The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company (SMG) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
August 4, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Jim King
executiveHello, everyone, and thanks for joining us for Scotts Miracle-Gro's third quarter earnings call this morning. With me today are Jim Hagedorn, our Chairman and CEO; Cory Miller, our Interim Chief Financial Officer; Mike Lukemire, our President and Chief Operating Officer; and Chris Hagedorn, Group President of Hawthorn. Shortly, Jim and Cory will deliver some prepared remarks, after which we'll take your questions. To make the most of our time, please limit yourself to one question and one follow-up. I've already got time scheduled with many of you following this call to address anything we don't get to. If anyone else would like to arrange some Q&A time, give me a call directly at 937 to 578 to 5622, and we'll find a slot as quickly as possible. A quick housekeeping note: Cory and I will be taking part in the Raymond James Consumer Conference on September 14, which will be held virtually. We'll share more details about the time and date a couple of weeks beforehand. With that, let's proceed with today's call. As always, I want to remind you that we expect to make forward-looking statements, and I caution you that our actual results could differ materially from what we say. Investors should familiarize themselves with the full range of risk factors that could impact our results, which are filed with our Form 10-K with the Securities and Exchange Commission. I also want to remind everyone that today's call is being recorded, and an archived version will be available on our website. With that, let's get started. I'll now hand the call over to Jim Hagedorn. Jim?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAppreciate that, Jim, and hello everybody on this morning's call. What we're covering today matters a great deal. Arguably no conversation we've had with investors during the last 12 months carries more weight, and that has zero connection to the fact that we've delivered yet another robust quarter and are still tracking toward a record-setting year. The reason is that the moment everyone anticipated has at last arrived. Sure, we're beginning to face difficult comparisons across both of our businesses. Sure, we're beginning to observe shoppers returning to their usual habits. And sure, much like numerous other consumer-facing companies, the expense pressure coming from commodities is beginning to feel like it never lets up. Yet when I examine our operations more closely, I find myself unable to feel anything but optimistic. Looking solely at a quarterly P&L makes it impossible to grasp what is taking place here. You must dig deeper, you must scrutinize, you must uncover responses to inquiries you'd never previously considered posing. For over 12 months, I've told anyone willing to hear me out that my conviction was that Scotts Miracle-Gro would come out of COVID as a fundamentally more robust enterprise; and the further we dig, the more scrutiny we apply, the more certain I become that this is precisely the outcome. Today's consumer base is substantially larger and more involved than it was before the pandemic struck. Our bond with those customers is deeper and more intimate than at any prior point. This is thanks to the transformation of our marketing efforts. Our capacity to connect on their terms has improved now because of enormous strides in our direct-to-consumer programs, and our capacity to deliver the finest achievable results for them has grown simpler thanks to an innovation team that keeps producing significant new offerings. Hawthorne, our growth engine, keeps beating the market and is setting itself up for success over the long haul; we've established competitive edges that rivals in this sector simply cannot replicate. We introduced science-driven innovation into this space. And we keep pursuing a vision that pushes us toward discovering fresh and imaginative avenues for expansion. Beyond the power of our operations, our balance sheet provides us with greater financial leeway than at any point in 10 years. We have chances to put money into near-term growth and we will chase those. We have chances to put money into growth over the long term and we will chase that as well. And we have the chance to give cash back to shareholders, which we'll also chase, particularly considering the recent decline in our share price; we aren't executing everything flawlessly here. When I search for significant shortcomings, I simply can't identify any at this moment. We've seized the full benefit of the singular opening that emerged across the past 18 months and have placed ourselves in an excellent position; and that, then, is the backdrop for how I'd like to lay out five separate subjects I intend to address this morning. To start, I want to talk about the ongoing strength of our U.S. Consumer business. Customer engagement stayed robust, and as we move through the coming year, we anticipate keeping almost all of the growth we gained in 2020. I doubt many other CPG businesses can make that claim. Second, Hawthorne — once again, the trends are exceptionally strong. We rose 48% during the quarter, and on a full year basis we still expect growth of 40% to 45%. Third, M&A — this morning we announced a small yet strategic bolt-on acquisition for Hawthorne. We keep looking at opportunities that are larger in scope, and we're more and more committed to finding creative ways to invest in other areas of the cannabis industry. Fourth, I'll offer some early thoughts on how we see next year; we aren't giving fiscal 2022 guidance today, but we do have a working thesis about next year. And I think long-term shareholders will be pleased by what they hear. And fifth, I want to discuss our evolving thinking about returning cash to shareholders. Let's begin with U.S. Consumer. Clearly, we've performed better on the top line than we anticipated at the start of the year. Consumer engagement came in above our expectations and let us raise our numbers twice this season. Of course, much of that benefit above $1 a share has been offset by commodity pressures that every company in the consumer product space is attempting to manage. I'll let Cory go deeper into those details. I want to spend my time on the strong underlying foundation of the business. The most critical takeaway is this: consumer engagement remains extremely high. Going into the season, our research indicated roughly 85% of consumers who entered the category last year would come back. We think the actual figure was likely nearer to 75%; even so, we're confident we've benefited from a higher overall level of participation, since one-third of all consumers said they increased their participation in our category this spring. When we subtract consumers who did less gardening this year from those who did more, our data indicates participation rose 8%. And that lines up fairly well with consumer purchases of our products at our largest retail partners. Entering August, POS dollars at our largest four retail partners were up 4%; in units, the figure is 8%. There's a story here and it matters to understand it; in most years, the gap between units and dollars is negligible; in 2020, though, retailers did almost no promotional activity; so POS dollars far exceeded units; this year retailers promoted more than in 2020. The shift in their behavior meant the difference between POS dollars and units swung back the other way; in our soils business, 4 for 10 and 5 for 10 promotions were brought back. POS dollars are up 5% year-to-date, but units — a more accurate reflection of our shipments as well as consumer activity — are up 8%; in mulch, dollars are up 11% and units up 20%. Additionally, certain branded segments exist where the promotional activity's effect compared to a year ago is not as strong, such as fertilizer for lawns, products for controlling weeds, and seed for grass. Point-of-sale revenue increased by 3%, 8%, and 14%, in that order. For the third consecutive year, we are observing growth in the double digits for grass seed. Thus, considering every category, the figures we are reporting would be impressive in any given year. Consequently, we are very happy despite the challenging comparisons. Nevertheless, we have lost a significant portion of the point-of-sale improvements we mentioned during the previous call, at which time the cumulative figure for the year so far stood at an increase of 20. The majority of that decline was anticipated due to the hard comparisons. But we think the outcome would have been stronger had it not been for the weather difficulties that certainly pushed the figures down during May and June. Over the weekend of Mother's Day, traditionally the biggest weekend for gardening, snowfall occurred in several important markets. Record-breaking cold arrived for Memorial Day across a large part of the Midwest and Northeast. Father's Day was only slightly improved. In truth, the entirety of June was very rainy across much of the Midwest. And naturally, the unprecedented heat and dry conditions in the Western United States have provided no relief either. We think the weather's effect was amplified during this year. A year ago, at a time when individuals were doing their jobs from home, we noticed far more point-of-sale activity taking place on weekdays than what we typically saw.