Treasury Wine Estates Limited (TWE) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary

February 14, 2023

Australian Securities Exchange AU Consumer Staples Beverages earnings 88 min

Earnings Call Speaker Segments

Operator

operator
#1

We appreciate everyone being on the line, and we're glad to have you join Treasury Wine Estates' TWE FY '23 Half Year Results Conference Call. <<operator_script>> At this point I'll turn the call over to Mr. Tim Ford, CEO. Please proceed.

Tim Ford

executive
#2

Thank you, operator. Good morning, everyone, and I appreciate you being here for the TWE 2023 Interim Results Briefing. With me today are Matt, Tom, Ben and Pete, just as we've had across quite a few halves now. All of us are glad to share our results for the first half of fiscal '23. This was a period in which we kept moving forward on delivering our long-term financial objectives. In doing that, I think we've established a significant proof point regarding how strong and resilient our global business is — especially our team's capacity to steer through the shifting economic landscape and the changes in consumer and market dynamics we've witnessed. We achieved solid earnings growth along with margin expansion during the half, as EBITS rose 17% to $307.5 million and the EBITS margin climbed 3.2 percentage points to 23.9%. We take particular satisfaction in reporting that margin expansion given the climate of elevated cost inflation, and we are making excellent headway toward our long-term target of 25% and beyond. Three main factors drove this performance: expansion within our luxury portfolio, the successful rollout of price increases across a number of key brands, and cost savings delivered by our global supply chain optimization program over recent years. Happily, and this matters a great deal, Penfolds, Treasury Americas and Treasury Premium brands each posted better revenue per case, EBITS and EBITS margin in the half.

Tim Ford

executive
#3

While the wider macroeconomic environment is still somewhat unclear, worldwide wine category trends have largely held steady. At the luxury end, the category's demand fundamentals remain robust, and our brands have kept performing well in every key market, which we expect to persist. In the important December quarter trading period, consumption and market trends at the entry-level premium price points in the US, $8 to $11, along with commercial wine price points globally, came in softer than we had anticipated, and that has contributed to volume declines in Treasury Americas and Treasury Premium brands, respectively. With that in mind, we do expect these trading conditions to hold consistent through the second half, and we remain on-track to deliver the expectations we set out in August for strong EBITS growth and EBITS margin expansion in fiscal '23. Now I'll briefly touch on a few other key performance and financial highlights. Premiumization of our portfolio sales continues, with 85% of our global revenue in the half now coming from the premium and luxury portfolios, up 2 percentage points versus the prior year. Net sales revenue rose 1% to $1.3 billion, driven by luxury sales growth and price increases across key portfolio brands, partly offset by declines in the commercial portfolio and the entry-level premium declines in the US that I mentioned earlier.

Tim Ford

executive
#4

That very robust sales mix—driven by the category's and our business's continued premiumization as well as price accretion—meant revenue per case rose 13%. So beyond the strong EBITS growth, we achieved growth in net profit after tax, and together with earnings per share that was up 19%. Cash conversion came in at 68%, consistent with what we expected at the end of the half, and we're on track to hit our full year target of 90% or higher, which we always achieve. Leverage improved to 1.7 times, comfortably inside our 1.5 times to 2 times through-the-cycle range, which speaks to the ongoing strength of our balance sheet and leaves us well-positioned, with options to deploy that strength to keep driving growth and shareholder value going forward. Lastly, the Board has declared a fully franked interim dividend of $0.18 per share, giving a payout ratio of 67% for the half—again toward the upper end of our target range, and a 16.7% increase on the prior comparable period. Each of the brand portfolio divisions made great progress against their key strategic and financial objectives during the half. Penfolds stayed focused on executing its strategy of drawing new consumers to the brand, expanding distribution and availability in a highly targeted way across a number of global markets and channels, with excellent top line growth delivered throughout Asia, Europe and Australia.

Tim Ford

executive
#5

EBITS rose 10% during the half, and the margin stayed exceptionally strong at 44%. Within Treasury Americas, top-line growth came primarily from luxury portfolio brands such as Frank Family Vineyards and Beaulieu Vineyards, while our premium portfolio saw continued growth from Matua, along with category-leading innovation delivered within 19 Crimes. Those are the highlights. During the half, we also put through price increases on key brands, which gave us a very strong foundation and significant progress toward our EBITS margin target of 25% for the TAM business. On the downside, sales volume fell in 2 of our entry-level premium price point brands, the 19 Crimes Australian source portfolio and the Sterling brand, both affected by softer consumption and market trends relative to what we expected in the December quarter. Apart from that decline, we're pleased with how we executed and performed against the broader US category and our competition. That shows up in our delivery of 35% EBITS growth and margin growth to over 23%, as I mentioned. That said, we also recognize that a favorable exchange rate did help that headline result. And on a constant currency basis, EBITS rose by 15%, which is the baseline measure this leadership team holds itself to.

Tim Ford

executive
#6

And for Treasury Premium brands, we kept moving forward on our long-term financial priorities, delivering 15% EBITS growth and lifting the EBITS margin to now more than 11%. The top line took a hit from declines across the commercial portfolio volumes that affected the whole category. Even so, thanks to a better mix, the price increases we delivered, and once again, an improved cost of goods, we were able to expand gross profit. So in a moment, Tom, Ben, and Pete will lay out in more detail the headlines I've just given you for their respective divisions. But before that happens, I'll pass things to Matt, who will walk everyone through the financial results in greater detail.

Matthew Young

executive
#7

Thanks, Tim, and good morning, everyone. I'm happy to walk you through our half year financial results. Group net sales revenue rose 1.4% and fell 1.1% on a constant currency basis. Several factors sit behind this revenue outcome, and the team will go into them shortly, but at a headline level, they matter and are worth understanding right away. First, our luxury brands keep delivering strongly across Penfolds, Treasury Americas and TPB, and they stand as a strong proof point that our strategy is being delivered in the half. Within Treasury Americas, as we flagged before, we're selling the lower-yielding 2020 luxury vintage, which was smaller than prior years. Given that, we've put through price rises to reflect the shorter supply, and those are offsetting the impact of lower volumes, as did the strong demand for our newly acquired brand, Frank Family Vineyards. Taken together, this meant luxury revenues for Treasury Americas grew in the first half at an overall level, but supply held them back. Most importantly, we're well set-up for the future through the strength of our luxury distribution, the price rises implemented in the period and COGS improvements still to come. Second, as Tim shared, we've seen consumption in market trends for entry-level premium wine in the US and UK, and commercial wine globally, soften in the important December quarter trading period relative to our expectations.

Matthew Young

executive
#8

Because of that, our revenue growth for Treasury Americas and TPB came in below what we expected. There are already plans in place to address these trends in the second half and beyond, and the team will speak to those. As a consequence, we recorded lower volume and constant currency revenue overall, yet with the better luxury mix and gains from higher pricing, NSR per case rose 13% for the group, and 11% on a constant currency basis. COGS per case was up 1% constant currency, which mirrors the portfolio mix — more heavily weighted toward luxury — and the fact that those wines were mostly sourced from the higher-cost 2020 vintages. Even so, the gains from our global supply chain optimization program launched in fiscal '20 came through as expected, with total benefits of $28 million in the half, keeping us on track for our targeted fiscal '23 run rate of $65 million. EBITS reached $307.5 million, a strong 17% increase on a reported basis and 14.7% constant currency, and EBITS margin rose to 23.9% — excellent progress toward our long-term target of 25% and beyond, achieved in a setting of elevated cost inflation. ROCE rose to 11.2%, reflecting strong earnings growth and relatively consistent capital employed.

Matthew Young

executive
#9

And lastly, leverage came in at 1.7 times, which is consistent with what we had anticipated as we work toward deleveraging throughout fiscal '23. Total material items for the first half of '23 showed a gain of $19.7 million, or $15.4 million after tax, tied to the previously announced programs of work as well as the acquisition of Chateau Lanessan. Apart from that acquisition, all of these programs have now been completed, and the total costs of the program came in under their initial estimates. Now shifting to the balance sheet. Net assets rose $160 million compared with the prior year on a constant currency basis. The main items affecting our balance sheet during the half, aside from working capital, include the acquisition of Chateau Lanessan and the divestment of non-core supply assets in Australia and the US. Looking at inventory in more detail. The total value of inventory was up 9% on the prior corresponding period. Current inventory rose $100 million, which reflects expected future demand for our premium and luxury portfolios, while non-current inventory was up $62 million versus the prior year. Within that, we'd note that premium inventory has risen, and it does reflect the moderation in sales performance for our premium portfolios during the half. This will be handled through the normal course of operations via future sales plans, or as we rebalance inventory levels through future vintages.

