The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company (SMG) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
May 5, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Jim King
executiveHello, everybody, and good morning. My name is Jim King, and I want to extend a warm welcome as we begin Scotts Mircle-Gro's conference call covering second quarter earnings. With me today are Jim Hagedorn, who serves as our Chairman and CEO; Cory Miller, our Interim Chief Financial Officer; Mike Lukemire, our President and Chief Operating Officer; and Chris Hagedorn, Group President of Hawthorn. Shortly, Jim and Cory will deliver some prepared remarks, after which we will take your questions; because time is limited, please limit yourself to one question plus one follow-up. I have already arranged time with a number of you following this call so we can fill in the gaps. If you would like to schedule some Q&A time, reach me directly by phone at (937) 578 to 5622, and we will arrange something as quickly as possible. A brief housekeeping note: Cory and I will take part in the William Blair Growth Stock Conference in early June, and once again it will be a virtual event. As a lot of you are aware, we have traditionally treated this event as a chance to bring the investment community up to date on how the business stands coming out of the critical month of May; further information about the event's date and time will be published a couple of weeks beforehand. That said, let's proceed with today's call; as usual, we anticipate making forward-looking statements, so I want to warn everyone that what actually happens could differ materially from what we say, and investors ought to make themselves familiar with the complete range of risk factors that might affect our results, all of which are filed in our form 10 K, filed with the securities and exchange commission. I also want to note that we are recording today's call, and an archived version will be posted on our Web site. With that, let's begin. I will now hand the call over to Jim Hagedorn. Jim.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAppreciate it, Jim, and hello everybody. My remarks this morning will take just a short while. During our analyst day gathering a few weeks back, we laid out a fairly thorough outlook, and there's no need for me to restate the central points the rest of the team covered that day. The key message from today's announcement and from this call is this: the business is still incredibly robust, and our confidence about delivering yet another outstanding year keeps growing. Within our US consumer segment, retailers continue to be very supportive, and consumers are fully engaged as we head into the busiest weeks of the lawn and garden season. Entering May, POS is running up about 25%, and recent weeks show promising momentum as we start lapping last year's record numbers. Over at Hawthorne, this past April gave us our largest four week sales month on record, which extends the momentum from our record first half and gives us the confidence to lift our sales guidance yet again. The innovation we highlighted at analyst day remains a key engine for this business, and it's helping widen the gap between Hawthorne and its rivals. The sole piece of negative news stems from matters outside our control, namely the cost environment. Like nearly every other company that most of you track, we keep dealing with substantial commodity inflation. So I'd actually like to start my comments right there, then move on to discuss each business briefly. Cory will tell you that margin pressure is running heavier than we anticipated, and as our press release showed, we're responding with forceful measures. Starting in the fourth quarter, we're putting through a price increase in the mid to high single digit range across our US consumer business, which will extend into fiscal 2022. We made a comparable increase at Hawthorne. Across roughly the last 15 years, we've raised prices in all but a handful of years. Typically, it comes to under 100 basis points. Pricing at that level has let us keep innovating, has let us spend more on marketing, has let us build a more technically skilled selling process at Hawthorne, and has let us make sure we're developing our people across every level and location of the organization. I'm not fond of price increases of this magnitude, plain and simple. Elasticity doesn't concern me in the consumer business, and the Hawthorne increase hasn't affected our order volume. Still, I'd rather have modest, consistent hikes than a move like the one we're making this summer. That being said, every raw material we purchase today costs materially more than we'd planned. Distribution expenses have risen as well. Therefore, we will take the steps necessary to safeguard the profit structure of the company so we can preserve the capabilities required to keep the business in good shape and act the way a sector leader ought to act; we feel lucky to operate in 2 exceptionally durable categories. We feel lucky to have obviously distinct operations that possess genuine competitive strengths. Thus, provided we stay dedicated to providing value to the individuals who purchase our goods, I think we can move these higher prices through with minimal or no interruption to the company. Having said that, let's shift to discuss our US consumer business, since we keep surpassing our own projections, and that is creating the possibility of upside relative to the guidance we updated only 1 month ago. At our Analyst Day meeting, we adjusted our sales guidance for the US consumer business to a range of 4% to 6% following last year's 24% growth; nevertheless, it is already starting to appear that this forecast was overly cautious. At present, consumers are acting nearly precisely as they informed us they would. Heading into the season, 86% of consumers who joined the category last year said they would return. Even more significantly, two thirds of them, meaning they would aim at a level that is even higher than what they reached last year. In the week following our Analyst Day event, we recorded our first ever $200 million week of POS with our top four retail partners. Measured across an entire month, April POS climbed roughly 25% even after accounting for an extremely challenging comparison in the final week of the month, plus the effect of a late burst of winter weather across the Midwest and Northeast that kept consumers indoors the week before. As was the case last year, gardening activity keeps setting the pace. As we enter May, consumer purchases of our soils have risen approximately 30%. Our long fertilizer business increased 15% year to date, and grass seed is higher by more than 35% as we enter May; this marks the third consecutive year of double digit growth in grass seed as we keep gaining from the extraordinary work of our lawns’ R&D team. Controlled products have risen about 20%. As we enter May, we are still up double digit across every region of the country with every major retailer; we keep observing a high degree of engagement across all retail channels. Keep in mind, however, May is a crucial portion of the business. We face a difficult comparison for the remainder of the year, and we anticipate giving back part of our first half POS gains; yet the degree of consumer and retail engagement is stronger than we had anticipated and is making us confident that we might achieve some extra upside volume on a full year basis. Since a large portion of the year remains ahead of us, we won't be adjusting the sales figure once more this morning, though an update will come in early June. That said, as you're aware, we are once again revising the Hawthorne