The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company (SMG) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
May 1, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Aimee DeLuca
executiveHello, and thanks for joining us on Scotts Miracle-Gro's webcast for the second quarter of 2024 earnings. My name is Aimee DeLuca, and I lead Investor Relations. Joining me today are Jim Hagedorn, our Chairman, President and CEO, and Matt Garth, our Chief Financial and Administrative Officer. Jim is going to give everyone a business update, and after that Matt will walk through our financial results. As part of this review, we'll be making forward-looking statements and talking about certain non-GAAP financial measures. Keep in mind that actual results might end up differing materially from what we tell you today. For a full picture of the risk factors that could affect our results, please look at our Form 10-K filed with the SEC. Once the webcast wraps up, our Chief Operating Officer, Nate Baxter, and Chris Hagedorn, President of the Hawthorne Division, will be here with Jim and Matt for a Q&A that's audio-only. If you'd like to hear that Q&A, just stay on this webcast. And if you want to take part, use the audio link included in our press release to join. Today's session is being recorded, as it always is. We'll post an archived copy on our website at investor.scotts.com. If you'd like to keep the conversation going after the call, feel free to email me or give me a ring. With all that said, let's begin with Jim's business update.
James Hagedorn
executiveMorning, everybody. Let me begin with my view from 30,000 feet. The company is in good shape. Hard to believe the fiscal year is already half over. All the work we've put in to reach a stronger position is coming to fruition, exactly as we said it would back when we set our fiscal '24 guidance; we committed to high single-digit growth in the consumer business and $575 million in adjusted EBITDA for this year; and we delivered that while producing $1 billion in free cash flow across 2 years by the time fiscal '24 wrapped up, lifting gross margin by no less than 250 basis points and securing a long-term fix for Hawthorne. On every one of those fronts, we've moved forward. In fact, across the first 6 months, we beat the targets we'd planned on key financial metrics that underpin our capacity to hit guidance. Free cash flow is a terrific story. It rose over $500 million versus the prior year, beating our first half target by $200 million. Our debt is down more than $750 million compared with a year ago. The clearest evidence we're in a stronger position is how much our leverage has improved. In Q2, we ended at 6.95x EBITDA, comfortably inside our covenant ceiling of 7.7x and an improvement over Q1. Given where our leverage limit sits, Q2 was the quarter with the least room to spare. Our banks set a harder metric for Q2 to push us into making choices. Nate and Matt collaborated so the operating and finance teams could get through it without strain. I'd like to thank the banks for standing behind us during an extremely difficult stretch for the company. The leverage maximums in our bank covenants will step down as '24 progresses, and we have strong confidence we'll stay within them. By the time the fiscal year closes, we expect to be in the 4s, with further gains in fiscal '25. Gross margin is another area where we're headed the right way. In the quarter it came in at 35.3%, 60 basis points above Q2 of last year. When the year ends, we anticipate at least 250 basis points of year-over-year improvement, with additional gains in '25. Keeping expenses tight is still a priority. Across the first half, SG&A represented 15.2% of net sales, matching our guidance and lower than prior year. All in all, I'm happy with how we performed; it speaks to the strength of our business, decisive actions and precise execution. Turning to the consumer business, here's what's going well. Net sales accelerated in Q2 as we generated a 2% gain over prior year. Year-to-date, consumer sales came in slightly below prior year; that mirrors how we're going back to our usual pre-COVID shipping rhythm with retailers, in contrast to last year's heavy upfront load in. Retailer inventories look healthy. POS units through the first half ran nearly 15% above prior year and 5% over plan. Those gains came from new listings and expanded share of shelf in exchange for investments with retailers. The DayLawn Savings promotion in March beat last year's campaign. We said these would add to growth, and that's exactly what happened. Through March, we saw point-of-sale increases in almost every category. Gardens climbed 18%; Controls gained 12%; Roundup added 9%; Lawns came in basically even. Pricing moves and promotional activity drove second-quarter year-over-year increases of 15% for Bonus S and 28% for Halts, and both of those are early season fertilizers. This year was the first in recent memory that we ran awareness-building advertising behind Halts. We've opened up space for the rest of the year and pulled it off as a smaller, leaner, more cost-efficient company. Consider what we've accomplished. We took out almost $400 million in yearly operating expenses and put $100 million of that money back into growth drivers such as media and innovation; we're a higher-functioning organization that moves with speed. The management team has everyone aligned, and our associates have a spring in their step; right now we're concentrated on Q3; we've set the foundation for consumer takeaway in this pivotal quarter, which accounts for 60% of our POS. April got off to a slow start, but it built momentum steadily as the month went on. The sluggishness came from the late season start in the Northeast, along with a deliberate decision by us and by our major retailers to move high-volume spring events and promotions toward the end of the month. That let everyone reduce the risk posed by unpredictable early season weather. The shift unfolded just as we expected. By late April, promotions and retailer rents were adding to POS unit growth. Looking forward, plenty of factors are working in our favor. Even with inflation, consumer sentiment has gotten better. People feel more confident about the economy and are participating at higher rates in our category, which shows the resiliency of our consumer business during uncertain economic times. Consumers care about their lawns and gardens, and we provide a low-cost, do-it-yourself way to improve their yard and their home. Retailers understand lawn and garden is critically important for driving their spring