The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company (SMG) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
July 31, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Aimee DeLuca
executiveHello everyone, and thanks for joining us for Scotts Miracle-Gro's webcast on our third quarter 2020 earnings. I'm Aimee DeLuca, and I lead Investor Relations. Joining me today are our Chairman, President and CEO, Jim Hagedorn, along with our Chief Financial and Administrative Officer, Matt Garth. Jim is going to give a broad update on the business, and after that Matt will walk through our financial results. As we go through this, we'll be making forward-looking statements and talking about some non-GAAP financial measures. Just keep in mind that what actually happens could end up being quite different from what we tell you today. For a look at the complete set of risk factors that might affect our results, please check our Form 10-K that we filed with the SEC. Once this webcast wraps up, our Chief Operating Officer, Nate Baxter, and the President of our Hawthorne Division, Chris Hagedorn, will be joining Jim and Matt for a Q&A session that will be audio-only. <<operator_script>> As usual, we're recording today's session. A copy will be made available on our website, investor.scotts.com. If you'd like to keep talking after the call, feel free to email me or give me a ring. So with that, let's turn things over to Jim for his business update.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveHi, everybody. At the start of our fiscal year, we set out the growth goals and the financial yardsticks for fiscal '24. With 3 quarters now behind us, our progress against those targets is much clearer. It's clear that we've accomplished almost everything we set out to do this year. Despite a weather season that was both erratic and stormy, we will post stronger outcomes on the financial yardsticks that matter for value creation and for establishing a growth foundation for next year. Market share, sales and point of sales at consumer level, free cash flow, debt reduction, leverage improvements, gross margin and EBITDA are among those yardsticks. We've continued to be disciplined about costs, and the company remains a leaner operation with better cost efficiency — one that can put money into strategic areas to grow volume and sales. Beyond that, it wasn't only a matter of spending more on media than we did the year before; we also directed those funds in a smart way so that POS opportunities could be maximized as we responded to things happening outside the business. The busiest stretch of the season is a good example. Because it got off to a sluggish start, we increased what we devoted to marketing and sales activities by 33%. As a result, Q3 brought both POS growth and profitability. Inventory was another area of difficulty we addressed during the year. After COVID, our inventory levels were much too high, and we ran into significant absorption issues. We promised to reduce inventory to $600 million during this year, and we will hit that goal. As we finish Q3, we're a bit above that number and, after accounting for inflation, below where we stood before COVID; accomplishing this was difficult, but our operating community delivered. When you look at all we've achieved, fiscal '24 reflects substantial headway. We know additional effort is required before we can achieve consistent growth, meaningful margin gains and more reduction of debt. And until every one of those outcomes is realized, I won't call our turnaround a complete success. Still, I can state confidently that we've made major strides along that road. During the initial 9 months, U.S. On the consumer side, net sales were up 2%, while unit POS increased by 10%. We expect a solid Q4 and are holding to our outlook of 5% to 7% net sales growth for lawn and garden. In addition, we remain on track to hit company-wide adjusted EBITDA of $530 million to $540 million, which marks a sizable profitability improvement of more than 20% versus a year ago. While our EBITDA goal for this year had been more aggressive, it was still a very strong year. The expansion we're seeing puts us in position to hit a two-year target: producing $1 billion of free cash flow before fiscal '24 wraps up. On top of that, we'll retire no less than $350 million of debt, which brings additional leverage improvement. During Q3, leverage dropped to 5.5x adjusted EBITDA — quite a change from the more than 7x we were dealing with under a year ago. Once the year closes, our leverage is going to sit under 5x. Restoring gross margin stands among our top priorities. We understand that climbing back to the mid-30% level we delivered in past years is a multiyear undertaking. Through this year so far, gross margin is up 260 basis points, which is better than the 250 basis points we set as our target for the full year. Beyond that, it lets us claw back over 1/4 of the 1,000 basis points we had lost. A large share of that margin erosion came from choices we made on purpose across the past 2 years aimed at generating substantial sales and free cash flow. We needed to assemble the financial strength required to work through our leverage position amid our financial crisis. Part of what we chose to do was give retailers better pricing in exchange for fresh promotions, new listings, and shelf space that would help us move more product. We surrendered some margin points, but doing so let us get into a position where we could capture share. That decision was the right one, and the results of taking that route are visible in our 2024 performance as well as in the foundation for future growth that we have established. Share improvements in the consumer business play a major role in our recovery. We knew the arrangement