Treasury Wine Estates Limited (TWE) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

August 13, 2020

Australian Securities Exchange AU Consumer Staples Beverages earnings 95 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

Good day, everyone, and welcome to the Treasury Wine Estates FY 2020 annual results briefing. Thank you for joining us. Right now, everyone is in listen-only mode. After the presentation, we'll hold a question-and-answer session today. If you'd like to ask something, simply press star one on your telephone keypad. Please note that this conference is being recorded today. I'll now pass the conference to your first speaker today, Mr. Tim Ford. Thank you, and please go ahead.

Tim Ford

executive
#2

Morning, everyone, and thanks for being here for the Treasury Wine Estates full-year results briefing. It's a particular pleasure for me today that some members of the TWE leadership team are on the call with me: Matt Young, our CFO; Tom King, joining from Shanghai, our Managing Director of Asia; Ben Dollard, out of California, our President of the Americas business; Peter Nilsson, our Managing Director of Australia and New Zealand; and from London, where it's late at night, Michelle Brampton, our Managing Director for Europe, Middle East, and Africa. On the 9th of July, we gave the market a business update covering our preliminary F20 performance outcomes, as well as a progress update on a number of the key strategic initiatives. In today's briefing, we'll go into further detail on both of those, but importantly, I also want to use this opportunity to spend some time detailing the strategy of Treasury Wine Estates, along with the strengths and the opportunities of the business, setting out the roadmap that I'm extremely excited to lead. We're a premium brand-focused global leader in wine, with strong positions in our priority markets, backed by a global footprint and business model that no other player in our industry can match.

Tim Ford

executive
#3

Having a range of businesses is one of our hallmarks and sits right at the core of how we operate. Our spread covers sourcing and selling across multiple regions, a lineup of famous and prize-winning brands, the various price tiers we compete in, and the wide variety of experiences our labels deliver to consumers every single day. Our push toward premium offerings keeps building steam in F20, and premium wine now accounts for more than 70% of worldwide revenue, compared with roughly 50% just four years back. Our skilled and committed team around the world numbers more than 3,000, and these past few years they have put in tremendous effort to reshape this company into what it is now. We take pride in the progress made to date, yet plenty of work remains ahead to strengthen an already solid business, to set Treasury Wine Estates up for the coming stage of expansion, and to reach our goal of becoming the premium wine company most admired anywhere in the world. Underpinning that goal is our case for long-term investment, built around five central pillars. First comes the wine category, in which worldwide consumption has risen over recent years, above all in the markets we prioritize.

Tim Ford

executive
#4

Those growth rates stem from consumption occasions leaning more toward socializing, celebrating, and sharing—occasions and trends that the wine category serves well. In wine, consumers have been trading up, and throughout our regions, premium price points keep standing out, driving volume and value growth ahead of the commercial end of the market, where overall consumption has been declining. E-commerce growth and consumers buying through multiple different channels have definitely accelerated during this pandemic period, and that offers a significant future opportunity for the wine category. Our global portfolio of well-known and trusted premium wine brands is capitalizing on these attractive category trends, led by our focused brand portfolios, which will keep driving our momentum and growth in every region. Through differentiated varieties, taste profiles, consumption occasions, and price points, these brands serve a wide variety of consumers, and we will prioritize further strengthening this brand portfolio by taking an increasingly consumer-led approach to innovation and brand building, ensuring we have the right brands and propositions in place to capitalize on the key drivers of category growth. Our competitively advantaged and differentiated route-to-market models give us a global distribution platform unrivaled in the wine industry, with our overarching goal being to stay as close as possible to our customers and consumers across each key market.

Tim Ford

executive
#5

One of the model's main strengths is efficiency, and that creates value for TWE, for its customers, and in the end for the consumer—something that has underpinned how our portfolios have grown over recent years. The clearest example is a key growth region such as Asia, where we have steadily expanded distribution and availability, and also lifted depletion rates for our brands across several years, by continuing and broadening investment until we became the leading imported wine company there in both value and volume. A key foundation of the business is our global asset base, with world-class vineyard and production assets located in internationally acclaimed winemaking regions including the Barossa Valley in Australia, Napa Valley in California, the Marlborough region of New Zealand, and the Bordeaux region in France—a genuinely global, multi-regional model without equal in the wine industry. That asset base underpins our focus as a growing premium wine company and reflects a multi-regional sourcing approach that lets us offset difficult vintage conditions in any single region sooner than our competitors can. Alongside this asset base sit our winemakers and viticulturalists, whose wine is consistently of exceptional quality, and as a result a number of our brands have earned significant industry recognition and accolades.

Tim Ford

executive
#6

Wine as a sector has always demanded a lot of capital, and over the last few years we've put growing emphasis on getting the mix right between owning assets and leaning more on outside supply arrangements—things like partnerships with growers and bulk wine suppliers. That strategy has helped lift the financial returns we're seeing right across the company, and it also gives us the flexibility and agility to respond as consumer demand shifts. On top of that, our capital structure—strong, flexible, and efficient—puts us in a very good position, both to steer through the challenges the market is facing right now and to keep putting money into growing the business going forward and sustaining the returns we deliver to shareholders. We see this as a genuine competitive edge for Treasury Wine Estates right through the cycle. All of these pieces underpin our ambition for long-term growth across every one of our regions, and hitting a group EBITS margin of 25% and above stays our headline financial metric target. When it comes to Asia, we'll be concentrating on widening our market leadership by pushing distribution depth, breadth, and availability across our premium multi-country of origin portfolio, while holding margins firmly in the high 30% range. In the Americas—and the U.S. in particular—our priority is building a future-state premium wine business in what is the biggest wine market worldwide and one where premiumization trends look especially appealing.

Tim Ford

executive
#7

Our focused brand portfolio is performing strongly right now, and it represents what lies ahead for our business in this region and market—and it's what will drive us toward our ambition of a 25% margin for the region. In ANZ, our priority is going to be harnessing our category leadership so we can innovate boldly and elevate the category, while also driving a shift in channel mix to build our market value share ambitions. And at EMEA, we'll focus on two things: premiumisation in this region, with continued improvement in our portfolio mix that key sales opportunity, along with increased investment in sourcing luxury wine from the region, particularly in France, where we completed our first investments in vineyard and production assets in fiscal 2020. Later in the briefing, I'll share more details about our TWE 2025 strategic framework, our Game Plan, and within that, our key priorities for fiscal 2021. Like many other industries and businesses, the COVID-19 pandemic has significantly affected Treasury Wine Estates in the recent months. During this period, in-home consumption of wine has risen significantly across many markets, driving high levels of activity through the bricks-and-mortar retail channels and, as I mentioned earlier, accelerating activity through e-commerce sales channels.

Tim Ford

executive
#8

Buyers have been putting a premium on how quickly and easily they can make purchases, and brands that are familiar and trusted are doing especially well, and as a result our main focus brands keep delivering solid results through those channels. Beyond retail and e-commerce, though, the major sales routes for our higher-margin luxury wine — covering on-premise, our cellar doors, and our global travel retail operation — were either shut down or heavily affected over the period. All through the second half of fiscal 2020, that took a serious toll on the sales volume mix and EBITS of our overall portfolio, most notably in Australia and the U.S. Fewer gatherings, social occasions, and events have likewise hit consumption in key markets such as Asia. Over recent months, though, we've observed steady gains in performance in a number of our key markets, as several of the hardest-hit channels reopen and consumers adjust to the new normal. Even so, we stay cautious about the near-term outlook, since a great deal of uncertainty persists regarding when and how fast recovery will come, including the ongoing closure of certain channels in the markets. On other important fronts of our business, I'm delighted to report that we came through the effects of COVID-19 with only minimal disruptions.

Tim Ford

executive
#9

Our worldwide supply operations have experienced no significant disruption, and we finished the 2020 Australian vintage successfully, with essential health and safety restrictions and protocols in place. At this point, we don't anticipate any interruption to our upcoming California vintage. In addition, our capital structure, liquidity, and very strong operating cash flow and cash conversion stay key strengths that will let us navigate the pandemic while continuing to invest in our brands and the asset base as appropriate to support our future growth ambitions. Lastly, our global workforce has moved smoothly to flexible and remote working arrangements, and we have made it a priority to redeploy our resources and team members from the affected parts of our business to support other markets and channels where activity has risen. Our resilience during this period highlights the fundamental strength of our diversified global business, our brand portfolios, and our organizational capability, which gives us optimism about our future return to growth in both margin and profit. That said, a number of recent trends from the pandemic are ones we also believe will become permanent shifts in behavior and absolutely represent opportunities for us to harness in both the short and the long term.

