Treasury Wine Estates Limited (TWE) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
August 19, 2021
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Company Representatives
unknownJoining us on the call today are Tim Ford, our Chief Executive Officer; Matt Young, our Chief Financial Officer; Tom King, Managing Director of Penfolds; Ben Dollard, President of Treasury Americas; and Pete Neilson, Managing Director of Treasury Premium Brands, or TPB.
Operator
operatorHello, and thanks for holding. You’re welcome to the Treasury Wine Estates FY ’21 Full Year Results Conference Call. Right now, everyone attending is in listen-only mode. <<operator_script>>. Please note that today’s conference, Thursday, 19 August, 2021, is being recorded. I’ll now pass the conference to your speaker, Tim Ford, Chief Executive Officer of TWE. Thank you. Over to you.
Tim Ford
executiveMorning, everyone, and thanks for being here for the Treasury Wine Estates 2021 full year results briefing. As a mark of reconciliation, Treasury Wine Estates recognizes the traditional owners of country across Australia and the ties they hold to land, sea and community. We honor their elders both past and present, and we extend that honor to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Island people with us today. I'm really pleased to be joined on today's call by these members of the leadership team: Matt Young, our CFO; Tom King, Managing Director of Penfolds; Ben Dollard, President of Treasury Americas; and Pete Neilson, Managing Director of the Treasury Premium Brands, or TPB as I'm sure you'll hear us call it today. Because our Investor Day was held so recently in May, today's presentation and commentary will center on our FY '21 results and performance, along with some additional and new proof points that highlight how we are progressing in delivering on our TWE 2025 game plan and financial ambitions. First, I'll give a summary of the FY '21 financial highlights, which reflect strong execution and trading performance around the globe. Reported net sales revenue fell by 3%; however, on an organic basis, which strips out the impact of currency and the U.S.
Tim Ford
executiveRevenue rose 4.4% after the commercial brands were divested in March. That top-line growth was driven by a $10 to $30 Premium portfolio, with strong results from several of our priority brands across the Americas, Europe and Australia. What pleased us most about this sales mix in FY ’21 was the 6 percentage point gain in the Luxury and Premium portfolio’s contribution to our global NSR, which now stands at 77%. EBITS came in at $510 million, essentially in line with FY ‘20, and the EBITS margin improved 0.6 percentage points to 19.9%, reflecting both our top-line performance and a better cost of doing business, particularly in the Americas and Asia. We are especially happy with this result given that the EBITS contribution of Mainland China fell $77 million during the year. Cash flow was very strong once again, with a 101% cash conversion outcome, helped by the smaller 2020 California vintage intake, the adjusted 2021 Australian vintage, and the shift in our regional sales mix in China. Net debt fell by $376 million, aided in part by favorable currency movement, which drove a significant improvement in our leverage ratio to 1.6x, down from 2.1x at the end of fiscal ‘20.
Tim Ford
executiveMaintaining a capital structure that is both flexible and efficient through a year marked by major disruption demonstrates what has been, and will keep being, a core strength for Treasury Wine Estates — one that will keep underpinning how we perform, what we invest, and how we grow, far into the future. Lastly, the Board declared a fully franked dividend of $0.13 per share, up 62.5% on the final F20 dividend, which brings the full year dividend to $.28 per share. That represents a payout ratio of 65% of impact, consistent with our long term dividend policy. Turning to how we performed across our regions, I especially want to call out and acknowledge the ongoing positive trajectory of our business in the Americas, which delivered substantial growth in EBITS and EBITS margin as well as NSR growth on an organic basis. H2 growth was also extremely strong throughout our Asian markets outside of Mainland China, and it reflects the initial success in half two of our Penfolds Luxury portfolio in satisfying previously unmet demand, along with the early benefits from the investment we are making in brand building and sales and marketing capability, which sets a fantastic foundation to support future growth across that region.
Tim Ford
executiveJust like every company worldwide, our fiscal ’21 results came in while the pandemic’s effects were still being felt. In each of our markets, the important sales channels are still at differing stages of impact and recovery. As this slide shows — an updated version of the snapshot we gave at the first half results — retail and e-commerce channels performed strongly all year, though growth has moderated somewhat recently as restrictions have loosened in markets including the U.K. and the USA, and we began lapping the pantry loading activity from the start of the pandemic in 2020. Yet at the same time, we’ve observed more favorable trends appearing in the key sales channels for higher margin luxury wine. In Asia, major disruption to these key luxury sales channels persists across large parts of the region, with some deterioration in the second half, which also gives context to the excellent performance of our team in delivering the results they did in those markets during that period. With vaccination programs building momentum around the globe and allowing restrictions to ease, we expect demand to recover further in these premium and luxury wine sales channels, and we strongly believe we are very well placed to execute our plans to deliver growth as this happens.
Tim Ford
executiveLooking back at fiscal ’21, for Treasury Wine Estates it proved a period of considerable transformation and accomplishment. As you’ll remember, when we reported full year 2020 results back in August, I laid out the TWE 2025 strategy along with five priority areas for the business that were meant to carry this plan forward across the year. Midway through, we brought in one more priority — putting into action our worldwide approach in response to the tariffs imposed on Australian wine brought into China. At this company, we take real pride in delivering on our commitments. Let me call out a handful of the wins we achieved this year on those priorities. Heading into fiscal ’21, our top goal was steering performance through the global pandemic, and I’m delighted to report that we got there by continuing to premiumize and by generating organic growth in both the top line and EBIT. That stands as a major accomplishment on its own, and all the more so once you factor in what happened to our business in China. Moving to a marketing model driven by consumers and experiences has been a genuine standout for TWE, and it has become a central source of momentum right across our brand portfolio.
Tim Ford
executiveWe've built on a foundation of data and insights to bring bold innovation into our portfolio. Through collaborations and partnerships with celebrities and key opinion leaders, plus a focus on digital engagement, we've driven appeal across a broader and more diverse consumer base. Our extensive global supply chain optimization program is now at an advanced stage, and we expect it to deliver annualized benefits of at least $75 million from F23 onwards. Beyond the emphasis on cost and efficiency, we've taken a transformational approach with this initiative, one that will leave our supply chain well positioned to support the future needs of our brand portfolio divisions and help us achieve our company wide growth ambitions. Accelerating the separate focus across our brand portfolios was a leading priority for fiscal 2021, and on the first of July we transitioned to a new divisional operating model led by Penfolds, Treasury Premium brands and Treasury Americas. This model won't just deliver increased focus and accountability throughout our business — it will also ensure we fully leverage the benefits of our global scale and diversification. While it's still early days, six weeks in, we're already seeing the benefits of this significant change program, with each division focusing on its own set of strategic priorities and performance objectives, and leaving us well placed to pursue previously untapped growth opportunities across the globe.
Tim Ford
executiveOur strategy for building a Premium wine business in the United States for the future has moved ahead considerably, and Ben will give you more detail on that later. And lastly, our worldwide plan for responding to the trade measures that were put in place in China advanced meaningfully during the second half of the fiscal year, as we met demand for luxury product and wine that had previously been supply constrained. Early indicators look encouraging, with Penfolds Bins &Icons achieving strong growth in Australia and in Asian markets outside of Mainland China, where NSA rose 15% and 38% respectively compared with the prior year. So with that, I'll now pass things over to the team, and first I'll hand to Matt, who will take you through our financial results in a bit more detail.
Matt Young
executiveThank you, Tim. Morning, everyone. At TWE, fiscal ‘21 gave us plenty of reasons to feel proud, and our financial results were definitely among them. Even with the difficulties we faced during the first half of this year, our teams showed remarkable agility in putting together robust response plans, and, even more importantly, they carried those plans through effectively, which highlighted the fundamental resilience of the business models, brands and people at Treasury Wine’s. So I'm happy to share with you the fiscal ‘21 financial results, which meet or exceed our commitments and give us a solid foundation for carrying on with the execution of our TWE 2025 strategy. In fiscal ‘21 we got back to top line growth, with group net sales revenue up 1.3% on a constant currency basis and up 4.4% on an organic basis. NSR per case went up in each region and rose 2.4% across the group, with momentum driven by our Premium portfolio, which led the mix improvement in the Americas, EMEA and ANZ. Because of that, our luxury and premium portfolios accounted for 77% of our global NSR, an increase of 6 percentage points in fiscal ‘21.
Matt Young
executiveOn a constant currency basis, COGS per case rose 10.6%, driven by the favorable shift in portfolio mix as well as the higher COGS on the Australian source Commercial Wine that we flagged earlier. Several one-off items likewise affected COGS in fiscal ’21, among them the inventory damage caused by the Californian wildfires, which insurance covered, plus one-off costs incurred in response to the changes in China and as a result of Brexit. Cost of doing business margin came in at 20%, up 1.8 percentage points, which reflects the organizational changes we implemented in the Americas during the last quarter of fiscal ‘20 and, more recently, in China, where we realigned our overall cost base to the reduction in sales volume in that market. EBITS reached $510.3 million, representing growth of 3% on a constant currency basis, while on an organic basis EBITS grew 3.5%. EBITS margin rose 0.6 percentage points to 19.9%, and finally ROCE improved 0.6 percentage points to 10.8%, with lower capital employed reflecting improved cash flow, which facilitated repayment of borrowings. Total material items costs of $88.5 million, or $66.1 million after tax, were recognized in fiscal 2021, and all relate to the previously announced programs of work. The most significant costs relate to the divestment of U.S.
