The Home Depot, Inc. (HD) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
February 20, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Isabel Janci
executiveThanks, Christine, and good morning to all of you. I'd like to welcome everyone to the earnings call for Home Depot covering the fourth quarter and fiscal year 2023. On the line with us today are Ted Decker, our Chair, President and CEO; Ann-Marie Campbell, Senior Executive Vice President; Billy Bastek, Executive Vice President of Merchandising; and Richard McPhail, Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer. Once we finish our prepared remarks, we'll open the call for questions. Only analysts and investors will be permitted to ask questions. <<operator_script>> Should we run out of time and not reach your question, you can contact our Investor Relations department at 770 to 384 to 2387. Before handing things to Ted, I want to remind everyone that the press release issued today and the presentations our executives will make contain forward-looking statements as defined in the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995; such statements carry risks and uncertainties that may lead actual results to differ materially from what we expect and project. Among these risks and uncertainties are, without limitation, the factors laid out in the release and in our filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission. Certain non-GAAP measures will also be part of today's presentation. A reconciliation of those measures appears on our website. With that, I'll hand the call to Ted.
Edward Decker
executiveThanks, Isabel, and hello everyone. The team will walk you through this shortly, but the fourth quarter of fiscal 2023 came in mostly where we expected it to. Looking at the full fiscal year 2023, sales reached $152.7 billion, a decline of 3% compared with the previous year. Same-store sales fell 3.2% against last year, and comps at our U.S. stores came in negative 3.5%. On the bottom line, diluted earnings per share landed at $15.11, versus $16.69 a year earlier. Following three years of remarkable expansion in our business, 2023 turned out to be a period of moderation. It was likewise a period of opportunity. We concentrated on several operational improvements aimed at strengthening the company, while still staying dedicated to the expansion opportunities we presented during our June Investor Conference. As we look back on 2023, we see that we are now better positioned in four key respects. We directed resources toward our employees — the lifeblood of this organization and the foundation of customer service — we navigated disinflation successfully while maintaining a strong value offering for shoppers, we right-sized our inventory while improving in-stock and on-shelf availability, and we reduced fixed expenses that had been added to the business during the pandemic. As you're aware, early in 2023 we announced an investment of roughly $1 billion in higher annualized compensation for our frontline hourly associates. That let us deliver better customer service, put ourselves in a favorable spot in the market, draw in and keep the most capable talent, generate more efficiency and productivity throughout the business, and improve safety more broadly. We also steered through a distinctive disinflationary climate. Our approach was to use our best-in-class cost finance team along with our merchants to handle cost shifts effectively, while simultaneously acting as our customers' advocate for value; and in our view, prices have basically settled across the marketplace. Following a multi-year stretch of record-breaking sales, we entered 2023 with inventory levels above what we would have preferred. The merchandise we carry has minimal risk of becoming obsolete, and despite that, our associates spent the entire year improving how productively we manage that inventory, all while achieving the strongest in-stock and on-shelf availability figures since the pandemic began. Looking ahead to 2024, we're quite pleased with our current inventory position. Productivity and efficiency define who Home Depot is, and as was shared during our June Investor Conference, we committed to cutting fixed costs by roughly $500 million, with the full benefit expected to land in 2024. The steps needed to realize that cost savings are complete, and Richard will walk everyone through the specifics shortly. Turning our attention to 2024, our priorities stay fixed on three strategic openings: delivering the strongest interconnected experience possible, expanding how much of the Pro wallet we capture by leveraging our distinctive ecosystem of capabilities, and opening additional stores. In December 2023, we completed a strategic purchase of Construction Resources — a top distributor of design-oriented surfaces, appliances, and architectural specialty products serving Pro contractors whose work centers on renovation, remodeling, and residential home building. This deal strengthens our already broad lineup of products and services. This lets our sophisticated Pro customers conveniently browse across different aesthetic product categories in a showroom environment, since that's the way they're used to purchasing these kinds of items; we're thrilled to bring Construction Resources on board as part of the Home Depot family; throughout 2024, we'll keep gaining knowledge and developing additional capabilities tailored to the complex Pro. We're broadening our product selections, fulfillment choices and our outside sales team, and we've just lately started testing trade credit offerings; on top of that, we're continuing efforts on fresh order management functionalities to handle complex Pro orders more effectively. On the complex Pro opportunity: by the time 2024 comes to a close, we will have introduced new fulfillment options, localized product assortments, an expanded sales force, and enhanced digital tools across 17 of our top Pro markets, while trade credit and order management undergo pilot development. What I want you to take from today's discussion is our strong conviction in this business and the quality of the foundation we are building for the future. The prospect of gaining share in a fragmented market valued at over $950 billion continues to excite us. Our team members and vendor partners have consistently shown adaptability and toughness, and I'd like to express gratitude to them for their efforts and commitment to supporting our customers and communities. With that said, I'd like to hand the call over to Ann.
