Treasury Wine Estates Limited (TWE) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
August 15, 2023
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorWe appreciate everyone joining us and thank you for holding. This is the Treasury Wine Estates FY 2023 full year results call. Everyone is currently in listen-only mode. After a presentation, we will hold a question and answer session. To ask a question, press the star key and then the number one on your telephone keypad. At this point I would like to turn the conference over to Mr. Tim Ford, Chief Executive Officer. Please go ahead.
Tim Ford
executiveThank you, and good morning. I appreciate everyone joining us for the TWE 2023 full year results briefing. On the call with me today, as usual, are members of our leadership team: Matt Young, our CFO; Tom King, the Managing Director of Penfolds; Ben Dollard, President of Treasury Americas; and Pete Nielsen, the Managing Director of TPB. I'm happy to share with you today our results for fiscal 23 — a year in which we delivered margin accretive earnings growth, building on the strong platforms we already have for luxury wine growth with Penfolds globally and also with our United States portfolio, and made significant progress in strengthening our operating model for the future. EBIT rose 11% to AUD 583.5 million in the year, and we grew EBIT's margin by 2.9 percentage points to 24.1%. We're especially pleased to report that margin expansion in an environment of elevated cost inflation, as we continue to make progress towards our long-term EBIT margin target of 25% and then beyond. Our performance was driven by continued growth in our luxury portfolios, where our momentum remains very strong, particularly for Penfolds — through the successful implementation of price increases across several key brands with strong equity, and also through incremental cost savings from our global supply chain optimization programs.
Tim Ford
executiveIt’s encouraging that premiumization trends keep advancing in our major markets, as luxury wine remains strong and the premium wine category overall stays resilient. Although volumes at commercial price points are still falling around the world, we’re taking proactive and decisive action so our operating model and our cost and asset base are properly positioned going forward, and we’ve made some very good progress in recent months, which I’ll discuss in more detail shortly. That said, we head into FY 2024 in a strong position to achieve growth, driven by our luxury brand portfolio, our culture-led premium brand portfolio, and the gains from the asset- and cost-based optimization initiatives we already delivered in FY 2023. Our confidence in where we’re headed rests on our diversified global business model, our brands, our markets, our channels, and the portfolios spanning multiple countries of origin, which have proved a major strength, allowing us to adapt and respond to the constantly shifting consumer and economic landscape, especially over the past year. Now, turning to some of the other key performance and financial highlights. Premiumization of portfolio sales carried on, reflecting growth in luxury sales as well as declines in the commercial portfolio, and 85% of our global revenue is now generated by the premium and luxury portfolios, up 2 percentage points from the prior year.
Tim Ford
executiveNet sales revenue did fall 2%, coming in at AUD 2.4 billion. Growth in luxury sales and price increases across key portfolio brands were partly offset by the decline in the commercial portfolio. That very strong sales mix—reflecting the ongoing premiumization of the category as well as of our business—meant revenue per case rose 13%. Beyond strong EBIT growth, we delivered an increase in net profit after tax, which along with earnings per share grew 17%. Cash conversion came in at 61%; excluding the change in premium and luxury, non-current inventory stood at 76%, below our annual target of 90% or higher. That reflects the timing of our sales in Asia during the fourth quarter, as well as earlier timing of supplier payments and promotional spend on our brands in Treasury Americas and Penfolds. For F 2024, we expect cash conversion delivery to be in line with the target. Leverage stood at 1.9 times, still within our 1.5 to 2 times through-the-cycle target, which leaves us once again with a strong balance sheet and options to use that strength to keep driving growth and shareholder value. Lastly, the board declared a final dividend of AUD 0.17 per share, taking the full-year dividend to AUD 0.35 per share—a payout ratio of 67% for the full year, which again sits toward the upper end of our target range and is an increase from 13% on the prior year.
Tim Ford
executiveEach of the three divisions in our brand portfolio — Penfolds, Treasury Americas, and Treasury Premium Brands — moved closer to its strategic goals during the year, and a real highlight was that every one of them delivered growth in NSR per case along with margin expansion on a constant currency basis. Penfolds was plainly the standout performer: strong double-digit top-line growth came through, which speaks to the power of that exceptional brand and to the outstanding work of the team, who keep extending distribution and lifting consumer demand around the world. At Treasury Americas, we kept building our exceptional luxury portfolio platform, putting through price increases across a number of brands and expanding distribution, all in a year when wine availability was constrained. Within our premium portfolio, Matua posted another year of double-digit revenue growth. Revenues for 19 Crimes did fall during the year, yet taken as a whole the brand is outpacing market trends on retailer scan data, which underscores how strong the brand equity in 19 Crimes remains. All told, EBIT margin for the division rose strongly, a reflection of this portfolio mix as well as better cost management. As for Treasury Premium Brands, we kept up excellent momentum across a number of priority brands, and that made possible double-digit gross profit growth for both the premium and luxury portfolios at TPB.
Tim Ford
executiveWhile commercial portfolio volumes fell across the entire category, which weighed on the top line, a better mix and the price increases we delivered helped us achieve gross profit growth. The team has done exceptional work implementing the new TPB operating model and the supply chain restructure that backs it up. In a moment, Tom, Ben, and Pete will each give you further detail on how the three divisions performed. Turning to sustainability: in F 2023, we kept moving forward on what is an ambitious set of commitments across several very important areas. On climate change and energy, one highlight was the launch of Australia's largest winery solar installation, located in the Barossa Valley, and a similar rollout will follow in California during fiscal 24. We remain on track to meet our goal of 100% renewable electricity throughout our operations by the close of calendar year 2024. As a business with a substantial agricultural footprint in key wine-making regions around the world, we have a duty to lead when it comes to water stewardship. In F 2023, we executed our strategy, known as Treasuring Water, which drew on the comprehensive review we finished the year before. Under that strategy, we have pledged to invest in smart water meter technology at all of our high and medium-risk sites, vineyards, and wineries by the end of F 2025, which will let us make smarter, data-led choices about how we use water, especially in our vineyards and wineries.
Tim Ford
executiveDestination Zero Harm remains the focus of our health, safety, and wellbeing agenda. In F 2023, we hit our target for lowering the serious incident frequency rate, and that was backed by the launch of the Build Safe Together campaign across the whole organization, which put a particular emphasis on mental health to add to the strength and physical health we already had. Female representation is still a key part of our inclusion, equity, and diversity commitments. We saw continued improvement in F 2023, with total female representation rising to 42.8% of our total employee population, up 0.9 points in the year, while representation of females across our senior leader cohort held broadly stable. Finally, on this topic, in terms of sustainable packaging, we did not achieve our goal for 100% of our packaging to be recyclable, reusable, or compostable by the end of the 2022 calendar year. That doesn't mean we're not making great progress in the area. For example, at the Barossa Packaging Centre, approximately 90% of production is now recyclable, with the remaining elements reflecting challenges for the broader industry. We are seeking to work collaboratively with our dry goods partners and peers to solve for these problematic materials by the end of 2025.
Tim Ford
executiveOur goal is to be a sustainability leader—not only within wine, but throughout the worldwide beverage industry. There's plenty left to accomplish, yet I have strong confidence that we're headed in the right direction to realize that ambition. During our full-year results update 12 months ago, we laid out what we anticipated for the wine category as economic conditions began to tighten, and our message then conveyed confidence that category fundamentals would stay solid across our major markets throughout this cycle—especially for premium and luxury wine. Happily, 12 months later, events are unfolding just as we predicted, with premiumization still propelling the category around the world and several important long-term consumption drivers holding firm. Luxury wine consumption is still strong, with double-digit value growth posted in a number of markets during the 2022 calendar year, according to IWSR, among them Asia, Australia, and the U.K. In the U.S., meanwhile, we observed modest growth across the market, chiefly because of lower availability from the 2020 vintage, which was affected—as everyone is aware—by the wildfires in Napa. Great results there. Every metric and indicator we monitor continuously points to this trend having carried on through 2023 year to date.
Tim Ford
executiveMainland China consumption did fall in the period, mostly because of pandemic effects, yet we stay confident about the substantial long-term opportunity for the category and for us in that market. The premium segment has held up, as the chart shows, displaying value and volume trends based on scan data, which is the finest gauge of consumer demand. Over the past year, the premium category in Australia and the U.K. has posted value growth, while the U.S. is in very slight decline, although the past 13-week data indicates an improving trend toward growth for the premium wine segment in the United States. In our key markets, we see these trends across both the premium and luxury wine segments staying largely consistent in F 2024. For TWE, strong luxury portfolio momentum carried on in F 2023. It was another year of exceptional performance. Penfolds grew revenue by 15% or more in Asia, Australia, and in EMEA, while also achieving double-digit growth in distribution across the global target account universe... Another highlight was portfolio expansion, with the multi-country of origin focus successfully expanding to include wine sourced from France and China across both the bin portfolio and the newly launched One by Penfolds tier.
Tim Ford
executiveWithin Treasury Americas, even with supply constraints, we broadened both the reach and the caliber of distribution for our luxury portfolio, and we put through double-digit price increases on key brands including Stags' Leap and Beaulieu Vineyard. Beyond that, revenue from our cellar doors and wine clubs rose 10% — a welcome return to growth for a channel that is highly profitable. As we get back — I should note — to a normalized level of luxury portfolio availability starting in fiscal 25, our confidence stays very high in the U.S. luxury portfolio as a solid platform for future growth, both within Treasury Americas and for the group. We also observed several of our premium portfolio brands carrying on their strong performance in F 2023, which speaks to our continued emphasis on investment and innovation. Two standouts were Squealing Pig and Matua, whose global revenue climbed 17% and 11%, respectively, in F 2023, with both brands expanding across multiple markets. For Matua specifically, this marked the third consecutive year of double-digit revenue growth, powered by the United States. Globally, the 19 Crimes brand got stronger as F 2023 progressed. First, in the U.S., 19 Crimes advanced across scan channels for the year, posting 1% growth against a premium segment that, as I mentioned earlier, slipped somewhat, and momentum clearly improved substantially in Q4, consistent with our plans and activation.
