Textron Inc. (TXT) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
January 25, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Eric Salander
executiveThank you, Greg, and good morning to all of you. Ahead of getting started, I want to note that during today's call we'll be talking about future estimates and expectations. Those forward-looking statements carry a variety of risk factors, which are laid out in our SEC filings as well as in today's press release. Joining us on the call are Scott Donnelly, Textron's Chairman and CEO, along with Frank Connor, our Chief Financial Officer. You can find our earnings call presentation in the Investor Relations portion of our website. Fourth-quarter revenues came to $3.6 billion, an increase from $3.3 billion in the same period a year earlier. Segment profit for the quarter reached $317 million, which is $7 million above the fourth quarter of '21. In this year's fourth quarter, we reported income from continuing operations of $1.07 per share. Manufacturing cash flow before pension contributions came in at $368 million for the quarter, $70 million higher than last year's fourth quarter; on a full-year basis, revenues totaled $12.9 billion, an increase of $487 million over last year. For 2022, segment profit was $1.2 billion, which is $89 million more than 2021. Income from continuing operations came to $4.01 per share, versus $3.30 in 2021. Manufacturing cash flow before pension contributions reached $1.2 billion, up $29 million compared with 2021; with that, I'll hand the call over to Scott.
Scott Donnelly
executiveAppreciate that, Eric, and good morning to all of you. We wrapped up the year with yet another robust quarter; during that quarter, aviation posted gains in both revenue and segment profit, which came from more aircraft deliveries, greater aftermarket volume, and solid pricing that outpaced inflation versus the fourth quarter a year earlier; we also kept seeing healthy order flow during the quarter, with customer demand spread across our aircraft product lineup, and finished the year sitting at $6.4 billion in backlog. Across the full year, we handed over 178 jets, an increase from 167 the prior year, along with 146 commercial turboprops, which rose from 125 in 2021. Textron Aviation Defense handed over 10 T-6 aircraft for the year, climbing from 5 a year earlier. Through 2022, robust aircraft utilization across the Textron Aviation product portfolio drove a 16% increase in aftermarket revenues. Over at Bell, revenues dipped somewhat in the quarter, as we had anticipated, because of reduced military revenue tied to the ongoing wind down of the H-1 program, which was partly balanced out by stronger commercial revenues. In December, the U.S. Army revealed that Bell's V-280 Valor had won the Future Long Range Assault Aircraft program competition; this selection speaks to the dedication of the Bell team and the design refined via the V-280 prototype across the past 10 years that made this win possible. Our initial contract award, worth as much as $1.3 billion spanning the first 19 months, with initial funding of $232 million for engineering and manufacturing development related activity, is presently paused while we await the result of a protest submitted at year-end by the rival vendor. On Bell's commercial side, we handed over 179 helicopters in 2022, an increase from 156 in 2021. Shifting to Textron Systems. Revenues came in essentially level with the fourth quarter a year ago. During the fourth quarter, Systems landed an additional anti-vehicle munition contract from the U.S. Army. That award carries a value of $162 million across a 5-year period of performance. In December, Systems revealed delivery of the Cottonmouth to the U.S. Marine Corps for testing through 2023. This vehicle was purpose-built for the Marine's Advanced Reconnaissance Vehicle program; during the quarter, Systems also handed over the sixth Ship-to-Shore Connector to the U.S. Navy following successful completion of acceptance trials. Shifting to Industrial; we recorded higher revenue in the quarter, fueled by greater volume at both Kautex and specialized vehicles plus favorable pricing, mainly, specialized vehicles. Shifting to Aviation. We handed over 6 Bell selector aircraft in the fourth quarter, among them the first unit into Canada. For the year, Pipistrel handed over 61 aircraft after the acquisition closed in April 2022. To sum up, we witnessed robust demand throughout our commercial product lines and the teams performed well, even with supply chain and labor constraints. At Aviation, the team performed very well, posting a full year segment profit margin of 11.5%. That came in above the high end of our original guidance range. Aviation's backlog climbed 55% to $6.4 billion at year-end, driven by strong order activity and customer demand. Turning to new products, we obtained FAA certification for the Cessna SkyCourier and handed over 6 of them to FedEx, our launch customer, in 2022. Textron Aviation Defense's light attack AT-6 Wolverine secured Military Type Certification from the U.S. Air Force, which opened the door to an initial international order for 8 aircraft. Over at Bell, the FLRAA contract awarded in December 2022 has firmed up the segment's long-term prospects and ought to deliver a growing revenue stream that, in our view, will fuel growth far into the future. Regarding FLRAA, the 360 Invictus is close to finished, and we anticipate its first flight in 2023, contingent on the ITEP engine being delivered. At Textron Systems, we moved our weapons programs forward through the award of our anti-vehicle munition programs, and we kept working on the robotic combat vehicle and armored reconnaissance vehicle development programs. Systems also secured Airworthiness Certification for 4 more F1s at ATAC, which raised the operational F1 fleet to 23 aircraft total, backing elevated demand across U.S. military tactical air programs. At Textron Specialized Vehicles, the company maintained its leadership in developing and producing zero emission gulf vehicles, turfmaintenance equipment and ground support equipment markets. At Kautex during 2022, we won contracts on 14 hybrid electric vehicle programs for our fuel systems. On the aviation side, the Pipistrel Velis Electro keeps collecting certifications worldwide, and it has now been certified in over 30 countries. Turning to 2023. In aviation, we foresee growth powered by more deliveries across every product line plus greater aftermarket volume. At Bell, we anticipate revenue growth in 2023 from higher military revenues tied to the FLRAA program and higher commercial revenues. At Systems, we expect mid-single-digit revenue growth throughout our businesses. At Industrial, we expect revenue growth at specialized vehicles and Kautex. In Aviation, we intend to keep investing in developing technologies and products that support sustainable flight solutions for unmanned cargo, next-generation electric trainers, eVTOL's and general aviation. Against this overall backdrop, we're projecting revenues of about $14 billion for Textron's 2023 financial guidance, and projecting adjusted EPS in the range of $5 to $5.20. Manufacturing cash flow before pension contributions should land in the range of $900 million to $1 billion; with that, I'll hand the call over to Frank.