season. Even with tepid retailer foot traffic during the first half, we've beaten their declines and helped draw people into their stores. We want to thank our retailers for their partnership and their awesome support. Let me discuss what you'll see in Q3. We'll put 25% more into our brand-focused advertising. It has to be nearly impossible for people to have missed our ads this year. We're blanketing television and radio nationally during peak news and high-profile sporting events. We're not chasing the fringe consumer. We're laser targeted on our core consumer, the 30-plus-year-old homeowner. The Q3 blitz began with the April launch of Miracle-Gro Organics with Martha Stewart. In the new Dirt Nerd spots, Martha shares how she relies on our products in her own gardens. The PR outreach alone surpassed 1 billion impressions; we're also expanding our Scott for Scotts campaign with actor Kristofer Hivju, who has fully embraced the role and established credibility with consumers. The creative's in a really good spot, and Kristofer is going to head up the rollout of a brand-new Healthy Lawn item — that breakthrough summer fertilizer plus fungicide for tackling disease. Even with zero ad backing, we're seeing solid POS momentum for Healthy Lawn already. Down at store level, we've grown fuel sales manager roles by 10% to back in-store activations and work alongside Bonnie Plants on building attachment with soils and vegetables. Through the first half, Bonnie sales have risen 12% versus a year ago. Everywhere around the country, spring has arrived in full force. Retailer programs that are running advertising are landing with real impact. May's weather models are looking favorable, and we're focused on handling the things we can control. Turning to Hawthorne, progress is happening. We keep rebuilding that business and boosting its capacity to deliver profit. I've pushed the team to hit a $10 million profit run rate. Across the last 2 years, Hawthorne went from 15 distribution centers down to 2 and eliminated more than 1,000 positions, now running with fewer than 300 people; as our newest step to shore up its economics, we're finishing the complete shift into manufacturing and marketing our own brands. To pull that off and sharpen our ability to put money into our brands, we've walked away from third-party distribution business where margins were weak or simply not there.
James Hagedorn
executiveAt one point this business was larger, so it mattered less, but right now we simply lack the wherewithal to fund items that move in low volumes at slim profitability — and frankly, I doubt rivals like Hydrofarm can manage that trick either. Our attention today is on the more lucrative, in-house brands that Hawthorne owns — Gavita, Botanicare, General Hydroponics, Cyco, Mother Earth and HydroLogic. Those labels rank among the industry's best, making up 80% of our sales, and they're on track to reach 100%, with profit levels matching what our consumer portfolio turns out. To support this change in direction, we've formed a partnership with BFG Supply so they can take care of our smaller retail accounts. We're confident BFG can deliver a better standard of service. Throughout the year, this partnership will bring down Hawthorne's cost structure. We remain at work on the long-term answer for Hawthorne — a precious, fully legal asset within the cannabis sector that offers tax benefits, top-tier brands, and research and development that leads the industry. At our sites in Kelowna, British Columbia; Marysville, Ohio; and Gervais, Oregon, we're studying genetics, competing products, growing methods, lighting, yield and much more. And we pass that knowledge along to our customers. Consolidation is going to roll through this sector — that's a certainty — and when it does, Hawthorne will play a major role in something much larger. Here's the vision I want to share. The cannabis business in America generates $105 billion annually. The vast majority of that money sits with illegal operators. The legal market accounts for under $30 billion. Shameful. And who bears the blame for this situation? Washington's politicians. They've wronged the American people by stalling on legalization and on policies that would back a legitimate industry. In this country, cannabis operates at a size on par with automaking, dairy, or brewing. It is 5x bigger than the U.S. energy drink market, and 9x bigger than the U.S. egg industry. It powers the economy. Beyond that, Americans — Democrats, Republicans and independents — support legalization. In red states such as ours, Ohio, close to 60% of voters gave approval for recreational cannabis last November. Right now, 38 out of 50 states have made cannabis legal, encompassing 3/4 of the population of the United States, and yet those who cultivate and sell through legal channels fight to turn a profit or bring in capital. They're also up against taxes reaching 80% and no way to access financial services. Meanwhile, shoppers at legal stores may face product markups of 50% to 100% because of certain state taxes. How is any of this logical? The legal market has no way to compete with illicit operators who refuse to abide by or respect the same rules. And consumers everywhere are the ones paying the price. It's time to even things out. I'm urging federal officials to act right away on 2 proposals. The first is the SAFER Banking Act in the United States Senate, which has bipartisan support. Senator Schumer must put it up for a vote, and the Democrats and Republicans blocking its passage must vote alongside the people. Next, there's the matter of rescheduling cannabis. What sense does it make to leave cannabis sitting in Schedule I? The DEA is currently examining that question. A change of that kind would ease some of the punishments connected to marijuana and cut the taxes people owe. My call to President Biden is to get rescheduling done. My call to former President Trump is to stand with the majority of Americans who favor reforming cannabis laws. My call to state leaders, including New York Governor Hochul, is to come down firmly on illegal cannabis sellers who ignore safety requirements, go after kids and skip out on taxes. If no progress comes on these multiple fronts, businesses that hold legal cannabis licenses will continue to scrape by or close down for good. Take California — the state has collected more than $700 million in cannabis taxes. That money is largely lost forever, since 72% of the businesses that were part of it have closed. I'm like plenty of other Americans: I've had enough of waiting while Washington won't act correctly — immediate