Tim Ford
executiveBeyond the U.S., 19 Crimes kept delivering solid results across every other market, with revenue climbing 8%, lifted by gains especially in EMEA and Asia. For this highly important brand, 19 Crimes, our priority during the first half of fiscal 2024 will be rolling out globally our new brand platform, our new package, and a highly innovative consumer campaign. We anticipate that continued growth and better performance for this tier will come through, particularly in the second half worldwide. As we've said before, across this year, 19 Crimes globally as a brand did fall short of our internal expectations. Even so, it beat the market within the premium category around the world. In May, we revealed our plan to put in place a set of initiatives aimed at reinforcing the operating model for TPB. Before I walk through those, it's worth restating what we've discovered about this business since it turned into a standalone division in July 2021, 2 years ago. The priority brands — among them Wynns, Pepperjack, Squealing Pig, 19 Crimes, and St Huberts The Stag — are showing themselves to be a true growth engine, linking strongly with consumers and offering a strong platform for capitalizing on the long-term premiumization trends in the category.
Tim Ford
executiveFor some context, revenue in our priority premium portfolio has compounded annually at 25% across the last 3 years. We see substantial opportunity to expand this portfolio beyond the core retail markets of Australia and the U.K., and we're achieving solid progress, especially in Southeast Asia, where real traction has been built over the past 2 years through growing awareness and distribution for our brands. Since TPB's essence is centered on category-leading innovation, inventiveness sits at the heart of this business's DNA. That has shown up in our product development within the Better For You space, through innovations such as Pepperjack Mid Strength and new packaging formats like magnums, which reflect how strongly this business focuses on being consumer and insight-led. These factors bolster our confidence in TPB's long-term trajectory, with top-line growth and margin expansion led by continued growth of the premium portfolio, which now accounts for more than half of division revenue. Commercial wine, though, consistent with overall market trends, has declined consistently each year, which drives the reduction in total division volume. We do expect commercial volume to keep declining, and with that in mind, we've launched a series of initiatives to get ahead of any long-term adverse impacts, aimed at right-sizing the cost and asset base and ensuring greater operational and strategic flexibility to support continued growth of these premium and luxury portfolios I've discussed.
Tim Ford
executiveThe steps we've taken include cutting overhead expenses so they match the business's future size and scale, reworking our commercial wine supply chain toward what will essentially become an outsourced model that is more capital-light, and divesting plus rationalizing our asset base. Moving commercial wine production over to third-party outsourced providers, shutting down the Karadoc Winery, and selling off commercial-grade vineyards are all key actions that have been or are being carried through to fiscal 2024. Once this program wraps up, we will have secured a number of significant benefits, among them variabilizing the commercial wine cost base, softening the effects of higher COGS stemming from lower commercial portfolio volumes, which reduces TPB's exposure to that commercial wine segment, and boosting our strategic flexibility and optionality regarding the remaining portfolio. As always, we keep evaluating asset and brand optimization initiatives that we believe will further reinforce TPB's operating model. We are confident this business is now structured appropriately to carry on its growth focus on the portfolio premiumization and margin growth strengths that this business does have. With that, I'll now hand over to Matt, who's going to run through the financial results.
Matt Young
executiveThanks, Tim. Good morning, everyone. I'm glad to walk you through the key points from our fiscal 23 financial results. At constant currency, group net sales revenue fell 4.9%, which reflected declines in the commercial portfolio within TPB and drops in the premium portfolio in Treasury Americas. Even so, Penfolds achieved revenue growth of 13.8%, and we benefited from incremental pricing across every division. Those price rises, together with a mix shift toward more luxury premium wines, produced a 9.6% lift in NSR per case, which supports our premiumization strategy. COGS per case rose 2.8%, reflecting the premiumization of the portfolio, though that figure includes the benefit of our 2020 global supply chain optimization program, which delivered $62 million on a run rate for the year. On a mix-adjusted basis, COGS per case came in line with the prior year, as expected. Cost of doing business margin rose 1 percentage point to 22%, driven by lower NSR but also by continued focus on brand investment across the portfolio. EBIT was AUD 583.5 million, up 8.6% at constant currency, and EBIT margin improved to 24.1%, with margin expansion delivered through a stronger portfolio mix, price rises, and strong cost management. ROCE rose 0.6 percentage points to 11.3%, which is progress on our plans to restore and grow ROCE.
Matt Young
executiveTo wrap up, our leverage rose slightly to 1.9 times, which sits within the through-the-cycle target range we've set, and it gives us flexibility to back investment and growth as well as shareholder returns. Thanks to our ongoing emphasis on revenue growth management, we achieved sustainable underlying earnings growth and margin expansion in fiscal 2023, and that will remain a priority in fiscal 2024. We'll keep investing heavily behind our brands, leveraging the momentum we're currently seeing across many markets to drive top-line growth. When we presented back in August last year, we discussed plans for targeted price rises in fiscal 2023. As Tim and I have already mentioned, those increases worked and helped lift our revenue per case and EBIT margin. This slide gives you more detail on the price rises we achieved on the brands we highlighted last year. Those included increases on the Penfolds Luxury Cabernet Bins, for example $10 per bottle on Bin 407. There were also increases on premium brands, including a 6% rise for 19 Crimes in the highly competitive U.K. market and a 10% increase on Matua in the U.S. Importantly, as we continue building the luxury portfolio platform in the U.S., we've implemented double-digit pricing during the current period on supply-constrained brands, products such as Stags' Leap Cabernet, which you see here, but also comparable price rises on the Chardonnay, as well as Beaulieu Vineyard, among other brands.
Matt Young
executiveOur revenue growth management capabilities will provide additional backing for top-line expansion and margin improvement going forward. Material items totaling $109 million, equivalent to $76 million post-tax, were recorded during the year and produced net positive cash flows of $34.5 million. Beyond the work programs already disclosed, expenses tied to rolling out our new TPB operating model and restructuring the supply chain were booked in the year. We anticipate this initiative wrapping up in fiscal 2024, carrying roughly AUD 90 million in total one-off costs, with cash costs of AUD 30 million overall linked to it. Turning to the balance sheet. Net assets rose AUD 90 million compared with the previous year on a reported basis. Main drivers affecting the balance sheet during the half, apart from working capital, include acquiring Château Lanessan and divesting non-core supply assets located in Australia and the U.S. Let me address inventory in greater depth. The overall inventory value climbed 8% against the prior corresponding period. Current inventory grew AUD 42 million, mirroring anticipated future demand across our premium and luxury portfolios. Non-current inventory rose $112 million compared with the prior year. Inside that figure, we observe an increase in premium inventory, which mirrors softer sales performance across our premium portfolios, and this is being addressed via normal operations, through upcoming sales plans, or by rebalancing inventory across future vintages.
Matt Young
executiveFor fiscal 24, our expectation is that mix-adjusted COGS per case will be in line with fiscal 23. This expectation reflects the impact of the lower-yielding vintage 23 intake as well as reduced portfolio volumes, and it also reflects the benefits from the supply chain restructure we announced recently. We think that keeping cost of goods flat during a period of ongoing higher inflation is a pleasing outcome, and it is testament to the flexibility of our teams in responding to changes in the supply chain. Turning to cash flow and net debt. Operating cash flow before interest, tax, and material items came to AUD 443 million for the year, with reported cash conversion of 60.6%. Excluding the change in non-current luxury and premium inventory, cash conversion was 76%, which was below our target of 90% or above. Cash conversion was impacted by the timing of sales, particularly into Asia, with a greater proportion of export sales shipping in May and June, as opposed to March and April and May than we'd planned. Given the value of the sales and the standard credit terms with export customers, this impacted our cash conversion by approximately 10%. Also impacting cash conversion was the timing of global supplier payments and brand investment spend on Penfolds and Treasury Americas.
Matt Young
executiveSpecifically, in these markets, spending on future programs came a bit sooner than in prior years as we prepared for key launches—launches such as One by Penfolds and the new 19 Crimes platform. For F 2024, we anticipate cash conversion aligning with the targets we've stated of 90% or higher. Turning now to CapEx. CapEx totaled $141 million for the year, including $102 million in maintenance CapEx and the purchase of a previously leased U.S. vineyard for $25 million. A highlight was our investment in solar technology across Australia and California, and it will help us reach delivery of 100% of energy from sustainable sources by 2024. We still expect maintenance CapEx for fiscal 2024 to come in at approximately $100 million. Lastly, on capital management. Our disciplined approach to allocating capital and managing cash flow overall has ensured an efficient and flexible investment-grade capital structure is maintained. This remains a key source of business strength and, importantly, will enable continued investment in fiscal 2024. Leverage stood at 1.9 times at the close of fiscal 2023, inside our target range of 1.5 to 2 times, and we expect to delever over the course of fiscal 2024.
Matt Young
executiveOur liquidity is still in very good shape — we have more than $1.4 billion in cash along with committed undrawn debt facilities — and by managing risk proactively, we'll make sure our cost of funds increases only modestly in fiscal 2024, even with interest rates on the rise. As Tim said at the outset, we announced today a fully franked dividend of AUD 0.17 per share, and our full-year payout of AUD 0.35 remains at the top end of our policy range. Thank you. I'll now pass things over to Tom.