Tim Ford

executive
#10

With our COVID-19 Plan Ahead agenda, the goal is making sure Treasury Wine Estates comes out of this pandemic as a fitter and stronger global business. People trends are our first area of focus — shifts in work and lifestyle arrangements mean we'll need to think innovatively about returning to work and about workplace models, and making remote working more efficient is a near-term priority that we're already doing a lot of work on. Supporting our global workforce during this period has also been of critical importance to our leadership team, and we will keep prioritizing the rollout of employee support programs, which focus on both physical and mental health and well-being. Tied to this, personal health has also become an increasing imperative for many of our consumers, and we will accelerate our programs to enhance our portfolio presence around the "Better for You" category trend. Among the broader consumption trends we are seeing at home is food-led wine consumption growing, and as I mentioned earlier, demand for well-known and trusted brands has stood out during this period. In response, we will increase our investment in our focused brand portfolio, and we will take a consumer and experience-led approach to brand building to implement interactive models that enhance engagement with the consumer whilst at home using technology more so than traditional formats.

Tim Ford

executive
#11

We're taking a fresh look at how we connect with buyers of our luxury wines, and we've launched a major, in-depth worldwide research effort that will inform how we sharpen our route-to-market portfolio and innovation strategies across our luxury brands. We also anticipate that hygiene and sustainability will stay top of mind for consumers. So innovating the formats of our packaging is likewise going to be a central focus for us. Buying patterns have shifted considerably over recent months as well, and in lots of ways they pack years of evolution into a very brief window. Our view is that these shifting patterns will leave a lasting mark on our channel mix over the long term, and they hand us a distinctive and thrilling opening. Chief among the initiatives we'll take forward: making greater use of customer data and insights to fuel engagement and transactions, and we'll put more investment behind existing as well as new e-commerce platforms, which are nicely placed to serve the growing consumer appetite for buying convenience down the road. We'll also work alongside our customers in this area to help move that opportunity forward on their own current platforms. There'll be more from us on how our Plan Ahead agenda is progressing and evolving in the months ahead.

Tim Ford

executive
#12

Now moving to how we performed financially in fiscal 2020, and I think this shows resilience amid really tough trading conditions. Net sales revenue fell 6% for fiscal 2020, as a strong first half was offset during the second half, when the mix of our portfolio took a significant hit from the COVID-19 effects I mentioned earlier. In the US, difficult market conditions meant revenue also dropped over the course of the year. EBITS came in 22% lower at AUD 533.5 million. Our EBITS margin fell 4 percentage points to 20.1%, while earnings per share dropped 26% to AUD 0.439 per share, reflecting both the weaker top line and the effect of elevated cost of goods sold per case throughout fiscal 2020, especially in our Australian-sourced commercial and masstige portfolios, and also driven by lower volume. On a positive note, cash flow was strong, delivering a 95% cash conversion result, up 16 percentage points versus the prior year, which helped us maintain a strong balance sheet. Consequently, we have declared a final dividend of AUD 0.08 per share, amounting to a AUD 0.28 per share payment for the full year and a payout ratio of 64%, consistent with our long-term dividend policy.

Tim Ford

executive
#13

With that as background, I'll pass things over to Matt now, and he'll walk you through the financial results in greater depth.

Matt Young

executive
#14

Thanks, Tim, and good morning, everyone. For many years at TWE, having a business that spans global markets, channels, sourcing regions, brands, and price points has been an intentional strategy and something we take pride in, yet the current environment has only made clearer how crucial it is to keeping our business strong going forward. Thanks to our global model, we have stayed profitable despite the challenges, taken advantage of areas of opportunity, generated strong cash flow, and kept our balance sheet healthy. We take particular pride in our strong financial position, which has enabled us to keep investing behind brands and behind our premiumization strategy while still delivering returns to shareholders, and we are confident that as trading conditions improve in our key markets and as we put in place the key elements of our strategic agenda, we will be well placed to become an even stronger business in the future. Turning to our key measures of performance in F20, group net sales revenue fell 6% on a reported currency basis, or 9% at constant currency, driven by a 9% decline in volume. NSR per case rose, driven by continued portfolio premiumization, particularly in the first half, but offset by disruptions to key channels for higher-margin luxury wine through the second half.

Matt Young

executive
#15

Even so, luxury and masstige brands account for 71% of worldwide NSR in F20, versus 69% a year earlier. COGS per case rose 6%, or 3% in constant currency terms, reflecting higher COGS on commercial and masstige wine sourced from Australia and luxury wine sourced from the US. The cost of doing business margin edged up to 21%, mainly because of the drop in net sales revenue. Total cost of doing business was better in F20, chiefly owing to key organizational changes made in F19 and hands-on management of discretionary spending during the second half, which included paying none of the discretionary incentives tied to F20 performance. EBITS fell 22% to AUD 533.5 million, and the EBITS margin dropped to 20.1%. Lastly, ROCE was down 3.3 percentage points at 10.6%, mirroring the EBITS decline alongside a fairly steady capital base. Before I turn to the balance sheet, I'd like to point out a few important things to help everyone navigate our F20 results, given that this is plainly an unusual year. First, as is true for many companies, understanding how we performed in F20 requires thinking about the business in two halves. You'll hear the team refer to this somewhat today as they discuss their regions.

Matt Young

executive
#16

For greater clarity, we've split our first-half and second-half results into the appendices of our profit report. Tim has already provided a solid picture of how COVID-19 affected us during the second half. Next, on this slide, regarding material items tied to long-term structural shifts—and in other years, significant acquisitions, divestments, and impairments—which sit outside EBITS, we recorded costs of AUD 37 million, or AUD 26 million after tax, in F20. The first of these concerned our investment in premium winemaking capacity in South Australia, which is set to deliver a one-third increase in luxury winemaking capacity. Beyond that, we incurred roughly AUD 11 million in restructuring costs across the US linked to our strategic agenda program. In each instance, we anticipate additional costs arising as both projects proceed, which we've flagged on the slide, while also delivering long-term benefits that we've likewise flagged, and Tim will go into these shortly. The last point covers several items recognized within EBITS in F20, as is normally the case. These involve asset sales, impairments, and incremental provisions. They stem mainly from our Americas region, reflecting multi-year work programs underway there and the F20 market conditions we've described before.

Matt Young

executive
#17

More specifics appear on this slide. Regarding the additional provisions for inventory and trade receivables, they stem from heightened uncertainty in today’s environment, stemming from both COVID-19 trading conditions and the continuing U.S. bulk wine market. We have adopted a prudent stance so as to keep provisioning at a high level in F20. Putting these on one page was intended to give investors insight into the trade impacts underneath. Beyond offering that transparency, my hope is this slide demonstrates clearly the quality of earnings at both group and regional levels. Turning to the balance sheet, it remains strong, flexible, and efficient. Net assets came in broadly in line with the prior year, driven by higher net debt and lower working capital and tax balances. Inventory, CapEx, and debt elements will be covered on the slides that follow, but let me briefly address receivables. Trade receivables are down because of lower second half sales, as outlined earlier. In our financial statements, investors will notice a modest rise in receivables aging in F20, yet I want to reassure investors that this gives us no cause for concern.

Matt Young

executive
#18

We've kept backing our customers, and they've backed us in return, as we navigate this shaky trading climate. In a handful of situations where patience and extra support were required, we provided exactly that. These commercial ties, I'm confident, are solid and will stay solid through F21. I don't wish to overstress the matter, but none of our customers are in financial trouble, and across our key markets no bad debts were written off during F20. Now, looking more closely at inventory, it rose by AUD 29 million to AUD 2.1 billion, carried at cost as of the end of June 2020. Total inventory volumes fell 9% versus the equivalent prior period, offset by a richer mix within the stock held and by elevated vintage costs on inventory in hand. Driving those volume movements were mainly the effect of the 2020 Australian vintage — lower yielding and costlier — together with luxury stock carried over from the back half of fiscal 2020. Luxury inventory as a whole climbed 8%, largely because of the pricier recent Australian and Californian vintages. Measured by volume, luxury inventories overall dropped 5%, a reflection of the smaller 2020 Australian vintage — down 45% at the luxury level — partly offset by unsold wine carried over that had earlier been earmarked for the second half of fiscal 2020.

Matt Young

executive
#19

As we've said before, the way we allocate our luxury product is a major advantage for the company, giving us room to maneuver through shifts in near-term demand or variation in a single vintage — as happened in fiscal 2020 — while still achieving growth over the long term. It's also worth noting that we feel very good about where our luxury and masstige inventory stands as a driver of future earnings growth. Although near-term consumption has taken a hit from disruption in certain of our major channels for luxury wine, demand from consumers for luxury wine across every one of our key markets continues to be a long-term dynamic, and we have confidence in it, and it has demonstrated resilience through earlier long-term economic cycles. Moving on to cash flow and net debt. As you'd expect, we've placed a great deal of focus on managing cash flow during this period, and our balance sheet and solid liquidity position are a reflection of that. Operating cash flow before interest, tax, and material items came in at AUD 661 million, consistent with the prior year. Although we've taken a prudent approach to managing our cash flow expenditure, we've kept investing in the business and behind our brands where doing so makes sense. In certain instances, brand investment was redirected to support sales channels that are growing, like e-commerce.

