The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company (SMG) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
February 1, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Aimee DeLuca
executiveThanks, and good morning, everyone. My name is Aimee DeLuca, and I'd like to extend a warm welcome to The Scotts Miracle-Gro first quarter earnings conference call. I've just taken on the role of leading Investor Relations, following 21 years here at Scotts in various finance and strategy positions. It's been a pleasure getting to know many of you already, and I'm eager to meet plenty more of you in the months ahead. With me this morning are Jim Hagedorn, our Chairman and CEO; Matt Garth, our new CFO; Mike Lukemire, our President and Chief Operating Officer; and Chris Hagedorn, Division President of Hawthorne. In just a moment, Jim and Matt will offer some brief prepared remarks. After that, we'll open up the call for your questions. I can see quite a few of you are already in the queue; given time constraints, we ask that you limit yourselves to one question and one follow-up. Matt and I will have extra time with many of you today to address some of the gaps, and I welcome anyone else who'd like to arrange follow-up time to contact me directly. So with that, let's proceed with today's call. As usual, we'll be making some forward-looking statements, and I want to remind everyone that our actual results could differ materially from what we shared this morning. Investors should take the time to review the complete set of risk factors that might affect our results. You can find those in our Form 10-K, which has been filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission. Please note that today's call is being recorded. A replay will be accessible on our Investor Relations site at scottsmiraclegro.com; so with that, let's begin, and I'll hand things over to Jim Hagedorn.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveThanks, Aimee, and good morning to all of you. On our previous call, I discussed the difficulties we faced in fiscal 2022, along with the tough decisions and bold steps we took to bring the company back to acceptable profitability levels. I said our leadership team was focused on this, and that we had complete belief in our capacity to properly resize the business and generate shareholder value. That takes me to where we are now. In Q1, we beat our overall net sales target, powered by the U.S. consumer segment and Hawthorne's resourcefulness in uncovering opportunities amid a struggling cannabis market. Record shipments to retailers drove strong load-in, a signal of confidence in the consumer for this lawn and garden season. Here's my summary of Q1: better days are ahead; we're headed the right way. There's still more to be done. And as before, we're on it. Our Q1 performance shows the transformation happening inside Scotts Miracle-Gro. We're running as a company that looks very different from a year ago. We've realigned our business; we're leaner yet more concentrated on delivering the greatest value. Our financial position is stronger. We're showing discipline. Above all, our whole company, across every function, is performing at its best. Let me give some context. In Q1, we're up against difficult comparisons in the U.S. Within the consumer division, 2022 marked only the second occasion in company history that we posted a profitable opening quarter. Customer involvement remained high as we entered a year ultimately shaped by retail deliveries that could not match demand. Something our latest Q1 results fail to show is just how remarkably our Scotts Miracle-Gro team members delivered amid a much tougher set of circumstances. Their resolve never broke, and they have greeted 2023 with resolve and a winning attitude. Our operating plan is being converted by them into actual results. Let me give you a fast rundown of how our results stacked up against the targets we set internally. On net sales, we came in about $25 million above plan. Gross margin finished almost 300 basis points higher than we'd planned. EBITDA landed at $21 million, while our internal forecast had called for zero. Net leverage stood at 5.9 times debt-to-EBITDA, which leaves us well below the 6.25 covenant ceiling. With Project Springboard, we're moving faster than planned and doing better than we expected, and we remain positioned to exceed the cost savings guidance we originally gave for the year. For SG&A, our guidance points to a mid single-digit decline versus fiscal 2019. Overall, I'm happy with where we are, though declaring a clear win would be premature. To build on what I said earlier, there's still work ahead of us; for our U.S. consumer segment, we are restating the full-year guidance we've given for how we expect it to perform. During Q1, the entire company mobilized around achieving a strong lawn and garden season. Hawthorne continues to face tough market conditions. We remain committed to improving its returns and reaching profitability by the time the year closes. Sales aren't really the focus here, even though the team has been working hard on that front. What matters more is taking apart a supply chain that was built out too far, along with the excess inventory. So far, our warehousing costs are down 40%, and we've reduced both SG&A and inventory by a third. Additional operational improvements and efficiency gains are still ahead. Let me walk you through our core business in more depth, because there are two sides to it. The first side: creating momentum and ensuring retailers are completely stocked and fully committed to us—that was accomplished during Q1. The second side: getting consumers excited and driven to visit stores, explore and buy on the web, and fill up on our products. That's what we're concentrating on in Q2 and Q3; we'll pursue both of those quarters and achieve the same outcome we delivered in Q1. Getting people involved early is hugely important. It's well known that shoppers whose first lawn and garden purchases happen before May shell out two times as much within the category. During the prior quarter, I mentioned that despite trimming costs, we would continue funding worthwhile initiatives that drive expansion. In the current year, we are increasing what we put into promotions and marketing, and we are spending twice as much on our lawn category compared with a year ago. When you add everything up, our overall working media outlay exceeds fiscal 2022 levels by close to 25%, and it will deliver better efficiency and sharper targeting. This year's total media expenditure will surpass even what we spent in 2019, the year before the pandemic. The early season, as everyone knows, is already underway across the South. Campaigns spanning omni-channel, along with radio, television and digital activation, have all begun. POS numbers are trending up in the South, and over the last couple of weeks, Bonus S has climbed 68% in Florida and 54% in Texas. Grass seed is showing similar momentum in that same window, rising 24% in Florida and 65% in Texas. Coming in March is a National Early Season Lawns Campaign. Miracle-Gro has teamed up with Roku and Martha Stewart around her new program, Martha Gardens. Also this month, we kick off the biggest launch in Roundup's history, introducing a new dual action non-glyphosate formula. Those are only a handful of the things on the way. We're aligning where we put our money alongside the retailers, and they're ramping up what they put toward joint media promotions plus activations inside stores. Early in the year, lawn and garden brings in the most foot traffic, and when we combine our efforts, POS can see a multiplier of 3 times to 5 times. Our operating plan has my full support. Shortly, Matt Garth — our CFO as of December 1st — will walk through the Q1 figures and what we expect for fiscal 2023. Before that, let me go back to our long-term strategy. Even though we run things quarter by quarter, we're beginning to do that while keeping growth in mind. Back in fiscal 2021, we introduced a growth strategy built on five pillars. That strategy still has my backing. Out of the five pillars, three belong to the consumer business, while the remaining two fall under Hawthorne. Within the consumer segment, the lawn and garden pillar serves as a stable, dependable generator of cash. The majority of new gardeners who joined our category during the pandemic are still with us. Sustainable growth is what our brands are delivering, and we continue reaching consumers through marketing, innovation, packaging, formulations, and products. That includes drought tolerant choices for building living landscapes that work in harmony with nature. Pillar number two is direct-to-consumer, a portion of category growth that takes in our e-commerce and retailer.com sites. A robust online footprint lifts brick-and-mortar POS, and direct-to-consumer platforms serve as tools for learning about and shopping for products. The lawn and garden omni-channel shopper — someone who buys both online and in store — spends 2 times as much in our category as a shopper who only visits stores. Keeping that in mind, we've upgraded our online product content and visibility, and last month we moved to a new e-commerce platform, which brings better efficiency plus stronger marketing and personalization tools across 10 brand sites. Live goods, our third pillar, acts as a natural entry point for consumers along their lawn and garden journey. Purchases of vegetables and herbs by consumers have held steady across the past two years, and nearly 60% of edible gardeners plan to plant more within the next two years.