figures this morning, since that operation keeps exceeding every expectation we've set. The second quarter represented the fifth consecutive period in which Hawthorne posted sales growth of no less than 60%. On a fiscal year-to-date basis, the business now stands 68% higher. Strong gains continue across every Hawthorne category, particularly lighting in North America. Cory will walk through the specifics shortly. Still, I want to praise the team for how they're running things at present. Our dedication to innovation, together with our 360 selling process, is showing up as a real competitive edge. Not only are we generating growth, we keep widening the gap between us and our rivals while establishing the benchmark for the industry. Though market share is hard to measure in this area, we're certain we're growing faster than our competitors. Hydro retailers recognize the obvious benefit of partnering closely with Hawthorne, and commercial growers keep viewing us as the undisputed leader here. If you haven't watched the presentations we posted last month, I'd urge you to visit our IR Web site and take them in. You'll soon grasp how and why this business is doing so well. Growth at Hawthorne persists across every geography. California, our biggest market, climbed 80% during the quarter. Michigan gained 60%, and we recorded triple digit growth in seven states, among them Oklahoma, where the business expanded 250% versus last year's second quarter. Beyond the existing marketplace, since November, eight additional states, including three within the past two months, have either broadened their current markets or permitted cannabis cultivation for the first time. Regardless of whether federal reform arrives under this administration, the momentum at the state level clearly isn't easing up; more markets will open and generate further opportunities for growth. And I'm certain we'll keep expanding our wings in the years ahead, leveraging our competitive advantages to fuel growth and further entrench our leadership in this space. Whether at Hawthorne or the US Consumer business, we remain in an excellent position right now. The team is firing on all cylinders. Every aspect of the business is strong. The M&A pipeline holds plenty of potential, and we have enormous financial flexibility. I know I've said this for several years running, yet I can't recall ever feeling this optimistic about our future; and I want our shareholders to know we take nothing for granted. We see opportunity out there, but we know success won't simply fall into our lap; we've got to go out and capture it. I'm certain we have the right team and the right strategy to do exactly that. Having said that, I'll now hand things over to Cory, who will walk us through the financials.
Cory Miller
executiveAppreciate it, Jim, and good morning to all of you. During my Analyst Day comments, I made a joke about how I've been lucky enough to report upbeat numbers just about every single time I've addressed the public since stepping into this new position. And once more, here I am, sharing results from yet another solid quarter and, again, able to revise our guidance upward. Clearly, the good news for this quarter keeps centering on the robust top line expansion across both businesses. That said, we're beginning to encounter somewhat greater margin pressure than we had anticipated. Per Jim's comments, that trend will probably persist through Q3 and afterward start to flatten out. I'll address the margin topic shortly, but first let me cover sales for the quarter. Sales across the whole company rose 32% during the quarter, and year-to-date we're up 47%. At the beginning of the year, we stated that by the halfway mark we'd be running ahead of our full year guidance, yet this is surpassing even those projections. The US Consumer business climbed 23% for the quarter and sits at 39% year-to-date. We kept benefiting from retailers stocking up early in the season, although the quarter's overall growth rate also lined up with the percentage of year-over-year POS growth; typically we don't dwell on the Other segment, which is mostly our Canadian business; even so, that business jumped 82% in the quarter and 75% year-to-date. That means growth for the quarter was worth over $40 million. Canada's situation closely mirrors the US. Consumers are deeply engaged, and retailers are boosting their inventory levels to remain ahead of demand; it's also worth pointing out that the Other segment's profitability has risen sharply this year; we aren't really putting much additional investment into that business, so the gains are dropping quite directly to the bottom line. Returning to the US segment. As Jim mentioned, following the robust figures we delivered in April, we see the possibility of upside to our recently updated guidance. Retailers keep placing orders aggressively, since they anticipate consumer demand will persist through the rest of the season. Because of the difficult POS comps coming in May, we'd like greater clarity before adjusting our guidance at all. With Hawthorne, though, that's clearly not the situation. We closed the quarter with a record sales month in March, which contributed to the 66% growth reflected in the press release. US lighting sales during the quarter rose by over 95%, while sales of growing environment products climbed almost 110%. Consumables also grew strongly, driven by growth exceeding 45% in growing media and 40% in nutrients. Momentum then continued into April, another record month, giving us a powerful start to Q3. That's why we feel confident enough to lift our Hawthorne guidance once more, to a range of 30% to 40% growth on a full year basis. At this point, our company-wide EPS guidance has not been changed; another revision will probably come in June, when we refresh the status of the US Consumer segment. Like Jim mentioned, margin pressure downward is greater than we had anticipated, and it is canceling out a large portion of the gains from Hawthorne. Actually, because the lower margin Hawthorne business is growing at a faster rate, its effect on our gross margin rate is larger than we had planned when the year began. Adjusted company wide gross margins fell 340 basis points during the quarter, landing at 36.6%. Through March, on a year-to-date basis, the rate came in at 33.7%, versus 34.8% during the same period a year ago. Although Hawthorne segment mix contributes heavily to that decline, commodity and distribution costs represent the largest problem. This pressure is outweighing by more than a little the substantial fixed cost leverage that the greater volume running through our supply chain has provided. Gross margin rate pressure will probably persist into Q3, and that is why our full year expectation now calls for a decline of 175 to 225 basis points. As Jim noted, we have already acted aggressively with pricing decisions at Hawthorne, and in our US Consumer business we will implement a sizable price increase too. Later in the year, these increases ought to start helping us, and they clearly will leave us better positioned as we build out our business plans for fiscal '22. Worth remembering is that we came into fiscal '21 having negotiated a planned price increase for our US Consumer segment, set to take effect in August and then carry through fiscal '22; yet as commodity prices kept rising, we adopted an even more aggressive stance. Being the industry leader in this category, we accepted the duty to keep innovating and to put money into marketing efforts that drive consumer engagement. Those investments require margin, and our choice lets us keep investing in the business in the manner our retail partners would anticipate. Turning to