Treasury Wine Estates Limited (TWE) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
February 17, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorLadies and gentlemen, thanks for staying on the line, and welcome to the Treasury Wine Estates FY '21 Half Year Results. <<operator_script>> Kindly note that this conference today is being recorded. I'll now hand the call over to your first speaker, Mr. Tim Ford, CEO for Treasury Wine Estates. Thank you. Please go ahead.
Tim Ford
executiveGood morning, everyone, and thank you for attending the 2021 interim results briefing. I'm delighted to be joined on today's call by these members of our leadership team: Matt Young, our CFO; Tom King, our Managing Director of Asia, who is based in Shanghai; Ben Dollard, President of Americas in California; Pete Neilson, the MD of the ANZ business; and Michelle Brampton from London, our Managing Director of the Europe, Middle East and Africa business. We certainly have a comprehensive agenda for today's briefing. And beyond the usual financial and regional updates, I'll shortly give an update on how our strategic agenda is being implemented, including the new Treasury Wine Estates brand portfolio-led divisional operating model that we've announced today. But beginning with our first half 2021 financial performance. Net sales revenue fell 8%, with the three key drivers being ongoing disruptions from the global pandemic on key sales channels for luxury wine; impacts to our China business from the ongoing MOFCOM investigations; and the continued proactive reduction of commercial wine volumes in the United States. Compared with the first half of fiscal '20, EBITS declined 23% to $284.1 million. EBITS margin declined 3.8 percentage points to 20.1% and earnings per share declined 24% to $0.243 per share, reflecting not only the decline in our top line performance, but also the impacts of higher cost of goods per case on the Australian-sourced commercial and masstige wines from the 2020 Australian vintage, in particular, which we've previously flagged, as well as one-off impacts relating to the California wildfires and the MOFCOM investigations.
Tim Ford
executiveCash flow performance was very strong, though—the 129% cash conversion result got a lift from the lower 2020 California vintage intake and from sales in China being phased earlier than we had planned. Our capital structure is still strong, flexible and efficient, with net debt down by more than $400 million in the half, and our leverage ratio of 1.7x, in line with the prior corresponding period. Because of that, the Board has declared an interim dividend of $0.15 per share, representing a consistent payout ratio of 62% and in line with our long-term dividend policy. So while our key top line and profitability metrics are lower versus the prior corresponding period, the execution of our COVID-19 Plan Ahead Agenda, which we outlined in August, is driving positive momentum towards recovery throughout our business, and that is evident when we compare our performance this half to the second half of fiscal 2020, a comparable period that was also impacted by the global pandemic. At a group level, EBITS increased 70% half-on-half. And as shown on the chart on the screen, the recovery has been broad-based, with every region delivering significantly improved performance, notwithstanding the varied disruptions that have been encountered—a true testament to the strength of our brand portfolios, our customer partnerships and the exceptional execution by our team globally in the conditions.
Tim Ford
executiveTo get a full picture of how we performed and to shed light on what demand is doing right now, it's worth remembering that key sales channels in every market are at differing stages of impact and recovery. Overall, retail and e-commerce remain open and keep showing strong growth, which mirrors how consumers shifted toward drinking well-known, trusted brands at home during the pandemic — and our focused brand portfolios serve that shift very well. And while we're seeing a positive mix shift across both retail and e-commerce as consumers trade up, the disruption to sales channels for higher-margin luxury wine continues to weigh negatively on our overall business performance. As the slide shows, the on-premise, cellar door and travel retail channels remain significantly disrupted in each of our markets. In the Americas and ANZ specifically, this has been a key driver of the declines in sales volume, revenue and EBITS on a year-on-year comparison. We remain confident, though, that as these channels reopen and consumption demand comes back through them, we are very well placed to accelerate the pace of our recovery — although the timing of this is hard to forecast, as I'm sure you'll agree.
Tim Ford
executiveMoving on to our strategic agenda now. During last August's full year 2020 results announcement, I set out the Treasury 2025 strategy and game plan, along with our 5 key priority areas for the business in F '21 that would start bringing that game plan to life. Since then, we've needed to add one more priority — implementing our global response plan to the measures MOFCOM announced late last November. Still, our top priority has been and will remain managing business performance through the global pandemic period and the recovery that follows. As I said a little earlier, executing this plan is generating positive momentum toward that goal. In the regional presentation coming shortly from the team, you'll see that our push to shift toward a consumer-led and experience-led marketing model is moving quickly, and I'm delighted with the innovation we're delivering across our brand portfolios, together with a genuine emphasis on fewer but bigger and more disruptive, impactful campaigns. The outstanding performance of 19 Crimes Cali Red in the U.S. is just one illustration of this priority in action, with several other exciting launches and innovations lined up for the second half of fiscal '21 and beyond.
Tim Ford
executiveOn the third priority, supply chain optimization, we're squarely on course to roll out this year the set of initiatives that will produce annualized cost savings of no less than $50 million from F '23. That timing mirrors the wine's release age along with how it flows through the P&L, and the initiatives will be executed during this year. There's likewise been considerable attention and conjecture lately, over recent months and weeks, regarding our intentions to accelerate separate focus across our portfolio. And today, I'm both delighted and excited to unveil the new global divisional business model that Treasury Wine Estates will run under starting with the beginning of fiscal 2022. This deliberately crafted global model is going to drive separate and greater focus and accountability from our teams and will, in turn, unlock our long-term growth potential as one stand-alone company. The growth to unlock is present in our markets, in our brand portfolios, in our margins and in our people. And this leadership team is persuaded the new operating model will strengthen our capacity to capture these. Under the new model, we will move away from a sales region-led business model toward one that is brand-led, running under 3 new stand-alone portfolio divisions.
Tim Ford
executiveThe first is Penfolds, and Tom King will lead it; it'll have the chance to concentrate on turning into a genuinely worldwide luxury iconic brand. Second, Treasury Premium Brands, under Peter Neilson's leadership, will sharpen its emphasis on providing consumer-focused, innovative premium offerings that serve a range of consumer occasions. And third, Treasury Americas, which Ben Dollard will lead, will concentrate on heading the premium wine category across the Americas, where the advantages of greater focus are already becoming visible. Backing these 3 portfolio-led divisions will be Treasury business solutions, led by Matt Young as part of his CFO remit, and it will handle delivery plus the ongoing centralization of business functions and processes that are shared and repeated across the 3 portfolio divisions. This represents the next stage of the global business services model we announced a couple of years back. Supply operations, under Kerrin Petty, will handle growing, sourcing, production and delivery for all our portfolio across all geographies, with the exception of the U.S., which will sit with Treasury Americas and Ben. And finally, a streamlined corporate center — a smaller corporate center — will handle group strategy, culture, capital management and allocation, governance, IT and stakeholder management.
Tim Ford
executiveStarting with F '22, we'll be reporting how the business performs under the new portfolio divisions. And internally, we're going to move quickly now to finish the detailed design and get implementation underway. Every one of these portfolio divisions comes with its own strategic, geographic and consumer traits, plus separate growth opportunities, and the focus and accountability this divisional model delivers will strengthen those benefits. As for Penfolds, we're completely certain it will reap substantial benefits from a stand-alone, separate focus while still being a core part of Treasury Wine Estates. Tom and his team will concentrate on generating future growth by growing the consumer base around the world, opening new sales channels in key geographies and driving the new U.S. and French country of origin portfolios. As for Treasury Premium Brands, made up mostly of brands sourced from Australia and New Zealand across every price point and sold mainly in the Australia, New Zealand, EMEA and Asia regions, Peter and his team will focus on building top line momentum and delivering a step change in profitability, putting in place a fit-for-purpose capital base and unlocking the potential of a diverse and iconic brand portfolio through innovation, free from the shadow and competing demands of the Penfolds portfolio.
