The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company (SMG) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
February 3, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Jim King
executiveHello, everyone, and thanks for joining us for The Scotts Miracle-Gro first quarter conference call. This morning we're doing things a little differently, since this is the first time we've handled this call remotely; shortly, you'll hear prepared comments from Jim Hagedorn, our Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, and from Cory Miller, our Interim Chief Financial Officer. Once those remarks wrap up, we'll open the lines live for your questions. Taking part in the Q&A will be Jim and Cory, along with Mike Lukemire, our President and Chief Operator, and Chris Hagedorn, who leads the Hawthorne Division. <<operator_script>> I've already booked time with a number of you following this call to fill in the gaps. Anyone who wants to schedule a Q&A session can contact me at (937) 578 to 5622, and we'll try to arrange something as soon as possible. Before we get started, a few IR logistics: on February 23, we'll take part in a virtual fireside chat at the Truist Securities Consumer Symposium. The next week, we'll be at the Raymond James 42nd Annual Institutional Investors Conference. Then, later in the spring, probably in early April, we plan to hold our own virtual Analyst Day, which will include recorded presentations from a number of our management team members and a live Q&A portion. A lot of those presentations are probably going to center on our Hawthorne segment, which should help you get a clearer picture of where our business stands right now and what we intend to do going forward. So with that, we'll continue with the call today. As usual, we anticipate making forward-looking statements this morning, and I'd like to warn you that our actual results may end up differing materially from those statements. Anyone investing should take the time to review the complete set of risk factors that might affect our results. You can find those in our Form 10-K, which has been filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission. One more thing I'd like to note is that this call is being recorded today. You'll be able to find both a recording of this call and a written copy of it posted on our site afterward. Now, let's begin, and I'll hand it over to Jim Hagedorn. Jim?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAppreciate it, Jim, and hello everybody on this call. Looking at the numbers we released today, three points stand out: number one, our company keeps gaining from the fact that Americans fell back in love with gardening, which brought millions of first-time buyers into this space last spring; number two, our people are executing at a really high level; and number three, which matters most, we made smart moves over time so that we're now positioned to seize the opportunity sitting right in front of us. Turning a profit in Q4 of 2020 as well as Q1 of '21 — periods where losses have been our historical norm — is a result not one of us would have called in earlier days. I've sat through enough of these calls to recognize that certain folks listening already want to raise questions about the comparables coming in the next year. I'd ask you not to; that subject isn't something we're thinking about at this point. What we're doing instead is staying completely dialed in on pushing as hard as possible throughout '21. That offensive-minded approach is paying off. As we moved into February, our two main business segments are each still running above even our most optimistic forecasts. Within our U.S. Consumer operation, sales climbed 147%, while purchases by shoppers at our biggest retail partners rose 40% during the first quarter and were running 35% higher as February began. So the consumer is still with us. Shipments, though, are now far ahead of point-of-sale as stores stock up in advance of the season. Cory will explain more later, but we too are adding to our inventory. Should this year bring extra upside, the last thing we want is a repeat of where we stood a year ago, missing out on sales we could have captured. On the other hand, if that upside never shows up, we feel good about how we can handle inventory positions as the year closes. And honestly, even if we finish with somewhat more inventory than planned, that's fine by me; the cost of goods isn't the only area where money is going out the door. We're putting more behind marketing, guided by one straightforward but ambitious objective: keeping the millions of shoppers who joined or came back to the lawn and garden space last season. Our approach involves targeted, highly focused social media pushes, backed up by conventional channels — among them the very first Super Bowl commercial in our company's history. I'll go into greater detail on all of that shortly. Over at Hawthorne, sales for Q1 were 71% higher, marking yet another stretch of robust expansion across every part of the product lineup. We're confident enough already to raise the full-year sales outlook for Hawthorne. This continued strong growth feels even more promising given that we're also advancing other long-range efforts. Our perspective on this operation has always been a long-term one, centered on becoming a genuine leader in the industry by creating value for the people we serve — the cultivators. I'll say more about that idea later on, and I'll also touch on a few other industry trends that I'm aware many of you are thinking about. Cory is going to walk through the details of the numbers shortly. But before that, I want to remind everybody that Q1 tends to be a minor portion of the overall year; we recognize there's still plenty of work in front of us this season, and at the moment we're keeping our heads down and staying focused on execution. This morning, I'd like to bring you up to speed on the actions we've taken since the previous call to propel the business, not only in '21, but over the long term. Before doing that, let me offer a handful of thoughts regarding some of the organizational shifts we've made lately. I'd like to welcome Cory to this call, and I can say with confidence to all of you that he is a highly qualified and very capable member of this team. Having been the finance lead at Hawthorne from its inception, he likely understands the nuances of that business better than anybody, and he has served as a genuine hands-on partner for Chris and the whole operating team. I'm certain all of you will quickly find that Cory will bring a great deal of value to these calls. During his time as interim CFO, he will additionally be a candidate in the search process, which we'll carry out across the coming several quarters. The remaining moves we announced last month, apart from Randy Coleman's departure, were each part of a talent management and succession planning effort that has existed for a long time. Among the most significant elements of a CEO's role, and one that far too rarely gets talked about with Wall Street, is human capital management. We've produced excellent results across the last several years because our business has operated at a higher level of effectiveness. And over the last 12 months especially, we've been operating with an intensity that is unprecedented. Obviously, the company we're running today differs from 5 years ago. And 5 years from now, it probably will differ once more. One thing that has become evident in the COVID environment is that how all of us work will change permanently, in a way that demands a different degree of flexibility and collaboration than previously; that demands we install a team that maximizes our likelihood for continued success, and it also means occasionally making tough choices. Over the past few months, we've done both. Starting in November, we implemented a series of organizational changes that in the end led to 3 senior members of the team departing. It also led to more than a dozen people being shifted into new or expanded roles. They all belong to a diverse group of roughly 25 leaders whom we had earlier identified as the brightest and most talented people in the company. Our aim is to broaden our capabilities and give them a stronger grasp of the breadth of the organization. We're adding a data-driven evaluation component on top of the hands-on job experience they already have, which lets them build on what they do well and address areas where they fall short. Beyond the moves we made public on January 11, Chris Hagedorn moved up last week into the roles of Executive Vice President of Scotts Miracle-Gro and Division President of Hawthorne. Dan Paradiso became Senior Vice President and Chief Operating Officer of Hawthorne. For 2 years now, Chris and Dan have operated as close partners. Hawthorne became an operating segment in fiscal 2017, generating $287 million in revenue that year — twice what it brought in the prior year, thanks to acquisitions. Based on our 2021 guidance, Hawthorne revenue should reach at least $1.2 billion this year, and no acquisition has been made since 2018. The business now carries more complexity, and the industry is plainly at a significant inflection point with an extraordinarily promising future. We believe Chris has shown the vision and leadership abilities required to elevate Hawthorne to the next level. With Dan beside him as operating partner, Chris will have greater room to sharpen our Hawthorne strategy while making certain we satisfy the near-term requirements of the business and our customers.