Treasury Wine Estates Limited (TWE) Earnings Call Transcript & Summary
August 15, 2024
Earnings Call Speaker Segments
Operator
operatorWe appreciate you holding, and thanks for joining Treasury Wine Estates' FY '24 Full Year Results. Everyone is currently in listen-only mode. A presentation will come first, and after that we'll open it up for questions. <<operator_script>> At this point, I'll turn the conference over to Mr. Tim Ford, Managing Director and Chief Executive Officer.
Tim Ford
executiveThanks, and good morning, everyone. I appreciate you being here for the TWE 2024 Full Year Results Briefing. With me today are Stuart Boxer, our Chief Financial Strategy Officer; Tom King, Managing Director of Penfolds; Ben Dollard from Napa Valley, President of Treasury Americas; and joining us for the first time, Angus Lilley, who was recently appointed Managing Director of Treasury Premium Brands. I'm happy to share our fiscal '24 results today — a year of substantial change throughout TWE, in which we sharpened our organizational and portfolio focus on becoming a global luxury brand led leader in the global wine category. EBITs rose 12.8% to $658.1 million, powered by robust luxury growth at both Penfolds and Treasury Americas, which also reflected the DAP contribution from the second half. Without that contribution, EBIT was up 6.4%, consistent with the guidance we gave for mid to high single-digit organic EBIT growth. Our luxury portfolio's performance was clearly the standout of fiscal '24, with luxury net sales revenue up roughly 30% group-wide, or 14.5% on an organic basis — evidence of the strong momentum we now enjoy at higher category price points in our key markets, where consumer demand for luxury wine stays strong.
Tim Ford
executiveWith that in mind, net sales revenue surpassed $1 billion at both Penfolds and Treasury Americas for the first time — a major milestone for each division. Net profit after tax on a statutory basis fell to $98.8 million, which reflects a post-tax material item loss of $318.1 million for the year, mainly from the non-cash impairment of goodwill and commercial brands in the Treasury Premium Brands business that we announced last week. Once those material items are adjusted for, NPAT rose 8.3% for the year. The key strategic priorities we carry into fiscal '25 are quite clear. First is continuing to execute our plan to re-establish the Penfolds Australian country of origin portfolio in China as well as in other global markets, and I'm pleased to report that this remains firmly on track, with strong customer demand and initial depletions performance matching our expectations. At Treasury Americas, Dow's delivery in the second half matched the expectations we set when we announced that acquisition last October — a pleasing outcome as that business continues on its strong growth trajectory. Our growth plans for Dow remain unchanged. And with business integration now well into execution mode, we remain on track to deliver synergies of US$20 million plus by the end of FY '26.
Tim Ford
executiveWe've now finished the review of the premium brands operating model that we flagged during the half year results update we provided to the market in February, along with the planned establishment of a global premium brands division and the divestment of our commercial brand portfolio — both significant actions we committed to taking, and I'll go into more detail on this shortly. Then, looking ahead to fiscal '25, we expect EBIT to land in the range of $780 million to $810 million, reflecting continued strong growth in the luxury portfolio in Penfolds and Treasury Americas, supported by stability across the rest of our global portfolio. Turning now to the other elements of our financial performance, which Stuart will cover in more detail. Briefly, though, NSR grew 13.1%, or 4.4% on an organic basis, with luxury portfolio growth partly offset by lower premium and commercial shipments in Treasury premium brands. NSR per case rose to $125 per case, up 14.2%, driven by the accelerated shift of our portfolio towards Luxury wine, while EBIT margin was in line with the prior year, with the benefits of improved portfolio mix offset by higher cost of goods on luxury wine, particularly in Treasury Americas, but predominantly in the first half.
Tim Ford
executiveFor the year, cash conversion came in at 82%. If you strip out the movement in noncurrent luxury and premium inventory, that figure was 95%. The Board has declared a final dividend of $0.19 per share, 70% franked, which gives a full year dividend of $0.36 per share for the full year — that's up $0.01 per share, a value increase of 16% versus the prior period. Moving on now to divisional performance, which Tom, Ben, and Angus will each cover in greater detail as well. Penfolds had another outstanding year of execution, with momentum picking up across the portfolio in Asia and solid top line growth once again delivered here in Australia. An EBIT margin of 42% reflected sales through the fourth quarter after the removal of tariffs in China, with increased shipments of entry-level tiers happening at the same time as we began incremental investment in the China market. Tom and the team are very well-placed to carry on the well-established strategy of growing global distribution and availability as well as consumer demand across a number of key global markets. With tariffs removed in China and what we see as a significant long-term growth opportunity, Penfolds is as well-placed as it has ever been to deliver on its ambition to be a global luxury icon, as we outlined at our Investor Update in late June.
Tim Ford
executiveTreasury Americas. Growth at the top line came from a Dow contribution in the second half, along with a 14% rise in revenue from the rest of our Luxury portfolio brands, helped by greater Luxury wine availability for brands like Stags' Leap and Frank Family Vineyards. Working against that was a decrease in our premium brand portfolio, headed by the 19 Crimes Cali tier, and this meant divisional organic revenue landed in line with the prior period. As I mentioned earlier, elevated COGS stemming from the 2020 California vintage weighed on margin during the first half, though it got better as we moved into the 2021 vintage in the second half. Lastly, revenue at Treasury Premium brands fell 6%, pulled down by softer commercial and Premium shipments, with consumption trends still weak at the below $15 price point, and our commercial portfolio also lagged the category there. On a positive note, the priority premium portfolio within TPB lifted NSR by 5%, powered by brands including 19 Crimes, Squealing Pig, and Pepperjack. Now, turning to sustainability: in fiscal '24, we've achieved strong progress across our set of commitments, all of which work together to help build a resilient business, foster healthy inclusive communities, and produce wine sustainably.
Tim Ford
executiveWe keep decarbonizing the business, and greenhouse gas emissions are down roughly 66% since fiscal '21. Renewable electricity now supplies more than 80% of global operations, and we're steadily boosting efficiency, putting money into new technology, and staying on course to hit our goal of 100% renewable electricity throughout global operations by the close of this calendar year. We keep investing to become a smarter business, concentrating on metering technology that delivers real-time data and insights so gas, electricity, and especially water — our most valuable commodity — can be managed effectively. On water metering technology, installations now cover more than 90% of our operating sites classified as high-risk catchment areas, and work is well along at our medium-risk sites too. That push has been the central priority of our treasury water strategy, launched in fiscal '23 so we could play a far more proactive part in water stewardship, given how large our agricultural footprint is. Destination Zero Harm remains our target and the engine behind our health, safety, and well-being agenda. During fiscal '24, we cut our 3-year rolling serious incident frequency rate by close to 40%. That excellent result stems from sustained efforts by every team to control hazards capable of causing serious harm, along with the continuing success of Build Safe Together, our campaign that places special emphasis on mental health.
Tim Ford
executiveWomen’s representation continues to be a central part of what we’ve committed to around inclusion, equity and diversity. We made further progress during the year, with total female representation rising to 43.7% of our employee population, an increase of 1 point, while the share of women in our senior leadership group improved by 2.8 points. And we keep working alongside our grower partners and our bulk wine supply partners — partners who matter a great deal to us — to encourage them to adopt the relevant sustainability certifications that exist around the world. For the vintages we finished in fiscal ’24, about 95% in America and 91% in Australia of our overall sourcing was sustainably certified. That puts us in a strong position to give our customers and consumers confidence that our wine is produced sustainably. We know across all of this that more work remains, but we’re proud of the progress we’ve made, and we’ll keep cultivating a brighter future for everyone who touches our business. Now, going back to our full year results in 2020 — it feels like a lifetime ago. We set out the blueprint for what was in our 5-year plan known internally as 2025, which was headlined by our ambition to be the world’s most admired premium wine company.
Tim Ford
executiveSo now that we’ve reached the close of this period and our attention turns toward the next stage of our growth journey—one built around our luxury-brand-led ambitions—it’s worth pausing briefly to consider how much progress we’ve made in growing and evolving the business during this time. Moving to an operating model led by our brand portfolio was an essential step, and we undertook it to bring greater focus and accountability throughout the business. Without question, that change has released growth and enhanced operating performance across all of Treasury Wine Estates. Over the period—which included tariffs imposed on Australian wine in China, changing consumer and market dynamics, and several economic headwinds—Penfolds has developed into a genuinely global, diversified business, with multiple markets now generating top-line growth and a portfolio that extends past Australia to include wines sourced and produced from 4 countries of origin: Australia, the United States, France and China—something previously unheard of in Luxury wine. Treasury Americas has been reshaped and now has a very clear strategic path as the leading luxury wine business in the United States, the world’s largest luxury wine market, following the acquisitions of Frank Family Vineyards in 2022 and, more recently, two significant additions to what was already a strong portfolio of luxury brands.
Tim Ford
executiveThis business is now in a strong position to turn into another standout luxury growth platform for Treasury Wine Estates, sitting right alongside Penfolds. During this period, TPB and Treasury Americas grew the count of their priority premium brands, and that gives us a base to build on as we now shift toward a global premium brands division. Throughout our supply chain, we've rolled out initiatives that lead the industry globally, aimed at driving efficiency, boosting automation, and cutting costs to contend with substantial inflation over the period, which helps us deliver consistent margins even through a stretch when volumes for our commercial brands have fallen as well. We've kept on investing, especially in capacity for luxury production. Yes, our state-of-the-art winery in the Barossa Valley stands as one example, and we've built a luxury sourcing and production asset base in Bordeaux, France. So that's how we arrive at where we stand today. As a team, we are certainly taking lessons from the past, yet we remain firmly focused on executing right now for what lies ahead. Looking forward, our vision stays firmly fixed on becoming the world's most desirable luxury wine company. That vision captures not just the fact that more than 75% of our earnings now stem from portfolios led by our luxury brands, but also that luxury price points make up a segment of the wine category that consumers are drawn toward.
