The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company (SMG) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

July 29, 2020

New York Stock Exchange US Materials Chemicals earnings 90 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Jim King

executive
#1

Hello, everybody, and thanks for joining us on the Scotts Miracle-Gro third quarter earnings conference call. Joining me today are Jim Hagedorn, our Chairman and CEO; Randy Coleman, our CFO; Mike Lukemire, our President and Chief Operating Officer; and Chris Hagedorn, General Manager of Hawthorne Gardening Company. I'm certain you've already had a chance to look at our press release from this morning, which covers the specifics of our record third quarter results, revised guidance for fiscal 2020, and news of further plans to return cash to shareholders; in just a bit, Jim will offer some prepared remarks that give more color on these matters and others. Following that, Randy will go a bit deeper into the numbers and set the stage for communicating our year-end results in November, which is also when we'll share guidance for fiscal 2021. Once Randy finishes, we'll open the call for your questions, and Mike and Chris will join in that portion as well. Because of how much content we're covering today, we'd appreciate your help managing the time by limiting yourself to 1 question and 1 follow-up. Should we fail to reach everyone in the queue or if there are additional questions we don't address, please dial me directly at (937) 578 to 5622, and I'll gladly give you as much time as you need. Naturally, our comments this morning will include forward-looking statements, so I need to remind everyone that our actual results could differ materially from what we discussed. A discussion of the risk factors that could impact future results appears in this morning's press release and in our 10-K, which, of course, is filed with the SEC. I'd like to remind everyone that this morning's call is being recorded. An archived version of the call will begin available on our Investor Relations website. With that, let me clear the stage and hand things over to Jim Hagedorn. Jim?

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#2

Thanks, Jim, and good morning, everyone. During the late 1990s, we created an advertisement connected to our partnership with PBS's American Experience. The commercial's script went like this: here at the Scotts Company, our work results in greener grass, taller trees, and more beautiful flowers. Should a superior enterprise exist, we'd welcome hearing about it. With each of us now reflecting on everything that has happened across the past several months, that line from the PBS advertisement feels more relevant than at any previous point. The value our category provides for people's emotional and physical health has never been as evident as it is in 2020. The role our products and brands play in making customers' lives better has never mattered more, and our ability to thrive despite tough macroeconomic conditions while still delivering for everyone with a stake in the company has never been clearer. It's a fantastic industry to work in, and all of us feel lucky to be a part of it. This morning's reported results, which set a record, leave us both thrilled and deeply humbled; looking at the full year, we now anticipate exceeding what were previously our rosiest forecasts. The extraordinary momentum we're seeing continues across both the U.S. Consumer segment and Hawthorne. At this point, all of our product lines across both segments are showing growth, and as we move through the last two months of this fiscal year, that upward trend looks like it will continue. First, I'd like to express gratitude to the people who buy our products and the growers who work with us for standing behind our brands. I also want to acknowledge our retail partners for backing our category and our company. Above all, my thanks go out to the team members at The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company, because they're the ones who made these results happen. What we've achieved this year has called for commitment, ingenuity, and teamwork at a level that has truly been remarkable to witness. I have to acknowledge that everyone who holds stock in this company, and every single team member, deserves our thanks — particularly the people working on the front lines at our manufacturing and distribution sites, plus the sales teams out in the field. Through every wave, whether this crisis grew worse or eased up, those frontline colleagues showed up day after day, and the dedication they displayed — sometimes even courage — is what let us stay on top of what customers needed. Even with the success we've had this year, it's important to keep things in perspective. We're aware that far too many Americans remain without work, and it's clearer all the time that getting the economy back on track will be a lengthy process. Naturally, we're aware that over 140,000 Americans have families who are still mourning the deaths of people they love. In addition, only a few weeks back, the coronavirus took someone who was part of The Scotts Miracle-Gro family. That individual was only 34, and losing him drove home how serious this crisis is. Our thoughts and prayers remain with his fiancée and his family. Moving on this morning, I want to split the remainder of my remarks into 4 sections. To start, understanding what drove our results this year matters, so at a high level I'll talk about the victories we've achieved in the U.S. Consumer as well as Hawthorne, leaving Randy to zero in on the financial side. Second, I want to cover where we anticipate ending up in 2020 and the spending we're undertaking for the rest of the year. Third, I want to offer a few preliminary thoughts regarding next year. This isn't guidance. It's much too soon for us to aim at particular figures for either the top or bottom line in 2021. However, to a degree, I want this call to serve as the road map for what we see in 2021. The clear question on the table this morning is how we comp this year's results, and we want to tackle that matter proactively. Fourth, I'd like to share where we currently stand on the balance sheet and how we're thinking about deploying cash, and also give you more detail on the special dividend we announced this morning — $5 per share, payable in September. There's a lot to cover, so let's jump in and go over current business trends. Starting with the U.S. Consumer segment: sales rose 21% for the quarter and are up 15% so far this year. We expect that year-to-date number to climb further, which is why we raised guidance for the U.S. Consumer business yet again, now to a range of 20% to 22%, compared with the earlier outlook of 9% to 11% growth. Entering August, we're seeing a 23% year-to-date rise in consumer purchases across our four biggest retail partners. If you dig into what consumers are actually doing, gardening is still the main engine, and that's true even though we're now several weeks past when that season would normally crest. For our branded soils, year-to-date consumer purchases have climbed over 40%, while plant food is up more than 30%. At Bonnie Plants — a business in which we hold a 25% financial stake — POS has risen roughly 50%, driven by the continued surge in edible gardening's popularity. Bonnie's performance in the past year keeps strengthening what has long drawn us to this category, along with our conviction that growing food at home matters greatly to where we're headed in the coming years. Within our controls segment, we're still posting sizable gains versus a year ago. For Ortho's outdoor insect control items, point-of-sale has climbed beyond 60%, while Ortho's indoor insect offerings have risen over 40%. Greater consumer engagement accounts for the bulk of these improvements, though better listing support has helped us too. Ortho's weed control items are running roughly 15% higher, powered by GroundClear's ongoing momentum as it keeps gaining share in the nonselective weed control category. Regarding Roundup, the product we represent on behalf of Bayer, point-of-sale has climbed 8% compared with the same period a year earlier. Within lawns, grass seed is carrying on its streak of several years, with POS advancing almost 25%. Purchases by consumers of lawn fertilizer have risen 9%. Throughout every retailer, our lawns portfolio just passed the $1 billion mark for the very first time, and we still have 2 months remaining ahead of us. In fact, how severe this summer has been and the harm it did to lawns ought to be favorable for our fall grass seed business too. Last, mulch moved into positive territory around the end of June, and POS now stands more than 4% higher as August begins. Keep in mind that mulch remained deeply negative as Q3 got underway and took a hit when retailers scrapped Black Friday events along with other aggressive promotions that leaned on mulch to pull foot traffic into lawn and garden departments. Although mulch is not a high-margin business, it is a highly strategic one. Retailers started reengaging aggressively with the mulch category starting in May. As they did so, we aligned ourselves with their efforts. When it comes to using digital channels to encourage customers to buy mulch in particular regions across the country, we follow a targeted strategy — and that paid off by clearing stock from our distribution centers as well as our retail locations. This joint initiative's positive results once again showed the kind of forward thrust this category is capable of creating for the entire lawn and garden segment.

