The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company (SMG) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
November 1, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Aimee DeLuca
executiveHello, everyone. Joining me on today's call are Jim Hagedorn, our Chairman, President and CEO; Matt Garth, our Chief Financial and Administrative Officer; Nate Baxter, our Chief Operating Officer; and Chris Hagedorn, Group President of Hawthorne. Jim and Matt are going to kick things off with some prepared remarks. After that, the operator will open the lines so you can ask your questions. Since we'll be sharing forward-looking statements, I want to remind everyone that actual results may differ materially from what we discuss today. For a full picture of the risk factors that could affect our results, please see our Form 10-K filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission. If you'd like to keep the conversation going after the call, feel free to email me or give me a ring at (937)-578 to 5621, and we'll try to find some time as soon as we can. One more thing — today's call is being recorded, and a replay will be posted on our website at investor.scotts.com. So let's jump in. I'll hand things over to Jim Hagedorn to get us started. Jim?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveThanks, Aimee. Morning, everyone. What you'll hear from me today is a look at how fiscal '23 wrapped up, plus the steps we've taken so we can keep building positive momentum in '24. Let me start by reminding you that a whole range of factors produced the financial position we're in now, affecting both our Consumer business and Hawthorne. Certain ones came from the broader economy — the post-COVID backdrop and weather that didn't cooperate — yet a great many stemmed from decisions we made ourselves while chasing growth. I recognize this has asked a great deal of our stakeholders and our associates. Stabilizing the business was our mission in fiscal '23. That placed enormous strain on our operations and on our people. It called for difficult decisions and swift execution. Through that effort, we achieved progress that is both legitimate and measurable. Cash flow came in $681 million better than a year ago, and we brought debt down by $361 million; we trimmed expenses beyond $200 million and are aiming at a further $100 million in cost savings; inventory is down over $450 million. And because of our banks, we now enjoy greater financial flexibility. We beat the lawn and garden category and gained share despite a tough environment. Looking ahead to fiscal '24, retail inventories look healthy. Our retailer relationships were put to the test and today stand stronger than they've ever been. Together, these things point to what we regard as a return to running the business in a more normal way. Credit for our progress goes to the strength of our brands, which enjoy record-high consumer awareness and trust, and to our people, whose resilience throughout this period has been remarkable. Turning to Hawthorne, I said when '23 began that my objective was to bring it back to profitability. By the end of Q4 it was running at breakeven, and it produced over $100 million in free cash flow during fiscal '23, which sets up profitability in '24. In addition to those accomplishments, we've added next-generation leaders at both the executive and senior levels, strengthening our talent pool with individuals bringing new viewpoints and vitality. Collectively, we are generating momentum that will boost our results and grow shareholder value. Matt is going to explain how we achieved fiscal '23 results that met or exceeded the guidance provided back in August. He will also present our fiscal '24 outlook. Our focus is going to be on the final stage of Project Springboard, while ensuring we protect and invest in the things that distinguish us. Those include our brands, our sales force, our innovation and our supply chain. Regarding fiscal '24, the team has developed an operating plan that is ambitious yet thoughtfully deliberated. The plan has four components. To start, we're raising gross margin to get to $575 million in EBITDA. Next, we're wrapping up a two-year push to hit $1 billion in free cash flow by the time '24 closes. Third, we intend to cut debt by at least another $350 million prior to fiscal '24 ending. And fourth, we aim to bring our leverage ratio down into the 4s by year-end. As for risks that might derail this plan, the bulk of them lie outside our control — consumer behavior and global developments. Even so, when you look at consumers as a whole, the folks purchasing our main lawn and garden items make up the most dependable and hardy segment; our retail partners and we alike expect this core consumer to show up in numbers that at minimum equal their turnout across the last twelve months. Our plan assumes no change for the consumer business we already have, plus added unit growth obtained through share gains, which will produce extra volume via greater promotional activity, shelf space and listings with major retailers that were absent a year ago. I'll cover that more thoroughly shortly. To start, I'd like to talk about the group of leaders responsible for carrying out this plan. The Board and I brought in a completely fresh team so that the people steering this company going forward would have the authority to do so, while also giving up-and-coming executives room to shoulder greater duties. That begins with Nate Baxter and Matt Garth. Our operating and management organization will be shaped by these two down the road. Both Nate and Matt are sharp, driven, and collaborate effectively with me and with one another. As seasoned executives, they give me exactly what I require in genuine business