Tim Ford
executiveThis is also about living out what defines a luxury business across all of Treasury Wine Estates. Being luxury led shows up for us in several distinct priorities—among them, making our leadership positions stronger in Asia and the United States, growing our portfolios at scale in other must-win markets, pushing further into emerging growth markets, and keeping up investment in our multi-country of origin luxury sourcing model so that future growth is possible. When it comes to our premium brand portfolios, we'll work to build value sustainably from inside the business in support of the luxury led emphasis that runs through the whole organization. Our executive leadership team came together with our global team last month to launch our new game plan, which you can see on this slide. One highlight of that launch was that, for the first time, we defined our organizational purpose: boldly cultivating. That purpose captures a shared focus throughout our business, built around the essential part every single person will take in shaping TWE's future—boldly cultivating value via our brands, our wines, our people, via innovation, via sustainability, and via the experiences we provide to our customers and, above all, to our consumers. It's a purpose that's uniquely TWE, and one we'll draw on every single day to move our business ahead.
Tim Ford
executiveFour strategic pillars underpin that purpose. They’ll steer how we make decisions and how we’ll succeed, with our focus on consumers, on our people, on a shared playing-to-win mindset, and on our commitment to deliver today while building for tomorrow. Our DNA — the force behind our culture and our standards — is at the foundation of all we do at TWE, and it stays the same. In the years to come, I’m eager to keep investors informed about how we’re progressing on this new game plan and strategy. Now to the future operating model for our premium brands. We’ve reached two conclusions. First, a global premium division will be created by 1 July 2025, combining the TPB and Treasury Americas premium portfolios. Second, we’ve decided to divest our commercial brand portfolio, including Wolf Blass, Lindeman’s, Yellowglen and Blossom Hill, as we announced last week. For this global premium division, we think this structure is optimal for creating and driving value across our premium brand portfolio. The benefits include one globally focused business with a streamlined operating model, more effective prioritization of opportunities in key markets, and improved investment and resource allocation. It will sharpen our ability to execute more effectively on key global premium brands such as 19 Crimes, Matua and Squealing Pig, along with our global innovation priorities.
Tim Ford
executiveWhat matters a great deal is that it opens up optionality for building shareholder value down the road. Our view is that these are the correct changes to make sure our worldwide portfolio of premium brands keeps underpinning a strategy led by our luxury brand. Making the key changes that allow the shift into the global premium division will be the central focus throughout F '25, alongside lifting the overall performance of that business, which we have to do. So on that note, Stuart, I'll pass things to you to walk through the financial performance in more detail.
Stuart Boxer
executiveAll right. Thank you, Tim, and good morning to everyone. I'm happy to walk you through the financial highlights for fiscal 2024. We'll begin with the slide we always use, which shows how our key metrics have trended. Group NSR rose 13.1% on a reported basis and 10.7% in constant currency terms, which reflects strong growth in our luxury portfolio at Penfolds and Treasury Americas, including the second-half contribution from Dow, and that was partly offset by weaker sales at Treasury Premium Brands. NSR per case grew 11.8% on a constant currency basis, including Dow, and 8% excluding Dow, and it was driven by those same factors — growth across our luxury wine portfolio, which sped up after the Dow acquisition and now accounts for roughly 50% of group NSR. Since F '20, NSR per case is up more than 50%, which shows how significantly our brand portfolios have evolved over that period. Moving down the P&L: COGS per case rose 12.7%, driven by portfolio mix and by the sell-through of higher-cost vintages across all divisions. As we expected, this metric improved in the second half, particularly at Treasury Americas, as the luxury portfolio moved from the wildfire-affected 2020 vintage to the 2021 vintage. Cost of doing business was up 7.2%, driven by the addition of Dow and by investment in brand building and overhead to support re-establishing Penfolds' Australian country region portfolio in China, partly offset by the $23.6 million gain on the sale of supply chain assets, of which approximately $20 million was recognized in the first half.
Stuart Boxer
executiveEBIT came in at $658.1 million, which is up 9.9% on a constant currency basis, while the EBIT margin fell 0.2 percentage points to 24.0%, mainly because of higher costs in the first half within Treasury Americas and the lower F '24 margin for Penfolds, as we had foreshadowed, tied to the removal of tariffs in China and specifically the step-up of entry-level Australian country of origin luxury tiers in that market, plus the high in-country overheads in Q4. Return on capital employed dropped 0.4 percentage points to 10.9%, which reflects the short-term impact from the acquisition of DAOU, given the growth nature of the acquisition. If you exclude the impact of DAOU, return on capital employed rose to 12%. Please note that the capital employed I have quoted excludes the impact from the Treasury Premium brand impairment. Leverage finished the year at 2.0 times, up from 1.9 times in the PCP, following the acquisition of DAOU, which we're pretty pleased with. We expect some further deleveraging in F '25 to return to within our 1.5 to 2 times range, consistent with our guidance tax have been recognized this financial year with a net cash outflow of $71.7 million. The most significant component of this was the non-cash impairment of brands goodwill and a small amount of commercial inventory in treasury premium brands, which we announced on the 6th of August.
Stuart Boxer
executiveAlso on TPB, we recognized net income of $14.2 million for the half, tied to the operating model and supply chain restructuring announced last May. That specifically related to a gain on the sale of surplus commercial vineyard and water assets. This program is now expected to wrap up in F '25, consistent with the initial program cost of $90 million net, subject to the sale of a final commercial vineyard and associated water assets in Australia. We also included $61 million of transaction and integration costs tied to the DAOU acquisition, with integration now well underway, which Ben will discuss shortly. Turning now to the balance sheet. Net assets rose $732 million on a reported currency basis, mainly because of the DAOU acquisition, which affected intangibles, property, plant and equipment, working capital and debt, along with recognition of the earn-out within other liabilities. Apart from the DAOU-related impacts, the other key balance sheet effects were higher working capital, driven by underlying business growth and increased luxury inventory following the Australian and California vintages, and the Treasury Premium brands impairment.
Stuart Boxer
executiveNow let me get into inventory with a bit more granularity. Compared with the same period a year earlier, total inventory volume fell 3%, whereas value rose 9%, reflecting growth in luxury inventory alongside a decline in premium and commercial inventory. Current inventory rose $30 million, reflecting anticipated growth in luxury sales. Non-current inventory climbed $164 million, reflecting higher luxury inventory following the DAOU acquisition as well as the 2023 Californian and 2024 Australian vintages, where we saw a substantial step-up in intake. Total luxury inventory grew 29%, with roughly half of that tied to DAOU and the remaining half tied to higher intake across our other luxury brands, including Penfolds, Stags' Leap, and Frank Family Vineyards. Moving on to cash flow and net debt. Operating cash flow before interest, tax, and material items came to $667 million for the year, with reported cash conversion of 82%. That cash conversion figure includes a substantial investment in non-current luxury inventory in both V23 in the US and V24 in Australia, as I've already described. Excluding the movement in non-current Luxury and Premium inventory, cash conversion stood at 94.6%. That result came in stronger than the 80% we guided to at our half year results, reflecting the resumption of shipments to China in the June quarter, where a high proportion were cash sales.
Stuart Boxer
executiveLooking ahead to F '25, we anticipate that cash term sales into China will make up a smaller share, since shipments will follow a more typical pattern across the year. Combined with growth in the underlying business, that should deliver cash conversion of roughly 80% for the full year, before the change in noncurrent Luxury and Premium inventory. Keep in mind this is a full-year target, and cash conversion typically comes in softer at the half year because of the usual seasonality in our business profile. Turning to CapEx: total CapEx in the period came to $190 million. That figure included maintenance CapEx of slightly more than $100 million and growth CapEx of $75 million, which covered the purchase of vineyard assets in New Zealand that support future sourcing of Marlborough Sauvignon Blanc, investment in lower no alcohol wine production technology here in Australia, and continued expansion of our Luxury wine operations in France. The rest of the CapEx was tied to DAOU. For F '25, we expect maintenance CapEx to stay at about $100 million, with growth CapEx of as much as $50 million planned. That includes refurbishing the Beaulieu Vineyard brand home in Napa, upgrading the tasting room and consumer experience so the quality reflects the luxury status of that brand.
Stuart Boxer
executiveLastly, we'll keep looking at possible investments in Luxury vineyards and production assets in order to back the growth goals for the Luxury brands we already own. Turning at last to capital management. First, and this matters a lot, we're really pleased that our investment-grade capital structure has stayed in place after buying DAOU. Our liquidity is still solid, with $1.2 billion in cash plus committed undrawn debt facilities. During the second half, we finished a thorough effort to lengthen and diversify our term funding structure, and that involved issuing a US$ 300 million Asian term loan that refinanced the bridge facility for the DAOU acquisition. Last, as Tim said earlier, today we announced a final dividend of $0.19 per share, which makes a full year dividend of $0.36 per share — a $0.01 rise over the prior year and a 16% increase in value, given the larger share count after the DAOU acquisition. The payout ratio of 72% came in slightly above our 55% to 70% target payout range, which reflects our ongoing emphasis on lifting shareholder returns in what was a unique year following the DAOU acquisition, while also balancing the strength of our balance sheet and capital structure.
