The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company (SMG) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
February 7, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Aimee DeLuca
executiveHello, everyone. This is Aimee DeLuca speaking — I oversee Investor Relations for The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company. I'd like to welcome all of you to the earnings presentation and business update for our first quarter of 2024. As part of our review, forward-looking statements are going to be made. Kindly keep in mind that what actually happens could end up being materially different from the figures we present today. For a description of the complete set of risk factors that might affect our results, please look at our Form 10-K, which was filed with the SEC; beyond that, during our remarks, some non-GAAP financial measures will come up as well. Those measures are not meant to serve as a substitute for our GAAP results — rather, they ought to be read alongside them. Joining me on this morning's webcast are our Chairman, President, and CEO, Jim Hagedorn, along with our Chief Financial and Administrative Officer, Matt Garth. An overall business update will come first from Jim, and after that Matt will give a brief review of how we performed financially through the first quarter, plus what we expect for the entire year. Once the webcast wraps up, Chief Operating Officer Nate Baxter and Hawthorne Division President Chris Hagedorn will be joining Jim and Matt for a Q&A session that will be audio-only. If you'd like to hear that Q&A, all you have to do is stay on this webcast. Should you want to pose a question, we ask that you pre-register through the audio link that was shared in our press release, where you'll find call-in details along with a unique PIN. Be advised that a recording is being made of today's session. A version will be archived and made available on our website at investor.scotts.com. If you'd like to continue the discussion once the call has ended, you're welcome to reach out to me by email or phone. Now, let's begin with the business update from Jim.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveHello, everybody, Jim Hagedorn speaking. I'm sitting in my office located in Marysville, Ohio. We're opening up so you can meet the folks who make this company run. We'll also walk through some visuals and charts that should give you a clearer picture of what we're doing. This company means a lot to us, and the clearer we are about who we are, the easier it is for you to get behind our perspective. Let me start by saying how happy I am with where we've gotten and where we're going. We're not in the same spot we were a year ago. We're operating this business the way it ought to be run, and that's a positive. A great deal of credit belongs to the management team, and that group is completely different than it was roughly 12 months back. This team has put together a strong plan for 2024 and is building excellent strategies for 2025 and beyond. They're coming together and collaborating effectively, which is also a positive. All of us are united around driving top-line growth, keeping a tight grip on expenses, and hitting the fiscal 2024 targets I laid out on our previous call, and Matt will get into that later. Genuine progress is happening daily, and during fiscal 2024, here's what needs to get done: achieve meaningful improvement in gross margin, boost spending on marketing, sales, R&D, and our other strongest competitive advantages, keep producing robust free cash flow, and direct most of that cash flow toward a substantial cut in our debt and leverage ratios while continuing to pay the quarterly dividend. Q1's results offer an early sign that we're headed the right way. POS climbed more than 8% in both dollars and units, and we gained 300 basis points of unit market share in key categories. That lift comes from conservative yet favorable pricing moves, plus extended fall promotions and media investment across Scotts and Tomcat. SG&A fell 11%, which came from successfully balancing cost control against investments in high-value programs and initiatives. Free cash flow, gross margin, and net sales all beat our operating plan, positioning us well as we head into the peak of our Q2 load-in. Regarding Q1 sales, I want to stress that how sales flowed last year doesn't tell you how retailer load-in will unfold this year; we're returning to a more typical load. Retailers are pleased about that, and we are too. Inventories look healthy, and order flows remain strong through Q2. We're positioned where we should be. There's plenty to feel optimistic about in our consumer business. Everything keeps confirming our outlook for high single-digit growth. A large share of that growth traces back to the top-to-bottom relationship we share with our retail partners. It's common knowledge that retailers have been pressing vendors to lower prices. We agree that as commodities soften, consumer prices ought to decline; in fact, our fertilizer and grass seed products had gotten quite expensive last year. We didn't observe any trading down as a result of our pricing. They chose to leave instead, taking the position that their yards were fine as they were. For buyers, price clearly carries weight, and for us, margins carry weight. Coming out of the post-COVID stretch, we saw our margin shrink. As best we can determine, merchants exited that stretch sitting on much fatter margins, while ours fell by roughly the same magnitude. Our goal is a major margin rebound, and that begins with no less than 250 basis points in the current year; that constrains how far we can cut prices. Until our margins return to the usual mid-30% range, we simply can't take part in many cost-outs. The encouraging part is that merchants grasp why we must pair price cuts with margin gains, since what we put into brands, sales, and innovation benefits lawn and garden along with the category's expansion. That's what our arrangement with them rests on; in return for lower prices on certain high-margin fertilizer, grass seed, and soil SKUs, we receive added merchandising chances through new listings and more shelf space; those moves will feed incremental volume gains. A portion of the growth will come from lower prices too, some of which we enacted last fall and will broaden in the spring. We know that cheaper pricing did generate incremental POS last fall. Now to spring. Since durable sales and foot traffic are under pressure at retailers, lawn and garden matters enormously to their growth, and this is territory that belongs to us; we'll put heavy investment behind our brands and sales support to fuel engagement and takeaway. That covers high-impact programming and creative, sharply targeted engagement with our core consumers, messaging voiced by influential celebrities who carry credibility with consumers, and heavy repetition beginning in March across mass media, television, streaming platforms, cable entertainment, and radio tied to major sporting and news events. What our spending and approach deliver is considerable. Every brand will hit its target core consumer audience no fewer than 17 times; working media has risen substantially versus last year. Miracle-Gro will receive 80% more marketing support, and working alongside Bayer, Roundup will spend 20% more. For Scotts, we'll shift when our advertising and promotions run to get better lift. We'll direct 33% more of our spend toward peak weeks for Scotts. Backing this advertising push are strong creative and celebrities. Miracle-Gro has a thrilling new tie-up with home and garden icon Martha Stewart. She's a multi-generational talent who embodies gardening and stands as the most genuine and influential figure in the field. Martha uses our products with enthusiasm and genuinely believes in Scotts Miracle-Gro. On lawns, we'll extend the success of our Scott for Scotts campaign, featuring Kristofer Hivju of Game of Thrones. Our data indicates that creative approach generated strong awareness and breakthrough, which are essential for our seasonal business. The major expansion of this year's campaign features the debut of Scotts Healthy Plus Lawn Food. It delivers better lawn condition across all seasons by preventing and treating disease, plus fertilizer that produces deep greening. Summer Guard is being phased out in favor of this item, which opens up a broader window for application and adds incremental POS possibilities. When it comes to sales, nobody beats us — full stop. So we'll keep putting money into our field sales team, and our merchandiser count is up 10% versus last year. We've combined the strength of our sales force with Bonnie's team to drive attachment. Other incremental wins can come from innovation. Miracle-Gro is introducing a significant new organics line this year, and we'll push the new healthy fertilizer hard later in the season. Hawthorne generated positive cash flow in fiscal 2023 and will do so again in 2024. Across these two years, it's tracking to be cash flow positive by over $120 million. Hawthorne plays a big role in paying down our debt. Our approach to this business has two parts. The first is near-term profit enhancement and cash flow generation. Hawthorne holds the industry's finest brand portfolio, and we keep reshaping its product line to emphasize the higher margin, more profitable Signature portfolio that Hawthorne owns.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveThe second thing is the long-term answer for getting back as much as we can from what we put into Hawthorne, while also unlocking what it's worth down the road once the market develops. We are looking at ways to create value and possible partnerships, which we anticipate will come together in stages, particularly as things move forward on the regulatory side. On the federal level, we're getting nearer to moving cannabis to Schedule III, which would make the justice system fairer and cut taxes for plant-touching businesses by more than 50%. That could serve as a big catalyst for growers to put money back into their operations. The SAFER Banking Act being adopted is also a possibility, and it would open the door for the industry to obtain ordinary bank capital. Those are potentially meaningful tailwinds for Hawthorne. Ahead of our yearly shareholder meeting last month, we contacted shareholders about proxy matters and to get their general thoughts; they said they were happy with the progress we've made. They asked whether we might speed up our recovery by roughly 12 months. Matt and I keep refining our multi-year financial strategy. At the corporate level and within the operating teams, there's agreement on what the financials ought to look like. Let me lay out what you should expect: top-line growth of 3% each year, gross margin sitting in the mid-30% range, and free cash flow being directed at paying down debt, which opens up financial flexibility along with actions that benefit shareholders. Later this year, we'll share more details about our long-term financial plans. Another encouraging sign is that consumers are engaged. Recent surveys show they intend to participate at levels that stay consistently high. A reminder to all: we outperformed the category in fiscal 2023 and during this last quarter. All of our current efforts serve as the building block of the future, and that's what grounds our optimism. In closing, my thanks go out to everyone for their support, commitment, and hard work. Above all, I appreciate everyone's shared confidence in Scotts Miracle-Gro and our goal of enabling individuals, no matter their age, to make their own patch of land their own. That serves as a reminder that our work holds significance for people, the planet, and neighborhoods. Thanks — now I'll hand things over to Matt.