Tim Ford
executiveWe think that with this separation, we will be better positioned to realize the full global potential of labels including Wynns, Pepperjack, Squealing Pig, Seppelt, Wolf Blass and St Huberts The Stag, among others. As for Treasury Americas — a standalone portfolio made up mostly of brands sourced in the U.S. and sold nearly entirely within the Americas region — Ben and his team will keep their focus on completing the brand portfolio and asset optimization program now in progress, building on the considerable momentum the premium-focused brand lineup currently enjoys, and seeking ways to close important gaps in the portfolio. Most crucially, they will remain committed to the strategy we set out earlier for this business, which is now in its second year of implementation. It is very important to note that the centralized supply chain structure across Australia and New Zealand, together with the Treasury business solutions divisions, will serve as the primary service providers to these 3 portfolio divisions. They will capitalize on the substantial opportunities created by TWE's global scale and supply asset base, as well as our ongoing push for best-in-class process and service efficiency. Lastly, we believe this new operating model will only strengthen the existing core elements of the long-term Treasury Wine Estates business case — namely, the attractive category fundamentals across our key markets, the best portfolio of premium wine brands, winning route-to-market models that have no rival in the global wine industry, an unmatched asset base in key sourcing geographies, and a strong and flexible capital structure that will underpin continued investment to drive future growth.
Tim Ford
executiveRegarding the U.S. business. Our intention to create the future state premium U.S. wine business is still very much on track, and as a reminder, it reflects a 3-stage strategy that we initially announced last August. After these plans are implemented — and we continue to anticipate completion by the end of the first half of fiscal 2022 — the future state business will be achieved with roughly half the volume, earnings at a level similar to the first half of fiscal 2020 annualized, and substantial progress toward our original EBITS margin target of 25%. When it comes to divesting brands and assets, we are moving forward with the planned exit of a significant portion of the U.S. commercial brand portfolio. In addition, we are announcing today that we will be exploring further opportunities for rationalizing our brand, asset and lease portfolio as we keep prioritizing growth of our focused premium brand portfolio to drive future performance and growth in that region. Through these divestments and restructuring activities, we anticipate generating net cash inflows of at least $300 million, along with one-off write-downs of approximately $100 million, incurred primarily in relation to noncash intangible and lease assets.
Tim Ford
executiveIn addition, we have now put in place an incremental program aimed at lowering the dis-synergies and stranded costs within the U.S. supply chain that are anticipated once the portfolio exits are complete. Moving on to our global response plan, regarding the provisional measures announced in late November by the Chinese Ministry of Commerce as part of their investigations into imported Australian wine — and it's important to note these investigations remain ongoing. The key elements of our response are underway, and we expect financial benefits to begin being delivered in this fiscal half. First, by driving incremental growth across TWE's global priority markets. We've finished our detailed assessment of the key global markets for reallocation over the next 3 years, and our confidence is growing around plans to reallocate the Penfolds Bins and Icon range that had been destined for China into other markets. Accordingly, we now expect modest financial benefits to begin toward the end of this fiscal year. To support reallocation, we have also increased investment in the priority Penfolds growth markets of Asia, the United States and Australia, and we expect benefits from this investment to start being delivered from F '22 onwards. In addition, we are allocating incremental volumes from the upcoming 2021 vintage intake to the supply-constrained — or previously supply-constrained — Australian portfolio of brands, including Wynns, Wolf Blass, The Stag and Pepperjack, which is important for Treasury Premium Brands' future growth.
Tim Ford
executiveMaking changes to the business model in China is another crucial part of how we're responding, and right now we're developing plans to broaden the multi-country-of-origin and brand innovation pipeline in that market. That covers opportunities sourced from France, California, and potentially other countries of origin, and the benefits from these are likewise expected to start in F '22. In addition, we've finished detailed scenario work on alternative operating and supply chain models, and we'll be able to explore those once the MOFCOM investigation wraps up. Lastly, on the global operating model changes: we have rebalanced our 2021 Australian vintage intake, which has already started to come in line with what we expect future demand to be. This has concentrated mainly on the commercial and masstige intake and portfolios. We've also settled on cost base and overhead reductions for our China business spanning corporate and centralized functions, and net of reinvestment these will deliver annualized benefits of $10 million starting in F '22. We do plan to keep a meaningful presence in China going forward — not just to drive a number of the key initiatives under the response plan, such as growing the non-Australian country of origin portfolio, but also to maintain the important customer relationships we've built over many years and, very, very importantly, to preserve and protect the Penfolds brand's presence within the China market.
Tim Ford
executiveSo with that said, I'll turn things over to Matt, and he'll walk you through the financial results in greater detail.
Matt Young
executiveThank you, Tim, and good morning to all of you. As before, the breadth of our operations across sales regions, sourcing, and brand portfolios has meant we achieved an excellent earnings result and kept our balance sheet healthy, even with a difficult environment. Group net sales revenue fell 8.2% on a reported currency basis, or 5.9% at constant currency, driven by continuing disruption in key channels for luxury wine and by the effect of the MOFCOM investigations on volumes in Mainland China. This was offset by strong results in retail and e-commerce channels across the Americas, ANZ, and EMEA regions, consistent with our response plans. NSR per case dropped 2.8% at constant currency, driven by a masstige-led mix shift, with the luxury and masstige portfolios together now accounting for 75% of global NSR, up from 73% a year earlier. COGS per case rose 6.7% at constant currency, reflecting, first, the portfolio mix shift; second, higher COGS on Australian sourced commercial and masstige wine; third, the effect of inventory damaged by the Californian wildfires; and finally, one-off costs incurred in response to the changes in China, such as rework and logistics. Cost of doing business margin fell to 19.6%, driven by the organizational changes implemented in the U.S.
Matt Young
executiveDuring Q4 of the prior year, along with a rebalanced promotional investment across Asia and the U.S., EBITS fell 21.6% to $284.1 million, while the EBITS margin dropped to 20.1%. Lastly, ROCE was down 4.1 percentage points at 9.5%, which mirrors the reduced EBITS profile across the trailing 12 months, especially in the second half of fiscal '20. Within material items there are several significant amounts worth explaining, and I'll now walk through those. This half, total material item costs came to $60.5 million, or $45.6 million after tax. The principal factor concerns the divestment plan for U.S. brands and assets, which Tim described earlier. As noted, once the broader program is fully complete, we anticipate a net one-off loss of roughly $100 million, mostly tied to write-downs of intangibles and leased assets. That impact will be booked across fiscal '21 and '22, and we recognized $50.7 million in the half. The $50.7 million loss mainly consists of a write-down of commercial intangible brand values plus a provision against commercial inventories and other costs. Offset within that $50.7 million is a gain on the sale of a Napa-based vineyard, divested as part of the overall program.
Matt Young
executiveMore specifics on how those items break down can be found in Note 7 of the half year financial report. I'd like to say this clearly: asset write-downs are never something we decide casually. That said, moving toward the future state of our U.S. premium wine business is unquestionably the correct path for driving shareholder value. So we have to keep moving forward with the plan, since the benefits are already beginning to show, and Ben will walk you through that later. Also on shareholder value, we anticipate the broader program will deliver a net cash inflow of no less than $300 million — a significant factor we took into account when weighing it against the write-downs, which are mostly noncash. Turning to the balance sheet, it remains strong, flexible and efficient. I realize we mention this every 6 months, but once again, it has been a crucial strength that has let us navigate the continuing recovery from the pandemic and the rollout of a global response plan addressing the changes in China. That resilience amid major challenges is something we take enormous pride in. Net assets came in below the prior year, reflecting a reduction in working capital, mainly receivables and inventory.
Matt Young
executiveTrade receivables came down because of how sales were phased earlier in Asia. Two things drove that: the restock recovery early in the half, plus the MOFCOM investigation being introduced, and that affected purchasing patterns. Net borrowings also fell by $393 million, since stronger cash flow let us repay the U.S. private placement notes during this half. Now, looking more closely at inventory, it's down by $133 million to $2 billion at cost as of the end of December 2020. Inventory volumes overall are 18% lower than the prior comparable period, and the reason is the lower-yielding 2020 vintages in Australia and California alike. Current inventory has come down, which mirrors the short-term sales volume decrease we expected from luxury channel disruptions and from the MOFCOM provisional measures. Luxury inventory volumes fell 9% in total, reflecting those smaller 2020 vintages combined, partly offset by luxury inventory being retained on the balance sheet for release in future periods. Let me take a moment to confirm that we have closely reviewed our inventory positions, especially given the current shifts in trading conditions across all markets, Australia and China included. We've sensitized a range of different outcomes, conservative scenarios among them, and from a valuation perspective we remain very comfortable with our inventory position.
