The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company (SMG) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
February 1, 2022
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Jim King
executiveHello, everybody, and thanks for joining us for The Scotts Miracle-Gro First Quarter Conference Call. Here with me today are our Chairman and CEO, Jim Hagedorn; our Chief Financial Officer, Cory Miller; President and Chief Operating Officer, Mike Lukemire; and Chris Hagedorn, who serves as Group President of Hawthorne. Shortly, Jim, Chris, and Cory will offer some prepared comments, after which we'll take your questions. <<operator_script>> I've already arranged time with a number of you following this call to address anything remaining. If anyone else would like to schedule some Q&A, you can reach me directly at (937) 578 to 5622, and we'll try to find a slot as soon as possible. A little housekeeping before we begin. During the week of March 7, Cory and I will be taking part in two investor conferences. The first is the Raymond James Annual Institutional Investors Conference, held at the Grand Lakes Resort in Orlando. The following day, we'll be in Boston to present at the UBS Annual Global Consumer and Retail Conference. Both presentations should be accessible through webcast. We'll share additional information about the date and times once we get nearer to those events; with that, let's proceed to today's call. As usual, we anticipate making forward-looking statements this morning. So I'd like to warn that our actual results may differ materially from what we say. Investors ought to acquaint themselves with the complete set of risk factors that could affect our results. Those are included in our Form 10-K, which is filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission. I'd like to remind everybody that today's call is being recorded. And an archived version of the call will be posted on our website. With that, let's get started this morning, and so I'll hand things over to Jim Hagedorn. Jim?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAppreciate that, Jim, and good morning to all of you. The opening quarter might only represent a modest slice of the total year, yet that certainly doesn't mean we're taking things easy here — far from it. Actually, a number of significant narratives emerged from Q1 that deserve a closer look. These include: sustained heavy involvement from consumers, which delivered a second consecutive year of profitability during Q1 in our U.S. Consumer segment, carrying solid momentum as the calendar year wrapped up; news of a third price adjustment in the consumer business, set to kick in during the year's second half; a boost to our full-year revenue outlook for that segment; at long last, some easing in raw material costs; our supply chain continuing to regain strength, leaving us in great shape to handle demand for the season ahead; restructuring work at Hawthorne that will strengthen that business further; plus lots of activity, among it two additional Hawthorne acquisitions amid the healthiest M&A pipeline we've seen in 25 years. Indeed, there's much to get through. Prior to diving into specifics, I'd like to tell a story that gives useful context regarding the strategy I laid out during our previous call and how it might create value for shareholders. As nearly all of you are aware, my siblings and I hold about 25% of this company. During a recent gathering with our advisers, we went over the financial return on our family's investment dating back to the Scotts and Miracle-Gro merger in 1994. Much like other investors who've held on long term, we've benefited nicely. What mattered most in that conversation, though, was a straightforward question: why? Why did we fare so well? That question is the piece of this story relevant to every shareholder. In my view, one advantage that comes from having a strong family stake in a publicly traded business is our tendency to think long term. And we aren't hesitant to adopt an activist mindset and acknowledge that a company sometimes needs to be reimagined. That moment is now. During our prior call, I mentioned that we're chasing five pillars of growth capable of doubling Scotts Miracle-Gro's size via both organic expansion and acquisitions across the coming 5 years. I further noted that we'd look into whether the company could be split into two separate parts. Clearly, none of that will occur instantly. Still, what we've already accomplished this fiscal year shows precisely how committed we are to this path and how daring we're prepared to be. So let's get started. I'd like to begin with the U.S. Consumer business. Normally I let Cory handle the figures, but I want to open by addressing the P&L. If your focus is solely on year-over-year comparisons, my response is that you're viewing this incorrectly. Consider it against historical context instead. Though it's still the year's smallest quarter, Q1 has grown progressively more significant when viewed across the full year. We shifted additional shipments into the quarter so we could serve our retail partners better, and that adjustment has given the business a meaningful lift. If you only look at the year-over-year figures, that point will escape you. Take Q1 volume: it's lower than a year ago, yet it's 107% above fiscal '20 and considerably greater than the average across the 4 years before COVID; that strikes us as a foundation we can build on. The gross margin rate declined 2% versus last year. Even so, the segment's margin has climbed by over 1,300 basis points relative to the average during the 4 years before COVID. And that's happening while commodities have risen sharply. Segment income tells the same story — it came in positive for just the second time in our history. On average, the bottom line came in $50 million stronger than in each of the 4 years before COVID; and looking forward, there's solid reason to think the first quarter of the U.S. Consumer segment on an EBITDA basis may stay profitable from here. Turning to consumer activity, that's another encouraging story. In Q1, POS — measured by consumer purchases at our largest retailers — rose 3% in units and 9% in dollars. Both figures came on top of a plus 40% comp from a year earlier. Ordinarily, I'd warn against placing too much weight on our Q1 POS. That warning still stands. What's changed this time is that the December quarter extends a pattern reaching back to spring of last year, one showing consumer engagement that has repeatedly beaten our expectations. COVID's effect on POS keeps muddying the straightforward year-over-year comparison; still, if you examine POS units across the past 4 quarters, we're 22% higher than 2 years ago. Even more significant, that 2-year comparison has strengthened over time, which hints the COVID lift might be longer-lasting than we initially thought, and that would leave us with a far larger base to grow from. I won't forecast whether POS for the March quarter turns positive, since our comps remain tough. That said, our latest consumer sentiment data, which arrived just last week, shows us that consumers still view gardening as central to their lifestyles. It also shows they intend their spending to match last year's levels — a meaningful detail given how much inflation is in the economy. And although we still anticipate a slight drop in overall participation levels, over 2/3 of the consumers who do intend to garden this year told us they expect to purchase more plants and have larger gardens. All that we're observing, and all that our retail partners tell us, is reinforcing our confidence as the season's peak draws nearer. We've raised our sales guidance for the U.S. For the consumer segment, we now expect a full-year range of negative 2% to positive 2%, which is 200 basis points higher than the range we gave before. This bump doesn't mean we've altered how we see the rest of the year playing out. Two factors let us widen that range. One, the first-quarter outcome came in above what we'd anticipated, and that ought to deliver a lasting gain across the year. Two, we've told our retail partners about an additional price hike for the back half, and that will move our full-year numbers by 1%. Making the tough call to raise prices a third time within one year is something Scotts Miracle-Gro has never done, yet we had to do it given ongoing cost pressure that turned into a larger headwind than anticipated. That extra point of pricing, kicking in during Q3, brings us back toward our objective of covering commodity cost rises that have plagued us over the last year. Thankfully, several important commodity inputs appear to have topped out during the last month, and it increasingly feels as though the toughest stretch is now behind us. As is true for others, distribution expenses remain elevated, though I'll hand that topic to Cory for a fuller explanation.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveThis latest price increase isn't just about defending our margins. It's also about standing behind our retail partners and safeguarding the competitive edges we've built. Through the years, we've established a leading position in the market and generated solid returns for the retailers we work with by putting substantial money behind innovation, along with support for sales and marketing. Those advantages fueled consumer engagement both before and throughout the COVID crisis. Our outperformance of rivals during COVID wasn't some stroke of dumb luck; we came out ahead because consumers put their trust in our brands to produce the results they're after. We came out ahead because our marketing team crafted messages that were relevant, that connected with those consumers, and that brought them into the stores. And we came out ahead because retailers understood they could depend on our sales force to assist in running their lawn and garden departments when the crisis was at its worst. With the labor market as challenging as it is today, our in-store sales force matters more than it ever has when it comes to backing our retailers, and that investment needs protection. The same holds for our supply chain, which managed to satisfy retailer demand at times when competitors simply couldn't. As I mentioned on the previous call, this degree of pricing isn't something we enjoy, and I truly don't. Still, the steps we've taken let us safeguard those competitive edges and deepen our ties with both consumers and retailers even more. On the subject of relationships, I'd like to give you an update on how Bonnie Plants is performing and on our live goods strategy. Both areas bring good news. To start, Bonnie POS is tracking right alongside our core legacy brands, and we anticipate yet another robust season in edible gardening. During the last few months, the Bonnie supply chain has seen meaningful gains, both through better processes and through a fresh wave of new talent. On top of that, we continue to see our sales and marketing efforts become more integrated. Consumers should end up with a better in-store experience, and our core brands—Miracle-Gro in particular—should gain more cross-selling opportunities. As you're aware, we view live goods as a key entry point into the consumer relationship. The category has already gotten better thanks to our relationship with Bonnie, and we think there's additional work we can do to widen the range of options consumers have. Alongside the Bonnie team and our partner, Alabama Farmers Coop, we've been actively looking into further M&A opportunities that might substantially bolster our live goods portfolio and deliver a greater degree of consumer-driven innovation and retailer support to the industry. It's too soon to reveal any specifics, but the prospects have us excited, and we'll tell you more as those discussions develop. Looking at it from just about every angle, I'm very bullish right now on what the core lawn and garden business can achieve. And I feel just as positive about the moves we're making to strengthen our franchise further and reshape what it means to lead in this industry. Before the onset of COVID, we already understood that shifts in demographics had begun tilting things our way. Millennials, we noticed, were developing an interest in this category and in the brands we offer. Yet the moment their daily existence revolved around where they live, they embraced gardening at levels far beyond anything we had anticipated. Ten years back, this cohort hardly registered in what we reported. Now they are the force behind our performance. What we must do is hold their attention, help them view gardening as something that matters in their daily lives, and help them regard the brands we offer as essential to doing well. Across the whole company, the actions we are taking and the money we are putting to work are the correct ones to make sure that comes about. So indeed, as we get ready for the season, I feel good about what lies ahead. That holds for fiscal '22, and it holds for the years that follow. And I'm certain Mike Lukemire, along with everyone on his team, shares that view. All right, let's turn to Hawthorne. I'll begin with what's plain to see. This year will clearly bring difficulties, and a sales drop is coming. Cory will walk you through the figures, though a great deal of what must be stated was already included in what we put out on January 4. Even though conditions in the market right now are maddening, we haven't lost heart. Our faith in this category and what it can achieve over the long haul remains. And during the last several months, plenty has been happening, all aimed at positioning the business to emerge even more robust once the market starts growing again. Many of you are aware that Hawthorne went through a painful slump in 2018. It was during one of these very calls that I openly faulted the team for letting the pressure of that period freeze them, telling them they had to rise to the occasion. This time, you won't hear anything like that from me. What we took away from 2018 has been an enormous help. And the manner in which the team is handling the present circumstances is as different as it could possibly be. To begin with, the team spotted the market's downward turn all the way back in June, which gave us the chance to get ready. Next, they recognized that the reality of the situation wasn't theirs to alter, so no desperate scramble took place to pursue sales that simply didn't exist. Third, and above all, they adopted an activist mindset and asked, "In what ways can this downturn be used to improve our business?" I have zero doubt that the solutions they arrive at will genuinely leave Hawthorne in a better place. So I'll take a brief pause and invite Chris to bring you up to date.