Tom King
executiveThanks, Matt, and good morning to all of you. It's a pleasure to share a truly outstanding result for Penfolds. Throughout this year, we have kept witnessing strong demand for luxury wine and for the Penfolds brand around the world. As a team, we have stayed sharply focused on delivering against our strategic priorities, and what we are achieving stands as clear proof of how good that work has been — and I feel enormously proud of the Penfolds team. Volume rose 7% and NSR rose 14%, powered by strong momentum throughout the portfolio in Asia, Australia, and EMEA, by the successful China launch of One by Penfolds, and by growth in our multi-country origin portfolio. NSR per case came in 6% higher, which mirrors an improved mix and was aided by price increases on our supply-constrained luxury Cabernet Bins. COGS per case went up, mirroring the release of wines from the higher-cost 2020 vintage as well as a larger contribution from the higher-cost U.S. and French portfolios. Cost of doing business was up 6%, since we kept investing in brand building to concentrate on speeding up our strong global momentum. All of this produced a 16% rise in EBIT to AUD 365 million, with an EBIT margin of 44.5%. Penfolds has had an exciting year, with plenty of execution highlights all over the globe.
Tom King
executiveWe elevated our strategic emphasis on generating consumer demand, drawing on our extensive understanding of our consumers—both luxurians and connoisseurs—to attract and re-attract consumers to Penfolds, and that shows up in the revenue growth of 15% and above that we achieved across Asia, Australia, and EMEA. Not long ago we brought on board our first creative partner, Nigo, a person whose creative abilities cover fashion, art, and music, to work with us on One by Penfolds, our new brand tier, which draws inspiration from culture, collaboration, and community and is aimed at connecting with the next wave of Penfolds consumers. We overhauled and enhanced our Recorking Clinics, an important means for us to connect with wine connoisseurs, giving collectors a chance to meet our winemakers and take part in a luxury brand experience that only Penfolds can offer. During the Lunar New Year period we introduced luxurious gifting formats, making sure Penfolds stays front and center for consumers at key gift-giving moments. We additionally achieved substantial progress in expanding global distribution and availability, carrying on the rollout of our targeted, data-led approach to scaling our availability in the right outlets with the right portfolio, and then bringing that to life in-store through brand activation to drive rate of sale. This approach of ours is delivering results, as Penfolds outlets and listings increase throughout our priority growth markets.
Tom King
executiveWhen it comes to our emerging markets in Asia, we're concentrating on expanding how many outlets carry our products. We kept seeing strong double-digit growth throughout Singapore, Malaysia, and Thailand, and that positions us nicely to keep growing our top line in those markets. Outlet growth in Hong Kong was slower, held back by pandemic-related restrictions throughout the year. In other key markets, we treat listings as the way we measure distribution. We also achieved improvement in those markets over the year. In Australia, listings rose 7%, which is a very pleasing result for a market that's relatively mature, and there our revenue climbed 18%. Listings in the U.K. doubled, powered by our collaborative partnerships with key grocery channel customers and greater brand investment in that market. In the U.S., listings went up for both the Californian and Australian-sourced wines, fueled by a significant focus in the on-premise and by-the-glass programming to build brand awareness and trial. I'm excited about the significant opportunity that lies ahead as we keep increasing our distribution, and we're confident that will keep supporting our delivery of top-line growth. Our other focus is expanding our portfolio, particularly by accelerating our multi-country of origin strategy. It was a milestone year for the Penfolds collection, with the 2022 collection, including the release of wines from 3 countries of origin: Australia, the U.S., and the inaugural release from France.
Tom King
executiveMore recently, we hit another milestone with the 2023 collection, which brought in a 4th country of origin through the launch of CWT 521 — the first wine at bin level that we've sourced and produced in mainland China. Another key highlight was the successful launch of One by Penfolds, which sold over 100,000 cases in China across e-commerce, retail, and on-premise. In July, we held the global launch of One by Penfolds, with wine from Australia, California, and France adding to this portfolio. That's just a glimpse at some of what we achieved in the past year. We've reached more consumers than ever, and through the expansion of our portfolio we're giving them more choice to experience quality Penfolds wines. I'm excited about what lies ahead for Penfolds in F 2024. Thank you. I'll now hand over to Ben Dollard.
Ben Dollard
executiveThanks, Tom. Good morning. It's great to be with all of you today, joining from the U.S. I'm happy to walk you through the fiscal 23 results for Treasury Americas. All in all, the Americas business is holding up well. We've achieved margin expansion, and across the year we've continued building growth on our key platforms. Our luxury brands — led by Frank Family Vineyards, Stags' Leap, and Beaulieu Vineyards — now represent just under 40% of revenue and keep gaining strength via distribution, expansion, and price accretion, even in a year when we had less luxury wine available to sell than in prior years. We're also making solid progress on executing our plans for the new and refreshed 19 Crimes brand platform — from the new package to the new consumer campaign to the next wave of category-leading innovation the brand has become known for. Now to the key financial metrics. Volume and NSR fell 25% and 18%, respectively, driven by the premium portfolio — in particular, 19 Crimes and Sterling Vineyards. That's consistent with what we signaled going into fiscal 23: reduced availability of luxury wine stemming from the lower-yielding 2020 ca vintage. Shipments trailed depletions by 600,000 cases, which weighed on volumes as distributors closely manage their inventory — a trend visible not just across the wine industry but broadly across other alcoholic beverage categories as well.
Ben Dollard
executiveLooking ahead, we have confidence that the strong, collaborative ties and joint business plans we share with our key distributor partners will guarantee appropriate availability levels so we can keep growing our priority brands. On a positive note, NSR per case rose 9%, which mirrors the portfolio mix shift and the successful implementation of price increases across key luxury and premium brands. COGS per case edged down slightly in this period, as gains from the global supply chain optimization program outweighed the impacts of mix shift. Cost of doing business declined, thanks to lower discretionary overhead costs. We posted EBIT of AUD 204 million, matching the prior period on a constant currency basis, with an EBIT margin of 24.8%, only marginally below our long-term margin ambition of 25%. Moving to progress on strategic priorities, in particular growing our premium and luxury brand portfolios. Within the premium segment, we keep investing in consumer engagement. Matua, our leading Sauvignon Blanc brand from New Zealand, has invested heavily in digital and event activation, promoting our Endless Summer campaign. Matua is expanding rapidly and gaining popularity with consumers, up 10% in IRI channels and outpacing the New Zealand Sauvignon Blanc category. Well, we have successfully launched new innovations, including Matua Lighter in the first half, followed by Matua Coolers cans in the...
Ben Dollard
executiveIn the same way, St Huberts The Stag serves as the official wine sponsor for the X Games, reaching consumers through their outdoor lifestyle. St Huberts The Stag is striking a strong chord with consumers, delivering 19% value growth in scan year and specifically outperforming the total ultra-premium category. Within the luxury portfolio, our execution remained strong despite supply constraints. We are bolstering our luxury platform and successfully implementing price increases across our priority portfolio. We have expanded the breadth and quality of distribution nationally. A further highlight is the improving performance of our cellar doors and wine clubs, with NSR up 10%. Our cellar doors form a key component of our overall luxury strategy and an important means of engaging directly with our consumers. Frank Family Vineyards stood out, delivering results ahead of expectations in its first full year as part of Treasury Americas. We anticipate increased availability of Chardonnay starting in Q4 of fiscal 2024 to support the growth we expect for this brand. Beaulieu Vineyards reached a significant milestone as the 2019 Georges de Latour earned a 100 point score and Wine of the Year from James Suckling. Additionally, the 2019 Napa Valley Cabernet received Wine Spectator's number one Wine Value of the Year.
Ben Dollard
executiveOur leading luxury portfolio is in a strong position. Although supply will stay somewhat tight this fiscal year, even as it delivers growth, we anticipate availability getting back to normal in fiscal 2025, which underpins our confidence in growth and our growth expectations. Turning to the next strategic priority, delivering category-leading innovation. The 19 Crimes franchise kept growing across scan channels, up 1% over the year and beating the market, which was down slightly. That came from Cali Gold, a leading sparkling wine innovation for 2022 and the number 3 innovation in the total category, along with other innovations such as Cali Blanc. Our first limited time offer for St. Patrick's Day of Revolutionary Red Blend worked well, generating significant demand and becoming one of our most productive SKUs in the period. We are focused on better performance in the Classics tier, and we are confident that the launch of the brand's new consumer platform and packaging in H1 fiscal 2024 will strengthen our belief in this important brand tier within the 19 Crimes franchise. We have launched two new brands at the $20-$25 price point, currently a significant gap in our portfolio and a growing segment of the wine category in the United States. Lyric, focused on the attractive Pinot Noir opportunity, and Tapestry, good red designed to appeal to the new luxury consumers.
Ben Dollard
executiveBeginning in Q1 of fiscal 2024, those wines will be available in restaurants and on shelves. Our strategic priorities in the Americas business keep moving forward, and when it comes to fiscal 2024 and the years after, we have confidence in how we execute. Thank you. Pete Nielsen in Melbourne will take it from here.
Pete Nielsen
executiveThanks, Ben, and good morning to everyone. I'm glad to share TPB's fiscal 2023 results — a stretch in which our priority brand portfolio kept building strong momentum in our key markets, and we took meaningful steps toward preparing the business for what lies ahead. Volume fell 10% and NSR fell 5%, respectively, largely because commercial volumes dropped, most notably in the U.K. and Australia, which mirrors the ongoing softening of category trends for wine priced below AUD 10. Partly offsetting that was strong performance in Southeast Asia, helped by substantial distribution growth we achieved over the past year and by continued momentum for 19 Crimes, whose revenue rose 8% across TPB geographies. NSR per case was up 6%, reflecting gains from price increases on select brands and ongoing portfolio premiumization, with premium and luxury portfolios now making up 61% of divisional NSR, compared with 58% this time last year. COGS per case rose, driven by a portfolio mix shift and partly offset by benefits from the supply chain optimization program. Cost of doing business improved 3% and included an AUD 6 million gain on the sale of assets in Australia in the first half, along with the prioritization of brand investment.