Matt Young
executiveThose brands and assets came with a cost of $62.3 million, tied mainly to writing down intangible brand values and inventories connected to the divestment of the U.S. Commercial portfolio. Offsetting those write downs was a gain from selling a Napa-based vineyard during the first half. So far, we've confirmed net cash proceeds of roughly $150 million from the divestments, and we're still on track for total inflows of about $300 million by the time the program wraps up. We also booked $18.4 million of cost tied to the ongoing overhead and supply chain restructuring program, plus another $7.8 million related to the luxury capacity expansion in South Australia. Turning now to the balance sheet, which continues to be a major source of strength for Treasury and one that let us seamlessly manage through the necessary changes to our business in fiscal '21. Net assets were down slightly against the prior year; however, after adjusting for currency effects, net assets rose by $113.4 million, with repayment of borrowings from strengthened operating cash flow as a key driver. Other key factors affecting the balance sheet during the year included the U.S.
Matt Young
executiveOn the commercial side, we divested part of the portfolio, and we have continuing plans to sell additional wineries, vineyards, and brands across the Americas. Now, looking more closely at inventory: it fell by $180 million, down to $1.9 billion at cost as of the close of fiscal '21. Currency movements played a big part in that reduction, and so did the sale of the U.S. Commercial portfolio brands. That transaction is reflected in the lower current inventory figure we now carry, and we now view this as our less commercial inventory overall. Non-current inventory came in flat versus the prior year — a high-yielding 2021 Australian vintage and inventory carried forward that has been set aside for sale in China were offset by the lower-yielding 2020 California vintage. Luxury inventory was down 2% in value, with volumes flat, and it stays a key piece of our ambitions for future growth. Current inventory is lower as well, which also mirrors the short-term sales volume decrease we expect from disruptions in the Luxury channel and from reduced sales into China. Back at our Investor Day in May, I shared some thoughts on the risks facing the Australian market given the effective closure of China, and on the potential knock-on effect for our business.
Matt Young
executiveThree months later, the macro observations we shared at that time still apply. First, demand trends in the domestic market remain positive, and consumption through retail channels has been strong, as scan data shows—with growth of just under 6% in value terms in fiscal ’21. Adding to this is the accelerated growth of Australian Wine exports, with export value outside of Mainland China rising 12% in the 12 months to June. On the supply side, the high-yielding 2021 Australian vintage helped rebuild the inventory position after the low yield of the 2020 vintage. That was also the case for Treasury Wines, where we chose to raise our holdings of Luxury wine to address the 2020 vintage and also to support long-term growth ambitions. The current market position is reflected in retail pricing trends, which remain stable across all price points; however, we will keep monitoring this, including trends in private label. So to sum up, we remain in a strong position as we come out of fiscal ’21, and we will continue to closely monitor both domestic and global trends. We do recognize, though, that ongoing management of vintage intakes will likely be needed across the next one to two Luxury vintages.
Matt Young
executiveWe've made some proactive moves ourselves, pulling forward several vineyard redevelopment programs that had long been planned into fiscal ’22. These are programs that were slated for future years, but completing them now assists us in managing short-term intake, while also making sure the vineyards are positioned to support future growth. Simultaneously, we're looking at our upcoming grower contract renewals, and our expectation is that intake from growers may need to come down over the medium term. Although we acknowledge this will remain a period of uncertainty for the industry, we are still well placed to navigate it, from both an inventory and a cost base standpoint. Turning to cash flow and net debt: operating cash flow before interest, tax and material items rose 4% for the year, with reported cash conversion of 100.8%; the main drivers there were a lower 2020 vintage intake in California, an adjusted 2021 Australian vintage intake, and the regional shift in sales mix in Asia. If you exclude the change in non-current Luxury and Premium inventory, cash conversion came in at 97%, in line with our target of 90% or higher. Moving now to CapEx: total CapEx for fiscal ‘21 came to $121 million, of which growth CapEx accounted for $66 million, including the investments in Luxury wine making infrastructure in South Australia and in technology.
Matt Young
executiveWhile total CapEx came in a bit under what we had expected for fiscal '21, the main reason for that was constraints in the supply chain. For fiscal '22, we anticipate CapEx of as much as $150 million, and that figure includes maintenance and replacement spending as well as ongoing investment aimed at supporting growth. We have taken a disciplined approach to managing cash flow, yet we stay committed to self-funded growth CapEx in support of our strategy. Now, turning lastly to Capital Management — I'm pleased to report that we held on to our strong investment grade capital structure, even with a number of major disruptions occurring over the course of fiscal 2021. Leverage came down to 1.6x for the year, which reflects a $376 million reduction in net debt, and it now sits comfortably back inside our target of as much as 2x through the cycle, and that is where we expect it to stay going forward. Importantly, our capital structure kept its flexibility over both the short and the long term, which puts us in a strong position to weigh a range of opportunities as we keep prioritizing investment in future growth and incremental opportunities. Our liquidity position of more than $1.2 billion is backed by substantial undrawn committed debt facilities spread across a well-diversified maturity profile, and this robust liquidity position supports keeping our long term dividend policy in place, and today we declared a final, fully frank dividend of $0.13 per share, which represents a payout of 65%.
Matt Young
executiveThanks — at this point I'll pass things over to Tom in Shanghai, who will talk with you about the Asia region.
Tom King
executiveThanks, Matt, and good morning, everyone, speaking from Shanghai. In Asia, the main channels for Premium wine sales are still in a mixed condition — China is completely open for business, while other important markets face continuing disruption, and persistent restrictions across the region keep causing substantial disruption, above all in travel retail. Given that background, plus the tariffs introduced in Mainland China, the TWE portfolio has performed solidly, and sustained strong demand for our brands helped F21 results. In the Asia region, net sales revenue fell 8%, reflecting lower shipments to Mainland China from late November onward, when the provisional measures were announced. Partly offsetting that decrease was a 20% rise in net sales revenue across the remainder of Asia, as we met demand that had previously gone unmet and demand for our brand portfolio strengthened in key markets such as Malaysia, Thailand, Singapore and Hong Kong. COGS per case rose 50.1%, owing to an improved portfolio mix and one-off costs, among them extra freight costs and clearance delays at Chinese ports. Cost of doing business improved 11%, thanks to realigning brand investments and overheads in China to our future state China business models. Regional EBITS came to $205 million, with an EBIT margin of 36%.
Tom King
executiveOur initiatives aimed at expanding demand and establishing distribution and availability for Penfolds Bins & Icons throughout key regional markets are moving along nicely, and investment in people and brand building is speeding up during the second half. Thanks to those investments and our emphasis on securing distribution gains—especially within retail and ecommerce channels—NSR for the Penfolds Bins & Icons range rose 38% in markets outside Mainland China. We additionally carried out several route-to-market changes during H2 throughout the region, which brought us nearer to our end consumers and positioned our business for additional growth. In Mainland China, we keep investing behind our multi country of origin portfolio growth strategy, which is developing with second half highlights that include the launch of the Penfolds California collection and the release of Rawson’s Retreat sourced from South Africa, with both offerings generating strong trade appetite. We have likewise kept investing behind the Penfolds brand in China, where consumer demand stayed strong. Looking ahead, we anticipate selling through a portion of the Penfolds Bins & Icons range in Mainland China at retail prices that are higher and tariff inclusive. Although we have not yet formed a definitive view on how this will look in volume terms, we do expect that EBITS contribution from China net of investment will be minimal in F22.
Tom King
executiveAlthough pandemic-related effects are still with us, we do anticipate robust expansion throughout the region, helped by wider availability and by stepping up our sales and marketing work. Regarding the growth potential of the Penfolds brand — across Asia and in the worldwide Luxury market as well — I am highly confident and genuinely enthusiastic, and on behalf of the Penfolds division I look forward to bringing you up to date on how we are progressing going forward. Thank you — I will now pass things to Ben Dollard.