action is what we need. I'd also like to talk about the 2021 investment we made in RIV Capital; this New York cultivator and retail operator is building value in the cannabis sector. RIV just launched a flagship adult-use dispensary in White Plains, and the numbers coming out of that location are blowing past what we projected. Beyond that, our cultivation presence in Chestertown has been scaled up, and we're putting up a brand-new grow site in Buffalo — together, those moves will make our footprint twice as large. On top of that, everyone here is genuinely enthusiastic about what could happen if RIV joins forces with a different company in cannabis. Details aren't something I'm able to share at this point, though a transaction is actively being worked on. Once completed, such a combination would mark a significant step forward for the way we've chosen to invest in cannabis over the long haul. It would demonstrate progress toward the goal we set for RIV — funding and supporting the development of a multi-state leader across cultivation and retail, stocked with premium cannabis labels. The new combined company would run cultivation and dispensary operations across the most sought-after states where licenses are scarce for legal medical use, adult use, or both. Under the terms of this deal, we expect the Convertible Note we currently hold with RIV to be turned into exchangeable shares of the merged entity. I'll close with this. We've stabilized and improved the financial flexibility of Scotts Miracle-Gro. Our difficult work over the last 18 months will benefit this company for the next 10 years. We're no longer managing through crisis; we are looking at the future again. Chris is leading a very exciting effort to recover our investments in the cannabis space and create long-term value. Nate and Matt have each been with us for at least twelve months, and by now they understand far better where this business needs to go in order to grow. A long-range financial and strategic plan is being put together by Matt, while Nate is assembling a multiyear consumer plan covering investments in technology, disruptive innovation and other value drivers. Their plans were already previewed for the Board of Directors, and everything will be locked in by the time summer ends. We anticipate being able to take you through them sometime in the fall. The work they're doing and the value it creates truly fires me up. In support of these efforts, I'd like to express my thanks to their teams. Finally, we've scheduled an Analyst Day for July at the Marysville headquarters, and once you're there, you'll get a close-up look at how we're preparing Scotts Miracle-Gro for the future. I'm really looking forward to seeing everyone then. Thanks very much. Matt is going to pick things up now for the financial section of the call.
Matthew Garth
executiveAppreciate that, Jim, and greetings, everybody. If you're watching the video feed, spring has clearly shown up here at Scotts Miracle-Gro headquarters. I hope you're making the most of this early part of the season with excellent offers on SMG items and all the mental and physical wellness advantages that come from getting back outside and building a beautiful lawn and garden. Let me kick things off by restating a handful of the things Jim mentioned. Number one, we feel good about how the first half went. Number two, there's no change to what we've projected for the entire year. And number three, we keep steering the things within our grasp to boost consumer involvement and hit the results we've laid out. Looking at net leverage, we closed the quarter at 6.95x against a covenant ceiling of 7.75x, and we're still on pace to land net leverage in the 4s by the time the fiscal year wraps up, which gives us significantly better financial flexibility as we head into '25 and past that. U.S. consumer outcomes came in solid, with total unit share across Q2 climbing right in line with what we'd planned. We saw especially notable momentum in growing media thanks to early market home center promotions. Over at Hawthorne, we keep refining the operation so it centers on our flagship proprietary brands. The distribution partnership with BFG we announced not long ago marks a significant step forward on Hawthorne's strategic journey. So now, let's go through the second quarter more thoroughly. Listing wins plus robust early season engagement and growing media pushed U.S. consumer second quarter net sales to $1.38 billion, a 2% gain versus last year and matching our second quarter record set in 2022; with terrific retail partnerships and execution from our teams, U.S. consumer net sales across the first half came in stronger than expected, finishing only 2% below the prior year at $1.69 billion. The decline in net sales for the first half largely reflects how we had scheduled our shipments, and that pattern has now returned to the more typical pre-COVID cadence that matches what our retailers expect. Stores look well prepared for the season. Because first half shipments were solid, combined with new listings and expanding media, retailer inventory units at the end of March were 3% higher than the prior year. As Jim mentioned, we closed out March with unit POS up in the mid-teens percentages while gaining 4 points of unit share, with mulch and rodenticides leading the way. Moving through April, POS units increased by high single digits percentages, and dollar POS grew by low single digits, reflecting price reductions and a mix for the early season that skewed toward growing media. Jim pointed out how critical the third quarter is, given that it represents 60% of our season. Because the heart of the lawn season is still in front of us and the majority of our new promotions haven't kicked off yet, we believe our guidance of high single digits net sales growth for the U.S. consumer businesses remains achievable. Over at Hawthorne, we're tackling the persistent industry challenges head-on by moving decisively to overhaul how we go to market. Walking away from distributed products will lower Hawthorne's topline, but margins will get stronger as we zero in on our proprietary and industry-leading brands, plus the savings we gain by shrinking our distribution network. During Q2, Hawthorne recorded $66 million in net sales, a figure that represents a 28% drop from the equivalent quarter a year earlier. Net sales for the year so far totaled $147 million, which is $78 million lower, or a 35% decrease, relative to last year. Those reductions stemmed from diminished volumes as well as price reductions. Turning to our outlook for the entire year, we now expect