Frank Connor
executiveAppreciate that, Scott, and good morning to everybody. Let's walk through what each segment delivered, beginning with Textron Aviation. Textron Aviation posted revenues of $1.6 billion, which came in $223 million above the same period a year earlier, driven by greater jet and defense volume along with stronger pricing. Segment profit reached $169 million in the fourth quarter, an increase of $32 million versus last year's fourth quarter, thanks to favorable pricing, net of inflation, of $29 million plus higher volume and mix, partly offset by an unfavorable performance impact. Performance covers unfavorable manufacturing performance tied largely to inefficiencies stemming from supply chain disruptions and added staffing connected to increased production, partly offset by reduced selling and administrative costs. The segment's backlog finished the quarter at $6.4 billion. Turning to Bell. Revenues came to $816 million, a decline of $42 million from last year, driven by lower military revenues, partly offset by greater commercial revenues. Segment profit was $71 million — of $71 million was $17 million below a year ago, mainly because of lower military volume and mix, partly offset by a favorable performance impact. The segment's backlog finished the quarter at $4.8 billion. Over at Textron Systems, revenues reached $314 million, $1 million above last year's fourth quarter. Segment profit of $40 million fell $5 million compared with a year ago. The segment's backlog finished the quarter at $2.1 billion. Industrial revenues came in at $907 million, $126 million higher than last year, driven by increased volume and mix of $95 million and a $59 million favorable pricing impact mostly in the specialized vehicles product line, partly offset by an unfavorable $28 million impact from foreign exchange rate fluctuations. Segment profit of $42 million rose $4 million over the fourth quarter of 2021, mainly on higher volume and mix, partly offset by an unfavorable performance impact. Textron eAviation segment revenues were $6 million and the segment loss was $10 million in the fourth quarter of 2022, which reflected Pipistrel's operating results together with research and development costs for initiatives tied to developing sustainable aviation solutions. Finance segment revenues were $11 million, and profit was $5 million. Below segment profit, corporate expenses came to $43 million in the fourth quarter. Interest expense, net for the manufacturing group was $17 million. Our manufacturing cash flow before pension contributions was $368 million in the quarter. For the year, manufacturing cash flow before pension contributions came to $1.2 billion, $29 million above the prior year, even with higher cash tax payments of $284 million in 2022 tied to the R&D tax law change. During the quarter, we repurchased roughly 3.3 million shares, returning $228 million in cash to shareholders; across the full year, we repurchased roughly 13.1 million shares, returning $867 million in cash to shareholders. Starting in the first quarter of 2023, we'll change how we measure our segment results. Starting from here, our segment profit figure will no longer include the LIFO inventory provision, amortization of intangible assets, or the non-service portion of pension and postretirement income or expense; those items are going to be disclosed separately on the income statement beneath segment profit. In our view, these adjustments allow for a steadier approach to measuring and assessing how each segment performs, and they also bring our reported results into closer alignment with what other businesses in our industry report. Slides' 15 and 16 of the investor presentation on our website show prior year results that reflect the recast of segment profit. Additionally, starting with first quarter of 2023 results, earnings per share will be reported on an adjusted basis, which leaves out the LIFO inventory provision and intangible asset amortization, both of which are noncash items. Now let's discuss our 2023 outlook, which is on Slide 9. Adjusted earnings per share should come in between $5 and $5.20 per share. Manufacturing cash flow before pension contributions is also anticipated to land at roughly $900 million to $1 billion. Shifting to the segment outlook on Slide 11, starting with Textron Aviation. Revenues should total roughly $5.7 billion. Segment margin should fall in a range of approximately 12% to 13%. Turning to Bell, revenues should be roughly $3.3 billion; our forecast calls for a margin between 8.25% and 9.25%. At systems, our estimate is revenues of roughly $1.25 billion, with margin ranging from about 10.75% to 11.75%. At Industrial, segment revenues should reach roughly $3.6 billion, with margin ranging from about 5% to 6%. At eAviation, revenues should be $45 million, alongside a segment loss of $65 million, mostly a reflection of our ongoing investments in sustainable aviation solutions. Finally, at finance, our forecast is a profit of roughly $15 million. On Slide 12, our projection is roughly $150 million in corporate expense; we also project net interest expense of roughly $90 million, a LIFO inventory provision of $130 million, intangible asset amortization of $35 million, and nonservice pension income of $235 million; the full year effective tax rate should be approximately 17.5%. Now to Slide 13. R&D should come to roughly $585 million, a decline from $601 million a year earlier. We estimate CapEx at roughly $425 million, an increase from $354 million in 2022. An average share count of roughly 205 million shares in 2023 is assumed in our outlook; that wraps up our prepared remarks. So Greg, the line is open for questions.
