The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company (SMG) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
November 4, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Jim King
executiveThanks, operator. Morning, everybody, and thanks for joining us for Scotts Miracle-Gro's Q4 earnings call. We're changing up how we run today's session, so here's what to expect. Joining me are Jim Hagedorn, our CEO; Randy Coleman, our CFO; Mike Lukemire, our President and Chief Operating Officer; Josh Peoples, our Chief Marketing Officer; and Chris Hagedorn, General Manager of Hawthorne. There's plenty on the agenda today. Randy will walk through the financials and give some clarity on the guidance we laid out in this morning's press release. Jim, Josh, and Chris will offer their perspectives, mainly on the opportunity ahead of us in fiscal 2021. After that, we'll take your questions. I'd respectfully ask that everyone in the Q&A limit themselves to one question and one follow-up. I'm happy to arrange time later today or tomorrow for anyone with more questions. I want to remind everyone that forward-looking statements will be made this morning, so actual results could differ materially because of a variety of risk factors. Those risks are highlighted in this morning's press release and explained more extensively in our Form 10-K, which is filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission. I also want to remind you that this call is being recorded. An archived version will be made available on our website, investor.scotts.com. So with that, let's get going, and I'll now hand things over to Jim Hagedorn for some opening remarks. Jim?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveThank you, Jim, and hello to everyone on the line this morning. As our release showed, we wrapped up a record-breaking 2020 with a solid fourth-quarter performance across every part of the business. Growth appeared in each category of the U.S. consumer business as well as Hawthorne, for both the quarter and the entire year. This morning we also shared our intention to raise the 25% financial interest we currently hold in Bonnie Plants by forming a 50/50 joint venture with its present owner, Alabama Farmers Co-op. Please don't let that announcement get buried beneath the coverage of our 2020 financial results and our guidance for the coming year; in our view, live goods represent a vital piece of the long-term strategy, and deepening our stake in Bonnie is the correct first step. I'll say more about that later on. I realize most of you would like to concentrate today on what fiscal 2021 holds. Honestly, that's where our attention sits too, and it's where I plan to devote the bulk of my time. Our EPS guidance, which points to 10%-16% growth in 2021, shows that we're entering the year from a position of strength. We're doing things a bit differently this morning so that my remarks land with better context. I'll hand the call to Randy at this point. He will cover several 2020 highlights and give you some specifics behind our fiscal 2021 outlook. Then I'll return and use what's left of my time alongside a few of my colleagues, so you can get a clearer picture of where we intend to take this business as fiscal 2021 begins.
Randy Coleman
executiveAppreciate that, Jim, and good morning to all of you. As everyone is aware, we basically put out our 2020 results ahead of schedule several weeks ago, when we indicated we anticipated closing the year at roughly $7.25 per share. Because of the thorough updates we provided earlier in the year, I'm not going to take you through the P&L line by line on this call the way I typically would. That said, I do want to offer a handful of reflections and call attention to certain important items. Beginning with sales, throughout my 22 years with this company, I have never witnessed the kind of expansion we saw during Q4. Within the consumer segment, point-of-sale gains reached 38% for the quarter. As Jim mentioned, that improvement showed up across the board. Something else was going on as well, however: retailers were attempting to restock inventory that had been drawn down, and that's what produced the 90% jump in shipments. We closed out the year with retail inventory sitting roughly 15% above where it stood 12 months earlier, with customers also continuing to purchase heavily through October and making plans for a sizable early spring. For the entire year, U.S. consumer sales climbed 24%, powered by POS expansion of a comparable figure. Gardening served as the primary engine, generating a 45% gain in consumer purchases of branded soils along with 30% in plant food. Insect control products rose 51%, weed control advanced 16%, grass seed climbed 31%, and lawn fertilizer was up 11%. Over at Hawthorne, the narrative was largely unchanged from what it has been. Chris will walk through some of those specifics shortly, so I won't get into them at this moment. What I can say is that September became the biggest sales month Hawthorne has ever recorded, and it was heartening to see Hawthorne convert better-than-expected annual growth into better-than-expected profitability rates as well. On the gross margin line, Hawthorne gained 240 basis points thanks to fixed cost leverage, a favorable brand mix, and pricing. Hawthorne's segment margin rose roughly 300 basis points, reaching 11% for the full year. That came in above what we had initially anticipated and, even more significantly, keeps us positioned to hit a segment margin target of 15% within the next few years. The U.S. consumer business delivered an 80 basis point lift in gross margin rate, driven largely by the same factors that pushed Hawthorne's rate upward. You will observe, however, that the rate across the whole company is higher by just 50 basis points. That reflects the quicker expansion at Hawthorne, where the gross margin rate overall sits approximately 10 percentage points beneath the corporate average. Even so, we couldn't be more pleased with the results we achieved. SG&A rose 47% during the quarter and 26% across the full year. Variable compensation represented the largest contributor, coming in at roughly $80 million above the prior year. SG&A also rose because of media, marketing, selling, long-term comp, and charitable giving. Interest expense got a boost from reduced debt levels and lower interest rates, finishing $5 million lower in Q4 and $22 million lower across the full year. We closed out the year with leverage sitting at 2.5 times average net debt to EBITDA; that's roughly a full turn beneath our target leverage and 2 turns below the ceiling our debt covenants allow. As we head into 2021, we have tremendous flexibility to put money into the business while also giving more cash back to shareholders. If I turn to cash flow briefly, you might remember my comments following Q3 — that free cash flow for the year would land near $400 million since we intended to build inventory. What happened instead was that product shipped out the door the moment we made it, as retailers sought to restock their own depleted supplies. Free cash flow ended up roughly $100 million above $495 million, which means there's still work ahead of us when it comes to building inventory next year. I'm happy to take any question regarding Q4 or our full-year results, though I suspect there aren't many surprises in what we released today. I'd like to give some specifics on our 2021 guidance and set things up for Jim to walk through our outlook from a more strategic angle; being transparent with shareholders has always been something we take pride in, so let me begin there. We anticipate enormous sales growth in Q1 across both major segments, with growth rates comparable to Q4 and likely even greater. Through Q2, we'll also likely be running well ahead of our full-year target, given how much momentum U.S. retailer plans have for a big spring. That said, past Q2 our visibility is far less clear, for obvious reasons. On top of that, our Q3 and Q4 comps are enormous. To illustrate, Hawthorne's second half growth in fiscal 2020 reached 69%, and between May and September, our POS comp in the U.S. consumer business hit 43%. As Jim and Josh Peoples will tell you, we think full-year growth in the U.S. consumer business remains achievable despite that reality. I'll let them lay out the reasoning. Were we to just keep the U.S. consumer number flat while Hawthorne expands at 20%, we'd anticipate earning approximately $8.40 per share. If the U.S. business fell by 5 points while Hawthorne grew to 15%, earnings would come to about $8 a share, which would represent a double-digit gain over 2020. At present we see gross margins falling approximately 50 basis points, which differs from what I said in our latest public remarks about 2 months back. Once we finalized our plans for the year, though, it became evident that we must boost our investment in warehousing for both businesses to bring inventory levels up to where we want them. Like