Matt Young
executiveWe also stay confident that our luxury and masstige inventory continues to be a source of future earnings growth. Now moving to cash flow and net debt. Operating cash flow before interest, tax and material items came in at $467.7 million, with cash conversion of 128.9%. If you exclude the change in noncurrent luxury and masstige inventory, cash conversion was 121%, which was above our target of 90%-plus, reflecting 2 major events in the year. Those were the impacts of the lower 2020 California vintage and earlier sales phasing in China. Operating cash flow performance outside these factors was excellent. That said, these 2 factors did play the primary role in the over delivery. We expect F '21 full year cash conversion to be in line with our cash conversion target. Turning to CapEx. Total CapEx for the first half was $68 million, of which growth CapEx was $38 million, including the investment in luxury winemaking infrastructure in South Australia and investments in e-commerce platforms and demand planning systems. The New South Australia luxury winery is on track to be operational in time for the 2022 vintage. And as you can see from the bottom of this page, referencing that red outlined section, it's a truly incredible facility from a sense of scale alone.
Matt Young
executiveI had the chance to visit the site just last month, and I came away amazed by what this investment will mean for TWE and for the industry. It also speaks volumes about the whole team, who put in hard work day after day to bring this fantastic project to life. For F '21, we expect CapEx of as much as $150 million, covering maintenance and replacement spending as well as ongoing business investment that supports future growth. We have managed our cash flow prudently, yet we stay committed to self-funded growth CapEx, which is essential to our strategy. Finally, on capital management: our capital structure still reflects an investment-grade credit profile. Leverage fell to 1.7x in the first half, driven by a $414 million reduction in net debt, putting us comfortably back inside our target of under 2x through the cycle. Looking ahead, we do expect leverage could rise modestly over the short term, but we are comfortable that we have a clear deleveraging path through both trading and inorganic opportunities, which will keep us below our 2x target certainly by F '22. As a result, we believe our balance sheet keeps its flexibility, in both the short and the long term. Our liquidity remains strong, with cash of $481 million and undrawn committed debt facilities of just over $1 billion spread across a well-diversified maturity portfolio at the end of December, giving total liquidity of more than $1.5 billion.
Matt Young
executiveThat robust liquidity gives us the ability to keep our long-term dividend policy in place, and today we have declared an interim dividend of $0.15 per share, fully franked, which comes to a payout of 62%. Thank you. I will now pass things over to Tom King in Shanghai, who will talk to you about the Asia region.
Tom King
executiveThanks, Matt, and good morning to all of you. Conditions differed across the various Asian markets, with channels in a mixed state and restrictions of differing severity weighing on consumption, especially in on-premise and travel-related channels. In China, the first half brought steady, progressive improvement, and by the end of that period channel operations were largely back to normal. On the consumer side, it was encouraging to witness robust consumption and demand for TWE's brands across Asia, China included. Even with external difficulties, our depletions growth in China stayed strong during the first half, and we likewise observed very encouraging momentum across several emerging regional markets — Malaysia, Thailand and Korea among them — which gives us added confidence about growth in those markets. For the Asia region in the first half, net sales revenue fell 18.1%, reflecting the effect of channel restrictions on luxury trading performance along with lower shipments to China after MOFCOM began its investigation in August, chiefly concerning commercial and masstige brands. A better mix within the portfolio, driven by demand for higher-end Penfolds Bins, partly offset the effect of lower regional volumes. That mix shift meant NSR per case rose 25.3% against the prior corresponding period. Cost of doing business was 11.3% better, helped by alignment of brand investments, service volumes and general cost management.
Tom King
executiveRegional EBITS came in at $127 million, with an EBITS margin of 38.2%. As we flagged back in November, we're now actively rolling out a global response plan after China brought in provisional measures. That involves putting money into sales and marketing capability so we can back distribution and availability across other key markets and channels, which supports the reallocation plans for the Penfolds Bins and Icon range. We're also bringing our brand investment and overheads into line with the revised volume expectations for the short to medium term. The early progress we've made gives us confidence in how Penfolds is being demanded in other markets. And, as Tim said earlier, we expect some benefits to show up from the Penfolds Bins and Icon range reallocation activity starting in the fourth quarter. Even with the impact of the MOFCOM measures, we'll keep working alongside our customers and partners to show our long-term commitment to our consumers and to the China market. It's abundantly clear that strong consumer appetite for our brands remains. Moving to brand highlights for the half. To mark Bin 389's 60th anniversary, Penfolds revealed a partnership with the Chinese luxury lifestyle brand Shang Xia, which extends the luxury credentials of the Penfolds brand and supports the Penfolds ambition of becoming a global luxury icon.
Tom King
executiveAcross Southeast Asia, we ran several activations centered on food and wine. The goal was to raise consumer awareness of wine as something that pairs well with traditional flavors in Asian cuisine, and to drive more consumption occasions. As part of that, Wolf Blass kicked off a Wok-Off campaign in Singapore, Malaysia and Indonesia, featuring an online cooking challenge with a celebrity chef. We also rolled out the Penfolds Meet Extraordinary digital campaign with Bin 389 in Singapore and Thailand, aimed at strengthening and amplifying Penfolds' positioning as a premium luxury brand throughout Asia. I'll now turn things over to Ben Dollard to talk through performance in the Americas region.
Ben Dollard
executiveThanks, Tom, and good afternoon to all of you, joining from California. It's great to be with you today. I'm genuinely happy about the strides we're making in the U.S. We keep putting money into our portfolio, concentrating on our priority premium brands, and that work is delivering results. While the task is far from finished, we're gaining confidence and building momentum in the business. Since I last spoke with you in August, the dynamics of the U.S. market have shifted. Throughout the COVID period, consumers have kept moving between channels—particularly retail and online outlets. Consumers are still trading up, with the $11 to $20 and above $20 price points in U.S. retail growing by 18% and 26%, respectively, in the 6 months to December. These dynamics gave us a favorable backdrop for our premium brand portfolio, which reinforces why this will be where our business focuses going forward. Although performance stayed strong in retail and e-commerce channels, our first half results were still affected by major disruptions to the key channels for luxury wine—namely on-premise, cellar door and travel retail—stemming from ongoing pandemic-related restrictions. Also, the California wildfires, which cut into cellar door traffic across the Napa Valley and Sonoma, along with the reopening of tasting rooms and the on-premise channels, will let us build further on our momentum.
Ben Dollard
executiveIn the Americas, first-half net sales revenue fell 7%, and that came from channel disruptions as well as the commercial volume cuts we've been making on purpose. Partly offsetting that was how we executed against our focus brands, and that produced positive results in retail and e-commerce, mainly from the masstige portfolio. Lower overheads stemming from the new organizational structure we put in place in June 2020, plus bringing our promotional spend in line with today's market dynamics, gave us original EBITS of $83.1 million and an EBITS margin of 15.5%. NSR and EBITS came back strongly from second half '20, which shows strong retail execution and how our brands resonate with consumers. Our focused premium brand portfolio keeps up its strong growth trajectory, beating the market materially with 31% value growth in the half, led by 19 Crimes, Matua, Beringer Brothers and St Huberts The Stag. What underpins these brands' performance is our emphasis on consumer-led innovation. 19 Crimes Cali Red's launch has been a tremendous success for us in the half. It's recognized as the most successful launch of a new brand in the category in 2020, with IRI scans more than 2x the next brand introduction.
Ben Dollard
executiveWe’re also really happy that 77% of Cali Red buyers had never tried the 19 Crimes brand before, and 20% of those consumers are new to wine overall. The response from both trade and consumers has been very encouraging. We keep putting investment behind our luxury portfolio, and distribution and velocity have both performed strongly. That focus will make sure our luxury brands are well placed as channels keep reopening. A few brand highlights from across the portfolio: launching 19 Crimes Cali Red with entertainment icon Snoop Dogg was a major success right from day 1. Augmented reality activations and solid consumer backing helped it become the #1 new wine innovation of 2020. We’re very excited to announce that Cali Rosé will launch in March, timed to the spring season. Within IRI channels, Beringer Brothers was up 37% in H1. That growth came partly from a partnership with the Country Music Association and from being the featured wine of choice for country star Kelsea Ballerini in her music video, which reached over 4.3 million views. Lastly, the first release of the Penfolds California collection in March will mark an important milestone for the brand in the U.S. Under Peter Gago’s leadership, the Penfolds winemakers have crafted a range of wines that showcase California’s best regional characteristics in a style that is distinctly Penfolds.