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveWe have great confidence in the growth potential at Bonnie Plants, where we'll operate with sharper execution across growing stations and retail locations, and also put money into innovation to encourage more customers to cultivate their own. Now I'll turn to Hawthorne, where our approach has two parts. First, we will preserve Hawthorne's competitive edge in the cannabis non-plant touching sector and professional horticulture. As the top solution provider for growers, we stand apart from companies that mainly act as distributors. Second, via our investment in RIV Capital, we'll establish ourselves as a significant participant in the consumer and retail cannabis arena in New York, which is expected to rank as the second biggest cannabis consuming state, after California. Looking more closely at Hawthorne, I've described how we merged back office operations and are refining our network; we're narrowing our focus. Equally important, we're pursuing innovation. Our researchers in Kelowna, British Columbia — the first R&D site in North America dedicated to cannabis research — are conducting trials involving lighting, nutrients, genetics and other technologies to boost yields, quality and energy efficiency. Comparable efforts are happening with hemp in Oregon, Florida and Ohio, where we launched a controlled environment facility to complement our greenhouses. R&D's efforts resulted in the debut of the market's most sophisticated and efficient LED to date, the Gavita 2400e; we've kept pushing innovation with the WEGA LED lighting portfolio for indoor growers of vegetables, fruits and flowers. WEGA should exceed last year's unit sales across Europe and North America and now represents one-sixth of Hawthorne's business. We seized the trend toward indoor agriculture, an industry that by certain estimates is roughly $40 billion yearly in the U.S. with a projected annual growth rate of 13.5% through 2030. Moreover, by adjusting the light spectrum for the WEGA, we can turn it into a superb no-frills LED choice for cannabis growers. One last note on the cannabis sector: when it recovers, and it will, growers will be prepared to spend on CapEx. We'll be ready to assist the turnaround. Consolidation is occurring in the industry and we foresee chances for high-value no-cash partnerships to further boost Hawthorne's capacity to deliver value-added and innovative solutions to growers. I'll move to the consumer aspect of cannabis through our convertible loan to RIV, an integrated cultivator and retailer in New York that owns the Etain cannabis brand. RIV possesses one of 10 vertically integrated licenses that covers a growing and processing operation and four dispensaries, and is building a state-of-the-art indoor growing facility in Buffalo. From a regulatory standpoint, New York has stumbled in creating and rolling out rules, which has kept the market from achieving its near-term potential; but let me be clear, New York will turn into a monster market and we will see it through. There is progress in value in our investment with RIV. In summary, we've adjusted the pace at which we're advancing our strategic pillars. Our strategy has moved away from a faster tempo toward a cautious yet consistent way of investing, which bolsters our capacity to expand and create value for shareholders. Once conditions permit, we'll return to a stance that favors shareholders more boldly. Cost management, EBITDA, and free cash flow stay at the center of what we do. During our previous quarterly call, we pledged $185 million in yearly savings spanning both phases of Project Springboard, to be delivered by fiscal 2024. By fiscal 2023, the entire $185 million will be realized, and we can now see a path to savings beyond what we promised. Looking back over this year, moments like this reveal how resilient and strong our business is, along with the resolve of our associates; our leadership and talent are outstanding. At a pivotal point in our transformation, we're instilling discipline in our financial processes, forecasting, and capital allocation. Collaborating with the leadership team and the Board of Directors has been genuinely enjoyable, and they've been a wonderful partner to me and the executive team. My gratitude also goes out to our retail partners and banks. The backing and dedication they've shown has been priceless and will help drive our shared success. Thank you. Let me end with this thought. People feel an emotional bond with their lawns and gardens, something our vision statement captures; we assist individuals of every age in expressing themselves on their own patch of the earth. Our top brands, innovation, and products bring this to life, serving varied needs. Whether in prosperous periods, pandemics, or downturns, people keep coming to us to improve their lives. I've frequently remarked that no business could be better to be part of, and that holds just as true right now. Thank you. At this point, I'll hand the call to Matt.
Matt Garth
executiveThanks, Jim, and good morning to all of you. Let me start by saying how thrilled I am to be here as part of The Scotts Miracle-Gro family. For a long time, I've bought this company's products myself, and I know from personal experience what it takes to get a beautiful lawn — putting down Turf Builder 4 times per year — and to grow a productive garden with Miracle-Gro soil and plant food. The welcome I've received has been warm, and Dave Evans handled my transition smoothly as he wrapped up his time as interim CFO. Since I came aboard, I've dug into operations, marketing, sales, human resources, and naturally, the finance side of things. To sum up what I've seen so far, we have a phenomenal team that each day strengthens the open, transparent and accountable culture that Jim and his team built. This quarter demonstrates that our shared push to bolster the company's financial strength through Project Springboard is paying off. That focus on improvements and savings won't stop, even as we put money into our future and innovation so we can extend our leading positions and generate substantial long-term value. Now I'll cover the first quarter results. Record December shipments in our U.S. consumer business produced Q1 segment sales that rose 8% versus a year ago, and along with the strong Project Springboard savings Jim mentioned, that more than made up for early softness at Hawthorne; we now anticipate reaching the $185 million in annualized Springboard savings by the close of the fiscal year, far sooner than we'd previously committed. Springboard actions, plus our team's ongoing urgency, will open up further upside as we head into 2024, with possible savings beyond $185 million that we can steer toward innovation, consumer activation and growth. Net leverage finished the quarter at 5.9 times adjusted EBITDA, well inside our covenant ceiling of 6.25 times. Let me shift to the P&L, starting with sales. Taking a look at our results, consolidated net sales were down 7% versus the first quarter a year ago. In U.S. consumer, the growth we saw in sales demonstrated how well our retailer partnerships worked for the early season build-out. Our sales and supply chain teams executed and coordinated impressively to deliver on customer expectations, and that included moving some Q2 volumes into Q1. When we look at the first half, our expectation remains that load-in will align with the plan we originally set and land a bit higher than the same period last year. At our four largest customers, first quarter POS came in as anticipated, down 19% in units and 8% in dollars. Across our major customers and categories, those POS unit declines were consistent. During our previous earnings call, we told you that we continue to expect POS units for fertilizer and grass seed to rise 10% for the entire year, with unit volume across remaining product categories holding roughly level compared with fiscal 2022. Our results so far in Southern markets during the early season indicate we are tracking right where we planned. That period, which we call Q1, accounts for less than 15% of the full year, and focus is appropriately shifting to our busiest stretch in Q2 and Q3. At the outset of the year, units held by retailers sat somewhat below where they were a year earlier, yet a strong Q1 load-in combined with the POS decline we expect has nudged retailer units somewhat higher. How replenishment orders come in for the back half of the year will depend on what consumers actually buy, as well as the steps retailers take to manage their inventory. Our own plans are aligned with where our retail partners intend to be on inventory as the year closes, and we're keeping an eye on how consumers are doing so that if demand levels shift, we can respond quickly and keep production in step. Turning to Hawthorne now. Difficult conditions that persist across the industry led to a 31% drop in top-line sales compared with a year earlier; that result stemmed from less activity among retailers and professional growers, which oversupply brought about, along with widespread uncertainty over when the market might come into better balance. When we first issued guidance, we assumed that for the full year, Hawthorne sales would be flat to down low-single digits. Given how slowly the business started and where the industry stands overall, our updated projection for Hawthorne is a year-over-year sales drop of 20% to 25%. Looking ahead, there's plenty to feel optimistic about regarding Hawthorne's future. By year's end, we intend to reach run rate profitability through the right, careful steps, all while improving our standing going forward. At the full company level, our earlier full-year guidance called for low single-digit sales growth; with the market difficulties Hawthorne is up against, we now believe a low single-digit sales decline in fiscal year 2023 makes more sense. We posted a 20% gross margin this quarter, which represents a 90 basis point drop from a year ago. Several factors helped counterbalance the decline: solid volume and pricing among U.S. consumers, an improved mix across segments, and faster-than-anticipated advancement on our Springboard objectives. These gains were mostly offset by weaker Hawthorne sales along with increased conversion expenses and commodity costs. Our outlook for fiscal 2023 still calls for a modest gross margin decrease, since reduced Hawthorne volume will be counterbalanced by savings from Springboard. During our previous quarterly call, we noted that because of unprecedented inflation, commodities now represent roughly one-third of our overall cost of goods sold. Right now, we've got roughly 65% of our overall commodity costs locked in, and more than 70% of total COGS is locked, so visibility for the remainder of the fiscal year is pretty solid. There are some encouraging signs in international freight rates, resins, and pallets, though bigger inputs such as diesel and urea kept tracking the underlying energy-related commodities. The team has done a strong job partnering with customers to handle inflationary costs and secure pricing that mostly offsets our dollar exposure. When it comes to Project Springboard, the clearest proof of progress shows up in SG&A, which is $26 million lower, or down 17%, compared with last year. Earlier, our full-year SG&A target was set under fiscal 2019 levels. Based on what we saw in the first quarter, our current projection is a drop in the mid single-digit range versus fiscal 2019. Moving further down the income statement, interest costs are higher, mostly driven by increased debt and rising rates; you may remember we flagged that 2023 could bring as much as $40 million in additional interest expense. Given how SOFR has shifted and the spread we currently pay at our leverage, we now expect that extra interest expense to come in closer to $60 million this fiscal year. Our adjusted effective tax rate came in at 25.5% for the quarter, and for the entire year we expect the ETR to fall somewhere between 26% and 27%. I'd also point out that we expect fully diluted shares to rise by roughly 0.5 million shares by the time the fiscal year ends. That takes us to the bottom line, where our GAAP net loss for the quarter was $65 million, or $1.17 per share, versus a loss of $50 million, or $0.90 per share, in the prior year. When you strip out impairment, restructuring, and other one-time items, our adjusted loss came to $56 million, which works out to $1.02 per share. A year ago, that figure stood at a loss of $49 million, or $0.88 per share. Across the whole company, the drop compared with last year was entirely driven by things outside our operations — mainly higher interest and tax costs. Adjusted EBITDA, in fact, climbed to $21 million this year, versus a $1 million loss the prior year.