Ben Dollard
executiveThanks, Tom, and good morning to all of you from Napa, California. It's great to be with you today. Fiscal '21 proved to be a milestone year, with meaningful progress achieved on our key priority. In the Americas, F21 performance showed net sales revenue rising 2%, fueled by strong growth in the Premium portfolio across retail and e-commerce. That gain was partly offset by the divestment in March of a significant portion of the U.S. Commercial brand portfolio. With those divested brands excluded, organic NSR grew 11%, reflecting strong consumer demand for our focused TWE 10 <<inaudible>> brand portfolio. Lower overheads, driven by the new organization structure put in place in June 2020, brought down our cost of doing business, and combined with strong topline momentum, that produced a 54% increase in regional EBITS to $168 million, while our EBITS margin rose 5.7 points to 17%. On an organic basis, EBITS grew by more than 66%. These results are pleasing despite the continuing impacts of on-premise and cellar door closures during the period. We successfully navigated COVID-induced channel shifts, delivered best-in-class innovation, and significantly transformed the business into one that is Premium focused and positioned for long-term sustainable growth. Our transformation continues, but I'm pleased with the progress we made throughout the year.
Ben Dollard
executiveIn the second half, the dynamics of the U.S. market changed. Retail and ecommerce channels stayed strong but cooled off as on-premise venues reopened across the country. On-premise and cellar door are now mostly open again, yet trading activity is still under where it was before the pandemic. That comes from staffing constraints, fewer on-premise locations, and continuing travel restrictions. Assuming COVID rules allow it, we anticipate these channels will keep recovering in the first half as we head into the important holiday season, and we're positioned well to speed up our performance once things are fully running. We'll keep watching local and national COVID mandates and what they might mean for the trading environment. U.S. consumer trends kept premiumizing, with the around $11 price points up 12% in U.S. retail for fiscal 2021 and the above $20 price points up 20% over the same period. Our focus portfolio of Premium brands keeps beating the market, up 23% in value for the year, led by 19 Crimes, Penfolds, Beringer Brothers, Matua and St Huberts The Stag. What's behind these brands' performance is tremendous retail execution plus outstanding innovation success. 19 Crimes, Cali Red connected strongly with consumers and ended the fiscal year as the category's number one growth skew.
Ben Dollard
executive19 Crimes Cali Rose came out in March and performed really well too, ending up as the number 10 growth skew for H2. We're building on that innovation success with <<inaudible>>, bringing in our second iconic celebrity alongside Snoop as we grow the 19 Crimes franchise. This new product launches in spring 2022, with standout packaging and world class augmented reality, and it's a terrific complement to Cali Red and Cali Rosé. We'll keep innovating with fresh 19 Crimes partnerships, variety <<inaudible>> and assortment, all while constructing the world of wine. The Penfolds California collection launch went well, with an outstanding response from critics, retail customers and consumers. Our depletion momentum was helped by our newly creative dedicated Luxury selling team, The Volt Collective <<inaudible>>. We're seeing strong volatility in reorder rates since launch, along with a healthy on-premise mix. Pleasingly, we've seen more distribution and interest on the Penfolds Australian portfolio as we've launched the California collection. Another exciting innovation is the recent release of Matua Lighter, launched for the US Summer and tapping into the conscious consumption trend — early days, but trade response has been positive. Our restructuring activities to deliver a future state US Premium Wine business are on track for completion by the end of the calendar year.
Ben Dollard
executiveMarch saw us complete the sale of a large share of our commercial profile — a milestone that mattered a great deal. Today the portfolio centers on Premium and Luxury. Beyond the supply chain work already underway, we keep looking at additional brands and asset rationalization. In fiscal 22, that will rank among our highest priorities. Another notable point was the announcement of our partnership with Republic National Distributing Company. That relationship accounts for roughly one-third of our business, and significantly, it covers our key markets of California and Texas. Transition plans are moving along nicely, and we feel positive about what lies ahead across the RNDC network. To sum up, fiscal ’21 brought substantial progress and momentum. Focus remains the heart of our business — serving consumers, retail customers and distributors. I’ll now pass things to Peter Neilson in Melbourne.
Peter Neilson
executiveThanks Ben, and good morning, everyone. ANZ put in a solid F21 performance, powered by our main Luxury and Premium brands across retail and ecommerce. On-premise venues in Australia have reopened on and off, but the important sales channels for higher-margin Luxury wine — travel, retail and cellar doors — are still subdued, and that continues to weigh on our results. In the ANZ region, NSR came in 2% higher than the prior comparative period, with growth in our Luxury and Premium portfolios driving that, partly offset by a smaller contribution from the commercial portfolio. COGS per case rose 14%, reflecting the mix shift, higher COGS on wine sourced in Australia, and some extra cost tied to finished goods meant for sale in China. Cost of doing business fell 9%, helped by lower overheads and reduced A&P over the pandemic-affected period. That produced regional EBITS of $143 million, up 3% on F20. Encouragingly, premiumization trends are still strong, with retail category growth led by price points above $10. In value terms over the year, the Premium segment of $10 to $30 grew 11%, and about $30 grew 26%. We did see some soft retail data in the second half as we cycled the peak pantry loading period in F20, but our priority brands keep delivering strong growth, led by Pepperjack, St Huberts The Stag, Wynns, 19 Crimes and SquealingPig.
Peter Neilson
executiveAlso worth noting, Penfolds Bins & Icons posted solid increases, with NSR rising 15%, helped by better availability and, for certain lines, higher pricing. Although growth in the category came from the premium price segment, the commercial segment kept shrinking, and we have no doubt it will stay difficult. That reflects two things: consumers moving away from the sub $10 category, and retailers favoring their own private label strategies over the leading brands. We are actively managing the commercial portfolio and the part it plays in our business. That involves collaborating with our retail partners to settle what role our brands should play, with our financial goals of EBITS and margin growth family steering those choices. The step change in our innovation agenda during the year produced some impressive results. Highlights included extending Pepperjack into Chardonnay, Malbec and Grenache and Tempranillo, with TWE becoming a leader in the fast faring Malbec and Grenache variety. Launching our SquealingPig gen sector was another tremendous success on the innovation front, building on the already strong momentum behind the SquealingPig brand. Behind the scenes, we have been very busy on the innovation front, and I look forward to sharing what we are bringing to life in the first half of F22.
Peter Neilson
executiveIt's encouraging to see the momentum building behind our focus brands, but COVID's effects and elevated COGS have taken a toll on our financial results over the last two years. Getting the business back to a high teens margin is clearly going to take work, yet the opportunity here is significant, and we have a clear roadmap pointing to where we're headed. We're collaborating closely with supply to bring COGS down, and we lean on our strong innovation pipeline and multi-country-of-origin strategies to generate incremental growth. Sourcing Argentinean Malbec this year illustrates a multi-country-of-origin strategy in action, and it's one of the factors driving growth for both Pepperjack and 19 Crimes this period. On the COGS side — on cost management — we were sharply focused during F21 on how and where we invested, making deliberate choices about the cost lines within our control. That discipline will continue going forward as we optimize our cost and capital base. To sum up, I'm very happy with the F21 ANZ performance. There's still work ahead, but I have confidence in the substantial opportunity in front of us as part of the broader Treasury Premium Brands division. Moving now to EMEA, where strong execution, combined with ongoing restrictions on people movement, drove retail sales upside across the regions — notably in the UK and the Nordics.
Peter Neilson
executiveRegrettably, that robust top-line result failed to carry through to the bottom line, as contributions fell in the Nordics within Continental Europe, hit by travel restrictions and a key retailer's rationalization efforts. Performance in the Middle East and Africa was likewise muted, owing to an absence of tourism. Across the EMEA region, net sales revenue rose 15%, powered by gains in the Premium and Luxury portfolios via retail channels, with the Luxury and Premium portfolios contributing 7 percentage points more, reaching 42% of EMEA regional NSR. COGS per case climbed 7%, pushed by the enhanced portfolio mix and pricier wine sourced from Australia and the U.S. Cost of doing business rose 10%, with the main drivers being accelerated brand-building investments behind key portfolio brands plus one-off Brexit related costs. That produced a regional EBITS gain of 1%, to $47 million, and an EBITS margin of 11%. Our priority brand portfolio saw strong growth in retail channels. 19 Crimes kept up its stellar performance through distribution gains, a strong NPD pipeline and engaging marketing campaigns, fueling a 152% rise in dollar sales in the UK, where it now ranks among the top 15 brands, along with strong growth across other key markets in the region.
Peter Neilson
executiveLindeman's continues to hold the top spot as a brand in both Sweden and the Netherlands, and our emphasis on sustainability for that brand is helping boost how relevant it feels to consumers. Thanks to Blossom Hill's solid brand equity, its sales returned to growth, with demand rising in UK grocery and impulse channels throughout COVID. Turning to Luxury, Wynns and Beaulieu vineyard were both successfully introduced on <<inaudible>>, the worldwide distribution channel we use for our icon wine, which moves us closer to our goal of raising awareness for our Luxury portfolio beyond Australia. To sum up, the region delivered a strong top line performance, and our brands are connecting powerfully with consumers. As with the ANZ region, there are certain hurdles to clear on the coach side, yet there is also considerable opportunity in a market that is both large and premiumizing. Thank you. I'll now hand back to Tim.
