The Home Depot, Inc. (HD) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
February 25, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Isabel Janci
executiveThanks, and hello everybody. On the line with us this morning are Craig Menear, our Chairman, CEO, and President; Ted Decker, Executive Vice President of Merchandising; and Richard McPhail, Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer. Once our prepared comments wrap up, we'll open the lines for questions. Only analysts and investors will be able to ask questions. One more thing to keep in mind — please stick to a single question plus one follow-up. Should we run out of time before getting to your question, you can reach our investor relations team at 770 to 384 to 2387. Before handing things over to Craig, I want to note that the press release issued today, along with the presentations our executives will make, contain forward-looking statements as defined in the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Such statements carry risks and uncertainties that might make actual results differ materially from what we expect and project. Those risks and uncertainties include, though are not confined to, the factors spelled out in the release and in our filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission. Certain non-GAAP measures also appear in today's presentations. A reconciliation of those measures can be found on our website. Craig, over to you.
Craig Menear
executiveThank you, Isabel, and good morning to all of you. Our business delivered yet another record-setting year in fiscal 2019, with sales reaching the highest level in the company's history. If you set aside the additional week that 2018 had, sales for fiscal 2019 rose 3.5% to $110.2 billion. Diluted earnings per share came in at $10.25. Just as we anticipated, we closed out the year with our best comparable performance during the fourth quarter. Comp sales climbed 5.2% compared with the prior year, and comps in the U.S. came in at positive 5.3%. Fourth-quarter sales totaled $25.8 billion, while diluted earnings per share were $2.28. During the quarter, we experienced broad-based growth spanning every geography and merchandising department. Each of our 19 U.S. regions delivered positive comps, and on the international side, positive comps were reported in both Canada and Mexico during the fourth quarter. As Ted will explain in more detail, both comp ticket and transactions increased in the quarter, and growth came from our pro customers as well as our DIY customers. We enjoyed a strong holiday season, setting sales records on Black Friday and throughout Cyber Week. These results speak to solid execution by our stores, our merchants, and our supply chain teams, in addition to our vendor partners, and they show that the consumer is overall healthy. I take pride in what we accomplished in fiscal 2019, since the team successfully steered through a number of external headwinds while keeping a relentless focus on our customer. Fiscal 2019 also represented a pivotal year in our transformation to build the One Home Depot experience. We are now two years into our multiyear investment and are realizing benefits. Our conviction is stronger than ever that these strategic initiatives are forging a value proposition unlike any other in the marketplace, one that will extend our leadership position for years to come. A majority of our U.S. stores now have a new look and feel, and we tackle customer pain points related to navigation and checkout. Our improved signage and store refresh package, together with investments at the front end of our stores, have elevated the customer experience and boosted associate productivity. These store investments are lifting customer satisfaction scores, which we believe are converting into market share gains. To complement what we are investing in our stores, we are putting capital toward strengthening the competitive advantages we have established by blending our physical and digital platforms into a more seamless interconnected experience. One example is our chain-wide rollout of digital appliance labels, which link ratings from the digital world to the physical world and enhance the in-store shopping experience. In addition, homedepot.com remains an engine of growth for our overall business, bringing in more online traffic and additional footsteps to our stores. That is why we keep investing in search functionality, category presentations, product content, and enhanced fulfillment options to remove friction from the online shopping experience. Setting aside the extra week last year, online sales rose 20.8% in the quarter and 21.4% for the year. More than 50% of the time, our customers opt to pick up their order in a store. That's what this connected retail approach can do. We've also grown what we can offer digitally, putting money into a B2B site built around what our pro customers specifically need. More than 1 million pros have now been brought on board. On top of that, in the quarter we finished rolling out a third-party CRM system — best-in-class — across every one of our pro sales and services teams. That gives us better visibility and lets us serve our customers more effectively. I'm eager about what lies ahead as we keep developing the tools to reach a pro whenever, wherever, and however they choose to engage. Another essential piece of a best-in-class connected shopping experience involves improved delivery and fulfillment choices. During 2019, we carried on with our multiyear effort to build the quickest, most efficient delivery network in home improvement; at this point, at least one of every facility type we're constructing is up and running. It's still early, yet the initial numbers make us happy. To illustrate, a dozen Market Delivery Operations, or MDOs, are now open, and they've let us move 20% of our clients' deliveries away from an outsourced model toward one where we hold more control over the customer experience. That's brought about real gains in our customer satisfaction scores for appliance deliveries. Our supply chain build-out will keep ramping up from this point, with the biggest wave of new facilities arriving in 2021 and 2022. As for 2020, Richard will walk you through the specifics, but we're anticipating yet another year of growth, with sales and comp growth both in the range of roughly 3.5%-4%, and diluted earnings per share of roughly $10.45. Our board gave the go-ahead today for a 10% bump in our quarterly dividend, bringing it to $1.50 per share, which works out to an annual dividend of $6 per share. We stay dedicated to a disciplined approach to capital allocation so we can create value for our shareholders. I take enormous pride in how far our team has come as we remake ourselves into the One Home Depot of the future. We express our sales growth as a percentage, but we capture share in dollars. Across the second year of our One Home Depot investment program, sales have risen by more than $9 billion, a growth level with no equal in our market. Looking toward 2020, my excitement about the opportunities ahead is greater than ever; we're investing to unleash the power of a genuinely interconnected customer experience by strengthening our already solid foundation so we can push our leadership position even further into the marketplace. Like any transformation, the work we're doing is complicated, and I'm proud of how our associates keep performing at high levels and stay focused on what matters most in our business, our customers. I'd like to finish by thanking our associates for their hard work and dedication in the fourth quarter and throughout the year. During the back half of this year, every one of our locations is going to get Success Sharing, the bonus plan we run for hourly team members. We're eager to keep building on the momentum we have as we move into 2020. On that note, I'll hand things over to Ted.