Matt Garth
executiveThe bridge from our quarterly GAAP net operating loss over to non-GAAP adjusted EBITDA is laid out in the financials inside the press release. That reconciliation covers $19 million tied to restructuring work still underway, which takes in Hawthorne, costs associated with integration, and other Springboard projects. Because depreciation expense came in lower than we had anticipated — largely a function of when capital expenditures landed and the impairments at Hawthorne — we are changing our adjusted EBITDA guidance for the whole year. The full-year bump in adjustments is now projected at under $20 million, which translates into low single-digit expansion in full-year adjusted EBITDA. Let me now shift over to how we're thinking about capital allocation. There's no refinancing risk anywhere close to us, and we finished the quarter sitting on more than $800 million of undrawn revolver capacity. Through this year we intend to handle the seasonal build in working capital and remain in compliance with our financial covenants. Free cash flow will go toward paying down debt, with a net leverage ratio target under 4 by the close of fiscal year 2024. During 2023 we're putting $100 million of CapEx to work, covering maintenance needs plus projects with high returns and quick payback. Continued backing of our quarterly dividend is also part of the outlook. To sum it up, we'll keep capital discipline tight and push leverage lower, all while making sure we fund the innovation and capability needed to deliver long-term growth at SMG. Keep in mind, please, that the guidance I've just given carries risk. What falls inside our control, we are managing carefully. Consumer engagement is the big driver of how we perform across the back half of our fiscal year. Working hand in hand with our customers, we have a bold, creative plan to bring the consumer in early and keep them engaged all season long. I'll echo Jim's enthusiasm regarding Hawthorne's long-term prospects and what that business could deliver in terms of growth and value creation. Let me wrap up by giving the first quarter its proper context. Q1 normally accounts for under 15% of our full year. Our busiest stretch is almost here, and I feel good about the plans we've set and about Mike Lukemire and his team's capacity to carry them out. That's where I'll stop, and I'll hand the call back to the Operator so we can take your questions. Thank you.
Jonathan Andersen
analystHello there, and good morning to everyone. I appreciate you taking the question.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveHi.
Jonathan Andersen
analystFirst off, regarding the U.S. consumer business, I have two things. First, could you share a bit more about any early-season indicators that might strengthen your confidence, especially for the lawns segment and the rebound you expect there in 2023? Second, I'd really like to hear more about the marketing strategy. You've mentioned a lot about stepping up and getting consumers engaged early in the season nationwide, and how crucial that is. Have you done this before, did it work well, and what specifics can you share? Thanks.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAlright, John. This is Hagedorn. I've been — I tell folks I won't try to tackle every question, but this one's good. Let's begin with the budget we set, and I think — some might say, well, you're lowballing or something; we believe we're being fairly cautious by essentially keeping it flat, and keep in mind, lawns dropped 20% a year ago. And we attribute that almost completely to weather. California, Texas, Northeast, Midwest, which I won't rehash, it was terrible <<inaudible>>. So we're at plus 10 for lawns, zero for the rest; so we don't see it as a particularly tough target, since I think plenty of us who've spent years in this industry said it was simply a brutal weather year for us, and I believe the same holds in agriculture; so anyone paying attention, I think, recognizes we're being honest here. The early-season figures for lawn actually look quite favorable. I don't know, Mike?
Mike Lukemire
executiveRight, no. What I mean is that across the past 14 days, we've seen gains of 57% and 64% in the areas where promotions are running. It's genuinely — things are shifting.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveSo lawns have to — what I mean is, lawns really do need to perform. Plus, I think Bonnie is looking at comparable sorts of quite encouraging figures for the early part of the season. So I'd say those early-season — they're cautious figures, and I think what we've seen in this first stretch of the season looks quite strong up to now. So I'd say that, Patti, maybe you'd like to speak to — Patti is the one who oversees the brands.
Patti Ziegler
executiveMorning, everyone.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveHold on — actually, no, that won't work.
Patti Ziegler
executiveAll right. Our team, the leaders of our strategic business units, and our marketing collaborators are genuinely enthusiastic regarding this season. We're especially happy with what we've accomplished early on, which we've already observed performing nicely down in the South, where our bonus product offer is working effectively alongside a retailer-partnered initiative. We're rolling this out at the very start of the season, echoing what Jim mentioned before regarding our understanding that consumers who engage early spend a greater amount within this category. This initiative goes by the name Lawn Savings <<inaudible>>, and we're executing it jointly with our retail partners, hitting the market even before their Black Friday deals begin. So we'll keep backing this consumer, drawing them into the category sooner, and we're thrilled about what this program could achieve and the boost it will provide.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveOn top of that, the spending level is really elevated.
Matt Garth
executiveThat's right. Extremely elevated.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveSo no one's playing games at this point. My sense is that the retailers were keen to make it happen. We're eager for it to succeed as well; we're putting money behind it; we've brought in fresh talent for the regular lawns advertising, swapped out Scotty the Scotsman for a different personality, plus the major event kicking off the season. So we aren't — Jon, I believe part of what went on last year was that we kept holding off on releasing our activation dollars until the weather cooperated, and that weather simply never showed up. And eventually you reach a stage where, if nobody has made a purchase, the year is growing old and conditions are somewhat chilly and damp, and folks think, my lawn is fine as it is. There's a strong case for drawing them in sooner; so it's somewhat of a return-to-the-future strategy, yet it's extremely well coordinated and the money is being deployed very aggressively; so I'd say our confidence level is fairly high, and thus far the POS, in my view, indicates the consumer isn't dealing with any meaningful issue right now.
Jonathan Andersen
analystThanks. That's all I have to say. Appreciate it.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveThanks, Jon.
Joe Altobello
analystThanks. Hey, guys. Good morning.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveHi, Joe.
Joe Altobello
analystI suppose I also have something to ask about the American consumer, and about what retailers are holding in stock, which you mentioned. It sounds as though those inventories are somewhat bloated — how large an effect could that have on what you ship during this year?