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#3

We have witnessed robust gains in the double digits across all retail channels; on a year-to-date basis, growth remains particularly powerful in hardware, club, and farm and fleet. As the economy started reopening nationwide during May and June, retailers within the home center channel came back to the table in a major way, which let them run with fewer limitations. The broader COVID-19 trends certainly benefited both our industry and our brands; yet I want to emphasize that what we achieved this year was not simply luck. All season long, our marketing group has performed exceptionally well by tweaking our messaging and ad campaigns, particularly online. At the start of the season, we were the only ones speaking with the consumer. Not only did the team shoulder the burden for the whole industry, they did it through clever, creative, and swift work that struck the proper chord at the proper moment in the proper venues. Our direct-to-consumer operation also took a major hit — meaning both home delivery and curbside or in-store pickup. Volume has risen by over 200%. That growth was simple for us to take on thanks to the foundation the team built across the prior several years. Rather than merely collaborating with our retail partners, our sales force went further. Throughout the worst of the crisis they remained involved, frequently shifting their schedules to labor in the middle of the night so our products stayed in stock, all while acting intelligently and safely. And our supply chain has performed extraordinarily well. I won't claim we were flawless — we were not — and with our teams putting in 24/7 effort to match record demand, we frequently adopted a bend-but-don't-break approach. At points, service levels dropped beneath our benchmark; that problem belongs to us, and we are striving to correct it; even so, this team handled an unmatched degree of turbulence amid a pandemic. Not only did they keep product flowing through the network, they accomplished it while putting social distancing and other safety measures in place, such as routine shutdowns to permit deep cleaning work at over 50 sites. It might be our single most extraordinary achievement of the whole year. Our supply chain faced pressure not only to match demand in U.S. Consumer, but in Hawthorne too. Hawthorne's sales for the quarter climbed over 70% on top of a comp of almost 50% from the prior year; and given year-to-date sales growth of 59%, we are raising our sales guidance for Hawthorne as well and now anticipate sales growth between 55% and 60% for the entire year; during the third quarter we recorded growth in each Hawthorne category across almost every geography. Lighting rose 129%, powered by our recently launched Gavita LED products. Nutrients climbed 45%, growing media 62%, and growing systems 81%. Within California, our biggest and most mature market, quarterly sales jumped almost 80%. At the same time, when it came to growing in markets that were recently given the green light, such as Michigan and Oklahoma, those were up 140% and 190%, respectively. Looking at the year to date, no market anywhere in the country was negative. Another key narrative is that we're just operating the business more effectively. The jolt we went through in 2018 feels like a long-ago memory now, yet the teachings stick with us. Our view of the marketplace is clearer, we're paying more attention to managing working capital, and the pipeline for innovation keeps getting stronger. Because of this, the team has managed to find the proper balance among generating growth, picking up market share, and improving margins. Once 2020 is behind us, we'll have gone beyond what was expected on all 3 of those fronts. Everyone at Hawthorne is owed credit for the way they've changed over the last 3 years. On one of these calls back in 2018, I criticized this group openly. Honestly, back then, that criticism was warranted. Since that point, though, they've come together as one and earned trust as a genuine leader in the industry. Not only did they welcome the concept of managing remotely, they've done exceptionally well with it. What they've achieved this year gives every one of us faith in what lies ahead for this business. The second matter I wanted to address is where and how we think we'll end the year. As you observed, we raised our adjusted EPS guidance for the full year, and I'll let Randy handle the specifics. I simply want to be direct. That range might be bigger, if that's what we chose. That said, we're taking on some expenses that weren't initially planned, since we have the room to do that and since it's the correct course of action. To begin with, on top of our usual bonus programs that cover roughly 1,500 people, we've chosen to give a portion of our gains to a wider set of associates. As I mentioned when I started my comments, the success we had this year would never have come about without them. They've earned a share of the result. That's why we intend, later this year, to issue onetime cash payments along with bigger retirement contributions to around 3,000 hourly and salaried associates who aren't part of our variable pay plans. These associates gave heroic effort all season long to help us produce this outcome, and they're at the top of the list when it comes to sharing in our gains. We also intend to boost our charitable activity this year, mainly through larger corporate gifts to The Scotts Miracle-Gro Foundation. In addition, we've increased our backing of particular initiatives near our home in Central Ohio, and of broader ones such as the 9/11 Memorial and the United Veterans War Council. Before the year ends, we'll give more than twice what we had planned to charity. Taken together, those efforts come to roughly $0.20 per share on an adjusted basis. That leads me into my third subject, which is how we currently see 2021. Jim King has mentioned that hardly a day passes without someone asking him about the difficult comparison we faced following this record-breaking year. So we're aware that this is the number one subject on everybody's mind. Just to remind everyone, no guidance is being given today regarding next year. Our plan is to offer that in November, but I do want to talk about the significant variances for 2021 when it comes to our capacity to comp this year from a sales standpoint and afterward from an earnings standpoint. Starting with the top line, let's begin with Hawthorne, since the situation there is fairly straightforward. Should we take the business's present run rate and extend it into next year, we'd anticipate seeing very strong double-digit growth during the first half of the year. Considering our existing order book alongside the market, that appears attainable. Obviously, our comps during the latter half of next year are going to be considerably tougher. So even assuming we're flat in the back half — and I'm not claiming that's what we expect — we ought to still be in a position to reach our long-term targets of high single-digit growth; over in U.S. Consumer, we recognize that the societal shifts caused by COVID-19 will eventually start to normalize at some point.

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#4

During our previous call, we mentioned that 30% of edible gardening engagement involved shoppers either new to this category in 2020 or coming back after time away. After that, we carried out further consumer research, and it shows us that participation in long care rose 14%, which means another 8 million households are using grass seed or lawn food for the first time during this year; we also understand that 28% of all homeowners reported devoting additional time to overall lawn and garden activities in 2020. Holding onto every one of these consumers will matter more than anything else in determining whether our U.S. Consumer segment expands in 2021. Let me begin by describing the main activity that attracted these consumers to us in 2020. Edible gardening is a solid starting point; we recognize that the majority of those who take part in edible gardening do not view it as a chore. It represents a passion and a lifestyle choice; and for years it has been the fastest-growing part of lawn and garden. We think most people will participate again in the coming year. To help make that result more likely, we understand that our bond with these consumers needs strengthening, and that requires us to remain connected with them. You will probably observe us continuing to communicate with them across the fall and winter, covering not only our products but also the lifestyle connected to gardening and spending time in the yard. We achieved significant enhancements to our marketing efforts during 2020. In fact, in my view we are performing as well as at any point in our history. Our team has reshaped how we connect with our consumers; our knowledge of them is deeper than it has ever been; and we no longer merely advertise at them, we now converse with them in a manner that is plainly producing results, yet that does not mean our work is finished. You will see us keep adapting to the marketplace more quickly than before, with additional creative assets and additional methods for deploying them. When next spring arrives, we also anticipate a different retail dynamic. Keep in mind that home centers, responsible for roughly 60% of our revenue, experienced little to no promotional activity during the spring that just passed. We anticipate an increase in promotional activity, particularly early in the season, though not necessarily a full return to how things previously operated. Obviously, consumers stayed engaged this year despite minimal promotional activity. We believe a better balance exists, and we are collaborating with those retailers to locate it; but keep in mind, our retail partners who are in that next year from a scale perspective enjoyed enormous success in 2020 and clearly recorded market share gains. They will not merely roll over in 2021, they are going to work hard to protect their space. Therefore I believe we will encounter a far more competitive retail landscape in the coming year. Lastly, we would anticipate taking some pricing next year, largely consistent with our historical behavior, and that ought to assist the top line too. We're also aware that despite the significant increases we've achieved in the current year, we missed out on certain sales because of constraints in the supply chain at the busiest point of the season. Although our outlook for the coming year is positive, you ought to anticipate a cautious approach from us when we provide sales guidance in November. If someone said to me at this moment that we could match this year's performance and preserve our margins, I would accept that. Obviously, we will motivate the team to exceed that. And as demonstrated this year, we have an amazing capacity to meet the challenge when growth exceeds what we anticipated. I would prefer to do that in 2021 rather than outlining an expectation that isn't realistic. That said, regarding earnings for the next year, achieving growth ought to be much simpler. Bringing SG&A back to a typical level should be valued at no less than $70 million or $80 million, and that is mostly a matter of variable compensation, so we have strong visibility into the possible upside in that area. Naturally, we will be in a far stronger position to provide specifics when we speak in November. But I want you to understand that our budgeting for 2021 has turned into our top priority, and we are attuned to the same concerns that we recognize all of you have as well. The final subject I wish to discuss is our balance sheet and our present thinking regarding uses of cash. When Project Focus was announced in 2015, we stated we would concentrate on 3 items: first, to maximize the potential of our U.S. Consumer business, and I believe we've performed excellently in that regard; second, to restructure our company-wide portfolio, which involved selling some businesses and buying others, and that is how Hawthorne developed into what it is today; and third, we stated we would concentrate on cash flow and giving cash back to shareholders, while keeping a target leverage ratio of roughly 3.5x debt to EBITDA. We had begun to return cash, but reduced that somewhat in 2018 after the difficulty we encountered that year pushed our leverage ratio above what we desired; yet once we returned to our comfort zone, we resumed our share repurchase activity in 2019 until COVID-19 struck us. We halted share repurchases in March as a precaution, which was the correct choice at that moment. Now, with free cash flow probably reaching its highest level ever and leverage significantly under our target, we wish to return to giving cash back to our shareholders. A special dividend returns cash to our shareholders' hands immediately and lets them choose how they wish to invest the money. In my discussions with some of our biggest institutional shareholders over the years, I've discovered that most of them are indifferent between share repurchase and dividend. So on this occasion, we selected the dividend. In all likelihood, the special dividend will take the place of any significant share repurchase activity for at least the next several months; thus we retain sufficient flexibility to act opportunistically. Additionally, our M&A efforts have been increased over the last few months, and right now we're exploring a few modest yet strategic possibilities involving U.S. Consumer as well as Hawthorne. For clear reasons, I won't be providing specifics today, yet we continue to identify strategic chances to broaden what we offer and put both operations in a stronger spot for ongoing achievement. Prior to handing the call to Randy, I'd like to close by recognizing the favorable circumstances that arrived for us during 2020. Toward the end of March, a press release went out from us noting a recent jump in business, while also admitting we had no idea where the season ahead might lead. Back then, we maintained a cautious approach, reducing SG&A and pausing our buyback program. We had no clarity on what lay ahead. Yet consumers responded, plainly showing that they regarded our product categories as essential while dealing with this public health emergency. The confidence that consumers and growers have placed in us, along with the confidence from our retail partners, remains something nobody on this team has lost sight of; we're putting in greater effort than ever to make our ties with them even stronger as we move into 2021.

