The Home Depot, Inc. (HD) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

May 16, 2023

New York Stock Exchange US Consumer Discretionary Specialty Retail earnings 64 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Isabel Janci

executive
#1

Thanks, Christine, and good morning to all of you. It's a pleasure to welcome everyone to Home Depot's earnings call for the first quarter of 2023. On the line with us today are Ted Decker, our Chair, President and CEO; Billy Bastek, Executive Vice President of Merchandising; Ann-Marie Campbell, Executive Vice President of U.S. Stores and International Operations; and Richard McPhail, Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer. Once our prepared remarks wrap up, we'll open the lines for your questions. <<operator_script>> Should we run out of time before reaching your question, you can reach our Investor Relations department at (770) 384 to 2387. Before handing things over to Ted, I want to remind everyone that the press release issued today, along with presentations our executives will make, contain forward-looking statements as defined in the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Such statements carry risks and uncertainties that might cause actual results to differ materially from what we expect and project. Those risks and uncertainties include, but are not limited to, the factors identified in the release and in our filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission. Certain non-GAAP measures will also appear in today's presentations. A reconciliation of those measures is available on our website; with that, let me hand the call to Ted.

Ted Decker

executive
#2

Thanks, Isabel, and good morning to all of you. During the last 3 years, we expanded our business by $47 billion, which equals 43%. Following that stretch of extraordinary growth, we anticipated that demand would soften in fiscal 2023, and the results from our first quarter bear that out. First quarter sales came in at $37.3 billion, a decline of 4.2% versus the same period a year ago. Comp sales fell 4.5% compared with the same period last year, and negative comps of 4.6% were recorded at our U.S. stores. Diluted earnings per share came to $3.82 in the first quarter, versus $4.09 in last year's first quarter. We didn't hit the sales targets we'd set for the quarter. The main culprits were falling lumber prices and bad weather — particularly out West, where severe conditions in California hit our numbers harder than in other regions. Billy can confirm that in areas where the weather was favorable, we saw solid demand in important spring categories like live goods and other garden products. If you take weather and lumber deflation out of the picture, our core results for the quarter were a mixed bag. We felt more strain across the business than we did when we shared our fourth quarter results a few months ago. Even though categories tied to projects—like building materials, plumbing, and hardware—showed some relative strength, a lot of departments had negative comps this quarter, and we're still seeing pressure across several big-ticket discretionary areas. DIY customers outperformed Pro customers in the quarter, but both came in negative. According to internal and external surveys, Pro backlogs are still healthy and above what's typical historically, though they've come down versus a year ago. Beyond that, recent external data points suggest the mix of projects in those backlogs is moving away from large-scale remodels and toward smaller ones. Although just one quarter of the year has passed, we feel that this quarter's results falling short of what we anticipated, along with falling lumber prices and ongoing unpredictability in underlying demand, justify a more careful sales forecast for the rest of the year. Richard will walk you through the specifics shortly, but our current guidance calls for a comp sales decrease of 2% to 5%. With this revised comp guidance in mind, we now anticipate an operating margin rate ranging from 14.3% to 14%, and earnings per share dropping somewhere between 7% and 13%. We keep steering through a distinctive set of conditions; we stay nimble and adapt to shifting customer behavior while consistently championing value. Beyond that, the money we've put into wages is clearly paying off as intended. Ann will go into detail, but since the latest round of pay increases kicked in, we're seeing more qualified people apply and fewer workers leaving. And finally, as you'd anticipate, we'll keep pushing on productivity and efficiency throughout the company. Even though things look murky in the near term, we're optimistic about where home improvement is headed over the medium to long term, and about our capacity to take share in a market this big and fragmented. We can't wait to talk through all the opportunities in front of us at our Investor and Analyst conference on June 13. Taking care of our people and shoppers continues to be what matters most to us. During this period, the folks in merchandising, our store MET crews, the partners who supply us, and those working in supply chain all did a great job delivering value and service to shoppers. Before I finish, I want to say thank you for how dedicated and hardworking they are. I also want to give a warm welcome to Billy Bastek, our newly named EVP of Merchandising. Billy has spent 33 years with the Home Depot, so he brings a great deal of experience into this role, since he has spent his entire career here in various positions of increasing responsibility throughout merchandising. Beyond being a standout merchant leader, Billy also does a wonderful job protecting our culture. It's my pleasure to have him join us on the call today.