Mike Lukemire
executiveAs far as our plan goes, my answer would be that this pump presents no issue at all; therefore what we are doing is simply examining, at our facilities, the assumption we built in that they might choose to reduce those levels somewhat more aggressively in light of POS, though we view that as a cautious assumption. So in truth, they have not said much to us about carrying a meaningful quantity of inventory.
Matt Garth
executiveRight, Joe. During my prepared comments, I noted that we began the year with low retailer inventories, and because of a solid December along with softer year-over-year POS, those inventories have risen; even so, retailer inventories remain under last year's levels.
Mike Lukemire
executiveRight, so my sense is we're sitting around 7% under where we stood at this same time a year ago.
Matt Garth
executiveYes.
Mike Lukemire
executiveSo.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAnd I'd say, Joe, from our side, the discussions we've been having—obviously Q1 went well for us, and that took a lot of effort. Luke, I believe, has made it fairly clear that regarding the sales that came through, he isn't really adjusting his load plan for the first half. So we're not treating it as incremental; I'd say this is the first time Luke has been conservative, but...
Mike Lukemire
executiveMy concern is that we might sell out of inventory, since my hunch is that it will perform well, though I can't be certain.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveJoe, that might be the main problem we've got — it's simply that we're putting in a lot of effort to hold the supply chain together.
Joe Altobello
analystAll right, that's useful. And regarding Hawthorne, three months back, the projection for that unit was around $700 million in revenue for this year. At this point, we're looking at about $550 million, so it's shifted quite substantially over the past couple of months. I suppose, first, have conditions deteriorated to that degree, or do you anticipate some kind of rebound, and second, if we assume $550 million in revenue, what does that imply for segment loss in fiscal 2023?
Chris Hagedorn
executiveHey, Joe, this is Chris. I'll handle the first portion and let Matt address the second. Yeah, it's really — your second assumption there is essentially that we had built an expectation of some market recovery in the earlier part of this year into our plan going in. We still anticipate seeing some recovery in the marketplace, but clearly, it didn't come about this quarter in the way we had been hoping. Now, I mean, I think it's worth pointing out, I received a text message from a competitor of ours <<inaudible>> yesterday, and this was — this is someone who — he was the President and CEO of General Hydroponics when we acquired that business, and someone we've remained close with over the years and very connected to the industry. He reached out to me and prompt yesterday and said, hey, been thinking about you, just want to let you know I feel the wins at my back out here in California for the first time in a long time. So we're beginning to hear some rumblings and see some signs, I think, that the industry is starting to gain traction, but obviously, given the way the last year plus has gone, we're going to wait before we start counting our checks. But I'll let Matt take the second part.
Matt Garth
executiveAnd from a profit standpoint, we didn't actually anticipate a big lift or extra EBITDA for our full-year forecast stemming from Hawthorne. As you'll recall, starting from our position a year ago, the work under Project Springboard to bring the cost base in line with our demand and revenue situation was expected to deliver a modestly positive EBITDA contribution. But now, given this reduction in top-line revenue, that figure slips somewhat, sitting near breakeven plus 5, so we'll manage our way through it as the year unfolds. And as Chris mentioned, any bright spots that exist will help offset any additional downside that might arise. So we essentially took the middle path on that 20% to 25% outlook, following a 31% decline in the first quarter, and we're again projecting increases for the remaining quarters of the year, which is some encouraging news we're seeing.
Joe Altobello
analystAll right, that's great. Thanks, everyone.
Chris Carey
analystHello, and good morning.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveHey there.
Chris Carey
analystI simply wanted to get some confirmation regarding the U.S. consumer. So volume shipped was level during the first six months of the year. To put a fine point on it, that would suggest shipments rising in Q2, and given what's expected for POS across the entire year, plainly, shipments will run underneath that. Are you indicating that organic sales growth for the U.S. consumer business ought to be higher by a high-single-digit rate in 2025, and perhaps shipments aren't lower by all that much, and under that kind of result, would you anticipate margins being able to widen again in the U.S. consumer business, or are the commodity effect and the other factors you're observing still fading away?
Matt Garth
executiveAllow me to clear up one point there. What we're projecting relates to the topline. Looking at it year-over-year, you're in fact witnessing total volumes declining, as we noted during last quarter's call, yet we are passing the pricing along. The pricing we've implemented is flowing through, and that shows up in the press release, laid out quite clearly. So, revenue will be marginally higher during the first six months. Once more, considering that the initial quarter's results exceeded our expectations and Jim addressed it, we likely shifted roughly $8 million to $10 million out of Q2 and into Q1. Jim likewise mentioned a moment ago that our forecast is to maintain that as we head into the second quarter. So that confirms a genuinely robust first half. Yet, once more, volumes down somewhat really, which means shipments, though that pricing is coming through. Regarding POS, you're entirely correct, and I'll address it in two parts. First, what has been shown and how it's performing, and you heard about that from Texas and from Florida, with the early spring regions of the country doing well and displaying encouraging signals of consumer engagement; that points toward where we are positioned for later in the season here in the Northeast and other sections of the country as temperatures begin to rise. Once more, still anticipating a POS that will be down somewhat, but once more, pricing extremely robust, and as Mike said a moment ago, if the consumer shows up at a solid level, keep in mind that we've adjusted our operations, we're manufacturing at a reduced level right now to assist us from a cash standpoint, and so we'll coordinate very closely with our customers to make sure they've got the product they require if POS arrives stronger.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveWell, this is Jim speaking. From where I sit — and I can't speak for Mike on this — I'd say putting our 2023 forecast together was a real struggle, and Dave was right there with us through a lot of it. What Mike and I did was essentially enter a zero, and that isn't because we believe there's anything wrong with the consumer; we simply preferred a cautious figure, and then a plus 10 on lawns following a minus 20, which in our view stemmed from weather and also struck us as both prudent and secure. So our aim was really to construct revenue figures that were — that were on the safe side, so personally I wouldn't take much away from that. My sense is that by the next call, we'll have a far clearer picture of how the consumer is holding up.
Mike Lukemire
executiveYeah
Jim Hagedorn
executiveStill, I wouldn't read too much exactness into the guidance we're giving. Inside the company, those talks got pretty fierce about how much we should promise and how to avoid ending up on the wrong side of things. So the flat figure came about for no reason beyond wanting to state a number we felt sure about, given what we've just been through in what we see as a truly lousy prior year.
Chris Carey
analystYeah. That makes — so…
Mike Lukemire
executiveYeah.
Chris Carey
analyst…just so I understand, when you say flat, you're talking about our organic volume shipments for the first half — you expect those to be flat, right? Sorry, I only wanted to make sure. I didn't mean to cut you off.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveNo. No; that's fine. You're the person asking the questions, and we're here to give you answers.
Matt Garth
executiveSo across every category, volumes will rise a little during the first half. But regarding, I suppose, the outlook I provided, Chris, to put a fine point on it, that somewhat greater figure versus a year earlier for the first half applies to the topline.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveGreat. Somebody wants to say, say it. The people here are all motioning.
Matt Garth
executiveWe are good.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveOkay.
Chris Carey
analystAll right. All right. Then, only as a follow-up, regarding the Hawthorne segment, correct? So this trajectory toward better profit by the time the year ends — so are you indicating that you anticipate that in fiscal Q4 the segment profit ought to basically be zero, meaning you're operating at neutral, and from now until that point, you're operating at negative; so, once more, the thought is to reach flat by the time the year ends, and then just on that, do you hold any perspective regarding U.S. consumer margin, the capacity to be higher or lower just based on the earlier question? So that's all from me.
