The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company (SMG) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

May 3, 2022

New York Stock Exchange US Materials Chemicals earnings 89 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Jim King

executive
#1

Thank you, Madison. Everyone, good morning. My name is Jim King, and I want to welcome all of you to The Scotts Miracle-Gro second quarter earnings conference call. With me this morning is our Chairman and CEO, Jim Hagedorn; our Chief Financial Officer, Cory Miller; plus our President and Chief Operating Officer, Mike Lukemire; Chris Hagedorn, who serves as Group President of Hawthorne; and a number of other people from the management team. Shortly, Jim and Cory will deliver some prepared remarks, after which we'll take your questions. I've already set aside time with plenty of you following the call to fill in a few of the gaps. If anyone else would like time, you're welcome to reach me directly at (937) 578 to 5622, and we'll do our best to get you onto the calendar as fast as possible. A little bit of IR housekeeping before we get started. On June 9, Cory and I will be taking part in the William Blair Conference in Chicago. As a lot of you are aware, we have traditionally treated this event as a chance to bring the investment community up to date on where the business stands coming out of the critical month of May, and it's our current intent to do so once again this year. We'll put out additional details about the date and time of the event roughly a couple of weeks beforehand. So with that, let's proceed to today's call. As we always do, we want you to know that we will have — we will be discussing forward-looking statements, so I'd like to caution all of you that our actual results could differ materially from what we say. Investors ought to make themselves familiar with the complete range of risk factors that might impact our results, and those are filed in our Form 10-K, which, of course, is filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission. I'd also like to remind you that we are recording today's call, and an archived version of it will be published on our website. So with that, let's get down to work, and I'll hand the call over to Jim Hagedorn. Jim?

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#2

Thank you, Jim. Hello, everybody, and good morning. Today's call won't follow our usual format. My opening comments are going to be briefer, and Cory's remarks will sit in the middle of my own. I'll begin with a handful of big-picture observations regarding both of our businesses and what they mean for guidance. To be specific, I'd like to talk about the way we steered through the first half, what we anticipate for the second half, and the effect all of that has on the outlook we're giving right now for the full year. After that, Cory will walk you through the figures. Further along in the call, I'll address how the outside environment is shaping the way we operate the company. To put a finer point on it, I'll lay out what we're doing to bring our margins back to where they belong. Beyond additional price increases, we're taking forceful measures to boost productivity and preserve our financial flexibility while the U.S. economy heads toward some difficult conditions. Let me begin with the U.S. Consumer segment, which delivered a very strong second quarter, with sales landing right in line with our guidance; as a matter of fact, we were on pace to do even better, yet terrible weather meant fewer replenishment orders during the back half of March. At the outset, our pricing approach achieved exactly what we intended, namely offsetting higher input costs; even so, commodity prices surging again once the war in Ukraine began created additional downward pressure that we were unable to offset. Even so, it was a solid quarter. That said, given our seasonality, I recognize that the gap in time from the close of Q2 until this call renders those results a bit stale. So today, we'll tell you what we're seeing in real time. POS as we enter May is down 12% in dollars. Slower consumer takeaway meant fewer orders during April from a number of our retailers. Consequently, for the rest of the year we need shipments to rise by double digits just to finish flat versus last year's levels. Let me be clear: that figure can be reached. Across the first 7 months of the year, we were up against POS comps of plus 35%. From this point through year-end, the comp is minus 9%. Even so, ending the year in positive territory is, admittedly, an aggressive target. That's the reason we view the low end of our sales guidance, plus or minus 2% from last year, as a fairly good result. As you'll recall from our prior call, we were optimistic about having upside to our guidance; but no one needs a meteorology degree to grasp why this season has gotten off to a difficult start. Across most of the country, I'd say spring arrived at least 3 weeks late. The encouraging part is that momentum seems to be shifting our way now. We've not only witnessed explosive growth during the last 2 weeks. What's both interesting and encouraging is that the earliest products of the season are the very ones moving through the register at this moment. Twelve months ago, those units would have sold 3 or 4 weeks earlier. This strengthens our conviction that weather has been the single biggest obstacle. Point-of-sale figures in important Southern regions, which had been declining by double digits only 21 days earlier, have improved to a mid-single-digit drop thanks to better weather and store promotions that were pushed back past the Easter holiday. As we move into May, POS has fallen 13% in the Northeast and 20% in the Midwest. Those figures aren't too distant from where Southern markets stood one month prior. Even though this season got off to a late and hurried start, we should keep in mind that the lawn and garden period generally runs deep into mid-June across those areas, and occasionally beyond, so we have confidence that POS will keep recovering in the coming weeks. Over at Hawthorne, consumables such as nutrients and growing media keep outpacing durables, which tells us growers remain involved but haven't yet shifted into expansion. Although modest improvement is appearing in the crucial West Coast markets, conditions in this segment have us trending toward the lower boundary of our guidance. Even so, the Luxx Lighting acquisition is already paying off, proving that brand's worth to seasoned commercial cultivators. Actually, every one of our recent purchases is delivering robust growth. Since we completed those deals, Rhizoflora, HydroLogic and True Liberty Bags have each risen by triple digits. On top of that, our European lighting operation began the year strongly and is on track for considerable growth across the full year. LED lighting, a space where we introduced meaningful innovation, is emerging as a vital category for the professional noncannabis horticulture sector in Europe and Canada. We keep looking for ways to make additional progress ahead, and that covers everything we can determine in real time. However, I'd also like to discuss the unknowns. Given how late spring arrived, we currently lack a reliable estimate of how this season's product mix might affect gross margins. And although we always anticipated a negative effect this year from fixed cost leverage due to planned reductions in utilization rates, we cannot yet determine accurately whether that effect will match our earlier assumptions. The season's delayed beginning has also left us unable to know whether, or how much, inflation and other factors are weighing on consumers. Keep in mind, our guidance already accounted for an 8% drop in units. We're aware other CPG businesses have recently encountered some price elasticity, yet we lack sufficient data for a well-informed opinion. Still, so far this year, no trading down to private label has appeared, and the majority of our products seem to be maintaining or marginally increasing their share. Pair those realities with a commodity picture that shifts nearly every week, and our earnings forecast becomes tougher to project than normal at this stage of the year. We have nonetheless determined that adjusted earnings of $8 per share looks like a difficult goal to reach. Considering how the shares have been moving, I doubt that catches anyone off guard. Yet what would count as a precise goal? Honestly, at this moment there are just too many shifting variables for me to offer anything beyond a rough estimate, and I'd rather not do that today. For us to give you a better-informed perspective, another several weeks are required, because 55% of our POS remains ahead of us. I'll pick my remarks back up in a few minutes, but let me stop here and hand it over to Cory.