Sheila Kahyaoglu
analystBetween FLRAA, it's clearly been a packed quarter for you. So congrats on that. And I believe you also tossed in an Aerojet bid and <<inaudible>>; therefore my interest was on aviation margins. In Q4, I believe you finished at 10.7%, possibly less, factoring in the recasting for LIFO. How should we consider the path toward the 12.5% margins in 2023?
Scott Donnelly
executiveWell, Sheila, here's my take. To start with, during the quarter, we understood there would be some supply chain headwind. And clearly, we added many new employees, which is positive, yet there were many effects simply from bringing all those individuals aboard and training them, along with those sorts of disruptions. So during the quarter, we absorbed many of those unusual impacts straight into expense rather than placing them into inventory; thus we did suffer a hit from that. LIFO remained present, clearly, within that reported figure. So clearly, on a recast basis moving forward, that will remain. But — so as we consider what occurs when we move into 2023, clearly, LIFO won't be sitting there. And I believe we will witness — once more, we're guiding to roughly almost $0.5 billion of additional revenue, and that converts at solid margins. So I think we hold a fairly bullish view regarding our capacity to push margins upward as we progress through 2023.
Sheila Kahyaoglu
analystThen, to build on the longer-term picture, how should we view margins at their highest and lowest points in aviation? Do things simply stay on an even path from now on? Could this be a business with 20% incremental margins?
Scott Donnelly
executiveSheila, as you're aware, because of pressure from analysts, our aim has been to push past 10% margins within aviation; we're fairly confident about reaching that. In my view, volume is going to be the main driver. You all know our typical conversion tends to land in the 20% to 25% bracket. My expectation is that we can keep that up going forward. Of course, that's what we're guiding for our 2023 conversion. Beyond that point, we'll simply need to observe what the market does. The encouraging part is that demand has stayed robust. Demand during the fourth quarter stayed robust, alongside solid bookings in Q4. So as far as the environment goes, I think we're feeling fairly confident. As for how margins behave going forward, I believe we would more or less stay around that area, anticipating roughly a 20% to 25% conversion tied to our revenue growth.
David Strauss
analystScott, can you walk us through what you're projecting for Bell — revenue climbing, margins declining, a fairly sizable amount? You brought up FLRAA being part of it; so what's your specific assumption there? Does it factor in a win following the protest? If you could shed some light on that.
Scott Donnelly
executiveAbsolutely, David, it does. The protest window wraps up during the first week of April. That's been incorporated into our estimates, on the assumption it gets settled within that timeframe. Clearly, on the margin side, the dynamic is that military revenue will keep dropping. Commercial revenue will provide a partial offset. Bookings have been strong this year, and we anticipate solid growth commercially. Then, of course, 3/4 of the FLRAA program will be included, which is a positive, though that business carries lower margins. EMD programs, after all, typically have thinner margins, and that's what our '23 guide reflects.
David Strauss
analystScott, could you specify the amount of revenue from FLRAA included here? And what should we anticipate for how it scales after 2023 when it comes to revenue?
Scott Donnelly
executiveWe won't provide a breakdown of program-level details, but it's evident that growth will occur as we move through '24, '25 and, I'd say, likely for a considerable period. This program, in my view, will deliver an outstanding boost to the company. Initially, it will be driven largely by CMD, which, as we've noted, brings strong volume and solid revenue, though margins won't be very large. From there, we anticipate continued expansion and improved margins as production programs, foreign military sales, and everything else tied to a successful FLRAA effort materialize.
David Strauss
analystAll right. And the final question concerns the aero supply chain. Can you give us an update on that? And it seems your deliveries came in quite a bit lower for the entire year than what we had initially expected back when the year started. So if there hadn't been supply chain constraints, how many more deliveries would you have been able to complete this year?
Scott Donnelly
executiveWell, David, I'm not sure we'll get into specific figures. But here's the thing — since roughly the midpoint of the year, we've been projecting that we'd finish up a few hundred million dollars below our original guidance, given that we keep encountering supply chain difficulties along with some labor problems. I'd say labor has definitely gotten better as the year went on, though much of that involves new people and training, which does hurt efficiency, but at least there's some improvement on that side. We've also had quite a few suppliers that faced difficulties or are recovering, yet there are always a couple still having a hard time. So that was a — we sort of saw that coming for the second half of the year. That's the reason we tried to give some indication that we thought this would land a few hundred million under our guidance; but I believe we've factored that in; so when we consider the guidance for next year, '23, it's — supply chain obstacles are still going to be there throughout, but we're — we feel we've properly accounted for that when it comes to the '23 guide.