other companies, in recent weeks we're beginning to see the possibility of greater commodity pressure, particularly from resin. The total company rate decline presumes roughly flat rates in both businesses, but a negative hit from segment mix, in line with what occurred in 2020 amid Hawthorne's dramatic sales growth. Also, keep in mind that we've got hedges in place on the main commodities we use — urea, fuel, and resin — covering roughly 65%, which is in line with what we've typically done historically. SG&A is probably going to come down somewhere between 6% and 11%. Built into our guidance is an assumption that variable compensation will run around $80 million less for the year, though a portion of that will be given back through a bigger planned spend on marketing and our direct-to-consumer initiatives. On free cash flow — which we define as operating cash flow less capital expenditures — we're looking at approximately $325 million; we also anticipate CapEx stepping up in fiscal 2021 to somewhere near $100 million, and possibly above that. My expectation is that working capital will end up consuming cash this year as we push inventory levels back up to where we'd like them to be. And lastly, because of how 2020 turned out, we'll be writing considerably bigger bonus checks, which is yet another cash drag heading into 2021. As you've already heard from a number of other companies, giving guidance in this kind of environment is difficult. Our inclination is to keep offering a range of outcomes we consider probable, but that's no simple task. In fact, one could make the case that 2021 may end up being even more turbulent than 2020 was. You'll see that our EPS guidance range is broader this year, which reflects that uncertainty as well as the reality that our earnings base sits much higher than it has historically. Let me remind everybody that adjusted EPS came in at $4.47 in 2019. The bottom end of our fiscal 2021 range implies an earnings increase of about 80% and $800 million in free cash flow across a two-year span. In fact, since Project Focus kicked off in December 2015, total shareholder return is up roughly 160%, and we've produced more than $1.5 billion in cumulative free cash flow. Turning to our Bonnie announcement — we aren't yet factoring earnings from that transaction into our guidance, but we'll bring you up to date once the deal has closed. The extra investment in the nature of our LJV is going to create a different P&L geography than what we've had in the past, and we'll make that clear when the appropriate time arrives. Over the remainder of this call, you'll hear from Jim and members of the operating team about how we're pushing to do even better. Should that turn out to be the case, we'll revise our guidance. Right now, attempting to predict the timing and effect of global events on our business simply isn't possible. Even so, assuming our present P&L estimates hold true, it will mark yet another year of record results for our shareholders. With that, Jim, I'll hand it back to you.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveThank you, Randy. Before I add to what Randy said, I'd like to share a few thoughts of my own regarding why I think our company sits in such a strong position at this moment — and that has little to do with COVID-19 or the shifts it caused in how consumers behave. On our call for the second quarter, I mentioned a saying posted above the doorway to my office, one I picked up from my father: luck is what happens where preparation and opportunity meet. It was five years ago that we started transforming this company through an initiative known as Project Focus; we sold off operations we felt could not deliver value to shareholders. We put money into new categories with faster growth rates, including brands such as Tomcat and Bonnie Plants. On top of that, we put money into a completely new operation by building Hawthorne. Hawthorne has just passed the billion-dollar mark in sales, and we've started beating the financial goals from our business plan when we set out on this journey. It has become, in short order, an operation essential to what lies ahead for us. What gets missed far too often, though, is the other benefit of Project Focus: the improvements we made to our core U.S. consumer segment; we committed ourselves to keeping our brands relevant in a marketplace that evolves quickly. Absent that work, this year's outcome could never have happened. We rethought how we handle R&D, and that soon produced, one right after another, the best new product introductions we've ever had: Miracle-Gro Performance Organics, Scotts Turf Builder Triple Action, and Ortho GroundClear. Every one of those was a home run. We started revamping the way we approach marketing. Our brand spending is up 40% across the last two years. We also added new agency partners to the mix, helping us rethink how we connect with consumers. Project Focus was all about effort and readiness, and fiscal 2020 gave us the chance to make the most of that readiness. We did that, and beyond it, we put ourselves in position to keep winning. Looking ahead to fiscal 2021, we see additional work ahead and additional growth to seize. Though we're still bullish on our strategy and what's coming, we're setting expectations prudently. On the previous call, I said I'd be content if we merely preserved the growth of our U.S. consumer business and safeguarded our margins, and I still feel that way. What really matters is whether we can outperform that. To put it plainly, do we think the consumer business can expand in 2021? Yes, we do. That's what our marketers think. That's what our sales force thinks. Our direct-to-consumer team thinks so, and so do our retail partners. We'll give all of them incentives to produce that growth. As we showed all through 2020, we know how to push toward stronger sales, and we'll be ready to do that when we determine they're within reach. There are sound reasons behind this optimism. To begin with, the momentum we witnessed during the year's second half hasn't decelerated yet. We're also aware that we missed out on sales during the past two quarters — roughly $200 million across U.S. consumer and Hawthorne combined — simply because we couldn't keep pace. The competitive situation in retail could prove intriguing as well. Our expectation is that smaller national retail partners will battle aggressively next season to hold onto the market share they picked up in 2020. Meanwhile, some of our bigger retail partners will likely ramp up promotional efforts in 2021 to win that share back. Keep in mind that, owing to COVID, these larger accounts had limited ability to draw foot traffic into their stores during March, April, and the first half of May. We remain optimistic, though there's no justification to raise guidance at this point. Exactly as we did all through 2020, we'll be as transparent as we can once we gain better clarity, and we'll revise guidance when and if that becomes necessary. We aren't attempting to be evasive. We're just telling the truth. Half a year ago, I could never have foreseen the world's current condition. Although we have decent visibility over the coming months, I'm skeptical of anyone claiming they can foresee what the world will look like come next spring and summer. That creates a huge divide between what's achievable in 2021 and what's probable. I'll say that our macro outlook matches that of numerous other CPG companies; we think the U.S. economy will stay sluggish across the next several quarters, and most consumers will remain in nesting mode next year; that ought to actually benefit our consumer business. Let me be clear regarding my objective for the consumer business in fiscal 2021, and this message is aimed at our long-term shareholders. I won't measure success this year merely by whether we grow. A more significant long-term mission exists here, and that's where the focus belongs. Millions of next-generation consumers knocked on our door in 2020. I'm mainly referring to millennials, the biggest generation in American history, who are currently becoming homeowners and gardeners. The aim isn't just to appreciate their company during a brief visit, but to retain them for the remainder of their lives. We'll invest significantly to forge the strongest consumer relationship we've ever had. If growth also comes in 2021, wonderful. If we slip back somewhat and still hold onto most of these new consumers, I can accept that as well. Achieving that goal is now a task resting with our new Chief Marketing Officer, Josh Peoples. Josh has spent over 20 years here. He rose from a junior marketeer to lead our lawns business and supervise the efforts of all the brand teams. In my time here, he stands out as one of the most reflective and analytical marketing professionals we've ever had. It's fortunate that we've kept him around for as long as we have, and I have no doubt that as CMO, he's the ideal individual at the ideal moment. Josh?