Ben Dollard
executiveThere's a lot of interest in this launch coming from our distributor and trade partners, and it will get backing through a strong media and marketing plan. I'm happy to share that the Somm Journal has given us our first 100-point score, for the inaugural vintage of Penfolds Quantum, which is the icon of the range. I'm confident we can build on these accomplishments and make 2021 a year to remember. I look forward to updating you on the successes of these activities at the end of the fiscal. Thank you. I'll now hand over to Peter Neilson in Melbourne.
Peter Neilson
executiveThanks, Ben, and good morning everyone. ANZ turned in a solid first-half result, powered by gains across our main luxury and masstige labels in retail and e-commerce. Yes, on-premise venues did reopen gradually over the half, but important sales channels such as cellar doors and travel retail are still feeling the effects of limits on people movement. In the ANZ region, NSR came in slightly under the prior comparative period, down 0.6%, while NSR per case rose 3%, which mirrors expansion in the luxury and masstige portfolios. COGS per case was up 9.7%, the result of the mix shift plus higher COGS on commercial wine sourced in Australia. We also took on some incremental costs tied to finished goods that had originally been meant for sale into the Chinese market. Cost of doing business rose as a result of long-term investment in e-commerce and planning systems. That produced regional EBITS of $75 million and a margin of 23.3%. Our choice to concentrate on fewer, bigger brands is delivering returns. Availability has improved and we're seeing robust growth right across our priority brand portfolio, with those brands together expanding at 2.5x the category in the half, led by 19 Crimes, Pepperjack, Wynns and Squealing Pig. We made deliberate calls to skip promotional programs, which drove some commercial volume decline but lifted the operating margin of the commercial portfolio.
Peter Neilson
executiveJust to briefly address how provisional measures or tariffs on Australian wine might affect that market. Right now, we aren't observing any shift in domestic sales activity or any downward pressure on pricing tied to these developments. That said, I'd point out it's too early to reach conclusions, since what will ultimately shape market dynamics is demand in other global markets along with the character of Australia's next vintage. So we'll keep watching it. Moving on to a few brand highlights. Squealing Pig remains the leader throughout the market, and this half we ran our biggest campaign ever, activated across media and retail channels. Squealing Pig is a strong illustration of product innovation designed to satisfy consumer needs across a range of consumption occasions, and our Prosecco and Sparkling Rosé have delivered enormous success, along with the recent addition of Ginsecco to the portfolio. 19 Crimes got off to an exceptional start in F '21, fueling category growth via new displays and NPD, with consumers demonstrating a love for this brand that echoes the exciting results we've seen from overseas. Another innovation win came from extending the Pepperjack portfolio into high-growth varietals.
Peter Neilson
executivePepperjack has held on to its #1 position for Australian Shiraz, and it has also moved into the #1 spot for Cab Sauv and for Malbec in the market. Those are only two of the recent wins we've recorded with our brands. A premium brand portfolio that puts the consumer first is a central element of our game plan, and right now we're delivering a step change in how we approach innovation. That's genuinely exciting, because the foundation we have to build from is fabulous. To sum up, I feel really proud of what we delivered in the first half. We've recorded some great achievements right across our brand portfolio and in how we execute at retail. I'll now pass things to Michelle Brampton, who will cover how we performed in Europe, Middle East and Africa.
Michelle Brampton
executiveThanks, Peter, and good morning to everyone, speaking from London. We've kept seeing excellent sales results through retail channels, and those have stayed very strong throughout the pandemic, particularly in the U.K. and the Nordics market. That performance shows our core strength when it comes to executing in retail channels, along with our growing brand portfolio, which keeps becoming more relevant to consumers as they increasingly choose well-known and trusted brands during the pandemic. We've worked really hard to serve our customers as well as we possibly can, and we've also concentrated on digital marketing to back online purchasing and the visibility of our brands. For the region, volume and NSR rose by 12.8% and 15.2%, respectively, driven by strong masstige portfolio performance in the U.K. channels and the Nordics. The biggest contributor to volume growth was 19 Crimes, with volumes up 150% across the region. And while that's largely driven by the U.K., the brand is now growing in every market outside of the U.K., and we're really excited about the future growth potential for the brand across the region. Blossom Hill also delivered solid volume growth, with strong brand equity helping the brand capitalize on the heightened demand in these retail channels. Wolf Blass and Lindeman's also delivered volume and value growth, and Lindeman's continues to be the #1 brand in the Netherlands and Sweden.
Michelle Brampton
executiveCost of goods sold for each case rose 10.2%, driven by a shift in portfolio mix along with increased costs for commercial wine sourced from Australia and the U.S. Higher expenses for running the business reflect first-half-weighted spending behind our focus brands, plus one-time overhead outlays tied to the Brexit transition, which was handled well. Because of these elevated costs, regional EBITS fell 26.5% to $25 million, with margin at 11.5%. Our target remains a mid-teens margin, though we note it will be affected in F '21 by the higher COGS I just described. Over the longer term, our portfolio is positioned well to capitalize on the premiumization trends we observe across key EMEA markets. Moving to some brand highlights for the first half. 19 Crimes kept accelerating, and it is now a top 20 brand in the U.K. A very strong Halloween campaign, spanning social media and in-store activity, produced a significant sales uplift. The Gin Fizz innovation under Blossom Hill has also succeeded, blurring category lines to create new consumption occasions, and we're eager to see results from the recent launch of a new flavor, Blood Orange. Lindeman's partnered with the Carbon Trust and earned certification as carbon neutral, a significant milestone on our sustainability journey as consumers increasingly make conscious consumption choices, whether through scrutiny of the end-to-end supply chain, packaging or health and wellness choices.
Michelle Brampton
executiveTo sum up, there's strong momentum for our brands across these markets. And we'll keep leveraging our portfolio to capitalize on premiumization trends in the market. Thanks, and I'll turn things back over to Tim.
Tim Ford
executiveThank you, everyone. Excellent work, team. To wrap up, then: the results we delivered in the first half of fiscal 2021 show how well we have carried out our COVID-19 Plan Ahead Agenda, and that is producing encouraging recovery momentum in every region where we operate — the growth rates for this half versus the second half of fiscal 2020, a period that the global pandemic also affected, make that clear. Going forward, we anticipate that trading conditions and our own results will stay broadly steady across each of our key markets during the second half, with China excluded. As for China in particular, we foresee only a minimal earnings contribution for as long as the provisional measures that MOFCOM put in place stay in force. That said, our confidence keeps growing regarding the reallocation plans for our Penfolds Bins and Icon range, and, as I mentioned before, we expect modest benefits to begin appearing near the end of the half. With all this in mind, EBITS for the second half of fiscal '21 should come in lower than the first half. Beyond the near-term picture, momentum behind our strategic agenda keeps gathering as we build the foundations for future growth and for delivering our Treasury Wine Estates 2025 game plan. Our new brand-led divisional operating model — Penfolds, Treasury Premium Bands (sic) Brands and Treasury Americas — will position the business for long-term success as a single stand-alone company, sharpening focus and accountability and, in turn, unlocking our growth potential across these distinct portfolios.
Tim Ford
executiveIn the U.S., we're still making headway on the major restructuring efforts that will bring us to the future-state premium wine business. And once the exit from our commercial brand portfolio is finished, that will mark a significant milestone. We'll also look into further rationalization across our asset and brand portfolios as we stay the course and keep prioritizing the premium brand portfolio to drive future performance and growth in that region. Implementation of our global response plan to the provisional measures put in place by MOFCOM is underway, and as I said, we expect the benefits to flow through as outlined in the presentation earlier. Importantly, the fundamentals of our diversified global business model remain strong, and I'm very, very confident that we'll keep supporting our execution going forward. We truly have the best global portfolio of premium wine brands, with strong market positions — I should say — an unrivaled global distribution footprint, a world-class asset base, a great team and a strong and flexible capital structure. And finally, I'm also pleased to let you know that we'll host an Investor Day on the 13th of May at The Hilton in Sydney. That will fall in the same week as our 10-year anniversary as a stand-alone company, as Treasury Wine Estates.