Robert Stallard
analystI want to begin by asking Frank something. Could you take us through the manufacturing cash flow and explain the reasoning behind your projection of a modest decrease in 2023?
Frank Connor
executiveSure. What it comes down to is our belief that working capital will keep performing well, yet we still face the ongoing impact of greater cash taxes tied to the change in the R&D tax credit. On top of that, we anticipate a somewhat reduced V and deposit activity coming from commercial volume. As a result, we're describing it around a 1:1 book-to-bill expectation when it comes to deposit activity, which creates a bit of a cash headwind compared with where we've been.
Robert Stallard
analystAll right; and then perhaps a question for Scott. Additionally, there's been quite a bit of discussion regarding the business jet sector about certain leading indicators beginning to decelerate. Have you observed any consequences of, let's say, activity flattening out or pre-owned inventory rising affecting your order activity?
Scott Donnelly
executiveNo, we have not observed that, Robert. I mean, I believe our order pace during Q4 matched what we saw in Q3. It's still pretty robust. I think when folks examine a few of these forward-looking metrics, it's difficult to monitor what — whenever you notice a slight uptick in used aircraft available for sale, which types of planes are those? What years were they built? We believe, clearly, the market has been extremely strong. Thus, people are aiming to list some aircraft for sale. They remain at quite low levels. So we aren't seeing that — the secondary effect flowing into the market for new aircraft. Therefore, we have not witnessed a significant shift in the amount of activity happening out there when it comes to orders. I mean it's — there are plenty of people ready reports. It's honestly tough to comprehend. At times there are so many comparisons of flying by region, by aircraft size versus '19, versus the prior quarter, versus '22; it's — but taking it all together; so none of that has had a meaningful effect on order activity, as far as we can tell.
Peter Arment
analystPeter, to follow up on what David asked about, regarding the supply chain and perhaps inflation as well. So it appears — I mean, <<inaudible>> anticipated <<inaudible>> yet it appears things are maintaining there? Or are they improving somewhat? And then too, could you perhaps discuss a bit how you are currently transferring the increased input costs?
Scott Donnelly
executiveWell, look, concerning the supply chain, Peter, I believe we have certain suppliers with whom we have faced difficulties, and we definitely observe them becoming healthy and improving; however, we have other regions where suppliers continue to struggle. I mean, I would rather not delve into excessive detail, but it concerns very particular components, very particular suppliers. Naturally, we are collaborating with them and attempting to get them healthy and do a superior job regarding bringing parts into the factory. And naturally, from our perspective, we perform a great deal of out-of-sequence work and exchange parts around. We would prefer to cease doing that; it represents an efficiency loss for us. Our people must work through it daily. So I think it is roughly the same, correct? As I stated, there are certain suppliers that are improving, but then you have one that is simply having difficulty catching up. I am not sure we are seeing many new suppliers arriving and saying, hey, I have a significant problem; we have a few there we have been struggling with throughout the year, and we are attempting to get them back on schedule; they are working at it, but they are just not quite there yet. And once more, we incorporated that into how we believe 2023 will unfold. Regarding the pricing aspect, Peter, we keep obtaining price, net of inflation. We are extremely focused on that. As these input costs rise, we must push price to recover that. I think the individuals are performing quite well at that.
Peter Arment
analystAnd as a fast second question about Systems — could you discuss a bit, after the Army's bill, how defense funding appears quite strong moving ahead? What's your view — we see slight expansion for Systems in this year, yet what about over the longer term?
Scott Donnelly
executiveWell, look, I believe regarding those FADEC figures, they look good to us. Considering what arrived via the omnibus for the present fiscal year's budget, it matched what we had anticipated; thus I think we're in good shape. The expansion — the positive aspect at Systems is that it's truly spread across nearly every product line. It isn't merely one specific item. Clearly, we've gained some fresh wins on the munition side, which is excellent; that has returned that business to growth. The Sentinel program keeps performing well. Our Ship-to-Shore, like I mentioned, we've completed deliveries. We'll begin negotiating the following production soon, but we'll conclude the DD&C during this year and commence production deliveries. The ATAC business has seen pleasant growth. Our electronics business has seen pleasant growth. It truly is spread across every one of the businesses inside Systems; and that omnibus budget which was appropriated aligns with, obviously, what we're guiding you folks toward.
Pete Skibitski
analystScott, is it reasonable to say that a few of your segments contain some cyclicality; and I'm curious — I'm certain you folks observe this — I believe the macro crowd's consensus is that there will be a mild recession at some point this year, possibly in the later part of it; so given how you see things, whether you share that view or not, does it make sense for you to perhaps even ease up on top line growth in those sorts of operations, perhaps like citation, perhaps TSV, in order to safeguard your margins and avoid hiring too aggressively? Are you considering your businesses in that light, or is that not really the case at the moment?