with retailers would produce share increases, but even we were surprised by how large those gains turned out to be. This year the lawn and garden category was either stagnant or shrinking, yet at our largest retail accounts we gained nearly 700 basis points of share, and that figure reflects the entire portfolio. If you set mulch aside, the improvement was still substantial, coming in at 300 basis points higher. Throughout my entire time at Scotts Miracle-Gro, I have never seen a stretch where we captured this much share within one year, and I want to express my gratitude to our retail partners. It reflects the strength of our brands along with our proven ability to deliver results and respond to external pressures. In terms of firepower, no one else possesses what we do. When it comes to selling, promoting, and moving our products, nobody does it better, and our brands are in the strongest shape they've ever been. According to a study conducted recently, consumers' views around trust and safety rose during the year for both Scotts and Miracle-Gro. The new organic soils line under Miracle-Gro demonstrates how well we can create growth via innovation, and it got a boost from a marketing push featuring Martha Stewart that audiences responded to well. By the close of Q3, that line had become the number one contributor to our unit POS gains in soils, and it has driven us to pick up meaningful share gains across the soils category as a whole. By collaborating with our retail partners, we delivered wins for them as well as for ourselves. Thanks to our campaigns and the promotions we ran together with retailers, a lot of customers came through their doors, which outperformed the sluggish traffic most retailers saw. Advertising is ours to run, we drive shoppers to their locations, we execute joint promotions, and we put our own sales staff and merchandise inside the stores. That approach delivers results, and nobody else in lawn and garden can do the same. Turning to Q4 now — we feel good about our direction. We expect a strong fall season, powered by promotional activity around lawn and control products that carry better margins, plus targeted discounts on key grass seed SKUs, and we'll invest heavily in marketing as well. Those efforts get a big boost over the Labor Day weekend. Another period when we bargain with merchants regarding spring is the fourth quarter. How we price our entire range will factor into those conversations. Everyone has felt inflation's sting, and what we charge hasn't matched what we pay. Given retailer worries and the margin strain they face, we'll take a very restrained stance on next year's pricing. For 2025, we still anticipate that pricing will add a minimum of 1% to net sales. Over the longer haul, our prices have to track inflation's pace. Turning to Hawthorne. This operation has generated cash and is profitable, delivering its first money-making quarter in 2 years. Its pivot away from selling third-party goods toward an exclusive emphasis on its category-leading brands produced a 6% rise in branded sales versus the prior year and a 144% profit gain. Hawthorne keeps pioneering top-tier innovation as well, having recently introduced 3 new LED offerings beneath the Gavita label.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveHawthorne is driving a turnaround on the supply side of the industry, and we're watching some fast followers attempt to copy our business model. Chris and his team have looked at many possibilities for forming partnerships or splitting Hawthorne off from SMG. They've put in a great deal of effort, but our conclusion is that it's preferable to keep Hawthorne in place for the time being, particularly since it's profitable, while we build the pieces for a longer-term answer. A few weeks ago at our Investor Day, we talked about our financial blueprint for the coming 3 years. The whole point is to get the company back to firing on all cylinders. You can find the details on our Investor website, but here's the shortened version. Matt and Nate put together a 3-year plan built on generating an average of 3% annual growth by way of innovation, pricing, and expansion of our retail and direct-to-consumer channels. We're aiming for adjusted gross margins above 30% and adjusted EBITDA of $600 million, along with further leverage reductions below 3.5x. These are sensible targets that will produce meaningful shareholder value, but I think we can do even more. I'm pushing and incentivizing the team to bring leverage below 3x during this time frame through additional top line and bottom line growth and outsized cash flows; we'll boost investments in our business, brands and capital improvement. In the coming year, we'll direct an incremental $25 million toward our brands and innovation. And earlier this month, we announced that Martha Stewart will serve as our Honorary Chief Gardening Officer, advising us on gardening trends, new gardeners and products. She'll also be at the center of our gardening campaigns in 2025. I see fiscal '24 as the bridge year in the transition away from the financial strain of the past 2 years toward a state where we can achieve the kind of returns our shareholders deserve. I give credit to the management team, Matt, Nate and Chris especially, for collaborating not only to speed up our progress, but to deliver on our commitments and get us to a great place for next year. I want to thank our associates for their resilience, and our banks, retailers, and the Board of Directors for their support. The past 2 years have been the hardest in the history of Scotts Miracle-Gro, but we're approaching our business with renewed optimism, enthusiasm and determination. I welcome the chance to have you continue with us on our journey. Now I'll hand it over to Matt.