Billy Bastek

executive
#3

Thanks, Ted, and good morning to all of you. To begin, I'd also like to express appreciation to each of our associates along with our supplier partners for the dedication they keep showing toward serving our customers and our communities. As Ted mentioned, sales during Q1 came in under what we had anticipated, largely because of deflation in lumber as well as unfavorable weather. We additionally witnessed a continuation of the pattern we noticed in Q4, with consumers scaling back on big ticket items and certain discretionary types of purchases. That said, in regions where the weather cooperated, we experienced strength in outdoor projects with smaller tickets. Now moving to how our departments performed on a comp basis in Q1. Positive comps were posted by 4 out of our 14 merchandising departments, and those were building materials, hardware, plumbing and millwork. In Q1, our comp average ticket rose 0.2% while comp transactions fell 5%. If you set aside core commodities, comp average ticket was mainly affected by inflation across a number of product categories, along with demand for new and innovative products. Deflation within core commodity categories hurt our average ticket growth by roughly 335 basis points in Q1, driven mostly by lumber deflation. In Q1, lumber prices fell significantly compared with a year earlier. To illustrate, framing lumber averaged about $420 per thousand board feet, versus roughly $1,170 in Q1 of 2022, amounting to a 64% decline. Now turning to online sales for the whole company. Sales that leverage our digital platforms fell about 2.9% versus Q1 of last year. Among customers who opted to do business with us online in Q1, more than 45% of our online orders were fulfilled via our stores. DIY customers did better than Pro customers during the quarter, though both were negative. Pro results took a disproportionate hit because of lumber deflation and a wet start to spring — that wet start to spring hurt both customer cohorts. Big ticket comp transactions, meaning those above $1,000, dropped 6.5% versus Q1 of last year. We did see some big ticket strength in Pro-heavy categories such as portable power, gypsum and pipe and fittings. Following a couple of years of unprecedented demand in the home improvement market, we keep seeing softness in big-ticket discretionary categories such as patio, grills and appliances, which likely reflects deferral of these single item purchases and pull forward; beyond that, we've seen demand soften in other parts of the business too, including flooring, kitchen and bath. This softer demand may reflect consumers shifting away from larger projects toward smaller ones; and although there are factors affecting the home improvement market, our merchandising organization will stay focused on being our customers' advocate for value; that means continuing to offer a broad assortment of best-in-class products that are in stock and available whenever our customers need them. We'll also keep leaning into products that simplify the project, saving our customers both time and money. That's the reason I feel such enthusiasm regarding the new offerings we're introducing to customers, including things like Leviton's Decora Edge, Viega Copper press fittings, or the debut of BEHR DYNASTY exterior paint, to give just a few examples. During the investor conference we have coming up, I'm eager to tell you more in person about these items and a few of the product innovations I like best. Our vendor relationships give us real strength, and when you combine that with our merchant organization, which is best-in-class, we're able to give customers top brands featuring the greatest innovation to address pain points, boost functionality, or deliver better performance — all at the finest value available in the market. Let's now shift our focus to spring. Even though the season got off to a slower beginning, we stay enthusiastic about the product lineup we've prepared for customers and we're still ready to assist them with outdoor living needs or outdoor projects. As we've told you on many occasions, we carry an excellent assortment of outdoor power products, and our selection from RYOBI, Milwaukee, DEWALT and Makita has something suited to everyone, built on an ecosystem of innovative tools that share the same battery platforms, plus our live goods are amazing; from shrubs to a range of flowers, herbs, and vegetables for every kind of gardener, we're set for spring. With that said, I'd like to hand the call over to Ann.

Ann-Marie Campbell

executive
#4

Thanks, Billy, and hello everybody. To deliver the strongest possible experience for customers, our conviction is that we have to concentrate on building the strongest possible experience for associates in retail. During the prior quarter, I discussed the investments we've made so that associates find it simpler to thrive at the Home Depot; we likewise shared that roughly $1 billion would be put toward yearly pay for hourly frontline associates. Today, I'd like to bring you up to date on the main areas where we've observed progress so far. Even in our stores with the heaviest volume, our capacity to draw in qualified candidate pools and to hire at the top tier of those pools has gotten better. And in March, the year-over-year gains in our attrition rates were the largest we've witnessed in quite a while, spanning every associate tenure cohort. Consequently, we're seeing better results on important customer service metrics, plus operational benefits through steadier staffing and fewer safety incidents throughout all our regions. What we're seeing is precisely what this wage investment was intended to accomplish. A consistent and talented workforce forms a crucial base for advancing both customer service and productivity. It additionally provides us with the capability and confidence to speed up other important initiatives that are producing favorable outcomes when it comes to customer service and productivity. We've made changes to how we handle order fulfillment so that picking and staging orders for customers happens with greater speed and efficiency. In the past, our fulfillment hours were assigned according to total order volume. These days, we've moved to assigning hours more precisely according to which kinds of products are being picked. To give just one illustration, picking and staging paint takes us less time than a patio set does. We're also batching fulfillment orders into groups so associates can pick several orders simultaneously; simplification remains a continued focus for us as well. We've discussed using the Sidekick application to assist associates in prioritizing the most valuable task more effectively. Driven by our machine learning logic, Sidekick sends associates to key bays where on-shelf availability is low or an item is out of stock. Since Sidekick's rollout last year, we've observed better on-shelf availability for all SKUs, though the biggest gains have come among our high-velocity SKUs, meaning the products that are key drivers of our business. This has amounted to an increase of roughly 300 basis points in our shelf availability customer service scores. Although this app helps us work more efficiently on task activity and enhance our customer experience along the way, Sidekick has only just begun. These initiatives represent only a handful of examples among the many kinds of projects capable of generating meaningful impacts for customers, our associates and our shareholders. I'm tremendously enthusiastic about everything our store teams are tackling to keep both the customer and associate experience front and center, and I look forward to sharing much more in a few weeks. Our incredible team members are the reason any of this can happen, and I’d like to express my gratitude to each of them for the work they put in daily to serve our customers. Having said that, I’ll now hand things over to Richard.