Hawthorne's net sales to decline 25% to 30% compared with last year, a reflection of the distributed brands being discontinued and a challenging short-term industry picture. Hawthorne posted a segment loss of $3 million for the quarter, compared with a $17 million loss during the same quarter last year. Segment loss for the year to date through March stood at $13 million, versus $33 million across the first half of last year. Better product mix, along with cuts to warehousing expenses, staffing, and project budgets, fueled the gain, though these were partly offset by softer sales volume and price reductions. In the second half, we anticipate additional gains, and for the entire year we project Hawthorne's contribution to total company adjusted EBITDA will be breakeven or better — this includes spending on sales, marketing, and innovation aimed at driving profitable growth in fiscal 2025 and afterward. For Q2, total company impairment, restructuring and other charges came to $77 million. These charges stem largely from noncash inventory-related write-downs totaling $67 million tied to the further shrinking of the Hawthorne warehouse footprint. Year to date, IRO charges totaled $64 million. Keep in mind that these charges don't count toward non-GAAP income. Let's turn now to gross margin and cost of goods sold for the company overall. On an adjusted basis, our gross margin rate came in at 35.3% for the quarter, up 60 basis points from 2Q of last year, with the improvement largely coming from distribution cost savings tied to Project Springboard. During the second quarter, favorable material costs were outweighed by unfavorable net pricing along with higher manufacturing labor costs. Looking at the first half as a whole, the adjusted gross margin rate was down roughly 30 basis points, since savings on distribution costs and a favorable segment mix were more than canceled out by negative net pricing and fixed cost deleverage caused by lower volumes. Year-to-date, material costs were basically flat. At this stage of the year, we've secured roughly 85% of the commodities we purchase, so we can see our costs for the entire year with a fair degree of confidence. Apart from increases in resin and labor expenses, the outlook for the rest of the year shows positive movement throughout most of what we buy. The pressure from resin pricing should carry over into fiscal 2025. In the first half, SG&A came in about $22 million better than the same period a year earlier. Measured against net sales, SG&A went from 15.3% last year and 16% two years ago to 15.2% now. These savings include over $11 million put back into media during the year so far, and they show how well the cutbacks in headcount tied to Project Springboard have held up. Amortization expense dropped $3 million, or 39%, in the second quarter of '24 compared with the second quarter of '23, and it was down $6 million, or 44%, on a year-to-date basis, driven by the Hawthorne intangible asset impairment taken in fiscal year '23. Going forward, our annual SG&A goal remains in the 15% to 16% of net sales range, and we expect fiscal '24 to come in at the lower end of that range. For the second quarter, non-GAAP adjusted EBITDA reached $396 million, versus $405 million during the same period a year ago. On a year-to-date basis, that figure stood at $371 million, compared with $426 million in the prior-year period. The decline in non-GAAP adjusted EBITDA year to date stemmed from fewer non-GAAP gross margin dollars, driven mainly by reduced volumes and pricing. Below operating income, our first-half results reflect a $19 million adjusted loss tied to the Bonnie JV, which is consistent with the adjusted loss recorded for that same JV during last year's comparable period. Bonnie's sales through March of this year were up 12% relative to last year, primarily due to stronger consumer engagement and improved store execution. Sales year-to-date through March account for only 20% of Bonnie's projected sales for the full year. Keep in mind as well that Bonnie's fiscal year concludes on July 31. Interest expense year-to-date through March was $4 million below the first half of last year, a 5% decrease, thanks to significantly lower debt levels, partly offset by higher average borrowing rates.
Matthew Garth
executiveBy the close of March, our total debt stood at $2.8 billion, compared with $3.6 billion a year earlier. Drawing on the accounts receivable program added $587 million, net of discount, toward paying down that debt. Robust free cash flow in the second quarter accounted for the remaining improvement. On a year-to-date basis, free cash flow usage improved by more than $500 million compared with a year ago, propelled by working capital reductions stemming from continued inventory gains, use of the AR sale facility, and AP timing. Looking at the full year, we expect interest expense to stay flat, since the gain from lower net debt gets offset by higher interest rates. As of the close of the second quarter, roughly 80% of interest rates are fixed through a mix of long-term fixed rate notes and interest rate swap agreements. Discount costs tied to the AR sale facility fall under other income and expense and totaled $13 million through Q2. Our adjusted tax rate through the second quarter came in at 28.6%, versus 26.4% during the comparable period a year ago. The main reason for that increase is a smaller benefit from stock-based compensation that vested in Q2, along with the negative effect of greater nondeductible executive compensation expense. Share count finished the quarter higher by 1.2 million shares compared with 2023, reflecting increased share-based payments. Share count is on track with our guidance of an extra 1.5 million shares issued by the close of the fiscal year. Now that the first half is behind us, our focus is on delivering a solid second half performance. This year, we're heading back to William Blair's 44th Annual Growth Stock Conference in Chicago, where we'll discuss our views on SMG's prospects and give an update to our 2024 guidance and outlook, shaped by May POS performance. Finally, as Jim mentioned, we'll hold an Analyst Day on July 16 at our Marysville, Ohio, Headquarters and Research Center. That day's agenda will feature chances to meet the new management team and see our new product innovation up close. We're eager to share more about our longer-term outlook and strategic objectives as we build greater financial flexibility and a stronger capacity to drive shareholder returns. An upcoming press release and invitation will contain the details. We can now move on to the Q&A.