partners. When Q4 wrapped up, I decided to move up the retirement dates for Mike Lukemire and Denise Stump. Both had intended to depart in '24, but it became obvious that we had to act faster to get clarity and to put Nate and Matt in position to handle daily business operations. Nate oversees the operations area, while Matt now carries duties that go past what a CFO typically does. By handing nearly all administrative functions over to Matt, he and Nate stand as equals. Between the two of them, authority and accountability are evenly distributed. We broadened the leadership overhaul so that Nate and Matt would be surrounded by people capable of rising to the occasion. On the people side, we've brought in a fresh Head of Human Resources along with a new General Counsel. Beyond that, we've charted a different course in both marketing and IT by doing away with the Chief Marketing Officer and Chief Information Officer positions. Those teams have been reorganized. Over in marketing, brand VP Ashley Bachmann shares leadership with Jodi Lee. As for IT, the VPs are Emily Wahl, who handles IT infrastructure, and Sayyed Nezhadi, who owns digital initiatives; both of them report up to Nate. In marketing, Ashley and Jodi are going to team up with a new creative agency, which will deliver world-class, compelling creative that inspires and motivates our consumers; they'll also collaborate with Mediahub, a partner of long standing known for world-class media buying, to deploy our media dollars effectively in line with our priorities. Let me return to the strategy now. Keeping the consumer franchise safe matters more than anything else. That's the real driver, and we need to put substantial resources behind every element that fuels our lawn and garden operation. At the top of that list sat marketing and sales. During fiscal '23, our advertising spend came in 25% above what it was in '22. One of my goals is to push our advertising budget even higher this year. Beyond that, we'll redirect the bulk of those funds into older, more traditional advertising channels, putting our primary customer first. As I noted, our main buyer represents the strongest segment within the entire customer base. These are individuals who already own homes and typically earn larger incomes. They carry little personal debt and hold above-average savings; both we and our retail partners are seeing signs that in '24 they'll spend more hours at home compared with '23; and right now isn't the moment to go after a wider set of new buyers. When it comes to retailers, their attention is on store visits; in their view, lawn and garden gives them the greatest chance to pull in more foot traffic. And lawn and garden is ours. Working side by side, we'll launch strong promotions and activations targeting our main buyer. As I mentioned, inventories at retail are healthy; we anticipate a robust retailer load. During the prior year, our sales patterns shifted because we managed that year with a near-term, quarter-by-quarter mindset. In fiscal '24, the load is going to track the more historical pre-COVID cadence. Let me take you through our plan for growing volume and share.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveWe directed roughly one-third of the gross margin rate gain we would otherwise have recorded in fiscal '23 back toward our retail partners, through trade support and small price cuts on select SKUs, to address elasticity. What we get in return is more listings, additional shelf space, and promotions — none of which existed for us a year ago. That should boost our capacity to generate the incremental volume growth required to hit our plan. And there's some encouraging early news; the fiscal year has begun very well for us. Across every brand, POS through the month of October rose 4% in units and 8% in dollars. On the fall lawn care push, unit volume rose more than 3%. Turf Builder plus 2 came in at 21%, Bonus S climbed 56.5%, while Gardens and Controls each added 4% and 5%. Home Defense, which is the biggest line under Ortho, increased 19%. Roundup gained 12.5%, and Miracle-Gro Potting Mix moved up 9%. We're carrying real momentum into the coming year. Now for Hawthorne: we've made progress across a range of potential paths that should benefit shareholders and create room for that business to grow. Talks are underway right now aimed at building a top-tier vertically integrated cannabis operation. At this point, I don't have anything else to say, though we'll provide an update at the earliest opportunity. Our dedication is to act in the best interests of Scotts Miracle-Gro, Hawthorne and the cannabis sector. That approach allows us to create chances for shareholders to participate in the industry's continued expansion and, ideally, achieve maximum returns, so that later on, every one of us can reflect and conclude it was a solid investment. I'll wrap up by saying this. To our associates: I recognize it has been a slog, and it stings more since winning is what we're accustomed to. Each person here must remain committed and concentrated on execution; this will be the year we turn the corner. Hello, everyone. We have gotten the company back on solid footing and achieved quite a bit. By the time this year closes, our cost reductions are going to be more than $300 million, and we remain on course to hit our target of $1 billion in free cash flow across a 2-year period. During that same stretch, we'll reduce our debt by over $700 million. We've also reshaped our leadership team and added fresh Board members who bring varied experience. Once this year is done, the majority of our problems will be behind us, and our brand strength will be much greater. The momentum we're building will serve us well over the next decade. Thanks. Matt, over to you.
