Treasury Wine Estates Limited (TWE) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
January 28, 2020
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorGood day, everyone, and thanks for joining us on the line for Treasury Wine Estates' F '20 Half Year Results. <<operator_script>> I'd like to let you know that this call is being recorded today. At this point I'll turn things over to our first presenter, Mr. Michael Clarke. Thanks, and please proceed.
Michael Clarke
executiveGood morning, everyone, and thanks for being on the call for Treasury Wine Estate's Fiscal 2020 Interim Results Briefing. With me today are Tim Ford, our Chief Operating Officer, and Matt Young, our Chief Financial Officer. I want to open today's call with a conclusion. Versus what we expected, H1 EBITS came in slightly short, and our revised full year forecast means our F '20 growth rate will fall below the guidance we gave previously. The main cause is a shortfall in our U.S. results, for three reasons. First, unexpected changes in our U.S. leadership cost us execution momentum during H1, and that will carry over into H2. Second, U.S. market dynamics: every supplier is attempting to shift surplus wine through the market at lower prices, which has accelerated private label growth. In a market that is flat to down, private label is up 15%. That is a massive market shift over a very short period, particularly following the recent U.S. vintage in October. Third, because of these market dynamics, we have been unable to recover or offset higher U.S. luxury COGS and higher Australian commercial COGS, since higher levels of discounting are needed as we try to hold share across all price points.
Michael Clarke
executiveAlso, we exited just under 0.5 million cases of commercial volume in the U.S. because of private label growth, aggressive pricing, and our higher COGS. We have examined whether that H1 shortfall can be recovered in H2, but with the market dynamics in the United States continuing, we think those aggressive one-off recovery activities — aggressive pricing, for example — would not be repeatable in F '21, and we would prefer to stay on our journey of growing our company profit each year, though for fiscal '20 and fiscal '21 at slightly lower growth rates than previously expected, and to reset the U.S. management team and rebuild momentum in execution, and strategically review how we will manage our U.S. and global wine — global commercial wine business differently and go into the back half of F '21 and then F '22 stronger. We would rather address these 2 setbacks, U.S. management changes and the U.S. market dynamics, while continuing to grow our company profits every year. We have considerably improved the profitability of our Commercial wine business over the last 6 years by rightsizing it and also removing costs and outsourcing supply to third-party suppliers. Given these accelerated market changes, private label, we will now address how we manage this part of our business differently so it continues to support, not drag our premiumization strategy.
Michael Clarke
executiveWe're pleased to say our Luxury/Masstige business keeps expanding in every region — Asia, ANZ, the United States and EMEA — and that's a genuine and growing strength for Treasury Wine Estates. Now, on to the results. The quality of what we're reporting today mirrors the underlying strength of our global business model, which sources across multiple regions, sells across multiple regions and stands as the wine business with the most self-distribution anywhere in the world. That model, which we have been steadily reinforcing over the last 6 years, has let us carry on our journey of delivering sustainable organic growth, and in the first half — in the first half of 2020 — against a backdrop of challenging conditions in one of our key markets, the United States. Over the first 6 months ended 31st December 2019, we achieved continued growth across key financial metrics, powered by the ongoing execution of our premiumization strategy, which is gaining momentum in each of our geographies. Headline net sales revenue rose 2%, driven by growth of our Luxury and Masstige portfolios, which climbed 7% in the first half and now accounts for approximately 73% of our global net sales revenue, and is reflected in our NSR per case, which increased 8% in the half.
Michael Clarke
executiveGroup EBITS rose 6% to $366.7 million, and the EBITS margin went up 0.9 percentage points to 23.9%. Net profit after tax before SGARA and material items came in at $229 million, an increase of 5%. Earnings per share also grew 5%, reaching $0.319 per share. We're still very happy with how we performed across Asia, Australia, New Zealand and EMEA, but our first half in the Americas region has been a setback and is disappointing, given the high expectations we hold for growth in this important market. Later on this call, Tim will talk -- will speak in some detail about how each region performed, but before that, I'll take a few moments now to discuss some of the short-term dynamics we've seen in our key markets that have affected the results and that we're announcing today. Beginning in the United States, where first and foremost, the recent unforeseen changes in our regional management were a setback for us and led to a loss of execution momentum and, as a result, performance through the half. Making our own loss of momentum worse were challenging conditions in the United States wine market, which, as we've highlighted before, is going through a period of considerable change.
Michael Clarke
executiveThe speed of this shift, and how it's hitting our business, has picked up during the last 3 to 4 months, after vintage. The trade war is affecting the market, our partners and competitors included, and wine that had been destined for Asia is now remaining in the U.S. market. That factor, combined with larger average vintages, has produced industry supply at levels above what was expected, and that supply has since been discounted in the United States. On top of that, some big market players are either in the midst of exiting their wine businesses or considering doing so, and this is causing major disruption in the market, since price discounting and heavy spending on promotional support are being used to hold up volume and value share ahead of a possible sale. In reaction, large market players are increasingly pushing commercial quality product as exclusives and private label offerings, which has fueled an accelerated structural shift and extraordinary growth in private label even as we see broader market declines across commercial price points. To try to hold onto market share, we've put money into promotional support as well, but that has been costly and has reduced our ability to offset the COGS pressures we said earlier we would have to manage in fiscal '20.
Michael Clarke
executiveIn certain sections of our commercial portfolio, though, we've made the deliberate decision to cut back on commercial volume that's lower margin—pardon me, lower volume commercial volume—since doing so was the most suitable step for us. On a brighter side, results for Luxury/Masstige have come in strong, with depletions up 10% and 5%, respectively, during the half. At those price points, we're also beating the market. Although today's conditions are difficult and will affect how the group performs in F '20 and F '21, we stay highly confident in the U.S. market as well as in our long-term prospects there. Premiumization as our strategy—supported by expanding distribution and availability for our focused brands via our optimized route-to-market—remains the correct approach, and it underpins our confidence that momentum will return under a new regional leadership team after these market effects fade. Moving to China now, where luxury wine consumption is still robust and our portfolio keeps showing strong momentum, with depletions growth running above 40% in the first half. We keep outpacing both the market and our rivals in gaining share within imported wine, which speaks to the strength of our competitively advantaged business model.
Michael Clarke
executiveDuring the half, we kept seeing the industry-wide pattern of working capital getting tighter throughout the market, with our customers having to cut back on inventory levels of competitors' products — something analysts watching Chinese customs figures and noting falling wine import volumes into the market will recognize well. This working capital squeeze has affected one of our biggest customers, an exclusive wholesaler for Rawson's Retreat along with a number of our lower luxury brands, which has had to restructure its operations and trim its excess stock of rival brands. As a result, we have reworked our customer partnership model with this partner so that distribution of these brands is better balanced across a wider group of partners, and we anticipate being back on track during the second half to secure continued shipment growth for Rawson's. Our volume and net sales revenue growth in the region, excluding this single partner, rose 14% and 22%, respectively, in the half. Setting aside the temporary effects of one customer, our competitively advantaged business model — built on self-distribution and investment in marketing and pull-through programs across our focus brands — keeps driving growth in this market, which is why we continue to outperform all our competitors by a significant margin.
Michael Clarke
executiveTo wrap up, we're happy with how strongly the business has kept performing across ANZ, Asia and EMEA, where EBITS beyond the United States together show a 20% increase. And although we've had an execution setback in the U.S. market, our attention to the expanding Luxury/Masstige segments, together with our optimized route-to-market — which is delivering strong performance in the direct states — underpins our confidence that we're still firmly on the right path in this important region. I'll now pass things to Matt, who will walk us through the financial results in more detail.
Matt Young
executiveThanks, Mike, and good morning, everyone. Our premiumization strategy and the diversification of our global business have allowed us to deliver sustained earnings growth that is margin-accretive this half, despite the setback in U.S. performance. And as always, we've kept investing heavily in future growth through the key parts of our value chain that focus on premiumization, while at the same time maintaining a capital structure that is strong and flexible. Looking at our key measures of performance. Group net sales revenue grew 1.9% on a reported currency basis but declined 0.7% at constant currency, driven by volume declines across the commercial portfolio, where volume was down 10% this half. This impact was partly offset by continued premiumization towards Luxury and Masstige wines, which grew 7%, leading to NSR per case growing 5% on constant currency basis and 8% on a reported currency basis to $87 per 9 LE. COGS per case increased in part due to the premiumization shift but also due to the higher cost of Australian commercial wine as well as U.S.-sourced luxury wines from higher-cost vintages, partly offset by lower COGS on Australian luxury -- Australian-sourced luxury wine. Higher commercial COGS have been difficult to mitigate due to the accelerated declines in commercial category arising from increased promotional activity in the market and accelerated growth in competition from private label.