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAnyone who's stepped into a new position or seen their responsibilities grow over these past several months is going to be among the people steering this organization going forward. We didn't make these changes by accident. They represent strategic moves designed entirely around building the next wave of executive leadership. With that said, let's get back to discussing how we operate the business and share where things stand with what we're doing. I'll begin with U.S. Consumer. During our previous call, we mentioned that our aim was to beat the full-year guidance we had given you. Our confidence that we can reach that target keeps building, and the team has put in serious effort toward making it happen; they're still sure we can hold onto the millions of customers who entered the lawn and garden space last season, and also bring in a fresh set of people to join in; this coming Sunday, in the second quarter of the Super Bowl, our very first TV spot, made specifically for this occasion, will air. A lineup of A-list celebrities and athletes who take pleasure in their backyards and being outdoors will appear in it, helping us deliver one straightforward idea: keep growing. Our CMO, Josh Peoples, shared with you last quarter that we were shifting toward maintaining a dialogue with consumers all year long; and rather than just promoting our brands, we aimed to highlight the act of gardening itself. We've stayed connected with consumers all through the winter, putting 3x more into media last quarter than we ever have at this point in any year. The purpose of the Super Bowl push is to keep those consumers involved and inspired, and it's one piece of an 8-week launch into what will be the largest lawn and garden season on record. As you're aware, COVID's reality has definitely given our business a boost. Although we think some degree of remote work will stick around permanently, Scotts included, many people will ultimately return to their offices, return to their kids' soccer games and, once more, leave for summer vacations. Even so, that doesn't mean they'll need to abandon their garden or lawn. We're putting in the effort to ensure they won't. We see the Super Bowl's wide audience as a solid investment, particularly considering the additional PR and marketing activation that accompanies it. And the timing works well, as well. Consumers grow impatient at this point in the year. They're eager to get outdoors again. They're ready to do yard work once more. Being able to address most of the nation simultaneously is sensible and pairs strongly with the intense targeting of our digital outreach work. On that note, we keep putting money into our analytical tools to deliver powerful and better-focused messaging to particular demographic groups. Those messages will go out at moments more carefully aligned with seasonal growing cycles, retailer promotions or, put more plainly, whatever the weather is doing outside. We're going to align what we do to reach out with a large number of our retail partners, ensuring that what we do adds to what they're doing and also takes advantage of promotional efforts we anticipate all season long. When it comes to our retail partners, we can't overstate how engaged they are. Their level of involvement is greater than anything we've ever witnessed, and that holds across every channel. In '21, they view lawn and garden as one of their most appealing categories. That translates into more backing for our brands, which explains why a meaningful share of the 147% sales growth during the first quarter came from retail inventory levels getting better. Shipment pace stayed robust through the opening month of Q2. We continue to feel confident that at the halfway mark of the year, we'll be comfortably above our full year guidance. And like I mentioned before, our optimism keeps growing regarding the U.S. Consumer segment's capacity to expand once more in '21. Let me remind everybody that the difficult comparisons don't show up until May and June, and roughly half of U.S. Consumer POS has traditionally taken place between May and our fiscal year-end in September. Because of that, we intend to proceed cautiously prior to reevaluating our present guidance. One additional point before I move to a different topic. We finalized the Bonnie Plants transaction at the close of the calendar year and currently hold a 50% equity stake in that business. This matters a great deal to us and reflects a degree of dedication to a lawn and garden category that we believe is essential to our success going forward. Live goods is what pulls consumers into the wider lawn and garden arena. It carries broad demographic appeal along with an emotional element unlike the other products we offer. Bonnie is the finest in the world at what it does, edible live goods. And Mike Sutterer, who heads that business, was formerly one of the leaders at Scotts Miracle-Gro. He's performed excellently at Bonnie, and I'm certain the JV between our 2 companies will generate substantial value for both. Though Bonnie serves as an on-ramp, particularly in edible gardening, other live goods areas strike us as equally appealing, and we like the thought of holding a bigger and more strategic presence across the live goods space overall. Among other things, live goods let us more effectively leverage the native brands we're creating such as Knock! Knock!, Lunarly and Greendigs, which additionally generates more momentum for our direct-to-consumer initiatives. We're ready to accept that live goods economics aren't as robust as those of our traditional products, but they're improving; but that isn't the point. As we consider our future, owning the relationship with consumers is a strategic imperative. For that to happen, those consumers need to see us as a gardening company, not merely a gardening products company. Live goods is essential to that goal. Okay. Let's shift topics and spend a few minutes on Hawthorne. For a fourth quarter straight, Hawthorne has posted sales growth of no less than 60%. Though that pace will probably decelerate over the coming months, we still expect growth through September. That's the reason we feel confident enough to lift our sales guidance merely 4 months into the fiscal year. The expansion we're witnessing is arriving from all over the country, from established growers as well as new ones. It's taking place in more mature markets such as California and Colorado, and also in newer authorized markets like Michigan and Oklahoma. It's arriving across every product category too. Lighting, though, remains the largest growth driver in North America, rising 126% in the quarter. A lot of you have inquired about how we differ from some of the other participants in our space who have found success going public. I'll tip my hat to each of them. They're solid operators running good businesses. Our business, however, differs from theirs, and by a lot. Sure, we distribute products the same way others do, yet we don't see ourselves as a distributor, since we don't run things that way. Rather, we function as a partner to the cultivators who rely on our products. We recognize that our success depends on their confidence in the technical solutions we deliver.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAnd we understand that this isn't just about getting a light or some nutrients for the lowest possible cost; to achieve the finest quality and the greatest plant yields they can, and to keep making their own operations better, they've got to run efficiently. So we take on the duty to innovate; that's the reason in Q1 we launched the very first R&D site anywhere in the world, located in Canada, dedicated solely to cultivating cannabis. That's the reason we grew our R&D work as well in Ohio and Oregon tied to the hemp sector, which for us serves as a stand-in for the cannabis plant. It's the reason we're developing fresh nutrient blends, improved controlled products and improved growing methods. And it's the reason we're putting our elite plant genetics talent to work creating superior plants. A mere distributor won't take those steps. Our position as a leader also demands that we oversee and better the marketplace, along with our ability to operate freely within it; that's the reason we put more money than anybody else into shaping the policy conversations surrounding this industry, and the reason our corporate foundation backs social justice causes connected to cannabis reform. I take pride in saying I think we've built a name as among the cleverest, broadest and most strategic businesses to have steered through this sector; and there's a great deal left for us to do; at no point have we seen Hawthorne as a fast route to pumping up our share price. Rather, we see it as a strategic chance to generate shareholder value over the long haul. With that in mind, for years we've kept up a discussion among ourselves and with our Board regarding whether our present corporate structure makes sense in light of what Hawthorne could be worth. At this moment, we feel at ease that it does. And though no possibility is excluded when we weigh our future choices, we lean against altering anything unless a financial or business benefit appears that gives us added optionality for expanding our business. Nor will I stand here and speculate about whether today's market valuations for Hawthorne are right. The market is going to settle that. But here's what I will say. 6 years after entering this industry, only now are we truly finding our rhythm. We've grown stronger, sharper and more strategic, and we hold ample financial flexibility to put money into the future. What's the meaning of that? It might mean many things. Obviously, we're happy with our portfolio as it stands, yet we're actively reviewing neighboring categories to make it even stronger; we might also pursue acquiring abilities we lack today that sharpen our knowledge or skills in fields such as, say, plant genetics. Though it's fairly simple to recognize that this industry holds enormous potential, gauging how quickly that shift will come is hard. Our banks have been fantastic partners, and we're grateful for their backing as we've broken new ground in this space. That partnership is going to stay vital as we examine a broader set of choices for where and how to deploy capital. The steady cash we keep generating, plus what we're able to borrow, means we can go after M&A in Hawthorne as well as in the U.S. Consumer business, and still keep room to hand additional cash back to shareholders. Beyond that, we can put money into things such as marketing, R&D and supply chain, so we capture the chances sitting directly ahead of us and simultaneously put our businesses in a stronger position going forward. On top of that, we gain from a deep pool of talent that we're developing into tomorrow's leaders. Anyone who's familiar with me understands that near-term numbers aren't what I fixate on, yet I genuinely feel bullish about the position we're in today. My confidence in our guidance and our near-term outlook is very high, though my feelings about what's coming down the road are even stronger. A large share of that optimism comes from working alongside Mike Lukemire, who keeps doing an outstanding job of running the business day in and day out. Thanks to his leadership on the operational front, I'm able to spend more of my time on strategy and matters such as capital structure and talent management. Mainly, though, it frees me to devote more attention to the meaningful opportunities ahead of us for driving shareholder value. With that said, I'd like to hand the call to Cory so he can walk through the financials.
