The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company (SMG) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
August 3, 2022
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Kelly Berry
executiveHello, everyone, and good morning. My name is Kelly Berry, and I want to welcome all of you to the Scotts Miracle-Gro Third Quarter Earnings Conference Call. Following a lengthy finance career here at the company, I have taken over leadership of Investor Relations. It's an honor to step into the role held by Jim King, our Executive Vice President and Chief Communications Officer, who has retired from Scotts Miracle-Gro following a 21-year career with the company. Jim has agreed to remain available over the next few months to assist with the transition wherever needed. I've already enjoyed getting to know many of you, and I'm eager to meet all of you in the months ahead. The remarks today from Jim and Cory were prerecorded. After the prepared remarks end, we will open the call for live Q&A. Following the Q&A, an archived version of the call will be posted on our website. Joining me for the Q&A this morning are Chairman and CEO Jim Hagedorn; Chief Financial Officer Cory Miller; our President and Chief Operating Officer, Mike Lukemire; Chris Hagedorn, Group President of Hawthorne; along with several other members of the management team. Before the remarks get underway, I'd like to inform everyone that the management team will be present at the Barclays Global Consumer Staples Conference in early September. Additional details regarding the date and time of that event will be published a couple of weeks beforehand. With that said, let's proceed to today's call. As usual, we want you to be aware that forward-looking statements will be discussed on the call today. I'd like to caution everyone that our actual results may differ materially from what we say. Investors should acquaint themselves with the complete range of risk factors that could affect our results, and those are filed in our Form 10-K. I'll now hand the call over to Jim Hagedorn. Jim
Jim Hagedorn
executiveThanks, Kelly, and good morning, everyone. There's a lot on the agenda for this call. We'll cover how each of our two main business segments is doing at the moment, what those results mean for our fiscal '22 numbers, and the steps we're taking to address the leverage heading into next year that has come in above what we had anticipated. Let me say clearly at the outset that we are not providing fiscal '23 guidance today; we intend to offer it in November, in line with how we normally do things. While some of the more granular elements of our operating plan for the coming year are still being worked out, several tailwinds and headwinds are already coming into focus. We'll pass along as many of those specifics as we can in this session. As for what I have to say regarding our current results, most of my attention will go to the U.S. consumer business. There's no question that it's the largest source of value for shareholders. That said, I believe it's quite simple to draw the wrong conclusion about the last several months, and I'd like to ensure you grasp the reasons our optimism hasn't changed. Prior to getting into those subjects, let me be upfront. On earlier calls, I stated that my focus was on the strategy we've set for the long term and that I wouldn't run things on a quarter-by-quarter basis. I've mentioned before that I make an effort not to pay attention to where the stock is trading or how the market is swinging, but certain situations demand that I make an exception — and this qualifies as one of those situations. It's common knowledge that my family and I hold the biggest stake in this business. Not a single one of us is happy about how we're performing right now or about what the equity is worth. I recognize that the same is true for the other people who own a piece of this company. You have every right to feel that way, particularly if you got behind these shares when they were priced far above where they sit today. A number of difficulties came up during this year — quite a few, in fact — and none of us could have seen them coming. There were also situations, Hawthorne being the clearest example, where our read on the market was simply wrong. That led to investment choices I wish I could take back, but that isn't possible. What is possible, and what I intend to do, is concentrate on the proactive measures available to us to bring this business back to a profitability level we can accept. To those who joined as shareholders more recently, and to anyone still digging into the company, we value your interest and we share the view held by many of you that meaningful upside exists relative to where the stock trades today. I hold the title of CEO in addition to being the biggest shareholder. That means I answer to every shareholder, and I'm fine with that. If this year's outcome stemmed from circumstances outside our influence, or from errors on our part, that distinction doesn't really matter. The important thing—and the focus of what I'll share with you now—is the actions underway to put us back on the right path. From this call, I want you to walk away with three key points. The first is trust that we grasp the difficulties ahead of us and are acting quickly. And even though we've been forced into a lot of tough decisions within a very compressed period—including eliminating hundreds of positions—at the same time we're protecting what makes us competitive and developing the leadership pipeline required for the future. Point two is trust in the basic, undeniable strength of our U.S. consumer business; shareholders need to see past how this unit performs financially during the latter half of the year. Those fundamentals haven't gone anywhere. Shoppers are still with us, and the outlook is still promising. And the third point is knowing why we believe we can bring this business back to the margins we've historically achieved, produce substantial cash flow, and regain the financial room to maneuver that growth and greater value require. A large share of that progress sits within our own hands, and we're moving fast to deliver it via something we're terming Project Springboard. Phase one was mostly a reaction, built to bring us in line with near-term conditions. Phase two concerns getting this business back to an appropriate level of financial performance and making sure we're positioned well enough to seize the opportunities that we think remain in front of us. Ninety days back, on a call like this one, I never could have forecast we'd be standing where we are today; we laid out how terrible April's weather would hit us and promised to recover part of the shopper engagement we'd surrendered during the season's opening weeks. That forecast largely held up. During any typical year, restocking orders would have tracked the spike in consumer POS that ran across May and June. Yet by the end of May, it was obvious those orders weren't materializing. What's shifted most since May is how retailers handle their inventory. I'll say more about that later on. That change flows straight through to weaker sales in our U.S. Consumer segment, unfavorable fixed cost leverage in our P&L, and inventory levels above what we'd anticipated; that mix is pushing our leverage past where we'd like it and leading us to prioritize debt reduction as our main cash use over the coming year. We're handling these matters aggressively as they unfold. And I'll come back to this topic again before long. Thank you, Kelly, and good morning to all of you. There's plenty to discuss today. How both major business segments are currently performing, what that means for our fiscal '22 results, and the actions we're taking to deal with the higher-than-expected leverage we'll be carrying into next year. Let me state up front that we aren't giving guidance today for fiscal '23, we intend to do so in November, consistent with our usual practice. Although certain finer details of our operating plan for the coming year are still being worked out, a number of tailwinds and headwinds are already becoming apparent. Alright, we can go over a few of those specifics today where possible. When it comes to what I have to say about how we're doing right now, most of my focus will be on the U.S. consumer business. Clearly, that's the largest source of shareholder value. At the same time, I think it's simple to misinterpret what has taken place during the last few months, and I want to be sure all of you grasp why our optimism hasn't changed. Before I get into those subjects, let me set the record straight. On earlier calls, I stated that my attention was on our long-term strategy and that I wouldn't run things on a quarter-to-quarter basis. I also mentioned that I make an effort to disregard the stock price and market fluctuations. That said, there are times when you have to make an exception—and this is one of those times. Everyone here knows that my family and I own more of this company than anyone else. None of us likes where our results stand today, and none of us likes where the stock trades. I know the same is true for the rest of you who own shares. You have every reason to feel that way, especially if you bought in at prices much higher than where we are now. A number of difficulties arose over the past year—more than one, in fact—and we had no way to see them coming; in other instances, Hawthorne above all, we got the market wrong, and that produced investment choices I wish I could take back, but that isn't possible.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveHere's what I can do, and here's what I will do: concentrate on the proactive measures available to us so that this business returns to a level of profitability that's acceptable. To those of you who joined as shareholders more recently, and to anyone still doing their research, we appreciate your interest, and we share the view held by many of you that significant upside exists relative to today's levels. I'm not merely the biggest shareholder — I'm also the CEO. That makes me answerable to every shareholder, and I accept that responsibility. Whether this year's results stem from circumstances outside our control or from mistakes on our part, that distinction doesn't matter. The things that count, and the things I'll be discussing with you today, are the steps we're putting in place to turn things around. I want you to leave this call with three main points. The first is that you can trust we understand what we're up against and that we're moving quickly. Even though we've had to make many tough decisions in a short window — including cutting hundreds of positions from our workforce — at the same time we're safeguarding what makes us competitive and building the leadership bench we'll need going forward. The second is that you should have faith in the fundamental, indisputable power of our consumer business here in the U.S. For those of you who own stock in this company, I want to stress that you shouldn't focus only on how the business performed financially during the back half of the year. Our underlying strengths have not gone anywhere. Shoppers are still actively involved with us, and what lies ahead is promising. The third thing I'd point to is grasping the reasons we feel sure we can bring this business back to the margin levels we've historically achieved, produce substantial cash flow, and regain the financial room to maneuver that we require in order to fuel expansion and boost value. A great deal of this progress falls under our own influence, and we're moving fast to bring it about via an initiative we're referring to as Project SpringBoard. During its initial stage, the approach has mostly been one of responding to circumstances, and it's built to help us adapt to the reality we face in the near term. The upcoming chapter involves getting the company back to an acceptable standard of financial results and making sure we're in a strong position to seize the chances we think are still in front of us. During the call we held 90 days back, I never would have guessed we'd end up where we are today; at that time, we described how terrible the weather in April had been and committed to recovering a portion of the customer involvement we'd forfeited during the season's opening weeks. That forecast turned out to be largely accurate; under normal circumstances, replenishment orders would have matched the jump in consumer point-of-sale activity that took place across May and June. However, it became obvious by the latter part of May that those orders would never materialize. The most significant shift we've seen since May involves how retailers handle their stock. I'll go into more detail on that subject later in my comments. That change results in reduced revenue for our U.S. business. On the consumer side, the P&L is showing us negative fixed cost leverage, and we also have inventory levels that are greater than we had projected. Those two factors combined are driving our leverage beyond a point we find acceptable, which is the reason paying down debt now ranks as our number one priority for deploying cash over the next twelve months. We are addressing these issues forcefully as they arise. I'll return to this subject shortly. Ahead of that, however, I want to give you an update on the results for each of our business segments. I'll keep my comments at a general level, and Cory will walk through the details underlying the figures. Despite the unexpected challenges we faced in our U.S. Consumer segment, my belief in the strength and stability of this business remains firm. This year's household penetration for our products is on par with 2020 — the year when 20 million new customers