The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company (SMG) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
January 29, 2025
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Executive
executiveHello there. Brad Shelton here, and I'd like to extend a warm welcome to the Scotts Miracle-Gro First Quarter Earnings Conference Call. I've just taken on the Investor Relations leadership role, having spent 17 years with Scotts in several finance leadership positions. It's an honor to step into the shoes of Aimee DeLuca, who is retiring from Scotts Miracle-Gro at the close of this month following a 23-year tenure with the organization. I've enjoyed getting to know many of you so far, and I'm eager to connect with each of you in the months ahead. Joining us today are Chairman and CEO Jim Hagedorn, along with Interim Chief Financial Officer and Chief Accounting Officer Mark Scheiwer. Jim will share a business update, and then Mark will walk through our financial results. Once the webcast concludes, President and Chief Operating Officer Nate Baxter and Executive Vice President and Chief of Staff Chris Hagedorn will team up with Jim and Mark for an audio-only Q&A session. If you'd like to hear the Q&A, just stay on this webcast. To take part, please use the audio link included in our press release. As usual, today's session is being recorded. A replay will be posted on our website at investor.scotts.com. If you'd like to continue the conversation after the call, feel free to email or phone me directly. At this point, I'll hand things over to a special guest that Jim has asked to share some commentary about Safe Harbor and forward-looking statements. All right. SMG Investor, it's me — the mouse that got killed in the Tomcat commercial Award — awkward. Miami, Jim Hagedorn, the big cheese of Scotts Miracle-Gro, asked me to come here and help kick off this Q1 fiscal earnings call. This whole thing is a little off brand for me, but I am a versatile rodent, so today I'm going to be super profession. During today's review, the company will make forward-looking statements and discuss certain non-GAAP financial measures. Please be aware that the actual results could differ materially from what is shared today. Please refer to the company's Form 10-K filed with the SEC for details of the full range of risk factors that could impact the results. I don't know what any of that means. So, I'm going to turn it over to Jim. Yes, my man. This is going to be light.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveGood morning, and I hope you liked the mouse kicking off our call. Let me start by saying how happy I am with what we posted in Q1. We've gotten off to a really strong beginning. The metrics that underpin our fiscal '25 plan were delivered on, and regarding Q2 sales load-in, as retailers get set for the lawn and garden season, we feel quite at ease. Their enthusiasm for this season is equal to ours, perhaps even greater. Because of all this, our confidence is high in both our fiscal '25 EBITDA guidance and what we see ahead through fiscal '27. Mark is going to take you through the financials, since what I want to talk about is how the company is being built for what comes next. It's a journey — I've said that many times. This particular one started when COVID ended and we came out of it facing serious financial limits, which pushed us into managing from one crisis to the next; since then, the company's financial footing has been restored, and now we're positioned for growth and ongoing improvement. That journey let us take a moment to think about where Scotts Miracle-Gro is headed and what we want this company to become. In the Air Force, the saying is that a significant emotional event is often what produces change, and that is exactly what we went through. We've reached an inflection point, and at this point we're making changes in order to transform the organization. Let me lay out our destination, its meaning, and the path to get there. Our core convictions are where all of this transformation work begins. These core convictions were created many years ago to steer our associates as they drive, protect and nurture our truly special and unique consumer business. Every person here has those core convictions printed on their employee badge, yet we got into the habit of giving them little thought. Bringing them back to the center and going all in on our consumer franchise is what our future is about. We keep evolving further, becoming a consumer marketing powerhouse whose competitive advantages go beyond what we possess today. Our focus is getting narrower and our franchise is being optimized through investment. That's our mission. And a new leadership team, aligned with that mission, is the one pushing this change. Fulfilling this mission is going to have a major, positive effect on our financials going forward; it will let us reliably accomplish these 4 things: first, produce ongoing sales growth of no less than 3% each year, rooted in higher-margin products and innovation across every channel in our consumer business. Second, become the lowest cost maker of high-performance products, which hands us leverage in pricing talks with retailers plus the capacity to offer consumers solutions that are both differentiated and affordable. Third, lift gross margin to 35% alongside mid- to high single-digit EBITDA percent growth; and fourth, throw off robust free cash flow to fund more shareholder-friendly moves. Among those are a long-term pledge to cut our share count considerably and possibly, later on, issue special dividends. Why are these things within reach? There's a straightforward answer. We have a consumer franchise that no one can match, and it sits in a category with a lot of room to grow. Demographically speaking, the wind is at our back. Owning a home matters just as much as it ever has. On top of that, a shift is underway: millennials are on track to become the biggest group of people gathering and purchasing homes, and this younger generation represents our up-and-coming consumer. What sets us apart from rivals are our superpowers — our brands, our supply chain, our in-store sales force, our ties to the biggest home and garden retailers across North America, our R&D, and our capacity to throw off substantial cash flow. Marketing serves as our jet fuel. We also have the most engaging creative out there, from that Tomcat mouse you just met, to Icon Martha Stewart, to actor Christopher Hive featured at the center of our campaigns, and they make our brands come alive. And when we pair our advertising with our retailer programs, we generate foot traffic and in-store consumer activation at levels never seen before — this stuff works. We also compete in a space where only a handful of retailers operate. Lawn and garden is completely essential to these retailers, making up about 1/5 <<inaudible>> of their total sales and roughly 40% of their spring foot traffic. Our capacity to draw consumers into their stores is vital to their success; they depend on us and we depend on them, and together we drive consumer takeaway. Building a franchise like ours would be tough for anyone. Now let me walk you through examples of the investments we're making to reinforce our franchise, capture market share, draw new consumers into our world, and deliver growth. This year, we're investing an extra $40 million into our business, from brand support to innovation, with the vast majority directed at advertising; we're widening our demographic reach to a broader consumer base; that includes the Hispanic population, which holds growing influence in lawn and garden; we'll roll out bilingual advertising on digital media and mainstream Spanish television alongside our traditional campaigns. At the same time, we're putting more money into consumer activation programs that our retailers run. These programs amount to a sizable yearly investment exceeding 10% of our net sales. Once you add these retailer programs to what we're putting into our own advertising and brand support, that combined investment approaches 20% of sales; that may sound like a lot, and it is; and we're going to keep spending even more in this area over the years ahead. Let me explain why. In return for our investments, retailers grant us more listings, share of shelf, and off-shelf displays; for each dollar we hand them to promote our products, they put in even more on activation and promotion of our brands. The effect of our integrated efforts shows up in the nearly 10% POS lift we posted last year; we beat the category by 3x, and even more once you count live goods. We'll see growth in these areas again this year. It began in Q1 with double-digit POS increases and meaningful share gains. You might be asking yourself how we can pay for all of this and still hit our targets. That's where transformation plays a role, and it starts with our position as the lowest cost, high-performance manufacturer. Getting there means removing cost and generating greater efficiencies. When pricing is difficult to obtain — and understandably so, considering where the consumer stands today — our capacity to lower our cost structure and capture operational savings matters more than it ever has. We are unrelenting in examining our organization, focused on optimization and savings. This is something we know well. Our multiyear Project Springboard initiative produced $400 million in annual savings, and from that we reinvested $100 million into the business for growth; in fiscal '25, we'll remove at least $75 million from our supply chain; that represents half of the $150 million in supply chain costs we've targeted by fiscal '27. I've asked Nate to find another $30 million in savings across other parts of our company by getting rid of anything that doesn't add value. Cross-functional work streams are reviewing processes to streamline and simplify them. I want to emphasize that we will balance cost out with key infrastructure investments in areas such as technology and automation. With that in mind, our CapEx will rise by $25 million to $100 million this year.