Matt Garth
executiveThanks, Jim, and good morning, everyone. I want to begin with a bit of context on where the first quarter sits within our overall year. Normally, Q1 accounts for under 15% of our yearly POS and sales. Still, it gives us an early read on how closely we're following our plan. This is the period that sets the groundwork for the beginning of our season and offers valuable insight into how our store sets, load-in, and advertising are shaping up. Season readiness is what we're concentrated on at the moment, and I can report that thanks to how our marketing, sales, and supply chain teams have executed, we're in a solid position. Overall, our first-quarter 2024 results exceeded expectations, with the U.S. Consumer business performing strongly enough to offset softer Hawthorne revenue. In the U.S. Consumer segment, point-of-sale dollars and units each increased 8% year over year. This performance was supported by a solid fall season and by pricing elasticity that, while cautious, proved favorable for important categories including fertilizers and soils. The key takeaway is that consumer involvement remains healthy. As for invoice sales, they fell short of Q1 2023, but we had forecast that, and it aligns with our view that this first quarter's shipments would look like the historical pre-COVID norm. To revisit that point, the shipment anomaly happened a year ago, during a period when we loaded in heavily and early alongside our retail partners. The key takeaway is that we're taking forceful action on the things we can influence, and that puts us on a path back toward more typical operations. Turning now to the quarter itself: companywide net sales were down 22% versus the first quarter of last year. Hawthorne saw a 39% decrease, while U.S. Consumer came in 17% lower. As before, the decline in U.S. Consumer is attributable to the shifted shipping schedule. Following a robust first quarter POS, retail inventories are in a solid position for the second quarter load-in. During the first quarter, units in retailer inventory ended lower by a low double-digit percentage compared with a year earlier, and that is consistent with what we planned. At Hawthorne, the sales trend has been similar to the pattern we saw as last year came to a close. There isn't any improvement in the broader market that we can cite, but the team continues to execute its approach of trimming the product lineup down to fewer brands that are more profitable; that reduces the top line while raising overall margins; to date, this effort has brought Hawthorne's portfolio mix up to 77% Signature versus distributed brands, compared with 65% a year ago. Now, on the full year outlook, we are reaffirming our guidance of high single-digit growth in the core U.S. Consumer business. At first, we projected that Hawthorne's net sales would decline by a low single-digit percentage across the entire year. We are now reviewing that forecast. Let me be clear: we'll keep making changes aimed at reaching break-even or better Adjusted EBITDA for this segment. Those changes are already producing results. Jim mentioned that this segment generates positive cash flow. On top of that, Signature Brands is selling at a pace that's expanding two times faster than distributed brands. A few more first-quarter observations: gross margin was 400 basis points above where it stood in the prior-year period. Consumables made up 400 basis points more of the mix than durables, finishing at 54%. Because the business is shifting so quickly and given the steps we're already taking, we're preparing an update to guidance for you. That will cover where things stand in our talks with prospective partners as we work to reshape the company and maximize shareholder value. Let's now turn to gross margins. For the whole company, the adjusted gross margin rate on a year-to-date basis finished the quarter at 13.7% of sales, compared with 20.1% a year earlier. The decline came from reduced volumes and absorption across both operating segments, plus sales of inventory that cost more. Our expectation remains that the adjusted gross margin rate for the full year will climb by no less than 250 basis points as we capture meaningful Project Springboard savings, bring distribution costs down, and push a better segment and product mix. We also look for material costs and fixed cost leverage to get modestly better as we move toward the second half of the year, once we've moved through roughly $275 million of pricier inventory, most of which sits in the U.S. Consumer business. Fiscal 2025 will give us additional runway to lift the total company gross margin rate once production is back at full levels, generating fixed cost leverage and delivering the benefit of cheaper inventory. Right now, commodity-sensitive materials are roughly 65% locked for the year, while total cost of goods sold is roughly 70% locked, which gives us reasonably solid visibility for the rest of the year. Moving to SG&A, the first quarter fell 11% from Q1 a year ago and 26% on a two-year basis; that speaks to the progress of Project Springboard along with substantial cuts to headcount and project spend. Our outlook for company SG&A expenses remains 15%-16% of net sales for this year and beyond. As Jim mentioned, we're moving part of those savings into efforts that create value. Among them are U.S. Consumer investments aimed squarely at brand marketing, set to rise $10 million, or 12%, versus a year ago to back the media strategy. Interest expense matched last year, and our expectation is that it stays level for the full year, since the gain from lower net debt is canceled out by higher interest rates. As of the close of the first quarter, 72% of interest rates are fixed through a mix of long-term fixed rate notes and interest rate swap agreements. Keep in mind that $2.2 million of other income and expense relates to the new accounts receivable sale facility. On an adjusted basis, our effective tax rate came in at 29.5% for the quarter, and for the full year we're looking at an ETR somewhere in the 29% to 30% range. That brings the P&L to a close. Net loss for the quarter stood at $81 million, equal to $1.42 per share on a GAAP basis. A year ago, the comparable figure was a loss of $65 million, or $1.17 per share. When you adjust for impairment, restructuring, and other non-recurring items, the loss was $82 million, or $1.45 per share. In the same period last year, the adjusted loss was $56 million, or $1.02 per share. For the quarter, our non-GAAP Adjusted EBITDA came in at a loss of $26 million, versus income of $21 million during the same period last year. The main drivers were reduced volume along with lower gross margin rates across both of our operating segments. That drop is mostly connected to the phasing we've previously discussed, and we are reaffirming our full-year EBITDA target for the total company of $575 million. Turning to the balance sheet, we ended the quarter with net leverage of 7.2x Adjusted EBITDA, which leaves us comfortably below the covenant ceiling of 8.25x. Given the seasonal patterns we usually see, we anticipate that working capital requirements and the leverage tied to them will reach their highest point at the close of Q2, at which time our covenant ceiling will sit at 7.75%, then move to 6.5x for Q3 and 6x for Q4. Keep in mind that we anticipate finishing the year well under the maximum covenant, in the fours. Our liquidity position is solid, with more than $1 billion of capacity available through our revolving credit and AR sales facilities as we enter Q2. The $3 billion of debt outstanding at quarter end marks a $384 million decrease compared with a year earlier, driven by lower working capital needs and a reduction in inventories we had previously purchased. Looking ahead to fiscal 2024, we've set capital expenditures at $70 million, which is over $20 million lower than what we spent in fiscal 2023, and most of those projects should deliver strong returns on invested capital. Our free cash flow is being put toward reducing debt and keeping our quarterly dividend steady. As I noted earlier, we expect free cash flow to reach or surpass $560 million, which brings us to $1 billion total across two years, supported by consistent yearly free cash flow above $300 million, along with one-time gains and net working capital balances. Just to reiterate, every initiative at Scotts Miracle-Gro is focused on creating value. Our 2024 goals are what this all ties back to: bringing in $575 million of Adjusted EBITDA by growing the top line, improving gross margin rate by 250 basis points, and keeping a firm grip on SG&A. We also aim to produce $560 million in free cash flow, which wraps up the two-year $1 billion target. Part of that means getting total company inventory down to where it stood in fiscal 2019 — roughly $600 million. The cash this generates lets us pay down $350 million or more in debt while still keeping our quarterly dividend. And we need to figure out a path for Hawthorne that takes advantage of where the industry is heading and delivers the greatest possible value to shareholders. Each of these goals is seeing real advancement from us, and through that work we're building a foundation for lasting value for shareholders. A couple of final points. First, you'll find a summary of our full-year outlook in the appendix of the presentation today. Second, I look forward to giving you our Q2 update at the Raymond James 45th Annual Institutional Investors Conference on March fourth in Orlando, Florida. With that, we're ready to take your questions. Thanks.