Josh Peoples
executiveGood morning, everyone. As Jim just mentioned, I've been at Scotts Miracle-Gro for 20 years now in a variety of marketing roles. I believe I've got a good sense of our business, and more importantly, the needs of our consumers. The one thing I've learned for certain over the past two decades is that lawn and garden consumers are different than in other categories. There is an emotional element to this space that is truly unique. Gardening is a form of self-expression that can be deeply personal. Understanding how to tap into that emotion, which by the way, is different for every consumer, is the most critical element between growing and standing still. What we've all learned more recently is that we need to take a different approach if we're going to tap into that emotion and strengthen our relationship with consumers. We can't talk about ourselves and our products like we used to. Our messages have to be focused on consumers, not us. As Jim said, we had tremendous success bringing new people into the category in 2020. About 30% of participants in edible gardening were new or lapsed users; we estimate about 8 million more people participated in lawn care than in 2019; we not only believe we can keep most of these new users engaged, but bring even more people into the space. Demographics will continue to help us. Millennial homeownership will continue to swell in 2021 and the years that follow. Our research indicates this group is more interested in lawn and garden activity than their parents and equally accepting of our brands. Jim mentioned the importance of innovation. I couldn't agree more. Our new product strategy has to be driven by consumer needs while being rooted in science. It's not sustainable the other way around. All of the products Jim mentioned, Performance Organics, Triple Action, Ground Clear, speak to the lifestyle of the millennial consumer. They have a great environmental profile and are easy to use; they also happen to deliver outstanding results. The most important innovation for us will be how we communicate. We were forced to throw out most of our marketing plans at the break of the 2020 season and work on the fly; we learned a lot from that experience and got smarter about what works. We enter fiscal 2021 following these three principles. First, to be creative-led. Second, to be always on. Third, to be data-driven. As we saw this past season, none of these focus areas exist in a vacuum. They exist together. As recently as just a few years ago, we would have taken months to produce a single TV commercial and ensured that everything was focus group tested; we also would have relied on just 15 or 20 creative assets to support the season. That's not what we're doing today. Instead, we're developing new creative approaches literally every day and creating thousands of them, not dozens in the process. So we're picking things up and evolving daily. Feedback comes in live, showing us what clicks with shoppers, so we're pouring more resources into the winners and cutting loose the losers fast. The key thing is, we aren't cutting corners on quality. Actually, it's gotten better. Looking at 2021, I'd anticipate more than 75% of our ad budget going toward digital, which lets us zero in on the right audience far more effectively. We'll be better equipped to vary our creative so it speaks to various groups and what they care about. Take a millennial pair, for instance, in the same home, tending the same garden—they might get two completely distinct versions, each shaped by what they do online or what they're into, whether that's cooking, hosting, or decorating. Folks in Chicago will probably get different ads than those in San Francisco, Dallas, or Boston. Our timing has gotten sharper as well. When the forecast looks nice in a particular city, we'll go all in to make the most of the weekend. If rain's on the way, we'll ease off. When a retailer runs a promo we want to back, we can zero in on the precise audience likely to bite; we've seen this method pay off. It shows up in our metrics and outcomes. Our retail partners notice it as well. That's the reason we'll collaborate with every one of them in 2021 to boost store visits and category expansion, while also powering e-commerce sales. You'll notice us expanding our lineup of digital-first brands not available in stores, such as Lunarly, Knock Knock, Bark Yard, and Green Digs. You'll also spot a bigger emphasis on indoor gardening and live goods. I'm certain our marketing is hitting harder right now than at any point since I came aboard, and I'm sure about our strategies for the 2021 season. I share Jim's view on the chance we have in 2021. There's a huge opening to position our company for many years of growth ahead; we aren't fretting over tough comparisons or things outside our influence. We're zeroing in on what we can affect, and I'm sure the moves we make in 2021 will pay off for Scotts Miracle-Gro well into the future. Jim, I'll hand it back over to you.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAppreciate that, Josh. Before we move on to Hawthorne, one final item. As I noted previously, in recent days we put our signature on a letter of intent to pick up a 50% equity stake in Bonnie Plants; that fits within a proposed JV alongside Alabama Farmers Co-op. Many of you are aware that live goods excite me greatly; Mike Lukemire feels the same way. That's the engine behind the category. Take away the plant, and gardening doesn't exist. When Project Focus was announced, I stated my desire for Scotts Miracle-Gro to transform from a gardening products company into a true gardening company, and edible gardening represents the ideal arena for that transformation. That's why raising our stake in Bonnie became such a clear call. Much like us, they've spent generations in this business. Within the space, they hold the single most powerful brand, plus an exceptional relationship with retailers, and consumers adore them. Josh brought up the emotional component of lawn and garden. Nowhere does that show up more clearly than here. Buying fertilizer and growing media is a fairly pedestrian experience, and honestly, not very inspiring. Grab a bag, drop it in the cart, bring it home, spread it on the lawn or garden. When it comes to edible plants, we're talking tomatoes, peppers, leafy greens, basil, rosemary, and a variety of other herbs and vegetables, consumers engage in a completely different manner. The shopping experience differs, it's more engaging. They linger far longer at the shelf hunting for the perfect plant; they become invested in the purchase process, and afterward they head home, and they nurture a plant that will put food on the table for their families. There's an emotional connection available to us in this category, a level of trust that matters critically. We know that connection runs especially deep with millennials, which is precisely what makes Bonnie such an important strategic fit. My belief is that our involvement with Bonnie over the past several years has benefited both companies, and I doubt they'd tell you otherwise; as it happens, Mike Sutterer, one of our former operators here, now serves as CEO of Bonnie. He grasps our vision and our goals, and we regard him as an outstanding operator. This has the makings of a great partnership and is critical to our long-term success. We won't cover too many details today since we remain several weeks away from actually completing the deal, but expect to hear more from us in the quarters ahead. I now want to switch gears and talk about Hawthorne. As I said earlier, we see double-digit growth as a real likelihood again next year. We have some good tailwinds in the near term and see the long-term outlook to be strong as well. Rather than going into the details myself, let me turn things over to Chris Hagedorn for a few minutes to share his view.