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveOn top of that, we're putting together innovation road maps that stretch out 5 to 10 years. Nate and his group are pushing against the way things have always been done, working to streamline and update the portfolio, with the main emphasis on products that carry higher margins. The Scotch fertilizer business illustrates this. It's a business with high margins, and we hold the market leader position, yet unit volume for us and for the category has been falling for over a decade. Part of that comes from what we've done ourselves. We're aware that our pricing has gotten out of whack, and we made things more complicated by moving away from the annual multistep solutions. Together with our retail partners, we went heavy in the spring with big events centered on single bag solutions. This year, we're moving back toward teaching consumers about the value of fertilizing multiple times a year. On top of that, climate change is making spring weather less predictable, which hits our long fertilizer business harder than anything else. So we'll distribute our loan spend across the year and direct more of it into the fall, when the weather window is more favorable and open. Looking at products, Nate's team, with support from our strategy group, is working up a strategy aimed at longer-term success. Among the options we're looking into are new formulations, natural fertilizers and liquids. When it comes to growth, our commitment to channel expansion is stronger than ever — an entire group of consumers buys only online, and many of them are new to our category. We have a team devoted to maximizing our POS this year across all retailer e-com sites. We're underpenetrated here, and we're aiming to turbocharge POS at the retailer.com channel; at the same time, the consumer team is reimagining our consumer-facing digital assets, with the launch of a refreshed Scotts Miracle-Gro brand website by year-end. It will position us as a house of brands with direct-to-consumer functionality. Direct-to-consumer gives us our chance to expand our subscription and our loyalty programs. With this reinvigorated focus on our business, we're getting back to basics. And that raises a question, what about our cannabis investments? We believe that moving Hawthorne out of Scotts Miracle-Gro is better for everyone; for our shareholders, this would eliminate the volatility of the cannabis sector and generate a significant uplift in gross margin. We and our banks think it would make it more clear what our equity represents and could expand our price-to-earnings multiple. Moving Hawthorne Gardening into a dedicated marijuana business would bring tax benefits and credit capacity to that company. It would also allow the plant-touching business to work alongside Hawthorne's world-class management team with formal relationships to Scotts Miracle-Gro. I know you've heard us talk about the separation before and you may recall that we moved off of it last year because we couldn't find a suitable partner. The difference today is there are more promising opportunities Hawthorne is now in a position of strength after the hard work to return it to profitability. The timing is right and we believe we can make the shifts <<inaudible>> still meeting our 2025 guidance. There's a different dimension of the transformation I'd like to cover; the management team has been rebuilt from the ground up, which has brought fresh thinking and new ways of doing things. Shire is the latest person to join, and he has fit in without any friction. And — when it comes to working alongside Nate, Chris and everyone else on the team, he's taken a collaborative tack. And this very week, we're ready to move ahead with a refresh of our Board of Directors. Tom Kelly, who has served as a director for a long time, has let us know he will step down from our Board as of January 31. For close to 20 years, Tom has delivered outstanding work, and we will certainly feel his absence. I'd like to express my thanks for his service. Later this week, my plan is to put forward Nick Miaritis, Chief Client Officer at VaynerMedia, to fill Tom's seat. Nick brings deep experience in consumer brands and digital marketing. Were Nick to be appointed, it would carry forward our push to add fresh capabilities and viewpoints to the board, together with greater diversity when it comes to age, ethnicity, gender and sexual orientation. Over the past 3 years, we've brought on 5 Board members whose expertise covers leveraged finance, fast-moving consumer goods, retail, market-leading brands, growth strategies, general management and C-suite level leadership; these shifts show where we're going. They give us the skill sets that line up with the strategy I've laid out today. Good things are happening at SMG. We're generating growth and recovering margin. Our financials keep getting better. We're making the most powerful franchise in lawn and garden even stronger. Scotts is an iconic American company whose rich history of market-leading brands stretches back nearly 160 years. We created this category, which holds extraordinary financial upside, and we keep shaping it. For our shareholders, that means more value creation and growth that lasts. My management team and I are fully devoted to this. I want to thank our retail partners, our banks, my leadership team and our associates for their commitment. Above all, I'm grateful to our shareholders for staying with us and backing us as we lift our business to the next level; now, I'll hand things over to Mark.
Mark Scheiwer
executiveThanks, Jim, and good morning, everybody. Before I dive into the Q1 numbers, I want to build on what Jim said regarding the transition and how smoothly it's been going. Over the course of my 13-year career at Scotts Miracle-Gro, I've held roles across numerous areas of finance, developed solid ties with our outside partners, and worked closely with the executive team and business leads. I believe in openness and transparency, and I'm eager to build relationships within the investor community. I've carried that approach forward during my early time here, and I'm excited to help the team move forward on our fiscal '25 and 3-year growth plans. My enthusiasm for expanding this business and creating value comes from my own experiences with my lawn and with gardening. I'm a dedicated consumer, and I can say from personal experience that Scotts Miracle-Gro owns the best brands in the industry. Turning to the quarter, we've gotten off to a terrific start. It's gratifying that these robust first quarter results sit well above what was expected. Although we feel good about the year, we're keeping our guidance unchanged, particularly given that Q1 accounts for under 10% of our total POS. The second and third quarters will drive the largest share of our full year performance. So expect us to take another look at guidance later in the fiscal year, just as we typically do, once the season is fully underway. What the first quarter tells us is that momentum is on our side. And our retail partners are deeply engaged. With the right strategies and investments, we're set up to drive consumer takeaway. On top of that, our first quarter results show the dedication of our supply chain team in working toward our full year goal of $75 million in cost savings, which, as a reminder, forms part of the $150 million 3-year target Jim described earlier. Now let's turn to the top line. In the first quarter, company-wide sales came to $417 million, up from $410 million. U.S. consumer volume gains rose 11% to $341 million from $307 million, which offset planned softness in Hawthorne; that included the benefit of stronger consumer engagement in the fall and earlier retailer load-in ahead of the spring season. We anticipate retailer load-in will be heaviest in Q1 and Q2, which together usually represent slightly more than half of our expected full year net sales. Replenishment orders in Q3 and Q4 will hinge on how much consumers sell through during the peak spring and summer selling season. As we've said before, for the full year we anticipate low single-digit core growth in U.S. consumer sales, which leaves out the effect of nonrepeating fiscal '24 sales for AeroGarden and bulk seed and fertilizer raw materials. POS is another positive story, rising 12% in dollars and 13% in units. Consumer takeaway was fueled by our fall advertising and promotional investment, along with more favorable macroeconomic factors. Hawthorne sales fell 35% to $52 million, compared with $80 million a year ago. A big drop was anticipated as a result of the strategic pivot Hawthorne undertook in April '24, leaving low-margin third-party distribution behind to concentrate on its more lucrative proprietary brands. Across the entire year, we anticipate a mid-single-digit decrease in Hawthorne sales. Even though Hawthorne's top line fell, its profitability rose substantially during the quarter, and we still anticipate that Hawthorne will deliver roughly $20 million of EBITDA for the whole year. When you total everything up, from the standpoint of the entire company for the full year, we anticipate net sales for the year landing at about flat compared with the prior year. Now, turning to gross margin. We delivered more than 750 basis points of gain in both GAAP and non-GAAP adjusted gross margin rates. The GAAP rate came in at 22.7% against 15.2% a year earlier; the non-GAAP adjusted gross margin rate stood at 24% against 13.7%. The main factors behind this include reduced material costs, beneficial fixed cost leverage, better product and segment mix, and decreased distribution costs stemming from the warehouse closures we carried out in the prior year. As I noted before, we anticipate that the $75 million in supply chain savings will help us reach our gross margin rate target of close to 30% for the full year. On timing, roughly 2/3 of the gross margin rate gain for fiscal '25 will land in the first half of the year. That's because of favorable material costs and the advantage from last year's closures of warehouses and other facilities. The rest will largely arrive in Q4, as we lap onetime inventory write-offs recorded in the fiscal fourth quarter of last year. Roughly 60% of total commodity needs for fiscal '25 were locked in as of the quarter's end; therefore we have strong visibility into input costs for the rest of the year. Taken together, we are on track toward our full year 30% gross margin rate target. Moving further down the P&L. SG&A came to $125 million, which is 9% higher than $115 million a year ago. This rise was primarily due to the investments we planned in media, technology and people. As we shared previously, our year-end SG&A target incorporates $40 million of extra investments in our business that Jim discussed. Together with higher performance-based incentives, these investments will push our SG&A for the current year to roughly 17% of net sales, compared with 16% last year. Adjusted EBITDA rose by close to $30 million; for the quarter, it was income of $3.8 million, against a loss of $25.8 million last year. This mirrors our Q1 gross margin recovery, combined with robust fall POS results and increased retailer shipments ahead of spring. Below the line, interest expense declined 21% to $34 million, thanks to lower debt balances and more favorable interest rates. We keep leveraging strong cash flow generation and working capital management to bring debt down further. We now anticipate interest expense for the full year coming in $15 million to $20 million below the prior year. When you look at Q1, our non-GAAP adjusted tax rate came in at 31.4%, and that reflects the seasonal pre-tax quarterly loss we recorded along with how discrete items landed in terms of timing. Looking at the full year, we continue to anticipate that the non-GAAP adjusted tax rate will land somewhere between 27% and 29%. On top of that, since Q1 tends to be a quarter where we post a loss because of how our business fluctuates with the seasons, the company has to rely on the basic share count when figuring out EPS. For this quarter, that figure stood at $57.3 million, whereas in the same period last year it was $56.7 million. That rise in share count comes from share-based compensation, and we expect it to grow to roughly 59 million shares on a diluted basis by the time the fiscal year wraps up. Our GAAP net loss for the first quarter totaled $69.5 million, which works out to $1.21 per share. That compares against a loss of $80.5 million, or $1.42 per share, in the prior year. On a non-GAAP adjusted basis, which strips out impairment, restructuring and other nonrecurring items, the loss got much better — coming in at $51 million, or $0.89 per share, against a loss of $82.2 million, or $1.45 per share, a year ago. Now let's turn to a few adjustments related to our GAAP numbers. During the quarter, we recorded $21.7 million in impairment, restructuring and other nonrecurring items.