enter the category. What's even more notable is that our overall consumer base skewed younger once again this year, driven by a steady stream of millennial and Gen Z buyers who are purchasing homes and joining the category. And on top of that, we retained a larger share of those younger consumers this year than in either of the prior 2 years. This business's demographics keep improving. That leaves us and our retail partners feeling very enthusiastic about what's ahead. Total POS units are down 8% year-to-date, yet that result matches the guidance we gave entering the year. Because of our aggressive pricing moves, we originally anticipated POS dollars would be flat on that volume. Instead, POS dollars are down 5%, though that's still consistent with 2020 levels. There are twofold reasons why recent POS dollars came in lower. First, retailers promoted low ticket categories such as mulch and soil more heavily. Meanwhile, volume in premium, lightly discounted segments — lawn fertilizer and grass seed in particular — is down almost 20%. Those two areas deserve a closer look, because there is a lot going on and this year's figures can easily be misinterpreted. Start with this: a volume decrease was already assumed in the guidance we originally issued. After adjusting for that, point-of-sale units across these segments are still roughly 12% under what we expected. Elasticity could account for part of that gap, but it appears to be a small factor. If elasticity were really the primary cause, our market share would have dropped substantially. No, that's not what occurred. We lost about two points of share, though the distance between what we sell and entry-level offerings was much wider than usual during this period. Let me explain more clearly. As you may recall, we introduced four separate price hikes across our branded lineup over the year. The private label side works differently. Their pricing is locked in annually, and once that agreement is signed, it holds for the entire season. Come next year, that pricing disparity should correct itself, since store brands will be implementing larger increases. So while the share loss isn't something we view as alarming right now, we are keeping a close watch on it. As for the other 10 points of the decline, we believe two primary factors are at play. The biggest one was the weather, and nothing we sell gets hit harder by it than fertilizer and grass seed. March and April brought cold, wet conditions across almost all of the eastern half of the nation, and that includes key early season markets such as Texas. Meanwhile, out in the Western United States, drought also acted as a drag. Two problems came from the weather. One, it pulled shoppers away from stores in April, the single most important month we have for fertilizer sales. Two, because it was wet and cool, lawns were in great shape come May. In our research, a larger share of consumers than usual said fertilizer or grass seed simply wasn't necessary for them this year. The second big problem was the absence of promotional activity. Rather than running highly visible promotions to bring in traffic, the way they had in years past, a number of key retailers went with an everyday low price approach in those 2 categories. Our experience shows EDLP has failed before, and it failed again this year. Going forward, we anticipate that early, well-timed promotion in these categories will come back next year. For us, fertilizer and grass seed are the first products to break, and we have to partner with our retailers to get consumers up off the couch and out into the backyard.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveRight now, the severe heat of summer is taking a toll on consumer lending. That should be a tailwind for this segment in the autumn, and we're hoping to get our first real read on both fertilizer and grass seed come September and October. If you look at point-of-sale data next to what we sell to the retailer, there's a gap that's clearly wider than what we'd anticipated. Some of you have suggested this means retailers are feeling less excited about this category. That isn't the case. We're already deep into planning for the '23 season, and the enthusiasm is still there. Retailers get what we get: when the macroeconomy is under stress, consumable lawn and garden items remain 1 of their best-performing categories. Let me make clear what's going on here. If you'd visited stores during late May and June, you'd have seen a surprisingly big pile of seasonal durable goods — things like grills and outdoor furniture — that just sat there unsold. Meanwhile, what was moving off the shelves? Our products. In May and June, our point-of-sale figures came in as the second best we've ever posted. That made it simple for retailers to trim their seasonal stock by carrying less safety inventory of what we make, and to scale back their reorders. Today, the retail inventory of our items, counted in units, sits 12% below where it was a year ago, and we expect it to drop another few points before the year is over. So the real opening here is that retail inventories are sitting at a much lower level than usual as spring approaches. Because of that, and given the conversations we keep having with our retail partners, we're expecting a solid, predictable sell-in right as the season gets underway. Our expectation is that retailers will come out swinging next year, leaning harder on consumable lawn and garden categories to pull shoppers into stores, which makes it more likely they'll push aggressively right at the start of the season with early-breaking items such as lawn fertilizer. Now, on to Hawthorne. Not much has shifted in that story. Cannabis pricing is still way down, and the reason is the surplus inventory that cultivators have been producing. As these difficulties persist, the part public policy has played in making the problem worse keeps becoming more obvious. A number of states granted licenses for much more cannabis output than the people living there would ever buy. When rules are lax and oversight is weak, the black market gets a boost, and that leaves an obstacle the regulated sector finds hard to clear. Our view is that the industry is undergoing a correction at this moment, as certain growers just exit given how difficult conditions have become. Although emerging markets on the East Coast keep expanding, that expansion cannot make up for what the mature markets are losing. As we look ahead to the coming year, a couple of positives stand out. In just a few months, we'll be cycling past some weak comparables, and we expect to report slight growth during fiscal '23. Our competitive standing is something we still feel very good about. Even with all the effort we've put into reducing costs, we've kept our focus squarely on safeguarding the things that make us different — for example, fresh thinking and winning business by technical merit. Competitors haven't taken that same approach. The takeaway is that our commitment to this industry and to our vision has stayed firm. The past 12 months have been tough, but after the dust settles, we'll still be here. So we'll keep pounding the streets, keep showing up in front of the retailers we serve, the growers, and the suppliers, working alongside them to address what they need and to put them in the strongest spot they can be in once demand comes back. That shows up across the board, from the programs we run for sales to the projects in our R&D funnel. The market is already shifting toward a setup in which big, innovative cultivators hold the best odds of coming out ahead. That's what we anticipated right from the start, and it suits what Hawthorne does best. Still, the most urgent job on our plate is getting Hawthorne back to profitability. Industry results have clearly worked against us, but so have certain calls we made on investments in the past. Plainly put, we built out this business's infrastructure far beyond what was needed, and I won't try to dress that up. What we have costs about $65 million more per year than what we actually require. We're acting fast to shrink Hawthorne's supply chain footprint, but that can't be done in a single night. Our aim is to bring Hawthorne back to the margin structure it had before, and to do so within 2 years. Past that, our eye stays on reaching a 15% operating margin. The last Hawthorne topic I'd like to raise concerns what lies ahead for it as a stand-alone business. For a number of reasons, the ideal scenario would be to spin the business off right now. One reason, and hardly a minor one, is how much swings in the cannabis industry drag down the equity value of SMG as a whole. Our analysis, though, indicates the present moment isn't right for such a step. A full or partial IPO doesn't make sense in a market like this one. Nor will we unload the business while its earnings sit at a multiyear low, especially when we have a plan for improvement that's both clear and achievable; we looked into the idea of merging the business with another party, but that would mean splitting the synergies with a different set of investors after we've paid bankers, consultants, lawyers and the rest; in the best case, we come out just as well off, or even better, by keeping control of our own fate and letting SMG shareholders capture 100% of the benefits from our restructuring work. The smartest path forward is to repair the business and hold out until the industry bounces back. So as far as I'm concerned, that wraps up this topic. I'd like to use the remainder of my time to return to a few of the themes I touched on before. My team and I stay firm in our vision, yet we recognize that our attention right now has to go toward the correct near-term steps that make it possible. In other words, we have to bring the business back to a profitability level that's acceptable. What that means is we have to zero in relentlessly on free cash flow that can be sustained, and it also means our balance sheet needs to be made stronger while we bring leverage down. Therefore, when it comes to M&A and buying back shares, we're pressing pause. We're still dedicated to leveraging the power of our brands to assist in countering inflation, and we'll cut costs wherever we can to the greatest extent possible, provided it doesn't harm the well-being of those brands. Turning to our leverage ratio, it was 5.1x when Q3 closed and will in all likelihood climb beyond that. Keep in mind, leverage for us gets figured on a rolling 4-quarter basis. Looking forward, our expectation is that leverage will top out during the March quarter at roughly 6x. After that, we'd anticipate a swift decline. Whether we can return to 4.5x by the close of fiscal '23, I'm not certain, but that is what we're aiming for. It probably won't be until fiscal '24, though, that leverage falls under the 3.5x level we prefer as our long-term target. Thanks to the recent changes made to our credit facility, we feel confident there's sufficient headroom to manage; and on that note, I'd like to express gratitude to our syndicate banks for standing behind us and being flexible. The difficulties in the business came up so abruptly this year that just weeks after we wrapped up a new facility, we had to go back into talks with our lenders.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveThey get that this isn't a normal situation, and they pushed us to look for additional wiggle room because of the murkiness out there in the wider economy. Here's what I said back to them. This business has real potential — we understand that — and we're determined to bring it back to the standard we're supposed to meet. On the U.S. Consumer side, operating margins ought to sit in the mid-20s rather than the high teens. We remain convinced Hawthorne can hit a margin in the mid-teens, and beyond that, we ought to be capable of consistently producing free cash flow productivity close to 100%, and during the coming year, that figure ought to come in markedly higher. In fact, our aim across the coming 2 years is to throw off a minimum of $1 billion in free cash flow, with the overwhelming share of that coming during fiscal '23. I have no doubt we can return to the performance level that both we and our shareholders look for and are entitled to; and you can count on this — we'll answer for it. Nobody in management is getting a bonus this year, and the equity grants handed out over the past few years have suffered a big blow too. To earn a bonus in the coming year, we'll need to see striking gains in specific targeted areas, particularly cash flow and leverage. The targets we're setting will aim at creating shareholder value rather than just posting small gains from a base that's unacceptably weak. We understand exactly what has to get done, and we're dedicated and single-minded about doing it. Everyone on this team understands how strong this business and our brands are; we understand how resilient this category is, and above all, we understand how devoted our associates are. Which brings me to this — I'd like to pause and acknowledge our people and express my thanks for what they've done over this year. We ran into hurdles nobody saw coming, and we had to impose changes that caught a lot of them by surprise, particularly since it was only one portion of the company along with so many of our onetime coworkers. All our stakeholders should hear this clearly: my team and I stay hopeful about what's ahead. We understand that our shared strengths and the edges we hold over competitors will put us back on the right path. That's what gives us faith that we'll deliver once more for our shareholders the results and the value creation they are owed. So with that, let's change topics. Cory, over to you.
