The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company (SMG) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
May 3, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Aimee DeLuca
executiveThanks, and good morning to everyone. I'd like to welcome all of you to the Scotts Miracle-Gro Q2 earnings conference call. Here with me this morning are our Chairman and CEO, Jim Hagedorn; our President and Chief Operating Officer, Mike Lukemire; Matt Garth, who serves as our Chief Financial Officer; and Chris Hagedorn, Group President of Hawthorne. Shortly, Jim, Mike, and Matt will deliver some prepared remarks, after which we'll take your questions. As is our custom, we anticipate making forward-looking statements, and I want to warn all of you that what actually happens could wind up materially different from what we discuss today. I'd ask you to look at our Form 10-K on file with the Securities and Exchange Commission so you can get acquainted with the complete set of risk factors that might affect our results. I've already got time lined up with a number of you following this call to address anything left unclear. If anyone else wants to talk further, you're welcome to reach me directly at 937 to 578 to 5621. We'll try to arrange some time as fast as we can. One more thing — please be aware that we are recording today's call, and a version of it will be archived on our website at investor.scotts.com. So with all that said, let's begin. I'll hand things over to Jim Hagedorn. Jim?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAppreciate that, Amy. Morning, everybody. There's a lot on the agenda, and if I had to boil it all down to one overarching idea, here's how I'd put it: what a year it's been. Even with all the difficulty, we've come out stronger, and we got there without putting our shareholders through dilution. Given our starting point, we've moved the needle on a number of key fronts in a remarkably brief window. That's the path we see carrying on through fiscal 2023 and fiscal 2024. The opening six months of fiscal 2023 demonstrate just how strong the franchise is in our core business. It throws off dependable cash, which gives us what we need to cut debt in a meaningful way, lift cash flow, and put money into growth. Roughly twelve months back, our free cash flow stood at -$1.2 billion; we posted sales shortfalls in consumer and in Hawthorne. Our inventory sat far above what we required. Input costs kept climbing while margin kept shrinking. Had we not acted right away, we were almost certain to breach our bank covenants. That period was stressful and harsh, yet our associates rose to the occasion. Not once did they falter or lose their bearings. They remained committed and stayed positive. They've carried out our plans with toughness and resolve; that's what we and our people excel at. At present, free cash flow is positive, having improved by close to $600 million across our first half. We're holding to our guidance of $1 billion in free cash flow generated through fiscal 2024. We're operating inside our credit facility covenants. Going forward, I don't anticipate any leverage compliance problems, since we see the low 5 x range as we close out the fiscal year. Let me say again that Mike Lukemire and I are striving to deliver something even stronger within that window. Input costs are getting better as well. Although we anticipate commodity costs rising by nearly $100 million versus fiscal 2022, that figure is roughly 20% below what we had modeled as recently as the close of Q1; these gains won't appear in margin rate until we sell through the inventory we bought at higher prices. We anticipate our gross margin rate dipping a bit under last year's level before we see more meaningful margin recovery in fiscal 2024. Across the first six months, SG&A came down by $44 million, driven by the cost cutting and efficiency gains from Project Springboard, which keeps surpassing expectations. Our Springboard target for annual savings was $185 million by the end of fiscal 2024. We're already three-fourths of the way there, and once this fiscal year wraps up, we expect to top $200 million in yearly savings. We'll get there while still funding the marketing and R&D efforts that matter most. Our efficiency push has reached Hawthorne too, where we've sharply trimmed its distribution footprint and its brands. All told, we've burned off more than $400 million in inventory. We're now entering the transition phase of our recovery. We're bringing things into balance and getting close to that point of inflection where we can move away from running the business under serious constraints and toward having somewhat more room to maneuver. In the end, that gives us more flexibility to fuel growth and create long-term value for shareholders. When it comes to creating value, Mike Lutkemeyer, Matt Garth, and I have settled on four financial goals: bringing leverage down to 3.5 x or below, delivering sales growth of GDP plus 100 basis points, lifting total company gross margin to 30% or higher, and generating free cash flow of $300 million or more each year. We'll also keep putting money into innovation, marketing, and incremental growth both inside and beyond our core business. That spans everything from alternative landscapes and natural and organic products to live goods. Plus strategic investments in Hawthorne. To make sure we rank initiatives by priority and pursue them in a coordinated, measured way, Matt is heading up a new strategy team that reports to me and will collaborate closely with our business units, brands, management team, and the board. Now that you have a feel for where we stand in our transformation, let's look back at the first half. Q2 was the quarter our U.S. consumer business needed, with sales matching last year's record Q2 . In March, we shipped more than in any other month ever. Six months in, we're level with the strong U.S. consumer sales from the same stretch a year ago. Even with worries about overall consumer spending, our retail partners get how important lawn and garden is, even when the economy is uncertain. History tells us the consumer keeps coming back for our category. Our shelf share makes clear we're the market leader. Our collaboration with retailers has never been tighter. We've built joint promotional campaigns and supported them with careful planning and aggressive early season execution. Our working media budget is 23% higher than a year ago. The Q2 work produced early season POS lifts in warm weather markets and product promotion attachment rates above historic trends. Where weather cooperates and promotions are running, consumers turn out, often in larger numbers. Key early markets such as Texas and Florida had a rough time last year; in Q2, we posted significant POS lifts. Bonus S rose almost 40% in Texas, while branded fertilizers were +17% in Florida. All told, Q2 was a strong quarter for our core business. Q3 has started well; lately, weather has been opening up in key markets, and with well-timed promotions alongside our retailers, we're seeing POS gains. In mid-April, we hit an all-time record POS week with our big three customers at $198 million, beating our prior record of $193 million in 2021 and surpassing our 2022 peak week by more than $30 million. Branded lawn fertilizer units across key retailers stayed positive through April, up 2%, and we're gaining share. In growing media, the signals are strong. Through April, our Mulch units have risen 10%, while during that identical stretch Miracle-Gro Garden Soil units climbed 21%. When it comes to non-selective and selective weed control, nobody has caught us, and we've picked up share at important retailers; Roundup is up 10% across the Northeast and Midwest, and the Dual Action formula, our new innovation launch, is beating what we expected. POS for it has passed $10 million, and it has opened up additional listings at a greater number of retailers. Reviews from consumers put it at the top of the category. So here's my reasoning for not being concerned about early-season weather. You're going to get peaks and valleys. Only in the past few weeks, we enjoyed terrific conditions across the Northeast and Midwest, and then cold and rain arrived. Shoppers go along with those peaks and valleys. Take California. During Q2, while heavy rains ruled, branded fertilizer POS came in at -8% versus the prior year. Better conditions have turned into an ally for us. Over the most recent four weeks, branded fertilizer POS reached +60% in California. California ended up as the number 1 volume state for Roundup in April, at +67%. As May and June arrive, with promotional activity building momentum, I anticipate this same pattern emerging in additional regions. Most of our media and promotional dollars still lie in front of us, and we will move that spending toward wherever it delivers the greatest return. Going forward, the weather picture looks good. Three years of La Niña brought severe weather swings, and now an El Niño is taking over that aligns better with historical norms. Temperatures and precipitation in May appear fairly typical. June projections follow a comparable path, which suggests we can stretch the peak lawn and garden season further into summer. These anticipated weather patterns resemble 2018, a year when we crushed POS throughout the summer. I'm gonna ask Mike Lukemire to jump in here with his thoughts.