Matthew Young

executive
#10

Now moving on to cash flow and net debt. For the half, operating cash flow before interest, tax and material items came in at $258 million, and reported cash conversion was 67.7%. If you strip out the changes in non-current luxury and premium inventory, cash conversion stood at 62.9%. Cash conversion was lower than what we saw across the last 2 half periods, but it matched our expectations, and that reflects a working capital cycle that's more normalized than what we saw historically before the disruptions of the last 2 years — and that's a trend we'd expect to see in half year results going forward. We still expect full year cash conversion to align with the target we've stated of 90% or higher for the full year fiscal '23, excluding changes in non-current luxury and premium inventory. To give this some color, cash conversion over the last couple of years ran higher than normal, and that was driven by a number of factors tied to vintage sizes and the rebalancing of our business in response to the loss of China market, including reductions to luxury inventory. As we've shared previously, we feel the better measure is to assess cash conversion excluding moves in non-current luxury and premium inventory, with our target being 90% or higher over the full year.

Matthew Young

executive
#11

This metric factors in builds as well as depletions. To give you a clearer view of that particular measure, we've added another slide that lays out how cash conversion has been delivered historically, on both a half-year and a full-year basis, with changes in premium and luxury non-current inventory excluded. The light pink bars you see are the first-half results for the last 5 years. Over the last 2 years, cash conversion has come in higher than normal, which reflects changes tied to sales timing — specifically, first half '21, when the impending loss of the China market led to an earlier shipment profile. Then in first half '22, we pulled sales forward within the half to lessen the impact of supply chain disruptions. But if you look further back, from first half '18 through first half '20, lower cash conversion was not unusual, reflecting the normal skew of luxury sales toward November and December. Importantly, though, when you look at the dark red bars, which show full-year cash conversion, you'll see that for all years, full-year cash conversion landed in line with our stated target of 90% or higher, no matter the variability in the first half, and we hold the same ongoing confidence and plans, which will deliver cash conversion in line with that target for fiscal '23.

Matthew Young

executive
#12

Turning now to capital expenditure. CapEx totaled $65 million across the first half. That figure comprised $36 million in maintenance CapEx plus $25 million for buying a vineyard in the US that we had previously leased. For fiscal '23, our expectation for maintenance CapEx remains roughly $100 million. Lastly, on capital management. At the close of H1, leverage had improved to 1.7 times, which sits comfortably inside our target range of 1.5 times to 2 times and aligns with what we expected for delevering through fiscal '23. Our liquidity is still solid, with more than $1.5 billion in cash along with committed undrawn debt facilities. Our capital structure still mirrors the disciplined, strategic way we approach capital allocation. As we said in August and repeat now, we are looking at capital management opportunities beyond ordinary dividends, though we will pursue them within the context of, and measured against, our priority of evaluating chances to invest in organic and inorganic growth or activity. Thank you. With that, I will pass things to Tom.

Tom King

executive
#13

Thanks, Matt, and good morning to all of you. Reporting another strong outcome for Penfolds is genuinely a pleasure. Demand for the Penfolds brand has stayed robust worldwide as we carry out our strategy centered on bringing in new consumers and expanding global availability. Volume rose 4% and NSR rose 7%, respectively, fueled by ongoing expansion throughout the portfolio in Asia, EMEA and Australia. NSR per case was up 2%, helped by price increases on our luxury cabinet bins that face supply constraints. COGS per case came down, mirroring incremental product costs taken in the prior period along with gains from the supply chain optimization program, partially offset by the release of wines from the higher-cost 2020 vintage. Our cost of doing business rose 5% as we keep investing in brand building and organizational capability while we focus on speeding up our global momentum. That produced a first half EBITS gain of 11% to $182 million, with an EBITS margin of 44.3%. The first half brought plenty of execution highlights. We achieved strong distribution growth in Asia, Australia and EMEA, successfully securing target accounts across our priority growth markets. Revenue in the Americas region declined, though that mirrors shipment timing in Latin America, and we keep delivering positive momentum in the United States, where our depletions continue to grow.

Tom King

executive
#14

August's launch of the 2022 Penfolds collection proved a tremendous win. For the first time, it brought together 3 countries of origin, among them the debut offering of the French portfolio, and critics, customers and consumers all reacted favorably. Within the 2022 collection sat the 2018 range, which earned several hundred point scores. Growth across our multi-country of origin portfolio carried on as we introduced One by Penfolds in China — a new culture-led, entry-level luxury wine tier made up of wines from France, the US and, for the first time, wine sourced and produced in China. A worldwide rollout is scheduled for early in fiscal '24, which will further strengthen our platform for connecting with new luxurians around the globe. We keep scaling our luxury standing by giving consumers immersive Penfolds experiences. Our venture beyond thematic rollout carried on, taking in gifting, in-store activation and media, along with the highly successful execution of Penfolds towers across multiple cities worldwide, among them Sydney, Singapore, Bangkok, Miami and Los Angeles. Those are merely a handful of highlights from a very dynamic first half of fiscal '23, and our results mirror the outstanding execution and momentum we've built in the business, which we expect to carry through the second half.

Tom King

executive
#15

Appreciate it. At this point, I'll pass things along to Ben Dollard.

Ben Dollard

executive
#16

Thanks, Tom. Morning, everyone. It’s great to be with you today from Napa Valley, California. I’m happy to walk through the fiscal ’23 interim results for Treasury Americas. Our Americas business has a positive outlook, and we’re outperforming the category. We keep bringing industry-leading innovations to market and are making meaningful strides in strengthening our luxury credentials. Volume and NSR fell 15% and 4%, respectively, due to the premium portfolio, mainly the 19 Crimes Australian sourced wines and Sterling vineyards. A strong luxury portfolio performance partly offset that, and I’ll cover this in more detail shortly. Outside innovation, depletions beat shipments by 200,000 cases during the half, and its after case rose 13%, reflecting better mix and price increases on key luxury and premium brands. COGS per case was higher this period, reflecting the improved mix, partly offset by gains from the global supply chain optimization program. Cost of doing business rose this period, driven by employee costs as staffing levels normalized after labor shortages in the prior period. We generated EBITS of $115 million, up 15%, with an EBITS margin of 23.7%, strong progress toward <<inaudible>>.

Tim Ford

executive
#17

All right. It looks like we've misplaced Ben there in the U.S., so I'll give my best attempt at channeling Ben Dollard. I won't claim that, well, I realize we couldn't even out on a few of the bits either, so I apologize for that. Treasury Americas will pick up right where Ben stopped. As he mentioned regarding the margin ambition, we achieved the progress we were aiming for during the half, and actually, we're ahead of where we thought we'd land. Luxury trends are still strong, too. We also have the lower-yielding 2020 California Vintage, and that is going to hold back our luxury volumes in F '23 — we've been clear on that point. During the first half, Frank Family Vineyards powered our luxury results, and it shipped ahead of plan in order to meet strong demand and fuel our distribution expansion in key accounts. We have a guarantee, or rather we acquired, a terrific brand in Frank Family, along with Vintage 22, which is the final vintage in California. The first one since we took on the brand, we successfully locked in the incremental sourcing needed to back the plans we have for delivering growth from F '24 onward. We also witnessed some incredible momentum behind Beaulieu Vineyard — BV, as we refer to it — this half, with Vintage 2019 Georges de Latour earning a 100 point score from James Suckling. That's an incredible achievement, and as a team we're very proud of it.