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#5

Thanks to the solidity and adaptability of our financial standing, we're also making our business more robust, setting ourselves up to win, not only during 2021, but throughout the years ahead. So with that said, let's pivot and turn to the figures. Randy?

Thomas Coleman

executive
#6

Thank you, Jim, and good morning to all of you. Today's release makes it clear that our third-quarter performance came in far above the level we had anticipated back when we revised our outlook roughly 7 weeks ago. The momentum we carried through June went past anything we have seen before, and it is still going right now. So before anything else, I want to echo Jim in expressing appreciation to our consumers and retail partners, and above all to our associates, for steering us through the COVID crisis so well and producing such exceptional results; this morning, I'd like to devote most of my time to some key remarks about the P&L. I won't walk through every figure. I'm aware that most of you have already reviewed them. I also want to build on what Jim said regarding 2021. Let me repeat that no guidance is being offered today, but I will also emphasize that we feel confident about our capacity to push earnings still higher in the coming year; so let's begin; on the top line, the key story to grasp is what is taking place within U.S. Consumer. Back in June, we lifted our guidance and anticipated 9% to 11% growth across the full year. Yet even while we were saying that, conditions were shifting in a way we hadn't foreseen. If I pull up 20 years of consumer POS data, a steady pattern of consumer behavior emerges. In any particular year, the timing of the season and the effects of weather might shift the flow of the POS curve somewhat within a season, yet it stays very consistent once the middle of June passes. That was our expectation. What we got instead was a season that stretched far past what we had anticipated and kept posting dramatic year-over-year growth for the remainder of June. With that consumer momentum in the market, we kept pushing the category through additional media and in-store support. That approach paid off. Point-of-sale jumped 50% in June versus the same month a year earlier. Because of that, U.S. Consumer sales for June came in above our forecast by over $100 million, measured against the assumptions behind the new guidance range we set in <<inaudible>>. That momentum has carried forward since. Take July: consumer purchases there are running 33% higher than a year ago. August, of course, is consistently the quietest month in lawn and garden, and that pattern will hold again in 2024, yet our current projection calls for a year-over-year percentage increase matching the off-season trend we've observed. A robust fall is also in our outlook, which Jim touched on during his comments. Honestly, fall product sales in September ought to be quite robust as well. The guidance we've revised operates on the assumption that what we witnessed through July carries on until the year ends, and that's what produces our full-year U.S. Consumer sales growth figure of 20% to 22%. With Hawthorn, it feels like we keep telling the same story. The strength we're seeing in the back half of the year simply wasn't something we anticipated. During Q3, sales rose 72%, compared with a 49% comp. So far this year, Hawthorne is up 59%, and looking at the whole year, we expect a range of 55% to 60%, because the coming 2 months involve comparisons that get somewhat harder. Jim already covered how Hawthorne is doing on profitability, so I'll just tack on a few extra observations. For the quarter, the segment margin rate landed at 13.5%, and on a year-to-date basis it sits at 11%. As I see it, the full year rate should hit the 10% target we set, even though it will decline between Q3 and Q4 because we're directing additional funds toward supply chain, sales and marketing, and other functions in order to strengthen the business over the long haul. Here's the funny part: my sense is that the margin rate would in fact be greater if the sales growth rate were closer to 25% or 30%. We wound up allocating a sizable amount within that band to stay aligned with demand, and some of those outlays turned out to be less productive and pulled margin down. All the same, the full-year rate gain will come in inside the guidance we initially provided, which keeps us on course for the 15% segment margin rate this business is capable of reaching over time. Let's move on now to gross margin. A lot of elements are shifting around, yet on the whole the picture is positive. On an adjusted basis, the gross margin rate declined 10 basis points during the quarter, landing at 36.1%. Even though both the U.S. During the quarter, both Consumer and Hawthorne posted gains. However, because Hawthorne carries lower margins and made up a bigger share of the mix, our overall margin rate fell by close to 80 basis points. Beyond that, the timing of a $20 million Roundup payment from Bayer — received in Q3 of last year — cost us an additional 85 basis points. Keep in mind that in Q2 of this year we recorded a similar lift to commission income, so there's no impact on the full-year rate. On the other hand, improvements in pricing and volume combined to offset nearly all of that drag. Looking at the year to date, we're still about 25 basis points ahead of where we stood last year. And once we reach September 30, we anticipate the full year gross margin rate will be about flat; in Q4 we intend to carry out a few supply chain initiatives that raise costs in 2020, which should help us deliver better service next year. Turning to SG&A, that 43% year-over-year increase really jumps out. So allow me to give some context. As Jim said earlier, this year we chose to share a portion of our results' upside with associates. Looking at the entire year, our projection is that variable compensation will land somewhere between $60 million and $70 million higher than the prior year, and during this quarter we adjusted our fall figure upward to account for that; in addition, we began setting aside money for hourly as well as salaried employees who typically aren't included in our bonus program, yet are receiving one-time bonuses this year, recognizing how much they contributed to what we achieved together; on top of those compensation items, we've increased our U.S. Consumer media spending by a considerable amount. We anticipate finishing the year at approximately 20% above the level we were at twelve months earlier. On top of that, we think consumer impressions are far outpacing the increase in our spending, since media costs have dropped considerably versus last year. Our aggressive investment in Hawthorne has carried on as well. The rise in SG&A is nearly matching the sales increase. Moving toward the operating line, interest expenses are down close to $6 million for the quarter and $17 million on a year-to-date basis. Between the robust operating cash flows, pushing share repurchase activity this year past Q2, and the absence of any acquisitions, we've been able together to bring borrowing down below what we'd anticipated, with lower interest rates lending a hand too. Turning to profitability, adjusted earnings equaled $3.80 a share — a 22% gain versus the prior year. Through the first nine months, adjusted EPS hit $7.20, up 34% from a year earlier. During last year's fourth quarter, we recorded an adjusted loss of $0.91, and we expect the improvement in earnings compared with a year ago to extend into this year's fourth quarter. Given continuing revenue momentum across every part of the business, along with net additional investments and incentives during Q4, our projection for full year adjusted EPS is $6.65 to $6.85 per share — roughly $1 per share higher than the guidance we gave previously.