Cory Miller

executive
#3

Thanks, Jim, and hi, everybody. Jim already touched on a number of significant matters, and I'll go into more depth on a few of those. In particular, I'd like to provide additional detail regarding some of the margin challenges we're encountering. Let's begin with the top line; we felt good about matching last year's sales figure in the U.S. Consumer business, with sales reaching just under $1.4 billion. Honestly, we had anticipated doing a bit better than that; however, as Jim noted, weather disrupted the reordering patterns at certain retailers. That was particularly the case in the Northeast and Midwestern markets, where the sluggish transition into spring was felt most strongly. The robust POS we've observed during the last few weeks is a welcome development, and reorders are matching the pace of consumer purchases leaving the stores. Still, since replenishment orders were affected all the way into mid-April, we're looking at a year-to-date shortfall as we head into May. I share Jim's view that we'll shrink that shortfall over the coming weeks, though likely not enough to push us into positive territory for the year. Our sales team is working 24/7 to show us we're wrong, and I hope that's what happens. Although the Hawthorne sales decline of 42% fell outside our guidance, organic sales were still basically consistent with our expectations. Let me walk through why. We had planned to start selling Luxx lights on day 1 of owning that business, but the manufacturing problem Jim brought up forced us to hold — forced us to hold shipments of those items until it had been resolved. After it was fixed, which occurred following the close of the quarter, sales have been robust. Had we been able to ship Luxx product during Q2, we would have been approximately within the range of the guidance targets we gave. While Hawthorne sales at the low end of guidance represents our best case at present, the encouraging news is that we've recorded a number of order days during the past month suggesting the market is beginning to improve; we'd anticipate those strong order days becoming steadily more frequent as the year goes on. Should that fail to materialize, though, we run the risk of falling short of our revised outlook. Let's turn to gross margin rate and the wider conversation about cost of goods. The adjusted rate this quarter came in 120 basis points under last year, which leaves us 200 basis points lower across 6 months. The pricing moves we made have mostly succeeded in countering our elevated costs. I say mostly because a gap began appearing in March. You may recall that on our previous call, I mentioned our key commodities had begun coming down from their peaks, and it seemed the worst was over. Then the war in Ukraine changed that. During my public remarks in early March, not long after the war began, I mentioned that we faced roughly $10 million to $15 million in added risk at that point. Our earnings guidance did not reflect that risk. Since then, the figure has doubled, and it has shifted from a risk to something real. We now expect a shortfall somewhere between $25 million and $30 million, stemming from our pricing moves on the unhedged commodities we still require before the year ends. At present, roughly 80% of our costs are locked in for the year, which includes approximately 90% of urea. The biggest remaining exposures are diesel and pallets. Because Hawthorne sales are lower, business segment mix is actually helping our margin rate. That said, the largest unknown that could influence the final gross margin rate is U.S. Consumer volume over the coming 2 months. Regarding SG&A, there isn't much to report. I will note, however, that it is probably going to fall more than we anticipated this year. To counter some of these developing gross margin challenges, we've chosen to reduce certain discretionary spending and hiring plans for the rest of the year. We're also preparing additional moves that will help the P&L in Q4 and extend into next year, and Jim will walk through those shortly. Variable comp also sits within SG&A, and we'd anticipate that figure coming in at no greater than 1/3 of last year's level, perhaps even less. Variable comp matters as a reward and retention mechanism, but it must also match performance. Turning to below the operating line, interest expense came in $9 million higher for the quarter and $17 million higher on a year-to-date basis. Greater borrowing levels caused that shift. At quarter end, our leverage ratio stood at 3.8x, consistent with what I indicated on our previous call. On a connected point, we just closed a new $2.5 billion credit facility. Within that, $1.5 billion is our revolver, with the remainder structured as a term loan. Together with our recent bond issuances, roughly 2/3 of our debt is now locked at an average interest rate of 3.4%. As you saw in the press release, adjusted earnings per share for the quarter was $5.03 versus $5.64, and the GAAP figure was $4.94 versus $5.44. Let's take a brief look at the balance sheet. The narrative is unchanged from last quarter. Inventory sits $575 million above where it was at this point last year. Once again, the causes are lower volume, especially at Hawthorne, plus greater costs in the U.S. Consumer business. With respect to Hawthorne, we had originally planned the year on the assumption of double-digit growth and had been accumulating inventory to satisfy that demand. Although we slowed production and in certain instances halted it as we reduced our sales forecast, a substantial portion of the inventory had already been produced or acquired. In the U.S. When it comes to the consumer business, our aim is to be positioned more competitively so we can serve our retail partners' needs. Yes, we're loaded with inventory, but we're noticing stress signals among certain competitors who can't manage to build ahead of the season. We achieved what we intended, yet inventory levels have climbed beyond our projections, since retailers modified their shipments during March and April because the season got off to a slow start. Based on what volume looks like over the coming weeks, we might choose to dial back some manufacturing sooner in the year than usual. Although that affects the P&L through gross margin rate, it will assist in speeding up an inventory gain. As you can tell, the story has many moving parts at the moment, and they leave us facing a greater degree of uncertainty than we'd typically have at this point in the year. We'll get a great deal — far more visibility as May progresses. Our aim is to give an update when Jim King and I show up at the William Blair event next month. I'm certain there are other subjects you'd like to talk about, and I'm happy to address them during the Q&A session. For now, though, I'll hand the call back to Jim.

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#4

Cory, thank you. Like I mentioned right at the beginning, the first half of this year has left me feeling good about what we've done; in the coming weeks we'll have a clearer picture of how consumers are behaving. Still, up to this point, what we're observing confirms something we've understood for a long time: the weather has a real impact. Turning to Hawthorne, we have no ability to fix the problem of too much supply in the industry, yet our confidence in this category over the long haul hasn't wavered, and the strides we're making in East Coast markets, where we've seen solid growth, give us reason for optimism. That said, across both of our businesses, I'll be honest — the last 3 seasons have felt like a roller coaster. Had we all been sitting in a room together back in 2019 trying to forecast what lay ahead, every one of us would have missed the mark. Because of all the energy we witnessed during 2020 and '21, we committed heavily; within our core business, the sudden leap in consumer activity, particularly across our growing media operations, meant we ran short on future capacity, forcing us to tackle that problem. That near-term capacity shortage also forced us to manufacture and keep larger amounts of inventory on hand so that we could meet the requirements of our retail partners. Looking at what we knew back then, we would make those same calls all over again. Over at Hawthorne, the business had grown to twice its size within a 2-year stretch, and excitement around cannabis and hydro was enormous. With markets on the East Coast growing, we felt we required a more costly physical presence in that region. Putting that physical presence in place likewise required us to accumulate inventory to supply those markets. While we understood that such growth couldn't last over the long term, the speed and severity of the reversal we've witnessed caught us completely off guard. Obviously, much has shifted. When it comes to our U.S. Consumer business, the inventory problem isn't only about the physical units — it's also about what it costs to produce them. And with Hawthorne, we built far more than was necessary, we take responsibility for that, and we intend to resolve it. Mike and the supply chain group he leads are moving right away to bring inventory down and convert it into cash. There's yet another obstacle that lies beyond anyone's control, though, and that's commodity prices. Once this year wraps up, we will probably have surrendered about 400 basis points of gross margin across 2 years, even after what we regarded as bold double-digit price hikes; we're implementing additional pricing during the fourth quarter, and once again, it will be bold; yet the reality is that, just like everyone else, we're merely trying to keep pace with it. Even should commodities begin to soften, recovering the margin we've given up will require a few years. That's terrible. So, starting today, we're making other bold moves to get the business properly aligned, bring down our SG&A, and return the company to a suitable — to a suitable level of profitability; we've committed to a goal of cutting our overhead structure by approximately 10% ahead of the beginning of fiscal '23. This push will touch every part of the operation. Over at Hawthorne, we're going to make our supply chain footprint smaller and bring headcount down. Across our U.S. Consumer businesses as well as corporate cost centers, we'll likewise operate leaner and pay closer attention to duplicate positions, duplicated workflows, and other structural problems that breed inefficiency. As a result, expect restructuring charges in Q3 and Q4. Let me be plain about this. The 5 pillars of our strategy have my full commitment. There's still genuine growth potential in our core brands; we can accomplish more with live goods and leverage that category to deepen our connection with consumers, and as we move forward, our e-commerce work will only open up more opportunities. Over at Hawthorne, the hydro category's potential stays robust. Growers are going to return to growing, and because of what we offer product-wise and our technical know-how, we'll remain the provider of choice; and lastly, the possibilities in cannabis's emerging segments are quite real as well. Through forming The Hawthorne Collective and the investment we subsequently made in RIV Capital, we have meaningful opportunity over the long term. With both Hawthorne and The Collective, we see a chance to build a leadership position across the whole cannabis value chain, from grower through to consumer, as the market grows. Chasing these pillars and generating long-term value demands that we possess the financial firepower to execute. Were we to sit back and wait for the commodity market to hand our margins back, that wait could stretch on; so waiting isn't what we'll do. We're going to move quickly to make changes and put ourselves in a better position to succeed. Beyond commodities, the broader U.S. economy's realities also mean we must be proactive. Over the past year, we've worked closely with some of the country's most respected and well-known economists; and for months they've been telling us what other economists only began saying a few weeks ago. A recession is looming. With the economic headwinds certainly headed our way, we have 2 choices: we can wait and see how windy it gets and then react or we can get in front of the storm; we choose the latter. Scotts Miracle-Gro is a great company. We hold a set of competitive advantages that nobody else in our industry has. And honestly, no matter the category, few other CPG companies have them either. Our people are one of those competitive advantages. So I'd ask your patience as I want to deliver a message to our associates for a moment because I know many of them are listening. The moves we're making this week will have a human impact. They were also sudden and probably jolting. I know that. Every member of my team does, too. We feel badly about the effect this will have on certain colleagues and friends of ours; even so, I want you to understand that our company's core fundamentals continue to be solid, and our long-term financial health is not something we worry about. What we are doing here amounts to an effort to turn this into a better, stronger company. The adjustments being made will begin with senior leadership, the very people I interact with daily. Yet these adjustments will likewise produce an organizational structure better matched to the way we anticipate the business developing over the years to come. And to those who hold our shares, as I mentioned before, you are owed transparency and well-informed perspectives on our guidance; still, what you are owed most of all is our utmost effort to deliver a robust return on your investment. The actions we are unveiling today are intended to reinforce our business, put us back on the proper path, and make certain we preserve the financial flexibility needed to generate value far into the future. Thank you for spending your time with us this morning. I realize there will be plenty of questions, so let's hand things over to the operator for the Q&A session.