Tim Ford

executive
#18

So we believe our luxury business is in excellent shape. Our brand portfolio is incredible, and we're highly focused on growing the luxury segment and building equity in our brands. Within premium, we have a concentrated set of brands that fits well with both current and emerging consumer trends. This half we've observed some softness in entry-level premium versus what we expected — specifically at that 8 to 11 price point — which hurt performance, most notably at 19 Crimes and Sterling. Digging deeper, though, 2 trends are playing out inside the 19 Crimes portfolio. First, our innovation keeps leading the category. Cali Gold came out this half and, in only 19 weeks, became the top sparkling NPD in the US market for calendar year 2022. That is a pretty remarkable result. It follows earlier wins from Cali Red, Cali Rose and, more recently, Martha Chard. And over the last 3 years, that means Treasury Americas has brought the number one innovation to the US wine category. On the second part of 19 Crimes, our core portfolio sourced from Australian wine has lost some momentum amid a tough market, and over recent months we've put a plan in motion to genuinely reinvigorate that portion of the portfolio for its next stage of innovation and growth. We'll share more specifics in a couple of weeks' time, but it's quite exciting, trust me, what we intend to bring to life there for 19 Crimes around the world.

Tim Ford

executive
#19

With that in mind, our confidence in the 19 Crimes franchise's outlook stays very strong. Performance across components is great; there are ones we need to lift, and lift them we will. Matua keeps delivering strongly. So when we discuss 8 to 11, certain brands are doing very, very well — Matua, for instance, is up over 30% in this half, backed by innovation through Matua Lighter, a mid-strength proposition. As we look toward half 2, we do expect trading conditions to stay consistent for the rest of the year, with more activations across our premium portfolio — 19 Crimes in particular sits at the top of our agenda and is expected to deliver a balanced earnings profile across the year. To sum up, we're confident in the US business's strategy and in the solid foundation we've built over the past 2 years for growth. I'll now pass things to Pete.

Peter Neilson

executive
#20

Thanks, Tim, and good morning, everyone, from a chilly evening here in London. I'm really pleased to report TPB's first half results for fiscal '23 — a period in which our core brand portfolio kept connecting strongly with consumers, and we made further progress on our key financial priorities: premiumization, earnings growth and margin expansion. A few of our key performance metrics: volume and NSR declined 10% and 5%, respectively, driven primarily by a 14% decline in commercial volumes, most notably in the UK and Australia, reflecting the continuation of softening category trends for wine below $10. That was partly offset by strong growth in Southeast Asia, benefiting from our significant distribution gains over the last past year and continued momentum for 19 Crimes, which grew revenue by over 11% across TPB geographies. NSR per case increased 7%, reflecting the benefit of price increases across select brands and markets and continued portfolio premiumization, with the premium and luxury portfolio now contributing 61% of divisional NSR, up from 58% this time last year. COGS per case increased, driven by the luxury-led portfolio mix, with COGS benefits from the supply chain optimization program being the key driver of improvement in our gross margin.

Peter Neilson

executive
#21

Expenses related to operations came down 7%, a figure that included a $6 million gain from selling assets in Australia as well as putting brand investment first. Consequently, EBITS rose 42% to $45 million, and the EBITS margin climbed to 11.6% — one more step toward our target of a high-teen margin. For 18 months now, we have operated the TPB business under the new divisional model, and the progress achieved has been genuinely considerable. Compared with when we introduced the divisional model, the business is in better shape, and we have delivered against its objectives and expectations. Much has been learned over this stretch, and we have gained far greater clarity regarding the opportunities and challenges that lie ahead. Our confidence stays very strong in the health and outlook of our core portfolio of brands, among them Pepperjack, Squealing Pig, 19 Crimes, St Huberts The Stag, Wynns and Rawson's Retreat, to name just a few. Consumers connect powerfully with these iconic and trusted brands, and they will serve as a great long-term growth engine for the business. Growing these brands globally is the right strategy for us, and we are witnessing strong distribution growth particularly across Asia and Europe. We have also confirmed how important leading category innovation and inventiveness are to the future of the TPB business.

Peter Neilson

executive
#22

Appreciate it. Tim, over to you again.

Tim Ford

executive
#23

Thanks, Pete. This is Tim speaking as Tim, not as Ben. So I think if we step back, 2.5 years ago we set out our 2025 strategy and the blueprint for the next stage of our journey as TWE, which centers on our ambition to be the world's most admired premium wine company. We're now effectively at the halfway point of that first 5-year plan and 5-year strategy, and we're firmly on track. That's reflected in the half year results we've announced today, and we keep showing not only progress toward our key strategic priorities but also further strengthening of the key financial metrics we outlined at the start of this 5-year journey, of which we're at half time. So if you look at the rest of the year, the execution priorities for each division remain consistent. We're focused on a very clear path to delivery, both in each of the divisions and also globally as TWE, with our long-term growth and financial objectives. And we continue to leverage our global strengths and capabilities around our culture, our people, our capability, technology, and looking at accelerating our focus and investment around sustainability, which we're doing a great job on, and pursuing innovation and complementary M&A to enhance our brand and asset portfolios.

Tim Ford

executive
#24

To sum up, we made solid headway on our growth goals during the first half of fiscal '23, especially with regard to EBITS growth of 17%, which was backed by better revenue per case and EBITS margin expansion in every division. Turning to the rest of the year, we anticipate that trading conditions will be largely in line with what we saw in the first half, and we remain on course to achieve both strong EBITS growth and EBITS margin expansion for the whole of fiscal '23. For the full year, we do expect the margin to come in at approximately 23%, and underpinning that outlook are our expectations for continued strong performance from our luxury brands and better momentum in Treasury Americas across our premium portfolio, led by increased activation for 19 Crimes. And lastly, we stay committed to our long-term financial objectives, which, as I remind you, were delivering sustainable top line growth and high single-digit average earnings growth over the long term. At our Investor Day next month, the leadership team and I genuinely look forward to laying out in more detail not only how we are progressing toward our financial growth objectives, but more importantly, what we are doing to drive the next phase of our game plan of our strategy, including updates on some exciting innovation within our brand portfolios, how we are building capability, and further detail on the key elements of our sustainability agenda.

Tim Ford

executive
#25

We’re glad to have everyone here in Napa, and we’re also looking forward to those days together. Obviously, we’ll cover more specifics at that point. So thank you for being with us today. Sorry about the switch in speakers as we moved along, but I’m sure we’ll now get to the Q&A, and Ben will be back online. So we’ll begin that. Thank you, operator.

Operator

operator
#26

<<operator_script>> Our first question is from Shaun Cousins of UBS.

Shaun Cousins

analyst
#27

I have just a couple of revenue questions. Regarding 19 Crimes, the US data we can see through the end of January continues to worsen, with the 4-week figure worse than the 13-week figure. Have you begun putting the new plans for 19 Crimes into action? How soon can those be rolled out, or will they really only start to have a positive effect in, say, the June quarter?

Tim Ford

executive
#28

I think I'll begin with the fact that the plans we're putting in place are aimed at the longer-term next phase of 19 Crimes. So over this half, we'll begin to carry out more of what I'd call the tactical implementation of those plans. As I've said at previous times, it's very dangerous to look at 4 weeks, particularly when you're lapping different periods and years of different periods. So look, from a 19 Crimes point of view, we have a lot of confidence, and there are 2 halves, and I want to make sure this is well understood as well. And I think it is, but I just want to make sure. When we look at 19 Crimes, not only the global brand, but within Treasury Americas, rightly the questions come from today. There are 2 parts to the 19 Crimes business. There's the innovation, which sits in the 11 to 14 category in the 19 Crimes in the IRI data that you see, which is around the partnership with Snoop, Martha Stewart and those sorts. We are significantly outperforming the category when it comes to our performance on 19 Crimes. It's slightly under our expectations, as we had very, very high expectations, but we are outperforming the category. So we continue to drive category-leading innovation.

Tim Ford

executive
#29

Looking at the 8 to 11 period, Australian core, we're basically aligned with the direction the category is heading across 13 weeks, 26 weeks, and 52 weeks, correct. On the last 4, Shaun, I accept your point there. I won't attempt to dispute that, since the data speaks for itself. But when you examine it across the longer timeframe, we aren't beating the category, and that was our own expectation, right? So we don't accept sitting in line with the category, which is the situation right now. That isn't what we expect. And that's precisely where we've underperformed during the past 6 months. What we'll be rolling out isn't just strong execution but a brand platform, which comes more toward the back end of this half, while the tactical execution is definitely in place across the coming couple of months. Another thing on 19 Crimes I want to bring up is, as we step back — and I'll be answering plenty of questions today covering the 6 months, but also keeping in mind this halfway point of our 5-year strategy, which the leadership team has devoted a big chunk of time to really analyzing and understanding whether we're on the right track at this midpoint.