Scott Donnelly
executiveWe definitely examine that, Peter. As I mentioned, nearly every business has some cyclicality, correct? So certain ones have it to a greater degree than others. For those we believe will be more sensitive to a recession, we've essentially built in an assumption that a mild recession will occur. My view is it won't be severe. We're definitely not contemplating anything on the scale of what happened around 2009, '10; however, I don't believe we face an economic circumstance that would produce that outcome. I'd say this: when you examine prior modest recessions, the part that has consistently hit us hardest has been a downturn in the aviation business. And my sense is we're positioned very differently from how we were during those earlier downturns, since we hold a fairly substantial backlog. So I believe the character of that backlog will let us — even in a scenario where bookings slow, which could certainly happen, and I would anticipate it if a modest recession truly takes hold, you'd witness bookings decelerate, yet you have close to 2 years of backlog in place that you'll keep working through. And my view is that will help you get through it. And we haven't enjoyed that for many years, Peter, as you're aware. So I think it's a situation that would mean slower bookings, but not something that would hold back our revenue and margin generation.
Pete Skibitski
analystAll right, that's reasonable. I've got just one more question. Scott, has your team made any progress toward finalizing the AH-1 agreement with Nigeria?
Scott Donnelly
executiveThe — well, I'd say it's working its way through the government contracting machinery, correct? So that ultimately becomes — given that it's structured as an FMS, the parties on that would be us and the U.S. government. And as you're aware, Peter, that sort of thing can take some time.
George Shapiro
analystFrank, could you give us a few figures? What was the aftermarket increase for the quarter?
Frank Connor
executiveAt Aviation, aftermarket accounted for 27% of sales. So you can sort of work out the V. On that basis, it came to 11%.
Eric Salander
executive16% for the year, and I think it was <<inaudible>> in the quarter.
Frank Connor
executiveYeah. And it came in — for the full year at Aviation, aftermarket represented 33% of overall sales.
George Shapiro
analystAll right. And Scott, you didn't call it out directly, but my read is that you're thinking about deliveries tied to the '23 revenue forecast, roughly 200 to 205 units. Does that sound right?
Scott Donnelly
executiveYeah, that's about where it lands, George. So that — we've had plenty of conversations, and when you go back to '19, the fleet makeup is really not the same, correct? I mean, compared with a few years back, we're definitely weighted more toward the super mids and the mids, but that's — based on our revenue guide, it'll likely come in near that two hundred or so aircraft.
George Shapiro
analystAll right, and Scott, when I examined Q4, and even after adding back that $16 million you referenced related to supply chain problems, the margin still came in below what we saw in the prior couple of quarters. So what other factors were at play?
Scott Donnelly
executiveHonestly, I'm not sure where the 16 — the inefficiencies we absorbed along with LIFO, which had an impact of roughly $10 million or so, are mostly what pushed us to the margin rate we disclosed.
Noah Poponak
analystScott, you brought that up already, yet your backlog now stands at several times the level it had only a few years back, while output hasn't followed. So at this stage, what does the typical wait look like? And how do you plan to handle the length of time customers are kept waiting for an aircraft?
Scott Donnelly
executiveWell, look, I mean it really differs depending on which model, correct? If you consider the longitudes and latitudes, the bigger planes within the family, our view is those ought to be delivered in a couple of years. And that's roughly where things stand. Then you move to certain of the smaller planes. Those usually involve a faster turnaround from order to delivery. But once more, those likely belong in that 12- to 18-month sort of range; so when we consider production volumes and what we're putting into our forecast, which has been — that in turn shapes what our sales team has regarding open slots and timelines, that's more or less the way we're handling it.
Noah Poponak
analystAll right. In the aviation jet business, how does the pricing now going into the backlog stack up against the pricing currently flowing into the P&L?
Scott Donnelly
executiveIt's better.
Noah Poponak
analystIs that going up or holding steady?
Scott Donnelly
executiveI don't know. What I mean is, a gap isn't something we track. Are you asking about inflation pricing — is that what you mean...
Noah Poponak
analystWhat I'm trying to figure out, I suppose, is this: I realize you've been raising prices as the market has gotten stronger. While the market was improving, was there a stretch when you held back on price increases so the backlog could grow longer first, before now charging more? Is that the approach? Or has it stayed fairly steady over the past few years?
Scott Donnelly
executiveIt's stayed fairly steady. I think the — but pricing — clearly, demand is strong, correct, which really helps when it comes to pricing. Yet in our view, this market has been wrongly priced for quite a while. I mean, as all of you know, this is a business with a great deal of R&D. Developing these products and getting them certified is costly, and you must have reasonable pricing to produce margins of this kind. We've always felt the business needed to return to being one with a double-digit profit margin, and we've been pushing price to ensure that, that's the situation.
Noah Poponak
analystAll right. And from your rivals, what might constitute a legitimate protest scenario regarding FLRAA?
Scott Donnelly
executiveMy view is that none would exist.
Ron Epstein
analystJust a fast one. Could you walk me through the LIFO adjustment that you folks are doing? I mean, doesn't it seem kind of unfair to leave inflation out of your costs?
