be held by the first half of 2025.

Stefano Gamberini

executive
#31

Alright. So we’re also getting a handful of questions regarding how procurement and authorizations are progressing. Could you bring us up to date on those?

Francesco Beccali

executive
#32

On authorization, I'd say we're moving in the right direction. The CapEx plan is also robust and very solid. Every one of the main HVDC projects has been authorized. On procurement, which draws more attention, we're alert to possible shortages and bottlenecks across the supply chains that matter, where the industry is putting money in. We handle that risk by putting in place a set of actions so that any drawbacks get addressed promptly and efficiently. So on the procurement front as well, we're very much on track, since we have already secured nearly all the procurement needs through the end of 2024, with group contribution helping as well. In fact, out of the 2024-2028 CapEx plan, over 80% has already been authorized, and over 75% is covered by these existing procurement contracts. That percentage rises above 80% once you count procurement contracts that are under negotiation, since the tender is still ongoing.

Stefano Gamberini

executive
#33

We've gotten a handful of questions regarding a possible CapEx update and the main new green development projects. Could you speak to that?

Francesco Beccali

executive
#34

So, right now we’re in the middle of putting together the new national development plan, and that’s going to be presented in the first part of 2025. With that in mind, we should be able to give you something more precise on possible updates to future CapEx needs during the first months of next year.

Stefano Gamberini

executive
#35

Thanks. Turning to the guidance raise we just went through — can you talk about what's driving the improved 2024 target, and will that also carry through to future years?

Francesco Beccali

executive
#36

Thank you for those very solid results shared with us today. As we mentioned in the presentation, the raise to our 2024 guidance stems chiefly from a bigger-than-anticipated contribution of the output-based incentive schemes tied to a substantial cut in MSD costs and the larger benefits for the system that we managed to deliver. I should remind everyone that the present output-based incentives framework wraps up at the close of this year. Because of that, our 2024 performance won't carry any upside into the years that follow.

Stefano Gamberini

executive
#37

All right. Turning to the dividend policy — does the higher 2024 guidance have any effect on how you approach the dividend?

Francesco Beccali

executive
#38

As you might recall, our dividend policy—which guarantees steady, predictable growth and complete visibility—calls for at least 4% annual growth over the period, using 2023 as the reference year. For 2024 alone, the minimum dividend per share will be whichever is higher: the 4% growth versus 2023 or the 75% payout ratio. Let me remind you that any higher dividend in 2024 will have no impact from 2025 onwards.

Stefano Gamberini

executive
#39

All right. Let's turn now to the Acea deal. Could you walk us through the thinking behind the agreement with Acea for the high-voltage grid acquisition that you announced today?

Francesco Beccali

executive
#40

Okay. As we noted in the presentation, this agreement reconfirms Terna's essential function in the National Electricity System, enabling improved planning and more efficient operational management of the country's transmission grid — particularly in Romania, to reinforce service continuity and security. Beyond that, taking over these assets will help enable better decision-making on renewal and development investments for the national transmission grid, again in Rome and Central Italy, opening up possible new growth opportunities. This transaction carries a very strong industrial rationale. Let me also emphasize that the deal will be EPS accretive beginning in year 1.

Stefano Gamberini

executive
#41

All right — what’s the timing on the purchase process, please?

Francesco Beccali

executive
#42

Our expectation is that we'll move forward with signing by, say, January 2025. As for closing, we anticipate that taking place around mid-2025.

Stefano Gamberini

executive
#43

What effect is this transaction going to have on your 2025 EPS?

Francesco Beccali

executive
#44

As we mentioned before, this transaction should wrap up around the middle of 2025. So the effect is going to be limited. That said, we anticipate it being EPS accretive right from year 1, adding a few euro million beginning on the closing date.

Stefano Gamberini

executive
#45

Alright, so how big is that fiber optic network, and what kind of revenue contribution should we expect from it?

Francesco Beccali

executive
#46

Like we mentioned, a portion of the network is contracted out to third parties. That gives us a guaranteed revenue stream starting in year 1, and later on we can grow the network's capacity even more.

Stefano Gamberini

executive
#47

We have time for two more questions. How much CapEx could you potentially add to your investment plans as a result of this deal?

Francesco Beccali

executive
#48

So, in the years ahead, the network that's part of this deal is going to need the investments required to maintain and renew its assets. On top of that, there are additional investments we might decide to make to develop the network, so we can improve how the system is managed and strengthen both the security and the continuity of service.

Stefano Gamberini

executive
#49

Are you considering any further acquisitions involving regulated assets in Italy?

Francesco Beccali

executive
#50

Like we mentioned in the presentation, this transaction falls within the perimeter of ARERA resolution 616, 2023, under which the authority gave distributors incentives to sell off certain assets. Formally, those assets count as belonging to the electricity distribution network, yet technically speaking they serve the high voltage transmission system more than anything else. That said, right now we don't have any further potential deal at an advanced stage of discussion. Still, other smaller transactions aren't ruled out going forward.

Stefano Gamberini

executive
#51

All right, thanks a lot, Francesco. That's all the questions we have. So, Francesco, over to you.

Francesco Beccali

executive
#52

Appreciate it, everyone — talk to you on the next call.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Terna S.p.A. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Terna S.p.A. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Terna S.p.A. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.