SG&A, it rose 18% in the quarter and 23% through the first six months. Higher planned marketing and media costs, along with larger accruals for variable pay, explain the increase. In Q3, though, the variable pay effect on our P&L will start to reverse, and together with lower stock based compensation it should still deliver a full year benefit of $50 million or more. I also want to point out that our SG&A guidance remains unchanged for now, projecting a year-over-year decline of 3% to 8%. That said, as potential upside begins to appear in the US Consumer business, we will likely use some of it, should it materialize as we expect, to invest further in our brands. Our focus with those investments isn't on seeing returns within this fiscal year. Instead, they're meant to keep deepening the connection we have with our customers and to propel the company forward in the years ahead too. Between SG&A and the bottom line, there isn't much to report, so unless you'd like to address the remaining parts of the P&L during Q&A, I'll skip them. On a non-GAAP adjusted basis — the figure our guidance relies on, which leaves out restructuring, impairment, and nonrecurring items — earnings came in at $322.3 million, equal to $5.64 per share. A year ago, that figure stood at $253.8 million, or $4.50 per share. As I mentioned, for the time being we're keeping our full year adjusted EPS guidance where it is, spanning $8.60 to $9 per share. Hitting the top of that range would mean our earnings more than doubled across a mere two year stretch. Turning briefly to the balance sheet. We ended the quarter with a leverage ratio of 2.1 times debt to EBITDA. As we shared with you last month, the pipeline currently holds a fair number of M&A opportunities, yet our capacity far exceeds what's needed to pursue the investments we're after, all while boosting our CapEx and giving cash back to shareholders. Looking forward, you might see us return to the bond market to raise additional capital and secure long term debt at today's rates. Although that could dilute results in the near term, we think securing funds at these elevated rates pays off over time, provided you share our assumption that rates will climb from here. Last, you'll see that CapEx is trailing the $125 million to $150 million investment Jim and I talked about with you last month. In most years, the bulk of our CapEx spending lands in the back half of the year, and we'd expect the same pattern to hold this year. That keeps us positioned to hit our revised guidance of roughly $250 million in free cash flow, which we calculate as operating cash flow minus CapEx. In closing, I wholeheartedly share the sentiment Jim expressed moments ago. Apart from commodity prices, which none of us can control, this business is performing at a level I haven't witnessed in my 20 year tenure here. My confidence in our guidance is very high. I see room to perform even better, and I believe we're setting the company up well as we kick off planning for fiscal 2022. With that, I'll hand things back to the operator, and we'll open the call up for your questions.
Jonathan Andersen
analystLet's start with Hawthorne. Jim mentioned, if I recall correctly, that this is the fifth quarter in a row where growth has topped 60%. You've lifted your guidance multiple times now. And for a good while, growth has been running above what you'd earlier framed as more or less a long-term target. In the prepared remarks, you also mentioned the new states that have launched since November, which will probably ramp up considerably over the next 12 to 18 months, and that appears to point to good things ahead for Hawthorne in the years to come. So how do you think about the sustainable growth rate for Hawthorne over the next two to three years? Why wouldn't that business keep growing at the faster pace you've shown lately?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveWell, I believe it will. In fact, while you're talking, Cory's over there whispering — which I think is nonsense — but remember, the one time you all really took me to the woodshed was when I said I didn't understand why this business couldn't hold roughly 15% for an extended period, and then 18 came along. And for anyone who's followed us for a while, I'd say that's probably the one remark I'd call a mistake — essentially promising that level of growth. To be honest, I'm on the same page as you. My concern is simply that there will be considerable pushback against locking in a specific figure. I keep trying to remind the team that when we made our move into live goods and Hawthorne, the situation was — well, if you rewind five years, we viewed our core North American Consumer operation as roughly a 1% to 2% grower, and we believed we could achieve something like two to three times that pace at reasonable prices through Hawthorne and live goods. I'd say that has proven accurate. Whether the growth can keep going—this is just how I see it—makes me genuinely happy when I look at it, and that has nothing to do with anything I did. It comes from what Chris, his team, and Mike did in actually constructing the business we laid out for all of you some time back, with these genuinely substantial competitive edges, and I believe we're now arriving at the stage—and I think I put this question to Chris a few weeks ago. Where do we stand on this journey toward becoming what I'd call — and I really dislike the term vendor — the ideal vendor, someone who genuinely performs well and brings real value to our business partners? I think you mentioned something like 80%. So there's still distance to cover. Things like supply chain, innovation, a bit of technical selling, and maybe additional product lines we ought to have in our portfolio. With that said, if you look at the lighting business — a pretty solid example of bringing innovation into the business — I believe that... I don't want to just toss out a figure, but I believe it goes beyond what Cory would feel okay about me stating. I'm not sure whether that responds to your question, but I believe what we're building is a business all of us ought to be genuinely proud of. Cory, please go ahead. Cory would like to add something. Perhaps we can hear from Chris if he has a perspective.
Cory Miller
executiveI'd like to piggyback on what was just said. In April, we moved 2 of our sites into bigger, newer spaces so we could boost production, and we also brought a brand-new site online. Because of that, we expect expansion down the road, and we're working to scale up our supply chain so we can send out more goods than we did previously. Like the prepared remarks mentioned, March closed out the quarter strongly, and April was a record quarter — actually a record month. So whenever we bring a site like this online and let our shipment volume rise, our goal is to hit yet another record month ahead. So the growth is…
Jim Hagedorn
executiveSure, you can approach this in a couple of different ways. Jon, I'd say we're probably on our third iteration of the supply chain footprint as the business has expanded. Mike would likely tell you that maybe that was an error — the second iteration was an error — because we didn't think large enough, since we just kind of settled into a facility and then discovered that it wasn't working. We have to do it over again. And it's somewhat stressful. But I believe we're leaving a great deal of sales on the table. So we keep going, I think, in both businesses, to be honest; and a lot of the credit belongs to the supply chain folks for sort of keeping pace; but I think if you asked, are we a strong vendor when it comes to supply chain delivery on time in full. I'm not sure, Mike, what would you say?