Chris Hagedorn
executiveThank you, Jim. Hi, everybody. I'd like to begin by spending a brief moment bringing you up to speed on what's happening in the industry right now. It's starting to seem as though the market has hit its low point. We haven't yet come off that low, but for roughly 1 month, daily sales patterns have held steady. That makes things a little simpler to manage. On top of that, we're starting to notice somewhat improved outcomes in consumable segments, such as nutrients and growing media, and that's another positive signal. You're all familiar with what the industry is dealing with at present, so there's no need for me to go into detail. During our January 4 announcement, I mentioned that we anticipate renewed growth in the year's second half; however, I won't try to guess precisely when that occurs or how large it will be. What I can say is that after this downturn finishes, our business is going to be much stronger; we've completed important acquisitions, have moved forward with restructuring where we manufacture, and have reorganized the management team around what the business will need going forward. You've likely already seen what we announced last month regarding buying Luxx Lighting and True Liberty Bags, but I want to provide a little more background. No one would dispute that within indoor cultivation, Gavita stands as the top lighting brand; for Hawthorne it has been a tremendous win and it's essential to our success over the long run; meanwhile Sun System, the private label brand that came to us through the Sunlight Supply acquisition, is a dependable fixture at an entry-level price. Within our industry, lighting matters more than any other category; it's an area where we committed ourselves to innovation and to leading. For growers, no other purchase costs them more than lighting, and nothing else affects their crop more heavily. When we nail the lighting strategy, it forges a bond with those growers, and that opens the door for us to present a full suite of solutions. Over the last two years, our R&D and supply chain folks have helped drive our progress in LED lighting, which is a critical space. We created the best products out there, and that has accelerated the industry's move to LEDs while also strengthening our market share. Even so, we recognized that we needed more than we had. Having examined every option available in the market, we determined that Luxx was the brand with the greatest potential. What sets Luxx apart is that cannabis growers designed it, and commercial cultivators rely on it widely, since they're familiar with its track record and have faith in how it performs. Present market conditions turned the financial case for buying Luxx into an extremely appealing one, particularly given the synergies we're able to realize from it. With the Luxx transaction, now is the ideal moment to start bringing our lighting manufacturing together into one place. Last week we shared that we'll be relocating our existing lighting production, primarily HPS lights, out of Vancouver, Washington and down to Southern California. We're going to relocate the other LED assembly work that we've had there as well. This relocation is going to cut our distribution expenses on both the inbound and outbound sides by a significant amount, let us get more out of our workforce, and make use of one of the strongest manufacturing sites anywhere in the SMG network. Those savings are going to let us remove considerable cost from every fixture and greatly strengthen a position we already hold as market leader, particularly in the LED market, which is so critical. As part of this restructuring effort, we are also shutting down the HydroLogic manufacturing facility, a business we bought last year. That production is being shifted to our Santa Rosa facility, the place where General Hydroponics first began. Also on the East Coast, we are consolidating our distribution operations in a New Jersey facility that we constructed recently, which positions us to meet anticipated demand from emerging markets in the coming years. Returning to the topic of M&A: the second acquisition we made public, True Liberty Bags, represents a considerably smaller transaction, yet it reflects our commitment to a strategy in which growers sit at the heart of all our activities. True Liberty's offerings play a role in the post-harvest stage, enabling freezing, storage, and transportation of substantial harvest volumes. These items are engineered to avoid cross-contamination and maintain the plant's quality. Though this is a specialized segment, it is an essential one. True Liberty holds an obvious top spot in this category, and growers operating commercially put their faith in that name. Over the past six months, we brought Luxx, True Liberty, HydroLogic and Rhizoflora into the fold, and those deals do more than boost the P&L. Thanks to these brands, Hawthorne matters more than ever to the people doing the cultivating, and they keep viewing us as something well beyond a mere distributor. What they see is a dependable supplier who grasps the finer points of how they operate, and who keeps putting money back in to deliver improved product options and drive stronger returns. We also made another set of changes by reorganizing the team so it concentrates on what the business requires once the market comes back. About 200 roles were cut as part of the restructuring. The decision itself was straightforward from a business standpoint, but saying goodbye to people who contributed so much to the team is never pleasant. We made every effort to help them transition smoothly. I truly hope things go well for each of them going forward. In addition, we adjusted some leadership at Hawthorne. Tom Crabtree came aboard several months back to head up our sales operation. You last heard from him at our virtual Analyst Day, where he appeared as part of the U.S. Consumer team. Tom brings an impressive résumé. Tom began his career in SMG's supply chain, later transitioning into sales, where at one point he overhauled the sales organization for The Home Depot. After that, he took charge of the entire U.S. Consumer sales operation. Above all, Tom stands out as an exceptional leader. He has a knack for assembling teams, inspiring them, and crafting initiatives that deliver measurable outcomes. Looking toward the future, I never questioned that Tom was the right person to take on the role of Chief Operator at Hawthorne, and he assumed that post recently. As you can see, even though sales have slowed right now, we haven't. All of these adjustments serve to make our company more robust and will assist in pushing Hawthorne even further ahead of our rivals. I'll be available during Q&A. However, at this point, I'll hand things back to Jim.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAppreciate that, Chris. As you recall, exploring chances in the cannabis sector's newer, more consumer-oriented segments ranks as the fifth pillar in our growth plan. Although SMG is able to put money directly into that area at present, we can create optionality we might take advantage of down the road. Forming The Hawthorne Collective and extending that convertible loan to RIV Capital both fit within this approach. Since RIV is publicly traded, there's a limit to how much I can share this morning regarding what they're doing; still, keep in mind we hold three Board seats there, and that board is quite engaged in shaping the strategy and vision for whatever lies ahead; viewed through that prism, I can say you should anticipate some significant news during the coming quarter. Consequently, we might decide to put additional cash into RIV across the remainder of the year, which would raise our ownership percentage should we convert that loan into equity. Even so, we would continue to hold a noncontrolling, non-ownership position. Plus, whatever extra cash we might add wouldn't come close to the size of the initial investment from last year. Speaking of Hawthorne and The Hawthorne Collective, one further point deserves mention. I'm aware that our discussion on last year's call about a potential company split drew considerable attention. Jim King has shared with me that he held literally dozens of conversations on this matter with existing or prospective shareholders. Let me restate that no definitive decision has been reached on whether to move forward along that path. Moreover, some time will pass before we do. That said, since the previous call, an internal team has been set up to examine this question and assist in exploring the appropriate courses of action. There are points in favor of a split and equally strong points in favor of carrying on as a single company. No pressure exists on our end to tilt either way, though we'll let the facts and analysis steer how we decide. Before I finish and hand the floor to Cory, here's a closing thought. It takes me back to that meeting with my family. Our business currently finds itself in a fairly strong position, and taking it easy while simply reaping what we've sown over the coming years would be simple enough. Yet the opportunities sitting before us are just too clear and too significant to overlook. Should we succeed in carrying out our strategy, this will become a far larger and more profitable enterprise that generates meaningful value for our shareholders. I won't claim we'll face no obstacles along the way. The difficulty level tied to certain of our efforts runs high; even so, any path worth taking can get slippery now and then. I'm confident that those who opt to journey with us in the years to come will be pleased they did. There's plenty of thrilling work converging as we move through the upcoming months and quarters. I'm eager to keep you posted on how we're doing as we go; at this point, though, I'll hand the floor to Cory so he can walk through the first quarter's financial results. Cory?