Pete Nielsen
executiveSo because of that, EBIT rose 4% to AUD 82 million, and the EBIT margin got better, reaching 10.4%. Now moving on to a few execution highlights. Innovation that leads the category matters a lot if we're going to hit our TPB ambition of delivering the pleasure of premium wine to more people on more occasions. We absolutely need to keep innovating our portfolio so it serves what consumers want today and what they'll want down the road. In F twenty-three, innovation highlights included our partnerships and campaigns with the Australian Open, Sydney WorldPride, the UFC in Asia, and our 19 Crimes campaign in the U.K., which brought both Squealing Pig and 19 Crimes to more consumers than ever before through bold and innovative campaigns. A disruptive 19 Crimes Obedience Gets You Nowhere campaign in the U.K. during the King's coronation drew a lot of attention from U.K. consumers and contributed significantly to the strong performance of 19 Crimes in EMEA, where NSR was up 10% in F twenty-three. We also kept up our record of bringing innovative new products into the wine category. One highlight was the introduction of our mid-strength category with the launch of Pepperjack Mid Strength Shiraz, a mid-strength wine that, true to its campaign tagline, "Really doesn't taste like 1." We also made pleasing progress in taking our priority brands global and growing in new markets and channels.
Pete Nielsen
executiveWynns kept expanding its footprint in luxury channels. Under one courtier, Vin Excellence, we've brought together BV's Georges de Latour along with Wynns John Riddoch — the partner best positioned to take these outstanding wines wider, reaching a network of international fine wine buyers and collectors across more than 100 countries via La Place de Bordeaux, the globally renowned fine wine marketplace. Our premium portfolio carried on widening its distribution worldwide, and a standout this year was robust depletions growth throughout Asia for all our priority brands, with Malaysia and Thailand among the key drivers behind that increase. Those are only a handful of the execution highlights from the last financial year. We've got some exciting plans in motion for F 2024, and we stay very confident about the health and outlook of our core brand portfolio — brands we know consumers love. Now that the business is structured the right way for us to keep premiumizing, I'm confident we can keep growing and improving our margin over time. Thanks. I'll now hand back to Tim.
Tim Ford
executiveThanks, Pete. Have you had a chance to hear from the team at this point? It's been, well, another strong year of, of advancement, honestly, for every one of our brand portfolio divisions toward their respective strategic priorities, and those priorities stay the same as we head into F 2024, with the execution being very clear for each team. You know, throughout TWE, again, consistency in terms of what we're aiming to execute. We'll keep drawing on our strengths and capabilities around the world and keep making headway on our key organization-wide priorities that you can see on the screen and in the presentation. Elevating our culture and growing our talent, and our people are our most important asset. Continuing to invest in technology that opens up long-term opportunities, great progress there. Pursuing category-leading innovation-... which we've discussed a lot already today, and also pursuing complementary inorganic M&A that will strengthen our brand and asset portfolio and keep, as always, pushing toward the sustainability commitments that I laid out. To sum up, I'd describe F 2023 as a really important year for TWE, when we adapted and responded to deliver the performance we're quite proud to outline today. Looking back at the year, we recognize that we delivered earnings and margin growth while navigating the ever-changing consumer and the tightening global economic environment.
Tim Ford
executivePenfolds keeps getting stronger — expanding distribution, bringing in new consumers, and posting excellent financial results. Our U.S. luxury business is still building on its strong platform, delivering growth in distribution, growth in direct-to-consumer, and price increases during a year when wine supply was limited. Our premium portfolio has beaten the market around the world, yes, driven by strong brands — leading brands. We've also taken proactive steps that will reinforce our TPB operating model, the wider business, and our supply chain going forward. That said, and because of this, we head into F 2024 with still greater confidence in our strategy — our premiumization strategy — greater confidence in how strong our diversified business is, and in our team's ability to capture and deliver on the opportunities ahead of us in the coming year. On the financial side, you know, we expect the year ahead to support our long-term financial objective, which also stays the same, and that is to deliver sustainable top-line growth year in, year out, plus high single-digit average earnings growth, with a group EBIT margin target of 25%, and then we figure out where we go from there. With that said, that concludes the presentation and commentary. I'll now pass it to the operator to open things up for questions.
Operator
operatorThank you. Should you want to pose a question, kindly hit star one on your phone and hold until your name is called. To withdraw your request, simply hit star two. In case you are using a speakerphone, please lift the headset before asking. Our first question is from Craig Woolford of MST Marquee. Go right ahead.
Craig Woolford
analystGood morning, Tim, and the team. If I could, I’d like to ask about cash flow. Clearly, the second half of FY 2023 came in somewhat lower, and you’ve walked through some of the timing factors. What I’d like to confirm is this: if it really is a timing matter, are you expecting it to be comfortably above 90% in FY 2024? Put another way, a stretch that we’d hopefully see return to normal. There are two parts to this, and other aspects as well. Why did sales land in May and June? I also noticed that this year you used some debtor funding for receivables. Could you explain the thinking behind that too? Thanks.
Matt Young
executiveThanks, Craig. It's Matt. Appreciate the question. So, cash conversion came in under where we wanted it, and as you noted, that was mostly a matter of when sales landed. I hope I've shed some light on the fact that the timing of those sales, especially in Asia, affected cash conversion by roughly 10%. If I dig a bit further into the reason, many of you are aware that in Asia in particular, we largely work to a quarterly purchasing rhythm, and that has been true for quite a few years. Our approach to dealing with customers is highly disciplined, making sure we have visibility into depletions and inventory levels. That process has been in place for a very long time and has served us extremely well in keeping the Penfolds brand a really strong business in that region. There's no broad pattern here that worries us. Every customer's situation differs. Be it shipping schedules or the other brands they carry, our partners are genuinely strong, genuinely major players who help us grow the brand in that market.
Matt Young
executiveThat disciplined approach is one of our strengths, you know, and if it means some shipments shift from March into April or from April into May, then under normal credit terms that will create some pressure on cash conversion. While that isn't an excuse for missing the target, I view it as a positive reason and a positive factor in how we run that business. Hopefully, in terms of understanding the strength of that business, you know, we've delivered half on half and half on half, and year after year, and Penfolds delivered that growth. Some of the data that Tom's shared with you, not just last year but this year, the growing availability and distribution gives us confidence in the strength of our partners, and that brand. I hope that sort of gives you a context that we don't see this as a challenge. It's a shame that we missed that target, but certainly for a positive reason in terms of the growth of the brand.
Craig Woolford
analystCould you just clear up that call on the receivables funding?
Matt Young
executiveYeah, I mean, it was fairly small. I believe it came to roughly $20 million, which across the whole of our balance sheet probably isn't all that material. Generally, you know, when we've done this in the past, we've done it in earlier years, you know, where those customers' credit quality, you know, lets us capture a cost of funds benefit, it continues to be an advantage for us and the correct financial call, not a, not a major factor in our cash conversion.
Craig Woolford
analystAll right, Matt, thank you.
Operator
operatorOur next question is from Michael Simotas at Jefferies. Go ahead, please.
Michael Simotas
analystMorning, everyone. My first question concerns what lies ahead for FY 2024. One quick clarification first, Tim: near the close of your prepared remarks, I believe you said FY 2024 would support the long-term financial objective. Does that imply you expect to deliver growth broadly in line with that long-term objective of high single-digit? What will it take to achieve that growth? Does it depend on a shift in the China regime, or a shift in the China tariff regime? And how significant is the 19 Crimes relaunch to that as well?
Tim Ford
executiveYes, absolutely. Hi, Michael. I appreciate that. Your reading of how I made that remark at the close is accurate — it's a key point to address, so thank you for raising it. Your take on it, I'd say, is fairly much on target. The way we'll achieve it is by carrying on Penfolds' trajectory. Running that forward, it will keep going. Yes, we anticipate top-line growth in the U.S. this year, partly from luxury, but also from gains in the premium portfolio. If you consider where we stand relative to the category and a few of the category trends across the last 13 weeks, that's definitely not an ambitious assumption. We anticipate further gains on 19 Crimes in the second half compared with the first half, simply owing to inventory transition. A new pack takes a few months to work through. After that's on shelf in the U.S. especially, the brand investment will truly take effect from then on. We do have expectations around that, though definitely not overly large ones, as we've mentioned previously. With TPB, I'd say, ongoing strong top-line results in premium and luxury, which commercial decline will offset.
Tim Ford
executiveIf you frame it at that top-line level and then carry it through alongside the COGS guidance, that's the shape I'd suggest considering for each division as we head into F 2024. That is what we intend to execute against.
Michael Simotas
analystThat's genuinely useful, thanks. On my second question, which concerns Penfolds: I realize you no longer really use the term reallocation, but if you consider how much luxury wine you are currently selling into markets beyond China, what percentage does that represent of what you previously sold into China? Could you expand a bit on how Penfolds' second half is phased compared with the first half? It sounds as though you plan to hold some product back in case access to China improves. Is that the correct way to view it?
Tim Ford
executiveYeah, I think it's not that I dislike discussing reallocation, Michael — it's simply that it's finished. I suppose, you know, if tariffs in China shift down the road, we'll be discussing reallocation once more, and that's fine. Actually, I look forward to that day. In terms of our Asia business, what we explain regarding Asia and the build is really about steady, ongoing distribution growth. Hopefully the data points we've shared with you today, and also in earlier presentations, demonstrate that incremental, demand-driven distribution growth, half-on-half, is what's driving performance. It lines up fairly well with the financial performance across most of the markets. Yeah, it sounds like a really boring explanation for Penfolds, but keep building distribution, bring new consumers into the category, bring new consumers into the brand, and they're consistently doing that. Tom may want to add to that as well, and I'll come back to the second part.