Chris Carey

analyst
#5

I realize how tough it is to provide guidance when there's this much POS sitting out ahead. You normally do refresh the market in June, sure, yet you're still saying U.S. Consumer should land at the bottom end of the range. One point I'd like to nail down, Jim: you mentioned that pricing actions are being taken in fiscal Q4, so should we expect U.S. Consumer pricing to come in above that roughly 8% level? And would that mean volumes are in fact off by something like 10% to 11%, and is that the figure we ought to use for POS finishing out the full year? Then my second U.S. Consumer question concerns profit. If you do finish inside the range as you're expecting, could you say a bit more about why visibility on profit is so limited? I know you brought up unhedged commodities; it sounds like mix is also a factor, with some of those higher-margin early season categories still not catching up, but any further thoughts on that shortage of visibility, which appears to sit around the profit line, would be useful too. So thanks for those 2 on U.S. Consumer.

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#6

Sure thing. I'll handle, I believe, the first piece of that, which is pricing; now I think you're probably wrong when it comes to the volume side, whether in units or dollars; so we aren't relying on pricing to hand us a bigger figure. I'd say the guidance we provided would stand without pricing. But pricing in Q4 is, hard to say, close to double digits, I believe.

Chris Hagedorn

executive
#7

The figure is in the double digits.

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#8

That's simply the level we need to reach, given what we're observing on the cost side. As for the broader picture on profitability, Cory, would you like to chime in?

Cory Miller

executive
#9

Yeah, on profitability — there have been plenty of conversations, both out in public and inside the company, over these past couple of months, since commodities have swung wildly. On the commodity side, we keep feeling the squeeze from what hits us on the unhedged portion. Costs have swung around quite a bit too. Back when I spoke in March, the conflict in Ukraine had only just begun. We were still working out what it would mean for the business. Now, I think we've got a clearer picture of the impact, and it's a bigger blow to us than we anticipated back in early March. So that's what's driving the pricing. It's also behind some of the uncertainty around our bottom line earnings right now, since we want to see how consumers respond to our products; we want to see where commodities go as we purchase that remaining 20% that isn't hedged yet, and how it all shakes out. And in another 5, 6 weeks, we'll have a much better read, which should let us pin that number down with more accuracy.

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#10

See, hear me out — I had a big hand in what you might call the absence of guidance, or rather, my effort to keep things vague on that front, and the main reason is that I walked into a room with our operating folks — we held a Board meeting this past Friday. While everyone was getting ready for that Board meeting, I put the question to our operators — they're always going to press for something like, where are we going to land. And every one of them said, "Man, don't go there." There's simply too much in motion at the moment. Personally, I don't see it as absolutely essential. My thinking is just that if I were to hand you something like a $1.5 range, well, we've — I believe we've already revised the guidance two times during this year. And I truly don't want to end up on the wrong side of that once more. Once that conference takes place in June, our visibility will be much greater. We'll have a grasp on mix. Nothing bad is showing up on the consumer front. That's not to say I/we aren't worried about cost, and not only for this year, but for the following year too. Even so, we aren't observing consumers turning to private label. As a matter of fact, I'd say almost across the board, we're picking up share — when you compare us with private label. So my sense is we're simply requesting a bit of latitude here, purely because I don't want to hand you an incorrect figure; and I think we're just attempting to play it safe.

Cory Miller

executive
#11

Right, and let me just tack something onto that. When you consider that the season is starting 3 weeks later, what we're observing in our year-to-date POS across the last 2 weekends is quite dramatic, with dramatic gains. So the picture looks really strong. We're getting back to a situation where the season breaks 3 weeks later, and we simply want to watch how that unfolds over a few more weeks.

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#12

Yeah. What Chris and I had been discussing prior to this call beginning was that sales shortfall — roughly 1/3 of it simply vanished across something like 10 days. So at this point the business is moving along quite nicely. We simply have to maintain that momentum. For the remainder of the year our comps are quite soft, and that is going to be a real boost.

Chris Carey

analyst
#13

That's quite useful. Cory, can — given what's happening with commodities, is there a way to lay out how much urea, resin, and diesel now represent as a share of your total COGS? Then maybe, Jim, at a high level, you mentioned that inventory at Hawthorne is running high. Should we expect possibly heavier promotional activity to move that inventory and perhaps boost your profit potential as we head into the back half of the year? That's all from me.

Cory Miller

executive
#14

Yes. Chris, I'll take the first one. When you consider commodities, and that would be urea, diesel, and resins, as a share of our overall COGS, we're forecasting roughly 32% for this year. And I'd like to put that next to fiscal '20, when commodities accounted for 19% of our COGS. So the rise in commodities is clearly pushing up that share of our overall COGS. That's fairly striking when you consider the 3-year stretch. Two, I think, was on the...

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#15

Yeah. I recall that, I do recall it. It seems like Chris is really enthusiastic about handling this particular one.

Chris Hagedorn

executive
#16

Honestly, my enthusiasm is limited. Chris — this is the other Chris speaking. Right. So here's the situation: at Hawthorne we hold long positions across quite a few categories. A range of different promotional efforts is being tested by us. What we keep running into, though, is that a number of retailers continue to carry stock left over from roughly the close of the prior fiscal year. Given that, there's a limit to how much good promotions can accomplish for us in this category at the moment. As a result, we're trying out various programs alongside retailers, aiming to shift some of that inventory around. Beyond that, we're examining a few fairly unconventional channels as a way to clear out some aged inventory. Along those lines, a deal was announced not long ago involving Cyco; that company operates strong, somewhat separate distribution networks in Australia. We're testing whether it's possible to get some product moving into Australia along with other markets; in short, we're looking into many different options in order to draw that inventory level downward. Promotions will play a role in that, though they won't be the sole piece of it.