Mike Lukemire
executiveMy take is that our performance was improving.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveStill, what grade would you give us?
Mike Lukemire
executiveI'd probably give us a B minus.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveI'd say Cory's point holds up — when we launch a facility, revenue does rise — but that's partly down to us having missed out on orders before because we weren't able to ship them. So some of that is expansion, and some is simply a better fulfillment setup that moves goods out the door more effectively. Chris, is there anything you'd like to add?
Chris Hagedorn
executiveYeah, I believe the two of you have already addressed most of that. Still, I do feel Cory and Luke touched on something — honestly, our service levels aren't where I personally want them to be. Some of our retail partners are likely on this call listening right now, and I imagine they'd sadly share that view. That said, we can still outperform our rivals even while falling short of the benchmark we set for ourselves. Things are getting better fairly quickly, and we're dedicating significant thought, effort, and resources toward strengthening that supply chain. Like Jim, if I let myself speak completely without restraint, I'd probably name a figure that would earn me a scolding from Cory; so I'll hold back — that's something I won't do. Even so, I'm incredibly optimistic regarding where this business is headed. I believe our service levels, which honestly represent our greatest constraint, will keep getting better. There's some M&A in the works that has me very enthusiastic, and it will close critical gaps in products and portfolio brands for us going forward, with those deals expected to wrap up before this fiscal year ends; so I'm genuinely thrilled about this company. I believe we can keep making it better. And I think that, to a significant degree, we've largely been our own biggest obstacle, and we're putting in serious effort to move past that. None of this is meant to downplay how strong and competitive our rivals are. But once more, I believe we've been blocking our own progress, and we're working hard to get past it.
Jonathan Andersen
analystTo follow up quickly regarding what was said about pricing — have you already set prices in Hawthorne? Are they around the same as those you mentioned for US Consumer, mid to high single digit? Also, since you're the leader, do you think rivals will match you, or have you already watched them do so?
Chris Hagedorn
executiveOur pricing has already been implemented, so it has now been available in the market for roughly one month, and we have not observed any effect on volume. Quite the opposite — it has been increasing. So you're saying, man, we should have taken more and we have the chance. And this is one of the way areas we really like the breadth of our portfolio. It lets us implement price changes in quite targeted segments while keeping some categories basically unchanged when it comes to pricing, and that is something we believe we can exploit to a far greater degree than our rivals are able to. As for whether we think competitors will do the same, we do. Usually, what we have observed is that there will be a lag of one or two months behind us before most of our biggest competitors copy us quite closely. So I don't think we have seen that arrive in the market as of yet, but we are sort of just reaching the point where we would anticipate it to be any <<inaudible>>…
Bill Chappell
analystSo my first question is about pricing and when that pricing kicks in. My understanding is that you mentioned it would occur more toward July and August for the US Consumer business, with the season mostly wrapped up around July 4th. I'm just trying to get a sense of whether you're already fully hedged for the bulk of what you need this year, meaning you're simply acting now with an eye toward next year? Or might we see something sooner, like reduced promotions or similar moves, that would affect May and June sales?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveReduced promotions aren't something I expect to see. To be honest, though, retailers are definitely paying close attention to margins at the moment. They're looking at pricing that's all over the map for themselves, I'd say. Still, I don't believe any action <<inaudible>> or any promotional adjustments out in the field on our product lines are coming. That summer increase is something we've discussed for a number of months now, as we watched the pressure sort of accumulate. Every retailer, in my view, is aware of the steps we're taking that are coming their way. I did ask Mike to think about moving the pricing up earlier. He wasn't really keen on doing that, I believe. And I get the reason why. Compared to what people have historically seen from us in the past, it's a pretty large number. It's been quite some time since we've ever — maybe one other instance during my 20 years here — looked at pricing at this sort of level. There's no choice for us here, I think. When Mike has talked with the retailers, he's told them that depending on what happens with commodities, we might need to go out again. But considering people's attitudes, and the limited upside from doing it now, I've grown more comfortable with Mike's stance of wanting to do it near the end of the summer, and that's fine with me. As for hedging, we're pretty typical for where we've been for anyone who tracks us on that front, which doesn't mean we aren't exposed, but I think we've largely been hedged. Even so, seeing some of these increases is still pretty eye watering. Mike, anything you'd like to add?
Mike Lukemire
executiveNo, I believe we had reached an understanding with retailers regarding August pricing, and we did raise the number, and I think we decided to take that path. We're in fairly solid position concerning what remains for us to produce. If any pressure is showing up, it's within particular categories — we're overselling the plant, as with soils, which leads to — you're purchasing at a higher level, so a portion of those elevated costs is arriving somewhat sooner. So for me, that's the pressure we're dealing with. But we examined the gap between May and August, and the amount we would net out from that simply wasn't that significant. So we opted to remain with August.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveOne more point to make sure everyone understands: we chose not to implement any meaningful price increases whatsoever throughout the COVID year, which was last year. And I believe retailers knew quite well that our stance on pricing last year was fairly gentle, since nobody could tell what was going on or that such an approach would be necessary. So a portion of this is simply catching up.
Mike Lukemire
executiveYes, think about it as two years’ worth of pricing here.