Mark Scheiwer
executiveWhat was in this activity was, first, severance for employees, which takes in costs tied to changes among the executive team; second, losses on valuation stemming from the investment we made in RIV Capital during fiscal '21; and third, the last stage of the cost cuts under Project Springboard, which got underway in fiscal '22. As you might remember, our Hawthorne Collective subsidiary made an investment through convertible notes in RIV Capital, which runs legal cannabis operations in New York state. Near the end of our first quarter, RIV Capital completed a merger with consortium. Because of that, we turned those notes into nonvoting exchangeable shares of consortium. From here on, those consortium shares are going to be treated as an equity investment, with our proportional share of Consortium's net profit or loss showing up on an equity earnings line within our P&L. Our plan is to record this on a lag, beginning in the third quarter of the current fiscal year. Now I'll shift to free cash flow along with the balance sheet. Our attention stays on free cash flow as a way to make the balance sheet even stronger; and during Q1, our total debt came in below the prior year by $337 million. Free cash flow usage of $475 million for the quarter mirrors the usual seasonal working capital build. Thanks to our solid financial results as well as how we manage cash flow, we've brought our leverage ratio down by yet another quarter turn. In the first quarter, our leverage ratio stood at 4.52x net debt to adjusted EBITDA. That sits comfortably under the covenant ceiling of 5.5x. Keep in mind that our covenant ceiling declines as the year goes on, dropping to 5.25x during the second quarter, 5x during the third quarter, and 4.75x during the fourth quarter of this fiscal year. The leverage ratio we expect will keep trending downward too, and we can see a path to reaching leverage in the low 4s by the time the fiscal year ends. As I close, let me restate our 3 major financial goals for this fiscal year. They are, first, put money into our brands so we hold onto and extend the sales growth seen in fiscal '24 from added listings and share gains. Second, push margin recovery forward via sales growth and supply chain cost savings, and finally, make the balance sheet stronger by paying down more debt and concentrating on getting back to a capital allocation strategy that's more flexible; we'll keep making meaningful headway on all of these in '25 and stay on track with our 3-year growth plan. Finally, we're keeping a tight grip on costs and, to repeat what Jim said, we're bolstering our core consumer franchise and what he refers to as our superpowers. Above all, our eyes are on the future, building greater value and shaping a more shareholder-friendly environment. Thank you, and now we can begin the Q&A. I'll hand things over to the operator.
Chris Carey
analystThe press release mentioned a robust autumn period across every category, plus some retailers bringing in product early for spring. First, do you expect any shift in timing out of the March quarter and into the December quarter? Does that carry any consequences for the March quarter? Second, with February nearly here, could you say more about the early signals you're picking up in various markets — I assume nothing is falling apart, but what's your sense nationwide as spring approaches? And perhaps touch on your exposure to the West Coast, Los Angeles County in particular. So, a bit on the December versus March timing question, plus those early-season reads.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveThat's quite a lot packed in there, dude. Let's begin with how well autumn went. And truly, the season is underway. Our Board meeting is happening in Florida — after this call, we're flying down there for Thursday and Friday sessions. Temperatures are predicted to hit close to 80% <<inaudible>>, I believe — for — I'm not sure, the coming 5 or 6 days; so without question, from a lawn and garden perspective the country is starting to emerge, and at the POS level the figures keep looking favorable. Nate and I spoke with a senior merchant, a very senior merchant. I believe that happened last week. What we discussed partly appears in the remarks I gave today, and we asked whether that rang true for them — essentially conversations around program dollars. But we also got into how POS is performing and their perspective — drawing on the business they're watching in autumn; and thus far, spring where markets are opening, did they possess data that kind of foreshadows what to expect ahead. They said yes, they did, and that — it wasn't limited to lawn and garden. It was broadly their sales, and they sensed this was a solid signal that the consumer is alive and well and ready to spend; this is a home improvement retailer; so that encouraged us. Their top worry, which connects to timing, is — whether they've got sufficient inventory in place at store level; what that told us is there's no nervousness around load issues and there's a belief — again, returning to this, grounded in what their POS data showed, not only in lawn and garden but throughout the chain. That the consumer seems to be in a buying mood. And that historically, that's a favorable indicator; so I believe it, I wanted to believe it as well; so I think that's a healthy thing. I'm not sure what I left out, Nate, regarding what I was...
Nate Baxter
executiveYes, I can offer a bit more detail on that. So after last summer, there was a lot of lung damage specifically. And I believe the fall point-of-sale really demonstrated that consumers were engaged. We know from history that not every consumer returns to make repairs in the fall. So that, I think, gives us somewhat greater confidence going into spring. As for the West Coast, it's truly not a factor for us. We're clearly very worried about what those communities are going through. But when you look at it from a business standpoint, it won't be material. And naturally, our teams will be there assisting people when the moment is right to rebuild. I'd also mention that the winter weather we've experienced, particularly across the Southeast and on the East Coast, leads me to think the common belief among our retail partners is that it will benefit lawn and garden. There's going to be plenty of essential repair work in the ring. So on the whole, given what we observed in the fall and the load-in that our Q1 figures from retail partners support, we feel we're as well positioned as we can be for a decent spring, and we'll see what happens.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAlright Chris, to return to the topic of how sales are phased, regarding that low single-digit guidance for the U.S. consumer we provided. Our expectation is that the first half and the second half of our fiscal year will be fairly consistent in terms of showing a similar pattern of sales growth. So perhaps there was a bit of an earlier load in than some of your models might have suggested. But generally speaking, I would say that low single digit, we should see it in the first half of the year and then in the second half of the year; and when it comes to traditional sales patterns, we've basically returned to our pre-COVID norms of 55% to 45% — with 55% of sales occurring in the first half of the year and then 45% in the back half. So on that front, we've returned to a somewhat more normal sales pattern.