Mike Lukemire
executiveAppreciate that, Jim. Momentum is on our side, and you can see it reflected in the results. Demand exists in regions where the weather has only just begun to turn. Retailers are fully committed and our team keeps raising its game, which is why the plan is delivering. Jim touched on how we've become flatter and leaner. We're fortunate to have tremendous talent accomplishing more with fewer resources. Our emerging leaders bring a now is now mindset along with a contagious energy for chasing opportunities. I consistently emphasize how vital it is to operate as a single team united around one objective: delivering the year. Internally, I'm watching us collaborate in a far more integrated fashion. That carries over into our retail partnerships as well. Alignment across every team has simply never been stronger. Stores are getting loaded up while we engage consumers aggressively. With labor shortages hitting lawn and garden centers, our field sales staff are stepping in to close those gaps. Credit for this belongs to Chief Marketing Officer Patti Ziegler, Head of Tech and Ops Dave Swihart, and Head of Sales Josh Meihls. Getting out early lifted foot traffic, and that lined up with regional pushes behind fertilizer and seed. On top of that we ran Scotts 4 Scotts plus the Day Lawn Saving national campaign. In areas with favorable weather, these drove POS lifts. Where conditions haven't turned yet, we still saw some early consumer takeaway. The Midwest and Northeast are primed, and California is heating up. The remaining critical element is shared investment and fine-tuning what we do alongside retailers. Nobody is stepping on anyone else's toes; during April, retailers launched spring events featuring joint advertising and promotions, and those promotions are a massive motivator for consumers. We intend to pour even more fuel on the flames. A substantial portion of our promotional and advertising push is still ahead. Additional events and campaigns are on the way. Stretching into Miracle-Gro and Roundup, there's a fresh campaign aimed at the newbie gardener titled All You Need to Grow, and it's part of the strongest gardens plan we've had in years. Roundup Dual Action gets backing from the biggest campaign in Roundup's history. Let me remind everyone: this isn't a sprint, it's a marathon. We'll get the most out of the season, we'll shift media and promotional dollars wherever needed, and we'll stretch the season further into the summer. That's clear to everyone. Which explains why no one is even contemplating pulling back. Everything remains ahead of us. When we commit fully to our activities, good things happen. I couldn't be more bullish about this season. Over to you, Jim.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAppreciate that, Luke. To continue with the marathon comparison you raised, I'd say our pacing has served us well. Our position is one we feel good about, and the path in front of us looks clear. When it comes to Hawthorne, though, our perspective is quite different. We're moving decisively to bring Hawthorne in line with what the cannabis market actually looks like today. A growing divide has emerged across the cannabis sector, splitting it into haves and have-nots. That may sound brutal, yet it isn't purely negative. Throughout the cannabis sector, plenty of people are achieving major wins. They're bringing in new technologies, more sophisticated cultivation methods, and broader product lines. A number of these are legacy operators; they turn out premium products and command per-pound prices above what they earned several years back; they sit at the core of the cannabis industry. This came through clearly at a summit we recently hosted alongside top stakeholders in cannabis. We assembled cultivators, vendors, and hydro shops to evaluate the industry's present state and its future direction. What we came away with is that the leaders in this space are seeking solutions and partners who can support their growth and scaling. We possess the capability to meet that demand. The cost and quality edge they require to succeed is something we're aligned with. Our commitment is to be the sole supply-side partner that creates and provides competitive solutions supporting their growth. In that spirit, we've reorganized our product line down to the 58 brands that matter most for profitability and importance to these participants, forming our Hawthorne Signature Plus portfolio. Innovation from our R&D is safeguarding the industry's long-term health. Studies conducted across numerous controlled environment facilities demonstrate what our LED fixtures, nutrients, and genetics can deliver. So far, we hold nine utility patents spanning electrical, thermal, and optics. Consider the Gavita Pro RS 2400e LED, a product capable of transforming things for cultivators. It increases yields by up to 50% compared with conventional HPS technologies, all while cutting energy inputs and allowing quicker crop cycles. Agreement also emerged at the summit that consolidation cannot be avoided. A brutal shakeout is taking place, and our expectation is that it will leave the top 25% even more dominant. Hawthorne holds a unique position to prosper; opportunity is ripe, which is why Hawthorne seeks involvement in innovative, value-creating, non-cash transactions that expand its scale and capabilities. Doing nothing means falling behind. I also want to address the industry's difficulties, which stem mainly from two sources. The first involves growth-related struggles that consolidation will resolve. The second is market volatility driven by government legislators and regulators. From the failure to pass the Federal SAFE Banking Act or 280E tax reform to the well-documented regulatory missteps in states such as New York, negative effects have hit the industry at multiple levels. We must keep in mind that tax revenue, job creation, and other economic gains hang in the balance here. Governors, legislators, and regulators must step up with proactive measures to steady this industry, and they should go further by refusing to hand out cannabis licenses beyond what people in their states can actually use. This has been a major problem. Excess supply brought about by bureaucracy and poor planning has damaged those who put in hard work and heavy investment to build a healthy, well-functioning industry that serves everyone and isn't vulnerable to wild swings that destroy legitimate growth. At the regulatory and political levels, Hawthorne is very active, pushing for policy and legislative change; that's one more way we bring important value to this industry. We're out in front, and my hope is that we start to see meaningful progress across many of these areas over the next year. Our position is enviable, since nobody else in this space is doing what we do. Let me close with this. Thinking back on my almost 30 years with Scotts Miracle-Gro, this has easily been the toughest stretch I've been through. In terms of challenge and difficulty, it was far harder than COVID. The heaviest lifting and the most extreme sacrifices are behind us, but more remains to be done. Our team is exceptional, a strong mix of deeply experienced people and next generation talent. It's a smaller team, but more empowered. Even as we sharpen our focus on future innovation and growth, developing people is a priority at every level. The recent arrival of executive and senior leaders shows our dedication to succession planning. We're making a strong team even stronger. I'm grateful to our associates, our board of directors, our retail partners, our banks, and our shareholders. Your support has meant the world to me. Every day, Scotts Miracle-Gro makes a difference in people's lives, That's a responsibility, together with the one we have to our shareholders and associates, that drives all of us. Thank you. I'll hand the call to Matt to walk through the financials.