Matt Garth
executiveThanks, Jim, and good morning to all of you. Like Jim mentioned, fiscal 2023 brought about major transformation at Scotts Miracle-Gro. What that means right away is that each associate is now focused on our strategy and priorities — protecting the positions and innovations that define our markets, while also working to recover operating margin and build greater financial flexibility. So let's dig deeper into how we performed in '23 and the guidance we're setting for fiscal '24. I'll begin with the top line. Company-wide sales were down 24% for the quarter, and we closed the year down 10% at $3.55 billion, right in line with the guidance we'd given for the fiscal year. U.S. consumer sales dropped 33% during the quarter, reflecting the shipment timing between Q3 and Q4 that we discussed earlier; across the full year, pricing came in almost 5% higher. Overall sales dropped 3%, hurt by reduced shipment volumes and by our consumer loans business, which carries higher margin but is more exposed to weather. We finished the year with POS dollars up close to 5%, helped by that higher pricing. POS units ended the year just slightly below 23, since bad weather in September kept the volume lift we expected from materializing; even so, our fall campaign has gained traction, and October POS units rose nearly 5%. Retailer inventory positions as we enter fiscal '24 look healthy. Across our 3 biggest customers, unit inventories finished the year down roughly 1% on average and right now sit about 2% lower. Most of that year-end retail inventory came from new, fast-turning growing media listings plus the build-up ahead of our fall and rodent campaigns. Over at Hawthorne, Q4 sales were down 11%, and the fiscal year was down 35%, both matching our guidance. We keep seeing signs that the industry is stabilizing. Still, it's too soon to declare a top-line inflection point. Turning to total company gross margin rate for the full year, it dropped roughly 260 basis points to 23.7%, though the faster rollout of Project Springboard savings helped us land better than we'd expected. Let me walk you through the margin shift. Pricing moves and Springboard results together contributed almost 600 basis points of year-over-year improvement. Things I'd call near-term headwinds — including 380 basis points from reduced production and debt-lowering inventory, 330 bps from higher material costs tied to COVID era purchasing, and 130 bps from a onetime write-down of excess and obsolete inventory — more than erased those gains. Now down to the income statement. SG&A stayed tightly controlled all year, with savings coming from Springboard efforts designed to create efficiencies across the organization. We kept funding our future by investing in our brands, our sales force, and our innovation pipeline. For the fiscal year, SG&A landed 10% below last year, at 15.5% of sales, matching our guidance. For fiscal '23, operating income finished at $292 million, equal to 8.2% of net sales, as faster Springboard savings produced gains beyond the 7% to 7.5% range we had guided. Adjusted EBITDA came in at $447 million. Turning beneath the operating line, interest expense rose considerably because of the higher rate environment, finishing the year up roughly $60 million. At SMG, average borrowing rates climbed 180 basis points during fiscal 2023, and 2024 will bring a further 80 basis point rise. As usual, our free cash flow came in heavier during the back half, meaning most debt reduction happened in Q4. A number of discrete items affected our effective tax rate in the fourth quarter, pushing the full year rate to 36.6%, far above what we had expected. Briefly, we recorded valuation allowances against deferred tax assets in some jurisdictions, which prevented those credits from being used in the current period. In total, fourth quarter adjusted earnings — excluding impairment, restructuring and other nonrecurring items — showed a loss of $2.77 per share, compared with a $2.04 loss per share a year earlier. Full year EPS reached $1.21. Keep in mind that figure contains onetime impacts of $0.25 tied to the U.S. consumer inventory write-down taken in the third quarter. Moving now to free cash flow and the balance sheet, we keep posting meaningful gains, with positive free cash flow of almost $440 million, more than $500 million of which came during Q4. Against the prior year, free cash flow rose $681 million, mainly from reducing inventories and other working capital gains. Inventories dropped more than $450 million compared with a year ago, and we expect another $275 million reduction in fiscal '24. That cash flow lets us sustain our quarterly dividend while bringing debt down by $361 million. Liquidity remains solid, with close to $1.2 billion of debt capacity at fiscal year-end. We also announced today the closing of a new accounts receivable sale agreement with JPMorgan, which replaces and increases the size of our earlier facility. Because the closing landed across quarter ends, it caused a dip in our cash flow. Had this program been in place at year-end, cash from operations would have been $50 million greater in fiscal '23. Bear in mind that the discounted cost tied to the AR sales will appear in the other income and expense line inside operating earnings and should come to roughly $20 million. We closed the year with leverage of 6.57x adjusted EBITDA against a covenant maximum of 7.75x. Keep in mind that adjusted EBITDA used for the leverage calculation includes $39 million of allowable increases to reported adjusted EBITDA for nonrecurring E&O and warehouse closure costs incurred in the third quarter; let's now shift to our outlook for fiscal '24. In setting full year guidance, our main objectives continue to be delivering robust EBITDA and free cash flow. The plan we're operating under is bold, and it shows how closely we're working with our retail partners, which should produce high single-digit expansion for the U.S. consumer business. Things we can't control could affect consumer takeaway and lead to a smaller growth path across the year. Better gross margin, paired with disciplined SG&A management, should deliver operating income equal to 10.5% to 11% of sales. Under the operating line, interest expense should be roughly level versus last year, since average borrowing costs are anticipated to rise, and debt paydown will occur in the fourth quarter, which is normal. Finally, our ETR will land in the 29% to 30% range, while share count rises by 1.5 million shares. Looking at net leverage, we currently view the second quarter of 2024 as the peak pressure point in the outlook, given how seasonal working capital phases. Keep in mind that we hold adequate headroom to absorb any external swings within our covenant requirements. In summary, the core strengths of our iconic brands, along with our supply chain and innovation capabilities and our talented associates, underpin our 3 near-term priorities: Margin recovery, the balance of $1 billion in free cash flow and a solution for Hawthorne's future beyond SMG; we are focused on executing with precision. We have a determined path forward and I'm confident that our trajectory is improving and that we can return to delivering outsized shareholder returns; with that, I'll turn the call back to the operator so we can answer your questions. Operator?