Tom King
executiveYeah, no, you're right. The idea of reallocation is completely finished at this point, and today's results really show the multifaceted growth opportunities we knew existed when we established that division a couple of years back. From where I sit, one standout from what was released today is the growth in Australia. We understood this market would need a bit of time. There was work required to win back hearts and minds with the trade and with consumers, and to get the right resourcing and investment in place. What we're seeing now is some genuinely strong activity driving awareness and consideration at the consumer level, bringing new, younger consumers into the category for the first time through some of the activation we're doing, along with some really positive shifts in our distribution. While that listings figure of 7% growth may look small, it sits on a significant base across the Australian market. When you factor in the rise in demand and the rise in availability, that is helping drive top-line growth. Other markets around the world are at a somewhat different stage when it comes to their maturity.
Tom King
executiveAsia keeps getting stronger and stronger. I mean that in a wide sense, since although we discuss several of the major markets such as Singapore, Malaysia, and Thailand, a number of the more emerging growth markets over the long term are producing excellent growth and excellent growth rates too. The approach we deploy around the world for how we build that demand as well as that availability is fairly comparable.
Tim Ford
executiveOkay, Mike, second question about how we're splitting the first half versus the second half. As we've been planning the year out, and obviously there are options and potential out there, things could shift in terms of the government's dealings with China. Still, from our perspective, it makes sense to build in some flexibility, leaning toward the back half of the year so we can handle our Penfolds allocation, especially Bins and above, more strategically this year. The depletions plan doesn't change. Across the year, depletions stay steady each month, but it's really our shipment profile — at this stage we want to keep that option open to ship more in the second half than the first half compared with what we'd normally do. Simply because there may be an opportunity for us to move some of that volume into other markets if the China tariff situation shifts, which I think we're all aware of right now. That's the reasoning behind it. We see it as a fairly strategic way to run the business.
Tim Ford
executiveThe reason we wanted to raise this point today is that we don't want to reach the half-year mark and then catch investors off guard. We will definitely provide an update, most likely at the AGM, on what our plans would be regarding it, in a couple of months' time. We're in the process of thinking through how we operate the business across multiple periods, and we're simply noting that today as what our plans are internally.
Operator
operatorOur next question is from Tom Kierath at Barrenjoey. Go ahead, please.
Tom Kierath
analystMorning, everyone. Appreciate the question. It sounds like Penfolds was weighted to the second half, and 19 Crimes was weighted to the second half as well. I think you're up against a gain on sale in the first half and AUD 30 million of Frank contribution in the first half. Would it be fair to assume that first-half EBIT will be down, with the second half sort of catching up to reach that high single-digit number?
Matt Young
executiveHi Tom, Matt here. Obviously, we haven’t provided a particular first-half versus second-half breakdown for the group, but I think what you’ve mentioned — first, it’s a highly strategic approach we’re taking with Penfolds, and that will benefit the long term. For the rest of the business, we believe the trends are fairly consistent, and the gain on sale you brought up is quite small in the overall picture. Clearly, we’re focused on top-line growth, average earnings growth, and driving that over the long term, with F 2024 supporting it, and we believe we have all the building blocks in place for that. I think the most important item to highlight today was Penfolds and the strategic manner in which we’re managing it.
Tim Ford
executiveYeah, and Tom, I’ll just add one thing on the 19 Crimes piece of that. You know, when I mentioned the second half, yes, we would expect that. In the U.S., that’s when the shift to new packaging will have taken place, more so than in the other markets. For the other markets, we expect their growth pattern to remain pretty steady throughout the year. When you put all of that together around the 19 Crimes brand, I think, yes, it will amount to relative consistency, with expectations slightly higher in the second half, though not heavily weighted.
Tom Kierath
analystYeah, yeah, no, I follow you. The second item I wanted to raise concerns depletions against shipments in the Americas. I see you mentioned that depletions are running 600,000 cases ahead of shipments, once you exclude the new products you've launched. I was just wondering whether you could provide a figure, an all-in figure, so not leaving out NPD, which I realize is quite substantial. The reason I'm asking, I suppose, is it looks like distributors and retailers are holding a whole heap of stock, and they're sort of destocking, and that's been going on for a little while now, but I just want to get a sense of exactly where you stand in that destocking position over in the Americas.
Matt Young
executiveHi Tom, absolutely. I might kick things off, and I believe Tim can add some perspective regarding the U.S. market too. Yeah, that 600,000 figure is likely the key one. In my view, the level of NPD within it is fairly modest. I wouldn't be concerned about that. What we've aimed to do is provide the figure that carries the greatest significance. I think you've highlighted a key element regarding the broader U.S. market, and certainly the—you know, throughout the industry we've observed retailers and distributors managing their inventory positions more tightly. As we're aware, with interest rate expenses climbing and supply chains in that market no longer being as tight as before, this has been deliberate work on their part, and that's likewise true for Treasury Wine Estates and other customers too. We remain sharply focused on depletions as well. Nor should we avoid acknowledging that results from our premium portfolio fell short of expectations, so that too has contributed to the extent of some of that destocking.
Matt Young
executiveAt its core, that's one component, and it's a factor behind how fiscal 2023 turned out. Tim, I'm not sure whether you'd like to say more about the broader U.S. market?
Tim Ford
executiveNo, I believe you covered that thoroughly, Tom. Honestly, I simply felt like praising you — which isn't something I make a habit of — regarding that note you penned about, I suppose, how U.S. distributors and inventory are faring with wine, spirits, and alcohol more broadly; from that angle, I thought it was quite accurate, really quite accurate. The drivers you identified are correct, along with everything else contained in that note. I do wish we had witnessed a spike a few months ago, as the analysis appears to indicate others did — but we didn't. Your observation about distributors truly pushing their inventory, and especially the expense of that inventory plus the capital cost needed to keep it stocked, is a genuine problem, and it genuinely applies across the entire U.S. — every state right now. Looking ahead, we believe depletions will track much nearer to shipments. With our plans, we've gotten aligned with our main distributors — in particular BBG and RNDC, our two largest partners throughout that market.
Tim Ford
executiveThat said, we will keep a pretty tight grip on it, though you shouldn't anticipate that kind of gap persisting in the future.
Tom Kierath
analystThanks, everyone. I appreciate those comments, Tim. Cheers.
Tim Ford
executiveWell done. Thanks.
Operator
operatorShaun Cousins from UBS has the next question in the queue. The line is yours.
Shaun Cousins
analystThanks. Good morning. Perhaps just one question about the cost savings arising from the Premium Brands operating model that would sit above the AUD 30 million in cash costs. At what point are those expected to come through? Will any of them land in fiscal 2024, and in what way will they help deliver the Premium Brands EBIT margin expansion target, or will a portion have to go toward offsetting, say, some operating deleverages as volumes moderate at TPB, please?
Matt Young
executiveOkay, Shaun, I'd say the margin goal we provided is an all-in figure. It accounts for, you know, how much deleverage occurs and, you know, given reduced portfolio volumes, and it also takes in the advantages of that program—though we shouldn't overlook the chance for added premiumization that Peter and the team have been pursuing. I'll begin with that, the more macro picture. On the specific program, including its benefits, we expect to reach a full run rate from it by fiscal 2024. Payback is very quick on that effort, especially where cash costs are concerned. You'll begin seeing that run rate reflected in the expectations. We've basically... It's, it's crucial to underscore what we stated: its effect is offsetting added costs we're encountering either from lower portfolio volumes or higher, you know, input cost within cost of goods. During fiscal 2024, we will realize those benefits, but to some degree it serves as an offset to the difficulties we've faced.
Shaun Cousins
analystDo you expect any of them to come out net positive? Do you think net savings will actually be generated?
Matt Young
executiveDoes that mean savings on top of what's already there?
Shaun Cousins
analystSure, go ahead.
Matt Young
executiveRight now, if we think we're going to deliver more than that, we'll update. You know, at this point, we feel comfortable saying it's going to be broadly in line with or above the $30 million.
Shaun Cousins
analystAlright, thanks. For my second question, I wanted to focus on what's planned for 19 Crimes Classic. Could you speak to the confidence behind relaunching that label? Specifically, how is the old label being cleared out without hurting the brand's long-term health — particularly since, I suppose, there's been evidence in the market of second-tier SKUs going at very low prices. So I guess what I'm asking is how you're handling the clearing of old product in a way that doesn't damage brand health and, in the end, doesn't get in the way of the 19 Crimes Classic relaunch succeeding, please.
Tim Ford
executiveI'll get us started, and Ben will probably want to jump in as we go. We have a really clear plan for executing the new platform, the new pack. You work through inventory during that stretch. I think you've also seen the market over there, and I think we've struck the right balance between aggressive promotional activity to drive volume and get it into consumers' hands, and preserving what the brand needs to stand for—the brand health, which remains pretty strong. The plans the team put in place during the last quarter give us more confidence that we've gotten that balance right. I think it takes that stretch of time, state by state in the U.S., where a new pack is required before we make the big investments. You'll see small examples—I'm sure you've seen them, we've seen them, everyone has seen bits and pieces where pricing falls outside our strategy, and we address it as it comes up, and we welcome you sending those our way when you do, Shaun.
Tim Ford
executivePlease continue with that approach. Yeah, from that perspective, there's a really clear plan and a really clear strategy. Our distributors are highly engaged with it as we move forward. I think the one thing we've observed throughout the year is that the brand equity remains strong. It's still outperforming the market. If you go back to our March Investor Day, we probably were a bit hard on ourselves regarding our performance against our internal plans, but we're still beating the market, and we have a lot of pretty exciting platform coming. Yeah, we feel good about it. There's no question about that, and it's in every market around the world. Ben, would you like to add anything to that?