Ann-Marie Campbell
executiveThanks, Ted, and good morning to all of you. I'm extremely happy with how well we're operating and with the investments we keep putting into the company. As Ted told you, we're still centered on three key strategic opportunities: delivering the best interconnected experience, expanding our Pro wallet share by leveraging our distinctive ecosystem of capabilities, and building new stores. As we keep working to deliver the best interconnected experience and take friction out of the customer shopping journey, our post-sale experience stands out as one of our greatest areas of opportunity. For most of our customers, that process has stayed basically the same across the last 44 years, and there are ways we can make it better; during 2023, we made major strides in removing friction from our online order management process. Today, we've upgraded our systems so that customers can more easily both modify orders and handle returns themselves online. During 2024, our focus will be on developing stronger capabilities to support an interconnected self-service returns process, one where customers can begin a return online and then finish it by mail or in a store; we've only just started this work in earnest, and we're quite excited about the friction we'll eliminate through this process while capturing meaningful productivity gains over the long term. Thanks to these enhancements and new capabilities in our returns process, we achieve efficiencies by cutting transaction time and boosting on-shelf availability, which enables better inventory management. We've also enhanced customer service by letting the customer begin and finish their return in whatever way they prefer. As we've often told you, our focus is on making our interconnected experience better and more convenient regardless of how customers decide to engage with us. As we shared at our Investor Conference in June, our plan is to open roughly 80 new stores across the next five years. Our existing network of more than 2,300 stores across North America makes the Home Depot the most convenient physical destination for customers shopping for their home improvement products. We have a premier real estate footprint that delivers convenience for the customer in a way we believe is almost impossible to replicate; and we'll keep expanding this footprint very strategically by investing in new stores in places that have seen significant population growth or where it makes sense to ease some pressure on existing high-volume stores. During fiscal 2023, we opened 13 new stores. Eight in the U.S. and five in Mexico. Within the U.S., our eight new stores were roughly divided between stores easing pressure from higher volume existing stores and stores where we identified void in new high-growth areas. As an example, we're already seeing great results for many of these new stores and are especially pleased with our Mapunapuna store in Honolulu, which lets us better serve the Honolulu market. For fiscal 2024, our plan is to open approximately 12 new stores. In addition to concentrating on eliminating hurdles and expanding into additional locations, we've got numerous programs planned for 2024 aimed at increasing our share of wallet among Pro customers. My newly formed team is going to concentrate on improving coordination so that we can provide our distinctive value proposition to every Pro even more effortlessly. Whenever we put money into new assets and capabilities to serve the sophisticated Pro better, that likewise enhances the Pro experience within our stores. Take, for instance, additional job site delivery orders being fulfilled out of our distribution centers, which translates to reduced crowding in our stores plus less time spent picking, packing, and staging orders for delivery. This affords our in-store Pro sales associates additional time they can devote to our Pros. Moreover, being able to complete large orders via our distribution network also translates into having additional product in stock and ready for purchase for all those Pros who are shopping in our stores; such enhancements advantage our associates along with every one of our Pros. The money we've put into these strategic initiatives, together with the money put into our associates, has positioned us to succeed. Keep in mind that early in the year, we revealed a major investment of roughly $1 billion in boosted annualized compensation for frontline hourly associates. Because of that investment, we observed what we aimed to observe: substantial enhancement in our attrition rates, especially among our longest-tenured associates, which generated better customer service, productivity, and safety. It thrills me to watch every one of our initiatives building momentum, and I wish to express gratitude to our incredible associates for everything they do. Having said that, I'll hand the call over to Billy.