Cory Miller
executiveAppreciate that, Jim, and hello everybody. In his remarks, Jim walked you through the big-picture view of what we observed across the quarter. What I'll do with my time is go further into the P&L and balance sheet numbers, so you come away with a few more insights. Let me begin by noting that on the whole, what we delivered this quarter largely matched the updated guidance we shared back in early June. One item came in below what we had anticipated. That was U.S. Consumer top line sales. Jim brought up how retailers have pivoted toward cutting inventory, something we've seen happening since May; we had already reworked our full year forecast for U.S. Consumer sales to reflect that, yet the pattern persisted and picked up speed; during the third quarter, POS units fell 6%, whereas our shipment units into retail dropped 18%. Sales in our third quarter declined 14%, and for the fourth quarter we anticipate a decline that's comparable or steeper. As a result, our full year sales outlook now stands at down 8% to 9%. Though retail inventory moves are obviously creating distortion in this year's figures, keep in mind that POS results broadly match what we guided at the start of the year. POS units rose 6% and in 2021. What that tells us about our performance this year is that we sit only a little behind 2020 results while sitting well above 2019 levels. Hawthorne sales declined 63% during the quarter. That business's run rate did slip modestly in the quarter, consistent with the updated guidance we gave in early June. Two factors drove the decrease: less outdoor growing in the third quarter than we had initially anticipated, plus additional postponements of capital projects among indoor growers, with both stemming from excess supply in the cannabis industry. Another point worth making is that the comparison was against record results. Hawthorne's all-time best sales quarter was the third quarter of 2021. We look for Hawthorne's run rate to strengthen in the fourth quarter, helped by innovation in our horticulture lighting business across Europe and Canada. We've just rolled out the WEGA, a new LED product built specifically for greenhouse applications in the vegetable and flower markets. As with our earlier LED innovations, it draws less power while producing optimal light output. Growers in the space have seen the return on investment case clearly, valuing the energy cost savings alongside superior results. Early orders for this product have come in above what we expected. Turning to gross margin rate. The adjusted gross margin rate this quarter came in 530 basis points under last year, pushing the year-to-date decline to 300 basis points below the prior year. The main factor behind the quarterly decline was fixed cost deleverage resulting from the volume miss in both segments. In the near term, warehouse and production expenses tend to stay mostly unchanged, and during the quarter those unchanged expenses had to be covered by a smaller number of units. The effect of spreading fixed costs across fewer units was factored into the updated full-year gross margin rate guidance we provided. For the fourth quarter, the drop in gross margin rate is going to exceed the decline we recorded in the third quarter. The main reason is a sharp reduction in output, which means a greater portion of costs will flow through to the bottom line during the fourth quarter. As anticipated, raw materials also placed substantial pressure on the quarter's gross margin rate. Following the invasion of Ukraine, nearly every commodity we purchase reached a new peak. Urea, after seeing dramatic spikes during the spring, has bounced back lately; that rebound reduced some of the strain this quarter, though it won't bring much easing for the rest of the year. Going forward, shifts in commodity prices will mostly affect us in the upcoming fiscal year, since we have locked in 95% of our commodities for fiscal 2022. Pricing and a favorable segment mix — stemming from weaker sales in the Hawthorne segment — partially counterbalanced the severe deleverage and commodity pressures. SG&A came in considerably lower this quarter, falling 30% compared with the prior year. Three main factors produced this outcome. Variable compensation was the first. As Jim noted, nobody on the management team will receive a bonus this year. Across the full year, variable compensation amounts to roughly $60 million. The restructuring plan we unveiled last quarter was the second source of SG&A savings. We communicated a goal of shrinking our overhead structure by 10%; that restructuring became the initial initiative under Project Springboard. We hit the reduction targets, and a portion of that benefit showed up during the quarter. Lastly, lower spending throughout the organization generated additional SG&A savings this quarter. We assessed each cost center for possible cuts and found ways to trim or postpone spending in all of them. We moved aggressively on these steps, while still holding firm to our views about which activities underpin our competitive advantages. For instance, we made a point of protecting research and development in both businesses along with our U.S. Consumer field sales team. The benefit we saw in the third quarter will extend into the fourth quarter. That prompted us to revise our SG&A outlook from a 13% decline for the full year to a 15% decline. With all of this now reflected in our expectations for full-year adjusted EPS, we anticipate landing between $4 and $4.20 per share. Turning to another topic, I'll now walk through the impairment and restructuring charges recorded in the quarter. Jim discussed the difficulties we've encountered in the Hawthorne segment tied to excess supply in the cannabis industry; those difficulties, together with excessive investment in the Hawthorne supply chain, produced a noncash impairment charge of $633 million tied to goodwill and intangible assets. On top of that, we booked a $46 million inventory write-down tied to winding down and retiring the Sun Systems brand. And then, the restructuring actions I described earlier generated $41 million in charges, which came from employee termination benefits along with fixed asset impairments. Moving under the operating line, interest expense came in $9 million higher for the quarter and $26 million higher on a year-to-date basis. That shift stems from increased borrowing levels. Those elevated borrowing levels, together with weaker earnings in the business, produced a leverage ratio of 5.1x when the quarter closed. Jim covered this subject in considerable detail during his remarks, so I won't go into it more; we anticipate our full year adjusted effective tax rate will come in at roughly 22% for this year. This favorable rate reflects a benefit from discrete items tied to the vesting of long-term share-based compensation awards, and although we aren't providing guidance yet for 2023, I'd like to flag some headwinds that will affect us next year under the operating line. The tax rate will probably be a headwind, since we expect to move back toward a more normalized rate nearer to the 24% seen over the prior few years. Interest rates will also be a headwind, given higher variable interest rates and higher spreads stemming from the recent amendment to the credit facility.