Cory Miller
executiveThank you, Jim, and good morning to all of you. I'll keep my remarks short today. Much of the ground has been covered already, whether through the pre-announcement we issued last month or by Jim and Chris earlier this morning. That said, there are several important themes I'd like to address, particularly regarding the changes we've made to our guidance, where cost of goods trends stand right now, and how we're approaching capital allocation going forward. Looking at the P&L, the top line held no real surprises. Overall company sales declined 24%, compared against a 105% comp from a year ago. U.S. Consumer sales fell 16% on a 147% comparison. Hawthorne dropped 38% versus 71% growth in the prior year. Within U.S. Consumer, POS was solid, as Jim noted earlier; and retailers ended the quarter carrying inventory levels consistent with where they stood 12 months ago; that outcome represented the best-case scenario from our perspective. They stayed committed to the category throughout the fall season and maintained suitable inventory levels in their stores as we head into the slowest weeks of the year. That positions them favorably as we shift into our key selling season; and the shipments we observed through January give us optimism. The midpoint of our raised sales guidance for the segment presumes an 8 point volume decline for the full year, fully offset by pricing. Trends over 4 months hint that this could prove a conservative estimate; but as Jim noted, we're under 10% of the way through the year, and it's far too soon to forecast what spring will bring. Turning to Hawthorne. The revenue decrease stemmed mainly from weakness across the broader cannabis market. The supply chain issues we've referenced before are hard to pin down precisely. Still, we estimate they accounted for roughly 5% of the downward pressure during the quarter; those issues, largely within the LED lighting segment, have been resolved, and we've restocked the components required to resume manufacturing and shipping LED lights, for which demand remains strong. Now let's turn to gross margins, since this is something important to grasp. As you're aware, Q1 results are often subject to the law of small numbers. That's precisely what occurred with gross margin. The adjusted rate dropped 570 basis points for the quarter, driven by the year-over-year volume decline and its effect on manufacturing, distribution and other fixed costs. Commodity prices also created a headwind during the quarter but were offset by a 400 basis point gain from pricing actions. Jim pointed out how important it is to view the gross margin rate within historical context, and I couldn't agree more. The quarter's result came in more than 600 basis points above fiscal '20 and over 850 basis points above fiscal '19. During the last few years, we've successfully shifted business into Q1 so that retailers are set up correctly for the season, and that ought to leave us with a profitability level that's higher going forward. When I consider the rest of the year, our gross margin rate guidance stays the same, calling for a decline of 100 to 150 basis points. At this moment, my expectation is that we land at the lower or worse end of that range. For the remainder of the year, margins ought to be fairly flat, though they could move somewhat quarter to quarter, either up or down, driven mainly by timing and mix. You likely noticed my quote this morning in the press release regarding commodity costs, and Jim mentioned it briefly as well. Allow me to explain further. Altogether, we're 70% locked on commodities for the year, a bit behind where we'd normally be. Typically, all of our costs on pallets would be locked at this point. However, we're sitting at only 30% since vendors aren't signing long-term contracts right now given how volatile lumber prices have been. On all other items, we're in solid shape, urea included, where we're almost 80% locked for the year. Even better, some relief is beginning to appear. Resin has been pulling back for a couple of months now. Urea has started following the same path. Nobody has been forecasting input costs accurately over the last year, so caution is warranted. Even so, I grow more optimistic that the pricing actions we've taken ought to offset these commodity headwinds across a full year. SG&A fell 2% following a sharp rise last year. Keep in mind that guidance calls for SG&A to decline up to 6% for the year, and it's something we're watching closely as the season gets nearer. The sole remaining item on the P&L deserving your attention is the $7 million loss on the equity income line, tied to our 50% ownership in Bonnie. Keep in mind, a year ago we didn't hold that ownership stake. Also, Q1 is a seasonal loss quarter for Bonnie. As Jim noted, the business has started the year solidly, and we're optimistic about the season ahead. On the bottom line, our seasonal loss on a GAAP basis came to $0.90 a share versus income of $0.43 last year. Adjusted earnings, excluding restructuring, impairment and nonrecurring charges, showed a loss of $0.88 compared with earnings a year ago of $0.39. You may remember that fiscal '21 was the first time in company history we reported a first quarter profit. Chris brought up in his remarks the realignment at Hawthorne. We anticipate those actions will produce a restructuring charge of up to $5 million in the second quarter. That charge will be left out of our full year guidance. Let me quickly address the balance sheet, with particular attention to inventories, which have risen roughly $590 million versus last year. To start, keep in mind that a year back, our inventory positions sat below the levels we'd have preferred, since in both of our major segments we were moving goods out almost as quickly as production allowed. Next, remember that during the prior year we deliberately accumulated an inventory buffer so that we could maintain suitable stock levels for our retail partners all season long. Then, roughly 25% of this rise stems from the elevated input costs we've faced across the last year; at this level, inventory still feels right to us, and we keep viewing it as an edge over rivals. We anticipate that certain competitors will again have trouble keeping up with demand this year, and we think that plays into our hands. Last, let me turn to how we're allocating capital. Our CapEx plan remains at about $200 million for the year, since we're still upgrading our supply chain and putting money into our e-commerce infrastructure. Keep in mind, the investments we'd been making assumed annual growth of 1 point or 2 for our U.S. Consumer segment. It's risen roughly 40% since fiscal 2019, and our capacity has been stretched to the maximum, so these outlays are required. Jim spoke more than once about the M&A possibilities ahead of us, so let me give you some background.
Cory Miller
executiveRight now, we're putting together a budget of just over $200 million for upcoming deals during the rest of this year. Should those remaining opportunities be pursued, they ought to boost earnings right away and significantly help move our strategy forward. When it comes to giving cash back to shareholders, during Q1 we bought back $125 million worth of our stock, and we have a 10b5 to 1 lined up for an additional $50 million in Q2. At present, no 10b5 to 1 exists for the year's second half, and we'd anticipate that any buyback activity in that window would take place on the open market. On top of that, we currently have no intentions for a special dividend this year. Based on how we see the business right now and the capital we expect to spend, we might go a bit above our 3.5x leverage target by the time the fiscal year ends; at the close of Q1, we stood at 3.3x. Should we go past that 3.5x target, we'd expect to return beneath it in a quarter or 2, and we would remain comfortably inside our existing debt covenants. Before opening the call for your questions, let me say I'm genuinely pleased with where things stand for us at this moment. We're aware there are some near-term challenges in Hawthorne, but our attention isn't on demand we cannot control. Our attention is on what we can control; namely, how we look once growth comes back. I'm certain we'll be positioned better than at any prior point, with an improved margin profile and competitive advantages that have grown stronger across the past several months. In U.S. Consumer, Jim's optimism is something I share. No further changes to our guidance are needed at this time. Still, the trends are definitely shifting our way for the season ahead and past that. And last, on a personal note, I've just finished my first full year in this role. Engaging with all of you was a new experience for me, and it has given me a greater understanding of the issues on our shareholders' minds. Through this new lens, I'm working closely with my colleagues to make sure we act as proper stewards of our capital and concentrate on driving value for all of you. And although I've also come to value how important this quarterly discussion with all of you is, it has also strengthened my belief that running the business quarter-to-quarter isn't possible. Value gets driven over the long term, and I'm certain the steps we're taking to strengthen the business will accomplish exactly that. Now let me hand the call over to the operator for your questions.