Tim Ford
executiveThanks, Pete, and thanks to Tom, Ben and Matt. So F22, which we've now entered, really marks the next stage of carrying out the TWE 2025 game plan, and that plan centers on our ambition to become the world's most admired Premium wine company. With the new divisional operating model in place, our F22 priorities will be driven by our brand portfolio divisions and by how they execute their own strategic and growth priorities. Tom and the Penfolds team are concentrating on building global demand for the brand through attracting new consumers and also extending distribution and availability in the priority channels and markets, while optimizing the portfolio for long term growth by executing our multi-country of origin strategy within the portfolio. With Treasury Americas now set to fundamentally change business, Ben and his team will be delivering more of the same in fiscal twenty two. More of the same that is driving relentless focus on premiumization across the business, delivering portfolio expansion through bold consumer led innovation and completing the brand and asset optimization program. For Pete and the TPB team, the focus is on expanding the fantastic portfolio of Premium brands across priority growth markets globally, and the channels within those markets.
Tim Ford
executiveCreating the multi-country-of-origin consumer offerings you mentioned, and also — this matters a great deal — putting in place a cost and capital base that is sustainable and fit for purpose, one that will underpin the margin ambitions we've set out for that division. Importantly, four priorities spanning the whole TWE group, led by our corporate and central functions and to be rolled out across the business, are what support the divisional growth objectives. The first of these is to keep lifting our culture and our talent, with genuine focus and investment going into nurturing and developing the next generation of leaders in our business, something we started strongly in FY'21. Our teams and our people are unquestionably our greatest strategic asset and strength, and they sit at the heart of our game plan, guided by the TWE DNA. Embedding sustainability across our business is the second global priority. After launching our next phase sustainability agenda at our Investor Day in May, we are now moving at pace to implement initiatives and measures right across TWE, centered on delivering key imperatives in areas including health, safety and wellness, water stewardship, greenhouse emissions and sustainable packaging, to name a few. Cultivating a broader future is what we will do.
Tim Ford
executiveThird, putting money into technology, tools, and platforms that produce data and insights will position TWE to develop capability and turn digitally enabled across the whole of our business — from the front-end case of driving stronger consumer engagement through to the back-end case of boosting the efficiency of our vineyard and winery operations. This year we're making a step change in how much we invest in technology as we set out to build the TWE business of the future. And last, we'll chase global innovation and inorganic growth opportunities that can either fill premium portfolio gaps across our brand portfolio divisions, leverage strengths we already have, or build new capabilities for what lies ahead. We're now in a fantastic position to look at a range of investment opportunities that will drive incremental growth in our business and maximize shareholder returns, because we have the backing of a capital structure that is in as good a shape as it has ever been. So to close, fiscal ’21 was a year of significant change, but more importantly of achievement for TWE — one in which we delivered organic top line and EBITS growth despite major disruptions and challenges. In F22 our focus will be on sustaining the strong momentum of our premium portfolios across all markets, as well as executing our plans to drive growth of the Penfolds luxury portfolio across key global channels and markets.
Tim Ford
executiveOur view of F22 is upbeat in every major market except Mainland China. Keeping our attention on the things within our control matters a great deal, and in F22 our priorities are crystal clear to us, and again, delivering exactly what we commit to. This is a genuinely thrilling moment in our company's history, as we move purposefully and quickly toward our ambitions and goals, guided by our new brand portfolio divisional model. So thanks for being with us today, and I'll now pass things to the operator, who will open the line for questions.
Operator
operatorThank you. <<operator_script>> The first question is from Michael Simotas at Jefferies. Please go ahead with your question.
Michael Simotas
analystMorning, everyone. My first question is about how strongly the Asia business excluding China performed. I was hoping you could give us a bit more detail on that. What portion of it came from moving wine out of China? What portion was simply solid underlying growth in some of those markets regardless? And was there a temporary lift for any of those markets because China shut down, or would you call that performance sustainable?
Tim Ford
executiveMorning, Michael. Appreciate the question. I’ll give a broad answer first, then pass things to Tom in Shanghai, who can walk you through some additional detail. As we laid out the plans for the global response—if you like—to the tariffs in the China market, we did state that our priorities for the second half of the fiscal year that just ended were twofold. The first was that we held a strong belief, which has since become reality, that unmet demand existed because of supply-constrained wines during that period, so that was step one. Everyone else wants to label it reallocation; we prefer to describe it as satisfying demand, and we will keep doing that. The second part was then really reorienting our focus on resources and investments—you know, to build distribution and make sure we had the right partners to build distribution across a number of these different markets as well. So without giving you a percentage split, which I’m sure they’ll expect me to provide, between those two—you know, clearly there was the—putting it one of the better ways, the one-off building of demand and satisfying of demand, but more importantly, I think the work—and Tom can go into more detail on what we’ve done in terms of really driving the agenda in some of these markets—is what we’re most excited about to set us up over the years ahead.
Tim Ford
executiveTom, would you like to add to that?
Tom King
executiveThanks, Tim and Michael. I believe it's crucial to remember that we did have some very strong canceled businesses—operations that were expanding prior to the China impact. Additionally, we kicked off this planning roughly a year ago this week, right when the initial investigation was made public. So a great deal of effort has gone into pinpointing where we'll direct investment, where we perceive the opportunities, and already in H2 and especially in Q4 we're seeing some of our upside materialize. Regarding the markets in Asia and beyond China—Hong Kong, Singapore, Malaysia into China, Thailand and Taiwan—we've been concentrating hard, as Tim mentioned, on pinpointing where we can bring in new consumers, boosting distribution and availability to back those consumers, and making sure we have the appropriate portfolio to satisfy consumer demands across various needs, states and occasions in various channels. Our approach has been fairly comparable to the one we've used in China, and that has fueled much of our success in recent years. First, making certain there's a truly clear portfolio plan, as I mentioned, that delivers on consumer occasions in these states.
Tom King
executiveMuch of that stems from what we learned in our luxury wine consumer study, which we funded last year. Then it was about teaming up with the right partners to make sure the right people are on the ground alongside us — partners who buy into our strategy and ambition and bring the right capability — and then backing them with our own people locally. So we're adding new capabilities spanning several different disciplines, whether that's key accounts sales managers helping with retail and e-commerce, businesses where our focus leans more toward driving the entry, entry level of the luxury portfolio and collaborating with customers to add category value by growing the premium and luxury segments. On top of that, there are luxury sales managers concentrating on widening our availability across fine wine, and also luxury retail and reaching high net worth individuals too. And over all of this, making sure we have the right representation incentive brand ambassadors to educate trade and consumers. I'm genuinely pleased to see that while there was an immediate chance to reallocate some of the products that previously couldn't be allocated because of excess demand, what's really coming through in H2 is a combination of these investments and that reallocation — and that gives us confidence going forward, not only in those Asia markets I've highlighted, but also across the U.S., U.K.
Tom King
executiveAnd Australia. I’ll give you a bit more detail — an example is Thailand, where, working alongside a strong local partner, we’ve developed a very solid plan with investments behind it, and that has produced multiple new listings in distribution with key retailers, whether that means getting the message into convenience channels or luxury wines into premium retail, plus expanding our broad and our wholesale network. In Malaysia, in the same way, a robust business plan with our distributors and the end customers is helping us grow distribution into retail channels. Singapore has stood out from an e-commerce standpoint — really strong growth, especially for Penfolds, and that has come from a focus on making sure we have the right internal capability; we’re working with the right platforms and partners to leverage the data so it informs our investments behind the portfolio. And then the last piece is a little different, which is where we have — and I said this in my script — that we’ve referenced significant market changes in Japan and Vietnam during the second half, to make sure we’re setting ourselves up with the right partners who want to invest and support our growth ambition, and there China, where we made a fairly big transition from a single regional distributor to working directly with multiple local distributors, to get closer to customers, closer to consumers, and ultimately closer to the market.
Tom King
executiveThese are the priorities we have moving forward. This is how the Penfolds division will be operated going forward under the new model, and it's a much sharper focus across everything we do, which is already beginning—we're already starting to see it come to life. Also in Australia, in Europe—where in Australia we established a dedicated on-premise sales team and a dedicated independent retail sales team, and in Europe we now have dedicated retail account managers—and we're starting to see some really positive conversations come to life at a customer level, so. I appreciate that was a somewhat long-winded answer, but I really wanted to bring it to life, so yes, there were some short-term reallocations, as we like to call it, but our focus now is absolutely on recruiting consumers, driving that distribution, and ensuring we have the right portfolio to meet those consumer demands.
Tim Ford
executiveMuch appreciated, Tom, and one…
Michael Simotas
analystAppreciate that useful context.
Tim Ford
executiveI think, Michael, there's one more thing I'd add here, and it's probably the most exciting aspect of what Tom and the team have accomplished. When you reflect on that slide we had in the deck earlier, about where some of the key luxury selling channels are located — you know, within Asia right now especially — we've seen some weakening in those over that half. The foundations the team has laid in some of these other key markets, and in cities within those key markets, really do give us confidence that we're positioning ourselves to succeed as things reopen as well. So yes, they've done a terrific job, so thanks, Michael.