Thomas Coleman

executive
#7

We don't view that as a cautious forecast. That said, back in early June, we plainly misjudged what demand would look like ahead in a season unlike anything we've seen. There's still a chance we land inside that range. Even so, my preference is to give clear estimates about what's ahead rather than simply disclose results once the books are shut, even in an environment this difficult where hitting things precisely is very hard. Let me note for everyone that our adjusted figures leave out the added expense of premiums paid to associates, who keep showing up at stores, factories and distribution centers as the COVID pandemic first hit. So far this year, what we've paid for the 50% hourly pay enhancement comes to roughly $18 million. That means we're shifting further away from the method we laid out a quarter ago; enhanced cleaning and maintenance costs won't be adjusted out anymore, since we intend to keep up those practices for the foreseeable future. As for next year, Jim gave his thoughts on whether we can grow once more, and the two of us see this the same way; we'll stay cautious while putting together our plans for U.S. Consumer, and Hawthorne growth ought to keep going, though not at the pace we're witnessing in 2020. SG&A ought to serve as a meaningful tailwind, letting us achieve operating income growth consistent with our long-term projections, all while we keep putting money into our brands, Hawthorn supply chain growth initiatives and our direct-to-consumer distribution models. Now on to the balance sheet. At quarter's end, our debt-to-EBITDA ratio was 2.8x. With the robust free cash flow we foresee this year, now projected at roughly $400 million, and with how confident we remain in the business going forward, we've decided to start giving cash back to shareholders once more, even if that's happening a few months sooner than we thought just a couple of months back. The special dividend announced today pushes our leverage to just above 3x, near the middle of our target leverage range. Going forward, we retain room to buy back shares next year, and to act on the existing pipeline of a few small and early-stage M&A opportunities, all while keeping leverage under 3.5x and perhaps getting back to a level close to where we are now by this same point next year. When it comes to cash flow for next year, I'd anticipate a slight step back for a handful of reasons. First, incentives accrued in 2020 get paid out in 2021, and that will be a substantial headwind next year. Additionally, as Jim mentioned before, the supply chain faced strain the whole year. Though I commend our efforts amid unprecedented demand increases, service levels did drop beneath our expectations at points. We've spent recent months trying to build up inventory. The pace of our top-line gains kept building, and we wrapped up Q3 carrying roughly $40 million less in inventory than we did 12 months earlier. A key point: you will likely observe us booking back out of those stock positions during Q4 and all through 2021, since we keep trying to stay in front of demand. Before I wrap up, I find myself thinking about how dramatically our world, our nation and our company have shifted across the last several months. Scotts was lucky enough to be able to assist our shoppers, and everyone on our leadership group and our associates feels deep appreciation for what we achieved this year. We appreciate your backing. So with that, let's turn to Q&A.

Jim King

executive
#8

Steven, let's go ahead and start the Q&A.

Jonathan Andersen

analyst
#9

A key dynamic at work this year, which you touched on in your prepared remarks, is reduced promotional activity, and I believe a few factors are behind that, above all COVID-19 and the limitations it placed on home centers. So my question is this: has that been beneficial — has the bulk of that benefit gone to the retailers? Or has Scotts also gained from less frequent and less deep promotion? And how do you expect this to unfold in 2021 and 2022? Do we return to a more promotion-heavy environment like the one we saw before COVID? Or have there been genuine lessons about consumer engagement that could be used here to perhaps temper how much promotional activity happens in the category?

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#10

I'll kick things off, then pass it to Randy. Jon, here's my take. First, I believe most of the benefit went to the retailers. I think we saw some benefit, but much of that came about because there was no voice, so to speak, for the industry/category, we increased our spending and basically just did what we wanted; and in certain ways that was positive because we didn't need to seek much permission; we essentially ran things for the industry. And I think that worked in our favor, and we learned a great deal from it. I doubt the retailer has pocketed much of that, because their operating expenses rose significantly. So they basically had to manage their labor and cleanliness and things like that in the stores. So I don't think retailers would be proudly claiming they pocketed much of it. But I think when we look at the margin at the retail level on our products, we believed it was — we believe it's much higher on the retailer side, much, again, I'll say it again, I think they spent most of that. We've discussed that — my — at least my perspective, and I think it's more or less our perspective here, is that Black Friday, we were growing more and more skeptical of these Black Friday events, mainly because if we looked at the early season, which is really tied to weather, what we saw was a very high miss rate for cold and bad weather, and at least 50% of everyone's promotional numbers go into these Black Friday events; and our view is with — I'll say, call it, roughly a 20% hit rate, which means an 80% miss rate. So we've been in conversations throughout the last 12 months with retailers saying, dude, this doesn't seem like the right approach. The amount of cash going out is huge relative to the outcomes we want, and in our view there's a superior method — something we describe as a rifle shot approach — going market by market, category by category, factoring in the weather, something we can't really pull off two weeks ahead of time with much ease. So my sense is that after this year, you'll find more people at the retail level who buy into that than was previously the case. What I mean is, everyone's examining the sales figures and concluding that the consumer clearly didn't need the sort of freebies they've normally received, particularly across some of our bigger categories. So I expect that will shift, and we're in conversations with retailers at this very moment about where the balance lands so that things become somewhat less centered on discounts. That's one piece of it. On the flip side, I think you'll observe that mostly owing to footprints — the large retailers, the big home centers — we face greater pressure not to make their shopping experience hazardous, whether for their employees or for shoppers. As a result, they capped how many people could come in; they cut back their promotions. We weren't on day shifts there. Throughout the worst of the crisis, we mainly worked nights. A few locations continue doing so. So where does that leave us? My expectation is that you'll end up somewhere in the middle, where we do run promotions. You heard what we said regarding mulch — when we reviewed our inventory position, what we found, I believe, was a great deal of mulch that we genuinely needed to clear out. So we began running highly focused marketing promotions, similar to what I've been describing — weather-driven, marketplace-level, nearly ZIP code-level targeting tied to weather — and we managed to clear out every bit of that mulch. Thus we're confident this method, which is a fairly novel way of handling what used to be Black Fridays, delivers results. What you're also seeing, though, is that the home centers gave up a fair amount of share. And I'd put it at approximately 10% — I'm not sure, Mike is sitting beside me. I can't say whether he's fond of that figure.

Mike Lukemire

executive
#11

Yes, yes, yes. I would say about 10% overall home center lost.