Jonathan Andersen
analystCongratulations, Cory, on completing your initial 12 months in the role. I'd like to begin by asking about the U.S. Consumer segment, specifically regarding demand or how consumers are engaging now that the pandemic is fading, or at least we assume it's fading. You've raised your full-year projections for that business, which points to a fair amount of confidence. My assumption is that this stems from real-time information you're tracking via point of sale. You mentioned survey data as well. What I'd like to hear more about is what's underpinning your optimism in that segment, particularly as shoppers start traveling again, heading back to offices, and dealing with the overall inflation that people are confronting right now across every consumer category. That's a major concern for the investors we speak with.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveJon, this is Jim Hagedorn. That's quite a loaded question. The POS figures are certainly solid. For roughly a couple of years, post-COVID, we began expressing that if only we could maintain those sales numbers; so for us to state, "We believe sales will land between down 2% and up 2%," is — Mike and I still find that difficult. Still, I'd argue the POS information, though limited in scope, essentially indicates consumers remain involved. The survey results once more simply show that folks desire a garden — that younger individuals seeking a garden care about gardening even more than their parents did, and they're prepared to pay out more. And finally from me, before I pass it to Mike, is the fact that retailers are genuinely excited about this category — I mean both e-commerce and physical stores — they're truly supportive and dedicated to it. I believe that's evident in how our products are flowing into stores, and I'd describe it as a significantly earlier and more effective retail loading than what we've experienced previously. So retailers are involved, and up to this point consumers appear to be purchasing. It isn't only us — live goods too, plus the information we're receiving along with our marketing strategies, our innovation, and new items; so I think that's essentially what pushes us to claim, "Sales will be flat," which doesn't exactly sound impressive. Does that sound impressive to you, Mike?
Mike Lukemire
executiveNot at all, though I tend toward optimism. Still, what we're noticing in the market is an uptick in living plants, plus appetite for those plants at a better quality tier. Larger pots are showing up, then, and buyers are responding positively to that. That instills in us some assurance that they're eager to take on more and to achieve better results. Consequently, when it comes to premiums — possessing a premium plant, premium items, that has in fact — we've observed indications that this has genuinely climbed. As for the pricing move up to this point, we haven't witnessed shoppers turning their backs on it. That, then, fuels our optimism; and right now, we're observing exactly that across the South.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveThat negative angle you brought up — basically, will pricing scare folks away from gardening? If I'm being straight with you, my answer would be that we have no idea, and neither do the retailers. Go back to '20, when essentially there wasn't any promotion happening — and compared with last year, I'd estimate promotions ran at roughly half the level of '20. Yet in '20, promotions were at zero; what followed was that retailers likely raised consumer prices by double digits, with no way to run any kind of promotional activity, no Black Friday events to bring prices down. And the business was insane. Of course — again, you pointed out that this happened during COVID, with everyone stuck at home, and so on. But I think the thinking was — we were pretty upfront in saying, "If we can just hold on to what we've got," and we grew — yes, units I believe were up something like 10% last year; so I know I've never witnessed pressures of this kind; and I'm certain our retailers are paying attention; this isn't covering — so on these three price increases, we're definitely in double-digit territory pretty much across the board. And it's still eating into our margin rate. So I think the big worry is what are we going to see? I'm not overly concerned about it; but it's something we'll monitor closely; and I just — honestly, I have to tell you, right, that's a lot of pricing. It's necessary, as I mentioned in my script, but I'm not overly concerned about it. I don't know, Mike, are you?
Mike Lukemire
executiveNo. What I mean is that every sign points to customers sticking with this activity. In fact, we're watching them move up to higher tiers. When it comes to live goods, those are just the first signals.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAnd it's not only live goods, Mike. When we look at Roundup sales down in the Southwest — that's sort of a bellwether for the market — well, I'm not sure what the figures are, but they're — it's big.
Mike Lukemire
executiveRoughly 45%.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveRight. So, what I’d say is, up to this point, things are going well, Jon.
Jonathan Andersen
analystThat helps. Let me ask something on a totally separate subject. Jim, you said there's an in-house group looking hard at whether to split the company up. Could you share anything more about the standards you're applying to reach that decision, what conditions need to be met before you decide, and how long that might take?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveSure. It's a fine question, and the answer is likely messy, which most people here would prefer I skip, but let me ease into it. To begin, consider Hawthorne as a lawful operation. That means we avoid many of the problems around reputational exposure and so on that companies touching the plant face, in terms of both taxes and banking. Bringing Hawthorne into our supply chain and R&D work gives us enormous synergies. So in many respects, you could argue it belongs where it is. That raises the obvious follow-up: "So why spin it off?" I see two reasons that strike me as the most obvious. First, within the investor base, there are likely individuals or institutions who'd tell you, "You own a wonderful lawn and garden operation, strong cash generation, extremely dependable." Meanwhile, cannabis draws an entirely different kind of investor. I suspect there's some validity in that. Whether it trumps the benefits of keeping it in, which I've described previously, I can't say for certain. Let me speak for myself here. Keeping it in means Chris stays with us. And honestly, as a CEO, as a mentor, and as his father, having him involved in the core — our family enterprise — brings me happiness. It would hurt to watch him choose a path heading elsewhere. Then there's the second matter: what we're pursuing with The Hawthorne Collective, which will come into sharper focus within the next couple of months, along with the work happening through RIV — I believe that will start to clarify things. A certain degree of control matters greatly to us. So the plan is, as things become clearer regarding Apollo or The Hawthorne Collective, call it whichever you prefer, we're discussing — not acquisition spending, to be clear. What I mean is the worth of certain businesses we intend to bring together in an alliance and build what I'd call the best — and this lies ahead, once these entities can be consolidated onto a U.S. exchange. I believe we'll build the most valuable pure cannabis play anywhere in the world. And I think we're quite far along that path; once again, you'll learn more soon. My view is that to keep a certain amount of influence here, it might be necessary to use Hawthorne as a form of currency inside that structure, so we hold an ownership stake—something that, I believe, both signals our dedication to this area and gives us the capacity to speak with real weight regarding how it gets run. That matters a great deal to me. So when it comes to deciding which approach is superior, I'm not sure how I'd weigh the trade-offs. Still, my sense is that everything will fall into place. That's about the most candid picture I can give you. So I believe you could wind up with some dis-synergies from separating things. Yet my sense is that the value that might be unlocked by forming an entity like the one we're describing here probably outweighs those fairly small dis-synergies by a good margin. So, I'm not sure—does that answer your question, sir?
Jonathan Andersen
analystGreat, that's really interesting.
Joe Altobello
analystMy first question is probably for Chris. With all the excess cannabis flooding the market right now — you've mentioned a few specific states, California and Oklahoma — are there other places facing the same problem? And do you worry that this rolling oversupply could keep spreading as we move through the rest of the year instead of improving?
Chris Hagedorn
executiveJoe, yeah, this definitely isn't something limited to just one isolated state market. California has been hit hard. And California, of course, remains our biggest single state market — it's still around half of what we do. Michigan, our number two market, is getting hit hard. That said, a lot of states are performing strongly — mostly in the Northeast, or really along the Eastern corridor as a whole. Of course, that's coming from a low starting point, much like what we experienced — and I'm reluctant to even bring up Oklahoma as a comparison — with the expansion we saw there several years back when it was also starting small. In certain states, we're looking at gains of 100,000% or even 200,000%, again from a tiny base. There are definitely some markets where we're still seeing strong performance. But when it comes to the excess supply, what our data tells us is that it's largely a result of the old illegal market. That market doesn't respect state lines at all. So we're noticing this pattern everywhere in the bigger, more mature markets. Places where the legal market is stronger or still growing tend to fare somewhat better. As for how long we expect this situation to last, my view is that it won't persist over the long haul. When legal markets improve and cannabis purchases shift away from illegal sellers toward regulated ones, these kinds of interruptions ought to become less severe and happen less often. Our guess is that this particular one will likely be finished soon — though the accounts we're hearing differ somewhat. We make a point of monitoring cannabis wholesale pricing quite carefully, since we've found that it matters. That single figure actually contains countless tinier figures within it, spanning both legal and illegal channels across various state markets. Every one of those prices differs. Still, taken together, it has likely served as our strongest forward-looking signal. We're keeping a close eye on it and speaking with folks we're tight with in the market who really know what's going on. You might be hearing that the excess inventory got cleared out in April, or possibly it'll happen a bit later, around the start of summer. Either way, we're pretty hopeful that come mid-summer, things should pick up really well; that's reflected in the numbers we're projecting for the rest of the year. Speaking for myself — and I don't want this to come across as a dig at Cory or anyone else here about how much we owe all of you transparency on the full-year numbers — the thing that keeps me up at night, and something I've talked about with the team, is that my focus is really on the path we're on as we wrap up this year. I'm pretty confident we'll end it on an upward path, again once that surplus inventory gets moved out or thrown away, because it does go bad. So the way we see it, somewhere over the next 2 quarters, it'll be mostly depleted and we'll be growing again. That said, that's the information we have.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAnd Chris, I'd like to restate my personal perspective here. Honestly, calling this an immature market feels like I'm being kind. You've got people saying, "I'm going to make a fortune, I'm going to cultivate all of this," then the market collapses and we end up cycling through these patterns together. I believe one thing Hawthorne must do is serve as a guiding force, helping folks grasp production and grasp pricing. This applies on the R&D front, yes, but the economics side of this business is also something we're bringing people in for — I won't name names, but these are well-known professionals eager to examine this emerging sector, assist in making sense of its economics, and deliver that as a service to our customers, essentially helping them see further ahead. Because it really feels like this industry's high beams only reach about 2 feet forward, and there's an awful lot of darkness beyond that. And the capacity to operate in that space is quite high. So once more, expect more updates on this. But our aim is to help this industry professionalize and to be a maturing sort of influence in the space. And I don't believe our competition can in any way make these kind of investments to benefit the industry.