Tim Ford

executive
#30

And with 19 Crimes, the reason is that if you look back 2.5 years, yes, it's now a 5 million case brand globally. It's doubled over that period of time. From a volume point of view, it's more than doubled from an NSR point of view, and it's 10% up more than 10% up from an NSR per case perspective. So this brand is all about innovation. And what we haven't done is got the blend right between the innovation around the core portfolio and the partnerships and the Cali collection within the United States. And we've learned from that and we'll fix it. This is not a problem. This is absolutely a continued growth engine for a lot of years from our perspective. Tom will tell, is our execution going to improve and been on the team now in the US, that's what they're going to do. And globally, we're going to do the same as well. So as I said, I'm not kicking the can. I'm trying to tease for the Investor Day, Shaun, in March, but we're going to take you through pretty much how we're going to roll this out in a great deal of detail, and I'm pretty sure you'll have the same confidence that I've got in it.

Shaun Cousins

analyst
#31

Thanks. My second question concerns what you said about 2023 — the second half of '23 — where you expect trading conditions to be broadly similar. Is it fair to characterize that as expecting a comparable revenue profile as well? When you mention the 23% EBITS margin ambition in the fiscal guidance for fiscal '23, the market has already reached that level, but the miss came on revenue. So if the first-to-second-half pattern repeats what we saw in the first half, on its face that points to a downgrade versus consensus estimates. I'm therefore curious whether your remarks on trading conditions being broadly consistent in the second half relative to the first half also imply that from a net sales revenue standpoint, please?

Matthew Young

executive
#32

Matt here. Absolutely — our commentary highlights earnings along with margin expansion, and it ties back to what we said at the beginning of the year about strong growth and margin improvement. A few perspectives I should share for each division: for Penfolds, we anticipate balanced earnings growth. For Treasury Americas, we also expect balanced earnings delivery, which I think speaks to your question. We're aiming to push a more premium portfolio mix in H2. H1 leaned more toward luxury. As you can imagine, that shifts the margin expectations, but it will fundamentally produce a different top-line picture for the Treasury Americas business in H2, with Treasury Premium brands facing essentially similar trading conditions to what we've seen, so more stable. So overall, the softening in that intra-level premium commercial segment, we expect it to persist and to affect revenue growth relative to our expectations. But certainly, given the luxury mix and the work we're undertaking in that area, we do anticipate balanced trading conditions and earnings in some of those divisions.

Shaun Cousins

analyst
#33

What it does suggest, though, is that revenue growth improves, since you begin to see the Americas — the US in particular — performing somewhat better, with less dependence on premium; sorry, with luxury premium needing to carry less of the load on the revenue side there too.

Matthew Young

executive
#34

That would be correct, based on what we plan for and expect from Treasury Americas.

Tim Ford

executive
#35

Sorry, let me just add something to that. If you think about it — yes, we have the next 6 months ahead. But as we move into fiscal '24, I'm certain that's also weighing on people's minds. Conditions have stayed quite steady across the last 12 months or so, when we consider the effects of inflation, interest rates, and all of those sorts of things. So we believe that consistency within the category is there. It's just those couple of points of execution that we need to improve so we can match the execution that's really strong in those other areas too. So our medium-term expectations on revenue growth are not changing. We don't view the Americas as now being a cost out to drive growth story going forward at all.

Operator

operator
#36

The next question is from Michael Simotas at Jefferies.

Michael Simotas

analyst
#37

I'd like to pick up where Shaun left off with his question about the outlook, since I think that topic has generated a fair amount of discussion and confusion this morning. During August, you stated that you anticipated strong EBITS growth, and at that point there was a very clear implication that this meant above 20%, which is roughly where consensus landed. You have made that remark about strong EBITS growth once more, and I do understand the point you just raised regarding revenue. Is it your suggestion that you still expect to achieve EBITS growth of around 20% across the full year, despite what was said about margins and despite the first half delivering only about 15% at constant currency?

Matthew Young

executive
#38

Michael, this is Matt. I believe we have set out the components for how investors ought to view the entire year. For the first half, a 17% rise in earnings is something we would call robust. And we believe, especially considering certain shifts versus what we had anticipated within the premium category, that we have managed to steer the business toward an excellent result. We remain dedicated to that, and I think we have provided you the core components for the first half compared with the second half that support achieving that robust growth.

Michael Simotas

analyst
#39

Right, I hear that. But six months back, you described 22% as strong in your view. So I'm simply attempting to pin down precisely what the message here is.

Matthew Young

executive
#40

Well, the first thing I would point out is that at no point did we ever suggest fiscal '23 would come in at 22% growth, and we didn't provide a specific figure when it came to fiscal '23 either. What we did do was reiterate that the growth would be strong. And without getting into various numbers, we believe we've delivered on that.

Michael Simotas

analyst
#41

Perhaps to shift direction slightly, regarding the US market. Look, it's fairly evident from certain industry data that backs up what you've said about the $8 to $11 price point, quite recently and late in the half of last calendar year, there seemed to be some softness at premium price points as well and some signs of trading down. I realize conditions can be uneven month-to-month, but is that something you're monitoring, or do you remain very confident at the premium end of the market?

Tim Ford

executive
#42

So what you're getting at, Michael, is luxury — you're talking more about the luxury side?

Michael Simotas

analyst
#43

I'd say we were viewing it as somewhat above $20, and toward the close of the calendar year we had a couple of months that were fairly soft.

Tim Ford

executive
#44

Yes. So for us, within that market, our portfolio is essentially $30 and up. So from where we sit, yes, we monitor it closely. We have not observed any softening. What we have seen is that IRI trends have shifted, because there is less luxury wine available to sell across all suppliers in the US market than there was before. So I have seen a channel shift there. Our results on the luxury portfolio are exactly where we want them to be. So no softening do we see, and no concern going forward do we see. And in fact, given how we have built distribution, how we targeted that distribution, and how we have taken price to improve the margin profile of our luxury wine during this half, that creates a fantastic platform for us going forward as more wine becomes available to sell when we release future vintages. So nothing but positive, I think, in terms of how we have built the luxury business and how we have used the conditions that exist this year to our advantage to layer grade platform.

Ben Dollard

executive
#45

Tim, it's Ben here — could I just add to what you said?

Michael Simotas

analyst
#46

From where I sit, that's absolutely the case.

Tim Ford

executive
#47

Ben, over to you.

Ben Dollard

executive
#48

Yeah, I think one element of how we view that space and our capacity to keep winning also has to do with innovation. So there's some white space in our portfolio, and we're actively working to bring in some new lifestyle luxury propositions that I think are really exciting and that will keep augmenting the portfolio. So beyond everything we're doing in terms of execution on the current portfolio, innovation is going to play an important role too.

Operator

operator
#49

David Errington of Bank of America has the next question.

David Errington

analyst
#50

Tim, over the years I’ve watched 2 Treasury Wine CEOs lose their jobs because of the situation. And I have to say, I’ve been burned twice and lost the little I had left here. What I still have is riding on what happens in the US commercial market. So when I’m told that the US commercial market is declining, I get anxious and start asking questions — is there an inventory issue over there, or what exactly is going on? Because once again, the stock is signaling that something is off. So please, can you give us something that builds confidence we aren’t looking at a repeat of the past, where problems emerge in that commercial segment, sometimes beyond your control because the market is weakening — but do you have an inventory problem? And can you give us a bit of reassurance, if you will? Because you’re telling us sales will improve in that fourth quarter, and I think you need to offer us something today that strengthens our confidence that you can fix a key part of your portfolio — entry-level premium and commercial in 19 Crimes — but I don’t think it’s sufficient for you to simply say, trust us, we’ll get it right.

David Errington

analyst
#51

Since, as I mentioned, getting this right matters quite a lot, could you sweeten the pot a little by walking us through some of the programs you have in place that give us some added confidence?