Matt Garth
executiveThanks, Jim, and hi, everybody. We feel really good about how we closed out the first half of the year, and about the early spring consumer engagement we're seeing so far. As previously announced, net leverage finished the quarter at 6 x against a covenant maximum of 6.5 x. Springboard remains on track to deliver more than $200 million in run rate savings by the close of the fiscal year. Consumers clearly are engaged and taking part in lawn and garden. Where weather has cooperated, engagement is strong, and as we anticipated, consumers are responding to the promotions offering them the greatest value. Shifting to Hawthorne, the cannabis industry's state remains volatile, and our recent restructuring there reflects stronger actions to improve profitability more quickly. Now let's go through the quarter in more detail. Beginning with net sales for the U.S. consumer business, Q2 sales reached $1.36 billion, only 2% below our prior year record. First half sales exceeded last year and came to nearly $1.73 billion. Our team has done an excellent job executing the first half load and plan alongside our retail partners. These results reflect their efforts on behalf of SMG in a difficult environment. Pricing of almost 10% year-to-date more than offset lower shipment volumes. Keep in mind those lower shipment volumes tie to our expectation for reduced retail inventory levels, which are down 6% in units against the prior year. As mentioned earlier, the season began soft because of extreme weather patterns that hit California. Still, we're encouraged by the strong POS through April. Consumers are price-sensitive and seeking value, while staying loyal to our trusted, high-quality brands. So far, we haven't seen meaningful trade down to private label, and we're seeing strong POS lifts from our promotions and media campaigns, particularly in branded fertilizers and growing media. To support these trends and keep driving profitable volume, our media and promotional plans this year will extend through the fall. That's different from last year, when we made limited investments in the back half of the season. As of today, POS units are essentially flat and dollars are up mid-single digits at our largest retailers. Product mix currently favors growing media, and we now expect that trend to persist through the full year. Within the lawns category, overall volume is down mid to high single digits through April. Our higher margin branded fertilizers, including Scotts Turf Builder Triple Action and Bonus S, are currently positive in units at key retailers and beating lower margin private label fertilizers. In categories beyond lawns and growing media, we continue to trend toward flat units versus prior year. At Hawthorne, the top line remains challenged amid continued market oversupply, limited and costly access to capital and an uncertain regulatory environment. For the segment, Q2 revenue came in at $93 million, while first-half sales reached $224 million. Those figures represent declines of 54% and 43%, respectively, compared with the equivalent periods a year ago. The shift was driven by North America Lighting and Growing Environment, since big-ticket durable purchases kept falling faster than replenishment of consumables. On a year-over-year basis, Lighting and Growing Environment together dropped 66% for the quarter and 53% for the first half. When hardware is included, North America Durables net sales accounted for 50% of total Hawthorne net sales during the quarter, compared with 56% in the same quarter last year. We continue to anticipate improvement in the back half of the year, when the outdoor growing season accelerates and our ProHort lighting business turns a strong pipeline of prospects into orders. Because market conditions remain broadly weak, daily sales rates have not yet recovered from where they stood in the first half, and that situation could continue. Our priority is still getting back to run rate profitability by the end of the year, and that goal has not changed. Roughly half of the savings from Springboard come from Hawthorne, and the brand and category mix changes Jim mentioned will have a favorable effect on gross margin rates once overall volume comes back; that said, although Hawthorne recorded a significant reduction in warehousing costs during the first half, the drop in volume, combined with higher material and freight costs, has more than offset year-to-date pricing actions, pushing the segment's gross margin rate down. As the press release noted, Hawthorne divested its Hurricane branded fans business, a move that helps speed up distribution cost savings through warehouse closures in Washington, California, Oregon, and New Jersey. In connection with this restructuring, Hawthorne recorded total GAAP charges of $141 million before income taxes, with $119 million of that amount hitting gross margin; these charges are excluded from non-GAAP income for the quarter. Now let's examine gross margin and cost of goods for the total company more closely. The adjusted gross margin rate fell 70 basis points for both the quarter and the first half, yielding rates of 34.7% and 31%, respectively. During the first half, pricing net of trade contributed nearly 800 basis points to the year-to-date gross margin, which more than offset higher material costs. That gain was insufficient to also fully offset higher conversion costs and fixed cost deleverage, driven mainly by the sharp volume declines at Hawthorne and lower production volumes in our U.S. consumer business. Since more than 85% of our COGS is now locked, we have a reasonable line of sight to our full year costs. Apart from resins, prices for most of our major raw materials are coming down. Thanks to our hedging program and remaining high cost inventory, we expect these improvements to begin showing up in the second half of 2024. As we look at the rest of the year, margins will face slight pressure from our revised mix expectations and additional trade investments. The net cost of the pricing and mix changes will be largely offset by continued strong productivity gains and moderating material costs. On the whole, for fiscal 2023, we continue to anticipate that gross margin rate for the entire company will rise close to 100 basis points. When we look at fiscal 2024 and afterward, we see plenty of room to enhance gross margins via recovery in volume and mix, moderation in commodity costs, plus our warehouse restructuring and other cost add initiatives. We keep demonstrating advancement on the SG&A line while not giving up our aggressive media plans for the year. As a matter of fact, working media spend should increase 23% versus the prior year. Measured as a share of sales, SG&A has fallen to 15.3% this year from 16% in the first half of last year, which reflects the considerable progress we have made from Project Springboard. We anticipate holding onto these savings going forward, producing SG&A of between 15% and 16% of net sales for the full year. I'll point out a few additional expected adjustments to our guidance.
Matt Garth
executiveOur outlook for the whole year still has us energized, and we're pleased with how well cost containment has gone to this point in the year. That said, the gross margin rate pressure we're seeing in the near term, along with the challenges at Hawthorne, together push us to lower our guidance for full year operating income to a decline in the mid-single digit percentage range, and our guidance for full year Adjusted EBITDA to a decline in the low single digits percentage range, both measured against fiscal 2022. With this updated EBITDA guidance, we stay well inside our net leverage covenant for the rest of the year, and the team will work hard to reach the target Jim and Mike have set of below 5 x. To close out the review, I'll offer a few remarks regarding taxes, interest expense, and the balance sheet. Through the Q2, our adjusted tax rate came in at 26.7%, compared with 21.7% through the Q2 of last year, mostly because of a one-time benefit in fiscal 2022 tied to the vesting and exercise of certain long-term executive compensation. On top of that, we anticipate our tax rate landing somewhere in the range of 27 to 28% for the full year. Interest expense for the quarter rose $20 million, or 71%, against prior year, and our expectation for full year interest expense is unchanged, at an increase of $60 million. Higher average borrowing rates of 5.3%, up nearly 2 percentage points from a year ago, were the primary driver of that increase, mainly because of higher underlying SOFR. Thanks to a mix of long-term fixed rate senior notes and interest rate swap arrangements, 61% of our debt carried fixed borrowing rates as of the quarter's end. Turning to the balance sheet, we're making solid progress bringing our inventory balances down. We've reduced production volumes and are selling through inventory that carries a higher cost. At the close of the quarter, inventory stood $467 million below where it was at the same point last year. Although the better inventory position will generate substantial free cash flow, the net change in total working capital, once offsets in accounts payable and other areas are included, should bring roughly $200 million of favorability in each of fiscal 2023 and fiscal 2024. Along with about $300 million in operating cash flow annually, we remain on track to deliver the $1 billion in free cash flow over two years that we're targeting. As I said last quarter, our approach to capital allocation will stay tightly disciplined; we're funding our quarterly dividend, and whatever free cash flow remains will go toward paying down debt. Let me close the financial overview with this. Over 55% of our expected POS is still ahead of us. It remains early. By mid-June, we'll have a much clearer picture of how the season is unfolding, and at that point we'll share an update on our progress. One last thing: I'm very excited to work alongside Jim to rebuild SMG's strategy team and to contribute in a meaningful way to long-term planning and value creation for our stakeholders. The group is already taking a hard look at the non-cash possibilities for Hawthorne that Jim brought up, and we're also updating our longer range plans so we can safeguard and grow the core lawn and garden business. At this point I'll hand things back to Jim.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveThanks, Matt. Latifa, we could go to the Q&A session now; that'd be great.
Matt Garth
executiveJust a quick note — if you'd like to ask something, press star one one on your phone. To repeat, that's star one one on your telephone if you want to pose a question. Kindly hold on while we put together the Q&A roster.
Chris Carey
analystHi. Good morning.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveHi, Chris.