Cory Miller
executiveThank you, Jim, and good morning to all of you. I'm grateful for Jim's warm remarks; being here with you today is truly an honor, and I want to begin by briefly telling you about myself. Even though I've served as the finance head at Hawthorne since the early days of that operation, my tenure at Scotts Miracle-Gro spans more than 20 years across a range of finance positions. The bulk of that period was devoted to backing the U.S. Consumer business. That said, I also spent time in our external reporting group and served as the Head of Internal Audit. Despite never having held a public-facing position, I possess a thorough grasp of the financials and extensive familiarity with the business. I've partnered with prior CFOs, Randy among them, helping them grasp the specifics of the business and get ready for their engagements with all of you. I'd like to take a moment to personally recognize Randy and express my thanks for his backing and guidance. What I aim to do today is continue from where he stopped, providing color and context around the results we released today while walking through our outlook for the remainder of the fiscal year; so let's get started. On our previous call, Jim noted that this year might at times be hard to forecast. He also stated that we would keep you informed about any shifts in our outlook and revise our guidance when necessary. Proving that prediction right took only 1 quarter. The key takeaway for the first quarter is that sales growth came in far above what we anticipated in our U.S. Consumer business; part of the reason was how our retailers timed their preseason inventory builds; that volume also caused our gross margin rate for the quarter to be exceptionally high. Two factors blunted those gains somewhat. First, we began noticing the effect of rising input costs. Second, we chose to boost our marketing investment even further. We anticipate that both of these patterns will persist. I'll return to those subjects afterward, but first I want to go directly to our bottom line. For Q1, we posted adjusted net income of $22.2 million, equating to $0.39 per share. That contrasts with a loss of $62.4 million, or $1.12 per share, during the same quarter a year ago. This marks the first occasion we've recorded a profit in the first quarter. The quarter was propelled by the 147% sales growth we posted in the U.S. Consumer segment. We had anticipated sales growth would match or come in slightly above the 90% growth we posted in Q4. POS growth stayed robust during the first quarter, rising 40% compared with last year. We witnessed consumer backing for every one of our brands, Scotts, Miracle-Gro, Ortho and Tomcat, plus Roundup. What we misjudged in Q1 was how large the preseason inventory build by our retailers would be. All through the quarter, but particularly in December, retailers sharply accelerated their ordering. Although this does signal that retailers are committed, for the time being our assumption is that it reflects sales moving from one quarter to another instead of an overall gain for the entire year. Another thing worth mentioning is the change to the fiscal calendar in this fiscal year. Consequently, Q1 contains 5 additional days while Q4 has 6 fewer days. In the U.S. Consumer segment, that calendar change had an effect of roughly $24 million during Q1. At Hawthorne, growth of 71% in sales was driven by a 77% rise in our North American business. In markets such as Oklahoma and Michigan, we recorded triple-digit growth, with increases of 178% and 133%, respectively. California saw an 80% sales increase. Hawthorne also gained from 5 extra days in the quarter, adding $17 million to the top line. For our own brands in North America — Gavita, General Hydroponics, Botanicare and Can-Filters, which we refer to as signature brands — sales rose 97%. Distributed brand sales were higher by 47%. This year, signature brands should come close to 70% of all Hawthorne sales; that share is much greater than what our nearest competitors achieve, since they mostly offer third-party products. This better mix stems partly from our ongoing strength in lighting, which reflects a strong dedication to R&D. The mix is also still helped by SKU rationalization, which became simpler to carry out thanks to insights we obtained when we launched SAP last year. Looking at product categories in North America, hydroponic lighting was up 126%. Growing environment products rose 83%. Nutrients were higher by 53%, and growing media increased 40%. A favorable product mix at Hawthorne contributed to a 340 basis point gain in the segment's gross margin rate during the quarter; nevertheless, fixed cost leverage was the main reason the rate improved for both Hawthorne and the U.S. Consumer segment. In fact, on a company-wide basis it produced an improvement of almost 1,200 basis points, reaching 26.7%. Although the gross margin rate has started off strongly, the Q1 figure does not reflect what we anticipate for the whole year. Warehousing costs are the main source of the fixed cost leverage. Because sales volume doubled in the quarter, warehousing represented a much smaller share of total costs than usual during Q1. That advantage will unwind in later quarters. Turning now to SG&A, it rose 31% in the quarter. The largest single increase came from the timing of marketing spend. Even so, we intend to raise our marketing investment for the full year above the level we told you about in November. Even so, we still expect SG&A to fall overall for the full year. Hawthorne's segment profit comes up often in questions, so I want to tackle it directly. As shown in the press release, segment margin for the first quarter, which uses EBITDA, came to 13%, or almost twice what it was a year earlier. Hawthorne is somewhere I kept my attention squarely on during my time there, and it makes me happy that genuine, durable gains are taking shape in that business. Jim and the Board showed the right kind of patience by letting Hawthorne reach an acceptable profit level gradually. Were we to push the matter right now, I have no doubt that a further 200 to 300 basis points of segment profit sits there for the taking. Even so, we keep putting sensible money into sales, supply chain, marketing, R&D, public affairs, and into nothing more than developing a stronger, deeper talent pipeline. What Jim said a few minutes back regarding a long-term view on creating value at Hawthorne hits the mark exactly. A moat is being built around this business, and we carry ourselves the way a genuine industry leader would. My belief is that this business can capture additional market share as well as seize opportunities in emerging markets along the East Coast. Ahead of finishing my remarks on the quarter, a couple of housekeeping matters deserve mention. To start, you might have spotted that share count sits 1.3 million above where it was a year ago. That stems from our use of diluted shares this quarter, since we posted a profit. In the prior year we relied on the lower basic share figure, something required whenever a loss is reported.