Joe Altobello
analystThat's quite useful. I suppose, simply to build on what you just said, do you observe any problems with cash availability among the hydroponics clients you serve right now?
Chris Hagedorn
executiveJoe, certain of these folks have come to our attention — it varies depending on where they sit at the retail level, and even among a few of our suppliers — and I'd say, at the danger of sounding harsh, and I certainly don't want to offend anyone on this call, especially not the people who buy from us or the people we buy from. But the level of business savvy varies quite a bit across these operations. Certain folks are genuinely well set up, keep a healthy cash cushion, and run things in fairly cautious fashion. Others are far more on a month-by-month basis. A number of those month-by-month players definitely find themselves in a tough spot. So not long ago we had a few folks over in Michigan, and the store owners in that area are simply feeling very low. Since, as Jim mentioned, what they can see ahead stretches only a short distance. They simply lack, in my view, part of the forward view that we enjoy. And after they've struggled for 6 months through conditions in the market that have been genuinely, genuinely brutal, those folks become discouraged. And yes, in certain instances, their cash is getting quite thin. So we're taking certain steps aimed at making things somewhat simpler for a number of our solid, dependable clients, the ones who can give us their financial statements and let us get a handle on how they operate. We're attempting to do the same for a few of our suppliers. But without question, some sort of consolidation is bound to happen because of this disturbance in the market. Certain companies won't make it. And from our standpoint, we don't focus so much on the store or client angle, but rather on the equipment and, in a sense, supplier angle — we see this as a chance to once more push consolidation further ahead. A number of players will drop away. That will open the door to more transactions coming our way at a very attractive price. So it isn't as though this benefits the industry as a whole, yet I do believe we're positioned to capitalize on a few of these situations.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveRight, I’ll only briefly address what Chris mentioned. As far as our receivables aging goes, I don’t believe we’re facing any major problems. That probably answers your question directly. That said, I do recall something—I believe it was Forbes, sometime during the summer—and the headline, I think, was that it’s going to be a bloodbath. Looking at it through a Darwinian lens, that bloodbath will produce stronger players. In my view, Hawthorne came out stronger because of what took place in '18. And we are fully dedicated to this space, and not in any way that anyone could call lame. The Luxx deal came in at a much lower price than the initial figure, given where the market was. There will certainly be opportunities—now, Hawthorne doesn’t have a massive list of targets it’s chasing. But there will certainly be stronger retailers, stronger cultivators. And just from a Darwinian standpoint, Hawthorne will end up stronger because of what’s going on here.
Peter Grom
analystSo I suppose what I'm really asking is a wider question about the full-year guidance. There are plenty of moving parts, I realize. Still, could you take us through the reasoning behind why the earnings range still feels achievable right now? When I run the figures quickly — midpoint of sales, gross margin at the low end, SG&A declining mid-single digits — the result lands much closer to the bottom of the range than the top. Reaching the high end looks somewhat harder. So first off, is that a fair read? And second, is there any conservatism baked in should things like consumer demand or weather deteriorate further? In the U.S. Consumer business, that doesn't appear to be the case, but I'm genuinely trying to grasp how we ought to frame the potential upside or downside to the earnings outlook.
Cory Miller
executiveYes. Peter, it's Cory here. When you look at the guidance we issued a month ago, we reduced the volume in Hawthorne. The quarter landed roughly where we anticipated. Our full-year view there really hasn't shifted much. That said, we did lower the sales level at Hawthorne. Naturally, that creates some drag on the earnings line. At the same time, our confidence in the U.S. Consumer business is stronger than it was when the guidance was set. Things keep moving in the right direction. Retail partners are engaged. POS sits in a place that leaves us comfortable. Net those two against each other on revenue, and what you arrive at on the bottom line matches the range we provided. At that time we issued a $0.40 range. Each day, I tend to pick a figure that moves between the low end and the middle of that range. That's likely where we stand as of today, I'd say. Considering margins and what we anticipate on the input cost side, my comfort level is higher now than it was a couple of months ago. So once you lock that in, the range you reach remains at 850 to 890. And were I to choose a number today, I'd say we're likely in the bottom half of that range. Still, plenty of things could improve. And within there we've got some conservative estimates that could push it up somewhat.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveOkay, Jim Hagedorn speaking, and I'll offer my perspective on this. You're aware of just how unpredictable this industry can be. A great deal hinges on the moment when folks across the country can head outside in a T-shirt and tend their gardens. So let's put it this way: the period from April to June is when everything really takes off. Given that up in Vermont, we're expecting around 15 inches of snow on Thursday and Friday, I believe Cory already walked you through the — so I'll begin by saying your reasoning doesn't strike me as all fubar. That said, our confidence remains fairly strong that a flat result for the consumer business is something we can hit. Should we manage to beat that, plenty of advantages tend to align for us. We'll have far more clarity roughly 2 to 3 months down the road. That would be the ideal moment for it. This business is largely within our control. Right now we aren't working through any emergency checklist or scrambling to act; we're simply operating as usual, aiming to execute our spring season alongside our partners. So we haven't yanked the ripcord and declared, "Oh, my God, we need to shield the P&L." We possess enormous capacity to do exactly that should conditions worsen, but we simply aren't at that point. Mike, anything you'd like to add?
Mike Lukemire
executiveNo, I'm cautiously optimistic; and we'll do the right thing as the season unfolds.
Peter Grom
analystUnderstood. That's really useful. I suppose I have a few quick follow-ups regarding Hawthorne — specifically the remark that the category seems to be bottoming out in terms of daily sales. I believe the wording was that it's holding steady. Could you perhaps help us put that into context as a percentage for January? Then there's the guidance of roughly flat to negative 10% — that uncertainty, correct? Since we're aiming to get the category growing by April or July, I mean, what exactly is assumed in that guidance? If it hinges on growth returning in July, would an earlier comeback mean upside? And then — I realize there's a lot packed in here — but Cory, in the January release, there was a statement that preorders had risen for nutrients and growing media. I might have overlooked this during the prepared remarks, but does that still hold true?
Cory Miller
executiveYes. Looking at what's happened since our last conversation or since we last reported numbers, I'd say we're essentially tracking toward that full year guidance. As Chris mentioned, the timing we anticipate for a turnaround falls somewhere between spring and summer. We're still working out how that translates on a daily sales basis. That said, nothing we're currently observing is pushing us away from the guidance we issued for the full year range. We remain fairly at ease with it.
Chris Hagedorn
executiveAbsolutely. And to build on Cory’s point — you brought up what we talked about in last month’s release regarding media sales growth and certain nutrient sales. So, indeed, we continue to observe preorder volume that has already surpassed our total orders — or, rather, the preorders we had for the entire prior year. Those will ship roughly from this month through June. What that truly tells us, though, is that retailers — even with that depression I brought up in my previous response — are feeling assured that a rebound is coming. They wouldn’t place orders at these levels unless they believed customers would be walking in to purchase; plus, within just the last few weeks, we’re noticing a fairly notable rise in propagation supply sales — again, folks starting seeds, doing clones, that sort of thing. Once more, these are all sorts of forward-looking market confidence signals to us that give us a fairly good sense that, again, when spring arrives, in early summer, we’ll witness this recovery. I don’t want to count my chickens before they hatch. But again, every indicator we have within our business is quite positive at this moment.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveYeah, I just want to add something, sort of a pitch for Hawthorne, I suppose. What you're partly witnessing, given these price levels, is how willing folks are to construct additional grows and put money in. And to a degree, I think that's retarded because of the pricing out there, plus people's readiness to build out when prices sit where they are. And if you look at, say, Hydrofarm, I hate to say it, I don't buy it, but I think they've got a consumer operation in Canada that's likely inflating their figure in an artificial way. On top of that, they lack the lighting operation that we have. So we've put a great deal into lighting; and here's the pitch portion, I think, if you examine what Hawthorne has accomplished over the last, let's say, 3 years with LEDs, if you examine HPS lighting, the older, conventional lighting, those figures have fallen quite a bit. What you're witnessing is a far swifter shift toward LED lighting than I think anyone in this sector, and we're the largest, would have expected. The effort Hawthorne has put in and the purchase of Luxx have simply created an extremely, extremely strong lighting operation in the segment of the market that's expanding quite nicely; and I believe that advantage will unfold across the coming years; and so I think you need to view Hawthorne this way: Hawthorne is hit harder because the largest portion of our business, which is lighting and, in a sense, HVAC, humidification, it's been air-conditioning and such. So we're far more engaged in, in a sense, build-out projects. And so I think if you can rationally examine what's happening there — but I think if you examine Hawthorne's franchise, I think it's simply a far more varied and strategic operation for this sector than someone who is essentially a distributor.