Matt Garth
executiveAppreciate it, Jim, and greetings this morning from Central Ohio. I hope you're having a nice summer, enjoying what your spring planting produced and everything your lawns and gardens can give you alongside family and friends. As Jim mentioned, our third quarter performance was outstanding across both of our primary business segments. The U.S. Consumer lawn and garden operation gained from consumers staying highly engaged, and our Hawthorne division reported adjusted segment profitability for the first time in 2 years. With free cash flow year-to-date nearing $500 million and pushing additional debt paydown, we closed the quarter at net leverage of 5.45x, which is a full turn under the covenant ceiling. These outcomes leave us confident about delivering a solid close to the year consistent with the updated guidance we provided back in June. Keeping that summary in mind, let's dig into the specifics of how we did in the third quarter. Our U.S. Consumer business gained from more promotional efforts and media backing, lifting net sales to $1 billion during the quarter, which is 11% higher than the same period last year. For U.S. Consumer, net sales year-to-date rose 2% versus the prior year, reaching $2.7 billion. Significantly, last year's third quarter gained roughly $100 million from replenishment orders in our growing media business, which we now anticipate shipping during this year's fourth quarter, producing sales growth of almost 50% compared with last year. That said, we anticipate closing out the fiscal year with U.S. Consumer net sales growth inside our revised guidance range of 5% to 7%, as order and shipment timing keeps normalizing over the rest of the fiscal year. During the third quarter, our media and promotional efforts focused on the Martha Stewart and Scott for Scotts campaigns, plus a shift toward heavier spending on controls as we addressed consumer demand for fighting increased pest and weed pressure. Let me echo what Jim said about share. The steps we took alongside our retail partners helped produce robust shelf performance, with SMG share rising 7 percentage points even while the lawn and garden category fell compared with last year. Through mid-July, unit POS year-to-date has climbed 10% versus last year, driven by gains in growing media and controls, whereas inventory units at our 3 biggest customers have risen 2% compared with the prior year. POS dollars year-to-date through mid-July are basically even with the prior year, reflecting a heavier mix of lower-priced mulch relative to other product categories, plus ongoing price and promo activity funded by SMG and our retail partners alike. Now turning to Hawthorne. The shift in go-to-market strategy toward proprietary rather than distributed brands remains on track. Sales for its signature brands climbed 6% in the third quarter versus last year. Total Hawthorne segment sales dropped 28% to $68 million for the quarter and 33% to $214 million year-to-date. Because we discontinued third-party distributed brands, this top line sales decrease was anticipated and won't hurt the total company adjusted EBITDA target. The reason for this is that the positive margin impact we were aiming for is coming through from Hawthorne's flagship brand strategy. In Q3, Hawthorne recorded non-GAAP segment profit of $3.8 million, marking its first profitable quarter in 8 quarters, versus a loss of $8.7 million in the third quarter a year earlier. Now let's turn to gross margin and cost of goods for the entire company. For Q3, the non-GAAP adjusted gross margin rate came in at 29.2%, up against 21.3% the prior year. The year-over-year gain largely reflects reduced distribution, material and E&O costs, along with higher Roundup commissions and better product and segment mix. Looking at the year-to-date picture, the non-GAAP adjusted gross margin rate rose from 27.6% to 30.2%, propelled by the same drivers behind the Q3 improvement, partly offset by pricing. Since 95% of our commodity inputs are now locked, we can see our full year costs clearly. Material costs for the full year are not anticipated to have any meaningful impact on gross margin. As we've said before, we expect to realize the advantages of recent material cost deflation in fiscal '25. SG&A rose $19 million during the quarter, up 15% against third quarter '23, reflecting greater investments in marketing and sales activities aimed at driving volume, plus higher variable compensation. Year-to-date, SG&A is essentially flat at 14% of net sales, as growth in media spending and variable compensation was offset by reduced amortization expense, mainly within the Hawthorne segment. When taken together, these adjustments have little effect on the calculation of year-to-date non-GAAP adjusted EBITDA, since the rise in share-based payments is largely offset by the drop in amortization expense. Q3 non-GAAP adjusted EBITDA climbed 86% to $237 million, up from $127 million last year. Year-to-date, non-GAAP adjusted EBITDA reached $607 million, compared with $553 million a year earlier. These gains were mainly driven by the volume and gross margin rate improvements mentioned above. Below operating income, third quarter results include $23 million in equity income from the Bonnie JV, versus $22 million for the same period last year. On a year-to-date basis, excluding the impairment charge taken in the first quarter of fiscal '24, equity income was $4 million for both fiscal '24 and fiscal '23. According to their latest projections, we expect fiscal '24 profitability from Bonnie to finish the year flat against fiscal '23. Interest expense fell by $8 million, or 18%, in the third quarter versus last year; year-to-date, interest expense dropped $13 million, or 9%, from a year ago, thanks to lower debt levels, partly offset by our weighted average interest rate rising from 5.3% to 5.9%. As of June 30, borrowings were nearly $600 million below where they stood a year ago, driven by roughly $500 million in sales of accounts receivable, net of discount, and other free cash flow generation from operations and inventory improvements. In addition, cash on hand grew to $280 million from $27 million last year. We're still on schedule to hit the remaining $1 billion of free cash flow across 2 years by the close of fiscal '24. As of the end of Q3, roughly 80% of our interest rates stay fixed, through a mix of long-term fixed rate notes plus interest rate swap agreements. Costs from discounts tied to the AR sale facility, recorded within other income and expense, came to about $22 million through Q3. Our adjusted tax rate for the third quarter stood at 26.8%, versus 25.8% a year earlier. That rise stems from the negative effect of greater nondeductible executive compensation expense, partly offset by reduced year-to-date discrete tax items. Through Q3 FY '24, and matching what we saw the prior quarter, our year-to-date share count grew by roughly 1.2 million shares compared with a year ago, largely because of higher share issuance tied to short-term and long-term incentive awards and media purchases made with shares for both FY '23 and '24. By the close of Q3, over 80% of our full year POS sits behind us, which gives us solid visibility for the rest of the year. We anticipate closing the year consistent with our guidance and believe we're set up for additional growth and margin gains in FY '25 and beyond. I'd encourage you to check out our Investor site, where you can review the high-level midterm financial targets we laid out at our recent Investor Day. Across the coming 3 years, we look to get back to mid-30s gross margin rates along with more balanced capital allocation, helped by ongoing robust free cash flow and a stronger balance sheet. That said, let's turn now to the Q&A. Operator, please open the line for questions.