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#12

So I believe they will want to recover that. And the ones who took it, I'd say wholesale clubs, hardware, general merchandise. I mean, that's quite a few players. Customers get separated into online and you've got direct-to-consumer. I believe there will be substantial pressure on them to hold onto that share. Farm and fleet was one more segment that performed quite strongly this year; so what's my view? My view is it creates a fairly competitive landscape as next season gets underway. And I don't believe we can persuade folks otherwise, because you'll have those who achieved large gains wanting to protect them; and you'll have those who came out behind. And keep in mind, lawn and garden is a huge category during a season for us, the single most significant category, the biggest nonlumber category in home centers across our season. So I believe a major battle is coming — and look, based on how things go with COVID, that could show up in the fall. I believe Halloween will be a somewhat strange season this year. So I think that creates fall chances for us to promote, which were — in my view, these go past discussions. I think actual planning is happening with our major accounts around making fall a larger season than it typically would be; so what's my view? Returning to what you asked. I believe next year will look different. I think the bulk of the gain wound up with the retailers. I think it'll be more competitive, and I think you'll see business spread more across the year than what you've seen previously. I don't know, Randy?

Thomas Coleman

executive
#13

Not really, Jon—I've got nothing further to contribute on that point. Jim pretty much covered everything, I'd say. You mentioned having another question you were hoping to pose?

Jonathan Andersen

analyst
#14

Yeah, I do. A fast follow-up, and this one might be for you, Randy. So, I'm aware — thanks for the remarks regarding 2021. I realize it's sooner than you'd normally do this, but I appreciate it. What I took away, I believe, is that you'd be fine with a roughly flat top line, I think in U.S. Consumer, that's what you mean. And still, you see a chance to increase earnings; so let's suppose roughly flat top line for U.S. Consumer happens and Hawthorne grows somewhat, but overall, modest top line growth because the comp is tough. Could you take us through, perhaps just broadly, a few of the main positives and negatives there? For instance, what are — I believe you cited $60 million to $70 million of possible swing in variable comp, and then there's this sort of one-time bonus for employees. I'm not sure whether that's additional to that. But just walk us through the gains that could produce solid earnings growth even with maybe lower top line than usual?

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#15

Look, before Randy gets into that, and he will, I just want to address the top line a bit. Part of what I do as we work through budget, which has been difficult, both the in-season period here and when we consider next year, is what would count as a victory. And so I think when we examined this, particularly at the start. And we now have, I think, far more detail than we did, say, even a month ago, about whether we'd be pleased if we could comp this year, keep our gross margins, and then capture the SG&A tailwinds; and I think Randy and I more or less established the expectations with the operating community that we believed that would be a good outcome. And I think that's what we conveyed today; and Randy can take you through the specifics of that, at least the SG&A tailwinds and our thinking. I do want to say a bit about the top line simply because I think it matters. I think anyone who — Mike is quite self-critical about our capacity to execute in season when demand was going kind of crazy. I'm far more lenient about that. And my wife and I did a lot of gardening this year. So we've visited quite a few garden centers purchasing things, and there were many empty shelves. I think Chris' demand on Hawthorne was also, I wouldn't call it excessive, but it was much greater than we had forecast and that business is much younger and we had just implemented SAP. So I think you could readily attribute maybe $100 million of money we left on the table across both businesses, which is quite significant simply because we couldn't fill orders at times. And I believe we performed extremely well, meeting a certain benchmark. Like we mentioned, we're aware there's room for improvement, yet we definitely missed out on significant potential revenue. My feeling is we won't let that happen again in the coming year. That is to say, there's been considerable conversation regarding stock levels, and Mike has launched key initiatives around what he refers to as the customer experience — which involves our buyers and ensuring we're the supplier we aim to be. Plus, we're seriously examining plenty of chances in Q4 and Q1 moving ahead, and shifting toward more of a business that operates throughout the year; I believe Halloween plays a part in that, and so does our direct-to-consumer operation. So I think we've — as we invest more time discussing and collaborating with our retail partners and our direct-to-consumer team, I think we genuinely feel there's potential to grow the top line. However, regarding this matter of, if we could match last 2020, I mean the prior year, this year, if we could match this year, maintain margins and capture the tailwinds, it would be an outstanding earnings year. And I think that's roughly our situation; yet I think we truly have greater clarity on growth in 2021 than we likely had about a month back.

Thomas Coleman

executive
#16

I'm totally on the same page as Jim on all of that, Jon. What I'd add is that our visibility is obviously far better regarding how Q1 will shape up and how that carries momentum through the fall. Once you move past that horizon, though, you're forced into making assumptions and running scenario analyses about global conditions and what those conditions will ultimately mean. We are doing exactly that; however, we're attempting to wager on which scenario proves correct, and I believe it's far too soon to reach that conclusion. That said, regarding your question about next year from a bottom-line perspective? It's fairly evident that if our incentive plans return to something closer to a target or normalized level, along with certain SG&A expenses we pulled forward from Q1 into Q4 as we try to get ahead and construct a stronger business for next year and the one after, and attempting to put a figure on that — in terms of the dollar portion of EPS where gross margins remain flat alongside flat sales growth, which trust me, we'll be striving for considerably bigger figures than that; yet as a baseline you simply have each scenario to measure against, that's how we're approaching it. And as we work to maintain equilibrium between sales growth, we're on track to be a $4 billion company this year. Meanwhile, last year we were slightly over $3 billion. So we're being tough on ourselves regarding service, yet working to keep pace with that. Rewind 4 months and we were pinching pennies, simply being cautious and making certain we could steer through this year; so once more, I offer everyone a hearty congratulations. But once you release much of that SG&A we're placing into our P&L here in 2020 and shift it into 2021, our operating margin rates will climb considerably, and we'll witness substantial accretion throughout the company and Hawthorne as well, which I recognize is a major priority for everyone. Still, we're working to keep things balanced. We're working to consider this year, but equally next year and the year after and the year after that. And I genuinely appreciate how we're operating the business at present in order to get ready for that. So with luck, that addresses your question, Jon, and I'm extremely optimistic about where we're headed at this moment.

William Reuter

analyst
#17

I’ll keep it to just one. I realize it’s somewhat early to be talking about line reviews for next year, but my guess is that your categories have ranked among the most productive ones for your large retail customers. Have those customers told you they intend to make dramatic changes to the shelf space given to your categories, or to increase it?

Mike Lukemire

executive
#18

Mike Lukemire here. Yes, line reviews are underway right now, and what we’re hearing is that retailers want to commit more heavily with us in that space; however, we won’t truly lock that in until December, when they wrap up their years. Still, the signal is that they are certainly moving toward fall; so expanded space is something we’re seeing. And among our retailers, we’re also seeing a readiness to commit more, do additional work, and build on what we achieved this year.

Thomas Coleman

executive
#19

One more point to make, and this is Randy speaking. Once more, as you consider how we approach the market and mention e-commerce rising 200% or perhaps even more, particularly regarding buy online and pick up in store, going forward, my expectation is that this will remain a crucial method by which the consumer shops. And I think we hold a genuine edge there simply due to national advertising, the nationwide reach of the brand across stores, no matter whether you're in Washington, the state of Florida, Maine, or California, we've got it covered. So my view is that we ought to place greater emphasis, both us and the retailers, on concentrating on key core SKUs that consumers are looking to come in and purchase. And I think we possess a significant edge to accomplish that; and that business has expanded more quickly than any other channel or any other component we examine.

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#20

Yeah, I want to jump in on that for a moment, because I believe Randy raised a key point here — it isn't only our company that's watching inventory numbers, it's also us working alongside the retailers. And once more, Mike is being tough on himself, yet this year really amounted to a kind of business battle, and when you go through something like that, things get broken; so we had what I would describe as a successful war, but we certainly did break some things. That's going to make us stronger, though it involves both us and the retailers. And I think this notion of focusing on our core SKUs and making certain we hold the inventory and the retailers hold it too, so we avoid being out of stock and having empty shelves; so I think you'll probably see some rebuilding of both our inventory and retail inventory across certain high-volume SKUs next year.