Jonathan Andersen
analystCould you share a bit more detail on what underpins the U.S. consumer business outlook for 2024? Matt mentioned a baseline that assumes high single-digit expansion after a couple of years moving the other way. What assumptions sit underneath that around point-of-sale, volume, and price, especially since it sounds like price investment is coming in 2024 — and what has to occur for you to reach that target?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAll right. Across the whole business, volume growth is flat, okay? If you examine it — and I'd frame it as a major question. When I highlight risk, what I said is global events and whether the consumer appears. Jon, you basically nailed it: we've been losing altitude. I told the lawn team that simply halting the decline and climbing a little would count as a heroic step. But when you consider footsteps — and these are roughly average figures I'm picking up on from sales declines at DIY retail — the number cited was around 12%, 13%, and that's what we're treating as a broad average. So our message is that this remains unchanged. Now, what shifts in a favorable direction — and it's a positive that brings us back to holding altitude — is this. Retailers are giving a lot of attention to Lawn and Garden as a category. Along with cleaning and maybe one or two other relatively affordable categories, retailers are saying that's where they'll concentrate their efforts. So an enormous amount of activity is underway at retail to pull consumers into stores for spring. I see that as encouraging. For me personally, all the data is difficult, and I think I stay quite up to date on it. But the question of elasticity within lawn and seed is, I believe, genuine. It's tricky when someone presents sales here and pricing there. Inside that, you've got weather, many other variables, and a cautious consumer. So I'm not certain I trust everything people tell me, yet directionally, elasticity is a concern. We changed pricing on seed and fertilizers, and since making that move we're observing very strong results. Once more, I count this as a positive that helps us argue we can level this out. If that happens, it's a big win. I'm not ready to hand it over just yet. Beyond that, there's the emphasis we intend to place on it. We made a marketing change. We spend considerable time on who our consumers are and where the strength lies. Our core consumer is the healthiest one out there. These tend to be college-educated homeowners with more savings and more income. I think the excess savings from COVID are running out for most people. And what we and the retailers see in the data is that individuals will spend more time at home doing home projects. I consider that a positive for us. I'm not sure if I'm overlooking anything on leveling the core business, and that's the starting point. And again, after a 13% reduction in footsteps through the front door at many of our big retailers, okay? Then the question becomes why you think it can grow. We not only recognized this elasticity, but we also understand the pressure retailers face to bring people into Lawn and Garden. Some of them pushed us to help cover part of the cost. At a moment when we're working to rebuild margins, I wasn't exactly open-minded when the sales force and Mike Lukemire came to me on this. My response was, in exchange for what? The performance of our business — and this is a genuine compliment to our sales force — is that in a very difficult year, maybe a couple of years, our sales force and our ability to execute in stores, and what that builds in relationships, is extremely powerful. So when retailers say, we need some contributions to support this effort, and in return we'll give you listings you don't currently have, and promotions that previously went to others will come to you — we sized that out, and it's worth doing. We traded about 1/3 of what would have been an acceleration in margin improvement for this. But I personally think it's very much worth it. And that takes you into — so the entire gain comes from listings we didn't have before, priced out at volumes that were what they were with other people the year before, and promotions that didn't go to us but went to others, priced at exactly what they were at last year. That's how we arrived at these numbers. I think we had a substantial debate, and we could have it again if others want to discuss it, because gross margin and our revenue figures are probably the most interesting parts as we've been preparing for this call. We feel — and I think Nate and Josh, who are here, feel very confident in this. Josh, do you want to speak to it?
Executive
executiveNope. Jim, I believe you put that nicely. Truly — that expansion rests upon three core foundations, which we'd describe as additional listings, additional promotions, plus additional merchandising space inside the stores, and after that comes that elasticity element, which is the least significant portion. So as we examine the initial outcomes, the team holds a great deal of confidence in it, and our retail partners share that same view. They are projecting that growth too.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveDuring our preparation for this call, every one of us asked: what is the major danger if shoppers stay away? I'm not certain how large that danger will prove as we move ahead. Many writers, I believe, are discussing the way consumers have used up their extra pandemic-era savings, where that stands now, and the idea that folks will take fewer trips and remain at home more often. That strikes us as accurate, and we believe foot traffic dropped considerably during the prior year. Do we expect things to deteriorate further? Honestly, this is likely the point where certain very smart individuals might respond that yes, conditions could get worse. We aren't claiming there is zero risk, but what we are saying is that our stance on volume reflects careful consideration.
Matt Garth
executiveYeah, if we begin with POS remaining flat — that's the assumption — and then move on, it's exactly what Josh described that generates that upper-single-digit shift in the top line. The bigger issue Jim raised, honestly, I believe we'll hand that over to you: sizing what the downside might look like past flat POS, since the remaining pieces here — what we're pushing out as you continue through the other financial statements, in terms of margin expansion coming from cost reductions, operating-side enhancements, and smarter approaches to how we go to market, which Nate will address in a moment — all of that. Everything we're undertaking centers on those three things sitting before us: restoring stronger margins to generate EBITDA, the remaining $1 billion of free cash flow, and a strategic answer for Hawthorne. All of it begins with the top line. So having this degree of insight, confidence, and connection with our retail partners, who let us collaborate with them on these improvements, makes for a solid start to the year.
Jonathan Andersen
analystAbsolutely, that helps. I've got just one brief follow-up. Regarding the EBIT or operating income guidance you provided for '24, it came across as a bit unclear, at least to me. Was it 10.5% to 11% that you mentioned? If so, that implies roughly 250 to 300, or nearly 300, basis points of operating margin improvement in '24. Could you break that down a bit between gross margin and the SG&A ratio?