Tim Ford

executive
#52

I'll handle this one, Ben. I realize you're likely eager to jump in, but I'll give the response. From a US perspective, I think, first of all, yes — this isn't an issue tied to the commercial wine category. We're no longer in that commercial wine category, which sits below — so that's the first thing to set straight, and that category keeps declining substantially. So I'm quite pleased we're out of it now. This is a markedly different business from what has happened previously. I'm not arguing with or dismissing your points about history, right? So please don't read that into this answer either. But if we step back and look at how I see this business today in Treasury Americas, again, at the midpoint of where we are, we're going to stay the course, and my conviction is strong. So I'm not faltering — that's point one. Point two, if you examine the components of our strategy in the US and what's delivering, our luxury business keeps performing well and keeps beating the market. Number one. We have premium brands that are beating the market. Matua is a great example of that.

Tim Ford

executive
#53

St Huberts The Stag gives us another instance of that smaller base, yet it is beating the market. With 19 Crimes we have innovation in 11 to 14, and that is outperforming the market by a wide margin. One component of a brand is declining, though it is a single-digit decline, and we need to put more investment behind it and improve the way we execute that brand, and we know precisely what we will do there. I won't walk through promotional activity and that kind of thing on today's call, but it's a wider question of how we build that brand and keep innovating, which is the point. So then you step back and ask, right, what makes the U.S. business different? Because I want to answer this in a fulsome way, since this is how I think about the US and why I believe it is different, and I certainly won't be the third CEO run out of town because of it. The first one is luxury, which I touched on. Our distributor partnerships are right on track. BBG, RNDC, in particular, our 2 large partnerships we made those changes 2 years ago. Absolutely, we are performing ahead of their house when you look at the wine category in that market.

Tim Ford

executive
#54

That is what we have to do. I mentioned innovation. We are, by a wide margin, the strongest innovator, and in the United States that is a growth engine—a 100% growth engine—and we will keep pushing that forward. And we have demonstrated it. We have completed the entire supply chain effort and the restructuring of the asset base. We also have cost of goods getting better continuously across the coming 2 years. So cost improvement ought to be coming through as well. And we have a team that, in my view, is performing tremendously. So we can either concentrate on the single pit that has underperformed across our most recent 6 months—not across the most recent 2 years, only during those 6 months—relative to our expectations, or we can offset that with what I would call the 7 or 8 other key proof points of our strategy that are exactly on track. So that is my view of it. That is how Ben sees it. It is how the leadership team sees it. And that is my perspective on it.

David Errington

analyst
#55

My second question — unless Ben wants to defend his turf on that one — but my second question is a bit of an ambush question. And you probably don't have the numbers in front of you, but I'll read them out to you as you'd expect, I would. Twelve months ago, you had a big step-up in luxury, current inventory, a huge step-up of around $180 million at cost, and we had another big step up, and I've been calling this out, we're getting big step-ups in current luxury. Now if I look at your increase in luxury sales, I mean for the half, I think Penfolds only increased by about $30 million. I think it's the number, about $30 million, that will do. And you've got the Frank Family sales increased by 70%. Now given that the cost increased the luxury cost inventory 12 months ago increased by $180 million and yet your sales of luxury have only increased by around probably 100 for a half. That suggests to me that you're holding wine back. So are you holding luxury wine back with the possibility that China might reduce its tariffs because the sales in luxury, the step-up sales in luxury on a volume basis just don't marry the increase in the inventory that we have been seeing over the last 12 to 18 months of luxury wine, particularly in that current inventory levels.

David Errington

analyst
#56

And especially 12 months ago, current luxury saw a really big step-up, and we simply aren't seeing that reflected in sales coming through. So what I want to ask is: are you deliberately holding it back? That would make sense if that's what you're doing, but I think you need to be transparent about it if you are.

Tim Ford

executive
#57

I never actually got to your inventory question earlier, and I don't want you thinking I was dodging it. There was no inventory issue for us in the US. So let me settle that point from your earlier question. My apologies for not answering — I kind of got rolling on the strategy part. On this topic, no, we aren't sitting on inventory because we expect China might really reopen during the coming period. Our inventory is — first, for this half, we've sold the inventory we intended to sell from a luxury standpoint, and we hold the appropriate level of inventory to meet our growth plan in the second half and on into FY '24 and into FY '25. That's the way we manage our luxury inventory. So you have the numbers, and I won't get into the detail. Matt can probably chime in if he'd like on how it all fits together, but the simple way we see it is that we have the right inventory to deliver our growth plan next half, next year and the year after, with China still closed at this point in time being our assumption.

David Errington

analyst
#58

But those figures just don't add up, Tim. I'm not sure whether Matt wants to — the math simply doesn't work, since current inventory has risen sharply, especially in luxury, over roughly the past 12 months. That increase isn't showing up in current sales. Something about your numbers is off.

Tim Ford

executive
#59

Instead of using the upcoming period to compete over figures on this bid — and let's not do that; we'll handle it with you as we move through the calls over the coming couple of days, David, and I'm glad to do so. So I'm not attempting to fiber-off here, but I think that's likely the best format for us to genuinely walk through and grasp what you're seeing. We'll walk through what we're seeing, and then we'll come to LA if that works.

Operator

operator
#60

The following question is from Richard Barwick at CLSA.

Richard Barwick

analyst
#61

To pick up on what David was asking, if inventory isn’t being adjusted in anticipation of China, then maybe the real question is: how fast would it take — or what length of time would be needed — to source and produce the 600,000 cases of bins and icons that were effectively being sold into China and now no longer are? So if China reopened today, how quickly could you create that extra volume?

Tim Ford

executive
#62

Clearly, this will take us several years as we build up the vintage capabilities and the intake needed to support that. Given that our age of release is 3 to 5 years, reaching those kinds of numbers would require a long period of time. I think, probably, since there are lots of questions around China, it's worth me just spending a bit of time on what we would and wouldn't do, if that's helpful, because clearly there's no change at the moment, and that's very important to note. But yes, there are positive tones saying we've also started to think through what could occur and would occur and what we would — should it change. I think there are a few things we would continue doing that we've already got in place. The first one is working with the Chinese industry around building out our Chinese wine portfolio in that market for Penfolds. We will continue to do that. We'll also continue to drive our French strategy and our multi-country of origin strategy. That's in place. That's on track. That's something we're really driving hard and we've got to continue to grow the other markets, particularly in ground and other parts of Asia that we've continued to — we've had some great success into the point now where we've essentially got supply manning demand.

Tim Ford

executive
#63

During that stretch, we’ll expand those portfolios while sourcing additional volume, which is exactly what we’ll need to do for bins and above. In an earlier time frame, we can source more of that entry-level luxury wine. Take Penfolds Max’s and similar tiers, where obviously we lack that long aging before release and can likely secure access more quickly too. That would be our focus if things shift in the coming period. But really, across the next 2 to 3 years, once we grasp whether a change occurs and how that change is structured, we’re going to lay this out, and we’ll be ready to lay it out in greater detail. But really, the crux for the 2 to 3 years on bins and luxury within the 600,000 cases you asked about will be global demand—we will considerably outstrip supply—and how we handle pricing and allocation during that stretch to keep every one of these markets growing the way we’ve successfully grown them over the last few years, plus re-entry into China, should that happen; that will be the central opportunity we must tackle across that period.

Richard Barwick

analyst
#64

I also have a question about the Americas, and regarding Frank's Family Vineyards, you mentioned it has proven to be an excellent acquisition. Looking at the figures, if you total the period from 2 to 6 months ago, revenue appears to be roughly $110 million, with EBITS of about $46 million — that's nearly a 42% margin. That is far beyond the numbers that were disclosed when you first bought the business. Revenue has risen by almost 50%, and earnings are up by over 60%. So that represents quite remarkable growth within a short span of time. But I notice you also mention, obviously, strong demand, on the one hand, but also a degree of channel fill, though it sounds like you're broadening distribution. So my question, I suppose, is how should we think about Frank's growth over the coming 12 and 24 months, presumably because of this channel fill, you wouldn't expect the same kind of growth that we've just witnessed.