William Bastek
executiveThank you, Ann, and good morning to all of you. I'd like to begin by expressing gratitude as well to each of our associates and supplier partners for the continued dedication they show in serving our customers and communities. As Ted mentioned, sales during the fourth quarter came in mostly as we had anticipated; even so, we did encounter some negative effects from January weather as well as deflation in core commodities; we observed a continuation of the pattern we've seen all year long, with weakness in certain big ticket discretionary purchases. Our customers keep taking on smaller projects while still putting off larger ones. Moving to how our departments performed on a comp basis in the fourth quarter, positive comps were posted by our building materials and outdoor garden departments, and 6 of our remaining 12 merchandising departments recorded comps above the company average, among them appliances, plumbing, tools, paint, indoor garden, and hardware. In the fourth quarter, comp transactions for us fell 2.1% and comp average ticket declined 1.3%; even so, we keep seeing customers trade up for new and innovative products. Deflation in core commodity categories hurt our average ticket by 35 basis points in the fourth quarter, driven by deflation in lumber and copper wire. During the fourth quarter, we continued to observe lumber prices declining on average relative to a year ago. That said, framing and panel lumber pricing saw its most stable levels in some time during the quarter. To illustrate, framing lumber opened the quarter at approximately $370 per 1,000 board feet versus roughly $395 at the quarter's close, a change of less than 7%. Big ticket comp transactions, meaning those exceeding $1,000, fell 6.9% versus the fourth quarter of last year. We continued to see softer engagement in big-ticket discretionary categories such as flooring, countertops and cabinets. In the fourth quarter, our Pro and DIY customers performed relatively in line with each other. Although internal and external surveys indicate Pro backlogs are lower than a year ago, they have stayed stable and elevated compared to historical norms. Now turning to online sales for the total company. Sales leveraging our digital platforms grew approximately 2% versus the fourth quarter of last year. We keep enhancing our digital customer experience with a number of new capabilities, among them an enhanced browsing experience featuring the best sellers in a local market and new product discovery zones, which highlights what's trending based on new and highly rated products. Among customers who transacted with us online during the fourth quarter, nearly half of our online orders were fulfilled through our stores. During the fourth quarter, we hosted our annual decorative holiday, Gift Center and Black Friday events; we saw strong engagement across all these events with our decorative holiday event posting a record sales year. Like Ted said, 2023 was a year when we made major strides in how we manage inventory and keep shelves stocked, all while steering through a pricing climate marked by disinflation and holding onto our role as the customer's champion for value. When it comes to our inventory levels, we're sitting in an excellent spot right now. Our in-stocks are the strongest they've been in quite a few years, and we're offering an appealing assortment for the home improvement needs of our customers. We're eager about what's coming in the year ahead, especially since the spring selling season is just about here, and we've got a fantastic lineup of new and innovative products spanning live goods through outdoor power equipment; we're thrilled to grow what we offer for Pro outdoor tools by introducing our new cordless battery powered, Milwaukee, M18, backpack blower and straight shaft trimmer, which widens our assortment for the Pro landscaper. Plus, our Spring Gift Center event keeps embracing cordless technology with a broad range of products from RYOBI, Milwaukee, Makita and DEWALT, and many of those are exclusive to the Home Depot and the big box retail channel. Our live goods program is another thing we're excited about. Every year, our merchants work alongside our national and regional growers to give our customers new and improved varieties that make the overall garden experience better. Together with our growers, we've invested significantly to bring customers new varieties that resist disease more effectively, handle different climates well and need less watering. By investing in our grower relationships, we'll be able to keep driving innovation that serves our customers' needs and betters their shopping experience, all while building loyalty to the Home Depot. Looking toward spring, we're excited to keep offering a broad assortment of best-in-class products that are in stock and ready for our customers whenever and however they need them; with that, I'd like to hand the call over to Richard.
Richard McPhail
executiveThanks, Billy, and good morning to all of you. Looking at the fourth quarter, our total sales came to $34.8 billion, which represents a 2.9% decline versus the prior year. Total company comps during Q4 landed at negative 3.5%, broken down as negative 2.5% for November, positive 1.1% for December, and negative 8.5% for January. U.S. comps finished the quarter at negative 4%, with November at negative 2.7%, December at positive 0.6%, and January at negative 9.1%. On a local currency basis, both Mexico and Canada delivered comps that beat the company average, and Mexico's comps were positive. Worth noting is that once you account for holiday timing shifts and January weather effects, monthly comps held fairly steady throughout the quarter. Turning to the full year, sales reached $152.7 billion, down 3% against fiscal 2022. For the year, total company comp sales fell 3.2%, and U.S. comp sales fell 3.5%. In Q4, gross margin came in at roughly 33.1%, down 20 basis points from the prior year. For the full year, gross margin was approximately 33.4%, a decline of 15 basis points year over year, which matched what we had expected. Operating expenses as a share of sales rose about 115 basis points in