Chris Hagedorn
executiveHello, everyone. This is Chris. To kick things off, I'll just say that 2020 was clearly an enormous year. Getting past the billion-dollar threshold mattered a lot to the team. It felt even sweeter because we knew we hadn't needed to do anything outlandish to reach that figure. To be honest, my sense is that we could have tacked on roughly another $100 million in revenue during this year. At certain points our supply chain was under so much strain that we ended up leaving some money on the table. We've been putting money into investments so those kinds of pressures won't come back down the road. Looking at 2020, it was a fantastic story in every respect. In our North American hydro business, we doubled our lighting business over the course of the year, powered by roughly $100 million of LED lights; two years ago this category didn't exist for us at all, and it appears we underestimated just how big it would become. LED sales came in more than 100% above what we had expected when the year began, and at this moment we're selling our fixtures as quickly as we can produce them. In North America, consumables posted 49% growth in nutrients and 64% in growing media. When you break it down geographically, growth showed up in literally every market. California, which is our single largest market, rose 78%, while newer markets such as Michigan and Oklahoma climbed 133% and 203% respectively. I'd also like to recognize the team, since we closed out the year with a second margin of 11%. My expectation is that figure will rise once more next year; we're doing well at balancing growth, market share, and better profitability. A few of you asked during the previous call whether too much inventory in the channel or some level of overcapacity worries us. At the moment we aren't seeing any indication of that. As a matter of fact, we anticipate the growth rate in the first quarter of 2021 will resemble closely what we saw in Q4. There's also solid reason for optimism in Q2. Later in the year, however, forecasting becomes somewhat less predictable, and clearly the comps we'll be up against in the second half will be difficult. The head start we've got should let us hit the 15%-20% growth that Jim mentioned earlier. The other piece of great news for Hawthorne is what we anticipate from yesterday's election. Look, votes are still being counted. I don't want to get ahead of myself; we expect New Jersey to approve recreational adult use of cannabis, and Arizona has a good chance of doing the same. Ahead of the election, polling also looked good in South Dakota, Montana, and Mississippi. Beyond that, the governors of New York and Pennsylvania have stated in recent weeks that they'll pursue legalization to help cover some of the budget deficits brought about by COVID-related issues. Who knows what will happen in D.C.? Our confidence keeps growing that the federal rules will shift too, even though that probably takes longer. What this year has made more obvious than at any point is that we created something quite remarkable at Hawthorne. It's tough not to be encouraged about what lies ahead, both soon and far off. Let me be upfront, everyone: this industry has had its highs and lows across the last few years, and we aren't assuming anything is guaranteed. Without question, we hold the top product line in the industry, plus the finest service and supply chain, even given the obstacles we faced this year. Earlier this month, we at last launched our R&D facility in British Columbia, the world's first of its type. Once we merge the cannabis cultivation efforts happening there with the hemp R&D we're already conducting in the U.S., I can say with confidence that we'll likewise own the strongest innovation program in the industry. Next year's prospects look quite favorable for Hawthorne, and we're eager to keep everyone informed as the year takes shape; so with that, Jim, I'll give it back to you.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAppreciate that, Chris. A final point regarding Hawthorne. The team there has accomplished an incredible amount, bringing the business to the level we always believed was achievable. They've firmly cemented their position as an industry frontrunner, and they've demonstrated they can handle intricate situations — like rolling out SAP during this year. I'd like to offer my congratulations for all they've achieved in such a brief window. As we wrap up, there's one more item I'd like to mention. Nobody could have foreseen what 2020 would bring, and I would be failing in my duty if I didn't pause to express gratitude to our associates. Let me begin with the field sales force, along with the people in manufacturing and distribution. When COVID struck, these individuals never had the option of doing their jobs from home; they continued showing up at work daily, and it would be untruthful of me not to recognize that they jeopardized their own well-being and that of their loved ones for this company; we gave them premium pay along with bonuses and extra 401(k) contributions. Any decent company would do the same. I doubt we could ever express enough appreciation to them. What I've witnessed this year has been truly inspiring, and I feel humbled to be starting my 20th year as CEO of this organization. Saying I've never been more confident about our position may sound like a cliché, but I mean it sincerely. We're currently bringing an entirely new generation of consumers into our core business. With Hawthorne, we're experiencing ongoing success in a rapidly expanding category. A multi-year streak has rewarded our shareholders, enabling us to more than double this company's worth across the five years that followed the launch of Project Focus. We can't predict precisely what fiscal 2021 will bring, yet one thing I'm certain of is that the right team is in place to handle whatever comes our way. With that said, I'll open the line for your questions.
Joe Altobello
analystThank you. Hi, everyone. Morning. I'd like to revisit those approximately 8 million new lawn customers that were brought in during the last year. When you look at the top end of your guidance, does it presume you retain essentially all 8 million this year? This might be one for Josh, if he's still available. In a stretch when they'll probably face greater competition for their weekend hours, not merely from promotions, is there a method to aim at those 8 million customers so they stay in the category? It seems you have a general idea of where they reside — do you actually have knowledge of who they are, allowing you to target market them digitally? Thanks.
Josh Peoples
executiveHi, good morning. Excellent question. Yes, at this moment the objective remains not just keeping, I'd say, those eight million, but frankly, attempting to attract still more as we move through 2021. Much of the consumer feedback we received — despite the fact that time might grow scarcer — was that they truly discovered lawn and garden as a passion area they had not genuinely explored or had not believed could exist. We feel quite confident about both knowing their locations and their identities, and I believe this is precisely where collaborating with our retail partners matters, to keep them involved and connect with them through fresh and distinctive approaches, and to keep expanding on what we accomplished during 2020.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveI suppose I'd push back a little and admit that I'm taken aback lawn revenue wasn't stronger. Joe, obviously a great deal of gardening activity sort of set the pace during this year, and I believe we've picked up sufficient knowledge that we should expect comparable expansion from turf care. Our offerings, I believe, are getting better. My sense is we'll have considerably greater promotional backing in the coming year, no matter what happens with COVID, short of a total lockdown. Retailers, I suspect, probably won't be as cautious as they turned out to be over the last year, and therefore I expect significantly more collaboration and far less hesitancy regarding drawing shoppers inside their locations. I'd be pressing the marketing team to outperform what they achieved with lawns and to match the pace set by the gardens folks.
Joe Altobello
analystThat's a reasonable pushback, I appreciate it.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveJoe, how's it going? Stay safe out there.
Joe Altobello
analystNo, that's right. Thank you. And then just one more for Chris, if I may. When you consider Hawthorne in this year, the original forecast was a rise of 12%-15%. You achieved 61%, which is a modest beat, I imagine. Could you give more background on that growth above 60%, how much came from the market? What portion was from picking up market share? And perhaps your outlook for 2021.
Chris Hagedorn
executiveThanks, Joe. That's a good question. Yeah. As you've heard regarding our 2021 expectations, we anticipate continued general market expansion, and we definitely plan to keep gaining share. To attempt to put numbers on the gains this year, we believe there's likely a strong 20% rise in consumer cannabis usage, and that's mostly anecdotal, though we do get it from data sources we have access to. It really appears that stay-at-home orders and similar factors did boost the typical high single-digit usage increases we observe in an ordinary year. We'd credit the remainder of our growth to share gains, though mostly powered by our capacity to keep providing a fairly high service level; we definitely faced our own difficulties this year, but I think our rivals dealt with even bigger ones. I have to give enormous credit to our innovation team; we introduced some truly fantastic products this year. The LED light we brought out under Gavita was the largest single product launch in SMG history, not only Hawthorne, but the whole enterprise. For that, I think I definitely have to give a lot of credit for our performance this year.
Joe Altobello
analystUnderstood. Excellent. Thanks, everyone.
Bill Chappell
analystAppreciate it. Morning, all. Circling back to Hawthorne, I'm just attempting to grasp — it's a comparable question — exactly how difficult those comparisons truly are, and what level of visibility you actually had. Chris, my recollection is you mentioned feeling that $100 million had been left on the table. By this point, I'd imagine you possess some sense — tell me if I've got this wrong — of the way states move forward after they legalize medicinal, and afterward recreational, and then money begins flowing in. Is the comparison genuinely that brutal? I realize March, with that sort of spike, was, but walk me through how the year actually unfolds, particularly the back half, once those states arrive and, as you put it, you did leave $100 million on the table.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveRight. Wow. Let me add a bit of a spin here, Bill. My sense is this is a year where, truthfully, and I believe we've been hinting rather forcefully during the recorded section of the script, there's this sort of gap between what we hope — and I think, drawing on our understanding of the business, both what consumers will do and what Hawthorne will do and what live goods will do — versus what we're sort of committing to inside the range. That fuels a — I believe diversity was a word used somewhere in the script, possibly by Randy — a range of perspectives on what we think might happen, what we'd like to happen. Those figures, the operating figures, differ quite a bit, frankly; we simply don't believe we're able to commit to that. I'd request that everyone listening bear with us on this. I don't think we can state it any more plainly that we're attempting to play it safe here. I know further discussions with all of you about this are coming. I think until — at minimum on the consumer side, where consumer takeaway exists, so let's say next spring — I think you'll keep witnessing, I'm not sure which word Randy chose, gigantic, enormous, ginormous, something resembling the growth rate we witnessed in Q4 and Q1. Q2 likely won't be quite as ginormous as that, yet they'll be fairly large numbers, I think, which will push you folks to sort of suspect we're sandbagging, or this entire believability factor. The hints we're attempting to lay let you folks sort of connect the dots. When you ask Chris, why don't you think you can outperform that? It's rather difficult to answer, since we do think we can outperform that. We're simply not committing to it, whether on the consumer business or the Hawthorne business. Chris can field the question. I'm not entirely sure how, but he can attempt to talk everyone down and talk himself down. Keep in mind that Mike’s operating plans differ from what we’re discussing here, though they do sit inside the overall set of expectations. We’re attempting to push this idea where the consumer side might decline by 5, Hawthorne might climb by 15, and even then we clear $8. Right? From that point you go forward, and the leverage builds quite quickly. Yesterday we held a board meeting, and I believe we more or less settled the budget and the incentive targets for the coming year. I’d say they aren’t too demanding, but they pay off well if genuinely great outcomes occur, and they’re reasonable if we land near the bottom of the range and nothing awful occurs. I genuinely think that’s roughly the situation we face. When someone asks you to justify your low figure, that’s fairly difficult to do. It simply means nobody has the answer, and nobody anticipated something like growth above 60% within one year. Chris, I don’t know—how would you respond to that question?