Bill Chappell
analystAnd I get that, but what I'm really getting at is a lot of the consumer packaged goods businesses are raising prices to try to bounce back during the back half of the year. You, on the other hand, are sort of doing that in your fiscal fourth quarter. So really, this is more about bouncing back in fiscal '22. Is that accurate — because the pricing you're discussing today doesn't really move the needle much…
Jim Hagedorn
executiveYeah, that's right. That's all there is to it. Again, perhaps on one occasion, back when I first arrived and, I believe, was heading up Miracle-Gro at that point, so I was serving as a segment leader, we implemented a price increase in the middle of the season. But in my view, doing that during the season is quite disruptive for this industry, and it simply triggers chaos, enormous pushback at both the retail and retailer levels against making such a move. So a few weeks back, I told Mike that in my opinion we ought to move it up. That said, I believe they put forward solid reasoning that the couple of months involved aren't worth the headaches it would create.
Bill Chappell
analystAnd you feel good about your guidance without needing to take that step, which is excellent. My next question is about Hawthorne — perhaps another angle on what Jon Andersen asked regarding the source of growth. I realize that with the lighting segment, much of it involved replacements for current clients. Part of that lighting revenue was simply items you couldn't supply last year. So it's a blend you're observing. Does it come from newer states, more recent buyers, or is it still powered mainly by restocking among the customers you already have?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveListen — wait a moment. I'll begin, Chris, if that's alright with you. Honestly — man, you're a friend; and I'm not suggesting this is some scheme to mislead anyone. But I don't believe that's accurate. If you examine the business today, I'd say half of it measured in dollars is LED. That means a significant technological shift is happening in this sector, and Gavita is mostly reaping the rewards. It's enormous; so if you look at things, obviously there's additional state capacity available. Some folks are making the switch; yet I believe a big innovation opportunity exists here. Many of you might be familiar with the general narrative. I think I've shared this with you before — we collaborate very closely with Michael Porter at the Harvard Business School; and Chris along with his group, Mike Lukemire, all traveled there. And we were talking about how we sort of put together various components sourced from suppliers globally. And we sort of trail behind technology that other people — that was in the past, incidentally. And Mike stepped out to use the restroom, returned and everyone appeared shocked when he got back. And he asked, what took place here? And Porter had remarked, man, if all you're going to do is follow others, you need to divest that business since you'll likely receive the maximum amount you'll ever get for it right now. So I'm heading back later in the week with Christopher and he tells me, you won't — I need to inquire how the Porter meeting is progressing and he said, but you won't be happy about this. And my response, I believe, led us to see lighting as a highly important strategic foundation for us within this sector. And I think I mentioned this during the virtual investor meeting. I take such pride in what they've accomplished, where I believe we possess the best LED fixtures by a wide margin and plenty of innovation coming down the line to genuinely propel this business for years to come. And so I think this isn't merely about the market expanding somewhat. Plus there were plenty of orders we were able to fulfill, and folks are saying — existing clients are picking up certain new lights. I believe we've advanced so far as a strategic supplier and innovator within lighting that I think — and anyone who'd like to come see us once COVID tapers off — what I'm telling you is you've got a standing invitation, we can get together here or get together in Oregon and sort of show you what we're up to, but it's impressive. So Mike — or Christopher, you're the one who ought to take this one.
Chris Hagedorn
executiveYeah, I believe you've touched on a great deal of it. There truly is a solid blend overall when it comes to replacement as well as newbuilds. What I mean is, whenever an additional state becomes active, that translates into many new facilities for us, so we are definitely equipping those. We're witnessing expansion in areas such as Oklahoma that keeps surpassing what we had anticipated. As a matter of fact, during the last month, Oklahoma exceeded Michigan for the very first time. So growth there is exploding, and those are newbuilds. I'd like to claim it's 100%, though it's the large majority. Then in areas such as California, newbuilds are still rising, yet we've also — we engineered our lights, especially the LEDs, so they'd function as a replacement product that's as simple as possible. Our new Gavita 1930 fixture was built so it can be swapped straight across, one for one, with an older HPS fixture. Even so, we're still moving an awful lot of our Gavita high pressure sodium line, which we keep improving to make the fixture more affordable, simpler to service, simpler to produce, and simpler for our customers to install. So honestly, we're observing growth everywhere. It's tough to pin it down to any single area.
Cory Miller
executiveAlso, let me mention that roughly half of what we do in lighting comes from LEDs. And when you look at all of our operations across North America, that figure sits at approximately 15%.
Joe Altobello
analystI've got a few things I wanted to ask. The first one is about margins. When you raise prices, is the goal to fully cover the higher costs dollar for dollar, or is your plan to hold your margin structure steady as we move into fiscal '22?
Cory Miller
executiveOur approach to pricing is aimed at keeping our margin structure where it is. Looking at where our margins stand right now, there's been a slight decrease. Part of that comes from the mix across segments, since Hawthorne is a business with lower margins and it's expanding more quickly than the US Consumer business. Companywide, margin is down somewhat; so inside each business, our pricing efforts are focused on preserving that particular business's margin structure.
Joe Altobello
analystSo, based on what you've laid out, with the hedges you've got in place and the pricing that's coming in August, it sounds like we probably shouldn't expect the gross margin outlook for '21 to move lower from here?
Cory Miller
executiveAs things stand right now, with commodities where they are and where we expect them to go, our margins should land in a very similar ballpark to this year. We'll keep working through the plan and see whether continued cost increases put any additional pressure on things. But at this point, we're aiming to kind of hold the structure we have in place.
Joe Altobello
analystAnd if I could just change topics somewhat to what's happening with the US Consumer. I realize we're still right in the middle of 2021, but what's your thinking regarding that business for the coming year? I'm aware you view this business as growing 2% to 4% across the longer term. But do you expect that business could decline next year following what looks like two really strong years in 2020 and 2021?