Chris Carey
analystAlright, excellent. That was thorough. I want to ask about Hawthorne for my follow-up. Jim, the idea of a strategic alternative for Hawthorne, I believe, has been considered for quite some time, and actually executing on anything has come with logistical difficulties, correct? So in a sense, I suppose there's consistently been some appetite, or a growing appetite, to take action with that asset as time goes on. Therefore, I guess what I'm asking is: do you feel that the logistical aspect of being able to actually take action with the asset is improving? Or are you just telling us that you're still dedicated to pursuing an alternative for this business?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveI would say both. So — I believe Matt and I were likely not in the identical position if you go back to when Matt was around. And I believe his perspective is that if it generates a profit — a number of you mentioned this while you were present at the investor day here last summer — first of all, it's positive that Hawthorne has returned to profitability, and that's reasonably good for the equity simply based on your PE. I'd argue that PEs tend to be greater in a business like ours than they are in the somewhat messed-up public equities available for cannabis; consequently, it does contribute value. Where I've landed — and so I'm sticking my neck out a bit here, because this is essentially the last 1.5 months — and we can discuss it later in the call — but it isn't that the market has treated Hawthorne so well; it's been very much internal effort to reduce expenses and do everything they can to reach the point they've reached. And I believe we're confident about the $20 million. We have — on my mandate, they sit on my Board for Hawthorne. That figure is larger than what Mark is using in our strategic plan numbers, which means I think it will be tough work for them to reach a number I'd consider respectable; that doesn't mean it's unachievable, and they've done genuinely, genuinely strong work, but it means it's a fairly small amount. And I think if you look and say, with all the sort of downside of good news, bad news, and I think heavily on the shareholders — clarity regarding what our equity represents — I was speaking with some of our outside advisers and I simply said, the question is, this could be far more valuable inside a pure pot business than it could be with us; this isn't a case where we're trying to unload it. Our goal here is to concentrate our investments in whatever way delivers the greatest benefit to shareholders. I'd add that Chris, who is with us, is the person who oversees that operation on our behalf. In my opinion, having the authority to act is what counts. So once that choice was made — and it wasn't mine alone; one step we took was to get the script finalized — I wanted every member of my leadership group to weigh in and confirm their agreement. It isn't merely about my own agreement plus that of a few advisers. It's whether all of you believe this is the correct step. And they answered yes. Turning to the logistics angle, logistics was never the obstacle. My sense is we simply asked whether it was roughly worth the trouble, assuming the choice is to retain it and the outcome is favorable. Keep in mind, this is a legal business. Is that the optimal approach? Making that change, in my view, boosts how profitable the operation is. The discussion takes on a different character when the business is losing money versus when it's steady and profitable, which is where it stands today. So I believe that after we reached consensus and I concurred on this path, my next move was to ask people to lay out the logistical obstacles, and we intend to discuss the matter with the Board. As I see it, the request to the Board will be for them to grant me authorization, contingent on several conditions, including coordinating with the banks and similar matters — meaning we do require the banks' consent for this. But in my judgment, all of that will be resolved within the coming 2 months, and we'll start the moment we're able. You might therefore witness the earliest phases of this, since we're discussing a variety of different assets. Relocating them might happen in as little as 1 month or 2. So I'd say we're essentially ready to act. With this consensus among the leadership group, I believe we still need to complete the last stage with our Board so they grant authorization, and for Mark to handle the bank negotiations so they sign off purely from a security standpoint, a securitization standpoint. After that, I expect you'll see us taking action. So I believe we've cleared both of those hurdles. From a decision standpoint, we feel we're in good shape, and from the logistical standpoint, as you phrased it, I believe we're already moving.
Bill Chappell
analystI've got something to ask, and it's really aimed at Nate along with the rest of the leadership group. Over the 20-some years I've been following this company, we've discussed ramping up marketing and advertising plus new R&D and things of that nature in order to boost sales. Still, I'm attempting to — if I examine your business, top-line growth can happen in 2 ways. The first is growing how many regular users you have, and the second would be growing the basket size, or what they spend annually. What I'm trying to figure out is whether a quantifiable opportunity exists in either area, and which of the two offers more of one? And what's your approach to kind of growing it?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveLet me dive in on the opening portion, since some of this involves going back to our core convictions and putting money into the brand. Bill, if we consider roughly the market a year ago, probably, I'd say, 3%. My sense is those figures look worse when it comes to live goods as part of the overall market. Our growth was roughly triple that; and much of — that represented considerable share gain. So this followed a stretch when we sort of wanted to recover the program dollars, and retailers pushed back on that. We addressed that, and it likely generated a great deal of confusion in this discussion a year ago. Rather than keeping that — those program dollars where they stood and likely even nudging them up somewhat. We gained considerably more shelf space along with promotional percent of promotion happening in the departments. That was genuinely beneficial for us, and we expect it to happen at largely comparable levels in the year ahead in terms of POS units; now it's a completely reasonable question to ask how long that can continue, how much share remains available to capture. I believe Nate has stayed quite focused on identifying where additional business exists in places where we're under-penetrated. And — so would you like to take that?
Nate Baxter
executiveAlright, Bill — that's a solid question. The short answer is that both matter, though let me lay it out like this. As spring arrives, I believe shoppers will notice that our messaging centers on frequency. Take lawn fertilizer and plant food as an illustration — we're aware there's a chance there. We've drifted away from our message regarding the multistep approach and the necessity of feeding, so that's going to be a major priority this year, and we believe we can grow that basket size. We'll also pursue some cross-brand efforts. Jim mentioned our new website, and we're collaborating with retailers on initiatives involving liquid controls. Say, for instance, we can find a method to pair those with certain fertilizers. Yet the user aspect matters, and Jim brought it up during his opening remarks — the need to draw in that next segment. Stepping way back to examine household penetration for lawn and garden generally, it sits below 50%. When I check the patterns across the past 10 years — the count of users, whether they're folks leaving the category or new homeowners lacking the confidence to participate — sadly, that figure is climbing. I view that as a chance. So although we've picked up share recently via innovation, listings, and retailer programs, we have to go beyond that. We need to address education. We need to address engagement. That's a powerful lever. Each 1% of household penetration equals another $50 million in ferts for us, for instance. But each extra 1/10 of a turn in what we term frequency — or the typical count of applications — is nearly the same for us. So the chance, to some degree, is that both exist. Short term, the emphasis is on what I'd call heating frequency, and over the mid to long term, we're entirely concentrated on engaging that consumer we haven't reached. I'd also note that I see a chance for us in the do-it-for-me space. I don't mean from a service angle at this moment. What I mean is getting consumers who opt to hire a professional to select our products, and that's something we'll consider in the midterm too.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveBringing up that dot com angle seems necessary to me. When I look at our business — we've got an entirely fresh group handling our brands at this point, and they're eager, passionate, and younger, and what they're doing really impresses me. Regarding the control segment, one thing stands out clearly: our penetration in those dot com players is quite low, whether we're talking about retailer.com, or the Amazon marketplace, as you'd call it, and strangely enough, you find competitors sitting right there. In retail we hold a dominant position; online, our dominance is plainly weaker. That means certain products need reworking, though much of this sits within the controls market — and I mean hundreds of millions of dollars here. So competitors are present in that space. You can see Procter experimenting somewhat there with Evo. That figure exceeds $100 million, and it happens repeatedly, not merely once or twice. So for us this is obviously easy pickings, yet we must pursue it. And I believe the young team operating that business beneath Nate, backed enthusiastically by Nate — a major opportunity exists here; the piece that might make someone uneasy is that when they sized up the opportunity, he mentioned something close to $1 billion. This circles back to what you asked, Bill. Honestly, I told him I killed that figure. Shrink it down so we don't lose balance, where we're making investments while pursuing something somewhat ethereal; still, substantial upside clearly exists. So this retailer.com matter strikes me as significant, especially among younger folks who are thoroughly accustomed to shopping online and visit brick-and-mortar locations less often. None of this works against that. I realize many of our largest retailers are quite active on com and excited about receiving our help. Yet plenty of opportunity and penetration exist there, and what frustrates me is that we're allowing others to operate in that space when we ought to claim that business as ours. So we intend to pursue it.