Q4 to 21.2%, compared with the fourth quarter of 2022. That Q4 operating expense result mirrors the compensation raises for hourly associates that we put in place earlier, along with deleverage stemming from our top line performance. On a full-year basis, operating expenses represented roughly 19.2% of sales, up approximately 90 basis points from fiscal 2022. Our operating margin was about 11.9% in the fourth quarter and about 14.2% for the year. Interest and other expense rose by $50 million in Q4, reaching $458 million. Our effective tax rate was 24% for both the fourth quarter and fiscal 2023. Diluted earnings per share came in at $2.82 for Q4, down 14.5% from the fourth quarter of 2022. For fiscal 2023, diluted earnings per share were $15.11, down 9.5% versus fiscal 2022. Merchandise inventories stood at $21 billion when the quarter closed, a drop of $3.9 billion, or roughly 16%, from a year earlier, while inventory turns reached 4.3x, improving from 4.2x in the second period last year. Now on to capital allocation. We put about $860 million back into the business through capital expenditures during Q4. That takes total capital expenditures for fiscal 2023 to roughly $3.2 billion. We opened 13 new stores over the year, which brought our store count to 2,335 as fiscal 2023 ended. Retail selling square footage came to about 242 million square feet, and total sales per retail square foot were roughly $605 in fiscal 2023. On top of that, we spent approximately $1.5 billion on three acquisitions in fiscal 2023, which speeds up our strategic initiatives and gives us stronger capabilities to serve our customers. Over the course of the year, we returned approximately $8.4 billion in dividends to our shareholders. Earlier today, we shared that our Board of Directors has approved a 7.7% bump in the quarterly dividend, bringing it to $2.25 per share, or $9 per share on an annual basis. Moving on, in fiscal 2023 we gave back roughly $8 billion to shareholders through buybacks, with $1.5 billion of that coming in Q4. Using the average of long-term debt and equity at the start and end of the trailing 12 months, return on invested capital came in at 36.7%, down from 44.6% at the close of Q4 fiscal 2022. Let me now turn to our 2024 outlook. To start, I want to note that fiscal 2024 has a 53rd week, meaning Q4 fiscal 2024 will be 14 weeks long. Comps will still be reported on a 52-week basis, though our overall guidance will be built on 53 weeks. As Ted mentioned, we're very pleased with the steps we took in 2023 to set us up for 2024. And even though there are indications the economy is moving toward normalization, the home improvement sector continues to confront headwinds as we look to fiscal 2024. A number of considerations shaped our fiscal 2024 outlook. On the favorable side, several pressures we dealt with in fiscal 2023 probably won't recur in fiscal 2024. During 2023, the Fed funds rate went up four times, existing home sales dropped sharply, and lumber deflation created roughly 110 basis points of comp pressure. That said, we anticipate continued pressure on our business in fiscal 2024. PCE-measured personal consumption growth is projected to slow versus 2023. Our PCE share is also still somewhat above 2019 levels and has been steadily moving back toward them. Interest rates that are higher at the start of 2024 than a year ago will probably keep weighing on demand for bigger projects. In addition, demand pulled forward during the pandemic, along with some projects being deferred, could affect demand in 2024. Taking these forces on home improvement demand into account, we're planning for another year of moderation, but with somewhat less comp sales pressure than fiscal 2023 brought. Our fiscal 2024 outlook calls for total sales growth to exceed comp sales, with total sales growth of about positive 1% and comp sales of about negative 1% versus fiscal 2023. The 53rd week, along with acquisitions completed and new stores opened in fiscal 2023 plus stores we intend to open in fiscal 2024, will lift total sales growth. We estimate the 53rd week will add roughly $2.3 billion in sales. Gross margin should land at about 33.9%, roughly 50 basis points higher than fiscal 2023. The main driver here is a cheaper product and transportation cost backdrop versus fiscal 2023, plus we gain from part of the roughly $500 million of fixed cost reductions we'll capture in fiscal 2024. On top of that, we're looking for an operating margin of about 14.1%. That number shows deleverage off of sales along with pressure from targeted incentive compensation, since we're lapping lower incentive comp than had been planned for 2023; partly offsetting that are the gains from that same roughly $500 million of fixed costs we'll achieve in fiscal 2024, showing up in both cost of goods sold and operating expenses. We're targeting an effective tax rate of about 24.5%. Net interest expense should come in around $1.8 billion. For diluted earnings per share, we're aiming at roughly 1% growth against fiscal 2023, with the extra week adding about $0.30; our plan is to keep putting money into the business, with capital expenditures running at about 2% of sales each year. Once we've funded the business and paid our dividend, our intention is to hand back surplus cash to shareholders through share repurchases. We feel we've set ourselves up to serve our customers' needs whatever conditions arise. The money we've put into the business has given us agility in how we run our operations. Looking ahead, we'll keep investing to firm up our standing with customers, use our scale and low-cost position to expand faster than the market, and create shareholder value. Thanks for joining today's call. And Christine, we're ready to take questions now.
Simeon Gutman
analystFirst thing I want to know is, when it comes to that comp of minus 1, how much reflects what's happening across the industry, and how much is share gain, which I'd guess is on the plus side, versus what you'd see by looking at how purchasing is trending right now — and Richard, you mentioned a few of the, shall we say, somewhat lesser headwinds that you said you anticipate dealing with in 2023.