Ben Dollard
executiveYeah, yeah, absolutely. I think, look, there are a few additional points to make on that. As Tim mentioned, it’s being handled very carefully, and it extends past the label itself. The label is an important piece, along with the upgrade and the consumer testing we’ve completed—we’re definitely excited to see that reach store shelves. Beyond that, we’re rolling out a fairly exciting new campaign for it. We’ve also gained considerable insight during the last six months regarding how we manage pricing, our programming efforts, and how we engage with retailers, and we’ve observed some encouraging outcomes from that, especially within the Classics tier. We view it as a comprehensive initiative spanning the entire 19 Crimes franchise. The final piece of that—and I believe we’ve performed especially well on this over the recent period—is our innovation platform. Along with the new label launch, we’ll also be bringing out additional innovations, particularly as we head into the Halloween season. There’s plenty to be optimistic about, and as Tim said—and I agree—the transition is being managed very carefully.
Shaun Cousins
analystGreat. Ben, thank you. Tim, thank you. Matt, thank you.
Tim Ford
executiveThanks, Shaun. I was hoping to add a bit more there.
Shaun Cousins
analystGo ahead, Tim.
Tim Ford
executiveRight, absolutely — I get it, because when you dig into this, and several of you on this call are examining it closely along with the IRI data, you'll notice that across the past 13 weeks, the average price on 19 Crimes has come down, though just slightly, when you view it across the entire category. On average, throughout all retail channels and across wholesale, it is definitely tracking with our plan. Our intention had been to push harder on promotional activity, to secure those end caps, to place it in consumers' hands, and that approach is paying off. I think if you look at that data as well, the gap versus where we stood 13 weeks ago, 26 weeks ago — although the price is a bit lower — remains firmly within that mid-$10 range across the board. That, too, serves as a fairly solid indicator of what we're doing with the brand.
Shaun Cousins
analystGreat, thank you, Tim. I appreciate the added detail.
Tim Ford
executiveAppreciate that, Shaun.
Operator
operatorOur following question is from David Errington of Bank of America. You have the floor.
David Errington
analystMorning, Tim. First, I apologize in advance if this comes off as at all rude, but I'd like to discuss your U.S. business. Now, I'm aware there's been plenty of rhetoric and plenty of talk, and you folks have really pushed today that this is a pretty good result. When I examine the actual figures and the return you're earning on your investment — leaving aside the return on your effort — you dropped 1.2 million cases in the second half. Your EBIT on a constant currency basis, if you strip out Frank Family, went backwards AUD 20 million. You're guiding us that in the market it's probably going to be down another AUD 20 million this year, because we've highlighted that your EBIT margin is expected to land in the range of 22%-23%, when this year it was 25%. That's obviously because there's another range here. I mean, there's always an excuse coming, Tim — either it's the COGS this year or it was the bushfires three years ago. I just don't understand. I just don't get your strategy in the U.S., where every year your EBIT seems to go backwards by 20 year, AUD 20 million, and it's likely to go backwards another AUD 20 million on an underlying basis.
David Errington
analystActually, on a—I believe you mentioned to Michael that revenue would edge up a bit, yet margins are set to decline by more than 200 basis points. That's quite a substantial downgrade, I mean. You've cut the market down to where EBIT will land around AUD 180 million. Nobody seems to have caught that yet, I don't think. What's the story in the U.S., Tim? What exactly is going on? EBIT is simply eroding away, and that's stripping out some of the excellent initiatives you're pursuing with Penfolds. Could you walk us through the U.S. a little, please? Why are you still there? Based on today's figures, you folks are moving backward at a very rapid pace, and should your second-half launch of 19 Crimes fail to deliver, well, I'm not sure what plan C or D would look like. Can you give us an update? Perhaps Ben would like to chime in, since I'm fairly disappointed with the Americas results today.
Tim Ford
executiveMorning, morning, Dave. Morning to you too. Yes, absolutely, I can. One thing I'd note is that if you're reading my remarks as pointing toward another downgrade in the U.S. on an EBIT basis, that wasn't what I meant for fiscal 2024. That's, I suppose, the first point. To, to return to the, the macro-
David Errington
analystTim, that's exactly what the bottom bullet point states. Tim, the final bullet reads that FY 2024 margin is expected to land between 22% and 23%, while this year's margin came in at 24.8%. You essentially indicated that you're hopeful for somewhat higher sales since you remain constrained. That implies EBIT next year will come in below this year. Can you explain why that isn't the case?
Tim Ford
executiveWe anticipate top-line growth throughout the year, and yes, the margin will—because of mix—drop back by 1 point, in our view. We're not saying, and I'm not saying, that we expect EBIT to go backwards year-on-year. That's the point there. I think, from the U.S. business more broadly, I actually have greater belief in the health of that business than I did 12 months ago, and I fully understand you disagree with me, and that's the good conversation we're about to have. You know, I think if you look at our luxury portfolio, it's not an excuse. We've called it out for years that coming into this year, we had less luxury wine to sell. What do you do when you have less luxury wine to sell? You focus on where you want to build distribution, and you improve the margin structure of that business through price increases, and we've done both of those. Yeah, we feel like the platform for luxury growth, less so in 2024. We'll see growth in 2024, but certainly into 2025, because we've got a lot more wine coming online to sell, and so you have to have the distribution right and your margin structure right.
Tim Ford
executiveIt's in improved condition for the years ahead. From the standpoint of the premium portfolio, once again, we are beating the market. When it comes to 19 Crimes, Matua is beating the market by a significant margin. Yes, we have a 1 million case brand on our hands this year. Matua will ultimately become a 1 million case brand across both its core portfolio and its innovation, which leaves us with 2 imported brands exceeding 1 million cases in the U.S. market, and those will keep growing going forward too. Consider the 2 strengths that gives us. What this year has also taught us, though, is that our performance at the price points between $15-$35 and $35-$40 isn't strong enough. The top end is good, and we're very happy with where that's heading. A couple of large brands are driving premium growth for us into the future, but we need more, and you can see some of the innovation we've launched there today. From a business health standpoint, I'd say it hasn't delivered that stellar EBIT growth. You mentioned, I believe, that year-on-year we dropped. For 2 years there, we grew substantially, through innovation, through our top line and through EBIT.
Tim Ford
executiveWe have not done so this year. We aren't avoiding that fact, but what I'm laying out are the reasons — and your question to me was about what gives me confidence and belief in that business — and I have it. You know, and I think the team there, through how they've adapted this year and the way they've responded, is, is pretty impressive. That's, that's my belief, Dave.
David Errington
analystOkay, but Tim, luxury premium is just 40% for you. How do you plan to offset that? Look, I understand, and maybe we should discuss it offline, but wow, you've been promoting the U.S. for quite a while now. I mean, we're talking about 20 years here. It has never delivered. I'm not sure when you'll ever admit that it will, but regardless, I guess we can take that offline. The inventory, what concerns me—
Tim Ford
executiveOnly one thing on that. Luxury accounts for 40%. Yeah, I believe luxury and premium make up 94% of the business. Yeah, most of that business now sits in luxury and premium. We've basically exited the commercial wine category.
David Errington
analystSo, Tim, are you calling the EBIT a good result for this year? Keep in mind that what we've seen over the last 2 years has really amounted to a recovery from COVID. Honestly, you can't claim that growth has been happening. If you go back to your earnings from, say, 3 or 4 years ago and look through the COVID period, you're still behind where you were. I'm not... Anyway, I guess my point has been made. On the inventory side, I have real concern, so if you could explain the large rise on the premium side. Looking at the figures, you've lifted premium by roughly AUD 100 million this year, and that's at a time when, effectively, looking at the inventory, total premium has risen to AUD 737 from AUD 637. So my worry is, especially with non-current inventory, that's exactly where there's a huge excess supply of B and C grade red. What is happening there? Is that something to worry about going forward? I believe Matt mentioned that you had plans to sell that through. What will you do with it? Because to me, that is a genuine concern — that is the real area where you have an oversupply glut. That's where the glut sits.
Matt Young
executiveThat's right.
David Errington
analystSo, are we looking at an inventory write-down here, or not?
Matt Young
executiveHey David, Matt here. No, I'd say we're in a genuinely strong position on that front. The work the team has put in across multiple vintages has served us well. You're definitely seeing a lift there, driven by the shifts in the outlook for the premium portfolio. When you talk about C grade, that's a very flexible grape variety that we're able to manage, and we already have plans in place for managing it as we head toward vintage 2024. Then there are the sales plans the teams have set up. Our risk in that area is very low, and we have a method for handling it. We've done an excellent job over the recent period, to the point where — rebalancing the luxury tier, so in your terminology, the B and the A — that's now in great shape as far as balance goes. At the industry level, there is pressure in the commercial segment, roughly the D and E. The industry is working through that. We certainly believe our inventory sits in a good spot and is well within our control, and we've had solid experience with this.
Matt Young
executiveI also want to point out that, you know, for quite a few years now, we've taken a really conservative approach when it comes to how we value inventory. As for whether provisions are needed, we've kept conservative provisions in place for a long stretch. In our business, that protection is there for us should things turn against us.
Operator
operatorOur following question is from Bryan Raymond at JPMorgan. You have the floor.
Bryan Raymond
analystThanks, guys. Just going back to the Americas, I want to get a handle on how pricing moves into FY 2024. You clearly took a fair bit in 2023. I just want to understand whether there are additional price increases coming through given the supply constraints that continue, or whether it's just annualization of the price rises you've already made, or whether we should expect only limited price movement into 2024?
Matt Young
executiveOn the macro level, Bryan, I'd say consistency is likely the right way to frame it. Within the luxury portfolio there will be certain segments and areas where our pricing roadmap means we take some pricing, but a great deal of that work was already done in fiscal 23. Building on the strength of some of our brands, there are certainly opportunities in brands such as Beaulieu Vineyard, given the accolades it is receiving. Those are longer-term plans, you know. The other thing you will begin to see is that the pricing strength we have achieved around Matua will continue — not through higher prices, but you will get the run rate from it. Then, as I think Tim mentioned earlier, the additional investment in feature and display, and how we manage that spend within the 19 Crimes portfolio, will also play a part. At the macro level, assuming an ongoing run rate is the way to think about it.