Mike Lukemire

executive
#21

Absolutely, and that pattern is unfolding on a large scale. However, in certain markets across the South, getting 80% of the POS in early will be necessary. So what I'm saying is, the momentum is strong at this moment—being prepared, capitalizing on it, and securing space on their shelves.

Joe Altobello

analyst
#22

Nice work, everyone. To start, I want to ask about the U.S. Consumer segment. Could you say a little about that in terms of edible gardening, and also gardening more broadly, and address both 2021 and what comes after? What I'm really wondering is whether you believe COVID is permanently altering how consumers view your categories right now, or whether this is mostly something short-lived — because if it's the latter, then even a soft sales performance would look aggressive going into next year?

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#23

I'm going to swear — s*** — I haven't — what's my take? Look, I suppose I don't agree. The thing I'd push back on is the idea that shoppers are looking at this differently. From where we sit, what matters is the way people relate to the category — my sense is that the draw of gardening, plus the obvious reality that everyone's been confined to their homes, has worked in our favor; even so, I think folks have honestly gravitated toward pursuits that make them happy. And to some degree, I believe they've rediscovered what it's worth. I mean, practically everyone has some kind of garden, right? Carli and I, for instance, spend time at our spot in Vermont. The garden we have there is pretty big. We intend to expand it in the coming year, and my guess is a lot of folks are finding a lot of enjoyment in it—often the very people who don't get much enjoyment out of gardening—and I believe we anticipate that continuing. The focus of what we do in communications is strange; I wouldn't exactly call it advertising. I'm not sure—Randy would have that number, Joe—about how across the past 3 or 4 years, it was genuinely—I have to say, Randy, who approached me roughly 3 years ago. And I believe I told you all this, that he said we are a branded consumer company. What's behind the drop in what we put toward marketing, while what we put toward promotions keeps climbing? Randy, honestly, I can't tell you the totals we've laid out over the past three years. We saw roughly a 30% increase last year, and this year brought another 20% on top. Beyond the money itself, there's the fact that right now media can be had at a bargain. Rates have climbed past that 20% mark — likely 35% once more. So the real task before us is holding those individuals' attention and getting through to them about the right place and the right moment. Look, I've generally held a pretty skeptical view of digital ads — it mostly amounts to repurposing TV-style spots, display banners, and nonsense on social platforms. That said, I believe we're producing some truly remarkable work right now, and honestly we're only at the beginning of it. So I'd say our capacity to hold people's attention is quite strong. As for me personally — truthfully, I can't predict what happens once restrictions lift, whether folks will immediately flock to taverns and catch COVID. Right now, my sense is they won't. The more individuals I speak with — the more conversations I have with my partners here, with my family, with my admin — people truly feel at ease in their own homes. When surrounded by strangers, they feel exposed, unsure of what those others have been doing. I doubt that will shift much during this fall and winter. So I expect you'll keep seeing folks who prefer staying home and doing things that bring them comfort. That desire was present all along. Luck didn't bring us to this position. My father had a saying — luck happens when preparation and opportunity come together. And prepare we did. We built this business for the situation that's now in front of us — not with COVID in mind, but because we felt people genuinely needed this service, and that's exactly how things turned out. So of course, is there risk? Absolutely — ask Mike and he'll say we're capable of topping last year. Randy and I are basically planning on that outcome — just look at everything we've laid out. If we manage to comp this year, hold our margin steady, and put an extra $1 on the bottom line, how would we feel? We'd call that a pretty great outcome. Might it go the other way? It could. I'm not anticipating that, but it isn't impossible. And Mike, I believe, isn't at the discussion phase with the operators in his business. I believe growth exists there. Proving that falls on us. We'll discuss it further in November. But here's the thing — Randy has likewise been frustrated about the financials. Each time we speak with you folks, we're undercounting. So it's difficult for us to even determine how Q4 will finish right now. I realize that's troubling Randy. Partly it's because we've been overly cautious. As you all know, in discussing our numbers, we under promise and over deliver. That habit hasn't helped us when it comes to financial accuracy this year. I think Randy cares more about the genuine numbers, not manipulated figures we can beat; and getting this culture to accept what the genuine numbers are has been challenging. So what you're hearing from us now is likely closer to the genuine numbers, meaning there's both upside and downside risk. Still, I believe it's balanced. Randy, what do you think?

Thomas Coleman

executive
#24

What I would mention is that we had an option to take the simple route, throw our hands up, and claim we would sort it out at a later point. We would let you know once we had the answer. Yet the SEC was quite supportive right when COVID began, telling us we ought to offer greater visibility into our forward-looking figures. We've made an effort to do so, though our culture pushes us toward caution and toward ensuring we meet our goals. I believe our June projection, when we presented at the William Blair Conference, was clearly far too low. We've made another attempt, stating that if we simply maintain the run rate from July for the remainder of the year, with retail inventory holding roughly steady, and the Hawthorne forecast showing possibly slight upside but looking fairly solid — if all of that happens, it ought to land within the range we discussed. That said, things are highly unpredictable at this moment, and there may still be room for upside. And Jim is telling me to go easy on myself, but around here I think all of us hold ourselves to a higher standard, and we've made our best effort at this point.

Bill Chappell

analyst
#25

Congrats on a fantastic quarter. I've got 2 things I want to ask quickly. Actually, maybe not so quick, given how this call has gone. The first concerns what we might expect for Hawthorne in the coming year. I realize you're only in the early planning stages. Still, do you actually have solid visibility into how these things roll out state by state — for instance, they start with medical use, then sales pick up there, and afterward recreational sales arrive? Having done this for a couple of years, I'm just trying to figure out whether you have that visibility, particularly when you mention the possibility of difficult year-over-year comparisons in next year's second half.

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#26

We're all sort of glancing around at one another, asking who's going to take that one; and I'm not sure. Chris, would you like to begin on it and then pass it over to Randy.

Chris Hagedorn

executive
#27

Sure, and I'll keep this pretty short — hi Bill, Chris here. From the way we've been following this across those last several years, as you said, we figure we've got a decent grasp now on the timelines once this stuff gets legalized one way or another, through a vote or a state senate bill, whatever it might be. Generally there's roughly a 12-month delay between a law passing and the point where we begin to see cannabis actually being sold. And usually there's around a year of lag time before our own business truly sees a bump from it. Then, generally, it takes a year or 2 for the state to feel comfortable with recreation before they — or sorry, with medical before they decide to move on recreational. So generally, the way we view it, other states have legislated somewhat differently, but we've estimated roughly a year from when the law passes until we start to see a genuine bump in our business in that geography, plus another year or 2 beyond that before the state begins to hit any level we'd call maturity — hope that answers what you asked.

Thomas Coleman

executive
#28

There are a few points I'd like to make here. Because of how this industry is structured, retailers simply don't have much room to hold inventory. That's why our visibility has improved considerably ever since the Sunlight Supply acquisition a couple of years back. As a result, we can see clearly what's happening on the retail side. The simple truth is they lack the space to stock up. Another thing we monitor closely is pricing at both the wholesale and retail levels in the market, and it's been pretty steady; it has risen substantially compared with a couple of years ago. So at present that looks solid, despite those results being elevated. Then, on the demand side, I'd say — as Chris mentioned during our previous earnings call, folks are remaining at home, whether gardening or pursuing other activities. Demand, in my view, is strong, and the reason for that makes sense, though whether it holds up is another question. I'd wager it does, but I believe we're positioned well, and with the strategy we're laying out today, plus more to come in November, if we merely maintain the same run rate across the first 6 months of the year, we'll achieve healthy double-digit growth next year. That mirrors the approach we used this year coming out of 2019, since looking at things 6 months at a time isn't possible for us. Still, I'd call that a very healthy position to be in.