Matt Young

executive
#20

On a reported basis, cash conversion came in at 94.7%, which is 16.3 percentage points better than the previous year. The drivers were lower Q4 sales and the smaller Australian vintage, partly offset by greater amounts of luxury wine inventory carried over from the second half of fiscal 2020. We've decided to revise how we set our long-term target guidance on cash conversion. Instead of targeting an overall reported figure of 80%, we'll aim more directly at cash conversion of 90% or above, excluding the yearly movement in luxury, masstige, non-current inventory. You've heard me discuss this metric many times before, and investor feedback indicates this is a better formal target, and we hope it brings greater clarity on our cash flow, especially since we remain focused on continuing to invest in luxury inventory to support future growth ambitions. And as the page shows, we have consistently achieved 90% cash conversion, excluding that investment in non-current inventory. Turning to CapEx, we likewise took a prudent approach in the second half, prioritizing liquidity management while continuing to invest for future growth. CapEx totaled AUD 189 million for the year, with growth CapEx of AUD 106 million, including investment in luxury wine-making infrastructure in South Australia and the acquisition of vineyard and production assets in Bordeaux.

Matt Young

executive
#21

Our South Australia luxury wine-making infrastructure investment is moving along nicely, and we sped up certain parts of that project over the course of the year. That said, we've run into hold-ups getting some equipment from abroad because of COVID-19 supply chain effects, so the new infrastructure should now be up and running in time for the 2022 vintage — a year behind the original schedule — though please keep in mind that this postponement won't affect our production capacity for the 2021 vintage at all. We're expecting fiscal 2021 CapEx of as much as AUD 200 million, covering maintenance and replacement spending consistent with prior year guidance plus ongoing investment to underpin future growth. Last, on capital management, our capital structure still mirrors an investment-grade credit profile. Leverage rose to 2.2 times during the year, mirroring the earnings decline. Even so, we're confident we can hold to our target of below two times through the cycle. Our liquidity remains solid, with cash of AUD 449 million and undrawn committed debt facilities of AUD 920 million spread across a well-diversified maturity profile as of the end of June, giving total liquidity of slightly under AUD 1.4 billion. That robust liquidity underpins the continuation of our long-term dividend policy and is echoed in the firm, assured yet prudent choice to declare today a final dividend of AUD 0.08 per share, fully franked, for a full-year payout of AUD 0.28, or 64%.

Matt Young

executive
#22

Thank you. It's a real pleasure for me now to pass things over to Tom King in Shanghai, who will speak with you regarding the Asia region.

Tom King

executive
#23

Thanks, Matt, and good morning, everyone. Even with the difficulties we faced during the second half of F20, support for our brand portfolio has kept strengthening across Asia, and the advantages of our business model are showing up more clearly than ever. Within the Asia region, net sales revenue fell 14.7%, a drop driven by volume declines in the second half across every key region, while most sales channels were closed during February and March. NSR per case rose 12% versus the prior year, reflecting continued growth in our luxury and masstige portfolios. EBITS came in 14% lower at AUD 244 million, which works out to an EBITS margin of 39.5%. In China, the market is displaying signs of recovery now that consumption occasions are returning, with weekly trends improving across all channels starting in April and channel operations now mostly back to normal. Consumption patterns are bouncing back quickly as additional on-premise outlets reopen and foot traffic rises. Our depletions for the second half tracked broader market trends, falling sharply in Q3 and then growing in Q4, helped by the removal of government restrictions and by sustained investment behind our brands. June depletions rose roughly 40% compared with the prior year. E-commerce sales, which were already growing strongly before COVID, sped up even more, and TWE stood out as the market leader across total wine, delivering 84% value growth in F20 against 28% for the total category.

Tom King

executive
#24

When it comes to TWE, sales in that channel likewise showed ongoing premiumization, even as the wider market moved online toward wines of lower value. We keep collaborating closely with our partners so that shipments and depletion rates stay aligned, and we feel good about where our inventory levels sit in the market right now. During the first half, we highlighted an inventory reset involving competitive brands by distributors and wholesalers. Downward trends in import data across every country of origin indicate that this reset is still underway and has, as a matter of fact, sped up because of COVID-19 and the effect it has had on working capital. Although we watch the geopolitical environment carefully, our attention will stay on building brands, investing in the market, engaging with our partners, and making sure we meet our own compliance obligations. Up to this point, we have not seen any evidence of problems that have affected our business or our customers' businesses. Moving to performance in other Asian markets, where, much as in China, following strong momentum in the first half, we experienced volume declines across key markets in Q3 before signs of recovery appeared in Q4. Markets and channels that depend on tourism, however, remain subdued. For the full year, Southeast Asia EBITS rose 8%, powered by a very strong first half, and we stay optimistic regarding the opportunities for long-term growth in those markets.

Tom King

executive
#25

When it comes to F20 highlights, our strategic emphasis on expanding distribution and availability keeps producing meaningful gains for the portfolio, and our depletions demonstrate that. Priority brands such as Penfolds, Wolf Blass, Maison de Grand Esprit, and Rawson's Retreat posted full-year depletion growth along with considerable market share gains. A business model built around self-distribution, together with our spending on marketing and pull-through programs, continues to fuel growth in this market. You'll also see that we've raised our EBITS margin guidance for the Asia region from the previous 35% plus to now sit in the high 30% range, consistent with what we've delivered over recent years, and we expect to sustain that going forward. On brand highlights, the Rawson's Retreat Your Ideal Wine Moment was a successful digital campaign designed to broaden our consumer base. That campaign drove higher brand awareness with 190 million online impressions, 5% depletion growth, and took the lead in e-commerce within the commercial wine segment. For Penfolds, we introduced the 60th anniversary year of the Grange Vintage Red Wine Magnum, backed by strong in-store activations that featured distinctive number animations. And over in Southeast Asia, Wolf Blass teamed up with the Michelin Guide to highlight wine pairing with Southeast Asian flavors via iconic recipes developed by Michelin-starred chefs.

Tom King

executive
#26

More than 20 million consumers were reached by the campaign, which sustained its momentum even with government restrictions in place. The program grew to offer virtual and home dining experiences for consumers, with a focus on wine pairings alongside elevated local dishes. It is clear that our brand investment stayed strong and focused in F20, delivering considerable positive momentum, and we look forward to building on that in F21. At this point I'll turn things over to Ben Dollard to cover performance in the Americas region.

Ben Dollard

executive
#27

Thanks, Tom, and good afternoon to all of you joining from Napa Valley, California. Being an Australian—born and raised in Adelaide, right near Penfolds Magill Estate Winery—it's a pleasure to address you today in my role on the Treasury Wine Estates Leadership Team and as President of our Americas region. For the past 25 years I've worked in the US market within the alcohol beverage industry, and most of that time has been spent in wine. I'm eager to take Treasury Wine Estates forward through what promises to be an exciting stretch ahead for us here in this region. During F20, net sales revenue fell 12% while EBITS dropped 44%, and our results mirrored how tough US wine market conditions persisted across the second half, among them the impact of COVID-19 and private label's ongoing acceleration, which affected us in two direct ways. To begin with, on-premise and cellar door traffic saw major disruption. Those other key channels beyond retail and e-commerce carry a heavier weighting toward higher margin luxury wine, so the mix of our portfolio overall took an adverse hit. Secondly, those disruptions prompted destocking across the industry as distributors trimmed inventory holdings, and that in turn pushed our shipments 7% below depletions in F20.

Ben Dollard

executive
#28

Retail channels keep delivering strong results, and we've observed encouraging momentum across our direct-to-consumer and e-commerce platforms. That said, stabilization elsewhere has come slowly, so on the near-term outlook we stay hopeful while exercising caution. Over recent months, we've taken a hard look at where our business is headed strategically and reimagined it, aiming to gauge how we can best capture our long-term opportunity in the US market. Tim will provide an update later in this briefing on the major structural changes now under way. Before that, though, I'd like to highlight several key elements that I strongly believe leave Treasury Wine Estates well placed to succeed going forward. America represents the globe's biggest premium wine market, and it carries on a multi-year premiumization trend, powered by robust growth at premium price points. Neither COVID-19 nor the recent market oversupply dynamic has affected this trend. During the 12 months to June 2020, the $8 price point and the $20 and above $20 price points each grew in U.S. retail, by 10% and 19% respectively. Fueling that growth is the evolution of the American wine consumer, including the next generation of wine drinkers now entering the category, who have been trading up to higher price points.

Ben Dollard

executive
#29

Those helpful premiumization trends create a really strong setup for the concentrated brand lineup we're focused on — a varied set of luxury and premium products that match where shoppers are headed, and that includes names such as Beringer, BV, Stags' Leap, Penfolds, 19 Crimes, Beringer Brothers, Matua, and St. Huberts The Stag. That lineup stands squarely for what our company will be going forward, and it delivered robust expansion all through F20, with the pace having picked up over the last six months to reach a retail gain above 27% against the year before. Nielsen and IRI retail channels, though big and essential to the wine segment, only capture part of the market. We anticipate that additional important channels — independent on-premise and off-premise, direct-to-consumer, and e-commerce — will likewise grow quickly in the Americas for our focused brands as we move ahead. We're putting investment behind those channels right now and connecting with our shoppers and retail partners there. Backing execution across our established core channels and our growth channels will be the revamped sales and operating models we've put in place lately. Those models will concentrate on several key areas, among them a devoted luxury sales team that will make our brands vivid across on-premise, independent, and retail chain accounts.