Matt Young
executiveThe cost of doing business margin rose a bit, reaching 20.6%, mainly because NSR went down. During the first half of '20, the cost of doing business went up as a result of extra brand-building spending in Asia and more promotional push in the U.S., which was partly offset by favorable overheads from ongoing optimization and simplification of both our business and operating models. EBITS grew 6% on a reported basis, hitting $367 million, while the EBITS margin climbed to 23.9%, bringing us nearer to our target margin of 25% and beyond. Material items totaling $22 million, or $16 million after-tax, tied to our investment in luxury wine-making capacity in South Australia, caused a small drop in reported earnings per share, which came in at $0.29. Excluding material items in SGARA, earnings per share rose 5%. Lastly, ROCE went up 1.1 percentage points to 13.6%, which shows our capital base continues to be managed with discipline. Turning to the balance sheet, it remains efficient and flexible. Net assets grew $69 million, pushed up by a rise in working capital and right-of-use lease assets following the application of AASB 16. The higher working capital compared with June 2019 mirrors the normal operating cycle, with receivables up due to NSR growth and the weighting of Q2 sales ahead of key consumption occasions.
Matt Young
executiveRelative to the first half of last year, working capital balances showed year-on-year efficiency, with debtor days in particular improving. As everyone is aware, AASB 16 leases took effect for TWE on the first of July 2019, and we have applied that standard on a fully retrospective basis. The result has been a grossing up of assets and liabilities on our balance sheet, an increase to EBITS, and a reduction in net profit after tax. A complete reconciliation of the impact on the first half of '19 appears in Appendix 1 to the profit report, and for the full year effects, we presented that in our F '19 full year results announcement. Turning now to inventory in more detail, which has risen by $50 million to more than $2 billion on our balance sheet, valued at cost as at the end of December '19. Noncurrent inventory rose $122 million, driven by luxury volume, the result of a strong 2019 luxury vintage in Australia, which was up approximately 10% for TWE on the 2018 vintage. Current inventory fell $73 million, reflecting updated sales volume expectations for the U.S., along with efficient inventory management of bulk wine sourcing arrangements across the Masstige portfolio. I would make 2 additional points with respect to our inventory balances.
Matt Young
executiveFirst, although we discussed certain pressures today in the commercial-tier segment — specifically elevated cost of goods and falling volumes — our adaptable sourcing approach and robust planning procedures let us handle our inventory levels well so we can react to those shifts in market demand patterns. Second, while the magnitude and caliber of the 2020 vintage in Australia has yet to be established, we stay confident that our Luxury and Masstige inventory holding represents a driver of earnings growth ahead. Moving on to cash flow and net debt: operating cash flow before interest, tax and material items rose to $378 million, powered by greater earnings and partly offset by working capital outflows, producing cash conversion of 85%. If you exclude the net movement in Luxury and Masstige noncurrent inventory, cash conversion came to 77%. We are keeping our full year operating cash flow guidance for growth consistent with EBITS growth, and as a result, underlying cash conversion should be roughly in line with fiscal '19. Lastly, we have preserved our investment-grade credit profile, with leverage bettering to 1.7x for the year. Our liquidity remains solid, with $336 million in cash and $722 million of undrawn committed debt facilities as of the end of December.
Matt Young
executiveNow on capital expenditures: for the half, total CapEx came to $113 million, with maintenance and replacement accounting for $51 million of that. Growth CapEx was $62 million, which went toward luxury wine-making infrastructure in South Australia and France, along with vineyard acquisitions and investments in IT systems. For F '20, we anticipate maintenance and replacement spending will fall within the prior guidance range of $100 million to $110 million, with growth CapEx reaching up to $135 million. Our South Australia expansion is moving forward as planned and remains on schedule to be operational ahead of the 2021 vintage. Thank you — I'll now pass things to Tim Ford, who will cover how the regions performed.
Tim Ford
executiveThanks, Matt, and good morning, everyone. There are a few things I want to cover before we go deeper into how each region performed. First, let me say again how happy we are with the way Asia, ANZ and EMEA keep performing — all three are still turning in extremely strong results, and together their EBITS, corporate included, rose 20% versus the prior corresponding half last year. Beyond that, I have confidence that the problems we're seeing in the U.S. market will be fixed, and that we'll get momentum back there, reaching the business levels and financial results we anticipate, with our focused premiumization strategy driving and supporting that. Ben Dollard, who is now our new Managing Director or President for the U.S. region, got off to a fast start in early January, and I have real confidence that with him leading and the wider Americas leadership team we now have, we'll recover that momentum as we head through the second half, and especially into F '21 and F '22. On that basis, we're holding to our medium EBITS margin target of 25% for this region. I also want to reassure you that, as an executive leadership team, we are intensely focused on lifting the Americas region's performance, and we stay committed to the strategy of growing our Luxury and Masstige portfolios that we already have in place, and we remain confident in the long-term prospects, especially for this portfolio.
Tim Ford
executiveOur attention will be on this while we keep building on what was a strong H1 across all our remaining operating regions and businesses. On America in more detail, as mentioned this morning, results felt the effect of a loss of execution momentum plus conditions in the market that are increasingly challenging. Net sales revenue fell 4% at constant currency, driven by commercial volume declines and the higher level of trade and promotional spend needed to hold share. That greater investment, together with lower volume, has restricted our capacity to offset the higher COGS per case in the market, which rose 3%, and taken together this produced a regional EBITS decline of 26% to $98 million, with an EBITS margin of 16.1%. While we are plainly disappointed by that result, what pleases us in this half is the ongoing premiumization of our portfolio, as our Luxury and Masstige depletions — not shipments — in the U.S. trade rose 10% and 5%, respectively, year-on-year. The Luxury and Masstige segments of this market keep showing strong growth for our business, with that strong depletions performance powered by a highly focused Masstige brand portfolio of 19 Crimes, Matua, Beringer Brothers and St Huberts The Stag, and a luxury portfolio headed by Stags' Leap wines, Penfolds, Beaulieu Vineyard and Beringer.
Tim Ford
executiveStill, that robust showing across Luxury and Masstige wasn't sufficient to make up for how the commercial segment did, since depletions volume there fell 10% compared with the same half a year ago. Part of that drop reflects a deliberate choice on our part to step away from lower-margin commercial-volume opportunities in cases where doing so made sense. We've stated repeatedly before that we won't pursue commercial volume with low or no margin merely to grow volume, and instead we direct our efforts toward premiumization. That said, we also acknowledge, in light of the half 1 results, that we need to strike a better balance than we managed this half between value and volume in the commercial portfolio, achieved through disciplined optimization of the dollars we invest commercially. As Mike discussed earlier, several factors — among them the trade war, potential business divestitures, and larger-than-average recent vintages — have produced elevated supply levels in the U.S. market and, consequently, heavy promotional activity in the U.S. wine market to shift that volume. In reaction, we've observed both the significant discounting already mentioned and robust growth in the private label and exclusive label market, as major market participants increasingly convert what is excellent-quality surplus wine into private label propositions.
Tim Ford
executiveRight now, private label and exclusives have been growing faster than the market across every price point segment apart from luxury. Now, when it comes to supply levels in the market, we're confident that will rebalance over time, but the accelerated trends we're seeing in the commercial tier are something we need to approach differently going forward. On how our new route-to-market model is performing, we're still very happy with the progress being made with our distributor partners as well as in our direct distribution states. In Florida, where we've shifted to direct distribution, we've beaten the market at every price point this half, and luxury growth in Florida was the highest in the U.S. for our business overall. In California, shipments were up year-on-year, with portfolio premiumization fueled by strong Masstige-led growth. That said, California is still a work in progress — the mix shift is happening more slowly than we'd like, especially our ability to replicate the growth we've seen in Masstige, which is a significant positive across the luxury portfolio, and while that portfolio is growing, it isn't at the level of Masstige. We keep focusing on luxury product availability and distribution in the independent and on-premise channels, particularly in California, and we see that as a significant future growth opportunity.
Tim Ford
executiveTo sum things up, even with the U.S. setback this half—which we've already walked through—our confidence stays intact in the portfolio, the people, and the business plans that will drive growth for this business well into the future. Now shifting to Asia, where we once more kept posting robust earnings gains in both North and Southeast Asia, powered by solid demand and excellent execution in our key markets. Net sales revenue for the Asia region rose 7%, while EBITS climbed 22% to $176 million, giving us an EBITS margin of 43% for the half. Worth pointing out here: we are holding to our EBITS—our earlier EBITS margin guidance of 35%, which also mirrors what we expect from growth in the Masstige portfolio going forward. In North Asia, we keep building momentum. Our distribution business model gives us the chance to outperform competitors who haven't put money into people on the ground or behind their brands the way we have across many periods. That investment, combined with excellent execution and leadership from the team on the ground, produced another strong result this half. As you'll remember, we sharply expanded our sales force at the close of fiscal '19, and that—together with an emphasis on instilling discipline and efficiency throughout our partner network, for both us and our partners—has generated meaningful distribution gains this half.