Bill Chappell

analyst
#29

Thanks, I appreciate that. Then for my second question — apologies if this was already covered — regarding your media spend for 2020, did you manage to spend the amount you'd planned? And looking ahead to next year, is it still necessary to stay at the levels you've traditionally maintained? My assumption is that advertising around things like early season baseball games or NCAA March Madness doesn't really make sense to run in the fall, but I'm simply trying to get a sense of what total spend looks like this year compared with what next year might bring?

Thomas Coleman

executive
#30

Right. So back during the March period and even into April, we were extremely cautious and worked to hold onto some of that money. Then once conditions began improving considerably in early May, we really — there was plenty of fuel to add to the fire, and again, we did that in June. We're still doing so now. Our fall program is going to be higher than at any point before. I'm not sure whether anyone expects us to go backwards next year, and it's tough to forecast what media rates will do next year. It's hard to imagine they'd drop once more. But then again, you never know; still, I'd anticipate that we'll keep investing in the brand as our business expands, and I don't see that changing whatsoever.

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#31

To put it plainly, our marketing team is certainly going to have a bigger budget going into the next year. Sports is an area we enjoy, though it has come with difficulties, and Major League Baseball, as an example, has shown a great deal of flexibility. Our stance is straightforward: if there are no games, there is no payment. That said, working with baseball has been a positive experience, and March Madness remains something we're fond of. So when you take a look at the folks handling our media, their enthusiasm for sports hasn't faded; we're also extremely active on the social front, yet sports alongside news are going to stay significant to us.

Carla Casella

analyst
#32

I've got some questions about M&A. You said you're still evaluating opportunities. I'd like to know whether you're seeing more of them come from smaller or weaker competitors because of COVID. And if you do come across an opportunity, how comfortable would you be? What would it take to push leverage above your target range for the right deal?

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#33

Let me take the second part first. I don't believe that's really needed. I've been encouraging Hawthorne to think bigger, and what they've landed on is pretty close to adjacent spaces, meaning smaller transactions. I wouldn't classify them as — so on the Hawthorne front alone, I'd say the opportunities we're looking at aren't struggling companies. The entire industry is honestly performing quite well; these are folks who are, I'd say, willing to consider joining us and cashing in all or part of what they've invested. That said, I think the business has come back to me arguing that there are pockets inside Hawthorne that are obvious opportunities where owners are ready to monetize and that would align nicely with our pillars or business — the areas where we operate. So I think they've come back saying we don't have to pursue huge deals, and I'm encouraging Randy and Chris. Randy — the strategy group reports up to Randy — to explore game-changing opportunities, which aren't in our current plans. Essentially, if we think this country is heading toward some form of national legalization, and given the tax code and banking difficulties, these businesses are struggling somewhat unnaturally. If we believe legalization is coming, what would we want to do — step in early? Those efforts are at very early stages, and I'm not saying we're pursuing game-changing opportunities there. But I do want the company examining whether there's a chance to go big. And what would that mean for Hawthorne, in relation to Scotts, alongside Scotts? I don't think we have the answer. But I don't want to lose the chance to have the strategic group and our banking partners help us examine industry structure, not for tomorrow, but roughly 10 years ahead, so we're being smart about it. For the moment, though, everyone's position is let's just focus on closing adjacencies that can be integrated easily. Often we're already working with these companies thanks to our relationship with Sunlight, our ownership of Sunlight, so that's the situation. On the consumer side, again nothing revolutionary — these would be businesses we already operate with, simply streamlining the ownership structure. Yet my guess is you're referring to an amount below $200 million across both Hawthorne and the Consumer side for 2021, or maybe near the close of 2020 should we keep moving forward; therefore I don't believe we need to run with leverage ratios higher than what feels acceptable to us; however, if we judged the opportunity to be sufficiently large, my sense is we could begin by speaking with our Board, and Randy would begin contacting our banking partners to work out the way we'd fund it.

Thomas Coleman

executive
#34

Also, Carla, I want to mention that back in 2018, when we acquired Sunlight Supply, our leverage actually increased to roughly 4.5x. We then took many steps to reduce that as fast as we could. So we feel really good about our current position. A level of 3.5x remains quite sensible. And once this dividend is paid, we still won’t be anywhere near 3.5x. So if the right opportunity came along, we’d do it again—but we don’t have the right opportunity. That said, Sunlight was definitely the right opportunity. At that time, the industry was experiencing a lot of change. If you look at where we stand today compared with 3 years ago, the #3 competitor exited the industry. When you compare us to our biggest competitor, now #2, our sales are 3 to 4x larger, and our profitability is 5 or 6x greater; so this has been a tremendous success. And as we look toward next year, we still have significant momentum and we can improve a great deal more. So there’s more to share on that.

Jim King

executive
#35

Steve, let me step in here. It would be great if we could take 2 additional questions, and after that we'll bring this to a close.

Alex Maroccia

analyst
#36

I'm attempting to gain a clearer picture of how lasting that U.S. Consumer improvement really is. Public landscaping wholesalers likewise posted fairly solid expansion during this quarter, which suggests that spending outside of DIY was roughly flat compared with a year earlier even with the pandemic, so given that, can you see at all how many of your end customers are taking care of their own yards to some extent while also hiring a professional?

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#37

Well, Alex, we'd have had far more visibility into that during the period when we were partners with TruGreen. Since that relationship no longer exists, our insight is nowhere near as strong. What I can say is that back then we could make those comparisons. When we examine sales broken out by geography. Take Florida — it was a terrific year for Scotts. TruGreen had one too, for instance. So as things stand, that's not something I can really address. But...

Thomas Coleman

executive
#38

I think most of it's Consumer gain, if not pro.

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#39

Take, for example, our home center channels, and ask yourself how much of that business was happening because a landscaper was hauling it around in the bed of a pickup truck. My sense is that you'd find considerably bigger gains over on the Consumer side.

Mike Lukemire

executive
#40

Absolutely, that's a fair point. What I mean is, folks weren't too keen on having others on their land, so it's a subject they feel strongly about. They preferred handling it on their own, and that's what I believe we're witnessing.

Alex Maroccia

analyst
#41

Thanks, that helps. One more thing — can you explain the thinking behind going with the special dividend instead of funding internal growth or using the capital some other way?

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#42

Sure. Chappell gave us credit for rambling, I guess. Essentially, we asked ourselves the question people usually raise: why take this approach? After looking at our equity, we felt it was valued about right, which pushed us toward returning cash through a special dividend. In the end, we just made the call because it seemed like the correct thing to do. For a while now, we've had conversations with a lot of folks — investors for whom I have real respect — and their feedback generally goes like this. They say the thing that bothers me about how you handle buybacks is that you buy hard when you're feeling good and your stock is high. Then later, once business turns weak and your share price falls apart, you'd rather pull back. What you ought to do is just give me the money and let me decide, since I've got a bit more nerve than you when it comes to buying during rough times. So because of all that, I think nobody was really leaning strongly one way or the other. A special was the route we decided on, and our feeling about it is positive. Also remember, yesterday there was a call with my family, and they asked what the future plans might look like. To the Street I want to say exactly what I told them: having reconfigured our businesses — TruGreen, with Scotts LawnService out and Europe out, while Hawthorne came in and live goods came in — our mode now is to pay down debt and then return to being shareholder friendly. This isn't a singular event when it comes to giving money back to our investors. Given where the share price stood, we concluded it made more sense to offer you a special distribution. Still, our goal is to keep providing returns to shareholders — the only thing left to figure out is the method — and whenever that chance comes up, we'll evaluate it then. That said, carrying on with this is our intention.