Mike Lukemire
executiveWell, I would never use the word backwards. So I believe we're going to find out quite a bit in May and June; but my discussions with retailers have them feeling optimistic even regarding 2022. So they're coming in sooner, so they're remaining longer; and this ties into where we want marketing activities to keep drawing consumers in; so I would say I expect us to be above zero. I won't give a specific figure at this point because everyone is staring at me so…
Jim Hagedorn
executiveOkay, my sense is that sticking a negative figure in there tends to make folks uneasy. But during that virtual conference we held, I believe what we hinted at was the possibility of a retrenchment happening next year. So that wouldn't catch me off guard. And so, my take is that Mike is reluctant to claim there's no evidence proving that would happen, yet I think our aim is to act responsibly; and so, Joe, I think you understand how to interpret that.
Joe Altobello
analystSo at this stage, Mike comes across as more aggressive than Jim, is that fair to say?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveOver the past 2 years, I'd say the person who has nailed the business most reliably has been Mike Lukemire. Randy, I believe, brought this up many times — when he felt he couldn't rely on his own finance team to get a forecast right, he would go to Mike and ask, what's your take? Then he'd come back to me and tell me he thought Mike was the best gauge around. My sense is Mike leans gung ho and optimistic. Lately I've put a lot of effort into reining him in, purely from a caution standpoint, just because — we're getting cool, wet conditions here as May starts, and I glance at my wall clock showing it's the 5th of May. It genuinely feels like we've gone a year and half without lousy weather. That's how it seems to me. So I'm working to hold Mike back — nothing negative in any of this, to be clear. What I'm saying is our figures remain conservative enough that as we speak with you folks, I honestly can't picture a scenario where we fail to hit or beat what we're putting out there. And what this weather gives us is a chance to sort of reset our supply chain, rebuild our in-stock position. I believe we've discussed this previously — our folks are worn out. So a bit of weather right now actually makes things easier; and if I can keep Luke's optimism in check, I think we wind up with tougher sort of angular shifts; among fighter pilots, square corners are always a problem <<inaudible>>. They're painful. So I think what we're looking at today, and Mike's frame of mind, actually sits well with me right now. But he is quite positive. And we'll simply find out what next year — and what I've communicated to Mike is, the upcoming investor conference you all attend where we discuss results through June — or through early June, that's a crucial date for us when we examine our manufacturing forecasts and our outlooks for the year. But it isn't frightening from your perspective. It's more a question of how much do we overshoot? Because I think what Luke is feeding in right now is actually pushing the numbers up, not down. And I'm attempting to just sort of temper that somewhat, mainly with an eye on inventory at year end.
Mike Lukemire
executiveYet the way consumers respond during the latter six months of this year and how that carries into '22 — that's the open question, and we'll have a clearer picture soon. So should it prove robust, I'd view that as quite favorable. Should it lose momentum, then we'd be able to examine developments in '22 and begin to form a view.
Eric Bosshard
analystA few items. To start, regarding what you said about gross margin for the coming year, I'd like some clarity. For '22, is the gross margin expected to match '21, or does 22% reflect a recovery of what was lost in '21, again, excluding the segment mix, and is that the result we ought to have in mind for '22 right now?
Cory Miller
executiveAt present, we expect '22 to match what we now anticipate for '21.
Eric Bosshard
analystSo there isn't a rebound — nothing in '21 will bring back what was given up. Correct?
Cory Miller
executiveOur expectation is that it will take as long as two years for that rebound to arrive. When we consider the commodity situation, the prices we currently have locked in, and how those two things offset one another, that combination will largely determine how much recovery we're able to achieve in '22.
Eric Bosshard
analystAnd on top of that, second…
Jim Hagedorn
executiveLuke, let's simply toss that in.
Mike Lukemire
executiveNo, assuming the mix is the same.
Cory Miller
executiveFrom a segment mix, assuming the segment mix is the same.
Mike Lukemire
executiveThis is the tricky part. When you consider the entire company, Hawthorne's expansion. And then, do we aim to bring those margins back on a segment-by-segment basis? Yes. Does the mix look different across the whole organization? That could differ. I believe that's the point he's making.
Eric Bosshard
analystAnd then, I really value how open you've been about the fact that no one can say with certainty how those figures will come out for May and June. Based on what your guidance suggests, point-of-sale for May and June would be down somewhere around 10%. Is my calculation correct, just to establish a baseline for what the guidance means for those two months?
Cory Miller
executiveThat's right. What we're guiding to right now would put the full year at roughly mid-single digits, while the next couple of months look more or less flat.
Eric Bosshard
analystMoving on to the final item — Hawthorne doing better than we anticipated. I realize you're inclined to respond to both parts. I'd prefer it if you didn't. Still, regarding the positive developments in California versus those in new markets, which stands out as the most significant deviation or improvement relative to what you expected — the established markets or the new ones?
Chris Hagedorn
executiveLet me take that first; and should Cory, Jim, or Luke wish to add anything, they're certainly welcome. From my perspective, the larger astonishment involves new markets, where we anticipate things being fairly explosive for us. What keeps happening in California is more of a welcome surprise to me. We're witnessing genuinely strong ongoing expansion from that business, among both the existing legacy-type consumers and cultivators as well as newer commercial players. That has been a genuinely welcome surprise for us; so in my view, that has stood out more than the new markets.
Eric Bosshard
analystSo Chris, what's your take on the reason behind that?
Chris Hagedorn
executiveMy view is that what we keep calling legacy cultivators are still delivering fairly explosive growth. Along with that, the recreational market rollout is still — I wouldn't call it infancy exactly, more like its adolescent stage. When it comes to California's recreational market, maturity hasn't arrived yet the way I believe it has in somewhere like Colorado. As a result, we keep witnessing extremely strong growth, both from those bigger commercial accounts and from all the retail activity across California that mainly serves those legacy growers.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveJust to put my team here on the spot a bit, Eric — I believe we'd still hit our Street numbers even if we saw double digit declines for the remainder of the year, roughly speaking. Isn't that right? I believe that's right. So what you said, I think, is basically accurate. That said, I don't think we'll see things get that bad, by the way. Not at all; and because of that, we stay positive, simply due to the fact that the bars we have to clear for the rest of the year aren't all that high.