Joe Altobello
analystOkay, for my first question, I'd like to revisit those 3-year objectives you shared with us a few weeks back — the 3% yearly sales increase along with the 250 basis points of annual gross margin improvement. When we consider how those goals will be paced, is there anything out of the ordinary for FY '25? What I'm really trying to ask is whether, at this stage, that ought to be our baseline assumption when we look ahead to next year?
Matt Garth
executiveAs we laid out for you during the Investor Day, Nate and I provided a picture of how that would unfold across the coming couple of years. And it seemed sensible to note that it might simply be distributed over 3 years. However, as we're aware, it could end up somewhat uneven. When you consider '25 emerging from '24, correct, we indicated we wouldn't capture certain raw material savings within our cost structure during '24. A small amount is there, yet that was set to arrive in '25; therefore you could observe somewhat greater margin recovery in '25 compared with '26 and '27. Still, without going deep into guidance for '25 right now, we'll spell that out for you once the fourth quarter wraps up, though I believe it's fine to begin viewing it as perhaps somewhat more in '25, with '26 and '27 likewise carrying on along that recovery trajectory. Then there's the pricing piece. What the team has been up to, and what Jim referenced during the prepared remarks, involved collaborating with retailers. You're aware that happens at present and continues through the fourth quarter. So perhaps, Nate, if you're willing, you could simply describe how that's shaping up and what your thinking is for the next couple of years.
Nate Baxter
executiveYeah. Thank you, Matt. As you mentioned, we are currently right in the middle of that process together with our retail partners. I would say we aren't seeing anything suggesting we won't begin from a strong foundation based on how we close out '24. I believe Matt is correct. There's likely somewhat more room for us in '25, though at the same time we are pushing hard on not just our cost reductions, but also our innovation and our pricing efforts for '26 and '27. So I'd say it's somewhat early to give the complete picture, but I think your thinking is headed in the right direction.
Joe Altobello
analystUnderstood. All right. Then perhaps, as a quick follow-up on that. That single point you anticipate coming from acquisitions — could you give us some clarity on what you're considering when it comes to M&A?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveWell, here's the thing — I can lay out, more or less, the characteristics of lawn and garden deals that carry minimal integration risk. Plus partners who, in my view, would mostly be willing to take Scotts equity as their form of payment. That's roughly the way our thinking runs on this.
Peter Grom
analystPerhaps we could revisit that margin topic Joe raised. Matt, if we pull back a bit and consider the pressure on margins along with its various causes across recent years, could you help frame the scale of the opportunity tied to raw material savings? Referring to what was said regarding '25, when more of that gets recaptured. Any perspective on where things stand in that journey would be useful as a starting point.
Matt Garth
executiveOur message has stayed the same, and I appreciate the chance to discuss how we've framed this during the last couple of years, since Jim, Nate, and I have each repeated the point that 1,000 basis points of gross margin have been lost. That happened because of the inflationary stretch. It also happened due to pricing ability when passing costs along to consumers during that span; and now, emerging from '24, we find ourselves having recovered roughly 250 basis points, plus 260 by the third quarter; and considering what's left of that, the 700 basis points. What we've communicated is that much of it now centers on recovering pricing to offset those inflationary forces that hit us. Where did those inflationary forces hit us? Certainly raw materials, accounting for slightly over 1/2 of it. Beyond that, our cost structure, where we made commitments in distribution and staffing, is where inflation has affected us, and those represent further chances to win back pricing, once more, that emerged throughout the last couple of years. Consequently, looking ahead over the coming 3 years, the pricing we will recover is, as we've stated, 1% plus, while cost reductions contribute as well, at about 1.5% annually, and remember the note we offered early in this call about how that could be somewhat more uneven; yet that addresses the 750 basis points going forward, through a mix of regaining pricing and, as we mentioned regarding certain supply chain cost reductions, that too will involve recovering pricing and achieving efficiencies during that period.
Peter Grom
analystAll right, that's helpful. And perhaps one more question for you, Matt. I believe you brought up an extra $25 million of investment for next year. Does that get covered by added cost savings, allowing you to remain inside your longer-term SG&A goal range? Or is your view that the additional gross margin improvement, or the profit dollars you expect, will be absorbed by that extra investment?
Matt Garth
executiveWhen this year closes, on a total SG&A basis, we'll land in the middle to the high end of the 15% to 16% range. Looking ahead to '25, once more, I won't speak to guidance, but we've communicated that an additional $25 million will be spent. I'd say it's sensible to expect us at the top end of the 15% to 16% range; so what does that imply? This is the part where the entire team plays a role. All of our efforts, in the prior year, in the current year, are aimed at building far stronger backing for our brands, for innovative products delivered to our consumers, and that is what we're working toward while generating more flexibility for this company going forward; that $25 million, alongside the added media spending we made this year in '24, produces immediate results that give us a lot of confidence. So I'll hand it to Jim and likely Nate.