Matt Garth
executiveThanks, Jon. I'm glad you asked, since I intended to get to that topic eventually. You're correct. Once you work it out, gross margin will exceed 250 bps. What we've discussed before about achieving that has centered on Project Springboard, extra savings from greater volumes we anticipate from these new listings. Also, simply resolving our excess inventory situation and returning to a more typical production level during the second half of the year. All of that contributes to margin. Turning to SG&A, as we stated earlier, the company's long-term model ought to fall between 15% and 16%. For 2024, our guidance is a range of 14.5% to 15%. SG&A will be tighter in 2024. That doesn't mean reduced dollars in key areas; we're reallocating funds toward marketing, the sales force, and innovation. That's the overall outcome of everything we're doing to concentrate on those 3 areas.
Bill Chappell
analystI want to piggyback a bit on what Jon asked, and I don't mean to sound overly doubtful, but look — around this same point 12 months ago, your messaging sounded almost identical: retail partners were on board, it was going to be a fantastic year, you saw minimal exposure on the issue, customers were crazy about the category, and growth was coming. Then inside of 6 months, global warming got the blame, along with some other factors. So do you have any fresh data set? Any additional information? Or is this simply a belief that, hey, at this point last year, the shopper truly hadn't returned to roughly 2019 levels; and now we believe we're there, so it becomes easier to predict?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveFeels like you've been pounding your f****** wheaties. Where I'd begin is that we operate in a world containing shoppers and retail partners. Even though we sort of felt like heels 12 months ago, here's the reality. Volume climbed roughly 4.5 points, alright? Did we deliver what we set out to in Lawns, which was the entire point? No. So what I'd say is the place we stumbled was Lawns. Incidentally, I genuinely believe global warming plays into that; yet when we ask retail partners about 12 months ago, you know their response — I realize you folks figure it stinks. Lawn and Garden was fantastic for us, and in our view you folks performed wonderfully. So what I'd say first, Bill, is yeah, this is merely more of the same grind. I believe that — do I possess data supporting it? Where I'd begin is that we did possess data. For us it was a fairly strong year; the spot where we failed to resolve their problems is Lawns, and that carries weight. Still, when I consider the year, I say — and perhaps I ought to simply feel awful. Yet we got a tremendous amount done while under enormous pressure; and did we hit the revenue figures? Not quite. My sense is we managed it nearly everywhere besides lawns, and that's a sizable business; we're calling it flat — we — the marketing approach — choosing a new sort of worldwide agency for Scotts. Plus the push toward a far bigger partnership on the creative side, a top-tier creative crew at an agency that I just — we simply haven't put pen to paper. So that's — Matt's likely in the middle of things like...
Matt Garth
executiveNo, no. I'm not slowing that down.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveSo I believe that will be a big boost for us. Many of the adjustments we implemented came about because of the decline; and I'm not sure about you, but during the spring, we noticed — I noticed — quite a few ads from that early spring initiative we ran. And in places where the weather cooperated, Texas and Florida, the outcomes were outstanding, right? Meanwhile, conditions in the Northeast during that period weren't good, and we barely saw any POS at all; there are plenty of lessons in that. But what it demonstrates is that the advertising, paired with the promotion, when conditions are favorable, performed very well. Weather played a role there. I'm not saying the weather is at fault. I've been telling everybody on this call that if we're going to talk about what went wrong with lawns, the very first item — the most important one — has to be self-examination. So we'll take a look — we consider who our core customer is, and we've gone after the young, rising, soon-to-be homeowner very hard, and that's where the spread of our spending goes when it's put into social media. You'd want to rent a table at this event, and everyone there was maybe a bit older than that demographic. Not one of us noticed anything. And that was one of the factors behind why we changed things on the marketing side, all right? Going forward, we're taking a much more aggressive and inventive approach, zeroing in on our main customer while returning to fundamentals when it comes to spending. On that spending discipline, there's nothing revolutionary — and since it's roughly March Madness season — we're talking about traditional media, news and sports, and holding onto that rather than chasing consumers who are having a harder time affording a home now than at any point before, because of interest rates and the limited supply available in the market; I believe the information we've gathered on this is something we can definitely share with you. And our retail partners can do the same, if you're looking at those same consumers, since this is a commitment all of us share. Feel free to criticize us harshly—we've earned that. Still, I'd say we got quite a bit done this year. Looking at sales, the results aren't terrible. The weather played a role, and so did we. There were some promotion-related issues at retail, which likely hurt the Lawn business. That said, I believe our plan for this year is solid. We're not setting expectations very high—essentially flat for a business that's currently down roughly 30% compared with the two prior years. So we're not exactly aiming for a home run. My take is that we're returning to fundamentals—going back to what we're already familiar with. Nate, is there anything else you'd like to say?