Tim Ford

executive
#65

Richard, maybe I should start by addressing that expectation. When it came to Frank Family Vineyards, what we laid out for the initial couple of years was essentially this: we'd hold things fairly steady, with a bit of growth but not a lot, since supply levels were limiting us—especially for the <<inaudible>> through Vintage 20 and later. That position hasn't changed. What you're noticing, and rightly pointing out for the first half of this year, is that demand led us to ship more than we'd likely have planned. With supply tight across the whole market, we see that as a great chance to expand distribution, and our distributor partners will accomplish that via depletions during the second half. So what you're seeing is broadly a first-half weighting—a pronounced first-half weighting for Frank Family Vineyards in the first half of 2023. There's no additional wine for us to sell in fiscal '23. That extra wine arrives closer to the end of fiscal '24 and afterward. So that's how to think about it—but Ben, maybe you could add some color from the distributors, retail, and on-premise side.

Richard Barwick

analyst
#66

And that applies to the margin as well. To my mind, that's a key element in this, Ben.

Ben Dollard

executive
#67

Yes. Look, I mean, Frank Family has definitely been embraced wholeheartedly across our network, and that's what shows up in the numbers — and it's not a silo system at all, it's demand. When we bought the brand, we recognized there was a chance to broaden our distribution, and quality distribution in particular has been exactly where we've concentrated. So that's precisely where our attention has gone, and the business looks very healthy when it comes to continued depletion growth in the second half. As for how we're thinking about growing the business, harvest '22, especially for Chardonnay, looks really encouraging and aligns with our growth ambitions. So taking a longer view on Frank Family, we stay quite bullish about that opportunity, with distribution growth offering a continuing runway. Our distributors are retailers and, above all, our consumers keep embracing Frank Family and the opportunity in front of us.

Richard Barwick

analyst
#68

So when you take everything into account, is there a risk that you've grown faster than the volumes can actually support?

Tim Ford

executive
#69

Our strategy regarding expanded distribution has been quite intentional, along with genuine account management and how strong that account management is. So as we handle supply across the next 6 months and definitely in the years ahead, I believe we are genuinely well prepared and well positioned to expand it in line with our plans.

Ben Dollard

executive
#70

There's one more thing worth mentioning too — even though you hear some talk about the Californian Vintage being way down last time, which honestly isn't a bad thing for the industry overall. But when it comes to Chardonnay, the Napa Vintage was actually way up. So we're really happy with how the Vintage turned out, and that was a big tick in the box since the growth in demand is clearly there. We had to get that wine supplied. So that was a positive for us in that half as well, and it will support what we need to do going forward, Richard.

Operator

operator
#71

<<operator_script>> Our following question is from Craig Woolford of MST Marquee.

Craig Woolford

analyst
#72

I figured I'd get a question in, like everyone else covering the Americas. There are two parts to it. The first is simply volume. For the first half, volume came in at 3.4 million cases. You said depletion versus shipments differed by roughly 0.2 million cases. Is that a reasonable benchmark for thinking about second-half volumes? That's part one. Part two is a rough calculation, since I haven't had much time this morning. Looking at price per case movement in the Americas, excluding Frank's and the divestment, it appears close to flat in USD terms. So I'd like to understand the price increases that were implemented and why there may have been some offsets there.

Matthew Young

executive
#73

Okay, I'll address those 2 questions. This is Matt speaking, and it's good to talk with you, Craig. On the volume side, yes, you've identified one of the elements that affected volume — during the half, depletions ran roughly 200,000 cases ahead of shipments. What we anticipate for the second half is that it will be more premium led than the first half was. It's difficult to do that without providing a specific figure, and we aren't able to do so at this point beyond describing the balanced earnings profile. That said, if you consider that, you'd generally expect greater volume if we succeeded in carrying out those premium plans, which we anticipate doing. So on a volume basis, that's a fair conclusion. One point I'd mention regarding <<inaudible>> price increases: a number of those increases were put through during the half and across different brands at various times. So in our numbers we're clearly seeing that those price rises have been delivered successfully. We've implemented 2 price increases on Matua during the past 12 months, and Frank Family did have a price increase.

Matthew Young

executive
#74

That accounted for a significant portion, and we've taken it out of the figures you're looking at there, but with Stags and 19 Crimes, especially 19 Crimes, it came in later in the half, and that's a fair-sized piece of it. So quite a few things are shifting around. The price increases are in place, and they've been accepted — certainly at the customer level, where we're seeing strong, I suppose strong alignment with what we expected on the volume side in terms of how the brands have responded to those price rises.

Craig Woolford

analyst
#75

The second thing relates to channels—you know, that traffic-light setup we use for COVID across the different channels. I'd just be curious, if you look back at the first half of '23, how far from normal—in quotation marks—was the channel mix? And is that a tailwind, things like travel retail coming back, for instance?

Tim Ford

executive
#76

I think if we were to show that chart once more, it would come out largely green everywhere, apart from a little Amber and GTR tied to the China market, I suppose, across that 6-month stretch, which involves Chinese travelers, or Asian markets now that Chinese travelers are coming as borders reopen during this half. For names like Penfolds in particular, we should definitely see an improvement in that channel going forward too. But yes, on the whole, it isn't — so the word normal is actually something we will never use right now, Craig. But given the conditions that exist today, certainly not pandemic affected, they are simply what they are today apart from that. So that should support Penfolds performance going forward as well.

Operator

operator
#77

Ben Gilbert with Jarden has the next question.

Ben Gilbert

analyst
#78

To start with one question about Penfolds and what you expect for margins easing in the back half of the year. I realize your earlier guidance leaned more toward some big pipe for this year. What is behind that, though — is it an increase in the promotional program, or what is your thinking? And as you have worked through the reallocation strategy, how do you see yourself positioned now with Penfolds?

Matthew Young

executive
#79

Yes, absolutely — this is Matt. On margin expectations, once we set that base a bit lower, we'd have thought — we were within our plans, anticipating likely stronger performance or a heavier weighting that might come from the Koonunga Hill and Max's tier, whereas performance this year has probably been weighted toward the upper end. We still expect that, and the plans are in place, and Tom can speak to how we're driving some of those more entry-level offerings, but that's the main driver, while the margin is higher than we'd anticipated. I'll pass it to Tom to give a sense of that, but also regarding the distribution build and reallocation.

Tom King

executive
#80

So, two years into the role when the tariffs hit China—honestly, we feel very good about how far we've come. The initial 12 to 18 months, of course, were about making that first push toward the places with the greatest demand among Asian markets, and across the halves we've already reported, we posted some quite robust growth. We're now 18 months into operating under the new divisional model, and that has genuinely let us tighten our focus on building greater consumer demand for Penfolds, pushing availability higher in a range of markets around the world, and then lifting the rate of sale once that availability exists by running genuinely exciting, engaging consumer programs—no matter where we turn up and engage with them. We never doubted that the Penfolds brand carries substantial equity in many parts of the world. And the strength of that equity has, frankly, been very encouraging to us in a number of markets, Europe especially, where this half we've reported really strong growth results. Part of the reason is that, for the first time, we've truly gotten behind the brand, backing it with a dedicated team.

Tom King

executive
#81

At this point we have a genuinely solid group of partners on the ground across every market where we operate, and they've committed to our strategy and want to travel this road alongside us. So yes, the early reallocation has us quite pleased, and now our focus is on the actual growth we're capturing from that broader, more diversified business.

Ben Gilbert

analyst
#82

And my second question is just on COGS. I realize you all now have a clear consensus regarding COGS as we head into '24. It appears there could still be something like an EBIT tailwind of up to $80 million in '24, assuming roughly a 10% decline in grade prices across certain markets. Is that off the table? And could you comment on whether you believe consensus has really grasped what you said about some of those COGS tailwinds as we move into fiscal '24?

Tim Ford

executive
#83

Absolutely. I believe the market gets it now. And what matters most is that we have a delivered proof point from the first half of this year regarding the flow-through from our supply chain optimization. And that is certainly, in my view, a 1.5% COGS per case increase from selling higher luxury vintages this year with the portfolio mix, but also the cost of those and the inflationary impact, I think, is a fantastic outcome. It remains consistent with what we expected — flat COGS on a volume mix adjusted basis for this year. And we have said before that we anticipate COGS per case improving going forward on a volume mix adjusted basis. We still expect that to hold. The program is in place, and the greater flow-through from the supply chain optimization, targeting $95 million — so a further $30 million from today — as well as lower cost vintages from Australia, will begin to flow through over the next couple of years. Having a specific number that I could sort of orient you to, but I certainly think the market has sort of heard what we've said about this and the building blocks toward improved COGS per case.