Matt Garth
executiveYeah. I believe that's, clearly, you're exiting the first quarter and you're observing the segment profitability in Hawthorn. So, yes, the trajectory as we progress through the year is going to improve and I believe we're going to get one more opportunity at that matter here in the second quarter as we begin to observe a bit of seasonal uptick; so we'll keep you informed about what's occurring in Hawthorne the next time we talk and the full year outlook there, but yes, gradually getting better as we work our way through the quarter. Regarding a U.S. consumer margin standpoint, you've observed a great deal actually occur in terms of what we had anticipated, I believe, what we had initially conveyed and compared with last year, what we managed to do. The team's performance, the costs that have been removed from the business, the efficiencies that we're operating have placed us — and you saw it in the gross margin line too — in a solid position to start to begin to consider how you get back to those kinds of early 30s, mid-30s type margins in U.S. consumer that Mike enjoys discussing and that is going to be a mix of greater volumes emerging from the production facility. That's going to arrive with time and perhaps we can obtain some of that this year. Keep in mind, we reduced that for this year. And the other element of that is going to be what occurs on the commodity side and so monitoring that, and as I just mentioned in my prepared remarks, we have roughly 70% of our COGS already committed. So fairly good outlook for this year, but that will be assisting us in progressing back to those margins as we continue.
Mike Lukemire
executiveNope. My sense is that it will bounce back once commodity prices settle, and beyond that, we've taken a lot of expenses out too.
Chris Carey
analystYeah.
Mike Lukemire
executiveMix will always play a role in our results. With such a solid lawn season, the mix is favorable. So over time, I feel quite confident that we'll return to that level, yeah.
Chris Carey
analystAll right, I really appreciate it.
Eric Bosshard
analystHello there, good morning.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveHi, Eric.
Eric Bosshard
analystIf I could, two items. To begin with, Matt, you mentioned there’s potential for more SG&A savings as we head into 2024, and I just wanted to probe that a bit for 2024 — clearly, 2023 still has a considerable distance left to run; but when you consider how much SG&A has already been removed from the business, and this is largely on the consumer side, I’m simply attempting to gauge how much needs to be put back into the business during 2024 to take care of customers and to propel the business, or whether the cost structure and operating structure as they stand in 2023 are what can be sustained, with growth in 2024 and afterward building off that base?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveTo start things off, I'll pass it over to Garth. If you take a look at the sales force handling our in-store merchandizing, things are going well there. And if you consider what's happening with innovation in R&D, that's also in good shape. Our team is certainly smaller than it once was — although, Eric, you might remember that when we were chasing those five pillars, our biggest issue was, as you'd say, "you in what army" — we hired a ton of folks, so we've sort of scaled back. It was — I kind of thought — I believe people here are starting to feel a bit better, but there was a lot of PTSD in this place. It's been quite a ride, honestly. That said, I believe our teams are leaner now — a lot of them right here in this building, and plenty over at Hawthorne — and my sense is that's roughly the size we plan to keep. I don't see us needing to bounce back by plugging a lot of holes or by neglecting work that should get done. We've tried hard to be disciplined, directing funds only to the places they're genuinely required. Spending on marketing has risen; what we're putting into stores looks solid. All in all, our setup seems about right. I'd say we haven't yet locked in all the things we think are achievable, and that's basically the point Garth is making — you're going to see additional G&A reductions in 2024 that can be sustained. Still, I don't hear any of the teams arguing that they need significantly more headcount. If you walked down my hallway, you'd notice quite a few new faces working alongside me, so we were quite deliberate about this. The way I see it, we took great care to ensure that those who remained are individuals who believe this business can be run far more efficiently than it used to be. Honestly, that expansion was exactly what we were after. I'd say we weren't doing anything out of the ordinary — plenty of businesses are saying the same thing these days. Even so, we made a point of hiring people who are comfortable with the way things currently run around here, and those who acted like they didn't support it are no longer part of the team. So, Mike, anything you'd want to add on that?
Mike Lukemire
executiveNot at all. I'd say we're lean, or rather, this marks my 9th year serving as President and COO. When I initially stepped into the role, things were fairly lean; we put money into numerous initiatives pursuing expansion, and I believe we've since recalibrated. That said, we aren't trimming the core of sales marketing or the basics we're built on. Instead, we're simply more disciplined as we rebuild, and we continue to want that expansion, we continue to have faith in it. The path to reaching it will be far more efficient.
Eric Bosshard
analystAlright, that's useful. Now for my follow-up, Jim, you brought up the pillars. Regarding Hawthorne, I was hoping to get a clearer picture of how you see things. A quarter or two back, I believe you wrote off roughly $1 billion that had gone into that business, and a quarter into this year you cut the revenue target by 20%. So I was somewhat taken aback when you said you remain committed to the two Hawthorne pillars from 2021, given that the landscape shifted so dramatically that you ended up writing off essentially all the capital you'd placed into the business. Why stay committed to those pillars? I'm just trying to get a handle on your vision here — it sounds like it's unchanged from two years back, even though the world around it has shifted…
Jim Hagedorn
executiveNo, I wouldn't call it unchanged. I think we've been — and look, we operate our own company, so I'm not pointing fingers at anyone or playing the victim here; don't take what I'm saying the wrong way; but in a sense we bore the cost of that business. Our belief in cannabis sector growth hasn't gone away; it's a bloodbath out there. I'm not sure whether it was Forbes or Fortune, about two or three years back, that predicted it would be a bloodbath. Well, that's what happened; but we've got money in there and we examine our business quite closely. And Garth stepping in alongside Mike, Chris, and me, essentially asking, who do we want to be? That really comes down to those pillars; and I think some folks here argued we ought to simply be the finest small Scotts company possible, which means something like low single-digit growth, and I — this isn't about chasing equity value, but it essentially means. What direct-to-consumer gives us, what live goods gives us, what Hawthorne gives us is growth; and we ended up on the wrong side of that. We paid the price for it. We've absorbed the pain from it. So the real question is, do we simply throw — set it ablaze? I went through something with Smith & Hawken, when the economic crisis hit in 2008, we acquired that. I believe we thought a deal was in place with Home Depot. It fell apart in a strange, messed-up manner involving Nardelli. But Dave was CFO at the time, and he told me, look, there's no profitability forecast here, Jim, and nobody's assembling one and everyone's chipping in; and with Smith & Hawken, you've got to make a call on Smith & Hawken. He laid it right at my feet and I sort of — I — we torched that thing. We sold off the pieces at auction and it was a fairly awful experience. I regret it to this day. Smith & Hawken, or Hawthorne, isn't facing the same circumstances. You could say that approximately half of the profit at Smith & Hawken, or Hawthorne, gets burned away because we built a supply chain that was simply larger than what we obviously require at this moment. That carries value. I'll put it at over $50 million. So my sense is this operation can fairly easily return to something like a 10% EBITDA margin, and that's basically how I see the opening stakes contributing here. And I believe we'll arrive there, and I believe much of this will come about because we adjusted the size of that supply chain; it's difficult, and you think that way since there's a great deal of inventory sitting there and we must move through it, and we will. But I believe we hold the view that growth exists in that business, that it's roughly a mess you can fix. Much of this I fault myself for, tied to extremely poor public policy. I mean, simply look at New York and ask, could things possibly turn out worse than what New York is experiencing. But keep in mind, California went recreational, and across the entire country things fell 50%; so safe banking never materialized, and many things we expected to occur did not. But if you'd like me to — I do think if — since I do reflect at times and I think we presumed federal normalization would have arrived by this point. That has proven far more difficult than we anticipated. I think you look at Oklahoma and Michigan regarding issuing permits well beyond what those states require; it simply — it's quite a mess. But we simply believe that absent that, we are completely invested in this space, we are dedicated to seeing it through, and we believe it will deliver a growth rate exceeding what the consumer business can achieve, and in the end, we believe we must demonstrate growth and we can accomplish it profitably. I'm not certain — that's my perspective.
Eric Bosshard
analystNo.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveGarth, you got a different view.