Ted Decker
executiveCraig, thank you. Everyone, good morning. The year closed out on a high note for us, as fourth quarter sales came in above what we had anticipated. Both our pro and DIY customers contributed to growth throughout the store. Every one of our merchandising departments delivered positive comps, with our appliance department leading the way, posting double-digit comps for the quarter. Decor and storage along with tools also recorded comps that beat the company average. Every other merchandising department was positive, though they landed below the company comp of 5.2%; during the fourth quarter, comp average ticket rose 4.4%, while comp transactions were up 0.8%. Part of what drove our comparable performance was a change in when our events took place, and Richard is going to cover that in a moment. Beyond that, the response to our Black Friday and holiday events was outstanding, and shoppers continued to move up to newer, more innovative products. After lumber and copper saw substantial deflation across the first three quarters of 2019, commodity prices had a more neutral effect in the fourth quarter. During the fourth quarter, comparable transactions for big-ticket items — those exceeding $1,000, which make up about 20% of U.S. sales — increased at a double-digit rate. Part of why our big-ticket results were so robust ties to when we moved our events on the calendar, plus solid numbers in several other big-ticket areas. During Q4, categories such as appliances, vinyl plank flooring, and the installation services arm each posted comps that beat the overall company average. Demand from consumers remains robust, which was evident throughout our yearly Black Friday gift center and decorative holiday events. Thanks to the way our merchants worked alongside our supplier partners, we delivered a terrific assortment of strong values and special buys spanning smart home, power tools, hand tools, and decorative holiday. Combining that distinctive product mix with outstanding service and execution generated amazing outcomes. For our company, Black Friday set a sales record, and our gift center event posted double-digit growth compared with the prior year. Customers were also taking on all sorts of projects around the house. Comps in the fourth quarter came in above the company average across a number of kitchen and bath categories, special window coverings, cleaning, and exterior paint. We additionally recorded substantial growth in the online-only home decor categories we refer to as HD Home, as we work to build awareness around these high-quality, style-forward assortments. Sales to our pro customers remained healthy, with momentum coming from categories such as pneumatics, concrete, hand tools, and caulks, every one of which outpaced the company average. Reflecting on 2019, our associates stayed fully dedicated to delivering strong everyday value and inventive products to the people we serve; at the same time, we put money into a store experience built around customers and an interconnected setup, so that we remain the authority in home improvement products well into the future. At our December investor conference, we walked through the investments being made across the entire company, and we also unveiled a fresh advertising campaign along with its tagline, "How Doers Get More Done," which we launched to highlight the spending behind these new experiences and capabilities. We believe it's important to demonstrate to our customers that The Home Depot is evolving alongside their changing needs. Even though this campaign hasn't been running long, customer feedback shows people are responding well to the upgrades we've made — they say we're saving them time and helping them wrap up their projects. Once that campaign went live, we had one of our strongest days ever for downloads of our award-winning mobile app, and we also saw use of mobile tools like product locator and image search climb by double digits. As we look toward 2020, we'll continue putting money into better meeting what our customers need and providing an excellent shopping experience. One investment you'll see during the first half of the year is a reset of our outdoor power equipment base. We know the outdoor power tools market is moving in a cordless direction, and within our tools department we've observed that once a customer picks a battery platform, staying with that platform delivers a great deal of value to them. In much the same way we've already handled our tools department, we are right now in the process of resetting the base of our outdoor power equipment, so that our assortment appears organized by brand, showcasing EGO, Toro, Milwaukee, Ryobi, DeWalt, and Makita, a number of which can be purchased only at The Home Depot. Through this fresh presentation, customers are able to clearly observe and easily purchase the benefits these cordless platforms deliver, including being better for the environment, more safe, and easier to use, all while providing sufficient power and runtime to get the job done. At this point, these powerful brands account for most of the batteries sold in the market, and currently hundreds of millions of them are in people's houses and at worksites. We presently offer over 1,000 cordless power tools, and because our supplier partners continually introduce new products, that number is only going to grow. In fiscal 2019, our wide and unique selection of outdoor power equipment delivered comparable sales growth in the double digits. Spring is almost upon us, so we are getting ready for another active season. New and innovative items fill our stores, and we just shared that we will add 80,000 new associates so we can take care of customers during our spring selling season. Having said that, I would like to turn the call over to Richard.