Jim Hagedorn
executivePeter, here's my take on it. I've got a Board meeting on Friday, all right. And one thing I've tasked Nate and his group with is figuring out what's needed to run this business the right way. I figure now is the ideal moment to ask the new guy who's brought in a fresh marketing team: what do you actually need to back this brand, or the product lines we have across multiple brands? Part of that involves examining the competitive landscape. And although I don't believe Zevo is truly coming after us — they're our partner, SCJ — I think they're doing the same thing we do: funding their business through advertising and marketing dollars, collaborating with retailers, and that's their franchise; we don't need to be taught that. We already know it. So what do I expect? Over the long haul, I believe they'll arrive with a wish list — and I don't mean that lightly — probably twice what we spend now. Now, we've got a business to operate, and we've got to work out how to do that profitably and kind of — keep in mind we're investors too. Perhaps the largest investors in the company are seated at this table. And so we understand that piece: we have to get this done in time, but I think what you'll see is that the need to spend behind this business, which we'll have to throttle as quickly as we can, ties back to the Board meeting — it's not merely what do you folks think you need to run the business? And that, I believe, is the biggest area where I think we feel we need it: sort of brand support, meaning direct to the consumer, plus some incremental innovation money. Accomplish that while pushing margins back to where they historically were, call it 35%. And that margin will go a long way toward paying for this stuff. But I think my challenge to them will be: can we, within our planning horizon, reach that point of, call it, $200 million or so in direct media, which we consider a sort of righteous number? But that — the trick is, and this is where tension exists between the operating community and the finance community here, is how to do that without trashing our P&L.
Matt Garth
executiveAnd an important piece of this — Nate might want to jump in on this too — is that spending, and over the last 2 years we've observed that customers do react, and we do achieve the growth we're aiming for from those investments. So yes, as the top line grows, it gives us a larger percent of SG&A available to deploy. That's the dynamic Jim is referring to. So we'll stay disciplined across all of our lines; but obviously, there is a route to growth and to enhancing the overall...
Jim Hagedorn
executiveHonestly, what I'd say is encouraging from all this is that we've already taken out roughly $400 million in costs, and a quarter of that got reinvested into the company. I'd treat that as a rough benchmark for what lies ahead.
Jonathan Andersen
analystCan you assist us — or assist me — with the point-of-sale bridge? According to what you said, unit volume rose 10% through the middle of July, yet dollars came in flat. With your guidance calling for 5% to 7% growth in the U.S. Consumer business, how should we reconcile that 5% to 7% revenue growth against flat point-of-sale dollars through mid-July? I realize certain factors are within your control and certain investments are being made by the retailer, but could you take us through it?
Matt Garth
executiveYes, quite straightforward, and I appreciate the slight leading of the witness there, since you are correct. Regarding the register transactions — the money customers spend at checkout — that figure isn't always directly connected to the revenue unit we report, which is driven by what we ship out. So when you compare flat POS dollars against the 10% POS growth we referenced in our prepared remarks, let me break that down a bit further. Roughly half of it comes from mix — meaning we're moving a great deal of mulch and soils, and those are positive developments, representing really strong strategic placements alongside our partners. The remaining half stems from additional promotional efforts on our side as well as those of our retail partners. They have the ability to raise prices on the shelf, and that can actually bring POS dollars down. That's the dynamic you saw in this case, in contrast to the 2% to 3% range we've posted through the year so far. Turning to the 5% to 7% figure for the remaining part of the year, Jon, it's actually pretty straightforward. We did have an unusual situation in Q3 of last year, and we walked you through it at the time. It came down to a shipment piece that landed in Q3 rather than Q4. Typically, our Q4 carries somewhere around $300-ish million. Looking at this year, the usual schedule for those shipments landing in Q4 means you're going to see sales up about 50% compared to last year. That's the piece that lets you work through the numbers and arrive at 5% to 7% for the entire year.
Nate Baxter
executiveIf you'll allow me, Jon, I'd like to offer a bit of context here. This represents a highly strategic move alongside our retail partners, and it produced flat POS dollars while also bringing shoppers through the doors, correct? So when you examine retailer traffic, it's flat to up 1%, yet in lawn and garden, that figure reaches up 6%. That's precisely the value we deliver to the marketplace, and many of those incentive programs — regardless of whether we or the retailers provide the funding — are built around generating that foot traffic and helping shoppers who visit those retailers build bigger baskets.