Cory Miller
executiveEarnings per share might also come under strain because of the number of shares outstanding. Because we have no buyback activity planned for 2023, equity awards will create some dilution. Looking at the bottom line, our GAAP loss per share came to $8.01, versus $3.94 of earnings in the prior year; that figure reflects the impairment and restructuring charges I mentioned before. Non-GAAP adjusted earnings per share, which leaves out impairment, restructuring and other nonrecurring charges, came to $1.98 for the quarter, versus $3.98 a year earlier. Let me turn now to the balance sheet and cash flow. We have achieved some movement toward our inventory reduction targets, even after accounting for the additional drop in U.S. Consumer replenishment orders. Inventory closed the quarter $445 million above the level of a year ago. Excluding the Sun System's write-down, that represented an $84 million gain relative to where we finished the second quarter. We have scaled back production across every one of our manufacturing facilities and will keep limiting output and cut our inventory levels dramatically through 2023. In the near term, that choice will weigh on our gross margin rate, but decisive inventory cuts will let us move fast to right-size our distribution network and bring our long-term margins back to a level we consider acceptable. We have likewise reduced our CapEx expectations; the plan now is to spend roughly $135 million, lower than the original $200 million target; we will cut our CapEx spending even more in 2023 as part of our effort to bring leverage down. The balance sheet and CapEx changes I just described were already reflected in the revised cash flow guidance of flat that we shared in early June; nonetheless, the further drop in U.S. Consumer sales will add more pressure on our free cash flow. We now anticipate negative free cash flow of $150 million for the year. Jim expressed his confidence in cash flow ahead, and I fully share it. Working capital reductions will deliver a powerful tailwind next year, and better performance plus lower CapEx will probably push the full year figure to around $700 million, or perhaps above that. Turning to capital allocation, we plan no changes to the regular quarterly dividend; and as Jim noted, every other use of capital is on hold, M&A and share repurchases included. Project Springboard is at work setting detailed targets for leverage and capital allocation, which we will present to all of you next quarter. Beyond question, bringing our leverage down and returning the business to acceptable profitability levels is our top priority. This has clearly been a hard year; it would be simple to dwell on the factors that hurt us. Rather, we are fixed squarely on what we can control as we forge a path forward. I am confident that our plan was designed with shareholder value creation as its guiding principle. We're fully aware that the real evidence of our strategy will show up in the outcomes we produce, and we'll hold ourselves responsible for those outcomes. At this point I'll hand the call to the operator so you can ask your questions.
Chris Carey
analystCould we take another look at what you're expecting for cash flow? I appreciate how much detail you provided, particularly regarding the sizable cash generation you anticipate for the coming year. But I'd imagine that the 4.5x leverage target, assuming that cash flow result actually lands in fiscal '23, suggests a fairly meaningful earnings rebound too. So there's obviously confidence in the business. So first, I guess, could you help us get a handle on what success you're anticipating when it comes to moving this year's inventory into the next one, which I believe is a major assumption underlying your working capital? Also, can you give us a sense of the magnitude? You mentioned some pressure on gross margin from carrying that inventory forward. Is that the only significant impact you expect? Or would additional steps be needed to get that inventory current? Or is it pretty much ready for the fiscal '23 season? And then I have a quick follow-up.
Cory Miller
executiveChris, it's Cory here. So there are several items to address. Regarding free cash flow for the coming year, we identify 2 elements that should largely get us to roughly $700 million. First, there's the usual cash flow pattern we observe annually, which comes to roughly $300 million. So our expectation is that the profits we bring in over the coming year will let us produce that amount of cash flow under normal circumstances. Then there's a second factor that will push next year's cash flow higher than what we'd typically expect in later periods: the inventory decrease we'll see as '23 comes to a close, and that figure ought to be approximately $400 million. Put those two together, and you arrive at $700 million. Once that's behind us, the inventory reduction gain won't come around again, though we ought to remain near that approximately $300 million level as a typical run rate. So as Jim mentioned, $1 billion across 2 years — that's essentially the math behind it. And for next year, the figure I provided was $700 million. The second piece of the question concerns pressure on gross margin. When you consider the squeeze we've been under this year, it basically comes down to three factors that combine into — well, they net out to the 300 basis points of pressure we saw year-to-date, with roughly 400 basis points expected for the full year. The first factor is what we pay for the inputs that go into the products, so that's where that pressure comes from. Then there's also pressure from declining volume. That hits us since our fixed cost leverage throughout the distribution network, our manufacturing footprint, and simply the everyday costs of running things all get spread over fewer units. Right, so those two items are the primary drivers of the pressure. What helps counterbalance that is the pricing action we implemented during this year, and it roughly makes up for the extra dollars we absorbed as our input expenses rose. In other words, the price increases we put through were sufficient to recover those added dollars. On its own, that has a diminishing impact on the rate, and then the leverage from fixed costs pushes the rate down somewhat further. So those are the 2 factors — actually 3 factors — that together add up to the gross margin rate squeeze we're seeing this year. Looking ahead to next year, we're putting through additional price increases, and we're also anticipating further cost escalation. Even though costs have declined as of late, our average cost for next year is still budgeted to sit higher than what we dealt with this year, given the timing of our input purchases and the timing of when those inputs are eventually sold. So that's the rate-related pressure we're anticipating for next year. Also, we haven't yet projected the full year; clearly we aren't issuing guidance on it, but we simply want to flag that a pressure point is going to exist.
Chris Carey
analystAlright, let me get one thing straight on that. How much of the inventory decrease ties to U.S. Consumer, and how much to what you expect from sales at Hawthorne? Then I have one more, and after that I'll come back in — since SG&A will drop quite a bit this year, how much of that decline do you figure returns in fiscal '23, say on a comp basis, versus what could stick around as lasting cost savings?
Cory Miller
executiveWhen you break down that reduction, as we've currently modeled it, roughly two-thirds sits in U.S. Consumer and one-third in Hawthorne. And when you consider the inventory levels we anticipate closing next year at, it still bakes in elevated cost inputs pushing that inventory up. So looking at the overall inventory build, a sizable chunk of the gain we've seen relative to last year comes from each unit simply costing more because of cost increases. So at this point, we're at two-thirds U.S. Consumer, one-third Hawthorne — and should costs decline in the Hawthorne, sorry, in the consumable market, we might see further inventory decreases, mostly on the U.S. Consumer side, though that hinges on costs falling as we produce it, tied to the inventory we're holding at year-end.
Chris Carey
analystAnd then just on SG&A?
Cory Miller
executiveThis year, SG&A expense is clearly below where it used to be; during our remarks we mentioned that $60 million of that stems from incentive compensation; as we put together the plan for next year, we intend to restore incentive comp; that will create a cost headwind. When it comes to other people-related costs, our initial plans right now don't involve any drastic changes on that front, but incentive is a fairly significant item that we're going to add back in.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveChris, this is Hagedorn. I’d like to bring up the Springboard project and give a sense of where things stand. Internally, we’ve been discussing Phase 1 and Phase 2 of Springboard. Phase 1 is essentially the emergency, “oh no, we have to act now” set of moves needed to remain in good shape, particularly as we go through our heaviest borrowing period next March. What we’ve achieved so far — and it’s considerable — I’d estimate is likely more than 1 turn of leverage. The team — and by that I mean the entire company — has been putting in tremendous effort, and when I speak with Cory and the team, my emphasis isn’t really on EPS 2 months from now. It’s on making sure our leverage — you’ve heard me mention 6 is — let’s say 6 or less next March. So, as I just noted, a great deal of work has already gone into that. If you simply look at the business, those results are probably beyond what you asked for. But we beat our July numbers. That’s the first time in probably 4 months that we’ve come in above our numbers. So that felt pretty good. I think we largely have a handle on the last couple of months of the year that Mike is comfortable with; and then our sell-in numbers — again, I’m not putting out a forecast for next year — but I think with Springboard, what we’re aiming for is, I won’t say completely achievable, but a very achievable number that everyone has a lot of confidence in. And so I think there’s probably room there, if Mike hits his numbers, to do better than that. So I think we’re becoming more comfortable; this has been a difficult stretch. I’d say it’s roughly since Memorial Day. But I think we feel like we’re getting back control of what’s happening, based on the fact that the last part was just that while consumer sales were okay, reorders were not, and we’ve been through that; but back to this question of G&A, and I’m really speaking for myself, but as the leader of the business, what we did was pretty blunt. We went into something like emergency mode, we made the — I think we’ve probably overachieved on SG&A reductions. And just to be clear, we’ll do whatever we have to do through March. At that point, leverage based on our assumptions goes down pretty quick, okay? Probably more than 4.5x. But I think that’s the number that sort of ended up in the script. But the Springboard target is better than that, more like 4x or something like that or just a hair over, I think, is kind of where the numbers that I’ve seen recently. Those figures get refreshed constantly. Yet as soon as we feel good about where peak leverage sits — and that ought to arrive fairly soon — we'll shift into Phase 2. Essentially, that phase asks how the company should be organized and how we lift the equity's worth back up. This isn't some kind of cosmic math, in my view. Right now people seem to treat '19 as a rough stand-in. I hear that among the analyst community, though we don't expect sales to return to that level. When it comes to org planning during Phase 1 of Springboard, we did lean on '19 levels. Looking ahead, we're going to be examining things. To give credit to the team at Hawthorne, they've embraced wholeheartedly that the situation is different, and there have been hard stretches. If you care about people, there have been hard stretches at Hawthorne. Our plan is to examine the entire organization and consider a fairly substantial redesign of how we operate. Keep in mind, we came out of that era of "you and what army" — the unconstrained language Luke and I used — into feeling far more constrained. That's fine, yet I believe we need to examine what must be done to create value. So you'll likely witness more of a redesign in the organization. SG&A should show that. Still, we haven't truly dug into that yet. Up to now we've been quite blunt, less refined than I'd prefer, yet that was what the situation demanded. We will enter Phase 2, though. I expect there's more to share with all of you regarding where it leads. It won't be terrible, but it will be far more deliberate about where value gets added in this business. What growth rates do we anticipate, and how do we back that up. My expectation is a focus on our brands. The focus will land on our in-store presence, our capacity to sell, our capacity to fulfill orders, and our capacity to innovate in the marketplace. Those, I believe, are the places we will put money. Still, I consider it a solid process. We simply haven't reached it yet, since we're only now getting a grip on confidence and have a rough sense of where we stand.