Cory Miller
executiveTo wrap up, Jim noted that the Bonnie deal has just been completed and we now hold a 50% ownership interest in that company. With ownership at that percentage, Bonnie's financial results won't be consolidated into ours. That said, the income generated from this business will flow through the P&L in a different way than before. Our prior ownership position came through a financing arrangement, and what we earned from the business came from commissions, royalties, and interest. Those appeared across 3 separate P&L lines. The sales line was affected by commissions, other income captured the royalties, and other nonoperating income reflected the interest. Starting in Q2, all of it will flow through the earnings from equity line on the P&L. The real year-over-year effect on '21 adjusted EPS is probably somewhere between $0.12 and $0.15. During Q4 of last year, as we've done in prior years, we booked a noncash fair value adjustment tied to the annual revaluation of our option to purchase a piece of Bonnie; that benefited our 2020 P&L by $12 million and won't happen again this fiscal year. This Bonnie discussion actually serves as a nice segue into an update on our full year guidance. So allow me to bring you up to speed on where things stand. We continue to stand behind fiscal year '21 adjusted non-GAAP EPS of $8 to $8.40 per share. To be clear, the Bonnie transaction was not included in the guidance we gave previously. Beyond that, given our strong start and the current outlook for Hawthorne, we're raising our guidance for sales growth in that business to a range of 20% to 30%; that's up against our earlier range of 15% to 20%. The probable rise in commodity cost, though, combined with prior unplanned SG&A increases, should mostly offset these gains; we now expect SG&A to fall 3% to 8% versus last year's level. Earlier, we had said SG&A would fall 6% to 11%. The company-wide adjusted gross margin rate, which we originally said would drop roughly 50 basis points in fiscal '21, is now expected to drop 125 to 175 basis points relative to '20. We expect that gross margin rate pressure to show up in the second quarter. Since our Q4 call, we've raised our internal forecast in order to build more of our own inventory. While roughly 3/4 of our total commodity costs are locked in as we enter February, we're trailing our typical monthly pace on urea and resin because of this higher inventory forecast. On top of that, we're experiencing cost pressures from those 2 commodities especially, and we also see some emerging cost pressures tied to distribution. These cost pressures will probably lower the gross margin rate in our U.S. Consumer business, which we had previously expected to be flat. We continue to expect Hawthorne gross margin to align with our original guidance for the year. But the stronger sales growth in the Hawthorne segment places even more negative pressure on the company-wide gross margin rate. For both of those segments, we'd anticipate solid sales gains in Q2, though not as high as what we posted in Q1. During that stretch, U.S. Consumer revenue should climb by more than 20%. At Hawthorne, the increase ought to be double that figure. Ahead of taking your questions, let me state that I'm as optimistic as Jim regarding what we'll deliver for the entire year. Four months in, we're significantly ahead of the position we'd projected. And when we release Q2 results in May, we anticipate landing considerably above our guidance for the full year. With the record-setting back half we had last year, we recognize there's plenty of hard work waiting for us over the coming months. Even so, Hawthorne's momentum keeps pushing that operation to unprecedented heights; and in the U.S. Consumer business, we're likewise making every correct move as the busiest point of lawn and garden season arrives shortly. I appreciate your time today. Now I'll hand it back to our operator so the line can be opened for your questions.
Bill Chappell
analystLet me get a clearer picture of the gross margin — the bridge, and how that mechanism functions. My understanding is that normally, by September or October, you've secured 75% to 85% of your commodities, and after that, in November, you move into pricing agreements with the different retail customers. From there you're basically locked in, with solid visibility heading into the following year. But it sounds like a choice was made, I think, to increase how much inventory you'd take on in order to capture — and this makes complete sense to me — what might be another huge season, while also retaining those customers. Consequently, that additional inventory you accumulated isn't covered, and meanwhile both the inventory and the commodity costs climbed. And so that's — and you mentioned it had already been priced. So that's the situation. Am I framing it correctly? I simply want to confirm I've got the dynamics right.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveCory, Mike, do either of you want to handle that one?
Cory Miller
executiveYeah, this is Cory speaking. I believe you managed to catch portions of that, and they're working. When you consider our current situation regarding commodity costs, roughly 75% is secured for this year. However, we're planning to accumulate inventory during the latter half of our fiscal year so we can be better positioned to meet customer requirements. So, since we intend to grow our own stock, our projection increased, meaning we'll need additional urea and resin plus internal distribution expenses compared to what we had in our earlier forecast—those are the spots where pressure is showing up. Therefore, with an outlook stretching from now into the future, we're ensuring a cautious stance on pricing for those input categories and believe we've accounted for what we expect the gross margin rate to be in the forward-looking plan.
Mike Lukemire
executiveOkay. So think about it — go ahead, Bill. Sorry.
Bill Chappell
analystNo, Mike, go right ahead, please.
Mike Lukemire
executiveIf you picture us staying level, then it's essentially normal operations. Our planning assumes it might turn out bigger. That means those expenses may end up mattering. So we're planning ahead, and we're anticipating a — personally, I lean toward optimism. I've got that optimistic streak. I'd rather be prepared. So should sales fail to materialize, I believe our coverage is greater than typical. Yet should sales show up, then higher rates bring expense pressure.
Bill Chappell
analystUnderstood. Just to wrap up that idea, though — we’re sitting in February right now. So even though you’ve got the extra inventory and/or extra costs included in the guidance, you aren’t factoring in any potential sales upside at this stage, since the season hasn’t truly begun yet. Is that accurate?
Mike Lukemire
executiveThat’s accurate — okay, so, but those pressures do exist if sales were to rise. So...
Jim Hagedorn
executiveBill, this is Hagedorn. What I'd put forward is that we've discussed this many times — we essentially operate with 3 distinct sets of figures. First, there are the figures we share with all of you. Second, there are the figures we use with the Board to establish our incentive plan. And third, there's what you might call Mike's internal operating plan, which is the most aggressive of the three. Mike is running things somewhere in the direction of his own plan. I'm on board with that, and so would you be if you knew all the details. Mike's larger worry, frankly, given how we see this year shaping up, is that we simply can't produce enough product for this year. So my suggestion is to work backward from that perspective, and I believe you'll find it — it would be simpler to grasp what we're discussing.
Bill Chappell
analystOkay, that's excellent. I believe I've got it now. Then only one more question for Cory or Chris, assuming he's present. There's plenty of chatter regarding cannabis legislation. I believe I'm accurate when I say the biggest impact would come from changes to commerce-related rules and banking statutes; so could you perhaps share — your perspective on whether, if something does happen within the next 2, 3 months, when would benefits begin to appear? Or might benefits show up during this year?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveFine. I'll take that one first, and afterward Chris can jump in. Though I feel somewhat disheartened when I see folks discussing taxation and such, I believe the Democrats in both the House and the Senate are far more open-minded. The Banking Committee — we've discussed at length how banking and taxation are somewhat absurd, sort of quertrons in the commerce of marijuana in states where it's legal. And so the Banking Committee is currently led by our own Sheriff Brown from Ohio. And we've devoted considerable time to speaking with both delegations to the Senate, though recently on the Democratic side. And I believe we're fairly at ease over time that normalization is going to begin to appear; and we discussed a great deal, as we prepared for the call, what's your take on the environment? And I think, as is typical, the politicians are last to the party, that when it goes to the people, the people decided, New Jersey was around 2/3 of the voters were in favor. So we do think things are becoming more positive. It's difficult to forecast the glacial pace of politicians for whatever reason they have, but it would be an enormous benefit to this industry if they were taxed and — as a normal company and could bank like normal businesses and have access to credit, et cetera. The matter of when state laws change until we begin to see benefit, it's a matter I know Chris spends a great deal of time discussing.
Chris Hagedorn
executiveBill, it's Chris here. As Jim said, this is something we devote significant time to and keep a close eye on—when states amend their statutes, we later conduct a review of when our operations start to see an impact. Typically, somewhere around 12 to 18 months pass from the point legislation is enacted until rules go into force, and then at some point business picks up as growers begin their build-outs. That's the general timeframe we plan around. So once more, if you assume the laws shift in November, you'd extend that out by 1 year or 1.5 years. As for the tax and banking legislation Jim brought up, obviously those delivered massive gains. We're lucky to be big enough and influential enough that we can actually sit down with lawmakers and the people who really drive change. Honestly, it's outrageous that growers who play by the book get hit with such a punishing tax burden because of 280E. We're going to fight hard to get that fixed. Like Jim said, trying to guess what the federal government will do next—anyone would tell you the situation is pretty hard to predict right now. At the state level it's more straightforward, though clearly that isn't where the biggest changes are needed. We'll keep doing everything within our power, though forecasting this remains tough.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveOkay, there are just two points I want to make. First, I believe the advantage of the areas we've put money into is that none of the calls are ours to make; in this case, we're really speaking on behalf of our customers. If we were being self-interested, we'd likely be putting funds into this area in a different way were the regulations not what they are. So we're quite optimistic and hopeful that the government will eventually treat this as something important and address it, for a whole range of reasons.