Scott Donnelly
executiveWell. Yes, — so Ron, that's a great question. Look, just so we're clear on the LIFO; so real inflation is still sitting in the segments. That's very much a cash impact; it stays in the segment. The sole item we're removing from the segment is this LIFO provisioning, correct? So under full accounting, which — again, I'm just a simple engineer, Ron, but the LIFO provisioning phenomenon is that I'm — I've purchased parts at one price. And now I have a new contract with a supplier. I have a higher price for that part. The moment that first part shows up, the LIFO provision is basically taking the actual price I paid for those other parts and raising them up to the price of that new part. So it's an accounting provisioning process; it's not an actual cost. So when I get to where that higher dollar part gets consumed by an aircraft, that's going to be in my cost. That real inflation is in the segment; it is cash and it is in performance. It's only that provisioning of that — the nature of this last-in, first-out accounting that is what we're pulling out of the segment.
Ron Epstein
analystSo I suppose there's a different way to put this. If we looked at your margins on a pro forma basis and brought them back to GAAP for 2023, what would those margins come out to without that adjustment?
Scott Donnelly
executiveWell, you'll get that complete disclosure, correct? That LIFO figure will be visible to you.
Frank Connor
executiveYou're going to notice the overall LIFO impact, Ron. And Ron, the thing is, nobody else operating in our industry uses LIFO — we do. From an accounting perspective, you have to keep tax and book treatment aligned. So in a rising-price environment, we get a tax advantage by speeding up those expenses for both book and tax reporting. Yet, as Scott pointed out, that isn't a genuine economic expense. We've essentially accumulated roughly $600 million of what amounts to a LIFO reserve on our balance sheet — earnings that were never actually realized, purely because of this accounting method that differs from what every other player in the sector does. So once inflation picked up and the LIFO figure grew larger, we believed it was necessary to call attention to it. And definitely, when looking at segment results, you should strip it out, since it doesn't represent a real economic cost to the business. It's really just a byproduct of the accounting approach we follow — but that LIFO-driven inflation will never convert into an actual economic expense for the business.
Scott Donnelly
executiveOkay, Ron, this has been something we've dealt with. LIFO has always been our method. Textron has always used LIFO too. In an environment without inflation, the effect is fairly minor. It's always been somewhat of a push; the amount is small. It hasn't caused problems. Yet when inflation shows up, suddenly you get these sizable noneconomic bookings. And like Frank mentioned, other businesses — every other player in our industry, uses FIFO accounting rather than LIFO accounting; so investors ask us a lot about what's behind these discrepancies; and so, I believe removing this makes sense. And honestly, the truth is we don't run the business that way, correct? I mean, when we meet with the business, when we're putting together our plans, when we're managing, when we hold our operating calls, LIFO isn't within their control, correct? It isn't economic; and so, that's not the way we manage the businesses, correct? We don't consider that; so it also makes sense not to report that in that segment because that's not how we manage these folks either; they don't control that LIFO; what they do control, and what they are held accountable for, is actual real inflation on that — on those greater part counts, correct? So that's — we aren't removing anything operational from the segment, but managing it based on what they control and the real financial impact.
Cai Von Rumohr
analystSo, like Sheila said, supposedly your team pursued AJRD. Pipistrel was acquired by you. FLRAA has been won by you folks; consequently it appears your company is turning into more of an a and b type operation. When we sort of examine multiples throughout the industry, it seems pure plays tend to command higher valuations, whether someone focuses on aerospace, or does air conditioning, or anything else. So when you consider your company, Scott, do any strategic initiatives come to mind? At one stage, I believe a spin-off of Kautex was something you looked at. What's your current thinking on that?
Scott Donnelly
executiveWell, look, discussing portfolio shaping or changes during an earnings call isn't something I expect we'll do. It's a topic we continually review. And with that, I think we'll stop there.
Cai Von Rumohr
analystAll right, that's helpful. Could you shed any light on — I'm not sure, honestly — but what is Lockheed's argument? What justification are they giving for filing a protest, since from everything on paper, your platform clearly appears far superior to what they offered.
Scott Donnelly
executiveWell, look, that whole matter is being handled right now between the Army and Lockheed. Because of that, there's not a great deal we can say. I suppose my only point would be that this — everyone on this call is aware, this has stretched across 10 years, correct? A tremendous volume of effort has been invested by the two contractors alongside the Army, spanning design, development, test, prototype, flight; the rigor of that effort has been extraordinary. So I don't — it's difficult for me to grasp what defect could possibly have existed in that process; to me it's almost impossible to imagine, though that question belongs to the Army and Lockheed. And obviously, our view is that the correct decision was reached. What our team accomplished makes me proud, and we can't wait to put this matter to rest and move forward with the program, which I'm certain the Army feels the same way about.
Cai Von Rumohr
analystGreat. So the final item would be how we're using our cash. You generate solid cash flow, despite the fact that it's lower than it was a year ago. Your balance sheet is in good shape. Most of what you've done has gone toward buying back stock. There's clearly a great deal of leverage involved there. Yet you also acquired Pipistrel. When you consider where that cash is headed, could you share a few views on M&A against buybacks, dividends, and everything else?