Matt Garth
executiveDefinitely not. And like you mentioned, we get together as a group and review this quite often. You're here at this moment, Chris, and I believe, you're quite conscious of this, Eric. Oh, Eric, my apologies. Yes, I've been going in reverse. You've been — you know about this. The sector itself, as Jim just described, likely, not in the best spot. But, what we do and I think this isn't only me claiming it, it's everybody in the company is quite distinctive. And the offering that we have, the strategic standing that we have, the customer standing that we have all place you in a really strong spot for a sector that has a somewhat extended schedule than we anticipated; that said, you also heard Jim mention in his prepared comments that this creates some strategic choices for us, which are we believe we're in a favorable spot, because of what we deliver to the market and there are others around who might not be in that spot, but we can all gain with each other. So, just examining it from a comprehensive view, how you navigate through this market, how you fortify our position and how we build a company that on any kind of rebound is in a powerful and victorious position is what we're aiming to do.
Eric Bosshard
analystGot it. That’s a big help. Thanks.
Andrew Carter
analystHey, thanks. Morning. I’d like to ask about Hawthorne, really getting into that 31% drop. I realize Vegas is entirely incremental. I believe you mentioned sixth; so is that a sixth incremental? But could you also get into, say, Signature brands compared with non-distributed, and how much of that non-distributed, whether rational or some kind of shift in focus you’re making this year, is captured in your topline outlook for this year and also in the quarter? Thanks.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveYeah. Hi. I’ll leave that to the smart guys.
Matt Garth
executiveYes. Hi, Andrew. So this year, we're expecting a Signature-to-distributed breakout of roughly 65% on the Signature side. Lighting and new trends keep fueling that for us.
Andrew Carter
analystThe real question, though, is whether your attention is on the products in the way they're distributed — is that where the focus sits?
Chris Hagedorn
executiveYes. Andrew, this is Chris speaking. Right. What I mean is, the emphasis — and Tom can walk you through more detailed figures once more, and for sure, Aimee and Matt will handle any follow-ups. But the thinking we're shifting toward, and this truly reflects how we see the marketplace changing and, honestly, tightening during the last 12 months, is definitely to lean further into what we refer to internally as the Signature Plus model — meaning far greater concentration on the brands we own. There are certain distributed brands where we hold unique relationships — Quest dehumidifier being one example. Beyond those, additional brands and products exist that, at least right now, we regard as necessary pieces of our portfolio and our overall offering, yet they don't generate much profit for us and we don't see them as delivering strong value for us — though once again, our customers need them. So my take is that we currently sit in a transitional phase, shifting away from what was essentially a distributor operation with a modest tilt toward our Signature brands, toward something much closer to a Signature-driven offering.
Matt Garth
executiveRight. Well…
Andrew Carter
analystI suppose.
Matt Garth
executive…Andrew, our main priority is the labels that belong to us, the ones we've built, the new products we keep creating, and we also keep scrutinizing alliances available, looking at where additional important elements of this segment exist that would be worthwhile for us to remain very connected to — all with the goal of acting in the best interest of the grower.
Andrew Carter
analystUnderstood. To put it more clearly, let me rephrase what I meant: regarding that 65%-35% split, what I was really wondering is whether you anticipate the 35% portion declining substantially over the course of the year — in other words, acting as an additional drag on sales, though one that likely won't be very visible; that's the point of my question — do you think that split will shift in a meaningful way, along with any related headwind?
Chris Hagedorn
executiveHi, Andrew. For the remainder of the year, I'd expect it to stay fairly consistent — that 35% distributed ratio. Once more, I believe the movement toward Signature Plus is something we'll observe increasingly across, let's say, the coming 24 months, and our expectation is that we'll manage to swap out a substantial chunk of the distributed sales we're opting to step away from using signature sales; therefore, what we're aiming for isn't a major retreat when it comes to total topline revenue from those sales, and to repeat, that doesn't account for what we anticipate seeing regarding marketplace recovery, but rather considerably greater profitability on every dollar of sales.
Andrew Carter
analystUnderstood. That message will be relayed. Thanks very much.
Chris Hagedorn
executiveThanks to you.
Bill Chappell
analystThanks. Good morning.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveHi, Bill.
Bill Chappell
analystHi there. A handful of quick items. First, I suppose, when I look back on 1Q, I'm somewhat unclear whether that was far stronger than you had anticipated or whether it was mostly about shipment timing. You mentioned a year ago that one piece of the trouble was that retailers weren't placing orders consistent with demand, so my assumption would be that there'd be some out-of-stocks or inventory you'd needed to rebuild. And then you also noted there was a retail inventory issue; and then I believe you said a few 2Q shipments landed in 1Q. So I'm — just help me get my head around it, is this basically a solid beginning and we'll see more or less, or are you genuinely ahead of plan <<inaudible>> as you start out.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveOkay, I believe I followed you, even though it got a bit muddled there. So I’m not sure whether you’re calling from a mobile phone, Bill. My sense is the quarter turned out much stronger than our expectations. Keep in mind what we faced in December, so we were actively controlling things, and at least for me, the main focus was leverage during that period. We reached arrangements with our retail partners for a sensible first-half load; we likely ended up somewhat ahead, only slightly, but I believe we described it as $25 million better. Even so, it wasn’t easy, because we had that stretch just ahead of Christmas when temperatures dropped sharply and getting shipments out became somewhat difficult, and I believe the supply chain group did an outstanding job handling orders so they could go out. I don’t believe we have any inventory issue whatsoever at retail. And I think the Springboard effort, which involved the whole company, was outstanding, and there’s no single individual you could really credit. It was genuinely an all-company push under intense pressure to ship the orders and bring our costs down through many very difficult choices we had to make, particularly when it came to personnel. So I think we delivered a solid quarter, and for those who follow us closely, and you do, it was, in my view, much of last year felt like we’d move forward one step and then it seemed we’d go back two, with the way things kept going, and what’s great about this organization is that this is a business that when facing a challenge performs well collectively. So all of that came together by the end of the quarter into a result that exceeded what we had anticipated. We were trying to remain inside 6.25, and landing at 5.9 was a truly strong outcome for us; and many people have commented on where they expected our leverage to land. To me, getting through this is a major win. And it comes back to our team and our retailers agreeing on reasonable figures and not an oversized load, since this is a normal load for us. But what we required were commitments for Q1 and Q2 that would align with the load. Yet because our leverage was tight, it would ensure that if we could deliver on our end, we could — we would receive the inventory and have orders, and every one of our retailers was excellent at getting product in, and our team did the work. So I think it was a strong result. Mike, I’m not sure.
Mike Lukemire
executiveYeah.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveI think Luke deserves a great deal of recognition, and so do the individuals overseeing Springboard — since Springboard provides an up-close, everyday, cross-functional look at the figures, and it meant everyone needed to follow through on their commitments, with any departures having to be caught right away. In earlier times, I believe we didn't run things that way at that location, yet it was necessary given our circumstances. Beyond that, the sales and marketing group, along with the supply chain, the operational side of the company, performed really well. And Mike, you've earned enormous praise for that.
Mike Lukemire
executiveNo. And I believe that's true of the retail partners we work with too. Everyone's aim is to be set. Our spending is happening sooner. Getting off to a quick start matters to us. The store sets have to be finished. We need that inventory sitting there. Chasing inventory isn't something we're interested in, and my sense is we're currently ahead on that front. So after that, what we're looking for is the consumer takeaway.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveRight. Bill, here's something else too: when it comes to the retailers, everyone's got their eye on spring. There's this odd anxiety people have — you just have to pick up a newspaper, and honestly it seems like things are loosening up somewhat. Still, if you sit down with the merchant partners, and I imagine you do, my sense is that nobody wants to see the season skipped. So nobody's pulling back on lawn and garden — in fact that's exactly where the attention is going, and that works in our favor.
Mike Lukemire
executiveCorrect. Without a doubt.