Jonathan Andersen
analystI'd like to ask about consumer engagement and point of sale. From what you're saying, April may have gotten off to a slower start than you'd wanted, though it picked up as the month went along. Taken as a whole, though, it hurt the point of sale year-to-date. What makes you confident right now that you can keep your expectation of upper single-digit sales growth for the U.S. consumer business? Again, my thinking is that in your first half year, U.S. consumer is down low single digit, so you'd need a solid acceleration in the second half of the fiscal. So could you speak to that a bit, whether it's promo plans or shipment timing, the weather outlook, just how much visibility and confidence you have at this point?
Nate Baxter
executiveSure. This is Nate. I'll begin here. So you're correct, April was somewhat a case of in like a lamb, out like a lion, but I should point out that at April's close, we had both our biggest POS and our biggest shipment week on record. As we move into May, that's still strong. You're not wrong, we have to look at significant growth. But looking at our models, most of our promos are still in front of us. Consumer sentiment is strong, and the weather is working in our favor. So that's basically the short version of why we're keeping our cautious optimism.
James Hagedorn
executiveJim speaking. For anyone located in the Northeast, let me rewind to Ohio — Ohio, I'd describe spring as basically in full swing at this point. Flowers are coming out everywhere, and conditions here are just about ideal. Since I'm based on the East Coast, my guess is we're roughly 2 weeks behind that. That floor represents, let's say, 1/4 of the market. So the explanation, Jon, for why I'm at ease with this: when you look at areas outside the Northeast — and keep in mind there's an Easter shift that impacted the early portion of April along with retailer promotions — as I mentioned during the scripted remarks, we moved those to a later point to dodge the exposure, since the worry, something I've discussed for a few years now, is that pushing too early in the month invites the possibility of poor conditions. I believe I've cited that figure as roughly 80% of the time it was simply chilly weather. Whenever it's cold and wet or snowing, you can have the best promotion imaginable, yet the stores sit empty. So you've got programs shifted later; still, if you examine what was happening, across the remainder of the country beyond the Northeast, essentially, that's the whole picture, with the Northeast trailing by roughly 2 weeks. But, Josh, what's your take? Josh heads up sales for us.
Josh Meihls
executiveAbsolutely, I believe that analysis is exactly right, and I'd like to emphasize a few points again. That all-time record week for POS units, which happened during the final week of April, was largely fueled by the Northeast joining in during the closing days of that promotion, and we're noticing at the start of this week that it's carrying on, so that segment of the business is picking up. That provides us with momentum heading into May. So as we consider May, our planning always assumes May will deliver our largest overall gain, since that's when we have the greatest number of incremental promotions. And if you look at the innovation and new listings we're counting on, Scott's Healthy Lawn, Miracle-Gro Organics Raised Bed, that's the period when they begin to reach their peak during May. The final point I'd make is that our retail partners have stayed fully committed alongside us. They've been terrific partners throughout this, as they push the business forward; we're making adjustments together with them. And I also want to express thanks to our field sales team, who are in stores daily making tweaks at the local level. So we're feeling very optimistic as we look ahead to May and June.
James Hagedorn
executiveAlright Jon, here's one last thing to mention. When you take a look at how the mid-teens figure has performed so far this year, through the close of Q2, it came in at roughly plus 8% — that's everything apart from mulch, meaning plus 8% ex-mulch. As April wrapped up, we were sitting at plus 8% ex-mulch. So the underlying results across product lines are solid, and then what Josh and Nate described is that momentum we're bringing into the rest of the year, along with the plans and initiatives we've got lined up for garden season, which will land on soils and fertilizers; that's what's going to create the difference needed to reach our full-year objective of raising volumes by 8% to 10%, while POS climbs even higher than that to account for the retailer inventory drawdown we've been flagging.
W. Andrew Carter
analystI suppose I'll start with a single question, and it's about Hawthorne — sort of a status update. You signed that deal with BFG. Have you finished exploring strategic alternatives for Hawthorne? I also saw that you held on to 2 of the distribution facilities, so my assumption is you're remaining in that business. So, once more: are you finished? Then, for the second part, I want to give you a chance to speak a bit about RIV Capital and what you referenced earlier regarding being at a late stage in merging with a different partner. Does what was announced yesterday alter your thinking in any way? My guess is that bids available now would be larger; plus the other item you brought up — you anticipated converting the convertible debt. Will you do so at the strike price originally set, or at market? And are you confident enough that you can hold an exchangeable share position — an equity position — rather than this debt structure, while staying listed on the exchanges and also with your debt partners?
James Hagedorn
executiveThat counted as one question? Fair enough. I need to keep the details straight. Look, before Chris and Matt handle some of the talking here, I want to begin. We taped that video last week. I felt very strongly about it. I believe people were ringing my phone at the conclusion of that presentation. I want to thank President Biden for doing what was right. My wife, who is a Democrat, often reminds me who your friends are. And although I find it difficult to pull a lever that amounts to saying, raise my taxes, I do believe that the — this current President has done what he said he was going to do. And I want to thank him; in my view, this is huge for the industry. What this will do is normalize taxes. If it happens the way, probably it will, we think, this will normalize taxes and is just a big step forward; we will have put a lot of capital to work because, as you know, most of the EBITDA of plant-touching people was going to the federal government. Now that money can be invested in growth; it can be invested in capital improvement, which I think you would agree with; we believe there's a lot of pent-up capital improvement and that if we were to estimate the amount of older non-LED lights, we'd say it's probably 50%; so we think there's a lot of opportunity on the "hydroponic" side to benefit us; but I think this is really good for everybody. And a lot of credit, I think, here goes to the President for doing what he said. Chris?