Tim Ford
executiveFor Luxury and Masstige in China, depletions were up an impressive more than 40% against the prior comparative period. Expanding both the breadth and the depth of our distribution continues to be our core growth strategy, and it is delivering results. We had earlier singled out 40 priority cities on which to focus for distribution depth, and happily our strongest depletion growth came from those focus cities, where our investment has been directed, and we also added 7 new cities during this half, which brings the total number of cities where we distribute in China to 146. Another pleasing aspect of this period was that growth was not solely driven by Penfolds — Wolf Blass has delivered impressive growth too, as has TWE's French portfolio led by Maison de Grand Esprit and the French portfolio under the Beaulieu Vineyard brand, together with new products launched into the market over the past 12 months, including brands such as Saltram. The e-commerce channel keeps growing in importance, with very, very strong volume growth and great momentum behind TWE brands carrying on through the half. As Mike mentioned earlier, one of our major customers in China restructured their business during this first half, which meant we in turn had to restructure our distribution arrangements for Rawson's Retreat and some lower luxury brands.
Tim Ford
executiveSo because of that change, the metrics for this period — volume, revenue per case, and EBITS margin — have been temporarily distorted. We expect shipping profiles to return to normal in the half we're currently in, and since it was lower-margin volumes that were affected, the earnings impact in the half was only small. Southeast Asia's performance in half 1 is just as pleasing. We've picked up distribution gains in a number of key markets, supported by better marketing activation and sales execution, with the focus on the Penfolds and Wolf Blass brand. This is a market we believe will keep growing. More foreign investment coming into the region, together with rising tourism, makes it an attractive market with plenty of opportunity for growth going forward, in our view. I'll now turn to the ANZ business — Australia and New Zealand — where, again, we remain pleased with how this business is performing. Net sales revenue fell 2.5%, largely because of lower commercial volumes, driven primarily, again, by growth in private label and a higher cost of goods, which meant we didn't pursue some low-margin volume opportunities where it made sense not to. As in the U.S., explained, we won't chase low-margin volume simply for the sake of volume growth, but will keep focusing our efforts on continuing the mix shift towards Masstige and Luxury.
Tim Ford
executiveOn top of that, we saw some short-term shifts in how our retail partners bought across portions of the luxury portfolio, driven by adjustments they made to their own spirits strategies. That did influence their near-term luxury purchasing patterns, but, as with the China discussion, it has not had any effect on our profitability. NSR per case rose 4.2% in the ANZ business, which shows the ongoing momentum behind our premiumization strategy. A favorable cost of doing business — reflecting gains from setting up the global business services function, in particular — drove EBITS growth of 14% to $85.9 million, with an EBITS margin of an impressive 26.4%. Our key focus brands, among them Penfolds, Wolf Blass, Squealing Pig, 19 Crimes and St Huberts The Stag, are fueling top line growth throughout the portfolio and delivering above-market growth rates in their respective categories. In on-premise as well, the team secured significant customer partnerships this half, giving strong brand visibility in key venues and marking great progress in our on-premise growth strategy. And finally, moving to EMEA, which now includes both the Europe and the Middle East and Africa segment. Once again we are pleased with how we performed in this market, holding their mid-teens EBITS margin in what is, as always, a challenging market.
Tim Ford
executiveThe decline in total regional NSR was once again due to lower commercial volumes — especially in the Middle East and Africa, where we chose to exit unprofitable volume in that business. That was offset by the premiumization strategy, as seen in other regions in the U.K. and the Nordics, particularly led by 19 Crimes, Wolf Blass and Penfolds. 19 Crimes keeps delivering a strong performance across the region, driven by expanded distribution in the U.K., together with growth in Continental Europe and the Nordics. And Lindeman’s remains the #1 brand in Sweden and the Netherlands. As we previously foreshadowed, Australian-sourced commercial wine COGS are having an impact, so we are focused on controlling investment levels and continuing to push premiumization in order to maintain a mid-teens margin in F '20. So I'll now hand back to Mike for concluding remarks.
Michael Clarke
executiveThanks, Timothy. As I mentioned right at the start of today's call, the underlying resilience of our business model — diversified across the globe — comes through in the results we're reporting now, and plenty of parts of our operations are tracking right where we expected them to, which lets us keep growing even with the near-term difficulties we're facing in the United States. That said, we're aware that sitting underneath those near-term difficulties are a number of longer-horizon shifts in the commercial tier that are growing more common and are having a bigger and bigger effect on both the markets where we operate and on our company, so going forward we'll need a more refined approach. Those shifts, which we've discussed on this call, include commercial COGS continuing to rise around the world, plus robust expansion in private label — now in the United States in addition to Australia and the U.K. And instead of simply viewing them as long-term negatives, we see these shifts as an opportunity to speed up our premiumization strategy, both via the investment we're putting into luxury production, as we shared at our recent Investor Day, but importantly, also via further changes that drive simplification focus and make sure we have the proper capital and cost structure for the entire business across every price tier.
Michael Clarke
executiveContinuing from work we've already finished, we're now carrying out a strategic review of our internal operating model, centered on the best way to run our commercial wine business differently going forward. As part of that effort, we will examine a range of options, among them refined supply chain structures and operating models, and this would encompass possibilities such as internal divisionalization but not demerger. As I noted at the beginning of the call, we have substantially enhanced the profitability of our commercial wine business across the past 6 years, and it remains a valuable part of our business. We anticipate this review will wrap up in H2, and we'll share further details over the coming months, including the potential upside to our future financial metrics stemming from restructuring the business. To close, the results presented today reflect the momentum behind our premiumization strategy and the strength of our global business model, which has once again delivered sustainable organic growth despite the challenging conditions in the United States market. While we're disappointed with our performance in the Americas this half, we are confident that we have the right strategy and the right team in place to course-correct and return this important region to margin-accretive growth, particularly once market conditions return to a more stable footing and supply is in line with demand.
Michael Clarke
executiveTurning to the latter half, we anticipate that the near-term effects in the United States will carry on for the rest of this financial year and on into F '21. Consequently, we are revising our guidance for F '20 reported EBITS growth to 5% to 10%, a figure under the roughly 15% to 20% reported EBITS growth we had previously guided to. For fiscal '21, our expectation is reported EBITS growth of 10% to 15%, and that will come from ongoing premiumization of our -- of -- plus expansion in luxury wine availability, set against our expectation that difficult market conditions in the United States could continue into the following financial year, together with the possible cost impact of what appears to be a difficult 2020 vintage in Australia. This F '21 guidance leaves out potential upside from any additional restructuring of the business, which would speed up premiumization and change how we operate the commercial wine business, and which could produce meaningful benefits down the road. I want to thank all of you for being on the call today and for your continued support of our business. With that, we will now take questions.
Operator
operator<<operator_script>> Today's initial question will be asked by Craig Woolford of Citigroup.
Craig Woolford
analystI've got a few questions about the U.S. — I'm sure that comes as no surprise. Looking at the results, the NSR outcome in terms of revenue growth seemed reasonable, but the earnings decline was quite significant. So I'm trying to figure out whether there were extra operating costs in that Americas business. And on top of that, was trade spend higher, or did it grow at a faster pace than sales? Put another way, did the ratio of trade spend to sales go up in that U.S. or Americas segment?
Matt Young
executiveCraig, this is Matt. I'll pick that one up. I believe you can — what you're describing is accurate. There are a few points to note. As you can see, volumes have fallen in the U.S. market. So volume is part of it, and that reflects a mix effect from the Commercial decline, partly offset by Luxury and Masstige. The main point you're making is valid, and it's what Mike and Tim and the rest of us have discussed: alongside the volume decline, there has also been an effect from the greater promotional spending needed in that market, and from the level of discounting taking place there, driven mainly by higher vintages and by participants seeking to leave their wine business. That is producing more discounting and promotional support in the market. You can read that both through discounts and through advertising, promotion and costs incurred to support that business. The third trend I'd mention is cost of goods, as we've noted previously. Higher cost of goods for Australian-sourced and U.S. luxury wines has been a challenge in that market, which we flagged, but it has been harder to offset this year once you also factor in the volume decline.