Chris Carey
analystCould you perhaps just put into context the reason guidance got taken down? Gross margins look like they're holding up. POS has been running level so far this year in U.S. consumer, and that actually strikes me as a noticeably stronger result than what seemed likely only a month back. U.S. consumer margins landed, as you know, pretty robust, with gross margin exceeding what was delivered. Could you just lay out how your thinking has shifted for the Garden business versus Hawthorne? At first glance, it does feel like Hawthorne is the main thing that moved here, and you simply aren't prepared yet to say the Garden business will make up for Hawthorne, since there's still plenty of POS left in front of us. Maybe I'm misreading that whole picture. And if you could just weigh in on how, in your view, retailer inventories stand right now at this stage of the year compared with what you'd expected. Thanks.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveI realize Garth wants to take this one first, but I'm going to jump in ahead of him. Look, I have to admit that when I arrived this morning and spoke with Matt, I told him, "You know, I ought to have rung you up last night and yanked that release." Because I believe Amy and Matt are, you know, attempting to keep expectations in some sort of balance coming out of the call. I'll credit them for doing that. I realize it serves the broader good. But I, you know, felt somewhat the way you're describing now, yesterday, as the press release was circulating for sign-offs, and my quotes were getting my approval. I think your read is correct that the one big adverse item here is simply Hawthorne. I wouldn't call it an enormous adverse item, and we are, I'd say, doing more than offsetting it with consumer. I think what's happening is Matt and Amy attempting to manage expectations. There is adverse sentiment around Hawthorne, and I believe that's essentially revenue-driven. Let's return to consumer. I think our feelings about consumer are genuinely excellent. You know, my take is, you know, get ready for a beatdown. You know, we enjoyed something like 1.5 solid weeks in April, and those figures were genuinely astonishing. You know, if you check the forecast, for instance for this coming weekend, it's precisely what's required at precisely the correct moment. We've got tremendous ammo, you know, heading into this fight on the marketing and promotional front. The retailers are locked and loaded. So are we. You know, I anticipate. You know, I believe Matt and Amy are probably going out, you know, a month from today. You know, we'll need to work out how they'll communicate a sort of market update to all of you, but we intend to do it somehow, I'm not sure that's finalized yet, because I think folks won't be attending that usual conference where we present in roughly a month, simply because folks will be out of town. What I anticipate is some genuinely fascinating data. You know, when you consider what's sort of going on, think about California and Texas, you know, Florida. The figures I handed to you folks today, those are genuinely excellent. You know, much of what occurred is that we never got a genuine spring. It never turned decent. For those of you located on the East Coast, you'll recall that a year ago, just the weather, no kidding, really just stunk. We never truly got a Midwest and Northeast season until, you know, after the Fourth of July. Texas was extremely dry, California, extremely dry. I'm referring to enormous states being down something like 30%. When you examine the data, I mean, the rain in California has seriously been our friend, all right? I mean, not only wonderful for fertilizers, but wonderful for herbicides since people wound up with plenty of weeds. You know, you look at particular markets such as Arizona, they're simply huge weed markets. You know, since people have these desert gardens, and they wish to keep weeds away. They've always been significant Roundup markets, but the Roundup figures are likewise genuinely astonishing. You look at, say, the lawn fertilizer figures for Texas, just really favorable. Same for Florida. You know, I think we've gotten a genuinely strong start to the season, a genuinely strong integrated program. Mike mentioned it during his remarks, but Mike's team on consumer has simply crushed it. The first half was genuinely, genuinely critical for us to steer clear of, you know, coven and hell. We didn't anticipate, you know, beyond what we'd agreed upon with the retailers. All we required from the retailers was to get the load in that we'd pre-agreed to get done, and it isn't excessive in units. We got that done. There was considerable concern, I think, on Matt's team, you know, about whether we could get it done as we were sort of staring at the final weeks of the quarter. People pulled it off, and they couldn't have pulled it off absent the effort Patty and the marketing team put in to get the retailers into the promotional plans. The first half genuinely came together well, and I'd say the season's, the season thus far where weather has been our friend, which let's just discuss southern markets, California has been genuinely good. Now we've got weather that's our friend in the Midwest and Northeast, which is like this coming weekend, and the forecast on the tool I rely on just carries us out looking warm and sort of normal precip for the Midwest and Northeast across the whole month. I feel genuinely good about it. The retail inventories, I believe that was another piece of your question, I believe are sensible. I wouldn't over-interpret sort of unit volume at retail being down. I think that's more a matter of just an insane quantity of units that occur in sort of soils. They're just arriving sort of at the proper moment. If you look at sort of major promotional events that occur with the retailers that push inventory into the store, it's just difficult to examine it. I think, you know, what I, Mike, what I'd say is the consumer market is roughly where it ought to be. I also want to thank our retail partners for, you know. I'm rambling too long, but I'm attempting to get plenty of material that I'd say at any point out on this question. You know, I think regarding the retail partners, given our sort of needs to get the volumes we'd pre-agreed in, we were somewhat whinier than usual. I want to thank our partners for tolerating our sort of whininess as we needed to ensure we executed against the plans we'd pre-done with them. Genuinely great friendships. You know, this is one where I know plenty of you folks were sort of predicting doom and gloom for us. maybe not you, but people were predicting, you know, covenant busts. our retailers knew we needed them, and they came through for us bigger than Dallas, and I want to thank them all for working with us. I don't know, Mike, anything you'd like to discuss regarding this season so far?
Mike Lukemire
executiveNo, I'd say any promo or event tied to weather is outperforming our projections by a wide margin. As we move into favorable conditions during the season, we're anticipating even more, and we have strong confidence we'll achieve the targets we committed to. Jim's correct — there's significant purchasing momentum, so that would happen since we'll adapt to market conditions as we deem appropriate.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAnd then finally, there's Hawthorne. Getting Hawthorne to breakeven is what we're focused on; that's the goal, right? There's a piece of this where, if you sat down with me... We held a board meeting last Monday and Friday. I believe it was Monday and Friday, Tuesday and Friday, whichever it was, but Friday for sure. My entire perspective on Hawthorne and cannabis shifted quite a bit while we were collecting information about what's going on in the market. The sales numbers basically come down to a few factors. First, durables are our biggest category. When it's really hard to turn a profit and plenty of folks are just scraping by, our strength in lighting ends up hurting us, particularly when you stack it against how much money we put into the business. That's fair — people are entitled to be critical. The more I dug in, the more Chris was traveling, that's what drove those revisions to my script. I mean, I'm not sure, we'd hit something like version 14 before we were done. There's plenty of positive things going on in the industry. It's, well, you start thinking everyone's struggling; it's a situation similar to regional banks. The weak players are hurting, and many companies in this space are hurting. The ones who are skilled at it, and there are a fair number of them, are genuinely thriving. Want to know what they're running? Our top-tier, most expensive lights, alright? They're achieving results with those lights, and those results are serious. We're conducting all this research. I don't believe anyone else is doing this kind of work where you're observing roughly a 50% gain in outputs. The price of lights becomes irrelevant when you're getting that sort of gain, but you need the capital, and if you're just scraping by, you're not purchasing it; that's why I say there will be winners and losers here, and a brutal shakeout is happening. We've got to push through it. So this is a situation where lots of positive things are occurring. I'd even say on the RIV side, there's significant pressure from people in New York's government to get New York sorted out. Honestly, it's embarrassing what's going on there. I think many changes are coming that will greatly benefit RIV and the investment we made in New York. There are simply many positive developments, and you just can't see them in the sort of — what's the term for when there's just... There's a phrase for it, just corpses everywhere. There are plenty of good stories amid the battlefield. Regardless, we aren't really running Hawthorne for top line at this point. We're really running it for bottom line. Even though it dipped, I believe we remain confident about reaching break even by year-end, and positive signs are showing up there. Among those performing well, we're observing value per pound as high as it has ever been for the folks using our product and who know what they're doing. Chris, that was a pretty long answer, but I can talk less after this.