Cory Miller
executiveAbsolutely. Chris, let me make sure my point is clear regarding that $60 million being removed from the plan—or from this year’s results—compared with last year, as it relates to variable comp. That isn’t the figure that will be included next year. There are a couple of reasons we ended up paying above target twelve months ago. Because of the steps Jim just mentioned, we’ll have fewer employees going into next year; hence that $60 million figure came out. What we intend to add back is nearer to $35 million.
Peter Grom
analystMorning, everybody. Hope things are going well for you. I just wanted to build on that previous question. I realize you'd rather not give guidance for fiscal '23. So maybe I'm overreaching here, but if I step back and pull together all the various pieces of what you've shared today, it doesn't really seem like you'd anticipate EPS growth, at least to some extent. So the U.S. Consumer business sounds like it should be fine, with Hawthorne seeing moderate growth. And I suppose, from how you answered Chris' question, it doesn't sound like you're expecting much margin improvement. Then, Cory, you pointed to a number of unfavorable items below the line. So is that the right way for me to think about it, given where things stand today? Or is there something I'm missing in that broader assumption?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveNow I'm curious to hear what Cory has to say.
Cory Miller
executiveOkay, so the first thing you mentioned is something I did want to emphasize — no guidance is being provided by us today. That means any range we'd hand over would be extremely wide. When we think about calling this year at $4 to $4.20, and then you turn to next year, what we foresee is neither a meaningful drop nor meaningful expansion, so we'd land in a band roughly near where we are in the current year. That's my preliminary take on it. Plenty of pieces still need to fall into place. Still, a dramatic swing away from where this year is expected to end isn't something I anticipate.
Peter Grom
analystAll right. No, that's genuinely useful; and then I suppose — the prepared remarks contain quite a bit of commentary, Jim, where you talked about how important it is to recover margin. So could you perhaps help us get our heads around the timeline? For instance, you brought up looking back at 2019, and on a revenue basis you're still roughly 30% higher than that, correct, while EPS sits lower. So what should we take as a normalized earnings figure? And is there any kind of timeline for returning to that, since it clearly doesn't sound like it happens next year.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveCory is making that same face I am. Come on.
Cory Miller
executiveWell, if you look at the market today, I'd say there's...
Jim Hagedorn
executiveJust give me a moment here. Let me put it this way. What I believe happened is — and if there are errors, I'll own them — we expanded a footprint for what you could call a $1 billion Hawthorne business, and that footprint would have sustained at minimum $1.5 billion in business, possibly beyond that. The expense of that, as I see it, is genuinely around $65 million annually. Inventory costs and so forth are included in that, plus all the warehousing and related items. Recovering their margins partly means eliminating that essentially excess weight — and nearly 50% of the profitability for that business comes from that. Plus we need to sell lights, our main category there. For us, that's a solid margin business; over time it ought to bounce back. Indoor growing remains the biggest piece of Hawthorne. However, wholesale prices need to reach a point where folks can reasonably justify spending capital to upgrade and expand cultivation space. Turning to the consumer side, for a couple of years we were simply distributing it through inventory. Mike and I decided to just finish that process and accumulate adequate inventory, which looking at it now you might question, yet when those choices were made, it appeared sensible. I mean, we've reduced inventory by roughly $150 million since — we reached our peak, but not many weeks back we were likely holding around $600 million in surplus inventory. So bringing that down — the adverse effect of simply closing off the taps, I mean, we're barely producing anything, which drags on margin considerably. And we've just implemented some pricing changes amounting to almost 10%. So I believe once all of that settles — the pricing takes hold, we return to standard manufacturing operations, our inventory returns to proper levels — every one of these factors ought to help. And Cory, I'm not sure where you want to go with it from here. But my view is — I think — this isn't terribly complicated. Not many moves are required on our end.
Cory Miller
executiveAbsolutely, and when each of those items starts contributing to the P&L is going to matter a great deal. Another element nobody brought up is that expenses have gone up. Even though we've seen costs decline lately, what we expect to pay on average for inputs in the coming year is still above what we've dealt with during this one. The price changes we implemented just this week should counteract some of that pressure, yet we continue to observe rising costs. As the year progresses, with luck we can reverse that trend. With luck, we can reach cost levels closer to what has historically been normal and what has occurred over the past 6 months. So I believe it all comes down to when things happen. Every step is being taken to bring our gross margin rate back to the target we have in mind, but it requires time for these things to work their way through the P&L and appear as better margins; that's the main thing I'd want to ask about, Peter.
William Reuter
analystRegarding what you just said about the recent 10% price increase, that's my first question. My recollection from the last call is that you had completed 4 rounds of price increases totaling 10%. So does that put us at 20% year over year now? Or what is our current position on a year-over-year basis?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveLuke, would you like to handle this one?
Mike Lukemire
executiveRegarding the total figure, I'm not certain. My guess would be 18%. Depending on how it progresses month by month, that's how you arrive at an average across the year.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAnd that's Michael Lukemire talking just by the way.
Mike Lukemire
executiveYes; so — but the 10% is definitely incremental.
Cory Miller
executiveRight, so this involves revisiting additional pricing moves. That means going back to last August and carrying those pricing averages forward, category by category, since each one is seeing a different level of pricing — yet the average sits at 10%, roughly 18%.
Mike Lukemire
executive6 Right.
William Reuter
analystOkay. After that, several remarks came up regarding leverage. During one section of the prepared remarks, you mentioned there might be difficulty reaching 4.5x in the coming year, yet Jim appeared excited that you folks might truly hit 4x. So which factors will determine that figure, and how much of your expenses are already fixed for 2023 as of now? And basically, is the thinking centered on elasticity, which, Jim, you noted in the prepared remarks seemed fairly low, at least during this year?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveWell, allow me — I'll hand part of this over to Cory and Luke, if he's willing. But keep in mind, our highest leverage window actually comes before we begin moving product to the consumer. Everything is retailer load. Thus, given present inventory positions and what we anticipate and what retailers anticipate needing, I believe we have a solid grasp of what that looks like. And it doesn't truly — elasticity isn't truly a factor at that moment when we reach our peak leverage point. So it's largely tied to sell-in, and I'd say the risk there would hinge on selling; that would be — volume would likely be the largest individual factor in that. I believe we comprehend our own expenses fairly well. And as I mentioned, we are fully on top of that. I recall Luke's figure rests on a high confidence level. And we suspect there's likely upside to that; but ultimately, much of the sort of worry we've experienced here across the last month, 1.5 months, I don't know, whatever it is, since the start of June has truly been consumer performance, not Hawthorne. It's been — I mean Hawthorne is simply bobbing along, not truly seen a recovery yet; we don't need to discuss that very much. I don't think that's news. But I think that consumer — setting aside, retailer inventories have truly pushed merchants to be very cautious in how they order. And it's not that they're not supporting the business, and it's not that they're not ordering. But there's 0 excess out of inventory, I'd say it's very minimal. That is a chance for next year, in our view. But much of the struggle over the last couple of months has been performance on the consumer side, and that's just reorders.
Mike Lukemire
executiveCorrect. And really, they're just going along with their — Mike here once more. They're switching those turn replenishment systems back on, and that is genuinely what's fueling the reorder rather than running efforts aimed at pushing particular items to generate activity, even though we will be doing a few things.
William Reuter
analystAll right. Then I have 1 final thing about that. From what it sounds like, nobody has told you that retailers feel any less enthusiastic regarding next year's season. And with that in mind, I believe you said that as of right now, unit inventories are down 12% versus a year ago. Our expectation ought to be that sell-in for next year will be extremely robust. Does that match what your conversations lead you to expect?
Mike Lukemire
executiveYes, that is absolutely what we expect. I mean, we're taking a cautious stance when describing how big it will be; but the — keep in mind, there's — really, POS isn't what's driving this. It's being ready for the season, and on fert and seed we're going to be reaching the season even sooner, closer to historical norms again, and you'll see promotional activity around those. So to begin earlier, we're going to be much more aggressive. And so — but the load end is fairly typical. And if you even consider this year, following the first half we were completely on our plan. That's a retailer lean in. Whatever comes after that depends on POS and on what the consumer does during those months.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveYeah, and one more thing along those lines. I believe we're observing a steady decline in retail inventory as we move toward the close of our fiscal year, which is likely — I'm not sure, something like — well, let's say roughly 3%. Again, that figure is one folks have mentioned; their view is it'll drop approximately 15% by the time the year ends. So we're — and that's baked into our plan — we keep watching retailers aim to wrap up the season fairly clean.