Stuart Boxer
executiveOur expectation is that we'll get the dividend payout back inside the target range starting in F '25. When the DAOU acquisition was announced, we noted that franking on the dividend had been cut to 70%, reflecting the larger share of earnings coming from offshore. Thank you. I'll now pass things over to Tom King.
Tom King
executiveThanks, Stuart, and good morning, everyone. I'm very pleased to share that Penfolds has delivered another strong result in what has been a truly exciting year, as we came out of the tariff period, kept building excellent momentum across our major markets worldwide, and set a record for luxury wine intake from the 2024 vintage. One standout moment this year was undoubtedly our ability to restart shipments of our Australian portfolio into China right away once the tariffs were lifted, which shows how thoroughly our team had planned. Seeing how positively our customers have responded has been fantastic. I was in China last week and witnessed the energy and buzz firsthand surrounding the return of Penfolds' Australian portfolio to that market. Although it's early days, our key performance indicators — including shipping through the June quarter, initial depletion performance, and our customer base moving to reordering — give us confidence in the demand for Penfolds in the market and in our long-term growth plan. While there's a lot of commentary about the current consumer environment in China, we still view the market as a highly attractive long-term growth opportunity for Penfolds, and we intend to play a key role in leading the revival of the wine category, particularly from fiscal 2026, when we will see a significant step-up in the availability of our Bin and Icon wines.
Tom King
executiveEarlier this month came the 2024 collection launch, and it was a big success once more — consumer response was strong, and the size of the in-store price rises was broadly consistent with the adjustments we told you about in late June. Penfolds' 180th year began in January, and celebrations will run throughout the calendar year to mark this huge milestone. A couple of highlights stand out from the second half — notably the mounting success of our Luna New Year campaign. This year we marked the year of the Dragon with a broader program spanning the Penfolds portfolio. Worldwide, we keep seeing stronger momentum in consumer engagement around this festive moment. One key milestone for the brand this year was the first Penfolds Evermore grant program. Winners were selected because of how they concentrate on community impact, on reshaping their own sector, and on helping bring about positive change within the wine industry. Through this program we have a chance to harness our business as a force for good and to keep looking toward a positive future for communities everywhere. Most recently, we celebrated our 180th anniversary with a commemorative limited release, being 180.
Tom King
executiveThis wine has already drawn considerable praise from critics and remarkable enthusiasm from collectors worldwide. Now moving to how we performed financially. We achieved robust revenue growth throughout every portfolio tier and price point, and we completed as planned the shift in weighting of Bin and Icon shipments toward the second half, ahead of China's re-opening. Volume rose 30% and NSR rose 21%, with NSR surpassing $1 billion for the first time, powered by strong momentum in Asia — standout results in Hong Kong, Thailand and Taiwan especially — plus the benefit of fourth-quarter shipments to China. We continue to see substantial opportunity to broaden distribution and availability and to build consumer demand across the region through our highly targeted approach, which drills right down to the level of the individual account in our priority markets. Happily, we sustained our momentum in Australia, where results were driven by performance in national accounts and direct-to-consumer channels. We recorded modest declines in EMEA and the Americas, which reflect the strategic reallocation of a portion of Bin and Icon volumes away from these markets to support rebuilding distribution in China. Over the longer term, we stay committed to growing the Penfolds brand in both regions.
Tom King
executiveBringing La Place De Bordeaux into our arrangement this half so it also handles distribution for our Luxury and Icon wines is merely a single illustration of that dedication, giving us a substantial distribution platform that will assist us in reaching additional EMEA markets with those Luxury and Icon wines. NSR per case fell 7%, mirroring the effect of portfolio mix stemming from the rebuilding of entry-level luxury tiers in China. COGS per case rose 4%, mirroring the sell-through of pricier 2020 and 2021 Australian vintages along with one-off costs tied to reworking product for the China market. We posted EBIT of $421 million and an EBIT margin of 42%, with the EBIT margin decline mirroring the rebuilding of entry-level luxury tiers and greater onshore overhead costs in China during the fourth quarter. We anticipate margin improving inside the 43% to 45% range in fiscal '25, then a return to our long-term target of 45% past that, with incremental volumes from our fantastic Vintage 24 becoming available late in fiscal '26. In fiscal '25, we anticipate delivering low double-digit EBIT growth, mirroring top line growth for the Bin and Icon portfolio, which takes in the benefit of price increases, partly offset by a step-up in brand building investment and overheads in China ahead of the greater Bin and Icon portfolio availability from fiscal '26.
Tom King
executiveTo wrap up, I'm very happy with how well our plans continue to be carried out, producing yet another strong outcome for Penfolds in fiscal '24. Our path toward becoming a worldwide luxury icon is advancing at a steady pace, and we look forward to carrying that momentum further in fiscal '25. Thanks very much. At this point I'll pass things to Ben Dollard in California.
Ben Dollard
executiveThanks, Tom, and good morning. I'm delighted to be with you from Napa Valley, California. Fiscal '24 has been an exciting year for Treasury Americas, with the DAOU acquisition completed, our operating model redesigned to sharpen focus between the luxury and premium portfolios, and a new Treasury Americas leadership team formed. All of this was carried out successfully while our underlying business builds momentum, especially at the luxury price points, where our portfolio beat the market and our key competitors, gaining nearly a full point of market share. We're thrilled to have welcomed DAOU into the Treasury Americas portfolio. Integration is going well and remains on track from a people, systems and synergies standpoint. The main synergy areas are integrating outsourcing and wine production, centralizing packaging and warehouse operations, and procurement and logistics. Synergies remain on track to deliver at least US$20 million per annum in benefits from fiscal '26. Our integrated supply chain will be a key source of strength for Treasury Americas, supporting our long-term growth ambitions for DAOU well into the future. Our route-to-market changes in the US have further strengthened our focus across our luxury and premium portfolios and have enhanced our distributor partnerships, specifically with RNDC and BBG.
Ben Dollard
executiveWe’ve unlocked value by building strong alignment around what we want to achieve with growth across our brand portfolio. It’s been especially encouraging to watch DAOU keep up its strong performance trajectory since we acquired it. DAOU was a leading growth brand in the luxury category for the year and now ranks as the #2 luxury brand in the US market. We have meaningful growth plans in place, fueled by broader distribution across the US, consumer experiences and trade activations. Moving to the key financial metrics. Volume and net sales revenue rose 10% and 19%, respectively, driven by the contribution from DAOU in the second half, in line with expectations. On an organic basis, NSR for our luxury portfolio grew 11%, with increased wine availability, enabling continued growth for Frank Family Vineyards and Stags' Leap. That was partly offset by NSR declines for the non-luxury portfolio. The main drivers here are the 19 Crimes Modern tier lapping innovations released in the prior fiscal year, while the Classics tier performed in line with the prior period supported by the launch of a new campaign, refreshed packaging and the UFC sponsorship. Matua delivered strong performance and remains a top brand in the category, driven by its core Sauvignon Blanc, which continues to grow in popularity across the market.
Ben Dollard
executiveInnovation is still a major source of growth for the premium segment. There's now a team solely dedicated to this portfolio. Within the premium team, 19 Crimes will be a top priority. We intend to keep investing and innovating behind 19 Crimes and Matua. That covers worldwide innovation opportunities aimed at boosting how the premium portfolio performs. For the year, depletions for our premium portfolio surpassed shipments by 200,000 cases. NSR per case rose 9%, a reflection of growth in our luxury portfolio, which accounts for more than 50% of Treasury Americas NSR today and will clearly power our earnings growth going forward. COGS per case was up this period as we kept selling through the high-cost fire impacted Vintage 20. Improvement began to show in the second half as we started the sell-through of Vintage 21. Cost of doing business rose 28%, driven by the DAOU acquisition. EBIT came in at $231 million, with an EBIT margin of 23%. Organically, NSR was flat while EBIT fell 9%, with higher COGS a major factor behind the margin decline, and note that this was more pronounced in the first half because of the sell-through of the 2020 Vintage.
Ben Dollard
executiveEntering fiscal 2025, we're concentrating on finishing the DAOU integration and keeping up the robust growth momentum for DAOU, while also generating growth throughout our luxury brand portfolio. A double-digit rise in availability will support this, along with bringing stability to the rest of our portfolio. We expect EBIT delivery to be balanced throughout fiscal 2025, which mirrors business seasonality and the realization of synergies from the DAOU acquisition. Luxury-led growth, together with enhancements in our COGS profile, should help lift EBIT margin toward our long-term target in the high 20% range. All in all, a year of numerous achievements for Treasury Americas, and we're energized by the opportunity ahead of us to build another outstanding luxury focused growth platform within Treasury Wine Estates. Thank you. I'll now hand over to Angus Lilley in Melbourne.
Angus Lilley
executiveThanks, Ben, and good morning, everyone. It's a pleasure to report Treasury Premium Brands' fiscal '24 results for the first time in my capacity as Managing Director, a role I've held since 1 July this year. For anyone here I haven't yet met, I've been at TWE since 2013 and have taken on a number of executive leadership positions, most recently Global Chief Revenue Growth Officer — a function now being folded into TPB. Before that, I served as TWE's Chief Marketing Officer. Leading the TPB business is both demanding and exciting right now, given that results over the past few years have been affected by tough market conditions for Commercial Wine and by our brands underperforming at these price points. Those dynamics have frequently obscured the success achieved within our premium brand portfolio, with labels such as Squealing Pig, Pepperjack and 19 Crimes making substantial inroads in our key markets. Our journey since visualization has surfaced plenty of learnings and foundations to build on. In FY 2025, we're concentrating on these priorities: accelerating our premium brand portfolio via compelling marketing campaigns, with emphasis on 19 Crimes, and building distribution across our innovation initiatives, which include new Pepperjack sub-brands, the Squealing Pig, Sparkling Portello expansion, plus Italian and New Zealand country of origin opportunities.