Richard McPhail

executive
#5

Thanks, Ann, and good morning to all of you. For the first quarter, total sales came in at $37.3 billion, which is a decline of roughly $1.7 billion, or 4.2%, versus last year. During Q1, our company-wide comps were negative 4.5%, with comps of negative 2.5% in February, negative 7.5% in March, and negative 3.7% in April. In the U.S., comps for the quarter were negative 4.6%, with negative 2.8% in February, negative 7.5% in March, and negative 3.7% in April. Our first quarter comp sales fell short of what we had anticipated, especially during March and April, and this was mainly due to 2 significant factors. First, deflation in lumber created a negative comp effect of about 220 basis points compared with the first quarter of 2022. Second, poor weather, especially within our Western division, put additional pressure on our results; in Q1, our gross margin was 33.7%, which is 8 basis points lower than the first quarter a year ago, largely because of greater shrink pressure; we have continued to offset cost pressures from supply chain and products successfully while holding onto our role as the customer's advocate for value. In the first quarter, operating expense measured as a percent of sales rose about 25 basis points to 18.8% versus the first quarter of 2022. Our operating expense results in Q1 reflect the planned compensation increases we announced on our fourth quarter 2022 call, along with a onetime gain from a legal settlement. Our operating margin in the first quarter was 14.9%, compared with 15.2% in the first quarter of 2022. Interest and other expense in Q1 rose by $72 million to $441 million, mainly because of interest on our floating rate debt and higher debt balances compared with a year ago. In the first quarter, our effective tax rate was 24.2%, which is up from 23.9% in the first quarter of fiscal 2022. Diluted earnings per share in the first quarter was $3.82, which is a decline of 6.6% versus the first quarter of 2022. During Q1, we opened 2 new stores, which brought our total store count to 2,324. Retail selling square footage was about 241 million square feet. At quarter end, merchandise inventories stood at $25.4 billion, basically flat versus the first quarter of 2022, and inventory turns were 3.9x, down from 4.4x a year ago. Now on to capital allocation. Once we have invested in our business and paid our dividend, our intent is to return excess cash to shareholders through share repurchases. In the first quarter, we put roughly $900 million back into our business through capital expenditures. Also during the quarter, we paid about $2.1 billion in dividends to our shareholders, and we returned roughly $3 billion to shareholders through share repurchases. Calculated using the average of beginning and ending long-term debt and equity for the trailing 12 months, return on invested capital was about 43.6%, down from 45.3% in the first quarter of fiscal 2022. I'll now share some thoughts on what we're expecting for fiscal 2023. You might remember that during the prior quarter, we gave guidance calling for sales and comps to be flat in fiscal 2023. During that same prior quarter, we pointed out that this outlook excluded any possible effects from lumber deflation, and we flagged that this could hurt how we performed both for the quarter and for the full year. Consequently, lumber took roughly 220 basis points off of comps during the first quarter. Because of how badly lumber and weather dragged down first quarter sales, demand softening beyond what we had anticipated, and lingering unpredictability in how consumers are behaving, we're revising our outlook so that it captures a spectrum of possible results. Our current expectation is that fiscal 2023 sales and comp sales will fall somewhere between 2% and 5%. Because our sales view has shifted, we're now aiming for an operating margin for the year somewhere between 14.3% and 14.0%. We're targeting an effective tax rate of about 24.5%. Interest expense should come in around $1.8 billion, and we anticipate diluted earnings per share will drop somewhere between 7% and 13% relative to fiscal 2022. As Ted pointed out, we went into 2023 expecting a moderating home improvement market, with monetary policy actions to temper overall consumer demand driving that. From where we sit, the consumer economy is going through a transitional period. If we set aside the near-term effects of monetary policy, it's clear to us that the home improvement customer remains healthy, and we think the medium- to long-term underlying fundamentals of home improvement position it as one of the most attractive markets both in retail and across the broader economy. With a wide product assortment, solid in-stock levels and associates who know their stuff, we think we're well positioned to serve our customers' needs. The investments we've put into our business have given our operating model agility. Looking ahead, we'll keep investing prudently to bolster our competitive position, and we'll use our scale and low-cost position to beat the market and return value to shareholders. Thanks for joining today's call. And Christine, let's go ahead and take questions.

Chris Horvers

analyst
#6

I've got a couple of things to ask about on the ticket side. In the first quarter, average ticket came in flat. My recollection is that a year ago, you saw same-SKU inflation, excluding commodity, running in the high single digits throughout the year. So when it comes to how much the ticket slowed versus 1Q a year ago, how much of that was purely same SKU disinflation on a year-over-year basis, and how much came from factors such as project size and trade down?