Jonathan Andersen
analystThat's useful. And it connects somewhat to what I wanted to ask next. So we're now 80% through the '24 season, at least when you look at POS, and you're either beginning talks or already in talks with major accounts about '25. In what way are your customers assessing how well the '24 season went, given that they made commitments to Scotts regarding additional listings and additional shelf space? How are they viewing whether the season succeeded or not? And what does that tell us about your capacity to keep those new listings and shelf space or perhaps expand them in 2025?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveThat's a large question. Let me begin by saying that, on the whole, I believe the season was rather disappointing, frankly. I think we performed considerably better, luckily, than that. But I think if you look at live goods and more or less everyone else, it was likely a declining market. I think the Northeast truly pulled everything down. And if you look at live goods, which I believe serves as a fairly decent gauge for this, I think there were substantial double-digit declines in the market for live goods at, say, the home center business. And I think that's in fact a fairly solid signal of what occurred during the season. Honestly, I'm attempting to — so I can treat this call a bit as, since I know our partners listen to these calls. I think what we did truly worked. I think what they did alongside us truly worked. And I think the numbers would have appeared much worse had we not been promoting our joint businesses together so heavily. And I do think that comes at the expense of margin. It does. And I think our partners must keep in mind what we were trying — all of us were trying to do is bring customers in to purchase things at a moment when many major durable categories face greater challenges. And I think we were extremely successful at that. And I think they need to keep that in mind when it returns to this question, "How do they view the season?", they ought to be fairly pleased, in my view, about how the season went and not concentrate so much on margin, concentrate on footsteps. And I think lawn and garden had a major impact, and I think we defied the trend partly with their assistance, but at a somewhat considerable cost to us in margin as we helped bring about so-called cost-outs. To the best of my knowledge, and this is what I expect since programs will change, if they aren't, is those programs remain intact. The numbers that we anticipated getting, and this goes somewhat back to sort of a call down, our call down earlier this year, what we anticipated from the deals we struck with retailers, we anticipated a fairly considerable revenue increase from that. Plus, things were far tougher than that. Yet the blame doesn't fall on the retailers for failing to deliver as expected. They delivered; the issue was simply that the market had declined. Therefore, what I anticipate—and this comes, I believe, out of conversations with them—is that those programs remain in place and could possibly be expanded.
Nate Baxter
executiveSure, I can address that, Jim. The way I see it — and keep in mind, we're still in the process of working out these programs alongside our retail partners — I have a lot of confidence that we'll continue building on the foundation we laid down last year. We're going to make some refinements regarding certain new SKUs that perhaps didn't move as well as we'd hoped. That said, don't forget, there's a great deal of innovation headed our way in '25, so I'd say it's largely a continuation of the same narrative. I'd rather not say anything further until we've closed out the fourth quarter and locked in our plans. Still, I feel quite positive about our current position.
Andrew Carter
analystI'd like to ask — you mentioned expecting to capture 1% pricing in the coming year, and I realize that figure reflects an average across the whole portfolio. So when it comes to lawns and ferts specifically, which is the category with higher margins and has been under pressure, would you consider directing more effort there, particularly given the inputs you're working with? I recall site one noting grass seed was down, with pricing falling 20% this year following a decline the year before.
Nate Baxter
executiveLet me try to address that. Andrew, here's how I'd frame it: in areas where we're confident the consumer won't react favorably, we won't pursue pricing. From a cost standpoint, we'll need to make back-end adjustments so we can compete there and generate the margin we're after. That said, I'd argue there's substantial opportunity across many categories — and it might not be confined to lawns and ferts and seeds specifically — to apply selective pricing, which is exactly what we've described; it will be surgical in nature. This will happen collaboratively with our retail partners. I have confidence we'll reach that goal. Jim, as you're aware, has been urging us toward additional pricing in '25. In our view, 1% is within reach. Considering where the consumer stands, I still regard '25 as somewhat of a transition year. Even so, I'm confident we can collaborate with our retailers to secure that pricing.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAndrew, I'd like to delve a bit into — I believe since — I appreciate you probing the soft spots, grass seeds and lawn ferts. The grass seed category was a letdown for everyone. My own view is there's some elasticity at play, but mainly it was terrible weather across the Northeast, and — I dislike admitting this — we had a somewhat cool and wet start to the season. We'll find out how autumn unfolds, and that'll be a terrific thing for us to observe, because as I fly back and forth to the East Coast, I'm noticing quite a few brown lawns; it's been fairly warm. So we'll see. One part of our problem is that we hold multiyear purchasing agreements with our suppliers on grass seed. That means we're carrying a great deal of grass seed inventory. And I suppose it isn't fully clear to me what occurred in — aside from the bad weather and perhaps grass, grass seed, becoming pricey, yet I do believe we'll be tinkering with pricing on grass seed. Consequently, there will be chances with grass seed since I want to see that inventory disappear. And we'll put money behind it. We experienced a modest loss of market share on grass seed during the first half of our fiscal year. We've observed a rebound in the second half, even though that's happening against a market that's shrinking overall. But we're beginning to identify some levers available to us, and I believe we'll keep looking into that, and we're hopeful regarding the fall season for lawns. So I think bargains exist on grass seed because I personally — I trust Matt concurs, we want to see that inventory get consumed. Regarding lawn ferts, we were chatting ahead of the call about how we feel concerning it. And I think no one here is content that we've fully determined what's going on with it; so I'd likely classify it as a category, it's an area where additional work remains for us. It matters a lot to us since it's high margin; we aren't quitting, but I think we'll be putting on our, what do you call it, the green eye shades as we consider the amount of investment behind lawns, which is whether we can get unit volume, sort of, up. And that would be the goal. And should we conclude we can't, then it will be a different approach to how we support the brand.
Nate Baxter
executiveI want to jump in on that, Jim. When it comes to fertilizer in particular, we entered this year following a horrible 2023 compared with roughly what we had planned, and we said that if we could simply keep our share steady within that segment, that would be enough. Set grass seed aside from the picture. That result isn't sufficient. I'm in agreement, yet we performed fairly well. We managed to keep it more or less even. So this marks the start of figuring out how we reinvent that business and draw the consumer in. Our view is that consumers have become somewhat indifferent toward their lawns, and addressing that will be a major piece of our broader media strategy.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAs I recall, we've got temporary staff handling the controls side of our lawn business, and our plan is to recruit external candidates to give a fresh feel to both the controls category—which is genuinely thriving at the moment—and lawns. So I'd say stay tuned for news on that front, and we'll make sure you're kept informed.