Richard McPhail
executiveThanks, Ted, and hello everyone. Before diving in, I want to offer a brief note: fiscal 2019 contained 52 weeks, while fiscal 2018 spanned 53 weeks. During the fourth quarter of fiscal 2018, that extra week brought in sales of about $1.7 billion. When we report comparable sales, or comps, we do so by matching 52 weeks against 52 weeks — weeks one through 52 of fiscal 2019 are measured against weeks two through 53 of fiscal 2018. Total sales for the fourth quarter of 2019 reached $25.8 billion, a drop of 2.7% from the prior year, which mirrors the overlap with the additional week in 2018. For Q4, same-store sales across the entire company increased 5.2%, while locations in the U.S. saw a 5.3% gain. The extra week in last year's calendar, plus the way that shifted things, means our monthly comparisons are thrown off depending on when Black Friday and Cyber Monday landed this year versus the prior year. Company-wide, the comp figures we reported by month came in at plus 1.2% for November, 9.9% for December, and 5.7% for January. Stateside, those monthly comps were up 1.1% in November, 10.4% in December, and 5.8% in January. Given how much the calendar shift distorts these monthly numbers, we believe it's more meaningful to evaluate November and December as a combined period. Taking those two months together, companywide comps came in at 5%, with January right behind at 5.7%; over the full year, sales hit an all-time high of $110.2 billion. If you set aside the extra week in fiscal 2018 — the 53rd week — our fiscal 2019 sales expanded by roughly $3.7 billion, a growth rate that no competitor in our space could equal; for the year, comps for the whole company climbed 3.5%, while U.S. comps climbed 3.8%. Fourth-quarter gross margin landed at 33.9%, a decline of 20 basis points from the prior year. Just like the quarter before, the shift in gross margin came primarily from elevated shrink and from how the product mix compared with a year earlier. Looking at the full year, gross margin came in at 34.1%, which is slightly ahead of the guidance we provided at the beginning of the year. Turning to the fourth quarter, operating expense measured as a percentage of sales declined 64 basis points to 20.7%, which was a modest improvement over what we had planned. In that quarter, we realized approximately 77 basis points of leverage from lapping both the fiscal 2018 impairment on certain trade names and the extra 53rd week we had last year. That benefit was partially offset by expenses related to our strategic investment plan, which totaled about $280 million — roughly $25 million higher than the prior year — and that created 12 basis points of de-leverage. For fiscal 2019 overall, operating expense as a percent of sales was 19.7%, a decline of 28 basis points versus last year. Our fiscal 2019 expense results beat our initial expectations, thanks to productivity initiatives in our core business. Throughout the year, investment spending tied to our strategic initiatives came to roughly $1 billion, which matched what we had planned. In the fourth quarter, operating margin landed at about 13.2%, while the full year came in at approximately 14.4%. Interest and other expense rose by $27 million in Q4, reaching $292 million, largely because long-term debt levels were higher than they had been a year earlier; our effective tax rate for the fourth quarter was 20.3%, and 23.6% for fiscal 2019. Several discrete tax items were the main reason the effective tax rate came in below expectations for both the fourth quarter and fiscal 2019. Diluted earnings per share in the fourth quarter reached $2.28, up 9.1% versus last year; for fiscal 2019, diluted earnings per share totaled $10.25, a 5.3% gain over fiscal 2018. Turning to a few more highlights; we closed the year with 2,291 stores, and retail selling square footage stood at roughly 238 million sq ft. Total sales per retail square foot for the fiscal year were $455, the best ever in our company's history. When the quarter wrapped up, our merchandise inventories had increased by $606 million, reaching $14.5 billion, while inventory turns were 4.9 times — a modest drop compared with the prior year. The year-over-year rise in inventory reflects the money we're putting toward accelerating merchandising resets and maintaining higher in-stock levels than we had twelve months earlier. Turning to how we allocate capital: during fiscal 2019, operations generated about $13.7 billion in cash, and we used that money — plus $2.4 billion in net debt issuances — to fund business investments, distribute dividends to shareholders, and buy back stock. Across the year, capital expenditures accounted for roughly $2.7 billion reinvested into the business. On top of that, shareholders received dividend payments totaling $6 billion. During the same year, we also repurchased roughly $7 billion worth of our outstanding shares — approximately 32.8 million of them — with about $3.25 billion, or 14.5 million shares, bought back in Q4 alone. Return on invested capital came in at approximately 45.4%, which is 60 basis points higher than where fiscal 2018 ended; that figure was determined by averaging long-term debt and equity at the start and close of the trailing 12 months. Now I want to spend a few moments walking through the highlights. As a reminder, our guidance is based on GAAP, and fiscal 2020 guidance will be built off the results we reported for fiscal 2019. Back at our December 2019 investor conference, we laid out some early thinking about 2020, and that same guidance still stands as of today. The U.S. consumer is in good shape, and the economy remains solid. GDP serves as the starting point for how we build our sales plan, and for 2020 our sales guidance bakes in U.S. GDP growth of just under 2%. On top of GDP, we factor in what we expect the housing backdrop to contribute, which includes demand stemming from home price appreciation, housing turnover, household formation, and how old the housing stock is. Looking at all of these figures together, the picture we get is a market that is both healthy and stable. When it comes to 2020 sales, our guidance makes the same assumption that we'll continue gaining share in the market. For fiscal 2020, we're projecting growth in sales, and in total company comp sales, of about 3.5% to 4%. Since fiscal 2020 represents the high point of our investment program, our expectation is that operating expenses for the year will climb at 1.2 times the rate of the sales growth we've projected. Across the full year, we look for operating profit dollars to reach $16 billion, putting operating margin at roughly 14%. For fiscal 2020, we're assuming an effective tax rate of about 24%. Diluted earnings per share for fiscal 2020 should rise approximately 2%, to $10.45. Looking at the full year, our operations should generate roughly $13.5 billion in cash. Of that amount, $2.8 billion is slated for capital expenditures to reinvest in the business. Beyond that, we plan to direct $6.4 billion toward dividends and to buy back no less than $5 billion of our outstanding shares. One more thing before I close out — I want to bring you up to speed on where we stand regarding one of our capital allocation principles. On the dividend front, instead of sticking with a 55% payout ratio, our approach will be to increase the dividend each year in step with earnings growth, which is exactly what we've done for the past 11 years. Earlier today, we shared news that the board approved a 10% increase to our quarterly dividend, bringing the yearly payout to $6 per share. With that said, I appreciate everyone being here on the call today. Christine, let's open it up for questions now.