Chris Hagedorn
executiveOkay, so having said all of that — and being realistic about it — internally, yes, I'm absolutely pushing the team toward a bigger, more aggressive figure than what we've got baked into the building. As Jim mentioned, the second half of the year we just wrapped up was something nobody in this industry, I think, has ever witnessed. Believing we can replicate that — it's definitely tough. Now, those prepared comments at the start of the call were taped earlier this week. At this point we've seen how the election turned out. We've seen how people cast their ballots on cannabis measures, and the support was overwhelmingly positive everywhere. We do anticipate some incremental business coming from what went down in states including New Jersey and Arizona and others; that said, none of this is going to flip overnight. What we've observed is that there's usually a 12 to 18 month gap between a state legalizing and any real uptick in business for us. I wouldn't anticipate a meaningful amount of business from those votes during this fiscal year. It appears that will likely be more of a 2022 uptick for us.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAlright, so I want to bring something up — while we were examining and attempting to break down the lighting revenue figures, and I could be a touch off here, but Chris, feel free to set me straight. Those high-pressure sodium fixtures, the HPS ones, basically the old-school type that run hot and so on — my belief is they climbed 50%. Obviously, the LED innovation delivered a massive win for us, and we're asking ourselves, "Where did that business go?" My sense is that in states moving toward legalization, you're witnessing build-outs happening, which in my view tend to run ahead of the actual market, and I believe that's a positive thing for us. You've probably heard me bring up — and I'm an enormous admirer of New Jersey's Senator Sweeney, who essentially drove that effort. My take is he couldn't get New Jersey across the finish line through legislation, and he basically gave up in frustration. This fellow is like an ironworker, alright? A big labor union guy, and among the handful of people whose language is even cruder than my own. He genuinely envisions New Jersey as a key hub of excellence for cultivation, and the Garden State carries real meaning for him. I really do believe you'll probably witness build-out taking place because, once more, when we consider where those lights are headed, and you point out that some folks are simply upgrading their lights and switching to LEDs, still a substantial amount of build-out is happening there. In my view, that build-out takes place ahead of the market, just as you would anticipate.
Randy Coleman
executiveJim, the single point I would tack on is this: when we examine how our light sales went this year — and everyone's aware that roughly 50% of what we sell comes from California — lights enjoyed a phenomenal year. Relative to the remainder of the nation, we over-indexed in California. Given that California is a mature market, our capacity to over-index tells me plenty of renovation and replacement activity is underway, and that bodes quite well over the long haul as well.
Bill Chappell
analystThanks — appreciate the color on that. First, I'll aim to move faster through the second item. Regarding your U.S. consumer guidance, Randy, correct me if my math is off. Take the bottom end of your range — call it a 5% decline for 2021 — that still implies revenue climbing 17% or 18% above where it stood in 2019. Could you walk us through the bridge there? My read is roughly five points across that two-year stretch comes from price, while 12 points come from volume, which basically presumes a normalized category growth rate of about 6% over those two years. Is that the proper way to frame it?
Randy Coleman
executiveBill, let me build that bridge quarter by quarter, then split it into first half and second half. Q1, as we've discussed, will be enormous. Growth rates will show up across the whole company, the U.S. among them, and it should resemble what Q4 looked like. We remain quite confident heading into Q2 — retailers will be stocking up, consumers should stay engaged, and we anticipate POS rates holding at the Q4 pattern, matching what we foresee for Q1, and carrying that into Q2. Past that point, our underlying premise — whether it lands at -5 or flat for the U.S. — is that we give back roughly a third to a half of the POS gains we picked up during 2020's back half, really from the starting line. One could call that quite cautious, since we believe folks will keep working from home. I don't see people returning to the office five days a week. My view is that those who just discovered this category will stick with it, having found enjoyment in it, and they'll want to keep leveraging the investments they made during this year. Only time will reveal the answer. Trying to guess what happens with the world, the economy, and how that maps onto U.S. lawn and garden strikes me as genuinely, genuinely difficult. That's the premise we've adopted, and we'd rather be upfront about how the math works to arrive at guidance of that sort. I hope that's useful, Bill.
Bill Chappell
analystYeah, that's useful. Thanks.
William Reuter
analystHello. Impressive figures. I've got two things to ask. First, across a two-year stretch, you'll be generating $800 million in free cash flow. So what do you intend to do with that money? As your results keep improving, your leverage keeps dropping. So what are your leverage targets now? That's all. Thanks.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveWell, Randy and I work closely together on this. I'll begin, then pass it to Randy. This is something where I believe we see completely eye to eye. While getting ready for the call, we guessed this question would arise. Right now, I'd say we're quite comfortable with our leverage and its current level. It provides plenty of choices. Honestly, I'd like to take some time to digest the election outcomes, plus what's going on with corporate tax rates, dividends, and personal income tax rates, which matter for this company, I believe, to our shareholders. I think we were quite ready to pay out a large special dividend if we thought taxes were heading up for the people who own this company, and that's every one of our shareholders; we certainly have a more active M&A pipeline than we did about two years back. Nothing wild. Regarding the Bonnie deal, we haven't discussed it much, but it's quite accretive. I'd call it roughly neutral for leverage. Here we're actually completing a deal, and it barely shifts leverage, while on the EPS line, it adds value. I think we feel good about it. I think we're examining very closely and devoting lots of time with the board to the changing cannabis and hemp market and how we make bets there. Live goods, I think, remains something we're interested in. We've made a commitment to shareholders to be shareholder-friendly, and we fully plan to follow through. What took place in 2020 has been quite positive. We didn't anticipate finishing this year at 2.5 times. I'd need to check with Randy, but looking at our year-end figures, I believe internal projections are lower, around 2.0 or so. We have plenty of flexibility. We're dedicated to being shareholder friendly, and we're dedicated to investing in the business, yet we don't feel any urgency right now to move quickly in any direction. Catherine, did you?
William Reuter
analystGreat.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveTalk about it enough here.
William Reuter
analystThat's quite useful, thank you very much. I'll share it with others.
Eric Bosshard
analystHello there, good morning.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveHi.