Bill Chappell
analystAppreciate it. So then, focusing in particular on Bonnie — I realize it serves as that entry point you mentioned for drawing shoppers in. Still, my take is that, across two of the three years since you acquired it, or came to hold a majority stake in it, that operation has fallen short of what you projected…
Jim Hagedorn
executiveWell, that was…
Bill Chappell
analyst… or is this year just seeing something else happen?
Mike Lukemire
executiveSo I'd say urban vegetable did really well, actually. We moved into some flower, and that didn't work out so great — the entire market was down and we didn't execute well there. So we're putting a lot of attention on exiting that, and early signs are — I mean, you'll see us a lot more joined up with our field sales across the Northeast. But it comes down to execution and not just walking away and tossing a whole lot of plants out. So from Bonnie I'm looking for a solid year, very focused.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveOkay, Mike, I get your point, that's reasonable. Still, when you think about the past two years or so, would you say you've felt let down?
Mike Lukemire
executiveWhen it comes to our chances to expand, I've felt let down in particular; so that's where I fell short. There are simply too many types, and with a number of our expansion opportunities, the execution hasn't been very strong.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAlso, some of the blame lands on us, honestly. What goes on in that area is substantially influenced by us. A great deal of things was pushed on them by us; that isn’t to say it went against what they were looking to accomplish. Still, my view is this is a business built on enormous volume, and plenty has been picked up by us, and shifting that business has proven, in my view, more difficult; even so, my sense is the team has a grip on it, and my sense is Mike along with the crew at our partners at AFC and the folks at Bonnie, men and women alike, are fairly well organized, and they are aware…
Mike Lukemire
executiveYeah.
Jim Hagedorn
executive… they have to achieve this year.
Mike Lukemire
executiveYeah.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAt Bonnie, we attempted too many changes at once, and that proved to be excessive. Even so, that business holds a special place for me, and it serves as an entry point for us. What I mean is that it continues to deliver growth of 6% to 8%, which outpaces the U.S. consumer, and when you combine the tie-in with the execution, that creates a route toward future growth for us. So we are not abandoning it.
Mike Lukemire
executiveRight.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveWe're dialing back, I'd put it this way — we simply need to carry it out more effectively.
Bill Chappell
analystAnd then, finally, regarding Hawthorne and New York, which has come up a few times—could you just help me get a clearer picture of whether you plan to put more money into that, and what the reasoning is? You mentioned it might end up being the number two market for consumption. Some people would argue it already holds that position—it's simply an illegal one. So how does that genuinely work in your favor if Oklahoma, Michigan, and California still aren't the ones supplying it, and how does that situation actually shift and turn into an opportunity across the coming 4 years or 5 years? Thank you.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveOkay, this is — you’ve kept the largest item for the end, I believe. If folks are going to sell out of their trunks, their cars, or in bodegas, and the state won’t enforce anything, that’s a serious issue, and it’s a serious issue in Canada too. Taking an industry as large as beer and having people produce it in their backyards and sell it from car trunks — that isn’t how a market ought to launch; there’s ample precedent, Colorado being a solid illustration of a market rolled out far more deliberately. So I believe you’re right that it’s a huge market, and we trust that, beginning with the governor and the legislature, they’ll be sensible in letting those who invested money or obtained permits through the social justice route actually earn a return. I don’t see any short- or mid-term need for capital in that business. That business, I believe, is adequately capitalized. And maybe one of the few New York permits holding over $100 million in cash. So the business has capital, and abandoning it — I’m not sure what that really achieves. We don’t hold shares in RIV. We’re a creditor to RIV. And we think that marketplace is correct. I also want to tell our partners who are investors in RIV that we don’t see this merely as a loan; we see it as this market matures, and we’ve got very straightforward internal rules about this conversion. I’m not sure whether we’ve discussed it publicly, which is that being able to normalize relationships with banks — meaning plant-touching businesses can bank, and U.S. exchanges, NASDAQ or NYSE, permit companies that touch plants to list — those are really our conversion parameters. It doesn’t presume federal legalization; it presumes more or less that we can bank and have a relationship with the public exchange, and I don’t think that’s so crazy; but I think what that signals to people is, we behave like equity holders, yet we aren’t — we’re creditors to that business, the sole creditor and the most senior creditor. But the business has capital. It’s an enormous market. We aren’t pursuing multiple states down here. We essentially say we won a big state. We concentrated early on, and I think you all knew this. New Jersey or New York, one of the big states in New York, we secured that license. It would be very simple to claim you overpaid for it. I think we probably wouldn’t nod our head to that; but that’s where things stand. We've put capital into this business, and we intend to stick with it until the end. In the end, we believe it's a worthwhile endeavor. That said, we aren't obligated to commit additional funds, and we're not pursuing it so aggressively that we'd ignore the reality. In fact, things are progressing in the way we'd hoped. If New York State were to finally issue its regulations—actually paying attention to what people are saying and giving not only us but the other MSOs that have poured billions of dollars into their operations across New York some kind of benefit tied to the scale of that investment—that would certainly help. It's frustrating, yes, but still worth pursuing. And I think each time we tell ourselves that, plus the fact is we're already in. So there's really no path for us to walk away. They haven't defaulted; they have enough money to finish this, and we're going to stay the course alongside them. Chris, is there anything you'd like to add here?
Chris Hagedorn
executiveAbsolutely. Yeah, I believe you covered the majority of it. But listen, RIV — and this is a company I devote a lot of my focus to, plus I sit on its Board. RIV possesses one of the strongest, if not the single most unique, balance sheets within cannabis. Like Jim mentioned, additional funding isn't necessary for them, at minimum not for a while. And regarding New York, sure, look, at this moment, I think anybody strolling along a Manhattan street and entering a corner bodega can observe a flourishing illegal marketplace operating there. We don't anticipate that lasting across many years. Once the regulated market in that state turns into the norm, which it will, in our view RIV is positioned to truly — well, I wouldn't call it dominating the state, but to capture a disproportionate slice of the market, purely due to the assets at their disposal. So it's a thing we stay genuinely excited about even though the prior year contained some disheartening points, obviously it did, and anybody who has been part of the cannabis sector, I believe, recognizes they've gone through that; yet the dedication from our end, certainly from mine, stays quite solid, and I think the potential we've witnessed has been delayed somewhat, however the ultimate thesis still holds.
Bill Chappell
analystGreat. Thank you.
Gaurav Jain
analystHi. Good morning. I've got a few questions. First, regarding the company's leverage and the bonds — those are trading at $0.85 to the dollar, so with the $1 billion of free cash flow you'll generate in the next two years, you could literally retire about $1.2 billion of debt and speed up the deleverage. And I understand that because of higher leverage, you have restricted payment restrictions. Could that be one path to consider — perhaps repurchasing roughly $25 million of that bond each quarter on the open market? Are those the kinds of possibilities you're weighing?
Matt Garth
executiveYes. We see multiple ways to apply the free cash flow we expect to produce toward reducing our debt. You've mentioned one of them, and our process involves assessing which of our borrowings carries the steepest cost and where the best chances lie. So whenever free cash flow comes in, we'll steer it toward the debt with the highest interest rates and retire that first. Our maturity schedule is in solid shape, I'd say. The way our debt is structured works well, and the coupons on our bonds are quite favorable. So the order of priorities would probably be: handle the Term Loan A first, bring the revolver back down, and after that, consider the bonds for possible buyback chances.
Gaurav Jain
analystAlright. So suppose, during the coming two years, you produced that billion in free cash flow, EBITDA got better since input costs came down, and leverage sits nearer to 4x — what then? Would that extra free cash flow begin flowing back into cannabis investments, given that you still have faith in the long-term thesis? Are you...