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#17

There are positive developments out there. A number of the businesses we partner with, along with customers, are beginning to witness, I'd say, favorable outcomes taking place on the West Coast. Several of the premium-tier folks we deal with, I believe, are experiencing genuinely strong results. Good results are also showing up in the East Coast business, and our qualified reseller — which is roughly another way of describing a near direct path — is likewise seeing good results. A great deal of this, I think, is being driven by California, so to speak; yet once more, customers are telling us they've actually enjoyed a fairly solid last 4 weeks, and you're beginning to observe wholesale prices edging upward, which, as I see it, we're treating as a reasonably good leading indicator. So the real question becomes how much time is needed to move inventory through the trade, which is likewise — which is quite elevated at the moment. So — yet there are glimmers of goodness inside the story that you don't need to kick the rocks very hard to find. So I don't believe it's misleading. It's simply that when you're looking at, say, Michigan and California, which are pretty seriously down, working through all of that just takes a while.

Joe Altobello

analyst
#18

Can you hear me okay?

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#19

Yes.

Joe Altobello

analyst
#20

Okay, great. So I suppose my first question is, assuming my calculations are correct, the Q4 price increase you mentioned today would be the fourth one this year? And then second, what contribution do you anticipate pricing making overall to U.S. Consumer sales this year?

Cory Miller

executive
#21

Yes. Joe, regarding the first part, this marks the fourth price increase within 12 months. It will be the third one we've implemented this fiscal year. So we took — last August was our first of the 12 months. And could you repeat the second part of your question?

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#22

What sort of impact will that have—what sort of impact will pricing have made over the course of the year? Joe, I believe we're looking at roughly 8% so far. So it hinges somewhat on how Q4 is phased. But I'm not sure—I'd say perhaps 1 point or 2 would be—for the fiscal year we're currently in. Folks on my couch are nodding. Thanks. I think—so I'd likely tack on another point or 2, along those lines, Joe. So, let's say, approximately 10%.

Joe Altobello

analyst
#23

That's useful. Next, and perhaps more significantly, a broad question regarding Hawthorne. Given where things stand now, do you have any second thoughts about the size of the prize over the long haul, or how appealing this operation really is? And does it change how you view either the odds or the schedule for possibly spinning that unit off?

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#24

Given that I'm kin to the person in charge, I'd put it this way — he's got fewer years on him, he's a kinder fellow than me. He hasn't dealt with as much turmoil. So it's clear to me he isn't having fun on this particular ride. The notion of those moments when all is wonderful and you feel brilliant — back then he looked quite pleased. My advice to folks is to not fixate on the share price, because when things go south, you'll feel like the biggest fool alive. So my answer would be — no. What I believe took place is the pandemic. Honestly, and I'm not attempting to justify anything. I keep — there's a plaque in my bathroom that my dad handed me, I believe, when I became President of this company many years back. It reads, "Horace to Jimmy, someday this will all be your fault." So if folks are upset, I'll accept that blame. As CEO, that's on me, nobody else. I have colleagues who report to me and perform wonderfully, and I'm performing wonderfully while navigating a very rocky road. Yet if you examine simply what occurred, we packed a decade's worth of consumer growth into a 2-year span. We figured we'd hand part of that back during last year. That didn't happen. We picked up 10%, approximately, in unit volume during last year. And at Hawthorne we saw 100% growth across 2 years; plus we broadened our presence, and maybe we got a bit full of ourselves. Still, it's the kind of thing that didn't seem insane back then. My sense is we were mainly trying to set the business up to succeed; but we've since gone through this year and '18. And I'd describe it as simply — far more turbulent than our consumer operation, which in the end still brings me to the view that — and I'm confident the opportunity exists. My team isn't about to retreat from our 5 pillars. I do believe that spinning off the business is likely beneficial. You'd have a far more predictable operation, generating strong cash flow, that people grasp quite easily. And then the cannabis portion of the business that people — I'd imagine the investment community can grasp it, at least until federal law and greater maturity work their way into that space, that it might swing around more. So I think — I'm not sure, what's my view? I think we're working — we keep working toward that separation. Not in my view is it any further away. Something out of the ordinary, though, I did do. Roughly 3 weeks back, I headed down to D.C., and I shouted at senators, telling them, "Please, do your goddamn job." Billions of dollars are being put into this space by us and by others. Plus, with 280E and banking, all of it is a genuine drag on a business that's already volatile, especially during COVID. And on top of that — Joe, this whole thing is — just a bit of a mind dump here. The supply chain runs a little longer. The durable side of the business is what we like. In the LED market, we've accomplished what makes me truly proud. I believe we are the — I'm fairly certain we're the world's global leader in LED horticultural lighting. Everybody here deserves great pride for what they've done to build that business. Longer, however, are the lead times, and there's vulnerability to people saying, "Temporarily, I can't make money." Now, once more, as I mentioned, wholesale prices are, I think, beginning to creep up, and many of those we're quite friendly with at the high end of the market have fared well through this stretch. Yet it leaves us somewhat more exposed to a market downturn, given that we've chosen to be powerful on the sort of technical side of the business; so do I regret it? No. I think it's — before the call began, I said, "God, damn it; it's been a bit of a ride here." So whether that helped, Joe, I don't know. A finger is being raised by Chris.

Chris Hagedorn

executive
#25

Yeah. No, let me jump in with a point here. So I suppose I'll expand a bit on what Jim mentioned. Look, clearly steering the company while it's dealing with the sort of upheaval happening at the moment is far less enjoyable than when you're putting up 70% growth quarters back-to-back again and again. I think that's self-evident. Still, look, the chance we're looking at remains ahead of us. Everyone at Hawthorne, I believe, remains fairly hopeful in spite of how the market looks right now. And like Jim mentioned, I was on the phone quite a while with that gentleman from California who truly is among the preeminent players in California's cannabis sector and has been for quite some time. He's starting to witness encouraging outcomes. Once more, there's a lengthy lag between cultivators beginning to notice their operations improving, them growing eager to put money back into their companies that move product via retail, and that finally getting to us; but if we examine the newer markets here, I mean, we have New Mexico, and all of these have small bases, New Mexico, rising more than 250%, Pennsylvania, climbing beyond 120%. So plenty of runway remains here while the market sort of rebalances, I believe, somewhat away from the more established markets such as California and Michigan, Oregon. So we remain hopeful. It's hard steering through all this, and it pushes us toward certain choices I'd rather not have to make simply to keep the company running more efficiently, yet the long-term picture for — I believe, for us remains extremely favorable, and we're genuinely thrilled about the company. And I believe that's underscored by the reality that we keep putting money in since we're able to acquire companies we're fond of at considerably better pricing.

Jonathan Andersen

analyst
#26

I'd like to ask about the POS patterns you touched on in that trend discussion. Weather has come up repeatedly in what you've said. And it's obvious that's played a big role. What I'm curious about is how you view consumer behavior, given that this year people have more opportunity to be out of the house, going back to trips and experiences, rather than being stuck at home and purchasing items that go along with that. Could that be a dynamic that's also influencing how consumers engage? And how would you tell?