Chris Carey
analystThanks, Jim. That was, as usual, exactly what we needed. It's always useful to hear the overall picture.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveI only let one swear word slip.
Chris Carey
analystYep. Yeah. So, hey, I'm just the first person asking a question on this call. You've got lots of time left to get caught up. Hey, let me put it really simply, and then I'll hop back in line. First, has your outlook on U.S. consumer volumes shifted at all for the year? Second, you brought up 30% gross margins. Should that be our framework for fiscal 2024? Thanks so much.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveI'll hand the margin piece over to Matt. Keep in mind what we told you is, you know, part of what I don't want my job to be is managing you folks. No offense meant by that. What I mean is, you know, I don't want to be held hostage by what all of you happen to believe. The only thing I can be held to is the commitments we've already made. We said flat +10% on lawns. Mike and I both thought those were incredibly easy given the investments we're making, and that's still how I feel. You know, what's my take? When you say Mike and I are aiming toward, you know, leverage in the 4s, that kind of presumes not much upside from Hawthorne and more upside from the consumer business. You know, where I live, driving in last night, you know, our birch trees still don't have any leaves on them. I, you know, I'd say this. Now, it's New England, but I would say I'd call this really early in the season with a lot still ahead. I think we're happy with the weather forecast. We're happy with the programs. We're happy with the marketing efforts. Personally, I see no evidence that the consumer isn't gardening or is avoiding our product line. you know, I think Mike and I expect flat plus 10 for lawns to come through; that we'll truly be able to tell you that, you know, in July or around then, once the season is roughly 80% done.
Matt Garth
executiveYes, Chris, regarding profitability, Jim touched on this topic. You caught some of it in my prepared remarks. Our targets for expanding revenue at GDP plus 100 basis points, returning to margins above 30%, keeping SG&A within the 15 to 16% band, and also generating free cash flow annually of roughly $300 million—each of these is foundational. In 2024, I believe we accomplish several of those items. On margin specifically, we're arriving from roughly a mid-to-high twenties level on a full-year basis in 2023. As you're aware and as we've discussed, raw material inflation and other inflationary pressures have had a major effect on our margin, which we've completely covered through pricing, yet that dilutes margin. Looking at the straightforward arithmetic, it's approximately 800 basis points of increase in pricing. You can observe that in the pricing gains shown in our press release tables. That's been countered by roughly 700 basis points—or 800 basis points if I round up—from inflationary elements. You still aren't seeing the margin improvement at this point. As we mentioned, certain commodity factors are beginning to ease; that will flow through; we have elevated cost inventories that both Jim and I referenced, which we're processing, and we're attempting to process them more quickly. Mike and his team have been essential in accomplishing that; it might accelerate margin recovery. At present, the mechanical arithmetic indicates this will occur near the close of 2024. In 2025, that's when we'd begin to see those 30%+ margins for the full year return.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAlright, and I apologize to anyone hoping to ask questions, since this is a topic where pricing will be significant for us. Obviously, through this entire inflationary period, we did factor those dollars into our pricing. It hurt us, I believe, by no less than 500 basis points. The reason I included those remarks in my script—which wasn't initially intended—was really to ensure my team recognizes we have targets we're working toward for enhancing the P&L. Gross margin serves as our jet fuel. That's what we rely on to run the company and grow our brands, and it truly is important. There's a piece in today's Journal about certain businesses that overpriced and managed to get away with it; we either chose not to or were unable to. Keep in mind, we aren't similar to a few of those companies mentioned in there, such as the building materials one, which got attention in this morning's Journal article. We're working with three or four major retailers—essentially the leading players in American lawn and garden. I believe we likely pressed them as far as possible on pricing, and we weren't hesitant about doing so, yet our margin shrank each time we took that step. My team has to grasp that gross margin is our jet fuel, and we require it to compete here. I don't believe we've settled on our pricing approach. It will probably hinge on discussions we're having right now and over the coming month or so with our retail partners, so they get it. A great deal will simply be how the business appears. How did the brand perform? Did we give up share? There isn't any clear share loss here. I'll just mention, a bit of sensitivity around our priciest grass seed, where we're examining this. So I believe we're currently pricing that in the market. I think pricing is necessary, and we can restore gross margin to where it ought to be if the retailers and the operating team agree that pricing is simply a quicker route to that outcome rather than holding out for commodity costs to decline, which they are doing. Okay?
Aimee DeLuca
executiveWait, why don't we move to Andrew Carter?
William Carter
analystHey, thanks. Yes, Andrew Carter. Thanks. Can you hear me?
Matt Garth
executiveWe can.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveWe can.
William Carter
analystAll right, fine. Let me put your question in plainer terms; what I hear you saying is that this guidance revision we made today brings only negatives, with no positives at all. More precisely, Hawthorne came in below what we had anticipated, yet you went ahead and restated the break-even, or run rate. Would it be fair to frame the whole guidance that way?
Matt Garth
executiveYes, I believe that's right. What you're really seeing comes down to a handful of factors in the way we're working through this. To start with, the work Mike and the team have pulled off is truly remarkable, and the degree of connection across the organization right now is very strong; we have a firm handle on all of it, and here's how you should interpret that. The load-out has performed really well; that was booked during the first half. On POS, you already heard both Jim and Mike walk through it. We've noticed some shift in mix, with our brand ed fertilizer doing very well, and private label fertilizers holding up fine. Mulch has also performed great. That represents a mix shift relative to our expectations, and it keeps POS at plus 10% in the lawns and ferts lawns segment, with the remainder roughly flat. That mix will shift as the year progresses, since we now anticipate mulches and soils ticking up somewhat. You might see lawns ease slightly while growing media rises a bit. There's some mix movement affecting margin there, but the larger issue, you're exactly right, sits entirely with Hawthorne. The critical thing here with Hawthorne is, as Jim put it, we're working through a lot of different hurdles when it comes to generating revenue, yet the entire delta in underlying performance stems from our cost outs. That's the reason we recorded a restructuring this quarter to further reposition ourselves and reshape it around where total revenue stands. We've eliminated 4 warehouses to make that happen, which takes cost out along with it. The path forward now keeps us positioned to reach break-even performance by year-end.
William Carter
analystAlright, great. For my second question, I was hoping to dig deeper — you mentioned that POS was expected to align with what you had anticipated. I just want to probe that remark a bit more, since March clearly got off to a rough start. That month came in softer. April, though, was solid. So what I'd like to know is this: through April, are you tracking with what you originally forecast, which would suggest some upside relative to your prior estimate? Or does the full-year guidance essentially hinge on weather conditions holding steady across May and June? Thanks.
Matt Garth
executiveRight, quite a bit happening. I meant to say — let me start things off. We could head right over to Mike. The floor's yours, Mike.
Mike Lukemire
executiveNo, I’d say we’re right where we currently expect to be. On mix, we’ll make adjustments depending on how much takeaway there is and when the season lands. We’ve still got so much POS in front of us, so as far as our guidance goes, nothing is changing; we’re simply running different models depending on what POS turns out to be.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveHonestly, Andrew, from where I sit, you're reading too much into this. What's obvious, I think, is that Garth had no desire for those figures to rise once this call wrapped up. It's not like we're constantly redoing forecasts each week based on what's happening in North America. Right now, folks are simply operating the business. The season has been good up to this point, in my view — does anything about it feel disappointing?