Bryan Raymond
analystAlright, that helps. Thanks. Then regarding the guidance—which now looks like high single-digit growth at the group level and a 45% Penfolds margin—I just want to confirm: if the China opportunity does materialize, would all of that be incremental, around NSR per case, I'd assume, and margin to those, or is some of it already factored into your existing guidance?
Ben Dollard
executiveCorrect, Matt — nothing in any of this year's statements, guidance, or plans accounts for a further China tariff change. Any such change would come on top of what's already reflected.
Bryan Raymond
analystAll right, great. So my last question is really about the longer term — specifically, your capacity to grow volumes in China if that chance arises. Obviously, this is a matter that would affect financial results perhaps 3 or 4 years out, but I’m just trying to get a sense of whether you can leverage higher volumes of luxury grapes for the Bin and Icon ranges from the main growing regions. How limited are you from an agricultural standpoint? Would you view that as something where you could meaningfully drive volume, or will it mostly come down to pricing realization and margin accretion?
Tom King
executiveYeah, Bryan, this is Tom King. I might take this one, and then let Tim Ford, Tim Ford, chime in as well. Look, clearly we're at an early stage still. We're certainly encouraged by how relations have strengthened lately, and as we ought to, we've been running some scenario planning regarding what that might eventually mean for us. At the outset, the chance is mostly going to be about how we optimize our allocations and revenue management throughout the Penfolds collection. We'll be seeking to secure incremental sourcing starting from V 24. What's great about the model we've built over the last few years when it comes to sourcing from various countries of origin is that we now have multiple platforms to boost our sourcing and grow our volume at the luxury level and, we hope, at the Icon level too. The opportunity exists. We've been encouraged by the first releases we've had from France and now from China. The most recent vintage in France was very encouraging for us when it comes to the scale of what we could produce, so we're feeling quite excited about the potential for what would be a genuine multi-country of origin play.
Tom King
executiveSo look, if things shift right now, there are certain elements of our Penfolds approach in China that will stay the same. We'll keep working closely with the local wine industry and aim to become a far bigger participant in it, building on the trial winemaking we've done so far. Our strategy of growing a multi-country-of-origin portfolio stays in place, and we'll keep expanding it with a focus on markets worldwide. The past two years have brought some genuinely strong progress. Our business is now quite balanced in terms of diversification from a demand standpoint across the globe. As we mentioned, I believe 6 months ago, we'll be seeking to move part of our Penfolds luxury and Icon tiers from the Australian collection over to China, should things indeed change. Sure, there's a chance for us to scale the portfolio, but that will take time.
Ben Dollard
executiveThat covers it. At this point you're fully aware of the overall approach regarding what our plans are. It is extremely clear — really, really clear — and covers many different angles. So, yeah, we'll see.
Bryan Raymond
analystCertainly. Wishing you success with that. Thank you, everyone.
Operator
operatorLisa Deng of Goldman Sachs has the next question. Go right ahead.
Lisa Deng
analystHello, everyone. I have a couple of questions, mostly about Penfolds. First, a follow-up regarding China. I believe you provided a figure last year indicating that mainland China generated roughly AUD 22 million to AUD 23 million in revenue and essentially broke even. I ran a quick rough calculation on this—sorry, on the global launch of One by Penfolds, 100 cases, or 100,000 cases. By my estimate, that would exceed AUD 20 million. Could you update us on how China performed in FY 2023, please? Revenue and profit both, if possible.
Matt Young
executiveHi, Lisa — Matt here. I should say this isn't a metric we intend to keep disclosing. It definitely served a purpose previously, while we were going through that transition, so that people had a clear picture. More broadly speaking, our intention is to keep backing our base and our investment in China through the multi-country of origin approach, and as a standalone market it won't be a major profit driver for us. The focus there is retention, but we don't plan to keep sharing the particular China market metrics.
Lisa Deng
analystOkay, one more follow-up on that. I suppose what I'm trying to get at is the sort of implied envelope for Asia Penfolds growth, because I'm not sure whether I've got this right — but if China sales land somewhere near $45 million to $50 million this year, FY 2023, while the backed-out sales figure for Asia comes in closer to just over $400 million, and yet we've actually seen quite decent distribution growth, as page 24 shows, does that mean sales per point of distribution have actually come down? I just want to get a handle on that sales per point of distribution, or the reorder and repeat orders coming from that expanded distribution footprint across the rest of Asia. Thank you.
Matt Young
executiveThat might be something better handled offline. Applying a mature-market framework — calculations around points of distribution and so on — to Asia is going to prove very hard, I think, given what data is available and that kind of thing. Here's how I'd frame it. What we hope people take away is this: in each of these markets, we're building distribution and growth, and we've succeeded at that with double-digit distribution, whether you're talking listings or outlets. That's the growth path we've laid out, and in last year's presentation you saw the runway ahead of us — we have multiple years of growth available to us doing exactly that. Across multiple years, we'll keep expanding distribution, points of distribution, in each of those markets. Tying that back to rate of sale in some of those emerging markets is going to be somewhat difficult.
Operator
operatorOur following question is from Richard Barwick of CLSA. You have the floor.
Richard Barwick
analystMorning, everyone. A question from me about the Penfolds target margin. You've raised it to 45%, up from the earlier 40%-45% goal. This follows on somewhat from Lisa's question. Could you explain the reason for that increase? What interests me especially is One by Penfolds, which I'd expect to carry a lower margin and ought to be a driver — sorry — of volume growth across the next couple of years. How does that fit with the expectation of a higher, sustained Penfolds margin?
Matt Young
executiveAbsolutely, Richard. I'd say that earlier goal of 40%-45% is likely the single measure we've never managed to reach. On the Penfolds side, we've consistently come up short when it comes to achieving a lower margin — that's probably the best place to begin. And I think, on that note, the expansion of premium was among the contributing elements, along with possible investments, correct? At this point we're in a situation where Penfolds now has the proper amount of investment behind it to expand across multiple markets, so we don't view that as a significant factor in dragging the margin downward. Second, we hold an expectation regarding both premium growth and margin — that we will achieve it — and when I say premium, I mean Koonunga Hill, Max's, and the new One by Penfolds. I think the way to read that is that we hold solid growth ambitions for those sections of the portfolio. We likewise have strong ambition and growth for the Bins and Icons and the tier above, and that is what gives us confidence at present, as we look beyond toward our future plans, that a margin of roughly 45% can be sustained going forward.
Tom King
executiveSure, I’ll add a bit to what was just said.
Matt Young
executiveAlright, Matt.
Tom King
executiveApologies, Richard — let me add a little more background on One by Penfolds. What matters to keep in mind is the equilibrium we're managing between pushing volume there and the strategic part it plays inside the portfolio, plus how it's now been set up for a brand-new consumer segment that we're going after for the first time. In the end, the long-term intention and the ambition is to draw those new consumers into Penfolds — perhaps into wine for the first time — and watch them, as time goes on, take more pleasure in additional luxury wines across the collection. Yes, volume exists as an ambition, but far more strategically, it has a role in attracting new consumers so they can enjoy luxury wines.
Richard Barwick
analystI believe you mentioned a target of 300,000 cases for One by Penfolds during the strategy day?
Matt Young
executiveYeah, that’s right.
Richard Barwick
analystDoes that arrangement still hold? To be honest, it caught me off guard that you've already shipped 100,000 cases in China alone.
Matt Young
executiveYeah, that remains within the target.
Richard Barwick
analystAlright, if I could just ask one more thing about U.S. margins. Clearly you're guiding down for FY 2024, and I suppose there are a number of factors behind that, but on the other side, you mentioned direct-to-consumer revenue grew, sorry, was up 10% in FY 2023. Obviously that's a strong result, and as you, Tim, pointed out, it's a channel with very high margins. What are your expectations for direct-to-consumer? I would have expected to see more recovery in that area, and that would have been a genuine positive tailwind for U.S. margins, yet you're guiding overall margins to go backwards.
Tim Ford
executiveI mean, that's among the elements that have grown, I suppose, when we take the overall view for 2024, right, we keep seeing our sales in the D2C business do better than our rivals in that market as well. When you put together the full picture — you know, the luxury portfolio, the premium portfolio, with the investment behind driving that, and then the D2C business, that mix, so to speak, inside it — yeah, we still expect D2C to keep growing. There's no question about that. You know, I don't believe it's going to take another step up when it comes to recovery; simply continuing to outperform the others is how we view that business.
Operator
operatorBen Gilbert from Jarden is our next questioner. The floor is yours.
Ben Gilbert
analystGood morning, everyone. I have a couple of questions, just two from me. First, on Penfolds, I'm just trying to pull together everything that was discussed on the call. The comments about distribution and volume growth staying consistent — do you think you can still achieve that mid-to-low teens figure? Sorry, that high-to-single-digit volume, along with the NSR per case type growth. On that point, regarding the second half SKUs, is that by design or by your choice, or is it just about being prepared for China? I just want to confirm that, because I suppose you're still seeing strong demand, and what's the risk that you start to put some of these markets you've spent a lot of time in, such as Australia, offside, if you begin shorting the market or giving less volume than they might like? Because there's just some talk around smaller sales forces, et cetera, in Australia, and concerns that if China does reopen, you might put some of the key customers to the back burner again.