Richard McPhail
executiveSure. Yes, Simeon, put simply, our expectation is that those macro pressures we identified suggest improvement demand will decline by a low single-digit percentage, and that we'll do better than the market. That's how we arrived at the guidance of a negative 1% comp. And as for the second part of what you asked, Simeon?
Simeon Gutman
analystI suppose that was the entire point; the question was how much of this reflects a macro perspective as opposed to a projection for housing plus market share, versus the fact that you have fewer headwinds than you mentioned for the current year, and you're layering on top of that how consumers are acting.
Richard McPhail
executiveWell, we consider everything together, and there are multiple cross currents at play. Once more, we're up against macro headwinds, though to a smaller extent than what we encountered in 2023. So again, to run through them quickly, PCE is anticipated to slow down. As a market, we continue to have a somewhat elevated share of PCE compared with 2019, which we recognize, and that has been steadily declining since 2021. Regarding interest rates, we still find ourselves in a situation where, although our customers possess the ability to spend, they're adopting more of a postponement posture when it comes to demand for large projects; and we think some spending was pulled forward during 2020 to 2022 that we're still working through. On housing, it's somewhat difficult to isolate. Clearly, home values have remained firm; we currently observe that home prices have risen by more than 46% since 2019. Turnover has fallen dramatically across the past two years, and that represents a headwind that may be partly offset by some degree of improvement in place. So in the near term, we're basically neutral on housing; and so that's — each of those factors affects our market. And then, as you mentioned, we anticipate gaining share regardless of the macro backdrop through our growth initiatives of Pro, the interconnected experience and new stores, and that brings us to our negative 1% comp outlook.
Simeon Gutman
analystOkay, that's reasonable. Then for a second question, could we discuss how the year is shaped? During the early months you were up against lumber deflation, and perhaps some weather played a role, so that ought to improve, yet the back half supposedly comes after interest rate reductions, and durables might pick up somewhat. So what's the right way to frame this?
Richard McPhail
executiveSure. Simeon, what happened with lumber really came down to how it compared with 2022 and 2023. If you look at the lumber charts — I would suggest you go ahead and bring them up — pricing for lumber stayed fairly flat throughout 2023, so a meaningful effect on 2024 isn't something we foresee. Regarding '24, to start, a typical seasonal pattern is what we anticipate for our business. Thus there isn't any seasonal movement in the way we view the two halves; we expect the back half to land a touch above the front half, while both remain negative, at minimum as our guidance suggests. It may be useful to remember that for 2023, the two halves tracked pretty closely together.
Zach Fadem
analystLet's begin with what you said about comps. I'd like to know your views on how Pro and DIY are trending, for the sector overall and for how much share you could pick up. Also, any initial perspective on traffic compared with ticket?
Edward Decker
executiveRegarding Pro against consumer, Zach — for our business, those two were basically identical in Q4. Across the industry, I don't anticipate much of a difference. What I can tell you is that among our Pro customers, in whichever segment we serve, the managed account customer who takes part in the ecosystem we are assembling was the top-performing segment in Q4 and all through 2023, and we'd look for that to keep going in 2024 too as we keep expanding the capabilities.
Zach Fadem
analystThen you mentioned the disinflationary pricing backdrop. What I'd like to know is whether you can break that down into commodity deflation versus promotions. And looking ahead to '24, can you take us through the indicators you're watching that point to disinflation having turned the corner?
William Bastek
executiveSure. Billy here. Appreciate the question; regarding commodities, that's baked into the guidance for future periods that Rich laid out in his prepared remarks. So — and when it comes to how often promotions are running, going back to before the pandemic, we haven't observed any change in promotional activity. The environment we're in is quite normalized. Our sense is that pricing has more or less stabilized, as we said earlier. So when it comes to promotions, their frequency, we see no distinction from, as I said, what we experienced before the pandemic. So it's very steady. On that front, we truly are in a healthy market, and we're looking forward to 2024.
Chris Horvers
analystSo I got curious — when you consider share of wallet, what takeaways did the holiday period give you? Any indicators of momentum out there? You brought up outdoor garden, which I'd guess means Christmas trees plus Christmas decor. Do you see any momentum suggesting that lower-priced softline goods are beginning to move, with more decor products picking up? Did anything stand out in appliances, or among the pricier items?