Mark Scheiwer
executiveOkay, Bill, just very briefly regarding the investment angle, as they’ve been discussing. For me, honestly, this fits pretty neatly into what we do best. I don’t see this requiring a huge long-term outlay; as part of our longer-term plan, we’ll keep investing. But the things Nate mentioned — we have amazing supply chain facilities and outstanding distribution capabilities. A lot of that is already available to us, so the return on our investment ought to be quite strong. Will investment be necessary? Of course, but I believe it can be handled without much difficulty.
Bill Chappell
analystThat's excellent. And as a quick follow-up — it can be harder for us at times to detect shifts in market share or similar things at the retail level while the season is underway; we typically learn about it once things wrap up. Is there a particular category — maybe lawn food? Could it be soils, mulch, some area where you're especially pumped up, like, hey, we are truly ready; we can capture large portions from others and genuinely accelerate growth? Or is it more of a wide-ranging situation, where momentum exists across the board?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAlright. If you'd rather not, the two of us can both take that one. Since this is another instance, in my view, of a solid question. When you look and ask, where does the business sit — it's simple to stick with what's already working. Controls and gardens are Hankin, and that benefits us, right? That's a high-margin operation; it's, I'd say, double digit is what we're observing and we anticipate that will more or less keep going. So I believe that's where you'll witness share gains of that kind, since those were simply part of the flow and that's favorable for us. On lawns, we aren't giving up share. I'd say we're — we're sitting in a truly, truly, truly strong position. I believe everyone these days is essentially saying, we need unit buying back, right? Keep in mind, a significant drop in dollar sales doesn't show up in loans, largely because we've been raising prices. And I think we've been noting that we've more or less hit the ceiling on that, mainly as far as the consumer is concerned. But — and it's a solid profitable business for us. Still, I think this multistep get bags up, we've got a genuine plan; and when you mention — this is the legacy business at this property in Marysville, and having everyone essentially be willing and open-minded enough to critically examine what's going on in the market and willing to make changes. The whole team is in a truly strong position and very open-minded toward change; and I think all of this is healthy. I wouldn't — don't interpret anything negative here; this is about getting people to be somewhat critical of the lawn business here. I don't know, it's like criticizing has aged or something. That's hard to pull off and escape unscathed. In this case, everyone is open-minded, and whether it's the brand team, supply chain, R&D, the leadership team, everybody and the board, everyone has interest in that. So we're — that's probably the most troubled there, but I'd say it's unit volume that I would be watching on that. And I think that would be something good for you to watch since it's one — if you asked me, there are Top 2 or 3 things you're working on. I would simply say continued recovery, margin investment in our business and lawns, and getting resolved — getting our Hawthorne assets all put together in a place that adds the most value; that's what I'm looking at.
Jonathan Andersen
analystWow, that's quite a bit to digest. I should mention that a mouse wasn't on my bingo card this morning.
Mark Scheiwer
executiveSo you do have a bingo card. Nice.
Jonathan Andersen
analystPerhaps I'll begin with gross margin — I'd really like to hear more detail on the pace of gross margin gains you anticipate across 2025, plus you've sort of set this 3-year target of returning to the mid-30s. And I believe, Jim, you described that final third — the portion arriving after 2025, if I'm not mistaken — as the toughest stretch to cover. Any fresh perspective on that 2027 goal and those tougher stretches, and how confident you feel about climbing back to that level?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveWell, before Mark begins, let me just jump in. My board has been applying a lot of pressure to get a longer strategic plan view than just through '27. I've pushed back quite firmly mostly due to precisely what you mentioned — first, I hold the belief that I want us to reach our new position before we begin sort of muddling things with numerous long-term objectives, and I don't mean those objectives lack importance, but I think we haven't fully finished repairing this business and bringing it to the place I described. I'm not certain I accept that it's much tougher, because I think the team — and I'll credit our newcomer here, Shire <<inaudible>>, who is performing absolutely wonderfully. And mostly, he's collaborating really effectively with the remainder of his finance team and the operating group. And — so I believe there's visibility into nearly everything we're discussing here; so I don't think it's as tough as you believe. I think it will demand that we tackle some additional difficult things. But I don't think we — but trust me when I say, we have visibility into the numbers. We're clearly aiming at a higher figure than where you folks sit. And I think that isn't unusual and that's, I think, what we ought to be doing; it's slightly tougher than you believe, mostly because incentive kicks in and simply renders a tough number tougher since we — the figure we give you already includes the incentive. So — but folks are quite driven and they're pursuing it; so, I suppose that's truly what I'd say — not such a tough visibility situation. Everyone is cooperating well to reach it. There's a lot of stuff that must occur but I think folks are tackling it. And we're attempting to springload that, particularly the change, what we refer to as transformation. We want to complete this as soon as possible, simply because it's tough on the company to undergo transformation when people aren't clear about what it entails. It sounds frightening, and perhaps to some degree it is, yet these are decisions we must take. Partly, it's to deliver the outcome that all of us and you are looking for — $700 million of EBITDA in '27, or at minimum that — but it's also so we can make the sorts of investments and operate the business the way we want to. And my belief is that we possess an extraordinarily distinctive consumer franchise. And part of how I've arrived at my thinking — it works for me, to put it that way — is that when you examine the multiples of genuine consumer brand businesses that lead in their categories, be it Proctor, Clorox, Colgate, Church & Dwight. I could name a bunch, I don't know. What you'll observe is multiple expansion that is fairly substantial relative to where we stand; and at our current position, we're probably fortunate it isn't worse considering the path we've traveled. So we want that, and we're aware we can achieve it. It does require us to scrutinize ourselves honestly and make some difficult decisions, and we will. But part of this concerns generating a financial result; part of it concerns putting money into the brand so that this franchise becomes exceptionally enduring.
Mark Scheiwer
executiveJon, I'll just follow up very specifically on the two things you asked about — phasing and the long term. On phasing for gross margin this year, we've discussed taking out $75 million in costs. We have a very clear line of sight to that. And like Jim mentioned, the team is pressing to capture more within the fiscal year too; but ultimately, as I said in my prepared remarks and all of that, roughly two-thirds falls in the first half. That $75 million will be realized across the fiscal year. The remaining one-third then comes through the back half. The reason the two-thirds is weighted more toward the front, clearly, is commodities. Inventory; we've done a good job, clearly, buying inventory at cheaper prices. Compared with a year ago, we've seen deflation in commodities. So we're now moving that lower-cost inventory through, and we're at a solid, even footing for the rest of the year. So versus a year ago, we were still moving through somewhat pricier inventory last year. In the first half — that's why you'll see that year-over-year gain from the cheaper inventory. So I'd expect further gross margin gains in Q2 compared with the prior year. Again, roughly two-thirds, as I mentioned. Then in the third quarter, likely fairly flat, and after that we get to Q4; during Q4, we'll start to lap the E&O charges of about $29 million we recorded, which will give us a favorable year-over-year comparison. So that's roughly how the phasing works this year. On the long term, I'd simply say we were settling near 30% for a full year. If you examine the core business, it sits above that, and lawn and garden gross margin is quite healthy; we're continually running what we refer to as 6Q <<inaudible>> savings project work and review, and the team examines it continually, looking well into the future; and they've already been putting plans together to deliver the next phase of the $150 million in supply chain savings. So that's another $75 million across '26 and '27; on the timing, we're still locking it down, but those — it would arrive over those 2 years. And it will be closely linked to the projects and activities we're reviewing; transformation will play a role in that, but the team has embedded it in their core; it's what we always did before COVID — we were skilled at removing those costs. And I think if you look back at pre-COVID U.S. consumer type margins, we traditionally sat in that 35% range. So we're confident we can return to those as we rightsize the supply chain infrastructure. I'd say the longer term is pressing a part of that. We'll aim to stay as flexible as we can on that front, and that's the reason transformation matters so much to us. Still, I believe you'll see us building step by step toward that goal. With any luck, I view '25 as a first installment on the path to the mid 30% range. The results from the first quarter, I'd say, demonstrate that. So with any luck, that gives all of you a bit more confidence. Nate, is there anything you'd like to add?