Ben Dollard

executive
#30

Beyond that, we’re refining how we operate and applying the skills we have in building brands, while collaborating more closely with our distributors so that we jointly steer the business’s strategic course. Standouts within our tightly focused brand lineup include the recent successful debut of 19 Crimes Cali Red — a multi-year partnership with entertainment icon Snoop Dogg — which brings our first California wines from the 19 Crimes label. The #StayHomeWithStagsLeap promotion delivered tremendous success during the recent lockdown period, supported by targeted digital advertising, and drove e-commerce growth for the brand of over 500%. Finally, our Matua brand keeps going from strength to strength, generating meaningful distribution gains in cold box throughout the market. Thank you. I’ll now pass things to Peter Nilsson in Melbourne.

Peter Neilson

executive
#31

Thank you, Ben, and good morning. During a challenging second half, the ANZ business came through reasonably well — solid results in the retail channel helped offset some of the hit from shutting down other important sales channels. As we've noted before, though, retail performance leaned toward the masstige portfolio, and weaker sales of high-margin luxury wines weighed on financial results. In the ANZ region, NSR fell 1.7%, while NSR per case was roughly flat versus the prior year, even though it dropped in the second half because of a mixed shift away from TWE's upper-end luxury portfolio. COGS per case rose 4.3%, reflecting higher cost of goods on Australian-sourced commercial and masstige wine from the 2019 vintage. That produced regional EBITS of AUD 133 million and a margin of 22.5%. Sales volumes in the current retail market remain elevated, with growth coming from price points above $10. TWE is outpacing the market in the $10-$20 price segment, led by focused brands such as Squealing Pig, 19 Crimes, and The Stag. We've also seen strong depletions for Wolf Blass, Lindeman's, and Pepperjack as consumers increasingly look for well-known and trusted brands in the current environment. Happily, in F20 we've kept premiumizing our portfolio and delivered a mixed shift toward premium volumes as we pursue specific growth opportunities across different price points, varietals, and occasions.

Peter Neilson

executive
#32

The way consumers behave has shifted at an even faster pace amid COVID, and we'll keep reviewing our business models and offerings so we can reach consumers in ways that are more convenient and have greater impact. Last, I want to call out how our viticulture, winemaking, and production teams performed — they did a remarkable job through obviously difficult conditions, not only holding production levels but also successfully delivering the 2020 Australian vintage in spite of the logistical hurdles involved. On brand highlights for F20, 19 Crimes keeps gaining momentum and ranked as the top brand in the wine category for value growth in F20. In March, we ran the brand's most successful through-the-line campaign to date, featuring 630 disruptive prison ship displays as part of the Find the 19th Cork promotion. 19 Crimes also came in at number four among the world's most admired wine brands according to Drinks International — an incredible result, especially given it had not ranked in 2019. Another highlight was the celebrations marking Penfolds' 175th anniversary. A gala event took place at Penfolds Magill Estate, with more than 100 guests from around the globe dining in the transformed Drives. As part of the festivities, Penfolds revealed a new rare wine, Special Bin 111A, a Clare Valley Barossa Valley Shiraz from the 2016 vintage.

Peter Neilson

executive
#33

Nearly 10 years have passed since Penfolds put out a special bin wine — clear evidence of the quality, criteria, and craftsmanship needed for a wine of that standing. We kept putting money into strategic partnerships that help our core brands grow. Seppelt teamed up with the Victoria Racing Club again across the Melbourne Cup Carnival, and that covers the naming rights for Seppelt Wines Stakes Day. TWE came back as the official wine supplier for the Australian Open 2020, after a successful partnership in 2019. We were back at Melbourne Park for the Grand Slam event, pouring an outstanding selection of wines from right across our Australian portfolio. Wolf Blass likewise kept up its link with the AFL, as the league's official wine partner since 2016. With a long history of involvement in Australian football, the brand is closely tied to sport — specifically chasing success in sport. That's only a glimpse of the many things we have going on, backing focused investment in our core brands. To sum up, I'm very happy with how the ANZ business keeps performing. I regard shifts in how luxury wine is being bought as temporary, and I still see a chance to speed up premiumization in this market.

Peter Neilson

executive
#34

At this point I'll turn things over to Michelle Brampton, who will cover how we performed across Europe, the Middle East, and Africa.

Michelle Brampton

executive
#35

Thanks, Peter. Good morning, everybody, speaking from London. We've certainly benefited from retail sales gains caused by lockdown-driven shifts in channels, particularly in the UK and the Nordics, but F20 results took a hit from declines during the second half in markets outside those two and in non-retail channels. Across the region, volume fell 4% and NSR fell 3.7%, with second-half drops in Continental Europe, the Middle East, and Africa, plus GTR, all stemming from channel closures, partially offset by a strong masstige portfolio showing through UK retail. COGS per case rose 7%, which mirrors an improved mix shift and elevated COGS on commercial wine sourced from Australia and the US. A favorable cost of doing business mirrors the disciplined way we kept investing in brands and managing overhead throughout F20. Regional EBITS dropped 25%, driven by weaker top-line results in Continental Europe, the Middle East, and Africa, and GTR during the second half. Wine as a category is now growing strongly across most European retail markets, powered by the worldwide, consistent shift away from on-trade toward off-trade. On the positive side, momentum is strong for higher-priced and branded wines, masstige wines especially, and TWE brands deliver that premium option. In the UK, TWE's second-half performance is powered by faster demand for Blossom Hill, Lindeman's, and the ongoing strong growth of 19 Crimes.

Michelle Brampton

executive
#36

As in other areas, we’ve witnessed a significant pickup in online shopping throughout key markets, as consumers increasingly move toward that channel for convenience and personal safety. Most EMEA sales are generated by our five main brands: Lindeman’s, Blossom Hill, 19 Crimes, Wolf Blass, and Penfolds. We kept investing in those core brands during F20. Among the highlights was the highly successful introduction of Blossom Hill Gin Fizz. Gin Fizz is the brand’s newest NPD product. It lifted volume sales by 195% in F20, tapping into the trend that blurs boundaries between drink categories. The launch was backed by Blossom Hill’s summer sampling campaign in Q1 of F20 and was featured in the online campaign Friendship Fridays in June 2020. More recently, TWE introduced a premium D2C platform, the Winery Collection, to engage consumers and provide direct access to our luxury portfolio spanning multiple countries of origin, responding to the online trend. We also formed a partnership with Wolf Blass and Deliveroo, in which 20,000 samples of Wolf Blass went out with Deliveroo orders, intended to strengthen the Wolf Blass brand’s quality credentials. Notwithstanding recent difficulties, our focus is on supporting customers and preparing for recovery.

Michelle Brampton

executive
#37

The approach we take in the region—building lasting growth and pushing premiumization, keeping our brands meaningful to consumers, and still delivering an EBITS margin in the mid-teens—is still solidly in place. At this point I'll turn things back over to Tim.

Tim Ford

executive
#38

Thanks, Michelle. I'm delighted to now share externally what we've been presenting internally over the past month — what we've named TWE 2025, which lays out our blueprint for the next five-year plan at Treasury Wine Estates. It takes the place of the Strategy House that many of you know well, and it's an evolution rather than a revolution of our strategy — but it sets out how we'll achieve our ambition of being the world's most admired premium wine company. To deliver on that ambition, we'll be bold in our decision-making and in how we innovate to drive change in the world of wine. And that will be the TWE way to boldly lead change in the world of wine. Supporting this, importantly, will be our DNA — the cultural code that will guide how we act and will shape the experience that everyone who touches TWE has. It reflects the next phase of our organization's cultural journey. And our Game Plan describes how we'll operate and grow our business and what success looks like for each part of our company across our brands, sales models, sourcing platforms, partnerships, and our talent. While there's a lot we're doing that is working well, we will pursue change and transformation in a number of key areas, acknowledging that we need to do things differently to deliver the next chapter of our growth story.

Tim Ford

executive
#39

This Game Plan rests on five pillars. First, with every brand in our portfolio, we'll keep a sharp focus on the consumer and on the personalized experiences we want them to have with our brands each and every time. Over the years, we've done well at aligning our business with a shifting mindset — moving from being agricultural-led to brand-led — and the next crucial stage of our brand-building journey will be placing the consumer even more firmly at the center of everything we do and every decision we make. Our diversified sales model, spanning multiple regions and channels, is a major strength, and we'll pursue greater balance in our sales mix by specifically concentrating on growing our premium brands via D2C and retailer e-commerce across all our markets and regions where they're a priority. As we do that, we'll keep strengthening the strong relationships we already have with our key distributor and retailer partners and elevate them further. Access to premium sourcing through our sustainable multi-regional sourcing and winemaking models in some of the world's most iconic winemaking regions gives our business a significant competitive edge. We intend to build on that in a way that's genuinely innovative, consumer-driven, and sustainable.