Angus Lilley
executiveWe’re driving efficiency by optimizing the portfolio, processes, and cost base, and making sure our investment lines up with the areas of greatest opportunity. Then there’s embedding the global revenue growth team inside TPB and, crucially, getting ready for our next stage as a global premium business starting 1 July, 2025. Before we move to the new operating model, the TPB and Treasury Americas teams are already working together on global brand and innovation opportunities, and the first of those will launch globally in the coming months during this half. Our recent announcement that we intend to divest the remaining commercial brands and combine the premium brands into a global business marks a significant step toward sharpening our focus and maximizing how the premium brands perform, along with the value they deliver to the TWE business. We are firmly focused on setting the premium portfolio up for success within TWE, and as consumers keep engaging with the category at premium price points, innovation and agility will be key components of our success. Turning to TPB’s key financial metrics: volume and NSR fell 10% and 9%, respectively, driven by double-digit volume declines across the commercial portfolio and reduced premium portfolio shipments, our under-performance relative to the category, particularly in Australia and the UK, which impacted performance, along with the reduction in shipments to Asia as we realigned customer inventory levels to better align with trend depletion rates.
Angus Lilley
executiveHappily, our premium brand portfolio kept generating growth, powered by 19 Crimes, Squealing Pig, and Pepperjack, and innovation around those core brands contributed to the NSR increase as well. Expanding our low and no alcohol ranges and continuing to roll out new packaging formats were both highlights. We also brought back the Australian country of origin for Rawson's Retreat in China during the fourth quarter, after tariffs were removed. We anticipate strong depletions growth in F '25. NSR per case rose 1%, which mirrors the portfolio mix shift. COGS per case was up 4%, caused by portfolio mix, with gains from supply chain optimization initiatives put in place in the fourth quarter of 2030 softening the effect of lower sales volumes. Cost of doing business got 13% better, mirroring the realignment of brand investment with reduced volumes plus the $10.5 million gain on the sale of divested non-strategic vineyard assets. EBITS fell 17% to $76 million, and the EBITS margin came in at 10.3%. Looking to F '25, we anticipate our top line will be stable, with trading conditions across our key markets expected to stay consistent, and EBITS delivery broadly in line with the PCP, excluding the one-off benefits from the F '24 asset sales. Thank you, and I'll hand back to Tim now.
Tim Ford
executiveThanks, Angus. So to wrap up before we take questions, let me summarize: '24 was clearly a strong year, driven by momentum in our luxury portfolio, which drove our group NSR and EBITS growth, no doubt about it. Looking ahead to '25, to reiterate, we expect to deliver EBIT in the range of $780 million to $810 million, with, again, that top line growth driven by momentum in our luxury brand portfolio from an execution point of view. As we do with all these presentations, we like to leave investors with our 3 priorities, our top 3 priorities. First for us is simply continuing Penfold's focus on growing distribution and availability, as well as consumer demand across key markets, in addition to re-establishing the Australian country of origin portfolio in China ahead of what we see as increased availability in an icon portfolio in fiscal '26. In Treasury Americas, simply driving the leading luxury wine portfolio in the US to continue the momentum across DAOU, Stags Leap, Frank Family and other luxury brands, which is supported by a double-digit increase in portfolio availability. Third, we must improve the execution focus and the operating performance of our premium brand portfolio globally as we continue the path to transition to the global premium division from the 1st of July next year.
Tim Ford
executiveThanks for being with us. I'll pass things over to the operator at this point, and then we'll take your questions.
Operator
operator<<operator_script>> Our initial question is from Michael Simotas at Jefferies.
Michael Simotas
analystI'll start with the commercial business. I was hoping you might be able to help us a bit in understanding the range of financial implications from that divestment. So it looks like there's roughly $60 million of gross profit. Then, if I use your back book as a guide, there are probably around $60 million of production and packaging overheads tied to that portfolio. How should we think about your ability to offset the costs associated with that product as the volume and gross profit come out of the P&L?
Stuart Boxer
executiveGood day, Michael — this is Stuart, and I’ll handle that question. There are a few things to cover at the outset. Clearly, you’ve noted the $60 million of GP; given the guidance of less than 5% that we provided, that is directionally the correct figure. Turning to stranded costs, we certainly anticipate that some will arise. In the end, though, how large they are and what remains with us will hinge on several factors. In part, it will depend on whatever transaction structure we ultimately reach and on the extent to which that structure allows us to reduce them. That said, we have already worked through a range of mitigation options. What I did want to highlight is that we have undertaken something like this previously. You’ll remember that back in 2021, when we divested the commercial portfolio in the US and effectively had the volume in that market, we dealt successfully with the stranded cost there. In part, we removed some of those costs in advance, and in part we managed the rest through the business afterward. One of the steps we took last year — you’ll recall that when we restructured TPB at the back end of the 2023 financial year and decided to close our Karadoc facility, that raised outsourced production of commercial wines, which effectively converted a fixed cost into a variable cost in that part of the business.
Stuart Boxer
executiveWe've adjusted things so that a portion of those expenses now behaves more variably. Another factor is that as that commercial business keeps shrinking, the cost burden carried by that specific segment is smaller than before. So I can't provide a precise figure right now for what the stranded cost would amount to, since, for the reasons I mentioned, it genuinely depends on how the transaction is structured. That said, I believe we have a reasonable handle on what's achievable there. Looking at the result, even if some stranded costs exist, when you examine the margin profile of the rest of the business, we're confident the net-net outcome will be considerably stronger, both regarding that margin profile and the growth outlook.
Michael Simotas
analystJust to clarify quickly, I suppose: ought we to view that lost gross profit — let's just call it $60 million — as the worst case? Or, since you still have some fixed production and packaging costs, might the drag potentially end up somewhat larger than that?
Stuart Boxer
executiveYes. So to kind of restate it, $60 million is the number we've put out there. And inside that figure, there's clearly some cost carry, obviously. And what I was getting at, I think, is that there's probably going to be some stranded cost on top of it — the extent to which we're able to mitigate those depends on what I just walked through a moment ago.
Michael Simotas
analystMy second question concerns China. A very large volume of wine at luxury price points was shipped into China during the June quarter. I assume Treasury accounted for a substantial share of that. How much of it has actually flowed through your P&L, as opposed to simply being product relocated from Australia? I'm just trying to make sense of the remark that the earnings impact, or the earnings benefit, in FY 2024 was very small. Is that because you earned money in the China market, partly offset by higher costs, but then you had to source the product from elsewhere, so you made less in Australia and EMEA?
Stuart Boxer
executiveYes, Mike. Absolutely — on that second point, you've got it right. What it really amounted to was us reallocating the Penfolds portfolio we already had. Had China not been open, those sales would have gone to other markets. So in a manner of speaking, our earnings profile for the year wasn't shifted by that reallocation, if you will. So your point there is exactly right. Regarding the guidance, that's precisely why we essentially landed at zero benefit on the bottom line, so to speak, in Q4 — because of that reallocation, but also, yes, there was a step-up in entry-level luxury wine, which normally, I'd say, would lift earnings as the market reopens, but we also have the increased costs we're investing behind around the team and brand investment to get things going as we reestablish that market, on top of what we had already been planning to do. So those are the moving parts on that side of things. So hopefully that's clear. It's very, very similar. What has happened is exactly what we laid out to the market, both back in March — what our expectation was — and in June, when we walked through a more detailed plan for investors around the China reopening.
Stuart Boxer
executiveRegarding the first part about wine being shipped to that destination, I believe we know whatever we've shipped and whatever originates from Australia is reflected in our P&L, since we've exported that product into that market. So from that standpoint, the shipment volume we control and manage is definitely in our P&L, so to speak. We didn't move product around between different markets or anything of that sort. Everything was shipped out of Australia. Because, if you remember, we withheld a portion of our allocation during the second half of last year, with that roughly 45%, 55% split we described, precisely to make possible that capability of shipping in Australia. So we were keeping stock, if you will, back in Australia in anticipation of the China reopening, which thankfully happened at the end of March.
Operator
operatorLisa Deng from Goldman Sachs has the next question — go right ahead.
Lisa Deng
analystI have a couple of questions of my own. The first one also concerns China. The consumer backdrop appears to have deteriorated each quarter, from December through March and then most recently in June; I was over there in July too. Your initial sell-in was carried out very well. Obviously, we factor that into the cash commitments as well. How are you viewing depletions — I believe you referenced expectations earlier — but how are we beginning to see sell-through, reordering, and sentiment among consumers or distributors? And when are they typically expected to place their next reorder, if you could give us a bit more detail on that, please?
Tom King
executiveAbsolutely, Lisa. Happy to provide an update. As we mentioned earlier, the plan as it stands today is performing right in line with what we expected. We were set to ship at the very start of April. So we got off to a quick start getting stock into the market, with customs clearances going smoothly, and from then through May, June and into July, that stock has been coming in and moving through our distribution channels. The early read on depletions from our customers in-market has been positive, and they're now at a point where they are reordering, or will be, in Q1 — which is a great place to be. We have plenty of activity planned for mid-autumn festival, which is coming up in roughly a month. So for us, that will be the true signal of how well the execution is going and what demand is actually there. But look, if I address one of your points more broadly, around luxury and some of the headwinds that luxury categories in China are facing, our view is that many of these categories, many of these brands, have come off 3 or 4 years now of very strong growth, during which Penfolds hasn't really been present in the market in any significant or meaningful way.