Chris Carey
analystSo I suppose I'd like to get somewhat granular regarding Hawthorne. Was it lighting that caused the drop in profitability during the quarter? How do you see profitability for this business moving forward from where we are now? And I ask this given all those little details you mentioned concerning inventories being at the back end, having additional components, demand being present, and your shipping of lights. That's question one, roughly. And connected to that, this restructuring appears as though it will let you bring down prices on lighting. Could you elaborate on that? Are you receiving resistance regarding lighting prices? Are you preparing for this industry shift to the East Coast as additional states begin to open up, and broadening your competitive position? So beneath all of that, there are many questions concerning lighting; but the main point is simply profitability along with certain strategic choices you're making to perhaps enhance your value proposition going forward.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveChris, this is Jim Hagedorn. Everyone wanted to respond to this one, so everyone is sort of competing, but I'm pulling rank on this one; we absolutely are not engaged in a race to the bottom on light pricing, definitely not. Our top light source is being built as quickly as we can produce them. And that truly connects back to what I said about LEDs. That's likewise the case with Luxx, where business is doing well. I believe it's the HPS and CMH lights, the more conventional lights, that find themselves under pressure. And I know Chris and his finance people were rushing over while you were posing the question, to sort of supply him. So I won't stand in the way there. Mark, would you like to — just come over here. Mark Scheiwer is our — he serves as the CFO for Hawthorne. I think you folks might be familiar with him. He was the — Scotts' Controller prior to moving over to Hawthorne. Would you like to say a bit about what's sort of propelling your figures?
Mark Scheiwer
executiveOkay, then. Regarding the drop in our sales, I'd say that for this quarter, roughly half of it relates to lighting. And I'd estimate that around 2/3 comes from our durables product line and such. So when it comes to that sales decline, that's a major portion of what you're seeing. And then clearly, given the broader drop in our profitability, fixed cost leverage has an effect on our figures and our earnings for the quarter. But I believe that as we scale up during the rebound in the back half of the year, we'll be positioned for profitability. So I'd say those are the main...
Jim Hagedorn
executiveChris, what I see as the key thing here is that significant move toward LEDs, away from the older kind of — I won't say metal-halide, since that would get me in trouble. But the older style...
Mike Lukemire
executiveHPS is what we're talking about.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveStill, when you step back and ask, "How does Hawthorne stack up against the market?", our standing in LEDs is genuinely, genuinely strong; and it's obvious that LEDs represent the direction the whole market is headed.
Chris Hagedorn
executiveAnd, yeah, to add to what you said, Chris, the wave of LED adoption we're witnessing truly isn't confined to cannabis. A key element of our approach involves viewing our product range and what we offer as far wider than simply catering to cannabis cultivators. Obviously, that's our core and main focus. Yet through our ProHort division in Canada and Europe, we're handling huge lighting installations, entirely LEDs. So as Jim noted, LED uptake is happening essentially everywhere in controlled environment agriculture, be it cannabis or something else. Of course, watching product categories that make up roughly 50% of our operations stall out here—that stems from folks simply being unwilling to construct new grows. Plainly, that will hit our profitability hard. Once the market recovers and cultivation resumes at a point where it makes financial sense for them, and cannabis wholesale pricing climbs back, we'll gain from it far more than anyone else thanks to where we sit; and as I mentioned, we anticipate that during the latter half of the year. Regarding the supply chain steps we've taken, as Jim said, we have no interest in competing at the bottom; we possess genuinely value-added lights and compelling innovation that justify the price they command in the market. And we believe customers aren't hesitant to pay it. Our challenge has been sustaining ourselves and providing those items while producing them as efficiently as possible. And shifting—bringing some of that production in-house isn't merely about cutting costs for us, boosting our margin, or giving consumers a cheaper price. It's also about exerting a bit more control over our supply chain and not relying so heavily on others and getting stranded. Because that's—it's tough when you're navigating a market like this, and you've got customers eager to order product while you simply lack the profit to fulfill those orders. So we won't put ourselves in that spot again. And much of what's fueling this is simply taking charge of our own future.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAnd finally on that point, Chris, Luke traveled to Temecula, where we operate a massive plastics facility, with an excellent workforce and an excellent management team. And Mike and Dave Swihart returned and essentially said, "We're relocating everything down to Temecula." And the benefit we're discussing is triple digit in dollars.
Cory Miller
executiveWhen you look at it for each fixture.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveThat's one area where — being any more precise probably isn't something we'd want to do. Still, this represents a really significant capability to fix cost. And giving that back isn't the point. We absolutely can compete. Market-leading products are within reach, at the opening price point as well as on the premium side, backed by technology that makes the pricing fair. But we're simply taking everything — what I mean is, we're doing — consider the LED supply chain spanning us and Luxx: it's kind of scattered across the globe. And that — anything you'd like to add there, Mike?
Mike Lukemire
executiveMy view is that you'll be able to get your costs into better shape, get your inventory and availability into better shape. On top of that, you're keeping a handle on the way your innovation gets introduced. So that's the kind of optimization upside that LED brings with it.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAnd puts it much closer to the market.
Mike Lukemire
executivePrecisely.
Chris Carey
analystThat's a terrific way to look at it. And I suppose, and I'll be brief here if I can nearly wrap that up from this point. Profitability in that segment, given the inventory situation, given certain staffing levels, given supply chain or whatever the cause may be, should show improvement quarter over quarter starting now. And maybe across the entire fleet, you're marginally profitable in Hawthorne during Q2, and you build further in the second half thanks to gains in lighting. If you could just lay that out to sort of assist in setting expectations for the segment, I believe it would be useful.
Cory Miller
executiveYes. Chris, I think your read on that is correct. We gave up a little in Q1, expecting volume to rise and return to positive territory in Q2. And when you look at Q3 and Q4, that's when the bulk of our profit by far will be generated for this year; so it brings us back to a full year figure that definitely isn't at the earnings rate we experienced last year, but it's a rate on a go-forward basis demonstrates a trend that we're headed in the right direction and returning to that point.
Chris Hagedorn
executiveLook — I'm not trying to pat ourselves on the back given the situation, with the figures we're posting at this moment. But returning to profitability in the present environment for this year, when you consider what the market is doing and then add on top of that the fact that our distribution center footprint has doubled, and that we've brought on a fairly substantial number of additional employees simply to keep pace with the category's scale and expansion across the last few years, getting back to sensible profitability this year, I really want to give credit to the team, because that is — it's quite an achievement given the situation, and it's something we take pride in and fully intend to deliver.
William Reuter
analystI've got just one question. During a few of Jim's opening remarks, he said the M&A pipeline might be the largest it has been in 25 years. Then afterward, when we were sort of talking about the year, we roughly calculated $200 million. So at first glance, those seem somewhat inconsistent. I suppose I was hoping you might be able to take those two statements and assist me in reconciling them, and then also address where and why you'd be prepared to accept leverage for the right acquisition.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveLet me begin with the M&A pipeline; I believe Bonnie is the one receiving the growth opportunity here. And part of what's great about that is Bonnie has leverage capability, and we're ready to contribute, and so is Alabama Farmers Coop; I was quite deliberate in saying our partners, since they truly are excellent partners. But we have an intriguing flow into Bonnie without needing to put up all the money ourselves. So the leverage capacity at Bonnie, along with a contribution from us and AFC, sort of gives us the ability to lever up the opportunities without Scotts having to fund the entire thing. Beyond that, the moves we're making on the RIV side are effectively already paid for; that money has already been contributed. And we discussed an additional contribution to create more opportunity within RIV. That's probably $50 million to $100 million more. But again, we're using RIV to reach where we want to get to without Scotts having to put in all the money for that. Keep in mind, they started with $200 million. And we put in, I think, call it $150 million toward that. So I think through that lens, what it means is there's a fairly significant opportunity that doesn't have to appear dollar-for-dollar on Scotts' balance sheet. I don't know whether that — Cory, whether that makes any sense.