Matt Garth
executiveWell, that — thanks for laying the trap. No. What we've aimed to get across to everyone on this call is that we take a disciplined stance on growth. We gauge each dollar and figure out what payback might come and what returns we anticipate. When it comes to Hawthorne, RIV, those sorts of bets we've placed and what we were just discussing with you, you heard Jim describe as non-cash. Within the cannabis sector, the businesses operating there carry extremely, extremely low valuations. Non-cash chances exist to consolidate and lay a foundation for creating value going forward. The way we prioritize free cash flow, which is what you're referring to, is this: first, make sure we put money into organic growth and the company's capabilities — those high-return, quick-payback chances that exist internally — doing so, ensuring we follow through. That amounts to $100 million of CapEx. Even so, we could likely deploy $125 million to $150 million and keep positioning this company for growth and free cash flow generation through those investments. Getting leverage back down to 4x opens the window for a balanced approach involving continued debt pay down, M&A and shareholder return activity. Keep in mind, this company's history in that 3 to 4 range is to chase shareholder friendly acquisi — activities via share repurchases, one-time dividends, those kinds of things, and that provides flexibility below 4 to start doing those again. So plenty is on the table as we generate free cash flow, deleveraging across the next two years with the $1 billion we're going to generate — that's priority one — and afterward we'll look, as we go below 4, at the more balanced approach.
Gaurav Jain
analystAlright, and a final question — I'm sorry if someone already addressed this — but U.S. consumer pricing looks really robust. So where does private label share stand at the moment? How wide are the price gaps? Is there any element that has you worried? If you wouldn't mind giving your thoughts on that?
Mike Lukemire
executiveHonestly, at this point the price gaps don't trouble us. We aren't observing any shift in share between private label and our brands — as a matter of fact, our share is growing, since shoppers generally lean toward branded products; so that's really not something that concerns us.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveLet me add my two cents here as well. I do believe the gap in price between store brands and name brands, mainly for us, ended up wider than it had been. Keep in mind, retailer agreements with us reset in price annually, and I think that let them—what I mean is, on quite a few of those store brand arrangements, we were taking a loss. I expect you'll observe a fix, since we pushed through fairly substantial price increases, as much as we could manage, and those were double-digit increases. Yet we did not lose share to store brands during the last year despite that wider gap. My guess is that gap will likely shrink. Still, I think it deserves a look, and we'll keep discussing it with you folks as we examine our pricing relative to store brands, in a sense. That said, I'd say it's a minor worry right now and likely adjusting after last year.
Mike Lukemire
executiveRight. That’s what we were observing. So things are moving the way they should. That said, together with our retail partners, we do conduct price elasticity studies and similar work to make certain of it. What I mean is, at this stage my concern tends to focus more on how the category is growing than on share — that’s always where my worry sits.
Gaurav Jain
analystSure. Thank you so much.
Mike Lukemire
executiveWelcome.
Carla Casella
analystHi. Kind of along similar lines — reaching your 4 times leverage goal by year-end while EBITDA dips a bit suggests a sizable debt reduction. Could you discuss what you anticipate on the working capital side, assuming you still expect $400 million of inventory release this year, and when that would land?
Matt Garth
executiveSure. Let me just confirm that's right. We referenced $1 billion of free cash flow produced across two years starting last Q3, I believe, and we also referenced under 4 times by the close of 2024, so not by the close of this fiscal year. Looking at it from the working capital angle, the inventory we intend to remove is $400 million. That will happen as the year progresses — clearly, at the moment we're in a somewhat filled position. We've mentioned that retailer positions sit 5% to 7% below last year and that our production is lower year-over-year. So we'll be releasing that inventory we're holding. That $400 million inventory release will help deliver a working capital benefit this year above $200 million, right, since we'll grow some sales, we'll have some AP coming through and we'll be paying, so net across all of that on working capital it's just above $200 million. What remains is cash from operations, excluding working capital, minus CapEx, to produce the rest of our free cash flow this year and next year. So viewed that way, you're roughly looking at above $300 million in free cash flow not tied to working capital, plus the working capital release.
Carla Casella
analystAll right, that's great. So then, may I pose one more question that follows up on that? You mentioned having robust liquidity, with more than $800 million at your disposal. Could you describe the amounts you drew down under the ABL as opposed to the AR facility, and was that $800 million of availability the sum of both facilities?
Matt Garth
executiveNo. That $800 million sits on our revolver. Regarding the ABL and the AR facility, you are — we didn't really move much over the — compared with last quarter. So I'd say they're roughly in the $400 million range.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveFor the season.
Matt Garth
executiveYeah; for the season.
Carla Casella
analystAll right, that's excellent. I really appreciate it.
William Reuter
analystHello there, everyone.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveHi.
William Reuter
analystWhen it comes to your — I'm attempting to consider elasticity; you mentioned that you folks have carried out some studies and collaborated with your retail partners, and I realize this differs depending on the product. But is there some method for us to consider how much more your prices are this year compared with last year?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveYeah. What I'd say is, we implemented pricing, I don't know, August, I believe?
Matt Garth
executiveCorrect.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveMy guess is that came out to an average of 8, or roughly that. I’m not certain of the exact figure.
Matt Garth
executiveYeah.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveSo my guess is that's likely what you'll observe, which is that pricing is going to appear; keep in mind, we've got the Real Mondo promotion happening early in the season. So probably what you'll notice is reduced retail margins during that early part of the season, especially when it comes to lawns, since we push really hard on promotions together with the retailers. That said, I think in general, what you'd be looking at is retail up 5% to 10% versus the same time last year, roughly along those lines; that's how I'd put it — there you go.
William Reuter
analystAll right.
Matt Garth
executiveThat precise figure isn't something I have.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveYeah. But I think it’s — remember, we sell the retailers set their pricing.
Matt Garth
executiveYeah.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveEven so, some portion of that pricing—or possibly the whole amount—will be handed along. Therefore, my expectation is that you'll see an increase of 5% to 10% relative to a year ago.
Matt Garth
executiveYeah. I mean I am sitting across from Joanna Mefford, who’s the CFO.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveOh! There you go. You got it.
Matt Garth
executiveShe's described it before through the lens of price elasticity, and that's partly why we're saying POS is flat across all categories, with basically just seed and fert up 10% — it comes down to that price elasticity, correct? So when prices go up, some of that gets offset by lower volumes coming through; so on a net-net basis, that's the force pushing POS in that direction.
William Reuter
analystGreat. Then just a single follow-up. During some of the prepared remarks, you mentioned there's risk for this year. Right after that, you brought up consumer engagement. Prices are locked in on 70% of your products. Are there any other significant risks that I didn't bring up that you folks were considering for this year?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveNo. What I'd say is — the biggest thing is always the consumer, and perhaps add weather to that, since that's likely the largest individual factor affecting the consumer; but I think given the economy and the general health of the consumer, the effort we've put in during the first half is the effort we're all familiar with. We develop programs alongside our retailers. We bring product in, stock the shelves, merchandise it. Ultimately, it all depends on the consumer turning out, and that, naturally, is the risk that I believe everyone in the consumer business is watching. Again, I think our sales figure is fairly conservative — flat to what has to be the worst year ever, recovering half of what we lost in lawns last year. Once more, we believe that was largely weather. And then, I'd add, Hawthorne, just beginning to produce numbers is — I'd consider those the two risks, and we're addressing much of that risk. When we say we can exceed $185 million, it's — we have cushion to cover if needed. On the upside, which people are beginning to feel somewhat optimistic about, especially regarding the consumer, is how much of that money can be put back into consumer activation. Keep in mind, it's already increased, but I think Patti's expectation on the brand side is that, if they outperform early season, there's additional money to keep driving activation. So I think the main risk is the consumer turning out and Hawthorne. Springboard savings are ahead of plan, and they will stay ahead of plan. And that provides us room to cover, and I think that addresses the question, I think.
William Reuter
analystThat covers everything I had. Thanks.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveThanks.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveThank you all.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.