Christopher Hagedorn
executiveAndrew, this is Chris. Yes, so I'd agree with everything Jim mentioned regarding the regulatory update. Clearly, it's — well, it's — as long as it remains just a leak, I believe it's somewhat premature to become overly enthusiastic. I think we have to observe more tangible action from the government, yet it's clearly a fantastic sign, and you witnessed how pure-play cannabis equities responded yesterday and I'm confident will keep doing so today. So that has us excited. Look, I won't dive into too much specifics regarding the RIV situation just — I mean, that's its own separate publicly traded company, and I just — I don't want to, in sort of an uncontrolled environment, reveal more than I should other than to say it's something we're truly enthusiastic about and we anticipate being able to disclose additional information. Returning to the start of your inquiries, regarding evaluating strategic alternatives for Hawthorne, I know Matt has something he'd like to add on this too. I would say, no, we haven't finished evaluating strategic alternatives there, keeping a — some distribution network for us. There are a few factors. First, the connection we share with BFG, it's still very new. We are extremely enthusiastic about it; they've proven to be excellent partners so far. We anticipate that will remain the case. And we're doing all we can to be strong partners for them. But it's not — we're not giving our whole business to BFG. We're still keeping a substantial number of customers that we'll serve directly. So we'll require our own DCs for that purpose. And additionally — and if you grasp what this entails, there's somewhat of a window here where we simply must ensure that BFG can keep bringing our customers onboard and serving them, not merely at the standard we've provided, but honestly, at an elevated service level and until — and BFG has only been accepting orders for 3 business days as of today. So following that, it involved onboarding them, getting their DCs halted; so we're going to work through this. We're going to keep some DCs here. Just in case any issues arise, we can intervene and ensure our customers are looked after. But that's something we expect, provided the onboarding proceeds as smoothly as we think it will, that we'll reduce that DC network even more. Matt?
Matthew Garth
executiveRight. Let me just piggyback on Hawthorne specifically — the effort Chris has been spearheading, and we've been working alongside him on it, amounts to a complete overhaul of that business and of the value it brings to our customers and to the consumers they serve. What that means is reigniting the science-based value proposition: top quality, bottom cost for the people we serve. And that's been reflected back to us, and demonstrated back to us, through how we've handled our relationships across this exceptionally tough stretch — we shrank Hawthorne's base, yet the capability stayed intact. Manufacturing capacity remains in place. Our highest-level relationships remain in place. When demand shows up, we'll be equipped to handle it. And, as Jim noted, the picture for that demand in hydroponics is looking up. That's what the work accomplished across the past 2 years has produced. It has also produced a situation in which we believe profitability is within reach for this year. And I won't — sorry, what was that?
Christopher Hagedorn
executiveThis month.
Matthew Garth
executiveThis month, right, exactly.
Christopher Hagedorn
executiveApril, the month we just wrapped up, was the first one where we beat our own internal forecast. The mix came in better than expected. We were profitable.
Matthew Garth
executiveExcellent. Thank you. Great data point there.
Christopher Hagedorn
executiveYes; so we are set for an exciting place for us.
Matthew Garth
executiveRight, and that's a really solid proof point. So Hawthorne's way ahead runs through profitability — and once you've got profit, you've got power, and that gives you optionality. Like we told you, at Scotts Miracle-Gro this year there are 3 things we're focused on: $575 million of EBITDA, the remaining $1 billion in free cash flow, and landing a strategic answer for Hawthorne. And once more, having that profitable route hands us optionality on the strategic route ahead. The only other thing in your 1 question with 17 parts, Andrew, is where we stand on various investment vehicles on the leaf-touching side that fit with every regulation and environment we operate in. We do have convertible debt sitting out there. Exchangeable shares, for the most part, get looked at and handled the same way. So either convertible debt or exchangeable shares — we're at ease with our position in both.
James Hagedorn
executiveAlso, Andrew, let me jump in here. The situation was somewhat uncomfortable because the 2 businesses in question are publicly traded. Once this is done, we'll hold the largest stake, and the issue arose of whether — given that the deal is nearly finished but hasn't crossed the line — I ought to have said something. Honestly, if I were speaking with both Boards at this moment, my message would be: stop sitting on your f** a and start moving. Waiting around has worn me out. What this could become genuinely excites us. Yesterday's rescheduling announcement, in my view, is truly positive news for plant-touching folks. We're eager to take part. Our investment here is substantial. At no point did we view it as debt. Our view has always been that it's shares; we've kept trying to convey that to the RIV shareholders, who seem to fixate on the possible fallout from the debt; our aim is to remain exactly where we are. Something we can state today is that moving to exchangeable shares works fine for us; our intent isn't for this debt to hang over the equity of the company that will exist going forward. Still, please, get this thing closed.