Cory Miller
executiveYeah, I believe that's accurate. When you consider what we've been doing during the past 6 months, we closed four transactions inside Hawthorne. Those are being brought together now. Looking ahead over the next 9 months through the close of the year, we're evaluating how much we can take on and fold into the company. On leverage, we finished the quarter at 3.3. My script apparently notes that we'll probably exceed 3.5. Reaching 3.5, 3.7 — we still feel quite secure relative to the covenants that exist currently. As for the possibilities Jim described, I'd say there are a few additional smaller ones on the modest end. There would also be chances during the remainder of the fiscal year, and it's about ensuring we keep pushing ahead with all of these acquisitions to run the five pillars we've set out and stay focused on our long-term strategy.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveWe also utilized a modest amount of SMG stock, and we expect to do something similar with live goods, just a small piece. When it comes to the inventory area, if you're essentially focusing on cash, and you examine the inventory area, there's been quite a meaningful rise — I'm not certain, perhaps $600 million, $700 million, I believe that's approximately the figure. But I think you could likely set aside $200 million or $300 million and say, "Had we possessed that during the prior year, we'd have been far more pleased." So I'll say roughly 1/3 of that is simply returning to the position we ought to have occupied a year ago, and the remainder represents investment to guarantee we can genuinely meet demand for the spring. We'll review that as time goes on. Still, I believe when we examine our inventory alongside retailer inventories, we're quite satisfied with the current state. We consider ourselves well positioned. We haven't stretched ourselves too thin, and we don't perceive retailers that way either. Retailers are currently placing substantial orders. Thus nothing suggests any kind of inventory problem at retail or on our side. Regarding the capital aspect, I think what we've indicated is a figure around — or at minimum what we discuss among ourselves is roughly $200 million annually for several years, perhaps 3 to 5, I'd say, along those lines. We'll monitor that as time passes and determine whether those figures seem suitable. Part of the problem, and I believe everyone recognizes this, is that we previously had a highly balanced system designed for, let's say, 0% to 2% growth. Now you look and you say, it's — I'm not sure, Cory, I believe, mentioned plus 40%, plus 35%, whichever figure that is. It has essentially resized what we require for manufacturing. And certain investments we're undertaking, such as this year at present and the following year, are partly about simply bringing our production capacity and our distribution capability — both for the core and at Hawthorne — to where they need to be given the growth we witnessed. And keep in mind, growth in consumer hasn't disappeared. It has in fact been sustained, so — yet I think past this year and the next, we'll examine how the business is doing. And there's no promise beyond — from my perspective, beyond that point if we don't observe the growth we're seeking. Anything you'd like to add, Cory, regarding that?
Cory Miller
executiveNo, I believe that works well.
Bill Chappell
analystMike, could we go a bit deeper on the pricing side — both what's being implemented now and what will be implemented in 3Q? And when I raised this question at the same point last year, you were pushing hard on promotions, aiming to grab or hold onto a large portion of the shoppers who had entered the category. My understanding was that you intended to dial some of that back. So first, I'm trying to figure out what share of this is list price versus what share is essentially a reduction in promotional activity. And second, whether a price increase lands in 3Q really hinges on its timing, given how much of the selling occurs April 1 versus June 1; so I'm just trying to get a handle on when that takes effect and what it looks like too.
Mike Lukemire
executiveOkay; that's quite a lot.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveYou should have written it down, Mike.
Mike Lukemire
executiveYeah, I get it. No, my sense is that what's taking effect in April was mostly tied to our media business that's expanding. And so — that's going to be scheduled, and we're coordinating with the retailers about when promotions and activity happen. And so — and Cory's got the figure for how it shakes out; as a percentage it's a meaningful one. But when it nets out, it comes to...
Cory Miller
executiveRight. When you net it all together, that comes to roughly 1% of sales. The main focus, though, is on our soil business. And Bill, to get to what you asked, the date we're targeting for putting that pricing into effect is 4/1.
Mike Lukemire
executiveRight. Our expectation is that retailers won’t return fully to the promotional approach seen before COVID—so yes, pre-COVID promotions. I’d put that at roughly 50% to 60%. On the promotional front, it will likely look much the same. What I’d say is that we’ve gotten sharper about which promotions we run to encourage a larger basket, and that’s been effective; we’re also putting more emphasis back on advertising, along with what we refer to as—what’s the term we use, Jim, buy-in markets or something like that?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveThe air raids.
Mike Lukemire
executiveWe run air raids in particular markets, where we hit those markets with advertising and timely promotion, rather than doing a national promotion. And with every retailer, that approach has worked.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveYes. Bill, here's what I'd say — Bill, my take is that when you spend time talking with retailers, there's a really competitive vibe this year; they all come across as quite hostile and determined to extract whatever they can. So we get where our programs stand. My sense is simply that retailers will be quite aggressive in 2019 as they try to solidify their businesses. The way they speak just strikes me as aggressive; so yes, I could genuinely envision a greater amount of promotional activity in 2019 compared with 2018. Let me add something here, since we're discussing retail, there was this young man back when I had just left the military, down in the Southwest, by the name of Craig Menear; and the two of us sort of came up together. Back during my time in the private Miracle-Gro days when I first encountered Craig, and I have to say I believed Frank was — Frank Blake was a wonderful CEO, among the very best. Menear was tremendous. It really tells me I'm getting old when folks I came up with are exiting the industry. I'm aware Ted has had people state in his press releases that it's about managing, sort of, the art and science of merchandising. My view is Menear was very much exactly that. Anyone who has spent time around Menear, when he pulls out those notebooks filled with all his stats, tends to get a little tense; but I want to, sort of, thank Craig for his tenure as CEO at Depot. And that's not because I don't love all retailers, because we do. And I want to congratulate Ted Decker on — and he's been a phenomenal merchant partner for us. And it will be fascinating to watch him having everything reporting to him; so I want to congratulate both of those guys and say, "Well, Craig, we'll miss you, dude."
Bill Chappell
analystMind if I cut in? Honestly, I'm not sure how to top that. But I'd like to pick up on the pricing topic. Just so I've got it straight — even with promotions scaled back by 30% to 40% relative to where they stood a year ago, you don't expect any significant volume decline? You feel confident these customers have stuck around?
Cory Miller
executiveThat's right. So when you consider pricing, there are roughly three waves...
Jim Hagedorn
executiveYes, we feel good about it.
Cory Miller
executiveWe are at ease with that. Still, let me make one thing clear. I mentioned the pricing set to take effect on April 1 — we're in the final stages of working through it with the retailers, and it brings us back to April 1. This marks the third of 3 pricing waves we've implemented. Back in August, we raised prices. That, of course, carries over into the current year. Then we introduced another round of pricing that kicked in on January 1. Ordering didn't slow down at that point. And now we have the April 1 pricing that we intend to roll out. It differs item by item throughout the various segments of our U.S. Consumer portfolio, but it roughly comes out to a figure within that 8% to 9% range we discussed previously.
Mike Lukemire
executiveYeah, I want to make sure we're clear that the promotional level isn't dropping back — I mean, it's at that same level; a year ago it went up compared with 2 years before, and it should stay roughly where it is. Pricing won't push it back down to 30% or 40%; on the other hand, we aren't seeing any rise in it, either — at least that's our read, or what they're telling us when we talk with them. So, picking up on what Jim said, with competition heating up, someone could make a move; still, that's the situation — everything points to that being where we land.
Bill Chappell
analystUnderstood. And then, Chris, I’ve got a quick question requiring a brief answer: does this year’s assumption—essentially your outlook—mostly involve California, Oklahoma, and other places returning to normal? Or do you anticipate a meaningful acceleration from new markets such as New York, New Jersey, Virginia, and Connecticut?
Chris Hagedorn
executiveYes. We’re truly considering two things: a recovery in the historically robust markets you mentioned—those West Coast states—plus Michigan. Yet, as I noted, we’re also observing considerable expansion in those newer markets. So, if you examine—allow me to bring up these figures. Consider Florida: we’re up 20%. Consider a state with a smaller base, such as Alabama: we’re up more than 1,000%. New York: we’re up more than 100%. Thus, growth is occurring there. The revenue—given merely the size of the markets in those states—will require some time to reflect the movement away from California. Therefore, achieving an actual equilibrium across the country will take time. So it will be some mixture. However, the main recovery will come from the more established states, simply because the remaining states are still too small.
W. Andrew Carter
analystI'll be brief here. I just want to confirm my understanding of Hawthorne's pattern across the year. Based on what you've guided, I believe that works out to somewhere between negative 9% and plus 4% for the rest of the year. Should 2Q land at a similar size to what we just saw? Or does it look more like a hockey stick? My other question: Hawthorne's trailing 12 operating margin sits at 9%. You closed last year at 12.5%, and the prior guidance called for a 50 basis point increase. Can you share any sense of where you think this business finishes, and what the long-term outlook is now that the supply chain initiatives are in place?
Chris Hagedorn
executiveAlright; Scheiwer is going to take this one.
Mark Scheiwer
executiveOkay. Regarding the second item, I'll need you to restate the first one for me once more. As for that second item, specifically about our EBITDA, or our earnings rate, what we'd anticipate during the latter half of the year is likely landing in that higher single-digit zone as our sales volume picks back up alongside a recovering market. Then, over a longer horizon, once we start flexing on that, we ought to be capable of returning to the level we reached in the previous year and move past it, so — and keep renewing our effort once more to get nearer to 15% as our overall goal; so I'd characterize it as a minor pause this year, clearly, and after that we'll resume that upward path once again next year.