Michael Simotas
analystCould I also ask something about COGS? Regarding the outlook remarks, you mention elevated COGS, which isn't surprising given the carryover from 2020 in Australia and also the U.S. Vintage. How should we think about COGS in FY ‘22 compared with FY ‘21? So should we interpret those comments as meaning they're elevated relative to what you'd consider a normal level, or will there be a further step up in F22 versus F21?
Tim Ford
executiveAnd what I think you should take from that is that it stays elevated. So right now we view COGS as elevated because of the historical vintage challenges. You’ve got Vintage 20 for commercial. The phrasing is meant to be “Remain Elevated.” The only thing I’d add here is that we are clearly focused on addressing that, and as we called out at Investor Day, we’ve completed the bulk of the work to do that, and/or we have reasonable expectations that natural trends will bring it down over time through Vintage ’21 in Australia and early insights regarding long-term pricing trends. So from our perspective, we haven’t set in our hands that we are looking to address that, but the benefit of those is likely to come through fiscal ’23 and beyond. So for fiscal ’22 it’s a remained top comment, but our focus is on the longer term, where we have more positivity.
Michael Simotas
analystAll right, that covers it. To put it plainly and avoid any confusion, the drag appears as though it will be comparable in ’22 versus ’21 — meaning it won’t be any worse.
Tim Ford
executiveYeah, that conclusion makes sense.
Michael Simotas
analystI appreciate that.
Tim Ford
executiveThanks, Michael.
Operator
operatorDavid Errington with Bank of America has the next question in the queue. Go ahead, please.
David Errington
analystMorning Tim, Matt, and team. Tim, I really don’t want to focus on negatives here, since I’m quite optimistic and positive, and I believe you’re doing a great job and that the team is in great shape. So please, these are simply two questions that I think — I don’t understand, and I think that TWE, if you can get this right, has a lot more upside. On your COGS, continuing from Michael’s question there, to walk through it, you had a 10% rise in COGS this year per case. The year before, you had a 3% rise in COGS, and the year before that, you had an 8.1% rise in COGS per case. Now, with all your supply chain optimization, with all the investments you’ve been making, and given that you’re the largest producer in Australia, I simply don’t understand why you still have a COGS problem. There’s always a COGS problem with Treasury Wine. It’s been happening since, you know, years ago. Why can’t you get on top of this COGS problem, given that you’re the buyer of choice, you’re the largest, and you should have the base systems? You’ve got a lead investment and you spend nearly $150 million bucks a year, which is more than anyone else.
David Errington
analystWhat's the reason the COGS problem is still there? I just don't get it.
Tim Ford
executiveThanks, David. I suppose I'll give my high-level take on this first, and then Matt can walk through a bit more of the specifics, since this is genuinely a major challenge for us and we're not trying to avoid that. The first point I'd make is that, as you mentioned, given our size, scale and capability, we really ought to be setting the pace on cost of goods, and we believe we're in the strongest position to handle some of the problems that have come up in earlier vintages. So on cost of goods generally, we believe that where we stand relative to others is consistent with what we'd expect when you consider it from an industry perspective. That said, the increases are not acceptable to us, as we've observed over the recent period, and I think if you look through, for instance, at the Treasury Premium brands business, what that means for that business is that we not only need to grasp the supply chain restructuring and work through those processes — which we have done and which will begin to flow through from fiscal '23 — but we also must take a very hard look at how we're actually starting from the front end of the business; how we're examining things right across an end-to-end view of our business: are we developing our products, our innovation and our plans in a way that genuinely gives us a margin structure allowing us some flexibility when variations arise from one vintage to the next.
Tim Ford
executiveThis is a wider matter for us than merely optimizing the supply chain. It's at the point where, especially given this divisional structure and model, our measurement will rest on those portfolios—not solely from a cost of goods standpoint, but also the asset base behind them—so we're now in a stronger position to concentrate on that differently than we could previously. That's the source of our confidence that we'll tackle this problem, but Matt, would you like to add something?
Matt Young
executiveAbsolutely, thanks Tim. Let me begin with David on the magnitude of those figures you brought up. I believe it's crucial to return to mix. So I'll take this year as a 10% increase, though we've observed a rise in premiumization across our products. Therefore I will — I'll just — regarding the size of the challenge you outlined, mix certainly has a part to play in our COGS, a case I'm confident you grasp, without escaping the reality of the difficulties we've encountered. Another contextual point to grasp is that we genuinely believe we possess the finest systems, processes, and network, and you know especially in Australia we have the scale needed to control our costs, and we act proactively in that area. The main drivers you're hearing about regarding — but however, what I'd say is that grapes and bulk wine make the biggest contribution to cost of goods, and whenever we get lower yielding vintages, those do tend to carry higher costs, whether through the network or the grape price, and those are industry-wide difficulties that the market sets. So for us, that's something you know we aim to handle via the flexibility of our supply, and as we say, we're in good shape, but some elements of that simply have to be navigated.
Matt Young
executiveSo, as I mentioned, when we look ahead to Vintage ’21, there are some positive signs. That vintage was bigger, and it has fed into our network, and we see a solid chance to improve cost of goods for Vintage ’21 in Australia. But the factor of rising grape costs across America, combined with lower yielding vintages in Australia, is the key one, and naturally the timing of release spreads that over a couple of years. So I remain very confident that we are in the best position and addressing in particular those costs within our control, and we are doing so proactively. We are making the fullest use of our network. And as I said earlier, we view the longer term outlook as more positive, supported by more normal sized vintages and the work we have done.
David Errington
analystAll right, all right. So my next question, Tim, and it's likely directed at both you and Ben. If I take a look at a snapshot of your divisions, I'm looking at, say, slide 18. Asia in '21; the EBIT is highlighted in '18. When I check ANZ, the EBIT for '21 is higher than '18. Looking at EMEA, EMEA isn't — it adds a bit of case. When I look at the U.S., its EBIT remains below what it was in '18, even after having invested $1 billion with the Diageo acquisition. Now you guys really talk up the U.S. in a big way. You're really saying this is it, and you give plenty of good reasons, whether it's portfolio expansion, it's always been the same. But when you look at that slide 18 or slide 19 and you examine the actual EBIT performance, FY '21 is still a long, long, long way away from where FY was in '17 in EBIT, and yet that's after a $1 billion investment in Diageo. So can you — I know it's going on a bit and probably you need to — but can you tell us in a couple of points why we should be bullish on the Americas business in terms of future EBIT performance, because when you look at that slide 19, you're still tracking a long way away from where you were in '17, and that's after a $1 billion buck investment in Diageo.
Tim Ford
executiveSure, absolutely. Look, I think there are a couple of points I'll begin with, you know, regarding our Americas business, and I think I've been fairly consistent on this over the last, you know, particularly the last two halves, and I will hand over to Ben to comment as well once I've given my responses. But there's a consistency in how we're executing in the U.S. market that we've observed across the last 12 months, which is, I think, staying the course when it comes to a very clear strategy and plan, and I think that's number one. We really are staying the course and it's working. Our portfolio is increasingly playing to where the consumer is going. It is increasingly playing to the price points where consumers are raising their wine consumption in that market. So the shape of the portfolio is closer to where we want it to be from an ongoing growth standpoint. We don't have a situation where half of the business is performing well while the other half is a drag on the business, which is where we've been over that period of time. The second point I'd make is that, you know, I think the proof points of what we've delivered over the course of this year, which have been delivered against the backdrop of circa a quarter, where 25% of our channels within that market are still significantly impacted by the pandemic in the U.S.
Tim Ford
executiveOnce you layer that into the historical financials and consider where we stood prior to the pandemic, that definitely gives me confidence too, and that part is still ahead of us. We are positioned to carry that out, and we have the right resources and the right partners lined up. The third thing I would mention is the U.S. business — this is difficult to quantify, but this is basically how I feel about it and what gives me confidence. Yes, I have delivered and executed a plan, and I think Ben will likely add — and I am sure he will — that it is one step along a trajectory. But at the same time, I have managed to deliver a significant change in that business while producing really, really strong outcomes. And Ben and the team, since they handle most of that business, spend the majority of their time focused on how we go about things. Are we running this two-speed business that I talk about quite often, which is delivering today and making sure we have the right set of initiatives, strategies and plans for tomorrow? And if you think about it, they have adjusted the route to market to a platform that will be a growth platform for us going forward, restructured the organization some four to eight months ago now, but delivered on that while delivering the business results, as well as some of the portfolio and asset changes we have made.
Tim Ford
executiveThat gives you confidence, and it gives you belief — you know they really can keep running the business that way, and the decisions we're making are building blocks so we can keep growing over time. So I guess that's my sense of it and my response, but Ben, what would you like to add to that?