Tom King
executiveIt's also worth noting that when you dig a little further into how brands are doing, they aren't all up against identical obstacles — brands that are winning, that genuinely connect with consumers and deliver value, can still achieve growth. And if we examine luxury wine more closely rather than considering the wine category as a whole or looking at import figures, what we've observed at the premium end — based on actual consumption data from e-commerce at RMB 500 and above — is double-digit growth in '23, with that rate speeding up in '24 as well. So that benefit has come through for us. We've witnessed it directly via our French, Chinese and US wines, all of which have been performing strongly. As for how we view market conditions, we're feeling quite positive about the market we're re-entering, given the strength of our brand and the demand we continue to see at the top end. So we're confident, very happy with how the plan has been carried out. And as I mentioned before, we have customers who are ready to place reorders for Q1.
Lisa Deng
analystOn the reordering terms — I believe we also discussed that cash conversion could be lower in 2025, since cash sales into China will return to normal patterns. Are we extending more sales on credit, or how are we thinking about that? And then the follow-up on that is also parallel input. When I was there in July, I did actually see a decent amount of parallel imports in the market, potentially only because I've visited 2 locations. So, it's granted not a full conclusive view, but what are the on-the-ground feedback on parallel imports potentially being a disruptor?
Tim Ford
executiveOkay, Lisa, I’ll handle the first question, and then I’ll pass it over to Tom for the second. The way I look at that cash element is that I regard F ’25 as essentially returning to normal — just a typical year in terms of how we run things. But when you consider the latter part of F ’24, clearly a great deal of sales happens within a very compressed window. So, purely to manage that concentration of credit risk, we had a peak in cash settlement, and next year it will simply revert to normal. That’s really the distinction, rather than any specific change next year — it’s about bringing it back to normal.
Tom King
executiveYes. One really key thing there is that the reordering happens on identical terms. Our cash conversion guidance doesn't come from tweaking terms in F '25 compared with what we did in Q4 of '24, and Tom, would you like to take that?
Tim Ford
executiveAbsolutely, Lisa. Parallel isn't something new for us to deal with. It's definitely an issue we've consistently worked to keep an eye on and handle throughout many years of operating in China. There's a silver lining, since it shows how strong the demand is in the market for Penfolds. So we view that as somewhat of a positive demand indicator. Still, none of this comes as a surprise. We were always aware there would be a stretch of time as China reopened — a sort of transition period — when some players in the market might seize the chance to push product into China. It's very disappointing when that occurs. What's even more disappointing is seeing prices show up on e-commerce at very low levels, well under what our authorized channels can deliver across the business in China. So we don't control what retailers do in the market, just as we don't control that anywhere. But it's disappointing and a shame to see people making sharp pricing decisions because demand is outpacing supply for the period ahead. So what we're doing right now is focusing a lot of our communications at the consumer and trade level on how to spot a product that comes from our authorized distributors in China, because they offer that confidence and security that the stock has been transported and stored properly and comes directly from the winery.
Tim Ford
executiveWe've also established quite solid ties with Customs authorities. As a result, we can now more effectively pinpoint where the origin lies when parallel occurs. Still, this is simply a continuing aspect of running our business in China, just as it always has been, and we don't view it as significantly affecting our ability to deliver on our plan and build our brand. So we'll keep watching things over the coming 6 to 12 months, but it's not unexpected.
Stuart Boxer
executiveAnd we do anticipate that — given Tom and I were both here last week, and we spent time with all of our — along with all of our major customers, and those authorized channels matter a great deal too, along with our partners. And we certainly stay closely connected with those partners when it comes to handling this. We expected it to be quite clear. We probably expect it to persist, though to a lesser degree from now until roughly the close of this calendar year. So, it's always part of running the China market. We're aware of that. We've dealt with it previously. We get it. But you're also seeing the price gap on some of the product already narrowing. So, we expect that to carry on over the coming few months. Happily, the conduct of our key partners is exactly right as we truly rebuild that market. So, not perfect, but much of what we anticipated, I suppose, at least gives you some flavor of how we feel about the way we handle it.
Operator
operatorDavid Errington from Bank of America has the next question.
David Errington
analystStuart, this is for you as well, and probably Mr. Dollard over in the US too. That said, I have 2 questions. The first concerns the second half in the US. I was genuinely delighted to see your luxury business — premium, sorry, luxury, forgive me — expand 14% during that second half, particularly with the US backdrop where luxury has been softening. But I'm working through some figures here. Once you strip out the DAOU acquisition, your sales — essentially your margin — fell to 18%. First-half EBIT came in at $93 million. In the second half, excluding DAOU, it was $100 million, and even so you'd have posted more than 20% growth in that luxury portfolio during that second half. So it genuinely surprises me that the second half wasn't more robust on the earnings side, considering how impressively luxury performed in that period. Could you unpack that for me? Because what worries me is whether the premium business, from an earnings standpoint, is really slipping away. My second question, if I may, and to be upfront, Stuart, about these material items — I'm not enjoying them. Over the last 4 years — and Tim, you'd prefer to be judged only across the last 3 or 4 years — your material items have now reached $1 billion pre-tax.
David Errington
analystThat's a huge write-down. Could you explain how long this material item is expected to continue? Because these are substantial numbers you're now taking below the line. So if you could address those two issues, that would be great. But congratulations to Bin. That luxury business, considering what competitors are doing, had a fantastic second half, but the numbers look really weak outside of that, and those material items are really starting to concern me. So if you could go through those two issues, that would be really appreciated.
Tim Ford
executiveOkay, so I suppose we’ll have Ben start us off — covering how they’ve performed and why we feel confident about that side of things. Ben, go ahead, and after that Stuart can handle the financial part.
Ben Dollard
executiveYes, thanks Tim, and hi David. I think the second half—certainly once we began executing against better availability from the 21 vintage—was a key driver of the momentum we built, particularly around Frank Family and Stags' Leap. So if you look at what the team has achieved with the acquisition of DAOU, the creation of our luxury effort, and really building a very combined and collaborative effort with our distributors, that has led to the momentum you mentioned in H2. Really, outside of DAOU, it's come on the back of Frank Family and Stags' Leap. So, as I said, we did see some softness in our premium business, specifically around the 19 Crimes Classics, and that absolutely is impacting results, as I mentioned earlier. That said, we had very robust plans in place for our premium business, with a very specific lens on 19 Crimes and Matua. But the job to be done right now is focusing on and executing and building on the momentum we have across our luxury business. So it's been pleasing, but the job is still to be done, particularly as we now fully integrate DAOU into the business as well.
David Errington
analystSo has premium's EBIT now leveled off? At your presentation today you shared a few figures, I believe, and working backward we get an EBIT of roughly $90 million to $95 million for premium. Is that a level you can hold steady at, or will it keep falling?
Tim Ford
executiveI'd say what we need to do right now is get the premium business on stable footing. And when you break that premium business down, there are parts we're really happy about — especially if you look at how Matua is growing, along with a few of the innovations we brought out lately and will keep bringing out. So the big push behind, and the reason for, splitting the portfolio this way is that we understand executing on the premium side demands a particular investment level and amount of effort, while executing on the luxury side and dealing directly with our consumer also calls for a distinct capability. So yes, I'm confident, and I think the team shares that confidence, that we'll keep putting the right level of effort and attention behind the premium business, even as we build on this luxury momentum. Sorry for interrupting you — that wasn't my intention. Also, I don't think we should downplay what Ben has accomplished too when it comes to separating the sales and marketing team, and how those teams are now focused on driving these portfolios. One thing we've definitely learned is how you execute and how you approach the various channels from a luxury business standpoint compared with a premium business from a sales standpoint.
Tim Ford
executiveBasically, the premium portfolio is mostly sold and executed via national accounts, off-premise retail, while the luxury businesses go through D2C, on-premise, independent off-premise, and national accounts too — and with the size and scale of the luxury business now, that's one of the learnings. First, we can't distract the team from driving what you rightly point out, David, is really good performance and some good momentum, but at the same time, having the skill set and the focus on this absolute execution in national accounts for these premium brands is where the success is going to lie. So it's a pretty important change within the Treasury of America's business, and we felt it was necessary to really drive this focus because, as you rightly say, you can't have a full P&L at the end of the year that has a great news story on part of the portfolio and yet we haven't got the performance on the rest. We recognize that.
Stuart Boxer
executiveDavid, I’ll attempt to address the remaining portions of your question. Regarding the margin question, we’ll likely need to handle that one offline, since I’m having trouble following your math. Still, my main takeaway was that throughout the year we felt very good that, overall, if DAOU is excluded — and DAOU clearly performed in line with our guidance — the rest of the business in the second half met our overall guidance and, from a margin standpoint, was certainly in line with, and perhaps a bit better than, what we expected when we gave guidance in the first half for that second-half margin. So we’re quite pleased with that result, and part of what drove the difference, if you compare first-half and second-half margin, was that as we began to move past the wildfire-affected 2020 vintage onto the 2021 vintage, we started to see that margin improvement come through in the second half. So we’ll need to work through your math with you offline to understand what you’re getting at there, because overall we were quite pleased with it. On the second item, about material items, I completely hear you.