Joe Altobello
analystOne question, and it breaks into just 3 parts, if you don't mind. So, first off, regarding that high single-digit unit POS gain you've recorded through April, how much comes from the base business as opposed to added shelf space and promotions? What will the comparisons look like during the back half? And do you still expect base POS and units to be flat for the year?
James Hagedorn
executiveOkay. I'll likely handle a portion of that, since I'm not certain how we'd truly know. If you consider what we described as the benefit from the programs we assembled, I believe we described that as a big chunk of the improvement coming our way. And I believe that's what's showing up. But I believe we're seeing genuinely strong results across essentially every category we compete in, including lawn. Keep in mind, we — that was a space where we truly believed a pricing reset was necessary; so lawn pricing dropped significantly last fall, and we observed POS gains. Nate and I sat in a top-to-top with one of our biggest retailers. And we required sales across assorted periods as we glanced backward, and we're examining the sort of JPMorgan lights in our back mirror. And what truly caught us off guard is when we — and this involved the chief merchant of one of our top retailers, who remarked, there was plenty of worry regarding inventory levels in Q4 — our Q4; and what truly caught us off guard was — and this originated from them. So this is the chief merchant and chief executive, who said, what was astonishing is how much of that product we moved, it was — it kind of became a fantastic promotion, and we finished with fairly solid inventory levels. I'll say outstanding inventory levels exiting last year's fall season. So I'm not certain how to reconcile what the gap is. I believe those programs mattered enormously. I believe those commitments from both companies, or either party, the buyer and the sellers, was — is enormously important to commitment to the category. And so I believe, to me, and I believe this is — I wouldn't panic over April when — for those folks residing in the Northeast, you'll understand what I mean, the weekends simply weren't great. The remainder of the nation was crushing it. And I believe when you consider the season, where the season was occurring, business was excellent; and I believe that demonstrates just that the consumer is highly engaged. And keep in mind, we stated we're going to advertise the advertising. I don't know about you folks. So I keep asking myself whether folks might be purchasing simply because they realize I'm someone who tunes in to television, since I'm noticing an awful lot of ads. Just yesterday, during what felt like the evening news in prime time on CNN, I caught the initial Healthy spot; so other than observing that, I'm not sure how to distinguish — hold on, I realize Matt is eager to speak. Go ahead, man.
Matthew Garth
executiveJoe, here's how I'd frame it. As you'll remember, our stated plan was high single digits, correct? And within that high single digits, the components were a 2% decline from price plus roughly a 10% gain in volume, and on that volume piece there's some price elasticity, let's say 1% to 2%. Listings and promos accounted for the remainder. During the first six months, the listings momentum that Nate and his team have generated is what's showing up. So what we anticipate for the back half is still ahead of us. Once garden season arrives, much more of that fresh promo activity will start appearing in our POS numbers, and that's the thing we're eager to see in May.
Joe Altobello
analystAnd do these get harder or simpler in the back half — apologies, the second half?
James Hagedorn
executiveSimpler. Our comparisons in the second half are favorable. That's right. Retailer inventory levels sit where we want them. So every element required is in place.
Peter Grom
analystJim, I simply wanted to ask — to build on what you said regarding, you know, the weather. And I just wanted to hear your perspective on how this is sort of unfolding relative to what you had anticipated. You mentioned that the Northeast, or the East Coast, is running a couple of weeks behind, while other markets are performing very strongly. But could you perhaps, on an aggregate basis, across everything you're observing overall, put weather side by side with what we've experienced during the last couple of years, and maybe also compare it with what you'd ordinarily expect in a typical year? And I might be mistaken here, but my understanding is that the guidance assumed no significant weather changes compared with last year, which I don't believe was particularly good. So I'm just attempting to grasp what we're seeing at present and then what to expect in May, since your weather models could actually indicate some favorability purely from a weather standpoint.
Nate Baxter
executiveYes, Peter, it's Nate here. I'll handle that question. So the weather has unfolded precisely the way we forecasted. We've invested considerable effort collaborating with our partners and our internal modeling team. El Nino gave us an advantage, which benefited us early in the season. And now, as everyone is aware, we're in the middle of a transition toward La Nina. On average, compared with last year, conditions have been warmer, and certain areas of the country have been somewhat wetter; that held us back in the South, but it's setting up a really favorable spring. The weather for the coming month, 1.5 months, appears extremely promising. So from where we sit, I'd say there have been no surprises. It's been favorable to us, exactly as our models forecasted, and we continue to view that as a boost in the second half.
William Reuter
analystI'd like to dig a bit deeper into those Project Springboard cost reductions. What's been realized so far? My understanding is that an additional $100 million is coming through in the current year — or 80% of that $100 million — which implies roughly $20 million more should flow into EBITDA next year. Does that match up?
Matthew Garth
executiveThat's right. What we shared with you was $65 million being delivered in '24. Of that last $100 million, $15 million had already been captured back in '23. That leaves approximately $20 million remaining to be secured in '25. So your math is correct. You can see the impact in SG&A, you can see it at the gross margin line, and in our capacity to hold onto those savings going forward. Also — and I mentioned this during the prepared remarks — I was quite pleased with how SG&A performed on a dollars basis. On a rate basis, it looks good as well. But looking at dollars, keep in mind we're down $20 million, and on top of that marketing spend is $10 million higher, so the real decline is $30 million. That speaks to how durable these actions are — and that's only counting the most recent round of reductions on a year-over-year comparison. So my answer is that it is reaching the bottom line. Will, where else would you like to take this?