Tim Ford
executiveWe’re also eager to highlight both our leadership group and the people across our business, and to share additional material about how we’re approaching marketing through the consumer and experience lens, the execution priorities tied to strategy for our new portfolio divisions, and the ongoing advances in our sustainability and technology efforts, along with other related subjects. So thank you for being with us today. I’ll now pass things to the operator for questions, and we’d appreciate it if each person could ask one question and then rejoin the queue. We have plenty of time, and we’ll get through as many as we can. So thanks for listening. And now to questions.
Operator
operator<<operator_script>> The first question this morning is from David Errington.
David Errington
analystTim, may I pose a question about a business I haven't exactly been enamored with — namely the U.S.? You appear to have delivered quite a solid performance there. I realize it's one question per person, and this is likely a multi-part question, but looking at Slide 7, 25% of your sales avenue was closed — that's on-premise, cellar door, and travel. My belief is that probably represents 40% to 50% of your earnings. So as a result, you've had a genuinely strong first half in which your performance — you've delivered roughly $80 million. And you've got — you're clearing out the other stuff. And your comment is that you're only expecting effectively $200 million of EBIT. I'm somewhat surprised you aren't a bit more optimistic about the U.S. business, because now you're getting $300 million of cash in the bank. You're sort of like half of your channel was shut. On the profitability side, you've still managed to achieve some great results. You've been — I mean, the way Ben spoke, I was getting excited about the U.S. And yet when you said, "Oh, by the way, the outcome is just doubling what you did in first half '20," which means you're only targeting $200 million, that left me a little flat.
David Errington
analystCould you bring us up to speed on that a little? There seem to be plenty of positive developments there. You turned in a strong first-half result, especially considering your most profitable channels were closed. You're exiting the things that generate losses or whatever. You're getting $300 million and yet you're telling us to expect only $200 million. I just think that -- last time I said the dog ate your homework. It just seems that dog might still be hanging around, eating the homework, if you can only deliver $200 million after all the stuff you're doing.
Tim Ford
executiveThank you. Thanks, David, and good morning. So I think the best — I'll let Ben — I want Ben to spend a bit of time answering this as well, but I'll start with it. I guess, I'll go back to my response to your statement back in August where you did say around the dog, it was eating the homework on the U.S. business. And my response at the time is we need to prove over time that we can deliver on the strategy and the plans that we have in the U.S. business before there's going to be a level of trust, I'm sure, from investors and others around the ongoing performance. And I shouldn't — hopefully, my commentary has not tried to play down my belief in our U.S. business and our U.S. portfolio either because that certainly wasn't the intention. I think the progress the team have made has been outstanding in the environment they're operating in, and as you rightly say, with some of the channel disruptions that exist there. However, in saying that, we have delivered a good half. We've delivered on the strategic agenda. We've got a lot more work to do.
Tim Ford
executiveAs far as my own view goes, once we’ve delivered across multiple halfs and consecutives, that’s the point where I’ll definitely become more bullish about what lies ahead for that business. I have extremely strong conviction in what we’re doing in that market. And I speak with a lot of our distributor partners, in particular, quite often, and belief is building right through the chain within the U.S. business. But it’s a start, and the team have made a great start. But Ben, I’ll hand it to you to give a little more context and hopefully bring some excitement with your voice versus mine, I guess.
Ben Dollard
executiveSure. Thank you, David and Tim. So, the expectation is that as channels keep reopening — that shapes how we think about visits to our tasting rooms. We also consider the on-premise side, which is reopening to differing degrees around the country. Naturally, then, we believe our luxury business will have consumers again, and we'll see an uptick in that business. That will take place gradually, since there isn't a single fixed date when everything reopens. So we're thoroughly ready for the moment it happens. And we've laid out — put in place many strong plans as the market begins to reopen. But I'd add that we've observed a shift away from those channels toward retail, and that is precisely the momentum visible in our business. We expect that to persist, along with the move toward more online and e-commerce-related platforms. But look, as Tim mentioned, we're building momentum. We're building confidence. The engagement and planning we have with wholesale partners throughout the U.S., and with our retail partners too, I believe has good depth and is very forward-looking when it comes to growth.
Ben Dollard
executiveEven so, plenty of work remains ahead of us. Where our core wines are concerned, the strategy's focus is quite clear.
David Errington
analystThe outlook is simply favorable. It appears considerably more encouraging.
Matt Young
executiveApologies — I realize I shouldn't lean too heavily on what the team has already covered. Still, let me make one thing clear about your point: that roughly $200 million you worked backward to against the pro forma — that figure is the pro forma target. To repeat, it's the fresh starting point for growth. So I'd ask you not to read the $200 million as either the goal or a ceiling. It is simply the baseline this team and this business will build from, drawing on the focused priority brands they are executing on right now.
David Errington
analystAlright. Alright. Alright. And at what point does that $300 million factor in?
Matt Young
executiveThat $300 million is going to be spread across the plan. So our aim is to finish the program within this calendar year.
Operator
operatorOur following question this afternoon is from Shaun Cousins, who is calling in on the JPMorgan line.
Shaun Cousins
analystOne question about the way you're redirecting wine that used to head to China, especially at the luxury end. Could you say a bit about how you're viewing Hong Kong and how significant it will be as a market? I'm aware of the very strong luxury wine export figures for December on a value basis. Are you aiming to reach China through Hong Kong? I'm just curious whether you could explain the part Hong Kong plays. And please explain that December movement as well.
Tim Ford
executiveAbsolutely, and thank you, Shaun. Let me begin with the reallocation process and how we're approaching it, if that works. Then I'll address the question specifically about Hong Kong. I think this gives me a chance to offer a fuller answer on the work we've completed over the last couple of months, because it's important that everyone understands our approach here and how it supports the statements we've made today. That growing confidence stems from a couple of areas. The first is engagement with our customers in these markets — markets where we plan to boost investment, sharpen our own focus, and direct more luxury wine, something we haven't had the opportunity to do before. Through those discussions and the work we've done, we've also come to understand the current distribution footprint and the focused outlet universe — where Penfolds is present today in those markets and where it isn't. That also means understanding the desire for the brands in these markets and the awareness that already exists, because it's important to state — and I assume everybody understands this — that these are not new markets.
Tim Ford
executiveThose aren't market entry strategies in our case. In most of these markets, we've had a presence for a very long time. It's just that we haven't had the wine available to allocate. So what we're doing is building on a platform, and that platform is a genuinely strong advantage we hold right across our business. And it differs from region to region, which is what gives us this confidence. Take Asia, for instance: pure growth of distribution and availability, backed by greater investment in that activation with people, within our teams, in those markets, engaging those accounts alongside our partners, will build distribution within those particular account universes. So that's the focus, if you like, in markets such as Asia, and also the opportunity that exists here in Australia, particularly in our independent retail and on-premise channels within this market, where we have a significant opportunity to increase distribution. The U.S. is different. And again, why it gives us confidence — the U.S. is the dynamics that we're building the Penfolds brand for the long term is the way I look at the U.S., and I know the way Ben and the team look at the U.S. It's still about distribution and availability. And you're going to get bored of me talking about distribution availability and velocity, as Ben put it as well, but that is the key to the success around this reallocation.
Tim Ford
executiveWe need to put money into raising brand awareness in the U.S., and the launch of the Californian collection — which is hitting the market right now — is a two-pronged attack together with the U.S., and our luxury selling team is being treated as our biggest new product development, or innovation go-to-market, anywhere in the world in the U.S. during this coming half, which is fantastic. So that's the difference. And if you look at how our Penfolds distribution in the U.S. compares — whether Californian, which clearly hasn't been distributed yet, or the Australian portfolio — against our luxury brands like Beringer, Stags' Leap, BV, that gap is significant. So as our selling team and our luxury sales focus begin to build that, we see the opportunity there. So that's the way we're going about driving where the opportunity lies for reallocating the Penfolds portfolio that had been destined for China. I think, hopefully, it also explains to you that while we say this isn't going to happen overnight — because it's a week-in, week-out, month-on-month build that will take us time — that's the method we use. And I always tell our teams internally that it's about how we do this, and the outcome will take care of itself.