Matt Young
executiveA variety of factors are at play here—volume, promotional support, and COGS—and together they're pushing what I'd describe as the leverage further down the P&L.
Michael Clarke
executiveLet me add something there, Craig, on top of what Matt just mentioned. Regarding the COGS line, there's another hit involved: when you turn your back on volume you'd intended to sell — an unplanned walkaway from volume — you end up with an overhead under-recovery inside the supply chain. That means an extra charge lands in COGS. So the contribution doesn't come through, yet those costs remain, and that's what damages you at the gross profit line. Then in A&P, trade sell carries a larger spend. Obviously, given the surplus wine in the U.S. market, there's heavier spending in A&P, in trade sell, and in D&R as well.
Craig Woolford
analystAnd regarding that walkaway, did that 0.5 million cases figure apply only to the U.S., or did it also cover the other regions as well?
Michael Clarke
executiveWe're looking at roughly 0.5 million cases here in the United States, and about 0.5 million cases in the rest of the world. In those other regions, though, we make up for it by exceeding our targets on Luxury/Masstige growth.
Operator
operatorOur following question is from Ben Gilbert with UBS.
Ben Gilbert
analystI'm really just curious about how fast things moved in the U.S., and I guess how it all unfolded so quickly. So if I look at — I know you've cited IRI data, and we have Nielsen data on the table that's probably showing you guys tracking down around 2%, 3% for the last quarter of last year. But when you look at what's implied, it would suggest that the route, which obviously hasn't recovered from this, sort of the on-premise looks like it was probably materially softer. I was just wondering if you could just sort of walk us through the couple of months and how it came on so quickly. And I suppose how you can still — how you're thinking about the ability to recover this price over time and I suppose sort of potentially pushing out that expectation for 25% medium-term margins in the U.S.
Tim Ford
executiveYes, Ben — this is Tim speaking. I'll take that one first, and then Mike can add on, if that works. There are a few elements, I'd say, that got worse as Q2 went on. The first one I'll mention is our own internal planning. Obviously, when the leadership changed — the unanticipated changes in leadership on the U.S. side — we did lose momentum as we planned for Q2. That's one piece of this, and we won't shy away from it; we're confronting it head-on. If you then connect that with the conclusion of the California vintage, and specifically the commercial wine portion of the California vintage, which wrapped up around September–October, there came a recognition across the whole market — one we'd fortunately reached a few months earlier from an inventory-balancing standpoint — but the market came to recognize that the excess wine in that marketplace, industry-wide, was larger than what people initially would have assumed, and larger than what other companies initially would have assumed. So that caught all of us off guard. What they observed at that point was a rapid, substantial pickup in the kinds of activities we've discussed. On top of that, I'd add that when you're attempting to shift volume and create space after a vintage, every company began offering considerably deeper discounts.
Tim Ford
executiveAnd for retailers — earlier in the half, they'd spotted the opportunity that private label offers, and I'm sure you've gone through the numbers across those 26 weeks, our retail partners had seen that private label opportunity. And once partners, and once suppliers too, had the chance to provide them with additional wine at lower price points under exclusive labels, they definitely accelerated their plans in that area, at the expense of promotional activity and the ranging of branded items.
Michael Clarke
executiveLet me just add two more contexts to that if I can. When you consider what every supplier has done — Treasury included, but the big suppliers in America too, given the surplus, the industry surplus picture — you really have a couple of options. You can attempt to shift that — either you hold onto the inventory, which nobody wants to do, or you push it out through your own brands, but then you're forced to discount those brands heavily, or you bring it to a retailer and give them either an exclusive trademark name, moving the product that way, or you place it under their private label brand. And every major player — if you look at IRI, Ben, all the major players have taken this route. And here's what we hadn't expected. We handled our inventory intake very well, so we intentionally cut back our inventory intake in October, and right now our inventory position in America is genuinely strong across Luxury/Masstige and commercial, which is great. And as you know, commercial is outsourced — we purchase it on the bulk wine market. But what we didn't foresee was that everyone would aggressively attempt to shift their inventory, their surplus, via exclusives and private label brands.
Michael Clarke
executiveClearly, it made a great deal of sense for the retailers to act this way, since suddenly that became genuinely high-quality juice flowing through their hands at attractive margins, while basically all the suppliers accepted markdowns just to clear that stock. And that is what, structurally speaking, has pushed this shift forward, which by the end of the year we have of course come to recognize — everyone was shifting their inventory in this direction. That resulted in private label expanding 15% within a market that is essentially flat. That represents an enormous shift in the U.S. market. Now, I do anticipate that — speaking purely for myself — I do expect a reversal once the industry returns to balance and demand aligns with supply, when you won't have excess inventory searching for a destination, and so it will move through brands, and so you'll get competition among brands — greater competition, in my view, among brands and private label. But meanwhile, as long as this excess inventory persists, which from an industry standpoint is happening right now, we believe through the back half of this year and we expect into next year, it will require another vintage before people quit — stop making wine and instead go to almonds or cannabis rather than wine to restore balance, and that is the point when normalization will occur.
Michael Clarke
executiveBen, one last thing to add: clearly, the second quarter is a major one on our calendar. Over in the US, the first quarter doesn't carry much weight for us.
Operator
operatorRichard Barwick at CLSA has the next question.
Richard Barwick
analystFrom what you've described, it certainly sounds like a great moment to be drinking wine in the U.S. — plenty of high-quality wine is sloshing around at markdown prices — and even so, the market doesn't appear to have reacted. Volumes continue to look soft, even with some gains at the premium price points. Does that make you uneasy when you step back and look at the U.S. wine market in the bigger picture? The second piece of that question: you cited IRI data and described the market as flat to down, yet other data sources suggest something different — Gomberg-Fredrikson, for instance, actually shows volumes up a little. Direct-to-consumer remains very strongly growing, and on top of that, the Aussie export numbers reveal a genuine rebound in the value of Australian wine heading in. So I think there's somewhat contradictory data circulating, and I'd really like to hear your perspective on that, and to fold it all into the broader shape of things — are you worried about longer-term growth in the market, given how much has been pushed toward the consumer and yet, arguably, they aren't responding?
Michael Clarke
executiveI'll spend a little time on this answer, and Timothy, feel free to chime in and add anything you think I'm leaving out. And I want to devote some time to it because I believe it will help with other questions that are coming, if you all don't mind. What I'd like is for us to examine the data from — we look at IRI, though you could use Nielsen, you could use plenty of different sources, and I'm fairly confident that once I've finished this, when you go back and check it, my hope is you'll observe similar kinds of trends. And I'd urge you to take a look at the data on which portion of the market is private label and which portion is branded, since this shift has produced a very — a major structural transformation in the United States. So it's a question of what's private label and what's branded. And what you won't find in measured IRI or Nielsen data is Costco, Publics, HEB, and a number of these other big players in America that are substantial, who do exclusives as well as private label. So if you don't mind, Richard, we're providing our data.
Michael Clarke
executiveAnd keep in mind that we believe we hold quite substantial data, for instance on China. We possess really extensive information regarding what is happening in the American market. But allow me to move on to those specifics now. So there are three elements I just mentioned. Measured private label, measured branded, and unmeasured private label, and we are considering that combined total. You are observing volume and value growth within the Luxury segments as well as the Masstige segments. And that remains an appealing area of the market for Treasury Wine Estates to compete in. We have outperformed the markets in Luxury and Masstige combined. We have outperformed on value and also on volume. So even absent the discounting we have been engaged in to try to hold share, which has damaged the P&L, we have not caused enough damage to destroy value. If I may phrase it that way. So we have been taking the right actions and that is why I have also hinted that we could push even harder in the back half to do even more discounting in Luxury/Masstige to try to secure more profit and try to reach the 15% guidance as one metric, and there are other things we could attempt to do. But then the difficulty is you would have to lap that next year.
Michael Clarke
executiveThat is not something I will permit to occur. The incoming CEO would not want it either. The two of us are in full agreement on this. We won't take that route, because postponing the issue into next year—after you've pushed heavy discounts on your brands during this year—means you then have to claw the pricing back the following year. So that's off the table. That segment of the market stays appealing, and it is the top priority for Treasury Wine Estates. Luxury/Masstige is precisely where our attention is fixed. On the second point, if you examine the commercial market—and I'll share some insight into how our strategic planning works—for Commercial, across the coming 8 to 10 years, our assumption is this: over the last 6 years we have restructured the scale of our business in Commercial, across the total company and in America as well. We shrank the size, we cut the cost, and we lifted profitability. So what we assumed we would do going forward is to assume a more or less flattish contribution from our commercial portfolio in America and also from around the world—flattish in dollar terms; I think brand contribution can decline, and I have no problem with it declining in line with market decline, but we know we can offset that decline through the upside from accelerated growth in Luxury/Masstige and the margins available there.