Mike Lukemire
executiveNot at all. What I'm saying is that this is inherently uneven, and as you're aware, half of our points of sale are still in front of us. Week to week, there are peaks and valleys. Some weeks have been terrific, while others were shaped by the weather. We're always fine-tuning things, yet we're holding to the outlook we've given for where the U.S. business is headed, so we haven't revised anything.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveThat'd be Andrew, which is pretty standard. This early in the year, we usually wouldn't be revising our figures either upward or downward.
Mike Lukemire
executiveHonestly, I usually won't discuss any figures with the finance person until May 31st has passed. That's simply how the season plays out. Depending on the region and what the weather does. All the promotional activity we've carried out this year, along with the timing we've worked out with retailers, has actually exceeded what we expected.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveLuke means business. At this stage of the season, our general preference isn't to invest much time reworking the budget. My view is that we simply keep operating, and regarding the consumer business, I'd describe our stance as neutral to positive.
Mike Lukemire
executiveYeah; we'll blow it out this weekend.
Matt Garth
executiveThank you, Andrew.
Joe Altobello
analystThanks. Hello, everyone. Good morning. I suppose if we stick with POS for a moment, you know, unchanged during April, considering the position you held 3 months back, that sounds fairly encouraging. Could you refresh our memory on how your comparisons shape up over the latter 6 months of this year, so we might place that within some context?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveVery straightforward.
Mike Lukemire
executiveRight. Those comparisons are pretty weak. Is there anything we have... I've got my eyes on the sales rep sitting right here.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveNo, though he is on his computer.
Mike Lukemire
executiveClearly, he isn't prepared. When you consider the rest of the year, comps range from low single digits to negative double digits. For the remainder of the year, we are facing a negative comp.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveYeah.
Joe Altobello
analystOkay, that's helpful. And then second, regarding the SG&A outlook — assuming I've got the arithmetic right, my sense is you're pointing toward roughly $570 million for this year. Clearly that's far under what was laid out during the past, you know, several years. What portion of that is only short-term, and what portion might return, I suppose, in 2024? Should we more or less remain around that, let's call it mid-15s % of sales?
Matt Garth
executiveYeah, that's the reason we've been so careful to provide that guidance, since I believe we fielded plenty of questions on it earlier in the year. You're basically spot on — it lands around the middle of the 15s, so somewhere in that 15 to 16% range. Previously it sat at 19%. We've already shown everyone the path we took, starting from a far bigger revenue curve. Project Springboard let us restructure what we put into SG&A. Looking ahead, treating 15 to 16% as the figure makes sense. Once revenue picks up, Joe, a portion of that spending will return, though for now we're holding it fairly steady.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveLook, Joe, you and I go way back, and things got insanely rough in this place, all right? Truly, they did. I believe I mentioned to folks that we were in for one hell of a long winter, and that's exactly what happened. We laid off a ton of folks, many of whom we'd only just brought on board. We shifted away from that mindset of, hey, anything's possible. What was that term we used, Mike? Unconstrained?
Mike Lukemire
executiveNot constrained at all.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveThen, within a very brief window, extremely constrained — and that was painful. I'd like to extend an invitation, Joe; you and I have been friends for quite a while. My suggestion would be: pay us a visit. Perhaps we could arrange some kind of event so you'd get the chance to actually sit down with what you might call the operating group. It's a reduced headcount, a fairly varied bunch, yet genuinely fired up. They never let it get them down. It would have been so simple for us to drift off course with morale collapsing across the board; instead we've got a group of young fighters steering this company, and they make me extremely proud. What I'd propose is that we figure out a way for you, along with other people, to get acquainted with a portion of that team. The team is smaller in size, but their engagement level is through the roof, and they're really charging ahead. Even though the figures have fallen and that was painful, my honest view is that those who remain are absolutely at the top of their game, and meeting them would leave you impressed.
Joe Altobello
analystThanks for that, Jim. I'll do my best to follow through on it. Thank you.
Bill Chappell
analystAnd thanks — good morning.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveHello, Bill.
Bill Chappell
analystHey, I suppose just a single, quick — well, not so quick — question about the Hawthorne operation. What I'd like is for you to explain why you feel sure that the reductions already made are sufficient to deliver solid profitability; it sounded as though you were saying that daily sales figures have not truly risen the way you'd have anticipated by now. Obviously, I recognize that visibility into that sector is quite limited overall. So which benchmarks are you watching that tell you, fine, we are heading toward breaking even, heading toward getting better, even if we assume the top line won't get better and might remain this soft — or softer — for however long we can see ahead?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveHonestly, I'm not sure. I'm glancing over at Chris and Matt regarding, I suppose, the path of operating profit, which is the way we typically frame it. What I'd say is, we have been discussing when we expect to see the industry hit its low point. Among the Hawthorne group, and with the folks in the industry we've spoken with, the sense I get is that we've either already reached it or we're sitting right at it. I genuinely believe that plays into this — there seem to be sufficient encouraging indicators now, in terms of value per pound, and in terms of product consumption among knowledgeable users, that we've arrived at that turning point. As for costs, I'm not certain. When we discuss reducing expenses at this company, on a yearly basis that's roughly close to a quarter of a billion dollars, Hawthorne accounted for about 50% of it. That's been — and I give everyone there a lot of credit — whatever Mike and I have accomplished, whatever Chris has accomplished, it's roughly an equivalent sum. So it has been extremely tough. I do think you picked up on remarks that we have to take action. Part of what I'm considering is that there comes a threshold past breaking even where, based on your sales volume and your mix, you simply ask, "Can we remain here?" We aren't abandoning this market. If you simply examine consumption, by Americans, of cannabis, those figures range from acceptable to strong. I don't believe Mike, Matt, Chris, or myself would say we only want to operate a North American consumer business. I think we return to where we stood previously, prior to when we began committing these investments, and ask, of the five pillars, do we require live goods? Do we require Hawthorne? I believe the response is affirmative. We appreciate the growth profile of that, and our confidence in both remains. I do think at the volume figures we're discussing here, we will need to partner with others in a comparable position who require scale. That's the takeaway from the signals we put out. Chris, I'm not sure where you stand on the business, and then Matt, let's address the operating profit.
Chris Hagedorn'S
executiveHi Bill. Chris here. Yeah, so I can give you a bit more color on the reasons we feel good about the back half. As Jim said, I believe tailwinds are beginning to show up across the industry, and given where we sit in the value chain, it could be one or two more months before they reach us. Once the end producers begin to see some recovery in pricing for what they sell, that will flow through to us. There's a bit of... you know, there's product sitting with retailers and all kinds of other factors that unwind over time; on top of that, we're anticipating the fairly typical seasonal uptick that shows up in Q3 and carries into Q4 with outdoor grows in states such as California. We're counting on that too. Beyond that, we have several states on the East Coast that we see as offering significant upside, markets such as New York, you know, Maryland. Missouri obviously isn't on the East Coast, I realize that, but for us it's an emerging market where we anticipate beginning to see some momentum. On top of that, our ProHort business — despite all the challenges in the North American cannabis sector — the ProHort operation for us, which is mostly the Agrolux brand, is performing very strongly. Those revenues come from the seasonal patterns of their customers, who are professional, you know, ProHort, lots of vegetable growers and similar operations, located in Europe and Canada. Their season means they prefer to purchase product at the close of our year. We expect those sales to arrive in Q4, and they represent substantial figures; we're hopeful. You know, look, should the market keep facing difficulties, we'll keep taking action, whether those are big strategic steps, like Jim referenced, or the kinds of internal steps we keep making. I think plenty of indicators exist, regardless of the headlines, that leave us optimistic.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveI think just to come on from a position of trajectory and profitability.