Nate Baxter
executiveRight, so not to get too far into it, but there are a handful of specifics worth mentioning, Jon. My business units are focused on three primary areas. To start, Jim brought up simplification, which I suppose we'll label a SKU effectiveness effort. Essentially, it's been quite a while since anyone took a rigorous look at profitability at the individual SKU level. I'm not suggesting we'll dramatically shrink the portfolio, but in my view my GMs should understand where their margins stand. That covers the first item. On innovation — look, innovation is going to fuel margin expansion, and we've been working to reignite it. Through the pandemic and the difficulties that followed, our attention was largely on taking costs out. We've brought in some strong people to plan 5, 10 years ahead, and then naturally there are the supply chain efficiencies. One more point I'd add: we won't pursue this in a way that hurts retailer margins. They're our partners, and we'll collaborate with them so the programs we implement create a win-win for both sides. So it's a big undertaking, but when Jim asked me whether we can reach 35%, I told him — I didn't hesitate. I believe we'll get there. I can't map out every single step along the path, yet directionally speaking, I have a lot of confidence.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveWhat I'd say is that pricing is going to play a role here — not the entire story, but it will factor in. Keep in mind, with Hawthorne, I'd put the figure at no less than 100 basis points.
Eric Bosshard
analystI suppose to kick things off, Nate or Jim — what I'm wondering about is, from a strategic standpoint, when you consider pricing alongside market share and gross margin, and how those 3 pieces fit together. This year you've got commodity savings, and those are paying for a certain amount of gross margin growth. Jim, you brought up a consumer who's sensitive to price. Then you also discussed gains in market share. So what I'd like to know is whether you feel a need, as this year plays out, to lean harder on promotions, to put money toward — you brought up this innovative multistep program involving being more aggressive with discounts as a way to drive consumer traffic. Does that fit into the picture? And clearly there's more private label competition in the mix right now, or do you believe the investment in the brand and in marketing is enough that you can push through all of that, which is essentially what happened last year. How do you see those points fitting together?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveWell, in my view they all tie together, but let me begin there. Once more, this is sort of my own word evolution; so that doesn't mean it reflects where everyone else at the table stands. There are plenty of people here. But what I'd say is — we took a look and I believe we've discussed with you folks that during our most difficult years, incentive dollars were plentiful to make sales occur at the times we wanted and needed them; and the retailers played along and they were grown-ups about it and every bit of it was voluntary. But what I think you observed is our margin decline while theirs rose. And at this point <<inaudible>> and difficulties are finished and I'd like my money returned. That's roughly where I landed. The more I've examined it, though, and the more I've considered it from a competitive angle, and this is among the reasons I've been talking with retailers at the senior level about it, is what we're witnessing is they're putting so much effort into drawing consumers into the store that for each program dollar we contribute, they're spending a greater amount of their own money, pushing our products and our brands. And suddenly, I began thinking to myself, if we're able to hit our margin targets, then I don't want that money returned. I simply want it working hard on my behalf. That was part of the conversation, which is I'm fine with this, but I think in speaking with Josh Meals, I don't know, a couple of weeks ago, he said we've got to have very sharp elbows then, because those programs have to work and they don't always work and sometimes they do, plenty of times they do. But that was really the conversation and the sort of journey regarding what — precisely what you're asking. What I'm observing, Eric, is it's quite virtuous. And when you view it that way, the investments in the brands, I mean our investments. When you look at what we're activating in stores and the dollars behind that, the figure is more than $700 million. From where I sit competitively, I'm in the business of building moats. I want that moat to be deep, and I want to keep others away from what's ours, all right? And we plan on holding onto it. Okay? And we aren't seeing anything wild out there, except you've got Procter sort of laying plans around our territory, and we'd like to throw a party for them too, even though it isn't really like they're not really — it's more SPJ, with the Xevo business, that they're kind of tinkering with. But — and I'd say if S.C. Johnson happens to be listening, we could use some funds to defend ourselves against them, but our money is going into defending the controls business, not that they're truly eyeing our stuff, but it has gotten us thinking about just how powerful this franchise is and how crucial it is that we protect it. And if we're able to make our gross margin figures work and hold that money in there, I believe we keep gaining outside share. And I think that's roughly how I tie it all together. So I don't truly see it as an option. I don't believe we've finished spending. When — if you looked at my Board at this moment, what I've got in there is a, I don't know, 25% increase over today in our marketing dollars; so this is all — we're not through with this work. This is the work that if I were — we got — we're leaving here after a 2-day board meeting. And I think everyone will come back and truly dig into transformation, and not just delivering the business day to day, because we're basically in season right now; but I think finishing the planning that will be needed to reach where we want to reach, everyone will really dig into it. I think if I asked people today for transformation discussions, they know plenty of work is already underway. I think they'd say, can we just get to the Board meeting first. And so that's what we'll do. But there absolutely is a connection among all of this. We aren't lifting our foot off the gas pedal, I think we — Eric, you've tracked us long enough. We've been through this before. There was a year, during the financial crisis, when I said, I can't really control anything. What I can demonstrate to people is that we can sell more and advertise more; now, that was fairly devastating to our P&L. Back then, the incentive rested on 2 things: ad spend and our market share in POS, okay? So it didn't even factor in profitability, simply because the world sucked <<inaudible>>. So what I said was, we're simply going to — even though conditions are terrible, to demonstrate that advertising delivers results. We hadn't worked out a way to keep up that amount of spending while generating the profit we had to generate. That's essentially what we found. The updated approach is that we will generate the profit we require, since we're going to undergo this transformation, and we're going to spend it. Once we're finished, it'll just be a somewhat different company. And it's going to be very focused and more similar to, I'm not sure, any.
Nate Baxter
executiveNo. I'd like to back up everything you just said regarding promotions — Eric was with us during the prior year. This year, we've pushed harder in that direction. The real skill, I'd argue, lies in managing the whole chain from the top of the funnel, through our media, all the way to when a shopper converts at the shelf, and ensuring that across that whole journey to purchase, those dollars get used the right way. So I'd put it this way: as we grow and as I settle in with a new team, we're devoting more time to considering, from top to bottom, how those dollars benefit us. Our retail partners have been terrific; and just to say a word about private label, for our retailers it's a significant piece of the business. Naturally, we back that business for them across many areas. To me it isn't a threat. I view it as one part of a good, better, best approach; and stepping back for a moment, when I look at private label share going back to 2019, the trend has been downward. So it's one piece of the puzzle here. I don't view it as anything that will throw our focus on growth and margin off track.
Mark Scheiwer
executiveOne more item, Eric, that I want to revisit is margin. Everything they described boosts volume, which in turn creates leverage on fixed costs, and that simply gives us more room to maneuver. That's the reason you can see what we're capable of achieving on the gross margin line both this fiscal year and going forward; so I'd say these pieces fit together well, and the finance team here will concentrate on keeping a proper watch on that and on margin recovery, while weighing that against the company's longer-term vision.