Bill Chappell
analystJim, staying on that topic, I suppose I'm still a bit unclear regarding what you said about U.S. Consumer retail results and the reason you feel so confident that merchants share the same enthusiasm for this category as we head into next year? What I mean is — based on what you described, they cut inventory mid-season for the first time in 20 years since their retail handling of consumables relative to durables was poor, and that's — I'm simply attempting to wrap my head around it; and beyond your expectation of a solid December quarter for sell-in, what makes you confident that they aren't? Are they — as enthusiastic about this category as they were during 2020 and 2021, when it was booming, and where they won't shift their focus to something else; so could you quantify it or provide additional specifics of <<inaudible>>
Jim Hagedorn
executiveLet me begin with qualitative aspects. And afterward, if people wish to quantify it, they're free to do so. I'll open with a few points, Bill, which are, first, our talks for the fiscal '23 season with our retail partners are quite far along; therefore it isn't as though we merely hope they feel enthusiastic. We're certain they feel enthusiastic. We're certain about the choices they've made regarding shelf space. They give us preference, incidentally. And we grasp, I believe, fairly well the promotional strategies headed into next year. That provides us with some assurance. I don't believe we're reinventing the wheel here in — as folks on Wall Street discuss; so I'll put it this way, if I were a merchant at a retailer, I doubt I'd be telling myself, "Oh, we're going to sell a boatload of patio furniture and outdoor grills next year." We possess a deep grasp of, I believe, difficult financial conditions within the economy and how that impacts our business; and I think many of you listening, Bill, I mean, you've known us for ages, I think what you witnessed sort of in, say, 10 was that as consumers grew challenged, lawn and garden consumable products and paint were sort of the major items we were selling for a good while as the consumer was under stress. So I think — I don't think, I know lawn and garden is a major category for retailers. They require it to succeed. They won't succeed, in my view, by selling durable products. They'll succeed by selling consumable products, and that is us. Okay? So we feel assured not just due to talks but due to our grasp of history. And the other thing that — there are a bunch of things that will be different next year for us. A portion of this feels like returning to an earlier era. Bill, my guess is that you'll probably observe promotion happening sooner. Throughout COVID, we pushed aggressively, I believe, and the retailers were on board with promoting and getting the consumer engaged during the season, rather than before it began. We discussed that subject extensively, since our view was that weather posed substantial risk. In my opinion, those promotional efforts were only slightly effective. What we've taken away this year involves a few things: we'd like to move early alongside the retailer on lawn fertilizer and grass seed. That category matters a great deal. For both them and for us, it carries high margins. Getting out in front of it early is the plan, and our brand teams are on it, plus our relationship staff working with our major accounts are on it, and there's real enthusiasm driving it. We're also going to put substantial money behind it, more of it, to make that happen. So even with all the difficulties we're facing, we aren't cutting back on activation for those early, high-margin items, and we're — so we'll be pushing very hard to get those moving. I'm not certain. That's my take — Mike and <<inaudible>>, would either of you like to chime in?
Mike Lukemire
executiveWhat I'd say is that they aren't destocking — no, that's not it. The replenishment systems are running low. Their shelves are stocked. Josh Meihls is right here with me, our head of sales. What we observe is that since the box carries so much additional inventory in durables, they're marking that merchandise down. So they push harder and do more; with that much discounting already happening, they're shifting toward protecting margin somewhat. Even so, this July was among the strongest we've seen in quite some time. We hit our targets, and all of it came from replenishment. In fact, if you simply look at the <<inaudible>>, Bonnie posted its greatest July ever. That was a gain of more than $25 million, something unprecedented for Bonnie. So that's happening without pushing harder with additional promotion around that activity, and they're relying on their replenishment system. That's what gives us confidence in the category. We want to connect that to launching a fall program, particularly around fert and grass seed, and to begin sooner, since we're also up against the clock with consumers too; and so if we don't get that early start while...
Jim Hagedorn
executiveYeah, one more thing I wanted to bring up — this whole elasticity question. As we were getting ready for the call, I had the lawns team come in and we talked it through. Consumers really do seem to respond more to deals. Take July — when we ran promotions, business came in stronger than in periods when retailers weren't promoting. That's something I think carries into next year: if shoppers feel squeezed, they're hunting for a deal, and our business has to be positioned around that. We brought up elasticity not because we have it figured out. The 2% share loss figure comes from Nielsen diary data. Honestly, I don't know that Mike puts much stock in it — at several of our biggest retailers, we aren't seeing any share loss whatsoever. But keep in mind, when we took all that pricing, we never planned for the entire category to shrink either. I'd say Scott's products are somewhat leading that. So heading into next spring, we're convinced promotion is what matters — retailers need to be offering bargains. We intend to monitor it closely; and it's not only us — the merchant teams are watching too — lawn fertilizer products are getting quite pricey. And we — so no share loss so far, but the category has contracted. Our read is that it's nearly all weather. This fall should tell us a lot. It's been hot in certain regions <<inaudible>>, which is tough on lawns. So it'll be worth watching, and when we report at year-end, we'll see how lawns and seed promotions performed while lawns were under stress.
Mike Lukemire
executiveOkay, so we actually noticed that for grass seed, even some of the items with higher price tags came in higher; Jim brought it to my attention that we do run promotions on part of that, and yes, we do. But — those efforts saw solid consumer pickup; and this year, grass seed and fert had far less promotional activity compared with prior years. So we're going to push harder and begin sooner, and we're confident we'll bounce back.
Bill Chappell
analystAlright, so I suppose this is a bit of a follow-up. One thing Scotts has been skilled at, going back through — whether you believe it or not — the 20 years I've spent covering this company, is that when weather turned poor, you could adjust spending within the season, so you'd still land at a comparable bottom line figure. I'm simply attempting to grasp why — I mean, with weather getting off to such a rough start early in the season, you found your hands completely tied owing to rising costs and how inventory was being managed, leaving no way to soften the weather hit? Because it looks like the damage to the bottom line was far larger than what I typically observe affecting the top line just a little.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAbsolutely. I've felt this, and I'm not requesting that anyone pity us or pity me. But imagine sitting at a campfire or a barbecue, and the smoke keeps trailing you wherever you move — that's exactly how this year has felt, in that we faced cost of goods problems. Hawthorne was the driver behind that, and it wasn't only — but it appeared we reached a moment where — and listen, I'm not attempting to justify it. But I believe once you hit roughly early May, suddenly many factors are stacked against you, and at that stage you really require a strong season. And I believe if even 1 of those factors — be it cost of goods <<inaudible>>, or the sort of final quarter for consumer — had not turned against us, we wouldn't be holding this kind of — this type of discussion; it was simply — we arrive at that moment, around early May, when you're either hoping you can salvage the year or it becomes capitulation; and that's what May resembled; we had a 1 of 2 Board meetings taking place this week, which is standard for us; we split the forward meeting up and to sort of clear all the bunch of — everything we need to handle, committee reports, all of that. And afterward we discuss, which happens Friday, what's going on in the business and where we're headed. But there were something like 4 Board meeting minutes dating back to April that needed approval. So I was working through preparation for the Board meeting, and I read through every one of those minutes from April. So roughly late July. Oh my God, it handed me something like PTSD simply reading it — the entire journey is captured there. And yes, Bill, things reached a stage of pure capitulation. Everything was sort of working against us. And I don't believe that's so unusual. My sense is that plenty of the businesses you likely track eventually reach a point where covering everything simply isn't possible. I believe our track record of adjusting as the year goes on is quite strong — it simply reached a point where — and Cory deserves the credit here; things felt somewhat messy at that moment, but there came a moment when we — everyone basically raised the BS flag and said, "hey, this is beginning to get serious." And that's essentially where we've been situated ever since Memorial Day, sir.
Joe Altobello
analystMy first question is about Hawthorne, I suppose. You said July turned out to be a very solid month. My understanding is that you meant U.S. Consumer. So could you make it clear — was Hawthorne's month also a good one? Or are you beginning to notice any initial indications of a shift in that business?