Stuart Boxer
executiveLooking back at what makes up that number, as you know, we’ve been working through an effort to really reshape the portfolio, and if you examine the largest pieces of that cost affecting the P&L, they’ve come from parts of the portfolio we either exited previously or are now discussing exiting — commercial here. So US commercial for TPB is really the outcome of legacy costs we were carrying forward there; obviously it isn’t something we like doing each period or trying to turn things into material items. They’re all tied to really specific initiatives aimed at reshaping the portfolio. I can’t speak to the future, but certainly, as we sit here, our main focus is on delivering really good quality operating earnings. If we need to keep refining the portfolio and that has some implications for material items, we’ll call them out and disclose them as clearly as we can, but it’s certainly not a priority for us to keep having material items. I fully understand what you’re saying.
Operator
operatorBen Gilbert from Jarden has the next question.
Ben Gilbert
analystTim, Tom — I’ve just got one question. It’s about the decision, which I think is clearly well flagged, around building a global TPB business. What’s the thinking on where that business goes in the future, given that for now it sits inside Treasury? Because you could argue the market is undervaluing the premium business relative to, say, your Luxury business, given the growth you have across some of your other luxury brands globally, and there’s obviously a pretty strong track record of demergers in Australia that I think in over two-thirds of cases can typically create value in aggregate. What is the board thinking on that? Is this something that, if you were going to see it, would happen after 1 July last year, just coming on some of the thinking that you yourself and the Board have got behind at the moment.
Tim Ford
executiveYes. What I can share at this point is what we've already announced, which is that we believe moving to the global premium model is the right approach to strengthen the business, propel it forward, and generate value from it. Clearly, that sets it apart from our Luxury portfolio, where we obviously see the stronger performance in our business, but also the stronger growth profile and the quality of the metrics of those businesses going forward as well. So that separation is important to unlock whatever future decisions we may make, but the only decisions we have made at this point in time are, one, we believe that in any scenario, the commercial brands and specifically the big 4 commercial brands we've outlined, we are seeking to divest those. We don't see those as creating value for us going forward, whereas from a global premium brand perspective, it's about how do we create the most value, and there are multiple different scenarios that we're discussing as a management team and discussing with the Board. But at this point in time, it would be premature to outline too many of those other than what we've actually outlined in last week and today.
Ben Gilbert
analystRegarding the appreciation, it's a significant undertaking, but you've begun and made solid progress. Are there any major risk factors we should consider, such as separate ERPs and similar issues, or is it simply a matter of scale—nothing straightforward—but do you think it's relatively derisked in terms of the path through to 1st of July next year?
Tim Ford
executiveI'd say most of the heavy lifting is nearly complete. Consider what's shifting in Treasury Americas as the sales and marketing team separates out. That piece is really the market-facing part of the business. From a complexity standpoint, it's likely the toughest, and it leans more toward people and customer engagement. And obviously Angus has taken over leadership of TPB, and the integration work he's done with his former team — he finished that on July 1 as well. So the back-of-house support functions — supply chain, systems and IT, all of that — will keep supporting every part of TWE, since that's our shared back office. From that angle, there are some additional changes still to come. But the real focus is making sure — as a priority, Ben — and that's why we've given ourselves, and signaled to the market, the timeline we're targeting: July 1, 2025. Our first priority is making sure we're performing in our premium brands businesses. Angus has been in the role for 6 weeks now, yes. He has a very clear plan for what he needs to do to improve that business, and nobody is going to dispute that we have to improve that business.
Tim Ford
executiveThat is what we are concentrating on. From the Treasury Americas standpoint, David notes that the dedicated team in the US indeed shares that same agenda item. So when we feel confident that we are on that path and have put in place what is required for us to do so, that is the point at which we will move further ahead with uniting the organization.
Ben Gilbert
analystOne last question from me. You’ve clearly done quite a bit on the productivity side, and you’re clearly going to fold several of those production sites for DAOU into the large one you have in Patrols. What kind of materiality are you seeing, or do you expect to see, when it comes to cost per liter — first from Penfolds across roughly the next 12 months to 18 months? And then from DAOU, bringing that in as well? Are we talking sort of double-digit-type benefits from the productivity gains you’ve implemented across both of those?
Tim Ford
executiveI'll handle that question, Ben. What I'd say is that the right way to approach this is to tie it on the DAOU side back to the $20 million plus of synergies we've guided to, and then you can carry that through your model that way instead of attempting to sort of reverse-engineer it via a productivity metric. Obviously, delivering synergies of that kind will produce productivity. But my suggestion is to focus here on simply connecting it back to the $20 million DAOU plus number. And in the same way, if you look at other parts of the network, we've once more provided fairly solid guidance on, say, Penfolds regarding our margin ambitions over the coming couple of years. So that is sort of incorporated into our thinking there. Another thing worth noting is that it won't sort of assist you in answering the question you're after. But yes, given that such a large share of their costs, particularly in luxury wine, sits in the liquid in the bottle, think about the vintages we've had in fiscal 2024, both in America and also here in Australia, are both very large, high-quality vintages as well.
Tim Ford
executiveSo since we're producing more of this luxury wine — as today's inventory figures show — to meet demand in fiscal '26-'27, especially, it's going to be a bigger vintage in terms of volume, and that ought to bring a better cogs.
Operator
operatorTom Kierath from Barrenjoey has the next question.
Tom Kierath
analystJust one question about Penfolds. Could you break out how much of those sales went into China compared with Asia excluding China during either half of the year? We'd just like a sense of where you stand in China relative to FY '19 levels.
Tim Ford
executiveYes. Unfortunately, no, that isn’t something we’re going to do. I understand that’s something you’d like. But when we consider the overall Asia business, the reallocation, and what goes into China compared with other markets, I don’t think it’s—it’s going to involve quite a lot of shifting, and separating out China especially from a P&L perspective—we don’t believe that would be very helpful for running the market or for managing our position there. And I’ve been quite clear about this since we discussed the China reopening: this is not something we will separate. We will discuss Penfolds Asia as a market—as a group of markets together—and that is the prudent approach. Consider where we stood 4 or 5 years ago in that market. So I apologize that we won’t provide that, but I believe most investors understand why we would take this approach, and we think it makes sense.
Tom Kierath
analystAll right, and then on the second point — those 7 million cases you're divesting, what share of that do you produce in-house as opposed to through a third party? My assumption is that the deleverage applies only to what you make yourselves, so it would help if you could break that out.
Tim Ford
executiveFair question. I can give you an answer that's directionally right, though I'm confident the team can provide you the precise figure when you meet later today. On the outsourcing side, consider Lindeman's and Blossom Hill — those are fully outsourced. Yellowglen has some volume running through our own facilities, Wolf Blass only a very small amount through our plants, and Lindeman's is basically outsourced. So if you total that up — and I shouldn't be guessing on analyst calls, but I will — it's likely 90% or more that's outsourced.
Stuart Boxer
executiveOne more point I would make about that — it concerns the production side Tim is referring to. Obviously, a considerable share of it is also bottled and packaged by us through our own facilities. That puts…
Tim Ford
executiveLooking at it from a winemaking standpoint, the vast, vast majority is definitely outsourced.
Operator
operatorOur following question is from Richard Barwick of CLSA. You have the floor.
Richard Barwick
analystLet me just make sure I've got Stuart's remarks about the financial effect of that commercial divestment right, so I'm understanding it properly. So I take it you mean that $60 million of GP impact. And were you essentially saying, Stuart, that on the cost side — so the cost of doing business side — you're hoping to more or less offset that cost? So if you carry this through to the bottom line, are you saying there's a $60 million hit to GP and on COD you're hoping it comes out a wash? And therefore the — you're referring to a $60 million hit to EBIT.
Stuart Boxer
executiveNot exactly, Richard. What I meant was this: the $60 million figure is okay to use. But inside that $60 million, some costs do actually flow through our network, even after everything we just discussed about outsourced production covering a fair proportion of it. We still have products being packaged, and we have wine makers and that kind of thing. So certain costs are absorbed within the effective cost of goods sold in that business. That's why, in my earlier discussion about stranded costs, I said I expect some stranded cost to arise. As a result, the net impact will come in somewhat above that $60 million — and precisely how much, as I mentioned before, hinges on a whole lot of factors. That's the point I'm trying to make. It will be somewhat higher than the 60%, because some costs are retained beyond that gross profit loss.
Tim Ford
executiveWhat I'd emphasize is that it's really the shared cost base — corporate overhead and technology — rather than supply chain per se; packaging does matter, yes, and we have to work through that. But that too hinges on what solution we land on for these brands and what the end state looks like. So it's more the corporate overhead component that we also need to work through. And we have to address it. We know — we have a plan in place to address certain parts of it. But again, it depends on where we end up. So I think I understand, if the goal is to understand what the P&L impact would be across the year, but it is — we're not dodging the question, but there are different scenarios. Different outcomes will result. But trust me, we've done the work showing that across all those outcomes, it's a higher-quality business at the end of the day from a metrics standpoint, even though you're removing a small amount of gross profit against a pretty large amount of volume.
Richard Barwick
analystThat's clear, I grasp it. Nobody, I believe, would argue with that. The result will be a higher-quality business. The challenge is simply wrapping our minds around the fresh earnings base you'll be growing from. One more thing, for clarity's sake: you're referring to what you expect from Treasury Premium Brands as we look toward '25. Essentially, stable top line and EBIT delivery roughly matching PCP. But that leaves out any one-off gain. That excludes the one-off gain stemming from asset sales during 2024. So could you clarify precisely what EBIT contribution those asset sales made in 2024?