Eric Bosshard
analystRegarding Bonnie, I'd like a bit more detail. Over the past 20 years, you've been fairly aggressive in testing various things across different adjacencies, yet you've never truly engaged in live goods. I'm wondering whether something has shifted in that sector's dynamics or in the profit potential there, and I'm especially curious how that thinking squares with the larger runway you have in cannabis — essentially, what changed in your thinking that made you want to enter live goods?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveOkay. Honestly, I don't believe anything did. We've been attempting live goods — Miracle-Gro plants and similar items. I'd describe that as modest success. If we consider the entire Project Focus strategy toward the business that we adopted, I'm not sure, whatever we say, five years back. The idea was to divest businesses we judged not beneficial over the long term, and seek out those with faster growth rates. Keep in mind, much has shifted since then, truthfully, which is that I believe we were seeing 0%-2% on core back then, and while that isn't an absurd figure today, it's obviously, we believe, superior to 0%-2%. We sought businesses capable of growing more rapidly. We did see live goods, especially herbs and veggies, as something that might grow at some multiple of zero two, and that has proven accurate. That's genuinely why we partnered with them through AFC, Alabama Farmers Co-op, and Bonnie to start with. The reason we held the 25% stake with them was simply because that's the furthest they'd permit us to go. Right? We've had other talks involving other opportunities, and I think we preferred the Bonnie opportunity. When AFC asked us, and Mike Sutterer asked us, whether he could head over there to improve their management team, we were highly supportive. If you asked, "What would Randy have criticized?" I think it would be many processes inside Bonnie that we felt might be improved. That's since we were somewhat involved, grasped the business, but only as a minority partner. I think Mike Sutterer concurs with those points, and he's addressed a great deal of that. As we examine the business, and bear in mind this will become clearer, but it's an average of earnings across the past three years, that it was a sufficiently large increase this year that we wanted to move faster. We possessed the right to reach 51%, they could refuse and repurchase our stake. We landed, I think, quite happily at this roughly 50/50 position, which we're actually extremely comfortable with. If you compare how profitable that operation is now with how it was prior to Sutterer joining, it's a huge change. Today it's a far more appealing operation than it used to be. Its growth rates keep outpacing those of our main consumer segment. There's this notion that we're aiming to be a gardening company. In case you weren't conscious of our enthusiasm for live goods, then perhaps we haven't communicated it well enough. To me, this isn't a choice that excludes other options, where you must pick one, such as consumer veggie, edible live goods, or something inside the Hawthorne operation. It's obvious we've poured enormous sums into expanding our Hawthorne franchise, and they've performed admirably at bringing all those components together. You don't sit on the board, yet I'd tell you the board strongly supports keeping an eye out for chances and, provided pricing is reasonable, putting more money into that operation. This is the spot where Randy and I clash, I believe. Mike Lukemire, Chris Hagedorn, and everyone else in the group push for transactions, while Randy Coleman and I, along with our finance committee on the board—which my sister, my twin, leads—have the task of reviewing those and judging them against many factors, including leverage that benefits shareholders and what we see as the long-term potential. Regarding the two of them, I'd say we feel good. If you take one message from that, it would be this: keep investing in live goods, keep investing in the Hawthorne Gardening Company, and keep delivering a shareholder-friendly response, and I'm quite happy with how the election turned out, at least concerning the Senate and the steadiness of taxation, at least for the immediate future. You surely have a comment to make.
Randy Coleman
executiveThere's never a time I don't have a comment to make. What I would probably throw in is that over the past 4 years, they've proven to be genuinely strong partners. The calibre of the people on that team is truly first-rate, and the experience of collaborating with them has been a pleasure. Looking ahead, I feel hopeful that we'll take things to an even higher level. It has truly been a strong partnership.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveEric, this will be brief, and perhaps it repeats something. Randy was among the harder folks to win over regarding our fresh merchandise strategy. Could you explain the reasons behind that and what has shifted?
Randy Coleman
executiveWhen you compare operating margins, Bonnie stands out as the top performer among live goods on a relative profit basis. Even so, that figure fell short of what our U.S. business delivers, and it also trailed our company-wide average. They have benefited this year from the same growth we've experienced, and their profitability rate now actually sits above our overall corporate average. There's plenty of confidence that they'll enjoy a strong 2021, exactly as Scotts will. I believe the adjustments we're making are the right ones to sustain a profitability rate of that kind. Once you reach that stage, it becomes simpler to get on board. In my view, the price we're paying is also reasonable, since it's calculated using a three-year average. Had we held off another year, the check we'd need to write would be considerably larger. As you put it, Jim, right now is the appropriate moment.
Eric Bosshard
analystOkay. Very good. Thank you.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveYou're welcome.
Jonathan Andersen
analystHey, good morning, everybody.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveHey.
Jonathan Andersen
analystHonestly, most of what I had has already been covered. But there's one item that caught my attention — Jim, you brought up how competition is playing out at retail in 2021. Could you expand a bit on what you're anticipating, whether by channel or regarding certain key customers? I understand retail pricing has gone up while promotions have come down. How much of that affected or helped you, or was it purely a retail-side thing? And how do you see it unfolding in 2021? Thanks.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveThat one will land me in a heap of trouble. Still, I believe it's a genuinely good question and I'd like to take a crack at it. We've discussed how the big-box footprint of some of our larger customers was affected when everything around essentiality and COVID risk took hold — nobody wanted anyone getting sick, and they were concerned about their own employees — so there was quite a bit of burying heads in the sand at the height of the season. What you ended up seeing was that a number of our comparatively smaller retailers — Tractor Supply, Ace, Costco — kept their noses to the grindstone and showed less fear, since I think their store format drew less criticism for drawing people in. Earlier in the season, you witnessed a huge share gain, a real beaucoup, among that next tier below The Home Depot and Lowe's. Then once roughly June arrived, you saw — and we had many great conversations with people I regard as friends at both The Home Depot and Lowe's — an effort to reconnect with the market. Looking at the back half of the season, they genuinely began performing quite well and capitalizing on the marketplace. A great deal of credit belongs to those smaller retailers, who did truly innovative work alongside our sales and marketing teams to grow that business. They've earned plenty of credit, and they'll be looking to protect their share. That figure we put out — roughly $200 million in sales spanning Hawthorne and the core consumer business — I believe a large portion was out of stock, or else stock sat in the consumer products space where customers wanted to purchase and nobody wants a repeat of that. Everyone is also saying, "We have to be in stock." That's what's driving our manufacturing processes at this moment. Retailers are purchasing aggressively. I think there's far less hesitation about putting money into the marketplace. So I believe you'll see a very busy promotional calendar as folks try to say, "Actually, this turned out pretty well for us." I think you'll see it with small customers, large customers, all of it. Let me bring up Walmart, just for the sake of it. I believe their performance this year was outstanding. They've excelled at keeping their focus on the market and collaborating closely with us, much like the rest of our retail partners. They're owed some recognition, since quite some time has passed since we described them as the leader in this area—and that's exactly what they were. Turning to pricing: given the comparatively low level of promotional activity, my honest assessment is that retailers captured the majority of that upside. We saw a modest amount of pricing benefit in the prior year, yet in our estimation retails likely climbed around 10% owing to reduced promotion, particularly those massive, intensive Black Friday occasions. What we've come to understand, I believe, is that on a per-unit basis, consumers weren't all that responsive to it. That isn't to suggest we ought to be lifting our prices to capitalize on the situation. I see it as a data point illustrating just how valuable this is. You've all heard me discuss these Black Fridays before. My general take is that they're nearly always badly thought out. We frequently miss on weather. Much of our marketing strategy addresses that at a far more nuanced level. The entire Black Friday concept genuinely warrants scrutiny. It wouldn't shock me at all if 75% of our promotional dollars flow to just a handful of weekends; we're sorting this out alongside our retailers, though the gain on our side was smaller than what retailers received. My sense is their expenses rose considerably as they grappled with hygiene and safety matters inside stores. A great deal of that money, I believe, went toward their operations simply to keep the doors open. I genuinely believe this deserves a serious discussion going forward: what does promotion actually mean in this category? What does pricing actually mean here? Does selling mulch at a loss—just to give one example—truly make much sense? There's still considerable work remaining on this matter, in my view. Mike and his team, I'd say, are deeply involved with many individuals who happen to be close personal friends of ours, attempting to make sense of it. I've personally held some of those conversations with senior management too. Where this ultimately leads, I can't say. My hope is they won't all develop amnesia, revert to that same pattern of giving product away and poaching share from one another in 2021, and forget what 2020 taught us—lessons I consider truly foundational. Once more, if anyone recalls, it's somewhat akin to looking at election outcomes. There are, I think, many lessons to be drawn here. You can't help but wonder whether, six months down the road, everyone will retreat to their respective corners and simply repeat the same tired nonsense they've always engaged in. There's genuine cause here, I believe, to think hard about what all of this signifies.