Eric Bosshard
analystAll right, that's useful.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAnd by the way, I'm with Chris on that. It's just that when you look at the legacy states — California, Michigan, those sort of big states of ours — the performance in those real established states, number one and number two, just keeps being really positive and drives a lot of business.
William Reuter
analystAbout the M&A you mentioned there being a lot of, plus the separate remark on possibly returning to high yield markets, I'd like to know what size you have in mind. My assumption is that everything here relates to Hawthorne. Also, what multiples are you currently observing for companies of that kind?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveThe bulk of what we're examining falls under Hawthorne, though live goods remain an area of ongoing interest for us too. On multiples, my sense is they've crept up somewhat on the Hawthorne side compared with before; our resolve not to pay too much hasn't changed. And I'd say historic multiples on the consumer side generally sit around that 8-ish range. So in terms of deal unit volume at least, the mix probably leans toward Hawthorne. That said, we've been vocal about wanting to keep shoring up and reinforcing the Bonnie business, and that continues.
William Reuter
analystSo regarding scale, what's the magnitude of the M&A chances available, whether measured by revenue, EBITDA, or similar metrics? Just so we can get some idea. That's everything from me.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveThere's more cash available than we'd be able to deploy. My view is this period is quite fascinating. During that virtual Investor Day, a central theme, I'd say, was that possibilities to expand this company through volume are likely the strongest I've witnessed. So because of that, we have a good number of options, and we've communicated that pretty plainly to people — meaning the pool of opportunity is sufficient, yet our capacity isn't endless, so we get to pick and choose. Often, within a particular segment, several alternatives exist for us. That means we're in a position to stand firm on price; as for scale, I'd say within core Hawthorne, these deals aren't massive. In live goods, you might deploy more capital. However, those are simply much larger — so 500 plus, roughly speaking.
Analyst
analystEarlier in this call, you mentioned a few times how price increases would help counter the gross margin squeeze. What we were hoping to find out is whether you have any initial sense of how willing customers are to accept those higher prices, or whether you're noticing any drop in volume, maybe as <<inaudible>> during this quarter?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveI'm going to hand it to Mike, since he's the one who has to deal with putting this matter to rest. But let me begin with what seems straightforward to me: this isn't up for discussion. When you consider where that money is going — well, you already know how I see it. And I believe all of you are aware — it's a never-ending front-page-of-the-journal type of strain on the folks who make things and purchase raw materials. Basically, we absorbed nothing during the prior year; and when you examine how much of that cash is already being used, roughly three quarters of it is gone. And I doubt we're saying anything that differs from what other suppliers are saying in, let's call it, the DIY hardware space. Keep in mind, pricing already went into effect at Hawthorne, and it was taken on board with no pressure at all on orders. On the consumer side of the business, the retail situation is somewhat different; so my hope is that we won't be threatened, because I see no benefit in that. This isn't about being greedy. It's simply about looking at what we're paying for; so it truly isn't up for discussion. I don't expect we'll face any kind of major resistance. I mean, verbally, we probably will, and we already have; but I think that gets in the way of business. The likelihood of that happening is small, though not zero. Mike, you're the person in charge of handling this.
Mike Lukemire
executiveRight, what I’m saying is this is likely the first occasion where we’ve actually had to do this. So we’ll collaborate with the retailers on the program. And should commodities rise once more, we’ve already said it might be higher; so we’re attempting to get it and work jointly and fix the problem jointly and not fall into a volume game. This is very different from negotiations in the past; this is a genuine issue for all of us and they’re dealing with those issues too, but we’ll get it resolved. And so I believe the discussions are good at this point.
Alex Maroccia
analystFirst up, regarding Hawthorne and additional territories. From what I gather, New York picked up quite a few lessons from that difficult launch in California concerning taxation; thus, honestly, it might enjoy greater initial success compared to what happened in California. That said, this territory isn't scheduled to go live before Q4 '22. So, do you foresee a situation during early calendar '22 where Hawthorne's expansion appears somewhat weak against those challenging comparisons, followed by a surge afterward in that same year? Broadly speaking, I'm simply attempting to determine just how significant additional territories have proved for the company across the last several quarters.
Cory Miller
executiveWhen examining each state that has launched, additional territories such as New York are far, far tinier. To give some sense of scale, California is roughly 100 times New York's magnitude. Consequently, as that launch unfolds, there might be a few obstacles regarding how it proceeds, yet it sits on an extremely, extremely tiny foundation. Therefore, it's something that won't even register within our results. Still, once all the pieces are in position and we begin functioning in what amounts to the new approach within a legal state, we anticipate a steady rise in the percentage growth rate that will be truly, truly robust across those additional territories. Yet we won't experience the struggle of reaching that growth the way we did with California in 2018, simply because we lack a sizable, already-established market in that location. Thus, it will unfold differently from those prior states, purely owing to scale.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveJim, do you have anything to add on that?