Thomas Coleman

executive
#43

Alex, here's the thing I'd mention — our free cash flow is landing above what we projected only a couple of months back. So roughly $400 million of, let's say, upside for this year, and we found ourselves facing a scenario where cash would sit on our balance sheet as we moved into July, August, September. So at first, we were thinking about taking some action in the fall, then we figured why hold off, let's just get it done rather than let cash sit idle, and paying down any form of debt capacity isn't really something we want to do; so that plays a big part in it. And if you go back and look at our share repurchases across the past, let's say, 5 years, these are rough figures I'm giving you, but we bought back roughly $800 million, and the typical share price came in near $90. So somewhere around there. So share repurchases are something we'll be doing once more. We won't be sitting around waiting for $90, I can promise you that.

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#44

Then the final piece of this is that, when Randy and I discussed how to weigh putting money into the business against returning it to shareholders, Randy landed on a view I fully share: doing both is genuinely possible for us. Neither area can be one we fail to reach, yet both are things we can manage; what you're watching today, I think, is that the amount Hawthorne asks for doesn't exceed what we're ready to give. And the Consumer business isn't asking us for more than we're giving either. So the business's investment needs are being met, and at the same time we're increasing the shareholder-friendly side; so right now, I'd say we feel things are fairly well balanced.

Eric Bosshard

analyst
#45

I have a single question, and then another one after that if we have a moment. It's a huge achievement that 8 million new consumers entered this category, regardless of how you choose to assess how '20 played out. Yet Jim, one thing I realize you've cared about for a long time is bringing additional people into the category. So here's what I want to ask: as you look ahead to '21 — my assumption is that in '20, they got involved in part since there was nothing else available to do. Looking at '21, with folks having a wider range of ways to spend their time, I'm wondering what your approach is, or what your main areas of emphasis are, to make sure they don't neglect their lawn and garden when other activities are available. How are you concentrating efforts to maintain their involvement?

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#46

Enormous. Enormous. Keeping that base of customers engaged as we head into '21 is our primary objective. I don't want to exploit this COVID situation in ways that feel wrong. I've experienced losing a child, so I understand that pain. Just a few weeks back, we lost someone on our team, only 34 years old with no pre-existing health issues. It's terrible. Yet considering how unevenly the U.S. has handled this, my own take is that autumn may land right in the middle of it, and folks will keep arriving. So I find myself thinking next spring's patterns probably won't look all that far off from what we've seen during this year. Oddly, and unfortunately, that works to our advantage, Eric. Looking ahead — we're putting in an enormous amount of effort, including everything we're doing alongside the intermedia, and we've restructured both our marketing groups and our advertising activities. When I mention advertising, I mean something broader—it's really about communications. Those players have virtually limitless resources to do whatever's necessary to hold onto their customers. And I realize the retailers are looking to accomplish the same thing. Meanwhile, our online and direct operations keep performing pretty well too. What I believe is propelling us forward is the fact that '22 will be the fascinating year. That's essentially where we're arriving—everyone, I think, is wishing that this will be finished by the time the '22 season arrives. Still, I'd say the '21 season is shaping up acceptably for us, though keeping those customers will be the primary emphasis. Plus, they truly lack the funds for that kind of thing. Looking back, what we accomplished during this year happened largely on the fly. Consider the sheer volume of material — my guess is you're talking about tens of thousands of individual content items getting made. When we couldn't book talent, that's how a great deal of it got handled. On the visual side, we wound up pulling from stock footage libraries; the whole thing would be assembled overnight — essentially, once we determined a piece was needed, it had to be finished within that single evening, and those creative people would work straight through until dawn so that something could be ready to broadcast about a day later. My sense is that'll get simpler down the road, but at that point we were basically figuring this stuff out as we went. Honestly, I'm painting a somewhat hopeful picture here, yet until recently I wasn't much of a convert to digital at all. Now it feels like it's absolutely central, and that isn't because we're handling it foolishly — I just believe there's a lot of room to do it far better; plus I think we've got an excellent partner in <<inaudible>>. Our teams have genuinely built themselves around this. Randy believes in it, and so does Mike. So my hope is that when we sit down for this same discussion a year from now, we'll be able to tell you that we not only held onto that group, but also managed to sell more, and that we avoided losing sales due to an inability to deliver; and that Hawthorne performs above high-single digits — that's my hope. Still, I believe we have plenty to demonstrate to the consumer goods community at large: that we're pursuing a fresh way of marketing our products, one that lawn and gardening is especially well suited to.

Thomas Coleman

executive
#47

Eric, I want to mention that we have clarity on who our consumers are, and our efforts are aimed right at them. We aren't cutting corners on cost, which means a significant amount of money is going toward this push. Beyond what we're doing on social media, we just created a fresh TV commercial, and it aired for the very first time during the opening baseball game that took place last week, appearing fairly soon after play began. That ad has a decent run time. If you happen to see it, and if it fails to stir an emotional reaction among viewers, then people pressed even harder, since it truly captures the essence of our mission, which centers more on lifestyle and on folks being with their families out in the yards, and personally I found it outstanding.

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#48

We are observing a growing number of folks engaging more deeply, during autumn and with gardening. They want that second harvest. Their AeroGarden has gone up tremendously. We witness that momentum from a 365; and then many individuals are relocating away from urban areas toward the suburbs, which represents a massive chance for lawn and garden. So those trends, in my view, we need to take advantage of them. That is where our level of skill at doing so is going to be what decides things.

Eric Bosshard

analyst
#49

All right, and I've got one more question. You came across as hopeful regarding pricing in the coming year. What I want to know is whether anything might get in the way of that, given that it seems your home centers gave up share during this year, and they'll be looking to bring customers in. How do you reconcile those two things — that your price can rise while theirs appears set to fall? And I realize perhaps the reverse occurred this year. Still, I'd like to hear your thinking.

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#50

How do I see it? Pricing is what we're after. And — but being candid, it's a battle this year. And I'd say for fairly sensible — there are retailers out there. A few of the largest retailers on earth who'd tell you, man, unemployment is everywhere, you folks are raking it in, your results are absurdly strong. Seriously, you're asking for pricing? But we have plenty of work ahead to move comp numbers; and so do they. So we also see it as — somewhat lopsided, given how little promotion there's been, and the impact that's had not so much on our margins, but on theirs, which I don't believe — because when you look at consumer price, consumer price has likely risen 10%. I'm not certain, roughly that much this year. We believe aiming for 100 to 200 basis points in pricing isn't out of line. Still, there's definitely pushback. We'll get that pricing, though I think it means Mike and I have to show up in person to explain our approach and how tough the comparison is this year—which, again, nobody should think it's impossible. I'm not saying it can't happen. That said, it's a big ask, and I think we've got a clear plan. So we will continue putting capital into the company so that we can serve as a stronger supplier, achieve improved satisfaction levels, and fund our brands. I'll share something Randy said to me roughly three years back, right as a budget meeting wrapped up — he asked why so much of our spending went toward promotion while marketing got far less, and told me that didn't strike him as playing to what makes our brands strong. Randy had a point, in my view, and we're working to get retailers on board with that thinking as well. They aren't in a place where they're totally receptive to our pushing for price changes, despite what I believe was genuine support we provided to the sector over this year. Mike, is there anything else you'd like to say about that?

Mike Lukemire

executive
#51

No, I'd say it's — every single one involves a conversation and a struggle to land on the correct place for...

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#52

Even so, Eric, we were managing to secure the pricing. The thing is, it just means we have to engage one-on-one to push it higher.

Jim King

executive
#53

Alright Steven, we'll stop here. I realize quite a few folks were waiting in line whom we couldn't reach. So please don't hesitate to contact me personally at (937) 578 to 5622. If not, the next public update we have planned is set, tentatively, for November 4, at which point we'll present results for the full year along with a more detailed outlook for 2021. Appreciate your time with us. Everyone, have a wonderful day.

Operator

operator
#54

This concludes today's call. Thank you for your participation. You may now disconnect.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.