Ben Dollard
executiveSure, thank you, and good morning David. Thanks for raising that question — I think Tim pointed to several important actions we have in mind. Let me add a couple of points on how we view prioritization and what it brings us, particularly in the areas of portfolio and following where consumers are headed. We're very sharply tuned in on that front, and we'll keep putting substantial effort in — not just on the TWE 10 <<inaudible>> portfolio, but also in how we approach innovation. Importantly, the restructuring work aimed at creating our future-state premium wine business remains on track, though it isn't finished yet. So that's something we keep devoting considerable effort to — whether it's how we configure our vineyards, our winery assets, and our brands, while continuing to push on costs — and that gives me confidence we're definitely heading in the right direction. Then there's another area where specific metrics are harder to attach, but it's similar in nature. Over the past 18 months, we've assembled a best-in-class team, and we have continuity in our leadership group, which I believe provides a strong foundation for us to take on the business now.
Ben Dollard
executiveWith that in mind, I believe every piece is now set for us to keep building on the momentum we have, along with the ties we hold with our distributors and the retailers, and also as we keep getting better each and every day. So I think, you know, from what has been discussed and from my own perspective, this ought to leave us feeling confident.
David Errington
analystI appreciate that. Many thanks to all of you.
Tim Ford
executiveActually, one more thing just occurred to me while Ben was giving that answer. I understand why you raised it, David, since even with negative time — but yeah, the earlier years are something we pay close attention to when checking how we're doing versus our plans, because it's simple to leave the pre-pandemic era behind and begin judging yourself against the years just before. In our case, those prior years with the pandemic and China were the two big problems. So I believe it matters that the way we operate the business and the way we gauge ourselves isn't necessarily only on a year-on-year basis, but rather how we'll stack up when we look back at those stretches of time before the pandemic and what our metrics are around that. That's a really crucial measure for us internally, so thank you for bringing it up.
Operator
operatorThe following query is from Ross Curran of Macquarie Group. Go ahead with your question.
Ross Curran
analystHi team, Ross Curran here from Macquarie. I was hoping we might be able to discuss the new divisional structure. That's slide 31, and how we ought to think about margins across the new divisions going forward. Where they currently trade — that roughly 44% EBIT margin for Penfolds — is that the appropriate level we should expect going forward? And then second on that, if you could perhaps dig a little into Penfolds performance, especially in Asia, and whether we've actually found a level there, close to $500 million of sales. Is that the right base for us to work from?
Tim Ford
executiveSure, I'll cover the margin structure, and then Matt can come in after me as well. I think hopefully we're pretty clear from our Investor Day about the margin structure ambitions that we certainly see. Penfolds will stay in that 40% to 45% range as we move forward over the journey, and then clearly during this fiscal year, as Tom outlined, there are some investments we're making to build that distribution and build that capability in the markets. So we expect we'd still land within that range in terms of what we deliver. I think it also provides a proof point, and hopefully everyone has picked this up over the last six months: we aren't seeing pricing reductions in the markets for the Penfolds portfolio. We're doing a good job with our customers and also doing a good job of maintaining that portfolio's margin structure and profitability as we look to build demand across the different markets around the globe — so that's Penfolds. On the U.S., we remain committed to our ambition of a 25% EBITS margin, and we won't stop until we get there as our first step, and then how do we keep growing that from there?
Tim Ford
executiveSo that's held fairly steady for a while now, and we're very, very strong — that remains our ambition. On TPB, obviously TPB, or Treasury Premium Brands, when you look at the numbers, with Treasury Premium Brands already cut the way it is, there's a meaningful and challenging margin gap versus our ambition, which sits around the teens ambition and the high teens ambition we laid out at the Investor Day. So that's still where we intend to get to. We think we have the roadmap to get them to begin seeing that within the next 12 months. It clearly won't happen in the first 12 months. Still, across the long term of our plans, we have a genuinely strong roadmap of multiple levers we need to pull to get there. I think it's a great illustration of why we hold a strong belief in the operating model we've shifted to. The understanding of Treasury Premium Brands, its P&L, financial structure and portfolio, and how we can actually transform that business, is really, really important obviously for Treasury Wine Estates as we then build three very, very strong divisions, because we have the portfolio, the demand exists, consumer engagement with these brands exists, and now we're focused on how we not only grow them but enhance the margin structure — and growing the top line is still the best route to enhancing that margin structure.
Tim Ford
executiveThat captures our overall ambition in broad terms and how we intend to keep concentrating the business and discussing those three divisions. Matt, is there anything you'd like to add to that?
Matt Young
executiveYes, I think regarding Penfolds in Asia, unfortunately it isn’t quite so straightforward as simply using that as the base. There are probably three factors to consider as you look ahead. First, those figures do include the first half of China, so obviously there is a component there that would not recur going forward. Tom walked you through the distribution and brand-building plans we are executing. We are seeing some success from that in Q4, and that will be a path forward for fiscal ’22. And then the third element is a key factor. Remember that it is a major driver of Penfolds’ performance in Asia, which comes through luxury channels and through the movement of people. So again, those are elements you would need to take into account regarding what that would look like going forward.
Ross Curran
analystI appreciate it. That covers everything on my end.
Tim Ford
executiveMuch appreciated, Ross.
Operator
operatorThe next question is from Richard Barwick at CLSA. Please go ahead with your question.
Richard Barwick
analystThanks, and good morning, everyone. I just want to pick up a bit on what Ross asked about Treasury Premium Brands. I suppose the weak spot there really stands out — it's Asia, with revenue down 46%. How much of that involves Rawson's that would have gone into China?
Matt Young
executiveAn overwhelming share of it—Asia broadly, but definitely Rawson’s and the other labels we had in China. As you can imagine, once the August announcement came, that meant talks with our partners there and carrying brands amid some uncertainty. And although we managed to sell Penfolds in the run-up to November, that proved a harder task, which we discussed at the half year for Rawson’s and the rest of the brands in Asia.
Richard Barwick
analystThank you. And then when you look at Penfolds and the Americas, that was a bit surprising to me. Given the California collection launch, that has gone backwards. I mean, does that reflect — going back to, I think, Tim’s answer earlier to David’s question about the channels that are shut? So if we think about Penfolds in the U.S., is it because of the Cellar Door and the On Premise?
Tim Ford
executiveSure, but underlying that is solid results from the California collection, even though it’s genuinely a small part of the year — so basically, you’re looking at just one quarter’s worth of performance there. That said, you’re right: channels like cruise, travel, and on-premise closures over the course of the year did weigh on the Americas, but we remain fairly comfortable with how that’s doing in the U.S.
Richard Barwick
analystNow, when we consider Penfolds in the U.S., it leans toward the channels that remain under pressure.
Tim Ford
executivePlus independent luxury retail, which includes on-premise, independent luxury retail as well as travel retail.
Richard Barwick
analystYeah, okay. And just one last thing from me—I mentioned minimal EBITs out of China in FY ‘22. Could you clarify or confirm that when you say minimal, you still mean positive?
Tim Ford
executiveEssentially zero, or slightly above it.
Richard Barwick
analystAll right, then — thanks, everyone.
Tim Ford
executiveAppreciate that, Richard.
Operator
operatorShaun Cousins from UBS has the next question, and his line is open. Shaun, the floor is yours.
Shaun Cousins
analystHello there, and thank you very much. Good morning. My question is about 19 Crimes, if I may. Since you mentioned that it has surpassed 1 million cases across EMEA, could you quantify how large the brand is overall? Also, should we anticipate that some of the brand extensions which worked well in the United States might show up in other markets? It appears to be a brand you've managed to extend widely, and clearly it has performed quite well too. So I'm curious about its current scope and perhaps what the plan is going forward for that brand, please?
Tim Ford
executiveYeah. Sure, Shaun, good to hear from you, and your use of "rather" feels a bit tough, but it's been quite successful. The — Well, we now have a second global brand in our portfolio. Well yeah, Penfolds is obviously a global brand, but 19 Crimes has clearly now reached that status too, and in broad terms it's roughly a 5 million case business for us worldwide at this point. And the point you raised, I think it's a really, really important one for understanding how we think about 19 Crimes. So obviously the United States has been the starting point for 19 Crimes' growth, where the core range, or 19 Crimes Core as we call it, yeah, it's kept delivering fantastic results for a number of years, and adding innovation through the partnerships with Snoop Dogg and Cali Red and Cali Rosé, and as Ben said, more to come is a roadmap in which we keep innovating, we keep engaging differently from other wine brands with consumers, and clearly it's working. Clearly it's a non-traditional way of connecting with consumers, and we certainly feel like we've learned a hell of a lot as we've built this in the United States.
Tim Ford
executiveAfter that, the next major market you encountered—and observed—was the U.K. Once more, it's a comparable approach, and you should anticipate that in time we'll keep taking what we've accomplished in the U.S. as a model and carry it across the U.K., and that turns into part of the 19 Crimes expansion plan; the same applies in Australia, the same applies in Asia. Asia contains quite a few markets, so those roughly four make up the sequence, and as we keep developing the market—moving a bit ahead with America, then into the U.K., then into Australia, then into Asia—we will subsequently carry over the successes we've achieved, since what matters is how we truly activate that brand and engage those consumers. So viewing it as a global brand, viewing it as a brand that needs and will keep having investment behind innovation, plus, you know, the way we do that via partnerships and digitally enabled channels—that is genuinely the crux of it and of drawing new consumers into the wine category. So yes, it's a quite, quite exciting future for what we internally call the 19 Crimes franchise, but hopefully I've clarified how we think about the model.