Operator

operator
#84

Lisa Deng of Goldman Sachs has the next question.

Lisa Deng

analyst
#85

To follow up regarding China's reopening: I get that Penfolds stock within China is at a low level, yet we also understand a fair amount of inventory is sitting outside the country—in places like Singapore or Hong Kong, for instance. Now that COVID border reopening is happening, and assuming tariffs begin to come down, what is our thinking on the potential for the gray market to re-enter? And how fast, how much, and how much of it would we be able to control if that occurs? That's the first question.

Tom King

executive
#86

Let me start by covering how our China business stands right now. The range we've got on offer in that market is performing very strongly. That includes the French wines we introduced, the California champagnes, and most recently the One by Penfolds brand spanning multiple countries of origin. That's the portfolio we've built our Mainland China operations around — our team, our partners, our customers, along with how we activate and execute in the market. And honestly, we're very encouraged by the reception these new countries of origin have gotten from the market and, at this point, from consumers. Beyond China, building growth in domestic markets remains squarely our focus. Markets throughout Asia matter a great deal to us and will keep offering us opportunities to grow. Looking forward, and as we reported today, even in our high market in Australia we're now seeing some strong growth, and that has come off the back of 12 months of hard work and resetting our Australian business in certain places. And across EMEA, we're seeing that high growth there as well. So demand for Penfolds is genuinely global at this point. And as we mentioned earlier, I think we're reaching a point across parts of our portfolio now where demand is exceeding supply.

Tom King

executive
#87

And as we've been doing lately, we're looking at raising prices. On your question about the gray market, that's a market that has always been there, and it's one we keep a close eye on. We've always been made a wave with the first people to make us aware of instances of product showing up. They are our own customers in China. And I connect that to how I started this answer — that we're working with those partners on building a new portfolio of countries of origin. And so any product that does steep-in it's very isolated, that causes disruption to our plans and to their businesses. So with travel now opening up and the borders, the big positive for us in Penfolds is actually the resumption of flights and travel to other markets. We've always had a very significant business in travel channels. We've got some really strong long-standing partners. We've got some great real estate across some really iconic airport locations, and we're really looking forward actually to welcoming travelers back from all over the world. How quickly that will come back, I think is still to be understood. Obviously, flights in and out of China, flight schedules need to ramp-up over-time, but we're very much ready and with inventory and with activation to welcome travelers back to travel channels.

Tim Ford

executive
#88

Lisa, just to restate, and especially in response to what you asked about inventory levels, without getting into specifics: the stock we hold in market has already been sold to those customers, with plans for selling it in those markets outside China. For Hong Kong and Singapore, we have a hub. So on that point, we feel comfortable with those inventory levels. We keep watching them. That inventory is supporting Penfolds depletions in markets outside China for the Australian portfolio. So I just wanted to round out that part of the question.

Lisa Deng

analyst
#89

What I was really referring to is a larger amount of inventory that gray market traders already hold. Do we have a sense of the size of that stock? It isn't ours, but it's actually held by gray market traders, and it could either fall outside our monitoring, be under our control, or head back into China and potentially upset that plan?

Tom King

executive
#90

We do keep an eye on that through the product reaching the market via customers, via our customers, and so on as well. And I think we've been fairly transparent about it in the sense that it's relatively small in nature as well and the number of alerts we've certainly received has come down over the last period of time. So from that angle, I mean, the challenge for us, if China were to reopen, would be around making sure our pricing architecture is right now -- just to be clear, we have a consistent pricing architecture globally. There might be a couple of percent here and there across different markets, but that reopening and managing that price and that consistency globally, we think is the best mechanism for us not only to protect that pricing and the margin structure of Penfolds, but also then to control what could potentially be more cross-market movement of product, which we know very well how to monitor and manage, so we've been doing it for over a decade. But I think that's -- we're well aware that, that could -- that potential sort of open, and it's a good problem to have, and we'll manage that.

Operator

operator
#91

Tom Kierath of Barrenjoey has the next question.

Tom Kierath

analyst
#92

I'm just trying to get a handle on the Americas and what happened in December, during the December quarter. So my sense is that for the half, revenues are down roughly 14% ex-FX on an organic basis. I believe in the first quarter you said trading was more or less in line with your expectations. So I'd assume that's roughly flat or a bit up. But wouldn't that suggest the December quarter is running down around 20%, 25% or thereabouts?

Tim Ford

executive
#93

I'll speak to that in general terms. The quarter covering October, November, and December is a really big chunk of the selling season — in the US, I mean, with the holidays, that period carries extra weight. So if you split a half at 50-50, thinking about that market from a shipment standpoint, I'd say that's not the right approach — that's the broad point. There's a key word in there when we describe how the US performed, I think, which is softening relative to what we expected as well on a couple of those brands, because the actual market has stayed fairly steady. And that's the distinction again. So on a couple of those tiers in the brands, we haven't delivered against our expectations. That's really where it stands for that quarter. Yes, so it comes down to execution, which is within our control. The market dynamic itself has stayed fairly steady. So I think that's an important distinction as well, Tom.

Tom Kierath

analyst
#94

Moving to Penfolds in Asia excluding China, the increase came in at roughly 8%, and that's a step down from what I believe were 100% or 120% gains across the prior few half-year periods. Could you walk us through the reasons behind that deceleration, and share how you're viewing growth in those markets for Penfolds going forward?

Tom King

executive
#95

Okay, so let me just clarify that the reported figure for Asia is 8% for the half. We feel good about that outcome, I'd say. Clearly, this is a shipment figure. Our approach to running the business, as it has always been, is centered on depletion. And when we evaluate our team, our partners, or how they're performing, it's distribution and depletion that we look at. Shipments are essentially a flow among those 2 levers. Of course, last year marked the first time we had wine allocation available for a number of markets in Asia following the tariff situation coming in, demand for it was strong, and we enjoyed a very successful growth year last year. Through this half, we've kept seeing the momentum we've built when it comes to establishing that distribution and activating behind the brand across a number of markets, and we're fairly pleased with the figures that have come through from a shipment perspective, and we remain confident that there is a significant runway of growth for the brand across a number of markets in Asia.

Operator

operator
#96

Jason Palmer with Taylor Collision has the next question.

Jason Palmer

analyst
#97

The first item concerned the inventory restatement you highlighted during the presentation. Is that a matter of discounting, though, or simply an internal clerical reclassification by the business? From what I understand, most of it moves out of luxury and lands in premium.

Tim Ford

executive
#98

Looking back, we made a mistake in how we sorted certain brands between categories. I believed it belonged in premium, mostly within that premium segment. So it was simply a correction we made to fix an error.

Jason Palmer

analyst
#99

My second question concerns how 2022 turned out in California — I know you commented specifically on Chardonnay and Cabernet. Napa volumes, I'm aware, rose slightly, while Chardonnay volume from Napa was essentially unchanged. Could you perhaps describe any further purchasing arrangements you've entered into involving Frank or Stags Leap during roughly the last year, so we can feel somewhat more assured about your capacity to expand those brands, please?

Tim Ford

executive
#100

The sole thing I’d say regarding this is that we are definitely not flat when it comes to our Vintage 22 makes versus prior ones on Napa Chardonnay, Napa Cabernet, and every Napa brand. So viewed that way, the market data I’ve looked at certainly points to meaningful year-on-year growth in Napa Chardonnay. So perhaps later we ought to compare data sources with the calls. But as far as we’re concerned, our intake is definitely not flat from a luxury wine standpoint in that regard, that’s certain.

Operator

operator
#101

Bryan Raymond with JPMorgan is up next with a question.

Bryan Raymond

analyst
#102

Turning to the U.S. and those price hikes you've managed to put through there — I'm just curious how durable you think they'll prove once the supply-constrained situation in the U.S. begins to settle and consumers there run into a few additional headwinds. Clearly, the luxury segment has likely held up a bit better, I'd have imagined, than the lower price points. But I just wanted to get a sense of where you see inflation or price increases flowing through past this year in the U.S.