Tim Ford

executive
#40

We’ll produce the wines consumers ask for at the lowest possible cost, and we’ll become a champion and leader in sustainability across our entire supply chain while still running with maximum efficiency. Building on that, we’re going to create a step change in how we pursue partnerships. We’ve always spoken about how important partnerships are and have built many lasting relationships and networks throughout our business, but we have to do more for the next phase. This shift toward mutually beneficial partnerships across a broad range — customers, growers, suppliers, government, industry bodies, and the communities where we operate — will be an absolute priority for us. And finally, our people, the most important pillar of the Game Plan, who are unquestionably our most important asset and the key to our future success. Under my leadership, we’re going to drive greater engagement across our global team, with a heightened focus on how we recognise and reward more broadly, how we better support and connect with one another, and how we keep evolving toward the fun, bold, and highly motivating culture we aspire to achieve in this business. While parts of the Game Plan and the initiatives within it will naturally evolve over time, you should expect the key elements underpinning TWE 2025 to stay consistent as a very clear path to the next phase of our long-term growth journey.

Tim Ford

executive
#41

Within our operations, F21 will have five priority focus areas where we’ll put this Game Plan into action. Managing performance—first and foremost, especially as COVID-19 affects the trading environment—is our highest priority. In areas where we’re succeeding, we’ll remain committed, led by our focus brand portfolio, which keeps performing strongly across our markets; at the same time, we’ll keep working closely with customers and suppliers to navigate the recovery, and we’ll concentrate on capturing the opportunities we’ve discussed that have arisen from shifts in consumer and shopper behavior. Speeding up our move toward a marketing model led by consumers and experience—a brand-building model—will also be a key priority. To achieve that, we’ll prioritize decisions driven by insight and data, technology development, and investment behind fewer but larger, more disruptive campaigns and innovation priorities. Next in F21 comes supply chain optimization. Many of you will remember the successful supply chain optimization program we launched about five years ago, which significantly cut costs and boosted the efficiency of our global supply network and, importantly, positioned us through greater wine availability to support the premiumization strategy that has produced strong growth across multiple years.

Tim Ford

executive
#42

We believe now is the right moment to launch this broad, program-driven effort once more in F21, so that we can get the most out of our assets and add greater emphasis on sustainability—an area in which, as I mentioned before, we plan to lead the industry and which matters enormously. On timing of release, we anticipate these initiatives will deliver annualized cost savings of no less than AUD 50 million by F23. Moving to the Americas and our strategy to build the future state premium wine business in the US, where, as Ben noted earlier, we have reimagined our operations to work out the best way to capture what we see as a major long-term opportunity for TWE. This future state business will have roughly half the volume it does today, yet be sharply focused on premium price points and differentiated brands, producing a comparable earnings level while making substantial strides toward our 25% regional EBITS margin ambition and a growth portfolio. This brand portfolio—which has been growing strongly and is beating the category in U.S. retail trade—embodies what our business in this market will become and gives us confidence that we can reach our ambitions over time. Through to the end of calendar year 2021, we will keep advancing the restructuring initiatives previously announced, noting that the organizational restructure—significant and recently finished—carries AUD 35 million of annualized cost benefit set to begin in F21.

Tim Ford

executive
#43

And then lastly, regarding our plans to speed up separate attention across the portfolio. As I mentioned in the update last month, we think long-term value will come from giving Penfolds and our other premium brands a separate focus. And what we'll prioritize this fiscal year is figuring out the best operating model for delivering that growth and value creation, and that could include a potential demerger or an internal divisionalization model as another option. As the slide shows, the features of the separate portfolios differ on key items like your brand hierarchy, the price point center of gravity, strategic priorities, and the future respective growth drivers, which hopefully underlines the rationale and the benefits that separate focus will deliver to both portfolios. And we'll give a further update on these initiatives with our first half of our F21 results. So to close, F20 was a unique year for Treasury Wine Estates, for our industry and the markets where we operate. Our results show resilient performance despite two significant market factors: COVID-19, which adversely affected overall demand and mix, and the U.S. market oversupply dynamics. Despite these challenges, consumers keep engaging with our brands at premium price points.

Tim Ford

executive
#44

Our operating results are still solid, underpinned by robust cash conversion and a healthy balance sheet. And while we've seen encouraging signals of recovery in a few of our major markets, we're staying cautious about the near-term picture, because there's still uncertainty surrounding how quickly that recovery will proceed. Even so, we believe we're in a good position to get back to sustainable growth down the road, once our markets settle. What fuels that confidence is the strength of our worldwide business — including the appealing category fundamentals in our major markets, where we hold a strong market position, the finest global portfolio of premium wine brands, a global distribution footprint that has no rival in the world of wine, and our world-class asset base backed by a strong and flexible capital structure. And tying all of it together is our world-class talent — our team. So our refreshed strategic blueprint TWE 2025 makes our ambition, our DNA, and our Game Plan visible for everyone, and it sets the foundation for our clearly defined F21 priorities, which center on a balanced agenda that tackles the near-term challenges in front of us while laying the groundwork for the next phase of our sustainable long-term growth journey. Or, as I like to describe it, the two-speed operating model with the cash cow — we take care of business today while planning for tomorrow.

Tim Ford

executive
#45

Thanks for being with us today. Our presentation ran a bit longer than usual, but I felt it mattered that you—especially our investors—heard from several members of our leadership team. I hope you found that worthwhile and enjoyed it too. Before we move into Q&A, let me apologize for July 9th upfront, when some feedback reached us that we ended the Q&A somewhat too soon. Sorry about that. We'll make sure that as we take questions today—and I'd ask each of you to keep it to one question if possible—everyone gets the time to ask what they'd like to know. With that, Operator, let's open it up for Q&A.

Operator

operator
#46

Thank you very much, everyone. We're going to start the Q&A portion now. So, to repeat: if you'd like to pose a question, simply press star one on your phone's keypad, and then please hold until your name is called. Should you need to withdraw your request at any point, you can do so by pressing the pound or hash key. Our first question comes from Craig Woolford at Citi. Craig, go ahead with your question.

Craig Woolford

analyst
#47

Morning, Tim and everyone. Each person gets a single question from me. Let me narrow it down. Oh boy, I actually have several. I'll zero in on the Americas, since that's the more fundamental matter. China does interest me, though I'm certain somebody else will cover it. So regarding the outlook for that Americas business, and looking at one of the pie charts in the deck, it appears there could be a volume reduction of upwards of five million cases for that business. Is that something you're committed to regardless of whether you can sell it? Put differently, you'd exit without necessarily selling it at a meaningful price. And tied to that, does it affect your ability to do direct distribution in the U.S. and in those key states where you've shifted to that model? I know this is a last question. I'm surprised by how focused you are on reducing commercial in the Americas. Why isn't that a global focus for the business?

Tim Ford

executive
#48

Thanks, Craig. Good morning. I'll handle most of the question, but once I've finished my parts, I'll also invite Ben Dollard to weigh in on the distribution model. First, on volume: the ambition we hold for the business, what we're aiming to achieve, is roughly half of where the business stands today. That ties into what I describe as playing to our strengths. It's the thinking behind the strategy, and it's what's really propelling the strategy we're pursuing in the United States. So the priority portfolio — the one Ben mentioned, the core nine brands in that market — is where we have premium price points and premium differentiated brands that give us margin uplifts and are growing, and where we have a consumer base that believes in and buys those brands. As for the commercial portfolio, we're exploring several different alternatives — yes, divestment is one of them, but there's also the possibility that, based on our planning and inventory over time, we simply wind those down more quickly than we have done across the last five years.

Tim Ford

executive
#49

That's yet another option. And we're actually examining various models. So I suppose that addresses the question about how the U.S. business looks from a volume standpoint. Globally speaking, I'd say the commercial emphasis throughout our business—and as you've seen in the figures we presented today—we keep raising the share of total NSR coming from premium brands, luxury and masstige together, now above 70%. We'll keep pushing that. We'll keep treating it as a key metric for our business. That said, differentiated commercial brands aren't harmful to us. Take 19 Crimes—you could say it's a commercial wine with a strong point of difference among our consumer base. When brands are strong and aren't necessarily exposed to marketplace volatility, that's again a strength for us, and we believe those brands will remain important to our business going forward. So Ben Dollard, I might pass it to you to speak about the distribution arrangements in the U.S. Sure.

Ben Dollard

executive
#50

Thanks, Tim. I'd say the foundation of our strategy—and definitely where we're headed going forward—is putting our attention on our core nine brands. That approach is clearly delivering results compared with how the market is performing. So with that in mind, and to address your question, Craig, we don't anticipate any changes when it comes to the markets we serve directly, or when it comes to the relationship we have with our retailers and the way we engage with them. And again, a lot of this will depend on our focus on our core nine brands and on driving and investing behind them. So for us, I think it's very much about concentrated effort and working very closely with our retailers and our distributors in those direct markets.