Michael Lasser
analystMorning, and I appreciate you giving me the chance to ask.
Craig Menear
executiveMorning.
Michael Lasser
analystThis concerns possible interruptions to supply coming from Asia. What assumptions have you made? Where does your supply chain stand right now? So far, have any problems turned up in obtaining product from Asia? Should this continue for a significant stretch of time, how would you estimate the possible effect on your sales and earnings across the coming few quarters?
Craig Menear
executiveMichael, I'll take that first, and then pass it to Mark Holifield. To begin with, no update covering this situation is included in the guidance we've given, obviously. Things are changing rapidly, and we're watching it carefully. For Q1, essentially all of our goods are already onshore or in transit. That leaves us feeling fairly good. Mark, perhaps you could give an update on
Mark Holifield
executiveAbsolutely, Craig. So yes, like you said, that shifts daily. When it comes to Q1 merchandise, it's either arrived already or it's in transit. As for Q2, things are still taking shape. On the direct import side, our sourcing offices throughout Asia are communicating with our top factories as those facilities start up again; when it comes to domestic vendors, we're collaborating with them to figure out and reduce whatever potential effects might hit their supply chains. Our team is engaged with every supplier we have, domestic as well as import, plus our logistics service providers, looking at things purchase order by purchase order and container by container to determine how our product flow is being affected, and they're doing what needs to be done; it's encouraging to see factories resuming operations, provinces in China resuming operations, this remains a fluid situation, and there's a great deal of variability regarding where things stand right now.
Michael Lasser
analystMichael, just to make sure we're on the same page: given what you're aware of right now, do you believe there's going to be a negative impact on earnings across the coming 2 quarters because of any supply chain problems, even if the situation returns to normal very soon? Or do you still have enough time to make adjustments given what you currently know?
Craig Menear
executiveCraig, here's my response: Michael, from what we currently know, we can't state that there would be an impact. Once again, our teams are handling this on a daily basis. Like Mark mentioned, purchase order by purchase order, container by container. We're also establishing plans to reduce any risk moving forward.
Michael Lasser
analystIs that something we include?
Craig Menear
executiveDomestic work accounts for 70% of everything we do.
Michael Lasser
analystAll right, thank you. For my follow-up, you've now finished a second consecutive year with roughly 1% comp traffic growth, following a long stretch when traffic ran higher than that. Should we treat 1% traffic growth as the new standard? How do you expect carrying out your strategic investment plan to affect traffic over the coming few years?
Craig Menear
executiveWell, here's how I'd put it — what the investment plan is meant to accomplish is putting us in position to keep expanding more quickly than the market does. I'd say part of the growth we recorded in earlier years came from a rapid bounce back out of a really tough place. Our consistent emphasis has been on striking the right balance between ticket and transactions, and that's genuinely where we're centered. Where that lands is something the market decides.
Michael Lasser
analystAll right. Thanks a lot, and best of luck.
Craig Menear
executiveThanks.
Scot Ciccarelli
analystMorning, everyone. To start, I want to piggyback on what Michael asked. The way I see it, with the gap between transactions and average ticket that's shown up, where would you say the cause of that split lies? You mentioned a recovery phase just now. My thinking is that such a phase ought to lift both sides of the ledger, rather than only one.
Craig Menear
executiveWhat I'd tell you is that certain areas where we've placed bets to keep expanding have sped up our ticket gains, mainly because we made a sizable commitment to appliances, and that has come back to us in a major way through the faster growth this business has delivered. The same applies to what Ted brought up concerning lithium technology, along with the higher average ticket in power tools and, more recently, outdoor power equipment. I believe a mix of innovation and investment has played a part in pushing ticket up, possibly to an even greater degree, as we gained share in those categories. The steadiness of our traffic increases across time has left us quite satisfied. As I noted, we'll aim to keep traffic and ticket in balance. We always want to be sure that balance stays sensible.