Ted Decker

executive
#7

Chris, inflation is still showing up in same SKU items for us. Setting commodity to one side — we used the illustration of lumber sitting at down 64% — our ticket and our average unit retail are still seeing inflation. That means the non-index, or non-commodity, prices continue to lap last year's cost in price. Beyond that, moderate inflation is still alive in 2023; so the average ticket still carries inflation with it.

Chris Horvers

analyst
#8

So when you're looking forward, how do you think about the size of the headwind that develops across the year? And what ought to be factored into the guidance? And tied to that, transactions have kind of returned to '19 levels. Yet during the first quarter, tickets remain up 37% compared with the first quarter of '19. My guess is perhaps a third of that comes from same SKU. So I'm just attempting to frame the risk surrounding ticket when it comes to disinflation, and also project size and trade down?

Ted Decker

executive
#9

Correct. Well, that's something we obviously examine closely. There has definitely been substantial cumulative inflation in price across our average unit retail and our ticket, yet broadly deflating that isn't what we anticipate. Now commodity prices, those essentially move weekly, and on a weekly basis we will set those up or down; however, price levels across a number of our products have risen and become established over the past 3 years. Innovation is embedded within that higher ticket; so when you consider ticket, much of that isn't merely cost and price, it's trading up to better product. When you consider battery-powered outdoor power equipment, what we've accomplished in the paint department with better and better paints, there's innovation, and alongside innovation, usually come higher price points. So broadly, we don't see those deflating as we work through this period of moderation.

Chris Horvers

analyst
#10

I suppose, just regarding — do you believe — if you kind of examine how project size has been trending, will that make ticket turn negative as the years go by? Is that the way you're looking at it?

Ted Decker

executive
#11

I wouldn't phrase it as as the years go by, definitely, at this moment, 2 of the largest drivers affecting both ticket and transaction are, like we mentioned; we have particular discretionary products, the best illustrations being items such as a grill, a patio set in appliances, those are typically one-time discretionary products, and those are under pressure. Those have been under pressure for a while. What was more recent in what we noticed during this quarter is that although projects remain strong and the Pro project backlog remains elevated. Projects are becoming somewhat smaller in size. And it's possible that projects are being postponed or it's possible that a project is being split into chunks; so instead — rather than completing a whole room or a whole basement, you begin approaching it in smaller chunks. And that obviously affects items per basket in overall activity.

Steven Zaccone

analyst
#12

Could you talk a little about what you've been seeing so far in Q2, especially since the weather around the U.S. has swung so much? And with that in mind, how should we frame Q2 relative to the second half? What would push you toward the top end versus the bottom end of your guidance for the full year?

Richard McPhail

executive
#13

Sure. Well, thank you. Thanks, Steven. Through the first 2 weeks of May, results are tracking with the guidance we gave. Quarterly guidance isn't something we break out, but those first 2 weeks align with what we provided. Over the coming weeks we'll gain a great deal of insight into underlying demand, since some of our biggest selling weeks are still in front of us. Consider what our guide suggests about the shape of the year. First, maybe we should go through the components of our range. So how we arrived at negative 2 and negative 5, and after that we'll get into the shape of the year. Negative 2 was really constructed by flowing through the Q1 performance, layering in the Q1 lumber impact on guidance, and adding a bit more lumber pressure expected in Q2. On the basis of where lumber prices sit now, we believe comp pressure in Q2 could reach 120 basis points. And that negative 2 scenario further incorporates our share of PCE, which moved at a faster pace than anticipated during the first quarter and then essentially holds at that rate through the balance of the year. Those, then, are the assumptions sitting underneath negative 2. For the negative 5 case, you simply take that PCE share shift assumption — our share of PCE — and assume that by the close of the fiscal year we return to 2019 levels of PCE share. That is what would give you the negative 5% case. On the shape of the year for negative 2, the high end of the range, our expectation would be a second half stronger than the first half, largely because lumber normalizes in the second half on a year-over-year basis. The bulk of the year-over-year lumber pressure falls in that first half. So with normalization under the negative 2 case, the second half comes in better than the first half. At the lower end of our range, our expectation would be the first half beating the second half, once again because of that assumption that our share of PCE keeps accelerating.

Steven Zaccone

analyst
#14

Great. Next, I'd like to build on what was said regarding this being a transitional time for the consumer. The question really is, how should we view this year — as a possible bottom for home improvement demand, or as part of a multiyear trend where maybe 2024 represents yet another decline? I realize there are many moving parts, and there's an Analyst Day coming in a month. Still, any thoughts you could share would be appreciated.