Tim Ford

executive
#51

The final point I want to raise, Craig, is this: some people hold the view that when it comes to total volume, scale is essential. My argument is that the scale of growing brands — brands that deliver margin to us, to our retailers, and to our distributor partners — those are the brands that will receive the focus of their sales teams and also their promotional activity, and so on. So when we discuss scale, and when I discuss scale, what I want is scale as a large percentage of our business made up of brands that are growing and delivering margin to all of our partners in the value chain. So perhaps that reorients the scale discussion somewhat as well. Thanks, Craig.

Craig Woolford

analyst
#52

Appreciate that, Tim.

Operator

operator
#53

All right. Moving on, our following question is from Michael Simotas of Jefferies. Michael, go ahead and ask.

Michael Simotas

analyst
#54

Hello, everyone. I’d like to pose my question regarding China. The depletion figure you reported for June is obviously quite robust. Could you provide us with some additional detail, please, about those depletions? And specifically, if you’re open to it, things such as how much of that reflects distributors clearing inventory that sits in the channel via promotion or through other methods, along with some remarks on on-premise versus off-premise, and also the kind of wine that is fueling that promotion—sorry, fueling those depletions—in terms of where it sits on the price spectrum, please.

Tim Ford

executive
#55

Yes, good morning, Michael. I’ll have Tom respond to that one.

Tom King

executive
#56

Thanks, Tim. Michael, yes. Well, we're clearly quite happy with the rebound in depletions we saw during Q4, especially in June. Right now we're staying cautiously optimistic, since we're aware that circumstances can shift quite rapidly. As for what has been fueling those depletions — especially the June figure — it's people gathering together again, ultimately because restrictions have been lifted, venues are opening, and business and social occasions are returning, though they aren't fully back to where they were before COVID. It has happened across the board, in every channel. Of course, June brings a major online shopping festival, the 618 Festival. That contributed very positively to how we performed in June. And it spans the portfolio too. Not one particular piece of our priority portfolio, nor any single piece of our business from a channel standpoint. For us, we truly have to wait and see how Mid-Autumn Festival turns out. We have strong pull-through programs lined up throughout the portfolio. Still, I think it's fair to say customers feel quite good about our brands, because those brands generate cash for them. And we will, of course, keep investing in our priority portfolio, as we did all through H2. Very pleased with how June turned out, but we remain cautiously optimistic as we look ahead.

Tim Ford

executive
#57

Thanks, Tom. And Michael, another thing I'd tack onto that relates to what you were asking about — whether this is essentially stock being liquidated. I believe that was part of your question. Yeah. What we're definitely observing is that the pull-through for our brands is what's driving depletions, and that pattern actually looks comparable across channels to what we saw before COVID. So yes, on a couple of SKUs and brands there have been the occasional instances of pricing dislocation, and frankly those have been pretty isolated over the past couple of months. I'm sure several analysts on this call may have come across a few of those. But Tom and the team are catching them really fast, and they're also staying very disciplined about the way we engage with and steer our partners through that situation too, so that the medium and long-term strength and health of our brands — which our pricing structures largely drive — keeps being handled effectively as time goes on. Thanks, Michael.

Operator

operator
#58

All right. Our next question is from Niraj Shah at Morgan Stanley. Go ahead. Sorry about that. Niraj? Ah, there we are.

Niraj Shah

analyst
#59

Yeah. Morning, everybody. I just have a question about intake. Clearly it's fallen a lot, especially luxury intake this year. Could you give us a little more detail on the flexibility you've got to, I suppose, even out the allocation and how you'd go about managing that?

Matt Young

executive
#60

Thanks, Niraj. Matt here — I'll handle that question. You're correct. Back in July we touched on this a little, and again today we're giving some insight regarding the 2020 vintage in Australia, which is down 30% overall. Today we did call out luxury at 45%. The value in our model, as we've also mentioned, is that we can manage across multiple regions, and across multiple years as well while doing so. A few of the ways we accomplish that: obviously, we allocate across multiple regions, and we bring wines to market at the right moment and spread that out — whether through back vintages, or through working in channels where vintage release matters more or less. Those flexible characteristics of our model are something we view as an advantage. You have seen examples from us in earlier years where we've done special releases or back vintage releases, and the ability to keep doing that and to plan for it across multiple years. But the heart of it is that luxury wine is clearly sought after. It's sought after across multiple years by collectors and immediate consumers alike, and that model lets us be flexible in how and when we release it.

Niraj Shah

analyst
#61

Appreciate it.

Operator

operator
#62

Alright. Our next question is from Larry Gandler at Credit Suisse. Larry, go ahead and ask.

Larry Gandler

analyst
#63

Morning there, Tim — is my voice coming through okay?

Tim Ford

executive
#64

Morning, everyone.

Larry Gandler

analyst
#65

Okay, great — excellent. Thank you, Liz. I’d like to return to Asia for a moment. Tim, Matt, based on what I laid out up there, it appears that across several regions and cases, Treasury’s retail and wholesale pricing on Penfolds has declined since COVID. That makes a certain amount of sense, since there may have been surplus inventory following Chinese New Year. You described the situation as fairly isolated, but it doesn’t really feel that way to me. Could you give us some sense of where average retail and wholesale pricing for Penfolds currently sits, and what that implies for the brand’s long-term health? What steps are you taking to try to rebuild value for your retailers and wholesalers?

Tim Ford

executive
#66

Yeah. Thanks, Larry. Well, I'll lead with that, and then I'll ask Tom to weigh in too. I think it matters to hear from the people in the markets as well. I definitely don't think we've seen a broad problem when it comes to what we charge for hotel resale across the major markets, across any of the channels they operate in. I'm firmly of the view that these have been isolated, and we've seen it, particularly in some of the bin ranges, Bin 389 for instance. We're aware there's been pricing, especially on online channels, that we wouldn't want to see in that market, and it hasn't persisted once we've really gotten underneath how the stock has been taken up by some of those customers and partners in the market there in China, so from where I sit, our retail pricing is holding up well. We haven't chosen to raise prices this year. That's a really key point, and it's something we've done consistently over the last five years, which is raise prices. But certainly, just to manage the market and make sure we have a much clearer view given the uncertainty around the future demand profile, we simply wanted to keep the pricing structures as intact as we can until we have a much better understanding of not just the pace but also the demand and the recovery.

Tim Ford

executive
#67

Tom, would you like to add to that?

Tom King

executive
#68

Yeah. I think to begin with that, it's really important to make clear that obviously neither retail nor wholesale pricing in the market is under our control. And look, from time to time, we do see pockets of pretty heavy discounting. But often, that's driven by new or newer entrants into the market looking to drive footfall or traffic. And ultimately, when those partners of ours do go deep on discounting, they'll burn through their limited allocations on a pretty quick basis. As an evolution of our market management policy, we have a model where each of our partners has a defined territory and/or a defined channel scope as part of our annual agreements with them, and that's something we've had in place throughout F20. Moving forward, and from the 1st of August, we've refined that policy whereby we're now putting in additional measures linked to some of our products that will only be available out of the Shanghai warehouse on a monthly basis where we'll be able to trade those products back to our direct customers, and ultimately, where we see people operating outside their defined contractual territories or channels, that gives us the ability to take recourse to those customers.

Tom King

executive
#69

Like we've mentioned previously, if there's a strategic misalignment with any partner regarding our brand strategy and how that strategy gets executed in the market, we have no hesitation about altering our model.

Tim Ford

executive
#70

Thanks, Tom. The final point I want to add, Larry, just to wrap up that question, is that this is something we're always working on and always focused on—not just in China but across other parts of Asia too. So it's a top priority. And I think what Tom described represents a pretty meaningful move forward in how we handle the partner network and the channel conflict that could potentially arise inside the China business. So thanks for the question.

Larry Gandler

analyst
#71

Appreciate it.

Operator

operator
#72

Alright. Our following question is from Richard Barwick of CLSA. Richard, go ahead and ask. Okay.

Richard Barwick

analyst
#73

Thank you. Hello, Tim and Tim. Tim, based on how you were speaking back on July 9th, I figured there was a pretty good likelihood that by this point you'd have offloaded at least one of your US commercial brands, or at minimum have something to announce. So what are you able to share with us today regarding how that effort is going and what the outlook is for actually divesting commercial brands such as Coastal or Main & Vine, for example?

Tim Ford

executive
#74

Good morning, Richard. Good to hear from you. Sorry to let you down. Regarding the progress — I'm genuinely pleased with how things are going in the US, in terms of how we're approaching the options we have for either divesting or, I suppose, shrinking the brands that we don't view as priorities for long-term growth of the US business. I hope I was clear earlier in saying that the entire sequence of work underway in the U.S. began with the internal restructure, the internal cost management, and redefining the way we operate with our retailers and distributors going forward, which has been absolutely the top priority over these last two or three months. And I think Ben and the team have done an outstanding job delivering what is a significantly different resourced model within the U.S. business. And we're making the progress we want on the potential divestments of the assets and the brands. And we have multiple alternatives for doing that. I mean, these things — it's a substantial piece of work we're undertaking. There are substantially different options we can take as we go down that path.