Matt Garth
executiveRegarding the revenue figure, we're taking a fairly cautious stance, and that's how we're framing it in this discussion. Chris and Jim, I believe, both highlighted that there could be room for upside. Across essentially every product category we're discussing, there's an encouraging outlook. As for the way we're presenting it to you, the earnings path rests on steps we've already implemented. Per Jim's comments, Project Springboard — with half of it originating from Hawthorne — is factored into that recovery plan. The restructuring we carried out is likewise aimed at Hawthorne. It removes a sizable chunk of warehousing expenses. That alone accounts for the primary gap between where we stand now and where we'll be at year's end. A revenue shift isn't strictly required to get us to that profitable level; the responsibility sits with us, the major moves are behind us, and from here it's simply a matter of executing over the coming months.
Bill Chappell
analystOkay, just a single follow-up question, and this one is about consumer POS. Maybe—hopefully—it's a quick one to answer. But I understand that you're happy with how the market, or how the business, is responding when the weather cooperates. Obviously, March weather was poor, and I believe you mentioned that April only had 1 and a half good weeks. In the years I've been covering this, it's been uncommon to be able to recover those March and April sales during May, June, and July in the southern half of the country. Is your expectation, and your optimism regarding POS, that the northern half, or the other markets that haven't broken, will perform better than expected? Do you genuinely expect that consumers who, because of weather, didn't come out in March or April will still come out later in the season and make an equivalent amount of purchases, since you're going to go deep into the season?
Mike Lukemire
executiveWell, I’m not expecting that. I don’t see us trailing by that much. What I’d say is that we’re going to catch up, we’re going to do what we told you we would do, and then we’re going to carry it out. I’d also tell you that we’ve actually been much more aggressive earlier, such as with fertilizer. Because of the weather, we did see in markets where weather wasn’t a factor that our units were flat to slightly up, since we got consumers out there. I’m actually more bullish than what we’ve put out there. I don’t.
Bill Chappell
analystYou don't think the weather's been that much of an issue?
Mike Lukemire
executiveActually, that isn't the case — it hasn't reached the scale it used to have in past years. Honestly, in a few instances, it may even be stronger than what I had anticipated.
Bill Chappell
analystOkay.
Matt Garth
executiveBill, you know.
Mike Lukemire
executiveYeah.
Matt Garth
executiveSuppose you rewind to 14 days back. I recall Luke saying at that moment, "We've got this under control. Supply chain is going to be run out of product." Then we get a pair of lousy weekends, and now there are two unpleasant words in play. Folks are starting to look worried. All of this stems from just a few rough weekends. Take a look at what the forecast shows today. Once more, mine extends out roughly 14 days. It simply appears really strong. In my view, our business has shifted toward May, June, truthfully. If someone came to me and asked, "Are you going to get April showers, does that concern you?" my answer would be, "Not really." I don't believe we require much to occur. I anticipate plenty will occur. I don't believe we require much to occur.
Mike Lukemire
executiveMy expectation is that POS will hold up. What matters is where we finish on inventories and matters like that, rather than POS being the problem. In my view, folks are fixating on POS far more than asking, "Where do retail inventories stand at the close, and when do shipments land?"
Matt Garth
executiveYeah, Bill, I think two things.
Bill Chappell
analystYeah.
Matt Garth
executiveThat’s what Luke is looking to find out: whether retail inventories will avoid a crash. You know, retail inventories have fallen significantly.
Bill Chappell
analystCorrect.
Matt Garth
executiveOur goal is to keep retailers involved. What I believe this weekend plus the next week and a half will accomplish is that we are going to be compelling those retailers to purchase product from us.
Bill Chappell
analystRight.
Matt Garth
executiveThat's a good thing.
Bill Chappell
analystUnderstood.
Mike Lukemire
executiveNobody ever wants to carry excess inventory. I'd say pulling point-of-sale data early is beneficial. When it comes to POS availability, honestly, we're moving in a direction similar to 2018. We pretty much crushed it on POS. I believe folks tend to over-associate POS with shipments more than is warranted.
Matt Garth
executiveBy the way, in 2018, the POS was May, June.
Mike Lukemire
executiveYeah.
Matt Garth
executiveRight? That's why we come-.
Mike Lukemire
executiveAccording to him.
Matt Garth
executiveYeah.
Mike Lukemire
executiveYeah.
Matt Garth
executiveWe're not good at short answers.
Bill Chappell
analystYeah. No.
Mike Lukemire
executiveWe're talking to ourselves now.
Bill Chappell
analystI'm happy to give it a shot.
Eric Bosshard
analystThank you. There are a couple of things I'd like to ask — one directed at Matt, the other at Jim. Let me begin with Matt regarding the consumer figures; right now it's obvious the tilt is favorable, on both sales and consumer, and I value the guidance and the transparency around it. Turning to gross margin, what I'm attempting to figure out is whether you enjoy that same kind of visibility into making headway? I couldn't fully grasp why gross margin only began to get better starting in the back half of next year. Which components of gross margin drive that, in the short term it appears pricing is holding and promotional spending is fixed for the year, yet are there also elements inside gross margin in consumer that we ought to keep in mind both short term and as we move into 2024?
Matt Garth
executiveYeah. I appreciate your putting it that way, since pricing indeed holds. Promotions are delivering. You've just heard the entire volume narrative, and how we view it across the remainder of the year. The largest factor in how margin forms, and incidentally, the margin erosion from the 30s, has come from inflation's effect. What we've accomplished, and you're aware of this, is that we've essentially secured this year. In 2023, 90% of our COGS is locked; we've started layering in for 2024; we do this for two reasons — ensuring supply availability and securing pricing on our COGS, giving us that visibility to collaborate with our retail partners on. Beyond that, we additionally carry high-cost inventories that we keep working through. Keep in mind, we entered this year with roughly about $1 billion of excess inventory spanning both businesses; we're moving through a large chunk of it, and that represents some, perhaps all, of the inventory relief we'll see across the coming 2 years — it's that pricier inventory. The steps Mike described for accelerating that, we're evaluating. So you've got those 2 dynamics: prices locked in and inflationary pressures easing. Simultaneously, we're already securing 2024. Then there's the high-cost inventory we're processing and attempting to do so faster. Once past that, you return to that natural 30s level for U.S. consumer type margin. Nothing else is in play. Incidentally, that's the reason Jim mentioned we possess other levers, correct? We've performed well on the SG&A front. We keep extracting operational efficiency across the whole organization. There's more pricing available if we ever need to pursue it.