Andrew Carter
analystThat sounds good. For my second question, I mean, the earnings recovery is sort of taking hold at this point, so what's your outlook when it comes to demand from Bonnie — where do you think that could go? I realize it's going to be a volatile business, given that it's nursery. And then please remind us as well: Bonnie's, beyond the business itself, does generate those incremental touch points of people in the store, which is a strategic benefit you're not willing to sacrifice, I don't think?
Nate Baxter
executiveYes. That's exactly right, Andrew. Live goods are something we love. Look, we entered the year feeling optimistic. What I'd say is this: Bonnie had certain structural items they needed to repair on the service level side. That was likely the biggest area where we, as a co-owner, gave them support. I believe they did quite well, and that's according to what the retailers told us. Bonnie has to grow; so they've got a plan for organic growth of 20%, but we're also beginning to examine M&A for Bonnie that will, more or less, accrete on their top and bottom line. So giving up is absolutely not happening. Live goods are something we love. There is a strategic attachment for us, but live goods had a very tough year. Things really fell apart in our Q3. And I'll repeat what Jim said earlier, which is they actually outperformed the other live goods retailers, even though everybody is down, call it, double digits; so I'm happy with the investment; we can always do better. And part of this changing of the guard that's happening in marketing with Sadie Oldham coming in on Gardens, she's going to directly own Bonnie as part of that, and we're going to make sure it's an integrated play with our Gardens team.
Matt Garth
executiveAndrew, simply move up one level, perhaps two. And keep in mind what we repeat at each conference: what exactly is our line of work? It could be cultivating more goodness, or delivering gardening right to people's homes so they can savor the rewards of investing time and affection into producing excellent vegetables, superior herbs, or beautiful flowers — or simply treasuring moments in their yard with loved ones on a wonderful lawn that lets you engage in sports, dig around, and genuinely experience being connected to their outdoor area. That's our purpose. So I'm merely responding to that remark about sacrificing Bonnie, which — as Nate made clear, definitely not. It aligns perfectly with our mission. And I'll take it a step further, if you're willing to hear it. The results at Hawthorne and what that crew has accomplished amid such an unstable setting are outstanding; I realize there's been extensive conversation — meaning us, the company, alongside every investor and analyst — regarding how that business has progressed and its place within our portfolio. This represents a strong result, showing we delivered on our commitments in a business facing serious headwinds. Yet keep in mind, it fits squarely with our mission. We assist people in cultivating excellent products, achieving excellent outcomes, and doing so in a way that gives them maximum fulfillment. Thus the entire portfolio, spanning from lawns to growing media to controls to Hawthorne, revolves around that vision and that consumer satisfaction. And as Jim mentioned earlier regarding the M&A question, there are additional brands we ought to possess. There are more perfectly aligned positions we should hold, and we have methods to obtain them; so simply bear that in mind as you consider the broader Scotts and our purpose — tremendous opportunity and tremendous profitability exist in all that we undertake; we will optimize that. And the positions we hold currently are advantages we intend to leverage even more.
Chris Carey
analystTo put it plainly, what would you have to observe in the lawns segment during Q4 for the POS figures to be reached? Apologies if this was already addressed, but broadly speaking, we've faced some mix-related pressure so far this year. Could you restate how much visibility you have into Q4 — in particular, closing part of that distance between POS and your guidance? I realize it's been discussed, yet questions keep coming my way. So perhaps a little additional detail would help.
Nate Baxter
executiveSure, Chris — Nate here. As we've noted previously, I believe, the fall lawns business accounts for roughly 20% to 25% of what we do. As Jim mentioned, optimism feels warranted after a summer that was pretty harsh in terms of heat and humidity. The lawns don't look good, and on the fertilizer side especially, we're beginning to see a response. Grass seed has already been handled, and we intend to push hard on it with improved pricing for consumers this fall. So I won't go so far as to forecast our final result, though we sense that our positioning is in place, the demand clearly exists, and the real task is putting our message in front of the consumer.
Chris Carey
analystFor the second one — considering how strong gross margin looks, or at least stronger than what was expected, could it be that you're essentially borrowing some of the gains you'd anticipated for the coming couple of years? How do you view the foundation for this year compared with where things stood a month or 2 back, and what's your sense of what's achievable next year — next year in particular — plus the pace at which gross margin comes back?