Chris Hagedorn
executiveBill — Joe, Chris here. Right. So no, that remark was about U.S. Consumer. Hawthorne's July was not a strong one, and I would say the patterns we've seen since roughly the start of this fiscal year carried on through July. Clearly we're doing a great deal, as has already been covered, to rein in whatever costs we're able to, as Jim mentioned, winding down the inventory and infrastructure investments we'd made, yet we haven't observed much of a rebound in the industry. We keep searching for those bright spots and signals that a recovery could be coming; even so, for July we hit our revised plan. And at this point we're confident in, once again, our revised plan covering the remainder of the year, though it doesn't factor in any meaningful market recovery.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveJoe, let me just share a few thoughts of my own. I'm aware that King told me he'd like to see me signal — meaning, essentially, move quicker. If any call has ever been worth discussing, I believe, in terms of grasping what's going on here, this one qualifies. I think that — I'm not sure, I believe it was Forbes or Fortune or <<inaudible>> that predicted it would be a blood bath, and how accurate they turned out to be. But at this stage, this is essentially a war of attrition, and we are not caving. We're on the beach, the landing craft have already departed, and we're going to battle our way off that beach. We understand the strategic advantages we hold compared to others. We understand the relationship we've discussed all along, which is cultivating it with cultivation partners. Retail sales of cannabis products haven't declined. What's down is the wholesale price. And the more we examine this, the more absurd it seems. This notion of enacting a public policy. States such as Michigan and Oklahoma have so many licensed producers producing so much cannabis that it is — that can't be sold because there's no — I don't know the exact figures, but let's say Oklahoma needs 0.5 million pounds. I believe the figure is around 11 million pounds or something like that, that they've licensed or if everyone grew to what the license permits; so that product can't be consumed within the state. It must be illegally shipped outside the state. And it is — when you consider the volume of it, it's pushing down the whole American market, and then add banking and taxation on top of that; and if anyone wants to know what your other mistakes were, Jim, it was assuming the Feds would actually get around to fixing the issues of banking and taxation on a product that's legal to around 75% of consumers in this country. We built our investment thesis on this idea that prohibition will end in this space, whatever exactly that meant; but where I think we'd largely say, banking is resolved and listing of top equities on the U.S. exchanges would be permitted; that was roughly our view that, that would get done in about 3 to 5 years. You heard me, Joe, discuss that; those things didn't happen. And I think our footprint size and the sort of assumption that while the states we're making improvements, the Feds would actually do their job, I'm speaking with Leader Schumer this afternoon to push for some action before this Congress changes because there are things they could do that have majority support and probably filibuster proof support if the Senate would like act on some of this stuff; but that's roughly the market we're living in. From a strategic standpoint, though, we held an R&D field day in Marysville not long ago — maybe about a week back — and we reviewed everything we've got going on in R&D. Chris mentioned — I'm not sure — I think it was Cory who brought up this new light being sold into Canada and Europe for greenhouse use. Picture something like a vegetable garden. You're looking at $100 million in sales during its first year. That's — I mean, this is a truly high-end product, with a great deal of IP packed into that light, and $100 million in its first year. Nobody else is doing this research. What are you trying to say? Am I giving the people? Anyway, sorry, Joe. People keep reading notes to me that I'd rather not see.
Joe Altobello
analystNo, I appreciate that. What it really comes down to, it sounds like, is that there are simply too many growers, and we let them stay in business — that is occurring, but not quickly enough?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveYes, that is completely correct.
Joe Altobello
analystAll right. If I may fit in one final question about inventory. You said you're aiming at a $400 million cut in the coming year. When I look at what you sold this quarter, it's close to what you sold in the June quarter of 2019, yet your inventories run $900 million above June of '19. So I suppose my question is whether $400 million will be sufficient?
Cory Miller
executiveWell, in our view, that amount of inventory is what's required to back our sales moving forward from that point. We'll keep examining what the retailers are asking for, and we'll pare down our inventory to the greatest extent we can. We believe the reduction we've got planned sits at the proper level. Clearly, should we reach that stage and find we can pull out more, we'll do so.
Jonathan Andersen
analystI have two things I'd like to ask, if that's alright. First, regarding Hawthorne and what's been said about getting the infrastructure to the right size — I'm curious whether your current plans assume a different sort of long-term growth rate for that business. In the past, I believe you mentioned something like 10% to 15%. But does everything being discussed here about rightsizing suggest a different structural growth rate for that business? Then for my second question, tacking it onto the first, I realize you aren't providing guidance for 2023, yet you did mention some puts and takes. I'm wondering if you could — I think you're taking more price in 2023. How much? You brought up share creep. Could you discuss what a typical year of share creep looks like absent repurchases? That would be extremely helpful.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveDo you want to?
Chris Hagedorn
executiveAbsolutely. Jon, regarding Hawthorne, I can address that from the standpoint of the rate of growth over the long term. Even considering the turbulence we've experienced, both from this disruption and then reflecting on 2018, when we went through that period, if you examine what I believe is our 5- or 6-year CAGR, it comes to roughly 6%. That is approximately where we view the business — growing at a mid- to high single-digit pace over the long term, clearly, with margin recovery occurring through '23, but truly reaching the margin level we're aiming for in '24.
Cory Miller
executiveYeah, regarding what you asked about pricing, after the move we made most recently this week, we're sitting 18%, 19% higher than we were roughly 12, 13 months back. So when we think about the cost increases we anticipate as we head into next year, our hope is that this price increase puts us in position to cover them; we keep watching costs as they come in. And we'll decide sometime between now and around the January time period whether we need to do anything further. Our hope is that we can get by with what we've already taken, but we keep monitoring it as costs shift.
Jonathan Andersen
analystAnd what would the usual share creep look like if there were no buybacks?
Cory Miller
executiveBy the close of next year, that creep will likely amount to roughly 1 million shares. I'd say that figure is a reasonable one to rely on. It might shift somewhat from there, but around $1 million.
Gaurav Jain
analystI have a few things to ask. The press release says consumer POS dollars declined 6%, units declined 8%, and it also notes pricing rose nearly 18%. Does that indicate the mix has moved toward cheaper items among what you offer?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAbsolutely. I'd say lawns being lower is a mix problem that in our view largely stems from weather; plus heavier promotional activity on our dirt and mulch lines, I believe, caused that.
Gaurav Jain
analystAll right, got it. And then the second thing — regarding certain balance sheet entries, such as accounts receivable and inventory — could there be any danger of write-downs, particularly related to Hawthorne, since that's consumer-facing? Its own customers, the retailers, may be having a hard time at the moment — the hydroponic retailers. So is there any exposure to write-downs on account receivables as well as on inventory?
Chris Hagedorn
executiveYeah. When you look at AR and inventory, those are the 2 I would also call out. Right now, what we've sold into retail — retailers on the hydro side are struggling somewhat. Some retailers are out there paying us slowly. Our belief is that we've reserved and stated it correctly on the balance sheet. So beyond what we've already booked to date, we don't foresee severe risk. Even so, we keep monitoring AR quite attentively. Regarding inventory, we review it, and going forward we did discontinue one brand — our Sun Systems brand. As a result, this quarter we recorded an inventory reserve tied to the inventory we carry for that brand. Our view is that everything we hold, along with the remainder of the business, is properly stated. We keep examining it. At this point we aren't selling below cost. We're carrying a lot of inventory. So when we examine the network, some inventory might potentially be eliminated, since we're seeking to rightsize that network and cut down the square footage available for holding product. But the product we currently have feels like good product, and as of today we have no unusual reserves against it.
Eric Bosshard
analystThere are a couple of items I want to raise. I've picked up on what you said regarding conviction and how retailers are placing large orders as we head into next year. What concerns me is the flip side of that — how much faith do you have that consumers will stay involved next year? My recollection is you mentioned that every customer acquired during 2020 has been kept. Meanwhile, unit volumes have fallen 8% this year. You're implementing additional price increases next year, and the consumer faces growing pressure along with declining confidence. So I'd like to know how you see consumer participation in this category shaping up for 2023.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveSorry, what did you say, Mike?
Mike Lukemire
executiveAbsolutely. I believe what you're going to observe is a shift in favor of value, and from the segments where, in my view, promotions will lean more toward value, Eric. So we're going to kick that off sooner. In certain respects, you could describe it as a throwback. But in places where value has shown up — for instance, in club categories and similar areas — shoppers have gravitated toward value. That means we'll provide value to consumers, draw them in alongside the retailers, and hold their attention. We anticipated — let me use Bonnie as an illustration — I suppose I was somewhat overenthusiastic in mentioning $25 million. The figure was $16 million, 25%. So, ideally I've set that straight regarding the and/or <<inaudible>>. Yet we didn't expect people to purchase at $5 — above $5, and even so we've witnessed solid consumer takeaway; and therefore — plus the signals on our higher-value items, once we extend some value, consumers have responded by buying in, so.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveYet Mike, you aren't anticipating anything wild — you're not counting on some insane debt prebuying for the coming year, are you?
Mike Lukemire
executiveWell, I do look at what Eric writes, and sure, Eric, some of those ideas have made their way into what we're doing. So your thinking on where things stand is solid, but my view is that I don't believe — I just don't see shoppers turning their backs on this. What we need is people coming through the door — we need traffic in the stores, and ours are the items that draw that traffic in, particularly during Q2. We simply have to pull that off, and partner with the retailers so it actually happens.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveBut do we need excessively heavy orders?
Mike Lukemire
executiveNo, that's not too much at all. You simply need to be prepared, and you have to start right away.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveThere's a point that's come up, and honestly it worries me a bit: suppose retailers load up heavily on durables — just inventory sitting in the box overall — and they hold it back until late January, when their fiscal year wraps up. Mike, when they do that, we simply can't deliver. I just can't secure the trucks. So if retailers need to hear one thing, it's this: our plan is built around exactly what's required to fill the stores, according to how we see it, how they see it, and how our sales team sees it. That can wait until January's final days. There's just no way we'll line up the trucks in time, so I'd say we're comfortable with where we stand. I — all of us do read your reports, sir. On this particular subject, I believe we'd take a different view.