Tim Ford

executive
#75

We have to be quite intentional about the order in which we actually do this, to make sure of a couple of things. First, that we keep managing those brands well during the period ahead while we're also trying to reshape the business in the U.S. But beyond that, this takes time. And we have to make certain we won't sell or divest these assets at any cost. We need to get the right price, the right operating model, or the right exit strategy — one that creates value for shareholders and for our P&L too. So underneath that strategy, it's a complicated set of tasks we're taking on. In short, I'm sorry to disappoint you. I genuinely believe the progress we're making is very strong. We're working quite hard on it. Nobody wants to get there faster than I do, believe me. Or perhaps Ben Dollard does. But it's certainly a very high priority for me. That's why we've laid it out among our F21 real key priorities — we must, must deliver that shape of that business.

Richard Barwick

analyst
#76

Tim, may I just get some clarity on that point? I hear what you're saying, and of course it's a balanced picture with plenty of moving parts involved. But do you expect that you'll actually be able to divest some brands, or is it too soon to tell?

Tim Ford

executive
#77

We can’t tell yet. Still, based on where we are right now, I do expect that we’ll be able to.

Richard Barwick

analyst
#78

Alright, sounds good — thanks a lot.

Tim Ford

executive
#79

Was it not the latter portion? My expectation, Richard, is that we will manage to do so.

Richard Barwick

analyst
#80

Got it. Thanks.

Operator

operator
#81

Alright. The following question is from David Errington at Bank of America. David, go ahead with your question.

David Errington

analyst
#82

Good morning, Tim, and good morning, everyone. Tim, since you were previously the supply chain expert, this question is likely for you, though Matt may also want to weigh in. It concerns inventory, and specifically I recall the intake. I clearly remember 2011, when a truly terrible harvest resulted from the reverse of what we've had lately—drought and hot weather. This time around, floods were the cause. And I distinctly recall that no 707 was produced whatsoever. You genuinely had to search high and low to obtain any Grange. Could you provide a little more detail about that 45% decline? The real difficulty lies in that iconic segment—the Grange and the 707s—where you now make it at 30, 40 dollars per bottle but sell it for 10 to 15 times that amount. Can you give us some insight into what the intake has looked like for those iconics? Did it fall uniformly in line with the 45%? Or were you able to do better in those super iconics? If so, the decline might not be as damaging to future profitability. And secondly, I'm somewhat puzzled about how the inventory's value can rise by that much while luxury volume is down.

David Errington

analyst
#83

Given how the mix shifted and all, with luxury down 45% and the total down 30%, the value still rose. To me, that indicates your COGS must have climbed substantially, and that makes me somewhat more concerned about profitability going forward too. So my question has two parts. I'm sorry about that, but this is a significant concern of mine.

Tim Ford

executive
#84

Absolutely, no trouble at all. Good morning, Dan. On the first question—regarding how that vintage effect is spread, I'd say the best assumption, without getting into each SKU individually, is that it's fairly even across everything. So it's clear that intake made it a difficult vintage throughout the entire range of our luxury wines. The encouraging part—and I want to be sure this point registers, since I believe most people already appreciate it—is that a smaller vintage does not mean quality suffers. It's definitely key to recognize that we produce to that quality standard. Sometimes that does result in lower intake volumes in a given vintage. So the shape of that reduction is quite consistent across everything, David. Another thing I'd note on inventory—and I'll leave it to Matt to say more about how cost and volume balance out and what the composition of that inventory looks like in what we've shared today—but the main thing from my side, and normally you wouldn't say this, is that during the COVID stretch, when we ended up selling far less luxury wine in the first half than we had planned, if a lower luxury vintage intake was ever going to happen, this was the year for it, since we can rebalance the years ahead to some extent on that basis.

Tim Ford

executive
#85

I'm attempting to find something favorable in what's otherwise unfavorable. I completely get that. But I suppose a major worry of mine as we entered the COVID period, once we grasped what lay in store, was what it would mean for how we position inventory going forward too. And of course, with the smaller intake, it won't come close to creating a problem for us here in Australia. And I think, as Matt laid out today, we've been fairly transparent regarding other inventory provisions. And we believe our inventory balance, even with the COVID implications, remains quite strong right across the board, so we can keep growing consistently year on year, even though the intake is smaller. So that's my response to the first part. May I let Matt address the second?

Matt Young

executive
#86

Right. Let me try to break this down for you in terms of volume versus costs. I'll be blending cost and mix here. So obviously, we've already flagged that luxury wine volume is off 5%. Two factors are behind that. First, clearly, the 2020 vintage was smaller — 45%. Sorry, at the luxury level. What offset that was the carryover from the vintage we had planned to sell during the back half of 2020. So from a volume standpoint, that's in there. On the mix and cost side, yes, the 2020 vintage has come in at a higher cost. The reason is that it's a lower-yielding vintage, which means cost recovery. That's one factor behind it. The second factor is that ordinarily the 2020 vintage would be larger, and it would be at an early stage of production. It would be bulk wine. That's lower. What we carried forward is finished goods from fiscal 2020. So there's a stage-of-production element, which I'll call mix. I do recognize that it's a higher-cost vintage for fiscal 2020, because it's lower-yielding, and winery costs and so on get absorbed at a higher rate. So a few dynamics are at play there. Hopefully, that helps clarify things.

Tim Ford

executive
#87

The final thing I would add is that I hope we made it clear today that we recognize we are facing a cost of goods challenge. There is no question about that. And the program of work we are putting in place to address it, we are partway through. So that is why we talked today about the financial goals on that front. However, we have to go stronger and harder than we have, and more work remains to be done on that front. There is no doubt about that.

David Errington

analyst
#88

Thanks, Tim. Appreciate it, Matt.

Tim Ford

executive
#89

Appreciate it, David.

Operator

operator
#90

The following question is from Andrew McLennan at Goldman Sachs. Andrew, go ahead with your question.

Andrew McLennan

analyst
#91

Morning, everyone. Perhaps building on that point about the AUD 50 million global supply chain cost reduction you brought up. So, Tim, is it your contention that this has largely been put in place to counterbalance the problems you just described regarding the higher cost of goods sold? Clearly, it will last longer than a single vintage. Still, I found that a notable step as far as the cost-out program goes. So could you walk us through what is expected from that global supply chain cost-out and how we ought to view it on both a net and a gross basis.

Tim Ford

executive
#92

Right, absolutely. So the important thing about these global supply programs is that they aren't really driven by the fact that we've had a tough vintage cost situation in Australian commercial wine, for instance. What it really is, is a body of work that any business needs to undertake at least once every three to four years, in my view, since demand shifts and your infrastructure shifts. I tend to frame it this way: the train set you've got on the supply chain side today won't be the correct collection of carriages four or five years from now, and you have to keep reviewing it constantly, so this is definitely one of the initiatives I was very eager to set up when I took on the leadership role — that we run that body of work once more, and it's wide-ranging. It's worldwide. It spans everything from how we handle packaging right through to the infrastructure sitting behind it too. So we understand the playbook these programs require you to follow. We've been through it previously. We believe we know how to get this kind of thing finished.

Tim Ford

executive
#93

What we’ve put a spotlight on today is a target of more than AUD 50 million, and that will be achieved by F23 according to the release age of wines. And that is simply a result of financial years and the way wine is produced and sold according to that release age. But it’s fair to say the supply chain team — no, they can, there is pressure for them to do more than that across the period as well.

Matt Young

executive
#94

Right, and I want to build on that. I do acknowledge the 50 basis points tied to the 50 we discussed back in July for this fiscal year. But let me put that into context: what we laid out in July clearly includes some elements that reflect rising Australian commercial cost of goods, along with the particular vintage we've been dealing with. So a portion of that ties to this specific vintage, and in a normal vintage those elements would normalize out and wouldn't show up in future years. That said, as Tim mentioned, this program of work began before the vintage — before the Australian vintage. It's a long-term effort that forms part of the rhythm we ought to have in place at all times. So the two are somewhat different, with the longer-term piece of work being a stable item that should serve us over a long period. And what we've described for COGS this year is an issue tied to a single vintage.

Andrew McLennan

analyst
#95

All right, thanks.

Operator

operator
#96

The following question is from Sean Cousins at J.P. Morgan. Sean, go ahead with your question.

Sean Cousins

analyst
#97

Thanks. Morning, everyone. I've got a question about the Americas ex-retail channel. You mentioned, I believe, 12% of volumes and 25% of NSR in July. Could you speak a bit about how that looks from an EBIT standpoint in the Americas? And perhaps you could give that breakdown for other markets as well. Then maybe for Ben: where do you see that ex-retail market at the moment? And what's the path to recovery there, please?