Joe Altobello
analystThank you. Hi, everyone. Good morning. For the first question — I realize this is a lighter quarter — could you perhaps walk through what's fueling that 8% POS increase? And then, as a follow-up, does the guidance for the entire year remain roughly flat, or is it also getting better?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveYou're asking whether the outlook for the whole year is —
Matt Garth
executivePOS.
Joe Altobello
analystPOS, that's right.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveIn the high single digits — that's what we're still projecting.
Matt Garth
executiveYeah.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveYep. But look, here's the thing. I've said pretty openly that the way we spent our marketing support money in Q4 really bothered me. There's a narrative that came out of the fall saying it worked. I'm not buying it. Joe, my take is that we'd begun cutting deals with retailers to take some cost out, especially on their lawn products, their seed products, and I believe some dirt products too. Those prices kicked in during the fall. As for the fall promotion, I think it got extended in a way that was mostly good — largely the retailers, you know — but the price adjustments are what truly delivered. If someone asked me what caused that, my answer would be: effective retail promotions. Our team members were executing their responsibilities, ensuring inventory was available and set to sell. However, the markdowns took hold quite quickly. When you hear what Matt and I have said, you'll notice references to price elasticity and pricing changes—those were downward pricing moves that formed part of the merchandising strategies we were building for 2024. Those new prices became active in stores, and in my view they performed very successfully. That's essentially what took place.
Matt Garth
executiveSo Joe, if you look at the specific year-over-year shifts in Q4, that 8% POS increase — like Jim mentioned — came from a couple of things. Yes, some elasticity worked in our favor, which was positive, and also the expanded placements with our retail partners that kicked off during Q4. You're going to see those really accelerate as we get into Q2. Now for the whole year, keep in mind what we guided to: high single digits top-line growth for the company, and that's made up of POS at the core consumer level remaining fairly flat compared to last year. The primary things driving it are those expanded placements — new listings and new promotions we're picking up. Price is going to decline, that trend persists, and we've already observed it in Q1. You saw that, but elasticity is offsetting it. That still puts us in the high single digits range.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveWe're continuing to build our gross margins up by no less than 250 basis points. So honestly, we're feeling quite positive about that. When you take a look at the share during Q1, I believe that likewise reflects, you know, a variety of merchandising programs over at the retail level.
Joe Altobello
analystUnderstood. That's quite useful. Perhaps we can turn to Hawthorne now. Clearly, the revenue outlook is still being evaluated, but since you kept the EBITDA target at $575 million without change, has your view regarding that segment's profitability shifted?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveThis is my take. I believe I read your note this morning, and we pulled guidance, which I somewhat regret, because profitability is going to be greater, all right? Margins are going to improve, and the cash flow goals remain untouched by anyone. That's an area we've been. And that's the thing I emphasized during my presentation; therefore, I'm not certain whether you stated profits are flat or increased. Cash flow matters and is vital for the company, and they're currently in the midst of attempting to determine our go-to-market approach; and when you examine what's occurring with, I believe, what's referred to as our Signature Brands, which are our own brands, the business is performing quite well. So I think it's the distributed brands that we're transitioning away from, and I believe what you're observing in those figures is partly just non-recovery. And so I think we can't really conceal that, which is, you know, the... I'm not sure, did I employ that phrasing? It appeared in my script, that the market recovery is elusive or similar. What might have been in the annual meeting script is that the recovery in hydroponics stays elusive, but it's being intensified by the reality that we're making decisions about what we promote and sell. Anything to add, Chris?
Chris Hagedorn
executiveYes, absolutely. So, as Jim mentioned — and Jim already touched on this — the decline in revenue, I believe, is really just the outcome of us closely examining the portfolio and making choices that matter for our company, so we can concentrate on brands and products that bring us greater profitability. In many or most instances, those happen to be our Signature items. So it comes down to trimming down what we offer, ensuring we're selling brands we can earn solid margins on and give proper backing to, and evaluating the business's health from that perspective.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveWell, Joe, from where I sit, there's no question that the operating team — Chris, Tom, and all the men and women working alongside them — are boosting how profitable this business is. Part of that comes from the decisions they're making to be the strongest Hawthorne possible, given where things stand today. I remain optimistic about the business, and I believe I've said as much before — the reality is that a large share of what we do, in fact the largest piece, is lighting. So when we discuss shifting toward consumables and moving away from durables, what that really means is there's simply a shortage of capital available to upgrade these grow facilities. Say we reschedule to 3 — let's just take that as a given. In my view, it's moved from HHS over to DEA. The President is behind it. Based on what you've read, and the politics around it, it looks to us like it's probably going to go through. It's not as though it's flawless — Schedule III isn't some ideal answer — but the thing it accomplishes is resolving the 280E problem. Rather than facing tax rates above 80%, you drop back to something like, I don't know, the 20s, let's call it, at the federal level. That would free up — that would meaningfully lift the profitability of legal growers, and that's, well, that's a substantial sum of money. And if SAFE Banking — which, I'd say the Senate side looks favorable, the House is tougher to call right now, though I believe it's cleared the House many times — SAFE Banking, meaning access to capital, the kind of real bank capital, at reasonable rates, which is likely about half of what folks in the alternative credit market are seeing today. Both of those developments together would be genuinely positive, and we think there are years of overdue capital investment needed in these grow facilities, and I believe this will be very good for the business. My worry — and here it is — is that Chris and Tom and the teams there want to be good citizens, and they aren't playing games when it comes to doing what they believe is necessary to improve the profitability of the business. You could hear that and think, "Well, obviously, that's a wonderful thing." What concerns me is that we don't squander what truly matters on the innovation front, and much of that lies in lighting and nutrients, how these products get used, all the supplies that feed into it, genetics — these are genuinely critical pieces of the future. This sector finds itself in an extremely strange, synthetic, and essentially politics-dominated situation, one in which anybody operating lawfully is unable to turn a profit. Consequently, I'd say, what lies ahead matters a great deal for it. That, then, is the friction that persists between myself and the group running operations. I can't say for certain. My sense is that Matt sits somewhere between the two sides.