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveIf the weather over the weekend turned out bad, that didn't matter much, since a larger number of shoppers were out on weekdays. This year, though, weekday foot traffic came nearer to usual levels, so Saturday and Sunday matter a great deal once more. That makes poor weather harder to get past now, and we've had plenty of it. I'm not offering this as an excuse. It's simply how things are. The business can be affected by weather; and this year it became a meaningful headwind. Come September 30, my guess is weather will end up costing us no less than 2 points of growth in fiscal 2021. Even so, consumer engagement is still encouraging. Our third quarter has historically made up roughly 55% of full year POS. During the 13-week stretch running April through June, POS declined 1% this year versus 2020, yet it gained 24% across those very same weeks versus 2019. Looking at just the final nine weeks in that stretch, which is when tougher comps began to kick in, POS fell 12% against 2020 levels; even so, it climbed 30% against 2019 over that same nine-week span. Should we extrapolate the present trends through the rest of the year, we anticipate full year POS dollars rising slightly versus last year. POS units will probably rise in the low to mid-single digits, and versus 2019, we anticipate POS for 2021 rising by over 25%. Today's consumer trends, together with planned higher retail inventory levels, leave us highly confident in our full year sales growth guidance for the U.S. consumer business, which we've set in the range of 7% to 9%. Plenty of excellent stories sit behind these numbers. I would enjoy sharing details about every one of them, but I'll move on and share a few highlights from Hawthorne, where strength continues to show across the Board. Sales through June are 60% higher on a year-to-date basis as the business keeps extending its market leading position. During Q3, our lighting business expanded 77%. Inside that figure, our market-leading Gavita brand expanded at over double that pace. We keep seeing new growth facilities come online throughout the country, and the retrofit market stayed a key part of the story along with legacy markets in the Western United States. Innovation keeps driving our lighting success. Specifically, we keep enjoying great success with our new LED lighting products, which give growers a one for one replacement for existing high pressure sodium lights. Beyond lighting, strength keeps showing in the consumable category too, which reflects growth in the actual cannabis market more accurately. Nutrients sales climbed 54% in the quarter and growing media rose 32%. Our signature brands outperformed the overall category by a wide margin. General Hydroponics grew roughly 30 points more than the total nutrient portfolio. Additionally, our Mother Earth and Botanicare lines expanded at a pace 3 times quicker than the remainder of our growing media operation. This broad-based strength produced the 48% increase recorded during the quarter, which closed with June standing as our biggest sales month on record. For the entire year, the growth rate we anticipate is slightly over 2 times greater than what we originally guided. The extra gains this year let us bring in better talent, strengthen our innovation work, and boost our marketing. We believe those investments will once again propel the business next year and in subsequent years. Clearly, another avenue for generating growth comes via M&A. Allow me to address the transaction we unveiled this morning. Purchasing HydroLogic is fairly simple. It's a bolt-on deal that can be integrated without much difficulty. It's also deeply strategic. HydroLogic stands out as a top supplier of products and systems tied to water filtration and purification. That positions it as an excellent complement to the irrigation supply operation we already run, sitting within a high margin category. Our pipeline still holds more M&A prospects across both business segments than we can currently absorb. The difficulty for Hawthorne is that a great many of the targets are small to medium-sized companies. You may assume small deals are simple to complete. Usually, the reality is quite the reverse. A shortage of advanced IT systems and financial controls renders the due diligence work tougher and slower. And we won't hurry the deal simply to close it, yet I can tell you solid progress is being made. On a separate note, we stay dedicated to deploying capital into parts of the cannabis sector nearer to the end consumer and to the grower, staying inside the limits of existing federal law together with our lenders' requirements. Following months of effort from an internal task force, a process has been established letting us make non-equity investments in other entities that put money into cannabis brands and operations. As a matter of fact, talks have been underway with prospective partners to activate this strategy, and we hope to witness meaningful activity before long. We've built a highly successful operation at Hawthorne, grounded in the present state authorized marketplace. Despite having zero involvement in plant touching activities, we grasp the space as well as anybody, maybe better than anybody. Our developing vision involves building the optionality to hold an early mover advantage in the wider U.S. cannabis market once federal law permits it. There's almost no question. This industry is set for considerable growth. And with the track record we have, I think we possess an absolute right to win here. I'm eager to share further details in the months ahead. Talking of the months ahead, I know everybody is curious about what fiscal 2022 holds. So let me shift direction and offer some high level thoughts. The simple portion of this equation is Hawthorne. This segment's run rate is still solid; an acquisition just closed, and with any luck, additional ones are coming. Our position as market leader keeps getting stronger. The very same obstacle that has persisted for multiple years is still in front of us; we're heading into fiscal 2022 facing rather difficult comparisons, yet judging by all the signals we're picking up, it's tough to picture growth falling under 10% to 20% in the coming year. I realize plenty of people view that as cautious, and maybe they're right; maybe our guidance range will end up looking different too. Still, erring on the side of caution has served us well across the last several years, and that's the route we'll stay on. I won't make an oversized commitment to growth here. The tougher questions heading into next year involve how much the U.S. consumer business grows and the ongoing strain from rising commodity costs. I'll handle the first piece. Cory will take the second. Before anything else, 2 months remain in this year; so Mike and I are making sure the team stays locked in right through the end. When it comes to next year, many pieces are in motion. So we won't get too granular this morning; even so, I'm happy with where we stand.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveA year back, I mentioned that keeping the growth we achieved in 2020 within our U.S. Consumer segment would make me happy, and that opinion hasn't changed. Through next April, we'll likely keep experiencing some pressure on the top line due to tough comparisons. So in a way, fiscal 2022 is going to look like a mirror of this year—a rough beginning that gets simpler as time progresses. At this moment, I think it's wise to assume the U.S. Consumer business will see a slight drop next year. A few of you have models pointing to a decline in the double digits. Given the anticipated advantages from pricing, we're aiming to outperform that, but it's too soon to say for sure. Naturally, we won't truly know until around this time next year, but our consumer business gained close to 10 years' worth of growth over the past year, and thus far it seems quite durable. Along with shifting demographics in the lawn and garden sector and an extremely hot real estate market, this puts us in a much better spot in a world after COVID. That's the reason we've invested so heavily in our brands this season and why we'll do the same next year; that's a current perspective, not formal guidance. There's plenty of work ahead in the coming 90 days, and our thinking might shift. We're still locking in listings and programs with several big retailers for next year. We might also implement a second price hike in January, based on how commodities move. And naturally, we have to make it through the fall season to see how retail inventory stands as we get ready for the next season. So we'd anticipate providing a far clearer view when we speak again in November. At the start, I noted that it's hard to grasp the business simply by examining the P&L. And I trust it's evident that we're feeling optimistic, and in that spirit, I want to touch briefly on another topic: giving cash back to shareholders. Considering the decline and our stock price since early June, it's obvious that doubts about next year are weighing on our value. I've often said that I view this business over the long haul and don't stress about quarter-to-quarter swings. I'm fond of our strategy. I'm fond of how we're positioned to carry it out. And I have faith in this team. And as you know, I've brought up the idea of a special dividend several times this year—I'm a strong supporter of purchasing our shares at these levels. I told Cory I'm at ease directing up to $250 million toward share buybacks in the coming months under our current authorization. So expect us to proceed with that. Before handing it to Cory, I want to share one final piece of perspective. Last week, while strolling around our campus in Ohio, I encountered a group of our R&D colleagues. Researchers in the field studying plants. The passion they showed for their jobs and their faith in what it might deliver for the times ahead truly moved me. It brought back the reason I enjoy being part of this place. You won't come across the kind of hopeful outlook we have here at most other businesses. That outlook got us through the first stretch of COVID and has powered the record outcomes we've reported each quarter ever since. So the tough comparisons still ahead don't trouble us, nor does the likelihood of a few quarters in negative territory soon; and we're not troubled by the idea that our customers might vanish once the world returns to how it was. Our vision is something we hold firm to. We hold firm to the mission we're carrying out; we hold firm that our company genuinely improves the world, and we hold firm that the chances before us have never been so abundant and that nothing ahead has ever looked so bright. With that said, I'll hand it over to Cory for a quick run through the figures, and he'll offer a few of his own initial reflections on the year to come.