Ted Decker

executive
#15

Yes. Let me start by addressing the consumer, their health, and how engaged they are in home improvement. Looking at the consumer broadly, they remain fairly strong, which is shown by ongoing growth in personal consumption. Then, considering our customer, we have one of the strongest customer bases in any sector. Our customer outpaces the overall consumer, and you'd expect them to hold solid jobs, see rising wages, and be homeowners — and together, those home values are up roughly $15 trillion since 2019. As we mentioned, we experienced outsized growth over these past several years: $47 billion in growth, with a 43% cumulative comp. That happened as consumers redirected their spending — as these healthier consumers redirected spending toward home improvement. And without a doubt, following that stretch of growth, moderation is inevitable, which is precisely what occurred in Q1. So, considering what this says about future consumer engagement in home improvement, a few things come to mind. We've witnessed a faster shift away from goods and toward service spending as the broader economy has normalized, and that's especially true in home improvement — clearly, people aren't spending every moment at home like they were in the previous few years. Then there's the effect of pull forward or deferral in certain categories, as I mentioned earlier — appliances and patio grills that experienced outsized growth during the pandemic's early years. And there's a newer dynamic we're now really seeing, again just this past quarter: a more cautious consumer amid broader macro concerns, including credit availability. That matches what we're seeing in our business and what I said about our Pros and consumers taking on smaller, less discretionary projects. And finally, given the buildup of inflation we've seen, there's definitely some price sensitivity, especially when it comes to those bigger ticket discretionary items. So overall, our homeowner consumer remains very healthy. It's simply a matter of digesting the outsized growth and that shift of consumption spending away from services and into goods, particularly home improvement. So we'll get through this period. Richard's talked about the PCE normalization. We don't know where that ends or how quickly it goes. There's an argument that PCE and home improvement stays elevated. Every factor we've previously discussed—home prices being significantly elevated, the typical house being much older, and individuals devoting greater hours to their residences—means these trends might point toward a new normal where PCE spending within our category settles at an elevated point. Even so, we will navigate through this shifting phase, and our confidence in this sector's strength stays extraordinarily high. Among every area of retail, it ranks as one of the very finest. The market is both sizable and fragmented, leaving us with enormous prospects for expansion ahead.

Zach Fadem

analyst
#16

Could you walk us through how we get from last year's 15.3% EBIT margin down to the 14% to 14.3% you're citing today? And more specifically, what's the right way to frame the pieces that move between gross margin and SG&A? Then, on Q1 in particular, cost controls came in a little stronger than we'd anticipated. Could you take us through what the legal settlement did? And is there anything else worth flagging on that front?

Richard McPhail

executive
#17

Sure thing, Zach, and thanks for asking. Let me start by taking you from 15.3%, the operating margin we actually posted in 2022, over to the 14.5% margin we originally guided to. If comps stay flat, and especially with inflation where it is, there's a certain amount of expense deleverage that our business will experience. Really, 3 things are at play. There's the natural deleverage that comes with the business; there's the $1 billion we're putting into wages, which, as Ann mentioned, has clearly delivered genuine gains when it comes to the customer experience; and then there are the productivity efforts we've built to counter part of that deleverage. Netting those 3 items against one another is what produced the 14.5% guidance at a flat comp. Turning to how we think about the revised guidance, the operating margin range we've pointed to mirrors what the natural operating margin looks like at these negative comp levels. Put differently, some levers do exist that soften deleverage, yet deleverage remains present in our model. Our activity-based payroll model is the biggest offset. That means when store activity drops, our payroll level — sorry, our payroll level drops along with it. So a natural cushion is there. Starting from 14.3% and going to 14.0%, that would represent the natural operating margin at negative 2 and at negative 5. Now, on the onetime legal settlement. The fact is, we did book a sizable onetime gain from a legal settlement, and our guidance bakes in the assumption that this gain gets offset over the rest of the year. That's simply a simplifying assumption on our part. That 14% operating margin is something we intend to protect, and we'd concur with operating with some degree of financial flexibility. As the year unfolds, we'll be weighing the levers at our disposal against the environment we're facing.

Zach Fadem

analyst
#18

Understood. Thanks for that context. I have a question about the bigger picture. Could you discuss which macroeconomic and housing metrics you think are most tied to your business right now? And given the golden handcuffs created by sub-3% mortgages, do you believe it will take longer for housing turnover to meaningfully bounce back?

Richard McPhail

executive
#19

Sure, let me address the second part first. The effect on housing turnover is something we've already witnessed. My view is that we've likely already felt the full effect of elevated mortgage rates on people who might sell. In today's environment, if your mortgage carries a low fixed rate — and let's keep in mind, 40% of owner-occupied homes have no mortgage at all; and among households with a mortgage, nearly 90% of them have fixed rates below 5%. So given where mortgage rates stand now, people are hesitant to put their home on the market, and there's a stronger motivation to remain where you are and make improvements there. And like Ted mentioned, you're at home more often and that home is aging. Plus you have no reason to sell and end up with a mortgage at a higher rate. So I believe that's already showing up in housing turnover. As for macro indicators, I agree with what Ted said — what we're observing in the business right now reflects the wider consequences of tighter monetary policy and tighter credit conditions. It was interesting to watch the quarter develop. If you examine our performance in February, the business was actually trending pretty favorably. In fact, February's dollar run rate, adjusted for typical seasonal curves, would have suggested a positive comp for the year. Then think about March — well, to start with, March took a hit from severe weather, especially in California; and that was also when we began seeing accelerating share shift. Some external factors were at play that perhaps don't have a direct effect, but as you're aware, in March, SVB collapsed. And when you consider the tighter credit conditions that came out of the external environment, we believe all of that simply adds up to broader — broader consumer caution. Like Ted said, our homeowner customer is incredibly healthy, with a very healthy balance sheet and healthy income. What we think we're seeing is a wider consumer economy dynamic.