Matt Garth
executiveYes. We addressed this when the Q&A started, but allow me to restate it in this manner and put it in the context of '24. Our statement regarding '24 was that margin recovery would reach 250 basis points plus. We're set to hit that. So that gives us confidence; it means we aren't taking anything from '25 in order to make '24 happen. And none of that is deliberate. It came from planning and discipline that we established, and that margin recovery is coming as the year progresses. That positions us, as we've mentioned, to capture the remainder of the approximately 700 basis points we believe we're short over the coming 3 years; and regarding your timing question, our comment was that although 2 weeks ago, I believe, 3 weeks ago, during the Investor Day, we described it as roughly even, there could be a chance for a stronger 2025 due to certain raw material effects. But that uncertainty — we'll share more clarity on it as we get into 2025; so let's finish Q4. Moving to — as Nate mentioned before, our POS trajectory remains on course for meeting our guidance; that covers how we've characterized the fall over the last couple of years with respect to lawns, normal, not really outsized; and then when we consider, if you're going to explore the topic of retailer inventories, we feel very confident about those positions. And keep in mind, a timing gap exists. Fall begins in our Q4, while for retailers, Q4 is in fact our Q1. So a load-in will occur during our Q4 for the fall sell-in, and that fall then takes place in our Q1.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveChris, as we're wrapping up the budget process for the coming year, no figure anyone has presented to me shows margin gains below roughly 200 basis points for next year. So my sense is we'll keep moving along that path. In my view, they could deliver more than that, yet as things stand, that's the amount they're prepared to commit to on paper.
William Reuter
analystRegarding the softness in the industry, I want to ask something. It has always seemed to me that this is a fairly nondiscretionary business that holds up well in a recession. Obviously, there are housing difficulties when it comes to the shortage of existing home sales. When someone purchases a new home, I'm certain they feel somewhat more eager to put money into enhancing how the outside looks. In your view, has the housing market driven the softness we saw this year? Or do you think it truly came down to nothing but Northeast weather? What would you say accounts for the market's softness?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveSure. I can only give my own perspective. To begin, my take is that weather explains most of it. People, I believe, are never happy to hear that. The Street has its own view, but my message to folks is that during the season, forecasting our business is simple. Just look outside. If spring arrives and you're able to wear a T-shirt, that's a favorable day for us. That said, I do believe pricing turned into a problem. And looking at the earnings being reported right now, from companies like Starbucks and McDonald's, my sense is that the consumer isn't as flush as the Democrats believe. So I do think that — we know that when we repriced lawn fertilizer and grass seed last year, we knew — it was immediately apparent to us that unit volume increased.
Matt Garth
executiveThat contributed to how we beat expectations in Q1.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveRight. And that worked out well for us, and well for the retailers too. But here's what I take from it — and honestly, I've always been fairly doubtful about this whole elasticity concept. You tell someone it's just a few percent more, and you figure, is that really going to stop them from buying? The trouble is, certain items climbed so high that — I don't believe it hit $100, but you were approaching roughly $100 for a bag of grass seed, or for a bag of lawn fertilizer; and my sense is that unless someone's lawn is in awful shape, folks are simply going, "Hey, I'm not sure." So I'd attribute most of it to weather, though I do believe pricing played a role. Over the long haul, I think the demographics of our business are tremendous. Homes have to get built, and younger people have to purchase them. Personally, I think interest rates have to come down. Buying a home today is tough for young people, in my view, so if the feds begin cutting rates, that's fine by me personally. But when you consider our long-term demographics, I'd say things look quite solid out there.
William Reuter
analystAll right — one more thing I wanted to add...
Nate Baxter
executiveNo, pardon me, my point was simply to back up what Jim mentioned, from a scientific angle, since I'm a bit of a geek. Models are what we're putting together, and without question weather mattered most. Pricing, sure, and how consumers feel — I'd say discretionary spending runs along a scale. So when lawns are holding up fine but people's budgets feel tight, they clearly hesitated a bit at the prices they saw, though weather <<inaudible>>.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveBut they didn't move to private label. They <<inaudible>>.
Nate Baxter
executiveThey just sort of paused on the category, so.
William Reuter
analystRight. So you cited weather as the main problem, followed by pricing and elasticity. Looking back, has there been any link at all to existing home sales or new home sales?
Matt Garth
executiveAbsolutely.
William Reuter
analystThere is? All right. So perhaps — I mean, might those depressed figures represent a third factor behind the softness?
Matt Garth
executiveYes. I mean, we have observed that across the last 2 years, and articles have appeared in a range of publications about it, correct? So when sales of existing homes run slower, folks undertake fewer projects to spruce up their properties before listing them. That applies to small jobs indoors and small jobs outdoors; and so one point we raised a year ago was that even under those conditions, we had watched $500 projects keep going as people worked on their front yards and the entranceways to their homes, yet they were not necessarily spreading those efforts through the remaining parts of the house or out into the backyard; and so that pattern is persisting.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveIf you go through the past transcripts of calls like this one, stretching back a number of years, you'd see that we had talked ourselves into the belief that younger folks would be living in condos and wouldn't care about having yards, so we brought in a few demographers, and their basic message was that a huge number of people are reaching their 30s and starting families. Craig Menear, who was CEO of Depot back then and is a genuinely great person, and I went back and forth on this, and his argument was, "Jim, nobody has better housing data than we do, and what it shows is that once people have a couple of kids and a dog, they want a yard." That mattered, because we needed to persuade ourselves that we were, so to speak, a 0 to pricing type of company, one that ran at roughly GDP plus a couple; and by and large, that's been the pattern we've observed.
Operator
operatorThere are no more questions right now. That brings today's conference call to an end. Thanks for joining. You can disconnect at this point.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.