Scot Ciccarelli
analystSorry about that—please continue.
Ted Decker
executiveScot, I was simply going to chime in with one more point. The fourth quarter was heavily driven by events. Our gift center, decorative holiday, and, as Craig mentioned, appliances—every one of those did extremely well. That lifts the average ticket, and it reflects shoppers who keep moving up to the new innovative items we're putting out there. Transactions pleased us, though they were somewhat held back by the absence of cold weather. Consider how in winter plenty of folks drop in for ice melt, for that quick smaller purchase, or even car washer fluid, and so on; with the winter being milder, those fast cold weather pickup products accounted for much of the steepest drag on transactions.
Scot Ciccarelli
analystAll right, that's useful. So I suppose, considering every one of the investments you folks have been putting into the business — in supply chain and technology — should we keep anticipating the same pattern we've witnessed here to carry on, or does it wind up having a more even effect down the road? Thanks.
Craig Menear
executiveAgain, I'd say we aim for some balance there. Is it going to be flawless in either direction? No; balance is what we'd be after.
Scot Ciccarelli
analystAll right. Thanks a lot.
Simeon Gutman
analystThank you. Morning. Let me start with something longer term. If we revisit the return we're getting on the money we've put in, it seems like certain expenses will ease up in the coming year, and that should help margin. On the revenue side, and I know you likely won't put hard figures on it, could you share where we should expect comps to improve first? Would it be the share of wallet among pros? Could it be MRO categories, or DIY? Which KPIs — ones that won't show up as obviously as comps — are you watching that signal to you that some of these outlays are starting to deliver?
Craig Menear
executiveTo begin with, every one of those areas you just listed is where our investments are aimed. When you say pro, you mean MRO, you mean consumer. Growing across each of those is what we intend to do. What we're truly setting ourselves up for with this investment is getting The Home Depot into a position where it can outpace the market's growth consistently, regardless of whatever conditions exist; that's genuinely the objective we're after.
Simeon Gutman
analystIs it necessary to hold off until the supply chain spending has completely rolled out, or not—should that happen gradually while all these other investments occur?
Craig Menear
executiveThe supply chain makes up one piece of the whole picture. As we've told you, we have investments stretching throughout our company—spending in stores, spending in the digital realm, in our marketing areas and our product development, plus the supply chain. We're putting more and more of these capabilities in place as the supply chain keeps growing, as we launch additional facilities during 2021 and 2022, most of them; we'll watch that keep expanding as we add more capabilities to address the market.
Simeon Gutman
analystAlright. For my second question — during Q4, it seems the business did somewhat better than we had anticipated. Could you break down any fundamental housing signals suggesting possible improvement, as opposed to seasonal factors? December sounds like it was a huge month. I'm not sure whether that's mostly holiday-related, and at the same time, you also didn't face as much weather disruption. If you could just address fundamental housing versus other things driving it.
Richard McPhail
executiveOf course. Simeon, Richard here. Looking at housing, every housing metric ended up pretty much right where we thought they'd land. In our view, that didn't have any meaningful effect on what we do. You brought up December. The calendar had a slight timing move from November into December. On the whole, it was simply solid execution throughout the quarter. Ted, perhaps you'd like to elaborate a bit on how strong the quarter was.
Ted Decker
executiveAs I mentioned in my remarks, we're happy with how ticket and transaction balance out, and we definitely appreciate the mix between consumer and pro, with pro performing well in Q4. In categories that lean more discretionary, we observed a highly engaged consumer — our artificial Christmas tree business was terrific, and our gift center posted record sales along with growth. On appliances, like I noted, comps were up double digits. It isn't only a case of a fridge breaking down and needing a swap anymore. More and more, these are discretionary buys. The consumer we just saw was very strong.
Simeon Gutman
analystGreat. Thank you.
Chuck Grom
analystHey, thanks. Nice quarter. Once you adjust for the timing of that event, revenue looks fairly steady throughout the period. I'm curious how we ought to view the pattern of comparable sales on a quarterly basis for 2020, and also whether you might share some perspective on how February has performed so far.
Richard McPhail
executiveThanks, Chuck. We don't give guidance by quarter, though we would note that for 2020, comparable sales should be spread fairly evenly between the first and second halves of the year. As for what we've observed in 2020 up to this point, our guidance reflects the best information available to us right now. The numbers we've posted so far line up with what we told you to expect.
Chuck Grom
analystAll right, that's helpful. Stepping back a bit, I was hoping you could expand on what the pro opportunity looks like as more of those customers get brought onto the B2B site, especially since the CRM piece is now going to be part of it. Thanks.
Craig Menear
executiveYes. So when it comes to the pro shopper, what we're really doing is creating an ecosystem around them — one that includes goods and labels, shipping, financing options, plus our online tools like B2B tool rental and plenty of other things. Naturally, having all of that work together lets us serve those pro customers far more completely, and it lets us keep expanding alongside bigger, more sophisticated accounts. As for the pro segment, our estimate puts us somewhere between 15% and 17%, and down the road we'd really like that figure to move much closer to the share penetration we already enjoy with consumers — that's the reason these investments are being made.