Mike Lukemire

executive
#27

What I'd say is that — we're noticing a bigger shift back toward the weekend. When COVID was going on, purchases happened on weekdays. Now we're seeing them on weekends; but we're not — plus it's hot out, so they aren't really leaving town just yet. That means we still have customers participating in certain early-season items, such as the crabgrass preventer. Normally, that gets applied in March; as of last week, it's the fertilizer product with the highest index. So that's a signal the season is going quite well, Jon.

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#28

Jon, that's a completely reasonable thing to ask, and honestly, it's something we wonder about too, particularly when the data isn't there yet, since it genuinely feels like — this is as if we're dealing with April 1 rather than May 1, and we're attempting to predict how the year will go. And obviously, last year consumers simply had a few more options available. Keep in mind that, more or less, folks who quit wearing masks got out and did things, and that number climbed. According to what our research shows, homeowners aren't aiming to devote a smaller amount of their time to taking care of their yard and garden. So my sense is that we simply lack that knowledge, and it's quite early.

Mike Lukemire

executive
#29

Right. Still, there's a pattern where people do more of their purchasing on Saturdays and Sundays, similar to the way things were prior to the pandemic. That much is certain. So, however, what we haven't observed — according to the research, shoppers have not abandoned it, and they continue to be fond of <<inaudible>>.

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#30

Jon, promotions play a role in this. We put in a lot of effort alongside retailers to secure their commitment to drive sales — you all likely recall that, prior to COVID, roughly 75% of the money we allocated for promotions went toward something like 3 or 4 Black Friday occasions. When you examined how successful those turned out to be, many fell around late March or early April, and weather problems were abundant. I've — for years we've been explaining to retailers that the success rate on these depends on conditions — when it's cold and rainy, customers simply won't come out, regardless of how low the price is on the items. So the initial major Black Friday occasion happened, I believe, at Depot last week; and...

Mike Lukemire

executive
#31

It'll be 2 weeks, correct after Easter.

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#32

And what I recall being told, I believe, was that perhaps their largest individual day involving lawn and garden was — please continue.

Cory Miller

executive
#33

One week.

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#34

The largest week they've ever recorded with us; so, there are numerous factors at play that make it really difficult to pin down, well, what exactly is it? One could say — I found myself waiting in a checkout line at a hardware store, and a fellow had a bag of STEP1, and it rang up around $78.50, in Massachusetts, this past weekend. And he couldn't have been nicer. I had a cart full of items, while he had just that one bag of STEP1; so he turned to me and asked, "Would you like to go ahead?" And I replied, "No, you were here before me, please go." But I kept studying his expression, and I even felt like saying, "Man, I happen to be the CEO of Scotts, and that was roughly $80 for a single bag of STEP1." Yet he didn't appear upset at all. He was cheerful as he walked out. I had anticipated hearing complaints about what on earth has occurred with pricing. But I believe if you examine — we aren't witnessing any downward trade to store brands, I mean, not at all. So it's — plenty of matters could keep you up at night. What I consider most significant is, if you take our word that we're roughly 3 weeks behind, it's comparable to attempting to be in April and predict the whole year. And I think Mike, right before we began, mentioned, since we had been discussing that they would aggressively pursue, as I phrase it, the year. And Mike commented, "Man, it's May 1."

Mike Lukemire

executive
#35

Sure. So, this is my 26th year doing this. The finance team is always eager to make a call on how the year will go. I wouldn't make that call until June 15, when it's time to reforecast. Honestly, I wouldn't even reforecast, given how much volatility there is. And this year, it's happening later than it ever has; but when I look at what's moving right now, it's the early season merchandise, and we're overindexing on our higher-priced items, so that gives me a different signal; and...

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#36

Yeah. So, look, I'd like to — there's been a — right now I'm moving forcefully to reduce costs and place orders so that inventory comes down; that decision comes from me. It's not that Mike wouldn't ultimately have taken the same step. But I sit in this position, in this role, between Cory and Mike, in a sense. And last week Mike was traveling. He was handling really critical matters that, if they get resolved, all of you are going to be pleased about; and I believe Cory was simply looking quite stern. And so Mike's perspective, I think — and as an operator, this has been my perspective too — is that I don't do these continual reforecasts during the early portion of the season, particularly when things are running behind. Doing it takes a great deal of effort. And I'd say often the operators feel far more at ease about the year; we held a Board meeting. So again, this is the sort of input Cory was giving me. And what I've essentially done is say, if you believe that could occur, then we're taking action on it immediately; and so on Friday, a Board meeting is scheduled. We're updating the Board on it. And the person leading North America sales came up, and he simply said, "Oh, bulls***." And so that's roughly where things stand at the moment, which is that I'm just attempting to be cautious and make the proper calls for the company. I'm not certain there's full buy-in at the operating level, yet these are the correct figures, but it's — I'm choosing the cautious and forceful path. And I must say, it's difficult, because this morning we began making personnel changes. And that stems from Cory giving me that quite serious look around the middle of last week. That's how quickly we've moved aggressively. I'm hoping we've gotten it right, that we haven't gone too far. But I think if you ask who are — the economists we retain are Larry Lindsey and Larry Summers. And both of them are fairly bleak; and we brought them on for precisely this purpose more than a year ago, to help us forecast the future somewhat. And as all of you are aware, the two of them basically — believe a car wreck is coming for the American economy. And so Cory turns very serious in the middle of last week. Mike is traveling. The season is beginning to pick up, yet we're behind; and our economists are telling us, "Be careful." And we're taking action. And that's what you're hearing. And that's partly why we won't commit to the bottom line figure. Just give us — once more, picture that this is April 1, not May 1. And at that point you have to see the issue, alright?

Jonathan Andersen

analyst
#37

Got it, that makes sense. One last quick follow-up. Maybe I'm oversimplifying, but would you say the early part of the season is more about lawn care, and the middle-to-late part more about gardening — is there a connection in your view? For instance, when spring shows up late and lawn care has a somewhat softer stretch, does that typically spill over into gardening? Or would you say they're actually distinct and largely independent, with each one shaped by its own set of drivers?

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#38

I'd say they're quite separate. The one thing that might concern me is whether retailers stay on board if the season starts off unevenly. That said, the feedback they're giving us is very encouraging. Turning back to what was asked about gardening — from what I can tell, the live goods category is showing at least as much weakness as what we're experiencing in our own business. Also worth remembering that buying a plant doesn't involve a very big-ticket purchase. For those people — King mentioned to me that they'd planted some things and then lost them to frost, and these days his main home is in the Carolinas. You simply can't plant anything in — up in Vermont we got snow just last week. So my read is that the season has just been delayed, though gardening really is a different story altogether. Many of you on this call, I'm certain, actually reside in suburban areas. Consider dandelions — personally, I'm fond of them given what they signal for our company. Even in this area, you aren't yet seeing dandelions truly emerging. So perhaps we aren't lagging. The reality is we are lagging — the weather is lagging — and gardening tends to be a warm-weather activity. We're noticing a fairly strong surge across Southeast markets, which to me suggests folks are putting on short sleeves, and that's paying off. But man, I really don't want to feed everyone a load of nonsense and then have you all turn around and go, "Hagedorn is completely full of it." Honestly, I'd rather not put myself in that spot — just give us two weeks or so, everyone.

Chris Hagedorn

executive
#39

Yes.

Peter Grom

analyst
#40

I trust things are going well for you; so I understand there isn't much clarity right now, but could you help us outline what POS has to be as we leave May in order to reach the low end of the U.S. Consumer target. And next, this is — I realize you mentioned this is likely the most delayed spring you've witnessed, but it's likely not the first delayed start you've encountered. So could you perhaps help us put into context what history has shown us? Should weather get better in May, can you do more than make up for a portion of the softness seen in April so that you're roughly flat for the year against the initial plan? And I suppose what's the crucial moment in May when it comes to weather where those sales are gone for good for the season?