Michael Clarke
executiveThat's essentially how our business model has worked. What's disrupting things right now and hurting our performance is the surplus inventory sitting in the market — there's a structural problem in the U.S. market — and people are, I believe rightly, working to push that excess through private label, whether as a private label brand or as an exclusive. An exclusive might be a trademark owned by a branded company — us, other suppliers. But you hand it exclusively to a retailer who will take meaningful volumes. They set up the exclusive because they're committing to those volumes, and then they push it through their store much like a private label brand. That's been substantial. And I think if you simply look at 15% growth in that segment of the market, it's been enormous from a volume standpoint. So building on your point, that has been huge. But from a profit standpoint we aren't taking part in it, and neither is Gallo, neither is Constellation, neither is Chateau St Michelle. They're clearing excess inventory at a discount to the supplier but at a margin for the retailer.
Michael Clarke
executiveSo it stands to reason the retailer would shift it. That’ll keep going as long as the market has a surplus, but that volume is going to the retailer. It isn’t volume in our brands, if you look at it that way, since we earn no margin on it. So hopefully that clarifies the volume and also the dynamic of what’s going on between Commercial and Masstige. As Tim also said, private label growth isn’t only in Commercial. The growth in private label and exclusive has been $15 and below. So that’s lower Masstige, but there’s also been faster growth in private label within Luxury. Now they are — they start from a very small base. And what that amounts to, we believe, is people shifting some of their surplus luxury that they didn’t want to discount in their brand. We’re assuming that’s what they did — they moved it through private label, which obviously, if I were a retailer, I’d want to grab with both hands, because as a retailer I’d like to grow Luxury/Masstige and Commercial. That’s background. Now let’s go forward. What do we want to achieve as a business going forward? We want to achieve a very strong Luxury/Masstige business in America that complements our very strong Luxury/Masstige businesses in every other market around the world where we can, for example, grow Penfolds in every one of those markets.
Michael Clarke
executiveThis ties back to the theme we've consistently stressed regarding creating a sense of apparent scarcity. During my tenure at this company, we've never been in a position to expand Penfolds in America in a sustainable way, for two reasons: first, inventory was insufficient, and second, margins were higher in Asia. Yet looking ahead, a diversified business strategy is what you want — one where your #1 brand alongside certain other luxury brands can be offered in each market where you operate. And the encouraging thing we're communicating on today's call is that we're achieving profitable growth of Luxury/Masstige across every geography worldwide right now, during this first half, America included, and we're outpacing our competitors. So the structure exists to support growth of the luxury portfolio and, specifically, to drive additional expansion of Penfolds going forward. What must change at this point is the reality that a structural shift has occurred in the U.S. market which we did not foresee. Simply presuming that for the next 8 to 10 years our company profit from Commercial can remain flattish is an assumption I don't believe we can accept any longer. That was perhaps a luxury available to us in recent years.
Michael Clarke
executiveWe believe a structural shift is going to impact the US market over the coming 2 years, in our view, until vintage sizes change. And on top of that, with elevated COGS on this Australian juice, chasing that volume under our existing business model—today's business model—with those higher COGS plus promotional spend won't make sense for us, given that other players in the commercial sector are likewise trying to move their Commercial wine. We'd prefer to walk away from it. But if you don't plan for that walk-away, it flows through the P&L, because our Commercial business has grown more profitable. Like it or not, that's actually a strength of our business, since we've lifted profitability. So what we need to do going forward now is not simply marvel at the structural change issue in America and elsewhere around the world—instead, we're going to roll up our sleeves and tackle how we restructure our approach to Commercial wine in our business, because it is a profitable part of our business. In the first half, though, it's been a drag.
Michael Clarke
executiveAnd as a lot of you are aware, we've explored numerous alternatives. We constantly examine optionality regarding ways we could operate various segments of our company in a different manner. We've previously run those models. Right now we're occupied with refreshing them and considering how we might place a distinct emphasis on Commercial as opposed to Luxury. Tim is in charge of this effort since he will have to implement it in the years ahead. I'm collaborating with him on it. Together we're taking ownership. Ideally we'll simply complete this, get it updated, secure Board approval, and return to the market. My plan—and Tim's plan, given that he has me working for him on this—is to finish it prior to my departure from the business. So this isn't something we intend to spend a lot of time on. We'll proceed rapidly because the work has already been done, we're refreshing it, and we're tackling it. I apologize to everybody. That was a long-winded response, but I wanted to use it to address several different points so everyone is grounded in what's inside Tim's head, Matt's head, and Mike's head.
Tim Ford
executiveI think you've addressed that thoroughly. The one extra thing I'd add just a bit to is — and first, let me echo Mike's remarks: yes, this is a joint plan, and we're aligned on what we need to concentrate on, especially over the very short window ahead, to tackle the challenges, and tackle them we will, emerging with a stronger business model that lets us accomplish 2 things. First, stay absolutely laser-focused on the growth side of our business that has been so successful so far and will keep being so, which centers on the Luxury and Masstige portfolio, while making sure the Commercial business gets the right focus so it can be a solid supporting piece of this business going forward rather than a drag, which it was in the first half of this year, unexpectedly. And when we plan it properly — and I'll connect this to the inventory point shortly — when we plan that business correctly, we know we can operate a very, very effective, efficient and profitable Commercial wine business. Just one build so we're all clear on some of the points we're making about surplus inventory in the market in that business: one example of our planning was that we did plan a significantly reduced intake in the U.S.
Tim Ford
executiveTurning to Vintage '19, which has just passed. So even though there's excess stock throughout the market, we feel quite good about where we stand internally on our inventory levels and the way we're handling them moving forward. And as we put investment behind the brands that are performing—Luxury and Masstige brands—they're expanding in many markets. Once that structural shift takes place in the U.S. business, we'll emerge better positioned than others in that marketplace to capitalize on it. That's our plan.
Michael Clarke
executiveThat's right, and let me add one more thing. When we announced back in October that I'd be handing things over to Timothy — and honestly, only 2 people on this planet actually call him Timothy: his mother and me — ever since that October announcement, we've been running things as if Tim is already leading the company and I report to him. Still, I want to be clear about one thing: I remain the CEO until I leave in Q1. In the end, this business will have a considerably larger and more profitable Luxury/Masstige segment worldwide across each of those markets — the U.S., Asia, Europe, and Australia as well. We'll also end up with a smaller but highly profitable Commercial wine business globally, one that supports our Luxury operations, though the Luxury business itself will be smaller.
Tim Ford
executiveOn the commercial side of things.
Michael Clarke
executiveMy apologies — that was the Commercial business. Please excuse me. Thanks.
Operator
operatorOur following question this afternoon arrives from Shaun Cousins, who is calling in from JP Morgan.
Shaun Cousins
analystI have a question about the coronavirus. So far, your release hasn't said anything about it. Can you verify that your fiscal '20 and fiscal '21 guidance includes no assumption of any adverse effect from the coronavirus? And if that's the case, why isn't it? Perhaps you could also share what you're currently observing on the ground regarding the impact in China thus far, particularly since that region is so profitable for you?
Tim Ford
executiveYeah, absolutely — it's Tim here. We haven't factored in any effect from the current coronavirus situation. Obviously, that's front and center for us right now, in terms of what the impact has been. And the reason we haven't is that it's simply too early to say. Our attention over the last stretch — especially the past 10 days — has been on looking after our people and making sure we have full management oversight of what's going on with our teams in China, particularly through the Chinese New Year period. As I'm sure you know, everybody there has been on holiday for the last week. So at this stage, no, we haven't incorporated that into any of our forecasts or plans going forward.
Michael Clarke
executiveLet me add to that. I believe it would be too early to begin factoring that in with certain figures moving up, down, or sideways. My first point is that this calls for a watching brief. On the second point, I think we clearly are — and as we've said regarding our existing business today, we sit in a better or stronger spot than most of our rivals, in that we ship product into China, and we pull it through at an accelerated depletions rate. So it's reaching retailers and consumers far better than anyone else's in the marketplace. And a number of you had actually gone and data mined the import data into China as well as consumption behavior in China, and you'll see that consumption keeps growing, particularly Luxury/Masstige at mid- to high single-digit growth rates. Yet, if you look at the import data, that hasn't been the case, and that's because many competitors have shipped product into China and they haven't necessarily pulled through with marketing and with local teams and pull-through programs, unlike us. So we're in a better place to drive pull-through. Another data point I'd share with you is that a small percentage of our business is on-premise consumption.