Edward Decker
executiveNo. Chris, this is Ted. We witnessed fantastic momentum. This sector has plenty of vitality. Sure, we're navigating certain macro pressures, as Richard laid out, yet the consumer remains healthy and involved. It's simply that right now they're involved in smaller projects. And you named several categories where we enjoyed fantastic engagement during Q4. Our Deco holiday program performed exceptionally, and the merchants behind it keep elevating it further. We're aware we captured an enormous share in Deco holiday because customers embrace what we offer. Our gift center assortment, featuring the brands we carry and the value that Billy and the team deliver to the market, generated an enormous response. As you noted, Deco Holiday in live goods did very well. Take totes, for instance — we moved record units of totes during Q4 as customers responded to our storage event; so traffic remains enormous, both sheer traffic volume and engagement. Again, it's only those pricier items. Though, one side note on pricier items: appliances ranked among our stronger relative performers. Much of that, I believe, ties to our service levels while we bring the TEMCO acquisition into the fold — the share of our deliveries they now manage, plus the service level scores and on-time-and-complete performance they give our customers. We consider that a major driver behind the momentum in our appliance business, along with the strength of our online shopping experience for major appliances.
Chris Horvers
analystAs a second question, could you explain the factors behind the drop in gross margin during Q4? You brought up the growth expected in 2024. And on the SG&A line, I believe you had a fairly large legal benefit in Q1 of the prior year. Will that impact the full 2024 picture?
Richard McPhail
executiveAbsolutely. Chris, this is Richard. Regarding Q4 gross margin first, I'd note that our gross margin is actually consistent with what we anticipated for the year; across both the full year and the quarter, we experienced some acceleration of pressure from pricing moves prior to cost reductions. The positive side is that you're seeing those at present levels, and as Billy said, we're at a relatively stable position at the moment in retail and cost. As we start moving through inventory layers, the effect of those cost reductions we implemented earlier in the year is now visible in 2024, and that's the primary factor driving the gross margin growth we've projected. About the settlement you brought up, I'm glad you asked; it's worth highlighting that there's a bit of geographic distortion in the year-over-year figures caused by that settlement. So as a reminder for everyone, we recorded a notable settlement in Q1 of 2023. It boosted operating expense; then, as we promised, we completely counterbalanced that gain with short-term expenses in 2023 that positioned us to reduce our cost structure moving forward; those short-term expenses were largely in cost of goods sold, including certain steps taken to streamline inventory levels. So that settlement's geographic placement and the offsetting cost produce a better comparison in cost of goods sold and a worse comparison in OpEx when looking year over year, though clearly, the two cancel each other out, and it's a matter of geographic placement.
Scot Ciccarelli
analystIn terms of your comp guide, could you walk us through how you're accounting for any gains or accretion coming from the complex Pro build-out, so we can get a clearer picture of the thinking behind that? And, just as a secondary question, could you also share how significant a margin drag you anticipate the incentive comp swing will create in '24?
Edward Decker
executiveRegarding complex Pro, obviously, the enhancements in that area and the belief that the managed account utilizing those capabilities will be the top-performing customer segment—that is factored into the comp sales guidance within total sales.
Richard McPhail
executiveRegarding the negative impact caused by reduced incentive bonuses during 2023, the primary and most significant factor behind deleverage is, as you’re aware, how our operating expense leverage or deleverage relates to growth in sales. Thus, the biggest contributor to that is straightforward sales deleverage, since inflation in operating costs continues to exceed sales growth. To a smaller degree, we observe deleverage stemming from the year-over-year incentive compensation.
Scot Ciccarelli
analystAll right. Might I pose a related question about that? So, simply for my own clarity — sure, I get it that managed accounts are, in a sense, growing at the quickest pace. However — can you folks sort of break apart, say, the standard relationship you'd typically have with such accounts, as opposed to the broader set of services you're delivering in particular markets? Or would separating those two things simply prove too tricky?
Edward Decker
executiveNo, that's not possible at all. And we do break things apart at each conceivable level. It's simply that we won't disclose every one of those specifics, as you might expect.
Chuck Grom
analystStepping back to the larger picture, I'm wondering what all of you are watching, whether by region or by product category, that points to unit volume demand in the home improvement space finally hitting a floor as we think about the coming 2 years?
Richard McPhail
executiveTo address the narrowest point first, across the most recent 3 quarters, what we've observed is essentially the greatest steadiness, and — I would say 3 quarters back, we recorded a pronounced bounce-back in transactions, and if you treat that as a stand-in for units, units tracked along the same lines. Through those 3 quarters, the steadiness has been encouraging. As we've noted previously, our definition of a healthy home improvement market requires both ticket and transaction to be positive. The favorable development is that ticket and transaction have started moving toward each other and, in truth, have drawn considerably closer together across those 3 quarters. . Both remained negative in the quarter, though that simply mirrors the macro strain that persists. Geographically speaking, we can't truly isolate regional variations in the rebound of transactions or units — it plays out more as a nationwide phenomenon.
Chuck Grom
analystAll right, that's great. And then here's one for you, Richard. How are we supposed to think about each point of comp? Let's say, hypothetically, you folks are being somewhat cautious with that down 1. I'm just trying to figure out how the model might react.