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#41

That's quite a bit. Look, the warm weather is what we're after. I mean what's going on in Ohio at this moment is the flowers have blossomed. The leaves are emerging, the lawns are beginning to truly turn green around here. That's the goal, okay, pretty much all over. If we observed — and frankly, at this point, I'm just — it would make me happy if it stayed fairly cool and wasn't overly rainy, particularly during weekends. We've erased these sorts of shortfalls and then some. Keep in mind, we've got very simple comparisons coming up. We — comparisons are roughly 9% in our favor at present, something like negative 9% is what we're measuring against versus through May 1, roughly positive 35%, I believe, is what we were up against. So the figures are easy for us. What's likely required is something along the lines of double-digit figures from now until the season wraps up. At minimum during the major weeks from now until roughly, say, mid-June, or thereabouts. That's roughly what we'd anticipate. But once more, we're facing negative 9% comparisons. So it isn't insanely difficult to achieve. And we've done it previously. As I mentioned, we had a worldwide shortfall and within only slightly more than 7 days, reduced it by 1/3. So that's — folks here appeared fairly stunned; and merely 2 solid weekends proved extremely, extremely beneficial.

Mike Lukemire

executive
#42

Right. I've attempted to attach a figure to that. Since, you know, when we examine the big 3, I'd estimate roughly 10% or more; and — though plenty of our other accounts are also leaning in; and a POS figure isn't something I could provide, yet that's the area where we'll...

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#43

There's one more factor here that I believe is shaping this season and will keep shaping it down the road. Let's say every promotional push got delayed until after Easter — that's a positive, not a negative. And that didn't happen by chance. It's guidance we've spent a couple of years now developing alongside the merchant teams. Since COVID, you're seeing far more retailers going after lawn and garden aggressively and trying to come out on top; so in my view there's much more internal battling for share inside the retail footprints, where they'll run their own promotions to pull the lawn and garden business into their footprint rather than someone else's; and so — things are quite competitive out there at the moment, which I think actually benefits the business.

Mike Lukemire

executive
#44

The number of folks involved in lawn and garden has grown beyond what used to be the norm. That's why I hesitate to rely on our big 3 legacy figures whenever you're considering the whole season. In fact, a few are nearly making it into that top 3 who aren't the ones that come to mind; so...

Andrew Carter

analyst
#45

To get a sense of where EPS is headed — and I realize you aren't providing guidance — you mentioned pressure in the second half. Is that pressure relative to the guidance you originally gave, or is it pressure compared with last year, which would imply the trailing 12 figure of roughly $7.40 might be the appropriate number for this year? That's my first question.

Cory Miller

executive
#46

Andrew, this is Cory. What I'd say is that pressure exists relative to the latest guidance we issued; and where that pressure originates — as we've discussed, commodities have been an enormous cost burden, plus the season got off to a late start. We're recovering that ground at this point. There's still considerable runway in front of us. But the pressure we're experiencing relates to that most recent guidance we provided at the start of March.

Andrew Carter

analyst
#47

Alright. For the second one, stepping back to a broader view — I get that there's a lot of uncertainty and that you're moving quickly. But let's revisit the money going into RIV Capital; my understanding is that it's a commitment of slightly more than $200 million for the year. They closed on Etain in New York just last month. Help us see that more clearly as a deployment of capital at this point, and you did bring up the separation — certainly delayed, but still something you'd like — still something you intend to pursue. Would I be mistaken to assume that Etain's operations will need additional funding, meaning subsidy that a standalone Hawthorne might struggle to provide?

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#48

Okay. Let me jump straight into RIV/Etain. One thing I'm trying to accomplish here, without alarming bankers and lawyers, is to explain what I understand RIV's strategy to be and why it appealed to us. Let's step back and note — keep in mind, roughly $200 million of capital sat there. We've put in, I believe on a total basis, something in the neighborhood of $215 million, or roughly that figure; so my sense is they possess the capital required not just to complete the acquisition, or having completed it, but also to build out the footprint for New York. That's what draws our interest and where we, I believe, share a view with Mark Sims, RIV's CEO, who served as my head of — was my Head of Strategy; our conviction is that — as this sector matures, profits will come from branded consumer products, exactly the business we're in today, and that ultimately, I don't want to use foul language around the Congress of the United States, but they'll get off their ass. And I believe we communicated quite clearly to them, I did, to leadership figures on the Senate side that — with Republicans capturing the house and possibly the Senate, they'd have let a tremendous opportunity slip to address SAFE Banking and 280E, both of which are critical matters for this industry; be that as it may, our goal is to build alongside RIV the greatest branded consumer cannabis company the world has ever seen. And our — I'm not overstating this; and when some people look at Etain, they ask, "Oh, my God, what is that? And that's a lot of money," which it is. But once we run the numbers, we can generate profit from it, alright? Let's begin there. I mean RIV can generate profit from it and we're eager to put money into that space. We're confident that when banking arrives. And I'm actually somewhat confident banking will arrive in — before, ideally, democrats lose a bunch of seats in D.C. But I do believe SAFE Banking will come, perhaps even 280E, addressing the tax consequences of it. So we truly have a strong liking for this sector. Our view is that when banking becomes possible and American exchanges permit cannabis businesses to list, that will be the moment for us to make the switch. Our plan is to completely — to make that conversion as soon as those conditions are met. And the approach we're taking, which hasn't become visible to you yet, and honestly that's a piece of the issue, involves the partners we wish to join forces with to create the best consumer-facing branded marijuana business the planet has ever witnessed; and we plan to accomplish that; and that's the reason we take this quite seriously; and that's the reason we see our money committed here as a long-term worthwhile bet. And as — as that takes shape, and you begin to observe developments, hopefully in the near term, emerging from RIV, I believe you'll gradually grasp more fully what it is we're attempting to build. And you'll notice that — and we aren't scattered or anything like that. This is among the things that, in my view, we owe to you folks, and my family finds itself in the same position as the investing public broadly, which is to say, "Fine, so OK, you've placed $215 million into it. You're not going to keep pouring money into that sector, correct, until you've demonstrated it works." And what I'd tell RIV is that I believe that's a genuinely good — we secured the state we were after. We secured New York; we hold 1 of the 10 legacy permits. This operates vertically across the entire chain from growing through manufacturing, shipping, right through to selling directly to consumers. We came out on top in New York. Demonstrate we can make it succeed. We'll provide every resource, and they possess the resources needed to accomplish this. You'll witness additional developments ahead; but I — what's my view? If we mess it up, the cause will be either that it's far more difficult than anticipated or we simply messed it up because we're a group of fools. But my belief is neither of those will occur. My belief is that 1 year from today, 1.5 years from today, you'll witness what we've accomplished, and you'll recognize that this can be replicated across other regions of the United States. However, we are constrained in our efforts to this Etain New York transaction. They have sufficient capital to complete it. You'll witness additional matters down the road. My intention is for this entire endeavor to be somewhat merged; we require the Congress of the United States to deliver what the American people desire, which is to resolve the legal problems surrounding this category. So that's my answer.

William Reuter

analyst
#49

To start, there were a few remarks regarding a continued desire to stay active within Hawthorne's business segments. My understanding is those may have been pointing toward M&A. Yet at the same time, there was commentary about your economists holding a fairly grim view of the outlook when it comes to recession. So I suppose, where does that leave your appetite for M&A in the near term?