Michael Clarke
executiveAnd I realize that when a virus is potentially in play, travel may be restricted for people, but that will have an impact on food, water and wine. And to be honest, that's something we're monitoring closely—we'll simply need to watch how it develops. The last thing I'd mention—and it's too early to make a judgment on this—is that if you look at Hong Kong, for instance, many people there said that with the demonstrations, businesses would decline. What we've found is that within our business, we've actually grown in Hong Kong. So it isn't always right to simply connect the dots in one direction based on what people are presuming. You have to understand the composition of the on-premise business, the composition of our home delivery business, the composition of the retail business, et cetera, and also how consumers are consuming. They might be consuming at home rather than in restaurants, for example.
Operator
operatorDavid Errington with Bank of America Merrill Lynch has the next question.
David Errington
analystThis is a bigger question of philosophy, but there's real bite to it. To begin with a statement: I've covered Treasury in various shapes and forms for more than 25 years, and I have never seen this business succeed in the United States — in terms of, first, being able to produce an acceptable return, justifying the method, the amount of money, the amount of man-hours that go into this business. And I've been skinned, and the company has been skinned, on setbacks, downgrades, excess inventory, market corrections, you name it. Now my question is, Mike, you say you want to use this market for multi — diversification. But why? I mean, when you look at the Luxury part, the gain that you're going to get is going to be wiped out by the cost of getting it there, because this business is largely a Commercial business that's going backwards in a hurry, and the cost to restructure another restructure, I mean, a review — what do you need to review? You know the answers, what do you need to review? I mean, if you don't know the answers now, you'll never know. So I'm asking, why do you need to do the review?
David Errington
analystWhat could that review possibly tell you that you don’t already know? So why keep going with this business, which has only ever offset that fantastic asset you have in Australia? This brilliant strategy of yours for moving into growth markets—the very thing that sets you apart where you hold competitive advantages. In the U.S. you have never had a competitive advantage, and I doubt you ever will. So why are you persisting with it? Why do you keep pouring money into it? Why do you keep pouring in the best resources you have—men, women, the smartest minds—into this market, when all it does is destroy value? So why persist with this, Mike and Tim? And you, Tim, are going to have to own this. You’re on this now—you have to own it. So why should we—I don’t know a single person investing in this stock who wants to own the U.S. asset from the standpoint of us buying it. We’re buying TWE for what you’re doing in Australia. Why are you doing this in the U.S.?
Michael Clarke
executiveAlright, David — thanks for asking. Timothy wants to start, since he's raised his hand. So he'll go first, and then I'll add anything he doesn't cover.
Tim Ford
executiveYes. So, yes. Thank you, David. And as you mentioned, I'll be taking ownership of this moving forward. So I think it makes sense that I respond first, regardless. I think the U.S. opportunity and the U.S. business — if we look back, and this will conflict with your statement somewhat, and I'll begin with that point — is that we've enhanced that business across multiple years, and especially during the last 4 or 5 years, to the point where, yes, we've had a disappointing result in this half. But when you consider the strengths we possess in that business, and there are several strengths, which I'll discuss, and the opportunity from a consumer standpoint, the trends that have driven our success in other markets around the world are the same trends we believe will persist in the U.S. The first one: the consumer keeps premiumizing, which fits and aligns with our portfolio and our brands. We have invested fairly heavily in our Luxury and Masstige brands over the recent period. We'll keep doing so to seize that opportunity, and we have the asset base behind that to do so.
Tim Ford
executiveTake Penfolds as an illustration — we've discussed this before. Growing our Penfolds portfolio represents a major opportunity in the U.S. market, and that growth can come not just from Australia but also from the U.S. and from Napa, as we've mentioned regarding the products we've made. For our business in the U.S., that's a key growth platform. So a big share of the value — not the volume — of the U.S. business is in fact expanding. You've seen that in our Luxury and Masstige results and depletion figures across the last 6 months, even though the half was financially difficult. That's the reason to believe, correct? And then, once you dig beneath those numbers and beneath that strategy, you compare how well we can execute in that market and what we've done against what we've begun to do. So this isn't starting now — we began over the recent period, especially across the last 12 to 18 months, and our distribution gains, plus our capacity to expand distribution in the right accounts with the portfolio we hold, are significant. So these aren't new market opportunities, and these aren't new channels that we need to develop.
Tim Ford
executiveWe're capturing our fair share of the market we have now — a profitable one, Luxury and Masstige — and we expect it to stay profitable as we move forward. That's exactly why I have confidence in the opportunity the U.S. offers us, and it won't require another 5 years for us to get there. We think it's here and now. The structural problems in the U.S. are going to shift as well. Also, we believe very few of our main competitors in the U.S. are in the wine business for the long term. And once we emerge on the other side of this structural change in the U.S. — which could take more than one vintage, hopefully just one, and that's what our business planning is built around — we'll emerge stronger, having put investment into the right areas of our business, and we'll stay in it for the long term, and in my view it will succeed. That's my belief.
Michael Clarke
executiveThanks, Timothy. Let me just build on that and be clear — Tim and I are very much on the same page, and my role now going forward is to support Tim. David, I'd like to respond to a couple of the comments, and I can appreciate someone who has been on this journey for 25 years — that is, you — compared with some of us who have perhaps been on it for 6 years so far, and some of us who will keep going. I'll be quite controversial here. It would have been fantastic if the people before Tim — Matt and Mike — had actually rolled up their sleeves and fixed America before we did our jobs. That would be nice. That's a wish. The reality is that we are in charge of running this business and delivering value for shareholders, and we inherit this business the way it is. And I think we have focused on how we optimize that business over the last 6 years and also on how we want to optimize the business going forward without destroying shareholder value. And I think we have improved shareholder value over the last 6 years, and we have hit a speed bump at the moment in this year, and we are going to address that.
Michael Clarke
executiveThat's the first thing. You've already heard from me and Tim why we believe the U.S. matters when you look at it through a Luxury/Masstige portfolio lens — having a profitable Luxury/Masstige business there, a place where we can sell our U.S. Luxury brands, and we're growing faster than our competitors in Luxury/Masstige, even during a tough period, and that's an encouraging signal for us, so we're gaining traction, and over the last 6 months we've achieved this without having a complete team in place. There's a fellow we're all fond of, Angus, who wasn't in a position to relocate to America. People in America thought very highly of him, and for reasons that are personal, he isn't making the move to America. We won't go into those details, but we have an equally outstanding person in Ben Dollard, plus a solid team supporting him, who can propel this faster growth in Luxury/Masstige, which will also carry Penfolds. Penfolds performs well when there's perceived scarcity. And I give you my word, if at any point you have an issue or we have an issue with the perceived scarcity of Penfolds, that will be a problem. So if you restrict how many markets or platforms Penfolds can be sold through in order to create perceived scarcity, my view is that over time you'd be capping what the brand's future potential could be.
Michael Clarke
executiveAnd America really does need to serve as a platform for selling Penfolds and the U.S. Luxury portfolio. The next element you brought up is that we already have the answers. That's right — we do have the answers. Sadly, per Australian Stock Exchange rules, the moment you alter your guidance, you must immediately inform the market. And we haven't had enough time to complete the plans that Tim, myself, Matt, and his leadership team understand extremely well what we're going to do. We simply can't discuss it publicly right now, today, since we haven't finished the work and we haven't finished reviewing it with our Board. Governance requirements exist that we must follow to review this with this Board. There's a unanimous stance among the leadership team regarding what we need to do to go and fix Commercial. It's something we've examined before, and we didn't act on it previously because we made driving Asia the priority, we made going direct in America the priority, along with other things that mattered more to us over the last 6 years. It has now reached the point where merely depending on -- of our Commercial business, simply ticking along nicely with no meaningful shifts in profitability was -- is something that won't happen, as if we must go and tackle it, which means we alter the size, we enhance the profitability, and it isn't a distraction.
Michael Clarke
executiveLet me put this to you, David: if we were up here presenting today, and there had been no structural shift in the market — no surplus inventory in the United States, private label growing at 15% — and if Angus McPherson were in the market, and we reported growth in Luxury/Masstige and never even mentioned our Commercial business, everyone would be delighted, because strategically that would make sense. Unfortunately — and I do like the challenge you're giving me, by the way — strategically, Commercial is a challenge, and we are going to need to rightsize Commercial even further. We're going to need to run it differently. My argument would be that there is a mindset that, as this business keeps growing, the Luxury side of the business — a mindset creeps into the people in our business; they're not wrong, they are humans — but the mindset that creeps in is that I can make a bigger profit number by selling more Luxury, and I don't have to worry about the Commercial side. That has now been proven: you cannot operate like that. We need a separate focus on Luxury and a separate focus on Commercial. And Tim and I are absolutely aligned that this is the right thing to do for this business going forward.