Tim Ford
executiveRight, Richard — that figure is the $10.5 million, the one we laid out, I believe, on that page.
Richard Barwick
analystRight. So that means, then, if what you're after is keeping revenue steady while absorbing $10 million — or 10.5% of EBIT — you'd be looking at, in effect, guidance pointing toward a fairly substantial decline in the margin you expect to achieve through Treasury Premium brands?
Tim Ford
executiveCorrect — you're right that a reduction does exist.
Richard Barwick
analystYes. And we can attribute that to the deterioration of commercial brands being discontinued, assuming those brands remain in the portfolio.
Tim Ford
executiveExactly. As those reduced volumes carry over from earlier years, that’s how it comes through—and you wind up with a COGS impact coming through as a result. That is the largest factor.
Operator
operatorBryan Raymond from JPMorgan has the next question.
Bryan Raymond
analystTurning back to the US, I'm curious how you view the pricing outlook now that supply has improved for you and the industry as a whole — especially since Napa will clearly have considerably more wine on the market, and then there's Paso as well with the DAOU business. My sense is they gained somewhat in recent years from a tight Napa situation. So I'd just like to hear how you're thinking about pricing in both parts of the business as we look ahead to 2025 and 2026. Thanks.
Tim Ford
executiveAppreciate that, Bryan. Over to you, Ben.
Ben Dollard
executiveYes. Hi Bryan, thanks. Look, I think from a pricing standpoint, we've spent a lot of time over the past really 12, 24 months in terms of positioning of our brands, how we think about revenue and most importantly, how we think about the pricing with our consumers. So I feel from a Napa Valley standpoint that we are well-positioned, and as we come into more supply that we're not concerned that there's going to be heavy discounting across the segment out of Napa. And again, the investment in our brands and how we're executing in market and the activities that we have with our distributors. All of those elements play an important role in protecting our equity. So from that regard, as I think about Frank Family or Stags' Leap, and BV is a very good example where we've been managing pricing very carefully over the last period and feel we're positioned now in a really good place. So I feel good about the pricing environment across the category, but importantly, within our portfolio. And then with regards to Paso Robles and the impact of increased inventory or availability coming out of other regions, I think Paso continues to present just an amazing value for the consumer, they probably we're able to drive, and brand DAOU really does -- it transcends from a regional standpoint, it really does transcend kind of the engagement with the consumer.
Ben Dollard
executiveTo reiterate, when it comes to holding and sustaining pricing with DAOU, we feel quite confident in that capability, and with a brand such as DAOU elevating Paso's profile—both within California and beyond—I think we're in a strong position.
Stuart Boxer
executiveI'd just tack one point onto that, Bryan. When you look at where Napa and Paso sit on price, that's among the main reasons we're so enthusiastic about the DAOU brand. Napa Cabernet these days generally has to hit $60 — $60-odd, $55, $60 per bottle at shelf — to produce the margin structure that we'd look for and that most other players would likewise require. DAOU Cabernet from Paso Robles, by contrast, is a great-quality offering at a core $25, $26 per bottle. That's a markedly different price point, and it's one we see the brand competing at. So I'd say the consumer in that segment is a different one. Sure, they also have the 60 to 100 reserve tiers, but from that angle we believe the brand itself is strong. So it's really — at this point it's a pleasant portfolio, so to speak, since you get that balance across entry-level luxury versus the higher-end luxury price points as well, going forward, with the combined portfolio that Ben now has in his hands.
Bryan Raymond
analystOkay, so I just want to make sure — thanks for that detail, it's really helpful. But let me double-check: you're saying prices rose quite a bit. They climbed significantly market-wide and for you as well, though we're in a supply-constrained situation, and you anticipate mostly keeping them where they are going forward? Or should we expect additional pricing actions to be taken — I'm just trying to get a clear picture of how this works.
Tim Ford
executiveNo, that’s a fair summary question. Now look, our growth road map—certainly over the next couple of years—is wine; as more wine comes online, it’s about growing distribution, growing distribution, and growing distribution, and that will be volume rather than price. We believe we’ve got the pricing architecture about right for the medium term.
Operator
operatorCraig Woolford from MST Marquee has the next question.
Craig Woolford
analystTim, Stuart, and the entire team — could you clarify something about the commercial portfolio? Are there various approaches you'd contemplate for selling it? Would you sell brands one by one? And if a decent price or a decent offer doesn't come through, is it a sale at any price? Also, how much capital is actually tied up in that commercial portfolio, out of the $6.6 billion in capital employed that you have?
Tim Ford
executiveYes. Let me address the capital question first. It isn't much. Clearly, it's working capital that's tied up in those businesses. But certainly, following the decision we made on Karadoc last year, few dedicated assets are linked to those brands, and the fixed assets have gone. Regarding how we'd sell them: first, I just want to say that we've had some inquiries and inbound interest even before this announcement was made, which gives us a sense that a level of interest exists out there. As we go through a process — and we're putting it together right now — we will consider different scenarios, because some brands may be more said, what do others base to where the distribution is. So we'll run a process and work it through. If you can do it in one transaction, great, but if it makes more sense to sell them separately because they're not necessarily tied to specific assets, then we'll look at that as well.
Craig Woolford
analystThen on the other item — given that this business always has plenty of moving pieces, especially with the DAOU acquisition and some shifts in the portfolio mix — but looking just at organic terms, do you anticipate that in FY 2025 your price per case growth will exceed COGS per case?
Tim Ford
executiveThat's something I find interesting. I'm trying to work out what the drivers of COGS would be.
Stuart Boxer
executiveYeah. I mean, definitely every one of the signals we've mentioned looks favorable when it comes to the COGS result, particularly as we shift toward improved vintages, and clearly we're also providing guidance more widely on margin and similar items, which is trending that way too.
Tim Ford
executiveYes. Let's be sure we follow up with you later today on that too, since broadly speaking the answer is yes, but I want to be certain it's yes. That's when you include a full year of DAOU along with the entire business. Still, the answer is yes.
Operator
operatorMark Southwell-Keely from Select Equities has the next question for you.
Mark Southwell-Keely
analystHello there. On Page 3 of the results announcement released today, it's stated that worldwide demand for the Penfolds Bin and Icon portfolio is greater than what's available. I'm just curious: how do you account for the fact that, in China right now, consumer prices for Bin 407 and 389 are trading at roughly 20% under wholesale prices and about 40% under RRP?
Tim Ford
executiveYes. Thank you, Mark. Tom, would you mind restating the points you made earlier?
Tom King
executiveAs I mentioned before, we're conscious that some parallel imports have been entering the market since the tariffs were removed, and certain parties are seizing the chance to turn a fast profit and potentially operate on extremely thin margins — something we find deeply disappointing, and it's a real shame given the supply-side constraint we face. So we're doing what's needed, as I laid out earlier, though we anticipated a scenario in which this would occur. What we are seeing across our own channels and the authorized challenge we face is that demand exists, and that has been good so far; initial sales are strong at the full retail price or the share.
Mark Southwell-Keely
analystRight now, essentially all of our transaction volume is flowing through the e-commerce site — 100% of it. That's not a trivial figure. Typically, when we observe something like this, it suggests they're putting pressure on the value chain, and that could call for the brand to step in — say, by capping supply or putting in extra investment. So I'm curious: if these patterns hold steady, what's your thinking there?
Tim Ford
executiveMark, I’m unable to say anything about the figures you’re citing there. I don’t know. That differs quite a lot from what we observe. So we’ve long been aware that situations like this sometimes arise. And we’ve never avoided being open about it. As I said earlier, we’re acting to make sure that where this is happening right now, it goes down and becomes as small as possible over time.
Tom King
executiveAddressing your question, Mark: how are we handling this? Our approach is to control how allocations go to those customers. We are completely clear about who our key partners in China are, and we deal with them directly. Sixteen or seventeen of them are fully engaged across the value chain, performing as we expect — reaching the retail price points, whether in Tier 1 or Tier 2 cities, especially for those core Bins. Sure, there are isolated cases. But the data we see doesn't match that picture, in my view. I don't agree that 100% of products at those levels are affected. So thank you for raising it.
Operator
operatorShaun Cousins from UBS has the next question. Go right ahead.
Shaun Cousins
analystTim, just on DAOU — the company has kind of pointed out that in past years, 63% of calendar-year EBIT has come in the second half of the calendar year. Is there any reason that wouldn't be the case in calendar 2024?
Tim Ford
executiveThere are a few points to address here. If you flip that onto our fiscal year, the figures we show at the back of the pack are closer to 60-40, and that's simply a result of the year-on-year growth. Shaun, that's only a small adjustment to that statistic. What we've guided to, though, is a broadly even outcome between the halves for the Treasury Americas division overall. Within that, at DAOU, the sales and EBITS mix profile isn't expected to differ dramatically from what we've seen previously, but you also have synergies beginning to be realized more toward the back half of the year, which will, if you like, provide a bit of a lift to second half earnings for DAOU, and for the rest of the business, it's typically fairly even in any case. So those are the elements leading us to that overall guidance.
Shaun Cousins
analystOkay, and maybe just one question about gearing and cash flow. You've cited reported cash at 82 — cash conversion was mid 82% and 94.6%, excluding non-current luxury and premium inventory — and now you're guiding to 80% for fiscal 2025, excluding premium and luxury inventory. Should we expect reported cash conversion to, sort of, come down to, say, 65%? The reason I ask is how you're thinking about your plans to deleverage. Your guidance is to reach the low end of the 1.5 to 2 times net debt-to-EBITDA at the end of fiscal 2025. Given what could be lower cash conversion on a reported basis, how does that — are you confident you get to that level of gearing? And how are you thinking about reported cash conversion for F 2025, please?