Scott Donnelly
executiveWell, listen, Cai, we're constantly reviewing whatever opportunities exist out there. Regarding what you asked about earlier, your remark, I'd say yes — in terms of where most of our capital gets deployed, we see our world as centered on the A&D sector. Pipistrel has proven to be a wonderful small business. It brought excellent technology into the firm and today matters to us when it comes to the future of sustainable flight; should similar opportunities arise, that would be wonderful. We've completed a few other smaller transactions, once again within the A&D sector, and we'd keep evaluating that. However, the main way we've put our capital to work over the past several years has been through repurchasing shares. We've been running around 5%, 6%. This past year we did another 5%, 6%, and my expectation is that's likely the path we remain on in 2023 too.
Kristine Liwag
analystScott, when it comes to what we're seeing on the Aviation demand side, can you bring us up to date on which types of customers are putting in these aircraft orders? Are these corporate buyers, individuals, fractional operators? Is the driver more growth, more replacement? Or are these first-time purchasers? More detail would help us get a better read on the demand picture.
Scott Donnelly
executiveAbsolutely. Not much has shifted from what we've been seeing. The composition remains the same. New buyers are still entering the market. The fractional segment is definitely performing well. On the fractional side, there are plenty of purchasers. For newcomers, I'd say that's an especially appealing avenue, correct? Knowing how to own this kind of asset isn't necessarily straightforward. Our fractional offerings are an excellent entry point for newcomers, and that side of things is performing nicely. Even so, demand for complete aircraft remains strong, coming from a blend of publicly traded firms, privately owned businesses, and family-run enterprises — basically the same type of clientele we've always served, I'd say. It's also consistent with what we've observed across jets, where activity is mostly powered by buyers in North America, roughly a 70 to 30 or 80 to 20 split, which is typical. Internationally, turboprops show even greater strength. Once more, we're seeing more momentum abroad — over 60% international versus domestic on King Airs, for example. So that pattern regarding who the purchaser is largely reflects our longstanding customer base.
Kristine Liwag
analystThank you. Perhaps I can build on what you said about supply chain challenges. For certain vendors that have been having a hard time for several years at this point, what does the fix look like over the long haul? What steps can be taken to ease their difficulties so that you're able to meet the robust demand for business jets? Are there alternative approaches, such as bringing parts of the supply chain in-house or something along those lines, to relieve some of that strain? What else could be done?
Scott Donnelly
executiveYeah, fair question. It's a combination of things, you know? In certain instances, there were smaller suppliers and technologies that were essentially functioning as part of us, and we ended up purchasing them and folding them into our operations. We've got a solid history of pulling that off in the past with certain key areas, like interiors. That one paid off tremendously for us. Just last year we closed a transaction in the actuation segment. Once again, a highly specialized aerospace technology. The bulk of the volume belonged to us; it's a vital supplier and a vital technology going forward; and while the figures aren't large, it was an excellent acquisition. So far, it's been performing extremely well for us. It's helped us get back on course. However, you'll always find some vendors where we represent only a tiny share of what they sell. It requires a lot of capital; it's a technology where bringing it in-house simply isn't practical. So for those situations, we simply keep collaborating with those companies. I believe all those suppliers are doing their best to catch up. Clearly, it's a solid business for them; so there's — I'd say, we don't have any suppliers that I know of who are unwilling or refuse to deliver. The issue is them rebuilding their resources and getting some sub-tier suppliers lined up, and those are companies that simply require considerable effort. Still, I believe they'll make it. As I said, we've already watched a number of them bounce back. Yet a handful of issues remain out there, and they're working toward resolving them.
Seth Seifman
analystI'll keep it to just one question. This is somewhat of a follow-up to what Kristine asked earlier. From a mix standpoint, I believe that although total deliveries remain below where they were in 2019, the number going to NetJets is likely greater. So when you consider how delivery growth will play out going forward, do you see the additional growth primarily tied to that biggest customer, or is it more about broadening the mix somewhat? Also, I would guess that the order for 200 Latitudes that NetJets placed has likely reached a conclusion quite soon. And how are you thinking about what to expect for the next batch of Latitudes from them?