Cory Miller
executiveAppreciate that, Jim, and good morning to all. Jim's point is one I share. We had yet another robust quarter in Q3. Coming into the CFO role from my new perspective, I've been able to observe how our team steers through a rather atypical market. They're performing excellently, capitalizing on the chances available to us, all while handling and getting past the difficulties. Everything they've done shows up in the results we've posted throughout the year and the strong numbers we reported once more this morning. Sales across the company rose 8% during Q3, and on a year-to-date basis we're now ahead 29%. We're still on target to hit our guidance for both the top line and the bottom line. That said, gross margin rate pressure is probably going to be even greater than we anticipated during our last conversation, and we're additionally encountering some unforeseen pressure below the line from Bonnie. I'll address those points shortly. Broadly speaking, though, I want to use my time to give you a clear picture of three items: what we've observed over recent months, what we anticipate for the rest of the year, and how we think certain present trends will carry into next year. Let's begin with the U.S. Consumer business, where sales dropped 4% for the quarter, yet stand 19% higher year-to-date. That keeps us squarely on track with the guidance I gave back in June, when we stated we anticipate sales growth of 7% to 9%. As Jim mentioned already, consumer engagement stayed incredibly strong all season long. Retailer inventory levels have risen as well across the last several months. This is bringing inventory levels back to where they ought to be. You've already been given the specifics of what's happening at Hawthorne, so Q3 needs no further explanation. Our confidence in this year's growth outlook for that business remains intact; thus, in both of our major reporting segments, maintaining our sales guidance requires a fairly dramatic shift in Q4's trajectory. Reaching our guidance would mean U.S. Consumer shipments falling 40% to 50% year-over-year during Q4; and for Hawthorne's guidance to hold, a range from flat growth to plus 15% is needed, which clearly sits below what we've witnessed over the past year. Yet those slower growth rates have nothing to do with the fundamental strength of either business. So allow me to break that down. Keep in mind that during 2020, the U.S. Consumer business grew 92% in Q4 and Hawthorne grew by 64%. So the comps are extremely high. That's the first headwind. The second is the shift in our fiscal calendar in 2021 that we discussed in Q1; on a year-to-date basis, through Q3, we've had more days than a year ago, while the shift had a negative impact of approximately $115 million on company-wide sales in Q3; it has added approximately $50 million on a year-to-date basis, which is pretty evenly divided between U.S. Consumer and Hawthorne. Naturally, that translates into fewer days during Q4, meaning that $50 million would be removed from Q4 to make the shift neutral across the entire year; over in U.S. Consumer, we're currently shipping fall items while continuing to restock other categories so that stores maintain proper inventory levels. Our visibility is solid at this point, and that's what gives us strong confidence in the guidance we've provided, assuming nothing unexpected occurs. Turning to Hawthorne, the additional significant year-over-year obstacle in Q4 comes from the 82% comp that we face in California, a state representing roughly 45% of our yearly U.S. sales. There are several reasons why we anticipate California's growth rate dropping considerably this Q4. The first, clearly, is that tough comp standing in front of us. The second involves the reality that weather patterns have created an unusual effect on this year's outdoor growing season out west, and that season matters greatly to that business. Favorable conditions early in the year let outdoor growers begin strongly, and a large number of them have already harvested their crops a second time. As for those who haven't, recent weeks of heat and drought have hurt their operations and reduced demand for certain products we offer. The third reason is purely about timing, along with our belief that a portion of sales got pulled forward into June. Back when we reset guidance in early June, we stated our intention to put some of the upside back into both U.S. Consumer and Hawthorne to keep fueling growth; at Hawthorne, that involved certain promotions originally scheduled for June, helping produce the record month that Jim mentioned. Consequently, we anticipate surrendering a portion of that year-to-date growth through the remainder of the year. Even so, when all is said and done, we still look for Hawthorne to close out the year delivering 40% to 50% growth, building on the prior year's 60% growth. As a matter of fact, after nine months, our sales this year already exceed all of 2020 by 7%. This business keeps flourishing. Let's continue down the P&L and turn to gross margins, where inflation's effects remain evident. Obviously, this is something every one of you has heard discussed by other companies in your coverage. At Scotts Miracle-Gro, we've observed consistent rises in commodities such as urea, diesel and resin, all of which are simple for you to monitor on your own. Normally, we'd anticipate urea prices easing somewhat during summer, yet that isn't occurring, since worldwide demand has kept those prices stubbornly high; beyond that, we're now experiencing pressure from inputs that are harder to track, like grass seed and stagnant peat moss. Over the last year, grass seed has likely shifted more than any other commodity we use, the result of an imbalance between supply and demand. A large share of that seed comes from the Pacific Northwest, so the severe weather they experienced this summer is probably going to hurt plant yields and definitely won't help ease the cost pressure at all; during Q3, those problems produced an adjusted gross margin rate of 30.8%, which is down 530 basis points versus the same period last year. I'm anticipating yet another sizable drop in Q4, and that would probably mean a decline of roughly 275 basis points for the entire year. Across nine months, the adjusted gross margin rate sits 280 points below where it was a year earlier. So far this year, distribution costs that came in higher dragged the gross margin rate down by 260 basis points, while material costs that were higher added another 130 points of strain on that rate. More than 100 basis points of fixed cost leverage partly counterbalanced those pressures; even so, out of the 390 points of downward rate pressure, roughly 235 basis points were unplanned; and although our big price increase went into effect this week and will provide support for the last eight weeks of the year, there have honestly been almost no other offsets to those elevated costs throughout the whole year. Looking toward next year, just about 25% of our costs are currently locked in.