Chris Hagedorn
executiveRight. So to build on what Mark mentioned, our objective over the long haul is an operating margin of 15%. We're fully confident that we will return to that — or rather, return to moving in that direction, the trajectory we followed across the last few years. On the first portion of your question, from a sales standpoint, we anticipate the second quarter looking somewhat nearer to flat, and then during quarters 3 and 4, that's when we really expect to witness the meaningful rebound. That's what I noted near the start of this call, when one of the initial questions came up: my greater focus is on how we finish out the year in terms of trend. So, as I've said, this quarter amounts to a punch in the gut. As spring arrives, we look for Q2 to level off somewhat. Even during strong years, Q1 has traditionally been our softest quarter; after that, we anticipate stronger sales — a comeback to meaningful sales growth during quarters 3 and 4.
Gaurav Jain
analystJust a fast one. Given your comments about Hawthorne's margins, that suggests U.S. Consumer margins aren't really down much at all across full year '22. So once commodity costs begin coming down — say they begin coming down at some point — does that mean you'll keep your pricing where it is on the consumer side, and your consumer margins will in fact get quite a bit better versus the figures you have this year?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAll right. I'll start and then hand it over to Cory. It's somewhat similar to the upside of shifting lighting production to Temecula; we don't see that as a lever for cutting our selling price. The sole thing on the consumer side, I believe, is some easing in cost of goods, and we're really hoping for that. I don't believe we'd be inclined to lower our pricing. That, I think, is something we talk through with our retailers. Much of it would hinge on what we observe regarding elasticity among consumers; so the thinking, I believe, would be to keep those — keep that pricing and — yet simply watch and see how the consumer is doing, and if we sensed weakness; and once more, that's a conversation we'd have alongside our retail partners about what all of us are seeing out in the market; but Cory, I'm not sure what you'd want to add there.
Cory Miller
executiveRight, I'll just build on that. If you're looking at our margins, two key pieces matter if we're going to return to a margin rate roughly level with last year. Sales volume is the first. As sales volume keeps climbing beyond what we originally planned, that gives us positive fixed cost leverage, which supports our margin rate. The second piece involves commodity costs. With about 2/3 to 3/4 of our costs for the year already locked in, we believe we're positioned well. For whatever portion is left to purchase, we're seeing some favorable trends. Costs are beginning to ease somewhat. That might let us capture some benefit across the rest of the year and the rest of the volume we bought, bringing our margin rate to a point that's roughly flat too. So based on how those two items land over the remainder of the year, U.S. Consumer margins could come in around flattish.
Eric Bosshard
analystRegarding the consumer segment, it's obvious you have a great deal of belief in how this season will unfold, which is why you've lifted your projections here in February. What I'm attempting to determine is where that belief comes from as we head into a year in which those 3 price hikes have already taken effect. I realize you feel fine about your inventory positions, but they sit well above where they've typically been by a fairly large gap. I suppose the heart of it — my question, really, has two parts. First, what explains this degree of certainty? And second, should the consumer turn up in April, see 3 price increases, and choose to act in a different way, what's your approach to navigating that? Or does that become something for the retailers to work out?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveMan, if elasticity problems arise, it falls on all of us to work out. So I think that — I'm just attempting to choose my words with care right here. Because I believe we've essentially already addressed that. Honestly, I don't consider the POS expectations we've described as flat to be especially bold. The retailers — and man, you likely possess the sharpest insight of anyone in the analyst community regarding what's taking place at the retail level; but it would truly astonish me if you hadn't picked up on how committed they are to lawn and garden and how aggressively they view it as a kind of central category they're eager to push forward. The homeownership picture, the demographics surrounding lawn and gardening, are simply very favorable for us right now. Yesterday I was handling a personal tax matter, speaking with our accountant from PwC. She has a child, and she told me, "We're going to move to New Jersey." But then she said, "We can't find a house. If we don't put in an offer immediately above the asking price, we keep getting beaten out on these houses. And it's just incredibly stressful trying to leave the city." So I think that pattern is something we've discussed frequently, and I believe it helps us over the long run. Because here's a massive group of people who are interested. And I think much like her — and this traces back to Menear telling me this roughly a year before I accepted it — when young people have kids, they want a home; and according to our data, they want a nice yard and garden; and so I think if you observe and say, "The retailers feel optimistic," you'd know that nearly as well as we do, sir, simply because I'm familiar with how you go about your work, and that's meant as praise. The POS data looks good; it has looked good. And all the demographic information along with our survey data, I believe, confirms that we have excellent plans this year. We keep honing what we do in marketing and what we do in innovation; so I'd say we're roughly as good as — what's the major unknown out there? It's whether these prices — keep in mind, these folks usually purchase one time each year. Generally, they aren't the kind of people who go out into the market and buy several times annually. So I figure we're somewhat shielded in that regard; but that's a whole lot of pricing. I'm not sure whether you total it all up, but versus a year ago it's likely somewhere in the teens; so that's an open question. And I'd say this isn't solely the retailers' issue. We won't view it that way. But we have substantial funds available to deploy in marketing our products. As you're aware, we're doing that quite differently from how we did it previously. Mike brought up those air raids, where we consider weather and the season, what's being grown, and we can be far more nimble and direct dollars toward getting results. Not only are we convinced of that, our retail partners are too. We're shifting increasingly away from, say, pre-set programs toward acting, say, in real time; so I'm not concerned. That isn't to claim there's zero risk tied to this; but man, you track us, and you and I have been conversing for what feels like decades. And I believe we've seen some fairly major price hikes over the years, especially in lawn fertilizer. And it likely cut the volume, yet the profitability on the lawn line rose considerably. So I think probably pounds, at least right after that huge bump. I don't even recall when that happened. It was probably '08 or thereabouts?
Cory Miller
executiveIn 2008 and 2009, right.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveMy sense is that our bag volume came in a bit lower, yet profitability on that business was much stronger. I'd also say the business is in very, very good shape. So I'm not sure. Is that responsive to what you asked? And Mike, perhaps that was meant for you, so...
Mike Lukemire
executiveNo, what I'd say is that our price increases have come in stages, and those stages are more granular than just particular categories. Actually, what we're observing is stronger volume, so no drop-off has shown up at all. That said, it's still early, and that's one encouraging signal. The second signal is that we now have more participants pushing into this category than at any point previously. You can see that with Tractor Supply and Ace, who are doing even more, plus TrueValue and Costco. So it isn't — there are plenty of players devoting more effort to lawn and garden than at any time before. As a result, interest in this category is far bigger than it used to be. So might the consumer walk away? That's not what we're seeing, and because of that, our confidence keeps building.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveOn top of that, I want to mention our retail-side partnership — no question about it, when you walk into a store, whoever the retailer happens to be, what you'll notice is a noticeably thinner workforce, since they simply can't staff every role they've posted, and that's where the Scotts team's value really shows up. Then, when you consider how we're approaching live goods alongside our traditional lawn and garden operation, the goal is to get additional associates placed inside those stores. That gives us a significant edge, being present precisely when store personnel can't handle everything going on; so it hands us plenty of — I wouldn't say control, but plenty of capacity to seize openings that competitors simply lack the staffing to act on.
Cory Miller
executiveYeah, I also wanted to mention three things there, Eric. The level of engagement from retailers is genuinely high. With the extra inventory we've got on hand this year, our position is much better — last year we lost sales since we weren't able to get shipments out fast enough, so having more stock now puts me at ease compared to how things stood 12 months ago. And the last reason I have greater confidence about this year's sales: the key weekends we had last year were pretty bad. Just think about it — each weekend we headed into, the weather was terrible every single time. Take Memorial Day, I believe it was. Snow was on the ground, and it ranked among the coldest ever recorded. So if you head into those key weekends and produce good results — they don't even need to be terrific, just good — that gets us to a place where flat units — sorry, flat dollars looks like a wager we're ready to take right now.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveYeah, and I'd say — when it comes to the online marketplace, part of that involves our legacy retailers and what they do on the web, but you've also got pure online players in there along with our own operation, and that piece is really starting to scale up. I mean, when I look at that business — every online sale of ours that falls under Patti's category, meaning our direct-to-consumer — I believe you're approaching something like $300 million, possibly even beyond that. What figure did she mention a couple of days back? Roughly $300 million, let's say. Those are becoming meaningful numbers. On top of that, that business is growing at a rate above average too.
Jim King
executiveAlright, everyone. Thank you for being with us today. Once more, just to note, we have a few investor relations events scheduled during the week of March 7. So ahead of that, we'll share details about the specific date and time. Should anything else come up that we weren't able to address in this session, please don't hesitate to call me directly. My number is (937) 578 to 5622. Appreciate everyone for attending. Enjoy the rest of your day.
Operator
operatorThat wraps up our discussion for today, everybody. We appreciate all of you joining us once more, and at this point you're free to leave the line.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.