Michael Lasser

analyst
#20

When you take a look at your whole assortment and try to figure out what unit demand is right now compared with what a normalized level would be, how many categories remain far above what a normalized level would imply? Maybe if you consider appliances, grills, and patio furniture — where units stand today against 2019 — and apply that same math across the rest of the business, what kind of downside comp scenario would that point to, even starting from here?

Ted Decker

executive
#21

Michael, that's a terrific question. I'd say we haven't drilled down to that degree of granularity by category. For sure, quite a few of those categories were running high. The ones you mentioned — patio grills, appliances — were elevated on retails because of innovation, plus on units because of outsized demand. When you consider normal replacement cycles and the pull forward of some of that product, it will simply require a bit of time to get back to normal. Other categories we haven't discussed as much that are — honestly, that are really surging — include things like building materials, where unit volume is still running pretty strong. We're seeing units in lumber rise significantly as prices decline, and you get attachment with building materials; then hardware, which attaches to both building materials and lumber — we're seeing our strongest hardware unit productivity and attach rate to those project starter categories. I believe, Billy, that's the highest attach rate we've ever posted.

Billy Bastek

executive
#22

Correct. When you look at how our building materials segment performed, we flagged it as an outperform, and lumber too — unit productivity remains strong in those operations, and we're seeing the attach smaller, with projects of a smaller scale certainly happening. Then Ted brought up a few of the — we did observe some pull forward in a number of those businesses we mentioned at the outset as well.

Michael Lasser

analyst
#23

For my next question, let's say we treat 2023 as the transition period and same-store sales at Home Depot return to positive territory in 2024 — would leverage on your expenses kick in right from the first dollar of growth? Or should we expect some offsetting items, like Richard, you brought up legal expense and said you anticipate giving some of that back during this year? Presumably there will also be an incentive comp tailwind since you reduced your guidance; so could some of those things swing back next year, meaning that even if our models show a positive comp, we shouldn't automatically assume you'd leverage expenses on the very first dollar of growth in 2024?

Richard McPhail

executive
#24

Well, we'll share more specifics on the 2024 outlook when we meet in June at the investor conference; with only a few months of 2023 behind us, we aren't modeling 2024 with that degree of specificity. But at a high level, Michael, our model is designed to leverage and it will leverage as volume grows. And there are certain costs we intend to remove from the business. Certainly, on the product side, especially with transportation, you'll see meaningful costs come out as we sell through existing inventory that was bought at the elevated transportation rates seen during COVID. Then when it comes to the operating model — stores and labor — that will always leverage as we grow. And clearly, Michael, we set cost and price separately, and transportation costs follow market dynamics. So we'll ensure we're positioned as the customer's advocate for value when it comes to price; but as Ted mentioned, we'll cover more of this in 2023 — pardon me, on June 13.

Michael Lasser

analyst
#25

Richard, may I ask you to be more specific about the meaning behind that remark? One point of discussion is that expenses have decreased — things like freight and certain input materials. That raises the question of whether we'll see deflation on a comparable-item basis in categories not tied to commodities at some point during this year. It appears Home Depot will keep championing growth — or rather, championing value, pardon me — but could you shed more light on that?

Richard McPhail

executive
#26

Correct. Once more, we handle cost and price as separate matters. Ted — as Ted mentioned, broad-based deflation isn't something we anticipate in this market.

Brian Nagel

analyst
#27

For my first question, I realize we've already touched on this somewhat, but I wanted to ask about the weather. I was hoping you might elaborate a bit on what you observed regarding the gap in comps between areas where weather caused problems and areas where conditions may have been better than usual? And then — I mean, based on our data, spring has shown up in many markets. So what are you noticing regarding any kind of improvement in seasonal categories now that spring-like conditions are beginning to set in?

Ted Decker

executive
#28

Yes, Brian, thanks. So weather, like we mentioned, hit hardest out West in a really unusual pattern. It wasn't just one bad weekend. We're talking record rainfall and even snow in Southern California. So in places where the weather stayed bad, when we compare the West with our Northern and Southern divisions, the effect was several times what we experienced elsewhere around the country. And broadly, we've discussed before the bathtub effect, and we wouldn't have revised guidance because of stronger or comparatively weaker sales in Q1 tied to weather, since we'd expect to recover that. So consider a shorter spring season up north, where folks will try to complete that activity within a limited stretch of weeks. If it doesn't happen in the first quarter, people usually catch up during the second quarter. The situation in the West, which factored into our guidance of minus 2 to minus 5, is that the West has flatter weather patterns. Our stores there are very large, with a very high pro concentration. When bad weather hits, you aren't really expecting a bathtub effect to recover during a short season. You simply lose that selling week; so geographically the difference was stark in the West, and we view that as essentially lost selling weeks. Up north, the pattern is closer to the bathtub. I mean, we didn't get many good weekends, but when we did, sales were extremely strong; so we're definitely hoping for improved weather in Q2.