Cory Miller
executiveThat figure is below what we'd typically see, and there are a couple of causes. To start with, securing rates on certain commodities, resin in particular, has proven more difficult. On top of that, for several weeks we've held off on hedging activity, hoping some easing would materialize. Jim made the point, and I'll echo it: our aim is to secure sufficient pricing during fiscal 2022 to counterbalance the commodity squeeze. The pricing just implemented in U.S. Consumer came in a bit above 5%. Should costs fail to start easing by the close of the calendar year, we intend to implement an additional pricing round in January; our retail partners have already been informed of this plan. With those matters aside, we continue to anticipate further supply chain investments, and negative segment mix will persist since Hawthorne's growth rate will far exceed that of U.S. Consumer. Consequently, the overall rate will probably drop once more next year, although a solid range isn't something I can provide at this moment. Over the last several months, the team has performed excellently, countering margin pressure through sustained attention to SG&A reductions. Back in June, my expectation was that full year SG&A would come in flat to somewhat above 2020. Recent weeks have brought some tweaks, and my expectation now is flat to somewhat below. A few items sit beneath the operating line that I'd also like to clarify, since both are exerting downward pressure on EPS. The impact of Bonnie Plants is the first. As you may remember, our initial estimate was that Bonnie would contribute $0.12 to $0.15 to this year's earnings. Come June, profits had started coming in weaker than anticipated because too much inventory had been built up; thus, when guidance was reset in early June, we assumed Bonnie's year-over-year effect on adjusted EPS would be neutral. Further deterioration in their results has occurred since then, now translating to roughly a $0.20 headwind across the full year. Although edible gardening participation rates stay robust, Bonnie Plants was positioned for a greater degree of growth. May and June underperformed partly owing to several difficult weekends caused by weather, as Jim described previously; as a result, more plants were grown than were needed. One key distinction between that operation and our two other major segments is that finished goods inventory cannot be carried. Building excess fertilizer inventory simply means carrying it into the following year, which is no big deal. When Bonnie inventory fails to sell and remains stuck in a greenhouse, it is destroyed, and that cost cannot be offset in any way. The gross margin damage therefore goes directly to their bottom line, and plainly that means the equity income benefit we'd anticipated will come in lower. When you're building out your models for next year, please keep in mind that a year-over-year headwind from Bonnie was something we anticipated all along for fiscal 2022. That's not a reflection of how the business is performing. Keep in mind that Bonnie's first quarter isn't in this year's results, because of when the 50 to 50 JV with them was struck. Bonnie's first quarter, which is a last quarter, will be included in fiscal 2022. While Bonnie's performance this year has been disappointing, we remain fully dedicated to live goods, especially edible plants. That category continues to be a key part of our strategy, and alongside the Bonnie team, we're improving how we plan so that we can better manage NCS as well as the inherent ups and downs of this business. Another area that could weigh on EPS is higher interest expense. At present, we're considering an additional bond offering to secure longer-term bonds, probably around 4% with a maturity of 10 to 12 years. If we decide to proceed with that initiative within the next few weeks, an additional few cents of headwind might accumulate before the year is over. This provides us with flexibility and liquidity, while securing favorable borrowing rates over the next ten years. Moving to the bottom line, GAAP earnings reached $4 per share during the quarter and $9.90 for the year-to-date, representing increases of 12% and 47%, respectively. Under a non-GAAP adjusted basis, which serves as the foundation for our guidance, EPS for the quarter increased 5% to $3.98 per share and 39% to $10.04 per share year-to-date. Prior to taking your questions, I want to elaborate on the topic Jim discussed. Twelve months back, we had confidence that coming out of COVID would leave us a superior, more resilient organization. I agree with his belief that this is precisely what took place. Within our U.S. Consumer segment, we've directed resources toward conventional advertising, direct-to-consumer channels, sales, supply chain, and R&D — moves that position us extremely favorably going forward. And at Hawthorne, the place where I worked for the prior six years, we've established competitive edges that kept driving that operation ahead as well. On top of that, with debt leverage sitting below 2.2 times when the quarter closed, we enjoy tremendous financial latitude to keep financing acquisitions and infrastructure upgrades, all while still giving cash back to stockholders. I should probably confess that I might be biased more than anyone else here, yet I genuinely believe our company now stands in an outstanding position as we face what lies ahead. And assuming those moves were correct for the company itself, then they were equally correct for the people who own our stock. That said, I'll wrap up what I wanted to say and turn things over to you for questions.
Jeff Zekauskas
analystMuch appreciated. I believe you mentioned — hello there, good morning. From what I gathered, you're lifting the prices in your Consumer segment by 5%; that doesn't seem like, it's sufficient to cover raw material, price inflation. Is that correct? And whenever you attempt to increase them 5%, that you actually receive 5%.
Mike Lukemire
executiveThis is Mike Lukemire. In fact, we enter with a bigger figure than that; this is a net across; and so within certain categories, we truly are above 5%. So you have to consider the mix. So there will be a range, and yes, in the early stage, it's sufficient, if it declines; but like we stated, we're tracking this alongside our retail partners and should it keep remaining elevated, we're going to implement another adjustment.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAlright, this is Jim Hagedorn speaking. This is one of those situations where, in my view, we landed somewhere quite solid, and it wasn't because our retailers were pushing us. I believe we reached a point of concluding that this looks promising. When you read the front-page stories — for instance, in the Journal just this past week — the headline was about growth, and I believe it said commodities are declining. Nobody truly has certainty, in my opinion. The retailers, I think, are attempting to figure this out — and we aren't alone in this. Still, I do believe the way we answered them was pretty distinctive: we told them, here's what we'll do right now. Should things calm down, we're fine. Should they not calm down, we're going to take additional action in January. That was the approach that, as I saw it, the retailers unanimously considered a very fair and sensible stance. So it all hinges on how commodity pressure plays out. Should it fall — should it decline, then 5% ought to be sufficient. Should it fail to decline, we'll take additional action. And the retailers know this and are on board with it. So honestly, I think we wound up somewhere quite solid.
Jeff Zekauskas
analystRegarding your urea, what quantity do you aim to have procured once the calendar year wraps up? Put differently, you need to secure the entire amount during Q4, that final calendar quarter, in order to make up the shortfall.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveTypically, we don't hold the whole position by Q4. So it'll be — our preference is roughly 50% hedged; we've made the decision against doing so. Our expectation is that pricing broadly eases, and we're watching that closely at present.