Richard McPhail
executiveAbsolutely. What I mean is, at the most basic level, you can picture that absent any management action, the inherent principle of leverage or deleverage works out to roughly 10 basis points for every point of comp, whether it moves up or down.
Michael Lasser
analystWhen we think about the previous two slumps in home improvement, the years that followed a handful of stretches with negative comps saw a fairly strong rebound. Do you notice anything at all, any signals, suggesting that this eventual upturn would play out differently?
Edward Decker
executiveNothing suggests to us that it would. Actually, if anything, the foundation supporting this market segment is still remarkably solid. Taking a step back and examining the macro picture, and considering the drivers we monitor most intently, home price appreciation is up 45-odd percent, while home equity has risen closer to 70%. Home equity—that $10 trillion to $12 trillion in gains accumulated since the pandemic—remains untapped. On top of that, HELOCs and cash-out refis are at multiyear lows after interest rates rose over the past two years. So there's massive potential sitting in homeowners' balance sheets and equity. We talk about how homes are now well over 50%—or over 40 years old. A lot of people are still working from home, certainly more than before the pandemic. So you've got that increased use of the home, plus the basic housing shortage, which I've seen reported as anywhere from 2 million to 6 million units short. And in the near term, even the 2024 forecast, we'll build 2,000-odd units less than demand. As a result, that shortfall won't begin to shrink anytime soon. Taking everything into account, millennials are roughly twelve months from overtaking all other groups as the largest contributor of spending among customers in our sector. They're at the peak ages for forming households and buying homes; so when I weigh all of that, I conclude there's enormous upside; and as we've said previously, in some ways the pandemic resembles an enormous hurricane, correct? What I mean is, we saw extraordinary demand and expansion in that segment, followed by a few stretches of softening once that surge faded. Yet as we see with every hurricane market, after you move through such a cycle, it comes back just as powerful as before. Given that context — core macroeconomic conditions plus the pandemic playing out across five years, comparable to a massive nationwide tempest — there's ample justification for tremendous confidence in what lies ahead. That explains the remarks we shared earlier regarding our satisfaction with the results we achieved; the leadership group working together with store employees, store leadership, and the supply chain performed exceptionally well in stabilizing this operation after that kind of pandemic upheaval, and our operational positioning simply couldn't leave us feeling any better. We're not pulling back from any of those strategic bets. The goal remains the same: delivering the strongest connected shopping experience out there, expanding the Pro ecosystem to serve Pros with complex needs, and having enough conviction in our model to kick off a fairly significant store construction initiative. So overall, Michael, we're feeling very, very good. Appreciate the question.
Michael Lasser
analystThat's really useful, Ted. Let me squeeze in one additional question. It concerns what Richard said regarding the rough guideline of a 10 basis point margin gain for each 1 point of comp; and knowing this is hypothetical, does it behave linearly, so that if you eventually return to a mid-single-digit comp path, you'd see margin expansion running above the trend rate as growth goes higher. And a remark was also made that this rough guideline would sit apart from actions that might be taken. So could you talk about what actions could be taken to bend that curve upward over time?
Richard McPhail
executiveThanks, Michael. Well, first, I really want to bring you back to what we said at the Investor Conference in June, when we highlighted a base case for once we get back to market normalization, a base case of 3% to 4% sales growth, flat gross margin, an assumption of operating expense and operating margin leverage and growth and EPS growth of mid- to high single-digit percentages. Inside that, clearly, there's a sort of implied leverage per comp point on our OpEx. What I'm handing you is a loose rule of thumb, as I'd describe it; it would mostly apply to our business model as it stands today, it definitely applied historically and I'd anticipate it applying loosely going forward. Built into that is a typical level of productivity and efficiency that our teams have delivered each and every year. I mean beneath all this guidance and our 2023 results, which pleased us so much, sits a tremendous amount of effort from our team, consider the efficiency in our supply chain, consider the efficiencies our merchants deliver annually in product cost. Worth particular mention, the productivity in our stores through some of the tools that unleash the power of AI and place it in our associates' hands, those are standard practice for us. They contribute to what I'd describe as normal operating leverage for the Home Depot, and it's something we've grown to expect from ourselves. So that's a lengthy way of saying, we always plan to lever OpEx at a particular point of sales growth. And I'd stay with the basic rule of thumb, perhaps higher, perhaps a bit lower during certain periods now and then. As for the question about which actions might exist, we always run with some degree of financial flexibility in the P&L. Even so, I'd say we gave it our absolute best, and I believe we hit our goal of cutting fixed costs late in '23 that had accumulated through the pandemic, therefore the $500 million in cost savings implied in our guide. Levers are always available; before choosing which ones to use, we first need to figure out the environment we're in. So at this point, we've laid out what we'd describe as our central case for 2024, though we'll run the business keeping the best interests of our long-term shareholders at heart.