Randy Coleman
executiveJon, let me give you some context on how pricing has played out for us in just the past few years, and how we're thinking about next year and beyond. As you may remember, we took no pricing in 2018. Then in 2019, we did a catch-up spanning two years. As we entered 2020, our expectation was roughly 75 basis points of pricing, and it came in higher than that, because we reduced some promotional spending. Much like retailers, we wound up directing that money toward media marketing, so it didn't all flow straight to the bottom line — instead, we put it back into the business. Pricing came in above 75 basis points, partly thanks to favorable mix, since the categories where we raised prices saw particularly strong sales; on an invoice sales basis, we managed to achieve more than 1% by year-end. As we move into 2021, we're beginning from a comparable position, though on a total company basis I'd put it at roughly 75 basis points. That figure could shift somewhat, either up or down, based on how the year plays out. We feel quite good about that, since we implement pricing nearly every year. Our aim is not to get too far out in front of things, and we try to take a long-term view on pricing, making sure it stays reasonable. For 2021, roughly 75 basis points, and that should offset commodity costs, which have begun rising somewhat over the past couple of months. What matters more to us, when we look at gross margin in a broader sense, is that we're making needed investments in warehousing and distribution simply to handle the volume, plus labor costs too. There's pressure on that front. Two months ago, our expectation would have been gross margin rates nearer to flat compared with a 50 basis point decline. We will certainly take pricing in 2022 as well, carrying on with that multi-year, continuous pricing strategy we've discussed.
Jonathan Andersen
analystThat's quite useful. Only a single brief follow-up: in Hawthorne, two years back, you were extremely forceful, as I recall, on the pricing side — I think it formed part of an approach aimed at strengthening market share, et cetera, bolstering ties with customers, and other matters. If I'm mistaken, set me straight, but I believe you perhaps pulled back on that somewhat over the past 18 months. On pricing, what ought we to anticipate from Hawthorne? Have we settled into a steadier mode, similar to U.S. Consumer, or should we look for changes there?
Randy Coleman
executiveTo put a figure on it, at Hawthorne we'll be raising prices once more. In 2021, likely not as much as the increase we implemented during 2020. Beyond a modest amount of pricing — and we obviously aren't attempting to be greedy in any way, merely sensible about it — we've also made dealing with our retail partners far simpler, and we've put in place fresh trade programs along with rebates, and so forth, that are considerably more sensible. Consider how we merged all those businesses acquired across a span of 3 or 4 years, each of which operated in its own manner with distinct programs. That has now been streamlined and simplified, making our business far simpler to engage with, and I believe that simplification will yield plenty of advantages too. Regarding Hawthorne, the situation resembles the U.S.: we anticipate raising prices nearly every year, yet we certainly don't wish to move too quickly ahead of ourselves. Chris, I'm not sure whether you'd like to add anything there.
Chris Hagedorn
executiveYes, definitely, Randy. I believe you've addressed that quite thoroughly; since the beginning of the year, we've implemented price increases. Randy, just as Randy mentioned, when we discuss this, we're truly focused on pricing along with our trade program. As you noted, reworking, streamlining, and making those trade programs more logical significantly simplifies things for us to manage, and it's much simpler for retailers to grasp their position with us. We anticipate fairly substantial gains from this as the year progresses.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAlright, thank you. One heads-up for the team — I'm aware Luke bears a heavy load on this front. Quite a few items across both segments, Consumer as well as inside Hawthorne, remain fully committed even as we speak. One thing we must watch closely: we understand what's been accomplished on the Consumer side, namely that concept of a single face to the customer. A great deal was done as we looked at the U.S. Consumer business, tracing back 15, 20 years. We assembled a bunch of companies into one relatively easy-to-work-with powerhouse. Hawthorne, I believe, is following that same path. This is a year where — and we're not the only ones — many companies have products that performed strongly through the COVID period. It's fair to state that roughly $0.25 billion of business went unfulfilled by us. That makes it tough to meet someone's gaze and say, "I'd like pricing." We need to be a stronger partner than that. Nobody seems to take it too personally, which honestly catches me off guard a bit, since I would, and I do. Mike, I'm curious — what's your take on whether it's even acceptable to have a pricing conversation right now, given we couldn't meet demand?
Mike Lukemire
executiveThat conversation isn't an easy one. When the goal is putting infrastructure in place for the business, my view is that you tackle it alongside the retailer, and both sides aim to come out ahead, since everyone is working to expand infrastructure for direct-to-consumer and for delivery to stores. If service levels are slipping, then for me, that hits close to home. I take no pleasure in poor service. Twenty-five years ago, I was right here during a stretch when we performed quite badly, and we went on to construct an excellent supply chain. Now we need to move up a level. You will notice capital outlays and spending aimed at creating that following capability.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveSure. There's somewhat of a distinct boundary here when it comes to this discussion. Mike really took these matters to heart during this year. Randy did as well. My sense is that Randy's concern stemmed from the fact that although the figures were excellent, we struggled considerably with the planning and budget side of things. I believe it will require us to work hard at making real enhancements to our processes and to how we approach budgeting. As for Mike's area, that being the supply chain—let me say this: this organization operated fully throughout what I consider a fairly major national crisis, and it could have been one for us; so I'm not suggesting that being here was awful. What I am saying is that what frustrated folks greatly was our failure to match the pace of expansion from a budgeting perspective, since we see that as a matter of credibility with our board, with ourselves, and with all of you. Mike's perspective grew increasingly bitter as summer wore on—that this cannot stand, that we are unable to deliver. I simply want to put that out there concerning pricing, that there's work ahead of us to make it right. If we're able to create a business where we serve as a flawless supplier, vendor, partner—call it whatever you like—to a retailer, and you simplify doing business, nobody has a complaint about that. Alright. If you're not shipping product, that conversation becomes far more difficult. It deserves mention just how tough the past roughly 2 or 3 months have been for Mike, since he has devoted the bulk of his hours, much like in earlier times, to committing himself toward enhancing our supply chain and our capacity to complete our deals—when someone requests something, we provide it 100% of the time, in full, within the timeframe they desire. We continue to be out of stock on items that matter for the future.
Randy Coleman
executiveRandy here. Let me add one more thing, since I don't think we've made this fully clear. All of us agree we're going to build far more inventory than what's required to stay flat in the U.S., and likewise to be up 15 or 20% in Hawthorne. At some point in the spring, we'll have to assess what the back half of the year looks like. But we aren't building that inventory just to hit the figures we mentioned in the guidance — we have to do better than that, and we have to get out ahead, and we're working hard right now to make it happen. A moment will come when we need to assess, but that moment isn't November 4th.