Jeff Zekauskas
analystAll right, excellent. All right. Thanks a lot.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveSure thing.
Peter Grom
analystHey, good morning, everybody. Thanks a lot for the discussion about fiscal 2022. But historically, I suppose, when I compare your initial remarks with what actually ends up happening, your statements have turned out to be wise. So I'd just like to know whether that's the way investors ought to view your early fiscal 2022 remarks today. And then, perhaps extending from that, inside the U.S. Consumer segment, does that presume some type of recovery from normal weather, or is it just the underlying trajectory?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveWell, Peter, welcome aboard, first of all. This is Jim Hagedorn. I think wise if — wise amounts to sandbagging, I think on Hawthorne, we were wise. Looking back, if you ask me what my biggest mistake has been recently regarding expectations, it was saying I didn't expect Hawthorne to have a year below 15% growth, at least not soon. Then I got hit with 18%, so I'd say wise is a good answer for Hawthorne. On the Consumer side, I'll walk that back a bit—it's this idea, and I've set the expectations with the management team. If we could hold onto the roughly 25% growth we had last year, I'd be extremely happy with that. And then basically try to maintain our margins—that's been harder this year. Honestly, my level of confidence regarding the consumer's position is quite high, since our unit sales actually exceeded the prior year's figure. Profitability has proven difficult. We had no real choice when it came to pricing. That was simply a step we were forced to accept. As a result, I can't say with certainty what a typical year looks like for the consumer. My own view — and perhaps this reflects too much optimism — is this: consider the two factors I've been using to guide the business, the first being where inventory stands today, and that number is elevated at retail. That part is accurate. Honestly, when we talk with retailers, margin levels above where they stood a year ago aren't really part of the conversation. Everyone seems extremely worried about running short on stock, so my sense is that there won't be much of a push to bring inventory back down. Going into next year, I believe folks genuinely want those shelves stocked full once more. For us, that ought to work in our favor during Q4 and, let's say, the early part of Q1. It's simply a matter of the weather being weak. What I mean is, it's the kind of situation where you look at it and feel truly positive about the businesses. We ran through, honestly, I couldn't even tell you the exact count of script drafts, though I believe it landed around pan — that's where I think we stood on this. Truthfully, for Scotts that story is quite persuasive, and it shows just how stable our business remains and how loyal shoppers are to us. Take Mother's Day, Father's Day, Memorial Day, plus the 4th of July — each one proved really challenging, at minimum for anyone located in Ohio or along the East Coast, and that region accounts for approximately, I'm not sure, over 40% of our sales. So the fact that we estimated it likely shaved 200 basis points off our growth — I believe that says something about how resilient this business is, because my usual line is, simply glance outside; so honestly I feel like if things normalize, next year could actually be a tailwind for us, and I'm less worried about an inventory correction heading into next year. So on the consumer side, I'm fairly bullish for next year. And for Hawthorne, I'd say being prudent is probably the right call. Does that track?
Peter Grom
analystNo, no. It absolutely does; that’s super useful. So perhaps just expanding a bit on a few of those points — the Q4 outlook for U.S. Consumer is quite a broad band, though it does seem to suggest an increase on a two year stack. And maybe this leans more toward the core side, but I believe, Cory, you said back in June, when you sort of lifted that guidance, that we were happy with the results, yet you didn’t really see much upside to that 7% to 9% number. So then, does that remark still apply? Or do you think there might be upside, given what’s been lease versus our expectation, just a stronger Q3.
Cory Miller
executiveHey, this is Cory; and when I looked at the previous occasion we provided guidance, the 7% and 9% we had discussed at that time was a fairly realistic view of where we believed the year would land. As we’re sitting here now, our Q4 figures appear like they’re going to be kind of flattish to reach a full year back in that 7% to 9% range. I don’t see a ton of upside above that. I don’t see a ton of risks to those numbers. I think that’s probably still a good range.
Peter Grom
analystAll right. I really appreciate it. I'll hand things over.
Jonathan Andersen
analystMorning, everyone.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveHey there, Jon.
Jonathan Andersen
analystJim, you brought up your initial remarks, at least regarding 2022, that the U.S. Consumer business would be slightly down. Given where commodities are sitting today, are you thinking about a second price increase within that outlook? What could the size of that increase look like? Then, if you could expand a bit on the assumptions the teams are using about keeping new consumers, and the particular actions you'll take—whether new products or the additional direct marketing you mentioned in the transcript—that would support that effort. Thank you.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAll right. That question covers a lot. Let me begin by showing a bit of reluctance to commit. Serving as a support to both the operating team and finance is among my responsibilities. I would say—and I suspect Mike would agree with me—that we deliberately avoid making commitments we can't meet. How we run things depends on that, in my view. One thing I want to state: we shouldn't make promises to investors beyond what we can deliver. Still, when it comes to POS, performance has been quite solid as of late, particularly in the East. For us, the key clinical question is whether—and I believe we've demonstrated our ability to hold onto those customers. In other words, that's already been accomplished. So deep down, my own outlook is likely rosier than what we're sharing with you. When we think about the year ahead and put together our budget—which is still a work in progress—I've made it very clear to Mike, and the two of us see eye to eye on this (though he's perfectly capable of speaking for himself), that we went back through all the prior years, and I believe we've mentioned this multiple times on recent calls. If, in earlier periods, there had been an opportunity for additional promotional hours or a bigger pot of media and marketing spend, Mike might have responded that he could negotiate arrangements with retailers and fund promotion through that route. That's the direction I'd want us to take. Randy, during his time, used to ask why, as a company with four brands, we kept being so restrained with our marketing budget. What's the reason for that? During the pandemic, we saw a chance to invest heavily in our direct initiatives, leaning on social media in a fresh way that we developed alongside <<inaudible>>. Last year left us feeling quite positive about it. Mike has since taken on more leverage, and I believe after last year he came away admitting he'd been mistaken. So, to put it indirectly, we remain firmly committed to marketing and brand building—it's not something we can skip. That's what makes us distinctive; we deal in branded goods. With that, Mike, would you like to…
Mike Lukemire
executiveYeah, I'd say I tend to lean optimistic anyway, though we were keeping the customers we had. My sense is we'll get sharper about localization, working alongside our retail partners, leaning on our marketing, and finding the right mix between promotions and marketing spend. Could we come out even stronger next year? Just look at August — the month is shaping up, we're opening around 7% or 8% up on a 35 comp. The consumer hasn't gone anywhere. And if we pair that with weather and focused marketing, I feel good about POS and what we'll do next year. Shipments, I see as a question of when the catch-up happens; given how far back we were, we're now in a better spot and managing that shipment flow; so I'd pretty much separate shipments from POS, but the customer is still with us. They keep purchasing, and there's room for more there. So — and I believe you'll pick that up from a few of our retailers in the categories.