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#50

Well, I don't believe we're keen on a ton of money heading out the door. Let me begin there. No, my sense is our appetite for M&A is actually pretty limited. It would need to be highly strategic. I've already communicated to my team that ordinary returns during wartime don't work for me; so with the Cyco deal, I think we — I told them returns of 15% simply don't work for me. And we set a minimum requirement on IRR of 30%. And that deal got completed using that as our planning. And our deals have been, I'm going to say, every small deal we've done has been very successful. But I'd say at this point our appetite on M&A is very limited. I don't think we're seeking cash out the door on pretty much anything right now. At present, we're just looking to get through where we are. Anything would be highly strategic and probably noncash.

William Reuter

analyst
#51

Great. Now, my second question. Earlier, Jim, when you talked about spinning off Hawthorne, you said it still makes sense as far as you're concerned. Then another analyst made a remark before about how the timing had gotten delayed. So what does that mean — where does that put you regarding, I suppose, the interest when it comes to timing, and how ought we to be thinking about it?

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#52

Well, here's what I'd tell you: stay tuned for news; that's my response, meaning we're at work on it. I believe everyone is involved in this and recognizes the benefits of getting it done. But all I'd say is stay tuned for news.

Eric Bosshard

analyst
#53

There are a couple of items I want to touch on; regarding the consumer, I'm simply attempting to gain some clarity around the restructuring that you're referring to. You've accumulated a substantial amount of inventory. Twelve months back, you were discussing capacity additions. Now, you're discussing restructuring to a certain extent. So I'm trying to grasp the backdrop for that, and also trying to grasp whether this ties only to a sluggish beginning in commodity costs. Or does this tie to a shifted outlook on demand and whether the consumer remains willing to keep paying elevated prices?

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#54

Okay. To be honest, I believe it's the first one. Yeah, it does feel like it came out of nowhere. But we've got about $600 million or more tied up in inventory. North America isn't keeping up. Hawthorne isn't either, and that's what's driving us to say, "Hey, we need to be careful here." So Mike and I started digging into things — honestly, only around seven days back — and we said, we want some costs cut. Keep this in mind, Eric: if you look at what's happened over roughly the past 2.5 years, the business has grown 30% or more, and this was a business we used to call 0% to 2%. In some ways, we had to expand our footprint. Looking back at the pandemic period, running low on stock was a terrible experience. Because of that, choosing to expand production capacity — meaning investing that money — along with growing our distribution network and holding more goods made a lot of sense. At this point, though, we're taking a hard look and asking ourselves whether we should dial things back. Some of that reduction wouldn't be smart. To be clear, we won't be cutting back our production operations, yet our stock levels are quite high. When you dig into those stock levels, a large share of it costs significantly more than it did roughly eighteen months back. So I've asked Mike to go after that inventory hard and bring it down, partly because my sense is we're carrying more than we actually require. As for how we see things going forward — honestly, I'm not sure we've truly settled on a view about whether we'll return to growth in the low single digits. When you look at housing, who knows what direction interest rates will push it. Though here's a sign of the times: Jim King's kids — or at least one of them — have been trying to purchase a home over in Atlanta, and they just keep putting in offers without landing anything. Housing is simply unavailable in numerous American markets — and last week the journal ran some genuinely fascinating pieces on this; the folks in question are young and eager to buy. That tells us something about our sector we've discussed frequently: namely, will individuals reside in condos located inside the beltways, or is homeownership the goal they're chasing? If anything, that category is still blazing hot. Of course, getting a mortgage has become more difficult, right? And more expensive as well? Even so, housing continues to be a major bright spot, and it's younger folks who are after houses and have made clear they want a yard, a dog, and children. We've already discussed what the demographics look like there. Honestly, I'm feeling pretty optimistic about it, yet I don't believe we've truly wrapped our heads around, given the trajectory we're currently on, whether the coming growth will be 1% or 2%, or more like 3% or 4%. And how exactly do we transition away from this plus 30%? We had expected to decline last year. So I'm not sure I can give you the satisfying answer you'd want by calling it developed — but that's the situation we find ourselves in.

Eric Bosshard

analyst
#55

I just want to get one thing straight, and then I'll ask about Hawthorne. On the extra inventory — if there's more than you need, is it because production ran too high? Or is it that your sales forecast is now lower than what you'd initially set out?

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#56

I would answer both; that's how I'd put it.

Mike Lukemire

executive
#57

There are items with longer lead times over in China. So you're placing a wager there. And — a piece of how we're improving our supply chain is that we're actually shifting more assembly into the U.S. And we'll have the ability to flex that.

Eric Bosshard

analyst
#58

However, at this point you mean Hawthorne, correct?

Mike Lukemire

executive
#59

Yes, Hawthorne is what I mean. The same applies to the U.S. To be honest, materials being available is one factor behind why we construct, since we have let sales go unclaimed. We have been bringing on additional capacity, yet that capacity turned into flexible capacity so we could act with greater agility.

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#60

Yeah. Eric, I think when we reflect on this, we're kind of trying to pin a bit of the blame on ourselves. The reality is, if you went back 12 months and said — we don't want to exist in a world where we lack product. During the first year of COVID, retailers didn't even yell at us, even though they were missing plenty of items; and I think we had a bunch of — we lost $100 million in Hawthorne sales and roughly $200 million in consumer retail. A year ago, we were extremely tight. I think we simply decided we ought to carry more inventory, and Mike was the one who made that call, and I backed it. Now that we're behind, you look at it and go, "F***, I wish we had a little less product sitting out there." But I want to crank things down, and we're prepared to be quite hardcore about getting there without messing up next year. And that's, I know, what Mike is...

Mike Lukemire

executive
#61

Okay, so that — we simply need to bring it back into proper alignment. When I think about inventory, I see it as a period over which we aim, on an annual basis, to reach our targets, though we do have the ability to right-size the supply chain. We're getting the capacity where it should be, and our supply chain is becoming stronger and more dependable — once again, that includes our raw material suppliers. Keep in mind, we weren't able to obtain materials; in certain instances, we were lagging by 4 or 5 weeks merely to receive raw materials for conversion. So...

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#62

Eric, one more thing I find genuinely fascinating is the sheer speed at which the switch to LEDs has occurred over on the Hawthorne side. And it isn't happening only there — the same is true for horticultural lighting, across both Europe and Canada, on what you'd call the noncannabis portion. Yet the whole industry is moving toward LEDs. And here's the thing — globally, we hold the top position in this area; even so, the very folks who sold us those companies told us, oh, this is going to take far more time; this transition is going to — plus these items have quite long lead times and carry a hefty price tag. So I'd say we're sitting pretty fat on those long lead items. And that — one piece of it is this shift toward LEDs. Another piece is simply how long the supply chain is.

Mike Lukemire

executive
#63

Right, so whenever the 1700 launched — that was our very first LED light — we wagered roughly $30 million on an investment, and that sum turned out to be insufficient; so we decided we'd take a bolder approach once we rolled out the following round of innovation and went a bit heavier; so...

Chris Hagedorn

executive
#64

Okay, so at this moment in our ProHort segment, the outcomes we're witnessing are truly outstanding. We provide them with some LED breakthroughs too — it's another kind of illumination. Those cultivators operate their fixtures in a manner that differs from what cannabis growers do. We handed them some new technology. They took it and ran. And at this point, the limiting factor for that operation is simply how much we can produce and ship out prior to the close of the year. So once we bring that innovation to market, it usually lands well.

Mike Lukemire

executive
#65

At that point, a wager becomes necessary, and there are times when our wagers prove correct and times when they prove incorrect. Consequently, the greater your ability to adjust capacity flexibly and to do so in places where conversion is possible, the more improved your control over inventory becomes; therefore...