Eric Bosshard
analystAll right. Then a follow-up, if I may. I believe you mentioned that your POS rose 9% or 10% <<inaudible>> in the prior year, against a market that grew 3, and you come across as more hopeful about '25 than you were about '24, for a wide range of reasons. Is that why both of those figures could improve in '25?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveWell, to begin with. I believe whenever we convince ourselves we're capable of more. Truthfully, we group things together. So I'd say the largest risk factor Nate likely has in his projections is consumer takeaway. And so it isn't a timid figure. It could add up to roughly low single digits, but it isn't go. Do I believe we might achieve more, especially with a strong year, which would be welcome. I believe the response is yes. But I believe it's somewhat similar to Nate saying he sees $1 billion of upside across all those other channels, dot-com included. We are squarely in recovery, in a positive sense. And I don't want to begin pursuing things merely because they sound appealing. But do I believe there might be — Yes, I believe so, I do. I believe the prior year was rough, man, it's like we — why did we gain so much? Because we have far more shelf space. That's the core reason. And I believe we performed really well on several of our marketing programs. The fall was fantastic, and for many reasons, correct? The weather cooperated, lawns had been fairly dried out. We simply had excellent programs assembled, so consumers kept encountering our product, with plenty of control activity happening, Tomcat included. So it genuinely clicked; and I believe that demonstrates the strength of the franchise; we just need to pull it all together now. So do I believe there's ongoing upside. I'm not sure I require double digits, because I think it's absurd to claim that, even though perhaps I think if we can merely sustain this for longer, which I believe is the smartest way for us to view it, I think it's genuinely beneficial for the franchise and it retains people. Look, the trouble when we — we claim more, and it's somewhat what we witnessed this year, and it's partly the criticism we received from ISS: we enjoyed a truly excellent year the year before; it simply wasn't quite as strong on the EBIT line as we expected; and I think partly, we were somewhat delusional when we suggested $600 million <<inaudible>> the prior year was so effortless; and our incentives were tied to that, just so you're aware. So where it truly causes problems, man, is the incentives, because the incentives are fairly leveraged. So we end up telling ourselves that we're capable of pulling something off. Then we have a genuinely strong year, though not fairly as strong as what we've had before, and the incentive falls apart. After that we go to the board and say it was a great year, so do you think an exception makes sense? This is something we do together with our Board. And — following last year, which was a really important recovery year for us, we paid a target, and it paid out at 100%. It would have paid out at a lower level. That was the criticism from ISS. So there's this truly deep negative leverage built into our incentives, meaning that when we promise ourselves too much, everybody gets held back. So we've kind of got to steer clear of that. So I'll just put that out there to chew on.
Analyst
analystAndrew here, filling in for William. First thing I'd like to ask about is that gross margin outlook you provided for the year — just to make sure I follow, most of the gain, roughly 2/3, lands in the first half. After that comes the fourth quarter comparison, and it sounds like you're suggesting 3Q stays level, and I realize you'd rather not dig into the fine details; still, looking back at 3Q of last year, the figure was 29.2%, which sat 700 basis points under 3Q '19. So what I'm getting at with your plan is whether there's simply a good deal of room to maneuver around how the mix plays out — especially since this is a lawns quarter, and maybe a lawn season that's closer to normal, or stronger results, might push the margin higher — but is there anything like that as I look more closely?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveYes. So we'd still anticipate — perhaps I chose my words poorly when I called it entirely level; instead, it ought to tick up somewhat. And you're correct, we ought to have a bit of room to maneuver there given our product line-up and how things unfold as we move into Q4.
Analyst
analystGreat. For my second question, I suppose what I'd like is for you to pull back and help us calibrate what the cost savings look like across the coming year? You've already got 30% gross margins. Your target is to move into the mid-30s, and taking Hawthorne out of the P&L — excuse me, removing Hawthorne — clearly provides a lift toward that. Previously you told us you can see roughly half of it. Beyond that, there's a — hey, go chase it down. And I believe this morning, when speaking with Nate, you also brought up a $30 million challenge. My assumption is that sits on top of the $150 million. Then my last question: you've stripped out all of these expenses, and it's obvious you're redirecting dollars into advertising. Yet when you consider the supply chain and the pressures that could hit it, is there any danger you won't be able to satisfy demand? I don't think — my hope is a COVID will never happen again. Still, that period was a — fill rates dropped and it truly strained things; so anything you can offer to build confidence that we won't face a — by '28 <<inaudible>>. Hey, we'll need to plow this back into the supply chain?
Mark Scheiwer
executiveYes. Perhaps I'll just — I'll address the supply chain, Andrew. Good question.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveI'll just jump in here. Andrew, Chris was making a certain gesture in your direction when "get rid of" came up — it was all in good fun.
Analyst
analystThank you, Chris. I appreciate it.
Mark Scheiwer
executiveNo. Look, you're pointing to something that was basically the framing when we began our supply chain overhaul — which really got going over 12 months back — and that framing was: design it for maximum flexibility. So when it comes to capacity, I have no worries, whether near term or mid to long term. Jim mentioned that extra $25 million in CapEx. A big chunk of that goes toward technology. It helps make us more efficient and provides the capacity we require. Honestly, I'm just proud of this team. We've gone down to around 6 distribution centers, from what I believe was a peak in '18 <<inaudible>> or thereabouts. So — we're absolutely making certain we aren't cutting too deep with those optimizations; and the investments will be visible. As a matter of fact, I'll be speaking at the conference in March, specifically about our manufacturing strategy.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveOkay, so maybe you could just spend a moment talking about the crew that’s down there, sort of…
Mark Scheiwer
executiveYeah. So, one big advantage on the supply chain side is that Dave has run it for many years, so there's a ton of built-in expertise. That said, Dave has recruited really well, and we now have a few younger VPs who are very focused on technology — if you attended our conference back in July of last year, you might have run into David Husky — but we have some genuinely sharp folks who are fully engaged in helping us rethink this whole area, from autonomous forklifts all the way through. The single largest initiative we've taken on is that main distribution center, located one mile away from the Marysville manufacturing facility. Every bit of our fertilizer ships from there and gets collected by our retail partners. We've eliminated $0.5 million — actually, let me correct that, roughly 0.5 million miles of truck travel annually across our distribution centers — so we have a truly solid team. You'll be hearing more from us on supply chain; regarding that $3 million Jim requested, I'd say most of it likely originates from supply chain, though everything will rest on a base of putting money into technology, whether that's supply chain, the field sales team, and so on.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveAndrew, I'd add that the whole company will be pitching in here. It's a bit like telling folks to wait until the Board meeting wraps up and then get to work sharpening the pencils, but plenty of teams are already at it right now. A great deal of that — I mean, much of it — isn't just Nate contributing. If you look at roughly 400 out of 100 going back into the business, a big chunk has come from the operating side; and thank goodness, because that's where a lot of money gets spent, so it's not out of place. Corporate will take part in this as well. And we're posing some really significant questions about who we want to be and how we bring value here. So, I — look, Mark can speak to it since he's the top bean-counter and keeps the score; but I don't find that number frightening in the least. Do you?
Mark Scheiwer
executiveDefinitely not. And regarding what you're bringing up, that benefit will also show up in corporate and SG&A. So part of it could be put back into the business, as Jim mentioned with super power, while another part could flow through to the bottom line. I believe this simply gives us more room to maneuver as we move forward with our '26 planning, which is already underway and has been a focus for us even during the season. So yes, everyone will take part in that effort. There's a great deal of opportunity in this area. I think a lot of technology over the last 5, 7 years has made doing our jobs much simpler and, I believe, helped us become more efficient. I think we have some solid ideas.
Jonathan Matuszewski
analystGood numbers. My first question concerns innovation. During your prepared comments, you brought up natural fertilizers and liquids. As a component of the upcoming product road map, I'm simply wondering how you expect those to add to that 3% sales growth across the medium term, and how do you view innovation as a driver of growth in the U.S. consumer segment going forward compared with what history shows?