Jonathan Andersen
analystAll right. Mike, how do you see the likelihood of another price increase coming in January? Are you ready to make a call on that right now?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveYes, I am.
Mike Lukemire
executiveWell, sure, each day seems to bring something different. Resin supply has me concerned, and I haven't noticed any easing in cost. So I'd probably point to grass seed. This year's harvest turned out poorly, and in fact there's a scarcity — we're headed for a scarcity when it comes to grass seed.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveHonestly, Jon, that's something we wondered about too ahead of this call. And the way things stand at the moment, it seems close to a done deal, though there are months separating where we are from where we'd be. And I'd say the pressure has caught us off guard, and on the bright side, the retailers get it, and this wasn't some half-measure — it was a thoughtful plan worked out alongside the retailers, where we asked, could we do this in two steps. And could we kind of create a bit of room and find some easing on commodities, which over the long haul I still think are transitory, though I'm not certain. The fed likely shares that view, I'd guess; but time will tell. Still, I'd say that if Mike chimes in on this, or if you'd been sitting in the room prior to this call, I think we'd have called it close to a sure thing given what we know right now.
Jonathan Andersen
analystAlright. Thank you so much.
Joe Altobello
analystThanks. Hi, everyone. Good morning. I suppose I’ll piggyback on what Jon asked — if you folks wind up implementing yet another 5% price hike in January. Beyond the 5% you already put through, what do your internal models indicate regarding the possible effect on volumes? Since I believe the historical danger has been that buyers don’t always shift down; they exit the category entirely when pricing climbs too much. So how big a danger is that if pricing next year winds up in double digits.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveLook, I’ve been out of spoken I think. I believe this inflationary pressure harms the American economy, full stop. And I believe that when you consider how things tend to get rough out there, we tend to be heard less under those circumstances. Consider the housing crisis — and I’m not forecasting a housing crisis here, what I mean is that throughout that stretch, which all of us recall, some folks refer to it as the great depression. If you consider the projects homeowners took on, they were doing what you might call garden projects and painting projects. And I believe this is an extremely sticky category. We have far more customers now than we used to. I believe the housing market is terrific. But I believe if everything folks purchase daily keeps climbing like our products do. And from where I sit, it’s like, what do you make of this — not seeing it. I am aware of the fact that I don’t grasp why certain players set prices the way they do, meaning commodities, what they’re up to, since they have the ability. And I believe it’s — to some degree, we bear responsibility. We strive to act responsibly in our pricing approach. I don’t know what might alter anything. But my view is, I think it harms America. And I think we likely aren’t entirely shielded from that, meaning, should prices rise by double digits. Do I believe demand might take a hit. I think less so than others, yet I think the response is likely, yes; and I think that’s a truthful response. I’m not certain what more you could say. I mean, I’ll turn it around — what’s your take?
Joe Altobello
analystIt's likely a combination of factors, clearly. In certain categories, we're observing fairly significant price hikes, and consumers are managing those reasonably well, while in other areas they're struggling more. So based on history in your sector, you'd have far better insight than I would. Your demand appears quite inelastic, so I'd expect the effect on volumes to be relatively minimal.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveRight. The one point I'd make is that we touched on this year somewhat and I don't believe we truly dug into it, which is what's going on with retail promotion. Mike and I have devoted considerable time to this. We need to keep in mind that last year's pricing to the consumer reached double digits, since there was no promotion at all, alright. Currently, I believe you're seeing promotion activity at roughly 50% of the level from before. That's approximately Mike's and my best estimate — it didn't remain as it was throughout COVID, we discuss especially in areas like soils and mulch, where promotion is heavy. We believe it returned to around half of that. So essentially, pricing to the consumer is likely lower by about 5 points this year, meaning some of that will be softened, but you can examine what occurred last year. And I realize there are many complicating elements, since people were at home with nothing else to occupy them. Yet they showed great tolerance for, I'm not certain, but I think the calculation we ran suggests roughly 11% or so was actually what consumers paid above what they'd paid the prior year across the full line.
Joe Altobello
analystAlright, I understand. Thanks, everyone.
Andrew Carter
analystHi there, thank you. Good morning to you all. I’d like to bring up the Hawthorne segment and what its margin picture looks like over the trailing 12 months — that figure sits at 12%, which is 100 basis points higher than the same period a year ago, and it’s 2x what you originally projected for sales, considering every investment you pointed out. So my question, I suppose, is this: you’ve discussed how sales are growing, but might you rely on that segment in the years ahead to lift earnings power, maybe even surpass the 100 basis points of margin expansion you’ve outlined as your expectation? Thank you.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveCory, this one’s yours.
Cory Miller
executiveSure, I'll handle that one. When you examine the profit percentages generated by the Hawthorne operation, we have deliberately tried to lift those by roughly 100 basis points each year. That approach let us keep the expansion we were after in that unit in line with the money we intended to commit to the category, and we have held to those 100 basis points. From a margin standpoint, I believe that operation can be viewed as moving upward, though it would come at the expense of growth. There are many rivals in this area, and many distinct competitors using varying pricing approaches, so we face that constantly. Naturally, over the long haul Hawthorne is meant to reach a profit percentage we feel good about and keep pushing higher. In the near term, though, we still want to focus on the expansion we are generating in that unit. Several quarters have come in above 50%. That tempo is something we want to maintain. We are putting money into our distribution centers so that rate of expansion can keep going, yet there is an idea that we want to keep lifting the profit percentage in some manner, weighing those two considerations as we move into the following year.
Andrew Carter
analystThank you. Moving to a different topic, I'm a bit unclear about the Bonnie's guidance. You now anticipate a $0.20 headwind this year, versus $0.10 to $0.15 previously, if I understood that right, and you had expected a headwind in FY2022. There are many moving pieces. But might we see some relief for Bonnie's on a year-over-year basis in FY2022? Or will it basically be neutral when you look at next year? Thank you.