Nate Baxter
executiveYeah. Yeah, definitely. It's great to have the chance to speak with everyone. So Bill, I suppose the question I'd pose is this: what's different in our approach compared with a year ago? Jim pointed to media and creative — for us, that represents a significant shift. Another piece, I'd say, is that our toolkit now holds more instruments. We've been growing our insights and data analytics group. That's something we're putting a lot of weight behind. Let me use weather as an illustration, okay? It truly comes down to results, not excuses. No question, it plays a role, but you won't catch us using it as an alibi. What we're attempting is to become smarter, applying predictive modeling along with machine learning so we can make adjustments. We demonstrated this during the fall. A horrible heat dome sat over the U.S. early in the fall, and the POS numbers showed what happened; we managed to shift certain media and targeting choices thanks to those models. So I don't want to lean on that too much, yet our operation has changed at a fundamental level, whether the topic is how we target marketing; and the major thing — I'll echo Jim here — is a focus on our core consumer. While we attempted to steer this digital transition, it's been difficult, and I believe we stopped seeing clearly who actually has money to spend right now. That's a significant shift; then when it comes to supply chain, we haven't discussed it much, but we've completed enormous optimization work, and I believe that simply aids us at the back end from a margin standpoint. So we're attempting to operate more cleverly than before; and I'll finish by saying — sure, it's an ambitious plan, but it's what I told the team internally yesterday; it presumes the consumer turns up in exactly the same manner as in '23. We aren't presuming the consumer will turn up more; there's a risk they could turn up less. But every one of these plans rests on that flat POS assumption; it's simply the new listings plus the promo gains that will help push volume.
Bill Chappell
analystUnderstood. And Matt, one more quick question, if I may, about the sort of top-line expectation for this year. I'm not sure, or I don't know whether you gave a figure for the fact that some shipments went out ahead of the usual timing, particularly during the March quarter. So I wasn't sure whether you — at the time you consider that high single-digit expansion across the whole year, I mean, what will the first half look like in terms of growth? Or does all of that expansion land in the second half?
Matt Garth
executiveYes. I mean, I believe Jim described somewhat the way seasonality played out a year ago compared with what we anticipate for 2024. And once you examine our historical averages, you'll notice revenue that's more normalized when comparing '24 with '23; so it will line up more closely with our past pattern. So yes, you would observe growth in the first half, since we are expanding in total, yet shipments as such would be spread more evenly throughout the year.
Joe Altobello
analystI have a couple of things, more like a point I'd like clarified, if that works. When you talk about the high single-digit increase for U.S. consumers that you anticipate during this year, how much of a drag from pricing is included in that figure?
Matt Garth
executiveRegarding gross margin, Jim noted that it accounted for roughly one-third of the effect. We've just gone over our expectations for where gross margins will land. As for the top line, though, that would have meant a decline in the low single digits; when I say low single digits, I mean something in the range of 1% to 3%.
Joe Altobello
analystThat makes sense to me too. Thanks for that. And perhaps as a follow-up on the gross margin topic. I believe you said it's up more than 250 basis points for this year. Given that a portion of that is driven by reduced input costs, how much visibility do you actually have on it? And at this stage, how much of it would you say is essentially secured?
Matt Garth
executiveYeah. No, that's a fair question. So when we break it down, there are several pieces involved. Our controllables are something we can see very clearly, and what I'm about to share with you, Joe, is likely over half. So all of what's coming from Springboard. Nate brought up supply chain. Perhaps you could expand on that a bit more, along with some of the optimizations we're pursuing throughout the remainder of the company; those items are, in your phrasing, secured. Roughly 50% of our raw material costs are secured. And based on what we've observed on the raw material side, that's <<inaudible>>, it's the one everyone likes to point to, it's — what we're observing is roughly 3/5 of what it was a year ago; so a benefit will be there. What remains open is a portion of the volume-related items at the high-single digits, you're capturing all of that. And once more, the high-single digits, we're describing as coming off a flat POS base, but the extra listings, the extra promos and merchandising we're securing and the inherent uplift plus some of the elasticity that's fueling that volume will help our operations side and assist us on a fixed cost leverage basis; that will add a bit under roughly 1/3 of the total there; so solid execution and securing the margin, volume is going to help us capture a portion of it.
Andrew Carter
analystRight. I'm not sure whether you mentioned this — my apologies if you did — but you referred to high single-digit consumer sales. What figure are you using for Hawthorne and other?
Matt Garth
executiveYeah, and I suppose I hinted at this near the start of what I said, though clearly I wasn't explicit enough. As you're aware, Hawthorne has a few advantages. By the end of the year we reached profitability. Revenue has steadied. We observed that in a daily rate over the course of the year. Throughout the year we removed quite a few of our distributed brands along with some of our proprietary brands to strengthen the portfolio as a whole. That will push sales down a little, so overall a very low single-digit figure for Hawthorne. So that's why I used that wording — we aren't yet seeing any shift in the trajectory of sales performance at Hawthorne or across the industry. Still, given those moves we've made in the business, it will be slightly down.
Andrew Carter
analystAll right. Then there's a second thing I'd like to ask, since you mentioned that what you're saying about Hawthorne involves seeking out a vertically integrated business, which caught my attention given that you hold an investment in a cannabis operator. In this case, are you aiming to do something with RIV to, say, reduce the risk tied to Hawthorne's earnings profile and split it off? Or are you still hitting the streets trying to bring more scale to Hawthorne within the hydroponics space?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveHitting the streets — we aren't in that much of a bind. We haven't reached the point of wandering the roads. Have we, Chris?