Matt Garth
executiveHonestly, I've got to say — the way you just walked through all of that, plus the discussions we've been having amongst ourselves, I believe it makes sense to let everybody in on it. We issued a long-range framework for what Scotts Miracle-Gro is, correct? Top-line growth of 3%, and we can dig into the details of that, with margins returning to the thirties. Hawthorne basically never came up; the reason being that an enormous amount of future potential is sitting there, and for the most part, it's essentially being overlooked right now — overlooked in our equity, overlooked in other companies' equities — and that's simply how things look in a setting where earning money is extremely tough. And as we mentioned, being able to deploy capital into that market — really tough at the moment; so as you go forward, opportunity is everywhere, but figuring out the correct moves and getting them in place right now is, well, it's difficult. Still, one thing is certain: whether we're talking about the Scotts framework or the Hawthorne framework, putting money into what lies ahead — the areas we understand, new ideas, promotion, our sales team — all of that delivers returns.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveJoe, I apologize for taking so long to respond, but this is a topic we've discussed extensively. A board meeting took place last week. As you know, we tend to believe in what's ahead, while Chris and Tom are dealing with the present reality, which leans toward the shorter view. That doesn't mean that's their preference, but I think they, well, they've got to function within our family here, within our community, and they'd like to contribute to it. Now, you know, that section of the script where we discussed cash flow — which is, you know, across 2 years, in excess of $120 million of free cash flow coming out of Hawthorne — that's a huge factor when it comes to debt. They're not total scoundrels, and this business is going to improve. And we've got a lot of, I suppose you'd say deal making, but we've got a lot of things we can't actually discuss at this moment, but you're going to begin to see them. I simply don't want the business to turn into what I keep telling them is a circus curiosity, where we let ourselves get small enough that we become somewhat irrelevant, and the things that will drive value going forward, we allow to slip away.
Chris Hagedorn
executiveOkay, and look — this is an earnings call, sure, but here we are, so I'm not a complete scoundrel. Let me be clear: the decisions Tom, the team, and I are making — acting as responsible corporate citizens while bringing an appropriate degree of profit back into the company — I believe we've made those with a strong sensitivity to what has set Hawthorne apart and made it special, and frankly the most successful player in hydroponics up to now, and we have zero desire to give any of that up. And what are those things? Innovation, the money we've invested behind our brands and our salespeople, and the effort we've undertaken alongside Scotts on the government relations front to help drive some of that rescheduling change Jim mentioned. So we care a great deal about preserving those elements of the company we consider distinctive and that must stay that way for Hawthorne to keep being what it was — and I'd argue still is, regardless of how the numbers came out. So we're working to make deliberate, thoughtful decisions. That said, there's a tension and a trade-off there, one I'd call healthy, between simply hitting some minimum level of near-term profit and not giving up what the company could become down the road. And as Jim said, that's really going to come through partnerships we aren't able to discuss just yet, but which we believe carry enormous potential to carry us through this stretch while — once more — not turning into scoundrels.
Analyst
analystHey, thanks. Good morning — Andrew here, filling in for William. I just wanted to ask a quick question, and maybe I'm splitting hairs on the SG&A guidance you gave. I believe you mentioned 15 to 16. My recollection was 14.5 to 15 last quarter. So did that shift come from something like extra marketing spend or similar, and would it require a stronger US consumer profit performance in your model, and did that play into the higher advertising? Thanks.
Matt Garth
executiveGood catch. We expect to finish at the lowest point of the 15%-16% band. That ties into how we're constructing the company's long-term model, which calls for 15%-16% of sales, returning to that typical conversational cadence. But as you noted, we'll be at the very bottom of that band, and it does factor in the items we've discussed. Sales should rise this year. SG&A dollars should also rise this year. The main forces behind that are our three priority areas: marketing, innovation, and our sales force. For all the other costs sitting in SG&A, our goal is to hold them steady or bring them down. That frees up space to keep that share of sales down, both right now and over the long run, and it lets us fund the higher spending in the places that create value for the company.
Analyst
analystThanks. For my follow-up, since you mentioned that Signature Brands now accounts for 77% of Hawthorne, I suppose the first thing is, can you help us understand the path to 30%? I'm not certain whether you'll separate that out. Could you share the margin gap between U.S. Consumer and Hawthorne, and likewise between Signature and distributed? The other part is: do you still believe there's worth in remaining in the third-party distribution segment? My sense is that when Sunlight was acquired back in 2018, much of the rationale involved visibility for gaining additional scale, but does that value still hold given how the category has shifted across the last six years? Thanks.
Matt Garth
executiveYes, and Andrew, I think, look, we, we don't disclose much of what you just requested, but let me, let me offer some trajectory here. At present, the company's overall margins largely mirror those of the U.S. Consumer business. And per our full-year guidance, that will remain true too. Hawthorne, during the prior year, when you observed an EBITDA loss around $48 million, shifting toward break even or profitability, and as Chris mentioned, they're pushing toward profitability, that will generate some positive gross margin, which is going to land in the sort of call it mid-single digits. And that isn't guidance. Don't model that out. It's a way point for where that business ought to be, which is far nearer to the overall corporate margins, though that will require time. So that's sort of laying the road on the margin side. You raised plenty of questions about certain decisions Chris and the team have made, so I'll have Chris address that.