Tim Ford
executiveSo that's the approach we intend to take. And even though providing exact specifics is hard—though many of you would appreciate that—regarding the timing, the financial consequences, and when the reallocation would happen. So that's a comprehensive response, but I believe it's a crucial one so you can grasp precisely how we're approaching this. As for your separate question about Hong Kong. Going forward, Hong Kong is a market of focus for us. There's no doubt about that when it comes to future growth across the various channels present there. The -- I'll begin by restating something I know we've said previously, which is that it's extremely important not to take Wine Australia data points and view them as a reflection of Treasury Wine Estates' performance or of what we've actually shipped out of Australia. So it's hard for me to speak to the overall Wine Australia data since we're merely one part of it. But as I mentioned, Hong Kong will be a focused market for us. Yet also given the market dislocation we've observed, and I'll get to the point of -- you didn't ask this, but I'm going to address it because I know it underlies the question.
Tim Ford
executiveCross-border parallel importing of our product is an area we watch extremely carefully. It matters a great deal to us — for brand health, for how we handle pricing, and for the way we actually run the business moving forward. Given how the dynamics have changed around the China investigation, the likelihood of this occurring has clearly gone up. So Tom, the team in China, and the broader Asian team are sharply focused on it, and we keep working alongside our customers — people we have now dealt with for several years. I believe we have gotten fairly adept at figuring out where inventory finishes up in different markets and at knowing where the real brand sits and what the price points are. I know plenty of companies run extensive market surveys, and I think the progress in how we have handled this is visible. Still, we have to keep watching and managing it for the long-term health of the Penfolds brand. So I think I have addressed the 2 questions, Shaun, and perhaps tossed in a third that — I realize it was underlying what you asked. Does that cover what you were looking for?
Shaun Cousins
analystYeah, so let me just make sure this is crystal clear. You aren't aiming to use Hong Kong as a route to reach China. Hong Kong really is — anything shipped to Hong Kong is a market we're focused on purely because of demand within Hong Kong itself, not as a way to grow into China?
Tim Ford
executiveCorrect—we'll develop brands in those markets using the consumer programs that we currently have.
Operator
operatorOur following question this afternoon is from Larry Gandler, who is calling in on the Crédit Suisse line.
Larry Gandler
analystI suppose I'd like to get a bit more detail on reallocation samples. I realize you folks are growing more confident. That also implies perhaps you can assist us in pinning down what the job before us actually is. And that's a matter we analysts were wrestling with around the time of the MOFCOM announcement. So perhaps you can help us truly get a grip on what reallocation entails, maybe volumes of sales that have to be shifted from one place to another.
Matt Young
executiveMatt here, Larry. Back in November, when we discussed the announcement, we attempted to convey how big the challenge is — in terms of the size of that business and the luxury and iconic bin range that had to be reallocated at this point. And my recollection is that accounted for roughly 25% of the portfolio we are selling. Converting that into figures and values is somewhat hard for us right now. Our feeling remains that the plans we have established will be developed across those 3 years. What I will say is we are not yet confident enough to declare that everything is fixed within 3 years, but the plans will be there, and we will do all we can to get there. So I realize that does not give you precisely what you need, but hopefully it provides a sense of where — how you should think about the work we are getting through. But the — I mean, what we have shared today clearly provides a really good line of sight into the levers available to us. So the reallocation plan, moving wine into other brands, and our capacity to carry that inventory forward into future years are all strengths of ours and plans we are well practiced at delivering.
Matt Young
executiveThat is partly why we keep feeling confident about those plans.
Larry Gandler
analystPerhaps that ties in with this as well. Could you explain what is really going on right now in China when it comes to how brands are performing? Could you give us a sense of it — are prices rising there because supply is scarce? And on top of that, how do you keep those ties with customers intact? You mentioned you were working on that.
Tim Ford
executiveAbsolutely, and that is a genuinely crucial question. I’ll pass it directly over to Tom. Since he handles this on a daily basis, he is in the best position to give you the detail.
Tom King
executiveYes. Thank you, Tim, and thank you, Larry. Look, I think the main takeaway is that demand for our brands, along with how consumers feel about them, is still strong. Obviously, right now, we have less inventory in the market than we'd typically want. But our priority was making sure we felt confident that product would be available for consumers across the portfolio during the whole of Chinese New Year. Depletion performance during the festive season will probably be affected by COVID-related limits on travel and gatherings in parts of the country. That said, we've begun to see some of our customers in certain channels raising prices over the past couple of months so they can keep availability up, minimize their out of stocks and manage their own cash flow. On top of that, we're clearly working with our existing customer base to support how our brands are executed in the market. That covers our brand protection work, which continues. And then, as we discussed today, we have the Penfolds California collection launching in China in H2, and we're seeing strong demand for it. And looking further ahead at the same time, there's strong appetite and demand for the Penfolds French portfolio, and we're continuing to develop that at pace.
Tom King
executiveAnd so yes, prices are rising, and I'm sure you've noticed that in your own market surveys too. But that comes down to inventory being low and our customers wanting to keep availability up while managing their cash flow.
Larry Gandler
analystTom, how are you actually going to produce small EBITS—or, as I think you put it, minimal EBITS? Given the fixed cost base you have there, have you reduced those fixed costs enough that you can genuinely turn a profit in China?
Tom King
executiveYes, look, we've already taken steps to cut back and control the cost base we're carrying, and that applies across the various lines of the P&L, whether that means shifting brand investment around within the region or keeping our overall fixed cost base in check. Look, at this point, I think it's worth remembering that these are only temporary measures, and we haven't given up on China. So we stay committed to our consumers in the China market and to our customers, and keeping a team here matters a great deal to us as we execute our response planning in H2 and look ahead to F '22 and beyond.
Operator
operatorThe next question we have today is from Richard Barwick, who's on the line from CLSA.
Richard Barwick
analystI'd like to ask about slide -- Page 12 of the press, regarding the $300 million of net cash inflows. Obviously, that is, to some degree, referring to the expectation that you can actually divest part of the commercial brand portfolio. What else would -- is included within the $300 million? And just to clarify, Matt, did you say that $300 million you're expecting that across calendar '21?
Matt Young
executiveI'll take that question. Thanks, Richard. So the broader $300 million figure comes about because of asset and brand divestments. I'd point out that we have already booked $50 million of that amount in the results so far, through selling a vineyard. That $50 million therefore does form part of the total. As for the remaining transactions, we're aiming to finish them — if things go according to our plan of wrapping up by the first half of fiscal '22, then we'd anticipate the rest being done this year. What I think sits behind your question is whether we have confidence around that level. Our plans have moved forward, and we do feel confident that the broader program is on track, yes. So yes — we still expect that cash flow to come in across this calendar year, and that remains the right time line.
Richard Barwick
analystYou're also cutting back on commercial volumes, though, Matt. Does that in fact undercut the worth of what you're divesting, or the chance to divest it?
Matt Young
executiveAt this point, no. Given the plans we're working through, how we're executing them, and the possible parties we might get involved with, we still see opportunity. And the — and I'd say the values that we — we won't be greedy, and we've mentioned this previously, this isn't new information. We won't be greedy when it comes to recovering value from these. We are — but we'll be patient and make certain that the outcome we deliver gives shareholders a better result than keeping the brands running.
Operator
operatorThe next question we have today is from Ross Curran at Macquarie.
Ross Curran
analystI was just curious whether you might be able to discuss what competition looks like right now. Are you noticing — or how are your talks with distributors proceeding, given that many Australian wine producers will have been shut out of the Chinese market and additional volumes are coming back, being retained in the domestic market? But taking a wider view, how are you thinking about the way competitive dynamics develop?
Tim Ford
executiveYes, Ross. Look, I think I can add a little more detail to what Pete said in his remarks earlier. I suppose we are watching this quite carefully in the current market. And just to be clear, I take it you mean more the Australian market, correct, when it comes to the customer base here and the pricing dynamics and the effects on margin, yes?
Ross Curran
analystYes. Absolutely.