Tim Ford
executiveHey, Ben. So the first half versus second half really comes down to shipment volume, and we have a very clear view of depletions plans and inventory, so we won't be shorting the market, as they say. That would mean the product isn't available to keep that distribution growth going. It's a pretty detailed and clear plan we have on that side. Yeah, we'll just, yeah, keep an eye on what we allocate over the next four to five months especially, yeah, which might, which might mean. Basically, what you're seeing is, you know, we might actually ship more in the second half, you know, into different markets, but we're not going to, you know, step back from the growth we've seen in these other key priority markets. You know, on that point, we've told our Australian customer base this as well, you know, Australia will remain an important market for us going forward. You know, if there's the occasional, the occasional remark out there, then it isn't grounded in fact. That's definitely not something we plan to do in terms of, you know, continuing to build what is a real, you know, strength here in this market now, because we've worked pretty hard over the last three years, in particular, to begin seeing the fruits of that pay off.
Tim Ford
executiveI’m aware that Tom and the team are, you know, really zeroed in on making sure this market keeps serving as a growth engine for Penfolds down the road. There’ll be understandable doubt, I suppose, from certain people—especially independent owners out there—but that is not going to happen.
Matt Young
executiveBen, I’d like to address the first part of your question as well. For Penfolds as a division, the expectation for top line growth is that it will help drive our growth for the whole company. We do expect that we’ll be seeking similar trends in Penfolds, based on the additional distribution and the opportunity that exists there. That should also benefit the broader group. Then, to restate the point Tim made about the ANZ business, it has been a genuine success this year, and to highlight the second half of 2023 compared with the second half of 2024 in ANZ, it is up 35%. It is a very strong market. It is certainly not one we are walking away from, and I think that is starting to demonstrate the success of building up what that team has delivered.
Ben Gilbert
analystThanks. I’ll take the second one. Could you explain why the COGS commentary has shifted so significantly during the last 12 months? At one stage, it was clearly anticipated to be a fairly substantial tailwind — roughly AUD 50 million+ into 2024 — but now it’s expected, on a like-to-like basis, to be flat. I understand you have factors such as glass costs, et cetera, along with energy, and the vintages, but clearly commercial, which is this current vintage, is smaller now. We’re talking, obviously, about the last few years, when costs should be lower, and in theory you also have some fairly substantial freight benefits, and as you said, you had 2 million case brands into the U.S., with a decent chunk of that coming out of Australia and New Zealand. It just surprised me that we’ve moved back to flat. I would have thought we should still see some tailwinds on a like-for-like COGS basis.
Matt Young
executiveSure, absolutely. Let me clear up the wording we used for fiscal 2024 when we said we anticipated improvement. We never provided a specific figure. What I'd say is that I'm genuinely proud of what the team has accomplished across multiple years on cost management. That effort has been substantial, and delivering flat COGS in the current environment is something we believe deserves recognition as an achievement. Now, the benefits we mentioned previously and anticipated are materializing — whether that's the lower-cost 2021 and 2022 vintages, or the full run rate from our global supply chain optimization, the roughly AUD 90 million we expect to come through — all of those are still materializing. However, we have yet to observe meaningful changes when it comes to logistics, energy, and dry goods. Those remain challenges, and we expect they will continue to be. The newer challenges that we've seen emerge over the last six to nine months and that are affecting cost of goods would relate to a lower volume outlook than we had expected. That affects production recoveries and costs, and additionally, vintage 23 in Australia had a lower yield, which does place added pressure on cost of goods.
Matt Young
executiveAnd that's especially true — well, for our portfolio overall, but especially on the commercial wines side. The way the team has been able to adjust to that situation and deal with a position that was likely worse than what we had anticipated, I think that's significant, and it really underscores the fundamental strength we have for handling it. You know, we're very comfortable with the outlook — that it's a good result. It comes in a bit under where we'd want to be, but it shows the flexibility the team has been able to respond with.
Ben Gilbert
analystActually, may I jump in briefly with a quick follow-up on one point? On freight specifically, do you see this as mostly a timing matter — that it's simply taking longer for certain freight expenses to settle down as you exit some of those ports in South Australia and New Zealand? Do you expect those gains to materialize? As for the COGS problem, was it tied to some of the disease issues or winds — has that had an effect too — or is it more a question of vintage in South Australia?
Matt Young
executiveWe still think that from a logistics standpoint, it's mostly a matter of timing with respect to Australia. As of now, we haven't seen that materialize, and the languages are still unwinding and have yet to arrive. Moving into fiscal 24, that's not something we're ready to raise our hand and say we expect to happen. On vintage 23, overall, the vintage was down. Yes, you're correct — whether it was weather or disease affecting parts of the industry, or generally lower intake given the outlook for volumes, that lowered the industry's overall intake. Treasury Wine Estates included, which, given a fixed asset base, infrastructure, et cetera, and COGS, will raise the cost per case of vintage 23.
Tim Ford
executiveFor the industry as a whole, that's not a bad outcome.
Matt Young
executiveYou've got it.
Operator
operatorThe following question is from Phil Kimber at E&P Capital. Please proceed.
Phil Kimber
analystHey, guys. Appreciate you taking my questions. My first one is about Treasury Premium Brands. With the revised mid-teen margin and, you know, just a little bit above 10% at the moment, the pathway to get there, does that require another sort of major move in terms of removing some of the commercial brands? Or is that pathway there based on, you know, the changes that you're, you're making in FY 2023 and into FY 2024?
Matt Young
executiveYes, thank you, Phil. A few points come to mind. Most of the restructuring effort is now behind us, and we believe the business is positioned well for its future shape and for the growth we intend to pursue. Two main factors should help us reach that figure. The first is continued expansion of our premium portfolio — both through the work on our priority brands in every market and through the remaining premium portfolio elements within those markets. The second is sustained emphasis on innovation. We see a chance to open up new occasions where wine currently isn't present, and if executed properly, this can be margin-accretive for us as a division. We also anticipate that the commercial category will keep declining in step with the market across all markets, and combining these pieces is what takes us to the outlook we have. There is nothing missing from our plan that we would need in order to hit that number.
Matt Young
executiveWhat will get us there is carrying on with these trends and keeping our attention on innovation.
Phil Kimber
analystThanks. On my second question — and apologies, I realize the U.S. has come up quite a bit already — but when I look at FY 2023 overall, EBIT at constant currency was flat, organic was down 10%. Frank Family Vineyards delivered a cracking result for you. Should we expect a similar pattern in FY 2024, where the earnings growth you're describing involves the organic business probably declining and another great result from Frank Family Vineyards? Or is it more that those organic declines are sort of rebasing now, so you won't have that drag again? I'm just trying to get a broad sense of the shape.
Tim Ford
executiveYes. No, I hear you, Phil. Appreciate it, and I'm glad to discuss the Americas business — I hope that came through in today's remarks. No, we aren't counting on it being driven solely by Frank Family in FY 2024. As you know, we have wine available across Stags, BV, Beringer, and the rest of the luxury brands too. Yeah, with that wine availability, performance would be far more consistent across the luxury portfolio. That's the plan. There will be some incremental Frank Family Chardonnay — our first vintage from that business since we acquired it lands in Q4, so there'll be a bit of that. It gives us the beginning of a step up in Q4, with the majority coming through F 2025, but it will be consistent across the luxury portfolio.
Phil Kimber
analystAlright, thank you.
Tim Ford
executiveThat's not a problem at all.
Operator
operatorSam Teeger from Citi has the next question — go ahead, Sam. Hey, Tim. Hey, Matt. If we set aside Cellar Doors, where NSR rose 10%, could you share a bit more detail on the broader U.S. on-premise picture and how those trends have shifted across the past six months?
Matt Young
executiveSure. Look, I think the way to think about that is how Tim described it earlier, which is ongoing enhancement and growth. You know, certainly visitation patterns are getting better gradually, and the patterns around staff availability—being able to open on more occasions in the U.S. market—are continuing.
Tim Ford
executiveHey, Dollard, Dollard could take this one.
Matt Young
executiveThat is correct.
Tim Ford
executiveAnd if he’d like to, from that side too. Ben, would you care to add a little more detail on the—?
Ben Dollard
executiveAbsolutely, absolutely, absolutely—certainly. Look, what we’ve observed is definitely a more stable situation when it comes to on-premise and, yes, with respect to our Cellar Door business and how it has performed. We have observed a comparable, comparable outcome for our on-premise business in terms of distribution quality. That is what we are concentrating on with our luxury portfolio. In fact, we have been quite pleased by how distribution has expanded for our luxury portfolio, and we have stayed very focused on the right accounts nationwide. On-premise is a very important part of our overall growth and of how we think about growth, and it is a very viable retail outlet as well. Yes, I, I believe the on-premise business, as we see it, is strong. We expect it will remain strong, and it is especially well aligned with where we are going with our luxury portfolio.
Phil Kimber
analystOkay, so regarding the new 19 Crimes items in the Americas, in which month did you begin — or when do you plan to begin — booking sales with distributors, and when will consumers actually be able to find them on shelves?
Ben Dollard
executiveRight. There isn't a single answer to that — as if everything will suddenly show up at once. It's a very carefully managed process, you know, driven by rate of sale, plus retail, feature and display, and promotional activity. In certain markets, we've begun to see the new package launch reach the market. Definitely with our Cabernet and some key retailers, we expect the real impact will occur in H2, when we see the broad component of the classic tier, you know, going into the new package. As I mentioned, there's no one answer for the whole country. It's going to depend on timing across the country.
Tim Ford
executiveWell, with any of these shifts, Sam, it's going to roll out gradually, you know, month after month. That's — we're not claiming everything will land in H2. What we're saying is, by that point, we expect it to be, yes, across the market in a meaningful way. Appreciate that. All right. I believe that covers all the questions. I'm glad everyone had a chance to, to ask them. Thank you. Great set of questions, and I look forward to speaking with a number of you in more detail over the coming days. Thanks for joining us. Cheers.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Treasury Wine Estates Limited transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Treasury Wine Estates Limited earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Treasury Wine Estates Limited or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.