Tim Ford
executiveObviously, our approach won't be attempting every single thing across every market simultaneously. That has to be built up gradually, and as we develop it, the U.K. and Europe clearly become the next destination for us.
Shaun Cousins
analystAnd when we look at those 5 million cases, would it be fair to say roughly 3 million of them are in the United States, in the Americas, and then the remaining two—1 million in EMEA and the other 1 million down in Australia? Is that the right way to think about it?
Tim Ford
executivePretty much. More or less accurate for the U.S. and U.K., Australia, and then Asia, you know. So Australia — Asia is probably — Australia isn't a million, it's under that, and then Asia accounts for the remainder.
Shaun Cousins
analystThanks — and one question is for Matt, about cash conversion. You mentioned that shifts in the regional sales mix had an effect. Is that because, as you've moved toward more distributors or different distributors, you're essentially getting paid sooner, and so should we expect that cash conversion has stepped up as a consequence of the change in route to market? Or could you expand a bit more on that regional sales mix shift and what it means for cash conversion, please.
Matt Young
executiveWhat we're seeing is a modest structural change — moving away from China, which had somewhat longer credit terms, toward other partners across the rest of Asia that offer somewhat shorter terms, and that's mostly tied to shipping time. So because of that, and because shipping times this year have been a bit earlier, that's the main piece. So I wouldn't say it ought to cause any major change to models around cash flow, but there is a modest structural change in that kind of move away from China.
Shaun Cousins
analystAll right, great. Thank you, Matt, and thank you, Tim.
Operator
operatorThe following question is from Phil Kimber with Evans & Partners. Go ahead with your question.
Phil Kimber
analystHey everyone. First off, I want to approach cost of goods sold from a different angle here. What I saw—and it's the first time in quite a while—is that your Cigar <<inaudible>> figure has actually turned positive. My read is that this might serve as somewhat of a forward signal regarding the COGS outlook for what's roughly our one-year EBITS and then two, three, four EBIT. Is that right, and does it leave you feeling confident that a reasonably solid COGS tailwind is genuinely on the way from FY23 onward? I just wanted to dig into that a little more, thanks.
Tim Ford
executiveI have to say, Phil, it's a wonderful occasion when Cigar comes up on an investor call. No one has ever posed that question to me before. So, look, I'd say Cigar takes in the current vintage along with the effect of earlier vintages, but during fiscal 2021, the current vintage effect of Australia as a Cigar is a profit, and that does point to a reduction in cost of goods for Vintage 21 in Australia. That isn't necessarily the effect of a trend, since future vintages and so on will have an impact. Still, for Vintage 21 in Australia specifically, that is definitely a positive sign, yes.
Phil Kimber
analystAnd that's really 23, 24 — commercial does come through, um, but that also has some tricky terminology now, though I can't remember it. So Masstige and Luxury are coming through in, sort of, the second, third, and fourth year.
Tim Ford
executiveRight, so commercial for this year. For next year, the year after that, and from then on, let's call it premium, and Luxury after that.
Phil Kimber
analystYes. My second question concerns the selling price, since the weight on this, in a sense, can be seen in a very off-premise market, driven particularly in the U.S., and those figures are now declining due to base effects. So I just wanted to get a sense of — as the on-premise portion of the business begins to improve, I mean, I just wanted to double-check that. The channel shift from on-premise to off-premise did, net-net, actually act as a drag on your earnings. So as those gradually unwind, hopefully that will become a tailwind on earnings. I just wanted to confirm there wasn't a risk that, with the off-premise on a year-over-year basis starting to come off simply because of base effects, it was — you know, there's a risk around it being a little bit of a hole in case the on-premise doesn't quite peak out as fast.
Tim Ford
executiveYeah. I believe the assumption behind your question is exactly right, since we are indeed seeing that as on-premise reopens, the mix of both our sales and our portfolio will keep getting better, and as a result the margin structure of that mix will improve as well. So we definitely view that as a favorable development ahead as these channels open up, and we have already witnessed it to some extent in the U.S. The U.S. is a strong illustration of those dynamics, and once I'm done Ben can likely speak a little about the U.S., which is probably the best example we have. So, first point, yes, we definitely see that trajectory as vaccination rolls out and things reopen with those more Luxury channels, and from a growth standpoint that is a positive for us. The second remark there, and as you say it is something we have been watching quite closely internally, you look at the Nielsen's <<inaudible>> or IRI or whichever data you choose to look at, and year-on-year the retail channels are down compared with the trends of what it was last year, when there was that initial real spark in the retail channels. So, that is factual broadly across the board, certainly in pockets of Premium price points, that's not right, but broadly across the board.
Tim Ford
executiveIf you move back an additional year and compare the current market with how it stood before COVID, it remains elevated. That’s a genuinely important point to keep in mind, and when we examine our figures and our performance, we focus not on lapping COVID and all the things people typically like to discuss. Right now the question is: are we part of a competitive set in today’s market? Yes or no? And are we in fact ahead of where we stood on a pre-COVID basis in fiscal ‘19 — that’s a better way to phrase it. So retail dynamics are still quite good when you step back and view things from that angle. There are, in a sense, two points here: yes, the softness in retail that you mentioned exists, but as a mix going forward, we definitely see the one plus one, hopefully equaling more than two, as it did in F19 — that’s how we think about it. But Ben, would you like to add anything, some color on that from the U.S. perspective, since you’re living and breathing it?
Ben Dollard
executiveYes, I have a couple of things to cover. Like I said before, things are changing in U.S. markets, and we definitely observed that in the second half on the retail side — often it's retail — and I'd point to two main areas. First, there's the rise of e-commerce expanding quickly, along with the involvement and dedication of our retail partners and consumers' wish to buy online. That has been — and will keep being — a huge focus area for us, and we're beginning to see the results of our efforts. Second, there are the cellar doors and how we've been approaching cellar doors and the closures. What we saw at this same time last year and as we reopen and welcome consumers back in. Clearly that's a plus from a margin perspective for our Luxury portfolio, and that's a clear shift we're going to see in the back half, assuming the landscape keeps developing the way it is today.
Tim Ford
executiveI hope that gives you a thorough sense of the answer. It's always nice to hear from Ben, since you can tell he has that upbeat tone about loss locked, once vaccination programs begin rolling out for us here in Australia. So that's good — I speak with him each morning to keep myself up. Thanks, Phil.
Phil Kimber
analystAll right, thank you everyone.
Operator
operatorBen Gilbert from Jarden Australia has the next question. Your line is open, Ben — go ahead and ask.
Ben Gilbert
analystGood morning, Tim and the team. I have one near-term question and one longer-term question. On the first one, I realize the wording around your medium-term targets and cost-out plans and so forth is all fairly comparable. It has stayed the same because the strategy is right. But clearly you have kept that qualification in there regarding the COVID impact or the capacity to achieve that kind of high-end single-digit earnings growth for this year, at least. Given the reopening, and Tim, to the point you just made, that the U.S. is opening up on-premise and it is going rather well, do you still believe that is conceivable for this year, or was there some reason to include that qualification, or is it simply general uncertainty?
Matt Young
executiveMatt speaking. The overall uncertainty matters, and it's also key that folks grasp the slide we included in the deck showing where each of the channels stands. What you should take from it is this: looking ahead, we don't anticipate big shifts in the landscape broadly speaking, apart from a gradual reopening in on-premise. We aren't counting on much growth in travel, which strikes me as a sensible assumption, and because of that the base is fairly steady. The main purpose is simply to let people see, especially through that slide, how the dynamics affect revenue as they make their own forward-looking assessments.
Ben Gilbert
analystAlso, Matt, in the second half did you see any gain from China profit, from Penfolds product that you shipped in pre-December? Since clearly it appears sell-through — sales of Penfolds — remains quite strong in the Chinese market. Everything is sitting with product, especially to move that at a considerably higher price. Did you record any profit in the second half?
Matt Young
executiveFrom a continuing standpoint, there's nothing significant you need to take into account. One small parcel did work its way through the process. But no — there's plainly still product headed to market, and Tom can speak to that somewhat, yet there's nothing to weigh from an ongoing view. Attention now turns to how that looks going forward, and I know there's some — perhaps Tom, if you'd like to offer a longer-term perspective on how we view Australian base Pinfolds for China.