Tim Ford
executiveAt this point, we honestly haven't encountered meaningful pressure on sales or on margins. Put another way, we're clearing inventory at reduced costs to soften the effects of shifts caused by Chinese demand. I think the important context there is roughly — let's say 10% of wine made in Australia went to China each year, and around 75% of that was closer to the commercial end when you look at volume. So I think — and the reason I bring that up is that as we head into this vintage, there are — I'm certain other businesses exist that I can't speak to, but what I know we've done is adjust our intake so it matches the demand we expect ahead, making sure inventory levels are appropriate, which then removes any need to shift wine held inside our own network at a discounted price. That will show up in pricing across the commercial-grade market, bulk wine and so on, which we're already beginning to observe as a decrease, and potentially also with growers, where fruit isn't being taken from them, which, as I laid out during the MOFCOM investigation announcements, was among the difficulties our industry has to confront.
Tim Ford
executiveOn balance, then, if that kind of pricing pressure does materialize, it would more probably come in May or June, once the vintage has been assessed and the vintage period is finished. That said, there's a counterpoint, and it's a favourable one: right now, during the pandemic, the U.K. market — as our results showed, which Michelle referred to earlier, and which hold broadly across that market — the Australian commercial wine segment in the U.K. is, well, it's certainly enjoying one of the stronger volume stretches it has seen in a very long time. So that is in fact offsetting a great deal of the supply, because demand out of Europe and the U.K. has risen over that period. So that's a supportive element, and in my view it's contributing to there being no margin compression or sales at reduced prices in the market right now. What our customers tell us lines up with that as well.
Operator
operatorThe next question you have today is from Craig Woolford, who is calling in from Citi.
Craig Woolford
analystTim and team, I just wanted to dig into your confidence regarding the reallocation of China wines, which is quite encouraging. First, I want to get a handle on the Asia EBITS contribution in November and December. Last year there was a release of $75 million of EBITS for the first 4 months. The run rate in November and December is actually higher. So if you could clarify that. And is that why you're confident about reallocation as you exit FY '21?
Matt Young
executiveCraig, this is Matt, and I can take that question. Yes, we did share this at the time — it was 4 months. The announcements, I believe, came at the end of that fifth month. So as you can imagine, we kept trading in that market, especially selling product in for the lead-in to the gift-giving season. We also recognize that some product was most of the way through our outbound process at our warehouse there and wasn't subject to tariffs. Those volumes kept moving and were able to reach the market in December. So that's the main driver, I suppose, from a China perspective. So there were still earnings from China in that market, albeit under pre-tariff conditions.
Craig Woolford
analystGot it. And on that confidence around reallocation — is it purely the order volumes you've been hearing about from customers in other markets? Or does something else underpin that confidence?
Tim Ford
executiveNo. I think if we go back to what I laid out earlier — I suppose I’ve recapped many of the points I attempted to make before — it comes down to our discussions with customers and how they see the future. What I mean is, with every one of these customers, we put together multiyear business plans, and those shape our investment plans, and those in turn shape how we allocate those wines. As we keep working through it — and we’re 2 months into that engagement process now — it may feel like a long time ago, but these announcements were made only 2 months ago. That is what gives us that confidence as we develop it, as we look at the distribution opportunity, and as we come to understand the awareness that exists in each market, especially for a brand like Penfolds in that market. So that’s — they’re not — it’s difficult to put numbers around those, Craig. I appreciate that. But I suppose that’s why I’m trying to give you the color of the methodology we’re going through here, because it does give us that confidence, and that is the most important aspect.
Operator
operatorOur following question this afternoon is from Phil Kimber, who is calling in on behalf of Evans & Partners.
Phil Kimber
analystI raised that question in the ASX release, not in the presentation. You did give Mainland China earnings. I'm looking at $124.2 million for the first half of '20, which wasn't affected by COVID. Does the Mainland China business have much seasonality? Or is that a solid business — a solid guide for us when thinking about what the actual pre-COVID earnings contribution from China was?
Matt Young
executiveThere are a couple of things at play in the Mainland China numbers. First, the MOFCOM investigation that was announced in August did have an effect on the organization — and I suppose on our non-Penfolds opportunity from that point onward, because of the risk that potential tariffs could land. Then, basically starting in November, there was the effect on Penfolds volumes and luxury volumes, and so on. So that piece matters. I think I've already touched a bit on the dynamics we observed. We did see earlier sales — I suppose some phasing — within China and Asia this year. And especially over the last couple of months, there were still some volumes that went out, potentially even after the provisional measures were announced, since they had moved far enough along in our process that the tariffs wouldn't hit them. As for the first part of your question — whether there's some seasonality — yes, there generally is some seasonality in the China market and in the Asia market more broadly. That typically comes in the lead-up to the gift-giving season. So we sell a reasonable amount of our product into the market so that it lands in time for those markets as well. That said, to give you some direction, that phasing is fairly consistent across Asia. So if you're trying to understand that balance, the Asia results we've previously delivered should give you a reasonable steer on it.
Phil Kimber
analystOkay, and apologies — I want to make sure we're clear that I meant the first half of '20, not the first half of '21. So that $124 million of EBITS came well before there were any COVID or MOFCOM problems. I suppose what I was asking is whether that figure is the guidance, a typical guide, and whether there's anything unusual in it, just so we can understand what the actual Mainland China EBIT is. Then from there we can form our own view of how much you could claw back from the redistribution of wine that you've mentioned. But I mainly wanted to establish the baseline first — what the earnings were — because I think you've only ever provided sales, not earnings.
Matt Young
executiveRight, I hear you. That’s a fair baseline. It wasn’t affected by COVID, it wasn’t affected by MOFCOM, and during that stretch it was on a sensible growth path. So yes, the one thing to factor into how you’re looking at it is that growth path from — within that market.
Phil Kimber
analystAll right. As for seasonality—the point you raised—should we look at Asia as a reference?
Matt Young
executiveAbsolutely.
Operator
operatorThe next question we have today is from Michael Simotas, who is with Jefferies.
Michael Simotas
analystI have one question about the new organizational structure. It's obviously brand-led. How do the sales organization and the supply organization fit around that? I suppose the Americas are fairly straightforward, but I'd be interested to see whether there will be any change in the approach to bundling and cross-selling, and also to procurement of product, given the overlap in the supply chain.
Tim Ford
executiveAbsolutely, Michael — I appreciate the question. I'll take the first one. That distinct emphasis on the sales and marketing operations, so to speak, inside these portfolios is definitely among the major shifts we will be implementing throughout the company — it creates that distinct emphasis, creates distinct margin tracking, and creates distinct tracking of growth targets along with the initiatives meant to propel those portfolios. So separation will exist across the globe. On the supply chain side, the rationale for keeping what I would describe as the ANZ supply operation, together with the Treasury business solutions function and division inside our company, is that those procurement opportunities exist — you mentioned one of them, but there are many throughout — where the advantages of the global operation, the collective strength and scale we possess, and our capacity to generate efficiencies are, in our view, considerably greater within that centralized setup, serving the 3 portfolio divisions. So that is definitely the structure we're establishing going forward. Yet with separation across sales, marketing, finance, strategy, P&C, and every other function that these centralized 2 divisions will support. The U.S. piece, as you correctly note, supply within the U.S.
Tim Ford
executiveWhen you look at this business, since a big part of it is self-supplying and selling into its own market, what it really does is give Ben Dollard and his team end-to-end accountability to push the margin expansion agenda and make sure the U.S. asset base and supply chain line up 100% with the commercial agenda across the business. So hopefully that clears up those dynamics. I mean, I'm sure plenty of questions will come up about how this operating model will actually function. And that was among the main reasons, Michael, we chose to hold the Investor Day in May, because it gives us a great chance to really dig into the specifics of the strategies that will drive growth in these portfolio businesses, since otherwise it can end up buried in a broader announcement — that's the intent behind that May day as well. So we're looking forward to sharing more detail then too. But hopefully I've answered your question well.
Michael Simotas
analystYeah, that does help. But can I get one point clarified? I just want to be sure about how sales and marketing are being split. Take the premium brand business — will it still be able to draw on the Penfolds brands when it sells into market? Or is it now fully separated, meaning that no longer happens?