Chuck Grom
analystThank you.
Chris Horvers
analystThanks. Good morning, everyone. A few follow-ups. To start with the seasonal business and how weather played in overall, what's your take on last year's weather effect? December had a lot of rain. I believe you flagged 85 basis points of headwind 12 months ago. January also brought warm conditions, in contrast to the polar vortex at the close of the prior year. Meanwhile, you didn't see snow melt or the snowblower. How would you size up weather's total effect?
Ted Decker
executiveChris, Ted here. I'd call it neutral. Exactly like you described, the season ran longer in certain markets, the ground wouldn't freeze, and so on, which let pros keep working. Conversely, you missed out on all your cold weather categories. Our merchants handling chore, snow, and ice melt aren't as pleased as some of our other merchants. On the whole, I'd say minimal effect, neutral.
Chris Horvers
analystUnderstood. Now regarding gross margin — compared with the third quarter, the result improved. You noted that shrink and mix remained challenges, and you mentioned analysts believe those pressures carried into 2020, yet things did improve somewhat. What changed in that situation and helped counterbalance it? Did either of those items ease, and does that alter your outlook when you consider 2020?
Richard McPhail
executiveShrink matched what we saw throughout the year, and as we've talked about, we're implementing measures to tackle it in 2020. We gained a strong advantage, just as we have all year, from certain supply chain investments we're making in productivity and supply chain. Shrink matched what we saw.
Chris Horvers
analystRegarding the change from the prior quarter, is there anything worth highlighting?
Richard McPhail
executiveThe pattern holds steady, and like I mentioned, our plan is to tackle it over the course of 2020.
Chris Horvers
analystUnderstood. Many thanks. Enjoy the spring season.
Richard McPhail
executiveThank you. Appreciate it, Chris.
Mike Baker
analystHello, and thank you. I have a few questions. First, regarding the comparable sales forecast for the upcoming year, which is 3.5% to 4%. In the current year, your comp was 3.5%, though lumber negatively impacted you by at least 50 basis points. Basically, your guidance implies a deceleration next year — in fact, the weakest comp in several years once inflation is factored in — even as housing appears to be improving. I'm just wondering about that mismatch: is it essentially positioning yourselves for possible upside?
Ted Decker
executiveThe approach we follow remains the same, and while it isn't a flawless model, Richard, could you please go over the specifics?
Richard McPhail
executiveYes, of course. Our approach to giving sales guidance hasn’t changed. When you break down what goes into that approach—everything from GDP forecasts to our views on housing-related support to the belief that we’ll keep gaining share—not one of those underlying assumptions has shifted meaningfully since December. That’s the reason we’re reaffirming that outlook.
Craig Menear
executiveOne thing I want to mention, I suppose. There's a tendency for folks to view our business through the lens of interest rates. For what it's worth, linking sales figures to rates has never worked for us, so that factor doesn't factor into how we think.
Mike Baker
analystSo, as a follow-up on that point, one would assume your business is tied to housing, correct? And that, in turn, presumably moves with interest rates. Would that be a reasonable way to put it?
Richard McPhail
executiveThat's a reasonable way to put it. For sure, during the very recent stretch, a few of those indicators have edged up somewhat. We won't revise guidance because of near-term swings or what we observe in housing. In our view, housing is healthy and stable. It will keep offering favorable support to our business.
Mike Baker
analystAlright, that's clear. If I may ask a second question — from what I remember, Q3 took somewhat of a hit because of when Black Friday landed, and presumably that was a benefit to Q4. I understand how the months moved around inside the quarter, but when comparing Q3 with Q4, did Q4 gain anything from that? And if it did, what was the amount?
Richard McPhail
executiveYes, it was approximately a 35 basis point swing in each direction, so Q3 was reduced by 35; that amount moved over to Q4, adding 35.
Mike Baker
analystAll right, thanks. Let me squeeze in one final question. You mentioned that your approach to comps hasn't shifted, yet the method behind the dividend is being altered. I'm just curious why that change is happening. Is this simply a matter of having a new CFO who views things differently, or is there another factor we ought to consider?
Richard McPhail
executiveWell, our policy of aiming to raise the dividend annually in step with earnings growth remains in place; we won't bind it to any particular payout ratio. This year's 10% bump, I'd say, illustrates nicely both our plan to keep lifting the dividend and our assurance about the business.
Mike Baker
analystAll right, that's clear. Thanks for your time.
Karen Short
analystHello, and thank you. I'd like to build on what was mentioned regarding the dividend. Should we assume a particular link between how earnings per share grow and how the dividend grows? As you pointed out, a rise of 10% is quite striking, since during 2020, it seems you're anticipating only about a 2% gain in earnings. It stands to reason that earnings growth will pick up speed in 2021.
Craig Menear
executiveOur overall approach to capital allocation remains exactly the same. Above all, we will put the necessary funds into the company so it stays positioned to succeed over the long run. When we have extra cash, we evaluate any possibilities that may arise, and we're dedicated to raising the dividend each year as earnings increase. After that, we'll keep seeking additional ways to give money back to shareholders, beyond other options, through buying back shares. Those fundamentals are what we consistently uphold here. We simply prefer not to tie ourselves to a specific percentage.