Cory Miller
executiveAs we head into 2022, one thing to flag for 2022 is that, given the timing of our entry into the JV, Q1 will be a headwind for us. That has nothing to do with the underlying business; it's simply a headwind for us because of when we entered that JV. But regarding the underlying business, when we consider the sales growth we expect that business to deliver, it's a balancing act between how much we believe we want the business to grow and how much we want to push that business to grow. The difference in the body business, as I mentioned in my script, is that if you build the inventory and it doesn't sell, it becomes a bad guy that hits the bottom line when you write that inventory off. So we need measured growth in body. We need to build the inventory to achieve that measured growth and be willing to give up a little volume to ensure we finish the year in the right spot from an inventory standpoint, if we don't have issues we must eliminate; so if we plan appropriately with Bonnie, we can see some earnings increase; we just want to ensure we're planning appropriately and then executing.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveYeah. I'd like to provide them some protection, honestly. Coming out of COVID, with the pressure to get product ready—live product included—we probably pushed quite hard to have everything lined up for the year. And you really have to look back at last year, that entire COVID year, and admit nobody could predict what would happen. Retailers had very high hopes. We had very high hopes too. We've spent heavily on adding capacity for the Scotts business. Here's a key point: we gained 25% of volume during COVID, and I believe we described that as roughly a decades worth of growth. Capacity was already fairly tight before COVID arrived—well balanced, positioned where you'd want it, and we were where we wanted to be—and after reviewing things, we concluded we should build in some flex capacity, even if growth rates return to something closer to normal and we retain most, or perhaps all, of the customers we gained. That's basically what we're up to. Turning to Bonnie, we did push for more production. And they seem—they're more attuned to weather, I'd say, than we are. But when you consider what inventory costs, and I—this may well make folks squirm—what do we figure earnings would have looked like had they not been forced to absorb that inventory, Mike? So, and do we—assuming the business avoids repeating that mistake going into next year, what does that gain us?
Mike Lukemire
executiveOkay, so there are a couple of points here. First, our assumption was for growth of 10%. That led us to put $11 million into investments beyond what had been spent during the prior year. Then, when you look at trend wives historically, it tends to run at about 40%. In the last year, ours was likely closer to 30%, since we essentially sold nearly every unit we produced. As a result, you ended up somewhat starved for business while that 40% figure was shrinking, and because we didn't hit the volume along with those investments, the business likely could have generated an additional $12 million to $13 million. That's the area where we're going to be somewhat smarter. So I won't apologize for leaning in aggressively and making that bet. I also believe it's a great business. But I do think we needed to be somewhat smarter about how hard we pushed. It's a bit like the bread business for those of us who have had experience in food. I believe we were somewhat bullish in our activity, so we'll make that adjustment. And I think that business — and we'll keep working on shrink, and we're learning a great deal about that business in terms of what the consumer needs and retail, so.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveMy take is that this ought to end up being a net positive overall, simply because to a certain degree we construct our figures around an assumption about what inventory we're holding; and looking back, I believe Mike's point is that whenever something carries expiration dates, we likely ought to exercise a bit more caution. That said, I think what emerged was somewhat of an aggressive push following COVID, and I don't view that as a mistake. As Mike put it, I won't offer an apology for essentially operating the business, though I would add that decision cost us somewhere between $10 million and $15 million in benefit from what we're not doing. We won't make that choice again.
Mike Lukemire
executiveWe're all going to repeat that. What I'd say is, back in March, we were in fact exceeding that 10%. So that's the way — with this particular one, you truly have to keep tracking it on a weekly basis, even more than is the case with our U.S. Consumer business.
Andrew Carter
analystAppreciate it — I'll relay that.
William Reuter
analystMorning, everyone. Just one fast item from me regarding how we deploy capital. You brought up a possible bond issuance — what kind of scale or size do you have in mind for that? Then, on where the proceeds would go, you talked about giving cash back to shareholders as opposed to M&A. Maybe you could say something about how big that M&A might be, and whether the 3.5% total leverage target still holds given everything going on. I realize that's a lot of questions — my apologies.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveSure. To me, this isn't really a case of choosing M&A. What I had in mind was a special dividend, and I believe we've consistently positioned ourselves as shareholder friendly. For much of the period we've discussed this — likely upwards of the last five years — our leaning has probably been toward shrinking the share count. Given the prices we witnessed over the prior year, we essentially concluded we'd just distribute it as a special; that strikes us as sensible. At today's prices, the call we've reached on being shareholder friendly is to accomplish that via repurchasing shares. That's the decision; as for M&A, the environment is quite expensive. Looking at it notionally, I'd say that 3.5 target remains a solid range for us. We believe — at least I do, and I think Cory does too, along with our advisors and Board — that if you were able to lock in rates, say around four, for the coming decade, that would be a sensible wager. So that's what we've chosen to do. I'm not sure what else to add. I'd say we're quite occupied assessing opportunities right now; it's — I don't — I wouldn't describe it as a frightening moment. I'd call it a tremendously exciting moment, in terms of Hawthorne and other efforts tied to adjacencies around Hawthorne, which I think we mentioned — more details to come on that — and there are opportunities even within the core business. But the key point is, yes, we're at ease with the leverage we've referenced previously; we see interest rates as an opening at present, when you stack it against what I suspect many expect down the road. That's about all; and as for the shareholder-friendly piece, our stance is that purchasing shares back at this price beats sending money out the door. That's roughly where things stand.
Mike Lukemire
executiveRight. The single item we didn't address regarding size — we're looking at roughly $400 million.
William Reuter
analystThat's everything I was after. Appreciate it.
Eric Bosshard
analystHello, good morning.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveHi there, Eric.
Eric Bosshard
analystThere are a couple of items I want to cover. To start, you made a brief remark, and I would really like to hear more about how you're viewing inventory at retail, plus the fact that your own inventories look especially elevated as you exit this quarter. I'm calling them especially elevated, but what's your perspective on retail inventories and the inventories sitting on your own balance sheet right now?
Mike Lukemire
executiveWell, my view is that first and foremost, people want supply available. So I'd say resin is in short supply. My sense is retailers are reluctant to run out. We're reluctant to run out too. So that's part of it. I'd add that we're keeping those consumers, and retail inventory will actually need to be bigger in order to support that business. Then the third piece is that a year ago we were far behind, so catching up accounts for some of this as well. And honestly, I wouldn't claim we've entirely caught up in some categories, and I attended a retailer event this past Monday. They essentially told us, you're among the few who stayed on top of it. So they paid us a compliment, and I'd likely judge us more harshly than they did. So looking at all of this, I believe they line up with the ongoing worldwide supply problem. That situation means stores everywhere don't hold sufficient inventory when you consider it as a whole, along with the worry about obtaining and maintaining supply.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveYeah. So I don't really — I can't say for certain what Mike's plan for building is, across the fall and winter. We're probably in that same boat. My sense is that Mike's operating plan came in above where the businesses are actually landing. I don't see that as a negative, if you look at unit volume against the 7% to 9% we gave.
Mike Lukemire
executiveCorrect.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveThere's no shame in that, I believe Mike was aiming toward a bigger plan. So I can't say what his build will end up being. And retail inventories, which are baked into our figures here, I'd say were a worry, especially among the planners and finance folks, that retail inventory levels sit higher than what we'd ideally like to see. But here's the thing: the more conversations we have with retailers, the more we examine what's happening out there, the more I — Eric, the more fear there seems to be about running out of stock. So on the inventory front, retailers aren't putting any pressure on us at all, even with their retail inventories elevated, because they care more about being set for next season and avoiding outages, since the COVID year got burned into everyone's brains, and beyond that there are simply lots of shortages. Take the situation where you can't really hedge: a supplier calls and tells you, I'm giving you a heads-up as a favor. Here's the price. Let me know the quantity you need. I'm working my way down the list. If you won't pay that price, I'll keep going down the list and you'll get no product. That's the kind of environment we're in. It's pretty lousy. So when it comes to hedging in a market where the question is just how much do you want, yes or no, and we're buying under those conditions, you won't hear many people, us included, griping about inventory levels. I think everyone simply wants to make it through this stretch.