Tim Ford
executiveTreasury Premium Brands is going to be fully carved out from them. I may ask Pete to say a few words on that, wearing both his current ANZ role and his upcoming Treasury Premium Brands role, since I believe there's a perception out there about the leverage Penfolds gets in certain markets worldwide. But it will be entirely separate. There will be 2 distinct conversations. There will be a distinct growth plan. There will be a distinct customer business plan for those portfolios throughout the organization. Pete, perhaps you'd like to add some color there?
Peter Neilson
executiveYes, Tim. Michael, a few points from me. First, in both ANZ and Europe, we haven't seen any portfolio selling in those markets. So for the business we have today, there's no dependence on leaning on Penfolds, as you put it, in either of those markets. What we have is sustainable, self-sufficient and stands on its own. What we've done across Asia over the last couple of years is actually build a more focused portfolio, with customers less reliant on Penfolds to establish and grow that business. We have fewer brands that retailers are depleting, enjoying, and standing on their own two feet in that market. So we don't expect to need Penfolds' leverage to keep growing that business in that market. And as I said with ANZ and Europe, we're very much self-sufficient without the Penfolds brand in those markets.
Operator
operatorBen Gilbert from Jarden is up next with a question.
Ben Gilbert
analystRegarding those results — they were really robust compared with what had been expected. I just wanted to get a handle on selling expenses, since the drop there is fairly substantial. And to follow up on what Craig mentioned about China, where the run rate seemed somewhat improved: did that mean you didn't need to spend as heavily on selling? I'm simply trying to work out whether that decrease in selling expenses is sustainable, or whether it was just a swift move to keep costs in check.
Matt Young
executiveBen, it's Matt. What you're mainly seeing there comes from adjustments we implemented in the U.S. business during last year's fourth quarter. So we reorganized the sales and marketing organization broadly speaking — a team with tighter focus, partly along the path toward where this business is headed — but with distinct luxury teams, distinct distribution and management teams, and a more focused portfolio, which produced a step change in our old model there. So that is what you're seeing as the primary year-on-year shift in selling costs.
Ben Gilbert
analystRight. So should we view that as kind of a lasting baseline? And the outliers as a few of the COVID problems fading?
Matt Young
executiveYou've got it.
Operator
operatorThe following question is from Glenda Korporaal, who is on the line with The Australian.
Glenda Korporaal
unknownGlenda Korporaal here. Just to check — can you sell any wines at all now out of Australia, maybe bulk wines? Is anything moving through the warehouse? And what's the situation with the baijiu brand, that brand of wine and Chinese baijiu? Then, over time, if we look at Penfolds Grange — if Penfolds Grange is sold in China, would that be fake? Obviously, supplies are coming from Australia. But at what point will Australian wine in China run out? Or can you get any wine through in a bulk sense or from other areas?
Tim Ford
executiveThanks, Glenda. It's good to hear from you. I'll address the final portion of your question, and then pass things to Tom to discuss how we see sales in China developing going forward. You raised a really important point about why we must keep our presence in China, and our team there, on certain critical matters — especially for the long-term health of the Penfolds brand. We run a very robust program focused on managing the IP and the brands we hold in that market, and we will keep going — yes, it comes at a cost, but we'll keep bearing that cost so that we can keep cooperating with the authorities in China, which we have now done for a number of years, to try to shut down these counterfeit wines and counterfeit labels, and so on. And we've received great backing from all of the authorities in China in that effort. So that work has to carry on. As for future supply of Grange into that market, well, again, that's an ongoing investigation. So at the current tariff levels, future demand for it and willingness to pay a price in China really remains to be determined, Glenda, from that standpoint.
Tim Ford
executiveAnd I'd suggest that once the investigation wraps up, we'll really get a sense of what the market dynamics would look like. But Tom, would you like to add something on the questions about what we can sell and are selling, and also on the Lot. 518 question?
Tom King
executiveRight, absolutely. The temporary measures currently in effect apply solely to still wine. That means our special Penfolds bottling lineup — Lot 518 and Lot 618, the baijiu-infused fortified wines — sits outside the scope of the investigation, much like the Penfolds brandy ranges do. As a result, those products can still be cleared in the usual way. And as I mentioned earlier, looking ahead to the second half, we will be introducing the California collection — the Penfolds California collection — into China. So we intend to keep up a presence and visibility for the Penfolds brand in that market, backing those products with activity. And to Tim's point, we are absolutely keeping the dedicated team we have here, which works across all of our brand protection initiatives as a priority.
Tim Ford
executiveOne more point I want to mention: with the future operating model involving Penfolds and Tom stepping into the leadership position at Penfolds, you may be thinking that there wasn't much cost involved simply from remaining in China. Tom and several members of his future leadership group will stay based in Shanghai, since, as I believe he mentioned earlier, we are not abandoning China at this stage. The investigation is still ongoing. Beyond that, many of the most talented people in our business are part of our Shanghai and China operations, and they will take on key roles within the future Penfolds leadership team as we move forward under the new operating model. So yes, the remit will potentially be wider than China alone, and I won't walk through the specifics of all the structures at this moment, but I think that provides important context as we make the transition to these changes in our internal operating model. So hopefully we've addressed all of your questions, and you gave me the opportunity to add one more, Glenda. Thanks for that.
Operator
operatorOur following question this afternoon is from Jason Palmer at Taylor Collison.
Jason Palmer
analystI’d like to ask just one question, if I may, about the supply side. Matt, I know you mentioned at the close of fiscal ’20 that there were COGS headwinds in Australia—especially for masstige and commercial. So my question is: now that we’re beginning to see some meaningful price declines, particularly in commercial reds, which clearly flow into 19 Crimes globally, could you discuss perhaps the size of potential COGS benefits that might come through or reverse in FY ’22, if you’re able? And second, regarding the smaller U.S. vintage, since you rely heavily on leased and owned vineyard for the premium end of the portfolio, what level of COGS pressure might you start to experience there, and what’s the timing around that?
Matt Young
executiveThanks, Jason. At this point in the vintage, it's a bit soon to be putting out, I suppose, directional figures. When we spoke last summer, I believe we were near the close of the fiscal year, so we're somewhat removed from that now. Still, to, I suppose, address your point, we see growing optimism regarding COGS over the longer term. So obviously, certain historical drivers—major events, water availability, the general industry balance—have created pressure. We've been putting a lot of effort into that. There's no dog-ate-your-homework mindset here on that. We've run major programs of work across a number of years. The program around driving COGS down by $50 million plus. And on Kerrin's behalf, I will emphasize the plus, driving a sustainability strategy to make sure we are balanced. But also, we are better placed than most companies to manage through it. But in terms of, I suppose, my comment around reason for optimism. So it is early to predict, but we are seeing a return to more normal vintage sizes in Australia. Water prices and conditions are normalizing. And as you say, as Tim sort of alluded to earlier, in terms of volumes in the Australian production market that will help, we think, in the long term.
Matt Young
executiveAnd our big work programs are now paying off, and we stay confident about those targets across the period. And look, the only other item I'd mention is the future operating model. We're hopeful that we could — given how we're structuring accountability and focus, we think we can keep improving. So when I think about sales and marketing accountability and focus sitting inside Treasury Premium Brands and Penfolds, where they spot the consumer need, whether that's price point, varietal product, with supply focused on producing that product at the right price, we think that will push different thinking and operating approaches than what we have today, to unlock opportunities around cost and asset base. So we view that as another opportunity, through that focus and accountability, to deliver an improvement. On the U.S. initially, it's a bit early today until the broader vintage is, I guess, balanced and, I guess, allocated within our process, for us to give a sense of it. Certainly, the vintage is down versus prior years. But we'll have more to, I guess, update once we have a better sense of that allocation process.
Jason Palmer
analystAll right, so is it possible that certain positives and certain negatives are canceling one another out?
Matt Young
executiveThe rationale behind our growing confidence.
Operator
operatorAt this point, no more questions remain on the line. Now I'd like to return the conference to today's presenters so they can offer their closing remarks.
Tim Ford
executiveAll right, thank you. And thanks to everyone for being here today. That was quite a bit to get through. I really am looking forward to speaking with a number of you on the call over the coming couple of weeks, and I appreciate your support. So we're right on schedule. I know today is a busy day for many people. So thank you very much. Cheers.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Treasury Wine Estates Limited transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Treasury Wine Estates Limited earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Treasury Wine Estates Limited or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.