Matt Young

executive
#98

I'll take the first portion, and then I'll pass it over to Ben to provide a picture of how matters stand right now. You're correct. We did provide that detail. We haven't separated it out at an EBIT level. What I can say, though, is that these are obviously luxury channels—especially our direct-to-consumer operation, and seller doors above all. They're strong businesses for us in the U.S., above all because of the experience and, I suppose, the wine tastings, the cable car, and other components, plus the experience you receive in the U.S. business. So they're profitable. So in terms of the shape of the P&L, they produce a higher gross profit and earnings there. We haven't disclosed that before and don't plan to keep doing so today. But I hear your point, and we'll give it thought going forward. But they have been closed. So, just so everyone understands, these are elements—they have been closed. They're profit pools that will return to us once those channels reopen. Ben, would you like to share how you're currently seeing things on the ground in those channels?

Ben Dollard

executive
#99

Right, absolutely. Thanks, Matt. I'll just add briefly to what you just said. Clearly, we've felt an effect in travel retail too, especially across Latin America, since the cruise line industry has essentially been shut down — so that's another factor we've had to weigh. Our visitor centers here in California have been reopening bit by bit, though it's been very gradual and keeps shifting, and things remain pretty fluid. But it's very clear that our e-commerce platform — across both our direct-to-retail and our B2B e-commerce operations — has kept delivering particularly strong opportunities for us. So we're cautiously optimistic as we think about the DTC part of our business starting back up, though of course, as we've reimagined the business, we've also put substantial investment into how we approach e-commerce going forward and into building a team dedicated to that area. So again, somewhat cautiously optimistic as we move ahead here.

Sean Cousins

analyst
#100

And Matt, could you cover the ex-retail channel across the other regions as well?

Matt Young

executive
#101

At the same time, the main area we clearly concentrated on was ANZ, and that's the biggest contributor. Europe is mostly retail, so there isn't much value in dissecting it. It's almost entirely retail—convenience and impulse. As for Asia, we haven't provided that breakdown; it's somewhat more complex to do given our model. Still, we've noted that point, and we'll keep considering how to disclose it going forward. For now, though, the way we've shared things—around our customer base rather than by channel—is the best approach available to us.

Sean Cousins

analyst
#102

Excellent, and thanks to Matt as well as Ben.

Operator

operator
#103

Philip Kimber of Evans & Partners is up next with a question. Go ahead, Philip.

Phil Kimber

analyst
#104

Alright folks, just a quick follow-up on Asia. It was clearly really encouraging to hear about the 40% depletions in June. But could you help us understand shipments a bit? And do you anticipate a significant gap between shipments and depletions in that market until conditions genuinely get back to more typical levels?

Tim Ford

executive
#105

Morning, Philip. How are you doing, Matt? Yeah. Regarding shipments versus our depletions plan — look, we will always run our shipment plans around replenishing to whatever the full depletions forecast is, especially for China. So does a lag exist? Sure, timing differs, there's no question about that, since obviously our P&L and profitability get measured on what we ship into that market too. So we watch inventory levels very, very closely — particularly across the last four or five months — keeping the pandemic in mind and thinking about cash flow challenges that could potentially hit some of our partners over in China. And I think we've stayed really disciplined in how we've shipped product to meet forward demand once we know what that forward demand is. So from that angle, I think the process we've had in place won't change. If we keep seeing continual growth in the forward forecast that lines up with what we've seen across Q4 in Asia, then clearly our shipments will match that going forward, likely with some lag as you see the replenishment cycles working. So that's probably the best way to answer that.

Tim Ford

executive
#106

That is simply how we ordinarily operate.

Phil Kimber

analyst
#107

Alright, thanks.

Tim Ford

executive
#108

Appreciate it.

Operator

operator
#109

All right, we’ve got a question coming in from Ross Curran at Macquarie. Go ahead with your question, Ross.

Ross Curran

analyst
#110

Hi, Tim. Maybe a somewhat gentler strategic question. The language surrounding the possible demerger of Penfolds appears to have become softer. And you've mentioned a few other options that the group has available. Could you give us a sense of how your thinking around the Penfolds portfolio may have shifted since our last strategic update a couple of months ago?

Tim Ford

executive
#111

Morning, Ross. The Penfolds work—and I'll refer to it as the separate focus work we've been doing, since that's genuinely what it is. I'm glad you raised the question, because I believe a couple of these points need clarifying. Our statements about exploring the Penfolds demerger remain absolutely on our agenda. All right? So I want that to be very, very clear. We didn't announce that in April when I wasn't CEO, and then suddenly we're backing away from it now that I am. That's not the case. As we've gone through the work—the diligence we need to go through, and I'm sure every shareholder would expect that of us as a management team and as a board—we need to ensure that what is the right operating model, including demerger as an alternative, to grow our business the most effective way going forward. Now, clearly, when we announced this in April, we also didn't expect to still be in the middle of a global pandemic. So have we actually slowed some of that work down to focus on the current business today? Absolutely, we have. Are we actually walking away from it?

Tim Ford

executive
#112

Definitely not. Yeah. The divisionalization option I presented today — if you consider a demerger, a logical first move would be to organize your company as it stands now into a divisional setup, which then lets you oversee the transition process of a demerger so you adopt a gradual path toward what we're aiming for here, namely making sure we've got the proper operating model to expand the business with distinct focus. And after that, how the structural result shapes up will likewise depend on that growth ambition, plus on generating the shareholder value we're looking to create through this effort. So hopefully, the sequence — and I'll keep using that word, I guess — there's a series of steps you kind of work through. From my perspective, softening the language, if you will, is simply an attempt to clarify the sequencing we'd follow. I'll be candid. I don't sense any time pressure to reach this decision, since it's a serious one — a big one. The board and I talk about it constantly. We'll keep updating as we judge necessary while we progress through that series of steps, so hopefully that provides a little more color.

Tim Ford

executive
#113

The slide in the pack that we discussed was meant to lay out the reasoning behind this, since that separate focus and the two portfolios — and by two portfolios I mean Penfolds, which is basically five tiers sitting under one luxury umbrella brand — differs on so many fronts from the wider portfolio we have across the rest of TWE. So that was the aim today, to try to demonstrate some of that thinking and rationale. Hopefully that gives you a little more color and hopefully clears up some of the — I think some of the confusion and certainly some of the questions that I'm sure investors and others currently have in mind.

Operator

operator
#114

Thanks. We've got another one coming from Aryan Norozi at UBS. Go ahead with your question.

Aryan Norozi

analyst
#115

Hey, guys. Just a couple of quick ones, maybe two minutes. During your second half, Asian volume dropped 38% year on year. Could you give us some sense of how that trend moved in the third quarter versus the fourth quarter year on year, especially June, similar to the color and depletions you provided? And what's driving the higher EBIT margin target into the high 30s compared with the prior guidance, please? Thanks.

Matt Young

executive
#116

That's a good question about the results, and I feel we've provided a fair amount of granularity quarter by quarter. I'm not prepared to address it just yet, so I'll leave that one aside. The main takeaway, I think, that both Tim and Tom conveyed is that we clearly came into Q3 heading toward Chinese New Year, and the COVID-19 difficulties in those channels posed a fresh hurdle we had to navigate. Across Q3 and Q4, we've been tracking depletions, collaborating closely with our customers, and ensuring they were aligned as our customers needed to work through it too, and that gives us confidence in the market's strength to grow from — and I think the confidence reflected in Q4 depletions going from flat to growth is a solid data point supporting our cautious optimism there as well. And sorry, the second part of the question concerned the target. So clearly, over the last few years, we've posted high 30s, and even 40% this year, for our EBITS margin. What you've consistently heard from us is guidance of 35% plus, driven by an intention to grow masstige wine in that market, which may expand the profit pool while lowering the EBITS margin and shifting some of the metrics.

Matt Young

executive
#117

I just wanted to point that out. Looking further ahead at this point, we believe we're actually able to hold onto that elevated EBITS margin while expanding both the masstige and luxury brands. So it's acknowledging that, now that we have better visibility into our portfolio and growth, and so on, for that market — that's the reason we've increased and lifted that margin for everyone.

Tom King

executive
#118

The other important piece there, I'd say, is that we've now posted something like a 38%-plus EBITS margin across several consecutive halves, including the most recent one. So when we put out a target of 35% or more, which we've had in place for quite a few periods, people can occasionally read that as a step down from where you're performing today — and frankly, that's exactly what we were trying to steer clear of with this.

Aryan Norozi

analyst
#119

All right, thanks.

Operator

operator
#120

All right. That brings us to the end of the question-and-answer portion. At this point, I'll return the call to your presenters, who may offer some closing comments.

Tim Ford

executive
#121

Thanks. Thank you all for being here. My hope is that today gave you a broader sense, I suppose, of the way we're handling things day to day and handling the challenges the business faces, but also — and I think this matters — of reminding everyone about the fundamentals of our business and the forward plans and how we're driving those two-speed agendas, as I like to call them, and also of giving you some insight into and an introduction to the wider leadership team, because when all is said and done, that's what it all comes down to. So I appreciate everyone's time and interest, and I look forward to many discussions over the coming couple of weeks. Cheers.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Treasury Wine Estates Limited transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Treasury Wine Estates Limited earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Treasury Wine Estates Limited or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.