Michael Clarke
executiveAnd as we mentioned earlier, this will be finished before my departure.
Tim Ford
executiveThe final thing I’d note is that this applies worldwide, not only within the US.
Michael Clarke
executiveRight. The fact that we're able to say we've turned our backs on volume in Australia, turned our backs on volume in China — though that's more down to a customer change — and also turned our backs on volume in Europe, and none of that has pulled in Commercial volume. That wasn't planned either, and it comes to just under 0.5 million cases, and it hasn't damaged profitability at those businesses outside of America — we've reached 20% EBITS growth across those businesses — which demonstrates that once a business is fixed in Luxury/Masstige, we can cover 4 issues. The trouble is we haven't finished fixing the U.S. business, but we will get it fixed.
Operator
operatorWe’ll take our next question from Larry Gandler of Crédit Suisse.
Larry Gandler
analystLet me close the call on what I hope is a more upbeat note. To my mind, the standout bright spot in the results was the 40% depletions in China. I think it would matter a great deal if you could provide as much detail on that as you did on the U.S. problems. A few things to cover in your response, in the way you explained how 40% growth in depletions was delivered — here are some items: did shipments run at a comparable pace to Luxury depletions in China? Could you speak to a few of the brands? On Bin 389, pricing has been soft, yet that evidently hasn't affected your volumes. For Lot 518, how is that new brand progressing? Bin 407 has consistently been in short supply — have you managed to lift that? Offer some commentary on other brands as well. Third point, if you could address this in your answer, allocations and the coronavirus. Frequently you aim to have customers buy their allocations by March. Given the coronavirus, will you push that back? The new warehouse is now up and running. Will it be at 100%? And regarding the 146 cities you referenced, where did that stand last year? Could you discuss your progress in penetrating Tier 2 and Tier 3 cities?
Tim Ford
executiveLarry, first off, thanks for the constructive question — I appreciate it. And second, I'm confident that through the many conversations we'll have over the coming 2 days, we'll be able, as a team, to address all the answers to those particular questions. But I'll do my best to stay at a broader level, if I can, simply for the sake of time. The first thing is your point, and it's among the most pleasing elements of this result and deserves highlighting: the depletions rate year-on-year for the half for China across our entire portfolio — yes, it's plus 4 — it's 40% plus. What pleases me most within that comes down to a couple of aspects. One is that it's the depth of distribution that's fueling that growth within our 40 key cities that we're concentrating on. What that means is we're getting better at allocating our investment dollars within those cities and getting value from them. Those cities have also been where we've focused our resourcing increases, with the sales team, et cetera, as well. So the information we have, and we track it very, very closely, certainly indicates that although we are well distributed across multiple brands in these priority cities, we still have an opportunity for increased growth from a depth of distribution standpoint.
Tim Ford
executiveThat's the first item, and it's the most encouraging piece. The second piece concerns our partners in those regions: we've invested considerable effort establishing disciplined approaches to partner sales territories, to the way we market our brands in particular territories alongside partners, and to how we back that up through brand investment. And my sense is our partners are reacting extremely favorably as we keep developing joint plans with them too. From that angle, the growth they're witnessing and the speed at which inventory converts into cash for them, driven by the pull-through programs, is proving highly successful for most of our partners in China right now, and I'm certain those near the market are hearing the same thing. The wider portfolio, once more, is performing well. You mentioned a few specific SKUs inside Penfolds, and I'll skip walking through each one, if that's alright, given time constraints, but what I will say is that one of the more encouraging aspects is we're beginning to see depletions growth landing where we want it across brands — not just in Luxury or the core section of Penfolds, but also among brands such as Koonunga Hill and the French portfolio, and so on.
Tim Ford
executiveFor us in China, having that brand portfolio matters as a selling tool beyond just the core Bins within Penfolds. Those 3 aspects are what please us most. We had the mid-Autumn festival period and the Chinese New Year festival periods, and our performance across the board in both left us very, very pleased. Hopefully that gives enough color on the 3 or 4 specific reasons why it's working that way. And clearly, we can go into more detail in future discussions, if that's okay. Yes.
Operator
operatorAndrew McLennan of Goldman Sachs is the next person to pose a question.
Andrew McLennan
analystI'd like to pick up where Larry left off, and again keep the focus on China. Clearly, the environment is a difficult one. And Tim, what you laid out is pretty much in line with what we've been hearing. So it's encouraging to hear about that sort of execution improvement showing up through higher A&P spending. But -- so when we sort of look through the issues, there's excess inventory sitting in the channel, though not necessarily of Treasury's products. You've obviously been sorting out your arrangement with Costco. You've also lost Mouton Cadet, which I believe will be a second half impact, though whether it's significant, I'm not sure. But you really have, I guess, been able to count on a high proportion of Penfolds sales from what we're hearing, which is a good thing to be able to count on. But it does suggest, at least to some degree, that there's an unanticipated buildup in non-Penfolds Luxury and Masstige inventory. But also, at the same time, we are seeing, as Larry alluded to, a deterioration in some price points for a number of Penfolds products, it's not across the board but Bin 389 is an example. I'm just wondering, first -- firstly, how do you resolve these price declines that you're seeing in products like Bin 389?
Andrew McLennan
analystAnd then, second, could you just confirm how confident you are about where inventory stands, and whether anything has piled up that will need to be worked down over time?
Tim Ford
executiveYes, absolutely — thanks for raising that. On pricing, the first thing I’d mention is what I said earlier regarding our partners. We collaborate extremely closely with them to make sure market discipline holds — both in the locations where they sell the product and in the prices at which they sell our products — so that everything lands exactly where we want it. And as I mentioned, there aren’t cases of behavior that alter that, no. There are cases of behavior we are very clear about and very much on top of, and we handle those with the individual partners involved on a case-by-case basis. Based on the information I have and see — which I think is fairly broad and fairly detailed — I do not believe we face a structural pricing problem in any portfolio, or any part of our portfolio, across China at this moment, in any of the channels. Isolated instances, yes, absolutely, and we address those, and we keep those management mechanisms in place, which I actually view as a genuine strength from having more of our sales team on the ground working with partners and so on, because we can address those situations and gain that insight ourselves rather than, I suppose, relying on the feedback you sometimes receive from different parts of the market.
Tim Ford
executiveThat covers the first point and how I'd answer it. Second, on inventory: we feel quite good about the stock levels held by our partners and within the China business. Compared with the same period a year earlier, actual days cover — the forward days cover across our portfolio — came in lower. We do monitor it, and I won't get into the details here, but as a leadership team we review it SKU by SKU and month by month, together with the management team in China too, to make sure shipments and depletions stay in balance, not just for Penfolds but across the whole portfolio. So on that basis, I'm very comfortable with where our inventory stands, both to support channel growth there — and it is a growth market, so we'll be shipping more inventory year on year because we're growing that business — and when it comes to the balance with depletions, I'm very comfortable with where it sits right now.
Michael Clarke
executiveTwo quick follow-ups on what you just mentioned. Regarding BPhR, we've agreed that going forward we won't be distributing their brand — or Mouton Cadet, pardon me — and instead we'll concentrate on our own French portfolio. I believe the reason behind that is pretty clear to everyone. And from a P&L standpoint, I don't think you need to be concerned. That's covered inside our ongoing business. Second, to add a little texture on this question about 389 as an example: Tim responded by noting that flash points can arise at times, but they aren't ongoing. What you really need to understand is that occasionally a given retailer — say, it might be e-commerce — is looking to push a big program. Maybe around Singles Day, and they want more of a certain SKU than what's been allocated to them, whether by us or by anyone else selling to them. And sometimes, to make their site more attractive, they'll go try to mop up inventory from others, consolidate it, and then run a price blaster for a specific event in China.
Michael Clarke
executiveIncidentally, this also occurs in other markets globally. You'll witness it with other big retailers in Australia, where you reside; you'll witness it with U.K. retailers; you'll witness it with retailers in the States. This is something retailers do constantly. Thus it isn't solely a phenomenon of China—it occurs in other markets globally. But when it occurs in China, folks often zero in on that and fixate on it rather than fixating on it in, say, the U.K. What we've done with those partners is to sit down together and plan more effectively going forward, since this serves as a lesson for our organization, and believe me, this market is expanding rapidly and every partner working alongside us operates dynamically—they aren't sluggish. So the conversation with our partner is more along the lines of telling us what you're aiming to achieve, and we can examine how to assist you. Discounting isn't necessary because everyone gains value if the price is right. And afterward we also hold a discussion with those parties who sold it to that retailer.