Chris Hagedorn
executiveNo, Cory already addressed it, I'd say. For us, New York is going to be a monster market, though developing it will take a little time. So I don't expect we'll see lightness there. The growth in New York, I think, is incremental upside for us.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveIt sort of ties back to that initial question — what do you figure the sustainable growth rate for Hawthorne will be? And that really comes down to how you define "light," I suppose, which gets you to a specific figure. I doubt you'll ever catch us saying, go ahead and assume a 60% growth rate. Cory sort of murmured from across the table, just tell them 15%. And Chris and I responded that it's tough for us to even put that out there. But keep in mind, we've been burned before. So it kind of hinges on where you're standing with it. Still, I believe if you take the long view, which is what I'd hope you all are able to do, then consider Pennsylvania, New Jersey — which is a Rex state — and New York is a Rex state now too. Suppose they ramp up more or less completely across a couple of years, that's comparable to California sitting on the East Coast, and that has to be a positive. So I think that's the lens we're using; though I do think it's — what growth rate are you all prepared to commit to for Hawthorne, or perhaps I should phrase it differently, what will you all plug into your models so we can respond to it? Because my sense is we'll probably land toward the lower end, not because that reflects what we're actually observing, but simply because we got burned quite badly when I stated that 15% per year seemed like a solid figure; and then, I believe, inside two years — honestly, it felt like the worst blunder I'd made with you folks in quite a while, pledging to a growth rate that — I suspect, looking back now, you'd agree as well, that was a reasonable, conservative number; yet for roughly a year and a half, it seemed like among the biggest errors I've committed in terms of talking too fast. I believe that happened at an investor conference down in Florida.
Mike Lukemire
executiveWe only look forward now. Don't look back.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveActually, that's something I do reflect on. When you take the long view and consider how we're expanding this business, becoming an indispensable ally to growers — you can see the map widening, Hawthorne's approach becoming more defined, rolling out those critical tools that position us as a genuine partner to the cultivators we work with, and on top of that, tackling the margin rate challenges. Margins at Hawthorne are considerably healthier than they used to be. So even though they sit below what we average as a corporation, the gains have been substantial. When you add it all up, it's difficult to conclude anything except that over the long haul, Hawthorne has been, from where we stand, a tremendous amount of fun. I believe our Board — we just had a meeting — but I believe the Board holds a lot of respect for the approach we built around moving into this business and has been extremely supportive, and the same goes for the entire management team. And so, if you simply — once more, we brought some folks around to meet you all. But when you consider how strong the management team is across the big three segments of the business, or perhaps four, meaning the consumer side, Hawthorne, and then the Scotts foundational piece, it's a genuinely impressive business and one I think is worth putting money into.
Alex Maroccia
analystThen my second question follows up on something asked earlier, about acquisitions. If we add companies onto Bonnie, where would the synergy come from, and would those companies resemble Bonnie but operate in other regions?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveLet me begin by saying this — I suppose they'd be Bonnie-like, though I don't believe a solid comparison for Bonnie exists. Bonnie's operation is genuinely one of a kind, and the brand is where that begins. Plenty of plants exist in this space. What Bonnie holds, though, is a branded operation built on a distribution and service model that's quite distinctive, and in my view nobody else possesses it. So even though Bonnie isn't the biggest player in what you might call the green space, I'd argue it's the most valuable, the most distinctive, and a great fit for us. That means whatever opportunities we're reviewing, we'd want them to fit in there. And looking at it — Mike has a better handle on these figures than I do. Yet if you consider that during the season we have a couple of thousand employees in stores, Bonnie likely has around 1,000, roughly that.
Mike Lukemire
executive1,500…
Jim Hagedorn
executive…staff members inside retail locations. Every company out there is assigning personnel to stores. And the lesson we took away from Scotts North America — which, years ago, was gathering up all of these operations and combining them — is that having something like 4 sales reps, 4 separate bills, 4 different vehicles, forklifts, and every headache that comes along with that is something no one actually wants. So my real emphasis right now is on synergies. Being able to — and this has been something like a longtime aspiration of mine. Whether it's still a smart plan, I can't say. But it has been an aspiration of mine to be able to say, inside a Depot or Lowes, could we staff a full time crew that never spends time out on the road traveling from one store to the next? That crew would handle only our products while working alongside store management. And I believe if we examine — so once more, think synergy here. Our capacity to pull that off, I believe, is coming nearer and nearer. Mike?
Mike Lukemire
executiveYeah, that's fair. And I keep thinking about how productive that square footage in the stores really is, and how you get more out of it instead of battling for room. But when you're adding stores while carrying less space, that forces you to be more productive. And our thinking is that the live goods solution can genuinely make a difference there.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAnd I'll put this out there — I won't claim we're the sole company capable of this, but my belief is we're among just a handful that genuinely possesses the capacity, beginning with Bonnie, to provide that sort of — well, dollar synergies may exist, and on our end I believe they do. Consider just the effectiveness synergy around in-store operations — this was King, and I'm certain he'll want me to stop talking here. Here's the thing: this is a case where, since we handle our own business inside stores and you observe plenty of other vendors, marketing folks similar to us who have committed to purchasing retailer programs, one thing I'll tell you that you're witnessing this year is an unbelievable shortage of ability to secure labor. We're fine. Yet my sense is retailers are facing an enormous problem. And the competitive edge that comes from having — what I simply call the in-store footprint, the quantity of concrete we control inside the store, enabling us to deploy our own army there and, as you say, extend that across other areas of the business, I believe that's extremely powerful and delivers a massive sort of advantage to the retailer that — my guess is if any of you speak with retailers, they'd tell you Scotts belongs to a very select group of vendor partners capable of bringing that level of strength into the store. It's possibly us along with Behr Paint. I'm not aware of anyone else, especially outside lumber, who can perform the type of work we do. So my view is the execution upside for retailers is gigantic.
Jim King
executiveThanks, everyone, for being with us on this call today. Should you have any follow-up questions or wish to discuss matters we didn't have time to cover, once more, feel free to reach out to me at (937) 578 to 5622. And as I mentioned at the beginning, Cory and I will be providing an update on where things stand with the business in early June at the William Blair Conference. A press release will go out a couple of weeks beforehand with the specifics of that conference, and in all likelihood, we'll also put out a press release tied to the remarks we deliver at that event. So with that, we'll wrap up now. Thank you for being with us today, and enjoy a wonderful spring, everyone.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveSee you guys.
Operator
operatorThis concludes today's call. Thank you for your participation. You may now disconnect.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.