Eric Bosshard
analystTo go back to this, Mike, it appears there's a contradiction: customers are seeking greater value, value is going to matter more, yet you are increasing prices by 10%; those two things still look like they conflict. Is there something I'm overlooking?
Mike Lukemire
executiveNo, nothing is being overlooked by you. What I think is going on is this: can you recall the amount you spent on fertilizer during the previous year? And when a value is offered and you have to provide it along with the activity, do you abandon it simply because that purchase happens only once every 12 months? And that's why, looking back through history with pricing, as far back as 2010, we implemented an enormous level of pricing; yet customers are searching for that value. And clubs and similar outlets are showing us this. I mean, when people bring up Walmart, they say, well, I check out Sam's. Sam's was actually higher, and there are situations where we are capturing. So a value equation is what people seek there; and my view is that promotion is the way we traditionally handled it. When times are tough, our belief is that they will come back to that activity, rather than flee from it.
Chris Hagedorn
executiveEric, my take is that there's a conflict here — pricing is being pushed by what our goods cost us. That isn't to say we're attempting to lift margin; what we're attempting is to hold margin steady, and we aren't managing that especially well. So it's among those situations that just kind of need to occur. Still, my sense is that we have faith in the retailers, as it were, and we've got a solid plan as we move ahead into the spring.
Eric Bosshard
analystAlright. Then one more thing for Chris. Those write-offs at Hawthorne, when you add everything up, appear to come to roughly $700 million. Regarding when those investments were made that you're taking charges on, could you give us a bit more perspective on that? What I'm attempting to determine is whether this is Sunlight from 4 years back, or is it Luxx from 6 months ago?
Chris Hagedorn
executiveIt's a mix. Honestly, nearly all of it is goodwill tied to the business, which includes brands acquired fairly recently. Some lighting technology has essentially turned outdated because we've managed to introduce new innovations. There's a — like we said, the Sun systems brand is one we're transitioning away from. So as I mentioned, essentially all the goodwill — I mean, I believe every single penny we've set aside in the business. Yes. And what does that $700 million amount come to in total?
Cory Miller
executiveMore than $600 million.
Chris Hagedorn
executiveThat's right. And after that, the balances tied to certain inventory we've taken out of the system through rationalization, mostly in Lighting.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveEric, we bring in outside folks to assist with those figures. There's an upside — I can't say precisely what the EPS gain is from, in a sense, recording this noncash charge at this point — and doing so also delivers a tax advantage over the long term. So really we took the bull by the horns and wrote off every bit of goodwill in that unit. And I believe — we believe, from an accounting standpoint, that it's the correct call. But I think it likewise settles the business somewhat to move ahead.
Cory Miller
executiveAbsolutely. When you examine how the impairment was determined, the weighting leans quite significantly toward the performance we're delivering right now as well as what we anticipate over the near term. Given that our growth rates are sitting in the mid-single digits for the foreseeable future, along with the numbers we're putting up this year and those that competitors in the space are putting up too, all of that feeds into the calculation, and this is essentially where it came out. The calculation was fairly mechanical, and because of how much goodwill we carry, we simply chose to write the whole thing down to 0, even though a few of the acquisitions happened fairly recently.
Carla Casella
analystOnly 1 more thing on that restructuring. What portion of it came in cash? My guess is it's only that $41 million piece. Also, should we expect a lot more cash-related restructuring during the back half? Then I've got 1 additional question after that.
Cory Miller
executiveThat's right — the pieces tied to cutting headcount were where the cash went. When we think about Q4 and probably Q1 as well, making the Hawthorne footprint the right size is going to affect the facilities we operate there. We'll probably see additional restructuring land there too. The split between cash and people-focused restructuring versus noncash is something we still haven't settled at this point; but most likely, it'll be a blend. A firm figure isn't available to me at the moment; however, if you consider dialing in our footprint and the DCs tied to it, you'll end up with a blend of inventory, discontinuation costs for that footprint, and in all likelihood some staff will be part of that as well.
Carla Casella
analystIs every bit of that captured within the cash flow guidance?
Cory Miller
executivePardon me, would you mind saying that once more?
Carla Casella
analystDoes the free cash flow guidance you provided for the coming year already account for all of that?
Cory Miller
executiveIt does.
Carla Casella
analystThen regarding Hawthorne — has the company ever shared what portion of that unit's revenue comes from cannabis as opposed to other indoor cultivation? And perhaps what the split looks like now compared with before, or how you expect it to trend over a longer horizon?
Cory Miller
executiveWhen you examine that operation, the overseas portion we run has almost no cannabis involvement. It's predominantly lighting supplied to greenhouses cultivating fruits, vegetables and flowers. So figure somewhere between $100 million and $125 million. As for what's left, largely within the U.S., though a bit sits in Canada, it's a blend, yet everything moves through retail or resellers. That means we aren't selling directly to the end consumer. As a result, we give up some visibility, but a substantial share does go toward cannabis. An exact percentage isn't something I can give you.
Andrew Carter
analystMy apologies — my line was muted. So here's what I wanted to raise: regarding Hawthorne, I realize you've said independent spending is off the table, and you've also mentioned that a sale isn't something you'd want to pursue. But why not take a closer look at that option? I mean, plenty of errors happened when resources seemed unlimited, and at this point you're operating with limited resources. Where's the danger that you won't be able to put money behind every opportunity? And then there's a second risk, I suppose: what happens if certain rivals or buyers roll up — could that hurt you, or if a well-capitalized player, somewhat like you were when you came into this market, arrives, acquires some of these assets at depressed prices, and that leaves you worse off? How are you weighing all of that?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveOkay. Honestly, I'm not sure where to begin, man. Let me start by saying some errors were made, in my view — yet if you poll everyone at this table and ask, do we enjoy this business? Do we believe it bounces back? Do we believe strategically it's a good spot for us? The response is yes. So you won't see us lacking commitment here. As for consolidation among others, I can't say precisely who that would involve. We've discussed assembling what amounts to a leper colony of all the publicly traded equity in this sector. And frankly, when I consider our strategic strengths and everything we've been building, I believe we're unquestionably the finest house on the block. So do I want to burn that house down? Not particularly. Let me begin with something fundamental — and here I'll admit I fell into this error — which is this: our distribution footprint runs roughly $65 million annually. We likely can't eliminate it entirely in '23, but for the most part, that will be finished in '23. That shifts a business that's at an unclear level — roughly breakeven as of now, actually a touch below that, but let's say near breakeven as of now — to something beyond plus $50 million, right? We believe this business does bounce back. We believe it will serve us better. Why do I claim that? Because if you ask who's winning here, in our estimation the more commercial players are the ones who will win; we know this sector, whether it was our pro turf operation, our pro horticulture operation, or let's call it a pro cannabis operation. This is a sector we grasp, we grasp how we deliver value, and we're putting those investments in. Among the problems we've faced while exploring different approaches has been our spending on innovation. As we've said previously along the way, the R&D efforts taking place in this extremely early-stage segment of cannabis growing are genuinely remarkable — the work being done here. It's our belief that this represents a key component of what lies ahead, and that whatever transaction we enter into with anyone would depend on whether they'd be ready to commit the same level of investment we are prepared to commit toward cultivation methods, toward boosting output, toward enhancing product quality — essentially all the efforts we've been engaged in. And I believe our response is that we doubt others would be prepared — in the current market — to put in what's necessary to strategically build a company for tomorrow. Look, we're not — we're unhappy, but let me begin by acknowledging that half the business's profitability, we messed up by essentially committing to build out a footprint for $1.5 billion, and we're now at, I'm not sure, $800 million or thereabouts. And we're absorbing that. And we'll need to correct it. And that responsibility falls on us, alright? The excess production problems will be resolved because companies will fail, alright? And that's what needs to occur. Joe, I believe, mentioned this before — there will be those who don't survive. That won't be us. So if we were to have interest in some kind of transaction moving forward as this — to consolidate for the better. It needs to improve our position, alright? And that's somewhat of a tall order, alright? So I'm not sure. I'd rather not debate the matter other than to ask, why not sell it? Because we're on the beach and the landing craft have departed, alright? And no one here wants to raise their hand and essentially end up in a prison or a war camp or getting shot on the beach; and we will battle through this, and that's a commitment to anyone who believes they can compete with us — we possess the resources to survive this. We have the capabilities to make it through, and we've been constructing a vision for the future that I doubt you'll find anywhere else; so we will not be made victims in any kind of consolidation. And that's — this isn't meant to disparage anyone else. In the conversations we've had with other people, they've been truly wonderful individuals, everyone is having a hard time at the moment. It's simply that we need to look at this and insist it must be better for us.
Kelly Berry
executiveAll right, thank you all. So once more, just a brief note that the leadership group is going to be at the Barclays Global Consumer Staples Conference on September 8, and we'll share the specifics as that date gets nearer. Until then, don't hesitate to contact me whenever you've got questions. We appreciate your being with us today. Enjoy the rest of your day.
Operator
operatorThat brings us to the end of today's call. Thanks once more for joining us. You're free to disconnect at this point.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.