Michael Clarke
executiveSo the question is this: obviously, you didn't have to sell that on your own in your area. You made the choice to sell it, turn into a distributor for us, and move it to that specific retailer — and in that case, your allocation drops in the following financial period. You've got to keep at this, and not only in China; you also do it in Australia, you do it in America, and you do it in the U.K. Just to add a bit of extra build.
Operator
operatorPhil Kimber of Evans & Partners has the next question.
Phil Kimber
analystMy question relates to what you said about Asia, where I believe you mentioned volume declined 10%, though it would have risen 14% absent that single customer problem. Running the figures, that comes out to roughly 500,000 cases — is that about right? It strikes me as a very large amount to flow through one customer and mostly a single brand for such an effect. So any extra detail you could offer on that would be helpful.
Michael Clarke
executiveI think the extra detail we can provide is that, as we said, it was an exclusive arrangement with that single customer, and that arrangement is exclusive no longer. That customer was distributing across a wide range of territories in China. We now sell directly to other Tier 1 wholesalers that we partner with. So we bypass that partner. And there's a clear reason we only referenced the restatement of volume in the NSR. We weren't going to — we saw no need to state what the adjusted profit figure would be.
Operator
operatorBelinda Moore of Morgans has the next question.
Belinda Moore
analystSure, I get that we're still in the early stages here and it's hard to put a number on this, but since it's such a current topic after the tragic bushfires, could you walk us through the process you're using to test for smoke taint? When might we get an update from you? And how should we be thinking about the impact on earnings in future years if it does occur, and perhaps what you've assumed in guidance?
Tim Ford
executiveBelinda, yes, absolutely. Fortunately for us — and I believe we've mentioned this before, though I'll expand on it a bit — our asset base came through the widespread bushfires across the country completely unharmed. From that standpoint, we were extremely fortunate. A number of our growers in the Adelaide Hills region, which represents a very small percentage of our intake, unfortunately did not fare so well. So when it comes to the intake plan, the bushfires themselves had essentially a 0 impact, apart from those growers. And I don't mean to minimize what those growers are going through with that comment. As for smoke taint and other considerations — when you think about how we operate across our various sourcing regions, we believe smoke taint will have no major impact whatsoever on our intake or on the quality of that intake. We are conducting testing for it. What we're testing represents a very small component of what our intake would look like, given the regions and the multiple different regions we source from, whether that's the Southeast, McLaren Vale, Barossa Valley, et cetera.
Tim Ford
executiveThe bulk of any smoke taint effects should stem from the areas around Adelaide Hills, and again, that's quite small. Having a footprint sourced from multiple regions is a real plus in situations like this, though we're also lucky that in the places where the bushfires occurred, the smoke taint effect—we believe, and testing is still underway, so I'm not saying this categorically—but we do believe it will be extremely minimal, if present at all, across our intake.
Michael Clarke
executiveAnd, Tim, adding on to what you just mentioned, the remark I made regarding cost for this vintage applies mainly to Commercial Australian juice in this particular vintage. With the heat spikes we've seen and with what we anticipate market volumes will be for the commercial vintage, there's a chance that Commercial wine out of Australia will keep carrying elevated COGS. And obviously, we're taking that into account as we consider how we'll operate the Commercial wine business in a different way.
Tim Ford
executiveYes. Two dynamics underpin what we're saying on that. And it's important to grasp that when we discuss COGS, that's the cost of the upcoming vintage, and we definitely have belief and confidence in the Luxury intake that we're receiving. Our Commercial wine intake for this vintage will carry a higher price, since market rates for Commercial wine sit above where they stood in Vintage '19. Yes, that's widely known among the grape growers, et cetera. So that will have an impact. And second, given the heat spikes we've observed, the use of water and water right now, per gigaliter, is priced at the highest level it's been in a very long time, and that will create a cost impact on the vintage. So that's simply what we're flagging beneath that, not to suggest that we believe the Luxury intake, et cetera, will be significantly impacted over the coming 3 or 4 months as we finalize vintage.
Operator
operatorJason Palmer of Taylor Collison has the next question.
Jason Palmer
analystMy question is about the U.S. What makes you confident that brands such as Matua, and 19 Crimes in particular — which for the past 2 to 3 years have been propping up that business's results — will hold up through this potential recovery you mentioned as supply normalizes in that market?
Tim Ford
executiveYes. I think those 2 brands deserve specific attention since they illustrate the point well. The work — and we've discussed this before regarding 19 Crimes — the market activation and brand planning efforts we're now placing behind a brand such as 19 Crimes moving forward genuinely give us a great deal more confidence. The second piece is that, once you dig into the specifics of 19 Crimes, you find a brand that continues to grow. You've seen that in the data over the last couple of months especially, since we've run stronger marketing programs than what we had during the early portion of the first half and also in the back half of last year. So our programming, our emphasis on execution, and our brand-building activity — yes, we're extremely pleased with how that looks, both at present and going forward as well. The second aspect of 19 Crimes concerns distribution — and I keep returning to distribution since that is the crucial element. As a brand, 19 Crimes has heavy distribution across U.S. distribution points. With the 19 Crimes portfolio and the count of SKUs beneath that brand, the opportunity remains substantial from a distribution standpoint as we sell our portfolio and return that brand to the growth we believe it can attain.
Tim Ford
executiveIt definitely expanded over the half, a bit during the last 3 months, and from a depletion standpoint it posted considerably larger numbers, and it remains a profitable brand for us, despite the COGS effects we've discussed. Matua differs somewhat, I think, in that its depletions are rising by more than 30%. And that shows up in any of the IRI data, and it has done so consistently. The category surrounding Sauvignon Blanc isn't really about New Zealand Sauvignon Blanc — it's about refreshment. That's a consumer need that will keep expanding in the U.S. market just as it is globally. So as we shape that brand and the activation of brand activity, and also the in-store execution around Matua, which we're going to do a far better job on, we hold a significant belief in that growth because of the consumer need, not merely because we like the brand or believe it's about New Zealand Sauvignon Blanc. Beyond that, when you look at some competitor activity and what might be arriving within the U.S. businesses, brands changing hands, and so on, there's a huge opportunity for us with particular brands — and I'll cite Matua as one — to capture share from people who hold that share today with their brands, and from our competitors.
Tim Ford
executiveThere are several elements at play here, but we believe that putting substantially more resources behind a brand such as Matua, with an approach driven by consumers that addresses that need, represents upside for us. The other piece, I think, concerns the U.S. brands — we discussed the Masstige brands, and both of them are imported brands. Yet if you look through some of the data and consider certain U.S.-produced brands focused on Masstige, such as St Huberts The Stag and Beringer Brothers as well, their bases are smaller, but their growth is significant. And once again, it comes down to distribution and execution of programming, which we believe we are far better positioned to carry out. We lost some momentum amid the management changes in half 1, but we now sit in a much stronger position than previously.
Operator
operatorThe last question this afternoon is from Peter Marks, who is on the line with Morgan Stanley.
Peter Marks
analystOne more question about China. I ran the same calculation Phil ran regarding the 500,000 cases of Rawson's Retreat. So I'm curious whether your partner over there still has inventory left to move. And if so, is the working relationship with them still solid? Second, you've described the impact as temporary — do you feel confident you can still move the same number of cases of Rawson's Retreat down the road? And then — so should we expect some volume recovery in Asia during the second half? Also, I'm wondering, did you sell any Rawson's Retreat at all in the first half, since that looks like a pretty large volume decline?
Tim Ford
executiveThe two terms I'll be using as we discuss this are depletions and shipments. And of course — I think it's key to recognize that we've collaborated with the partner — our main partner in China, regarding a transition as they restructure their business, we — and alongside them, so we keep working with them and collaborating, and we will keep working with them moving forward. So that's a crucial point to make, in my view, since they matter a lot to us as a partner. Second, the inventory levels you mentioned form a significant piece of the transition plan that, once again, we've worked on jointly with that partner and with our new route to market partners, which are our existing wholesalers. So the inventory transition inside the market has been carefully planned, well executed, it has affected shipments during the first half, yet our depletions keep moving back on track, especially across the period before Chinese New Year. So our confidence and our forecast for the brand remain very strong heading into the second half. But as you correctly note, there is a shipment decline, and it's temporary, in the first half that we expect will be fixed as we move forward in China.
Michael Clarke
executiveThe shift from a single partner to several partners was handled with a great deal of collaboration among everyone involved. That brings us to the end of the call, and I'd like to express my appreciation to all of you for joining us this morning on such short notice. Many thanks.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Treasury Wine Estates Limited transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Treasury Wine Estates Limited earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Treasury Wine Estates Limited or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.