Chris Hagedorn
executiveRight, Andrew. So it's not as if we have no interest at all in distributing brands that belong to other companies. What matters to us is earning a return on the effort we put in. And the truth is, there were quite a few brands — several within this category, actually — a portion of which we continue to distribute and a portion of which we've stopped distributing, that delivered margins for us that were incredibly thin, at zero, or even below zero. Now, back when we completed the Sunlight deal, and during that surge of growth we experienced across 2020 and 2021, those items did things like raise the size of the basket and assist us in certain other respects. Once the category contracted, those factors simply shifted for us. So it isn't really that we hold a philosophical objection to distributing goods made by third parties — it's that we need programs in place that let us earn a profit on those goods. And on that front, we've run into difficulties. Now, clearly, whenever possible, I'd say our top preference is to collaborate with third-party vendors on building programs where there's sufficient profitability for the vendor, obviously, the manufacturer, for us, and for the retailer in the end, while staying competitive. But with things having tightened up, I think we've been pushed into some hard decisions. So, to repeat, profitability is where our attention is, and without going into specifics, it's obvious that our Signature portfolio earns considerably more than the large majority of what we distribute.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveOkay, so Andrew, this is Jim. To start, I thought that question was genuinely a good one. Alright, I'm not certain we're fully prepared to give an answer on that. And I believe that once we hopefully make announcements soon about new relationships, it will begin to make sense; but since we have been looking for partners for Hawthorne, for a kind of strategic scale, well, we've spoken with, I'd say, the usual suspects. The issue is, everyone wants to accomplish the same objective. No one is asking for an expanded assortment — quite the opposite. Almost every conversation we have centers on one shared aim: trimming the number of SKUs, lifting gross margin, and carrying less stock. That was a strong question, honestly. My guess is you'll get a lot more detail on this, maybe two calls from now or the one right after, once things start coming into focus. As we geared up for today, we've tried to be pretty clear about our intentions, and I don't want anyone to take away the wrong impression from our comments or from where we currently stand. What I can tell you with confidence at this moment is that Hawthorne plays a major role in this cannabis operation, especially when it comes to supply. For us, and for any others we might team up with, figuring out the answers there is like solving a jigsaw — and it appears to be quite a bit more tangled than that. So here's part of my message: I don't want folks to think, "You make a statement, then you reverse it, then you make it again, then you reverse it again." That's simply not what's happening. The situation is essentially a puzzle we're still working through alongside other key players in the industry, attempting to land on an approach that benefits everyone involved. That said, meaningful headway has been made. So all I can really say is that an announcement isn't possible at this moment, and I believe that, regarding... Through our connection with RIV, we do have portions of our operation that involve touching the leaf. My sense is that movement is happening on both sides of the business in ways that folks will likely find intriguing and quite striking. However, when it comes to certain of those matters, we're still sorting through the remaining pieces and figuring out how to get it done. Plus, we aren't tackling this jigsaw solo—we're working on these jigsaws alongside others, and the outcome needs to work for them too. That said, I'd call it solid movement, and right now Chris, Tom, Matt, and Dimitar are each performing at a high level, which is impressive. It's also something where I get to engage a bit with them, mostly around where this is all headed. And, well, I'm not sure. Truthfully, it can be hard. Sometimes it comes across almost like rapid-match dating. Even so, we understand exactly what Hawthorne represents, and if you look back briefly at the choices we made around distribution, that really comes down to the near term, along with profitability — and inside that Rubik's Cube, Hawthorne's profitability carries huge weight when you're in that sort of dating, you know, dowry situation. Dowries always matter. So that's another thing pushing some of this, which is that you have to live in today's world, because when you're working through the Rubik's Cube puzzle, the folks on the opposite side are completely living in the same crappy world as everyone else. So when you bring up something, people are glad about it, instead of, like, scratching their head and going, "What?" You know. So plenty of solid work is going on and, you know, like, that's just a good question.
William Carter
analystThank you. I'll hand it over.
Jonathan Andersen
analystHello, good morning to all of you.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveHey there.
Jonathan Andersen
analystI'd like to switch topics back to the consumer side, U.S. Consumer. In Q1, did sales come in as expected versus your plan? Also, I've gotten a lot of questions regarding the full-year guidance, which implies roughly 10% volume growth. That growth, as I understand it, rests on new listings, but why should we assume that new listings — a fourth facing of the same item, let's say — would be as incremental as the listings you had 12 months ago? So could you discuss how Q1 went relative to budget, and then explain why the volume guidance is sensible when it comes to incrementality, if indeed it's purely listings driven? Thanks.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveOkay. I'll kick things off, and then I think Nate can take over, and Matt can fix anything we got wrong. North America exceeded expectations in Q1. That one's easy. They beat their numbers quite handily, so that's good. On the believability of the numbers, first off, I'm not certain we're saying double digits. My understanding is we're saying high single digits. But look, we don't need to argue about it. I don't know the exact figures — 8, 9, something in that neighborhood is probably what I believe they are. Jon, I'd begin by noting that we know precisely what we're taking over, okay? So these aren't truly new listings; they're listings that people previously had and that we acquired, where we knew exactly what the volume was. So there isn't really any guessing involved; this is simply what it was worth, and now it belongs to us, okay? And it isn't only new listings, because it's extra promotional support for things that weren't promoted previously. We have products like that, where they advertise something else and don't advertise it. So you get promotional support, which is their own advertising, plus discounts and promotional periods, where we had none before, or it's incremental on top of what we already had; so if we did have promotion, there's more. And I think those numbers — I won't, you know, I know people say, "What?" But our view is that this is just straightforward, meat and potatoes translation. That's not — I don't think anyone's being overly. If anything, I think they're probably conservative. But I don't know. Baxter?
Nate Baxter
executiveRight, John, if I could just add a note about the first quarter. The 300 basis points of growth we recorded were concentrated in three categories: rodents, fertilizers, and certain selective weed products. We enjoyed a solid extension into the fall. I realize Jim wasn't happy with how the fall started, yet remarkably, once October 1 arrived, a combination of promotions, media, and weather produced the lift we were looking for. As for the growth we anticipate across the year, consider the breadth of new listings. Beyond extra shelf space for items already on shelves, we have Healthy, we have Miracle-Gro Organics, we have full distribution of Bayer's new Dual Action Roundup, we have a fairly substantial gain in private label soils, and we also have our new Max fertilizer line. So in addition to more shelf space for existing listings, we truly have a robust pipeline of new innovation heading to market. I'll hand things to Matt for any closing remarks, though I believe we feel quite confident. And once more, echoing Jim, our plans were constructed bottoms up alongside the retailers, so this isn't a guess — it's a partnership with our retail partners.
Matt Garth
executiveThat is, that is really strong focus on the final item there. Thank you, Nate. So purely from a modeling standpoint, for all of you, let's ground ourselves in a couple of items. Our expectation for POS, that plan question, was roughly +5%. During Q1, we ended up at +8%; so that is, that is positive, correct? That is the beat that both Jim and Nate have been discussing. When you construct the entire year, let's work through the nuance occurring here, which is volume higher by 10%, yes, sales greater, high single digits. The distinction is the price decline we provided in guidance, which will be around... Well, we described low single digits, but my characterization is 1%-3%, so let's say 2%. So let's put this bridge together; we anticipate no change in U.S. Consumer activity versus the prior year. That applies to the positions we carried last year or the positions we're gaining share with this year. Then you stack on top of that, price lower by 2%, elasticity plus a few other modest growth areas tied to existing brands of roughly 2%, and those two items cancel out. What Nate and Jim mentioned regarding listings, new products, and new promotional activity along with expanded promotional activity, that adds up to plus 8%, if you treat high single digits as approximately 7%-9%.
Jonathan Andersen
analystAll right, that's useful. There are two additional items. The first is merely a tidy-up. Regarding retail inventory, I believe you mentioned that, at the close of the quarter, units had fallen by double digits. Does that bring you to a level that's more typical, or does it sit below what history would suggest? I'm simply considering what this means for the seasonal build in the fiscal second quarter. And, if I may append one last item concerning leverage, the covenant does step down from 8.25 to 7.75 during what is, as you know, your certain seasonal working capital peak. So from a working capital standpoint, cash gen, and EBITDA, what has to occur in 2Q in order to, as you know, remain inside that covenant's limits? Thanks.