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#66

All right. You were headed to Hawthorne, sir?

Eric Bosshard

analyst
#67

Right; and moving over to the Hawthorne side, your dedication and belief there comes through clearly. Five acquisitions have been completed by you during the past 12 months. You mentioned the RIV deal, along with your remark regarding a 30% return target on acquisitions. All of that makes sense to me. That said, this year this business, when viewed through a profit lens, will be perhaps only slightly profitable. The spin is intriguing; however, from where an investor sits, what margin figure for this business ought investors to be anchoring on? I believe you referenced exiting this year at 8% or 10% margins. In other words, is this business on a trajectory, or do you hold the conviction that we arrive at a 10% margin business in the coming year? Or should investors instead look past <<inaudible>>

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#68

Look, I won't — getting into next year isn't something I want to do, because there is a great deal — Eric, at this juncture I don't wish to discuss next year, since a great deal of planning is underway for it. That said, were you to ask my folks what margins we're aiming for in that business, here's what I'd tell you: over the relatively near term — meaning my focus isn't really on next year right now, but rather perhaps the period after next year; though not the present — next year is impossible for that. The work on it simply hasn't been shown to me yet. Even so, I'd say above 15%, not below 15%. And I need to be cautious there, because given what we're currently going through, people have, as it were, laser beam eyes. What I want to be certain of is that what people are building toward is the business — as we move through — transformation comes about because of a significant emotional event — I'd call this a significant emotional event period. And I want to be certain that people are building a business that represents the partnership we desire with the cultivation community. We don't simply choose to become a distributor. So, Eric, my view is that the numbers sit above 15%, though much of that hinges on who we are and what it will take to arrive there. So yes, I'd say 15 plus percent, sir.

Gaurav Jain

analyst
#69

The majority of what I wanted to ask has already been covered. There's one thing I wanted to check quickly regarding buybacks of stock. With what's been said about the possibility of the economy being a car crash and your planning for the worst case, is it fair for us to expect that no repurchasing of shares will happen for a pretty long stretch of time?

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#70

That's likely a fair way to look at it. The sole case I'd carve out might be simply attempting to match the dilution created by share options; generally speaking, though, I'd say the response is low to 0. The one item I believe we'd consider is asking: what would we need to do so that our share count stays pretty constant?

Cory Miller

executive
#71

Correct. As of the close of the second quarter, the total for this year stands at $175 million. For the third and fourth quarters, there’s nothing scheduled, consistent with what Jim mentioned.

Gaurav Jain

analyst
#72

And Jim, just one more thing on that — I mean, look, as you mentioned, Larry Summers is likely the economist with the gloomiest outlook around. And you've kind of — you've kind of admitted that a different company became overly optimistic during the prior year; so could there be a danger that you're now becoming overly pessimistic about how this plays out?

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#73

Yes, yes.

Gaurav Jain

analyst
#74

Also, what's your approach to making sure — I realize this is tough for you to — what I'm getting at is, how do you even go about planning your staffing levels and anticipating what might unfold 2, 3 years from now? So in what way do you assess that, then plan and build the organization to handle something along these lines?

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#75

This is my reasoning. Whether it's actually true, I can't say, but — inside my mind, it is true. I believe Mike, myself, and the other leaders can examine the corrections we're about to put the business through at this moment and ask, will this improve how decisions get made? Will this make us a stronger company down the road? What steps must we take to move that inventory out and, in a sense, tidy up the balance sheet and get ourselves leaner and more ready to compete? My sense is that if conditions are not as bleak, at least when it comes to lawn and garden, and keep in mind, we bring plenty of experience from navigating downturns. They aren't awful for us. If you consider, say, 2010, 2 categories, 2 product groups were moving at home centers: paint along with lawn and garden, items costing under $100; so I wouldn't call us immune to recessions, yet I truly think we can withstand them. Now, if we're cutting too deep, then what Mike and I will take comfort in is that we've opened up chances for some younger staff to take on more work, which will foster a quicker decision-making culture that I believe matters greatly in certain areas of our business, and that we'll be seeing a truly strong young cohort carrying significantly more responsibility within the company. So I'm not sure, Mike, if you'd say — does all of this pay off, particularly when sales aren't as poor as Cory seems to expect?

Mike Lukemire

executive
#76

Well, I think it's simply — until the commodity situation, we were running without limits, pursuing as much growth as possible, and we were investing heavily. I think the moment has come to recalibrate, reset, and return. When I initially stepped into the COO role and Jim handed me that responsibility, we held the organization flat and we built — we had a fantastic stretch. We're sort of returning to fundamentals, holding flat, rebuilding. That's...

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#77

Yeah, I mean, what's my take? I'd actually call this a good thing, even if there's some sadness involved in the business. We're aiming to remove, I'd say, no fewer than one layer from where decisions get made. When you're experiencing all this growth, that extra layer tends to sneak in. Doing away with it is tough and affects people, but I believe we'll see plenty of decision-making benefits result from it. That lets us seize opportunities. We're working to create flexibility here. And having the resources to pursue what we want to pursue, rather than ending up on the wrong side of everything, is a real gauntlet.

Carla Casella

analyst
#78

You've covered a lot on the inventory side, but I'd like to ask whether you can help us understand the split within that inventory increase — how much came from pricing as opposed to volume, and how much came from Hawthorne as opposed to consumer. My second question ties into that somewhat. Your short-term borrowings have risen quite a bit. What portion of that is the revolver, and what portion is the accounts receivable facility?

Cory Miller

executive
#79

Carla, it's Cory here. On inventory, the increase is, let's say, $600 million, just to keep the numbers simple. Roughly half comes from Hawthorne and half from U.S. Consumer. Within both of those businesses, about 2/3 of the rise is units and 1/3 is cost. So commodity costs are pushing our inventory cost up by roughly 1/3 of the total increase in each business. Now for the second part, on short-term borrowings: those are higher, and inventory accounts for part of why they've gone up. The short-term piece of our debt is mostly the revolver. We are drawing on the revolver. The banks are happy to see us drawing on the revolver, and that's exactly why we wanted to be sure we had a facility — one we just closed on — that was sized right for the business. So when you look at the short term, it's largely revolver usage.

Carla Casella

analyst
#80

All right. And so is that supposed to begin arriving — I mean, would you say we've hit the top? Or has the busiest period already gone by?

Cory Miller

executive
#81

We're more or less at that top point, since the biggest sell-in is taking place right now. Stock levels are elevated. Once we begin gathering cash from the sales going on at present, we'll begin reducing that revolver balance until we reach the level we typically sit at when the year wraps up.

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#82

And push stock out of the system.

Cory Miller

executive
#83

And push stock out.

Jim Hagedorn

executive
#84

Yes.

Carla Casella

analyst
#85

So have you done away with that receivables financing arrangement? Or has part of it been tapped too?

Cory Miller

executive
#86

No, we haven't done away with it; it's being tapped. I don't have the figure in front of me versus a year ago, but it's still being utilized quite consistently with our historical practice.

Jim King

executive
#87

Okay. Thanks, Madison. And thanks to all of you for being here this morning. Once more, just to remind everyone, Cory and I are going to be in Chicago on June 9 for the William Blair event. In all likelihood, we'll put out a public communication ahead of that event, most likely the day before. In the meantime, should you have any questions I can assist with, feel free to reach me directly at (937) 578 to 5622. Thanks again for being with us. Have a wonderful day. Go garden. Bye.

Operator

operator
#88

That brings us to the end of today's call. We appreciate everyone for joining in. You're welcome to disconnect at this time.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.