Brian Nagel

analyst
#29

All right, that's useful. And very useful as well. Now for my second question — I realize there are a lot of moving pieces in play, and you're facing different year-over-year comparisons across the year. Still, when you consider the revised outlook for '23 that you provided today, is it essentially built on things continuing the way they have so far in '23? Or does it bake in some kind of either betterment, additional weakening, or something along those lines, as the year goes on?

Richard McPhail

executive
#30

Exactly, Brian. That's the reason we provided the range. I'd say that in particular, the low end of that range would reflect more deceleration than what we've witnessed up to now. And it aligns with the scenario we described at the start of the year, which was essentially: if our PCE share goes back to 2019 levels by year-end, that's what you'd get. And once more, that would mean a faster pace of reversion compared with what we've witnessed. So the negative 2, again, more or less — it factors in that we experienced more pronounced reversion than anticipated in Q1 and that we'd maintain that share through year-end. It isn't an exact science, and that's the reason we gave you a range.

Scot Ciccarelli

analyst
#31

So Richard, you mentioned that even after the wage investments made this year, you're still defending a 14% operating margin. What other — I mean, on the SG&A line, how much room do you figure you have? Since labor is your largest kind of plus bucket, as I understand it, yet you're putting more money into labor, not less. So how are we supposed to think about the way you're handling that piece?

Richard McPhail

executive
#32

Well, the wage investment once more, which has genuinely shown it delivers a great deal of gain when it comes to the customer experience, is baked into our guidance. That investment has been made, and it will add approximately $1 billion to our cost structure, yet it sits inside our margin structure. Once more, as the year moves along, we'll be looking at the levers we can use in light of the environment. We put money in to win over the long term. At today's level of investment, we feel at ease; we'll keep judging our investments in light of the environment, and there's some room to maneuver on our end as well.

Scot Ciccarelli

analyst
#33

And one more quick question — given that rates out in the market are higher, does that shift the way you're approaching capital allocation? Not really on the strategic side, but in terms of how aggressively you'd want to issue debt in order to repurchase stock?

Richard McPhail

executive
#34

From a debt-to-EBITDA standpoint, we're feeling good about our position. A $1 billion maturity came due in April, and rather than refinance it, we paid it off. In the near term, there's no real necessity for us to tap the debt capital markets, and we'll keep an eye on how market conditions develop.

Ted Decker

executive
#35

But we feel good about where we are from a leverage perspective.

Brad Thomas

analyst
#36

Could we spend a bit more time on what's happening in the Pro segment? My sense is that this marks the first quarter in several where it trailed DIY. What's the read on Pro? Any improvement? Have conditions improved weather-wise? And what's your outlook from here?

Ted Decker

executive
#37

Sure. I'll hand it to Hector to cover the Pro side and the things we're encouraged by; though stepping back, keep in mind that lumber hit the pro disproportionately, and on top of that a really robust Pro operation in the western region. Still, we're pleased with how our customers are responding to what we can offer them.

Hector Padilla

executive
#38

Absolutely, Brad — Hector here. When you look across a 2-year span, we came out ahead, and like Ted and Billy both pointed out, the outsized effect came from lumber along with the weather. The thing that has us most enthusiastic is the progress we're making with our Pros. We're putting our new supply chain assets to work and leaning on the expanded pro capabilities we've discussed previously; wallet share with them is climbing, and as their spending with us rises, they're open to bringing more of what they buy together with Home Depot. Our brand resonates with them, so do our assortment and the value we offer, and we're witnessing that in plenty of markets. I'm eager to talk with you in greater depth come June about how the Pro business is performing and about the capabilities we're putting in place.

Brad Thomas

analyst
#39

Great. And just to tack on a quick second question — clearly there are some shifting factors at play here, with weather and deflation. My understanding is that your earlier forecast for the home improvement market called for a low single digit decline. What are you now building into your updated outlook?

Richard McPhail

executive
#40

Well, we opened the year assuming PCE would be flat. Some economists have nudged that PCE forecast up a bit; however, given what we see in terms of the PCE share our market captures and the changes that have occurred, we anticipate our market will fall somewhere in the mid- to high single digit range. So baked into our guidance is the assumption that we keep gaining share.

Simeon Gutman

analyst
#41

I'd like to ask about home prices. An argument has been made that demand has somewhat decoupled from turnover, and that prices might carry more weight. Specifically, I want to ask how that might shape the rhythm of the year, because if you strictly follow prices, the lag effect might imply that core in the back half gets somewhat worse. I'm just wondering how you think about that?

Ted Decker

executive
#42

Well, of all the housing metrics, Simeon, we believe home value correlates most tightly with home improvement spending. Of course, turnover and household formation also influence spending for us. And as you mentioned, there's typically a lag effect when it comes to appreciation or depreciation in home prices. What I think is different here is how sensitive people will be to the fact that I was up 45% in home value since the end of 2019. And sure, right now, month-over-month, values are down a little, but I'm still up 40% or 38% compared with where I stood at the end of 2019. That psychology is hard to eliminate given the general consumer apprehension stemming from overall inflation in the macro picture and climbing interest rates and all the chatter about whether a recession is coming or not coming. So I wouldn't expect that to have that large of an effect. We aren't anticipating a big effect in 2H.