Mike Lukemire
executiveThere’s people that actually talk to you about pre-buy in your capacity.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveRetailers.
Mike Lukemire
executiveRetailers. That’s the situation they find themselves in; and so — and at this moment, I’d link it somewhat to commodities, and so unless global supply chains are repaired, it’s sort of an uncertain world out there for retailers and for us. And so we’re attempting to balance that to remain in stock and supply and keep in out and keep the restores.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveBut are you feeling too fad right now, your inventory?
Mike Lukemire
executiveActually, after talking with the retailers this week, I'm feeling somewhat anxious, no doubt. As you're aware, that happened with him on Monday, so there…
Eric Bosshard
analystSo on that note, back in June you mentioned ramping up CapEx to add capacity. And clearly, plenty is happening in the business at the moment, and much of it is pretty favorable, but when it comes to your willingness and intentions for expanding capacity on the consumer side of the business — given your inventory position and your growth outlook for next year — just walk us through again what the approach is for adding consumer capacity?
Mike Lukemire
executiveWe are adding, we are expanding media capacity. And beyond that, we're evaluating our capacity for liquids and fertilizer; so we lack — we have the ability to be more flexible, but what I'd say is, our inventories are weighted more toward the raw materials side, making sure I've got models and caps and stag compete to convert. So the outages I experienced came more from the manufacturing side due to missing components than from our actual capacity. So that's a balancing act we're working through…
Jim Hagedorn
executiveBut Eric, that perspective — what we took away from COVID, I'd argue those takeaways still hold up. We were, I'd say, close to ideal for roughly zero to 2% growth given our manufacturing footprint. Then you get 25%, and on top of that you add more this year. I think when you look at that you conclude it just doesn't work, and that isn't us saying, oh, we've lost our minds. We'd have to build every sort of capacity, and then, normal consumer behavior. Suppose you keep all of it. But should things revert to a more typical mid-single to low-single digit growth pace, we can't run in a situation where everything exceeds capacity. This comes back to a people matter. Our workforce, I'd say, is fairly PTSD out. That doesn't help; and frankly, so I'll advocate that people ought to get vaccinated, but many of our Midwestern sites sit below the national average on vaccination rates. So essentially we're back to protective gear and fairly reasonable infection rates once more. And so it feels like nothing, and it's just — it's truly — and so we can't run our plants at that intensity and we can't run our people at that intensity, and so we do need to, I believe, sensibly add some capacity; and I'd say, I've placed a lot of pressure on Mike and I'll say the folks handling capital allocation to say, no, we don't need to go overboard here. Where do we truly need to commit the money? And it isn't a massive sum. I think we're — I don't know, roughly what CapEx went from previously to today it's around 2x, but I think it's something like 75 to 150 or thereabouts. It isn't enormous in dollars, but it's completely essential to where the business stands now.
Eric Bosshard
analystAll right, and then may I pose just a single additional question about the promotional plan <<inaudible>> I'm not sure. I'll accept that offer. If the promotional spending — you describe retailers as having moved halfway back toward normal, and both of you would agree the category is simpler absent those promotions. My feeling is the consumer likely holds a different view. Shoppers enjoy promotions, in my opinion. They enjoy getting a bargain. What's your outlook for where this heads in 2022? And what effect does that have on you regarding your involvement in it?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveWell, it's up in retail or partnered up site. I believe you can't — everyone has a budget set aside for that. And we did, I think Mike essentially stated it. First, I'm a believer, and I believe each of our big retailers is, a number of our general merchandise folks are simply everyday low price folks. So there it isn't as significant a matter as with the home center crowd. But this is a huge topic of argument for everyone. I believe this 50/50 world is correct. I believe, if you examine this — this is my opinion, and it remains my opinion. It's more informed rather than less informed sir on is that most Black Friday events are inefficient, too costly and too early in the season, and too apt to have weather misses, when it's around April, and my estimate of the miss rate on that is roughly 80%, okay. We call it above 50%. And that's costly and wasteful, and I believe the retailers, absolutely on the basis of what we've experienced the last two years, concur with that figure. No one wants to return to how things were previously. Conversely, certain of those retailers were more promotional than others. This year and I think gain share, so I — this notion that you tell consumers they like it, I believe that's shown to be correct. This notion of targeted and weather dependent, it's not a question of whether you're in a promote mulch or soils, throughout the year, you're going to. What's at issue is, must you do it on a particular day that you plan six, eight months ahead early in the season when you're simply likely to wind up with weather problems? I believe the answer is that's a horrible idea; and — but I believe if you declare, I won't do it at all, I believe you'll lose share; and I believe since consumers truly want that, and it's a thrilling category to shop that comes once a year and lots of energy is generated partly by us and partly by the retailer. So I — what do I think, I think this 50/50 is a justified figure. I think that on the extremely promotional categories, which tend to be early season. Consumers definitely react to this — that's certain at 100% — and it usually draws them into the store. Once they're inside, they pick up additional items and are likely to stay more loyal across the year. So I believe there's a danger in calling it unnecessary, or saying everyday low pricing is — I actually enjoyed how strange that came across. And I'd say pat fairer was probably the greatest — I'm not sure, merchandiser, the most instinct-driven merchandiser ever. And I think he holds the view that promotion truly counts. So I'm with you on this, though I'd call it 50/50, just far more focused. And none of that changes anything. Mike, is there anything you'd like to add?
Mike Lukemire
executiveNo. I'd probably describe it as being a lot like this year, though a bit more focused in some spots where the promotional effort had certain soft points. So — but I wouldn't claim things have returned to how they were before COVID. From no retailer am I observing that. So — but in the event you had 10 discounts on Black Friday, perhaps just three of them would remain — that sort of situation. The approach leans toward being more particular in order to draw shoppers in, then convert them through marketing and by being more local. That's the pattern we're observing.
Eric Bosshard
analystAlright, that gives us a useful way to look at it. Appreciate it.
Jim King
executiveJim King here — thanks, Tracy, and thank you all for being with us. Once more, just to note, Cory and I are going to be at the Raymond James event on September 14, where we’ll give an update on the business transit strategy in general terms; and until then, if anything comes up or you want to follow up after this call, don’t hesitate to reach out to me directly. My number is 937 to 578 to 5622. Thanks to everyone for being here. We’ll be speaking with you again in early November.
Operator
operatorThis concludes today’s call. Thank you for your participation. You may now disconnect.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.