William Reuter
analystFirst off, I didn't see any guidance regarding free cash flow. It seems sensible to note that it's been $325 million for the year. Does that figure remain unchanged? Or might inflation in input costs and a somewhat more aggressive inventory build bring that amount down?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveCory, could you handle that question?
Cory Miller
executiveYeah, the $325 million free cash flow guidance is the figure that's out in the market right now. We're going to reaffirm that guidance as we move forward. And when we consider how consumers are picking up products, when we consider what we deliver to various customers and the inventory needed to meet those service levels, we'll keep balancing the inventory we're holding against any strain we could see on that cash flow figure. But if we end up in a scenario where we're accumulating that inventory, sales are likely in a really good place too. So we'll be weighing those factors against one another; and we'll share more about guidance when we get to the May call.
William Reuter
analystAlso, regarding what Jim said about M&A, you brought up plant genetics. On the prior call, you indicated that any M&A likely wouldn't be particularly big or would not push leverage up meaningfully. Do some targets exist there, or elsewhere, that might have shifted that view, such that M&A could be bigger in scale than you'd anticipated before?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveWell, I — Jim Hagedorn speaking. That's a good question, and it's fair. A couple of weeks back we worked through a process, basically asking what's happening on many fronts, where does our own capital stand, and what does leverage look like, and so on. And given all that we know and where we believe the business will land, even if we acknowledge having a pretty strong pipeline of M&A possibilities right now on the Hawthorne side as well as the Consumer side, along with shareholder friendliness, roughly matching what we did a year ago, we ended up right about where we'd expected and wanted, and where I believe we'd told you folks before, meaning under 3.5x on leverage; that reflects what we think the business is doing at present; so I believe we're in a genuinely strong position when it comes to opportunity. We're already into Q2. And I believe we'll aim to schedule anything meaningful for roughly the back half of the year, giving us far more visibility, similar to the earlier question you raised about how free cash flow is shaping up. So I believe we don't intend to get too far over our skis, yet I believe we've got a fairly strong pipeline across both sides of the business; and even the capacity to land approximately where we stood a year ago on what you could call shareholder friendliness, likely centered on a special dividend; so — though that isn't settled yet. That's what we're discussing internally and with the Board's Finance Committee. But I believe we're likely tilting more toward putting extra money into a special dividend rather than share repurchases at this point, though — once more, not yet decided; so I believe when you boil it down, we don't intend to overpay. We feel quite at ease with where the business stands and that upside exists, and that we have the funds to do whatever we wish, and that we possess really solid visibility, I believe, into things we find exciting and that would benefit this business going forward.
Joe Altobello
analystLet's revisit the SG&A outlook briefly. From what I gather, the change versus your earlier projection — or rather the reduction, I should say. Does that stem entirely from marketing? That's my first question. And secondly, assuming it does, could you walk us through how your view has shifted over these last 3 months? Is it purely that you perceive a bigger chance this year and wish to seize as much of it as possible? Or did that emerge from discussions with your retail partners? Or a mix of both?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveMike, how about you describe your take on the sorts of opportunities out there for '21, plus the ties to the major retailers; and after that we — my feeling is it's preferable — after that we can move on — we can have Cory address merely how he's — merely SG&A overall. Still, I genuinely believe this is a really thrilling moment to be working at Scotts, and it's — my sense is we've never enjoyed anything like stronger or greater confidence across every one of our partners for the <<inaudible>>. So, Mike?
Mike Lukemire
executiveAbsolutely. The whole picture is different now. You can't approach it the way we used to — those giant three-player promotional pushes, and so on. The work itself — we aired lots of seasonal spots. What drives it is an ongoing dialogue with shoppers; our approach involves speaking with them all the time and interacting with them. We notice that uplift — their desire to garden, their desire to care for their property — and that's what we're conveying. So where the marketing once meant maybe 500 assets, now we're producing millions; it's a conversation every single day; we're putting money behind it. We're interacting with them. We're linking that back to the retailers. We're shifting how we promote. Promotional efforts still exist, but they're aimed more precisely. They're more tailored. We spread it across every channel. And our focus is convenience and holding their attention in the business and genuinely assisting them with their health and wellness at home; so from our vantage point, we said there's a chance daily to interact with them and speak with them about whether it's indoors or outdoors, and that carries through completely in how we think. So the involvement on the spend shifts with consumer interaction, and we'll keep developing that. To me it isn't a single occurrence. To me it's ongoing enhancement to seize the growth.
Joe Altobello
analystAnd what's your view on where your...
Mike Lukemire
executiveJim, is there anything you'd like to add to that?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveHow big is our share of voice?
Joe Altobello
analystIt has always been huge. What I want to know is, from the sound of it, that number is climbing.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveYes, it is certainly climbing. Well, we — here's the thing, we picked up a great deal over the past year. I'd put us at 100% of the share of voice during that period. That only happened near the finish, roughly when things became safe; and on that — I'm not pointing a finger at anyone. What I am saying is that while no one had a clue what was going on, while nobody grasped essentiality, we threw our weight behind our own business, and I believe we accounted for probably 100% of the whole industry's voice across many months during that peak stretch of the season a year ago. The — as for this year, my assumption is that a few other players will be fooling around in this space. The key point is that fooling around is not what we're doing. And the retailers — the connection we now share with our retail partners is far healthier; not that it had been poor previously. It was simply that we lacked the knowledge to do better. As things stand, the marketers over on Scotts's side along with those on the retail side are deeply engaged, collaborating every single day, simply carrying out what Mike described. Store ops — previously it was the case that, say, craftery people would maintain a relationship with the merchants. Mike and I would handle the top-to-top type of things, and beyond that, not much happened. These days the marketeers have a seat at the table. And equally significant to that is store ops. As it happens, I believe all of us used to regard store ops folks as nothing but a nuisance; and I'm not sure why, though part of it comes down to the fact that they grasp what we do in lawn and garden, and they recognize how vital it is for their stores. Yet it turns out that once you pull the store ops people in alongside merchants, alongside the marketers, alongside those top-to-top conversations Mike and I have more or less always conducted, you get a far healthier setting in which everyone depends on everyone else to move the business forward; and that's genuinely thrilling, and it's likewise fueling not only the work we do for lawn and garden, but work that virtually all of the retailers, both in physical locations and online, their use of social media, all of it is rising. My guess is the single area that has fallen, apart from the Super Bowl item, is likely broadcast and cable television, I think, given that people are growing increasingly savvy regarding our online spend, more and more so. Still, it is 100% different. Yet without question, we are — Mike is running things from a very aggressive standpoint. And in my view that's the correct approach. When you look at our sales forecast, that initial sales forecast, my recollection for consumer was roughly 0 to negative 5. We simply will not accept that, all right? So retailers just wouldn’t go for it, which raises the issue of what steps will be taken to guarantee a different outcome. And when I speak about how things stand between me and Mike and the operating community, here’s what truly benefits me — and I believe shareholders too, though for my own part — Mike belongs to that category of people who move through things with real intelligence. The two of us discuss what we can do to bring consumers in, retain the ones already with us, and push the business harder if possible. Keep in mind our perspective — the figure differs somewhat from what you’ve previously been told, yet I consider it careful and better defined. Looking across Hawthorne and Scotts, the entire consumer side, we likely gave up close to $300 million in sales during the prior year because we couldn’t ship. Consequently, virtually no retailers were actually running promotions, apart from certain hardware chains, and we extend enormous credit to them for that effort and for their courage amid the unknown. Yet nobody was promoting during the prior year. The product we required wasn’t available. So that — when I tell Mike we aim to hold onto those customers and expand the business where possible, that’s entirely unlike the guidance — what we handed to you folks of 0 to minus 5; that’s the subject of our discussions, and Mike’s operating plan looks very different, highly aggressive, yet not so locked in that we can’t adjust should everything fail to align; and at this moment, if you’re taking a single thing away from this call, it’s having roughly plus 40 first quarter POS, as I recall, and by month’s end, around plus 35 or some nonsense along those lines. My take? It gives us considerable confidence that the consumer isn’t heading somewhere other than where our plan currently points. So yes, you observe substantial inventory buildup, but you’re likewise seeing — and I mean right now, where conditions are favorable, Florida, Southern California, and so forth — truly outstanding POS sales growth. So it’s quite an exciting period; that’s a solid question. Cory, I’m not sure whether you’d like to assemble it all numerically — what’s going on with SG&A for the year.