William Reuter
analystNo — I suppose what I was actually asking is this: what amount of savings is set to land in 2024? My understanding is that figure is $65 million. Then, for the rest of the following year, I believe the number is $20 million. And regarding that $65 million that's going to be realized, will it come in evenly across the year? Or how much — I think perhaps you said you're down $30 million year-to-date, when you brought up the $20 million and the $10 million?
Matthew Garth
executiveRight; so many of those savings arrive early in the year. They'll help you out during the second half of the year. That means you're also picking up some of it in the first half figures.
William Reuter
analystAll right, but it seems as though an additional $35 million is expected during the latter six months of the year. Should we be thinking about it that way?
Matthew Garth
executiveThat's okay. Honestly, as I stated, we likely received over 50% of it during the first half, you'll see run rate, a portion of it in the second half; yet yes, I'm fine.
James Hagedorn
executiveOkay, look, I also believe there's more for us to do. I'm aware that reworking the supply chain in North America matters enormously to this company. If Matt and I were laying out our thinking — and Nate knows all about this at the corporate level — what we anticipate is that we'll boost marketing spending by a large percentage, and the same goes for innovation efforts. To pay for that, we'll keep taking money out of the business in places that can finance the things that set us apart and move the business forward. I believe you'll witness fairly substantial share gains in the current year. What I tell the team is that we hold a reasonable share, an efficient share, call it whatever you like right now. By the time this year wraps up, we'll hold more share, and we truly need to be a vendor that's an excellent partner to our retailers and to our consumers — performing in a way that matches the share opportunity in front of us, and then holding onto it. That matters. And I think as we work through all this, plus some of the investments we placed behind this year and perhaps the next one with our retailers, which produced the sort of program and share gains we're now seeing — once those wrap up, we must be a partner that doesn't shed those gains when the programs conclude. So I'd say this is among the things I want the business to demonstrate to Matt: that we can lift our margins because of what we've done, and that the money we put into the business will preserve that share rather than forfeit it. And that's genuinely critical to where we're headed.
Eric Bosshard
analystThis is Eric calling in from Cleveland Research. There are quite a few figures here, and I simply want to confirm I've got it straight — from what I understood you to say, units for April rose 7% to 9%, while dollars increased 1% to 3%. Before I get to my question, did I state that correctly?
Matthew Garth
executiveNo. My actual words were that we should revisit this and construct it step by step, correct? So there's an 8% lift since that represents roughly high single digits alongside a price decline; and honestly, Eric, I believe if you review the materials Aimee posted to the website, you'll find a helpful small margin bridge included there. There's also a helpful small revenue walk that reveals part of this breakdown too. So regarding the U.S. consumer, our aim in detailing this was POS, with nothing unexpected. Sure, the first half landed in the teens, excellent. Mulch performed quite strongly, yet the core underlying business sits precisely where we want it, at plus 8%. And that aligns with what we were targeting; that's the reason Jim brought up references to the plan. So we discussed it relative to our forecast. We aren't caught off guard. And looking ahead, we recognize that further gains will arrive via promotional activity. So returning to the level we require on POS as of April is within reach, so a highly meticulous approach to how we temper the year and what our messaging is, spanning revenue through cost, through margin, through free cash flow and through net leverage; so on net leverage, while we're discussing it, I don't truly foresee a problem for the rest of the year or for the remaining stretch under our credit facility, which extends through 2027; so I believe there's ample runway. There's room to maneuver. You heard Jim address it. We aren't operating under pressure. So regardless of whether POS fluctuates somewhat, we hold levers ready to pull, and we'll stay compliant. So I feel quite positive about the broader picture of how the new management team is working to guarantee that commitments are fulfilled now, both retailers' and ours with our stakeholders, shareholders included, and then the road ahead for what we're setting out for the coming decade.
Eric Bosshard
analystAll right, sounds good. So when you look at POS dollars, up until the end of April, are they running 1% to 3% higher? Did I hear that correctly?
Matthew Garth
executivePOS dollars — no. My apologies. POS dollars, looking at the period ending April, 1% to 3%, that's right.
Eric Bosshard
analystAll right. So here's what I think I'm attempting to work out: that figure is the one you set a goal of reaching the high single digits for, across the year. Through April, it sits noticeably below your unit performance. So how do you account for the gap between those two? And what, essentially, closes that shortfall during May and June?
Matthew Garth
executiveLet me follow your arithmetic. What you're essentially laying out is that pricing rose through April, whereas you anticipated a decline and we anticipated a decline, which I don't believe is accurate; then for the rest of the year, there's ground to recover on units; so pricing has fallen so far this year. That matches our expectations. Units have risen so far this year; that's what we anticipated. Net dollars have grown by a smaller amount, and that too is what we anticipated. Looking ahead, significant gains are arriving in May. April into May accounts for 50% of the year. So during May, the promotions tied to soils, which incidentally carry highly appealing margins, nearly bond like margins. That upside will show up in the POS figures. And those represent fresh promotional volumes that were absent a year ago.
Operator
operatorWe appreciate everyone joining us for today's call. That brings the program to an end. You're welcome to hang up now.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.