Eric Bosshard
analystAll right, that helps. So Jim, near the start of your remarks you brought up this idea of a base or foundation. I'm not sure those were your exact words, but you described a shift the company is now making toward growth. What I'd like to know is how that looks from a strategic standpoint, given that you also mentioned reshaping the strategy team and this move toward growth. I have to admit I was also taken aback that Hawthorne came up in that context, given the direction that's already been established there. And I value what Chris said about tailwinds building in that business. So when you bring up a shift toward growth, help me see what that actually involves or what options are on the table.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAll right, let's begin with innovation. Consider the money Patti controls. Looking at what the marketing group was given as this year began, I wouldn't call it unlimited, but on their core brands they pretty much had what they asked for. If you were on a secondary or tertiary brand, though, things were quite tight. Turning to R&D, those budgets stayed largely whole. Compared with the cutbacks that took place throughout this business, R&D mostly escaped them, though not entirely. On earlier calls like these, we mentioned that when something offered only a marginal return, or a return that sat further out in time, we either killed the program or placed it, well, placed it in cold storage for later so we could handle it then. Not to let it spoil, but to pull it out afterward. I do believe that as we — Eric, basically, here's how I'd put it: we can see light at the tunnel. That winter, once more, I don't have another way to phrase it, truly was awful; we — we're discussing islands. It seemed like an island right here. We had faith in ourselves. I can't be certain everyone else had faith in us. This company merits enormous credit for carrying out what had to be done, both hitting sales figures and driving costs down. For us, more than $200 million in sustainable savings extracted from the business — that's truly remarkable, and heroic. Nobody was idly sitting around discussing growth, all right? Now, with light showing at the end of the tunnel, it isn't about mere survival anymore, it's about how we expand beyond this. I think we're beginning to line up investments. As for the strategic team, Amy used to run our strategy group, and that group got gutted in, like, a single day. What's evident is that in corporate, we're essentially redirecting existing top-tier thinkers into Matt's group. What I meant is that at the corporate level, we have to work through a number of these opportunities—without really putting that weight on the operating team—and in part develop metrics we can use as guideposts for the business going forward, but also to make the investment choices that will drive growth in both sales and margin here in the company. That's what I was getting at: I think we're seeing light, and we're basically saying, you know, growth is gonna become something that matters, and how do we thoughtfully get there? I didn't say that we're free, but I think we see a view of this less burdened than it was.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveI think it makes sense. You gonna make those, Mike?
William Reuter
analystHi, good morning.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveHey.
William Reuter
analystYou brought up the possibility of further price increases. Would that happen partway through the season, or are you mainly talking about the point when shelf space gets reset once the season wraps up?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveActually, it isn't really about shelf resets. Right now we're in the middle of talks with our biggest retailers about the coming year. That conversation is ongoing, and I haven't ruled out raising prices. I, I'd say there's likely pressure against doing so. Part of what I'm telling my team and our retail partners listening in on this call is that our gross margin is genuinely important. Being able to grow our way past this, which everyone requires, both us and our retailers, comes down to whether we've got sufficient ammunition to operate the business. We've just emerged from a stretch that was fairly tight. Should we require price increases to bring us back to historical margins, since that's the only thing under discussion, then from my standpoint, that's a tool sitting in our tool bag. Do you agree with that, Mike?
Mike Lukemire
executiveI accept that.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveOkay.
Matt Garth
executiveOur initial focus is on reaching that point, shipping units, and aligning costs alongside our retail partners, so we won't have to take that step unless it becomes necessary.
William Reuter
analystGot it, that's very useful. Regarding the $200 million in run rate cost savings you expect by year-end, I'm not sure whether you gave us the split showing how much comes from SG&A and how much from COGS. Could you give me a rough framework to work with?
Matt Garth
executiveWhen we discussed this previously, I believe it was about one-third SG&A and two-thirds COGS. Actually, my mistake, it's reversed. Two-thirds SG&A, one-third COGS.
William Reuter
analystGreat. And finally from my side, I wanted to know whether there's anything new you can tell us regarding the long-term vision for Hawthorne. In the past, whenever this question came up, I believe your answer was essentially, "This isn't the right moment to make a move. The business needs to be fixed first." Jim, earlier you noted that your thinking on cannabis had shifted somewhat, so I'm wondering whether that might have altered the strategic approach to that asset.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveWell, here's the thing. The decision to move into cannabis is roughly 10 years old now, and it had strong backing at the board level. I believe the investor community felt the same way back then. Perhaps folks have forgotten. I was the one who drove it. Luke, Matt, and I have faith in this business. I know we've said that we're taking off the table any consideration of a spin or a merger that would end up spinning into different equity. That was accurate, and it still is. What I think has shifted over the last, say, few months is that when we examine this sector and see the wreckage around us — including some genuinely strong companies that, in our view, are a bit like arrivals at Ellis Island, as in, send them our way... How did it go, Chris?
Chris Hagedorn'S
executiveMy impression is that you lack resources and you are the crowded multitudes; for us, longing to turn a profit.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveSo, when we look around, there are others at solid companies facing the same circumstances we are. We're examining very carefully what sorts of mergers might exist in which everyone essentially contributes their operations into a combined entity possessing enough scale to reach a point where we aren't constantly offering explanations and they manage to last. Within that kind of conversation, we have a lot of faith in the assets we hold — truly the top labels in the supply sector, extremely commanding. Others could bring elements that improve both sides, and we're willing to consider such mergers. That matters, because I genuinely believe remaining as we are is difficult. It's simply that, when your company is making, say, $10 million, $15 million, $20 million, any figure you'd care to name, it becomes one of those situations that requires enormous effort. It never stops feeling like a perpetual hunt for capital. My view is we must be part of an operation exceeding $1 billion in revenue and above $100 million in profit before it truly begins to seem strategic — a sustainable market leader. We possess an excellent company to bring to Ellis Island, so to speak, yet I believe we require additional immigrants, more huddled masses, to come aboard with us. Chris, I'm not sure what your take would be.
Chris Hagedorn'S
executiveRight. So, I think Jim covered quite a bit of it already. On a personal level — I won't call it optimism exactly, but what I will call it is my confidence in this space — and, as you all are aware, we've devoted considerable time and considerable capital to it. Over the last 18 months, we've poured a lot of pain into it too. Jim brought up what the Hawthorne team has contributed when it comes to lowering costs across Scotts overall. I especially want to recognize Tom Crabtree. He's sitting right here with us. Tom is truly the person who drove the daily effort behind bringing those figures down for Hawthorne. That was grueling work, and I know it weighed heavily on Tom and on everyone on that team. I want to give a huge shout-out and simply convey my thanks, my appreciation, and my respect to every person who did that; there was a purpose behind all that effort. Walking away wasn't the goal. What we were after was making this business sustainable — shoring up its basic soundness, so to speak, and getting us ready for what comes next. As everyone can see, disruption is what this business is experiencing right now. Honestly, it was miserable having to steer it through that, and to feel like the one accountable for it. There are deals to be pursued here that, from what we can tell, would be accretive in essentially every respect. Some strong players exist out there. The way I see it, we're obligated to look into those possibilities — not just because we have to find a path toward capturing synergies and getting that business, as Jim put it, to a point where it's profitable at a level we can genuinely take pride in. Beyond that, though, there are such remarkable opportunities right now where, if that falling knife of Cannabis valuations hasn't yet reached the floor, it's terribly near it. Our view is that chances are coming to form partnerships and alliances that might not be around later; as sort of hunters in this space, we've got an obligation to take a shot at this moment, so.
Matt Garth
executiveLet me just stress one point that both of you brought up — this comes down to creating value. With Hawthorne, we hold a really distinctive spot, since we deliver the full solution. Like Chris mentioned, that carries substantial worth for the people we serve. When we think about consolidation — Jim brought it up, Chris brought it up — there's a way to accomplish it without cash, and that shapes how we proceed, and frankly, it leaves us better positioned for whatever choice we end up making later about where this entity sits.
Operator
operatorThat's a really useful way to look at it, thanks. Thanks as well. Everyone, that brings the Q&A portion to a close, and with it, today's conference call is finished. We appreciate your joining. You're free to disconnect at this point.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.