Simeon Gutman

analyst
#43

All right, that makes sense. One additional item regarding the revised outlook, Richard. When you take the middle point between negative 2 and negative 5, to be clear, does that presume the core gets worse compared with Q1 and the lumber effect also gets worse compared with Q1?

Richard McPhail

executive
#44

You should view the lumber effect as something we assume stays the same in every scenario. So roughly 120 basis points of pressure hitting Q2, followed by extremely small, truly insignificant pressure during the back half. And once more, Simeon, we provided a range simply to offer a fair perspective here. Drawing conclusions this early in the year is difficult. So in our view, using a range is the most useful guidance we are able to provide.

Seth Sigman

analyst
#45

I'd like to build on the assumption that the portion of spending going to home improvement will return to what it was in 2019, and clearly that suggests conditions deteriorate from this point. Yet I suppose there have been earlier cycles in which that share drops too far on the way down and ends up beneath its prior level, and we've already discussed pull forward quite a bit today. Still, how do you view that possibility, and what makes it incorrect in this instance?

Ted Decker

executive
#46

As we've stated, the guidance we provided reflects our best estimate for 2023, and in a downside case of minus 5, that would mean you've returned to 2019 levels by the time the year ends. So purely mathematically, one could argue there would be a bit of a carryover effect into 2024. Then your question is whether it goes too far. Honestly, we don't know. Like I mentioned before, there's just as compelling a case, maybe even more so, that the level where you land is a greater share. If for no other reason than your asset class is significantly larger. I'm not talking about billions of dollars here. We're actually talking about trillions of dollars in additional value for this asset class. So when you consider the percentage of investment in any asset class, your base is far larger. We mention that homes now average more than 40 years of age, and large numbers of homes are hitting that 20-year and 40-year sort of witching hour of age. We're all aware we spend additional time at home, so wear and tear is greater. We've discussed all of these dynamics previously, and I'd say if you were forced to make a call, you'd conclude that spending would potentially end up settling at a higher level.

Seth Sigman

analyst
#47

All right, that's reasonable. One more thing regarding the EBIT margin outlook for this year. From what I understand, what you've presented at the bottom end — a 14% margin alongside negative mid-single-digit comps — lines up well with the scenarios you described during the prior quarter, yet it does factor in that Q1 SG&A gain. Could you help us get a clearer picture of whether that means the underlying figure is in fact weaker? My recollection is you might have mentioned something offsets it. Perhaps you could shed some light on that.

Richard McPhail

executive
#48

Appreciate the question. To be clear, we aren't assuming the underlying would come in lower. What our guide does assume is that the benefit gets offset across the rest of the year.

Isabel Janci

executive
#49

Christine, we have time for one more question.

Steven Forbes

analyst
#50

I just wanted to ask a bit more about what's happening with lumber. You mentioned something regarding deflation in prices. I'm curious whether you could describe exactly what occurred with unit volume over the quarter. And after that, what does the guidance bake in for the back half, as the price comparison gets easier when it comes to unit expectations, correct, during the second half?

Billy Bastek

executive
#51

Yes. Thank you, Steven. This is Billy. Like we discussed, Richard said in his earlier remarks, we expect the biggest pressure from lumber during the first half; across the full year, we believe the effect of lumber deflation on the comp comes to roughly 100 basis points; even so, we are witnessing robust unit activity in plywood, dimensional lumber, PT decking. That's 220 basis points, as we noted in Q1, plus approximately another 120 basis points in Q2, which is included in the guide, and then for the back half of the year we do not anticipate any material lumber impact, though we continue to see very strong unit results in the categories I listed.

Steven Forbes

analyst
#52

So perhaps this — you're anticipating that unit volume will get better during the second half? Or how would you describe the path of unit trends, correct, with lumber specifically baked into the guidance?

Billy Bastek

executive
#53

As pricing settles on a year-over-year basis, units will show that as we move toward the more rational condition we saw in the latter half of last year.

Steven Forbes

analyst
#54

Then, only a fast second question. Is there any kind of glimpse into what we ought to anticipate at the Analyst Day that's coming up? You may have said something earlier regarding potentially addressing 2024, but I couldn't tell whether you might clarify any kind of previewed thinking about what we ought to anticipate hearing at the Analyst Day?

Isabel Janci

executive
#55

I appreciate that question, Steve. What you'll likely hear from us, I believe, is discussion of the updated TAM that we will present for you, our growth opportunities for pursuing that TAM, and somewhat more on why the sector and the business excite us so much.

Isabel Janci

executive
#56

Appreciate that, Christine, and thank you all for being here with us today; we're eager to talk with you at our Investor Conference happening on June 13.

Operator

operator
#57

Everyone, that brings us to the end of today's teleconference. You can go ahead and drop off your lines now. We appreciate you joining us, and enjoy the rest of your day.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete The Home Depot, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to The Home Depot, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in The Home Depot, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.