Jim Hagedorn
executiveYes. Jim, I'll take the opening part of that; this really falls under Nate's area. But what I'd share with you is this — it connects to a key priority of mine, which is watching unit volume and loans improve. Keep in mind, share isn't slipping away from us. The problem affects the entire category. One factor, in my opinion, is worry among younger people regarding chemicals used in the yard. Therefore, I genuinely believe organic offers a path to keep people from being sensitive. So we understand how to pull this off. It isn't difficult. So getting or we simply — often, you just — you have faith in organic, you apply it in the field, and it simply doesn't sell that well to consumers. But one reason, I think, that people don't feed is their worry about our chemicals; and so we want to have — we want to make certain we're examining that closely; and so we're going to do so. Nate can address formulation changes, though I'd add that innovating is extremely hard when you're working with controls. The number of controls isn't that large. Honestly, there isn't much innovation in ag chemicals. And so you're usually stuck with the same actives; and so I'm attempting to instill in everyone here that if this were Procter and we were discussing Tide, I believe they'd take for granted that cleaning power, the convenience of cleaning for homemakers, all of that improves with time. What kind of world are we in where we're basically working with technology that's 30 years old and considering it acceptable. EPA is attempting to push us toward that because they're examining the total exposure consumers face across a lifetime, including the food they eat and their pesticide exposure <<inaudible>> in that regard. And so they're restricting the ability to apply actives as a means of reducing lifetime what they'd term risk up, which translates to less effectiveness. So a shortage of innovation in the actives means applying less than what's probably optimal to achieve the controls you want. And I believe that creates a need for genuine innovation. Then I'll move to the other part, which is my perspective on the seasons and that I think and I cannot — we bring on truly excellent weather people. I cannot obtain a truly solid answer regarding whether what we're seeing in the spring ties to climate change. The reason, I believe, is that we keep witnessing this pattern repeatedly, and it lands right in April, which is peak time for that kind of behavior, and honestly it's wide open then. Plus we run advertising, we drive demand. Retailers are happy about it as well since they're focused on lawn and garden. Spring is coming. But my take is this: if you ask many of the researchers around here, they'll tell you they plant in autumn and claim autumn offers the ideal window for feeding. Still, we're battling for spring, and we're battling what I consider unpredictable weather — meaning spring forecasts fluctuate far more than autumn ones. That's the takeaway I get from the experts. In other words, you see forecasted weather more often during spring, in April, than you do in autumn, especially across the Midwest and Northeast, right? So I'm working to shift things in that direction, and there's one more item they do. Should customers fail to put our products down on a wet lawn, that grade of control won't be achieved. The control will be decent, not excellent; and excellent is what we're after. If you ask the specialists here — whether it's supply chain folks, the knowledgeable ones, supply chain folks, R&D staff, senior leadership — they use straight feeds alongside liquids, liquid pesticides, which deliver truly strong control since it penetrates directly into the leaf. Application doesn't require a wet product, something we suspect some folks — actually plenty of folks — skip. That explains why you're picking up on innovation, seasonality, and promotion spread across the year instead of concentrated solely in spring, while working to elevate autumn's role with organics and liquids. Our aim is to address the factors that lead customers toward weaker outcomes, or make things overly complex, or leave them coping with poor weather; that's the reason behind everything you're picking up on. As for innovation specifically and where Nate is headed — well, he isn't me; that's a positive thing. No, he's — he's someone deeply focused on process, with a plan for every situation. And innovation amounts to a planning workout. It's an exercise in investing over the long haul.
Nate Baxter
executiveSure. Here's how I'd frame it, based on the way we think about innovation: for the consumer, it comes down to ease of use, effectiveness, value, and safety. Depending on who that consumer is, the order of those priorities shifts, but I believe Jim touched on that. This year, the complete Miracle-Gro Company organics line is launching. In gardening, that has been a major success, and we recognize how much it matters. We also have several new lawn innovations arriving. There's our OM Scotts, essentially our heritage line — no pesticides, no herbicides, just straight food and straight seeds — and it will come in a curved, recyclable bag, so we're experimenting with new form factors. Personally, I'd love to see less plastic out there, but it has to perform. We have an all-natural option that will go head-to-head with the P&G offering hitting shelves this summer. Here's my view: I want to provide whatever the consumer is looking for. If someone wants everything all natural, we'll have those products — yet we'll also offer genuinely smart products that work well and are safe, with active ingredients in them. And we'll have conversations with consumers. This ties into education, and I can't emphasize that enough. We can dream up every great product imaginable, but if we aren't talking with the consumer and helping them grasp how to use it, it's going to flop. So that will be a major component. Then I'll close with this: I believe we're the sole company in this category with the horsepower to work alongside some of our active suppliers — some of the large ag companies. We're looking 10 years ahead; we're examining biologicals. We're involved in some of the crystal research they're conducting, seeking more natural methods to boost performance, whether that's a controls product or a fertilizer plant food. Building that will take time, but it absolutely will — provided we stay committed to these questions: Is it easy to use? Is it effective? Does it deliver value? And is it safe? I'm quite confident we'll be out front on innovation.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveWent announce your new partner on innovation committee.
Nate Baxter
executiveRegarding Rob Candalino <<inaudible>>, he's a fantastic addition to our board. He's stepping into the role that Tom Kelly is leaving. Everyone on my team holds him in high regard. Since he's an active CEO still in the trenches battling away, he's likely provided us with more perspectives during the past few months than we'd gotten in quite some time. So he's truly an excellent new board member; and although it pains me greatly that Tom Kelly is departing; and I believe Tom deserves enormous recognition for what this company has become across the past 20 years. Our team is completely new and that makes me quite enthusiastic.
Jonathan Matuszewski
analystThat's helpful detail, and one fast follow-up. There have been many mentions of the chance in the dot-com channel alongside several of your big retail partners. Could you size up where you currently sit regarding penetration? And please shed some light on the steps needed to capture that chance. I believe someone mentioned perhaps optimizing product sizes so they work in that channel, but is there anything else?
Nate Baxter
executiveYes. Broadly speaking, in DIY brick-and-mortar, measured by units, we hold roughly 40% market share across basically all our categories. In the e-comm arena, we're only barely into the double digits. So the opportunity is enormous. Here's the issue. I dislike singling out my former employer, Intel, but I worked there many years ago and joined when I regarded them as the most forward-looking tech company anywhere. I think everyone is aware of the difficulties they face now. One attempt they made, and I believe they've drawn a lesson from it, involved constructing an ideal formula for building, designing, manufacturing, marketing and selling CDUs; and whenever they pursued adjacent businesses, they attempted to force that identical formula onto them. We must view things the same way; we've created a wonderful franchise around DIY, brick-and-mortar lawn and garden. We're absolutely not abandoning that. Growth exists there. Yet for us to perform well, whether in e-com or omnichannel, where smaller, lighter packaging is required, you won't grab a Roundup or ortho in a grocery store, though you might grab an easy-to-use apartment size form factor. We must be present there. So the team is already addressing that. The opposite side involves the Pro segment. We must be able to cost effectively supply product at large scale to work with small and medium-sized professionals. So yes, we definitely must re-imagine it. And my sole mandate for my team is that we avoid forcing the way we operate today onto those growth opportunities.
Jim Hagedorn
executiveJonathan, perhaps to put some size around that, just to pick up on it. You mentioned roughly 10% or thereabouts; for certain categories it falls in the single digits, and for others it edges a bit higher into the low double digits. In other categories it sits above 10%; so it really comes down to the category; but echoing his point, there's a great deal of opportunity for us there, particularly around the form factor and simply different kinds of offerings and all that good stuff.
Jonathan Matuszewski
analystThank you. Best of luck.
Operator
operatorThat brings an end to what we had to share with everyone today. We appreciate all of you taking part. At this point, feel free to leave the call, and we hope the rest of your day is great.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.