Cory Miller
executiveYes. Thanks, Jim. If we look at the shifts in SG&A, most of that growth will come from media and marketing. We also plan to put some extra money into real-time analytics, which should help us get better results from our media marketing work, plus there are some upgrades we want to make in our supply chain and with our sales team. So when you consider the increases we highlighted, most of them fall under media market.
Eric Bosshard
analystPerhaps I could get a bit more clarity here. From what I'm hearing, you're pulling roughly 100 basis points from gross margin compared with the prior guidance, tacking on $25 million to SG&A, and leaving the sales outlook untouched. So it feels like we're getting the pessimistic scenario for margin while sales get nothing. That's really an observation, I suppose. My question then would be this: does what you're describing on the margin side only materialize if the sales side turns out stronger? Or are we looking at a higher cost of doing business overall?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveFine; that question has a lot of layers. Let me be as candid as I possibly can. When we established the '21 guidance — keep in mind the situation we were in at that time. Nobody had any idea how COVID would play out; at least during my time here, we'd never seen such a wide gap between our own internal figures and the guidance we gave to The Street; and given all the unknowns, we believed that gap was warranted, alright? And on top of that, it still delivered a great result on the earnings side. That's more or less how we rationalized it to ourselves. Take the Hawthorne business, for instance — they simply keep surpassing the numbers; so essentially our only option was to pull back the Hawthorne top line figure for the year, simply because defending it was going to become impossible, alright? On Consumer, we're near that point. We just couldn't quite close the gap. We devoted a great deal of internal discussion to this; so part of what you're picking up on, Eric, is a tension that was always present but not particularly visible. It will grow increasingly visible as time goes on. But keep in mind our reason for doing it; we did it because our knowledge was so limited, and we didn't want to come in below expectations when we could essentially commit to, or at minimum guide toward, what we viewed as a strong outcome with minimal growth. And we thought — once more, that gap was enormous; I don't believe we could have kept that discussion going logically where Hawthorne is concerned, yet I don't think we've lifted the earnings figure for it. My sense is we merely said be careful about sales gross margin or words to that effect. I think that was simply — but it's more about trying to hold the line where we are and retain people so that — I don't want to lose this war, because you're among the finest analysts around, man, maybe the finest, when it comes to grasping the business; so I understand the difficulty you're raising. So as I said, on a Consumer figure we were close, that's what we're telling you. So I believe if you go through the script closely, you'll notice we've grown more confident, and in a way we've gone past the upper bound of that range. Those are approximately the terms being used out there, I'd say. And we simply don't want to revise our cash flow figures or our EPS figures at this point until we gain a bit more visibility. So your question lands right in the middle of that, meaning I sort of can't assist you there because — yet I do understand how difficult it is. And in some measure, that's precisely what you're compensated for: to sort of hear our gibberish and determine what you take from it. But I think you're correct, if that's any help.
Eric Bosshard
analystAll right. All right. Next question, somewhat separate: regarding last year's promotional activity, the retailers pulled back significantly. Sales performed well. What's the plan right now, or the expectation, when it comes to their involvement in promotions this year? Does that have a bearing on your profitability? And what do you figure that implies for how it affects volumes in Consumer during '21?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveI'd say it's enormous. So saying that if we hit Mike's numbers, our numbers are going to look much better on the things you folks focus on is no overstatement. So that, I believe, is basically a given; so if you take that and ask, "Where do the retailers stand? Are they embracing this?" It's crazy. Retailers aren't simply purchasing the inventory because they want it. They intend to sell it. And every one of them has plans to move that product off the shelf, and so do we. The piece of the issue that is — it isn't an issue; we — Eric, we discussed this — we've discussed this for years. I never could truly get the retailers on board with this dedication to Black Friday events. But we've discussed this during our calls, which is that when you examine Black Friday events, they're incredibly expensive. They usually come early in the season, and we usually didn't get the weather we hoped for, so when we ran them, they weren't very effective. They badly hurt margins. Mostly, I believe because — they were expensive for us, but they were equally very expensive for the retailers from a margin standpoint. I believe there's a far more refined approach to promotion now than there was back then. And much of that stems from what everyone learned during COVID. But I believe there's a very strong and refined marketing strategy supporting all the retailers. And I've never witnessed a more aligned group of people who understand that lawn and garden is a hugely important category to kick the year off with; and I also believe that, look, your reports are always among those things that contain many perspectives on the retail-merchant relationship, what's sitting on the shelf. From what I understand, there is — it's tough to obtain a lot of the offshore-sourced patio merchandise. And so — no, I think our space has gotten better too since our product is in stock. And so I'm not sure, Mike, is there anything you'd dispute in what I just said?
Mike Lukemire
executiveAbsolutely not. Plus, in my view, when it comes to targeting and store traffic, they've grown considerably more advanced. That said, Eric, they're going to run promotions, and that will either look different or deliver stronger results. On top of that, they picked up plenty of lessons over this year. So I believe things will improve for the two of them.
Jonathan Andersen
analystI'd like to ask about the more recent customers or households that have come on board since COVID began. What do you know, or what have you discovered, regarding these new or so-called reentry consumers and how loyal they are to the category? My reason for asking is simply to draw out what underpins the confidence, or level of confidence, that you have about retaining them after COVID.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveThat's a fair question, I'd say. Mike, once I finish riffing on it a bit, you'll handle this. If you examine our figures across the last several years — and as a management team, plus with our Board, we devote a great deal of time internally to discussing the fundamental assumptions built into our incentive plans and similar items, and what those were meant to address — but when — we're now in the final year of that multiyear long-term incentive plan, and for anyone participating, it's performing quite well; and — but if you look at those assumptions, we viewed the Consumer business as roughly a 0% to 2% business. And live goods and hydroponics, we viewed as about 2 to 3x that. So if diversification into some faster-growing categories, such as live goods and Hawthorne, were possible, we considered that a positive. What we've observed — and this predates COVID, so it covers a couple of years before COVID — is that everybody assumed young people would remain in metropolitan areas, living in apartments and condos, with no desire for a yard. And it was crazy near, I believe, was the first person to tell me those metrics are bulls***. When it comes to homes, nobody knows more, I think, than we do, Jim, at Depot. And we began examining those figures, and we said, we're seeing a lot of — and then we brought on demographers to study it, and we saw it reflected in our own data, that 0% to 2% turned into roughly 3% to 4% or 3% to 5%; and this is before COVID, all right? So I think we began noticing a shift like what you were describing even prior to COVID. What's evident in COVID is that the home experience matters to people, a yard matters, being able to spend time with their families matters, everything that we essentially stand for, even more so. And then, looking at the demographics, whether it's AeroGarden — Chris, I don't know, what were AeroGarden sales for this last period?