Chris Hagedorn
executiveThat's not how I'd put it.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveLet me tell you where I stand — this is what I've told the team, and I wish we had NDAs in place with you folks so we could fill you in. Honestly, I'd really like to hear what you think about how this is taking shape. But my starting point is Hawthorne, in that we can't remain here bucket. They've returned to profitability, and they will contribute. Chris, I believe, says maybe we can get out of mom-and-dad's basement, except what we're getting is basically a studio in a pretty shabby neighborhood. Reaching that point demanded enormous effort, and many people endured a lot along the way. There's likely no analyst who understands it better than you do. So you get it — the road here has not been easy. And this notion that, for us, we can't remain here; they are — luckily, I believe, others fall into that same bucket. The direction I've handed Chris and the team on this, Matt included, is this: I believe the business has to be comfortably above $1 billion. It has to deliver earnings in EBITDA terms of triple digits. Strategically, it has to matter. What I mean is it must carry some kind of theme; it also has to be big enough that people track it; and I do believe we've reached that point. And it isn't as though we are — I don't think we dominate. But when the stock sat in the 200s, in our view the consumer business along with Hawthorne were both fully valued. So separating them wouldn't have delivered any genuine gain. As I see it now — Hawthorne probably carries a negative valuation. It's underappreciated, and I don't mean that in the harshest sense, by our shareholders, or at least many of them, and they would prefer a solution in which it isn't part of Scotts. So those are roughly the priorities Chris is working to handle.
Chris Hagedorn
executiveAbsolutely. To expand on Jim's points and tackle your question as thoroughly as I can, Andrew: when we evaluate the possibilities for Hawthorne, everything we're looking at, I believe, entails taking it out of SMG in one way or another. There are numerous paths. As Jim noted, many businesses out there possess what I'd call solid fundamentals, yet have been hurt by an exceptionally harsh market decline, and they're seeking partners too. Some of these operate on the hydroponics equipment supply side, similar to Hawthorne, while others resemble RIV more closely. Now, I'll be careful here, since I'm clearly both an employee at Scotts and a board member at RIV. If a chance arose that worked well for RIV's shareholders as well as for SMG and Hawthorne, I'd be thrilled to imagine a scenario where those — I'll refer to them simply as 2 parts of our broader cannabis investment portfolio — I'd be thrilled to see them housed together. So should that chance come along, it's something we would, I believe, go after, or at minimum have interest in. At present, though, our emphasis remains on, once more, businesses we think — I'd frame it as 3 conditions: deals that deliver benefit and accretion to SMG and its shareholders; deals that help the operation we've established at Hawthorne, meaning they let us keep driving and backing matters such as innovation — specifically equipment innovation tied to lighting. That's an area, I believe, where we've achieved significant progress. I think the sector overall has gained from it, and we intend to keep that going. Then there are more forward-looking R&D bets, such as genetics, and finally, something that helps the industry at large. So those represent the 3 conditions. I believe plenty of deals exist that meet those requirements, and we're actively chasing several right now. As Jim mentioned, there's a great deal of compelling activity. I'd be glad to tell you more, but I expect we'll have far more to reveal in the coming months.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveLet me be upfront: we're not chasing anything out of desperation, and we're not stuck unable to decide — that situation was 3 years ago, and valuation is the key factor here. To me, this looks like a case where teaming up with someone makes sense. In past releases, I think our wording was something like cash free, or along those lines; the real point is that this is where we come together, we understand we'd be one of the partners, possibly leading to those shares being distributed to the Scott shareholders, but starting out — having ownership isn't a requirement. Nor is being in charge strictly necessary, though we do want to be a partner that's respected when it comes to how the business is run. When we talked about this company, and I think Matt had these points written down as we were getting ready—this started out being run by professionals, and that hasn't changed. We've got a professional management team that can add value here. And within this company, as you know, there are lots of distinct tiers, if you will, when it comes to professionalism. So in addition to these wonderful brands and this excellent R&D pipeline, we also have professional leadership that's used to what life is like at a public company and can bring something to this whatever co. I think that's quite thrilling. Now, as with any deal conversation, everybody we're talking to right now is excited. The issue isn't a lack of excitement. What matters is getting into the practical details and pinpointing the weaknesses in people's companies. There's one thing we understand about the way we're looking at this. Partly, it comes down to this — be it Hawthorne or RIV, it's completely unencumbered and puts no strain on anyone. As you're aware, I question whether any other company could make that assertion, so we believe we bring plenty to the table for these mergers. Regarding RIV, I can't offer an opinion on its behalf. Still, RIV holds what amounts to an extraordinary pile of money that simply isn't found elsewhere in this industry. That's why we're also excited, and we have a Board meeting scheduled for Friday to bring them up to date. I really have to hand it to Chris in particular, since in this situation we aren't dealing with a single counterparty — there are several of them involved. There are many possible combinations, which makes it messy. It can start to feel like a grind, I think, when you're juggling so many prospects and discussions, and the situation keeps shifting, moods shift, folks make poor decisions, and folks rehash disputes from the past. Still, here's my read: I'd wager that quite a few of the people we've talked with are listening in on this call as it happens, or they'll catch the replay afterward. If all parties are able to keep things in proportion, then working alongside others lets us build something quite distinctive. To me, that looks like a genuinely strong answer here, since a few of those operations stand to earn quite a bit, while what we hold is highly valuable and doesn't weigh on anyone's financial statements.