Nate Baxter
executiveWell, let's just flip that around; so I'd call this a bit of cheating, my man, you know. So you placed, like, the big mondo question sort of concealed at the end, saying, "Yeah, just one more thing." So let's just tackle that first, which is the pinch point for leverage at the end of Q2.
Matt Garth
executiveYou walked through all of it clearly, and that's... Yeah, it really does drop from 8.25 down to 7.75; we flagged that this point would be our tightest across the leverage profile over the next couple of years, right here in the second quarter of 2024. So what should you take away from that? The takeaway is that our working capital build is squarely underway. That's right. Inventory is shipping out, AR is building up, and payment collection isn't really happening yet in Q2, so working capital sits at a high level. Beyond that, EBITDA continues to grow. You raised — we raised, pardon me — the difference in phasing that shows up versus one year ago. So one year ago, if you recall, the first six months landed somewhere between the mid-50s and high 50s when expressed as percentages. This time, it'll be closer to 50%; so there's some shifting between the first half of last year and the first half of this year. Even so, what that means is that in the second quarter of 2024, a strong EBITDA trajectory will be visible, and that gives you a bit of help with the room. But the room, as we've been telling you, is at its tightest. Across the span, across the horizon, we've given ourselves about a half to a full turn per period when we coordinate with our banking partners. We've got a quarter to 0.5 a turn of room. In Q2 that gets even tighter, because of what that working capital requires and because of the path shift we have going from last year toward where we intend to end up this year. All the same, it's manageable for us. We have a number of levers at hand, ranging from additional efficiencies we're chasing, additional spending controls we've implemented, and additional coordination we can do with our retailers concerning when shipments go out and where and how we execute promotions. So that effort is in motion, and we'll manage it as we get closer to the end of the quarter. As it stands right now, though, we're confident in remaining in compliance, and we have plenty of room to do so this quarter. Beyond that, as we've stated, it opens up considerably as we move through the rest of the year, and our expectation is — to wrap up this year in the fours.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveLet me add one quick point on that. The conversations we had with our banking partners that produced that particular touch point, that pressure point, that sort of sharp corner — none of that happened by chance. My view is that it amounted to a commitment they expected from us, and that was the case; we understood it before we went in. That's what they were after. It was a matter of them telling us, "Here's what you have to do." We get that. When I say in the script that we aren't operating this business the way we did 12 months ago, this isn't some weekly or monthly exercise in managing leverage, which is the situation we found ourselves in during the prior year; what we're really focused on is this single point. We haven't been... Retail inventories are in very good shape, and we haven't been in any sort of deal mode aimed at pushing product into stores. There are opportunities and contingencies that we need to work through. So my sense is we entered the year aware that this would be our tightest point. We put together a plan that people feel good about; we've beaten that plan, and we have contingencies ready should we need to act. So I'd say it doesn't get much better than this, though it is something of an artificial sharp corner. In aviation, folks don't care for sharp corners and curves, but I think it was somewhat imposed on us, and we are fully able to manage our way around it.
Jonathan Andersen
analystYeah. Well, we're-
Jim Hagedorn
executiveYeah, but allow me to address the first question first. So, John, regarding inventories at retail, we are exactly where we planned to be. I believed I heard you mention a 10% decline, but actually we're down 5%, and that's precisely the position we want. It's in line with the retailers. Keep in mind, our goal is to reach a final year-end inventory of roughly $600 million. So, together with our retail partners and our supply chain team, we're going to concentrate on ensuring the inventory is ready for load in. I'd say the retailers are in a solid position. We're expecting that we probably need to ship 150 million units in Q2, and we're right on schedule with that.
Matt Garth
executiveTo close with one last point on this, as we've described the situation with inventories at retail throughout the last 12 months, they sit at elevated levels. They're above what those retailers would prefer to carry, and they're bringing those positions down, which shows up in all of our actions — reduced output during last year, and this year, holding that output at a low level. Our expectation is that they'll bring inventories back to their typical level, which is tied to some percentage of POS. That figure is roughly 15% of POS. Right now, we're at about 16%-17%. So a natural reduction in retailer inventories will occur as we move through the year. Our plan already accounts for that; it's the reason we describe things as healthy, and from that we draw the confidence to state: inventories will come down this year — the Scotts inventories. Retailer inventories will come down this year as well.
Jonathan Andersen
analystThat was really useful. I'll try to fit in just one additional question.
Matt Garth
executiveJust one more?
Jonathan Andersen
analystYeah, my apologies. Two questions. So once more, it's tough since there are so many pluses and minuses, but is this a quarter where EBITDA might be higher than the prior year, and then in Q2, so that we can get through the leverage covenant?
Matt Garth
executiveYeah, you know, we don't provide guidance on that sort of thing. Here's what I'll do. The timing pattern here matters a great deal, right? So looking at U.S. Consumer, in Q1 of last year, roughly 13% of our annual sales came in. This year, that figure was about 10%. In Q2 of last year, of 2023, roughly 48% of our annual sales came in; this year, that number will land between 40% and 43%. So that ought to be useful to you, since incremental margins are holding about flat, plus a modest gain as we spread that out over the year. You'll see your usual SG&A shifts that we bring in alongside sales. So the response is, possibly. The way this plan truly gets constructed is around EBITDA dollar growth in the back half of the year, when you'll witness larger shipments... greater sales and also the fulfillment of the initiatives we have around margin expansion and the start of the cheaper cost inventories that we'll tap into near the end of the year.
Jonathan Andersen
analystGreat. Thank you very much for taking the time.
Chris Carey
analystHello, good morning. I told myself I shouldn't ask more than a single question during this call, but I believe I'm about to—
Jim Hagedorn
executiveMan, after Anderson, honestly, man, you could—
Chris Carey
analystI mean-
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAsk twice at this point.
Chris Carey
analystChris, I suppose it's time for me to field some critical questions.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveall right, bring it on. Let's hear it, Chris.
Chris Carey
analystHow about this instead? Let me ask something quick regarding the balance sheet. Clearly, things will be pretty tight for you in fiscal Q2. Could you discuss backup plans in case things get even tighter than you anticipate? What I'm really getting at is this: I believe you have an accounts receivable facility — what's the amount drawn on it? And does your leverage calculation take that into account? Hopefully that one's fairly fast. Now, I think the wider question would be: how much visibility do you have on mix within your U.S. Consumer business for this year? Last year, mix proved a genuine headwind for the business, hitting both top line and margins, since your lawn care and growing media really underperformed. So you're mentioning visibility around shelf space and the POS, and I follow you on that. How confident are you that mix will land where you expect? Should we still be concerned about weather, or do the shelf space gains you've secured give you confidence that mix won't be this volatile factor in the model like what we saw last year? So, thanks for that wider question and the confirmation-
Jim Hagedorn
executiveI'll handle the opening part, and then I'll probably hand things over to Matt. But if you're referring to Q2, I'd say it's more an execution matter than anything else. It isn't truly a POS problem. What we're really talking about is getting inventory deployed into the field for the second half, which is when consumers buy products. And just for context, we haven't requested that retailers do anything, alright? If we had to, just for context, you're looking at roughly a couple days of sales. That's all. The fix for this stuff is moving a couple days of sales into Q2 if we need help. We're trying not to actually provoke additional discounting. But honestly, sales at that point in the year are so large, at the quarter's end, that it's... When you ask what contingencies involve, there's probably some internal things we could do, but it comes down to a couple days of sales. It isn't really asking much. All you'd need to do is shift a couple days of sales and pull it forward, and that covers it. So just, before everyone gets all strange about it, this is a couple days of sales, and the problem is only if you get a massive snowstorm or something similar, where you can't deliver — that's the sort of thing that would set you back and would have to be corrected for. So, I mean, I don't think there's anything here that's difficult to grasp. It's simply about getting a product out into the field, and then if the figures become large enough and a blizzard hits the Northeast, what's your move? And I believe Nate and the teams working with him, no question, have a handle on this.