Ben Dollard

executive
#103

Look, we have taken a very deliberate approach to how we manage pricing across our brands, and particularly when it comes to our luxury portfolio. So this has been a genuinely focused effort. I think as premiumization keeps showing up in the category and in the marketplace, the pricing we have implemented specifically across our luxury portfolio — we feel very confident that it can hold and that it will stick. And we are watching it very closely in relation to how we think about distribution and quality distribution. So we are pleased with the results we have achieved so far. And as I said, we will keep monitoring it and look for further opportunities where that makes sense.

Tim Ford

executive
#104

I'd add as well, Bryan, that at those higher price tiers — which, again, is something we've highlighted today — the increases we've implemented line up very closely with what you'd find across the rest of the market at those same tiers. So in New Zealand, with Matua Sauvignon Blanc, we're putting through price rises in line with that section of the category, and similarly with the other 19 Crimes, again in line with what the category shows. So against the competitive set, we don't anticipate those being major drivers.

Bryan Raymond

analyst
#105

Moving to my second question, which concerns Penfolds' travel channel. I recall having seen certain figures previously, though perhaps I overlooked them in today's materials. Could you put a size on how large the Penfolds business is within that duty-free or travel retail segment, so we can gauge the possible upside? A comparison of the figure before COVID against the present one would, I think, be genuinely useful, if that can be done. This is quite hard to do, because firstly the business has been transformed entirely since the time we originally undertook this, and measuring how big that business is — which would let us estimate its potential scale upon recovery — has proven difficult. Therefore a precise number or a precise guide isn't something I can provide, yet clearly we did have the historical breakdown previously, although circumstances have shifted since that point.

Tim Ford

executive
#106

I think if you want to get a sense of Penfolds, this half is a really good one to do that with — I mean, Penfolds is right where we expected it to be for this half. So on the top line, and from a margin standpoint it's slightly above what we anticipated, but even so, from that perspective it's a pretty great performance, and the mix of growth across the various markets and the various channels, the spread of that business and how consistent the growth has been across those channels — it's been a fantastic half from that point of view. So that's the best guide, I think, when it comes to the future trajectory of that business in terms of consistency. It's right where we expect it to be and on our plan, which then rolls up. It's clearly a big part of our Treasury Wine Estates business when it comes to delivering the objectives that we've set around the total business.

Operator

operator
#107

Larry Gandler of Credit Suisse has the next question.

Larry Gandler

analyst
#108

Turning to China, there's a point I felt deserved some attention. Should China reopen and we indeed witness that rise in luxury demand, you talked about possibly having to think through pricing in that part of the world. I simply remember that the last time Chinese demand really began to open up, quite a bit of harm was perhaps inflicted on Australia and Southeast Asia by orienting toward Chinese pricing instead of China's demand — aligning prices with China. Is that something you're contemplating doing on this occasion? Would you seek to align pricing when confronted with that demand?

Tim Ford

executive
#109

Yes, absolutely. Our pricing structure worldwide is going to be fully consistent. And honestly, we've been doing that for some time now. I realize you're likely looking back — perhaps even to those final couple of years before the tariffs took effect in China — and we became far better at handling our pricing architecture on a global basis. With the way things stand — with Tom heading Penfolds as one division now, it's up to him and his leadership team to manage that effectively. And thanks to our operating model, we can do that far more effectively across all the various markets. But your point is exactly right. We'd handle it consistently, we'd handle it globally, and we have to make sure that the markets where we've enjoyed great success over the last couple of years building ourselves are certainly not disadvantaged in any way, shape or form from that standpoint.

Larry Gandler

analyst
#110

Yet that is exactly what would happen, since should the Chinese consumer prove willing to spend more, and you allow volume to rise toward that top price point, then by implication you would be starving those other markets. So what is your approach to striking that balance?

Tim Ford

executive
#111

That's the potential. I suppose pricing isn't something we control. I completely understand that, but the way we distribute product is what lets us control it. So that comes down to which partners we work with and how we actually handle allocation of that product when demand is greater than supply. We're fairly confident those mechanisms are in place to manage that broadly very well. If it should happen? I'll simply say it again.

Operator

operator
#112

The following question is from Phil Kimber with E&P Capital.

Phil Kimber

analyst
#113

I just have a quick question for clarification. Regarding the outlook remarks about Penfolds, you mentioned supporting balanced EBIT delivery through FY '23. Then for the Americas, you said delivering a balanced earnings profile across the year. Can I confirm you mean earning dollars there rather than earnings growth? Put another way, whatever you achieved in the first half, something similar in round numbers in the second half, or were you referring to growth rates?

Tim Ford

executive
#114

Your conclusion is right, Dollars.

Phil Kimber

analyst
#115

My second quick question is about New Zealand — I'm not sure whether you have any update on that yet. Have any of your vineyards suffered damage? I mean, are there concerns, especially for a brand such as Matua, regarding the ability to source fruit following the terrible hurricane events of the past couple of months?

Tim Ford

executive
#116

The answer is that our vineyards are okay, our people and teams are all okay as well. They've gotten a little more rain than usual, but nothing like that top end of the South Island — where Marlboro is located — that would really have much effect on the vintage at this stage. So yes, we're lucky so far.

Operator

operator
#117

The following question is from Ross Curran at Macquarie.

Ross Curran

analyst
#118

Tim, one more quick point of clarification. Regarding Penfolds specifically, you mentioned lower shipment volumes and the timing of sales in LatAm. I wanted to ask how significant LatAm is for the Penfolds brand. And with the timing issue you flagged, does that imply it returns in the second half?

Matthew Young

executive
#119

We haven’t broken out LatAm’s size by dimension. What I’d point to is that the US in particular—and what we refer to as the US trade portion of that business—keeps expanding and remains genuinely strong. We aren’t guiding to all of that amount returning, though we definitely would anticipate higher shipments or shipment timing shifting into the second half for LatAm. Broadly, however, across the—we’ll handle that throughout the larger portfolio and the broader markets.

Ross Curran

analyst
#120

Is Latin America significant for the Americas?

Matthew Young

executive
#121

Given that this represents a fairly limited portion of Penfolds as a whole, it does matter significantly for the Americas — yes.

Operator

operator
#122

Sam Teeger from Citi has the next question.

Sam Teeger

analyst
#123

Which U.S. channel has underperformed expectations the most, especially during the December quarter? We'd appreciate any insights you can share about customer trends across the different segments of the US on-premise channels.

Ben Dollard

executive
#124

Look, the weakness we mentioned around 19 Crimes is mostly — that brand sits mostly within our national accounts on the off-trade side, and that's precisely where we've been seeing some of that weakness, and it's exactly where our attention is concentrated in all the things we've discussed today regarding the 19 Crimes body of work and the activation we're putting in place. When we think about channels in general, and the on-premise in particular, we've watched on-premise come back strongly, with fewer accounts overall, but the accounts where our brands are a good fit are doing especially well. Much the same applies to our Cellar Door when we consider visitor traffic and the revenue we're bringing in from our Cellar Door — we're happy with how the year has begun, especially since visitor traffic is up versus the prior year and overall spend for gas is rising. So that's an encouraging signal when we think about our Cellar Door traffic. So on the whole, from a channel standpoint, I'd say our portfolio is looking to be in good shape, certainly for the second half.

Tim Ford

executive
#125

Thank you. So we have one minute left. I appreciate you joining. I’m grateful for the questions, and I’m looking forward to follow-up conversations with not quite everyone on this call over the next 2 days, but even more so I’m looking forward to spending a couple of days together in our US business with our US team and the ELT in Napa, which is only 3 weeks away. So we’re in no doubt that we’ll keep exploring some of today’s topics, and you’ll leave with, certainly, the confidence that this management team has for TWE going forward. So thank you for your time, and I look forward to the conversations. Cheers.

Read the full transcript via the API

You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Treasury Wine Estates Limited transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.

Get the API View API docs →

This call discussed

For developers and AI pipelines

Programmatic access to Treasury Wine Estates Limited earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments, full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.

More tools for stock research

OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Treasury Wine Estates Limited or any ticker on your watchlist.

StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.