Scott Donnelly
executiveWell, to begin with, I don't know what share of sales back in 2019 came from fractional versus what it is now. But when you consider diversification, selling a fractional aircraft is actually a more diversified sale than selling a single jet. Keep in mind this isn't a case of one buyer being concentrated in NetJets. Keep in mind, NetJets is selling that aircraft out there to roughly 8 people, correct? So each sale we complete with NetJets is a sale from NetJets to a whole group of different customers; so it's quite diversified. So I don't anticipate NetJets, or any fractional operator for that matter, to behave wildly differently from overall market demand, correct? If the market is robust and people want to fly privately, you'll see this mix of people who opt to do it through a fractional, which is actually a lot more people because, again, they're purchasing a fraction of an aircraft, not an entire aircraft. So when I look at our mix, I regard the mix tied to the NetJets business as a very good mix, correct? That's a very diversified sale. It's a very diversified market; and that's kind of what they do every day, correct? They're out there working and talking to lots and lots of customers across a broad customer base to sell that fraction of an aircraft. And obviously, as you all know, one thing we do now is collaborate very closely with NetJets and look out roughly about a year for when these things enter backlog depending on how their sales team is performing out there selling these aircraft. So that's a significant chunk of our backlog and a significant chunk of our business. As you all are aware, it tends to carry a lower margin since we — it's essentially a wholesale transaction. But they're the ones out there spending money on sales teams, reaching out, and selling to that big customer population. So NetJets, along with other fractionals, stays a really important piece of the business, and these fractional owners are a really, really important piece of our customer base. When it comes to the arrangement with NetJets, we're constantly talking about forecasting unit volumes. Once you approach the end of a given quantity buy, obviously we'll collaborate with NetJets on what happens next. But that's sort of a business arrangement between the two of us, obviously. But the actual forecast and backlog reflected in our numbers is really sort of a rolling 1-year process, no matter what the size of the overall arrangement is between ourselves and NetJets on latitude and longitude volumes.
Doug Harned
analystI'd like to return to what we discussed regarding how large the backlog has become, since it's obviously expanded significantly over the years. And given that the backlog decelerated on a sequential basis this quarter, how would you compare — how would you contrast the demand you're seeing for new aviation sales against essentially the waiting period that exists? Put differently, at some point you're simply going to lose customers when they must wait an excessive amount of time. So at this stage, do you perceive a limit on growth stemming from that?
Scott Donnelly
executiveHonestly, we haven't observed that. I mean, I believe the entire industry faces a comparable set of circumstances, correct? If we found ourselves in a scenario where you couldn't obtain an aircraft for 18 months to 2 years while a competitor had one available to deliver the next day, then sure, that customer could be lost. And clearly, I think someone might instead purchase a pre-owned aircraft or do something along those lines. But I think at present, every player in the industry is dealing with this same dynamic. And honestly, that's exactly where this industry ought to be, right? I mean, these are sophisticated assets. Frequently, customers already own aircraft. They have to divest their pre-owned aircraft; so look, I think the — keep in mind, this industry actually operated in this manner for an extremely, extremely, extremely long stretch. The anomaly occurred from 2008 until 2 years ago, when there wasn't much of a backlog in this class. Broadly speaking, this industry has been a backlog business. It ought to be a backlog business. Once you specify aircraft and configure aircraft and customize the aircraft, it's — this is — this really is where we find ourselves today, which is what normal ought to look like, rather than what we witnessed across the past 10, 12 years.
Doug Harned
analystNow, once you reach that point — and it's obviously a favorable one — the answer is invariably to bring on more capacity, and we've witnessed that during earlier cycles too. As you survey things right now, what would you need to observe before making substantial additions to your output capacity?
Scott Donnelly
executiveSee, I wouldn't frame it as mainly a matter of our output capacity. I mean, clearly we're working through certain supplier problems, and that doesn't really come up in the tactical discussion. But keep in mind, when we discuss delivery schedules, what the team is out there marketing as we consider that backlog, they're marketing planes and serial numbers that get handed over on particular dates, correct? So that's the way you handle this backlog, and after that you have to ensure you align your manufacturing timetable with whatever those promised handover dates happen to be. So should you begin noticing the order rate easing, you'll end up selling fewer of those future slots, and then you'd tweak your manufacturing. If suddenly you say, hey, 2025, it appears you might have 5 additional latitudes or 10 additional M2s, then you go ahead and do that, and you modulate your output capacity to fit. But I believe so long as you're out there examining this roughly 12-, 18-month, 2-year type of horizon, it gives you the means to do that. And once more, that's the way this industry has forever operated.
Doug Harned
analystAnd then, finally, one more item. Regarding the limitations originating in the supply chain, are there particular spots at this moment that you'd single out as the toughest?
Scott Donnelly
executiveYeah. I could actually name a few part numbers that represent our greatest difficulties. That isn't something we'll do. I won't push specific suppliers in front of the bus; however, yeah, a few specific products, a few specific technologies from a few specific suppliers constitute our largest bottleneck. Sure, there's constantly a lot of small things happening, but without a doubt. Getting a few of those folks straightened out would help a great deal. And once more, that doesn't mean we suddenly convert that into delivering far more aircraft, since, once more, we've given our customers committed dates. What matters far more to us at present is eliminating every inefficiency across our production runs, where we must build aircraft, move parts between them, and perform work out of order. Having to run around chasing all that material is extremely, extremely damaging to maintaining a solid, steady production operation.
Operator
operatorEveryone, a recording of this call is going to be accessible starting at 10 a.m. Eastern Time today, and it will remain available up to January 25, 2024. To hear it, you can reach the AT&T Executive replay system whenever you like by calling 1 (866) 207 to 1041, then keying in access code 4482216. If you're joining from outside the U.S., please dial (402) 970 to 0847. With that, we've reached the end of today's conference. We appreciate your participation and for choosing AT&T teleconference. You're welcome to disconnect at this point.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Textron Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Textron Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Textron Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.