William Reuter
analystI've got 2 quick questions. First one — you sort of touched on this when answering the earlier question in Q&A. When it comes to how much additional shelf space or slotting you picked up because of the price cuts, can you give us any way to frame that?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveIt's fairly substantial. I'm not certain I want to, but if you take this business of $3-plus billion and you're referring to high single digits, which I'd call accurate — just do the multiplication and you'll arrive at a figure; and there's been — Matt has truly driven a process of really pressure testing this matter of how confident you all — how does the operating side feel about this.
Nate Baxter
executiveYeah, this is Nate. Honestly, the thing I appreciate about Matt is that he makes sure we stay accountable. What I'd say is we carried out a thorough bottoms-up effort, collaborating closely with retailers. That work isn't fully wrapped up yet. As many of you likely are aware, we'll complete it and simply make the call ahead of Thanksgiving; we've gotten through nearly every one of the operating plans, side by side, working on them alongside our retail partners. And like Jim mentioned, you can run the numbers yourself; even so, we feel quite good about those figures. And once more, what I'd put forward is that new listings along with promos and merchandising account for roughly the same share and make up most of it, while the remaining smaller portion comes from growth tied to price elasticity.
William Reuter
analystUnderstood. And you all did a fantastic job walking through how the marketing approach will shift regarding where those dollars get allocated. I just want to confirm I captured a few of the figures you provided accurately. Did you mention that marketing went up 50% during fiscal year '23? And then I believe you said it will rise even more in fiscal year '24. Did you attach any specific figures to that? I don't think I heard any...
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAlright, it's 25%, alright. That was the year that just wrapped up. I want to write more on my big whiteboard over here. This is where Matt has been tracking the movement in the '24 budget. He still had one more media figure listed there that has shifted since yesterday, but it's a positive; and so we're aiming to invest more money, but that will happen as we resolve matters toward the outcome we're pursuing, which I believe we told you is $575 million. And just to give a bit of clarity. $575 million is what we must hit for target incentive payout, alright? So I'm just — I'm giving you a figure that the whole management team is heavily incentivized around. The other figure is a — I'm not certain whether I said 50%, but essentially, it is above 50%, which involves taking funds that would have gone to digital and shifting them back into traditional media formats. So it's held at least at what we spent last year. If we're able to add more, that's what we're striving for and then a very major shift toward more, what I refer to as, traditional media since I think people label it analogue or linear, a term I find insulting as someone older because I likely fall into that group. I don't use a flip phone, though.
Nate Baxter
executiveOkay, Bill, let me just add something here. The main point isn’t really about boosting media spending by a large amount, even though we are hunting for money to do so. It’s about the way those funds will be used. Jim mentioned the new agency handling our account, along with our collaborators at Mediahub. How we deploy those dollars in the year ahead is going to look completely different from how we deployed them in the prior year. To my mind, that’s the more significant part of what’s happening with working media.
Analyst
analystI'd like to know what to anticipate regarding the increase in working capital across the coming 2 quarters, and whether you think cash will be produced from working capital over the rest of FY '24. Also, do you anticipate being able to completely repay the revolver at some point in 2024?
Matt Garth
executiveYeah. Our company experiences a typical seasonal expansion of working capital. Since we're a business with strong seasonal patterns, that's exactly what we'd anticipate. During the first quarter, our efforts go toward securing inventory so we can deliver it to retailers once the season arrives. As a result, you observe cash being consumed in the first quarter. After that, the largest working capital increase shows up in the year's second quarter; typically, inventory rises to a level that's 25% to 30% above where we currently stand. Along with accounts receivable as you progress through the first half of the year, that's the primary factor. So this pattern will happen again. The latter half of the year is when most of our free cash flow gets produced, and as I mentioned, during '23 essentially the entirety of our free cash flow came in Q4. What takes place in '24 should match that. We'll then apply that free cash flow toward reducing debt. Regarding which debt we select for paydown, you mentioned the revolver. There's also Term Loan B that we can use. Our senior notes are already in place and won't mature until the start of 2026, and that $250 million maturity is something we can handle. So options exist for us, though most likely the funds will go toward retiring whichever debt carries the greatest cost at that point, whether that's the revolver or the term loan base.
Nate Baxter
executiveI just want to mention that we're at the early planning stage for an investor field day. We'd love to have all of you come out, let's say, in late spring. So keep an eye out. With Matt and Jim and the rest of the team and me, I think quite a bit has changed here, and we'd like to share with you not just what's different operationally, but also some of the innovation we have in the pipeline. So watch for that.
Operator
operatorWe appreciate everyone joining us for today's call, and with that, the program wraps up. You're welcome to leave the line now.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.