Karen Short
analystAll right, thank you. That's useful. Regarding the guidance of 14% for operating margin, clearly you finished this year slightly above that, at 14.4%. Is there anything worth highlighting about that 40 basis point decrease compared with the previous 30 basis points?
Richard McPhail
executiveNo; it simply reflects better-than-expected performance in Q4 and essentially rounding up to 14.4%, rather than what we had anticipated for 2020, and those expectations remain unchanged. Look, strong execution throughout the business, from sales to gross margin to operating expense. It was a collective effort, and the results we achieved make us proud.
Karen Short
analystAll right, so my final question. Could you share anything new regarding more personalization and features for the B2B? Perhaps any insight into how the pros are behaving and/or converting among those you have brought on board?
Craig Menear
executiveWe keep encouraging deeper involvement from the pros we have brought onto the B2B website; what we observe pleases us as those pros ramp up their involvement. Once more, like I said earlier, we are creating a full ecosystem centered on the pro. That website makes up one piece of this experience, yet it includes everything I described previously.
Karen Short
analystAll right, that's great. Thank you.
Brian Nagel
analystHello there, and good morning.
Craig Menear
executiveGood morning.
Brian Nagel
analystThanks for taking my question, and congratulations on a solid quarter. I'd like to pull back for a moment. Back at the December meeting, a lot of our discussion centered on the investment initiatives, and at that point you noted that certain benefits from them were arriving more slowly than originally expected, though they were still on the way. So I'm hoping for an update on that. Looking at the business today, you posted a really strong quarter. You sound enthusiastic about these initiatives. Has the progress you're seeing on that front exceeded what was described back in December?
Craig Menear
executiveAs we said back in December, we expected to keep seeing those investments pay off as we go forward. That's exactly what's happening. As Ted pointed out, this quarter in particular reflected a mix of factors: the momentum from the events we launched, the products we introduced to the market, and the ongoing advancement of our initiatives. All of those elements together are what produced the results this quarter. Yes, we're happy with the growth we keep seeing from the initiatives. At the same time, I'm genuinely proud of the team. Our stores executed exceptionally well. The supply chain group performed wonderfully. Our vendors delivered fantastic products and value. The fact that customers can begin that shopping journey online, research items and/or buy them there — all of it is driving the type of performance we delivered in Q4.
Brian Nagel
analystUnderstood. For my follow-up, Craig, I suppose this is a comparable sort of question, and it concerns shrink. That's another subject we devoted considerable time to during the December analyst meeting. To what degree might shrink serve as a swing factor in 2020, assuming you managed to achieve better performance than what we witnessed in 2019?
Craig Menear
executiveAs we discussed back in December, I believe we're currently rolling out our programs aimed at reducing the effect of shrink. Realizing the upside will require some time before it makes its way into the P&L, since inventory at the stores is essentially counted only once per year.
Richard McPhail
executiveThis is being introduced in stages.
Brian Nagel
analystUnderstood.
Richard McPhail
executiveWe have tested certain methods. Those outcomes give us a lot of confidence, though we continue to pick up things along the way. Our confidence is high, and like Craig mentioned, beyond the phased introduction itself, there's the matter of when it actually shows up in the P&L, and that happens with a delay as we build up inventories.
Brian Nagel
analystSounds good. And best of luck as we head into spring.
Craig Menear
executiveAppreciate it.
Richard McPhail
executiveThanks.
Liz Suzuki
analystExcellent, thanks. About the 2020 margin guidance, could you discuss the assumptions you're building in for product margin, as well as how mix affects gross margin?
Craig Menear
executiveThat's something we keep to ourselves for competitive reasons.
Richard McPhail
executiveYeah. We can't detail that competitive reason.
Craig Menear
executiveNo, that's not something we would do. Yeah.
Liz Suzuki
analystAll right. Given how robust appliance sales have been, is there no thought that mix might work against you, say? Does your gross margin assumption factor in anything related to mix?
Richard McPhail
executiveYes, it does. When we laid things out back in December, and if you walk toward that 14.0% guidance, you begin from the reality that on a business as usual basis, we will produce operating expense leverage, underlying just about everything. Keep in mind this marks the peak year of investment within our three-year investment program. Margin will feel pressure from that. We observe the effect of shrink, and as we've stated, steps are being taken by us to address it; mix plays a role too. That mix pressure is a favorable kind of pressure; it's the pressure showing that in categories such as appliances, such as power tools, such as outdoor power, we are gaining share. Even though we believe mix pressure exists there, growing incremental market share, incremental sales and incremental operating profit dollars is what we aim for; we accomplish that by going after the market opportunities right in front of us.
Liz Suzuki
analystUnderstood. Alright. Have any items been left out of the tariffs after the fact, such that you're receiving money back now? Do those reimbursements serve as a beneficial reduction to your cost of goods sold?