Matt Garth
executiveFrom my perspective, the broad picture—much like Jim framed it—is the right jumping-off point here. As things stand in our current projection, we're looking at somewhere between a quarter and a half a term of available headroom. The reason we keep signaling to everybody that this stretch is the most severe and the most constrained is that across the last several quarters, we've essentially been running at three quarters to a full term each quarter. That's what we're really flagging for you; Jim has characterized it exactly right. We're discussing it openly. Here we are at the start of February. We're handling it, and all the work Nate and his team are carrying out is aimed at delivering on the guidance we've set, while we'll deal with whatever uncertainties arise. To claim we're at ease—I do feel at ease. There is risk involved, so we're being open the way we always are, and that's how Scotts operates; thus I feel quite confident about handling the covenant, confident about delivering in the quarter, confident about our ability to secure the margin. As Jim noted, the opening half rests mostly on us; it's the closing half where the consumer enters the picture, and this is likely a smart moment to hand things to Nate, since that's where you can address the mix, the weather, and the insights you've been generating that differ from what we've seen before.
Chris Hagedorn
executiveOkay, I want to spend just a moment on the team. This group is new. They've just completed their first full season playing alongside each other. What gives me a lot of confidence is that Matt and Nate are fully engaged with this, and their message to me is: we've got this handled. I believe that's credible. So for us, that's the correct approach — we've got this handled. You're all aware of how we operated last year. The difference now is that we're managing pressure at quarter's end rather than across a whole year, and we don't need to spend time discussing leverage the way we did. We're now putting leverage at the center of our strategic planning. When I said we intend to speed up leverage reduction by 12 months, that is not a casual statement. Right now this is active discussion, conversations with our board, building out incentive plans for 2024 and 2025 that ask: what do we need to accomplish to bring leverage down, say by a certain point, within our strategic planning window, say 3 years. And we are approaching this very seriously.
Matt Garth
executiveOne more item, apologies.
Chris Hagedorn
executiveYeah, one more item. So, when they claim they've secured it, I genuinely have a lot of confidence, and it gives me a positive feeling regarding these two men collaborating, which is that this isn't some tense, anxious discussion. They're figuring it out. A major piece of that is sales. A major piece of that is supply chain, and nobody has... You know, and I believe it matters a great deal that you all avoid blowing things out of proportion over, you know, essentially a single day that we went through, which happened every day during the prior year, and this is, you know, I'll put it this way, we've got this handled.
Nate Baxter
executiveOkay, Chris, I'll jump in briefly on that. From a product standpoint, the first-quarter mix came in favorably, and we tie that to October and November — the stretch of fall that ran longer than usual. Our sales organization has a clear directive: keep pushing the mix toward a better place at all times. But let me pull back even further and say a bit about how our approach differs now. Jim brought this up during his prepared comments, but Matt and I — the way this company operates today is completely different, so here are a few illustrations. We're posting these results while running a supply chain with roughly 2.5 million fewer square feet of distribution and warehouse space. How do we pull that off? By leaning hard into data analytics. A great deal of predictive modeling goes into helping us see — not just week to week, but quarter to quarter and across a full-year outlook — which factors carry the highest probability. Sure, weather comes up constantly, and it matters, but it isn't the top factor. Plenty of other things play in, such as consumer sentiment and promotions. To echo what Jim said, we feel really good about how the season is loading in. Our media and creative, which will draw consumers into the stores, have us feeling even better. The investments we're making are good ones, and they're smart ones. I won't revisit those figures Jim covered in the prepared remarks, but based on all of this, we feel very, very comfortable about hitting that full-year forecast. One last thing I'll leave you with: since we're relying on this kind of predictive analytics, our capacity to adjust in real time sits on a completely different level than it did 12 months ago, and we do it constantly. So again — a day or two out, sure, we're hoping no snow arrives in late March, but we have contingencies in place, plus a supply chain and a sales team ready to flex along with whatever comes.
Matt Garth
executiveChris, one more thing — our treasurer hurried in and passed this to me since I hadn't wrapped up my response to what you asked. All right, he was seated there in the room, and afterward he shared it around with everyone so nothing would be hidden, that being how Scotts does things; we had drawn $140 million against the AR facility. That facility totals $600 million, which leaves us $460 million available to draw during Q2. Keep in mind, this gets counted as cash collections, not as debt, it sits off balance sheet, and all of that works in our favor regarding net leverage.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveFeeling good, Scheiber?
Chris Carey
analystAppreciate it. Thanks, everyone.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveHe's showing a thumbs up.
Matt Garth
executiveYeah, the treasurer liked that answer. Good.
Chris Carey
analystYeah, that's helpful, thanks.
Peter Grom
analystHey, everyone, good morning. Hope all is well. Maybe just one clarification on something Jon asked, regarding the phasing. So in U.S. Consumer, the 40%-43% of full year sales landing in Q2 — does that suggest something like a mid- to high single-digit decline? Just want to confirm I heard that correctly. And then, stepping back, the mid-30% gross margin target — given where we've been, that's a pretty remarkable improvement. Could you offer some guardrails or thoughts on a reasonable timeline, and on when that might be reached? Thanks.
Matt Garth
executiveOkay. Phasing first. In the first half of this year, we'll do about 52%. During the same six-month period a year ago, the figure was 61%. I broke out the numbers for each quarter separately, for both the current and prior year. So indeed — as you heard during our prepared comments and as you've seen in the release — that's the reason volumes declined on a year-over-year basis during Q1; they'll also be lower compared with a year ago across the first half; so your understanding is correct. As Jim mentioned, we discuss the margin build virtually every single day. At the moment there's considerable conversation and focus on scenario planning regarding what Scotts' future might look like; and today you saw us establish some markers for what that could be. We're looking at 3% growth on the top line for the year. What that 3% actually amounts to is something we'll probably dig into at Investor Day later this year. The margin story is a little more dry, honestly a bit less thrilling, since we'll get some natural relief from where we sit now when it comes to raw materials and from leveraging our fixed costs. So here are the main pieces. Last year we were at 23.7, and we guided to a 250 basis point increase. I'm saying 250 basis points of expansion. Jim's saying 250 basis points or better. Don't overanalyze that — he simply wants more, and all of us agree we're going to push for more. That puts you at roughly 26%. You can work out the rest yourselves. To return the company to that mid-thirties range, you'd have to see the fixed cost leverage component kick in, and that covers all of it—from distribution and absorption to simply operating more efficiently in every area of the business. That accounts for approximately half of what's needed to close the gap. The remaining part is really about the raw material release, and you heard Jim mention it during his prepared remarks; throughout the past several years and through COVID, we managed to price for raw materials, but we did not price for the margin we normally earn, so that on its own has diluted the company's margin. Since those input costs are now coming down, our approach is to hold onto as much of our pricing as possible, which lets us bring back the maximum share of that margin. That's the final piece in completing the effort of closing the gap on the path toward the margin goals we've established. Last year that figure stood at 23.7%.