Chris Hagedorn
executiveSo far for the year, they're up over 100%.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveRegarding AeroGarden and indoor cultivation among the younger demographic, that's up over 100%. Broadly speaking, when you examine indoor growing overall, the figure is greater. When it comes to herbs and vegetables, younger folks show a fairly substantial level of dedication. So what's my take? My take is that we genuinely appeal to them. Then there's the matter Eric raised — can we keep these customers around? That's the difficulty we're currently working through. I doubt you'd discover — I doubt what you'd uncover is diminished dedication to this area. Our survey results indicate that among those who took part this year, the overwhelming majority not only plan to do it once more, but lean toward doing it on an even larger scale. That holds for my wife and me too, though we don't fall into that younger group. Still, I suspect we're actually quite representative — meaning we desire — we'd never truly grown our own garden previously. It sounds almost pitiful to admit. Others had always handled it for us. Here, we did it on our own. We figured out what succeeded and what failed, and we're after a superior garden. This mattered greatly to us. We would return — if we'd been away for a day, the very first thing we'd ask was, "How's the garden doing?" It was almost as if it were one of our children. Many others shared that feeling. So Mike, would you like to discuss what we're doing to retain people and just how crucial the younger gardeners are to us?
Mike Lukemire
executiveOkay, so we're in touch with them daily, even just in terms of what's happening with media. There's a huge amount of analytics available to us. Jim and I are right here, and we're hearing from every marketer about how we're connecting when we engage — our approach with the consumer is simply different; it isn't the conventional gardener perspective, if you think about it. And from that, I believe — it's — we are — what they're telling us centers on convenience; we've ramped up our D2C efforts, making it easier to get in. They're looking for more information. Food matters greatly — food supply and safety — and within that engagement space there's curiosity about enhancing the entire home. And we're receiving that — the data we have now is far superior to anything we've ever had in our discussions, and it was linked to the marketing push. After that, we're going to develop products. We've built some digitally native brands that connect more effectively and — such as Knock! Knock! and Lunarly, which are connected to their home and their improvement, plus Greendigs, which covers the whole — now consider your home, a plant inside your home and how that impacts the cosmetics of your home and betters your design; so we're far more engaging and dialed in — and our innovation is connected and our communication is connected to these people more than at any previous point. So — and so — and that's our method for trying to win them over and speak with them. And I mean, I'm likely more optimistic, I could keep going. But we're receiving feedback, and we're communicating with them and connecting with them, and it's taking place.
Jonathan Andersen
analystYeah, that tracks for me. What prompted my question is that tending your yard and putting in a garden involves a real degree of dedication, and you get a real degree of payoff from doing it, and that payoff seems to stretch out further than what you'd get from buying some other product or doing some other activity. So that's useful. My second question concerns Hawthorne. You mentioned this briefly, but I'd like to hear about your signature brands. From what you're saying, it sounds like you're shifting that portion of the portfolio, or you expect to shift it, so it represents 70% of the business. What has that figure looked like in the past? And where do you see it landing going forward? Then, on Hawthorne's margins, roughly 13% on a segment margin basis this quarter. What longer-term target do you have for profitability in that segment? And is your focus at present more on — if I had to frame it as a choice — driving sales growth through aggressive pricing, or expanding profit through more rational pricing? Could you discuss how you balance those two objectives? So once more: the mix with signature brands, the margin goals, and your competitive positioning?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveLook, I'll begin and then pass it to Chris. I believe we do distribute products. We have several very important partner companies, and I want to make sure they know we aren't trying to shoot them in the head in the areas where we distribute. What we see as our key pillars — our thinking is that we can rationalize the line. And so a portion of those activities, we're going to own. And I — but I don't think that comes as any surprise, and I think you can examine our business and see where that sits. As for the guidance I'm giving Mike and Chris, I'd describe the environment out there as a bit more competitive than it used to be. I think mostly, there are other smart people who look at valuations out there and say we ought to participate. So it's — no, that doesn't scare me at all. It's not as if we're saying, "Oh, poor us, it's competitive." But I think my leaning with them is — I think I'm probably still leaning slightly this way, and I've got a lot of salesman in me, I think, and that leaning is toward — for growth. I don't think it would be — I don't think choosing to say — because by the way, I am bothered like a son of a b**** about what's happening with some of the commodities that I think are completely unjustified when it comes to pricing and that you're hearing about kind of for the first time from us, but we're kind of on it right now as well. All this stuff about plastics, ocean freight, domestic freight, insurance — it's a whole lot of garbage, the way people are charging what they're charging for that. To me, that's genuinely terrible for America. And yes, I believe it's genuinely terrible for America, yet the people sitting on UDC now figure they ought to push tax rates up 33% on businesses like ours. Honestly, it's like, what on earth? So when these folks talk about sales growth, I've got my biases. As far as competing goes, I'm completely in favor of it. And at this moment, I wouldn't choose to charge an outsized amount on pricing. We've taken a hard look at the Hawthorne programs and streamlined them; there are infinitely fewer versions of our programs now, they're tightly focused, particularly around competition, which — that's something we like. Anyway, I don't want to hog all your time...
Chris Hagedorn
executiveAll right. So look, he already said most of the...
Jim Hagedorn
executiveApologies, Chris.
Chris Hagedorn
executiveNo worries. Regarding the mix of what we own—our so-called signature brands—versus distributed goods, 70% is likely around the target we're aiming for; that's roughly 20 points above our historical level. One key point to keep in mind: before the Sunlight Supply transaction 3 years ago, Hawthorne wasn't a distributor in any way. We only moved our own items. So when we brought in Sunlight—which now serves as something like the distribution center for Hawthorne—we've been reshaping that operation into what we envision rather than what it used to be. I'd say that work likely isn't finished, though I believe we're significantly nearer to completion than before. And certainly, some categories exist that, for various reasons—perhaps the nature of that business falls outside our expertise—we won't manufacture them, or whatever the case may be. Certain items our customers will forever demand that we may not wish to produce ourselves. As Jim mentioned, we have several vital strategic supplier allies whom we have zero plans to leave, and they collaborate with us exceptionally well. I concur with Jim about striking a balance between advancing and preserving market share versus profit. I believe we remain—we've spent roughly 6 years on this at Hawthorne. I still consider us in this sector's early stages and, I believe, lean toward acting boldly to keep or capture more share wherever necessary. I do believe we can somewhat have things both ways here—as we proceed—as Jim noted, we had more than 20,000 distinct promotional initiatives, mostly something we took on from all the companies we bought and Sunlight, where each had separate arrangements with particular dealers and particular retailers. We've undergone a truly thorough effort during the last year and streamlined it considerably, as Jim stated. So we're still running promotions, and I believe we're doing so far more intelligently and with greater precision. Jim touched on the rivalry. We addressed it in the prepared remarks—there are companies going public in this area, raising substantial capital, and acting very aggressively. I believe we must treat that rivalry seriously; we do. I believe we leverage our portfolio's breadth, every product we provide, together with focused promotion to ensure we protect our share. Thus my inclination will favor expansion over profit. Yet once more, I believe we can produce fairly solid margin figures while also pursuing growth targets. Cory, could you share your thoughts on the longer-term margin figures for Hawthorne? Clearly, that's an area you've been focused on for quite a few years.