Ted Decker
executiveYeah. Let me begin by expressing enormous gratitude to our combined merchandising, finance, supply chain, global sourcing team, since they spent the entire year dealing with this tariff matter. I mean, we devoted considerable energy to it, and those teams performed remarkably well. That carries over into the exclusions, because that represents an entire scope of effort where, pardon me, you have to track whatever is being filed and sought for exclusion and truly break it down to the SKU identifier and then submit all the necessary documents to secure the approvals. That's a tremendous amount of work that the team is presently handling. One major category, a tremendously fast-growing category for us that has now been excluded, is luxury vinyl plank within the flooring business. That's likely the largest single one, and we're actively pursuing getting those previously paid tariff dollars refunded.
Liz Suzuki
analystAll right. Did those refunds have any effect on your Q4? And going forward, is it more likely that a portion of that will show up during the first half of the year?
Richard McPhail
executiveA bit of that was present. There were pluses and minuses during the quarter, and we're very pleased with how the business performed overall.
Liz Suzuki
analystAll right, thanks.
Zach Fadem
analystHi there, good morning. I'd like to know if you could address in detail what you anticipate for the e-commerce segment during fiscal 2020. With every effort underway related to fulfillment and pro, I'm wondering if you think that 20% growth figure will persist, if you're continuing to introduce new categories, and what factors you see driving 2020.
Craig Menear
executiveWell, our e-commerce operation has us enthusiastic, and it functions within an interconnected retail approach overall. In our view, the entry point of the store now sits inside the customer's pocket and at the job site, and for the majority of our shoppers, the buying journey truly begins online, even when it concludes at a physical location. As Ted has mentioned, we've broadened our product selection online into additional home-related categories. We see that as an ongoing chance, since customers have told us they feel we can deliver strong value in those home areas, and they have confidence in us to provide it. Our digital operation, we believe, remains a growth driver, in both the online sphere and the brick-and-mortar sphere.
Richard McPhail
executiveThis isn't its own standalone operation. Our merchandising group—the single merchandising group we have—handles it. Instead of viewing it as a distinct business, you should see it as a capability.
Zach Fadem
analystUnderstood. Regarding appliances, I'm wondering whether you might elaborate a bit on what bringing home delivery in-house has meant. Given the market share you've picked up in that area across the last few years, can you say how much share, in your view, remains available to win, and where you believe that share is being taken from?
Mark Holifield
executiveYes, we feel very good about it. Pardon me. This is Mark. The work our Market Delivery Operations, or MDOs, have accomplished makes us quite happy; those facilities are run by Orange Apron The Home Depot associates, and they make sure product arriving at those sites gets sent out quickly to the customer without damage. They also focus on delivering an excellent customer experience, coordinating with the delivery teams. We're very happy with how things are going. Craig noted during his remarks that 12 of these are now open. Roughly 12 more leases have been signed, and we'll keep expanding those throughout 2020. While we do that, our on-time performance, our reschedule rate, and our customer satisfaction all keep getting better.
Ted Decker
executiveWhat I would call a chance for continued expansion. A great many players remain—regional outfits, super-regional chains, and even small family-run furniture shops that carry appliances. Our view is that a substantial amount of share is still available. It's obvious Sears gave up ground across the years and shrank its store footprint quite dramatically; we continue to see an enormous market where we've brought a disruptive mindset for quite some time, and that keeps delivering benefits as we gain share.
Zach Fadem
analystUnderstood. Thanks for the time.
Isabel Janci
executiveChristine, there's room for one additional question.
Seth Sigman
analystExcellent. Hi, everyone. I appreciate you fitting me in. There are a couple of follow-ups I have. To start, regarding the guidance, and in particular how it's paced. Richard, my understanding is that you provided us with a comparable sales cadence that stays similar across the year. What's the right way for us to consider gross margin and SG&A, and I suppose just how the investments are timed? Should we expect more strain on operating margin during the first half compared with the second half?
Richard McPhail
executiveTo begin, our approach is to look at it in halves, and we don't give guidance for any specific half. What we see is a year that's fairly even throughout the entire company.
Seth Sigman
analystUnderstood. Alright, one more thing regarding that exit rate, with January coming in stronger. Should we factor in some kind of pull forward driven by weather, or is it more a mix of what you're doing plus just healthy demand in general? And something tied to that on the macro side. Sounds like you're keeping a fairly cautious stance. What I want to know is whether you're noticing any improvement or divergence in markets that slowed down last year and are now picking up somewhat? Any shift in how things are performing that might make you feel the housing environment is simply more favorable for the business at this point? Thanks.
Craig Menear
executiveSeth, I'd start by saying, when it comes to regional variability, the quarter we just finished was among the tightest we've experienced lately, and no broad variability is showing up. It's too soon to know how things will shake out across the first half. Our habit has been to frame this in halves, since weather can do anything and either speed up or push back a spring, and after that you typically try to make the most of it during the first half. That's basically how we handle it. Nothing we're seeing would cause us to think about it any other way at all.
Seth Sigman
analystAll right, that makes sense. Many thanks.
Isabel Janci
executiveWonderful. Thanks, Christine, and thanks for being with us today. We're looking forward to talking with everyone during our Q1 earnings call in May.
Operator
operatorThat brings us to the end of today's teleconference. At this point, you're free to hang up your lines. Thanks for joining us, and enjoy the rest of your day.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete The Home Depot, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to The Home Depot, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in The Home Depot, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.