Peter Grom
analystUnderstood. Many thanks. I'll hand it over again.
William Reuter
analystMorning. Hopefully I've just got a couple of brief ones. First off, regarding your longer-term leverage objective, I believe the figure 3.5 times didn't come up during this call. Is that still the goal? And when do you figure you might be able to hit that target? That's all.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveWell, I'll let Matt set me straight. You know, that's the strange aspect of holding the CEO role. But at a board meeting last week, I put the question to Matt... There are lots of genuinely positive developments in the American business. A great deal of change is coming, particularly regarding Hawthorne and the cannabis business. That means there are numerous hours of genuine, involved conversation happening with the board. We look at January as a kind of warm-up for August, which is when we typically lay out a refreshed three-year strategic plan. So remember that three-year piece, because it's going to be significant in this context. When I reviewed the initial draft of the agenda, I told Matt it came across like just another ordinary board meeting, and I was hoping for something bigger than that. My goal was for this to be a genuine conversation about what we'll be doing across those three years. Some things have shifted since then. There's a new person in charge of the consumer business. A lot is going on over on the Hawthorne side. As for Matt, he's been with us roughly a year, I'd say. So I told him, "It's your turn to lay out your own vision for how our financials should look over what's probably a longer horizon than three years, but..." And it has to be a plan that the operating team won't react to with grimaces and rude gestures. This has to be something everyone signs on to together, yet what you're really seeing is Matt beginning to shape our approach to finance. And now, for the first time, he's been here long enough to understand both his own position and the team around him — and honestly, he handled it extremely well. Still, that point mattered a great deal to the conversation we're currently having. My familiarity with this topic is somewhat sharper than usual, simply because it's come up in our discussions so frequently. I don't want to jump too far ahead, but I believe that once those three years are up, hypothetically the figure would land around 3.5, roughly speaking. Therefore, assuming you've been following along, when we talk about pulling that forward by a year, you might interpret it as one extra turn of leverage, taking things from where the present blueprint lands—roughly 3.5—down to 2.5. So what would need to occur to make that possible? In this situation, I have to go to every business leader, along with Matt, and say, "What will this require from us?" The answer falls somewhere in the range of $60 million to $100 million in extra incremental EBIT—I can't pin down the precise figure; and my instruction was, "Unless it's attainable and we can construct plans around it, don't give me anything." My sense is that the team has not stepped back from that commitment. That isn't to say every piece of the roadmap is finalized. Still, I believe it addresses what you were asking — namely, where things stood once we reached the conclusion of what you could call our existing blueprint, plus the push I gave them to move more quickly. Part of the reason for that push is what shareholders have told us — and my family would echo it — basically, get moving faster, and that's a message we're working hard to act on. On top of that, we are right now in the middle of some very substantial discussions — happening live, as in today — with our Comp and Org Committee, focused on crafting long-term incentives linked to hitting these targets. So, Matt, I'll leave it to you to pick up from here.
Matt Garth
executiveAll the pieces line up, and that's a major declaration about how we intend to drive shareholder value going forward and reach our net leverage goal — which, sure, previously stood at 3.5. Jim and I have gone back and forth, you know, considering how volatile things are, considering the danger inflation rates pose, considering the way we want to run this business moving ahead — might 2.5 to 3 be preferable? Naturally it would be preferable; so we're putting plans in motion both to speed up deleveraging and to pursue a reduced target level, so 3 to 3.5 is ultimately where we landed, and that's our mission. Yet what does that let us accomplish? This isn't merely a financial approach — this is the Scotts model, and it's tremendously thrilling. Jim and I keep telling Nate and his team, "We will consistently hand you chunks of expense so you can reinvest in what Scotts Miracle-Gro is. What's our purpose? GroMoreGood — help everyone feel wonderful about their own patch of the Earth and enjoy it as much as possible. That demands innovation, it demands marketing, it demands a sales force that stands apart. Those are our moats. And strategically, that's what produces an extremely high free cash flow yield that Scotts Miracle-Gro is capable of delivering. Now, regarding what we do with that cash, here's what we've stated: we delever over the short term, then we go back to shareholder-friendly activities and investments to grow that free cash flow sustainably down the road, which will, in turn, fund greater shareholder-friendly actions. So we feel truly great about the near term, and we feel extraordinary about what lies ahead for Scotts Miracle-Gro and about what we can deliver to shareholders and the value we can create both for our consumers and for our shareholders. That's the point of this long-term plan. So everybody here in this room is shaking their head up and down — well, nodding their head up and down.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveWell, look, and a piece of this, which, you know, is included in here, is very strategic investment in the business. For instance, within the plan we're developing, the assumption is at least a 50% increase in brand support.
Matt Garth
executiveYes.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveWe're putting at least 50% more behind innovation. Those are substantial figures, so we're not playing a short game here — this is a long game. And honestly, mid-30s is where we should have been all along, historically. Nothing here is being reinvented; we're simply emerging from COVID, and, well, demand got a bit unpredictable, especially on the cannabis side. Still, the pressure on cost of goods was genuinely severe. Where that rebound shows up, we'll let it unwind on its own, naturally. But it circles back to the arithmetic Matt laid out. You're looking at roughly 900 basis points of margin, and we've climbed to that point while still funding these investments. Again, not every piece is settled, yet I believe folks grasp the main categories they're chasing, and no one is ducking. For this team, that's a genuinely positive development. Everyone here is collaborating extremely well. I felt truly down, honestly, when Mike decided to leave, and with Denise too. I had no idea how things would turn out. Even so, the group has really pulled together nicely. I'm honestly eager to get all of you out here so you can meet the folks in person. It isn't only the team, the people sitting around this table at this moment. There's an entire layer beneath them — people who endured last year, man, and got roughed up badly, man. Do you follow what I'm saying? We implemented plenty of staffing shifts, especially among senior leadership. As Ken used to put it, folks had "a spring in their step," or words to that effect. He — I used to show off my Scotts quite a bit; yet I sense a somewhat arrogant mindset taking hold, you know, across the business, pretty much everywhere. So right now it feels like a pretty decent place to be. And those plans we're discussing, well, they'll bring us back to value creation, folks. When all is said and done, nobody likes where the stock price sits, and I believe we understand what needs doing. Assuming the markets behave rationally, we'll win back a great deal of share price. That's, well, more or less how we get compensated, and I think that's what you all should expect from us. That said, we're going about this in a manner where, if you examine what actually generates value — our capacity to execute out in the field, our sales team, our ties with retailers, extending all the way to the CEO level — well, we've got these remarkable brands. We'll be pouring money into every bit of that. I think it's... Well, Matt basically put it this way: if you're not one of those things, you probably, you know, face difficulties on, you know, you're spending less. Still, my sense is much of that effort is behind us already, and folks have kind of adapted to how they eat while on Ozempic, right? Even so, we are putting money into what comes next.
William Reuter
analystGreat. Thanks so much.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveYeah.
Operator
operatorEveryone, that wraps up the question-and-answer segment of today's event, and with that, the conference call is finished as well. We appreciate that all of you joined us. You're welcome to leave the line now, and we hope your day is a great one.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.