Cory Miller
executiveOkay, thank you, Chris. Jon, as you know, if we look back a few years, we discussed aiming to reach 15% for segment earnings percentage, and we are still working toward hitting that goal. So we are weighing the path to 15% against what we spend, what we put into promotions, and what it takes to go out and gain more space. And we will keep at it. Growing the category matters to us. Growing Hawthorne inside the category matters to us. So our focus will stay there. But we never forget that our objective is returning to that 15% segment; and one more thing regarding signature brand mix. When you examine signature brands and the expansion we have achieved, much of that expansion comes from the innovation in our products. A major portion of our signature brands is our lighting portfolio. We brought out an LED light just over a year ago. And the expansion from that LED light, together with the other lights we sell in the market, has really pushed up our total lighting business, which lifts the signature brand mix along with it. That said, we believe 70% is roughly correct; and we do not intend to move away from that figure and push it higher or lower.
Jonathan Andersen
analystThat's genuinely, genuinely useful. I'll bend the rules and fit one additional question in, if there's room. I just wanted to ask about Roundup. My understanding is that you may have been approaching some decision points regarding Roundup and the relationship with Bayer. Is there any news on that front — milestones, thinking, or plans for that business?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveYes. As it happens, I'm looking at my lawyer through a video link; that's a fair question. The answer is affirmative. There was a chance for us to exit the relationship, I'm not sure, roughly 3 weeks back. We proceeded — across the last, let's say, 18 months, each and every Board meeting included a portion on, as we approached that decision, what our course would be. And with the Board having quite open, very clear sight of that decision — or at minimum the recommendation management put forward, which was to allow that option to lapse — the — I won't claim anyone handled this flawlessly. One thing I can say: on our own, we have confidence in the product's safety. That's due to the work we've done ourselves to examine it. Sitting on our Board is a future EPA administrator who likewise carried an outsized voice while we reached these decisions. So we — the product's safety sits very comfortably with us. Broadly, I back Bayer's efforts to move past this. And I'd say they have — a great deal of progress has been achieved there. We weighed what Roundup contributes to our business against what that option was worth to us, and we simply felt at ease carrying on. And so — and the business keeps performing strongly in — not just last year, but has gone on performing strongly through the first quarter. So the answer is affirmative: an option did exist for us. It wasn't particularly appealing to us, and we chose to keep going. So Ivan, is there anything you'd like to add?
Ivan Smith
executiveNo. I believe you've expressed that nicely. We've held discussions with Bayer regarding this matter throughout the months, and we feel at ease with the way they're managing their exposure to it, plus we keep seeing solid retail performance in our consumer engagement. So given every one of those factors you mentioned, Jim, I think we've made the call to leave that behind.
Alex Maroccia
analystThe first question I have is directed at Chris. It's clear that cannabis has been the main item in recent headlines regarding Hawthorne. That said, could you describe for us what the vertical farming sector looks like at present, and talk about whether your partners in that area are expanding?
Chris Hagedorn
executiveSure. We do pay attention to vertical farming. It was, without question, among the earliest guiding principles, in a sense, for the nation of Hawthorne. To be frank, the level of expansion we had anticipated there hasn't materialized. My view is that producing food profitably under that kind of setup, in the form it takes today, is difficult; yet more and more capital keeps flowing in. Kimbal Musk, who is Elon Musk's brother, has been putting money in aggressively. A great many newcomers have been coming into this area and trying to get it to succeed; we certainly support all of that. Many of the items we've brought to market, even though our development efforts and our marketing are aimed at the cannabis segment, can be applied to — and indeed get used in — vertical farming operations; even so, at this moment I wouldn't call it a particularly significant portion of what we do. Once more, we keep promoting our offerings in that space as a kind of secondary priority for us. Still, at this point, I'd describe it as being at such an early stage, and it isn't truly something that's...
Alex Maroccia
analystDoes the situation look any different over in Europe?
Chris Hagedorn
executiveIt's something we're keeping an eye on. Over in Europe, yes, things are different. What you're noticing — I would put it this way: the difference in Europe applies less to vertical farming companies and more to indoor growing overall. That's genuinely the area where our business in Europe is mostly focused. And we're witnessing solid, robust expansion there, especially in our lighting segment, as we keep seeing additional greenhouses for producing food get constructed. But over here in the U.S., I believe it's — we're still at a point that's too early to truly make a call.
Alex Maroccia
analystAll right, that helps. Now let's switch topics for a moment. In what way will you evaluate the payoff from the money put into the Super Bowl ad compared with other promotional efforts you've undertaken previously? Obviously, it's the broadcast with the biggest audience each year, but I'm simply attempting to understand how the viewer overlap varies substantially from your usual focused advertising outlay, or a few individuals simply strolling into stores and noticing goods displayed prominently?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveI suppose I'll handle this one. I'm hardly the greatest authority on the subject. Back when I initially began overseeing a business I was accountable for, that was our English operation. This reveals my age somewhat, yet the U.K. had merely 4 channels: 2 belonged to the BBC with no commercials; and 2 were ITV channels, roughly one airing standard shows and one more like educational programming; so essentially there was just a single flagship channel; and a program existed back then named Coronation Street, to which around 40% or so of every television set in the U.K. was tuned, making it an incredibly effective purchase. Those same qualities belong to the Super Bowl. You simply get a genuinely massive audience. Much of what appeals to us, I believe, is the demographics. There are younger viewers, I believe, and plenty of men. So it matters for specific segments of our company. Thus, I believe that when examining a sort of cost per $1,000, it — and you examine things like contemporary, I'm not sure what — be it YouTube, Facebook, or Instagram, and you consider the sort of strength — TikTok, those purchases carry considerable strength when it comes to reach. The Super Bowl, I think, resembles that. We generally leaned toward spending on things like basketball a bit afterward, March Madness type of content; we never truly advanced to that — its scale. What we're attempting at present, along with keeping what we desire for fresh buyers, the ones we already had from the previous year that we regarded as something deserving of the effort. And the fascinating aspect is that the activation surrounding it lasts roughly 8 weeks. It includes something like a sweepstakes component. Every single one among the talent, the sort of individuals we've enlisted, all of whom are genuinely compelling, we can promote toward every one of them, and every one of them possesses somewhat distinct demographics. And I believe it aligns nicely with our current activities. I think folks were waving things at me, attempting to make me read, "Stop." All right. So I believe it's a quite intriguing approach for us to sort of tackle our problem this year, namely keeping the people who came aboard. Plus it dovetails nicely with plenty of the social media efforts we've got underway. And as I see it, the marketing crew is absolutely at the top of their game on this, with Mike and me basically imposing hardly any restrictions regarding the way we go after these consumers — "go after" in the sense of how we reach out and market ourselves to them. Mike, anything you'd like to tack on?
Mike Lukemire
executiveTo me, the way gardening gets defined really matters across that entire — and we are pushing on it extremely hard. And so — and it gives us a way to cascade and reset alongside all these new consumers. And so — and I believe that is establishing the tone for where we are headed as opposed to how we historically viewed it. So I feel optimistic it will prove very effective, since I have much higher numbers than the ones we are sharing. But — and so...
Alex Maroccia
analystAlright, that answers my question well.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveIs that all? Would you like to explain the situation with Roundup, or not? Are we of the view...
Jim King
executiveJim King? Go ahead, Jim.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveIn case that wasn't obvious — and it has to be, since somehow we're hearing things back — we've remained in this partnership, and we haven't used any option to exit the arrangement with Bayer. So when it comes to Roundup, our relationship with Bayer carries on. Just wanted to make that clear if it wasn't already.
Jim King
executiveOkay, Catherine, that looks like every question we had lined up today, so thanks to all of you for being here. Over the coming couple of weeks, we'll put out press releases about our involvement in the Truist event as well as the Raymond James event. And once more, if anyone has additional questions and would like to contact me personally today or at any point this week, my number is (937) 578 to 5622. Thank you all for taking part, and we'll speak with you again before long.
Operator
operatorThat concludes today's presentation. Thank you for your participation. You may now disconnect.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.