Tim Ford
executiveLet me begin with gearing, then. The guidance we've given on gearing is to land ourselves within a range of 1.5 to 2 times. We haven't pointed to any specific spot inside that range, Shaun. That's really the first thing to note. And that guidance lines up with the outlook we've provided for cash conversion, CapEx, and similar items. So that's essentially the main element of it. Then, on the matter of the different cash conversions — the reason we anchor ourselves to cash conversion, excluding the building of non-current luxury and premium inventory, is that it depends very heavily on the coal and on how large the vintages turn out to be as they arrive. So that piece is more of an add-on that happens over the course of the year. Right now, we're expecting what you might call normal vintages. But clearly, should we end up with different outcomes, we'll deal with that situation when we get there. Still, that 82% is the figure we can — so that 80% is the one we can call at this point, based on the factors we know of and that sit within our control.
Shaun Cousins
analystEven so, do you still feel confident that we'll land inside that 1.5 to 2 times net debt-to-EBITDA range by the close of Fiscal 2025?
Tim Ford
executiveRight, and the figure stands at 2.0 times. So at the close of F 2024, we're literally sitting right at the top end of that range. Clearly, we're very close indeed.
Operator
operatorPhil Kimber from E&P Capital has the next question in the queue. Go right ahead.
Phil Kimber
analystI've got a question — I believe it's on slide 10, the one showing the global operating model and luxury versus premium. So could I just confirm: the EBIT you present there for the premium brands business of 170, you're essentially saying that includes commercial, and that it's going to come down — speaking in rough figures, to about $100 million? You mentioned 60 of GPs and, roughly speaking, stranded costs. I just want to verify that's accurate. And second, you mentioned optionality regarding that global premium brands business. Does that optionality potentially involve a comparable effect, where a substantial amount of stranded costs might need to be taken into account when we consider any potential optionality you could pursue in that business? If you could comment on those two, that would be great.
Tim Ford
executiveI'll respond to the second question, and then Stuart can address the first. What I'd say is that, when we consider how best to generate value for this business going forward, the answer is clear: different scenarios produce different results. With that in mind, we're very aware of how significant the volume of treasury premium brands is to our luxury portfolio. Optionality that supports our luxury-led strategy is a really important element here — that business currently does support our strategy across the board, and because of that, going forward, we won't make a decision — sorry, let me rephrase that. Any decisions we make will ensure that whatever supporting role anything else in our business plays — whether it's our cost base or whether it's our other portfolio of brands — absolutely backs what is now nearly 80% of our business from a Luxury perspective. So there's a whole range of different scenarios we could speculate about. But until we've actually settled on what we want to do, right now, put simply, we're going into a global Premium business. This business here on Page 10, as you rightly point out, is the pro forma of what that business would look like if we combined those 2 businesses today, and also the separation of the Luxury brand — we think it's really important for investors to be clear.
Tim Ford
executiveOver on the left side of the page, you can see how future growth looks when this serves as the foundation for our earnings and margin structures, and so on. But let me be really clear: the focus is on the absolute best way to create value not only for the P&L but also for shareholders, with Premium Brands playing a supporting role going forward.
Stuart Boxer
executiveAnd regarding that first part, I believe Tim's comment about pro forma is significant. What we've done with these figures is essentially break them apart and then distribute them across the various heads, and so on, to give you a feel for it. So as we work through what we mentioned earlier regarding losing that $60 million of GP along with stranded costs, and so forth, and how we handle overheads, all of that will carry through into those figures. So at first glance, I understand why you made that comment, and it aligns with what we stated previously, but we are actually going to work through it properly and then recut those figures for you once we're ready to do so—though it's somewhat early for that.
Phil Kimber
analystAnd my apologies — just to make sure we're on the same page, those figures, as I understand them, don't cover the roughly $70 million in corporate overhead that you reported separately, right? Is that accurate?
Stuart Boxer
executiveYeah, I believe you've got that right.
Phil Kimber
analystYes. Sorry. And then one more, if I could. Just regarding Asia, I saw in your fact book that you've listed some of the biggest Luxury wine markets, and there's a lot of discussion about China, which makes sense. But on Page 9, Asia ex-China is $3.8 billion versus $1.1 billion for China. Could you say a bit about some of those other markets, Asia ex-China, and how they're doing? For instance, I'm guessing Japan is a large one in that. And it doesn't usually receive as much attention, but it sounds like those are quite big markets in their own right as well.
Tim Ford
executiveAppreciate the question. Phil, that’s a good one — we’re grateful for it. Tom, go ahead.
Tom King
executiveThank you, Phil. I take real pride in being able to discuss our additional Asian markets and the effort put in across a great many years—though especially during the recent few—on Penfolds to genuinely speed up expansion in those places and establish what our data now shows: truly robust brand equity and demand strength throughout our consumer base. Now that China is open, our focus on those markets and the money we put into them will not lessen. The achievements we've recorded in places like Thailand, Malaysia, Singapore, and Hong Kong—which, frankly, keep getting stronger—leave us seeing quite a lot of runway still ahead, especially in Thailand and Malaysia. Beyond those, I'm quite enthusiastic about the long-term possibilities in markets including Indonesia, Vietnam, and throughout Endo China. So we've kept up a solid level of investment as we enter F 2025 and beyond, and we've made it a priority to hold allocations steady in the markets I just listed. And we'll keep putting money into our on-the-ground teams and the resources required to keep delivering the growth ambition we hold, which is quite comparable to China's—playing a leading part in establishing and growing the luxury wine category.
Tom King
executiveWhat China's reopening does for the other markets is this: even as we've moved a portion of Australian wine back into China, we can now give priority to allocations of our French, US and Chinese wines for markets worldwide. That means we can take the Penfolds global source portfolio — along with the storytelling and the experiences built around it — into a greater number of our markets across the world now.
Operator
operatorThe last question is from Sam Teeger at Citi.
Sam Teeger
analystHey Tim and the team. Could you speak to how Frank Family is performing differently across the various channels, and what the main reason was that led Leslie to come onto the Board?
Tim Ford
executiveBen, you can handle the first question, and I’ll field the second one.
Ben Dollard
executiveWe have put a lot of emphasis on expanding and cultivating Frank Family's on-premise distribution. So it makes me quite happy that we have managed to keep a really healthy balance between on-premise and off-premise. Our attention has truly been on how we keep building trial in the on-premise, and that is precisely what we have been doing. Beyond that, the growth we have been getting from Frank Family has also come through our penetration in the independent channel, and through working with our strategic accounts nationwide in those accounts where Frank Family definitely has a key role to play. So nurturing the on-premise has been a very deliberate effort on our part, while also just growing it in the independent strategic accounts. So I am really pleased, and I have complete confidence that we will keep going down that path with the brand.
Tim Ford
executiveAnd regarding the Board change with Leslie Frank joining our Board—for anyone who wasn’t aware—yes, we’ve been looking. John took over as Chairman, and clearly we’ve been going through the refreshment of the Board and changes of the Board members, as every Board does, and we’ve certainly been seeking further luxury brand expertise, further luxury wine category expertise. Concern just gives me a chance to reiterate it—they haven’t picked it up already. That’s the core of our business today and our growth going forward. Understanding of the Californian wine industry in connection within that as well as a lot of skills Leslie brings from her own career previously, which she’s had a very, very esteemed career itself, not just within the creation of Frank Family Vineyards as a brand. So a lot of great skills she brings ticked a lot of the boxes we were seeking. And we’re really, really pleased that she agreed to join the Board, so. All right. Thank you, Sam. Thank you, everybody. It’s a wrap. Just to briefly sum up as I like to do, for those that are still on the call. Very clearly, we feel we’ve got great momentum, particularly in our luxury brand platforms, Penfolds and Treasury Americas.
Tim Ford
executiveThere is clearly work ahead of us when it comes to the premium side of the business. We know that, but we have also moved on it — sitting back and marveling at problems isn't how we operate here. So we've made some quite specific moves, which we laid out not just last week but, I hope, for you today as well, and which you'll see play out going forward too. That leaves us feeling very confident about the opportunity sitting in front of us, and the category headwinds that everybody enjoys discussing have been around for some time, they're still with us, and we think our marketplace results across the globe will stay strong on the back of that momentum. So thank you for being here, and I'm looking forward to ringing you in the coming week or two. Cheers.
Read the full transcript via the API
You're viewing the first half of this call. Get the complete Treasury Wine Estates Limited transcript — plus 132,000+ transcripts from 7,000+ companies, speaker segments, AI summaries and full-text search — through the EarningsCalls.dev API.
Get the API View API docs →This call discussed
For developers and AI pipelines
Programmatic access to Treasury Wine Estates Limited earnings transcripts and 132,000+ others is available through the
EarningsCalls.dev REST API. Plans from $39.99/month — full transcripts, speaker segments,
full-text search, and the recently-added /api/v1/transcripts/recent polling endpoint for ETL pipelines.
More tools for stock research
OptionsBell: an unusual options activity scanner that tracks options flow across all US stocks and emails you when large trades appear in Treasury Wine Estates Limited or any ticker on your watchlist.
StockMarketScan: a stock screener with alerts: 24 pre-built screens refreshed every 5 minutes, watchlists and email notifications. Both offer API and MCP access and fair monthly pricing.