Seth Sigman
analystI'd like to dig deeper into the macro picture and the margins. On the macro front, you provided several factors that are already baked in. The key thing I really want to know is: what has to happen for comps to turn positive again? Is it simply a matter of completely working through the two years of reduced housing turnover, which will occur at some point during this year? And fundamentally, is it possible to get back to growth even if existing home sales don't pick up?
Edward Decker
executiveWithout a doubt. As we've stated for a very long time, home turnover forms the foundation of home improvement demand, yet it has remained fairly consistent. Roughly 4.5 percent of housing stock represents a multiyear share of turnover, which works out to about 5 million units. The reason we're highlighting this as a factor over these past two years is the sharp decline; and it's well understood that the improvement cycle shifts when you don't move and remain in your house, but a lag effect exists; and one could argue that lag effect runs a bit longer right now given the interest rate environment and the fact that people are simply cautious about when they begin a larger home improvement project in a home they intend to stay in for an extended period. So that captures the housing turnover dynamic. We believe it will play out. Turnover is literally at a 40-year low, and we don't expect it to drop further. So you'll work through that roughly two-year pressure. And then, do we return to growth? Without a doubt. I'd put it this way: we hold a neutral view on housing for 2024. We don't anticipate added pressure, nor do we believe we're quite set for a hockey stick recovery. Richard has been saying for a while, along with the Fed's position of higher for longer. I think we now recognize that longer will extend through the first half of this year. So even with a cutting cycle in the back half, there's a timing effect involved in getting mortgages, moving homes, taking out a HELOC loan, et cetera, to get a bigger project underway; that's why we're essentially projecting a slight moderation continuing into '24. But as we mentioned, the back half is marginally stronger; and we believe all the macros align for a return to normalcy after that, and with the capabilities we're building, and we're gaining share today with x percent of these capabilities complete. Extremely optimistic about how we're hitting the ground running as we keep building into a stronger market and the share gain opportunity.
Seth Sigman
analystAll right. Only one more question. Richard, you provided several sensitivity figures related to EBIT margins. I suppose what I really want is something more specific regarding SG&A for the current year. I understand there are many moving parts that return. But could you help us understand what underlying base SG&A growth ought to look like for this year? I believe the headline guidance sits at about 4% growth. But perhaps what does it equal once you strip out incentive compensation and a few of those costs you're lapping alongside the benefits you're lapping, simply so we might reason through that?
Richard McPhail
executiveSure, what I would say is the optimal lens here is that at present — our P&L hands you a suitable starting point for your models, there's considerable noise within operating expense. When you consider how the settlement was distributed in Q1, when you consider how the costs we took on were distributed, then when you consider how the $500 million in cost out was distributed, two-thirds of that will land in OpEx, one-third of that will land in cost of goods sold, and you simply end up with considerable noise. Once more, the primary force behind operating expense growth will just be inflation across our base of operating expenses. And our view is that should you examine our gross margin and our operating margin guide, they give you the suitable starting points for your modeling.
Isabel Janci
executiveChristine, we have time for one more question.
Steven Forbes
analystTo wrap up the call, I'll stick with just one question. Ted, I'd like to revisit the complex Pro topic. I value the points you made during your prepared remarks regarding the pilot of trade credit. Could you perhaps elaborate on some initial takeaways concerning those recently introduced features, as we consider the potential contribution of the managed account customer to growth in the years ahead?
Ann-Marie Campbell
executiveSure, I'll start on that. Thank you, Ed. To begin with, we are at an early phase. Also, just to note, HD Supply already offers trade credit. Thus, as we build out our program, there is plenty to learn from that. In my view, usually in the room, and Chip — you bring a great deal of that with trade credit, and his expertise is also assisting us in shaping some of the finer points of how we approach this. So I'll pass it to Chip.
Chip Devine
executiveAbsolutely. Appreciate it, Steven. Trade credit is unquestionably an essential capability, and we're directing a lot of attention toward that intricate initiative. So when we put resources into our professionals and the tools they need to handle bigger projects for their clients, trade credit is unquestionably required. So it's still early stages, as Anne said, and we're running pilots with several different customers, but we intend to build that out and scale it over the coming couple of quarters as we also automate it within our selling system.
Isabel Janci
executiveAppreciate that, Christine, and thanks to all of you for being here with us today. We're looking forward to talking with you on our Q1 call in May.
Operator
operatorEveryone, that brings us to the end of today's teleconference. At this point, feel free to drop off your lines. We appreciate you joining us, and enjoy the rest of your day.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete The Home Depot, Inc. transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to The Home Depot, Inc. earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in The Home Depot, Inc. or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.