Jonathan Andersen
analystI really appreciate everyone jumping in on this. Thanks a lot, and best of luck out there.
Alex Maroccia
analystMorning, everyone. I appreciate you fielding my question. Could you walk us through the opportunity in the cannabis space in Jersey and Arizona, and how that stacks up against other states where medical users are already well established?
Chris Hagedorn
executiveSure, I can share what we understand so far. Obviously, a great deal of regulation still has to be drafted in both of those states, so I think offering our take is a bit premature on the morning when we got word that the votes came out favorably. That said, if you simply consider how big the opportunity could be, New Jersey especially, I'd call it substantial. Our expectation is that those folks, especially given that New York and Pennsylvania haven't acted yet — first of all, I really do think New Jersey will serve as a catalyst for those two. They've waited such a long time, especially with the budget shortfalls from COVID that frankly every state faced, but those two in particular, that they'll simply allow New Jersey to capture their cannabis dollars. It's a simple subway trip under the river, from Manhattan over into Jersey, and just as simple to get from Philly into New Jersey. I believe we're going to witness a substantial amount of tax revenue crossing that border. It's similar to what happens with lottery states bordered by states without a lottery. The talks Jim mentioned earlier with Senator Sweeney give us reason for optimism in New Jersey. They lead us to believe there will be a marketplace regulated sensibly and taxed sensibly, one that ought to be fairly permissive for business; we see a meaningful opportunity there, and it's a market where we've been expanding our service and sales operations in preparation. As for Arizona, our view is that it will be — the opportunity isn't quite as large purely in terms of raw numbers, but once again, that state has been steadily moving in a positive direction; we already have a solid footprint there. Our sales force is located there with well-built ties to the major cultivators in the state, along with retailers. We're optimistic about both states. New Jersey strikes me as the more thrilling one, not just because of what it could become, but also because of how we believe it will propel the remainder of the Northeast.
Alex Maroccia
analystWhat's your take on that region — Connecticut, New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania — compared with, say, the West?
Chris Hagedorn
executiveOh, listen, we're very optimistic. This has come up before. Our research, and ultimately reality will tell, indicates that cannabis buyers in the Northeast consume more per person than those in California. That's what we'd anticipate. When you add those states together, you get a comparable population, roughly 40 million individuals. For us, it ought to function like California, though clearly split across several states. Something worth flagging, since we've mentioned it: California remains our biggest state by a wide margin. Roughly half of our overall revenue still comes from California alone; we anticipate California's share will shrink as the Northeast launches. Much of the cannabis cultivated illegally in California, we suspect, exists to supply the black market in the tri-state area. As those states build out their own more settled, lawful in-state markets, we'd expect that revenue to migrate around the country for us, with activity in those states taking the place of some of what we currently do in California.
Alex Maroccia
analystUnderstood. That's logical. To build on that, could you describe what the retail landscape in Hawthorne looks like right now? I'm aware that a particular retailer has acted quite aggressively lately when it comes to buying up other companies. What's the right way to view consolidation in this industry and the effect it has on relationships?
Chris Hagedorn
executiveYeah. Consolidation in the industry is certainly happening. I'm guessing the retailer you mean is GrowGeneration. Aggressive is definitely the right word for them; it's also probably worth noting that two days ago they said they'd bought a retail chain based in Northern California known as The GrowBiz. Among the bigger retail chains in California and across the country is The GrowBiz, and as a Hawthorne customer they've been extremely loyal on a consistent basis; our expectation is that this positive relationship will keep going; the relationship we have with GrowGeneration is good and strong. They rank as our biggest retail customer; their approach has been aggressive, and collaborating with retailers that are large and aggressive is something deeply embedded in our DNA at Scotts Miracle-Gro. As we've watched them expand, they added former The Home Depot executives as advisors. Their goal seems obvious to me, and it's one we know well from being a partner to it; we anticipate nothing negative coming out of it. The relationship between us and Grow Gen and their executive team is good and strong. To us, they've been a wonderful partner.
Alex Maroccia
analystGot it. Thanks, everyone.
Sarah Clark
analystHello, good morning. Sarah Clark here, filling in for Carla Casella. We really appreciate you squeezing us in, and sorry if you've already covered some of these points. We joined the call late. Regarding working capital, what's your view on how that gets back to normal after COVID? It seems you've been keeping inventory in check while also seeing payable days rise. What do you expect that to look like as we head into next year?
Randy Coleman
executiveAbsolutely. Randy here. I'll handle that one. On working capital, let me begin with inventory. By the close of September 2020, ideally we'd have had roughly another $100 million of inventory compared with how we ended the year. As I said during our prepared comments, the moment we could purchase product or produce product — it depends which business we're discussing — it was pretty much going right out the door; that's going to weigh on free cash flow in the coming year. Considering how inventory stood at the close of Q1 and even Q2, I'd anticipate we'll be substantially above those levels by the time we wrap up those quarters, simply because we're attempting to build ahead of demand we're striving to satisfy now and where we believe demand will land in the back half of the year. As I mentioned, an inflection point will arrive at some stage in the spring when we have to determine how the picture looks. We'll be examining the same things you are. As for payables, they rose, and receivables climbed quite a bit too during the fourth quarter, purely because sales were so strong. Attempting to project that forward to what it resembles 12 months from today — I don't believe we can do so precisely, since it will hinge on, once again, so many variables and what consumer demand turns out to be and how everything unfolds and whether we must keep building. Beyond working capital, let me touch on SG&A for a moment. We moved a number of projects into Q4 that normally would've been spread across Q1 or Q2. Really attempting to get out ahead of things. We'll reach the third and fourth quarters of next year. Should things go as smoothly as we're hoping internally, our SG&A might be even greater because we'll maintain our foot on the gas and continue investing. There's plenty of flexibility in that area as well. If we need to decelerate, we retain all our flexibility; it's going to be fascinating. I can't give you a perfect answer to your question since there's simply so much uncertainty at present, but that's how we're approaching it.
Sarah Clark
analystNo, that was really useful. Thanks. One final question from us. You mentioned M&A briefly. In what ways have valuations shifted before COVID compared with today? That's everything from our side. Thanks, and congratulations on a strong quarter.
Randy Coleman
executiveCertainly; regarding M&A, the multiple for the Bonnie deal was negotiated back four years ago, so it stands at eight times trailing three years EBITDA. There isn't much happening there that the current marketplace would alter. As for the other transactions we're chasing at the moment, I'd say things haven't shifted much, and I don't believe it's being pushed up or down by what's going on globally with COVID. We're reviewing a handful of opportunities in the pipeline. It's still so early that we can't make any commitments at this point. On the subject of cash usage, past the Bonnie deal, there will be matters we discuss likely next quarter, or the one following that, and the one after that. Stay tuned.
Sarah Clark
analystGreat. Thanks.
Jim King
executiveThank you; for those people who have additional follow-ups, if you want to call my office directly, you can reach me at nine, three, seven, five, seven, eight, five, six, two. Right now, we are tentatively scheduled for our Q1 results to be released on January 27th. We have no kind of active IR plans between now and then. Put it on your calendar and we hope to talk to you then. Thanks for participating today, everybody, and have a great day.
Operator
operatorThat does conclude today's call. Thank you for your participation. You may now disconnect.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.