Tom King
executiveYes, I’ll take that one. I’d say the genuine bright spot for us is that consumer demand remains strong for both brands, even as pricing has kept climbing and some areas of the portfolio have risen quite sharply versus where they stood a year earlier. We intend to launch the new Australian collection in H1 of this year, and those bottles will of course carry tariff-affected prices. So it’s a little soon to judge whether Penfolds can stretch that far on elasticity, or what demand will actually look like at a higher price point. The encouraging part is that the brand is still strong with consumers. We are shedding some distribution, since retailers and wholesalers are finding it hard to keep supply and stock in place, and a lot of our partners continue managing their own cash flow and operations so they can preserve and build growth as we roll out the multi country of origin portfolio in F22 and after.
Ben Gilbert
analystThat's useful. And maybe the second one for me, just on the strategic front. I saw you made some comments about capacity for funding. First, did you folks make a decent attempt at trying to sell? I was surprised — I figured you'd have had more synergies from some of the benefit you got out of the INDC <<inaudible>> deal. And second, is there much out there right now from an M&A standpoint, particularly in the U.S., which I think is probably always the biggest opportunity?
Tim Ford
executiveYes. I won't say either way whether we examined specific items. But I think the way to address it is this: any acquisition targets we do review — and we will review them, and should, when such opportunities come up — must fit with the Premium price point of our portfolio. So if something sits below that Premium price point, you can infer from that, that generally speaking, unless there's a major strategic justification beyond it, it won't be a priority for us when it comes to deploying our capital going forward. So they have to be additive — any acquisition would have to add to our portfolio, and be complementary to what we have today. I don't believe we necessarily need more of exactly the same thing. What we do need is to actually build out the portfolio in a way that builds on the strengths we've got. The U.S. is certainly a market — I mean, we've all seen there's a fair bit of activity in that market at the moment. Well, I think that will continue to be the case over the next year or two in particular.
Tim Ford
executiveSure, opportunities are going to present themselves — I don't doubt that at all. But hopefully that gives you a sense of the color and the shape of our priorities as we evaluate those.
Ben Gilbert
analystAbsolutely, that sounds excellent. Appreciate it, everyone.
Tim Ford
executiveThanks, everyone!
Operator
operatorThe following question is from Peter Marks of Barrenjoey Capital. Go ahead with your question.
Peter Marks
analystMorning, Tim and Matt. I wanted to see if you could add some detail on how much of that non-Asia growth came from building availability as opposed to sell-through. What I'm trying to get at is what selling and selling out looks like, because I would have thought — maybe I'm not looking at it the right way — but wouldn't that be the strongest signal of demand?
Tim Ford
executiveYes, I remain fairly at ease. From an inventory standpoint, our approach is to keep forward days of inventory cover aligned with what we had a year earlier, and I'd say we are still in that position. So clearly, once we had sold and fulfilled that demand — which I suppose was latent in the market — the selling certainly has to meet that demand. As you have likely observed across many years for Asia, shipments run ahead of depletions, mostly driven by rising demand for the brands. That is definitely true of what we have done. There is no pipe fill, so I would not describe it as a bump that needs worrying about. I do believe it is a genuine — let's call it an underlying performance in those markets.
Peter Marks
analystThat's quite useful. Now for my second question, I was hoping to get some clarity on certain one-time costs that may have sat above the line. From what I can see, there appears to be an $8 million benefit tied to wildfire insurance claims, yet there may also have been a roughly matching headwind in China from some one-off costs, so the two could essentially cancel out. Beyond that, could you shed any light on the one-off costs in ANZ connected to that product that was originally intended for China? And also, how large were the Brexit costs in EMEA?
Tim Ford
executiveOkay, I’ll take that one. Let me begin with insurance, and for anyone who wants to work through it, especially the balance sheet P&L, note 4 in the annual report’s financial statements is worth reviewing, since it contains some sizable movements. You’re roughly correct that, on a net P&L basis, the impact is approximately $8 million; that reflects the effect of closing our Sterling Tasting Room and the lost profit from product that was damaged. So I’d say that is an underlying base that should appropriately remain above the line. As for ongoing — as for other one-off costs, there were a range of different items, including reworking products in China and in Australia that had been destined for China, plus Brexit costs. We have not broken those out separately in the accounts. We have essentially provided them as color around the COGS impact. From that standpoint, yes, they are one-off and will not continue next year, but I think most of those fall within COGS, and the guidance we have provided on elevated COGS for fiscal 2022 is the right way to think about that line.
Peter Marks
analystYes, and then have you put a number on how much Brexit has affected things?
Tim Ford
executiveNope, we haven’t — not in that particular market.
Operator
operatorThe following question is from Bradley Beckett at Credit Suisse. Go ahead with your question.
Larry Gandler
analystHey, everyone, this is Larry calling from Credit Suisse. Appreciate you taking the call. I have a couple of questions—I just want some clarification, going all the way back to what Mike Simotas asked. Matt, you said you agreed with Michael that it remains elevated, which means the drag in FY’22 will be similar to FY’21. But that contradicted the earlier portion of your answer, where basically you said elevated was kind of similar. That is a big distinction. So I just want to clarify: in FY’22, will it be a similar drag, or a similar absolute level of COGS?
Matt Young
executiveOn a mix-adjusted basis—adjusted for volume mix—COGS per case comes out about the same in absolute terms.
Larry Gandler
analystUnderstood. So while fiscal year 2021 took that hit, fiscal year 2022 won’t carry the same drag, since we’re looking at comparable COGS.
Matt Young
executiveThat's correct. There's no incremental drag coming into play. On a volume mix adjusted basis, it will stay at those elevated levels seen in fiscal '21, and again, it will take longer term for that to come down as a result of the programs and the roll through of lower cost vintages.
Larry Gandler
analystAll right, that clears up that point. Turning to the lower-cost vintages — I realize Matua may look like a relatively smaller piece of the business, though it's a very important growth brand, especially in the U.S. As all of you are aware, the supply picture there has gotten almost desperate; essentially no new planting can be done in Marlborough, and we're short on supply. I believe grape costs are climbing toward 50%. So with that in mind, I know you've done a fantastic job securing grapes for FY ‘22, but over the longer term, what's the strategy for Marlborough, Sauvignon Blanc, and Matua in your hands? And what impact did that have on your overall grape costs?
Tim Ford
executiveYes, thanks, Larry. Over the longer term — I won't necessarily lay out the plans we're currently examining, since we're in the midst of weighing a few options for that longer horizon. As you mentioned, in FY '22 and FY '23, our teams did a fabulous job securing access to supply for Sauvignon Blanc — not only Matua for the U.S., but also Squealing Pig here in Australia and certain other markets around the globe. It's a growth engine for us, and over the coming years we'll need to secure access to more fruit, and we do believe there are certain ways we can achieve that. We have certain plans to implement across that, though none have come to life for say '24 and beyond at this point. But it matters to us, and it's a higher priority for us, because we see this category continuing to grow and continuing to be a growth engine for us, and Ben touched on the launch of Matua Lighter earlier, and you can sort of join the dots on consumer trends around health and wellness.
Tim Ford
executiveHe has connected the pieces regarding Sauvignon Blanc as a style category — a proposition with lower alcohol or even no alcohol for New Zealand Sauvignon Blanc. You can definitely see strong demand ahead as well. So that's one of those areas where the short to medium term is handled, but there's still work for us to do on the long term. So your points, and the fact that you wrote about them, which I read with interest — you know, I believe you're correct. It's a challenge we have to grapple with, but we feel there are still some levers for us to pull, so. And then obviously, as those constraints arise, prices are simply adjusting the market too, and you've witnessed that with the U.S. in particular across a few of the other major Sauvignon Blanc brands as well, which we keep using as a potential for us going forward to protect the margin structure of the portfolios as well, given the rising fruit costs over the last vintage or two.
Larry Gandler
analystAlright, one question here for Matt. Basically, does that Sauvignon Blanc cost jump represent a big enough increase to shift the needle on your overall COGS outlook?
Matt Young
executiveNot to that extent. The sole point I would add — and I believe the remark regarding Australia is likely more pertinent — is this. The one other thing I would append to what Tim said is that clearly a portion of the COGS difficulty for New Zealand during this year — and by this year, I mean the current vintage — relates as well to how large the vintage is, with that vintage having been affected late in the process. So there is a — overall it was a vintage with lower yields. A vintage of more normal size in the future would fix part of that cost base.
Larry Gandler
analystAll right, thank you very much. Appreciate it, everyone.
Tim Ford
executiveAlright. I believe we’ve unfortunately reached the end of our time. Today’s presentation slot was shorter, and ideally the Q&A portion will be longer so we can give fuller answers. I know a few people didn’t get the opportunity to ask their question, but we will definitely follow up on those during the one-on-one sessions we have scheduled over the coming couple of weeks. So, to close things out, thank you for being with us today. Thank you for supporting TWE and for the analysis you do on TWE, and I hope you share our confidence in what has been a strong year for our business, especially given the circumstances, and that we have positioned ourselves for a robust stretch ahead for both our business and our team. So cheers! Have a great rest of your day.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Treasury Wine Estates Limited transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Treasury Wine Estates Limited earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Treasury Wine Estates Limited or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.